The URL can be used to link to this page

277495 . � ` � � , ,� � ;�f�� City of St. Paul COUNCIL FI 0 RESOLUTION RATIFYING SERVICE CHARGES By File No. 18113-81 In the matter of the placing of and collection of cost and expenses (for "service charges") for the annual operation and maintenance costs of the City-owned "Town Square" public spaces located in the area bounded by the following streets: Cedar Street, Eighth Street, Minnesota Street, and Sixth Street for the period running from July 1, 1981 to June 30, 1982. Preliminary Order 276952 approved 6/4/81 Final Order 277126 approved 7/14/81 A public hearing having been had upon the service charges for the above improvement, and said service charges having been further considered by the Council, and having been considered finally satisfactory, therefore, by it RESOLVED, That the said service charges be and the same are hereby in all respects ratified. RESOLVED FURTHER, That the said service charges be and they are hereby determined to be payable in one (1) equal installment. FINALLY RESOLVED, That upon ratification of subject service charges the City Clerk is hereby directed to transmit a certified copy of this Resolution to the Ramsey County Auditor so that the service charges levied herein shall be extended on the proper tax lists of the County and collected in 1982 along with current taxes. COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Council: Dat�CT � t�' Yeas Nays � Certif ed Passed by Council Secretary �u�'i In Favor L�.�� . :i � OC7 5 A��,:;...t;x Against �r'1:.''v'�u t;�r; Mayor �Ghr,v►��r T��:'��:� �'�;��t� 0 CT 2�41981 . 1Ar+�---� . � .. .. p . . . . . . . . � . . . .. .. ' � � � ' .. ' . . . .. ... �� . ' . ` . . �� . � � r/ . � � ' . � . . � . .� ' l � � �� . . � . - . . - ..`�V � � . . . ... . . . . ' � . • � � . . .� . . � ., .. �� . . . - . . . . . . . .. . . . � . . . . . .. . . . � . ' . " � .. . . . , . . .. ' . ' . . .�� . � � � ' . . , � .. � � . . . . . � . . � � . . . � . . �. . .. ' . . .. � , " . . � .. . • � . . � � ' . . ' . . . . . � . �. .. .. � . . � . . . . .. - . . . L . � ' . . . . . � . . , � . _ . � ` ; �_ t�ctober 2T, 1981 , � ; , y l�C'• Yd s'tar'1' � �ity A'�torn�y ,. R000 6#�, City H�►3.1 ' - . • Ikar Sir s . d�taoh*d for your L�Torestion is s copy o! l�hs � of � l�an�aota Public �dia to tl�e epecial us�tsss�►ts at�d atrvi� ' _ . al�srg�es i'or gbMn S�usr� as ratltie8 by C.�`. 2?`�495• � ; , - _ ' y��.y t,�.a�y �pyr�� . • Albert �B. ois+oa Ctt�}r q.erk , . � , , , , Att+t�h. . ABOtIa , , ' cas Yaluation �ug3aeer . • , • , , ' � ' i ; - � � : � � '. , � ... s. . _ �. . .. ;.�� „J �� ., � � ' � . . � .. . ' .. , � . . - . �r�'. . 'u� . .. . ` . , . . . . . . � ,� .��lr �. . . . . . . . . ( �►� . . � . . . . I . . . . ' . . . � ' . . .. _ � ' � . � . � � . ,.. , .. � � \ . "1 � ' . . . , � . � . . .. � � . , � . . � . . . � ' . � , � � . ' .. . � . . � . . � � .,. �� : . � � . . .. . . . �� . i ' . . �. . �� . �.. . . ' � . . � , . . � � � ,. � . . � , � . . . - . � . � � . ' � . . � . �� , . ' .. . . . ' , . . . - _ . ,/ . . - ' � , . . . j - � . . . . . . � ' � . - , , . .. • . � . . . . � . , . , ' . � / "'' . i . . . . ,� . .. . . � - I�O�v�eeblr �, j98�. . ' � . , . ; : , , . . b�: Ed �t,t� C#ty At#tarstey , . � , : Room �7,� a.ty;�i].�. - • . . ,, . . taesr Slr: . . � � � f � - � � Attiohs�!•!or yaur intbxmal�ion. la n l�crtilae lrom�tbs 1�is�ric� ��ourt'c�t xvtice o�' A�pea�l sad Appeai �t�rom Spseial Arsesaa�tta . � . ;'aeid 9i►rvic� t�rges regerdir►g op�ra�io�:arld �ts�nae� o�` �� 9quaxe PaFk an behal? oP First B�ptiet �hurcti. . , � VerY 'trW,Y Y�o!utr�s ,' , . , � . � - . . .. � . , �� . . . . _ l.. .' . , . . . , � .. �. ' . � �� Vt�PW�. �� .. ... I . _ . � � . . City Clerk ; , . _ �. - . � � , _ , At�h. ' � � . ;- , . : . < � __ . t r �t1� � _ � ., a�,a Valwi,tAoa �gi�t�er ,� • � ' , ' ' . . `� � ' . . ,4 — �. , . ' `'� . / ' , , � . \� ' . ' " i . \ ,,� . ,, F \\ ;j . • ? � . � ;� � ' �� \ , ° , � . ; , , _ `e� , � " — �; ' � ` �;. ;: _ `,, :� , . . - '\ � \ . _ • _ .,_ �. ,; . •�, � , , , _ .. , _ . , « e � �� `�� '�+:.�, ' ' Y . ; MEIER, KENNEDY, QUINN & SHUMAK�R 1�� "'a"'`'��-.::,,.� " ^ Attorneys at Law �lC�D ' �, Jf WILLIAM C. MEIER 11920-tDetl � �� `�UIT� p M�p1 1� OTA BUILDING ALOIS D. KENNEDY,JR. 1 /��/ TIMOTHYP.OUINN �e�r ^ SAINT�AIJU/VIII�ESOTA55101 GORDON W.SHUMAKER � �! 'r�,I��M►{� (6�212'26-8844 ANDREW J. EISENZIMMER � � n � G�Fj�� LEO H. DEHLER � � `, �'�"i�� THOMAS B.WIESER OCtOb@Y' 1 5� 1 981 , The Honorable Albert Olson City Clerk, City of St. Paul Room 386 , City Hall St. Paul Minnesota 55102 Re: Notice of Appeal from Special Assessments and Service Charges Dear Mr. Olson: Delivered to you herewith for filing, pursuant to Section 14 .01 .4 (Appeal) of the Saint Paul City Charter, is the Notice of Appeal from Special Assessments and Service Charges in regard to the special assessments and service charges against the properties of the named Appellants, The Archdiocese of Saint Paul and Minneapolis, The Church of The Assumption, The Church of St. Louis, The Church of St. Mary, and St. Joseph' s Hospital, listed in the Assessment Roll adopted by order of the City Council October 1 , 1981 to finance the annual operation and maintenance of "Town Square" . We respectfully request, as provided for in Section 14.01 .4 , Subparagraph 4 , of the City Charter, that you deliver to us, on behalf of the Appellants, a copy of the Assessment Roll, certi- fied to by the proper City Officers, so that we may file it with the District Court, as required by said Section 14.01 .4 , Subparagraph 4. Yours very truly, MEIER, KENNEDY, QUINN & SHUMAKER Timoth P. Quinn TPQ:sh Enclosures . � � a �`�� 9.s . . . r,.• ..-...:z a�:ras4��._ ... ��a-m �h- ' , . . . . . . . , F��Eo Dc� �� l s� P�i '8f ,.�rv ,.,� r,��'� �FFiC� .. ��,...,�t, `. . . ...., =�:�i��. STATE OF MINNESOTA DISTRICT COURT RAMSEY COUNTY SECOND JUDICIAL DISTRICT -------------------------------------- The Archdiocese of Saint Paul and Minneapolis, The Church of The Assumption, The Church of St . Louis, The Church of St. Mary, and St. Joseph' s Hospital, all Minnesota corporations, NOTICE OF APPEAL Appellants, FROM SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS AND SERVICE CHARGES vs. The City of Saint Paul, a Minnesota Municipal corporation , Respondent. -------------------------------------- The Archdiocese of Saint Paul and Minneapolis, The Church of The Assumption, The Church of St . Louis, The Church of St . Mary, and St. Joseph' s Hospital, Appellants above named, owners of the parcels of real estate hereinafter described, hereby appeal those certain special assessments and service charges levied by the City of Saint Paul, a Municipal corporation, Respondent above named, against those certain parcels of real estate owned by Appellants, as set forth hereafter, pursuant to that certain assessment roll listing said properties and said assessments and service charges, adopted by Order of the City Council of the said City of Saint Paul, on October 1 , 1981 , for the purpose of financing and apportioning the cost of that certain local improvement described in the Notice of the Public JY'i � ' � Hearing on said proposed assessments and service charges as "service charges resulting from the annual operation and maintenance of the City owned 'Town Square' public spaces located in the area bounded by the following streets: Cedar Street, Eighth Street, Minnesota Street, and Sixth Street. " This notice is given in accordance with, and pursuant to, the provisions of Chapter 429 , Minnesota Statutes; Chapters 13 and 14 of the Saint Paul City Charter; and Chapter 62 of the Saint Paul Administrative Code. I . The properties owned by Appellants against which the appealed from assessments and service charges were levied, and the amount of said assessments and service charges are as follows: The Archdiocese of Saint Paul and Minneapolis (Catholic Youth Center) I .D. No. 04-63500-070-55 $ 61 .77 The Church of The Assumption I .D. No. 04-63500-015-03 $965 .78 04-14000-060-09 259 .43 1 ,225 .21 The Church of St. Louis I .D. No. 04-66000-030-12 $ 180 .71 04-66�00-050-12 1 ,001 .41 1 , 182. 12 The Church of St. Mary I .D. No. 03-34000-041-02 $ 22 .65 03-34000-041-11 181 .87 204 .52 St . Joseph' s Hospital I .D. No. 04-14000-020-03 $ 19 .21 04-14000-092-03 23.37 04-14000-132-03 230 .22 04-14000-152-03 34 .32 04-14000-081-03 19 . 13 I .D. No. 04-38000-010-58 8.71 04-38000-011-58 5 .04 I .D. No. 04-64000-081-00 831 .45 04-38000-010-66 23 .69 04-14000-020-04 17 . 16 1 ,212 . 30 $3 ,885 .92 , -2- � , ' II . Prior to the Public Hearing held on September 22, 1981 , Appellants presented to the Mayor and members of the St. Paul City Council their written objections to said assessments, setting forth the applicable facts and law, and the qrounds for said objections, a copy of which written notice of objections is attached hereto, marked "Exhibit I" and made a part hereof. Prior to the continued Public Hearing, held on October 1 , 1981 , Appellants served additional written notice of objections to said assessments, a copy of which written objections is attached hereto, marked "Exhibit II" , and made a part hereof. III . The grounds for the appeal from said assessments and service charges levied against said properties to finance and apportion the cost of said improvements are as follows: 1 . That the assessments, in each instance, are fraudulent, in that the City Council was aware of the absence of any economic bene- fit to the above properties as a result of said " improvement" to be financed by said assessments. 2 . That the assessments are made upon demonstrable mistakes of fact and law. 3 . That the assessments , in each instance, are in an amount in excess of the actual benefits to the above properties being assessed; the actual benefits being none. -3- r 4 . That the assessments constitute an unconstitutional taking without compensation. IV. That on October 15 , 1981 , within twenty (20) days after the entry of the Order of the City Council adoptinq said assessments, Appellants filed the within Notice of Appeal with the City Clerk of the City of Saint Paul, in accordance with Section 14 .01 .4 , Subpara- graph 1 , of the City Charter, and requested a certified copy of the Assessment Roll for filing in the District Court, as required by Section 14 .01 .4 , Subparagraph 4 , of the City Charter. WHEREFORE , Appellants pray that the court set aside said assessments against the above properties , determine that there is no economic benefit to any of the said properties as a result of said improvement and order that said properties not be assessed in any amount for said improvement. Dated: October 15 , 1981 . MEIER, KENNEDY, QUINN & SHUMAKER By: Timo y P. Quinri Attorney rfor Appellants 430 Min sota Building St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Phone: (612) 226-8844 -4- � . • ,. . � � MEIER, KENNEDY, QUINN & SHUMAKER �Itornel�s af [.aK ' WILLIAM G. MEIER i�920-tpe�� September I J � � 78� SUITE 430. MINNESOTA BUIIDING ALOIS D. KENNEDY.JR. TIMOTMY P. OUINN SAINT PAUI., MINNESOTA 5310) GORDON W. SMUMAKER (6121 226-8644 ANDREW J. E19ENZIMMER LEO H. DEHLER THOMAS B.WIESER The Honorable Georqe Latimer Mayor of the City of Saint Paul , And The Honorable Members of the St. Paul City Council City Hall and Courthouse St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Re: Town Square "Assessments" ( Catholic Church Properties) Dear . Mayor Latimer and Members of the St . Paul City Council: The undersigned is General Counsel for The Archdiocese of Saint Paul and Minneapolis and represents the following Catholic in- stitutions in regard to the assessments proposed to be levied against the listed properties for the annual maintenance of "Town Square Park" , payable in 1982: 1 . The Catholic Youth Center 150 North Smith Avenue $ 76 .99 2 . The Church of The Assumption 51 West Ninth Street 1 ,527 . 16 3 . The Church of St . Louis 506 Cedar Street 1 ,473.46 4 . The Church of St. Mary 261 East Eighth Street 254 .92 5 . St. Joseph ' s Hospital 69 West Exchange Street 1 ,487 .24 On behalf of the above named entities, we hereby formally ob- ject to the proposed assessments on the grounds herein set forth, and respectfully request that these assessments be stricken from the assessment roll . Enclosed herewith , marked "Exhibit A" and made a part hereof, is a formal legal opinion and position paper briefly setting forth our formal legal position that if any of these five properties, which include three churches, a youth center and a hospital , are to be assessed, it must be shown that some economic benefit will enure to these properties as a result of the proposed " improvement" ( annual maintenance expense for "Town Square Park" ) . The applicable law is clear: That the economic benefit which must enure to real estate in order for an improvement to be assessed against such real estate must consist of an increase EXHIBIT "I" � � , � MEIER, KENNEDY, QUINN & SHUMAKER The Honorable George Latimer The Honorable Members of the St. Paul City Council September 15 , 1981 Page Two in the reasonable market value of the property proposed to be assessed, as a result of the proposed improvement. I am certain that the City Attorney will concur in the applicable law in this instance. Also enclosed herewith , marked "Exhibit B" and made a part hereof, is the appraisal prepared by William J. Dunn, Realtor and Appraiser, setting forth the facts in this case, namely: that each of the properties is presently being used to its highest and best use and that there is in fact no economic benefit to any of these properties. The appraisal points out that the market value of each property is not increased to any degree as a result of the pro- posed "improvement" . Mr. Dunn is a recognized expert appraiser who has appeared literally hundreds of times in district courts of Minnesota testifying in regard to these kinds of matters. Since there is no increase in the market value and there is no • benefit to any of the properties the law holds that there can be no assessment levied against these properties for the proposed "improvement . " The principle involved in these proposed "assessments" is a basic principle which our clients have an obligation to their constituen- cies to uphold. The amount involved in each particular assessment is not necessarily overwhelming ( at this time) but for any of these institutions to acquiesce in such an "assessment" would be a prece- dent which we cannot advocate. On behalf of The Archdiocese of Saint Paul and Minneapolis, The Church of The Assumption, The Church of St. Louis, The Church of St. Mary and St . Joseph' s Hospital we respectfully request the Honorable Mayor and Members of the St. Paul City Council to strike the proposed assessments against these five properties from the assessment roll. Your consideration of this request is greatly appreciated. Yours very truly, MEIER, KENNEDY, QUINN & SHUMAKER _/- -- , , -- - ._ ` ��____.,� .� Timoth ' P. Quinn � � TPQ:sh cc: The Archdiocese of Saint Paul a d Minneapolis The Church of The Assumption The Church of St . Louis The Church of St. Mary St. Joseph' s Hospital T0: The City of Saint Paul. FROM: Timot}�y P. Quinn , Esq . , General Counsel The Archdiocese of Saint Paul and Minneapolis DATE: September 15 , 1��1 RE: Special Assessment on Church Property ISSUE ARE CHURCHES AND CHURCH PROPERTY SUBJECT TO A SPECIAL ASSESSMENT LEVIED FOR NONABUTTING PARK MAINTENANCE PURPOS�S? DISCUSSION Minn. Const. art . 1� § 1 provides in part : Taxes shall be uniform upon the same class of subjects and shall be levied and collected for public purposes , but public burying grounds , public school houses , public Yiospitals , academies , colleges , uni- versities , all seminaries of learning, all churches , church property , houses of worship, institutions of purely public charity , and public property used exclusively for any public purpose , shall be exempt from taxation except as provided in this section . (Emphasis added) . Constitutional exemption from general taxation does not , tiowever , exempt such property fzom special assessments. 70 Am. Jur . 2d Special or Loct�.l Assessments § 65 (1�373) . Exemptions from special assessments must be found, if at all , in express st�ztutory provisions . 13A nunnell Minn . I)igest 2d Municipal CorporAtions § 9.04 (3d ed. 1�381 ) . Such a statu- tory exemption from local assessments does exist with respect to public ceMetery associations and did exist for railroad com- pany land. No such special exemption exists for churches or church property not used as buryin� grounds. ERHIBIT "A" , � . The uniform taxatioii clause of Article 10 � 1 is consid- ered in conjunction with Minn. Stat . § 42�.051 which provides that " ( t ]t�e cost of any im�rovements , or any part thereof , may be assessed upon property benefited by the improvement, based upon ttie benefits received . . . . " The benefit to the property from the improvement must be based upon "wtiat increase, if any, there has been in the market value of the benefited land. " City of St . Louis Park v. Engell , 283 Minn . 309 , 31G , 16Fi N.W. 2d 3 , 8(19G�) . If there has been no increase in the market value, the special assessment is unsuppor ted and r�ay not be col lected . That test was set f or th by the Minnesota Court in 1977 when it stated: The test is whether the improvement for which the assessment was levied has increased the market value of the property , against which the assessment operates , in at least ttie amount of the assessment . Continental Sales & Equipment Co. v . Town of Stuntz , 257 N . W. 2d 546 , 549 (Minn . 1977) . It has been suggested tt�at such a difference in market value "should t� computed by determining what a willing buyer would pay a willing seller for the property before , and then after , the improvement has been constructed. Carlson-Lang Realty Co. v . City of Windom , hlinn . , 307 Minn. 3G$ , 369, 240 N.W .2d 517 , 519 ( 197G) . " Nyquist v . Town of Center , Crow �Ving County , 251 N.W. 2d 695 , G�7 (Minn. 1977) . In Nyquist , the Court reversed and remanded the case for a new trial because the town board and trial court failed to base the special -`�- assessment on a showing of a change in market value resulting from the improvement. It is , of course, true that the present use of the land is not dispositive. Market value may be calculated on the highest and best use of tt�e land . Anderson v. City of Bemidji , 295 N.W .2d 555 (Minn . 1980) . Stated differently, "the test is whettier the land could be used for purposes which would benefit from the improvement . " Village of Edina v. Joseph , 264 Minn. 84, 95 , 119 N.W.2d 809, 817 (1962) , as cited in Southview � Country Club v . City of Inver Grove Heights , Dakota County , 263 N.W. 2d 385, 388 (Minn. 1978) . Consequently , if the church property in the instant case is presently dedicated to its highest and best use and no benefit to the land from the improvement can be demonstrated by way of increased market value , the special assessment will not survive constitutional scrutiny. CONCLUSION The limitations on special assessments are as follows : (a) The land must receive a special benefit from the improvement being constructed, (b) the assessment must be uniform upon the same class of property , and (c ) the assessment may not exceed t}ie special benef it . *** Any special assessment which does not meet these requirements is an unconstitutional taking witt�out compensation . (Citations omitted) . Southview Country Club v . City of Inver Grove Heights , Dakota County , 263 N.W.2d 385, 387-388 (Minn. 1978) . If it is -3- demonstrated that the existance of a distant enclosed park area in no way enhances the value of the church property upon which - the special assessment is being levied, the assessment will necessarily fail . -�- .�_1_ � ? � � �� WILL7AM J. DUNN �'ea�tor and � prai�er ��' o�'�� REALTOR� �i � � ' APP A1 ER SALES - APPRAISALS RESIDENTIAL - COMMERCIAL - INOUSTRI/1L 624 COMMERCE BUILDIN� ST. PAUL, MINNE50TA 55101 Z22-2789 September 14, 1981 Mr. Timothy P. Quinn Attorney at Law 430 Minnesota Building St. Paul, Minnesota 55101 Re : "Town Square Assessm�nts" on following properties : The Catholic Youth Center 150 North Smith Avenue, St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 The Church of The Assumption 51 West Ninth Street, St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 The Church of St. Louis 506 Cedar Street, St. Paul, Minnesota 55101 The Church of St. Mary 261 East Eighth Street, St. Paul, Minnesota 55101 St. Joseph' s Hospital 69 West Exchange Street, St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Dear Mr . 4uinn : Pursuant to your request, I wish to advise that I have made an in- spection of the above parcels of real estate and herewith render you the following appraisal. PURPOSE AND DATE OF THIS APPRAISA L The purpose of this appraisal is to estimate the fair market value of the above �arcels of real estate as of July 14, 19$1 before and after the construction, operation and maintenance of "Town Square" , and "Town Square Park" . MARKET VALUE DEFINED Market value is defined as being the value in terms of money which a willing buyer will pay and a willing seller will accept after a "EXHI�IT I3" , � �. � 7�� . , P. 2 - Mr . Timothy P. Quinn MA RKET VALUE DEFINED (Cont'd) parcel of real estate has been exposed for sale a reasonable length of time with neither party acting under duress and both parties having full knowledge of all the uses to which the property may be put. RIGHTS TO BE APPRAISED: I am appraising the title in fee simple to the above captioned par- cels of real estate, free and clear of all incumbrances, except the usual easements for utilities. ADDRESSES OF SUBJECT PROPERTIES : 150 North Smith Avenue, St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 • 51 West Ninth Street, St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 506 Cedar Street, St, Paul, Minnesota 55101 261 East Eighth Street, St. Paul, Minnesota 55101 69 West Exchange Street, St . Paul, Minnesota 55102 ASSESSMENTS LEVIED AGAINST ABOVE FIVE PARCELS : St. Joseph' s Hospital: I .D. No. 04-14000-020-03 04-14000-092-03 04-14000-132-03 04-14000-152-03 I .D, No. 04-38000-010-58 04-38000-011-58 I .D. No . 04-64000-081-00 04-38010-010-66 04-14000-020-04 Total assessment for above parcels - $1,487 .24 Church of St . Louis : I .D. No. 04-66000-030-12 04-66000-050-12 Total assessment for above parcels - $1,473 .46 P . 3 - Mr. Timothy P. 4uinn ASSESSMENTS LEVIED AGAINST ABOVE FIVE PARCELS: (Cont 'd} Assumption Church: I .D. No. 04-63500-015-03 04-14000-060-09 Total assessment for above parcels - $1, 527 . 16 Catholic Youth Center : I .D. No. 04-73500-070-55 - $ 76. 99 St� Marv' s Church: I .D. No. 03-34000-041-02 03-34000-041-11 Total assessment for above parcels - $ 254 . 92 Total of above assessments - - - - - $4, 819 . 77 PRESENT USE OF SUBJECT PROPERTIES : At the present time and for the past many years, the above parcels of real estate have been put to church and charitable use . HIGHEST AND BEST USE OF SUBJECT PROPERTIES : I am of the opinion that the highest and best use of subject properties is the use to which said properties have been put for the past many years . BENEFITS TO THE ABOVE PARCELS OF REAL ESTATE THROUGH THE CONSTRUCTION, OPERATION AND MAINTENANCE OF "TOWN SQUARE" AND "TOWN SQUARE PARK" : Your appraiser is of the opinion that the market value of the above parcels has not and will not be increased as a result of the con- struction, operation and maintenance of "Town Square" and "Town Square Park" and that the above parcels of real estate have not � and will� not receive any benefits through the construction, opera- � tion and maintenance of "Town Square" and "Town Square Park" . This appraisal report is preliminary in nature, and a complete de- tailed appraisal report will be rendered in said matter at the time formal testimony is required, but from a study made of said parcels P, 4 - Mr . Timothy P. 4uinn BENEFITS TO THE ABOVE PARCELS OF REAL ESTATE THROUGH THE CONSTRUCTION, OPERATION AND MAZNTENANCE OF "TOWN SQUARE" AND "TOWN SQUARE PARK" : (Cont'� of real estate and their highest and best use, your appraiser, as stated above, is of the opinion that the above five parcels of real estate have not and will not receive any benefits by the construc- tion, operation and maintenance of "Town Square" and "Town Square Park" . , Respectfully submitted, G�T�� s�i�— """ William J. Du�n, A�,S .A . � WJD/vo , ; � � ';� s/�� . , . " This Appraisal is L�_.�de subject to the following limiting conditions: 1. The legal description furnished me is assumed to be correct. 2. I assume no responsibility for matters legal in character nor do I render any opinion as to the title which is assuined to be marketable. Liens and encumbrances, if any, have been disregarded and the property has been appraised as though free and clear and under re- sponsible o�vnership and competent management. 3. If sketches of Qoor plans or plots are includecl in this report, they are to be considered only as being approximale and submitted to assist the reader in visualizing the property. I have made no survey of tlie property and assume no responsibility in connection with such matters. 4. The information in this report identified as being furnished to me by others is believed by me to be reliable, but I assume no responsibility for its accuracy. 6. Possession of this report or a copy thereof does not carry ��ith it the right for publication, nor may it be used for any purpose by anyone but the applicant without the previous writ- ten consent of the appraiser or the applican t and in any event only with proper qualification. 6. I am not required to give testimony or attendance in court by reason of this appraisal with reference to its subject property, unless arrangements have previously been made therefor. 7. I have no present or contemplated interest in the property appraised. 8. 7'he distribution of the total valuation in this report between land and improvements applies only under the existing program of utilization. The separate valuations for land and building must not be used in conjunction �vith any other appraisal and are invalid if so used. WILLIAM J. DUNN , A. S.A. Realtor- - - Appraiser • � , • . �UALIFICATIONS OF �VILLIAM J. DUNN 624 COMMERCE BUILDING,ST.PAUL,MINNESOTA 55101 AS AN APPRAISER OF REAL ESTATE A.Member: St.Paul Area Board of Realtors, Inc. Minnesota Association of Realtors National Association o(Realtors Tri-State Chapter 20 of American Right-of-Way Association National Association of American Right-of-Way Association Senior Member American Society of Appraisers•Twin Cities Chapter Senior Member American Society of Appraisers•National Association B.Real Estate Appraisal made for tollowing: City of St. Paul Villages in Ramsey County County o(Ramsey ' State of Minnesota Department ot Highways Department of Administration Referee in Bankruptcy at St. Paul Probate Court oi Ramsey County Districl Court o(Ramsey County Northwestern State Bank ot St. Paul Northwestern National Bank of St.Paul Economic Laboratory,Inc. Housing and Redevelopment Authority of Saint Paul Miller Hospital Credit Union Northern States Power Co. Owners Attorneys Agents C.Experlence: Engaged in the general real estate business since 1928, including buying, selling, appraising, managing and leasing real estate for others. Engaged in the buying and selling of real estate for myself slnce 1928. Appraising real estate throughout various counties in Minnesota, including Ramsey, Hennepin, Scott, Dakota and Washington Counties since 1928 for owners, agents, attorneys, courts, banks and various governmental agencies. Have been appointed a commissioner by the District Court of Ramsey County in many condemnation proceedings during past several years. Have testified as an expert on real estate values in courts and before commissions in a number of counties in Minnesota during past several years. �f� •�.� �.� ,• � � �' MEIER, KENNEDY, QUINN & SHUMAKER A!lUfI1P�'.f O( �AN' � WILLIAM G. MEIER ii9�O��ee�i S'e tember 29 � SUITE 430. MINNESOTA BU�LDING ALOIS O. KENNEDY. JR P � 981 TIMOTHY P. OUINN SAINT PAUI. MINNESOTA 55101 GORDON W.SHUMAKER 16121 22B•8844 ANOREW J. EI5ENZIMMER lE0 H.DEMLER THOMAS B.WIESER The Honorable Members of the St. Paul City Council City Hall and Courthouse St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Re: Town Square "Assessments" ( Catholic Church Properties) Dear Members of the St . Paul City Council : As you know, I appeared at the St. Paul City Council Hearinq on September 22 , 1981 and also presented a written ob�ection to the assessment of the various Catholic church properties. From comments and observations made by various members of the City Council at that hearing on September 22 , 1981 , it appeared that there was significant support on the Council for striking the church properties from the assessment roll, because it had become evident that there was, in fact , no economic benefit (the leqal test) to these properties as a result of the proposed " improve- ment" (maintenance expense for Town Square Park) . If that is the prevailing view on the Council, and the new as- sessment roll to be considered on October 1 , 1981 still has the church properties listed, I strongly urge the members of the City Council.- to adopt a specific resolution making a finding that it has been demonstrated that these specific church properties do not, and will not , benefit from the proposed improvement and that, therefore, it is RESOLVED that the proposed assessment roll be amended by striking those specific properties from the assessment roll, prior to the motion to adopt the assessment roll, as amended. Thank you very much for your consideration of this proposal . Yours very truly, MEIER, KENNEDY, QUINN & SHUMAKER �__�`�`-� �-5 . � .- .��T -� - �_,--�._ Timoth P. Quinn� TPQ:sh cc: The Archdiocese of St . Paul & Mi neapolis The Church of The Assumption The Church of St . Louis The Church of St. Mary St . Joseph ' s Hospital EXHIBIT "II" ��5 ��/ � /S I �C�,),)� '"�;�J�J�.. ✓ �.'l.�-�� • L�--�=2"_.<.�,:.,' �"�°"..r_„� ��`�''1, �"�,` �. ��...�i=�.�� CJ1.��=-�.,� � ��l'�� . ST/s�--J � 174,�3� , t�� $ -,-,-- --��t: ToT��; �:C�E.� ��L. `` 5 � `� �:��-` ; � .�'l', i�:�:.T^ $ �'��/�,f��-''e�' :�_1..�U 99.�;. . Z � � ox�o� ; ��aC.�J�:._:�� I� 1, ��:� `'' . E r 6=7:-� s6. 1 Z t �. +,i. � � �� f SK�' �.�0, 84� �' 1.�3�� Q` � `��5�,� 44 � Cr��'� 150, 8�� , C"? '��. � I��Qa � ' ��a _ ; � 28�,�2� � mi� : � cri� , S'r '�/ ; . �C�3�22'�d $ . fl27�',68 � i 8,2� $ f � , ��3,22�� ' .c� � s`�b � 4�,458 ' ''i"G� ��`. � �5,�� ; �_�521 Gb � �,c•,a,g �. j I.�T , 1��"��,fl�� .O S 2 � �G � �4,S �O I , �_Q33645 ' �3 _ __ �s�c . z,�s �,2�9 : � .033�4� , . � �q,2�� ; _ , �_ , � � i � , � � _ � ; � '003g3l� � I � 8� ,; � . 3,43�,99� : � r i .. .. . ...... .. ... .. y . . . . . . ��.. . � �� _._ '; � 5� 9, �34 ,i . _ ,;� c�c�.�s� �,�c�� R-�� 5 �3��t3 ��.�� '. � 1SO,�4�un' @ _� ,�022�.°' = �'� 21,0�4 , �:`�� .,# ,:rt sasoLtrTt+�ai srlrso �' . CHA1QE�i�ill�F�NG �^ a �� a.��rz -�u,e;•. .. -:Cwnefl'!'l�W�. f'� ', .IA tlle ma/ta oEYh!yli�i�i�ton�' �eoatanddq�st��w�vl�MMt�N")fa� . the�ualo�aa4im anda�t�ec�tsei.` Ci��01Vlt�d='�d�'�`� ,� IoA�e�1�ffiR�•�� ' steelt�`�e�di��tr�eR�� 1iR nuota Street.and 83sth�e�t llif�d ntnntoB 3rem�ulY-ir_1lli�.lo JY�it Sp, 19tt un8�t:P�lie�:�!'1�`IIP/Il4lIA_� eivei:�.►o,a.r sr�.;�sovea:��st�� The a�rrnl��r�e�-l�� na+�t�1�s �t �' to M mrie uNi.: �F!��, in a�etlMa,w�tb-f� as�111l��Wi$�+*'�14;DI ��i��er..- .,.. 'Pi�cpl�el�Ir�e9i111iYo46-qR-�. ��f�?��i', aa��ile �t_�!4*: famd� ��`. be it .�„�:r u.i'�;.�, - � . . ' R8S0��Ili#�kfltli�$Ml�T� be and tba aP� Pr44e.d.. „v � . . -:;��-:r�. .. �= i�1w had`.oA s�l1�7lhY�R�hR j�� t�IB�h�itp�:: o'olael�:rl.�E;+ tf#�i.: Coart3�umeaeAd�ltH��ui1�'+i4�4�£�^: ty of St.Paul;.th�1 t�e Dlm�e�lx�4f��1p!*�r: Qiv�rp0�e��l��.�fl�!ie9�!�� theCh�rter�ata WQaotke P1acR o�h�T�4aetut�4 cd�tbes- mail.a�tHe t �ed�t�!'tbi�'fdt or lols�tbe �`b�na' Nft0�9`� nottce�d2!lc��•', .'�sk•_ r. tsvc•:r. �`: File No.1811i81: . `""�`` AdoD'�5q 9ie�l'�'ttt�t fl;i�98f`"' w. :1:�:. - ; . nrpro�ea n�.cav,is�t.,. °;� cAutu�i�?,1� ..,-:,� . , �� IGr f O�a�� ST. PAUL CITY COUNCIL PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE OPERATION AND MAINTENANCE SERVICE CHARGES FILE N0. 18113-81 PAGE PURPOSE To consider ratification of the service ctiarges resulting from the AND annual operatis�n and maintenance of the City owned "Town Square" LOCATION public spaces lo�ated in the area bounded by the following streets: Cedar Street, Eighth Street, Minnesota S treet, and Sixth Street. HEARING Tuesday, September 22, 1981 at 10:00 A.M. City Council Chambers, 3rd Floor City Hall - Court House SERVICE The City Council proposes to operate and maintain Town Square Park CHARGE as permitted under Chapter 429, Minnesota Statutes, Chapter 13 and 14 of the St. Paul City Charter and Ghapter 62 of the St. Paul Ad- ministrative Code. The City Council further proposes to collect the service ctiarges incurred in the operation and maintenance of Town Square Park under ttie St. Paul City Charter. The total estimated project cost for Operation and Maintenance from the period July 1, 1981, through June 30, 1982 is $624,000.00 which amount will be charged against the affected property owners, LEGAL The legal description of the parcel of land to be charged and the DESCRIPTION amount of said service charge is: AMOUNT F � Yi 'r -2- �,�l�� METHOD OF PAYMENT After ratificatfon and adoption of the service charges, in the amount indicated above, the City Clerk shall transmit a certified copy of the service charges levied herein to be extended on ttie proper tax lists of the County and collected in 1982 along with the current taxes, the said service charges to be payable in a single installment. If for wt�atever reason total payment is not made during the year 1982 then interest on the outstanding balance shall be computed at the rate of 8%. per annum, and running from the date of ratification until the date of payment. APPEAL City Council decisions are subject to appeal to ttie District Court. You must first file a notice stating the grounds for the appeal with the City Clerk within 20 days after the order adopting the service ctiarges. You must also file the same notice with the Clerk of District Court within 10 days after filing with the City Clerk. NOTE: Failure to file the required notices within the time specified shall forever prohibit an appeal from the special charges. QUESTIONS Call 292-7021 and refer to the File # above. City staff �aill be available to answer any Last minute questions on this project in Room 218 City Hall from 9:30 - 10:00 a.m, the same day as the tiearing. Notice sent by the Valuation and Assessment Division September 4, 1981 Department of Finance & Management Serv. • Room 218 City Hall - Court House St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 , , �'7�� AMOS 5.DEINARD LAW OFFICES HUGH M.MAYNARD SIDNEY LORBER M. PATRICIA SCHAFFER SIDNEY BARROWS LEONARD, STREET AND DEINARD KENNETH H.PROCHNOW HAROLD D•FIELO,JR. MICHAEL A.NEKICH ALLEN I.SAEKS 1200 NATIONAL CITY BANK BUILDING �1AME5 V. ROTH THOMAS D. FEINBERG ROBERT L.DEMAY MORRIS M.SMERMAN 510 MARQUETTE AVENUE CONSTANCE R.BARNNART GEORGE REILLY ANGELA M.BOHMANN DAVID N.cox MINNEAPOLIS, MINNESOTA SS402 JOHN R.WALD STEPHEN R.PFLAUM JOHN A.BIUMENFELD�JR. CHARLES A.MAYS TELEPHONE C612� 339-1200 PAMELA J.MORET NANCY C.DREHER TELECOPIER (612� 339-1200 ROBERT D.ARKIN LOWELL J.NOTEBOOM ROBERT P.THAVIS GEORGE F. McGUNNIGLE�JR. JAMES G.BULLARD FREDRIC T. ROSENBLATT JOSEPH M.FINLEY BVRON E.STARNS - STEVEN D.DERUYTER September LG� �9 p� GEORGE B.LEONARD CI672-1956) ALAN J.WILENSKY ARTHUR L.H.STREET CI877-1961) STEPHEN J.DAVIDSON BENEDICY DEINARD(1899-1969) STEPHEN R.LITMAN - DAVID C.ZALK OF COUNSEL EDWARD M.MOERSFELDER IRENE SCOTT ROBERT LEWIS BARROWS HAND DELI`7ERED Mayor, City Council and City Clerk 5t. Paul City Hall St. Paul, MN 55101 Re: Special Assessments for Town Square Park Operation and Maintenance Charges for the Year Ending June 30, 1382; Your File No. 18113-81; Our Fi1e No. 10-9-48 Dear Mayor, City Council and City Clerk: We are the attorneys for Saint Paul Hotel Limited Partnership and Saint Paul Parking Ramp Limited Partnership, who are the tenants of the Port Authori:ty of the City of Saint Paul under long term leases which cover the entire block bounded by 5th Street, 4th Street, St. Peter 5treet and Market Street in downtown St. Paul. The St. Paul Hotel block is comprised of th.e following five tax parcels; Parcel A = 04-63500-Og1-1Q; Parcel B = 04-6350Q-09d-10; Parcel C = 04-6350Q�05Q-1�; Parcel D = 04-7A200-051-1Q.; and Parcel E = 04-7Q20Q-050-10 . Saint Paul Hotel Limited Partnership leases the land described in Exh.ibit "A" . Saint Paul Parking Raznp Li�mited Partnership leases the land descr�lied in Exhibit "B° . Each lease requires the tenant to pay real estate taxes and special assessments. Each lease authorizes the tenant to contest real estate taxes and special assessments. We have received a Public Hearing Notice concerning special assessments for operation and znaintenance charges for Town Square Park for the year ending June 30, 1982 for Parcels A, B and C. We Mayor, City Council and City Clerk September 22, 1981 Page 2 assume that there will be similar assessments against Parcels D and E, although we have received no notice thereof. On behalf of our clients, Saint Paul Hotel Limited Partnership and Saint Paul Parking Ramp Limited Partnership, ��e object to the proposed assessments and all future assessments for Town Square Park in their entirety. Without limiting our clients to the following grounds of objection, we note the following: l. The entire St. Paul Hotel block is in the process of reconstruction. The St. Paul Hotel is being rebuilt on the land described in Exhibit "A" and will not reopen until October or November, 1982. A new parking ramp is being built on the land described in Exhibit "B" and will not open until the summer of 1�82. Thus, during the year for which the proposed assessments are being levied (the year ending June 30, 1982) the block will produce almost no income and will not benefit by Town Square Park. 2. Even when the St. Paul Hotel is reopened and its new parking ramp is opened, they will not T�e bene- fited by Town Square Park. Both will be economically damaged by Town Square Park, because the park will greatly benefit the Radisson St. Paul Hotel, the major competitor of the St. Paul Hotel. We respectfully demand that the entire St. Paul Hotel block be deleted from the assessment district for Town Square Park. Our clients ' written objection is enclosed. �Tery truly yours, LEONARD, STREET AND DETNARD ay %'��'` �. �'r��°�`O� HugFi M. Maynard HDZNt:s th Encl. ' . �� A EX�I T - LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF HOTEL PARCEL Fee Title (All Torrens) Lots 3, 4, 5, 6 and 7; The Northerly 20 feet of Lots 2 and 8; The Northerly 20 feet of the West 12 feet of Lot 9; All in Block 10, RICE AND IRVINE'S ADDITION TO ST. PAUL. Lot 6, SUBDIVISION OF LOT 10 AND THE EASTERLY 48 FEET OF LOT 9 OF BLOCK 10 IN RICE AND IRVINE' S ADDITION TO ST. PAUL. E��T 8 LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF RAMP PARCEL FEE TITLE (Torrens) - Lot 1; That part of Lot 2 lying Southerly of the Northerly 20 feet of said Lot 2; The Southerly 17 feet of the Northerly 37 feet of Lot 8; The Southerly 17 feet of the Northerly 37 feet of the west 12 feet of Lot 9; All in Block 10, RICE AND IRVINE'S ADDITION TO ST. PAUL. The Easterly 10 feet of Lot 2; Lots 3, 4, and 5; All in SUBDIVISION OF LOT 10 AND THE EASTERLY 48 FEET OF LOT 9 OF BLOCK 10 IN RICE AND IRVINE' S ADDITION TO ST. PAUL. (Abstract) That part of Lot 8 lying Southerly of the Northerly 37 feet of said Lot 8; That part of the west 12 feet of Lot 9 lying Southerly of the Northerly 37 feet of said Lot 9; All in Block 10, RICE AND IRVINE'S ADDITION TO ST. PAUL. Lot 1 and that part of Lot 2 lying Westerly of the Easterly 10 feet of said Lot 2; All in SUBDIVISION OF LOT 10 AND THE EASTERLY 48 FEET OF LOT 9 OF BLOCK 10 IN RICE AND- IRVINE' S ADDITION TO ST. PAUL. OBJECTION TO SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS St. Paul Hotel Limited Partnership and Saint Paul Parking Ramp Limited Partnership hereby object to any assessments against the following tax parcels: 04-63500-091-10; 04-63500-090-10; 04-63500-050-10; 04-70200-051-10; and 04-70200-050-10; for Town Square Park operation and maintenance for reasons stated in our attorneys' (Leonard, Street and Deinard's) September 22, 1981 letter to the Mayor, City Council and City Clerk of the City of St. Paul, P�innesota. SAINT PAUL HOTEL LIMITED PARTNFRSHIP By St. Paul Hotel Development Company, a General Partner :�� _._ . .. By �-� Ro ald &. tolpman, s President Datedc Septem5er 22� 1981 5T. PAUL P�RKING RAt�iP LIMITFD PARTNERSHIP By Saint Paul Hotel Limited Partnership, its General �artner By St. Paul Hotel Development Company, a General Partner . /� ;- '? By . /a- � ,��;��l-�� : � Ronald B. Stolpman, i Presrdent Dated: September 22, 1981 "�- r��. j MEIER, KENNEDY, QUINN & SHUMAKER The Honorable George Latimer The Honorable Members of the St. Paul City Council September 15, 1981 Page Two in the reasonable market value of the property proposed to be assessed, as a result of the proposed improvement. I am certain that the City Attorney will concur in the applicable law in this instance. Also enclosed herewith, marked "Exhibit B" and made a part hereof, is the appraisal prepared by William J. Dunn, Realtor and Appraiser, setting forth the facts in this case, namely: that each of the properties is presently being used to its highest and best use and that there is in fact no economic benefit to any of these properties. The appraisal points out that the market value of each property is not increased to any degree as a result of the pro- posed "improvement" . Mr. Dunn is a recognized expert appraiser who has appeared literally hundreds of times in district courts of Minnesota testifying in regard to these kinds of matters. Since there is no increase in the market value and there is no benefit to any of the properties the law holds that there can be no assessment levied against these properties for the proposed "improvement." The principle involved in these proposed "assessments" is a basic principle which our clients have an obligation to their constituen- cies to uphold. The amount involved in each particular assessment is not necessarily overwhelming (at this time) but for any of these institutions to acquiesce in such an "assessment" would be a prece- dent which we cannot advocate. On behalf of The Archdiocese of Saint Paul and Minneapolis, The Church of The Assumption, The Church of St. Louis, The Church of St. Mary and St. Joseph' s Hospital we respectfully request the Honorable Mayor and Members of the St. Paul City Council to strike the proposed assessments against these five properties from the assessment roll. Your consideration of this request is greatly appreciated. Yours very truly, MEIER, KENNEDY, QUINN & SHUMAKER Timoth P. Quinn TPQ:sh cc: The Archdiocese of Saint Paul a d Minneapolis The Church of The Assumption The Church of St. Louis The Church of St. Mary St. Joseph' s Hospital . . , . T0: The City of Saint Paul FROM: Timothy P. Quinn, Esq. , General Counsel The Archdiocese of Saint Paul and Minneapolis DATE: September 15 , 1981 RE: Special Assessment on Church Property ISSIIE ARE CHURCHES AND CHURCH PROPERTY SUBJECT TO A SPECIAL ASSESSMENT LEVIED FOR NONABUTTING PARK MAINTENANCE PURPOSES? DISCUSSION Minn. Const. art . 10 § 1 provides in part : Taxes shall be uniform upon the same class of subjects and shall be levied and collected for public purposes , but public burying grounds , public school houses , public hospitals, academies , colleges , uni- versities , all seminaries of learning, all churches, church property, houses of worship, institutions of purely public charity, and public property used exclusively for any public purpose, shall be exempt from taxation except as provided in this section. (Emphasis added) . Constitutional exemption from general taxation does not , tiowever , exempt such property from special assessments. 70 Am. Jur . 2d Special or Local Assessments § 65 (1973) . Exemptions from special assessments must be found, if at all , in express statutory provisions. 