274508 WHITE - UTV CLERK - -l' J��A�,/
PINK - FINANCE /� t- � �Sf\
■ . COIIRC 11 n►s r,r�t,�
CANARY = DEPARTMENT �J Y OF� SAINT PALTL File NO•
BI.UE - MAVOR �
` uncil Resolution
,
Presented By
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
BE IT RESOLVED, That the Council of the City of Saint Paul
hereby certifies and approves the action of the City of Saint Paul
Board of Appeals and Review pertaining to the following listed
property and as shown by the E�cerpted Minutes of said Board of
Appeals and Review, dated February 12, 1980, and marked E�iIB2T A,
and attached hereto and made a part hereof by reference:
DATE OF BOARD
MINUTES CASE NO. PROPERTY APPELLANT
2/12/80 05-80-H 148 W. George St. C. A. Lindeke
(seven units)
BOARD ACTION: Granted variance of Section 54.11, St. Paul
Legislative Code, to permit occupancy of Apts.
�#2 and #3 where tenants share bathroom, effective
for either the period of tenancy of Apt. ##2 by
the present tenant, Minnie Uschmann, or until
there be a change of right, title, or interest
from the present ownership by C. A. Lindeke, Sr. ,
whichever might be firs� terminated, at which
time said variance shall be nullified; on con-
dition that occupancy of each of the said apart-
ments be restricted to no more than one person,
that all remaining code violation designated in
letter of 1/3/80 be brough t into compliance, and
contingent on a decision from the St. Paul
Zoning Board of Appeals as to the number of units
that may be legally operated on this property.
COUNCILMEN
Yeas Nays Requested by Department of:
Butler In Favor
Hozza
Hunt
Levine __ Against BY
Maddox
Showalter
Tedesco Form Approved by City Attorney
Adopted by Council: Date
Certified Passed by Council Secretary 'Z''�� �
By
l�pproved by ll�lavor. Date _ Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
BY - — BY
wHITE - C�TV CLERK •Y���'Y■!�I
PINK - FINANCE COURCIl �� ����J�
CANARY= DEPARTMENT GITY OF SAINT PAUL File NO. �
BLUE - MAVOR
" � Council Resolution
Presented By
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
-2-
Property Description: Nelson Stevens Kings Addition
N. 25 ft. of Lot 11 and E. 45 ft.
of Lot 4 and all of Lot 3, Block 6
-----------------------------
and be it
FURTHER RESOLVED, That the City Clerk is hereby authorized and
directed to transmit a copy of this resolution for recording to the
Ramsey County Office of the Register of Deeds.
COUNC[LMEN
Yeas McMAHON Na s Requested by Department of:
Y
��' _J'� [n Favor
I�e�e-
Hunt
Levine _ � __ Against BY
Maddox
Towalter �AR 4 ,�O
Form Approved by City Attorney
Adopt y Cou cil: Date
C tified ;sed by ouncil Secreta �'� �~27+�
Ap o e by IVlavor. te � � � Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
BY --- BY
�S�tED MAR 2 5 1980
. _ _ _ . _
-3-
�x �-11 ,C�l T �4 �. �
" �����,���
�
CASE N0. PR�PERTY APPELLANT .
05-80-H 14� ��. Georg� S-�. CoA. Lindeke
- (seven un.its) __
SUBJECT: R�quest varia.�c� ot S�k. Paul Legi.slative Code , Section Sh. l�.,
perta n ng �o requir�m:ent t�at e�ch dwell.�ng uni�k con�ain ba�hroom
faciiities �pith�n i�� �a alls , ta permit occupancy o� .A�ts . #t and #3
where �enants sha�°� a bathraom, because ��mplianc� ;�ou1.d cause practical�
difficulty, and t�:nants do not object to th� arxax�g�m�nt.
APPEARANC�: C.A. L�nd�l��
Alice Bijjani
PROCEEI3INGS : �Ir� Lindek� tald the boax3 tha� his mol�he� hacl owned this
property slnce 1�35. She had been granted a vara.anc� on tl�.e shared bath-
room for the two �anits for so long as she c�w�.ed th� pro�er-�y. She had
since died and Nir� Linc3eke and his b�n�hex ir.h�xi�:ed th� building which .