13A Dunnell Minn. Digest 2d Municipal Corporations § 9.04 (3d ed. 1981) . Such a statu- tory exemption from local assessments does exist with respect to public cemetery associations and did exist for railroad com- pany land. No such special exemption exists for churches or church property not used as burying grounds. EXHIBIT "A" ' ,: � �'7�7495 - The uniform taxation clause of Article 10 $ 1 is consid- ered in conjunction with Minn. Stat . § 429.051 which provides that " [t ]he cost of any improvements , or any part thereof , may be assessed upon pxoperty benefited by the improvement, based upon the benefits received. . . . " The benefit to the property from the improvement must be based upon "what increase, if any, there has been in the market value of the benefited land. " City of St. Louis Park v. Engell , 283 Minn. 309, 316, 168 N.W. 2d 3 , 8(1969) . If there has been � no increase in the market value, the special assessment is unsupported and may not be collected. That test was set forth by the Minnesota Court in 1977 when it stated: The test is whether the improvement for which the assessment was levied has increased the market value of the property, against which the assessment operates , in at least the amount of the assessment . Continental Sales & Equipment Co. v. Town of Stuntz , 257 N.W. 2d 546, 549 (Minn. 1977) . It has been suggested that such a difference in market value "should be computed by determining what a willing buyer would pay a willing seller for the property before; and then after , the improvement has been constructed. Carlson-Lang Realty Co. v. City of Windom, Minn. , 307 Minn. 368, 369, 240 N.W.2d 517 , 519 (1976) . " Nyquist v. Town of Center , Crow Wing County, 251 N.W.2d 695, G97 (Minn. 1977) . In Nyquist , the Court reversed and remanded the case for a new trial because the town board and trial court failed to base the special -2- � } assessment on a showing of a change in market value resulting from the improvement. It is , of course, true that the present use of the land is not dispositive. Market value may be calculated on the highest and best use of the land. Anderson v. City of Bemidji , 295 N.W .2d 555 (Minn. 1980) . Stated differently, "the test is whether the land could be used for purposes which would benefit from the improvement. " Village of Edina v. Joseph, 264 Minn. 84, 95, 119 N.W.2d 809, 817 (1962) , as cited in Southview � Country Club v. City of Inver Grove Heights , Dakota County , 263 N.W.2d 385, 388 (Minn. 1978) . Consequently , if the church property in the instant case is presently dedicated to its highest and best use and no benefit to the land from the improvement can be demonstrated by way of increased market value, the special assessment will not survive constitutional scrutiny. CONCLUSION The limitations on special assessments are as follows : (a) The land must receive a special benefit from the improvement being constructed, (b) the assessment must be uniform upon the same class of property, and (c) the assessment may not exceed the special benefit. *** Any special assessment which does not meet these requirements is an unconstitutional taking without compensation. (Citations omitted) . Southview Country Club v. City of Inver Grove Heights, Dakota County , 263 N.W.2d 385, 387-388 (Minn. 1978) . If it is -3- demonstrated that the existance of a distant enclosed park area in no way enhances the value of the church property upon which the special assessment is being levied, the assessment will necessarily fail. -4- • � Ur O WILLIAM J. DUNN l�ea�to� a�c� �pprai�er �� o REALTOR� � � ' APPRAI Eii SALES - APPRA15AL5 RESIDENTIAL - COMMERCIAL - INDU3TRIAL 624 COMMERCE BLJILDINC3 ST. PAULr MINNESOTA 55101 22Z-27B9 September 14, 1981 Mr. Timothy P. 4uinn Attorney at Law 430 Minnesota Building St. Paul, Minnesota 55101 Re: "Town Square Assessments" on following properties : The Catholic Youth Center 150 North Smith Avenue, St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 The Church of The Assumption 51 West Ninth Street, St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 The Church of St. Louis 506 Cedar Street, St. Paul, Minnesota 55101 The Church of St. Mary 261 East Eighth Street, St. Paul, Minnesota 55101 St. Joseph' s Hospital 69 West Exchange Street, St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Dear Mr . Quinn: Pursuant to your request, I wish to advise that I have made an in- spection of the above parcels of real estate and herewith render you the following appraisal. PURPOSE AND DATE OF THIS APPRAISAL The purpose of this appraisal is to estimate the fair market value of the above parcels of real estate as of July 14, 1981 before and after the construction, operation and maintenance of "Town Square" , and "Town Square Park" . MA RKET VALUE DEFINED Market value is defined as being the value in terms of money which a willing buyer will pay and a willing seller will accept after a "EXHIBIT B" P. 2 - Mr. Timothy P. 4uinn MARKET VALUE DEFINED (Cont'd) parcel of real estate has been exposed for sale a reasonable length of time with neither party acting under duress and both parties having full knowledge of all the uses to which the property may be put. RIGHTS TO BE APPRAISED: I am appraising the title in fee simple to the above captioned par- cels of real estate, free and clear of all incumbrances, except the usual easements for utilities. ADDRESSES OF SUBJECT PROPERTIES : 150 North Smith Avenue, St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 • 51 West Ninth Street, St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 506 Cedar Street, St. Paul, Minnesota 55101 261 East Eighth Street, St. Paul, Minnesota 55101 69 West Exchange Street, St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 ASSESSMENTS LEVIED AGAINST ABOVE FIVE PARCELS: St. Joseph' s Hospital: I.D. No. 04-14000-020-03 04-14000-092-03 04-14000-132-03 04-14000-152-03 I .D. No. 04-38000-010-58 04-38000-011-58 I .D. No. 04-64000-081-00 04-38010-010-66 04-14000-020-04 Total assessment for above parcels - $1,487 .24 Church of St. Louis: I .D. No. 04-66000-030-12 04-66000-050-12 Total assessment for above parcels - $1,473 .46 �'- +'- �r�� . , � . �: MEIER, KENNEDY, QUINN & SHUMAKER Attorneys at Law WILLIAM C. MEIER 11920-t98t1 September � 5� � 70� SUITE 430. MINNESOTA BUILDING ALO15 D. KENNEDY,JR. TIMOTHY P.QUINN SAINT PAUL. MINNESOTA 551 O1 GORDON W.SHUMAKER (6121��44 � ANDREW J. EISEN2IMMER e�;'f� �[� / � � LEO H. DEHLER �� {� � THOMAS B.WIESER r � r r `, ��"1 f�� The Honorable George Latimer � 3 '� r,r.,� Mayor of the City of Saint Paul, And ' �� E The Honorable Members of the St. Paul City Council " City Hall and Courthouse St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Re: Town Square "Assessments" (Catholic Church Properties) Dear Mayor Latimer and Members of the St. Paul City Council: The undersigned is General Counsel for The Archdiocese of Saint Paul and Minneapolis and represents the following Catholic in- stitutions in regard to the assessments proposed to be levied against the listed properties for the annual maintenance of "Town Square Park" , payable in 1982: 1 . The Catholic Youth Center 150 North Smith Avenue $ 76 .99 2 . The Church of The Assumption 51 West Ninth Street 1 ,527 . 16 3 . The Church of St. Louis 506 Cedar Street 1 ,473.46 4 . The Church of St. Mary 261 East Eighth Street 254.92 5. St. Joseph' s Hospital 69 West Exchange Street 1 ,487 .24 On behalf of the above named entities, we hereby formally ob- ject to the proposed assessments on the grounds herein set forth, and respectfully request that these assessments be stricken from the assessment roll. Enclosed herewith, marked "Exhibit A" and made a part hereof, is a formal legal opinion and position paper briefly setting forth our formal legal position that if any of these five properties, which include three churches, a youth center and a hospital, are to be assessed, it must be shown that some economic benefit will enure to these properties as a result of the proposed "improvement" (annual maintenance expense for "Town Square Park" ) . The applicable law is clear: That the economic benefit which must enure to real estate in order for an improvement to be assessed against such real estate must consist of an increase , P. 3 - Mr. Timothy P. 4uinn ASSESSMENTS I,EVIED AGAINST ABOVE FIVE PARCELS: (Cont 'd) Assumption Church: I .D, No. 04-63500-015-03 04-14000-060-09 Total assessment for above parcels - $1, 527 .16 Catholic Youth Center: I .D, No. 04-73500-070-55 - $ 76.99 St. Marv' s Church: I .D. No. 03-34000-041-02 03-34000-041-11 Total assessment for above parcels - $ 254. 92 Total of above assessments - - - - - $4, 819.77 PRESENT USE OF SUBJECT PROPERTIES : At the present time and for the past many years, the above parcels of real estate have been put to church and charitable use . HIGHEST AND BEST USE OF SUBJECT PROPERTIES: I am of the opinion that the highest and best use of subject properties is the use to which said properties have been put for the past many years. BENEFITS TO THE ABOVE PARCELS OF REAL ESTATE THROUGH THE CONSTRUCTION, OPERATION AND MAINTENANCE OF "TOWN SQUARE" AND "TOWN SQUARE PARK" : Your appraiser is of the opinion that the market value of the above parcels has not and will not be increased as a result of the con- struction, operation and maintenance of "Town Square" and "Town Square Park" and that the above parcels of real estate have not � and will not receive any benefits through the construction, opera- tion and maintenance of "Town Square" and "'Town Square Park" . This appraisal report is preliminary in nature, and a complete de- tailed appraisal report wi11 be rendered in said matter at the time formal testimony is required, but from a study made of said parcels . , '�' P. 4 - Mr. Timothy P. 4uinn BENEFITS TO THE ABOVE PARCELS OF REAL ESTATE THROUGH THE CONSTRUCTION, OPERATION AND MAINTENANCE OF "TOWN SQUARE" AND "TOWN SQUARE PA RK" : (Cont'c of real estate and their highest and best use, your appraiser, as stated above, is of the opinion that the above five p arcels of real estate have not and will not receive any benefits by the construc- tion, operation and maintenance of "Town Square" and "Town Square Park" . , Respectfully submitted, �il ' ,-=.� '-/�\�--•�r—' � �= �lilliam J. Du n,,�'A ,S.A . � .. WJD/vo � . ` r�'74�5 This Appraisal is tx:�de subject to the following limiting conditions: 1. The legal description furnished me is assumed to be correct. ' 2. I assume no responsibility for matters legal in character nor do I render any opinion as to the title which is assumed to be marketable. Liens and encumbrances, if any, have been disregarded and the property has been appraised as though free and cleax and under re- sponsible ownership and competent management. , 3. If sketches of floor plans or plota are includ ed in this report, they are to be considered only as being approximate and submitted to assist the reader in visualizing the property.I have made no survey of the property and assume no responsibility in connection with such matters. 4. The information in this report identified as being furnished to me by others is believed by me to be reliable, but I assume no responsibility for its accuracy. 6. Possession of this report or a copy thereof does not carry with it the right for publication, nor ma.y it be used for any purpose by any one but the applicant without the previous writ- ten consent of the appraiser or the applicant and in any event only with proper qualification. 6. I am not required to give testimony or attendance in court by reason of this appraisal with reference to its subject property, unless arrangements have previously been made therefor. 7. I have no present or contemplated interest in the property appraised. 8. The distribution of the total valuation in this report between land and improvements applies only under the existing program of utilization. The separate valuations for land and building must not be used in conjunction with any other appraisal and are invalid if so used. WILLIAM J. DUNN , A. S.A. R.ealtor- - - Appraiser • . . . � , ' - �`1�749� QUALIFICATIONS OF WILLIAM J. DUNN 624 COMMERCE BUILDING,ST.PAUL,MINNESOTA 55101 AS AN APPRAISER OF REAI ESTATE A.Member: St.Paul Area Board of Realtors,Inc. Minnesota Association of Realtors National Association of Realtors Tri-State Chapter 20 of American Right-of-Way Association National Association of American Right-of-Way Association Senior Member American Society of Appraisers-Twin Cities Chapter Senior Member American Society of Appraisers-National Association B.Real Estate Appraisal made for following: City of St.Paul Viilages in Ramsey County County of Ramsey ' State of Minnesota Department of Highways Department of Administration Referee in Bankruptcy at St.Paul Probate Court of Ramsey County District Court of Ramsey County Northwestern State Bank of St.Paul Northwestern National Bank of St.Paul Economic Laboratory,Inc. Housing and Redevelopment Authority of Saint Paul Miller Hospital Credit Union Northem States Power Ca Owners Attorneys Agents C.Experience: Engaged in the general real estate business since 1928, including buying, selling, appraising, managing and leasing real estate for others. Engaged in the buying and selling of real estate for myself since 1928. Appraising real estate throughout various counties in Minnesota, including Ramsey, Hennepin, Scott, Dakota and Washington Counties since 1928 for owners, agents, attorneys, courts, banks and various governmental agencies. Have been appointed a commissioner by the District Court of Ramsey County in many condemnation proceedings during past several years. Have testified as an expert on real estate values in courts and before commissions ln a number of counties in Minnesota during past several years. ��am.�r�. �� '� 5 NESLORBERD e��so LAW OFFICES HUGH M.MAYNARD � G . M. PATRICIA SCHAFFER SIDNEY BARROWS KENNETH H.PROCHNOW NAROLD D.FIELD.JR. E L RD, STREET AND DEINARD MICHAELA.NEKICH ALLEN 1.SAEKS � �� 0 NATIONAL CITY BANK BUILDING MARTMA C.BRAND TNOMAS D.FEINBER�y�Q � JAMES V.ROTM MORRIS M.SHEi7MAN 510 MARQUETTE AVENUE ROBERT L.DEMAY GEORGE REILLY � CONSTANCE R.BARNNART DAVID N.COX C,�TY CL�4� 5 d�f�l NEAPOLIB, MINNESOTA 56402 ANGELA M.BONMANN CNARLES A.MAYSUM �i ��'��, ��'��, PAMEI.A J MOR TFELD,JR. NANCV C.DRENER TELEPHONE AND TELECOPIER ROBER7 D.ARKIN LOWELL J.NOTEBOOM C612) 339-1200 ROBERT P. TMAVIS GEORGE F.McGUNNIGLE.JR. JAMES G.BULLARD FREDRIC T. ROSENBLATT JOSEPM M.FINLEV BYRON E.STARNS - STEVEN D.OERUYTER C (�p GEORGE B.LEONARD CIB72-1�56) ALAN J.WILENSKY �e tember �.1 �701 ARTMUR L.N.STREET CIB77-1961j STEPHEN J.DAVIDSON P � BENED�CT OEINARD C1899-1969J STEPHEN R.LITMAN - DAVIO C•2ALK OFCOUN3El EDWAFiD M.MOERSFELDER IRENE SCOTT ROBERT LEWIS BARROWS HAND DELIVERED Mayor, City Council Members and City Clerk St. Paul City Hall St. Paul, Minnesota 55101 Re: Special Assessments for Town Square Park Operation and Maintenance Charges for the Year Ending June 30 , 1982; Your File No. 18113-a1; Our File No. 10-9-48 Dear Mayor, City Council Members and City Clerk: Our clients Saint Paul Hotel Limited Partnership and Saint Paul Parking Ramp Limited Partnership hereby withdraw their objections to the above-described special assessment. Our clients first heard of the proposed assessment the day before the public hearing held September 22. They were naturally dismayed at the prospect of con- tributing to an indoor park four blocks away, adjacent to a major competitor, so they objected to the assessment. At the hearing, we heard of the long history of negotiations to fairly assess the costs of Town Square Park. We have discussed this with our clients and they have decided that, in the interest of cooperation with the City of St. Paul and other downtown interests, they would withdraw their objections to the proposed assessment. Very truly yours, LEONARD, STREET AND DEINARD By ?a� �r, ''h�� Hugh M. Maynard HMM/cj �� , � � . � MEIER, KENNEDY, QUINN & SHUMAKER Atlorneys al Law ALOIS D. KENNEDY'JR. 1981 September G9 � � 78� SUITE 430. MINNESOTA BUILDING TIMOTHY P. QUINN SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA 55101 GORDON W.SHUMAKER (612)226-8844 ANDREW J. EISENZIMMER LEO H. DEHLER THOMAS B.WIESER The Honorable Members of the St. Paul City Council � City Hall and Courthouse St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Re: Town Square "Assessments" (Catholic Church Properties) Dear Members of the St. Paul City Council: As you know, I appeared at the St. Paul City Council Hearing on September 22, 1981 and also presented a written ob�ection to the assessment of the various Catholic church properties. From comments and observations made by various members of the City Council at that hearing on September 22, 1981 , it appeared that there was significant support on the Council for striking the church properties from the assessment roll, because it had become evident that there was, in fact, no economic benefit (the legal test) to these properties as a result of the proposed "improve- ment" (maintenance expense for Town Square Park) . If that is the prevailing view on the Council, and the new as- sessment roll to be considered on October 1 , 1981 still has the church properties listed, I strongly urge the members of the C,ity Council to adopt a specific resolution making a finding that it has been demonstrated that these specific church properties dQ not, and will not, benefit from the proposed improvement and that, therefore, it is RESOLVED that the proposed assessment roll be amended by striking those specific properties from the assessment roll, prior to the motion to adopt the assessment roll, as amended. Thank you very much for your consideration of this proposal. Yours very truly, MEIER, KENNEDY, QUINN & SHUMAKER -�--_--.--�_ Timoth P. Quinn TPQ:sh cc: The Archdiocese of St. Paul & Mi neapolis The Church of The Assumption The Church of St . Louis The Church of St. Mary St. Joseph' s Hospital � ' m i m � � � � j , � m z m Z � a Z a o a m � 3 o v 3 Z ^ � A m y ° C 0 o a �' Z y m � Z c � � o o i (f) G1 = C 3 a � m � � � � rr �• rr � � rt ' i ro� ro I c a � ' � � � � . ,� � 3 r• r• rt � �C � N C� N N O rD fi n � x � � � 0 N ; - �� T 0 W N S Q U A R E A S S E S S M E N T P L A N 0 P E R A T I N G & M A I N T E N A N C E ; � .�t 2 - -..--k ty�.,� —_e.r�•r �•r �/ �� Y . .�ROY[--� �'—� I -- I-_.^�� _ . ' .. ._. ...' :'. . . .. \1 -. ,J........ -, .I ` , _ _ f , �J _ _ x . � : � � � / � , D �� ; \`��t < �.A ,� �..: ,, _ � � � , �. , , , , . � � � ':� {� � ;t ,. //;;-; � . ° \ ^� ��a �� . +c �� i ��.�`� �� \. `o. �a� . � �. � � - - - �� ,�: � «»...�....« !i • x/ \ (� �'l � > ' : . /� ,y ) ..�i � S .�� , �:.' J '� � �,,/� \\ � \� '� �� / `.�� / . �- � - n � -�''f M�T'1�.mA=: .: %l. �. .��.� ��/' �. �/ \ \� i�� i�/ � /.•�/:�,. ` \\• ��Y � X�AtE�`^`�T'-�NQ �� ' ��+� , �.i 9c!�: f��PA�#�►14 C�N��IPpt �� ,,�� :�' '�+ �_ � ",, ;-�� ' — � S,:',. + `4!�� % `t'f ,� s �` f'� � �' • � � � � �:;.i :,�� *J «»r � '"� . ., '"% s/ �.. ,. �::: . „ ,:.��' �.i~�v ... .i . , t � � ♦ �.J/ ��,��' - � �-..� .��,:'. . � �� i� :;.s��,.. . �-�--� �'''� y �'y� �`,j�, o t � ��',�; ` �j�'`� �. � �. � �^ . �%- kY�ir:� � `, , �i,\' i /� .�:. i .. � �� y� ,s' � �_-�%•�/ ,r - .� • ,% .�,. / � � �,� •/.�� _ ' j�` / +`,' `; r4�• ``��'/ �� 1 l'�.i' r, � P(•� � / ^y"`I,V T� • � r ,r4�' � Q ` � �', /�• � �'� __ "_ �'� �- f � _�� C _ . / '� ,� � E �.� / f j�� . �b � �' '' h, �ql ` ��' r } �N � � � d� �' / i� y� _ �.-- r :, .� � i � �.�'� i ��' a .+ /� 5 ' � �J.:,. v � /�e 'v p�, �� iW.� ' ...S��rn y� � o ` f :�.• ,fi°,. �� c',. •t � L J, �,� '��: j.. � �1 �, � � � -.�' f�' //: •.:J'� •2 i�. � [ JQ'� � � � � � � ' / � ��',4,+' S�iTM a �� • � f I ��/ y4� `�' iN � �� f,p ^ ' .•.�.•�'. ,♦ � ' 4 Ss � � . ` { � 4 ! or— . \ v�1 , . �". ' �\ ..�� / r �� e � ��w, . ^ � � /�� /• ;��j; •� ' . .•" � 1..� �-tr'` h a' /.� . �� C;. �'/ 4y� 1 • �'� �i�� \\� '/, fS� 9� � ' •Fs_�'� ' �/' 1t, '<s%"" � �, 8 . .. � C�,l• ,1 " , . . ._'--�� .��0 � / . I�A �'�,`E�E� � �?,r � , �-- „� P ^�' c .• �r,. ' � �,�j' / \. ,' , '" �+• � ��1: ' `� ♦ �' �.� f�F � �'T "c \ . . .i; ,e f� . � �' 1 ' / 1 ��,F �:� ,, , ,,�,, � B.3 , s�,c� < � �' j] �< <',��/ �.I 'J� I✓ - ' , \ I y�. ' Y`� , \�� .�L' . � � �' .��. . _ • P � _ �:'�_ ��q�- 1/ �• �. ,' r• . v f •7� Z�� l `,!ti'``�" ZONE 2 � � z01vE 3 � zorr� 4 �tY. ��ZZ r81 7°8�8 I , , �� ; r��.�� _�__.__ __ ._� ___._.__---_.___..._. __._._ __.________ ._,.�...__ _..___ __$_3_I _._-_� _._� __._. _. ..__ --, ___._ -----___��_��,jt ___.��..� �.. __ ____� _.._,. ....__. ._ ._____._._ _ ____ __._.___._____�.____-.--_ _.._ _._.�______._ ___.___��_M_____�2��_Qs,,�______.___..___..___.� ___ __ ._ _._ _.---------� ____._. _A_.-----._._:__.._ ._.�___._._. _______._______.__�.___._._.___..__.__._____ __ _ __ ______..___._._._M. _�__..�R�.__.___.____ ---A��._.________.__...__��,�_..._. ,..__..�._._��._Q_____�__�___._w��'2.��2�U��"__.___.�.�_ _ °' �__�_��.5��3�..___.__ . _.---._.___.w__.________._��_ --- _..____.___,�_ __..____._..___.____.___.___. __._Y...__ _--____._..�:_.-�__�.�__`�. �` .. t 6 ��° �.�,3�,?��a� � �_i_�,.�.3�.�.___ _____.___._.._.______._..__. �x� �� .._�_a�.___.__.___._.______..__.____._______�__�..a.__...�._._.� �_v..__ _____.._._._._..�...G�?5�.�...�.__._....._._.__ ____._.._.__.__._____..____.___._.__._._.__._.__._._.__.__.___��_..---____. ___.._.__._________._._._.____._._._� _ ___ _�_____,�a..._.��(Z2.2.�'_.___._.1�.,23�,�_l..a'_�__..__...__.._��4.�_� ____.____�_._.._.__.___. ZoN�� _�_�_....s�L. .4_�°I 3� a'_..�, � s i �,4_`��.___�1�_!,.� �. ��.._._______._�____.__..�.__�.c�.t�_��.._ _..�.__��_.._��.��2�� 2d'_.�._.4._�.��3��'_.__ � ___►4�..�..a�__. _._.__.__ __._.__.__._.__.�C��L.___�____._______.�._.__.______ __.._______.��1_4�,�t_�°_'__�_._��C�.2ti.4.,.�.�_�. � �! ' I F� F-' � N l� l� O� f-� � K�� . ln N W ln OOOO � � 0 O - O O O O O O O w �I ' G O � 00� � � � i � I I :� � �° I �� .P O� V O V �� C!] (/7 W I-��•,'- .. F� ft {� O� � �O O W �O O� �j, r't � � N ! �O W! �O O O O O lJ� � �i (D O ' 00 �O 0000 V N � W fD O � O O `C �'�' I 1 �' y _ ' � � ~ � �wN w � wrnrn v . t-r l N O .. .. .. .. � .. .. .. � :�Cp W ' W O d� V O W l.n N �O ', 1-h �v O O ,00 V 00000� I--� � I p O 00 �O OOOON V . �i J I I . � O n r+ £ 9 '� x N x r tTf 'y t� cn cn �d cn cn � C� c� ►d c., c, c� n+ � w • w C w C �• � a? � E � w � 4 a o � w su w i--� � r-n !� r-� :: rr rr n�C r��• 9 c� H Oo cD �-+• m C� H N m �C m f� C) H r• � m �C � � t� pq f''• O O r. fD (D • "i (� O :") O O � f� o f� O O fJ fD �-S (D fD O O �-n cr N �-t W N- W � n tn r �-t ri ri O K cn rt rt . r� rt fn rr '� 'd O 't7 [n rr O K � O rt c-r � N I '� r* ^• � � � r � c� R cu n c�r � m c� r c� �n rr w n G r- r� o o t� ,-r h- ^. O R rt I--' W K �C F-� CY � ti !�'• !-' K K 1-' K K F-' � C) � F� K r! � b� ^ rr � p"t 7 QQ (D 'L3 G rt fD C) 'b 'C7 R OG .� �. • v 'H] � 'L3 (D f, fT (D 'C7 (D (D [Tl � f� TJ Q� CJ Cn � N C7 `4� C�7 CJ C7 fD R c. L 0 F'a �t C �': G W • N � N � *t F-� � N t`� I� rS < rt fD N 0� Y. K F-� >C f� m W �: N t=i � � - a n x r• m N v. • w (� n K �C o� �" co �o N G Y. U4 Cro �G a v, c: -, �t � a� n m �n � n r� m r� m < m a u� w � c� �o m r� �..°� r• .n t �u sr v, .n rt a� �n x a 2s • �• a� cn I a a � r G b sr m v, m ;�, a • t� �. u� � m • n � � �a k n N rt G �-n r• cn r� � �t fr � rn co � � C� r• N• r-n 1 f u�i 1 A rn't7 �' K 't7 ri rn A G � rn r-t -,t�.L�o � cD rt N � O rr �• C "U N• r* A� 'ri tn �-�r tT.' tn m I-'• 'rt Cv u� t�• R. � G ,�d . � µ .� � . r-+ �v m • �: G �C � • tri � w r• tli '� cn n r•ov � '� '� 'o ao x oo � oo �� r � y � r m � � � � m � � � � (� . 'J Ip (f. F'�' (!� n � C) � V. p PJ fD (D (D O N � ' tA :, tA (p � (D U1 ..� . . rt N rt � N n � � y I � � N � N i�-' � I . V �F-' I--' N O� ln � I--' ,�OD N: ' ` .P N�� W W .4� O� � �� (V p O 00 N 0000 �' ln O 00 . Oo OOOON� O� I I I l I `. � ' � � � I I I � i ' � 1 I � , i � ! rt I I ! � . � � ! , 1 , i � , � � � � ` � ! � � � i � I ; ; � � li , ! , � ! i � N I I 4 � � 1 I � i I , � ; � 1 � N � . � � f ' � , ! � , , � I � . � j � � � � i � i ` + � � � 11 i ! � , � � . ., • � N o� o. c� o ., �o ao 00 �o in � � i. 00 0 o rn rno � � 00 0 0 � � o 0 � K � m n cn 5'' rt W O OO N � fD 1 W fD � u, w �v •e rr 0 0 0 0 - 00 � � o a;� � . , ; ; • ., r � � � o a� w w o �o � ►-n � �i-�oo rn w w � 00o v, cno 000 0 00 . i ' o � r ro r N r cn c� cn �n �n ro � �-d � r� r� ro rn � c� �-+,. � o w o w o � ro �n �o �o r-� w r � N ►� w N w r �-n c� H w N �e w �• w c� H � � n � n c� H � � G c� H w cu �u �C c� �- co r- O O M p. fi W O P- O O � rf G G G O O � O � O O M C C r'i C O C C� _ t!� rt O W O F� K W U� rt ri W �S ri K cn rY C�' ►i �' tn rt O W W O N K G N r► w � r� � � r* w r- r- r- N• rr w w r- r► w �i rr rt N r* i-* 1-' � OG F-'00 K F--� rt F'- c't rt rr F� � r't � F-' � O O F+ O �"t O tzi 'b N 'd �C � �C �C 'd OQ fD 't7 ri ►'i ri (D rt G m r m a n a�s r� m cn n m ro �cs co r� cu n �c w n o x o w o w o n ro w �n � � c� n � � w c� n ►-� x � � w �n cu t=s � c, �v � x � w � � � n o �-* x � r* w x m �o o �-r k rt �-1- x a � v� a �o x' xKr: v� � � � � � m � � n mt �u � � wK w �n w � a� �n a n m o n m m .n a� ro cn c� .o w � r* � a� K �n m � - � tn � E t�i • w �-c � �-c • � • w • � • rr u� �-t • rr � o0 00 (p r► rn w �G rr n T1 w m rn � �n o cu w rn (D u, ro n ri O4 r�h`C O W f� R'+ (D ct 09 R+ N rh K (� [Y+ rt �-t (D O • rr rt F+• �o :Y o � � ai � � [�f �v � � m �i N •�-:; [rJ tn � £ m f� Oa �n >C N m G X C . . yS tn G Oo W ►t x' Q� fD N 'O � tn fD 'U 'O 'O 'd N 'O fD 0o P� I9 �C (D �t 'O (D O tD K 'L7 (D rr t� m l'� � ►i < h� � F-� � C 1-� n tn W DC � o m cn C W N- �n t� N N• r• o � 'tl R7 U1 (D (rD{ F'• n (D (D (D fD f7 (D U� OQ ".� f-' � G (D � fn ffi ' (D fp rt � U1 i�+- • x N ID "d (� N � N N -- F-' I--� N N V W .� 00 A W v V I--' O� F-' N �O O O O I-� t-� O O O O 0o O� O ;} ! N , R � . K fD � (D '.3 rt , � N I • Q' � „ �� . , N I-' f-' 'J • O O O O O O O � , O O O O O O �� N � Y � � � xn l� N F-' t� ri 1 (D O 0000 00 1 ��4' c'�'t O O O O O O O R+ r ; � 0 � N N I--� �"h '. . rt O i-� t-� W Cn tn O O O O O • O O O O O O O C� H Htd � �dbd � W c� H v� r � � c� zcnr�, rL. t� nc� ro �ntnG� hiEL� rn 0 0 � � � w r� w G o o x r� w w o G c .n o w X o o m -o m n w w ro - rn v, rr n n. a.�t a�• N• m rr � � m n p cr v � u� m rr � � n w n o �t oo � N- n w �u o0 0o n o0 o N rr w E m � m rr �b W n � r� � x � C G n m r� n � n • • o • n a. � w � • K N• �b ►t n o o r• m N• � o u� K r� v � ►-� r• �cs � �n v w v� w � o o � � � � n a �° w fD Gd O � � N � ri � fD L� fD R'+ ri [� �' !D !D ►t O F� W �-i fD tn F-� 1 F-� by rt �-+ � rr rr rr (D �-t f� n tn o rr tn � � � w tn tD G G. 't7 f� n rt n "d � O G rt �'i rt p. W r"i fD � G� � R OG O F'• U]00 Q� N fD W fD W � �n (D (n � fD !n (D 1 W In rt fD K rt fD r► W (D F-� ,a . p . . x . f+. rr .n K rr n (� N � �-t � C N• w C tu � n �C � N a C `G ri f� C A� tn I--� rt ►i O QO (D A� 'O O i-�• F-� F-�• (D fJ ri ►-'� . w � a+ a+ sr sr v, m w H w N• C C cu � oo v � � � � • ,cr n w � n R v, n v, o r• w � r* ru N x co ►� w rr o0 m n fD �t (n ro �t • m o cn p n I--� m N R. w "c3 N a+ �-+, F-� r• fD ri fD C K fD R^ 't7 F�• (D rt 1-� N (D f) ri � O �1 • G �v �rs N•�o ni m r�r, u� N m ' v, p o N w 'n o w w v � w 7y o n r• t� cn u, G � cn O tT� f� W !-�00 F+• fD O C� (D 1 fD rt 'CS 0o t�] ►i n � n w m n rr rr a. •o• ro x ny � C v�i � E w � ��-r � w n ro � 'L7 � O P> �'t OG 7 � (� !D O � � N F+• N OG fD O V� tn tn 0'� rt O � U� 7C � � rt N t�] ►t 't7 K x t=7 � • F�. 'O x m � b � N N m N -_ o rn w V N F-� V V � O O O O O O 0 0 0 0 , i � ,. '� . � , rt , w n � � .; � � R � I N I { n � _ _�...—,..,�.�----^�-_-�.--_,--.-��,.. _ �.r,.s,...A..-.---°-,�-._--,._T.�•� .. _ _ ��^�rm�:we: � / � � . � ! l� l--� ln O ' N � O O �O ln C� V�i � O O O O � � � ' N fD i ; + W F-' h' i, � � \O N � v �O �'Tr' � I-+ O O � � O ; E (D � O O O O R� fD ln O O O O O �C r7 � , :,,. � i � •j ; 1 ! ' � � � � �r I-+ C N v d� O � O u tr v Ffi � lJ� O Vl U7 � - ... �(7 . lJ1 F1 . O O O i O O O O O ' , ' � � £ £ x � cnrarac� �ic� r� ro �n � �dHroa9 0 w m c �* rt � � r-� � �- � n �o w n n w a a �-+, cr rr a � m � m m �o r• � c� y o w � o w �t � � M c� fD cu c7 H n w p� n C� C� C� I-� rt o o v n w rY, C K F'• r� r• o n n o o � � . . . rr � m �r co cu ov m c� o � � � !n tn r-r � ri (D n R� [� (D m F-' f�' � • � rt Q+ rr N � � 1 I 1 F�- R. F-� re K � tn t� tn F� C) C� 'c7 (D (D F'- R'+ �t 2+ td �d v� � o � x tTJ x H w E (0 9 (n � � o rr K G m m c� r--1 m � � r� C m n w n a. �C � �* � � w w GT �. rf E �-t � rr c� G cn 9 � �t rr � �o C� w � �C rr fD r w c� r* C c� w co cn w c� � � t-� r-r N• � a. v� oo cn K w � n .n p � o co m C � .n N � C*� rt rr G • tn (D � m fi (D �-S � � � c � o w � x � co � n, w I m w w n K sr -o r• K w n E � rt n �-y m .. co cn < w N• c� � m m x c� b � �n r• � .� �v t� � y �o h7 m. .. c� cn w n � oo cn x m 0 o a o �"'::• n m � m � �o �n � w O O cn rt N W rn rr c� � I i-r � � �p • rr (D O fn !-'- r't (D (!: (D � � [zj (� fn �Y OQ 'd � . �C a 'd v - (� � � N � (p 1W VI ln t-' N .. (,n f.a� N 00 � C!� _' , pp Ui W O O F-' O O O Q O O ' _� ;; . N � � � �5 • � ' . � n � � � ! N I 1 R. t 1 1 I � � ; �. � � i � � . ; . �; ,, , - - � � �'�'�4Q5 . N 1—+ V N �' t O O� N 'A'. i I—� W O O; l� W O �, ; • ;N, ; . � ! x i• � ' 1 , F-' ' V F-' CA CA � . � � w o r r* � n w w o w m N W O �C rt i f2+ . i �.N ��, � � � �-' [v oo 'O . .. � V p N ;, � • Oo W p OD � p `�1'. . i ' : � '�' H H r G� ri ty C7 H H H :' ' O w • t-�t c�-t � C� p u�i C� H f�i tn f�i � O p � tn w w a o m � o 0 o m o w � tu w N- ►� F-� � cn K rt v, rr H � .t � �� n �, �* w w r* m w w r* u� rt � � o b '� �rs ~ � b ~ r`�- ��_N w aµ. w t� u� co �' �n cr m c� � � m � t-� co � � � F rt rt � ri ti o0 0o rr rr rr I�- OQ 'd rw-r cn F��- cn N i I K (D ►�t �-t Q. � o�o w � w � � w .� w � w w 'n x � v�i � d n ►�t � � io u�, �a 'd �1 G '=i cn f� F�- rr �-t fD n � °o w °o � � � n w a' w . m cr � rc �s n t-� CJ rr � N 5�C � � � R+ C�i � 'd `G O "d O QO V�i Ui `�C rr SC lp F'• µ •d a � �o � � � _ � . � � c� ; W � N , V W O i I � W p p � O O • ( . ' � �� , rt • � `� i w � rt . � (n , � n � N � ' fD r ` �:, - j ';;� �'., � . 1 Bud et BOMA City Cleaning Expense Wages $ 57,100 $ 46,380 * $ 44,680 Contracts 10,400 7,600 * 9,000 67,500 53,980 * 53,680 Electrical Expense MTC & Supplies 1,000 -0- * 1,000 Lite bulbs 3,300 2,000 � 3,300 4,300 2,000 * 4,300 HVAC Expense Wages 10,000 20,000 * 10,000 Mtc. & Suplies 10,900 -0- , * 2,575 � 20,900 20,000 * 12,575 Elevator Expense ' Mtc. & Supplies 1,300 1,300 * 1,300 Contract Service 11,400 10,000 . * 9,350 12,700 11,300 * 10,650 Plumbing Expense Mtc. & Supplies . 3,800 3,800 *. 3,800 Contract Wages 17,600 -0- * 13,100 21,400 3,800 * 16,900 Security Expense Delta Service 2,500 2,500 * 2,500 Security Service 5,900 900 * 3,000 8,400 3,400 * 5,500 General Operating Expense 2,600 2,600 * 2,600 Building Mtc. & Repair . - Wages etc. 1,900 100 � 1,900 Mtc. & Supplies 2,100 2,100 * 2,100 4,000 2,200 * 4,000 Energy Chilled/Hot Water 44,700 31,400 42,510 Electricity 21,200 20,150 ` 20,590 6�,900 51,550 63,100 Water 4,100 3,000 * 1,450 Insurance . 8,100 8,100 * 8,100 Landscaping 42,034 42,034 * 42,034 � �'7'74��► Page -2- Budget BOMA C3ty Administration Management Contract 10,500 -0- 10,500 Pro3ect Exp. 6,500 -0- 6,50d �.�,000 -o- 1�,000 Totals: $278,934 $203,964 $241,7$9 NOTE: (*) Items City and BOMA agree on after City recommendation put together. IG� 1 / �a�V :<�::.:,,,::�::;. <�`��Tr �.��- ' CITY OF SAINT PAUL �'�a` �'��% =o `�`� _ . DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY SERVICES ; ,- :;;� . �'� ..�Ifl� �; 4IFI i 11 � c+.� ;a �--�` ,,,_ DIVISION OF PARKS AND RECREAT(ON ��`''�tf� •.s• � TOWN SQUARE PARK ,:=�:,R.•.�:�`` GEORGE LATIMER 445 Minnesota St., Saint Paul,Minnesota 55101 MAYOR . 612-227-3307 A SvRVEY QUES'TIO:�I�IRE FOR TOjVN SRIJARE PARK. � � 1. WHAT CITY ARE YOL? FI�i? ' ,, MPLS. SI'.PAL'L: �` y_ ;rSPLS.S[JF3. ST.PAUL Ori�t . 2. P��IAT AGE Q�uOP 1X� �'OU BELp�,'G �0? 0 - 20-- - 20 - 40 40 - �60 60 8�JVER � • 3. OCCUPATION � . 4. WHAT BR�OUGHT YOU TO �jVN SQI.JARE P�RK G�DE'Vi S �AY? , , �•SEE IT FOR TI� F�RST TIME 1i0 SEE IT AGAIN � A PREVIOi�S VISIT , � TD SEE A PII��ORMEIA'CE WAS SHOPPIl�G LIES'CTRE TI11�TE BEF�ORE OR �FI'EF3, A EUSINFSS APPOINi��I' WORK DO�VI�PPOjVN . TO EAT I��i OR SNACK . 5. DO YOU VISIT S'IbRFS OUTSIDE OF �SYN SQUARE TrIAI�, �YHILE DOjYN'POj1'N'? YES NO 6. w�iERE SYILL YOU GO �TF�. YOUR VISIT 1�0 ��ti�T SQiTARE PARK? � � HQ'�iE , BACK TO �i'ORK SHOPPING � � Orl�iII� � � 7. DO YOU jYORK�IN A SCTRR,OUNDI�IG D0�1'I�TPO�YN BUSII�TESS? YES NO 8. DOFS ��'VN �QIJ� PARK It�E,T YOUR �YPECTATIUiVS? YES 1�T0 ' Oa1��1IINTS 9. DO YOU F�L THAT THIS PARK �-LAS B�N BII�iEFICIAL � D0�1iI�TI'OS4N SSIn'T PAUL? . (entertazi�nt �vise, develoi�nent wise, etc. ) YES NO �`,;;.''N`� ,:uuutta;... . - .<:>`�t=r �°r:;, CITY OF SAINT PAUL �� 4 � �� ,�P � ;r�'' . . �o ;,� �; . DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY SERVICES =� *nn�Fr,m - :� iu�t_�t sg�i �,� ;.. DIVISIUN OF PARKS AND RECREATION .,,. ��,,. •.,.�,..��'�^ • TOWN SQUARE PARK 'L•:t:;r:•:::.^-... . GEORCE LATIMER - 445 Minnesota St., Saint Paul,Minnesota 55101 MAYOR � 612-227-3307 SCTR,UEY RESULTS T0�9I�T SQUAR.E PARK SURVEY TAF�N TfiCJR.SDAY, SZ�'I�1fBER. 17, 1981 , . Intervi�ws �Tere made by Park staff of incoming visitors of the G�,rden Ievel of Town Squaxe. A total of 160 people were questioned. � •�� jVhat City are you from? Age Group St. Paul 42 Jo 0-20 12°Jo St. Paul S�.ibuz'b 15 0 20-40 45°Jo Minneapolis 11% 40-60 24% � I�Iinneapolis Suburb 15% • 60 + 19;'0 Out of State 1?% � � • � . �Yha.t brought you to Tow� Square? To eat lunch/snack 31% Visiting gardens 19% First visit 150 Performance 11� � . Shopping ?% Work downtown 7% , � Leisure � 5% . • Other( study, etc. ) 5% . Do you visit stores outside of Town Square hiall While Downtown? Yes 74q'o . No 26% lYhere will you go a,�ter leaving Town Squaxe? Ba.ck to �rnrk 43ro ' ' Shopping 15`�0 Hane - 3�% � Other 8 0 Work Do�vntov�n? YES-50p NO-50O7o Does To�cn Square Park meet your expectations? � I'es 98°fo No 2°Jo Do you feel tha.t this Park has been beneficiai to Da�vnto�vn St. Pa.ul? YFS 99.3 0 . � � NO .7% . �O . . _----_ • � ., . '+' � . 2�7'74�� ""`°��°'°"�� C I TY O F SA I NT PA U L _a�`t t i r o�Li4. ' ~� '"' '�' DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY SERVICES �o .f. _:�. �; '� �uurnm� •= %� "" �i�" '= DIVISION OF PARKS AND RECREATION ;. ..°� �`�o,,. ,... �' . TOWN SQUARE PARK �,�m..��° GEORGE LATIMER 445 Minnesota St.,Saint Paul,Minnesota 55101 MAYOR 612-227-3307 August 20, 1981 M E M 0 R A N D U M T0: Mark Senn, PED & Robert P. Piram FROM: John Poor, Town Square Park _ SUBJECT: Promotion Advisory Committee - Year 2 budget , Attached is the Year 2 program budget outline as presente� to the Town Square Promotion and advisory committee on Thursday, August 6, 1981. The breakdown and logic is as follows: Program performance fees @ $2,000= $16,000 � (8 month figure) - this represents a reduction by approximately $1,000 per month form the year 1 budget of $3,000 per month. This was reduced because we now have a better access to free performances and use more of them to offset program costs. � October - 1 year anniversary month $3,500 necessitated due to our extensive involvement in the homecoming "81" celebration. . June, July and August @ $1,000 per month $3,000 total was reduced from � � year l due to the reduced activity during the summer months. Proposed programming year II $22,500 was reduced from budgeted year I amount of $29,370. The actual spent in year I was about $26,000 based on a 10 month year, so the year II reductions represent significant cuts. Thirty-Seven Hundred and Fifty Dollars were budgeted for the schedule of events that are distributed to the public. We have reduced this figure significantly by combining 4 months into 2 calendars ( a 2-month calendar} during the summer months when there is less activity. Information negatives at $1,591 reflects a significant reduction when - compared to year 1. These are a series of -three identical negatives approximately 9" x 12" that are placed in the information pylons on three levels and advertise the daily activities in the park. This amount �O � � �'�4�5 Memo Page 2 to: Mark Senn fr: John Poor 8/21/81 was reduced significantly from the }iear 1 actual cost of $43.-- per printing. The cost per print remains the same but we have changed the format to get more mileage out of each one. Previously they were printed for "the week of". Many weeks there was space still available . on the printed negative. We now label it "up coming events" and put as many days events as possible and thereby enabling us to reduce from 52 printings per year to approximately 37. We will also check into � bidding printing for further reduction in cost. Miscellaneous $1,500 is the daily small items needed like microphone � batteries, materials for programs such as making Christmas decorations, repairing sound equipment, piano tuning etc. Amounts based on actual experience. Piano - $2,000 - a new piano is needed. Ours is the laughing stock of the musieians uniun. Our present one belongs to Parks & Recreation and is committed to other locations and is in need of extensive repairs. r Choir Risers - $450.00 for three sections. Risers get extensive use � throughout the year. To date, we have been using two sections belonging to Parks & Recreation; but they are not always available. Reel-to-Reel Tape Recorder/Player $500.00. Many of the performance groups entertain- ing in Town Square require this type of equipment. It is used extensively by the true professionals,dance schools, fastiion show coordinators, etc. Many good groups have turned us down because of thP lack of this piece of equipment. The bottom paragraph is self explanatory. It is and has been my understanding for some time that all costs for programming and related activities will be paid from rental income and likewise the e�cess income should also be used at programming's discression (for lack of a better word) . We have worked very hard on the rental income program during year I with the understanding that it was to affect programming. If that changed, it may well reduce the incentive _ to generate rental income. The bottom line of this memo is that Jim Miller and Company-the select group comprising the Town Square Programming Advisory Committee are forwarding a recommendation to the Mayor's Office that the program budget be reduced from $22,500 for actual programming to $9,000 or to $500.00 per month with the exception of October. Should this recommendation be accepted by the city, I would recommend that we either hire another additional person to attempt to secure free programming or that we forget programming altogether. Mediocrity many .times, is worse th an nothing. If we don't have the money or tools to do things right then lets not do a lousy job--lets not do it at all. t1e have a fine facility and I believe that we have produced a fantastic number of quality programs for a small amount of money during our first year. 1 Memo Page 3 fr: to: 8/21/81 As the advisory committee is advisory on1y, I would suggest that we set aside their recommendation and go on with planning programs as outlined in the year II budget. It appears that the advisory committee's sole goal is to reduce the amount spent on programming and maximize the rental income only for the benefit of reducing the operations and maintenance budget. Within this committee there appears to be no concern over the quality or content of programs, only a concern of how much money can be derived from rental income. Income projections were also discussed. Regular rentals for year II were projected to produce about $50,000.00 net. Another area of great concern by the committee is the dead end near Scandia Crossing that has gone unused for a year. We are loosing income due to this space not being used or finished. This area should produce income in the neighborhood of $18,000.00 and needs immediate attention. mkv , �� , � � � ��"` CITY OF SAINT PAUL :1.��L�T� h, . V h �II �R�� '� ,�-'" �r. DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY SERVICES :., ��t;um s� �utj/it�tt�I �" ;'° ^5' DIVISION OF PARKS AND RECREATION ��`"^ "',' � TOWN SQUARE PARK '��Illq\\1��`� GEOItGL LAl'IMEK 445 Minnesota St., Saint Paul,Minnesota 55101 MAYOR 612-227-3307 YEAR II PROGRAM BUDGET OUTLINE AUGUST 1, 1981- AUGUST 1, 1982 Program performance fees 8 months @ $2,000 16, 000 Anniversary month- October 3, 500 June, July, August 3, 000 Total performance cost $22,500 Printing costs 10 monthly program calendars $ 3,750.00 37 infonnation negatives $ 1,591.00 � Total printing costs $5, 341.00 SUBTOTAL $27, 841.00 Micellaneous-repairs, film, batteries, . Christmas decorations, etc. $ 1,500.00 �'�-�O $ 2,000.00 Choir risers $ 480.00 Reel to reel tape $ 500.00 $4, 480.00 TOTAL YEAR II PROGRAM BUDGET $32,321.00 ' 11ny money in excess of the above amount will be used for purchase or repair of rental equipment, including tables, chairs, kitchen accessories. °�4 . , ''�� `7�4'9� �` � CITY 0�= S��iN C PAUL �\TY ' - I S :.. -�� _^ i DLPARTMEtiT OF CO;�i�ti�iUVITY SERVICES ,., : . + � � 1! ?31�(II y�' . . '`=•��':�" ;= DlV1510N OF PARKS AtiD RE(:RFATION J TO�VN SQUARE PARK • �1�t5 ��r;:cs�ta. St., Saint Paul, Minnesota 55101 GFURGE L.AT1;�1ER 6�2-227-3307 ` n!Al'OR � � �� R �, l�, _� September 18,� 1�81 � � ICE�UFQ �i � S�A 2� 1581 '' � . . N ,ti y Mr. James Piillar, Chaii�m:in • � Town Square Progr,�m and Fromotion .�dvisory C�?mmittee Cv 13�� Americati �T3t1_O[1.31 13:�nk Bld;;. .�i' �7 St. Paul, PiN 55101 Dear Mr. rtiller: � The To�an Square Progr��m and Promotion Advisory Committee has been very helpful during the past year and �.�e have received many fine ideas to assist. us in proyiding e£fective, efficient programming at Town Square. Those members �.ho have stuck �oith us are to be commencled for the time and e£fort they have contributed. The primary fUI1Ct1011 ��f tliis committee is to work �oith us to ensure that the programming for Toc.�n Square is of good quality, appropriate for the facility aild pruperl�' promoted. I�owever, I �in very concerned about the apparent preoccupation of the committee with the issue;of operation and mainten.�ilce costs for Town Square. . Frankly, I �.�as surpris�d t,�h��n the committee recommended a programming ` budget of $500 per month rather than the $2000 per month included in the proposed 1'ear II To�an Squ:�re budaet. The only reason for this recommendation would seem to be the diversion of rental revenues from programming to reduce ��peration ai�d maintenance expenses. This action " seems questionable in light of the Program Blld PLOI110t1AI1 Advisory Conunittee's role of prorioting pru�ranu-ning. Over the p�riod ��e have gro�ranmied To�an Square, every effort has been made to provide quality programs at a reasonable cost. As you may recall, our first year of prooramming was done with a budget of $29,370-- a substantial reduction frum ti�e $65,000 projected earlier. This April it �aas agreed by all, including the Program and Promotion Advisory Committee, that effectivc� imme3iately To�,m Square programming would be a self-sustaining bud��t usi�i� rental profits. In fact, to reduce the deficit in the overa.11 op�r:�tions budget at yearend (July 31) , �oe transferred rental incom� profits to cover the Year I programming. �:�.��..� .. � � to: r1r. James �tiller Page 2 fr: Jolin Poor 9/18/S1 Our proposed budget far Year II was prepared by looking at each months` needs, activities and the season; cae also considered tlie kno:�Ied�e gained by our staff in Year I on obtaining free entertainment. The budget for Iear II �.as reduced by approaimately 24% for actual programs, a significant reducti��n. ' Additional cuts have been made since the �lugust 6, meeting �ahich cut the costs ior prinLing by nore than 50%. I believe our budget, as prepared, �oas �aell within our capabilities of producing using projected rental profits. �,�e liave and �,rill continue to operate �oith the understanding that programming will Ue paid Uy rental profits and that the basic reason for rentals is to produce income for programming. � The Program,�iing and Fromotion Advisory Committee h.i.s been helpful many times with good sound recommendations on various items. Hocaever, on this parti.cular issue I do not agree �aith the recommendation and have instructed nry staff to proceed �aith programming at the pre-planned bud�et level. We ha��e reduced the do�.ntown cur�munity's burden foi `all programming - e�penses and toill coiitinue to do this, but to tie our hands by eliminating most pro�raT�ming or the incentive for programming this .fine facility in a proper tnanner is not acceptable. Sincerely, � � � .c`/ _(,/ �z.i/ Johnf W. Puor Planager, Toc�n Sqiiare Park cc: rlayor Latimer Thomas I:elley - Ro t Piram riark enn mkv ,..`. . �' � . . , � . _ .. . `� , �,. Y:�/ .. •., � . .. . � , . . . � .! . ! �.. ' ... . .. .. � . ', � . . . � / ' .. ' . ' • • .. ' , . . . . . � . . . r � : , � . . , ;��-�� - . � -, ; .�. r � , , � . ,y , , . .. . . . � . � . . . . ' . .. , � . . . . -�' . �� .t� .. ,.. � ' � . . ' . .. . , . . ... . . . ! 3'. . , . . � � , . ,\ . . . . . . ' . �. . . � . . . ' .. " .. 1 . . . .. . . . . \ . ^ � � . . . �� . _ , � , - ;� . � � . �. . � � ." . ' � � . \. . ' '.1 , . . . , � . . . . . ... . . - . . � \� � � . � .. . . ,� � � . . . ' . . ' , ' . •� � ' . _ . . .. � ; /. � . .% - . � � . � � . . � � . . . . . . . -. .. i`' • � . + : � , 1 . i . ' . � � .. � - . , • . . . . � . . .�-" . . , . . . � � .,�� ,. � . , . , �. " - � .. � . � - - � . � . : e . . . �. .' . . . � � I:. . .. . . . . .. . . � . . . .. ,. / zl . �•-t � ... . . . , � . . � � . -� � .� , � . �. . � .. . . _. . .� ..� . .. . � . � � . r �L�. .. . .. . � ' � � . . �. , - �,��. . , . . , . . . . .� , , . � . . , . , Septembe� 22i ],f�81 ' ` � _ , . �, �� : .� � , �° � " ' . , ' Coumnc3lm�n G�rge �iCI�hon ' - Cha�rme�n, Finance,,�lsaegement b Persom�� Co�tt� � � `�'. . , ; ?t�i Floor, City.Hall ,� ,.__ � � , , . ,.�;� � , , ,� . Dear Cauueilma�c -MaMabons , � ' : � . . � The -City Covncil, �sl.d over to Octobrx Ut� l�st, a �Re�o}�u�iic�n � � Ratifying 3ervice Chax�es fo� the arinua). opere►tion ar� - � ' ' ; :, , tq�311teli�uiCe ,COSt� for' the C3ty�wtl6d "TO�iA 3qtt�lY'e" pi1b13.0 , `.. ' spseea Xocated in the_ ar�a boudded by Ce��s Sighth, Mianesfl�s . and Sixth $treets under P.O. 27�95�. �he pub�;3� ha�ri.�iS aa ,• . ; thia item wa,s concluded at tc�dqy•s •Cousrcil meeting� at�d'the� y " �` � .i matter �ras re�errtd to the- Firiance, A�aasp�cment 8o Personi�ei' Committqe. - . . � ! . � ti ' �i�x�y�tru].�* y+o�s, '. . . . � . , � - , , ;. � � � � � . �� Albert� B. Ola�n�: � � , • ,� � � � � � � � � � _ � � City��Clerk � � � �. ! , � � , � � � � . � � � � ' . � . � . �� . . _ . r�. . - .. . .. . . \ �� , .. . � . . . 1 . � � �-,� A�:l.$ ; . ,� . Y� - , CC i �'1ROACQ, ��i• '� � � p$D ` � . 1 . � : ', �y � � � , �City Attorney , . � " . ' ' � - . � ,;. � : " �; � � , y�;: � � � � � , � � � � � , � , , _ , � , � ,. - , r :� �� r � • , , :` �? _ , / . � � ' � _ � ' % �� -� �',' � . . � � . , . . . . . . � � . -�, s `- . . . . . � � . . �r . . . . '� . . 37 , y, , . . � � . . . r ' . . '� �"� F�t;�. . . _ , . . . � .. ' . � i . ' . ' 't �.iJ,;: . . � . . ' . . . � . . � .. . . t�.1: t . � � . . . � �:, ': � . ' . . . � . . � ' . . . . .,Ytf ±y '�f _ ' . . . . . � . _ . , Y_ �N . . . ' . . - . . , . , ' . �,�',��'PT . � . . . . � ' .. . . A �T � � . ' .. .. � • .� � . . , . - � � . u_ �;t�',yL.�•��. � +3` $EPTEMBER 29, 1g81 . � . �"�►-` !'`'` �"e . • TOWN SQUARE ASSESSMENT �� f `�" ST. PAUL CITY COUNCIL � FINANCE COMMiTTEE GEORGE MCMAHON� CHAIRMAN i � �. YEAR � � BUDGET �AUGUST �� 1981 THROUGH JULY 3�� 982� A. OPERATIN6 EXPENSES2 CONCOURSE � �2'I��'It�. $TREET�SKYWAY 'I'74.�$32 LoFr 241,788 TorA� � 537,634 8. PROGRAMMING EXPENSES • 2 2� C. iTOTAL TowN $QUARE YEAR � � BUDGET � �j69,955 Z. SOURCE OF FUNDS . A. OXFORO 1 . CONCOURSE ASSESSMENT ON TowN SQUARE $ 121,014 II . STREET�SKYWAY ASSESSMENT , ON TOWN $QUARE �4��399 l II1 . ASSESSMENT ON OXFORD�S OTHER PROPERTIES FOR Lo�-r 22,122 IV. RENTAL OF CITY SKYWAY SPACE ZO�OOO v. TOTAL � 303,535 B. PUB�IC PROPERTIES �CiTY Ee COUNTY� 1 . SPECIAL ASSESSMENT FOR ZONE 1 1,300 11 . SPECIAL ASSESSMENT FOR ALL 4 zowES 31,050 � � � . TOTAL S 32�350 cf � P . SEPTEMBER 29, 1981 � PAGE Z C. DOWNTOWN PROPERTY ASSESSMENT �OTHER THAN OXFORD� 1 . SPECIAL ASSESSMENT FOR ZONE � � '13�'I�j3 il . SPECIAL ASSESSMENT FOR ALI. � 4 zoNES 170,616 � � � . TOTAL y.. ; . $ 183�749 D. OTHER — NET RENTAL INCOME I . PARK NET RENTAL INCOME � �O�OOO � I1 . TELEPHONE RECEIPTS 321 111 . TOTAL $ 50,321^ E. TOTAL $ 569,955 �j. SPECIAL ASSESSMENT BREAKDOWN A. SPECIAL ASSESSMENT ON OXFORD FOR TOWN SQUARE � 2('I�4�3 B. SPECIAL ASSESSMENT ON ZONE 'I i . Pus�ic $ 1,300 � I I . BUS 1 NESS 8c OTHER �3,133 I11 . TOTAL ASSESSMENT ON ZONE � � �4,433 C. SPECIAL ASSESSMENT ON ALL 4 ZONES I . OXFORD — OTHER DOWNTOWN PROPERTIES g 2Z��2Z ii . Pus�ic 31,050 111 . CHURCHES �� IV. BUSINESS Sc OTHER 'ICO�6�6 223.788 D. TOTAL �PECIAL ASSESSMENT S 499�634 L�. SOURCE OF FUNDS BY LEVEL OF TOf14lN SQUARE A. CONCOURSE: $121 ,014 I . SPECIAL ASSESSMENT ON OXFORD FOR TOWN $QUARE $ 121,014 .� �� ' $EPTH�7 BER Z9� �9S'I � PAGE 3 B. $TREET�SKYWAYt ��T4�832 I . SRECIAL ASSESSMENT ON OXFORD --- FOR TOWN SQUARE � �4Of399 II . PUBLIC SPECIAL ASSESSMENT FOR ZONE � �I�3OO ( 11 . SPECIAL ASSESSMENT ON DOWNTOWN BUSINESS �c OTHER FOR zoNE, 1 13,�33 r • � IV. RENTAL OF CITY SKYWAY SPACE TO OXFORD ZO�OOO ' � 174�832 c. LOFT: $241,788 . 1 . SPECIAL ASSESSMENT ON ALL Q- ZONES FOR DOWNTOWN BUSINESS ac OTHER � �6��6t6 ' 11 . SPECiAL ASSESSMENT ON DOWNTOWN � CHURCHES �O�OOO + III . SPECIAL ASSESSMENT ON PUBLiC OWNED PROPERTY 3'I�O5O IV. SPECIAL ASSESSMENT ON OXFORD�S ..:.,. OTHER PROPERTIES 2Z��I22 V. PARK NET RENTAL INCOME IN EXCESS, ' OF PROGRAMMING 'IB�OOO � 24��788 D. PROGRAMMING� �32�32� I . PARK NET RENTAL INCOME $ 3Z��jZ� $ 569�955 cf --......�..�..�..�. _ ____ �:r.�.�:.:.,:.:: .� ;�,�::_ � �� . $EPTEMBER 29, 1981 � PAGE 4 �j. LOFT MANAGEMENT FEE. TliE CITY WILL PAY OXFORD A �'17�000 MANAGEMENT FEE IN YEAR ( I FOR MANAGEMENT SERVICES RELATING TO THE LOFT. THE BOMA OPERATfNG ADVISORY COMMITTEE AND THE CITY WILL PREPARE BID SPECIFICATIONS RELATING TO THIS CONTRACT AND IN GOOD FAITH PURSUE THE PUBLIC BIDDING OF THIS MANAGEMENT CONTRACT IN YEAR ( II . _ E). ENERGY CHARGES. THE CITY� OXFORO AND THE BOMA OPERATING ADVISORY COMMITTEE WILL REVIEW IN DETAIL OXFORD�S ENERGY CHARGES TO THE C1TY FOR THE �OFT AND � NEGOTIATE A FAIR RATE. i • 7. RENTAL INCOME. ANTICIPATED PARK RENTAL INCOME FOR YEAR ( I IS AS FOCLOWSS —` NET REN TAL INCOME FROM WEDDING RECEPTIONS� PROMS� ETC. 50�000 — RENTAL OF CITY OWNED SKYWAY SPACE TO OXFORD ZO�OOO — TELEPHONE RECEIPTS 32�1 TOTAL RENTAL INCOME � 7O��jZ� NET RENTAL INCOME IN EXCESS OF �70�32� WILL FIRST BE APPLiED TOWARDS YEAR II NET OPERATING COST OVERRUNS FOR. THE LOFT I�! YEAR II . SECONOLY� THE ADDITIONAL RENTAL INCOME WILL BE APPLIED TOWARDS LOFT OPERATING COSTS IN YEAR III . THE DCDC PROGRAMMING ADVISORY COMMITTEE WILL CONTINUE TO REVIEW Al+1D ASSIST THE CITY WITH ITS MARKETING EFFORTS. H. PRpGRAMMiNG .BUDGET. THE FROGRAMMING BUDGET OF �32,32� AS PROPOSED BY THE CITY WILL BE IMPLEMENTED. EXPENDITURES IN THIS {►REA ARE CONTROLLABLE� THE �3Z�7jZ') BUDGET �S A CEILING OR UPPER LIMIT. NO ADDITINAL PROGRAMMING FUNDS WILL BE PROVIDED EITHER FROM ASSESSMENT OR RENTAL INCOME. THE DCDC PROGRAMMING ADVISORY COMMITTEE WILL ;REVIEW ALL PROPOSED PROGRAMMING EXPENDITURES� POtIC1ES� AND EVENTS AND MAKE RECOMMENDATIONS REGARDING APPROPRIATE PROGRAMMING ACTIVITIES. 9. STREET�SKYWAY MAINTENANCE. OXFORO WILL PAY ��40�399 OF THE ESTIMATED OPERATING �XPENSES OF �'17L��H3Z FOR THE STREET AND SKYWAY LEVELS �N YEAR II . THE CIT'! AND OXFORD WILL IN GOOD FAITH PRUSUE OXFORDfS ASSUMPTION OF �OO� OF THE STREET AND SKYWAY IEVEL EXPENSES IN YEAR III . s �O. HOURS OF OPERATION. THE DCDC PROGRAMMING� BOMA OPERATING AND CHAMBER FINANCE COMMITTEES WILL REVIEW AND DETERMINE WITH THE CITY AND OXFORD THE APPROPRIATE ROUTINE HOURS THE LOFT SHOULD BE OPEN. THE LOFT MAY CONTINUE TO BE OPENED OUTSiDE OF ROUTINE HOURS� IF RENTED. i • ��. CONTRACTS. THE BOMA OPERATING ADVISORY COMMITTEE AND THE C�TY WILL REVIEW IN DETAIL AND PREPARE BID SPECIFICATIONS FOR PRODUCT AND SERVICE CONTRACTS RELATING TO THE LOFT. THE CITY WILL IN GOOD FAITH PURSUE THE PUBLIC BtDDiNd OF THESE CONTRACTS IN YEAR ( II . • �Z. CHURCH SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS. IF THE CITY IS TO LEVY A SPECIAL ASSESSMENT� IT iS LEGALLY REQUIREO TO INCLUDE CHURCHES IN THE ASSESSMENT PLAN. THE CITY� OXFORD� AND DOWNTOWN ORGANIZATIONS WILL CONSIDER ASSISTING THE CHURCH ORGANIZATIONS� AS EACH DEEMS APPROPRIATE. 4T 1� . �� SEPTEMBER 29, 1981 � PAGE 5 �7j. DCOC PROGRAMMING ADVISORY COMMITTEE. THE OCDC PROGRAMMING ADVISORY COMMITTEE WILL CONTINUE TO REVIEW AND MAKE RECOMMENDATIONS REGAROING THE CITYtS TOWN i SQUARE MARKETIN6 STRATEGY AND PROGRAMMING EXPENDITURES� POLICiES� AND EVENTS. THE CITY WILL IN GOOD FAITH ATTEMPT TO IMPLEMENT THESE RECOMMENDATIONS. �4.. BOMA OPERATING ADVISORY COMMITTEE. THE BOMA OPERATING ADVISORY COMMITTEE WILL CONTINUE TO REVIEW AND MAKE RECOMMENDATIONS REGARDING THE OPERATtNG COSTS AND POLICIES OF TOWN SQUARE AND APPROPRIATE ALLOCATIONS OF OPERATING EXPENSES. THE CITY WILL IN GOOD FAITH ATTEMPT TO IMPLEMENT THESE RECOMMENDATIONS. , � . � �5. CHAMBER FINANCE ADVISORY COMMITTEE. THE CHAMBER FINANCE ADVISORY COMMt7TEE WILL •CON'TINUE TO REVIEW AND MAKE RECOMMENDpT10NS REGARDING THE FfNANCING OF TOWN SQUARE OPERATING AND PROGRAMMING EXPENSES. THE CITY WILL fN GOOQ FAITH ATTEMRT TO IMPLEMENT THESE RECOMMENDATIONS. �6. YEAR II PLAN. THIS PLAIV IS FOR THE SECOND YEAR OF TOWN S(,�UARE PARK�S OPERATIONS ONLY. THE COMMITTEES DESCRIBED ABOVE WILL CONTINUE TO EXPLORE THE RESOLUTION OF THE TOWN SQUARE CONCERNS. OPPOSITION REMAINS IN DOWNTOWN TO THE USE OF SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS FOR THE FINANCING OF THE OPERATING AND MAINTENANCE EXPENDITURES OF TOWN SQUARE. • � �* : , , ' �� , � ��:��,� (1) one Installment Finance I'ile No. 18113-81 ASSESSMENT ROLL I hereby certify tttat �he following has heen compared with and is a corrECt copy of the assessment of benefits , costs and expenses arising from ttie annual operation and maintenance costs of City-owned "TOWN SQUARE" public spaces located in the area bounded by the following streets: Cedar Street, Eighth Street, Minnesota Street, and Sixtti Stree� for the period runnin� Er�m July 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982. COSTS AND EXPENS�S $624,000.00 FINANCING Net Assessment $624,000,00 -1- � � Finance File No. 18113-$1 Page 1 tl�ri� 3 ASSESSMENT ROLL RI:: The cosr.s of operaein�; and m�intainin�; ttse "TOWN SQUAR�" public spaces for a period from July 1, 1981 to June 30, 1982 AMOUN'T 1-A SL. ,loseph 's Hospital 04-14000-020-03 $ 23 .94 Subject to St. Peter Street and except Northwester.ly 50 feet & excepe Southeasterly 1/b Lots 1 and 2, Block 3, Bazil and G�lerin's Addition. S t. Josepti's Hospi t�l 04-140�0-092-03 29, 13 Subject to street ttie followirtg except Westerly SO feet Lot 1 , Block 5$, Irvines Enlarf;ement of Rice and Irvines Addition to Lhe Town of St. Paul and in said Bazil and Guerins Addition except Nort}�easter.ly 24 75/100 feet I.ot 9, Block 3, Bazil and Guerin's Addition St. ,Toseph's Hospital 0[+-140b0-132-03 286.96 Sui�ject to Hi�hway and street the foliowin� Southeasterly 25 feet of Lots 1 and 2 and Northeasterly 2�°+ 75%100 feet af Lot 9, and Northwesteriy 50 feet of lots 14 and 15 and all of Lots 3 thru 6 and 10 thru 13 , I31o�k 3, Bazil and Guerin's Addition. St. Jasepti's Iiospital (��+-140U0-152-03 ��2. 77 Soutk�easterly 1�0 teet of Lots 14 and 15, Block 3, Bazil .and Guerin's Addition St . Jo>eptt' s Hospital 0l,-3f�00O-(�10-58 10.86 �,lesterly 2y Feet af Lo� 1 , 131ock 58, Irvine's EnlarRement of Ftice and Irvine' s Additi.on St. ,Josepli's Hospital 04-38000-011-58 6.29 Eas�erly 21 feet of Westerly 50 feet of Loc 1 , $lock 58, ` Trvinc�ti I:r��(�r};emf��C �f RicE� �+nd I�'vinefi Addition 1-I� Ct�urcti of ttie Holy Redeemer 04-14000-0$1-03 23.85 Subject to Highway; Lots 7 and 8, Biock 3, Bazil and G�aerin's Addition. 2-A Hillcrest Development 04-14000-020-02 6�+. 16 Lo�� 1 and 2 , Block 2 , Bazil and Guerin's Addition Hillcrest Development u4-14000-030-02 32.08 Lot 3, Block 2 , �azil and Guerins Addition Hillcrest Development U414000-050-02 64, 16 Lots 4 and 5, Block 2, Bazil and Guerin's Addition Hillcrest Development 04-14000-061-02 37.06 Lot 6, I31ack 2, Bazil and Guerin's Addition � -?� � Ffnance File No. 18113-81 Pa�;e 4 thru 6 ASSESSMENT ROLL 1tE: 'I'lie costs at operating and maineainin�; the "'TOWN SQUAR�" public spaces for a period From July l , 1981 , to June 30, 1982. AMOUNT 2-A Hillcrest Development 04-14000-090-02 $ 32.08 . 'I'I�at part of Lot 10 Southwesterly of a Line 150 feet Southwesterly [rom and parallel to Soutt�weseerly line of 47abasha Screet and all of Lot 9, �31ock 2 , Bazil and Guerin's Addition, Z-i3 Jol�n C. neMosS ; Bill C. lleMoss ; James C. DeMoss; Michael DeMoss and Ct�arles �. D�MoSs 04-140C�0-080-02 64, 16 l,ots 7 acid 8, Block 2, Bazil and Guerin's Addition �-C Housing and Redevelopment AuChority 04-1G000-110-U2 45.23 Lot 12 and that part of Loe 11 Northeasterly of the followin� descrihed line beginning on ttie Norttiwesterly line of said lot 74 `,0/100 feet from the Souttiwesterly line of Wabasha St. tl�ence Southe=:+sterly parallel to said street 100 fee[; thence Northeasterly parallel to lOth St. 9 50/100 feet; thence Soutt�easterly parallel to WaUasha St. 25 fe�t 3 1/2 inches; tt�ence Northeasterly parallel to lOth St. 5 feet; thence Souttteasterly to point on lOtti St, b0 feet Southwesterly of Wal7asha St. in nlock 2 , Bazil and Guerin's Addition. : 2-D Josepliine M. Goodman U4-14000-1Od-02 51.01 In tt�e Cit:y of St. Pa�l Revised description number 466 a, specific part of Lots 10 and 11 , Block 2, Bazil and Guerin's Addition. 3 City of St. Paul - Health Department 04-14000-010-01 251. 5b Block 1 , Bazil and Guerin's Addition 4 State of Minnesota - Department of Administration 04-66000-122-05 356,��4 Subject to roads; Lots 1 t}�ru 12 , Block 5, Roberts and Randalls Addition 5 City of St. Paul - Public Safety Building 04-66000-142-06 423.44 Subject to Street; Block 6, Robert and Randalls Addition G-A 1'erkegwin Investment Co. U4-66000-031-07 9b.24 Lot 1 thru 3 , Block 7, Raberts and Randall's Addition i�erkegwin Investment Co. 04-b6000-140-07 96.24 Lots 12 tt�ru 14, Block 7, Roherts and Randalls Addition 6-}3 City and County Employee's Credit Union 04-66000-051-07 64. 16 Lots 4 and 5, Block 7, Roberts and Randalls Addition 6-(; Tt�e American Oil Co. 04-66000-070-07 70. 57 Lots 6 and 7, Block 7, Roberts and Randalls Addition • _3� . Finance File No. 18113-81 Pa�e 7 thru g ASSESSMENT ROLL RE. Tl�e costs of operating and n�aintaining the "TOWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period from July i, 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUNT 6-D Litton E. S. Field 04-66000-100-07 $ 29.94 Soulheasterly i/2 of Northwesterly 2/3 of part Southwesterly of Old Randall Line of Lots 8, 9 and 10, Block 7, Roberts and Randall's Addition. I.itcor► E. S. Field 04-66000-110-07 56. 67 Norttiwesterly 1/3 of Lots 8 and 9 and Northwesterly 1/3 of part of Lot 10 Southwes�erly of Old Ranc3�11 Line and except Southeast- erly 75 feet part of Lot 10 Norttieasterly of said line and ex- cept Soutlieasterly 75 feet Lot 11 also subject to easement ttie Nor�lieasterly 20 feet of Southeasterly 75 feet of said Lot 11, Block 7, Roberts and Randalls Addition, Fi-E Alano Society of St. Paul, Inc. 04-66000-111-07 48. 12 With easement over I�ortheasterly 20 feet of So�ttieasterly 75 feet of Lot 11 ttie following Southeasterly 50 feet of Lots 8 and 9 Souttieasterly 50 feet of part af Lot 10 Soutt�westerly of Old Randall Line Southeasterly 75 feet oE part of Lot 10 Northeasterly of said Line and except Norttieasterly 20 feet of tF�e Souttieasterly 75 feet of Lot 11 , Block 7, Roberts and Ran�alls Addition 7 City of St, Paul - City Market . 03-14500-141-00 712,24 Vacated streets adjacent and following subject to Highway Lots 2 ttiru 8, Alock 14, Hoyts Addition also subject to Higtiway and S treets Lots 1 thru 13 and 14 thru 24 Cons tans Addition and in said Borups Addition subject to Highway the follnwing Tract Northwesterly of lOth Streer and adjacent Lots 1, 2 and 3 and all of Lots 1 thru 6 and 11 thru 14, Borups Addi[ion to St. Paul 8 St. Joseph's Hospital 04-64000-081-00 1 ,036.36 E. Rices Enlargement of Rice and Irvines Addition Vacated streets accruing the following; part of Northeast 1/4 of Northwest 1/4 af Section 6, Township 28, Range 22, lyin� Nortt� and Northwesterly of West Nintli and Exchange Streets also except Northwest 50 feet of Lot 1 and 2; all of Block 4, Bazil and Guerins Addition also Lot 9, Block 66, Irvines Enlargement, and Lots 2 thru 8 of Re-survey of Lots 1 thru 8, Block 66 of Irvines Enlargement and in said E. Rice's Enlargernent Lots 1 thru 8, E. Rice Enlargement of Rice and Irvines Addition. St. Joseph's Hospital 04-38010-010-66 29, 53 Lot 1, glock 66, Ix'vine's Enlargement RE°Survey of Lots 1 ttiru 8. St. Joseph's Hospital 04-14000-020-04 21,39 Northwesterly 50 feet of Lots 1 and 2, Block 4, Bazil and Guerin's Addition. • -4- � Finance File No. 18113-81 Page 9 thru 11 ASSESSMENT ROLL RE: Tlie costs of operating and maintainin�; the "TOWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period from July 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUNT 9-A City of Se. Paul 04-14000-125-OS $394.96 Subject to easements, the following; That part below a plane surface at elevation 103. 5 feet St. Paul Datum of the following: All of Registered Land Survey 328 and in Bazil and Guerins Add- ition, all ttie remaining part of Lot S, Bazil and Guerins Addition. 9-B Galiery Towers 04-14000-070-OS 52. 15 Cond�minium No. 123, Gallery Commerciel Condominium; Bazil and Guerins Addition, Tt►at part between plane surface 2levation of 103. 5 reet and 130.89 f�et, (St. Paul Datum) of following: �3eginning at Norttiwest corner of Block 5, tt:ence Northeast in Nortt� line 171 .09 feet rhence Southeast 135.5 feet thence Southwest 170.6 feet to Street ttience Northwest along street to beginning, parts of Registered La nc� Survey 328 and Block S, Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1 and an undivided 44.2% interest in common elements, (subject to easements) Gallery Towers 04-14000-080-05 65. 78 Condominium Na. 123, Gallery Commercial Condominium; Bazil and Guerins Addition, that part between plane surface elevation of 103.5 feet and 130.89 feet (St, Paul na[rum) of following; Beginning at Northwest corner of Block S, ti�ence Northeast on Nor th Line 171 .09 fee t tl►ence S ou ttieas t 13 S. 5 fee t thence Soutliwes t 17d.6 fee t to s treet thence Norttiwes t a lon� s tree t to beginning, parts ef Registered land Survey 328 and B�ock 5, Bazil and Guerins Addition, Unit 2 and an undivided 55.87, interest in common elements (subject to easements) 9-C Twenty Broadstreet Leasing Co. , Inc. Lessee: City-5tate of Minneaota 04-93280-012-07 135. 59 Re�istered Land Survey 328, Subjec[ to easements, t�eat part above a plane surface at an elevation of 103.5 feet City batum of the following: Beginning at Nortt�westerly corner of tract A Registered Land Survey 3`l8 thence Norttieasterly to Nortt�easterly corner of Block 5, Bazil and Guerirrs Addition, thence Southeasterly to Souttieasterly corner of Block 5, thence Southwesterly to South- westerly corner of Tract G, Registered Land Survey 32$, thence Nort}�westerly to be�inning: being part of Lots 2 anc] 3 and all of Lots l , 11 and 12, Block 5, Bazil and Guerins Addition and in Registered Land Survey No. 328, All of Tracts A and G, Registered Land Survey ��328. � • -5- Finance File No. 18113-81 Page 11 thru 13 ASSESSMENT ROLL RE: Ttie costs of operating and maintainicig ttie "TO'WN SQUARE" public spaces for a period from July 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUNT 9-D Fountain Development Co. 04-93280-014-06 $ 69, 59 Part above plane s�,rfa�e elev�tion 103 .5 feel of following: Part lying Northwesterly of tract leased to Gallery in Doc- ument #2071482; Beginning at Southwest corner Block 5, Bazil and Guerins Addition ttience Northeast to Souttieast Corner Tract F of Re�istered Land Survey 328 thence Northwest to Northeast corner Traet B thence Southwest 30.27 feet thence Southeast 135. 5 feet thence Southwest at right angle 170,6 feet to East line of street ttience Southwest on said line to beginning: Beiag part of Block S, Bazil and Guerins Addition and in Registered Land Survey 328 all of Tracts B and D and part of E and F. 9-E Por t Au tt�ori ty Gallery Partnership 04-93280-013-06 93, 12 Part above Plane surface elevation 103.5 feet of following: Beginnin,g at Soutlieasl corner TracC F thence Norttiwest on Norttieast line of Tract F 68.34 feet ttience Southwest at ri�;fit angles 34.42 feet thence Northwest at right angles 22 .64 feeC tiience Soi�th west at riglit angles 26.67 feet tlience Nortti at right angles 16.33 feet tttence Southwest, at right angles 30 feet ttience Norttiwest at rigt�t angles 30 feet thence southwest at ri.ght angles 62.67 feet thence Soutt�east at righL angles 25.33 feet thence Southwest at ri�;ht anf;l.es to Eas� line Street thence Southeast on East lir►e Street to Soutt�west Corner I,ot 7, Block 5, Bazils and Guerins Addition thence Northeasterly to beginning. Part of Lot 7 and 8 and 9, Block 5, Bazil and Guerins Addition and in said Registered Land Survey 328 Tracts E and F. 9-r Gallery Towers 04-14000-090-OS ,44 Cocidominiuro No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; that part ahove plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) of followin�;; beginni�g at Northwest corner of. Block 5, t}ience Northeast on Northerly line 171 .09 feet thence Soutl�- East 135. 5 feet ti�ence Southwest 170.6 feet to East line of Street t}lence Norti�west 135. 5 feet to beginning being parts of Ite�;ister�d Land Survey 328 and Block 5, of Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 301 and an undivided .457% interest in common elements , (subject to easem�nts) P.obert W, aad Kathleen M Johnson 04-14000-098-OS .38 Condominium No. 1.24, Gallery Tower Condominium; ttiat part above plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (St, Paul Datum) of following: Beginning at Northwest corner of Block 5, thence NorCheasr on Northerly line 171.09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 feet thence Southwest 170.6 feet to East line of street thence Northwest 135. 5 feet to beginning being parts of Registered Land Survey 328 and Block 5 of Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 303 and an undivided ,396% interest in Common elements. ` -6- • �'�'1'74�5 F:lrir�r�ce File No. 18113-81 Pag� 13-14-15 ns:��;ssM�.N�r t��r.�, It"r',: 'I°l�k: cr�scs ct o{�eT'atin�; and ruaintai.c�ir�t; tt�e "1'(3WDi SQUAAE" publi.c spac�s ft�r a period �rca�n Ji�1y 1 , 1981 tc, J�.inc: :30, 138�. Ar40�JHT ,;. ,r (;allery Towe�s � 04-14000-094-05 $ . �4 (;oi?don��ii�iuin N�.>. 1'�� , f;�ll�:a�, 'I'uwer Condominiurn; C't�at E�art .�+U�;ve �,larie si��riace ei.t>v::ii_i_oi� 130.'39 fec:c (at . Paul iy� C�!m) of followi��g: Uegicinir�i�r al tVoi-tlit•�esr corner nf' Rlock �, thencr� ;;,;<;;-tl��a:;i on NorLi�erly ti_r,z 171 ,0) �E��t Ci�er;c}� Scautt�E�ast i >; 5 fr�et Ci�en::e So;�tl;w�r,t 17().6 t�.=�c t:o 1°;ast lieze af Str.ee�t . . . , . � _�r�l;�i� t�t,r thw��st: ��5. � i;-� �. �o r�e};.trinf�Y�; r�e�.r��; parCS of kcat;' i.>tt�rt�d i.and ::urvey 32Ei za;�_1 3ilucic `; uf 3a�.i1 t�r�d ��.�eric�s �;dc:,i.Cion. U:ii_t3b2 r;ntl �an und�va.<ied . 557% iatc:r�at in ti�.�<<�mun elenrwz�t_s. Gallery Towers pt{-14000-11`Z-OS .45 i;anc�i��mir�i.urt� hz,. i24�, Gslla�ry Tcwex CGnc;�s��i[�i.u[�ry Cttat. E��rt ai>ovc plar�e �;urf�ce e.Lev�tios� 13().89 ie�rt (Sr. Paul. DaCirm) ��t PoLlcJ;.�ir,.r;; Bc:�;innin�; at 1Vorehwe�st corner �rf Block 5, tt:c:��ice i�i�r. tiic>ast oc� idart:kierly litte 171 .i)9 fe�t thEnc� Soixtki-� e��>t. 1J.`. `: [eec thence Sc�uthw�st 170,b t�.:�e� to �t�st 1i.rie of :>t�_��et ri�.:nce 1�c�rrl�west .1.35. 5 feet ta bcgic�ning beinR parts :_,L :teF;.t�;�c<�red T�and Survey 3l8 ar��d H1�cEc S, B�ziT �nd (; :��ri.n�+ ,�;;clir.ion. Unit 304 and an uctdi.vi;:iec9 .45Y3% interesL ... cam��,r�u e.en,c:nts. Gallery Towers � (?4-11{000-116-OS •�9 t.e>:�dca�i:iium N�. 124 , Gaillery �'ower Concic�minium; tiiat pert .:��,.�ve plane s�rt:�ce elevation 130.i39 feet (St. Yaul Datum) �;i follor,a�ng: Si:�;inni.n� et Nurtt�wesr corner af nlock Sf L?«i:�c_e idortr�east on Northerly lin� 171 .09 feet thencc Sauth- e.i�:.t:. 13�. 5 f�:�t th�enct Southwest 170.6 f.eet: to E�st 1.ine of srrt�e� ti�encc_ �7orthwest 135. 5 feet to be�inni.ng bein� parts or lte�;i�tex-rd T.�nd Survey 32$ and t3lock 5, of Bozil and G:.�e�i-ins Addition. Unir. 3�5 and an unclividecl .398% interest i.n cotannun element� . Gallery Towers 04-14000-120-OS .43 :;osuli�miaium h]o. 124, Ga�lery Towex� Condominium; rhat pbrt ��.,ve �lane SurEace elevation 130.89 feet (St. Pa�l Uatiim) oi` �ollowing: Bekinnin� at Norttlwest carner of Block S, ti��nr:e. ivortt�east on Norl:h�rly line 171 .09 fe�t thence South- s�::st: 135. 5 feet chence Southwest 170.fi Eeet ta East. line �sf s..�:eec. tl�F�rlce NaxthwesL 13%• 5 reek t� beginnin�; be.ir�ig parr.� c,i i<eF;ist�ered L�c�cl Survey :31t3 aud Iilock 5 of Ba•r_il and C,�,erins Addicion. Unit 306 a►id t�n undi.vided .443% interef;t i.a c:�mmon elernents . � -7- � }�inanr.t� H'ile No. 18113-81 E'a�:;e 15,16,17 t��SESSMENT' Rt7t.L lY�: 1`1:�: cosi:s ut o��er.�atin}; and maic�tair�:i.nF; C}�e '"7'tx11V SQUAiiE" public space� tar a };E-riod €:rom ,July I ; 19�1 to June 30, 198i., � P.MC1llN'T ;-w� Gallery Towers Ot+-14000-124-U5 $ . 51 (;oridomir�iutt� iVo. 124, G��.:e:r�: Tower CondornirYium; i:ht�t part �,l�c>ve pI<+��e surface el�vatic;�� 1.30.�i9 feet (St . Ya«1 Ciat.inn) c;i ioll.c,��it�F;: E��;irininE; �t! i;i�rtliw�st c�raer� or Block 5, tlzence i��rt:lie�isr on Nortl�s�rly 1.i.ne 1 %1 .U9 feet �}Mence SouCh�ast -'�.`i. ` t+.et tkience Soutii�.�er:t: 1.7U.6 Eeer. co East li�t� c�f Stz�eet t; tr��ce N��rthwr�st J35. 5 r:r�ef� to t,ef;innin� beinK par�s of Re�;- i <. �.� •red :.anci Suz•vey .32�•: �rY;; llle��lc 5 of �ia�il and Guerins r,�_`tl'_r.ic•�;. Unie307 and z�i•� undj.vided . 524% i.r�tereat in Ct�iClllTIUR �'],Lmf?S1LS, Gallery Tnwers 0��-14000-128-OS . 55 t;or�dominium No. 12Zi , Gal.lery Tower Condaminium; that� p�rC �t�o�r� piane siariacc �rev�tion 13(�.89 feeL' (St. Paul Datum} �i follewing; Be�;i.ani.E1�; at Nor�.hwest corner of Black 5, tlience Northeas� on tavrtlierly line 171 .09 feet thence 5nuth- east 135. � feet tlir-nce 5f�ut}�we�t I7�1.6 feet to ]Cast line of :-,ta-eet c.i�c:nce horthwP�:;t; 135. 5 feet to beginnfng being parta� o±' Re�is re�red T,and SurvLy 328 and Hl.ack .5, Br�zil end ;3��eri.ns Additio�i, Unit 308 and �n undivided . 566% �nCerest i.n cummoci elements. Gerald T. Byrns Ot,-1400U-132-OS .44 C;�,n:9ominiuln No• 1:4 , �all.ery T��taer Condominium; Chat part' ��!�ove pl.arae surf�cc: ele.vacioi� 1"30.89 feet (SC. �'aul Datum) �L folio�aing: Bef;inn.L�it; ak NorthweAt cor.ne: of B1ock S, :_i�ence Northe�3sC an Piortt�erly line 171.09 fe�t Chence South- o-�K.rt 135. 5 ieet thenc� Sc�uthwest 170.6 feet tc� East line of sr= cet thence Northwest 135. 5 f.e��t to beginnin� bein� parts ui k��gistered I,A�d Survey 328 and Blor_k 5, of Bazi1 ac�d (;�iez•ins Addition. Urixt 401 and en undivided .457%, interest ii: r_ontmon elentettt:i; . Gallery Towers 04-14000-136-OS . 54. �;,�i,.c;i�niin's.uru No. 124, Gellery Tc>wcr C;ondomi.nium; tl-�at part .,l�o-vt� pla�ie :��rface elevation 130.t39 feet (St. Yaul 1'�atum) c�� followii�f;: Bc�ginnin�; at Norchwesc corner of F3locic 5, �f,c•nce Nor�l��rdst: on Noi:tLerl.y line 171 .09 LeeC ehence South- c>a:.t. 1:35. 5 feer. thence ;c��ttiwest 170.6 �ec:t. ta EasC line of �:�:� _�et t:i�e��ce N��r�k�wes� 135. 5 feet to I;e�,inniiig hein� parts ot ltet;istered Land Si�rvey 318 and Block 5 of Ba�il and :;��i-ins Addit.iUr�.. Unit 402 �;nd an undi.vided . 557% interest rn curnmc�n elt>.[nenis . • °�' • Finance File ho, i8113-81 P�ge 17,18,19 � ASSE::�S�12;NT RULI. RL: Tt�e casi:� ot aperaCing �riri cnaintaining Ctie "T(3WN SQUARE" public sp�aces for a �eciod �rorn July 1 , i9$i to ,)un�e 30, 1982. AMOEINT `�-�:' An�eline I. Nitti 04-14000-140-OS $ .38 Candominium No. iL4 , �;�llery 'rawer Condominium; that part <�b�ve pi�ne surface �lev�tiun 13U.$9 Leee (St. paul Detum) c�f Eallowlri�;: I�e�;istriictf; ac Nor��hwest corner of Blork S, thence rlor. tt�east oii Northerly l.ine 171 .09 feet Lt�ence Soutlleas� i3:i. 5 feeC tlience Sr�zrE��ide�t 17�.6 feet ta �;ast l.ine of Str�et ct�e�zce Northwe.�t 135. 5 f�ee to k>e�inning bEin� parts of Reg- i.scered Land Survey :92rS �and Bloc.k 5 of ]3azi1 flCltj GuerLns .1d:litioi�. Uczit403 ��zd •�:i undividec� ,396% interest in cornrnc3cr e1�mc�nCS. Gallery Towers 04-14000-144-05 .45 Condorninium No. l<<+, Gallery 'Tower Condominium; that part above plane sur�ac:e t>ltvation 13O,89 feet (St. Paul Detum) of following; Begii�ctiri�, aC N�rlhwest corner of B1ock 5, thence Nc,reheast ou Northerly li.ne 171 .G9 feeC thence Soulh•- east 135. 5 teet thence �outliwest 170.6 feet to E�at lin� of scr�� t:t,e��ce Norttiwese 135. 5 feet to beginning Ueing parts cif Regi�t��rE,d Land 5urvey 32.8 and t3lock 5, Ba�il and �,_ierins a��iCion, Unit 404 Uc:d an undtvid�d .468% interest in commor: elemer�ts, Gallery Towers , 04-14000-148-05 . .39 Condomii�ium No. 124 , Gallery 7Cawer Condominium; that part above pl�c�i surface elervation 130.8� feet (St. Paul Datum) 01: following: Beginc�.ing �L Nnrthwest corner of Block S, �ilence Noxtheast an Northerly line 171.0� feet thence SouCh- e�st 135. 5 feet thence Sauthwest 170.6 feet to East liT4e of screet tl,ei:ce [�orthwest 135. 5 feet to beginning being parta ��f Regis tered Land Survey 328 and �31ock 5, of Bezil ac�d G::erinx Addition, Unt.t 405and an undivi�ed .398�� inCerest in cc�ncnoi� ele[nent3 . Gallery Towers � 04-14000-152-05 .43 (;c�nduminiutli No, 12��, Gt�llery 'rotaer Condamin.iurn; that �art �,Lr,✓e plane surl'�ce elevatiori 13U.89 feet: (St. Paul Datum) ,:�� [olluraint;: Bc:gi.nnin�; a t Norttiwes t corner of Block 5, �!�cnce Norcheas4 c�n Norttieriy line 171 .U4 fe�t thence Soutt�- easi: 135. 5 feet thence Stiuttiwest 170.6 Eeet to E�st line of S r_�e�e tlience Nortt�wes t 135, 5 fe�t to bef;inning being parts ;yz :t��;;isLa�red Land Survey 3'L$ ar��i 111ock 5 of Baril and t;uerius Adciitton. Unit 4U6 �,�ld an undivideci .4�+3% interest :�i common elements . � • -9- F'imm�ce �ile ,No. I8113-f31 Yag� 19,20,21 ASSk:�ST�IENT R(7LL It�.: Tt�e costs of o�,erating ar,ci rn�icttai.nin�; tlie ��arr 5QUARE" public spaces f:or a ,>ericd �rom ,]uly ]. , 29fi1 ro J��ne 30, 1)$2. AMOUNT '1-�� Gallery Towers 04-14000=156-05 $ • �l Ccn;3c�mini.un� !�;u. 1'l4, [�allery 'ToweT- Condominium; that part_ above pl.anc, sur face c:levati.on 130.89 feet (St. Peui Datum) �il: 1t1� LUWl.Rf;: ]�St��innis�f; at Nor[hwest corner of Black 5, tt�ence Cdu►'�lia>��HC c�n N��i: chtr�.y ll.�Z� 111 .09 F.ec�C thence Southeast 1 ";:. `> Eec�t t:isi�rice Soutl�wesL 170.6 feet Co Ec�et line of StreeC �I��n�e Northwe5t 135. 5 feet lo i�e�,inning bcing parCs of Reg- is��:red Iaand St:t•vey 32Fi and Block 5 of Bazil and Guerins E�ddi.�iou. tlr�i.t 407a,ed an undi.vicled . 524"/ i.nteres t in commori eli,�ri��r�ZS, Gallery Towers 04-14000-160-OS . 55 C;.�ndocninfur�i No. 1'L4 , GaLlery 'Power Condomini.um; that part �bove plar�� surface elev�lioc� 130.E39 feet (St. Paul Datum) of foll�wt.c��;: Beginnln�; at iJorthwest cornez' of B1ock 5, thence hiortheast on Nortlierly line 1.71 .09 feet thence South� ease l:i�. � teat thence SoutlrwFSt 170.6 feer to East 1Sne of street tt�Ytice Nort�hwest 135. 5 feet ta beginnirig beic�g parts oi: }te�:;i�,t�red L�nd Survey 32$ and Block S, Baz�t1 and (;u�rin:; Additian, Uni.t 408 and an undivided . 566%, interest i�� coarmon ele.mentz�, Gall�ry 'I'owers . �4-14000-164-05 •�4 (;�,ndomi.nium DI«. 1'L4 , Gallery 'Tower Condc�m%nium; ttrat port �bi>ve plane surface elevatio�� 130.89 feet (St. Paul Detum) ui f��Ilowing: Begi�znin� at Northwest corner of Block S, ci;ec►r.e NorLheasC on Nortl�erly li.ne 171 .09 feet thence Sou[h- east. 13:�. 5 �eet tFience Souttiw�st 170.6 feet to East line oE :;trt-et thence NorChwest 135. 5 feet to beginning being parts or Itegi,�ered Land Survey 32t� gnd Block 5, of Bazil and ir+�eri.ns �dditian. Unit 409 �nd an undivided ,457% interest i.;l c:ommon e lements . Gallery Towers 04-14000-168-OS . 59 Co��ciominium Na. 124, Gallery To�rer Condominium; that parC ;�f�nvc �lane surface elevation 130.89 feet (5t. Peul Datum) ��E follc>wing: Beginning at Northwest corner of Rlock 5, tE�e�rtcc� Northeast on Norttierly line 1.72 .09 �eet tl�ence �outh- �ast= 1.35. 5 feet thence SoutYiwest 170.6 feet ta East line of �yt.re�c Ll�ence Northwest 135. .`� fz�f+t co i�eg�nning bein�; parts o�= ,tef;i.s tered La�ild Survey 328 anil Block S of Bazil and ;;�:�rins Addition. Unit 41� and an undivicled .606% interest i.n common el.e.ments . • . -10- Finance Nile No. 18113-81 Page 21-22-23 . ASSI:SSP�l�,NT ROLL It.�;; Ttie cUS�s ot operacin�; r�r,.cl n�af.ntainin�; the "TO'�1N SQUARE" �ublic s�aces for a period from ,Jtll.y 1 , 19$1 t:> .]une 30, 1�82. Ai•t0 UNT 9-k% Gallery Towers 04-14000-172-OS $ . 76 i;<,nilomi�iium idcr. 1'l4, Gallery 'Cower Condomirtium; that parC <it�ove pl.�ine sur.•�ace el.evation .L3f).t39 feel (St. ptiul Datum) of foilowi.n�;: Be�inni�ig at NorC.t�west corner of Block 5, thence tlo.-cheasc. or� Nc,rth�rly line 171 .U9 teet �t�enc� Soutt�eant i :l�. ; feet tl�ci�ce Soi�tt�wFSt 170.E; feet to East lir►e of Street �i,a:��;e Nop•i�ieaest 135. � fee�� to Le�;innirtg beir�p� parte af Reg- i :,��red Land ;;urvey 3Z8 a�ici Blc�<:k � of 13azi1 arid Guc►'ins l::lifir:ion. linft411 ar.d asi u��divided . 7�6% intere�t i.n cornn;v�i el.emenC:>. Gallery Tower.s 04-140U0-176-OS .44 (:undam:'t.rYi.�ut, tdo. 114, �allcry '1'awPi� Cor:di�sni.niurn; thet parC d�uo��e pi�l�sc� si�r.Yece e1ev:�ti.:>�� i30.89 fec:t (St. Peul Datum) �;i: fc,llo�.�c��;: Ae�;inninh ar [��rtt�wc�sC cEyrner ot $lock S, r_lien�e Norttieast ory N�rtttec•ly lirie 171 .()9 xeeC thence Sc�ulli- �-�a:,[ 13 5. i f ee t f:t�ence Sai�ttiwes t 1/0.6 fee t cu �as t 1 ine of �Cl'£'CC tliei�ce Nartlrcr�st. .i35. 5 f�et tc, b��innir�g bein� parts ot Re�i.stered I.and �ur-vey 32$ ar��3 Slock 5, BIIZil and GuErins Additio�., `Urc'it. 501 and an un�.livicied .457% ittterest i,i conimoti eleanent:.,. Gallery Towers • 04-14000-180-05 . 54 ;.._�i�d:��ii.!iiurn k�io. 12t+ , Gallery Tower Condominiu�n; tkiaC part ��uove pi��ne surface tlevation 130.89 feet (St. Puul IIatum) =�f £ullowing: Be�;inni_ng at Nor�hwe�t corner oE Block 5, ti�ence Northeast on N�r�t�erly line 171.09 feet tt�ence South- r�ast 135. � leet [t�ence :iouthw��t 1'10.6 feet to Eest line of str��et tEierice �;crtt•�wesC 135. 5 feet t� beginning heing parts �>i: R��;istered L:dcid Survey 32£3 anc3 k3lock 5, of Bazil and C;��s:.�°ins Addieivr:. Unit S02 and an ��«divid�:d . 557% interest ;.�i i.'OIt1CP,O Ct E'�E'.ti1C;C1 t 8 . C�allery �rUWEYS 04-14000-184-05 •3� ;,o,i:l.;minium Na. 124, G�llery Tower Condom2niurn; that p�rt �.:I;��vca ��lanc su,'I.�ce t�levaL'lon 130.fi9 feel (St. Paul Tlatum) c�: 1<�llowin�;; Be�;i.rinin�; at Nc�rtF�wesC curner of Block 5, the:,c�: Northe�;sc on Norel�ec�ly ].irde 171 .09 feet tl�enc� South- ..a�;c i3;. 5 i:.�cc.. thence 5c�u�hwest 1/0.6 L-'eet to F.ast line oF :.ireet tiience Nortt�west 13�. 5 feet Co l�eKinning bein� parts of. itegistered Land Survey 328 and Block S of Bazt.l and G�.�erins Addicion. UniZ 503 and �n tsndivided .396% int.erest ic� co�nmc�n elcrnenCs . � � -11- Fic��rrit_°t File Na, 18113-�31 Pa�e 23-24-25 ASS�:S�>r1f:N7' ItOI.I. }:{�;: 't.'l�c� cosls of �pc�rar_irig ar;cl cr�aintainisrK ttie "'T(7WN SQUARE" public spaces f.ar. a r>eriod £i-otn ,1�1}' ] , I;)�}1 t:� June 30, 1982, P.hSC)UNT' ��_�,^ (;allcry Towers U4-14000-188-05 $ �� i;c>ndoa�iniu�n Ni�. i "11t, �,allery 'I'c��i:r CoE�c3t�uii.niurr; ctiat part <:l;ove pla�ie :,ui-l�ice� elevatic�n i:?(i.f�6) feeC (5t. . Neul 1)�tum) oi� f��llc�wi.tif;: BeKinnin�, at Nnrt:t:�•�r.st corner of H.lock �, thence t;Y�rtiieast on Norcl�erly ?'Lr�� 71 .0� �e��L cl�f�nce Souliieast _ 3`;. 5 feeC tf�eric.�= Sautliwe.,r_ i. �0.o reet c.o F.'asr. line of Street � 1:;:�ice Norcha;er�C l."3S. � ta�c�C ia bec;in.tin� �;Eri.crf; Parls of. Re�;- >�.c_i�d Lar,<1 ;�;uivey "i?!i ts::�.f Iflrcl: `, of k�azil an<i Guerii�s �',<:iiLClu[l. Ut1I.tSOL� ��j ur, �,;i�livided .468% inCir�et in :.c:r,xuor� �.Lem�nt_s. i�;ark R Mueller 04-14(300-192-OS .39 i;uibd�rr�i�i�LiEn Nc�. .l"1�� , G�l.i�:�i:y 'Towtr Condoa7iriiuert; th+�t pc�rt ai�:,ve �31a,�e surf�s�e eleva�:ion 130,E39 feet {St. �'aul I�atixm) oi f»llo�a�._:�;: F3ef;inning at:. l�c�rtt�wes� carri,er nf Block 5, tlic�nce l�c�rt.tt�_ast ou Nor. tilr=rXy ltne 171 .09 fee[ thence SouCh-- ��:�5c 1;35. `_� ��et: thence So�ztl�4�esC 17U.6 Yi:r,t to ��st line af :.t:rc�et t�_<:��ce ivur.tti�a�st. 13�. � feec: Co b4�;iriisin� bQiny� p�rts �:•�f� k��gi�t�-red I.ar�d S�rvey 3'Lf3 flnc� �31ock S, B�zil and i:;u�rins nddition. Uc�it Sq5 actd ac� undi.vi.ded ,39$% ineerest �:, carnrnoii elezur�i�ts, Gallery Towers . 04-14000-196-OS .43 i;;.;�.�d�;E�iiniu;�i No. 124 , C,allery ;',"ower Condominium; that part ub��v� plane surface elevation 130.£34 feer_ (St. Paul DaCum) �I: Eoliowin�;; B�y,ir�niiz�; �t Northwest corner of Block 5, t.i:ence Nurthe.�st :>n Nurtt�erly line 171.09 feet thence South- ti>ar�i 135. 5 feet tt�c�rtitE �outhwest 17�.6 feet Co F.ast line of 5t::eet: tlience N+�r�hwc:.�t 135. ,5 feet to beginninp being parta o� �-;egistered Land Survey 328 and B1ock S, of Bazil anc� (;«��s�inx Addition. Unir. 5�6 and an undivided .443% interest ir: comsnon elem�:r►ts . Gallery Towers 04-14000-200-OS , 51 Cunckt��i.nium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condnmini.um; that part <sbo�;•�r plane surface elevation 130.ti9 feet (St. Paul llatum) ��r full�winf;: �3egianing at Northwe�t c�rner of Block .5, ct,ence Northeast on Nortlierly line 171 .09 feet thence South- e�:�r 13`_i. 5 fe�t thQnce SouChwesC 170.6 teeC to East line of stre:c�t ef�E'T1�E Nor�i:kest 135. 5 feeC ta begin�iin� being parts c�l: I:E��;istered Land Survey 328 and B1ock 5 of Bezil and (;��::�ri.ns Addit:ion. Uf;ic507 aeid c�n undivided • 52G°�. intereat �.�i �:o�nai�n E:�.Ef(1('_t1CS . • � -12- � Finance E'ile Nc,. 18113-t31 Y,�� 25-26-17 ASSI:SSMF.N'I' Rt}I,L itE: '1't�� coscs at oper�i;i.nf; anci main�aii�in� el�e "T(�JIV SQUARN:" public spaces �nr a �c�riod �Erom Jialy i , 19$1 t:a Juc�c� 30, 1982, AMUIINT `%-1` Ga l lery Towers 04-I4400-204-05 $ , 5� Concfcsminium tJc�• 1"L4, Gel.l.ery Tucacsr Co��c3ominium, thaC parL' aLove plane surEaLe el.evation ] 30.fi9 Ec�et (Sr. paul Dar_um) =:�L fol.luwin�.;: Iie�;inni.n�; �,r. Nor[}iwest corner of Bl.ock 5, ttiencc> t•��r�hea�t: o�: No.'C_lierly lic:ae 171 .U9 feet tt�ence SouCheast ! �.`_�. 5 feet ti�t�ac� Soulh�aeasc: 170,6 te�t tc� �ast l.ine oF Street: r��e��ce Nor'tti�aest 135. 5 tclet to be�,inniri�; bE�ir►� parCS of Reg- i�tered Lanc1 5urvey 32r3 an�l tilack 5 af Bazi7. and Guerins .<`;�Jditi.on. 1_iniC 5n� and ari undivideci . 566% lntereSt in curnrnon tlemenCS. Kevi.n I,. Curtin 04-14000-208-05 ,44 Cocydomini��;n No. D�24, i;�li�ry Tower Condomiaium; th�t pr�rl �above plar�c� surface e1r:v��t:ion 130, 89 feet (Sc. Paul Datum) of folluwing; �3egincting �-at Northwest cornei- of Ble�ck 5, ti�ence NUrtheast an N�r.t't��rly licie 171 .05 f�et thence Southw e.ast 135. � teet thence Suutliwest 110.6 faet to East line of sr_reet t:l;rnce Norttiweat 135. 5 £eet to b�qinning being �Sarts of Ke�istered Ldcid Survey 32£3 and �lock S, Bezi1 and Guc�:rins AddieLon, Unit 509 and an undivfded .457% interest in common elements, Gall�ry Towers • 04-14000-212-OS . 59 „ondominiurn 2Jo. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; that part st>ove plane sur�ace eY.e.v�tiun 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) uf f�-�l lowing: Begin►iin�; a t Northwes t corner af Block 5, ti�et�ce Northeast on Norr.l�erly Iine 171 .09 feet Chence South- rasc 135. 5 feet thence Southwe�t 170.6 feet to East line of �t:reet thence N�r. thwest 135. 5 feet to beginnin� being parts o£ kegiscer•ed LaE�d Survey 328 and Block 5, of Bazil and G��erin� Addi�i.on, Unit 510 and an undivided .606y interest iii conimon eICITtF'.I1�8 . Gallery Towers 04-14000-216-05 . 76 �,ondo�niniuru No, 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; tha t part al,ove E�lane sui-f.ace elevaCion 13Q.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) of followin;;; Beginning at Narehraest corner of Block S, tt�c,r�cc I�loc�r.heast on Northerly line 171 .Oy feeC thence Sau[h- c��sr 1:i5. 5 feee thence Soutl�west 170.6 feet t:o EAet line of st�r.eet tt�e��ce Nc�rtt�west 135. 5 feet to be�i.nning bein� parts of Ref;isrerf:d I..and Survey 3'l8 and Bluck 5 of Bazi1 and ;,�erins Additic;n. Uni[ 511 and an undivided . 786% iriterest ioi cc�mrnon elements . • -13- • Ficiaace File No, 181i3-81 Pr�ge 27-28-29 ASSESSMENT KULL RE: �h� ca�ts of o�3er�t�nK and aiaii�tai.ninh the "'�UWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period ��rom Jul.y 1 , 198i c� J�lne 30, 1�82. AMOUNT j-1�` Gallery Towers 04-14000-220-05 $ ,44 (;<�c:doi�iinium Na. 11�t, Gt�llzry To�;er (;oncic�miaium; [hAt part �ai}ove plan� s�.�rftic� elevat:i.an 13t).89 f�eet (SC. Paul Datum) :�f follotiair►g: F�eE;�.C1Yl�R}; at Noret�west corrier of Biock 5, thenc� �`7urtt�east o�z N;>rtherly liis� I71 .0�) f+eet tli�nce Sautheasl 135. 5 Eeet r.l�ence �outt:wc,�st 170.6 feet to East l.ine of Street �:tieuce Nor t:hwe.�t 13`�. 5 f.�eE t to t>e�irYning heinq parte of Reg° i:��c�r-ed Lar�d 5urvey 328 and i;lock 5 of B�7il and Guer3.r�s kt!ciitic,ri. Unit601 and an unriivided .4577o intereat in ;E,rarnon �iements�. Gallery Towers 04.-14U00-224-OS • 54 C;ondominium t1o. J.24, Gallery Tower Condom�nium; that part ubov� pl�ne sur.F.ace ��c:�ratioci 13Q.89 f+�ct (SC. Patxl L�atum) ot foLlowir��; BeginnXri� at N�rthwest corn�r c�� lock 5, thrsnce I�ortheast on Nc�rtl�srly line 171 .09 feet thence South-• east 135. 5 feet thence 5uuk.hwest 170.6 feet Co East li.ne of s�.reet thence Northwest. 135. 5 :Eeet to beginnin$ being parts ot Re�;ister�d Lz�nd Survey 32$ end Block 5, Bazil end t:.uerins Addition. Uni.t bU2 • ttnd an undivided . 557y interes t in common elemFnes, Gailery Towers , 04-14000-228-OS •38 C;ond�rui.niun� No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominiuu�; thet part �bove plane surface elevati.on 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) �f following: Beginnin� at Northweat corner of Block 5, tl�enc� Norttieact on Norther.ly line 171.09 feet thence Sauth- e��st 135. 5 feet thence SouthweAt 170.6 feet to East line of street tlience Northwest 135. 5 feet ta beginning being parts af ltegistered Lend Survey 328 and Block 5, of $azil and Guerina Addition, Unit603 and an undivided .3967 interest tn comman elements . Gallery Towers 04-14000-232-05 .45 Coctdominium No. 12�+, Galler.y Tower Condominium; that part �,l�c�vF� plane surface elevacion 130.89 feet (St. Paul I)atum) c,� fvl.Zowing: �ieginning at IVorthwest corner of Block 5, chetice NortheAS� oei Ns�rttierly line 171 .09 feet thence Sout}i- e�ist 13S. S fc.<�t tliec�ce Southwest 17U.6 feet to Eaet line of rat..ei�t �'r�ence Noi�ttieaest 135. 5 teet to beginning being parts �>f r�e�;istex-ed Lar�d Survey 328 and Block 5 of Bazil and G;,erins Adciici_an. Unit604 and �n undivided .4bg%� int.e�est i.e� common elt�rne«is . . -14A- • Finance File No, 18113-81 Page 30 ASSESSAIENT ROLL RE: The costs of operating and maintaining the "'TOWN SQUARE" Public sp,aces for a period from ,July 1 , 1981 to ,Iune 30, 1982. • AMOUNT 9-F Gallery Towers 04-1.4000-240-d5 $ .43 Condominium No 124, Gallery Tower. Condominium; tY;ar. part above plane surface elevation 13Q.89 feet (Sr. Paul Da eum) of fol lowin};: be�;inning a t Nortl�wes t corner of I31ock 5, tl�ence Northeaat on Nortt�erly line 171..09 Yeet ttience Southeast 135. 5 f�et t:lience Soutl;west 17U.6 fe�L to East line of street Chence Nor�tiwest 1"35. 5 feet to beginnin� beictc; pa�-ts of Re�istered Land Survey 328 and Block 5 of Bazil and Gueriris Adc3ition. Unit 606 and an undivided .443% interest in common elements, :;allery 'Ta�aers 0l,-1��000-244-U5 . 51 Cun�ominiurn No. 124 , G�llery T'i>wer Condorninium; tha t parC above plane surface elevatiori 1�0.�39 fee� (St. Paul 1723L"U[Tl) of foilo�ain�: 13e�;innin�; at Northwest c.orner ot 151ock 5, thence iVortlleast on Nortl�erLy line 171 .09 feet tl�erice Soutt�east I35. 5 Peet the:ice Soi,thwest 170. b feet to L'ast line of street thence Northwest 135. 5 fe�:t co l�e�;innin�; bein�_; pazts o£ Itef;istered Land Survey 328 and Block 5, of Baz_il and Guerins Addition. Unit 607 and an undivided . 524%. interest in Common elements, • -I4- � �'iR8[10E ��.�F. �O, If;11�-$1. f'a�:;e 2.9 31 ASSES°��11�:N"l' KOI.L 1:1:: 'I'l�r� ccis;s c�t �t��:-a<.in�; and mrjir.taii�izi� Clie "`1(3CJN St�UAHE" public; spaces Lor a E��Eei-ioc� �fi-tyr��i J�rl.y :l , 19�31 to .I;��iie 30, 7.982. AciOUNT ',�-�•' Galler-y Towers �4-14000-236-05 $ ,39 (;on.ioaii�iiun� Nc�. i:��; , GA llery 7'ower. Condominium; Clia t pab t �:bvve ��lane yurf:�ce elevation 13U.$9 feet (St. Yaul Detum) :�t followinf;: �iet�,inning at N�rthtvest corner of Bloc4c 5, ttience ;:UrC(lK�3St on tloril;erly licie li1. .09 feet t.hence Sauttie�st l 't5. 5 feer tlle�s�c:c� Southwest. 170.6 f�eC eu EasC Yine of Street r_lience Nortliwest 1:15. 5 �HeC tn t�e�;i�ining t�ei.n� parCs of Reg- fst��red Land 5urvey 3'l8 and Block 5 af n�ezi'i aiid Guerins st�dir.i��2. Unir.605 and an undivided .398%; ir�t�rest in common ElernEnts. Gailery Towers 04-1t}000-24f3-05 , 55 i;.�rsdominiutn Nc>. 121►, (;�llery 'tower Condominiuin; tiit�[ p�rt �:t>ove plane surf,.rice el�vation 130, 89 feet (St. Paul T3atum) c>� Follawi��g; Be�;i�ynin�; at teai°thwest c�a�ner of �Slocic 5, �i«nce Nurtt�eas� ora Northeriy line 171 .09 feet thence Soutl�- ea s r 13 5. 5 �ee t thence Sou Ck�wes C 1 70.E .[ee t. to Eas t I i.ne of street cl�ence Nortr�west 135. 5 fect to b�,ic�ning bein� parts �>f kegisterec� L�ind Survwy 32.f3 �nc] I�lock 5, Bezi.l and i��_:�rins Addition. Uait 608 atZCi an unt.livided . 566%. interest i�i cammc;n elements. Gallery Towers . 0l+-14000-252-OS .44 Cr.;rldo�uinium Nc�. 124 , Galleiy 'Tower Cacido�Pxirzium; t:t�at part above plane� surf�ce elavstion 130.89 f�et (SL. Paul ilatum) of following: BeginnLng at Northwest corner o£ Bloc4c S, tl�eiicP 7Vortheast on NorCherl.y line 171 .q9 Eeet thence 5outh- east 1'35. 5 feet thence Sc>uthwest 170.b feet to East line ot st_r�eC ttlence Nc,rchwe3t: 135. 5 feet to beginninq being parts ot Regi.ster�d I,an<l Survey 32$ and Block 5, of Bazil and Gueri.ns Ad;9ir.ian, Unit 609 and an undivided .457% int�resC i.r� c ommo ri e 1 eme s�� . Gallery Towers 04-I4000-256-OS • 59 i,or��iominiun� Nu. 124, Gall.ery Tuwer Conclominium; that pert at:�r_jvcr plane <�urfac:e elevation 13U.89 Eeet (Sk. Paul natum) oP Eullc>wir�f;: Bcginning aC NUft:fiW�6C corner of. Block 5, cl,ence Northec�st on Norttierly line 171 .09 feet tt�ence Souti�- e<ist 135. 5 feet ttience Southwest 170.6 Eeet to Bast line of <,tre�-t tlience Nc�rtl,west 135. 5 feet to beginning being parts i;f K��;lstt�rt�.3 i,and 5urvey 32t3 and Bl.ock 5 of Bt�zil and C:�:er-lns Aadi.Cion. iJni.t 61� and ari undivided .606"/ int�rest :ilt CGiilrlOCl (_�L-'t11E'[1C5 . � • -15- Finance File No. 18113-81 Page 32-33-34 �.SSESSMENT ROLI. KE: 'I'he cosCs of op�ratinA arid mt�icttainin� ttie "TOWN SQUAR�:" publi� spaces for. a period £rom July i , 1�81 t:o June 3U, 1982. AMO IJNT 9-p Gallery Towers 04-14000-260-OS $ • 76 (;andominium No. 12�►, Gal.lery Tower Condominium; that part above pl.nne surface elevar.ion 130.89 feer (St. Paul Datum) ;>i follocaici�;: Behinnin� �t Nor. thwest corner of Block 5, tY�ence � Nc�rtlieast r�n �rorrt��rly line 171 .09 feet thence Southeast i35. 5 fee� thence Southwest ] 70.b feet to Eest line of Street rlience Norttiwest 135. 5 feet tc� be�inning F,eing parts of Reg- t�;tered Land Survey 328 anci ��lock 5 of Bazil and Guerfns �".clditioci. Unit 611gnci an undivided . 786% interest in c�:ornmo« elements, � Frank T• Y. Lee 04-14000-264-05 .44 Candas��.nium No. 124, Gbller}r Tower Condominium; that �erC abc�•vc plane surface eLevation 130,89 feet �SC. paul Detum) c>r foilowing: Begins�ing at iVorthwest corner of Block S, thc�nce Nortt►east nn Norttierly line 171 .Q9 fe�t thence Sou�h- e�sc 135. 5 feet thence S��uthwest 170.6 feet to EasC line of ' str<.�t� tttence Norttiwe�C 135. 5 feet r.o beginnin� be$ng parta ot E:i:�;Lster�d Land Sur�rey 3?.8 and Hlack 5, Bazil and ;;u�::ri.ns Addition. Unit 701 and an undivided .457% interest ie1 �ommc>n elements, Gallery Towers . 04-14000-268-OS • �' Conjominium No. 12µ, Gellery 7:'awer Condominium; that part above �lane surface elevation 130.89 feet (Sr. Paul Datum) o� following: Beginnin� at Northwest corner of Block 5, thence Northeast on Northerly line 171.09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 feeC thence Soutt�raeat 170.6 feet ta East line of street thence Northwest 135. 5 feet to beginning being parts csf Ttegistered Land Surve,y 328 and Block 5, of Bazil and �t�erins Addition, Unit �02 And an undivided • 557% inter�st in common elernents . Gallery Towers 04-14000-272-OS '38 t;o��d��mini�m No. 1'l4, Gallery Tower Condominium; that part ��hnve plane surf.r�ce elevation 130.89 feet (St. Pa�l Datum) ��f following: Begianing at Northwest corner of Block 5, chznce Nortt�east on Nortt�erly line 171 .09 feet thence South- <_.xsc 135. 5 feet thence 5outhwest 170.6 feeC to East line of sereet tl�e�ice Norttiwest 135. 5 feet to beginning being parts o,`.- fte�iscern<1 Land Survey 328 and Block 5 of Bazil and C;uerins Addition. Unit 703 and an undivided .396% interest in cumnion eleinen[s . i -�6- • �`7��4�5 Finence File No. 18113-81 pe�e 34-35-36 ASSE5SMENT ROLL RE; 'Zhe costs of operatinA tirici rnaintainin� the "Ti7WN SCjUARE" public spaces for � period �rom J»ly l , 7.9$:i to ,�une J0, 198"l. AMOUN'� �s-F Gallery Towers 04-14000-276-OS $ .45 c;ondorc�ini_um No. 1'14, Gall.ery Tc7wer Cond�minium; that part aLove plane surface elevati�n 130.89 feet (St . Paul DAtum) c�f Eoilowic;g: Beginninf; �it Nortiiwest corner of �ilack 5, thence r�c�rtheast on Northerly �in� 171 .09 fe�� thence Southeast 1:5�. % Leet tt�ence Southw�.�st 170.6 Eeet c:a East: line of Street tl:ence rii>retiwest 1 t5. 5 feer. to be�;inning b�ing parts of Reg- istez-ed I:a:ic! Survey 328 er�d k31�ck S of Bazil ��nd Guerins :'idcii.tioii. U�lit704 ar►d .�i� undivid�d .468y interest in common el�ments, Gallery Towers 04-14000-280-05 .39 Ce�ndominium No. 124 , GalTery Tower Condominium; that part abvve plane surface� ele.vation 13U.89 feet (St. P�ul Datum) of following: Be�ir�ning at NorCtiwest corner of Block SY thence Northeas� on Northerly line 171 .09 feeC thence aoue}i- er�st 135. 5 feet thence Soutl�west 170.6 feet. to East �line of strf�et tt�ence Northwest 135.5 feet co beginning being parts of Kegis�ered Land Survey 328 and Block S, Bazil and Guerir►s Addi tion, llnit 705 ar�d an undivided •398�� in�eres t in commor� elements, Gallery Towers , 04-14000-284-OS .43 Condominium No. 1`L4 , (;allery Tower Conda►ninium; thet part �bove plan� surface clevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul D�tum) of following: Beginnin�; at NorthweAt carner of $lock S� ei�erice Northe��t on Northerly Ii��e 171 .09 feet thence South- c-ast 135. S ie��t Chence Southwest 170.6 feet to E�asC li.nc of s t.ree t th� ��ce Northwes t 135. 5 f.eet t.o be�inninK t�ein� parts ai: Kegistere� L�nd Survey 328 and f�lock 5, of Bazil and Guer.iris Adc3i_tian, Unit706 and an undivided .443% interes;: f.n i:ccnmon el.>ments . Gallery Towers 04-14000-288-OS . 51 (;:,�idoinini.u►r� No. 124, (;allery Tower Condominium; that part al�ove �71.ane surtace elevation 130.89 feet (SC. Paul Datum) vi: f.cllowing: Be�;inning at Northwest carner of $lock 5, it;er�ce Northeast on NorCherly line 171 .09 feet thence Sauth- e��st 1s5. 5 feet thence SoutlYwest 17U.6 reel to East line of s;:a��c�t tkierace Nortt�west 235. 