C.A. Lindeke managed. He requestPd a conti.nuatio� of the variance.
Alice Bzj j ani said there was a zoning problem, but: rhat Mr, 1,indeke liad
applied for legal non- con�Urming sta�us . She explained that the building
was a standard six-pl�x, two floors , �?:hree units per f�,00x, bu� one firs�
floor uni� had been split intq t�ao sma�l apartment�s .
h1r. Lindeke said neither uni?�: w �� ever rented ta more than one tenant.
Each nad a beautiful kitcheri ar�d there was r�io possible ��ay to instal_1 an
additional bathroom because of lack z,f space . It woul�: als�a be wastieful
to deconvert the two units back into ene b�acause one kitchen would have
to be taken out. One of the occupants had lived there £or 3S years , a
birs . Ushman, at a rent of $70 per �r�n.th., and re].ocating i�ratz�d b� traun��tic
for her, emoticnaliy and firLaneially ,
�
6�fi �'
-4- y�� �
. � �� � m��;
4 BO�RD ACTION : Chairman Wozniak moved that a permanent variance be granted
to permit sharing of the bathroom between Apts . #?. and #3 , with the
restriction that no more than one person occupy each unit , and on con-
dition that all code violations listed ii�, the 1/3/80 Certificate of
Occup an cy letter be bxought into compliance , contingent upon a decision
by the zoning board that the property may t�e opera�ed as a seven-unit
complex. blre Tieso seconded. NI�TI�N FAILED TO CARRY.
THE VOTE: Ayes - 2 Nayes - 2 (Naibi, Reiter) Abstentians - Q
BOARD ACTION : Mr� Reiter mov�d that a variance be granted for fihe shared
bathroom for the lifetime c�f the occuparit af Apt.._-#2 , A�rs d Ushman, provided
that all the i,tems �.n the 1/3/80 letter be taken caxe o£, and conditiona�.
upon the decision of the zoning baaxd. Cha�.rma.n Wazniak �econded.
MOTION FAILED TO CARRY. ��
THE VOT�: Ayes - 2 Nayes - 2 (Naibi , Tieso) Absten-Cions - 0
BOARD ACTION: Mr. �Jaibi moved tha-G a variance be g�°anteci to permit the
s -�iar� at �ooma effec-�ive for either �h.e period �f tenancy of the presen�
occupant or for the period of NIr. Lindeke's owner�hip, whichever termin�te�.
first , with the restri,ction that occupancy of �ach unit be c.onfined to ane
person, that all code vi�lations be b-rought inta comp�Iianee , and contingent �,
upon the decision of the zoning board. I�Ir. Reiter secand�d. MOT7ON GARRIEI?
AND SO ORDERED.
THE VOTE: Ayes - 3 Nayes - 1 (Tieso) Ab�tentions - 0
- Chairman Wozniak expressed t'-.e �ginion that the camplication of the
motion as passed might pose a proble� of enforcement. �
Mr. Reiter explai.ned that he voted in the affirma�iv� nn this mation
because �f the long-t�r.� tenancy of Mxs . Ushman, who a� age 75 wo�.ld have
difficulty adjusting to relocation. He said he hacl postured his motian
in relation to the original waiver gr.anted to the appellan�G` s mother
during her ownership. If Mr. Lindeke should return to the baard in the
future, th� board would be aware of the reas�ns why the vaxiance was
granted tod�y. .
� 2/I2'f 80 - Meeting ?�TO. �SR
r
� �
D�INUTES �F THE 1�4FETI�TG
ST. PAU'L BO�RU 0� AT�PE�tLS �, ���'IE6V
Tuesday, February 12 , 1.98Q
City Council Comni_itt:ee I�ocam 7Q7
City Hall anc�. Go�.�rt House
lo �Q p.m. �.,
hiEI�IBERS PRESENT: D.Do Wozniak, Chai.rman '
Arthur Tieso
Ae Wali I�ai.bi
`Tho�as Rei�er
I�fENiBERS ABSENT: �styr B. Peake
Ron Glas�man
AGENCIES �'R�SENT: Com�un�ty �ervices De�fi . �- Divisi.on af Hatzszng and
Bui2di.ng Cade �n£orcement ;
�.�ice Bij j ani
Ear� ConT�v
Sam Blue
_ OTHERS PRESENT: Mary Pat i.ee, S�. Ppul Tenants Union. _
LQac:��ine Yunker
Fre�l �unk�.r
D.J. lwhzn.ra .