5 Eeet to t�egin<<ing being parts oE F�.��;iarere�3 Land Survey 32F� and �31ock 5 of Bazil and Guc�rins Addita.on. Unit 707 and an undivided , 524% interest :n common elemenCS . � -17- � Finance Ffle 1V�. 18113-81 Pa�e 36-37-38 AaiF:SSMT:N'1 R�I.I. l;E: Tt�e costs �t apereting �nd ni�intaining t}ie "'T(�JN SQUAF�E" public s�aces tor a period �rom July 1 , 19£31 eo ,7une :jU, 1982, AM�UIJNT '�-r Gallery •Towers 04-14000-292-OS $ . 55 Condominium No. 1.24, Gailery `Po�aer Condominium; tt�at part • Libove plare�e sur. face elevatio.i l3Q.f39 feet: (St. PAUl DAtum) <;f foliowin�;: Iieginnin�; �t Norc.t}we�C corn�r of Block 5, Ctience *JC�rthear�t on t�!<,rtherly 11nc 111 .C�1 feet ehence Southeast 135. 5 fe�t t:i�r:�ice Sou�:I�west 17;).f� feec tc� East Line oP Stre�t t.liei�ce N�rtti�a�?st 135. � 2:��et. t:o i.,c>�,inriin�; heirig parCS of Rep- :.:;�c�red L�ind Survey 328 anci nlc,:��: .'>> of' Bazil and Guerins Addtr.ion. Uzitt 70f�rid a�t undivi�ic�d . 566°J 3_�1terest in ..�i�TlillO[l 1_'1 E'IF:!'CI t 3, (;allery Towers O�F-14000�296-OS .44 !_'c ndo!nin3.um No. 1�4, Gr�tlery� "Tower Gondotninium; that p�rC ' .al,;jve plane :iurtact: e.�evatic,n 130,89 teet (St. P�ul D�tum) c>i: followiiyg: Be�i.�7i�irt� �c lVurthwest cnrner ot Block 5, tite:nce Noi-thea�at on Nor�:lierl.y line 171 .09 feet thence So�tti- e>�ist 1"3`_i. ; fEet thenc� S�uCi�west 170.6 feet to East line of :>t:r;�et tl�encr� N�rthw�est 1"i�. 5 feet to beginr�ir�g being parts ��i R.egist�:red Larid Siirvey 32tj and Block 5, Bazil end t:uf�rins Additiacz. Unit. 709 �snd an un�3ivided .457% interest 'Lr� c�[ntnon ele[i+�:�lt�. Gallery 'I'o�aer� � 04-14000-300-OS . 59 (;c:n�;o�ninium Nc�. 1�4, C;a11�z�y Tower. Condomi��i�m; that E>azt al;ove plane �.<<rface €:levatian �3C1.89 feet (SC. Paul. T�tum) a[ �ollowing: Beginnic�g at NorChwest corner of Block 5, �ftence Nurr_het�st on tVorcherly line 171 .09 feet r.hence �outh- cast 135. � ie�:t thence SouttiweaL 170.6 feet Co East 11ne of street the;:. � North�aest 135. 5 feet to beginnink being parts :�i T�egistLrtJ Land 5urve 32$ F3Cl(j Block 5, of Bazil and (;uerins F.d�:iiCi_on, Unit �1� an:.i an t�ndivided .606%, �nterest: in co�rimor� �.r ie,nents . (;allery 'Towers 76 Q4-1��OU0-304-05 t;u„d.�r,�i :��iii�c� No. 12�{, (;�llery 'Tower Condo�ninium; that part :�;,,�v;;� F,(ane surEace ele.vation 130.t39 fee[ (Sr_. Paul llatum) :,E foi iowin�;; I3eginni�ig at tJortlrwtsC corner oE Block 5, �t;ence .�Urti�easr. on Nort}�erly line 171 .09 feet tl�enc� Soutit- :.rsst 135. 5 f:eet thence Southwest 170.6 Eeet to East line of si.i�•��c t:lienee Nortl�west 135. 5 iei:t co l�eginning l,eing parts of };c�,isLerc=� Land Survey 328 ar�d fil.c�ck `_� of BFjzll and (;u�rins Addit:ion. Unit 711 a�ici an undivided . 786%. i�iterest ir� common elements . � _lg_ • FinHnr_.e Filc� No. 1cS11:3-�1 �rah� 38-39-40 ��s�,rssriF�:cr•r kot,i. f;F?: ",'k�E� ��,:cc�� ot oc>err�tin�; ��t�i m�intainii:�� tli� °1'i'C74JN SQUAitE" public s��aces Eor a p��riad f;aum ,Jul.y 1 t 1y81 �,; .luc;E� 3Uq 19F32. A MO t7Pd'f' i-f� Gallery Tc�wers 04-14000-308-OS $ .44 C;cndc�minidisu Pdo. 12�� , ('allti�y 'i'or,d�r t;��nclominium; Ci�at par't �t�ovc� ��lane surta�:2 elcv�a�iot� 13U.t39 feet (St . I�au'1 I)atu[n) ui: tc�lln+atnt;: ]3e�;tnr�ir+.f; at Nortf�tre:�t cc�rner c>t Rl.ock 5, thence ri:�rllieast: on tJorti�c-r,y Ilne i71 .(39 l�et tl�ence :ioutt�c:�st . _ 1_35. `_? tE�;�t tlience Ss�utnwc>si 1�1 ).t� teet t_o k;a5t 11ne i�f Street ti�ei�ce N��rrhwest 13`_�;. ; t�et to l�e�;in��irig i>eiz��g parts o£ Re�- i�;tirrc•�� Lancl Surt�rv :s`'Ei f�?n�! Lllvc:k `� i�f l�t3ril and Gua�r'3.ns Ac3diCi.ou. U�ii t $Ol.�nci acz unc�ividecl .457% �nteresr. i.n coti�i*�c;�i elerneziCs. Gallery Towers 04-14000-312-05 . 54 �;oi�idcrninium r�o. 12�� , i;�].lr�ry T��wer Condc>sninium; Chat part ��l�ove plF�ne surfacc� elc�vaiiun l"30.89 feet (5C. Paul D�tum) �:�!: iolloc:f.r�g: negi�lc�f�cg at Nortiiwest cc:�rrter of Block 5, �I<<�cic� Nc>rti��st on N�rtiierly line ].71 .Q9 feet ctience Soutli- e��st 135. 5 feet the.nce Sotit:hwe�st: 17U. 6 feet to Exst line of :st:rc��t tl�erice NorCllw�:st 135. 5 reec to be�inning beiryg parts ;��_ Re�:;istered I�and 5urvey 328 and lilock .`a, I�azil anc3 ;;�,.�rins i�ddi�i..��u, UniL £�02 and an �sndividc:d , 557% in+�eresC �.n C011l(Il0[1 e1at::ents. (;allery Towers , 04-1�,000-316-05 .38 i;ondomir,iur�i i:a. 124 , G�I1ery Towt.r C.ondomini�.�m; tt��C part <ji;ovr plarie surfar.e elev�tiact l�it).89 feet (SL. Yau1 Datur�i) i�i: iollowin�;: Begii�nin�; at Northwest corner of Block S, _hence Northeast on N�r�h�.rly line 171.U9 feet thence SouCh- east 13�. 5 £ec�t then�e Sauthwesr. 170.6 Eeet lo East line of street th�ence rJorthwest 135. 5 feet to beginning being parts c;�: ttegi.stere� Land Survey 328 and Block �, of Bazil and Guei°ins AddiCian. Unit 803 and an undivided ,396%. interest i�; c�[eimc�n eiemenCS . Gallery Tawers ,45 04-14000-320-OS i;onc�ominiiim N��. 1?4, Gallery lower Condominium; tha t part ai�c;ve plane surlac�e elevation 130.89 feet (5t. Paul 13atum) �>f. t:.11r>wi«f;; Ilegi�ining �i4 NorC}iwest cor.ner or Bluck 5, i '�:enc�. Northa�ast on Nortt��rly line 171 .09 fee� thence South- e>��;� 1L4;. 5 t.`Pet �hence SnuChwes[ I70.6 feet to East line of �:c�:�.�:�t �lience Ncirthwest 135. 5 feet to Le�;ine�in�; being parC:� of. R��t;iste:ed L,dnd Survey _3'l8 and Block 5 of Bazil and G�.�•ri:ls Addir.i.c�n. Unit��4 and an undiyided ,468% intPrest ' iiY cainu�on �:l�nients . � • -19- �i:ibnce Nile N�. 1811.3-$1 C'age 40-41-42. ASSESSMEN'I' ROI,I. ��}:: '7'lie cos�s of operatin�; a�id main�.-.aiizi.ri�; t1iE; "'fi�tdN SQUARP:" puhl:c spaces L-or a period �rc�in July 1 , 19$l to June 30, 1.9�i2. AMOUN'T �i-1' Lawrence T. and Gladys 0'Donnell 04-14000-324-OS $ .39 Cc;ndc�miniinn i�o. 114, Ga11�r.y ':'c�wr.:r. t;ondv►ninium; Cliat �art above plan� surface el�vatior� 130.f39 feet {St. E'�ul Datum} of lallowi.n�;: f�eginninei �t: Nortt�west corr�er of Black S, thence Nor�k�east: on Norcherly l�_ne 171 .09 f.ee.t tlzer�ce Southeast 135. 5 feet Ctience� Sauti�west 170,fi feet t:o Fast line of Street tli�nce Norchwest 13.5. 5 feet. �o l�e�;ir�ninb being parts of Reg- istered Land S��rvey :�2ti and Block 5 of Bazil and Guerins Ac�dition. Uni.t��s and an undivided •398`� int�rest in c�m�no:i elements, Gallery Towers 04-14000-328-OS •4� C�rnc;ominium Na• 1Y4, G�ll�ry Tower Condamini.i�m,, that part a1�c�ve plane surface eJ.evaCion 130.89 feer (S�. Paul Detum) c�: £allowin�: Be�;iririin�; at 13orlhwee:t carner af Block 5, � t:��ence NorCheasc on Narti�erly l.ine 171 .09 feet thence South- e�st 135. 5 feet thence SouCliwest 1'/0.G Leet ta EaBt line of street tt,ence Northwest 135. 5 fe�e to btiginning being parta „f Re£;i:;�.�red Land Survey 3l8 and Blc�ck 5, Bezil and Guerins Addition. Unit 806 and an undivided .443% interest i_n commo+i elements. Gallery Towers • 04-14000-332-OS . 51 (;ondomini.um No. 124, Galler•y 'Tawer Condominium; t�hat part above plac�e surf:�ce elevatian 130.89 feet (SL-. Paul DaCum) aE follawing: Beginning ar Northwest corner a£ BZock S, ti,ence Nartheast on Nurtherly lizie 171.U9 £eet thence South- east 135. 5 feet thence Saut:t�west 170.6 feet to East line of :: creet thence Nor[hwest 135. 5 feet to beginning being parts oF Registered Land Survey 328 and Block 5, af B�zil and Guer.ins Addition. Unit $�� and an undivided • 524°� interest in common elemencs . Gallery Towers 04-14000-336-OS . 55 Cc�ndomLnium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; that parC above pla�ie surfac� elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) c,i ?:ollowin£;; Beginning at Northwest corner of Block 5, ehence Northeast on Norrt�erly line 171 .Q9 feet ttience Soucti- ��ast 135. 5 feet thence Snuti�west 170.6 feet to East line of s�reet ti�ertce Nortt,we:st 13i. 5 feet to beginning being par. rs af FieFistered Lar.d Sui-vey 328 and Alock 5 of Bazil and ;;uerins Addition. Uni� 808 and an undivided . 56b% inte�cest i.c� common c:Iements . , • • -20- Finance File No. 18113-�31 p�� 42-G3-44 ASSESSt1�N'r ROLI. RE: Tt�e costs of operatia�r ancl maintai.nin� th�e "1(�dN SQUARE" public spaces fur a period £rc,ti� July 1 , 1981 t:c� June 3(), 19�2. AMQiJN'Y' y_I, Gallery Towers 04-14000-340-05 $ .44 Condomicsium No. 12G, Gallery `I'c,�aer Condominium; thar. part al>ove pl��ne surface elevatio�� 13Q.F�9 tect (St . P�ul �iatum) oi- followi�i�;: TiegirininY at NorChraest corner of Block 5, tt�ence ii<�:•theast on Northerly line 171 .09 feeC Cl�ence Southeast i ;`,. ; f�e[ thence 5otrtt�ta�:st. 1%i7.6 feet �o East line of' Street Lt;:�i,ce Narch�aest 135. 5 feE�t to be�;inninf, beinK parts of Reg- i :; :erE�d Latid Survey 32Fi c��icl 131acE: 5 of }iazil and Guerins z��id�.t:ion. Unit �09aiid an undivir.fed .k57% interest in c:ot�imcrn elements. � Gallery Towers 04-14000-344-05 . 59 e�ozicic�minii.im Nc�. 11�+, Grillery Tuwer Car►dominium; that part r,bove pla.ne surface elevation 130,t39 feet (St. Paul ll�tum) c�f following: Beginnin�; ae Northwest corner �f Block 5, tl�er�ce Northeast on Norlltierly line 171 .09 feet thence Sou[ti- ea<_�_ 135. 5 reeC thence Soutliwest 170.6 feeC to EaeC line of street thence Northwest 135. 5 feet to beginning being pazta c,t Regi,tered Land Survey 3�8 and Blork 5, $azil and G�.;erins Aclditi.on, Unit 810 a«d art undivided .606% interest in common elements. Gallery Tawers 04-1G000-348-OS � • 76 Condpminium N�. 124, C;�lle.ry Tawer Condominium; that part abave plarie surface elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) uf following: Beginning at NorthweHt corner of Block 5, tl�ence Northeast on Northerly line 171 .09 feet thence South- e�st 135. 5 feet tt�encs Southwest 170.6 feet eo East line of st:reet thence Northwesr 135. 5 feet to be�innin� being perta of Tte�istered I.and Survey 328 and Black S, of B�ezil and Gu�rins Addition. Unit $11 and an undivided . 786y i.nterest i�i common eiements . Gallery Towers 04-14000-352-05 .44 Condciminiucn �7u. 124, Gallery Tower' Condominium; that pert above p1ar.�� surface elevation 130.89 fett (St. Paul Datum) of folloraiuf;: Be�;inni�7�, at N<�rttiweat corner of Block S, ::t,ence NOS'C�lE'F3st on NarCl�erly Line 171 .09 feet tl�ence South- ��asc 135. 5 teet �hence Soutkiwest 170.6 Peet to E:as[ Iirie of si.rcret tl:ence Norr.hwest 135. S feet_ to 1�eYinning being parts oI Re�;iStecec3 I.:and Survey 32n and Block S of Bazil and Guerins Additi�in. Uriit 901 and an u�divided .457% interest� i.ri c;ommon elemenrs . � -��- � Finance F'ile Nra. 1$i1.3-81 Page 44-45-46 C�SSESSTiEN`�' ItUI.L RL: Ttie cae�ts ot oper�ting and ��aineaini��; ti�e 10T(�1ld SQtlRRE" public spaces for a period f.raiu ,3uly 1 , 1981 tu ,)une .30, 1��f2. A1�10UN'I' y� }� (�allex�y Towers OG-14Q00-356-05 $ . 54 CUi1dORililfUtTi No. 1.24, t;rril.t�ry �'ower Condorairiiun�; Ctiet part �bove plane sur¢ece El.evat:ton 130.89 feet (St. Paul D�tum) of foiiowint;: geginnin}; ae Nor. tftwest corner of Tilock 5, tl�ence PJurtl:eas� on Norttierly ILne 171 .09 feez thence Southeast ; 35. `: �eet tk�ence Sc7irtt��;,;. l 'It).6 feet to �aHt line of Street �1��-nce Nortt�wesC 135. 5 feer. to t>YKinning hein� parte� oF Reg- i.s ic red Lbncl Survey 328 Rtt(J Block 5 of Br�zil. and Guerins Ac :iit.ion. Unit902 anci a�i �.en�l�vi�ed . 557% inCerest in c:i��;�;t��-`« elemenrs. Gallery Towers .38 04-14000-360-OS Cc,ndominium No. 12�a, Gallery Tower Condominium; that part abovE pl�ne �urface eleva�ion I30,89 £eet (St. Pnul Uatum) o�' f.olluwing; Beginning at Northwest corner of $lack .5, r.hence Northeast on i3ortiierly line 171 .0� feet [her►ce Soutti- east 135. 5 Pee� then�;e ;,vuthwest 170.6 feet to Eaet line �f :�r.reet tilence NorChweye. 135. 5 feet to beginning being parts uf �te�istered Land S�arvey 328 and Block 5, �azil and (;u2rins Addition, Unit903 and an undivided .396% inter�sc Yn comci�on eleri�ents. Gallery Towers , 04-14000-364-05 •�'S t;ondominium No. 1'l4 , t;�ller.y Tower Condomfnium; that pert ahove ptane surface e1�vaCion 130.�39 feet (SC. Paul Datum) 3i: fallUwing: Be�innin� at NorthwesL corner nf Block 5, chen�ce Northeast on Northerly l�n� 171 .09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 teet theilce :�outt�west 170.6 feet to East Zine of str.eet ttience Northwest 135. 5 feet to be�inning being parCs a.F �te�;i.sr.ex•ed Lanci S�1rvey 328 ard Block 5y �E l�ezi2 and 4::u.�i-ins Addit.i.on. Unic 904 ar�d an iicidivided •46�� intere�t ir� conimon e lements . G�llery Towers 04-14000-368-05 .39 Condomii�ii�m Nu. 12.�+, G�11ery Tower Condc�minium; that part �+i>c>ve pla�xe �;urLace elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul Darum) c;[ Lc�llowing; t3eginning aC t�orthwesc corner of Block 5, ;:l,er,ce Norcl�er�st on Nox�ti,erly line 171 .09 feet tlience Soutl�- eas� i35. .`; 'teet lhence Soulhwest 110.6 f.eet to East line of� st:.-�>er_ t�l�E�sice Nortf�west 135. 5 feet to I�epinnin� bei�Y�; ��arts <yi 12ef;i:>cered Land 5urvey 328 and 13I�ck 5 of B�i'L�L and G«erins Addii.ion. Unit905 and an undivided .�98% interesC � i; r_orr�mon elE�ilE2RCS . • • _22_ Finance gile iVo. 18113--81 pag� 46-47-48 ASSESSI�:NT It�)1.'f� t•:I;: '1't�e Lo�ts of operating a�z� maintaiizir�f; Che '"T�J1V SQUARE" public spaces fur- a period ti'urn ,1u1y 1 , 198i co ,Tune 3U, 1yF32, AMUUMI' .;_�; (;allery Towers 04-14000-37'L-05 $ ,4� Cl)[iOO[CilIILUTII tvo. 124 , Gal.lrx�y 1'uwir Cc>ndc�min��ni; thaL �art_ <�bove ��larie s��rface elevatiun 1.3C3.8a Eec-� (St. Paul Detunij ot: iollo;ai.af;: B��;z.n�Yin,�; a�. Norcliwest. c:or�Yer of T31.ocic 5, tt�erice Norci:ea,e on NortlicrxEy 1i;�� 171 .09 i:eet thernc� Sc�uCt�east 1 35. 5 tF:e t thc=rEc� So:.ttt,�..;;-:;t 1 70.6 E`eF e c�7 �;es t li.ne of 5 trc�e t �f��c;�re Nor�l�wesC 135. 5 :=c�•� to be�;t_su�in�; bcit7�; part� of iteY` ie,r� rz�c? Lan�l S�lr.'vey 31f; <�nci };lock � uf �i:�ril. and G�.ierins r',;i�i i i i�n. Uni.c 906 artd an uaditricled .443%: i�lteres t in :.:c;rt�.�rr,n a�i;�.�m�nt�. Gallery Towers 04-14000-376-OS . 51 c.;r�,�:iorninii�m Nc3. i%4 , G�s11�ry 'Towc�r. Condc,minitim; that C'>srt ��l�,;ve piar.�e surEr�ee c-lc�vatior-� 7.3i)�89 feeC (St. Paul U»tum) �;!: iol:to�aing: B�ginniii�.; at iVort:hwcst corner nf. f�lc�cic 5, t .-.r=��cr Nc�r[he�ast on tdcirttierly licie 171 .04 feet thence Sourh- e<�=,� 1:35. 5 feet then�� :;o«tl�we�st 170. 6 feet tc� �asC line of .,s_r�:•c�i: tl�encti Northwest. 1:?,5. � fc>et to be�.;innin� beinp, parts ��t Ke�;i:� �L�i ed t..and Survey "32:s and Y.•lock 5, f;�zil t�nd t;u�>rins Addi_lic.n. Unit907 as�d an undivi�ed . 524% interes�: i:i c:crn�rrioi� el��me.nLS, Warren D. Stortroen • 0�,-14000-380-OS . 55 i_;,;ndomini�.an IVo. 114 , Callery Tawer Condaminium, that part ahove E�iane surface elevation 130.89 fcet (SC. Paul I�tum) of }ollo�aing: Beginning ar. Nortliwes� corner af Block 5, tl�ence Northeast on NorCherly line 171 .09 feet tl�ence SoutYi- er�st 135. 5 teet thence Southwest 170.6 feet to Easl line of :,treet thence Norttir.�esC 135. 5 feet to begir�ning being parts c;ti Registered I,and Survey 328 and Block 5, o� i3pzil �and G.:ei-ins Addition. Unit908 ��d an undivided . 566%, inteiesc i.i7 r_vmmorr e).r_mei�CS . RutYi E. Erickson 04-14000-384-05 .44 �;onciomiz�i.uni Nca. 124 , G�llery Tower Condaminium; that part �;ibove pla��e siix-Lace elevatiod� 130.89 fee� (St. Paul Datum} �_�I` followinf;: Beginciing at North��est corner of Block 5, tt�i�nce NorCheast on Northerly 3.ine 171 .09 Leet tt�ence Soutt�- j�<�se: 135. 5 feet ti�ence So�thwest i70.6 Eeet to E�st line of street tl�ence Norti,west 135. 5 feet to l�eginnin�; bein� parts ' oi Re�;istered I.,and Si:rvey 3l8 and Block 5 c�f ti&�il and c;uarins Addition. Uni� 909 snc� an u�idivided .457% interest tii comman elernents . • -23- • Finanii: Pile No. lt3i l�i�-81 Page 48-49-50 A55ESSMF:N'C KOLI., Kf:: 'Ti�c= cc>.�c:_� o*" oper�,r.ing; anc3 rnaint.ciiiin}z ttie "'T'�7N SQUARk;11 public sp�ces foi- a peric,d `r�;rn Jijl.y i , 1.981. to Ji:�le� 3�, 1�i82, AMOUMT' `1-t' Gallery 'lowers 04-14000-388-05 $ . 59 ;;anciu��r; ��iu►n No. 1'l4 , C�i7.�c�r;r 'j'ow�� Cundominium; that part 1ztu,ve pzr+zie surface el.ev�I.ic�u 13f).�:9 f�ec (SC. Yaul Datum) o(` follur�i��g: I3e�;i�te�is►�; at. NoittiweEt c�r�7er of Block 5, ltie�lce Pac;,�tti:�<ist: c�rt t�ort:tierly li.�ie 171 .09 reet thence Southe�ist i3 :i. ', tcet r.Eience South�a�st 170.6 ftiet to �;ast li�Ye of Street tl�c-r«e taorchwest 135. S ieet tc� Le�;ianin}; heing parts of Reg- �t:; ; c �;�i�d L�:�nd ��urvey 32£3 ,=�:�d T;lock 5 of }x��ril. a�Yd Guerins ':d��i c ion. t)�ii�910 and ��;: undi vided .606% i.nteres k in i.:�:ltiliFii:i[l EL('.TIIC'11L3, Gal.l.ery Towers 04-14000-392-05 . 76 C;a�'�<;�-�,�iini:ir€r I�cs. 1'14, (�alx�ry Tower Conclomicnium; rhr�t part cit,ove pl�an� surface eievarion 1:l0,89 feet {SC. Paul Datum) ol 'tallo�aing: Beginn�.r��; 3t Northwect corner oC $lock 5, tiience TVorth�ast. asi Nart:tjerly line 171 .09 feee rchence SouLh- e�st 135. 5 feet thence Sc�utt�west 170.6 Eeet to East lioe of sr.reet t��ence Northwe:�;: 135.5 f��et ro begirxning beic�g p�rts c�f Registered Land Sur•v�:, 32f3 and Dlock 5, Bazil and Gueri�7s Ad�liti.ori„ t,n�.L 911 and �n undivided . 786% ineer�at i� cotumoct elemerits, Gallery Towers 04-14000-396-OS .44 Cc�nciomiui.utn No. 12ti , Gallery '1'ower Conduminium; that part f�bave plane surface ele�✓ation 130,89 fcet (Sto Yaul t�t.um) of. follo;ain�;: BeKinnirsg at Nurthwest corner of Block 5, t.l�e,«ce Norttieast on North�rly li.ne 171.09 feet thence Sauth- east 135. 5 feet tt�ence Southwest 17U.6 f•eet ta East line of sr.ree.t ti�ecice N�rthwest 135. 5 feet to beginning being parta aF �ZeKistered Land Survey 328 and Block 5, oF Bazil �nd �u�:rins Addttion, Unit1001 and an ►�ndivi.ded .457%, int.erest iii coninion eiements . Gallery Tawer.s 04-14000-4Q0-OS . 54 ��oncloniin:[�.im t�fo. 124, Gt�llery T'��wer Condominium; ttiat part .3l�ove plane :;ur�a�ce elevati.on 13G.89 feet (St. Pau1 T)atum) ��f i:�;X!«wirif;; Heginnin�; at IVorthwes[ carner of BiQC�C 5, ri�e�rsca� idort.hefisl on Nortlierly line 171 .Oy f.eet ttien�e SouC}i- ..r�s�.: 1_s'>. � reet ttience Southwest 170.6 feet to E�st 1ine. of sr.. eer thecice Nortl�w�st 135. 5 feet co l�eginning being parts �:�1 ke�;istc�rcd Lan�3 Sui'vey 328 and �3Locic 5 of Razil �nd i:ue.rins Acidition. Unit1002 �nd �c� undivided . 557% interest in comn�on �IelnP_RtS . • • -24-- 1'inance File r�o. 18113-81 page 50-51-52 ASSE�SMEtJ1' [t0I,1. K}s: 1't�c: cvsCs of <�peratiri� arid �ri��icttaini.iK tt�e "'I't�JN SQUAIf{d:" �ublic spaces for a � pe��i.od £r�otn Ji+ly 1 , 1981 Co .lune 30, 1�82., AMUUNT 9�r; Gallery Towers 04-14000-404-05 $ •38 C;onduni;.�iy�+n No. 1"24, G�ller.y T;�wer Candominium; thaC part ��ve: E�Eane surface eleva tion 130.$9 Eee t (S L. paul Da tum) �.�f. t�ollowing: $egieu-ii��c; at Nort.tlwest corner of Block 5, rhence rlortlieast un N�rttierly lir:e 171 .09 feet t:li�nce Soutt�east 135. 5 feiat thence Sour.t�saes� 1f0.6 Ceet ca East line of Street rtl�nce NorthwesC 135. `i f.e,rt �o bekinning being parts of. Reg- i:��c�red Land S�lrvey 3?_8 c+nc! Slock 5 of Bazil �nd Guerins l�dc)icion. Unit 1003 & ari ut�divided .�96% intereaC in �.~rxmuon ele+nents. Gallery Towers 04-14000-4Q8-OS .45 ;;oncicsmiriium IVo. 12�t, (,�,llery Tower C�cad�c�minium; that part ubove plane surf&ce eledation 130,89 YeeC (St. Paul Datum) ot fvllc,wing: �eginai�i�; �t NorthwesC corner of Biock S, ti��nce Nortiieast on idortlierly line l/1 .b9 feet Chence Soutti- e�+st 135. 5 feEt ti�ence So<<tliwe,r. 170.6 feet tm Ems� lin� of :;treet t}ienc_e Nortt�weat .13,S. ti teet to beginnin� being parts t�f Re�;istered Larici Sur.v��_y 328 and I�1ock S, Bm2i1 and Gu4:.rins Addirion. L)ni.t 1004 6 an undivided .468y� interest i�i common elemenr.s, Gallery Towers ' 04-14000-412-OS .39 Cr7i�dor�ficli.um No. 12�� , Gallery Tower Conduminium; tt�et part above piane. surftice elevation 130.89 feeC (Sl. Paul Datum) of followinf;: Beginnin�; at NorChwest corner of Block S, thence Northeast on Nareherly line 171.09 feet thence Sauth- ' east 135. 5 Leet: thence �outhwest 170.6 feet to East line of screet thence N4rthwest 135.5 feet to beginning being parta cf Registered Land Survey 328 and Block 5, of Bazil and G«erina Additian, Ur�it1005 � an undivided •3g8�'� interest i_n cc�mmon elements. Gallery Towers 04-14000-416-05 ' •�3 e,ondominium N�, 12�+, Gr�llery Tower Condominium; Lhat part above plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul Uatum) ��f fol.lawin�;: Begi.nning a t Northwes t corner of. Block 5, ck�ence Norti�Esast on Norttterly line 171 .09 feet thence Sauth- east 135. 5 feet thenc�e 5outh�aest 170.6 feet to East line of str.e�t tt�ence Northwest 135. 5 feeC t.o begi.nnin�; b�ing Rarts of Rehistered L�nd 5urvey 328 and Block 5 of Bezil and Guerins Addition. �1nit 1006 & an undivided .4437 interext • ir� commo[1 eleizieriCS . • • -25- Finance File No. 1&113-81 ��e 52-53-54 ' f�ciSESSMEN7' RULL R�:: TY�e costs uF o�c:ratin� and m�intafrii.n�; t�tie "TOWI� SQUARE" public space:, fc?r �� pEriod �rom ,I�.�ly 1, ly8l to June �iU, 198'L, AMOLiNT `J"� G�allery,;Towers 04-14000=420-05 $ . 51 Gandamiriit�m Ida. 12�� Gallery Tower Condominium; that part above plene surf�ce elevatinn 130.89 feet (St. Paul D�tum) o(: �ollc��aliz�;: Be�inning ar. NorChwest corner o� Block 5, thence rlorth�:asc o�1 Northerly line 171 .U9 feet t;hence Ss�utheast 1�i5. 5 LEC�t tt�enc� Souttiwest 17t1.6 feet re► East Iine of Streec tt�erice N�rtliwest I35. 5 feet tc be�ic�ning bei.np parts of Reg- i.st:ered Land Surva:y 328 Arid BZock �J O� BA`L�Z and Guerina Adcli t:1on. Unit 1007 & dn undivided , 524% inter�at in cocnn:on elements. Gallery Towers 04-14000-424-05 . 55 Condoc�inium No. 12�+, Gallc-ry Tower Condominium; that ��rC F�bc�ve plane surPace elev�txan 130.�9 feet (St. Paul Datum) oE fallowinK: �e�inning at Northwest corner af B1oCk 5, thence Nnrthe�st on Northerly line 171 .09 feet thence South- easr. 135. 5 Fee�t tF�enr.� 5outt�west 170.6 feet ta �ast 11ne af street �:l�er�ce Narthwe.�t 135. 5 feet to be�innin� being part� of Itegistered Lar�d Su��ey 328 anc3 Block 5, Bacil And Guerin�s Addition, 11ni: 100$ & an undivided . 566%, interest in conirnon �lements. Bryan Hannaford , 04-14000-428-05 .44 Cc�c�daminium No. i2'z, (�allery 'Tow�r Condor�iniutn; that part abave plane surE�c� elevetion 130.89 fee[ (St. Paul Datum) of followin�;: Be��:in►iing at Northwest corner af Block 5, t:heace Norttieast r�n Nartherly line 171 .U9 feet thence South- a:�st 235. 5 feet cti�c�ce Southwest 170.6 feet tn East lfne of s tree t ttience Nor.'tt-�ti�res t 135. 5 fee t to beginning Ueing par ts of Registered I,and 5urvey 328 �nd Alock 5, of Bezil and Guc�rins Addir.tan, i7nLt 1009 & an undi�vided .457°1 inl�rest in cornmon elerr�ents . �;allery Towers 04-14000-432-05 . 59 Condominiuca No. 1"l_4, G�liery '!'owe=r. i;i�r,daminium; that ptirt :�!��,vc plane surPace elevatiun 130.89 f�et (St. 1'aul liatum) �f follcwiug: Beh-Lnc�ing at Northw�st corner of i�lock 5, t.l�e�YCe Norttte�sst on Nortlie.rly line 171 .09 feet thence Souti�- r�<.st 135. 5 Eeet thenee Sc�utf�west 170.6 fe�C r.o $ast line �sE st_x•eet tl�t.rrce Nori:hwe�r 135• 5 feer_ to beginning bein�; perCs c:�.i.� Regi:�t:e:red I..�nd Si�rvey 3[8 and Blocic 5 of Bazil pncS �;uerins A��ciitiori. UiYir101Q � an undivided .�06"/<, i►2tLrest ica cornmon elcmPnts . • -26- • Finance File No. 18113-81 Page 54-55-56 ASSESSMENT ROLI, RE: Ttie costs of operatin�; and maintainin� the "TOFIN SQUARE" public spaces for e period £rom July 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUNT y'F G�llery Towers 04-14000-436-05 $ . 76 Condominium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; that part above plane aurface elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) of followin�;: Beginning at NortFiwest corner af Block 5, thence Nortt�east on Nortlierly line 171 .09 feet thence Soutt�east 135. 5 feet thence Soutt�west 170.6 feet to East line of Street tt�ence Northwest 135. 5 feet to beginning being parte of Reg- istered Land Survey 328 and Block 5 of Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1011 & an �ndivided , 786% interest in common elements, KEitti D• and S usan B. C. Sorensen 04-14000-G40-OS .44 Condominium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; thet part above plane surface elevation 130,89 feet (St. Paul Datum) of following: Beginning at Northwest corner of Block 5, tt�ence Nortt►esst on Norttierly line 171 .09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 feet thence Soutliwest 170.6 feet to East line of streeC thence Northwest 135. 5 feet to beginning being parts of. Registered Land Survey 328 and Block 5, Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit1101 & an undivided .457% interest in common elements, Gallery Towers . 04-1400U-444-OS . 54 Condominium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; that part above plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (St, Paul Datum) of following: $eginnin� at Northwest corner of Block 5, tl�ence NortheasC on Northerly line 171 .09 feeC thence So�th- east 135. 5 feet tt�ence Southweat 170.6 feet to East line of street thence Northwest 135. 5 feet to beginning being parts of Ke�istered Land Survey 328 and Block 5, of Bazil and Guerins Addition, Unit 1102 & an undivided • 557`� interest in common elements . Gallery Towers 04-14000-448-OS •38 Condominium No. 124, Gallery 'Cower Condomi�ium; that part �bove plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) c,t following: Beginning al Northwest corner of Block 5, t:hence Northeast on Northerly line 171 .09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 feet thence Soutliwest 170.6 feet to East line of s�reet thence Northwest 135• 5 feet to beginning being parts of Registered Land Survey 328 and Block 5 of Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit1103 & an undivided .396% interest in common elements . • -z�- • Finance File No. 18113-81 Page 56-57-58 . ASSESSMENT ROI,L RE: 'I't�e costs of operatin� and maintainin� ttre "TC�1N SQUARE" public spaces f�r a period Erom July 1 , 1981 to June 30, 198'L. AMOUNT �'N Gallery Towers 04-14�00-452-OS $ .45 Condominium No. 1`1_4, Gallery Tower Condominium; that part �bove pl�ne surface elevation 130.89 feet (St . Peul r)atum) o( following: Be�inning at Northwest corner of Block 5, theace Norr.l�easC on Northf�rly line 171 .Oy feet thence Southeast 1:�5. 5 Eeet thence Southwest 1�0.6 feet to F:ast line of Street thence Norehwe>t 135. 5 feet to be�;innin�; being parts af Reg- istered L�nd Survey 328 and Biock 5 of Bazil and Guerins AddiCion. Unit 1104 & an undivided .468�� interest in <.ommon �lements. Ga1lEsry T'owers 04-14000-456-OS .39 Co�dominium No. 124, Gallery Tower L'ondominium; [hat part above plane surFace elevation 130, $9 feet (St. Paul Datum) of following: Be�;innin�; at Norttiwest corner oE Block S, ttience Northeast on Northerly line 171 .09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 teet thence Southwest 170.6 teet to Eest line of street thence Narthwest 135. 5 feet to beginning being parts of Registered I.and Survey 328 end Block 5, Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1105 & an undivided .39f3% inl-eres[ in common elements, Gallery 'Towers � 0�F-14000-460-OS ,43 Condominium No. 124 , Gallery Tower Condomi.nium; ttiat part above plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) of following: Beginning at Nortt�west corner of Block 5, tl�ence Norttieast on Northerly line 171 .09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 feet thence Southwest 170,6 feet to East line of street ttlence Northwest 135. 5 feet to beginning being parts of Registered Land Survey 32$ and Block 5, of Bazil and Guerins Addition. , Unit 110b & an undivided .443% interest in common elements . Gallery Towers 04-14000m464-05 . 51 Condominium No, 124, Gallery Tower Condorninium; that part , above plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (St. Pa�l Datum) of followin�;: �3eginni�ig at Northwest corner of Block 5, tf�ence Northenst on Nortlierly line 171 .09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 fee� thence Southwest 170.6 feet to East line of street tl�ence Northwest 135. � feet to be�inning being parts of Re�istered Land Survey 328 and Block 5 of Bazil and �uerins Addition. Unit 1107 & an undivided . 524%; interest in common elements . � -28- . Finance File No. 18113-81 Page 5$-59-60 ASSESSMENT KOLL RE: Tt�e costs of operating and maintaining Ct�e "TOWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period Erom July 1 , 1981 to ,Tune 30, 1982. AMOUNT 9-F Gallery Towers 04-14000-468-OS $ . 55 Condominium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; that part above plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) oE followin�;: Beginninf; at Northwest corner of Block 5, thence Northeast on Northerly line 171 .09 Eeet [hence Southeast 135. 5 feet ttience Southwest 170.6 feet to Eaet line of Street tt�ence Northwest 135. 5 Eeet to beginning being parts of Reg- iseered Land Survey 328 and Block 5 of Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1108 & an undivided , 566%. iciterest in common elements. Gallery Tocaers 04-14000-472-OS ,44 Condominium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; that part above plane surface elevation 130,89 feet (St. Paul Datum) of following; Beginning at Northwest corner of Block 5, thence Northeast on Northerly line 171 .09 feet thence South- east 135.5 feet thence Soutt�west 170.6 feet to East line of street tlience Northwest 135. 5 feet to beginning being parts of Registered Land Survey 328 and Block 5, Bazil and Guerins Addition, Unit 1109 & .an undivided •457°� interest in common elements, Gailery Towers , 04-14000-476-OS . 59 Condominium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; ttiat part above plane surface elevation '130.89 feet (St. Paul I3atum) of following: Beginning at Northwest corner of Block 5, tt�ence Norttieast on Northerly line 171 .09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 feet thence Southwest 170.6 feet to East line of street tl�ence Northweat 135. 5 feet to beginning being parts of Registered Land Survey 328 and Block 5, of Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1110 & an undivided .606% interest in common eleme�its . Gallery Towers 04-14000-4$0-05 • �b Co�idominium No, 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; that part aLove plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) of followinf;: Beginning al Northwest rorner of Block 5, thence NorCheast on Norti�erly line 171 .09 feet thence South- e��st 135. 5 feet ttience Southwest 170.6 feet to East line of street Clience Nor•thwest 135. 5 reet to t�ef;inning bein� parts of Ke�istered Land Survey 328 and Block 5 of Bazil and C;ueri�is Adclition. Unit 1111 & an undivided • 786% interest in comman elements . • -29- • Finance File No. 18113-81 Page 60-61-62 ASSESSMENT KOT.I. RE: The costs of operatin� and maintaini�z� tl�e "1'(�JN SQUARE" public spaces Eor a period £rom :tuLy 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUNT 9-I� (;allery Towers 04-14000-48G-OS $ .44 Condominium No. 124, Gallery j'ower Condominium; ttist par[ above plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) of followi.n�;: Be�innin�; at Nortt�west corner of Block 5, thence Northeast on Nor�tierly line 171 .09 feet thence Southeast 135. 5 Leet tkience Southwese 170.6 feet to East line of Street thence Northwest 135. 5 Eeet to t;e�;inning bein� parts of Re�;- istered Land Survey 328 FIl1CI Block 5 of Bazil and Guerins Additio�i. UniL 12Q1 & an undivided ,[�57°/, int�.rest in common elemencs, Gallery Towers 04-14000-488-OS . 54 Condominium No. 12r�, Gallery Tower C,'oadominium; that �art above plane surface elevation 130. 89 feet (St. Paul Datum) oE following: Be�;inning at Northwest corner of Block 5, ttience Norttieast on Norttierly line 171 .09 feet thence So�tli- east 135. 5 teet tlience S�uch�.�est 170.6 Leet co East Iine of street elience Norttiwest 135. 5 £eet to l�e�inning being parts of Registered I,and Survey 328 and Bl�ck 5, Bazil and Guerins Additian, Unit 1202 & an undi.vided . 557% interest in common elemenCs, Galiery Towers , 04-14000-492-05 .38 Condominium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condomi.nium; that part above plane surface elevation 130,89 feet (St. Paul I?atum) of followin�;: Beginnin�; at Northwest corner of Block S, tllence Northeast on Northerly line 171 .Q9 feet thence South- easc 135. 5 feet thence Southwest 170.6 feet to East line of street the�ice Northwest 135. 5 feet t� beginninq being parts of kegistered Land Survey 32$ and �31ock S, of Bazil and - Guerins Addition. Unit 1203 & an ��ndivided .396% interest i.zi common elements . Gallery Towers 04-14 000-4 96-OS .45 (;undominiun� No. 1'24, Gatlery Tower Condorninium; that part above �lane surface elevatian 130.t39 feet (St. Paul Datum) of following: Be�inning at Norttiwest corner of Block 5, thence I�ortl�east on Norttierly line 171 .09 feet thence South- eas[ 1`35. 5 feet [hence Southwest 170.6 Eeet �o East line of street tlience NorCt��west 135. 5 feet to l�e�inning hein� parts of Re�istered Land Survey 328 and ALock 5 of Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1'L04 & an undivided .4b8% interest in common elements . . -30- • Finance File No. 1$113-81 Page 62-63-64 ASSESSMENT KOI.L RE: The cos�s of o{7eratin� and maintai�iug Ctie "T(�IN SQUARE" public spaces for a period �rom ,Iuly 1 , 19£31 to J�ane 30, 1982. AMOUNT y'N Gallery Towers 04-14000-500-OS $ .39 Condominium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominiuen; that part ebove plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) of. followicig: I3eginnirYg at Northwest corner of Biock 5, thence Northeast on Northerly line 171 .09 feet thence Southeast 135. 5 feet tf�ence Soutt�weat 170.6 feet to East line of Street thence Northwest 135. 5 feet to beginnin� bein� parta of Reg- istered Land Survey 328 and Block 5 of Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 12U5 & an undivided ,398% interest in common elements, Gallery Towers 04-14000-504-05 ,43 Condominium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; that part above plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) oE following: Bebinning aC Northwest corner of Block 5, ttience Northeast on Northerly line 1�11 .09 feet thence South- east 135.5 feet thence Souttiwest 170.6 feet to East line of street thence Northwest 135. 5 feet to beginning being parts of Registered L,and Survey 328 r�nd Block 5, Bazil and Guerins Additiori. Unit 1206 & nn undivid�d .443% interest in com�non elements, Galle ry Towers > 04-1400U-508-OS ' . 51 Condominium No. 124 , Gallery Tower Condominium; that part above plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) of following: Beginning at Northwest corner af Block 5, tl�ence Northeast on Northerly line 171.09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 feet thence Southwest 170.6 feet to East line of street tt�ence Northwest 135. 5 feet to beginning being parts of Registered Land 5urvey 328 and Block 5, of Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1207 & ari undivided • 524`� interest in common elements . Gallery Towers 04-14000-512-OS . 55 Coridominium No, 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; that part above plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) of followin�;: Beginning at Northwest corner of Block 5, chence Northeast on Nortf�erly line 171 .09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 feet thence Southwest 170.6 Eeet to East line of street ttience Nortl�west 135. 5 feet to I�eginning being parts of Regis�ered Land Survey 328 and Block 5 of Bazil and Guerins Additiori. Unit 1208 � an undivided . 56b% interest in cornmon elemencs . • -31- • Finance File No. 18113-81 Page 64-65-67 ASSESSMENT ROI.L KE: Ttie coscs of operaCin�; and maintainin�; tl�e "T'(nJN St�UARE" public spaces for a period �rom J�11y i , 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUN'I' `�-I� Christoplier E. Bilkey 04-14000-516-05 $ .44 Condominium No. 124, Gailery Tower Condcrminium; Chat part above plane surface elevatio�i 130.89 �eet (St. Pa�l Detum) oE followi�ig: I3e�inni«t; at NorttiwesC corner of Block 5, ttience Northeast on Northerly line 171 .09 feet thence Soi�tlieast 135. 5 feet thence Southwest 170.6 feet to East line oE Street tlience Northwest 135. 5 feet to be�inning bei�7g parts of Re�- istered Land Survey 328 and Block 5 of Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1204 & �n ur�divided ,457/, interest in common elements, Galler;� Tawers 04-14000-520-05 . 59 Condaminium No. 124, Gallery Tower Coadominium; that part above plane surface elevation 130,89 Eeet (St. Paul Datum) of followinb; I3egi�ining at Northwest corner of Block 5, thence Northeast on Northerly line 171 .09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 feet tlience Soulhwest 170.6 feet to East line of street thence North�aest 135. 5 feet to beginning being parts of Ke�;istered Land Survey 328 and Block 5, Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1210 & an undivided .606% interest in common elements, Gallery Towers , 04-14000-524-OS . 76 Condominium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; that part above plane surface elevation 130.F39 feet (St. Paul Datum) of following: $e�inning at Northwest corner oE Block 5, tl�ence Nortt�east �n Narlherly line 171.U9 feet tt�ence South- east 135. 5 feet ttience Southwest 170.6 feet to East line of street ttience Northwest 135. 5 feet to beginning being parts of Kegistered Land Survey 328 and Block 5, af Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1211 & �n undivided • ��6°� interest in common elements . Gallery T�wers 04-14000-528-05 .44 Condominium No, 124, Gallery T'ower Condominium; that part abc�ve piane surEace elevation 130.69 feet (St. Paul Datum) e�t lol lowinf;: Iieginning a t Nortt�wes t corner of Block 5, tl�euce Northe�sC on Nor�l�erly line 171 .09 fee� thence Soutti- east 135. 5 feet thence Southwest 170.6 feet to East line of s�r-cret thence Norti�west 135. 5 feet to l�eginning bein� parts of l:e�;istered Land Survey 3?.8 and Alock 5 of Bazil BClCj Guerins Addition. Unit 1301 & an uridivided .457% interest in common elements . • -32- • Finance File No. 18113-81 Pa�e 66-67-68 ASSESSMENT ROLL RE: The costs of operating a�id mai��taini�i� tlie "TOWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period �rom July 1 , 1981 to June :30, 1982. AMOUNT `3't' Ga llery Towers 04-14000-532-OS $ . 54 Condominium No. 124 , Gallery Tower Condominium; tiiat part above plane sur£ace elevation 130.89 feet (St . Paul Datum) of followin�;: Be�innin�; at Northwest corner of Hlock 5, thence Northeast on Norttierly line 171 .09 feet Chence Soutl�east 135. 5 feet tl�ence So�thwest 170.6 feet co East line of Street thence Norchwest 135. 5 feet to beKinning heinK parts of Rep- is�ered Land Survey 328 arid Block 5 of Bazil a�d Guerins Addition. Unit 1302 & an undivided . 557�� interest in common �lements. Gallery Tawers 04-14000-536-OS •38 Condomi«ium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; Lhat part above plane surface elevation 130,89 feet (St. Pa�l Detum) oE following: Beginning at NorCt�west corner of Block 5, thence Northeast on Northerly line 171 .09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 feet tt�ence Southwest 170.6 feet to East line of street tt�ence Northwest 135. 5 feet to beginning being parts o£ Registered Land Survey 328 and Block 5, Bazil and Guerins Addition, Unit 1303 & an undivided .396% interest in common elements, Gallery Towers • 04-14000-540-OS .45 Condorninium No. 124, Gallery Tawer Condominium; that part above plane surface eleva[ion 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) of Eollowing: Beginning at Northwest corner of Block 5, tl�ence Nortt�east on Northerly line 171 .09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 feet ttience Southwest 170.6 feet to East line oE street lhence Nortt�west 135. 5 feet to beginning being perte oE Registered Land Survey 328 and Block 5, of Bazil and Guerins Addition, Unit 1304 & an ►individed •468°� interest in common elements . Gallery Towers 04-14000-544-OS Condominium No. 124, Galiery Tower Condominium; that part .39 above �lane 5urface elevation 130.89 f.eet (St. Paul patum) of followinf;: Beginning at Northwest corrier of Block 5, tt�ence Northeast on Norttierly line 171 .09 Peet tl�ence South- east 135. 5 teet thence Southwest 170.6 Eeet to East line of street tl�ence Nortt�west 135. 5 feet to l�eginning bein�; parts of Re�istered Land Survey 328 and Block 5 of Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1305 & an undivided .398% iaterest in common elements . • -33- • Finance File No, 18113-81 Page 68-b9-70 . ASSESSMENT RUI.I. RE: I't�e costs of op�ratin� and maintainin� Che "'I'OWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period £rom July 1 , 1981 to ,lune 30, 19F�2. AMOUN'f 9-F Gallery Towers 04-14000-548-05 $ .43 Condominium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; that part above plane surface elevation 130.89 Eeet (St. Paul Datum) ot foliowing: Beginnin�; at Northwest corner of Block S, thence Nortk�east on Norttierly line 171 .09 feet tt�ence Souttieast 135. 5 feet tl�ence Southwest 170.6 feet to East line of Street tl�ence Nort:hwest ]35. 5 feet to he};i�,�i�►�; being partR of Re�;- istered Land Survey 32t3 and Block 5 oE Bazil attd Guericis Addition. Unit 1306 6� an undivided ,443°/ interest in common elemen[s. Gallery Towers 0�+-14000-552-OS , 51 Condominium No. 124, G�llery Tower Condominium; that part ebove plane surfnce elevation 130,89 feet (St. Paul Dat�im) of following: Beginning at Northwest carner of Block 5, �hence NortheasC on Norttierly line 171 .09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 feet thence Soutt�west 170.6 Feet to East line of street thence Norehwest 135. 5 fee� to be�;inning being parts of Re�istered Land Survey 328 and Block S, Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1307 & an undivided . 524% interest in common elements, Gallery Towers � 04-1400U-556-05 . 55 Condaminium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; that part above plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) of following: Beginning at Nortliwest corner of Block 5, tlience Northeast on Northerly line 171 .09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 feet thence Southwest 170.6 feet to East line of street ttlence Northwest 135. 5 feet to beginning being parts of Kegistered Land Survey 328 and Block S, of Bazil and ' Guerins Addition. Unit 1308 & an undivided . 566% interest in common elements . Gallery Towers 04-14000-560-05 .44 Coiidominium No. 124, Gallery 1'ower Candominium; that part al��>ve plane surface elevation 13U.t39 feet (St. Paul Datum) of followin�;: Beginnin�; aC NorCtiwest corner of Block 5, Chence Northeast on NorLlierly L�l1E 1�1 .09 Eeec Chence South- e��st 135. 5 feet thence Soutli�vest 170.6 Feet to East line of s�reet el�ence NorChwest 135. 5 �eet to l,ef;innin�; beinK parts of Ret;istered Land Survey 32� and Biock 5 of }3azil and (�iierins Addition. Unit 1309 & an ur�divided •457%interest i.ri common elements . • -34- • Finance File No. 18113-81 Pa�;e 70-71-72 ASSI:SSMENT KOI.L RE: The costs of operating and maintainie7�; tk�e "T(�1N SQUARE" public spaces for a period �rom July 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUNT `��'I' Gallery Towers 04-140(�0-56G-05 $ . 59 Candominium No. 124 , Gallery 'Tower Condominium; that part above plane surface elevation 130.89 Feet (St. Paul Datum) oL followinF;: Be�;inninf; at North�oes[ corner of Black 5, thence Nc�rt►�ease on Nor[k�c�rly line 171 .09 fcet therice Southeast 135. � fee� therice Southwest 170.6 feeC to EasC line of StreEt thence Nor�t�west 135. 5 feet to i�e�;irtning heinq parts of Re�;- istered Lan<I Si�rvey 32t3 and I31ock � c>f f1a211 and Gueri��s Addition. Unit 1310 & an uudivicled ,606"/,. interest in cotrmun �lements. (;allery Towers 04-14000-568-05 . 76 c;ondominium No. 124, Gallery 1'ower Condomini.um; ttiat part al�ove plane surface elevation 130, fi9 feet (St. Paul Datum) of f<�lluwing: Be�;inning at Nortt�west corner of Block 5, ttience Northeast on Nortlierly line 171 .09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 teet thence Southwest 170. 6 feet ta E�st line of street tlience Northwest 135. 5 feet to beginning bein� parts of Registered I.and Survey 328 and �lock 5, Bazil and Gue.rins Addition. Unit 13u1 & an undivided • 786�� ineerest in common elements, (;alle�-y 'Towers ` 04-14000-572-OS .44 Condominium No. 124 , G�llery Tower Condominium; that p�rt above plane surface elevatio�i 130.�9 feet (SL. Paul Datum) of following: Beginnin� at NorChwest corner of Block 5, thence Northeast on Northerly line 171 .U9 feet thence South- eas� 135. 5 feet thence Soutt7west 170.6 feet to East line of street ehence Northwest 135. 5 feet to beginnin� being parts of Registered Land Survey 328 and Block 5, of Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1401 & an undivided .457% interest in common elements . Gallery Towers 04-14000-57b-OS . 54 Conduminium No. 124, Gallery Tower Candominium; that part above �lane surface elevation 130.ti4 feet (St. Paul Uatum) ot Lollowin�;: Beginnin�; at Northwest corner of Block 5, tt�ence Northeast on Norttierly line 171 .09 Feet thence South- e<ist 135. S Yeet thecrce Soutl�west 170.6 Eeet to East line of sereet C►ience Nortt�west 135. 5 feet to I�eginning bein� parts of Re�;istered Land Survey 328 and Block 5 of Bazil and Guerii�s Addition. Unit 1402 6� an undivided . 557% interest in common elements . • -35- • Financ�: E%ile No, 18113-81 �'�f;e 72-73-74 ASSF.SSMENT KOLI. IZE: TZie costs ot operatin�; a�id maintainin�; Ct�e "`i'(xdtV SQIJARE" public spaces for a period £rom J�lly 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMUUN'r f-�' Gallery Towers 04-14000-5t30-OS $ .38 C<>ndc;minium No. 1"L4, G�llery Tower Cand�minium; Chat part above plane surface elevation 130.89 ieec (St . Pa�jl I)atum) of: Tollowin�;: i�e�;inninf; at Nortttwest corner of Block 5, thence Nortlieast on Northerly line 171 .09 feet thPnce Sour.heast 135. � fr.et tl�ence Southwest 170.6 feet t.o East line of Street cheuce Norehwest 135. 5 feet to begi«nin�; being parts of Rey,- istered Land Survey 328 and Block 5 of Bazil and Guerins Additioii. Unit 1403 & an ��ldivided ,396% interest in comn�oci c�tements,. Gailery Towers 04-14000-584-OS .45 Condominiiam No. 124, Gal.lery Tower Coi�dominium; that part �bove plane surEace elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) of following: Beginning ae NorthwesC corner r�f Block 5, , t}�ence Nortiieast on Nortlierly licie 171 .09 feet thence Souttz- � east 135. 5 fe�t tt�ence Sou�liwest 170.6 feeC to East line of street tkience Northwest 135. 5 feet to beginning bein� parts of Registered I,and Survey 328 and Alock 5, Bazil and Guerins Addition, Unit1404 & an undivided ,468% interest in common elements, (;allery To�aers , 04-14000-588-05 .39 Condominium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; that part above plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (Sl. Paul Datum) of following: BeginninK at Nortliwest corner of Block 5, tfieace Nortt�east on Northerly line 171.09 feet tt�ence South- east 135. 5 feet tF�ence Southwest 170.6 feet to East line of street tlience Northwest 135. 5 feet to beginning being parts of �tegistered Land Survey 328 and Block 5, of Bazil and Guerins Addition, Unit 1405 & an undivided .398°1„ interest in common elements . Gallery Towers 04-14000-592-OS .43 Condominium No. 12<<, Gallery Tower Condominiuen; that part al.�ove plane surface el.evation 130.t39 feet (St. Paul Datum) of followinf;: Beginnin� at Nortt�west corner of Block 5, c_t;ence Northeast on Nortlierly line 171 .09 fee� thence South- east 135. 5 feet thence Souttiwest 170.6 feet to East line of str-eet tlience Northwest 135. 5 feet to (�e�;inning bein� parts of Re�;isCered Land Survey 328 and Block 5 of Bazil and Guer.ins Addition. Unit 1406 & an undivided .443% interest in c�mmon elements . • -3b- � Finance File No, 18113-81 Page 74-75-76 ASSF.SSIYtENT ROLL RE: The casts of operating and maintaininK the "T(�JN SQUAR�"' public spaces for a period �rom Jilly 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUNT 9-F Gallery Towers 04-14000-596-OS $ . 51 Condominiurn No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; that part above plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) of followin�;: Be�innin� at Northwest carner of Block 5, thence Nc�rCheaeC un NorCl�et'ly llne 171 .0�) t'eec t_hencta SouCheael 135. 5 Eeet tl�ence Souttiwest 170.6 feet to East line of Street tlience Northwest 135. 5 Eeet to be�;inning being parts of Reg- istered Larid Survey 328 and Block 5 c�E Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1407 & an undivided , 524%. interest in common elements. Gallery Towers d4-14000-600-OS . 55 Cor�dominium No. 124, Gallery Tower Coc�dominium; Chat part al�ovF plane suriace elevation 130,89 feet (St. Paul Detum) of following: Beginning aC Northwest corner of Block 5, thence Northeast on Northerly 1ir�e 171 .09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 feet thence Soutt�west 170.6 feet to East line of street t}ience Northwest 135. 5 feet to beginsting being parts of Registered I.and Survey 328 and Block S, Bazil and (;uerins Additio�i. Unit 1��08 & an undivided . 566% interes[ in common elements. Gallery Towers , 04-14000-604-OS .44 Condominium No. 124, Gallery Toraer Condominium; ttia[ part above plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (St, Paul Datum) of following: Beginning at Northwest corner of Block 5, , thence Northeast on Northerly line 171.09 feet thence South- esst 135. 5 teet thence SouthwesC 170.6 feet to East line of street ttience Northwest 135. 5 feet to beginning being parts of Registered Land Survey 328 and Block 5, of Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1409 & an undivided •457�� interest in common elements . Gallery Towers 04-14000-60f3-OS . 59 Condominium No, 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; that parC abave plane s�irface elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) of foliowinf;: Beginnin�; at Northwest corner of Block 5, thence Northeast on Norttierly line 171 .09 feet thence South- � east 135. 5 feet thence Souttiwest 170.6 feet to East line of street ttience Nortliwest 135. 5 feet to l�eginning being parts of Re�istered Land Survey 328 and Block 5 oE Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1410 & an undfvided .606% interest in common elements . � -37- • Fin�nce File No. 18113-81 pa�e 76-77-78 ASSESSMENT ROLL RE: Tl�e coscs of o�eratin� and maintainiii�; ti�e "TOWN SQUARE" public spaces Eor a period �rom ,7uly 1 , 1981 co June 30, 1982, AMOUNT y-N Gall.ery Towers 04-14000-b12-U5 $ , 76 Cuiicic�minlum Nc�, 1 ..'�� , G�ll.ctry '�'�>wcr Cc7nduminium; Ll�ol pt�t C above plane surface elevation 130.$9 feet (St. Paul Datum) of following: Be�inning at Northwest corner of Block 5, thence Northease on Northerly line 171 .09 feet thence Southeast 135. 5 feet tk�ence Souttiwest 170.6 feet to East line of Street thence Nor�hwest 135. 5 feet to beKinning bein� parts of Reg- istered Land Survey 328 and Block 5 of Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1411 & an undivided , 786% interest in common Elements. �allery Towers 04-14000-616-OS .44 Condominium No. 124, Gailery Tower Condominium; that part above plane surface elevation 130,89 feet (St. Paul Dat�im) of followin�;; Beginning at Northwest corner of Block 5, thence Northeast on Northerly line 171 .09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 feet thence Soutiiwest 170.6 feet to East line of street thEnce Northwest 135. 5 feet Co beginning being parts of Registered I,and Survey 328 and Block 5, Bazil and �uerins Addition. Unit 1501 & an undivided •457°� inCerest in common elemenls, Gallery Towers , 04-14000-620-OS . 54 Condominium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; that part above plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) of following: Beginning at Nortt�west corner of Block 5, tlience Norttieast on Northerly line 171 .09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 feet thence Southwest 170.6 feet to East line of s tree t tt�ecice Nor thwes t 135. S fee t to beginning being par ts of Registered Land Survey 328 and Block 5, of Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1502 & an undivided . 557%<interest in common elements . (;allery Towers 04-14000-624-05 .38 Conduminium No, 124, G�llery Tower Condr,rninium; that part above �lane surEace elevation 130.t39 feet (St. Paul Datum) of following: Beginning at Northwest corner of Block 5, thence Northeast on Northerly line 171 .09 feet thence South- eas� 135. 5 feet thence Souti�west 170.6 Feet to East line of sCreet tlience Northwest 135. 5 feet to I>eF;innin�; being parts uf Re�iseered Land Survey 328 and Block 5 of Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1503 & an undivided .396% interest in common elements . . -38- • Finance File No. 18113-81 Page 78-79-$0 ASSESSMENT �ULL RE: Tlie coscs of operaCin� aad maintaininR tlie "TC�JN SQUARE" public spaces for a period £rom July 1 , 1981 to ,)une 3U, 198'L. AMOUNT <a-N (;allery Towers 04-14000-628-05 $ .45 Condomini.�m No. 124, Gallery 'I'ower Condominium; that part above plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) of following: Beginnin�; at Northwest corner of Block 5, thence Northeast on Northerly line 171 .09 feet thence Southeast 135. 5 feet thence Southwest 170.6 feet to East line of Street ll�enCe Northwest 135. 5 feer. to be�irinin�; heir�� art4 of Rep;- is�ured L�ancl Survey 32t� ancl Block S af Bazi1 and Guerins Addition. Unit 1504 & an undivided ,468% interest in common elements. Gallery Towers 04-14000-632-05 .39 Condominium No. 124, Gallery T"ower Condominium; that part above plane surface elevation 130, 89 feet (Sl. Paul Datum) ot following: Be�;innin}; at Nortt�west corner of Block 5, thence Northeast on Northerly line 1/1 .09 feet thence South- f�asr 135. 5 feet: tt�ence Southwest 170. 6 feet to East line of street thence NorChwest 135. 5 feet to be�inning being parts of Itekistered I.and Survey 328 and I31ock 5, Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 150� & an undivided .398% interest in common elements, Gallery Towers , (u+-14000-636-OS .43 Conclomi�iium No. 124 , Gallery Tower Condominium; Ct��t part above plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (SC. Paul Da[um) of Followin�;: Beginnin�; at Northwest corner of Block 5, tlience Northeast on NorCherly line 171 .09 feet. thence Soutti- e�st 135. 5 teet ttierice Sotithwest 170.6 fe�t to East line of street thence NorthwesC 135. 5 FeeC to beginninK being parts oE Kegistered Land Survey 328 and }31ock 5, of Bazil and Cuerins Addition. Unit 1506 & an undivided .443% interest i.n common elements . Gallery Towers 04-14000-640-C�5 • 52 (;uuclaminium No. 124 , Gallery 'I'<�wer Condominiutn; that parC :;i�ov� F�lane s�irface elevati.on 130.89 teet (St. Paul Datum) ��t toilowin�;: Ae�;innin�; at NorthwesC corner of 't)Lock 5, �l;ence Northe�st on Nortl�erly line 171 .09 feet thence South- e<3s� 135. 5 teet t}ienc� 5outh�aest 17�.6 Eeet to East line of stxee� cV�ence Ncir�t�wesC 135. 5 feet to I�e},inninF; heing parCs oi Kc�f;i5tered Land Survey 328 and Black 5 oi: 13azi1 and Guei iiis Additi.oii. Unit 1507 & a�t u��divided • 524`� interes c in i:ummon elements . • -39- • Finance Filc No, 18113-81 Page 80-81-82 . ASSF.SSMENT RULL RE: Ttie costs oY aperating and maintaininK ttie "TO'WN SQUARE" public spaces for a period �rom July 1 , 1981 eo June 30, 198'L. � AMOUNT `�'1' (;allery Towers 04-14000-644-05 $ , 55 i;ondomiuium No. 124 , Gallery Tower Condominium; ehat part �1>ove plane surEace elevatiori 130.89 feet (St . Paui Datum) oL followin�;: BeKinnin�; ac Nortt<<aest corner of Block 5, t}ience Nortl�east on Northerly line 171 .09 feet thence Southeast 135. 5 feet thence Southwest 1�d.6 feet to East line of Street clie�ice North�aest 135. 5 feet to l,e¢;inning being parts of Reg- istered Land Survey 328 and Block 5 of Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1508 & ar� undivided , 566% interest in common �lements. (;a 11ery Towers 04-14000-648-05 ,44 Condominium No. 124, Gallery 'I'ower Condominium; [hat part �bove plane surEace elevation 130, 89 feet (St. Paul Datum) oE followin�;: Be�;innin�; at Nortf�west corner of Block 5, Lhence Nortl�east on Nortlierly line 171 .09 feet ttience So�tt�- east 135. 5 feet thence Southwest 17U.6 feet to East line of street thence Northwest ].35. 5 feet to beginnin� beinR parts of Registered Land Survey 328 and Block 5, Bazil and Guerins Addition, Unit 1509 & an undivided .457%, interest in common elements, Gallery Towers , 04-14QQ0-652-OS . 59 Condominium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; tiiat part above plane surface elevation 130.£39 feet (St. Paul Datum) of following: Beginning at Northwest corner of Block 5, tl�ence Northeast on Norll�erly line 171 .09 feet �hence South- east 135. 5 feet thence Southwest 170.6 feet to East Line of street thence Northwest 135. 5 feet to beginning being parts oE Registered Land Survey 32F3 and Block 5, of Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit1510 & an undivided .606% interest in common elemenCS . Gallery Towers 04-14000-656-OS • 76 Condominium No. 124, Galiery Tower Condominium; that part above pla�ie s�irface elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) uf follo�aing: Beginning at Northwest corner of Block S, thence Northeast on Northerly line 171 .09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 feet thence Soutliwest 170.6 Eeet to East line of sCreet tl�ence Northwest 135. 5 teeC to l�e�;inning being parts of Re�istered Land Survey 328 and Block 5 of Bazil and (;uerins Addition. Unit 1511 & an undivided • 786�� interest i.�i common elemenCs . • _'1�0- • Finance File No. 1H113-81 Page 82-83-84 ASSF.SSMENT RULI. RE: 'ilie costs of o��eraCinF; and maintainiuF; Lkie "TU'WN SQUARE" public spaces for a pt�riod �r�w July 1 , 19F31 �o June 3U, 1982, AMOUNT - `3-F Gallery To��ers 04-1Q000-660-OS $ .44 Condominium No. 1'14, Gr�llery Tower Condominium; that part �bove plane surface elevatio�� 130.89 feet (St . Paul Dat�m) oE Eoilowinf;: BeKinninf; at: Nortt�west corner of Hlock 5, thence Northeasc on Northerly line 171 .09 feet Chence Southesst 135. � feet thence Southwe�t 17(3.6 teet to East line of 5treer tl�ence Nor�l�we?�t 135. 5 feet to t,e};inning being parts of Reg- istered Latid Survey 328 and I31ock 5 of l3azii and Guerins Addition. Unic 1601 & an uadivid+ed .457% interest in commo�i �lements. Gallery Towers 04-14000-664-OS , 5E► Condominiurn No. 124, Gc311ery Tower Condominium; thac part above plane surface elevation 130,89 feet (St. Paul Detum) of followinb: Beginning at Norttrwest corner of Block 5, thence Northeast on Northerly line 171 .09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 feet thence Southwest 170.6 feet to East line of street tlience Northwest 135. 5 feet to beginnin� beinR parts o£ lte�;istered I,and Survey 328 and Block S, Baril and Guerins Addition. Unit 1602 & an u�divided . 557% interest in common elements, Gallery Towers , 04-14000-668-05 •38 Condo�ainium No. 124 , Gallery Tower Condominium; that part above Plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (Sl. Paul Datum) of following: Beginnin� al Nort�iwest corner oE Block 5, thence Northeast on Northerly line 171 .09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 feet thence Southwest 170.6 feet to East line of street thence Northwest 135. 5 feet to beginnin� being parts of Ke�;istered Land S�rvey 328 and Block 5, of Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1603 & an undivided .396% interest in cornmon elernents . Gallery Towers 04-14000-672-OS .45 Concluminium No. 124, Gall.ery "Towc:r Condominium; that part al>ove ��lane surEace elevar.ion 130.89 Eeet (St. Yaul Datum) of foi lowinf;: Be�;innin�; a t Northwes t corner of Block 5, �hence Northe�st on Norttierly line 171 .09 feel thence South- c,a�;t 135. 5 feer. thence Soiilhwest ] 70.6 Feet to EAAC line of s1.r��ec Clieuce NorCl�wesC 13`�. S Eeet. tc� l,e};Lne�1n�; bein�; par. �A of Re�istered Land Survey 328 and Block 5 of Bazil and Guerins AddiCion. Unit 1604 & an undivided •468�� interest in common elements . • -41- • Finance File No. 18113-81 Page 84-85-86 ASSESSMF.NT ROI.L RE: Ttie costs ot operatin� and maineainiii� ttie "TOWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period £rom JuLy 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUNT 9-F Gallery Towers 04-14000-676-05 $ .39 Condominium No. 124, Gallery 1'ower Condominium; that part above plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) of following: Beginnin�; at Northwest corner of Block 5, thence Nortt�easl on Norttierly line 171 .09 feet thence Southeast 135. ` fNer. the-�� Soutt�we�� 170.6 f.eeC r.a Faet line af StreeC tlieiice Nozlliw� ht 135. 5 Let�l to be�;inning betng parts of Reg- istered Land Survey 328 and Block 5 of Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1605 & an undivided ,398% interest in commori elements, Gallery Towers 04-14J00-680-05 .43 Condominium No. 124, Gallery Tawer Condominium; that part above plane surface elevation 130,89 feet (St. Paul Datum) o£ following: �eginning at Northwest corner of Block 5, ttience Northeast on Nortlierly line 171 .09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 feet thence Southwest 170.6 feet to East line of street ttience Northwest 135.5 feet to beginning being parta of Registered Land Survey 328 and Block 5, Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1606 & an undivided .443% interest in cammon elements, Gallery T�wers , 04-14U00-684-OS . 51 Candominium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; t}iat part above plane surface elevetion 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) of following: Beginning at Northwest corner of Block 5, tlience Nortt�east on Nartherly line 171.09 feet thence Soutt�- east 135. 5 feet thence Southwest 170.6 feet to East line of street thence Northwest 135. 5 feet to beginning being parts of Registered Land Survey 328 and Block 5, of Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1607 & an iindivided • 524y interest in common elements . Gallery Towers 04-14000-688-OS . 55 Cundominium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; that part above plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) of f�llowing: Beginning at Northwest corner of Block 5, thence Northeast on Norttierly line 171 .09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 feet thence Souttiwest 170.6 feet to East line of street tiience Northwest 135. 5 feet to l�eginnin�; bein� parts of Re�;isCered Land Survey 328 and Block 5 of f3�ril and Guerins Addition. Unit 1608 & r�n undivided . 566%interest in common elements . • -42- � ��`Y�V Finance File No. 18113-81 Paqe 87-88 ASSESSMENT KOI.L RE: The coscs of operating and maintaininK the "TUWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period �rom July 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUNT ��' Gallery Towers 04-14000-692-05 $ .44 Condominium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; t1�at part above plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (St . Paul Datum) of followin�;: Be�inning at Northwest corner of Block 5, thence Northeas� on Northerly line 171 .09 feet the�ice Southeast 135. 5 teet tl�ence Souttiwest 17U.6 feet to East line of Street tt�ence Nor�hwest 135. 5 feet ta be�inning being parte of Reg- is�ered Land Survey 328 arid Block 5 of Iiazii and Guerins Additi.on. Unit 1609 & an undivided ,457% intereat in common elements. Gallery Towers 04-14000-696-OS , 59 Condominium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; that part above plane surface elevation 130, Fi9 feet (St. Paul Datum) oE followinb: Beginning at Northwest corner of Block 5, thence Northeast on Northerly line 171 .09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 feet thence Souttiwest 170.6 feet to East line of street ttience Northwest 135. 5 feet to beginnin� being parts of Registered Land Survey 328 and Block S, Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1610 & an undivided .606°/r interest in common elements. ` Gallery Towers 04-14000-7U0-OS � , 76 Condomiaium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; that part above plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (SC. Paul C�tum) oE Eollowing: Beginning at Norttiwest corner of Block 5, tlience Northeast on Northerly line 171.09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 feet thence Southwest 170.6 feet to East line of street ttle�ice Northwest 135. 5 feet to beginning being parts of Registered Land Survey 328 and Block 5, of Bazil and Guerins Addition, Unit 1611 & an undivided . 786% interest in common elements . Gallery Towers 04-14UU0-704-05 .44 Condominium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; that part at�ove �l�ne surface elevation 130.89 feet (Se. Paul Datum) of following: Be�;inning at Northwest corner of Block 5, thence NortheASt on Nortfierly line 171 .09 feer thence South- east 135. 5 feet tt�ence Southwest 170.6 feet to East line of street tl�ence Nor�hwest 135. 5 feet to be�inning being parts of Re�;istered Land Survey 32F3 and Block 5 of Bazil and G��erins Addition. Unit 1701 & an undivided •457°� interest in common elements . • -43- • Finance File No. 18113-81 Page 89-90 ASSESSMENT RULL RE: The costs of operating and maintaininK tlie "TCJWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period �rom July 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUNT 9-F Gallery Towers 04-14000-708-OS $ . 54 Condominium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; that part above plane surFace elevation 130.£39 feet (St . Paul Datum) oL followin�;: Beginning at Northwest corner of Rlock 5, ttience Northeasc on Nortlierly line 171 .09 feet thence Southeast 135. � feet thence Southwest 170.6 Eeet to East line o£ Street tiience Norchwest 135. 5 Eeet to beF;innin�; beir�g part� of Reg- istered I,and Survey 328 and I31ock 5 of Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1702 & an undivided , �57�� interest in common elements, Gallery Towers 04-14U00-712-OS ,38 Coudominium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condorninium, that part above plane surface elevation 130.F39 feet (St. Paul Uatum) oE £ollowing: Be�;inning at Nortt�west corner of Block 5, tlience Northeast on Nor. therly line 171 .09 feet thence South- e�st 135. 5 feet ttience Southwest 170.6 feee: to East line of street �h�ence Northwest 135. 5 feet to be�inning beinR parts of Registered Land Survey 328 and Block 5, Bazil aad Guei�ins Addition. Unit 1703 & an ur,divided .396% interest in common element:s. C;allery Towers , 04-14000-716-05 .45 Condaniinium No. 124 , Gallery 'Tower Condominium; tl�at part above plane surface elevation 13U.89 feet (SL. Paul patum) of followin�;: Beginnin�; ar Northwest corner of Block 5, tl�ence Northeast on NorCherly line 171 .09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 £eet thence Southwest 170.6 feet to East line of street chence Northwest 135. 5 Feet to beginnin� bei.ng parts of Ke�.;istered I,and Survey 328 and Block 5, of. Ba-r.il and Guei-ins Addition, Unil 1704 & an undivided •46�°� interest in comn;on elements . Gallery Towers OC+-1j�000-720-OS .39 t;un�lominium No. 124, Gallery Tower Coiidc�rni.niuni, t}�a [ parC �ihove �lane surEace elevation 130.H9 fee� (St. Paul natum) i,i (vllowint;: Ne�;iiu�iu� al Nc)I�thWesL curner of 131ock 5, tLence Nortl�east on Nortl�erly line 171 .09 feet chence South- easc 135. 5 feet tt;ence Southwest 17d.6 feet Lo East li.ne of s�re<=t tl�ence Nortt�west 135. 5 teet to l�e�;innin�; bein�; parCs of Re�;istered Land Survey 328 and Block 5 of Bazil and Guerins Additioci. Unit 1705 & an undivided •398�� interes� in cornmon elements . • -44- � Finance File No. 18113-81 Page 91-92 �ss�ssMrN•r xoLi, RF..: 1'tie coses oi operatin� and maintairilrf�; Che "T(7WN SQUARE" public spaces for a period �rom July 1 , 1981 co June 30, 19�2. AMU UN'f `�-F Gallery Towers 04-14000-724-OS $ .43 Condominium No. 124 , Gallery Tower Condomiriium; Cliat part above plane surface elevation 130.89 Eeet (S [. Paul Daturn) of fol lowin�.;: Be�;inning a t Nor thwes t corner of Block 5, tt�ence Nortl�easc on Nortl�erly line 171 .09 Leet thence Soueheast 135. 5 feet thence SouthwesC 170.6 teet to East line of StreeC tl�ence Norchwe,t 135. 5 feeC to I,e�;innin�; being parts of Re�;- 1r;tcr��cl Lanc1 Survey :�2t3 �n�l lilock � of 13azil and Cuerins Addition. UniC 1706 �" ��l uudtvicled ,443% interesC in common Elements. Gallery Towers 04-�4000-728-05 . Si Condominium No. 114, Gallery Tower Condominium; tliat part above plane surf.ace elevation 130,89 fee� (St. Paul Datum) oE Eollowing: Be�;irining at Northwest corner of nlock 5, thence Northeast on Northerly line 171 .09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 feet thence Southwest 170.6 feet to East line of strec�t �lience Northwest 135. 5 feet to beginnin� bein� parts of Registered Land Survey 328 and Block 5, Bazil and G�ierins Adcfition. Unit 1707 & an undivided . 524%. interes[ iri commo�Y elements, C;allc.ry Towers . 04-14000-732-OS . 55 Condominium No. 124 , Gallery Tower Condominium; tt�at part abuve plane surface elevation 130.F39 feet (St. Paul Ilatum) oE Eollowin�;: Beginnin� at Northwest corner of 131ock S, tt�ence Northeast on Northerly line 171 .09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 Eeet tt�ence Souttiwest 17U.6 feet to East line of sCreet thence Norttiwest 135. 5 feet to beginninq being parts of Kegistered Land Survey 328 and Block S, of Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1708 & en undivided . 566%interest in common elements . Gallery Towers 04-14000-736-OS .� Condominium No, 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; that part above plane surtace elevation 130.89 Eeet (St. Pa�l Datum) �>f following: Be�inning at Northwest corner of Block 5Y thence Northepst on Nortl�erly line 171 .09 feet thence South- e�sc 135. 5 feet thence Southwest 170.6 feet to East line of ' screec tl�ence NorthwesC 135. 5 feet to be�inning bein� parts of Refiistered Land Survey 328 and BLock 5 of B�zil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1709 & an undividecl .G57%, interest in common elements . • -45- • Finance File No. 18i13-81 Page 93-94 ASSF,SSMENT itOLL RE: The costs oE operaCing and maintainin�; tlie "T041N SQUARE" public s�aces for a period �rom July i , 1981 to �une 30, 1982. AMO UNT �-I� Gallery Towers 04-140U0-740-OS $ , 59 Condominium No. 1"l4, Gallery Tower Condominium; tiiat part r�hove plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) o[ following: Be�inning at Nortt�west corner of Alock 5, thence Nortt�east on Northerly line 171 .09 feet thence Southeast 135. 5 Leet tkience Souttiwest 170.6 feet to East line of Street tl�ence Norchwes[ 135. 5 feet to beKinnin�; being parts of Reg- istered Land Survey 32$ and t3lock 5 of Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1710 & an uadivided ,606%, interest in common �lements, Gallery Towers 04-14000-744-05 . �� Condominium No. 1?.4, Gallery Tower Condominium; that part above plane surface elevation 130, H9 feet (S �. Paul Dati�m) of following: Beginning at Northwest corner o£ Block 5, thence Northeast on Nc�rtherly line 171 .09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 feet thence Southwest 170. 6 feet to East line of street thence Northwest 135. 5 feet to be�;inning being parts of Registered I,and Survey 3Z8 and Block S, Bazil and Guerins Addition, Unit 1711 & an undivided , 786% interest in comm�n elements, Gallery Towerti , 04-14000-748-05 .44 Condominium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; th�t part above plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) of following: Beginnin�; at Northwest corner of Block 5, tl�ence Northeast on Northerly line 171 .09 feet thence Soutti- east 135. 5 feet thence Southwest 170.6 feet to East line of ' street Chence Northwest 135. 5 fee[ [o beginnin� bein� parts of Registered Land Surv�y 3'l8 and Block 5, of Bazil and Gilericis Additian, Unit 1801 & an undivided •457`� interest in common elements . Gallery Towers 04-14000-752-05 . 54 Condominium No. 12<<, Gallery Tower Condominium; that part at>ove pl.ane surface elevation 130.t39 feet (St. Paul Datum) of foilowinf;: Beginnin�; at NarChwest corner of Bloc.k 5, thence Northeast on Nortl�erly line 171 .�9 feet thence South- easc 135. 5 Yeet thence Southwest 170.6 teet to F.ast line of street tl�ence Northwest 135. 5 feet to I>e�;innin�; being �arts of Kc��;istered Land Survey 328 ai�d �31ock 5 of Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1t302 & an undivided . 557°Jinterest in common elements . � -46- . Finence File No. 18113-81 Yage 95-96 ASS�;SSMENT' ROLL RE: The costs of operating and maintainin� the "TOWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period �rom Juiy 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUNT G_F Gallery Towers 04-14000-756-OS $ .38 Condominium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; that part above plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) of following: Beginning at Northwest corner of Block 5, thence Northeast on Northerly line 171 .09 feet thence Southeast 135. 5 feet tt�ence Soutt�west 170.6 feet to East line af Street ttience Northwest 135. 5 fee[ to be�inning being parts of Reg- istered Land Survey 328 and Block 5 of Bazil and Guerins Additioci. Unit 1803 & an undivided ,396% interest in common elements, Gallery Towers 04-14000-760-05 .45 Condominium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; that part above plane surface elevation 130,89 feet (St. Paul Datum) o� followinb: Beginning at Northwest corner of Block 5, thence Northeast on Northerly line 171 .09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 feet thence Soutt�west 170.6 feet to East line of street thence Northwest 135. 5 feet [o beginning being parts of Registered Land Survey 328 and Block 5, Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1804 & an undivided .468% interest in common elements. Gallery Towers .39 04-14000-764-05 ` Condomini�m No. 124, Gallery 7Cower Condominium; that part above plane surface eleva[ion 130.89 feet (S[. Paul patum) of following: Beginning at Northwest corner of Block S, , tt�ence Northeast on Northerly li�e 171 .09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 feet thence Southwest 170.6 feet to East line of street thence Northwest 135. 5 feet to beginning being parts of Registered Land Survey 328 and Block 5, of Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1805 & an undivided .398%; interest in common elements . Gallery Towers 04-14000-768-OS .43 Conduminium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; tha[ part al�ove plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul natum) of followin�;: BegLnnin� at Northwest corner of nlock S, Ciience Northeast on Norttierly line 171 .09 feet [hence South- east 135. 5 feet thence Soutt�west 170.6 feet to East line of street thence Northwes[ 135. 5 feet to beginning being parts of Refiistered Land Survey 328 and Block 5 of Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1806 & an undivided .443% interest iri common elements . • -47- • Finance File No, 18113-81 Page 97-98 ASSF.SSM�NT ROI.L RE: Ttie cos�s of operatinA and maintainin� Che 1bTOWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period Erom Ju1y 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMO UN'T �`� Gallery Towers 04-14000-772-05 $ , 51 Condominium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; lhat part above plane surface elevation 130.$9 feet (St. Paul Dat�m) of. following: Beginning al Northwest corner of Alock 5, thence Norttieast on Northerly li.ne 171 .09 feet �hence Southeast 135. 5 feet tl�ence Southwest 1�0.6 feet to East line of Street thence Northwest 135. 5 feet to beKinning be�.ng parts of Reg- istered Land Survey 328 and Block 5 of Bazil and Guerins Addition. UniL 1807 & an undivLded , 524^� inLerest in common elements, Gallery Towers U4-14000-776-OS . 55 Condominium No. 124, Gallery Tower Co�ldominium; thac part �bove plane surface elevation 130,89 feet (St. Paul Datum) of following: Be�;innin� at Northwest corner of Block 5, ti�ence Northeast on Northerly line 171 .09 feet thence Sauth- east 135. 5 feet tt�ence Souttcwest 170.6 feet to East line of street ehence Northwest 135.5 feet to beqinning being parts ot �e�;istered Land Survey 3`L8 and Block 5, Bazil and Gueriiis Additior�, Unit 1808 & an undivided . 566% in�erest in c�mnioii elements, Gailerys Towers O[�-140U0-780-OS � .44 Condominiurn No. 124 , Gallery Tower Condominium; t}�at parL above �71ane surface elevatio�t 130.89 f.eet (Sl:, Naul Datum) of Eollowin�;; BeginninF; at NorthwesC corner of Block 5, tl�ence Northeast on Norcherly line 171 .09 feet thence South- eF�s t 135. 5 fee t thence Southwes t 170.6 fee C to Eas t line of street thence Northwest 135. 5 feet to beginnin� being parts uf Registcred T.and Survey 328 and Block 5, oE Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1809 & an undivided .457% interesC i.n common elements . Gailery Towers U4-14000-784-OS . 59 i;uncluminium No. 124, G�llery Towc:r Cocidominium; tt�at part abov� plane surEace elevatior� 130.H9 feet (St. Paul Datuni) ot l:ullowinf;: I;e�;iz�nin� at NorChwest corner of 131ock 5, ct�e�ice Nortlieast on Nortt�erly liiie 171 .09 feeC tl�ence Sout}i- ea5c 13�. 5 "eet thence Soutliwest 170.6 Eeet to East li.ne of s � ri�et Cl�ence Ncr�hwest 13.5. 5 rcc:t to l�e�;innin�; bein� parts of: ?te?,isCered Lanc� Survey 328 and Block 5 oE Bazil and Guerins Addition. llnit 1810 & ��1 undivided . 606% interest iu curnrnon elements . � -48- • Finance File No. 18113-81 Page 99-100 ASSESSMENT ROLL RE: The costs of operetin� and maintainin� Che "T(7WN SQUARE" public spaces for a period �rom July 1 , 1981 to ,Iune 30, 1982. AMO[JNT 9-F Gallery Towers 04-14000-788-05 $ . 76 Condornit�ium No. 1L4, Gallery Tower Condomini�im; that part above plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) � oF fol lowing: Iie�;inning a t Norttiwes t corner of $lock 5, ttience NortheasC on Nor[herly line 171 .09 feet r.hence Southeast 135. 5 feet ttience Southwest 170.6 Feet to East line of Street tlience Norchwest 135. 5 feet to beginning being parts of Re�- istered Land Survey 328 and Block 5 of Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1$11 b� an unclfvided . 786% interest in common elements. Galiery Towers 04-140U0-792-OS .44 c;ondominium No. 124, Gsllery Tower Condominium; that E�art above plane surface eLevation 130,89 feet (5t. Paul Daturn) of following: Beginning at Norttiwest corner of Block 5, thence Northeast on NorCherly line 171 .09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 teet thence Southwe�st 170.6 feet to Eust line of street tlie�ice Northwest 135. 5 feet to beginning being parts of Kegistered Land Survey 328 aad Block 5, Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1901 & an undivided .457%, interesC in comrnon el�ments. Gallery Towers �4-14000-796-05 � •38 Condominium No. 124 , Gallery Tower Condominium; that part above plane surface elevation 13U.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) of following: Beginning at Northwest corner of Block 5, thence Northeast on Northerly line 171.09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 Eeet thence Southwest 170.6 feet to East line of street ttience Northwest 135. 5 feet to beginning being parts of Registered Land Survey 328 and Block 5, of Bazil and Gueri�is Addition. Unit 1903 & an undivided .396°/�nterest in common elements . Gallery Towers 04-14000-800-05 . 54 Condominium No. 12�+, Gallery Tower Condominium; that part above plane surf.ace elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) of following: Beginning at Northwest corner of Block 5, thence NortheasC: on Nortt,erly line 171 .09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 feet thence S��thwest 170.6 feet to East line of street tV�ence Norttlwest 135. 5 feet to I�eginnin� being parts � of Re�iseered Land Survey 3'L$ and B1ock 5 of Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1902 & an undivided � 557'� interest in common elements . � -49- � Finance File No. 18113-81 Page 101-102 ASSESSMENT RUI.I. Rf�: The coscs of operating and maintaininK the "TUWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period �rom July 1 , 1981 to June 30, 198'L. AMOUNT 9-F Gallery Tawzrs 0[+-1[,000-804-05 $ .45 Condo�z�inium No. 124 , G�llery Tower Condominium; that part above plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) of Eollowing: Beginnin�; a[ Northwest corner of Rlock 5, rhence Nortiieas� on Northerly line 171 .09 feet thence Southeast 135• 5 feet rhence Southwest 170.6 feet to East line of Street �hence Northwest 135. 5 f.eet to beginninb being parts of Reg- istered Land Survey 328 and I31ock 5 c�f Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1904 & an undivided .468% interest in commo�i elements. Gallery Towers 04-14000-808-05 .39 Condominium No• 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; that part above plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) of following; k�eginning at Northwesc corner of Block 5, thence Northeast on Northerly line 171 .09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 feet ttience Sou�l�west 170.6 feet to East line of street tlience Northwest 135. 5 feet to beginninK being parts of Registered I,and Survey 328 and Block 5, Bnzil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1905 & an undivided .398%, interest in common elements, Gallery Towers • 04-14000-812-OS .43 Condominium No. 17_4 , Gallery Tower Condominium; that part above plane surface elevation 13U.89 feet (St, Paul Datum) of foilowing: Beginning at Northwest corner of I�lack 5, rhence Northeast on Nor�herly line 171 .09 feet [hence South- east 135. 5 feet thence Southwest 170.6 feet to East line of street tkience Nor[hwest 135. 5 feet to beginning being parts of. Re�is�ered I.and Survey 328 and Block 5, of Bazil and (;uerins Addition, Unit 1906 & an undivided .443%; inte�esC in common elements . Gnllery Towers U4-1400U-816-05 ' �� Condominium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condomini�m; that part al�ove piane s�irt-ace elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) of f.ollowinf;: Beginnin�; aC Nocttiwest corner of Block 5, thence Northeast on Northerly line 171 .09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 feet ttience Southwest 170.6 feet to East line of st.reet tl�ence Northwest 135. 5 feet to I>eKinryinK being parts of Re�is�ered Land Survey 328 and Block 5 of Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1907 & an undivided . 524% interesC ii7 common elements . � -SO- • Piaanc.e File No. 18113-81 Page 103-104 A5S�SSMENT ttOLi, RE: Ttie costs of operaCing and maintainin� the "TUWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period �rom July 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUNT 9-F Gallery Towers 04-14000-820-OS $ , 55 Coadominium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; tt�at ,part above plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) of followinK; Iie�inning ac Northwee� cor�ier of Hlock 5� thence Northeast on Noreherly line 171 .09 feet thence Southeast 135. 5 feet tl►ence Souttiwest 170.6 feet to Easr line of Street . ttience Northwest 135. 5 feet to beRinning being parta of Reg- istered Land Survey 328 and Block 5 of Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1908 & an undivided ,566% interest in common elements. - Gallery Towers 04-14000-824-05 .44 Condaminium No. 124, Gallery Tower Corrdomin�.um; ttiat part above plane surfbce elevation 130,89 feet (St. Paul Datum) of following: Bebinning at Northwest corner of Block 5, thence Northeast on NUrtlierly line 171 .09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 feet thence Soutt�west 170.6 f�eet to East li.ne of street ti�ence NorthwesC 135. 5 feet to beginning being parts of Registered Land Survey 328 end Block 5, Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1909 & an �ndivided .457% ineerest in common elements, Gallery Towers . 04-1400U-828-05 . �9 Condominium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; that part above plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) of following: Beginning at Northwest corner of Block 5, tt�ence Northeast on Nartherly line 171.09 feet thence South- eas[ 135. 5 feet thence Southwest 170.6 feet to East line of street tt�ence Northweat 135. 5 feet to beginning being parts of Registered Land Survey 328 and Block 5, of Bazil and Guerina Addition. Unit 1910 & an undivided .606% interest i�i G c�ma�o n e l+��me n t a . Gallery Towers 04-14000-832-05 • 76 Condominium No. 124, Gellery Tower Condominium; that part above plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) of followinb: Beginning at Northwest corner of Block 5, thence Northeast on Northerly line 171 .09 feet the�ce South- east 135• S feet thence Soutliwest 170.6 feet to East line of street tlience Northwest 135. 5 teet to beginning being parts of Re�istered Land Survey 328 and Block 5 of Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 1911 & an undivided • 786°� interest in common elements . • -51- • Finance File No. 18113-81 Page 105-106 , ASSESSMENT RULL RE: The costs of operating arid maintaininR tt�e "TOWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period �rom July 1 , 19$1 to June 30, 1982, AMOUNT y-� Gallery Towers 04-14000-836-05 $ ,44 Condominium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; that part above �lane surface elevation 130.89 Feet (St. Paul Datum) o[ following: Beginnin� at Northwest corner of Block 5, tt�ence Northeast on Northerly lir�e 171 .09 feet thence Southeast 135. 5 feet thence Southwest 170.6 feet to East line of Street thence Norlhwest 135. 5 feet to beKinning being parts of Reg- istered Land Survey 328 and Block 5 of Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 2001 & an undivided ,45$% i�iterest in common elements. Gallery Towers 04-14000-840-OS . 54 Condominium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; �hat part above plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) of following: Beginning at Northwest corner of Block 5, ttience Northeast on Norttierly line 171 .09 feet thence Soutt�- east 135. 5 feet thence Soutt�w�st 170.6 feet to East line of street tt�ence Northwest 135. 5 feet to beginning beinR parts of Kegistered Land Survey 328 and Block 5, Bazil and Guerins Addition, Unit 2002 & an undivided . 557% interest in common elements, �allery Towers , 04-14000-844-OS .39 Condominium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; ttiat part above plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul I3atum) of following: Beginnin� at Northwest corner of Block 5, Lhence Norttieast on NorLherly line 171 .09 feeG thence South- east 135. 5 feet ttience Southwest 170.6 feet to East line of street ttience Norttlwest 135. 5 Feet to beginning being parts of Registered Land Survey 328 and Block 5, of Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 2003 & an undivided •397�� interest in connnon elements . Callery Towers 04-14000-848-05 .45 Condominium No, 114 , Gailery Tower Condominium; that part .ai�ove piane surface elevation 130.H9 feet (St. P��1 Datum) oi foll.owing: Beginnin�; at Northwest corner of Block 5, tl�ence Northeast on Nortl�erly line 171 .U9 Eee� Chence South- east 135. 5 feet thence Southwest 170.6 teet to East line of st.reet rl�ence Northwest 135. � feet to 1>e};inslin�; bein� p�rts of Ref;istered Land Survey 328 and Block S of Bazil and i;uerins Addition. Unit 2004 & an undividPd .468%, interest in common elements . . -52- • Fir�ance File No. 18113-81 Page 107-108 . ASSF.SSMENT KOLL RE: Ttie costs of operating and mainCainiii�; the "T(7WN 5QUARE" public spaces for a period £rom July 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUNT y-I, Gallery Towers 04-14000-852-OS $ .39 C�r�dominium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; �hat part above plane surface elevation 130,$9 feet (St . Paul Datum) oF following: BeKinning at North�oest corner of Block 5, thence Northeas� on Northerly line 171 .09 teet thence Southeast 135. 5 feet ttrc.nce Southwest 170.6 feet to East line of Street thence Norlhwest 135. 5 feet to be�inning being parts of Reg- istered Land Survey 328 and Black 5 oE Ba-r.i1 and Guerins Addition. Unit 2005 & an undivided .399% iriterest in commo�r �lements, Gallery Towers 04-14000-856-OS .43 Cond�minium No. 124, Gal.lery 'Tower Condominium; tIIAC part �bave plane surface elevation 130.Fi9 feeC (St. Paul Datum) of followin�c lie�;inning at Northwest corner of Biock 5, ci�ence Northeast on Norttierly line 171 .09 feet lhence South- east 13�. 5 feet thence SouChwest 170.6 feet to East Iine of street Ctiei�ce Northwe.t 135. � feet to l�eginnin� bein� �arts of RegiStered Land Survey 32ti a�id Block S, Bazil and (;uerins Additiort, Unit2��Ub b� an ucidivided .443% i<iterest in cornmon elemen[s. G�llery Towers 04-14000-�60-05 ` . 51 Condoniinium No. 12�w , Gallery Tower Condominium; that part above plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (St. Yaul Oatum) uf L=ollowin�;: Bef;innin�; at NorthwesC corner of Biock 5, tl�ence Northeast on Nortt:erly line 171 .09 feet ti�ence South- east 1SS. 5 Lee� thence So�itl�west 170.b feet to F:ast line of s�reet Chence Northwest 135. 5 Feet to beKinriin�; being parts of Re�;istered Land Survey 328 and Block 5, of �a•r.il and (;uerins AddiCion. Unit 20U7 & an undivided . 525%. i�Ytez•est in common elements . Gallery Towers 04-14000-864-OS . 55 Con:iorninium No. 124 , Galiery Tower Condoniiniurn; tt�at part a�c�ve ��lane surEace elevaCion 130.t39 feet (SL. Paul Datum) of followin�;: Beginnin� at Norttiwest corner of Block 5, cf,ence Nortliea5t on Northerly line 171 .09 Feet tk�ence South- easc 135. 5 feet thenc.e Southwest 170.6 feet to East line of str��ec cf�enc� Nortl�west 135. 5 iet�t to I>e�;innin�; hein�; parts ot Rec;is[ered Land Survey 3'1t3 and Block 5 of Bazii and Guerins Addition. Unit 2008 & an undivided . 566`/ t�1terest iii common elements . • -53- � ' Finance File No. 1$113-81 Pa�e 109-110 ASSESSMENT KULL RE: Ttie costs of operatinA and maintaininK tl�e "TCJWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period �rom ,7uly 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUNT 9-F Gallery Towers 04-14000-868-OS $ .44 Condominium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; that part above plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (St. Paul Datum) oE following: Beginning at Northwest corner of Block 5, thence NorCheast on Nor[tzerly line 171 .09 feet thence Southeast 135.5 feet thence Southwest 170.6 feet to East line of Street ttience Northwest 135. 5 feet ta beginning being parts of Reg- istered Land Survey 328 and Block 5 of Bazil and Guerins Addition. Unit 2U09 & an undivided .457-� interest in common elements. Gallery Towers 04-14000-872-OS . 59 Condominium No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; that part above plane surface elevation 130,89 feet (St. Paul Datum) of following: Beginning at Northwest coraer of Blo�k 5, thence Northeaet on Northerly line 171 .09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 feet thence Souttiwest 170.6 feet to Ea�t line of street tfience NorthwesC 135.5 feet to beginning being parts of Registered Land Survey 328 and Block S, Bazil and Guer.ins Addition, Unit 2010 & an undivided .606% interest in common elements, (;allery Towers � 04-14000-876-OS - • 76 Condominiurn No. 124, Gallery Tower Condominium; tt�at part above plane surface elevation 130.89 feet (5t. Paul Datum) of followi.ng: BeginninA aL Northwest corner of Block S, thence Nnrtheast on Northerly line 171.09 feet thence South- east 135. 5 feet thence Southwest 170.6 feet to East line of street thence Northwest 135. 5 feet to beginning bein� parts c�t ttekic�ter,ed I.end 3��rvey 328 end Hlack 5, of Bazil an�) Guerins Addition. Unit 2011 & an undivided . 787% interest in common elements . i(� Cilyo uf St. Paul - ArCs and Science Center 0[,-14000-010-06 $343.25 Subject to streets as widened for Capitol Approacti ]ilock 6, Bazil anc� Guerins Addition • -54- • Finance File No. 18113-81. Page 111 thru 113 ASSESSMENT ROLL RE: Ttie costs of operating and maintaining the "TOFIN SQUARE" public spaces for a period from July l , I981 to June 30, 1982, � AMOUNT 11-A Cap� Industries , Inc. 04-660U0-020-12 $616.47 In tt�e City of St. Paul Revised descr.iption number 497 a specific part of Lots 1 thru 3 , Block 12, Roberts and Randall's Addition, Cap{� Industries, Inc. 04-66000-031-12 398,40 In the City af St. F�aul revised description number 498 a specific part of Lots 2 and 3 , Block 12, Roberts and Randali's Addition. Ca�7p Industries , Inc. �4-66000-040-12 471 .16 All tliat part of Lots 2 and 3 Southeasterly of a line running from a part on rhe Southwesterly line of Minn- eso�a St. 125 33/100 foot Southeasterly from the cor- ner of said Lot 2 to a part on tlie Southwesterly line of said Lot 3 and 119 feet Souttieasterly from the intersection of said Southwesterly line witt� the nortl�- westerly line of said Lot 2 extended Southwesterly in a scraigt�t line T.ot 4, Block 12, Roberts and Randalls Add. 11-Ii Tt�e ChuzcYi af St. Louis 04-66000-030-12 , 225.24 Nortt�westerly 50 feet of Lots 1 and 3 , Block 12 , Roberts and Randalls Addition. The Church af St. Louis 04-66000-050-12 1 ,248.21 Lots 4, 5 and 6 and that part of Cedar Street vacated between the Southwesterly line of said Lots and ttie present Northeasterly line of Cedar Street in Block 12, Robert and Randall's Addition. 