W�3te�� J. Hans�rr
Linda Kohl .
K.W. Koo�z
. �ar� Metzg�g .
STAFF PRES��t'T: Pa�ri.Gia Moxne�s �
Chairman Waznial� called t:he ��e�ting to �r�er a� 1 :4Q p.m. �
�ii.nutes af the m��ting of 1/8/8Q w�xP �.ppxaved �.� �l.istxibuted. tc� the
mzmbers.
��
, ,i
� , , , y
. . . . � . - � . . . , s � . �'t . . . . ., � . . . . %:..:
. . : . � . ' � �� . � , . � . . . . � . . � � � ' � ., ;..
.. 1 � . . .. � ' . . . .. . ' . . � . - . , . ' ' . , . . � � . . . .. . � . ��M1Y
.�� . � . . . .. . . . . . .
' . ,' .. ' . ' ' � .. - _ � : . . ,. . ,. .. , ' .1�`;�
. . . . . . . , . . . .. . . . � � � . � � � � . � .
.. . . . , . � . . . . .�. ;� �..
. _ . . . . , . . . . _, .
- � , . � � . � � � � . � � - .. . . . - . � . . � � , � . . � ... �� . . , .. ..
1 I ; � " _, " , ,.,,
_.. � . . ' � , . � . . . � . . . . . . r. !
. , � . � � . , . � .. , . ., . � . �. . . . � .. . . � . . . . . , . . .. .. . . . � `.M��,
� � .. . . � . . . " . . . _ . . . . . `, . . .. -
. . , � . . . . . - . � .. �. . � . � �_ . , . . � . . - . ' � . � . . . � � , .
. . . ' '. �'. . .. � . . . , � . . . , - .
� _ � , , . � � . . . � .. .. . . . ... ' . ' �. . i . _:�
, , r' ?
� . � � . . � . t . : . .. . ' . . .. � � M
. . . ;. , . . . . . . . :.� , �.�:
, . . . . , . . .. .. . � . ' ' : �.
� � . ' -: � - . . . . . ` . l 4 _
` �. � ' ' . _ .� � ... r . . . . 1 ~ .�. . ' � , - . - , . , .
. . . . . .. . . ... . • i.��:.. 1��:
. . �..��' ' . . , . � . '� ' . ' . .. . . �.... . . � � ,/�.�
1 . . � � '� _ . � " .. ' . � . . �� � . � . ` . .. '
- . . . .. �., . . .. . . . . . � , � .. �'(
, � � Msrch'29`, L$80 �,. � ��
� _ � � � . -�
� , _ .
, . - :; , -
: , � ,
, � ,
, � . � � '
• - , � r
.. . . . , .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . � �1 .. . - . . � � �k
_ . `; . : , i .� ' . . � ' . . � � � � . ' - ,. � .. . � .
. ' � , ,. . � Y�� � , � . : . . ' . . . . .� . � . . .. .. . �. �. . � � � .. r;
' , Beg�,ster oF Da�d�e f , ' � . �
� ; l�rt Rldl�r, City flall
. St. �'�s�, I�tinnesots � r ,
, ' _ � " , -
• :�e,ar Sirs . , , ,.` ;.
' ��
, Attscbe�d #cr, �iling.in yoeir office ia a cer���ied copy pf �Co�n631
� F3�e No. ;2�4508, adopted'b�c the C�tp Co�Cil;on'I�rr�h �, 19$0. . a F
� _ _ _ . ' , � . ;,' .�'.
: 9e trul � ,;�
i'Y Y: Y'our .
, . , . . , , �
l � , , - , ,�,� i
. •, , � Bose Mi.x ; . . ' �
� : G�tyr Clerk ', `:.
. . _ � - . . � ,;
� ; sc�scb: . , :
. , dcr - `� ` J � ' -
� , , ,
. , .
, � �:x
, , ;�:
. -. , � ��
, �'.
.
; , ,.' a.;�
, - _
,
_ ,� � •~
. „. � .
, � . M
'
_ , , �
' . , � ,� t
, � - , • . '" ' � ...�.���