11-C Tt�e Central Presbyterian Church 04-b6000-080-12 1 ,114.06 Part of Cedar Street vacated adjacent and following except Souttlerly triangle bein� 8 99/100 feet on Cedar Street and 111 25/100 feet on extended South line of Lot 9 and all Lot 7 and 8, Block 12, Robert and Randall's Addition. The Centrel Presbyterian Church 04-66000-102-12 �84•22 Vacated Cedar Street adjacent and following South- erly lriangular part of said vacated street adjacent and of Lot 9 being 8 99/100 feet on Cedar Street and 111 25/100 feet on extended Southerly line of Lot 9 and except Northeasterly 100 feet Lot 10, Block 12, Roberts and Randall's Addition, 11-D Lucille A. Schmid C/P Robin Hood Construction Co. 04-66000-101-12 660.51 Northeasterly lOQ feet of Lot 10, Block 12, Robert and Randall's Addition. { � -55- • Fin��nce File No. 18113-81 Page 114 thru 116 ASSESSMENT ROLL KF': Tlin costs of: operatins; and maintaininf; the "TOWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period from ,7uly 1 , 1981 tv June 3U, 1982 . AMOUNT 12-A Hillcrest llevelopment 04-G6000-060-11 $384.$1 Lot 6, Block 11 , RoberL and Randalls Addition Hiilcrest Development 04-66000-070-11 744.55 Lot 7, Alock 11 , Robert and Randalls Addition 12-B Carl Pedro and Sons Inc. 04-43IIOU-U10-00 188• 72 Except Nortlieasterly 20 feet for street; Lot 1 , Lamprey's Subdivision of Part of Block 11 Carl Pedro and Sons Inc. 04-43800-020-00 314. 53 Lot 2, Lamprey's Subdivision of Part of Block 11 Carl Pedro and Sons Inc . 04-43800-030-00 314. 53 Lot 3, Lamprey`s Subdivision of Part of Block 11 , Carl Pedro and Sons Inc. 04-438U0-140-00 212.83 Except Nortfieasterly 'LO feet for street Lot 15, and all of Lot 14, Lamprey's Subdivision of part � of Block 11. 1'L-C City of St. Paul - Police Department U4-43800-OSU-00 752.94 Lots 4, 5 and 16, Lamprey's Subdivision of part of Block 11. 12-ll Ervin J. Nerenberg C/P Claseman and Assoc. , Inc. 04-43800-070-00 407,12 Lots 6 and 7, Lamprey's Subdivision of part af Block 11. Ervin J. Nerenberg C/P Claseman and Assac. , Inc. 04-43800-080-00 183.47 Lot 8, I,amprey's Subdivision of part of Block 11, 12-E Jack Geller 04-43�300-110-00 511 .13 Lots 9 thru 11, Lamprey's Subdivision of part of Block 11. Jack Geller 04-43800-130-00 323.33 Lots 12 and 13, Lamprey's Subdivision of part of Block 11. 13-A Perkegwin Investment Co. 04-66000-020-10 427.76 Except Southwesterly 48 feet of Lots 1 and 2 , Block 10, Roberts and Randalls Addition � -56- . Finance File No. 18113-81 Pa�e 116 thru 119 ASSESSMENT RULL RE: The costs of operating and maintainin� ttie "TOWN SQUARE" puhlic spaces for a period from July 1 , 1981 to J�ane 30, 1982 . AMOUNT 13-A Perke�win Investmenl Co. 04-66000-021-10 $201 .30 Southwesterly 48 fee� of Lats 1 and Z , Block 10, Rober�s and Randalls Addition Perkegwin Investment Co. 0�-GG000-040-10 314.53 I.ot 4, Block 10, Roberts anci Randalls Addition. 13-$ Marvin Sct�loff 04-66000-030-10 314.53 Lot 3 , Block 10, Roberts and Randalls Addition Marvin Schloff 04-66000-140-10 272.59 Soutt�westerly 50 feet of Lnt 12 and Souttiwesterly 40 feet of Lots 13 and 14, Bloek 10, Roberts and Randalls Addition. 13-C Dunor Associates C/P Northern Pro. Inc. 04-66000-100-10 2,012.98 � Lots 5 tliru 10, Block 10, Roberts and Randalls Addition 13-D Tord L. Bjork, et al C/P Intermode Corp. 04-66000-110-10 . 314,53 Lot 11 , Block 10, Roberts and Randalls Addition. 13-E Firestone Tire and Rubber Co. 04-66000-143-10 670.99 Northeasterly 100 feet of Lot 12 and Northeasterly 110 feet of Lots 13 and I4, Block 10, Roberts and Randalls Addition. 14-A Hillcrest Development 03-03900-010-00 209.01 Lot 1, Auditors Subdivision No. 24 Hillcrest Development 03-03900-020-00 218.49 Lot 2, Auditors Subdivision No. 24 Hillcrest Development 03-03900-030-00 545.G7 Lot 3, Auditors Subdivision No. 24. Hillcrest Development 03-03900-050-00 638.20 Lots 4 and 5, Auditors Subdivision No. 24 Hillcrest Development 03-03900-061-00 149.72 Northwesterly 35 feet of Lot 6, Auditors Subdivision No. 24 Hill�rest Development 03-03900-070-00 679.51 Lot 7, Auditors Subdivision No. 24 i -58- � Finance File No. 18113-81 Page 122 tt�ru 124 ASSESSMENT ROLL RE: Tt�e costs of operating and maintaining the "TO'FIN SQUARE" public spaces for a period from ,Tuly 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982. , AMOUNT 14-F Irvin� and Marie Eisenberg 03-34500-041-00 $180.33 Subject to street; Lot 4, Hoyts Subdivision of Morrisons Block oE Hoyts Addition, Irving end Marie Eisenberg 03-34500-050-00 239.88 Lot 5, Hoyts Subdivision of Morrisons Block of Hoyts Addition. 15-A Ideal Brass Works Inc. 89,g2 03-75000-030-00 Souttieasterly 140 feet of Southwesterly 30 feet of Lot 8 and all of Lots 1, 2 and 3, Horace Thompsons Subdivision of Block 4 of Hoyts Addirion. 15-8 Jerome Hirsh 92 .71 03-75000-060-00 Southwesterly 38 feet of Lot 7 and all of Lots 4 thru 6, Horace Ttiompsons Subdivision of Block 4 of Hoyts Addition, 15-C Ttie First Baptist Church and Congregation of St. Paul 143.93 03-75000-080-00 Northeasterly 2 feet of Lot 7 and except Southeasterly 140 feet of Southwesterly 30 feet of Lot 8, Horace . Thompsons Subdivision of Block 4 of Hoyts Addition 16-A Port Authority of St. Paul 166.37 C/P St. Paul Ares Labor Center 04-63500-104-56 Subject to Highway Lots 1 , 2, 3,8 and 9, Block 56 of Irvines Enlargement and in said Rice aad Irvines Addition (Subject to Highway) Lots 8 thru 10, Block 56, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 thru 25 and 42 thru 4 5 and Blocks 54 ttiru 56. 16-B Housing and Redevelopment Authority 65.55 04-63500-103-56 Part of Lots 7 and 8, Block 56, ici Irvines Enlargement Also part of Lots 7, 8, 9 and 10, Block 55 in said Rice and Irvines Addition lyin�; between the present Highway and atreet right-of- way and proposed Highway and street right-of-way lines, Block 56, Rice and Irvines Additi�n, Blocks 1 thru 25 and 42 thru 45 and Blocks 54 thru 56. Housing and Redevelopment Authority 20.53 04-38000-032-56 S ubject to Highway a Tract of land Nor�h and Northwest of the following line; heginning at NorL-heast corner of Lot 1 , Block 56, Thence Soutt�west to West line of Lot 1 and 15 feet South of North line tt�ence Southwest to West line of Lot 2 and 40 feet South of North line thence Southwest to West line of Lot 3 and 85 feet South of Nortti line and there terminating being part of Lots 1, 2, and 3, Block 56, Irvines Enlargement of Rice and Irvines Addition � -57- . Fiaance File No. 18113-81 Page 119 thru 122 ASSESSMENT ROT.L RE: The costs of operating and maintaini��g ttie "TOWN SQC7ARE" public spaces for a period from July 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUNT 14-A Hillcrest Development 03-03900-091-00 $607.04 Except Northwesterly 35 feet, the following: Lots 8 and 9, Auditor's Subdivision No. 24 Hillcrest Development 03-03900-092-00 134.83 Northwesterly 35 feet of Lots 8 and 9, Auditors Subdivision No. 24. 14-B Ideal Security Hardware Corporation 03-03900-060-00 491 .92 Except Northwesterly 35 feet; Lot 6, Auditors Subdivision No. 24 14-C Twin City Picture Praming Company 03-03900-100-A0 194.00 Lot 10, Auditor's Subdivision No. 24 Twin City Picture Framing Company 03-03900-131-00 125.22 Subject to street and except Nortt�westerly 1 33/100 feet the Southwesterly 3 feet of Lot 12 and except Northvesterly part measuring 1 56/100 feet on Southwesterly line and 1 33/100 feet on Nortt�easterly line Lot 13, Auditors Subdivision �to. 24. 14-D Abel Swanson, Jr. 03-03900-110-00 89.33 Lot 11 , Auditors Subdivision No. 24 Abel Swanson, Jr. 03-03900-120-00 171.48 Except Southwesterly 3 feet and except Northwesterly part measuring 1 33/100 foot on Norrt�easterly line of said Southwesterly 3 feet and 1 19/100 foot on Northeasterly line of Lot 12 said Lot 12, Auditors Subdivision No. 24. Abel Swanson, Jr. 03-34500-011-00 291 .50 Subject to street the following Northwesterly 1 56/100 to 1 19/lU0 feet more-or-less of lots 12 and 13 Auditors Subdivision No. 24 and in said Hoyts Subdivision part of Lot 2 Southeasterly of line running from part on South- westerly line of and 4$ feet 8 1/4 inches from Westerly corner to part on Northeasterly line of and 48 feet 7 1/8 inct�es from Northerly corner of said Lot 2 and all of Lot 1 , Hoyts Subdivision of Morrisons Block of Hoyts Addition 14-E Surgical Service Center, Inc . � 03-34500-031-00 360.66 Subject to street part of Lot 2 Norttiwesterly of a line running from part on Southwesterly line of said Lot 48 feet 8 1/4 incties from Westerly corner thereof to a part on Norttieasterly line of said lot 48 feet 7 1/8 inches from Northerly corner thereof and aIl of Lot 3, Hoyts Subdivision of Morrisons Block of Hoyts Addition. � -59 . Finance File No. 18113-81 Page 125 thru 127 ASSESSMENT ROLL RE: Tt�e costs of operating and maintainin� the "TOWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period from July 1 , 19$1 to June 30, 1982. AMOUNT 16-C S ta te of Minnesota 04-38000-041_56 $ 14. 76 Subject to Higtiway; Lot 4, Block 56, Irvines Enlargement of Rice and Irvines Addition. 17-A Knut D. Park et al 19.25 04-63500�010-04 Witti party wall agreement the Southerly 1/2 of Lot 1 , Block 4, Rice and Irvines Addition Block 1 tliru 25 and 42 thru 45 and Blocks 54 thru 56. Knut D. Park et al 23.52 04-63500-090-04 The Easterly 10 feet of Southerly 2/3 of Lot 8; Also, Westerly 1/2 of Lot 9, Block 4, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 thru 25 and 42 tt�ru 45 and Blocks 54 thru 56. Knut D• Park 19.25 04-63500-122-04 Witt� party wall agreement the northerly 1/4 of Lots 11 and 12, Block 4, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 thru 25 and 42 thru 45 and Blocks 54 thru 56. 17-B Independent Sctiool District ��625 - Career Studies Center II 19.25 04-63500-011-04 ' Northerly 75 feet of Lot l , Black 4, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 tt�ru 25 and 42 thru 45 and Blocks 54 thru 56. Independent School District �b25 38.49 04-63500-020-04 Lot 2, Block 4, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 thru 25 and 42 thru 45 and Blocks 54 thru 56. 17-C Emma W. Tarras 37 .53 C/P Ronald & Grace Colosimo 04-63500-030-04 Except Westerly 20 inches, Lot 3, Block 4, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 thru 25 and 42 ttiru 45 and Blocks 54 thru 56. Eama W. Tarras 39.46 C/P Ronald & Grace Colosimo 04-63500-040-04 Westerly 20 inches of Lot 3 and all of Lot 4, Block 4, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 thru 25 and 42 thru 45 and Blocks 54 thru 56. 17-D Rict�ard D. Slager 19.25 04-63500-050-04 Easterly 1/2 of Lot 5, Block 4, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 thru 25 and 42 thru 45 and Blocks 54 thru 56. 17-E Kro11s, Inc. 25.66 04-63500-052-04 East 10 feet of Lot 6 and West 1J2 of Lot 5, Block 4, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 thru 25 and 42 thru 45 and Blocks 54 tt�ru 56. . -60- • Finance File No. 18113-81 Page 128 thru 130 ASSES5MENT IZULL RE: The costs of operating and maintaing ttie "TOWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period from July 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982. , AMOUNT 17-F Au�ust F. , Robert A. , and Arnold W. Kroll 04-63500-061-04 $ 32 .08 Loc 6, Block 4, Irvines Enlargement of Rice and Irvines Addition to the Town of St. Paul and in said Rice and Irvines Addition; Except East 10 feet; Lot 6, Block 4, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 thru 25 and 42 thru 4; and Blocks 54 thru 56. August F. , Robert A. , and Arnold W. Kroll 04-63500-080-04 25.66 Northerly 1/3 of Lots 7 and 8, Block 4, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 thru 25 and 42 thru 45 and Blocks 54 thru 56. 17-G Catholic Charities of the Archdiocese of St. Paul and Minneapolis C/P 0'Halloran and Murphy 04-63500-070-04 32.08 Except Easterly 10 feet, the Southerly 2/3 of Lot 7, Block 4, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 thru 2S and 42 thru 45 and Blocks 54 thru 56. Catholic Charities of the Archdiocese of St, Paul and Minneapolis C/P 0'H�alloran and Murphy 04-63500-081-04 14.97 Southerly 2/3 of Easterly 10 feet of Lot 7 and except the Easterly 1Q feet of the Southerly 2/3 of Lot 8 , Block 4, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 thru 25 and 42 ttiru 45 and Blocks 54 Lhru 56. 17-H Selvina H, Park 04-63500-100-04 56.56 Easterly 1/2 of Lot 9 and except Easterly 2 98/100 feet of Northerly 61 55/100 feet of Southerly 112. 53 feet lot 10, Block 4, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 ttiru 25,. 42 ttiru 45 and Blocks 54 thru 56. 17-I Louis W. Sctiapiro 04-63500-101-04 .78 Easterly 2 98/100 feet of Northerly 61 SS/100 feet of Southerly 112 53/100 feet of Lot 10, Block 4, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 ttiru 25 and 42 thru 45 and Blocks 54 thru 56. 17-C Ett�el Joan Scott C/P Baillon Company 9.62 04-63 500-110-04 Westerly 1/2 of Southerly 1/2 of Lot 11, Block 4, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 thru 25, 42 ttiru 45 and Blocks 54 thru 56. EtFiel Joan Scott C/P Baillon Company 04-63500-121-04 19.25 Souttierly 1/2 of Northerly 1/2 of Lots 11 and 12, Blnck 4, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 thru 25, 42 thru 45 and Blocks 54 ttiru 56. 17-K John I. Wolters 04-63500-120-04 28•87 Easeerly 1/2 of Southerly 75 feet of Lot 11 and the Southerly 75 feet of Lot 12, Block 4, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 ttiru 25, 42 ttiru 45 and Blocks 54 [hru 56, . -61- • Finance File No. 18113-81 Page 131 thru 134 ASSESSMENT ROLL RE: The costs af operating and maintaining tt�e "TOWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period from July 1, 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUNT 18-A Church of the Assumption 04-63500-015-03 $I ,203.80 Subject to Easements and vacated street accruing the following: A triangular tract bounded on the North by North line of vacated 9th street and on the Southeast by 7th Street and on the Southweat by St. Josept�'s Lane being a part of Block 3, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 thru 25, 42 thru 45 and Blocks 54 ttiru 55. Church oE the Assumption 04-140U0-060-09 323.36 Bazil and Guerins Addition part of Northwest 1/4 of Section 6, Townstiip 28, Range 22, between 9th and Exchange Street, and Souttiwesterly of Block 9 in said Addition and in said Addition tlie Southwesterly 8 feet of Lot 7 and the Northwesterly 5 67/100 feet of Northeasterly 25 feet of Lot 7 and all of Lots 3 tt�ru 6, Block 9, Bazil and Guerins Addition. 1£s-B German Roman Catholic Aid Association 04-14000-070-09 258.25 Except Narttiwesterly 5.67 feet of Nort}�easterly 25 feet; the Norttieasterly 42 feet of Lot 7, Block 9, Bazil and Guerins Addition, 18-C Archie L. & Bernard Gin�old 04-14000-091-09 , 230.65 NorthwestErly SS feeh of Southeasterly 115 feet of Lots 8 and 9, B1ock 9, Bazil and Guerins Addition. Archie L. Gin�;old 04-14000-090-09 251 .62 Southeasterly 60 feet of Lots 8 and 9, Block 9, Bazil & Guerins Addition. 1�5-D John E. Blomq uist, Inc . 04-14U00-020-09 272.59 Norr.tiwesterly 3 1/4 inches oE Lots 8 and 9 and subject to ease- ment and except Northcaesterly 85 feet Lots 1 and 2, Block 9, Bazil and Guerins Addition. John E. Blomquist, Inc. 04-14000-092-09 146.78 Excep� Northwesterly 3 1/4 inches and except Southeasterly 115 feet of Lots 8 and 9, Block 9, Bazil and Guerins Addition. 18-E Al�e Sect�ter et al U4-1t+000-021-09 356.46 Northwesterly 85 feet of Lots 1 and 2, Block 9, Bazil and Guerins Addition. 19-A Housing and Redevelopment Authority -- Piolette Apts. 04-14000-032-0$ 733.90 Northwesterly 5/6 of Lots 1 and 2 and Northwesterly 2/3 of Lot 3, Block 8, Bazil and Guerins Addition. • -62- • Finance File No. 18113-81 Page 134 ttiru 136 ASSESSMENT ROLL RE: The costs of operating and maintaining the "TOWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period from Ju1y 1, 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUNT 19-B County of Ramsey -- Juvenile Detention Center 04-14000-082-08 $934.94 Nortf�westerly 2/3 of Lots 4, 5, 6 and Southwesterly 72 .b8 feet of following described Tract: Southeasterly 1/3 of Lots � and 6 and Northwesterly 50.36 feet more-or-less of Lots 7 and (Subject Co easements) Lot 8, Block 8, Bazil and Guerins Addition. 19-C Aid Association for Luttierans Greytiound Lines, Inc. 04-14000-091-08 839.b6 Beginning at Southerly corner of Lot 11 ttier.ce Narthwest on Southwest Line 50.6 feet thence Northeast parallel with South line 0. 58 feet thence Southeast to a point on Southeast line 0.30 feet Norttieast from beginning ttience to beginning and also except Sauthwest 72.68 feet of North 0.36 feet of South- east 100 feet of I�ot 7 and 8 the Southeasterly 100 feet af Lots 7, 8 and 9, Block 8, Bazil and Guerins Addition, 19-D William H. Wietzman and Tobajoy Levitas C/P Tobajoy Levitasj Griffin Co, 04-14000-120-08 208.76 Except tt�e following;Beginn�n� at South corner of Lot 11 the�ce along Soutt�westerly line thereof 50 60/100 feet thence North- easterly parallel with street 0 58/100 foot thence Southeasterly to a part on Norttiwesterly line of said slreet 0 30/100 ,foot Norclieasterly from part oF beginnin� thence ta beginninK the Southeasterly 1/3 of Lots 11 and 12 , Block 8, Bazi1 and Guerins Addition 19-E First Trust Co, and Norman M. & Benjamin C. Rose - Executors C/P Ferris J . Alexander 04-14000-121-08 209.69 Northwesterly 1/2 of Southeasterly 2/3 of Lots 11 and 12, Block 8, Bazil and Guerins Addition. 19-F J. Joseph Ahern, Jr. 04-14000-122-08 $1 ,086.80 Subject to and with easements and except Southwesterly 72 68/100 foot the following Southeasterly 1/6 of Lots 1 and 2 and Southeasterly � 1/3 of Lots 3 tiiru 6 and Norttiwesterly 1/3 of Lots 7 thru 8, Block 12, Bazil and Guerins Addition 20-A The St. Paul YMCA 04-14000-030-07 838.99 In the City of St. Paul Revised description number 468 a specific part of Lots 2 and 3, Block 7, Bazil and Guerins Addition. S t. Pa u 1 YMCA 04-14000-080-07 . 635.35 Lots 7 and 8, Block 7, Bazil and Guerins Addition St. Pau1 YMCA 04-14000-090-07 210.73 Lot 9, Block 7, Bazil and Guerins Addition 20-B Central Manor 04-14000-031-07 500.90 In ttie City of St. Paul revised description number 989 a specific part of Block 7, Bazil and Guerins Addition. • •-63- • Finance File No. 18113-81 Page 137 thru 139 ASSESSMENT ROLL KE: The costs of operating and maintaining the "T�1N SQUARE" public spaces for a period from July 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982, AMOUNT 20-C Central Towers 04-14000-032-07 $740. 57 In the City of St. Paul revised description number 990 a specific part of Block 7, Bazil & Guerins Addition. 20-D Griffin Companies 04-14000-033-07 27.30 Except South 204. 59 feet more-or-less; ttie west 4.07 feet of Lot 3, Block 7, Bazil and G�lerins Addicion Griffin Companies 04-14000-050-07 399.87 In ttle City of St. Paul revised description number 469 a specific part of Lots 3 & 4 and 5, Block 7, Bazil & Guerins Addition. Grif[in Companies 04-14000-060-07 260.01 That part of Lot 5 Southwesterly of the followin� describ- ed line beginning at a part on Southeasterly line of Exctian�;e Street 4l. 33/100 �eet Northe�s[erly fram Nortt�- easterly line of Wabasti� Street thence Soutt►easterly at Right Angles wieh Exchan�e Street 21 66/100 feet thence Southwesterly at right angles 1 50/100 feet thence Souttieasterly parallel to first described line 43 25/100 feet ct�ence Northeasterly at right angles 1 SO/100 feet , tt�erice Southeasterly paraliel to First described line to Souttieasterly line of said Lot 5 and all of Lot 6, Block 7, Bazil and Guerins Addition. . 21 Ferris J • Alexander 04-14000-040-12 785.73 Tt�at part Norttiwesterly of street as opened of Lots 1 , 2, 3 and of Noreheasterly 35 feet of Lot 4, Block 12, Bezil and Guerins Addition 22-A Minnesota Public Radio, Inc. 04-66000-051-13 $1,277.68 Lot 2 adjacent and following: Subject to street; Lots 3 & 5, Block I3, Roberts and Randalls Addition. 22-B Port Autt�ority of ttie City of St. Pa�il 04-66000-080-13 $1 ,570.28 Lot 1 part of Lot 2 Norttieasterly of extended Southwesterly line of Lot 6 .and except Souttieasterly 25 feet for street Lots 6, 7 and 8, Block 13, Roberts and Randalls Addition � 23-A Oxford Development Minnesota, Inc. $3,49$.18 04-66000-020-14 Except Lots S and 6 and Souttiwesterly part of Lots 7, 8 and 9 measuring 90 98/100 feet on Northwesterly line of Lot 7 and 90 22/100 feet on Northwesterly line of widened 8th Street and except widened 8th and Roberts Streets, Block 14, Roberts and Randalls Addition. • -64- • Finance File No. 1$113-81 Page 140 thru 142 ASSESSMENT ROLL RE: The costs of operating and maintaining ttie "TOtiJN SQUARE" puUlic spaces for a period from July 1, 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUNT 23-B Peter P. and Evelyn M. Nerenberg 04-66000-060-14 $1 ,247.97 Souttiwesterly part of Lots 7 and 8 and a part of Lot 9 Northwesterlq of widened 8tti Street measuring 90 98/100 feet on Norttiwesterly line of Lot 7 and 90 22/100 feet on Nortt►westerly line of said Street and all of Lots 5 and 6, Block 14, Rot>erts and Randalls Addition. 24-A Hillcrest Develnpment 04-66000-030-15 1,560.53 Lots 1 thru 3, Block 15, Roberts and Randalls Addition Hillcrest Development 04-66000-140-15 594.30 Except Southeasterly SO feet the Northeasterly 10 feet of Lot 12 and Northwesterly 74 feet of Southeasterly 100 feet of Lots 13 and 14, Block 15, Roberts and Randalls Addition Hillcrest Development 04-66000-040-15 478.24 Ttiat part of Lot 4 Northeasterly of a line running from South corner of said Lot to a part on Northwesterly line 1 95/100 foot from West corner of said Lot 4, Block 15, Roberts and Randalls Addition. . 24-B General Engineering Development Chimera Thester Company • 04-66000-041-15 304.04 Roberts and Randalls Addition, All that part of Lot 5, Northeasterly of a line 14 feet Sauthwesterly from and parallel with Old Robert and Randall Line and that part of Lot 4 Souttiwesterly of a line running from the South corner of said Lot to a part on the Northwesterly line 1 95/100 foot from the West corner mf Lot G, Block 15, Robert and Randalls Addition. 24 -C Marvin 0. Larson 04-66000-060-15 151.31 In the City of St . Paul, Revised description number 499. A specific part of Lots 5 and 6, Block 15. Marvin 0. Larson 04-66000-071-15 438.31 In tiie City of St. Paul, Revised De�cription Number 500. A specific part of Lots 5, 6 and 7, Block 15 24.-D F. M. Gaertner, Jr et al 04-66000-070-15 286.75 Northwesterly 52.50 feet of Southweaterly 84 feet of Lots 6 and 7, Block 15 Robert's & Randall's Addition. � -65- � Finance File No. 18113-81 Page 142 thru 144 ASSESS'MENT RULL RE: The costs of operatiag and maintaining ttie "TaWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period from July l, 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOtJNT 24-E Marvin Sc►Zloff 04-b6000-080-15 $292.14 All that part of Lots 5, 6 and 7 Southeasterly of a line 112 50/100 feet Southeasterly from and parallel to South- eas terly line of 9th S treet and Soutt�taes terly of a line 14 feet Southwesterly from and parallel with Old Robert and Randall Line in said Block 15, Robert and Randall� Addition, Marvin Schloff 04-66000-120-15 338.11 Except Southeasterly 26 feet for 8th Street and except Northeasterly 10 feet of Northwesterly 100 feet of Lot 12, Block 15, Roberts and Randalls Addition. Marvin Schloff 04-66000-141-15 357.62 Except Southeasterly 100 feet of Lots 13 and 14, Block 15, Koberts and Randalls Addition. 24-F Junior Achievement 04-6b000-090-15 $1 ,078.78 Exc�epp� Sc�tr�I�et�H�ttr-ly 26 feec Eor �3�h Stx�c� pbr� of I.o� l� Souttiwesterly of tlie Old Robert and Randall line and ex- cept said street Lots 8 and 9, Block 15, Roberts and � Randalls Addition. 24-G Richard A. , J • Stuart, and Jean B, Markoe C/Y Elv�ren Paint Supply Co. 04-66000-110-15 534.55 Except Southeasterly 26 feet for 8th Street part oE Lot 10 NorttiEasterly of Old Robert and Randall Line and except said street Loc 11, Block 15, Robert and Randalls Addition 25-A Federal Land Bank, et al 03-81000-011-00 206.62 Subject to streets; ttie following: Southeasterly 1/2 of Lot 2 and all of Lot 1, V. D. Walsh's Rearrangement. Federal Land Bank, et al 03-81000-021-00 58.71 Subject to street; the Northwesterly 1/2 of Lot 2, V. D. Walsti' s Rearrangement F'ederal Land Bank, el al 03-81000-031-00 93 .94 Subject to Street; Lot 3, V. D. Walsti's Rearrangement Federal Land Bank, et al 03-81000-041-00 270.07 Subject to street; Lot 4, V. D. Walst►'s Rearrangement � -66- � Finance File No. 18113-81 Page 145 thru 148 ASSESS��tENT ROLL RE: The costs of operating and maintaining the "TOWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period from Jul�r 1, 1981 to June 30, 1982, AMOt7NT 25°B Vomela Specialty Company 03-81000-050-00 $587.96 Lot 5, V. D. Walsh's Rearrangement Vomela Specialty Company 03-81000-071-00 630. 94 Lots 6 and 7, V. ll. Walsh's Rearrangemeat 25-C Soloman W. Miller, et al C/P Ftonald E. and Gayle E. Peterson 03-81000-080-00 178.90 Except Souttiwesterly part measuring 107.21 feet on Souttieasterly line and 104 .08 feet on the Nortliwest- erly line of Lot 8, V. D. Walsh's Rearrangement. 25-D Harold Edsel and June C. Pomeroy 03-81000-082-OU 259.80 Norttieasterly 34 31/100 feet more-or-less the following except �aidened 8th Street the Soutt7westerly part of Lot 8 measurin� 107 21/100 fee[ on Southeasterly line and 104 08/100 f.eeC on Northwesterly line of Lot $, V. D. Walsh's Rearrangement. Harold Edsel and June C. Pomeroy 03-81OOU-083-00 149. 55 Except IVortheasterly 34 31/100 feet more-or-less tt�e ' following except widened 8th street the Soutl�wescerly part of Lot 8 measuring 107 21/100 feet on Souttieast- erly line and 104 08/100 feet an Nortlzwesterly line of Lot �, V. D Walsh's Rearrangement 2b-A Hillcrest Development 03-34000-030-06 $1 ,132 .30 Lots 1 ttiru 3, Block b, Hoyts Addition 26-B Joseph Mast, et al 03-34000-060-06 $1,132 .30 Lots 4 tt►ru 6, Block 6, Hoyt's Addition 27-A Electronic Assistance C/P Ideal Security Hardware Corp. 03-34000-020-03 99.71 Southeastexly 50 feet of Lot 3 and all of Lots 1 and 2, Block 3, Hoyt's Addition. 27-B ideal Brass Worka, Inc. 03-34000-030-03 30.05 Northwesterly 100 feet of Lot 3, Block 3, Hoyts Addition 27-C Ronald H Lindquisk 03-34000-060-03 95.92 Lots 4 and S except Northeasterly 53 feet; Lot 6, Block 3, Hoyts Addition Ronald H. Lindquist 03-34000-062-03 28.84 Subject to street; Northeasterly 53 feet of Lot 6, Block 3, Hoyts Addition � -67- • Finance File No. 1$113-81 Pa�e 148 ttiru 1 S1 ASSESSMENT ROLL RE: The costs of operating and maintaini.np, the "TOWN SQtJARE" public spaces for a peri.od f rom July 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUNT 28-A Cl�urch of S t, t�iary 03-3�t000-041-�2 $ 28.23 Except Norttierly 50 feet; Lot 4, Block 2, Hoyts Addition Ct�urcti of S C . Mary 03-34000-041-11 226.69 Subject to Highway part of Southeast 1/4 of Section 31 , Township 29, Range 22 between Blocks 2 and 11 Hoyts Add- tion and in Hoyts Addition except Southwesterly part af Lot 2, Block 2, measuring 42 22/100 feet on Nortkiw�esterly line and 38 51/100 feet on Southeasterly line Lots 1 , 2, 5 and 6, Block 2, and Lots 3 and 4, Block 11 , Hoyts Addition 28-B Hilda L. Sandberg 03-34000-031-02 53 .91 Subject to Highway Southwesterly part measuring 42 22/100 feet on Norttiwesterly line and 38 51/100 feet on Southeasterly line oP Lot 2 and all of Lot 3, Block 2, Hoyts Addition Hilda L. Sandberg U3-3[+000-042-02 14 .11 Nortt�erly SO feet of Lot 4, Block 2 , Hoyts Addition Hiida L. Sandberg 03-34000-011-11 . 42 .34 Subject to tiighway; Lot 1, Block 11 , Hoyts Addition Hilda L Sandberg 03-34000-021-11 14.53 Subject to Highway; Lot 2, Block 11, Hoyts Addition 29-A City of St. Paul -- Old Masonic Temple 04-63500-010-55 25.66 Northerly 2/3 of Lot 1 , Block 55, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 thru 25, 42 tYiru 45 and Blocks 54 thru 56 City of St. Paul 04-63500-021-55 25.66 Northerly 100 feet of Lot 2, Block S5, Riae and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 ttiru 25, 42 thru 45, and Blocks 54 thru 56. City of St. Paul 04-63500-051-55 115.48 Lots 3 ttiru 5, Block 55, £cice and Irvine� Addition, Blocks 1 tl�ru 25, 42 thru 45 and Blocks 5G chru 56. 29-B Housing and Redevelopment Auttiority Lessee: American Linen Supply Co 04-63500-020-55 25.66 Sautherly 1/3 of Lots 1 and 2, Block 55, Rice and Irvines Addition, Blocks 1 thru 25, 42 thru 45 and Blocks 54 thry 56, • -68- . Finance File No. 18113-81 Page 151 tl�ru 153 ASSESSMENT ROLL RE: Ttie costs of operating and maintainin�; tlie "TOWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period from July 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982, AMOUNT 29-C Tl�e Diocese of St, Paul CiP Catholic Youcti Center 04-63500-070-55 $ 76.99 Lots 6 and 7, Block 55, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 tl�r� 25, 42 thru 45 and Blocks 54 �tiru 56. 29-D Gordon R Larson, et al 04-63500-080-55 38.49 Lot 8, Block 55, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 thru 25, 42 tt�ru 45 and Blocks SG tt�ru Sb. 29-E American Linen Supply 04-63500-100-55 76.99 I.ots 9 and 10, Hlock 55, Rice t�nd Irvines Addition Block 1 tl�ru 25, 42 thru 4.� and Bl�cks 54 thru 56. 30 Housing and Redevelopment Authority 04-63500-112-OS 74.10 Subject to �treers and vacated streets accruing and the following: excepc part deeded for Civic Center Block 14 and excepl par� deeded to the St. Paiil Companies in Lots 1 and 12 and all of Lots 2 tl�ru 11 , Block 5, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 tliru 25, 42 thru 45 and Blocks 54 tliru 56. 31-A Port Authority of the City of St. Paul 04-63500-020-54 51.33 Nortl� 100 feet of I,ot 1 and Nortti 2/3 of Lot 2 , Block 54: Rice and Irvines Addition, Blocks 1 t}iru 25, 42 thru 45 and Blocks 54 ttiru 56. Port Authority of the City of Sr. Paul 04-63500-032-54 47.48 Subject to Boulevard; Lot 7 and all of Lot 3, Block 54 Rice and Irvines Additian Blocks 1 tltru 25, 42 ttiru 45, Blocks 54 ttiru 56. Port Authority of the City of S[. Paul 04-63500-041-54 39.14 Subject to Boulevard; ttie following part of Lot 6 ly3.ng East of extended C7est line of Lot 4 and said lot 4, Bllock 54, Rice and Irvines Addition, Blocks 1 thru 25, 42 tl�ru 45, Blocks 5G ttiru 56 Porc Auttiority of the City of St. Paul 04-63500-051-54 30.15 Subject to Boulevard; . the following part of Lot 6 lying West of extended East Line of Lot 5 and said Lot 5, Block 54, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 thru 25, 42 thru 45, and Blocks 54 thru 56. 31-B Gaertner Holding Co. 04-63500-080-54 43.63 Southerly 50 feet of Lots 1 and 2 and Northerly 30 feet of Lots 8 and 9 and except Northerly 30 feet and except Kellogg Boulttvard the WESterly 20 feet of Lot 8, Block 54, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 thru 25, 42 thru 46, and Blocks 54 thru 56 -69- � �inance File No. 18113-81 Page 154 thru lSb ASSESSMENT ROLL RE: The costs of operating and mai�taining the "T(�IN SQUARE" public spaces for a period from July 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUNT 31-8 Gaertner Holding Co. 04-63500-090-54 $ 25.66 Except Norrherly 30 feet and Westerly 20 feet and Except Kellogg Boulevard Lots 8 and 9, Block 54, Rice and Irvines Addition, Blocks 1 thru 25, 42 thru 45, and Blocks 54 thru 56. 32 Ttie S t . Paul Companies , Inc. 04-635�0-073-02 63 .39 Subject to streets and easements and vacant streets adjoining; 621 .53 Lots 6 and 7, Block 2, Rice and Irvines Addition, Blocks 1 tt�ru 25, 42 thru 45 and Blocks 54 thru 56. The St. Paul Companies, Inc. 04-63500-130-02 7.49 As recorded in Book 17 Town Plats , Page 18, Lot M, Block 2, 73.39 Rice and Irvines Addition, Blocks 1 thru 25, 42 thru 45, and Blocks 54 thru 56. St. Paul Companies, Inc. 04-63500-011-06 Part Souttieast of New 7tt� Street as constructed and NortYiwest 292.93 2,872.08 of Old 7tti Street now know as West 7tt� Place and Northeast of New 6tti Street and Westerly of center line of Auditorium Street being part of Blocks 3, 5 and 6, Rice and Irvines Addition, Blocks 1 thru 25, 42 thru 45 and Blocks 54 thru 56. 33-A Jot�n Bertil Mattson C/P Mickey's Inc. 04-14000-010-10 161 .04 Except Northwesterly 26 feet for Street; Lot 1 , Block 10, Bazil and Guerins Addition 33-B The St. Paul Companies, Inc. 04-14000-020-10 463.95 Northwesterly 1/2 of Lot 3 and all of Lot 2, B1ock 10, Bazil and Guerins Addition The St. Paul Companies, Inc. 04-14000-030-10 144.14 Southeasterly 1/2 of Lot 3, Block 10, Bazil & Guerins Addition Ttie St. Paul Companies, Inc. 04-14000-040-10 288.32 Lot 4, Block 10, Bazil and Guerins Addition Ttie St. Paul Companies, Inc. 04-14000-050-10 272.59 Lot 5, Block 10, Bazil and Guerins Addition St. Paul Companies, Inc. 04-14000-Ob0-10 225.41 Lot 6, Block 10, Bazil and Guerins Addition The St. Paul Companies , Inc. 04-14000-070-10 152 .02 Except Street; Lot 7, Block 10, Bazil & Guerins Addition � -70- • Finance File No. 18113-81 Page 157 thru 159 ASSESSMENT ROLL RE: Tlie cosCs of operating and maintaining lhe "TOWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period from July l , 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUNT 34-A Ferris J. Alexander 04-14000-010-11 $234.08 Except Northwesterly 26 feet for street; Lot 1 , Block 11 , Bazil and Guerins Addition 34-B George D Gekas C/P Ferris J . Alexander 04-14000-020-11 187.26 Except Norttnaesterly 26 feet for street and except North- east 30 feet for alley; Lot 2, Block 11 , Bazil and Guerins Addition, Fee:George D. Gekas C/P Ferris J . Alexander 04-14000-030-11. 2p2.g7 Except Northeasterly 30 feet for alley; the Northwesterly 26 feet of Lot 3, Block 11 , Bazil and Guerins Addition 34-C DownGown State Bank C/P Gambles Continental Bank 04-1�+U00-031-11 187.26 Except Northeasterly 30 teet for alley and except North- �oesterly 26 feet of Lot 3, Block 11 , Bazil and Guerins • Acidi tion. Fee: nowntown State Bank . C/I'; Gambles Continental $ank 04-14000-060-11 195.07 Except Norttieasterly 3U feet for alley; Northwesterly 1/2 of Lot 6, Block lly Bazil and Guerins Addition Fee: llowntown S ta te Bank C/P: Gambles Continental Bank 04-14000-081-11 162. 56 Soutt�easterly 25 feet of Northeasterly 2/3 of Lot 8, Block il, Bazil and Guerins Addition 34-D John E Blomquist, Inc . 04-14000-040-11 487.67 Lol- 4, Block 11 , Bazil and Guerins Addition 34-E Elizabeth S Klaverkamp -- c/o P. Klaverkamp C/P Plitt Nortti Central Theaters 04-140U0-050-11 365. 75 Norttiwesterly 37. 50 feet of Lot 5, Blc,ck 11 , Eazil and Uuericis Addition. Fee: Elizabetti S. Klaverkamp -- c/o P. Klaverkamp C/P; Plitt North Central Ttieaters 04-14000-080-11 g1 ,2g Southeasterly 25 feet of Southwesterly 1/3 oE Lot 8, Block 11 , Bazil and Guerins Addition, � -71- � Finance File No. 18113-81 Page 160 thru 162 w ASSESSMENT ROLL RE: The costs of operating and maintaining the "TOF1N SQUAKE" publ!`c spaces for a period from July 1 , I9f31 to June 30, 1982, � AMOUNT 3�+-F L. N. Arvanitis , et al 04-14000-061-11 $195.07 Except Norttieasterly 30 feet for alley; the Souttieasterly 1/2 of Lot 6, Block 11 , Bazil & Guerins Addition L. N. Arvanitis , et al 04-14000-070-11 195.07 Except Nortt�easterly 30 feet for alley; the Northwesterly 1/2 of Lot 7, Block 11, Bazil and Guerins Addition L. N. Arvanitis , et al 04-14000-071-11 195.07 Except Nortt�easterly 30 feet for alley; the Southessterly 1/2 of.' T,ot 7, Hlock 11 , Ba�il and (;��erins Addition 34-G Port Authority of St. Paul Lessee: C. G• Rein 04-14000-140-11 2 ,925.99 Lots 9 thru 11 , Block 11, Bazil and Guerins Addition 34-H John S. Owen; �Joseph D, and Mary T. Sargent C/P Plitt Narth Central Theaters 04-14000-051-11 365. 75 Norttiwesterly 25 feet of Lot 8 and Except Northwesterly 37. 50 feet of Lot 5, Block 11, Bazil and Guerins Addition 35-A Oxford Development Minnesota Ine. 04-58400-021-00 1 ,5?0.10 Part of Lots 1 thru 6, Block 12, Bazil and Guerina.Addition formerly opened as 8th Street and vacated in Document No. 1584463 and in said Pfeifers Place Plat 1 , Lot 1 and except Southwesterly 5 feet of Lot 2, Pfeifer's Place Plat 1, Oxford Development 04-58500-020-00 2,355.21 Southeasterly 0 5/10 foot of 8th Street vacated adjacent and except the Norttieasterly 5 feet Lot 1 and except the Northeasterly 5 feet of Northwesterly 37 80/100 feet Lot 2, Pfeifer's Place Plat 2. Oxford Development 04-58500-022-00 146. 57 Subject to easements ttie following Southwesterly 5 feet of Lot 2, Pfeifers Place Plat 1 and in said Pfeifers Place Plat 2 the Northeasterly 5 feet of Lot 1 and Northeasterly 5 feet of Northwesterly 37 80/100 feet pf Lot 2, Pfeifers Flace Plat 2. Oxford Development 04-58500-030-00 1 ,171 .20 Lot 3, Pfeifer's Place Plat 2 Qxford Development 04-58500-040-00 1,074.00 Lot 4, Pfeifers Place Plat 2 � -72- • � �r��V Finance File No. 181I3-81 Page 163 thru 165 ASSESSMENT ROLL RI:: 'Clie cosls oE operatin}; and meintainin�; tt�e 10TOWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period from J�11y 1 , 1981 to ,]une 3U, 1982. AMOUNT 35-A Oxford Developmenc 04-14000-110-12 $1 ,263 . 53 Lot 11 , Block 12, Bazil and Guerins Addition Oxford ISevel�pment 04-14000-120-12 1 ,263. 53 Lot 12, Block 12, Bazil and Guerins Addition Oxford Development 04-14000-140-12 1 ,656. 57 Subject to and with easements and party wall agreement and except Nortt�eas�erly 64 66/100 feet Lot 15 and wirti party wall a�reement and except NorttieasCerly 66 feet Lots 13 and 14, Block 12, Baz il and Guerins Addition. Uxford Development 04-14000-171-12 1 ,852.16 Part lying Southerly of F3th Street as open across Block 12 and Part Nortlierly of Pfeifer Place Plats 1 and 2; Lots 1 tt�ru 7 and Lot 17, Block 12, Bazil and Guerins Addition Uxford Developrnent 04-14000-160-12 716.00 � Except Southwesterly 50 feet; Lot 16, Block 12, Bazil and Guerins Addition 35-B Theodore L. Storer 0' Hara Development Minnesota , Inc. 04-14000-141-12 1y656.57 Subject to and witti easements and party wa11 agreement the Norttieasterly 64 66/100 feet of Lot 15 and sub�ect to party wall agreement the Northeasterly 65 feet of Lots 13 and 14, Block 12, Bazil and Guerins Addition. 3E� Uxford Development 04-66000-122-20 187,174 .79 Subject to easements and the following: Northeasterly 171 . 53 feet of Southe�sterly 25 feet of that part of vacated 8tt� Street below a plane surface at elevation of 75 feet city Datum and all of the remaining part of So�ittYeasterly 25 feet of vacated 8th Street accru- in� to Block 20 of Roberts and Randalls Addition; Also, � except N�rttieasterly 1 foat of Lots 1 and 12 for street and Northeasterly 1 foot of Cedar Street vacated adjacent Lots 6 and 7 and all of vacated East Seventh Place adjacent and Lots 1 thru: l2, Block 20, Roberts and Randalls Addition. 37-A Oxford Development 04-66000-010-19 10,194.63 Subject to stree[ and except Soutiieasterly 1/2 of Lot 8 and except Southwesterly 1/2 of Lot 11 and except Lots 9 and 10, Block 19, Roberts and Randalls Addition 37-B 3ack N. Pritzer, et al C/P F. W. Woolworth 04-66000-100-19 2,078. 58 Southeasterly 1/2 of Lot 8 and Southwesterly 1/2 of Lot 11 and all of Lots 9 and 10, Block 19, Roberts and R�ndalls Addition, � -73- • Finance File No. 18113-81 Page 1b5 thru 168 ASSESSMENT ROLL RE: The costs of operating and maintaining the "T�1N SQUARE" public spaces for a period from July 1, 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUDIT 38 Hillcrest Development 04-66000-011-18 $357.62 Lot 1 , Block 18, Roberts and Randall.s Addition Hillcrest Development 04-66000-021-18 336.16 Lot 2, Block 18, Roberts and Randalls Addition Hillcrest Development. 04-66000-OSO-18 177.51 Northwesterly 30 feet of the Southwesterly 91 feet of Lot 5, Block 18, Roberts and Randalls Addition Hillcrest Development 04-6b000-060-18 151 .57 Southeasterly 25 62/100 feet of the Northwesterly 55 62/100 feet of the Southwesterly 91 feet of Lots 5 and 6, Block 18, Roberts and Randalls Addition Hillcrest Development 04-66000-121-18 4,131. 95 Soutl�westerly 75 5/10 feet of Lots 8 and 9 So�thwesterly 4 feet of Lot 11 and Northeasterly 45 feet of Lot 10, Lot 3 all of Lot 4 except Southwesterly 91 feet of Nor�h- westerly 55 62/100 feet Lots 5 and 6 all of Lot 7 except Southwesterly 75 5/10 feet Lots 8 and 9 except Northeast: erly 46 feet Lot 10 the Northeasterly SO feet of Lot 11 all of Lot 12 and Southwesterly 44 feet of Lots 13 and 14 all in Block 18, Block 18, Robert and Randalls Addition Hillcrest Development 04-66000-140-18 416.27 Northeasterly 66 feet of I.ots 13 and 14, Block 18, Roberts and Randalls Addition 39-A Hillcrest Development 03-49000-�12-00 2,403.16 Except Lots 6, 7 and 8, and except Northeasterly 21 66/100 feet of Lot 5 and except widened 8tti and Jackson Streets the entire Subdivision, Mayalls Subdiviafon of Block 1, of Whitney and Smiths Addition Hillcrest Development 03-49000-070-00 206.67 Northeasterly 10 5/10 feet of Lot 6 and except Northeast- erly part being 5 to 40 2%10 feet wide for Sibley Street, Lot 7, Mayalls Subdivision of Block 1, Whitney and Smiths Addition. , 39-B Mortimer I. Silberstein 03-49000-OS1-00 122.04 In the City of St. Paul revised description number 461 a specific part of Lots 6 and 5, Mayalls Subdivision of Block 1 of Whitney and Smittis Addition, 39-C Bernard Weitzman, et al 03-49000-060-00 190.81 In the City of St. Paul Revised Description number 462 a specific part of Lot 6, Mayalls Subdivision of Block 1 of Whi�ney and 5miths Addition. � -74- • Finance File No. 18113-81 Pa ge 168 th ru 171 ASSESSME KT ROLL RE: Ttie costs of operating and maintaining the "TOWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period from July 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUNT 40-A Housing and Redevelopment Authority 03-82000-056-02 $1 ,409.08 Subject to streets; Lot 1 thru S, Block 2, Whitney and Smittis Addition 40-B Hillcrest Development 03-82000-101-02 1 ,805.30 Subject to Street; Lots 6 thru 10, Block 2, Whitney and Smiths Addition 41-A Hilding T. Ostrom C/P Dale Werth 03-82000-020-03 21.39 Norttieasterly 50 feet of Southwesterly 100 feet of Lots 1 and 2, Block 3, Whitney and Smiths Addition Fee: Hilding T• Qstrom • C/P: Dale Werth 03-82000-021-03 21 .39 Northeasterly 1/3 of Lots 1 and 2, Block 3, Whitney and Stniths Addition 41-B Western riachine Manufacturing Co. 03-82000-030-03 26.95 Except Soutt�easterly $ feet for alley; Lot 3, Bl�ck 3, Whitney and Smiths Addition. , 41-C Lawrence A. Applebaum C/P Omer B Katke 03-82000-072-03 7.91 F.xcept Street and except Northwesterly 8 feet for alley and except Southwesterly part measuring 75 08/100 feet on Soutt�easterly line of Lot 6 and 74 61/100 feet on North- westerly line of Lot 7 the Southwesterly 100 feet of Lots 6 and 7, Block 3, Wtlitney and Smiths Addition Lawrence A. Applebaum C/P Robert Frederick 03-82000-103-03 28.17 So�thwesterly 50 feet of Lots 1 and 2 and except Soutti- easterly 8 feet for alley Nor�t�easterly 12 50/100 feet of Lots 8 thru 10, Block 3, Whitney and Smiths Addition, 41-D First Trust Co, of St. Paul and Hella L. Mears C/P Austin J Baillon 03-82000-OSO-03 14.11 Except street and except Nortiiwesterly 8 feet for alley �t�e Northeasterly 1/3 of Lots 4 and 5, Block 3, Wtiitney and Smitt►s Addition Fee: First Trust Co, of St. Paul and Hella L Mears C/P: Austin J. Baillon 03-82000-051-03 7.06 Except street and except Northwesterly 8 feet for alley ttie Souttiwesterly 25 feet of Northeasterly 1,12 of Lots 4 and 5, Block 3, Whitney and Smiths Addition. - - • -74 A- • Finance File No. 18113-$1 Pa�e 171 thru 173 ASSESBMENT ROLL RE: The costs of operating and maintainin� tt►e "TOWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period from July 1 , 1981 to June 30, ].982. AMOUIVT 41-D Fee: First Trust Co. of St. Paul ancl Hella L Mears C/P: Austin J. Baillon 03-82000-070-03 $ 28 23 Except street and except Northwesterly 8 Feet for alley Southwesterly 1/2 oE Lots 4 anc3 5 and Northeasterly 25 feet of Lots 6 and 7, Block 3, Wt�itney and Smitt�s Addition, Fee: First Trust Co. of St Paul and Hella L. Mears C/P: Austin J. Baillon 03-82000-071-03 7.06 Lo� 7, Block 3, Wliitney and Smiths Addition Fee: First Trust Co. of St. Paul and Hella L. Mears (:/P: Austin J. Baillon 03-82000-104-03 29.64 Subject to street the foll�wing except Southeasterly 18 feet and except Norti�easterly 10 feet the South- westerly 2/3 of Lots 9 and 10, Block 3, Whitney and Smiths Addition. 41-E Marion I. Katke C/P Ka t-TCeys Key and Lock Co. 03-82000-073-03 7.Ob In the City of St. Yaul revised clescription number 465 a specific part of Lats 6 and 7, Block 3, Whitney and Smietis Addition � 41-F Phyllis A. Kappas C/P Mrs. Andrew Kappas, et al 03-82000-074-03 7.Ob In the City of St. Paul revised descriprion number 442 a specific part of LoLS 6 and 7, Block 3, Whitney and Smiths Addition, Pt�yllis A. Kappas 03-82000-075-03 7.01 Except street and except Narttiwesterly 8 feet Eor alley par� of Lots 6 and 7 Southwes�erly of following described line be�;inning at a parC on ori�inal Norttiwesterly line of s�reet 24 42/100 feet Norttieasterly from Souttiwesterly corner of said Lot 6 thence Northwesterly to a part on Nortt�westerly line of said lot 7 Distance 23 85/100 feet Northeasterly from Northwesterly corner of said Lot 7, Block 3, Whitney & Smiths Addition, 41-�G Everett A. Needels 03-82000-090-03 25.66 Except Southeasterly 8 feet for alley the Southwesterly 2/3 of Lot 8 and of Southeasterly 18 feet of Lot 9, Block 3, Whitney and Smiths Addition. Needels Company, Inc. 03-82000-101-03 3.64 Except So�theascerly 18 feet the Northeasterly 10 feet of Soutt�westerly 2/3 of Lots 9 and 10, Block 3, Wtiitney and Smiths Addition, • -75- • Finance File No, 18113-81 Page 174 thru 176 ASSESSMENT ROLL RE: Ttie costs oE operating and maintaini.n� ttie "TOWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period from J uly 1 , 1981 to ,Tune 30, 1982. AMOUNT 41.-G Needels Co, Znc. 03-t32b00-102-03 $ 25.86 Except Soutt�easterly 8 feet for alley Southwesterly 37 50/1.00 feet of Northeasterly 50 feet of Lots 8, 9 and 10, Block 3, Whitney and Smiths Addition. 43-A City of St. Paul 1 ,327.48 04-63500-043-15 Subject to streets and any vecated stree�s accruing �lie following: The West 97 feet of I.o� 2 and all of Lot 3, Block 17, Lots 1 , 2 and 3 and 5outh 25 feet of East 30 feet of Lot 6 and South 25 feet of Lot 7, Block 16, I.ot� 3 �hru 10, Block 13. Al.so, par� lyin� Nor[t�- erly and Easterly of line described in llocument � 1787664, Lots 4, 5 and West 30 feet of Lot 6, Block 16, Block 14 and 15, Rice and Irvines Addition, Blocks 1 ttiru 25, 42 ttiru 45 and Blocks 54 thru 56. Housing and Redevelopment Authority 04-63500-OSG-16 13.94 Subject �o streets and any �racated streets accruing the following: Part lying Souttierly of line described in Document ��1787664 of Westerly 30 feet of Lo� 6 and all of Lots 4 and 5, Block 16, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 tliru 25, 42 thru 45, and Blocks 54 thru 56. City of St. Paul 04-63500-071-17 306.68 Vacated streets and alley accruing and following: except Soutti 25 feet; the East 30 feet of Lot 6 and except South 25 feet; Lot 7 and all of Lots 8 and 9 all in Block 16 and in Block 17 all of Lots 4, 5 and 6 and part Weaterly of East 143 feet of Block 17 of Lot 7, Block 17, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 thru 25, 42 ttiru 45 and Blocks 54 thru 56. City of St. Paul 04-63500-021-13 596.05 North 1/2 of 4th Street as vacated in llocurnent �� 566347 accruing 1-19-72 , Franklin Street as vacated between � 4th & Sth Streets �nd .tollowing: Lots 6 thru 13„Block 12 and Lots 11, 12 end 1 and 2, Block 13, Rice and Irvines Addition, Blocks 1 tl�ru 25, 42 thru 45, and Blocks 54 ttiru 56. 43-B Ttie Minnesota Club 04-63500-080-17 � 16.14 Westeriy 38 50/100 feet of Easterly 143 feet of Nortti- erly 98 feet of Block 17 being part of Lots 1 , 2, 7, and 8, Block 17, Rice and Irvines Addition, Blocks 1 thru 25, 42 tt�ru 45 and Blocks 54 thru 56. The Minnesota Club 04-63500-081-17 28.66 Westerly 67 feet more-or-less of Easterly 143 feet of Southerly 100 feet of Block 17 being part of Lots 7 and 8, Block 17, Rice and Irvines Addition, Blocks 1 thru 25, 42 thru 45 and Blocks 54 tt►ru 56. • -76- • Finance File No. 18113-81 Page 177 thru 179 ASSESSMENT ROLL KE: '�he cos�s of operating and maintaining ttie "TOt�IN SQUARE" public spaces for a period fram July 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOIINT 43-R The Minnesota Club 04-63500-090-17 $ 75.45 In the City of St. Paul revised description number 492 a specific part of Lots 1 , 8 and 9, Block 17, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 ttiru 25, 42 thru 46 and Blocks 54 tt�ru 56. 43-C West Publistiing Co. 04-63500-020-12 61 .59 Lots 1 and 2, Block 12, Rice and Irvinea AddiCion, Blocks 1 tt►ru 25, 42 thru 45 and Blocks 54 thru 56, G3-D Amherst H• Wilder Foundation 04-63500-030-I2 46.19 Soutt�erly 30 feet of Loe 4, and all of Lot 3, Block 12, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 tttru 25, 42 thru 45, and �locks 54 thru 56. � Amtierst H. Wilder Ctiarity 04-63500-050-12 46.19 Northerly 1/2 of Lot 4 and all of Lot 5, Block 12, Rice and Irvines Addition Blacks 1 tliru 25, 42 thru 45 and Blocks 54 t}�ru 56. 44 St. Paul Fire and Marine Insurance 04-63500-121-06 , 65. 76 Part Southerly of 7tti Srreet of Block 6, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 thru Z5, 42 thru 45 and Blocks 54 thru 56. 45 St. Peul Fire and Marine Insurance 04-63500-040-07 691 .96 Except Easterly 10 feet; Lot 3 and all of Lot 4, Block 7, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 thru 25, 42 thru 45 and Blocks 54 ttiru 56. St. Paul F�:re and Marine Insurance 04-b3500-101-07 2,012.98 All Southerly of 7th Street of Lots 5 and 6 and ell of Lots 7 thru 10, Block �, Rice and Irvines Addition, Blocks 1 thru 25, 42 thru 45, and Blocks 54 thru 56. St. Paul Fire and Marine Insurance 0�+-63500-120-07 1 ,572.64 Easterly 10 feet of Lot 3 and all of Lots 1 , 2, 11 and 12, Block 7, Rice and Irvines Addition, Blocks 1 thru 25, 42 thru 45 and Blocks 54 thru 56. 46-A The St, Pau� Gompaniea 04-63500-100-02 12.58 Part Southerly of 7th Street of Lot 10, Block 2, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 thru 25, 42 thru 45, and Blocks 54 thru 56. • -��- • Finance File No. 18113-81 P�ge 179 thru 181 ASSESSMENT ROLL RE: Ttie costs of operating and maintaining tt�e "TO�WN SQUARE" public spaces for a period from July 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982, AMOUNT 46-B Baillon Company 04-63500-110-02 $113.23 Part Southerly �f 7th Street of Lot 11 , Block 2 , Rice and Irvines Addition, Blocks 1 tliru 25, 42 thru 45 and Blocks 54 tllr� 56. 46-C Diana K. Lewis C/P: B,aillon Company � 04-63500-120-02 232, 75 Except West 7th Street and Wastiington Street Lot 8, Block 10, Bazil and Guerins Addition to St. Paul and in said Rice and Irvines Addition Except West 7tt► Street Lot 12, Block 2, Rice and Irvines Addition, Blocks 1 thru 25, 42 thru 45 and Blocks 54 thru 56. 47 City of St. Paul -- Aacmi Park 04-63500-010-01 220,67 Block 1, Itice and Irvines Addition, Blocks 1 thru 25, 42 thru 45, and Blocks 54 thru 56. 48-A Jack N. Geller, et al 04-19500-030-07 975.33 Norttiwesterly 2/3 of Lots 1 thru 3, Block 7, City of St. Paul � Blocks 3 thru 12, 17 ttiru 26 and 31 thru 39. 48-B Northwestern National Life Insurance Company � � Lessee: Wabasha Court Association 04-19500-031-07 975,33 Lots 10, 11 and 12 and Southeasterly 1/3 of Lots 1, 2 and 3, Block 7, Gity of St. Paul Blocks 3 thru 12, 17 thru 26 and 31 thru 39. Fee: Northwestern National Life Insurance Company C/P: United Properties 04-19500-090-07 3,888. 12 Except triangle for bth and St, Pe[er Streets; Lot 4 thru 9, Block 7, City of St, Paul Blocks 3 thru 12, 17 ttiru 26, and 31 . thru 39. 49 Ttie Dayton Company -- J. R. A, Boline - Assistant Treasurer C/P: D. H. C. Property--Tax Department 04-19500-161-06 16,425,83 Subject to street and easements part of 6th and 7th Streets as vacated in Document �'�450184 accruing and following Lots 1 ttiru 16, Block b, City of St. Paul Blocks 3 thru 12 , 17 �}�ru 26 and 31 thru 39. 50-A Oxford Development Minnesota Inc, 76,492.41 04-19500-062-OS Subject to Street and easements and vacated streets accruing but no part of vacated East 7th Place and the following: That part above a plane surface at elevation of 72 feet City Datum and Northerly of a line beginning on Southwesterly line of Block 5, City of St. Peul Addition and 172 feet Northerly of Soutt►west corner, tt�ence Northeast to Northeast line of said Block 5, and 173.44 feet Northerly of Southeast corner being part of Tract A and all of Tract B of Registered L�nd Survey 320 & in City of St. Paul Addition part of Lots 4, 5, & 6, Block 5 City of St. Paul Blocks 3 thru 12 , 17 thru 26; and 31 thru 39 • -��- • Finance File No. 18113-81 Page 1�32 thru 184 ASSESSMENT ROLL RE: Tl�e costs of operaCing and maintaining ttie "TOWN SQUARB" public spaces for a period from July 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982, AMOUNT 50-A Oxford nevelopment Q4-19500-082-05 $42,269, 99 SuUject to Streets and easements a nd vacated street accruing and that part above a plane surface at elevation of 71 feet City Datum and the following: The Southwesterly 120.5 feet more-or-less of Block 5, Southeasterly of a line beginning on Souttiwesterly line of Block 5 and 172 feet Norttierly of Soutt�west corner, thence Northeast ta Norttieast line of Block 5, and 173.44 feet Northerly of Southeast corner being part of Lots 4 , 5, 6 and 9 and all of 7 and 8, Block 5, City of St. Paul Blocks 3 ttiru 12, 17 thru 26, and 31 thru 39. SO-B St. Paul Joint Venture Aetn: John Hein 04-19500-123-05 Subjecr to streets and easements , that part ab�ve a plane 5,181,29 surface at elevation of 71 feet City Datum of the following: except Southwesterly 120. 5 Eeet more-or-less, that part South- erly of a line beginnin� on Southwesterly line af Block 5, and 1�2 feet Nortt�erly of Southwesterly corner, thence Norttieast- erly co a point on Northeasterly line of Block 5, and 173.44 feet Nortlierly of Southeasterly corner being part of Tract A and all of Tract C of Registered Land Survey Na. 320 and in City of St. Pau1 Additian, part of Lots 4 and 9 and all of Lots 10 tlrru 12, Block 15, City ot St. Paul Blocks 3 thru 12, 17 �hru 26 and 31 thru 39. ' 51-A American National Bank, et al 04-19500-032-04 2 ,737. 64 Subject to street; the Northwesterly 5%6 of the following: LoCs 1 tllru 3, Block 4, City of St. Paul Blocks 2 thru 12 , 17 thru 26 and 31 thru 39 American National Bank and Trust Company 04-19500-051-04 2 �442•82 Subject to alley; Lots 4 and 5, Block 4, City of St. Paul Blocks 3 thru 12, 17 thru 26 and 31 thru 39 American National Bank and Trust Company 606,49 04-19500-081-04 Subject to alley; Lot 8, Block 4, Cit� of St. Paul Blocks 3 thru 12, 17 thru 26, 31 tt�ru 39. 51-8 A11en I)• Sf1pYt?8 y et al 04-19500-070-04 1 ,347. 76 Lots 6 and 7, Block 4, City of St. Paul Blocks 3 thru 12, 17 etiru 26 and 31 tliru 39. 51-C Tw�.n C�ty Federal Savings and Lo�n Association 04-19500-082-04 45•��g Subject to alley; Tt►e Soutti 5 feet of Lots 4, S, and 8, Block 4, City of St. Paul Blocks 3 thru 12, 17 thru 26, and 31 thru 39 r _ _ � ��4�5 79 Einance File No, 18113-81 Page 184 tl�ru 187 ASSESSMENT ROLL FtE: The costs of operating and maintaining the "TOWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period from .Tuly 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUNT 51-C Twici City Federal Savings And Loan Association 04-19500-134-04 $3 ,841,96 Subject to sereet, alley and pedestrian walkway the follo�vi«g Tract: Lots 9 and 13, Block 4, City of St. Pau1 Blocks 3 thru 12., 17 thru 26 and 31 thru 39 Twin City Federal Savings and Loan Association 04-19500-1G%-04 3,228. 73 • Subject to sCreeCs , alley, air rights and pedestrian walkways the following Tract: Soutt�easterly 1/6 of LoCS 1 , 2, 3 a�d all of Lotx 14, 15 and 16, Block G , City oE St. Paul Blocks 3 tiiru 12, 17 thru 26 and 31 thru 39. 52 Minnesota Mut�al Life Insurance Company 04-4500�-062-00 6,870.16 Subject to street; Lot 1 ttiru 6, Auditors Subdivision No. 56 53-A Tlie Rutomot,ile Club C/P: Minnesota State Automabile Association 03-ti2000-112-08 766,82 Sul�jecr to street the following: except Southeasterly 35 "reet Locs 6 anc3 7 Block 2 , City of St. Paul and in said Whitney and Smiths Addition except Southeasterly 35 Feet Lots 10 and 11 , Block 8, Wt;itney and Smiths Addition, • 53-B Ttie Lowertown St. Paul Compa�y 03-82000-123-08 3 ,724. 51 Vacated street accruing and subject to street ttie following: Southeasterly 35 feet of Lots 6 and 7 and all of Lots 8 and 9, Block 2 City of St. Paul Also, all of Ewing and Chutes Subdivision and in said Wtiitney and Smiths Addition the Southeasterly 35 feet of Lots 10 and il and all of Lots 2 .Chru 9 and Lot 12, Block 8, Whitney and Smittis Addition. 54-A Security Holding Company 03-82000-020-07 566. 15 Lot 1 and except 5outtieasterly 10 fee� for alley; Lot 2, Block 7, Whitney and Smittis Addition. Security Holding Company 03-81000-120-07 1$$' �2 Except Soutlieasterly 10 feet for alley; Southwest 1/3 of Lots 11 and 12, Block 7, Whitney and Smiths Addition. Security Holding Company 03-82000-122-07 188' �2 Except Southeasterly 10 feet for alley; Northeasterly 1/3 of Lots 11 and 12, Block 7, Whitney and Smiths Addition. 54-8 Custom Properties , Inc. 524.21 03-82000=030-07 Northwesterly 50 feet of Lots 4 and 5 and all of Lot 3, Block 7, � Whitney and Smiths Addition . -£30- . Finance File No. 18113-81 Pa�e 187 thru 190 ASSESSMENT ROI�L RE: Tl�e costs of operatin� and maintaining the "Tt�JN SQUARE" public spaces for a period from July 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUNT �4-C Railr.oader Printing House 03-82000-040-07 $209,69 Souttieasterly 100 feet of Lot 4, Block 7, Wkiitney and Smittis Addition. � Kailr.oader Printing House 209,69 03-82000-050-07 Southeasterly 100 feet of Lot 5, Block 7, Wtiitney and Smiths Addition. 54-D Alfred R. Jr, and Carol H 5undberg 314. 53 03-82000-U60-07 Lot 6, Block 7, Whitney and Smiths Addition 54-E First Trust Company of St. Paul and Hella L. Mears 03-82000-090-07 943. 58 Lots 7 ti�ru 9, Block 7, Wtiitney and Smiths Addition First Trust Company of St. Paul and Hella L. Mears 03-82000-100-07 314. 53 Lot 10, Block 7, Wtiitney and Smittis Addition 54-F Annette Newman i88 �2 03-82000-121-07 Except SouttieasCerly 10 feet for alley Southwesterly 1/2 Northeasterly 2/3 of Lots 11 and 12, Block 7, . Whitney and Smitlis Addition. 55-A Benjamin C. Rose 03-82000-020-06 18. 18 Except Southeasterly 15 feet; Southwesterly 50 feet of Lots 1 and 2, Block 6, Whitney and Smiths Addition 55-B Buckbee Mears Realty 03-82000-022-06 Except Southeasterly 15 feet; 18.18 Northeasterly 50 feet of Lots 1 and 2, Block 6, Whitney and Smiths Addition 55-C Edward M. Abramson 03-82000-121-06 9.45 Exeept Souttieasterly 15 feet Northeasterly 25 feet of Southwesterly 50 feet of Lots 11 and 12, Block 6, Whitney and Smittis Addition. Edward M. Abramson 03-82000-021-06 18. 18 Except Southeasterly 15 feet Southwesterly 1/2 of North- easterly 100 feet of Lots 1 and 2, Block 6, Whitney and Smiths Addition, Edward M. Abramson 03-82000-122-06 9.09 Except Southeasterly 15 feet Northeasterly 25 feet of Southwesterly 75 feet of Lots 11 and 1'2, Block 6, Whitney and Smiths Addition Edward M, Abramson 03-82000-124-06 9.09 Except Southeasterly 15 feet Northeasterly 25 feet of Lots 11 and 12, Block 6, Whitney and Smiths Additon • -81- • Finance File Na. 18113-81 PagE 190 thru 193 ASSESSMENT ROLL RE: Ttie costs of opereting and maintaining the "TOWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period from July 1, 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUN'T 55-D Bert Moses 03-82000-123-06 $ 18, 18 E xcept Southensterly 15 feet Soutt�westerly SO feet of Northeasterly 75 feet of Lots 11 and 12, Block 6, Smitt� and Whitneys Addition 55-E Control Data Properties, Inc . 03-82000-060-06 128.32 Subject tn street; Lots 3, 4, 5 and 6, Block 6, Wtiitney and Smiths Addition. Control Data Properties, Inc. 03-82000-090-06 96.24 Lots 7 tt�ru 9, Block 6, Whitney and Smiths Addition Control Data Properties, Inc. 03-82000-100-06 32.08 �,ot 10, Block 6, Whitney and Smiths Addition 56-A Super America Stations 03-82000-020-OS 68.44 Part of Kittsons Addition to St. Paul, Southwesterly of Broadway and Between extended Northwesterly line of Lot 1 and extended Southeasterly line of Lot 2, Block 5 in Whitney and Smiths Addition and alsn all of said Lots 1 and 2 , Block 5, Whitney and Smiths Addit�:on. , 56-B Ctiarles W. & Thomas E. Erickson and Kathryn E Wirth C/P: Charles Erickson -- Bakota Investments 34.22 03-82000-030-50 Part of Kittsons Addition to St. Paul, Southwesterly of street and between extended northwesterly and South- easterly liaes of Lot 3, Block 5, in said Whitney and Smiths Additian and said Lot 3, Block 5, Whitney and Smitt�s Addition. Fee: Charles W. & Thamas E, Erickson � KAthryn �. Wizth C/k': Ch�rlea Lrt�keon -- �ekar� �nve�Cm�ne� 03-82000-050-05 68.44 Except 6tt� Street p�rt of Kittsons Addition to St. Paul Southwesterly of Broadway and between extended North- westerly line of Lot 4 and extended Southeasterly line of Lot 5, Block 5 in said Whitney and Smiths Addition and said Lots 4 and 5, Block 5, Whitney and Smiths Addition. 57 County of Ramsey 04-63500-Oi0-08 1 ,532.21 Block 8, Rice and Irvines Addition, Blocks 1 ttiru 25, 42 thru 45, and 54 thru S�i. 58 Commercial Srate Bank 04-63200-010-09 217.82 Except 6th Street; Lot 1 , Block 9, Rearrangement of Block 9, Rice and Irvines Addition • -82- �nance File No. 18113-81 • Page 193 thru 195 ASSESSMENT ROLL RE: Ttle costs of operating and maintaining ttie "TOWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period fram July 1, 1981 to June 30, 1982, AMOUNT 58 Commercial State Bank 04-63200-020-09 $ 99.39 Lot 2 , Block 9, Rearrangement of Block 9, Rice and Irvines Addition Commercial State Bank 04-63200-030-09 257. 70 Lot 3, Block 9, Rearrangement of Block 9, Rice and Irvines Addition Comme rc ia 1 S ta te Ba nk 04-63200-040-09 581. 12 Excepe Souttieasterly triangle for streets; Lot 4, Block 9, Rearrangement of Block 9, Rice and Irvines Addition 59-A Samuel H. Maslon - Executor C/P: Estelle A Levine 04-19500-020-08 130.04 Souttieasterly 20 feet of Lots 1 and 2, Block 8, City of St. Paul Blocks 3 thru 12, 17 thru 26, and 31 tt�ru 39. 59-B� Carl Pedro and Sons, Inc . 04-19500-021-08 195.07 Northwesterly 30 feet of Southeasterly 50 feet of Lots 1 and 2, Block 8, City of St. Paul Blocks 3 tt�ru 12, 17 ttiru 26 and 31 thru 39. . 59-C Ivan J. Gerber 04-19500-022-08 164. 70 Northweaterly 25 1/3 feet of Southeasterly 75 1/3 feet of Lots 1 and 2, Block 8, City of St. Paul Blocks 3 thru 12, 17 tt�ru 26 and 31 ttiru 39. 59-D L. & M. Holding Company 04-19500-023-08 - 160.41 Northwesterly 24 2j3 feet of Southeasterly 100 feet of Lots 1 and 2, Block 8, City of St. Paul Blocks 3 ttiru 12, 17 thru 26, and 31 thru 39. 59-E Lillian J. Patoile, et al C/P: Northern Federal Savings and Loan 04-19500-024-08 325. 11 Northwesterly 50 feet of Lots 1 and 2 , Block 8, City of St. Paul Blocks 3 thru 12, 17 thru 2b, 31 thru 39. 59-F Sixtli Street; St. Peter Street Carporation, et al 04-19500-060-08 1 ,937.27 All of Lots 3, 4 and 5 and exeept West triangle for streets measuring 21 feet on West 6th Street and 19 60/100 feet on St. Peter; Street; Lot 6, Block 8, City of St. Paul Blocks 3 tt►ru 12, 17 thru 26, 31 thru 39 • -83- • Finance File No. 1$113-81 Page 196 thru 198 ASSESSMENT ROLL RE: The costs of operating and maintaining ttie "TOWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period from July l, 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUNT 59-G Jacob Schmidt Company C/P: Shelter Service Corporation 04-19500-070-08 $162. 56 Except Sautheasterly 100 feet; Lot 7, Block 8 City of St. Paul Blocks 3 ttiru 12 , 17 thru 26, and "31 ttiru 39 � 59-H The 372 Company C/P: S1►elter Service Corporation 04-19500-071-08 325.11 Soutl�easterly 100 feet of Lot 7, Block $, CiCy of St. Paul, Blocks 3 thru 12, 17 thru 26, and 31 thru 39 59°I Victory Auto Park, Inc. C/P: Jack N. Geller, er_ al 04-19500-090-OS 907.06 Lot 8 and except Northeasterly 10 feet of Southeasterly 105 fee�; Lot 9, Block 8, City of St . Paul Blocks 3 thru 12, 17 ttiru 26 and 31 t_tiru 39. 59-J Franctiise Realty Interstate Corporation C/P: McDonalds (U89-22) U4-19500-091-OS 312.11 Nortt�westerly 30 feet of Souttieasterly 105 feet of Lots 10 and 11 and 12 and NortheasterZy 10 feet of Lot 9, Block 8, City of St. Paul Blocks 3 thru 12 , 17 thru 26 and 31 thru 39. 59-K Rasmussen Sctiool of Business, Inc . 04-19500-120-08 �80•26 Southeasterly 75 feet of Northeasterly IO feet of Lot 9 and Soutlieasterly 75 feet of Locs 10, 11 and I2, Block 8, City of St. Paul Blocks 3 thru 12, 17 [tlru 26, 31 thru 39 59-L United Properties, Inc. 04-19500-121-08 438.90 Nortl�westerly 45 feet of Lots 10 ttiru 12 , Block 8, City of St. Paul, Blocks 3 thru 12 , 17 thru 26, and 31 thru 39. 60-A Norttiern Federal Savings and Loan C/P: Curtis L. Carlson 04-19500-084-09 1 ,582. 78 Subject to streets and with air riglits; the Northwesterly 77 feet of part of Lot 6 lying Southwesterly of the Northeast erly 207. 99 feet of Block 9 and Northwesterly 77 feet of Lot 7 and 8, Block 9, City oE St. Paul Blocks 3 thru 12 , 17 tt�ru 26, and 31 �hru 39. 60-B Housing and Redevelopment Authority 04-19500-114-09 3 ,314.48 Subject to streets and air rights the Southeasterly 83.6 feet of Nortt�westerly 160.6 feet of Block 9 lying Southwesterly of tt►e Northeasterly 207.99 feet of said Block and part of said block lying Southeasterly of ttie Northwesterly 160,6 feet and Iying SouthwesCerly of ttie Northeasterly 262.04 feet of said Block being part of Lots 6 ttiru 11, Block 9, City of St. Paul Blocks 3 thru 12, 17 thru 26 and 31 thru 39 • -84- • Finance File No. 18113-81 Pa�e 199 thru 201 ASSESSMENT ROLL RE: "The costs of operatin� and maintaining the "TC1WN SQUARE" public spaces for a peri.od from July 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982 . . AMOUNT b0-C Economics Laboratory, Inc. 04-19500-131-09 $3,892.b7 Subject to streets and except: Northwesterly 160.6 feet; tt�e Northeasterly 96.29 feet of Block 9, City of St. Paul. Blocks 3 ttiru 12, 11 tY�ru 26, and 31 ; tliru 39, 6U-D Haddington Associates C/P: Economics Laboratnry, Inc . 04-19500-161-09 2 ,261.37 Subject to streets and except Northwesterly 160.6 feet; the Southwesterly 165. 75 [eet of Northeast- erly 262 .04 feet �F Block 9, City oE St. Paul, I3locks 3 tt�ru 12, 17 tYiru 26, and 31 thru 39. 61-A Northerly Centre Corporation 04-19500-042-10 15,34.3.G1 Witt� Air rigtits over Cedar and Minnes�ta streets and , subject to Streets Llie follnwing: Northwesterly 160.6 feet of NortYieasterly 207.99 feet of Block 9, and ex- cept Southeasterly 135.65 feet; ttie H. L. Carvers Subdivision ai�d except Souttieasterly 135.65 feet; Langevins Subdivision and in said City of St, Paul except Southeasterly 135.65 feet; Lot 9 and all of Lots 1 rhru 4, Block 10, City of St. i?aul Blocks 3 ,ttiru 12, 17 thru 26 and 31 ttiru 39. 61-B Nortliwes�ern Mortgage Co. . C/0: North�restern National Bank 04-19500-092-10 5,967. 71 Except Soutt�westerly 11 feet and except Souttieasterly 13 feet the Southeasterly 135 65/100 feet of the following H. L. Carvers Sut�division of part of Alock 10 City of St. Paul vacated alley in and Langevins Subdivision of part of Block 10 City o£ St. Paul and in Said City of 5t. Paul lot 9, Block L0, City of St. Paul Blocks 3 thru 12, 17 thru 26, and 31 thru 39 61-C Housing and Redevelopment Auttiority 04-19500-033-10 F383.96 Soutl�westerly 11 feet of Soutt�easterly 135 65/100 feet , of H. L. Carvera Subdiviaion and SouClieA�terly 13 feel oE Langevins Subdivision and Soutt�easterly 13 feet of said Carvers Subdivision Iying Northeasterly of said Southwest- erly 11 feet ttiereof and Soutlieasterly 13 feet of Lot 9, Block 10 City of St. Paul, Blks 3 thru 12, 17 thru 26, and 31 ttiru 39. 62-A American National Bank and Trust Co. 04-19500-034-11 2,757. 18 Subject to street and except Southeasterly part measuring 24:43 feet on Southwest line of Lot 3 and 24.24 feet on widened Robert Street; the following: Lots 1 thru 3, Block il, City af St. Paul Blocks 3 thru 12, 17 ttiru 26, and 31 tt�ru 39. • -�5- • Finance File No. 18113-81 Page 201 thru 2�3 ASSESSMENT RULL RE: 'The costs of operating and maintairiin� the "TOWN SQUARE" public spaces for a p�rio<1 from July 1 , 1981 to Ju�ie 30, 1982. AMOiT[JT 62-A Americnn National Bank and Trust Co. 04-19500-071-11 $3,790. 58 Subject to streets and except part in Southeasterly 175.01 feet of Block 11; Lots 4, 5 and 8 and all of Lots 6 and 7, Block 11 , City of St. Paul $locks 3 ehru 12, 17 thru 26, and 31 thru 39. b2-B San Francisco Real Estate Investors 04-19500-134-11 8,141.99 With air rights; subject to streets ; walkway; the following part of Lots 3, 4, 5, 8, 14, 15 and 16 Soutlieast of a line beginning on Souttiwest line of Black 11 , 175.01 feet Northwest of Southwest corner of Block 11, ttience Northeast to a part on Southwest line of Lot 3,24.43 feet Northwest of Southwest corner of Lot 3, thence Northeast 40. 5 feet �o a part 24.37 feet Northwest of South line of Lot 3, Thence Southeast at right angles 38.37 feet thence Northeast et right angles 14.2 feet ttience Southeast at right angles 32 feet tt►ence Northeast at right angles to West line of widened Robert Street also all of Lots 9 thru 13, Block 11, City of S[. Paul, Blocks 3 thru 12, 17 thru 26, and 31 thru 39. 62-C Housing and Redevelopment Authority 04-19500-165-11 . 991.28 Subject ea air rights; subject to street, part of Lots 1 , 2, and 3; part of Lots 14, 15, and 16, Described as follows: Beginning at a part on West line of widened Rabert Street 24.24 feet Northwest .of South line of Lot 1, thence Westerly 90.07 feet to a part 24.37 feet Northwest of South line of Lot 3 , thence Southeast at rigtit angles 38.37 feet thence Northeast at right an�les 14.2 feet thence Southeast at right angles 32 feet thence Northeast at right angles to West line of widened Robert Street thence IVortt�west thereon to beginning in Block 11 , City of St. Paul Blocks 3 tiiru 12, 17 thru 26 and 31 thru 39. 63-A The Federal Land Bank of S�. Paul, Federal InCermediate Credit Bank of St. Paul and St. Paul Bank for CooperatiNes 04-17500-010-01 2,250, 15 Lot 1, Block 1, Capital Centre No. 1 Lot 1 ,: Blocks 1 and 2� Farm Credit Banks of St. Paul 04-17500-030-01 1 ,53$.42 Lot 3, Block 1 , Capital Centre No. 1; Lot 1, Blocks 1 and 2. 63-B State of Minnesota -- Dept. of Administration 04-17500-020-Q1 1 ,989.61 Lot 2, Block 1 , Capital Centre No. 1; Lot 1 , Blocks 1 and 2. -86- �r/ `3a7V . • Finance File No. 18113-81 Page 204 thru 206 ASSESSMENT ROLL RE: The costs of operating and maintainin� the "TOWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period from July 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUNT 64-A Ho�sing and Redevelopment Authority 03-82000-020-09 $712,93 Except Souttiwesterly 14 Eeet Norttiwesterly 1/2 of Lot 3 and except Souttiwesterly 14 feet Lots 1 and 2, Block 9, Whitney and Smiths Addition. Housing and Redevelopment Authority 03-82000-040-09 285.17 Except Soutliwesterly 14 fee� Sou[heasterly 1/2 of Lot 3 , and NorttYwesterly 1/2 of Lot 4, Block 9, Wtiitney and Smiths Addition. Housing and Redevelopment Authnr�.ty 03-82000-120-09 616.47 Except Southwesterly 2 feet fnr alley; Lot 11 and all of Lot 12, Block 9, Whitney and Smittis Addition. Housing and Redevelopment Auttiority 03-18500-074-13 103.21 Except Norttieasterly 10 feet for alley, part of lot 10, Block '9, Whitney and Smiths Additian to St . Paul between extended Nortl►westerly and Southeasterly lines of following and in said City of St. Paul except Southwesterly 8 feet for Street tt�e Southeasterly 1/6 of Lots 6 and 7, Block 13, City of St. Paul Blocks 1 end 2, 13 thr� 16 and 27 thru 30 Housing end Redevelopment Authority . 03-18500-080-13 49.49 Except Souttiwesterly 8 feet for Street the SouCheasterly 20 feet of Northwesterly 40 feet of Lot 8, Block 13, City ' of St. Paul, Blocks 1 and 2, 13 thru 16 and 27 thru 30 Housing and Redevelopment Authority 03-18500-090-13 88.91 Except Northeasterly 10 feet for alley part of Lots 9 and 10, Block 9, Whitney and Smiths Addition to St. Paul between extended Northwesterly and Southeasterly lines of following and in said City of St. Paul except Southwesterly 8 feet for street the norehvesterly 20 feet of lots 8 and 9, Block 13, City of St. Paul, Blocks 1 and 2, 13 thru 16, and 27 thru 30. , Housing and Redevelopment Auttiority 03-18500-093-13 337.80 Beginning on Northeast line of Jackson Street and 44 feet Northwest from Northwest line of Stti Street thence North- west on street line 67. 5 feet ttience Northeast bl feet on centerline of Wall to part on Norttieast line of Lot 8, Block 13, and 111 .95 feet Northwest from 5th Street thence Norttiwest 20.2 feet on East line of Lot 8 ttience Northeast on Center line af Wall to Southwest line of alley thence Southeast on al.ley line for 88.15 feet thence Southwest to beginning, being part of Lot 9, Block 9, Whitney and Smiths Addition and in Said City of St. Paul, part of Lots 8 and 9, Block 13, City of St. Paul, Blocks 1 and 2, 13 thru 16, and 27 thru 30. Housing and Redevelopment Authority 03-18500-075-13 525.34 , Norttiwesterly 126.78 feet More-or-less of following: aub�ject to streets��nd alley; Lot 10, Block 9, Whitney and Smiths Add. and in said City of St. Paul Lots 6 and 7, Block 13, City of St. Paul, Blocks 1 and 2, 13 ttiru 16, and 27 thru 30. , • -87- • Finance File No. 18113-81 Pege 207 thru 210 ASSESSMENT ROLL RE: The costs of operating and maintaining the "TOWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period from July 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUNT 64-B Basic Properties 03-82000-050-09 $199.62 Except Southwesterly 14 feet; Southeasterly 1/2 of Lot 4 and Nor�hwesterly 10 feet of Lot 5, Block 9, Whitney and Smiths Addition. Basic Properties 03-82000-051-09 199.62 Except Southwesterly 14 feet; NorthWesterly 35 feet of Southeasterly 40 feet of Lot 5, Block 9, Whitney and Smiths Addition, Basic Properties 02-82000-060-09 313.69 Except Southwesterly 14 feet; Southeasterly 5 feet of Lot 5 and except Southwesterly 14 feet Lot 6, Block 9, Whitney and Smiths Addition. 64-C Taps Investments - 03-82000-070-09 614.80 Except Southwesterly 2 feet for alley; Lot 8 and all of Lot 7, Block 9, Whitney and 5mitt►s Addi tion. 64-D John S. Connolly C/P: Deil 0. Gustafson 03-18500-092-13 , 185.28 Except Northeasterly 10 Eeet for alley the Southeasrerly 44 feet o£ Lot 9, Block 9 Wiiitney and Smiths Addition to St. Pau1 and in Said City of St. Paul except Soutl�westerly 8 feet for Jackson Street Southeasterly 44 feet of Lots 8 and 9, Block 13, Wl�itney and Smiths Addition. 65 City of St. Paul 03-82000-010-10 3,774.33 Block 10, Whitney and Smith Addition 66-A Finch Associatee , 03-82000-020-11 17,11 Subject to alley on Northeasterly and Southeasterly sides; the Southwesterly 60 feet of Lots 1 and 2, B1ock 11, Wtiitney and Smittis Addition. Fee: Finch Associates C/P: Control Data -- Attn: Property Tax Department 03-82000-060-11 89.82 Except Souttiwesterly 10 feet for alley; Lots 4 thru 6, Block 11, Wttitney and Smiths Addition�. Finches Associates 03-82000-110-11 190,34 Lot 3 and Lots 7 thru 11, Block 11, Wtiitney and Smiths Addition. Finches Associates 03-t32000-121-11 11. �6 Except Southwesterly 95 feet; Lot 12 , Block 11 , Whitney and Smiths Addition • -88- • . Finance File No. 18113-81 Page 210 thru 212 ASSESSMF.NT ROLL RE: The costs of operating and maintaining the "TOWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period from July 1 , 1981 , to Jucie 30, 1982. AMOUNT 66-B Seested[ Carpet and Linoleum Co. 03-82000-021-11 $ 38.49 Except SouChwesterly 60 feet; Lots 1 and 2 , Block 11 , Wl�itney and Smittis Addition 66-C Kobert J. U'Neil C/P: Finct� Associates 03-82000-120-11 20.32 Southwesterly 95 feet r�f Lot 12, Block 11 , Whitney and Smiths Addition. 67-A Aaillon Company 03-82000-023-12 41. 55 Subject to easements ttxe followin�; Part of Kittsons Addition to St. Paul So�tliwesterly of Street and between extended Northwesterly and Southeasterly lines of Lots 1 and 2 in Wliitney and Scnittis Addition and in WhiCney and Smittis Addition part of Lots 1 and 2 Norttieas�erly of a line running fram a point on Norttiwesterly line of and 71 feet more-or-less from most Westerly corner of Lot 1 to a point on Southeasterly line of and 70. 71 feet from most So�itl�erly corner of Lot 2, Block 12, Whitney and Smittis Addition F3aillon Company U3-82000-024-12 , 30.31 S�bject to easemenCS ttie fnllowing; part of Lots 1 and 2 Southwesterly of a line running frc,m a point on Norttiwesterly line 71 feet more-or-less from the most Westerly corner of Lot 1 to a point on Southeasterly line of and 70.71 Eeet from ttie most Southerly corner of Lot 2, Block 12, Whitney and Smiths Addition. Baillon Company 03-82000-032-12 13,83 Subject to easements; the Southwesterly 64.67 feet of Lot 3, Block 12, Whitney and Smirhs Addition. 67°B Ffrst Trust Company of St. Paul C/P: Baillon Co. 03-82000-061-12 40.11 Southwesterly 64.67 feet af Lots 4 thru 6, Block 12, Whitney and Smiths Addition 67-C Broadway Holding Co. 03-82000-Ob2-12 84. 51 S«bject to eASements the following: Part of Kittsons Addition to St. Paul Southwesterly of Street and between extended ldorthwesterly line of Lot 3 and Southeasterly line o� Lot 6, Block 12, Whitney and Smitha Addition and in Said Wtiitney and Smiths Addition except Southwesterly 64.67 feet Lots 3, 4, 5 and 6, Block 12, Whitney and Smiths Addition. � �g- � ��:�� Finance File No. 18113-81 Pa�e 213 r.hru 215 ASSESSMENT FtOLL RE: 'Tkle costs of operatin�; �nd maintainin� ttie "TOWN SQUARE" public spaces for a pe.riod from ,Tuly 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUN� 69 City oE St. Paul -- Rice Park 04-Ei3500-010-11 $2 ,907. 28 Block 11 , Rice and Irvines Addition, Blocks 1 thru 25, 42 ttiru 45 and 54 thru 56. 70 S �. Paul Ho�el Associates C/0: Russell C Dougias 04-G3500-050-10 692. 1? Norttierly 20 feet of 47esterly �90 feet of Lot 2 , and West- eriy 90 feet o£ T,ots 3 and 4 and part of Lot 5 , Westerly of- a line ruaning from a part on Norttierly line of and 71 feet Easter.ly from Northwesterly corner of lot 5 to part on 5outlierly line of and 70 31/100 feet F.asterly from Sou�hwesterly carner of Lot 5, Block 10, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocke 1 th�-�� 25, G2 thru 45, and 54 thru S6. St. Paul Hotel Associates �8a I •� (o C/0: Ru,sell C. Douglas �D 04-63500-090-10 �� In the City of St. Pa�l revised description #487 a specific part of Block 10 Subdivision of Lot 10 and in Rice and Irvines Addition a specific part of lots 1 thru 9, Block 10, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 thru 25, 42 thru 45 and 54 thru 56. 70 St. Paul Hotel Associates C/0: Russell C. Douglas 04-70200-OSO-10 $180.33 Sub. Lot 10 and East 4/5 Lot 9, Easterly 10 feet of Lot 2, and except Southerly 40 feet Lots 3 and 4, and 5, Block 10, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 thru 25, 42 thru 45 and 54 thru 56. St. Paul Hotel Associates $132.52 C/0: Russell C Douglas 04-70200-051-10 Sub. Lot 10 and East 4/5 of Lot 9, Southerly 40 feet of Lots 3, 4, and 5, Block 10, Rice and Irvines Addition, Blocks 1 thru 25, 42 thru 45 and 54 thru 56. and�part of Lots 8, 9 and 10 Norttiwesterly of a line ' � be�;inning on Southwesterly line of and 51. 5 feet Not9th- westerly from Sou[tiweaterly corner of Lot $; thence North- east at right angles for 51.96 fest; Thence Northwest at right angles for 3. 5 feet; thence Northeast at right angles for 12.G feet; thence Northwest at right angles for 25. 75 feet; thence Northeast at right angles for 84.96 feet more- or-l�ss to East line of and 80.7 feet Northwest of South- easterly corner of Lot 10 and all of Lots 3 thru 7, Block 21, C3.ty of St. Paul Blocks 3 thru 12, 17 thru 26 and 31 thru 39. � -90- • Finance File No. 18113-$1 Page 215 thru 218 ASSESSMENT ROLL RE: The costs of operating and maintainin� the "'��G,IN SQUARE" public s,paces for a period from July i , 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUNT 71-B Fee: Port AutlioriCy of St . Paul Lessee: Capitol Properties 04-19500-120-21 $1 ,137,89 5outtieasterly 1/6 of Lots 1 and 2 and all of Lors 11 and 12 , Block 21 , City of St. Paul Blocks 3 thru 12 , 17 thru 26, and 31 thru 39. 71-C City of St . Paul 04-19500-102-21 664. 13 Part of Lots 8, 9 and 10 lying Soutlleasterly of a construction building line described as follows: Beginning on Westerly line of and 51 . 5 feet Northwesterly from Southwesterly corner of Lot 8; ttience Northeasteriy parallel with Souttieasterly line of Bl.ock 21 for 51•96 feet; thence Northwest at right. angles for 3. 5 feet; thence Northeasterly at right angles for 12,4 feet; tlience Nortt�west:erly at rigtit angles for 25. 75 feet; thence Norttieasterly at rigt�t angles mare-or-less for 84.96 feet more-or-less to point on Easterly line of and 80.7 feet Northwesterly from Souttieasterly corner of said Lot 10, Block 21 , City of St. Paul, Blocks 3 thru 12 , 17 thru 26 and 31 thru 39 72-A Economics Laboratory, Inc. 04-19500-010-20 816.87 Witt� easement over 2 foot strip Souttieasterly of and adjacent the Northwesterly 75 feet of Southwesterly 167 5/10 foot ,of Block 20, City of St. Paul Blocks 3 thru 12, 17 thru 26 and 31 thru 39. 72-B Victory Auto Park, Inc . 04-15500-020-20 2,333.31 Subject to 4tt� Street and subject to Easement over Southeast- erly 2 feet of Northwesterly 77 feet of Block 20 and except Nortt�westerly 75 feet the Souttiwesterly 167 5/10 feet of said Block 20, City of St. Paul Blocks 3 thru 12, Blocks 17 thru 26 and 31 thru 39. 72-C Minnesota Mutual Life Insurance Co. 04-19500-030-20 2,963.38 Subject to 4tti Street and Cedar SCreet and except Southwesterly 167. 5 feet; Block 20, City of St. Paul Blocks 3 thru 12, 17 ttiru 26 and 31 ttiru 39. 73-A Minnesota Federal Savings and Loan Association Res 1 Ea te te Owned 04-19500-020-19 1 ,084. 50 Subject to alley; the Northwesterly 20 feet of Lots 11 and 12 and all of Lots 1 and 2, Block 19, Ctty of St. Paul Blocks 3 tt�ru 12, 17 ttiru 26 and 31 thru 39. Minnesota Federal Savings and Loan Association Real Estate Owned 04-19500-121-19 707,24 Except £ollowing beginning at Southwest corner of Lot 11 L-hence Northeas.�prly 1 �t2/100 foot on South line thereof thence Northwesterly 90 08/100 feet to part 1 31/�.00 feet East of West line tt►ereof thence West to said West line tt�ence South to beginning and sub�ject to alley and except Northwesterly 20 feet North and East of alley and subject to easement in Document # 1352307 Lots 11 and 12 Block 19 City of St. Pgul Blocks 3 ttiru 12, 17 thru 26, 3� thru 39 • -91- � Finance File No. 18113-81 Page 219 tlYru 221 ASSESSMENT ROLL RE: The cosCs of operating and maintaining the "TOWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period from July 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUNT 73-B M�c3w�'�t Federal 04-19500-064-19 $1 ,690, 57 Lots 3 and 4 and Northwesterly 125 feet of Lots 5 and 6, Block 19, City of St. Paul Blocks 3 tliru 12, 17 thru 26 and 31 thru 39. 73-C S t. Paul Attile tic Club 04-19500-063-19 162. 56 Southeasterly 25 feet more-or-less Lots 5 and 6, Block 19, City of St. Paul Blocks 3 ttiru 12, 17 thru 26 and 31 thru 39 St. Paul Aehleric Club 04-19500-081-19 975.33 Lots 7 and 8, BLock 19, City of St, Paul, Blocks 3 thru 12, 17 thru 26 and 31 thru 39. 73-D Northwest Publications, Inc. 04-19500-101-19 885. 79 City of St. Paul Blocks 3 thru 12 , 17 thru 26 and 31 thru 39 a Tract beginr�ing at Southwest corner of Lot 11 thence North- easterly 1 42/100 feet on Sc�utt� line thereof tt�ence North- westerly 90 08/100 feet to part 1 31/100 feet East of West line thereof thence West to said West line thence Soutt� to beginning and except 1Vorthwesterly 15 feet for alley, Lots 9 and 10, Block 19, City of St. Paul Blocks 3 thru 12, 17 tl�ru 26, and 31 thru 39. , 74 First Na�ional Bank 04-27500-022-00 6,035.93 Subject to easements; and subject to street Lot 1 and subject to street and except Southeaeterly 98.15 feet Lot 16 and a1Z of Lots 2 thru 7 and except Soutti�asterly 98. 15 feet Lots 14 and 15 all in Black 18 City of St. Paul and in said First National Plat A and B, The First National Pla t. 75-A Empire Building Carporation 04-19500-050-17 90$,88 Except Northeasterly 9 feet for alley and except Southwesterly 4 54/100 feet the Northwesterly 102 5/1.0 f�et of Lots 3 tt�ru 5, Block 17, City of St . Paul Blocks 3 thru 12, 17 thru 26 and 31 thru 39. Empire Building Corporation 04-19500-OS1-17 697.36 Northwesterly 102 5/10 feet of fallowing: Lots 6 and 7 and Southwesterly 4 54/100 feet of Lot 5, Block 17, City of St . Paul Blocks 3 thru 12, 17 thru 2b and 31 thru 39. 75-B P. E. M. Company Association 04-19500-111-17 3 ,094. 92. Subject to pedestrian concourse ttie following: except East 9 feet of Lot 3 and except Northerly 102.5 feet; Lots 3 thr�� 7 and except East 9 feet; Lot 12 and all of Lots 8 thru 11 , Block 17, City of St. Paul Blocks 3 thru 12, 17 ttiru 26, and 31 thru 39. • -�2- � Finance File No. 18113-81 Page 222 thru 224 ASSESSMENT ROLL RE: The costs of operating and maintaining the "TO�WN SQUARE" public spaces for a period f rom July 1 ,° 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUNT 75-B P. E. M. Company Association 04-1�500-010-02 $1 ,555.46 Lot 1 , Blnck 2 , Capital Centre No. 1; Lot 1 , Block 1 and 2. 76-A Norttiern Pacific Railway Co. 03-04�00-150-02 1 ,063.02 In tt�e City of S�. Paul revised description 4k435 a specific part of Drakes Bearrangement A and part of Lots 2 thru 10 and Lot 15, Block 2, Auditors Subdivision No. 32. Idortliern Pacific Railway Co. 03-04000-152-02 506, 18 BeginninK on Nartheasterly line of Jackson Street and 145 23/100 fee� thereon from Northwesterly line of 4tt� Street thence to right et right angle. with said NorCheasterly street line 63 77/100 feet thence 32 minutes 30 seconds to right 110 92/100 feet thence 90 de�rees 32 minutes 30 seconds to left 73 445/1000 feer, ttience 90 de�rees to left r.o a line parallel wi�t and distant Northeasterly 63 77/100 feet from said Northeasterly street line thence co left on said para11e1 l�.ae 14 41/l00 feet thence 90 degrees to right to said Nortl�easterly street line tlience Souttieasterly to bef;i.nning bein� part of Lots 5 ttir•u 15, Nlnck 2, Auditor' s Subdivision No. 32. 76-B Great Northern Railway Co, 03-04000-151-02 1 ,027,04 Southcrly 144 475/1000 feet of Lots C and D, Drakes Rearrangement A and in said Audi�ors Subdivision No. 32, tl�e Soutiieasterly 70 79/100 feet of Lots 13 tt►ru 15, Block 2, Auditors Subdivision No. 32. Great Northern Railway Co, , 03-04000-153-02 ' S49, 71 Beginni�ig on Norttieasterly Line of Jacksan Street and 145 23/100 feet tl�ereon from Northwesterly line of 4th Street thence Norttieasterly at right angles witti sai.d street line 63 77/100 feet thence right 0 degrees 32 minutes 30 seconds 110 92/100 feet thence right 89 de�,rees 27 minutes 30 seconds for 73 385/1000 feet thence ri�;tlt 90 degrees to said Nortlieasterly street line tt►ence to be�innin� being part of Lots 13 thru 15, Block 2, Auditors Subdivision No. 32. 76-C i•lidway Merctiandise Mart C/P: Midwest Management Co. 03-23500-010-00 1,261.26 Lot 1 , Block 2, Auditors Subdivision No. 32 St. Paul, Minn. and in said Drakes Rearrangement Lots A and B, Drakes Rearrangement A. • -93- • Finance File No. 18113-81 Page 224 thru 227 ASSESSMENT ROLL RE: The costs of operating and maintaining the "TOWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period from July 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUNT 77-A St. Paul Postal Employees Credit Union C/P: Ronald S. Colosimo 03-82000-010-15 $243.23 Except Souttieasterly 20 feet for street and except Nortt�westerly 10 feet for alley; Lot 1 , Block 15, Whitney and Smiths Addition 77-B Arthur 0. Johnson and Ben B. Blizen C/P: Ronald S. Calosimo 03-82000-030-15 462.15 Except Souttieasterly 20 feet for street and except Northwesterly 10 feet for alley; Lot 2 and except Souttiwesterly 5 feet; Lot 3, Block 15, Whitney and Smiths Addition. 77-C Hillard M. Marver, et al 03-82000-060-15 570,34 Except Southeasterly 10 feet for alley; Lots 5 and 6, Block 15, Whitney and Smiths Addition 77-D American National Bank and Trust Co. and Sheva Bernstein C/P: H. Rosenthal Co. 03-04000-010-01 391.06 Lot 1 , $lock 1, Auditors Subdivision No. 32. 77-L Strauss Knitting Mills, Inc. � 03-04000-U50-01 684.20 Witti party wall agreement; Lots 2 ttiru S, Block 1, Auditors Subdivision No. 32. Straus Knitting Mill, Inc. 03-04000-060-01 73,05 Subject to party w�ll agreement and subject to ease- ment; Lot 6, Bloek l, Auditors Subdivision No. 32 77-F Merrill Kuller, et �1 C/P: Magdalene Weschcke 03-04000-080-01 319. 73 Subject to parky wall and alley agreement and 4th Street; Lots 7 and 8, Block 1, Auditors Subdivision No. 32. 77-G Maurice L. Baratz, et al 03-04000-110-01 506.05 Except Southeasterly 20 feet for 4tti Street and subject to party��all agreement and with easement Lots 9, 10 and 11, Block 1, Auditors Subdivision No. 32. 78-A Herbert J. Bernick, et al c/o: Murray Partnership 03-82000-021-14 62.35 Part Northeasterly of a line running from part on iVorth- west line of and 0 18/100 foot Northeasterly from West corner of Lot 1 to part on Southeast line of and 0 41/100 feet Southwesterly from East corner of lot 11 of following Lots 11, 1 and 2, Block 14, Whitney and Smiths Addition. � -94- � Finance File No. 18113-81 Page 227 ttiru 230 ASSESSMENT ROLT. RE: Tt�e costs of operating and maintainin�; the "TOWN SQUARE" puhlic spaces for a period from July l , 1981 to J�ne 30, 1982. AMOUNT 78-A Hert}ert J. Bernick, et al C/P: Murray Partnership 03-tS2000-121-14 $ 59.47 Part Southwesterly of a line running from part on Northwest line of and 0 18/100 feet Nortt�easterly from West corner of Lot 1 to part on Southeast line of and 0 41/100 feet Soutt�westerly fram East corner of Lot 11 of Following Lots 1 , 11 and 12, Block 1G, Smitti and Whitneys Addition. 78-B Ben Blizen 03-�32000-030-14 1.5. 53 Except Nortt�westerly 18 feet and Southwesterly 25 feet for alley; Lot 3, Block 14, Wtiitney and Smiths Addition, 7$-C Nortl� Central Company 60,20 03-82000-OSO-14 Lots 4 and 5, Block 14, Whitney and Smiths Addition 78-D Jacob Posnansky, et al C/P: A. R. Sundber� 03-82000-080-14 91, 53 Lots 6 and 7 and except Southweseerly 1 foot; Lot 8, Block 14, Wl�itney and Smiths Addition 78-E American Beauty Macaroni Company ' C/Y: A. R. Sundherg 03-82000-090-14 31,32 Souttiwesterly 1 foot of Lot 8 and all of Lot 9, Block 14, Wtiitney and Smittis Addition, Fee: American Beauty Macaroni Company C/P: A, R. Sundberg 03-82000-100-14 20,68 Except Nortt�easterly 25 feet and Northwesterly 9 feet for alley; Lot 10, Block 14, Whitney and Smiths Addition 79 The Gillette Company 03-82000-061-13 199.02 Part of Kittson's Addition Southwesterly of Broadway and adjacent and following: Lots 1 tl�ru 6, Block 13, Whitney and Smi�hs Addition. 8I-A City of St. Pa�l 04-04200-1$0-00 204.34 V�cant alley adjacent and Lots 2 thru 18, A�iditors Sub- division No,34. 81-B James Jerome Hill Reference Library 04-0420Q-190-00 83. 58 Vacant alley l�etween and Lots 1 and 19, Auditors Sub- division No. 34 82-A Northwestern Bell Telephone Company 04-63500-062-19 1,421.62 Subject to Boulevard; the following tract: Westerly 1/2 of Lot 7 and all of Lots 3 thru 6, Block 19, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 thru 25, 42 thru 45, and 54 thru 56. ! • -95- • Finance File No. 18113-81 Pa�e 231 thru 233 ASSESSMENT ROLL RE: The costs of operating and maintaining the "TOWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period from July 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUNT 82-A Northwestern Aell Telephone Co. 04-63500-081-19 $1 ,191,47 Subject to Kellogg Boulevard; Tt►e following Tract: except East 1f�.98 feet lying South of the North 51 .96 feet and except West 18,7 feet of East 18.98 feet of Soutti 17.46 feet of North 51 .96 feet; Lot 9 and except part lying Soutt� of North 51 .96 feet; Lot 10 and Easterly 1/2 of Lots 2 and 7 and all af Lots 1 and 8, Block 19, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 thru 25, G2 thru 45 and 54 thru 56. 82-B Baillon Company 04-63500-022-19 120,36 Westerly 1/2 of Lot 2, Block 19, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 thru 25, 42 thru 45, and 54 thru 56. 82-C M�t111EliUtA Museum of Art, Inc. 04-63500-090-19 241. 56 Except Kellogg Blvd. and except Northerly 51 96/100 feet of Lot 10 and sxcept said Boulevard and .except Eesterly 28%100 feet of Nartherly 17 46/100 feet part of Easterly 18 98/100 feet of Lot 9 Southerly of Nortkierly 34 SO/100 feet of said Lot 9, Block 19, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 ttiru 25, 42 thru 45y and 54 thru 56. 83 City of St. Paul/County of Ramsey City Hall and Court House , 04-19500-010-22 2 ,755. 55 All of Davidson and Merremans Subdivision of Lots 1 and 2 of Block 22, St. Paul Proper and in said City of St. Paul except Northwest 1/2 of Lot 6 and of Southwest 44 55/100 feet of L�t 5, and except Lots 1 and 2 all of Block 22, City of St. Paul Blocks 3 thru 12, 17 thru 26 and 31 thru 39. County of Ramsey 04-19500-060-22 237.91 Except Northeasterly 5.45 feet; the Northwesterly 1/2 of Lots 5 and 6, Block 22, City of St. Paul Blocks 3 thru 12, 17 thru 26 and 31 thru 39. 84-A St. Paul Joint Venture C/P: Radison Hotel Corporation 04-19500-164-23 2,739.41 Subject �o Boulevard and street ttie following Tract: except Northwesterly 66 86/100 feet the Southwesterly 1/2 of Lot 4 and except Northwesterly 66 91/100 feet Lot 5 also except Nortt�westerly 65 feet Lots 6, 7, and 8 also Lots 9 thru 13 and except Northwesterly 20 9/10 feet of Northeasterly 44 feet; Lot 14 and all of Lots 15 and 16, Block 23, City of St. Paul Blocks 3 thru 12, 17 thru 26, and 31 thru 39. 84-B H. Kretz Realty Company Corporation 04-19500-08U-23 408.89 Northwesterly 65 feet of Lats 6 thru $, Block 23, City of St. Paul, Blocks 3 thru 12 , 17 [hru 26 and 31 thru 39. , • -96- � Finance File No. 18113-81 Pa�,E 233 �k�ru 236 ASSESSMENT ROLL RE: The costs uf operatin� and maintainin�; tt�e "TUWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period from Jilly 1 , 1981 to ,Tune 30, 1982. AMOUNT f34-C Milton Rosen C/0: Clapp '�homssen Co. 04-19500-050-23 $210.44 Nortliwesterly 66 86/100 feet of t��e Southwesterly 1%2 of Lot 4 and ttie Northweseerly 66 91/100 feet of Lot 5, Block 23, City of St. Paul Blocks 3 thru 12 , 17 thru 26, and 31 ttiru 39. 84-ll begree of Honor Protective Association 0�+-19500-140-23 667,64 Subject to street tt�e following Lots l, 2 and 3 and the Nnrt}�easterly 1/2 of Lot 4, Also, Norttieasterly 44 feet of Norttiwesterly 20 9/10 feet of Lot 14, Block 23, City of St. Paul Blocks 3 thru 12, 17 thru 26 and 31 thru 39. 85-A Nortlawest Publications, Inc. 04-19500-020-24 524.21 Except Soutt�westerly 2 feet of Lot 2; the Northwesterly 5/6 of Lots 1 and 2, Block 24, City of St. Paul Blocks 3 thru 12, 17 thru 26 and 31 thru 39. Northwest Publications, Inc. 04-29500-030-24 419.37 Southeasterly 1/6 of Lots 1 and 2 and Southwesterly 2 feet of. Narttiwesterly 5i6 of Lot 2 and all of Lot 3, Block 24 , City of St. Paul Blocks 3 thru 12 , 17 thru . 26 and 31 thru 39. Fi5-B Dacotati Investments -- C/P Minnesota Buildin� Management 04-19500-050-24 434.05 Except Southeasterly 12 feet for alley Lo.t 4 and except Soutt�easterly 12 feet for alley the Northeast 1/2 of Lot 5, Block 24, City of St. Paul, Blocks 3 thru 12, 17 ttiru 26 and 31 thru 39. Dacotat� Investments C/P; Minnesota Building Management 04-19500-060-24 434.05 Except Souttieasterly 12 feet for alley Southwesterly 1/2 of Lot 5 and except Southeasterly 12 feet for alley Lot 6, Block 24, City aE St. Paul, Blocks 3 tk�ru 12, 17 ttiru 26 and 31 thru 39. Dacotah Investments C/P: Minnesota Building Management 04-19500-080-24 184.90 Norlhwesterly 40.Q8 feet of Lot 7 and of Souttiwesterly 3/5 of Lot 8, Block 24, City of St. Paul Blocks 3 thru 12 , 17 thru 26 and 31 ttiru 39. �35-C William Bick, et al 04-19500-081-24 505.34 Subject to Boulevard and except Nor[hwesterly 40 08/100 feet Southwesterly of Northeasterly 20 feet of Lot 8 the following Southwesterly 5 feet of Lot 9, and all of Lots 7 and 8, Block 24, City of St. Paul Blocks 3 thru 12, 17 thru 26 and 31 thru 39. • -97- � Finance File No. 18113-$i Page 236 thru 238 ASSFSSMENT ROLL RE: Ttie costs of operating and maintaining the "TOWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period from July 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUNT � $5-D Y. W. C. A. 04-19500-120-24 $1 ,188.24 SubjecC to $oulevard the Northeasterly 45 feet of Lot 9 and all of Lots 10, 11 and 12, Block 24, City of St. Paul Blocks 3 tt�ru 12 , 17 thru 26 and 31 thru 39. 86 Kellogg Square Partnership 04-19500-163-25 3,845. 54 Subject to streets; the entire Block consisting of Lots 1 thru 16, Block 25, City of St. Paul Blocks 3 thru 12, 17 thru 26 and 31 thru 39, 87 United 5tates of America Federal Office Building C/P: General Services Administration 04-17500-010-03 3,199,21 Lo� 1 , Block 3 , Capital Centre No. 1 ,. Lot 1, Blocks 1 and 2. 88 John N. Geller 03-17500-011-04 2,007.36 Except Southwesterly 50.59 feet of Norlhwesterly 125.07 feet formerly known as Lot 5, Block 27, City of St. Paul Addition; Lot 1 , Block 4, Capital Cen�re No, i; Lot 2, Block 4 John N. Geller 03-17500-021-04 1,294.13 Soutt►westerly 50.59 feet of Northwesterly 125.07 feet of Lot 1 , Block 4, formerly known as Lot 5, Block 27, City of St. Paul Addition and all of Lot 2, Block 4, Capital Centre No. 1 , L'ot 2, Block 4. 89 St. Paul Union Depot Co. 03-18500-030-28 3,585.61 Subject to streets; Block 28, City of St. Paul, Blocks 1 and �2, 13 thru 16 and 27 thru 30. 90-A Arthur G• Johnson, et al C/P: Grace Colosimo 03-33000-050-02 27•80 Lot 5, Block 2, Hopkins Addition Fee: Arthur G• Johnson, et al C/P; Grace Colosimo _ 03-33000-060-02 27•$� Lot 6, Block 2, Hopkins Addition Arthur G. Johnson, et al 03-33000-110-02 9.62 Southeasterly 90 feet �f Southwesterly 1/2 of Lot 11 , Block 2, Hopkins Addition, • -98- F nance File No. 18113-81 Page 239 thru 2G2 ASSESSMENT ROLL RE: Tt�e costs of operating and maintaininK the "TOWN SQUARE" public spaces for a period from July 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUNT 90-A Arlhur G. Johnson, et al 03-33000-111-02 $ 9.62 Southeasterly 90 �eet of Northeasterly 25 feet of Lot 11 , Block 2, Hopkins Addition Artt�ur G. Johm�.4on, et al 03-33000-120-02 19.25 Southerly 90 feet of Lot 12, Block 2, Hopkins Addition 90-B L. Jotin Halper; ;Corinne H. Epstein and Judith A Halper 03-33000-020-02 55.05 Lots 1 and 2, Block 2, Hopkins Addition 90-C Rodric and Renee Guindon C/P: Roger Nielson 03-33000-030-02 27. 52 �ot 3, �lock 2, Hopkins Ac3dition 90-D SchefEer and Rossum Co. 03-33000-040-02 � 27. 52 Lot 4, Block 2, Hopkins Addition 90�E L. A. Venaglia, et al 03-33000-080-02 59.88 Except alley; Lots 7 and 8, Block 2, Hopkins Addition 90-2� Arthur C. Kootz and Margrete K Suries - Trustees C/P: Dodson - Fisher Co, 03-33000-100-02 59.88 Except Alley; Lots 9 and 10, Block 2, Hopkins Addition 90-G Ben Benjamin Blizen 03-33000-121-U2 21,39 Except alley and except Soutl�easterly 90 feet; Lots 11 and 12, Block 2, Hopkine Adc3ition 91-A ATR Electronics, Inc. C/P: Albert Goffstein 03-33000-030-01 87 .52 Lots 1 thru 3, Block 1 , Hopkins Addition 91-B Great Northern Railway Co. 03-33000-060-01 86.62 Lar.s 4 thru 6, Block 1 , Hopkins Addition 93 NorChern States Power Co. 04-63500-041-21 204.04 Vacant streets accruing and ttie East 25 feet of Lot 5 and all of Lots 1 thru 4, Block 21 , Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 thru 25, 42 ttiru 45, and 54 ttiru 56. • -99- � rinance File No. 18113-81 Page 242 thru 244 A55ESSMENT ROLL RE: Tt�e costs of operating and maintaining the "TOWN SQUARE" public spaces for a peri�d from Ju1y 1 , 1981 to June 30, 1982. AMOUNT 94 West Publist�ing Company ' 04-63 500-011-20 $ 69. 50 St. Peter Street as vacated in Document ��1784641 accruing and following: Easterly 12 .54 feet of Lot 2 and all of Lot 1 , Block 20, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 thru 25, 42 thru 45, and 54 thru 56. West Publishing Company 04-63500-083-20 313.48 Vacated streets accruing and subject �o s�reet and easemenLs the following: Excepl East 12. 54 feet Lot 2 and all af Lots 3 thru 8, Block 20, Rice and Irvines Addition Blocks 1 thru 25, 42 thru 45, and 54 tliru 56. 95 County of Ramsey - Ramsey County Adult Detentian Center 04-04 000-06 1-QO 160, 54 Subject to streets and easements and vacaled streets adjacent; commencing on center line of St• Ppter Streec 69•13 feel South of center line of Old Third Street thence Nortti 80 de�;rees 45 minutes East 30. 72 feet for bep,inning tlience continue Nortti 80 degrees 45 minutes East 311.99 feet tl�ence Soutti 56 de�;rees ].2 minutes East 11 .31 Feet thence South ll degrees 12 minuCes East to . Railroad rif;l�t-of-way thence Southwest on Railroad ri�t�t-of-way to extended center line of St. Peter St. : tt�ence Northwest on said center line 120.53 feet thence Northeast 36. 79 feet to beginnin�y being part of Northeast 1/4 of Section 6, Township 28, Ranpe 22, and in Auditors Subdivision No. 25 part of Lots 1 thru 6, Auditors Subdivision No. 25• 96 Brooklyn Center Development Corporatior► 04-04300-092-00 78, 59 Subject to 2nd Street the following: Part of Lots 8, and 9, Souttieasterly of a line beginning at a part on Norttieasterly line of said Lot 8 and 3 feet from most Easterly corner thereof, tlience Southwesterly 90 55/100 feet to a part an Souttiwesterly line of said LoC 9 and 2 50/100 feet from West corner of said Lot 9, Auditors Subdivision No. 35 Brooklyri Center Development Company 04-04300-093-00 141, 15 Vacated streets and alleys accruing: part lying South of lisie beginning on Souttiwesterly line of Lot 7 and 54. 57 feet North of Nor'thwest corner of Lot 8 ttience deflect to the right 79 degrees 19 minutes 241 .6 feet to p�rt 105 feet North of Northeast corner of Lot 8, of Lots 1 thru 7, Also, part lying Northwesterly of a line beginning at part on Nortt�easterly line of said lot 8 and 3 feet from most East- erly corner therenf thence 5outhwesterly 90.55 feet to Narth part on Southwest line of saic3 Lot 9, and 2. 50 feet from West corner of said Lot 9, of Lots 8 and 9, Auditnrs SuUdivision No. 35. � � -100- � � t The assessmemt of benefits , coses and expecises have been filed in the office of the Department of Finance and Management Services. Within twenty days after t'tie order adopting tl�e assessment, or makin� a reassessment, a new assessment, or supplemental assessment, any person may appeal to the District Court by filing a notice of appeal with the City Clerk stating the grounds upon which the appeal is taken. Such notice st�all be filed with the Clerk of District Court wittiin ten days after the filing witt► ttie City Clerk. . a � � �� - • MEIER, KENNEDY, QUINN & SHUMAKER Atlorneys a! Law WILLIAM G. MEIER Ita20-t9Et1 SUITE 430. MINNESOTA BUILDING ALOIS D. KENNEDY.JR. TIMOTHY P.QUINN S�41NT PAUL.MINNESOTA 55101 - GORDON W. SHUMAKER 1612)226-8844 ANDREW J. EtSENZIMMER LEO M.DEHLER THOMAS B. WIESER OCtOber' 1 5 � 1 981 �? --• '. �� _; � � �,.. � � . .. ,.� � - :« -- rn ,� The Honorable Albert Olson � n "J � _� � City Clerk, City of St. Paul , .:; �= Room 386 , City Hall � � St. Paul Minnesota 55102 "' "� - Re: Notice of Appeal from Special Assessments and Service Charges Dear Mr. Olson: Delivered to you herewith for filing, pursuant to Section 14 .01 .4 (Appeal) of the Saint Paul City Charter, is the Notice of Appeal from Special Assessments and Service Charges in regard to the special assessments and service chargets against the properties of the named Appellants, The Archdiac�se of Saint Paul and Minneapolis, The Church of The Assumption, The Church of St . Louis , The Church of St. Mary, and St. Joseph' s Hospital, listed in the Assessment Roll adopted by order of the City Council October 1 , 1981 to finance the annual operation and maintenance of "Town Square" . , We respectfully request, as provided for in Section 14 .01 .4 , Subparagraph 4 , of the City Charter, that you deliver to us, on behalf of the Appellants, a copy of the Assessment Roll , certi- fied to by the proper City Officers, so that we may file it with the District Court, as required by said Se�tion 14.01 .4 , Subparagraph 4 . .;.p" Yours very truly, MEIER, KENNEDY, QUINN & SHUMAKER � . T imoth , P. Qu inn TPQ :sh Enclosures : ..:� ��%� - - � , � Fi��o �� 1� t �� PH '�! r.�;`� t`t ":i��.�'s ncc�� . - �4 ;: i. STATE OF MINNESOTA , DISTRICT COURT RAMSEY COUNTY SECOND JUDICIAL DISTRICT -------------------------------------- The Archdiocese of Saint Paul and Minneapolis, The Church of The Assumption, The Church of St. Louis , The Church of St. Mary, and St. Joseph' s Hospital, all Minnesota corporations, NOTICE OF APPEAL Appellants, FROM SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS AND SERVICE CHARCES vs. The City of Saint Paul, a Minnesota Municipal corporation , Respondent. -------------------------------------- The Archdiocese of Saint Paul and Minneapolis, The Church of The Assumption, The Church of St. Louis, The Church of St . Mar_v, and St. Joseph' s Hospital, Appellants above named, owners of the parcels of real estate hereinafter described, hereby appeal those certain special assessments and service charqes levied by the City of Saint Paul, a Municipal corporation, Respondent above named, against those certain parcels of real estate owned by Appellants, as set forth hereafter, pursuant to that certain assessment roll listing said properties and said assessments and service charges, adopted by Order of the City Council of the said City of Saint Paul , on October 1 , 1981 , for the purpose of financing and apportioning the cost of that certain local improvement described in the Notice of the Public � � � � �1�� Hearing on said proposed assessments and service charges as "service charges resulting from the annual operation and maintenance of the City owned 'Town Square' public spaces located in the area bounded by the following streets: Cedar Street, Eighth Street, Minnesota Street , and Sixth Street. " This notice is given in accordance with, and pursuant to, the provisions of Chapter 429 , Minnesota Statutes; Chapters 13 and 14 of the Saint Paul City Charter; and Chapter 62 of the Saint Paul Administrative Code. I . The properties owned by Appellants against which the appealed from assessments and service charges were levied, and the amount of said assessments and service char_qes are as follows: The Archdiocese of Saint Paul and Minneapolis (Catholic Youth Center) I .D. No. 04-63500-070-55 $ 61 .77 The Church of The Assumption I .D. No. 04-63500-015-03 $965 .78 04-14000-060-09 259 .43 1 ,225 .21 The Church of St. Louis I .D. No. 04-66000-030-12 $180 .71 04-66000-050-12 1 ,001 .41 1 , 182. 12 The Church of St. Mary I .D. No. 03-34000-041-02 $ 22 .65 03-34000-041-11 181 .87 204 .52 St. Joseph' s Hospital I .D. No. 04-14000-020-03 $ 19 .21 04-14000-092-03 23. 37 04-14000-132-03 230 .22 04-14000-152-03 34 .32 04-14000-081-03 19 . 13 I .D. No. 04-38000-010-58 8 .71 04-38000-011-58 5 .04 I .D. No. 04-64000-081-00 831 .45 04-38000-010-66 23 .69 Q4-14000-020-04 17 . 16 1 ,212 . 30 $3 ,885 .92 , -2- � �� II . Prior to the Public Hearing held on September 22, 1981 , Appellants presented to the Mayor and members of the St. Paul City Council their written objections to said assessments, setting forth the applicable facts and law, and the qrounds for said objections, a copy of which written notice of objections is attached hereto, marked "Exhibit I" and made a part hereof. Prior to the continued Public Hearing, held on October 1 , 1981 , Appellants served additional written notice of objections to said assessments, a copy of which written objections is attached hereto, marked "Exhibit II" , and made a part hereof. III . The grounds for the appeal from said assessments and service charges levied against said properties to finance and apportion the cost of said improvements are as follows: 1 . That the assessments, in each instance, are fraudulent, in that the City Council was aware of the absence of any economic bene- fit to the above properties as a result of said "improvement" to be financed by said assessments. 2 . That the assessments are made upon demonstrable mistakes of fact and law. 3 . That the assessments, in each instance , are in an amount in excess of the actual benefits to the above properties being assessed; the actual benefits being none. -3- �^Jr'7 / � ` � �( � II . Prior to the Public Hearing held on September 22, 1981 , Appellants presented to the Mayor and members of the St. Paul City Council their written objections to said assessments, setting forth the applicable facts and law, and the grounds for said objections, a copy of which written notice of objections is attached hereto, marked "Exhibit I" and made a part hereof. Prior to the continued Public Hearing, held on October 1 , 1981 , Appellants served additional written notice of objections to said assessments, a copy of which written objections is attached hereto, marked "Exhibit II" , and made a part hereof. III . The grounds for the appeal from said assessments and service charges levied against said properties to finance and apportion the cost of said improvements are as follows: 1 . That the assessments, in each instance, are fraudulent, in that the City Council was aware of the absence of any economic bene- fit to the above properties as a result of said " improvement" to be financed by said assessments. 2 . That the assessments are made upon demonstrable mistakes of fact and law. 3 . That the assessments , in each instance, are in an amount in excess of the actual benefits to the above properties being assessed; the actual benefits being none. -3- • �) �� Z,/ �� t 4 . That the assessments constitute an unconstitutional taking without compensation. IV. That on October 15 , 1981 , within twenty (20) days after the entry of the Order of the City Council adopting said assessments, Appellants filed the within Notice of Appeal with the City Clerk of the City of Saint Paul, in accordance with Section 14 .01 .4 , 5ubpara- graph 1 , of the City Charter, and requested a certified copy of the Assessment Roll for filing in the District Court, as required by Section 14 .01 .4 , Subparagraph 4 , of the City Charter. WHEREFORE, Appellants pray that the court set aside said assessments against the above properties, determine that there is no economic benefit to any of the said properties as a result of said improvement and order that said properties not be assessed in any amount for said improvement. Dated: October 15 , 1981 . MEIER, KENNEDY, QUINN & SHUMAKER By: . Timo y P. Quinri Attorney for Appellants 430 Min sota Building St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Phone: (612) 226-8844 �<-�._, y �"t� ` ,�� '�`f �� i �.t.ti-� n <� ��}� `� � / � �5� ,�� a � . z ,�;, , ,�-� �� -4- � � � a7 �y�'�" ' MEIER, KENNEDY, QUINN & SHUMAKER Arrornn•s at Law • ' WILLtAM G. MEIER it920•tYe�� September � 5 � � 70� SUITE 430. MINNESOTA BUILD�NG ALOIS O. KENNEDY.JR. TIMOTMY P. OUINN SAINT PAUL. MINNESOTA SS101 GORDON W. SHUMAKER (6121 228-8844 ANDREW J. E13ENZIMMER LEO H. DEHLER THOMAS B.WIESER The Honorable George Latimer Mayor of the City of Saint Paul , And The Honorable Members of the St. Paul City Council City Hall and Courthouse St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Re: Town Square "Assessments" (Catholic Church Properties) Dear Mayor Latimer and Members of the St . Paul City Council : The undersigned is General Counsel for The Archdiocese of Saint Paul and Minneapolis and represents the following Catholic in- stitutions in regard to the assessments proposed to be levied against the listed properties for the annual maintenance of "Town Square Park" , payable in 1982: 1 . The Catholic Youth Center 150 North Smith Avenue $ 76 .99 2 , The Church of The Assumption 51 West Ninth Street 1 ,527 . 16 3 . The Church of St . Louis 506 Cedar Street 1 ,473.46 4 . The Church of St. Mary 261 East F.ighth Street 254 .92 5 . St. Joseph ' s Hospital 69 West Exchange Street 1 ,487 .24 On behalf of the above named entities, we hereby formally ob- ject to the proposed assessments on the grounds herein set forth, and respectfully request that these assessments be stricken from the assessment roll. Enclosed herewith , marked "Exhihit A" and made a part hereof, is a formal legal opinion and position paper briefly setting forth our formal legal position that if any of these five properties, which include three churches , a youth center and a hospital, are to be assessed, it must be shown that some economic benefit will enure to these properties as a result of the proposed " improvement" ( annual maintenance expense for "Town Square Park" ) . The applicable law is clear: That the economic benefit which must enure to real estate in order for an improvement to be assessed against such real estate must consist of an increase EXHIBIT "I" ' � p` r�� , . MEIER, KENNEDY, QUINN & SHUMAKER The Honorable George Latimer The Honorable Members of the St. Paul City Council � September 15 , 19R1 Page Two in the reasonable market value of the property proposed to be assessed, as a result of the proposed improvement. I am certain that the City Attorney will concur in the applicable law in this instance. Also enclosed herewith , marked "Exhibit B" and made a part hereof, is the appraisal prepared by William J. nunn, Realtor and Appraiser, setting forth the facts in this case, namely: that each of the properties is presently being used to its highest and best use and that there is in fact no economic benefit to any of these properties. The appraisal points out that the market value of each property is not increased to any degree as a result of the pro- posed "improvement" . Mr. Dunn is a recognized expert appraiser who has appeared literally hundreds of times in district courts of Minnesota testifying in regard to these kinds of matters. Since there is no increase in the market value and there is no . benefit to any of the properties the law holds that there can be no assessment levied against these properties for the proposed "improvement . " The principle involved in these proposed "assessments" is a basic principle which our clients have an obligation to their constituen- cies to uphold. The amount involved in each particular assessment is not necessarily overwhelming ( at this time) but for any of these institutions to acquiesce in such an "assessment" would be a prece- dent which we cannot advocate. On behalf of The Archdiocese of Saint Paul and Minneapolis, The Church of The Assumption, The Church of St. Louis, The Church of St. Mary and St . Joseph' s Hospital we respectfully request the Honorable Mayor and Members of the St. Paul City Council to strike the proposed assessments against these five properties from the assessment roll. Your consideration of this request is greatly appreciated. Yours very truly, MEIER, KENNEDY, QUINN & SHUMAKER -� , �� _ � � Timoth P. Quinn ~ TPQ:sh cc: The Archdiocese of Saint Paul a d Minneapolis The Church of The Assumption The Church of St . Louis The Church of St. Mary St. Joseph' s Hospital T0: The City of Saint Paul FROM: Timothy P. Quinn , Esq . , General Counsel The Archdiocese of Saint Paul and Minneapolis DATE: September 15 , 1�81 RE : Special Assessment on Church Property ISSUE ARE CHURCtIES AND CHURCFI PROPFRTY SU�3Jf��CT TO A SPECIAL ASSESSMENT LEVIED FOR NONABUTTING PARK MAINTENANCE PURPOS�S? DISCUSSION Minn. Const. art . 1� § 1 provides in part : Taxes shall be uriiform upon the same class of subjects and shall be levied and collected for public purposes , but public burying grounds , public school houses , public hospitals , academies , colleges , uni- versities , all seminaries of learning, all churches , church property , houses of worship, institutions of purely public charity , and public property used exclusively for any public purpose , shall be exempt from taxation except as provided in this section . (Emphasis added) . Constitutional exemption from general taxation does not , i�owever , exempt such property from special assessments. 70 Am. Jur . 2d Special or Local Assessments § 65 (1�373) . Exemptions from special assessments must be found, if at all , in express str�tutory provisions . 13A nunnell Minn . 1)igest 2d h4unicipal Corporations § 9.04 (3d ed. 1�381 ) . Such a statu- tory exemption from local assessments does exist with respect to public cemetery associations and did exist for railroad com- pany land. No such special exemption exists for churches or ctiurch property not used as buryin� grounds. ERHIBIT "A" . . ��1�Cl� � The uniform taxation clAUSe of Article 10 § 1 is consid- ered in conjunction with Minn. Stat . § 42�.�51 which provides that " [ t ]he cost of any improvements , or any part thereof , may be assessed upon property benefited by the improvement , based upon the benefits received. . . . " The benefit to the property from the improvement must be based upon "wtiat increase, if any, there has been in the market value of the benefited land. " City of St . Louis Park v. Engell , 283 Minn . 309 , 31G , 16�i N.W. 2d 3 , 8(196�) . If there has been no increase in the market value , the special assessment is unsuppo.rted and r�ay not be collected. That test was set forth by ttie Minnesota Court in 1�77 when it stated: The test is whether the improvement for which the assessment was levied has increased the market value of ttie property , against which the assessment operates , in �it least t}ie amount of the assessment . Continental Sales & Equipment Co. v . Town of Stuntz , 257 N. W. 2d 546 , 549 (Minn. 1977) . It has been suggested ttiat such a difference in market value "stiould bc� computed by determining what a willing buyer would pay a willing seller for trie property before � and then after , the improvement has been constructed . Carlson-Lang Realty Co. v . City of Windom , Minn . , 307 Minn. 3G8 , 369, 240 N.W .2d 517 , 519 ( 1�37G) . " Nyquist v . Town of Center , Crow Wing County , 251 N.W. 2d G95 , G�7 (Minn. 1977) . In Nyquist , the Court reversed and remanded the case for a new trial because tt�e town board and trial court failed to base the special -2- assessment on a showing of a change in market value resulting from the improvement. It is , of course, true that the present use of the land is not dispositive. Market value may be calculated on the highest and best use of the land . Anderson v. City of Bemidji , 295 N.W . 2d 555 (Minn . 1980) . Stated differently , "the test is whether the land could be used for purposes which would benefit from the improvement . " Village of Edina v. Joseph , 264 Minn. 84, 95 , 119 N.W.2d 809, 817 (1�62) , as cited in Southview � Country Club v. City of Inver Grove Heights , Dakota County , 263 N.W. 2d 385� 388 (Minn. 1918) . Consequently , if the church property in the instant case is presently dedicated to its highest and best use and no benefit to the land from the improvement can be demonstrated by way of increased market value , the special assessment will not survive constitutional scrutiny. CONCLUSION The limitations on special assessments are as follows : (a) The land must receive a special benefit from the improvement being constructed, (b) the assessment must be uniform upon the same class of property , and (c) the assessment may not exceed t}le special benefit . *** Any special assessment which does not meet tYiese requirements is an unconstitutional taking without compensation . (Citations omitted) . Southview Country Club v . City of Inver Grove Heights , Dakota County , 263 N.W.2d 385, 387-388 (Minn. 1978) . If it is -3- demonstrated that the existance of a distant enclosed park area in no way enhances the value o� the church property upon which the special assessment is being levied, the assessment will necessarily fail . -4- \ � _ 1 _1_ �� / . WILLIAM J. DUNN �ea�to� an� � �' � �P �; � 4 p�nrai�er � REALTOR A P AI SALES - APPRAISALB RESIDENTIAI - CpMMERCIAL - iNDL1STRI/�L 624 COMMERCE BUILDINQ ST. PAUL� MINNE50TA 55101 ZZ2-2789 September 14, 1981 Mr. Timothy P. 4uinn Attorney at Law 430 Minnesota Building St. Paul, Minnesota 55101 Re: "Town Square Assessments" on following properties : The Catholic Youth Center 150 North Smith Avenue, St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 The Church of The Assumption 51 West Ninth Street, St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 The Church of St. Louis 506 Cedar Street, St. Paul, Minnesota 55101 The Church of St. Mary 261 East Eighth Street, St. Paul, Minnesota 55101 St. Joseph' s Hospital 69 West Exchange Street, St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Dear Mr . Quinn : Pursuant to your request, I wish to advise that I have made an in- spection of the above parcels of real estate and herewith render you the following appraisal . PURPOSE AND DATE OF THIS APPRAISAL The purpose of this appraisal is to estimate the fair market value of the above parcels of real estate as of July 14, 1981 before and after the construction, operation and maintenance of "Town Square" , and "Town Square Park" . MARKET VALUE DEFINED Market value is defined as being the value in terms of money which a willing buyer will pay and a willing seller will accept after a ��XHIBIT T3�� P, 2 - Mr . Timothy P. 4uinn MA RKET VA LUE DEFINED (Cont'd) parcel of real estate has been exposed for sale a reasonable length of time with neither party acting under duress and both parties having full knowledge of all the uses to which the property may be put. RIGHTS TO BE APPRAISED: I am appraising the title in fee simple to the above captioned par- cels of real estate, free and clear of all incumbrances, except the usual easements for utilities. ADDRESSES OF SUBJ�CT PROPERTIES : 150 North Smith Avenue, St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 • 51 West Ninth Street, St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 506 Cedar Street, St. Paul, Minnesota 55101 261 East Eighth Street, St. Paul, Minnesota 55101 69 West Exchange Street, St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 ASSESSMENTS LEVIED AGAINST ABOVE FIVE PARCELS : St. Joseph' s Hospital: I ,D. No. 04-14000-020-03 04-14000-092-03 04-14000-132-03 04-14000-152-03 I .D. No. 04-38000-010-58 04-38000-011-58 I .D. No . 04-64000-081-00 � 04-38010-010-66 04-14000-020-04 Total assessment for above parcels - $1,487 ,24 Church of St . Louis : I .D. No. 04-66000-030-12 04-66000-050-12 Total assessment for above parcels - $1, 473 .46 � � �7�,��'! , - P. 3 - Mr. Timothy P. Quinn � ASSESSMENTS LEVIED AGAINST ABOVE FIVE PARCELS: (Cont 'd) Assumption Church: I .D, No. 04-63500-015-03 04-14000-060-09 Total assessment for above parcels - $1, 527. 16 Catholic Youth Center : I .D, No. 04-73500-070-55 - $ 76. 99 St� Marv' s Church • I .D. No. 03-34000-041-02 03-34000-041-11 Tota1 assessment for above parcels - $ 254 . 92 Total of above assessments - - - - - $4, 819. 77 PRESENT USE OF SUBJECT PROPERTIES : At the present time and for the past many years, the above parcels of real estate have been put to church and charitable use . HIGHEST AND BEST USE OF SUBJECT PROPERTIES : I am of the opinion that the highest and best use of subject proper_ties is the use to which said properties have been put for the past many years . BENEFITS TO THE ABOVE PA RCELS OF REAL ESTATE THROUGH THE CONSTRUCTION, OPERATION AND MAINTENANCE OF "TOWN SQUARE" AND "TOWN S�( UARE PARK" : Your appraiser is of the opinion that the market value of the above parcels has not and will not be increased as a result of the con- struction, operation and maintenance of "Town Square" and "Town Square Park" and that the above parcels of real estate have not � and will• not receive any benefits through the construction, opera- tion and maintenance of "Town Square" and "Town Square Park" . This appraisal report is preliminary in nature, and a complete de- tailed appraisal report wi11 be rendered in said matter at the time formal testimony is required, but from a study made of said parcels P. 4 - Mr . Timothy P. Quinn BENEFITS TO THE ABOVE PARCELS OF REAL ESTATE THROUGH THE CONSTRUCTION, OPERATION AND MAINTENANCE OF "TOWN SQUARE" AND "TOWN S4UARE PARK" : (Cont '� of real estate and their highest and best use , your appraiser, as stated above, is of the opinion that the above five parcels of real estate have not and will not receive any benefits by the construc- tion, operation and maintenance of "Town Square" and "Town Square Park" . Respectfully submitted, G-;�'""r�'��s-►�.i"��. L William J. Durin, A .S,A , WJD/vo i.. This Appraisal is cx:..de subject to the following limiting conditions: 1. The legal description furnished me is assumed to be correct. 2. I assume no responsibility for matters legal in character nor do I render any opInion as to the title which is assuined to be marketable. Liens and encumbrances, if any, have been disregarded and the property has been zppraised as though free and cleaz and under re- sponsible o�rnership and competent management. 3. If sketches of Qoor plans or plots are includect in this report, they are to be considered only as being approximate and submitted to assist the reader in visualizing the property. I have made no survey of the property and assume no responsibility in connection with such matters. 4. The information in tliis report identified as being furnished to me by others is believed by me to 6e reliable, but I assume no responsibility for its accuracy. 6. Possession of this report or a copy thereof does not carry ��ith it the right for publication, nor may it be used for any purpose by anyone but the applicant without the previous writ- ten consent of the appraiser or the applican t and in any event only with proper qualification. 6. I am not required to give testimony or attendance in court by reason of this appraisal with reference to its subject property, unless arrangements have previously been made therefor. 7. I have no present or contemplated interest in the property appra.ised. 8. The distribution of the total valuation in this report between land and improvements applies only under the existing program of utilization. The separate valuations for land and building must not be used in conjunction `vith any other appraisa.l and are invalid if so used. WILLIAM J. DUNN , A. S.A. ftealtor - - • Appraiser • � � �� QUALIFICATIONS OF 1A/ILLIAM J. DUNN 624 COMMERCE BUILDING,ST.PAUL,MINNESOTA 55101 AS AN APPRAISER OF REAL ESTATE A.Member. St. Paul Area Board of Realtors, Inc. Minnesota Association of Realtors National Association of Realtors Tri-State Chapter 20 of American Right-of•Way Association National Association of American Right•of-Way Association Senior Member American Society of Appraisers-Twin Cities Chapter Senior Member American Society of Appraisers-National Association B.Real Estate Appraisai made for lollowing: City of St. Paul Villages in Ramsey County County of Ramsey � State of Minnesota Department of Highways Department of Administration Referee in Bankruptcy at St. Paul Probate Court of Ramsey County Districl Court of Ramsey County Northwestern State Bank of St. Paul Northwestern National Bank of St. Paul Economic Laboratory, Inc. Housing and Redevelopment Authority of Saint Paul Miller Hospital Credit Union Northern States Power Co. Owners Attorneys Agents C.Experience: Engaged in the general real estate business since 1928, including buyinQ, selling, appraising, managing and leasing reai estate for others. Engaged In the buying and selling ot real estate tor myself since 1928. Appraising real estate throughout various counties in Minnesota, including Ramsey, Hennepin, Scott, Dakota and Washington Counties since 1928 for owners, agents, attorneys, courts, banks and various governmental agencies. Have been appointed a commissioner by the District Court of Ramsey County in many condemnation proceedings during past several years. Have testi(ied as an experl on real estate values in courts and before commissions in a number ot counties in Minnesota during past several years. " o? �� _.�� " MEIER, KENNEDY, QUINN & SHUMAKER AfIUfI1P{'.S pl �.ON' WILLIAM G. MEIER It920-�eB�� Se tember 29 � SUITE 430. MINNESOTA BUILDING ALO15 D. KENNEDY. JR. P i 9 8� TIMOTHV P. OUINN SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA SS101 GORDON W. SHUMAKER 16121 226-8846 ANDREW J. EISEN2IMMER LEO M. DEMIER THOMAS B. WIESER The Honorable Members of the St. Paul City Council City Hall and Courthouse St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Re: Town Square "Assessments" (Catholic Church Properties) Dear Members of the St . Paul City Council: As you know, I appeared at the St. Paul City Council Hearinq on September 22 , 1981 and also presented a written obiection to the assessment of the various Catholic church properties. From comments and observations made by various members of the City Council at that hearing on September 22 , 1981 , it appeared that there was significant support on the Council for striking the church properties from the assessment roll, because it had become evident that there was, in fact , no economic benefit (the leqal test) to these properties as a result of the proposed " improve- ment" (maintenance expense for Town Square Park) . If that is the prevailing view on the Council , and the new as- sessment roll to be considered on October 1 , 1981 still has the church properties listed, I strongly urge the members of the City CounciL- to adopt a specific resolution making a finding that it has been demonstrated that these specific church properties do not, and will not , benefit from the proposed improvement and that, therefore, it is RESOLVED that the proposed assessment roll be amended by striking those specific properties from the assessment roll, prior to the motion to adopt the assessment roll, as amended. Thank you very much for your consideration of this proposal . Yours very truly, MEIER, KENNEDY, QUINN & SHUMAKER ��`"'�-� "� �--- ------ Timoth P. Quinn� TPQ:sh cc: The Archdiocese of St . Paul & Mi neapolis The Church of The Assumption The Church of St . Louis The Church of St. Mary St . Joseph ' s Hospital EXHIBIT "II" � . , , ,. , , , , , : _ ,. : : l , . . � , , : ,. { , _ . , � ,., ., . _ . . . � ; , . � . ,� �. �, . � " � .. �;�; . ' . . }. ,� . . _ ' i, tk a�;i 1 , � � . ' .. � � . , . r� . ��4 I . � � r y � �k 1 \ � ! �i��. � � � � ( I . • � • �� ( r �,: , ,. • e � y'° ° I � ` �, ., � �� _ : �. ... '.. . . � �� , .. . � '�.1, ,�, �� r � . . . - , y . . . - , . , . � �,�?:3 r � � ' . .. � , ... . . , . . . � .. . #' �q _ . . , � ..I `. . . - � . , ... . . . \ � _ ` �. �� ,. � . . � . . . . ' . _ . , . ' . . . . . . � ., ' r k'� `y r _ . : ' � , .. . . . � . ` . . .' I , 1� . � � . . � . . . � . . . . , . .. ' . .. . � . . . . . . . . . . i� � �., � . � � . . - ' .. � ' . - � . . t ; � . �� l� . �»� \ 1 ��r . ' , _ . " . .� ' .i ' l�l'•�1� ��*it`i' . . ' , ; t / , , ; �i�� w't►�0�3/ I '� � � 64Ts'Gi�y �u ; . ' � #� ,,. I�r 8ir; , • "? ; � � � � � - " . A'�t,a+�►tpfl lc�r°y�c>uu� itsstb�atib� is a acgy' ci2' '�b1�lt .�t�l �r!``�M ° , , , : "- � ,��ll�lMi_N�Y�� Y� � �� C� ��lT,� � � � , l �. - . �� .. f :., � ' �ea�Dti +�td ��zw'it� �hat`�ss i'ox' 4�,,$±� �i :1"'at3�'`�1 ,,� [' � ' " bp C.l�. �?7�95. , � , � ' � � , , ., . . - ; _ ; �'Y tY"+�],Y �pt��r. > : : .': . , : ,, ; . . � — � . � , ; _ �,x" � i . ��y �y +�}� .' ' .. . ',� v -'�_. . ' . � . . .. 1 . #FiVir��+L�ii 'Qi�� . ` . i �.. S,s. , . � _ � � ,� ' � � � � � ��r",��iy'`�(�.!!k� � � � ' , ';a # . . - }: . f � , � - , , .. .. . . . . .. . . � . . _. `9, A�treth. _ . ' :�' . , . , } _ 7: { . ,l►�OtL�► ` � � . _ - . \ _ , �: { ! ' ' ' ';t , ` �� Sltia'�3tHi li�ig�' ' � � � . . , ' � . _ , ' .,� , , y _ � ,; . ., , , ' . . �{ ; ., . .. ,. . ,: , - , , _ , r i , , , � � �, _ - � : ; , � , ' : � , „ , , . � , �5 � , . ,. . . � ., . . ._ . . .. ,_ . . . . � ,_ . . .r� . , . . . ., . . - .�� . �� . : . . � . . . . �,:: , . �. ,.: .Y, . .. '�� :�� `.�. ��,�. ., . .... , . . ... , .. . ; . . . .." . . �-� � �..:i .:i . . .,. . . _ .. , . - � . . ., � . . _ . . .. . . . . . � � ,. . � . .. . .' � . . . . • �,,. . � . .� . .. ,. .. . . . � . � . . . . . . . . _ . � . .. - � ., � . . . 1 . �! �., � �i .i �; � t � �'.c}�T'�'?4 +�" r; � .� S` � ;�i }` � �'' ! - j �,'Jay� I. �� '� s� J ..-;-a{� � -� � �- � Y�.� .�� rt��:' �� -��F � ' 1"�� N � �+yy,�, � ..!t4 - '4 - *x� �.. : s 4� ,�, t� �3z r� . .r'� 1.: a�; ty.� + . 3� 1 , ' �J ti�� '. { k �i,+��t -1+t �'� � &.x '.�'!S'7'a :. eq� � lt �'� n.1` ri� � -� �. � ^ � � . ". t �� t�• vY� r� # �, �� ''� . /��+ ( �_ '' � ,' f , ?r i i�E �'�`G' �'` `t ��"1� �' '_,� � �. # fi ' . �� ',� ' ;'t. ry- d '�P '� 1 :�: J -� ,'�-.. r .4 } v �4,t � � ' � �� r rl� "i. \ � y . � ;� `f ;i` -:�� ' `4� r. 'i ` R� .� `�x �'r , y t �� t + d rc r � � �! r° h� � � �t �A�.' � � rrt ';i 'l� _. .. � � ..� ��(�l k` i .l��S � t '� . i. � c� �3 1^ �} r - -�� 1�� , i � �".� ' : a --f Y'�'�� / - '.�� } 1 � �'` r ,..t l. t a::", , �� '�. a� � - '}� /�. ,+e r �� - �``�� ' � rF: � rtY� k k" �.`�e� � � �. � r � , � U �::r .' . . . .; �..: .. ,� . ��j � .1� . . . .� - .. � + �;� ��bf �w .� ' 'l. . � c � , . , � � �� ' � � � . � .. , � . � . . ' . . , � . . . - �: . , - � i .,+ s ; :/`� ��;' � . . � :8.' _ . , ' . . . . . . . \� Ir r�;.- �;t 4 ' . . . ' I . . . • .. � � . . . �_� . . i . ... _ � . .. � . .. 't. � � �.^ ��i � ' ' j' ' � . . , � , �.:�. � - .. � '/. � r . ' ,� ` ,. . ': . � . �. i . d , � �� . . . ' . �� ° .�'��° ,�� ' ` t �. � '� t3 � ' !4 .1 , '� . i. / � , � _ . :`I � ` j � , � .- .k .' ' • . ' ' ' ,•._ � ' . . y, . X. �'. . �' . � ,� . - . �. �,� , . :, . . , . . .. .. ., � � i 1 �� _ t, . , ' . < ,� z .• � ��.� . . ... _ r � , � i x. F:' i4 1^ , . .. . . . . r. ,. . . . . . � % . Fi�r . -1 _ , : ,. � ' . �_ . - . . . � " � � � . ' . ! , t .' ';. . -.... � �' � . � . . . , , � . 3y! °r�, y,�.� . ,, �..� . ".. . � „ . � ' ' .� . .. � . . . , ' ' G'� � � ��+ , � � , . � , � - ,. � , i � i ,� ,' ,,.: ' �, ,,. , , " � � , r'' ��pi `�ir �.��. - . I .. � � � � ' � � � .� . . ' . �- � � .. . �� , .4: � ,.,: : . '•� .. ' .. , i . : �.,' . .. . ' - _ . . ' . .) . . . .. . . . � ' . �1' �� C . � - ; � ��'��, �,: � ; °,_-- � - �� . � �. - - , , , r _ . . , . . ; . � , { .; . �. . , __ , i , . . . :. F � . . _, _ ,,,. _ , . '- .., ,;.. ', ,.� , _ �.f� �.. ; , : , .: . ; e , -:�. ��. ; , . .� ,. �.;, ':'� �_ : ., ,: ; _ � t , . ; . . .� i . . `I h' . '�. � ' r� � -:, '. ��.. �� ' �y E ' r' � ,, .�. � . , , , : , _ F � x ,� , . . .,: , � . , ,. F., .; " :, � . , _ , : . . , , . , . � _ . . � , ,. � � . .� ,- �; � � . � .1�� . - � �:.: . ` _ , � Yr: � " . � . t ' , > _ a ..,:� . . .. � .. . ,.: . , ..i. . . . . . . . . . . �� , , � .. . .. . �. . .�. . .. i. �. � . . .� .. - . �. . - � . . . .. _ ' .. , . 1 . .x ��,'� � � � � . . . ' . . . . . . . - . . ' ' . �. .. : . . . . .. � ' �,. � . . .. - � � � � � � . .. . . .. � . , � � �,�...... �� . � ��.. - . _.. - � � . . �. . .. ,� : ,. . .- . - .`� . ` .. . � � . . . , .:. . .. �✓-+ .. . -. . , , ..� . - , -. . ,.;�. . ,��. .,. . � • . . . , . �... ��' ' , i . . �. . ' . .,. .. . , .,.. -. . .. . � . . � � . ti . . � . . . . . , _ � , �. . � , . . ,. ; �:li . - � . � ' . ' .. � � � . . . t�.< _ . � . . .. . .. � . . . . �. . .. � � , . , . 4�� J - r. . , , . . . ... . : . . . . , � ' � �� F . . . x �� ' . . ._' . . . . . ' - .. � . ' , � � . . _ _ � , . . :. � '.,_. � i. ,. ; : . �. � .. . . '. ... . �� .. ... , . , . . . .� • ,. ,. � . � . . � . E.��1�� .. _ � .. . . . ' . � . - , � . .. . . - .. . . .� . . . - , , �R � � � . � � X. "�f s' . , ` �f . ,:' ! . ` � �. � -^� i - , � . . i - - � r . � . .. ,� , . . . �M 1 u� . ' . . 1 .. . .' . , i- . . , . . I � . ` . f �. . .._ . �f � � � . .. . . . . . � . . .. _ . ^ :•. . :.. � . , .� .. .. . . �: � � ... ; .� � . �.. � ..� . � . .. � � ... , � . 1 y , . '�� ,. j r ;is' ,i � . . � %Y. . .. . ^..� .,- , . . . . . . . ... � t. 1., � . \ . .. . - . . . . . .� . .� .� . . _ . � , . . ' . . , . ,. ` , � . y.i:.. . � j � . � / � - � - . .. ; . . - � .. -�. . � . . . ._ � . , . � . . . ..� . i � � 1 1 � ., , , � ;: ' , _ . - - , < � ; '' i .:� , ; . , , �_ • � , . ; , . - � : , ,, � _ - _ . , . , , . - , _.. � ' . � • . N f i . . . � . , - - � A � . . ; - . . - i . ,t� � . � . . � - , . . . r �. . F ., I . :,. , '. . �� , ;-�,' ` _ .� ..�. '� : . :.��... , - � . .. , ' . . . ' d. 1'� �� .1 . . . . . . .. . . .. . • � . . '` � . T ' r:. . � �., � . . . . . . � . � „ ,� . � ,. . , . . . . . 4� . .., . , , �.�. . . .. . . . .. . � . - � � .. . � . � . � . . . . . . . . , . . '.. . . .. .. . _.. _ � . . � ` �\ �� d� �� . , � ,� y�,t,o, . 04 �� CITY OF SAINT PAUL OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY � iiii�ii�n o . „ EDWARD P. STARR, CITY ATTORNEY �.a• 647 City Hall,Saint Paui, Minnesota 55102 612-298-5121 GEORGE LATIMER � MAYOR HAND DELIVERED October 20, 1981 c� � � c,�-` � _.t�, � Mr. Albert B. Olson �a '"'� n+ City Clerk :u, � ° City of Saint Paul ?o � Room 386, City Hall y� � St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 � � `.�'i" Re: Notice of Appeal from Special Assessments and 5ervice Charges Dear Mr. Olson: Enclosed herewith for filing pursuant to Chapter 14 of the Saint Paul City Charter please find the Notice of Appeal from Special Assessments and Service Charges regarding special assessments and service charges levied against property of the Public Housing Agency of the City of Saint Paul for the annual operation and maintenance of "Town Square" . 5aid special assessments and service charges were ratified by the City Council on October 1, 1981. As further required by Chapter 14 of the Saint Paul City Charter, I am requesting that you provide me with a copy of the Assessment Roll, certified to by the proper city officers, so that I may file it with the District Court. Sincerely yours, �� .:��.� CHERYL P. COUGHLAN Attorney for the Public Housing Agency of the City of Saint Paul CPC:rl Enc. . J • fiLfO � ,�.�� • • � OcT �� 1 5v PM �i a . _ ClTY CL�RK'S OFFICE 5T rAUL= �1{NN. STATE OF MINNESOTA DISTRICT COURT COUNTY OF RAMSEY SECOND JUDICIAL DISTRICT — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — In Re the Matter of Special Assessments and Service Charges for the Annual Operation and Maintenance of "Town NOTICE OF APPEAL FROM Square" Public Spaces for 1981-82 SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS levied against the Public Housing AND SERVICE CHARGES Agency of the City of Saint Paul — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — TO: ALBERT B. OLSON, City Clerk, City of Saint Paul JOSEPH GOCKOWSKI, Clerk of District Court The Public Housing Agency of the City of Saint Paul, owner of the parcels of real estate described in Exhibit A attached hereto by virtue of Chapter 228 of Laws of Minnesota 1977, hereby appeals those special assessments and service charges levied by the City of Saint Paul against said parcels for the annual oper- ation and maintenance of "Town Square" public spaces for 1981-82. Said special assessments and service charges were ratified by the City Council of the City of Saint Paul on October 1, 1981 (Council File No. 277495) . This notice of appeal is given in accordance with and pursu- ant to the provisions of Chapter 429, Minnesota 5tatutes; Chapters 13 and 14 of the Saint Paul City Charter; and Chapter 62 of the Saint Paul Administrative Code. The grounds upon which this appeal is taken are as follows : 1. The Public Housing Agency of the City of Saint Paul is exempt from the levy of all taxes and special assessments of a city, county, state or any political subdivision thereof pursuant to Minn. Stat. �462.575. 2. The amounts assessed against the property identified in the attached Exhibit A exceed the benefits to the property resulting from the improvement financed by said assessments, the actual benefits to said property being none. � � , _ , �n� � �.� • . ' � ' Frc�o .�. . OCT �O � �� a� Exhibit A CITY GIERK'S 0��10E S't At{UL� MINN. Parcel 04-14000-110-02 (545 North Wabasha) Lot 12 and that part of Lot 11 Northeasterly of the following described line beginning on the Northwesterly line of said Lot 74 50/100 feet from the Southwesterly line of Wabasha Street thence Southeasterly parallel to said street l00 feet; thence Northeasterly parallel to lOth Street 9 50/100 feet; thence Southeasterly para11e1 to Wabasha Street 25 feet 3 1/2 inches; thence Northeasterly parallel to lOth Street 5 feet; thence Southeasterly to point on lOth Street 60 feet Southwesterly of Wabasha Street in Block 2, Bazil and Guerin's Addition. Parcel 04-14000-032-08 (10 West Exchange) Northwesterly 5/6 of Lots 1 and 2 and Northwesterly 2/3 of Lots 3, Block 8, Bazil and Guerins Addition. These parcels may be otherwise described as follows: Parcel 04-14000-110-02 (545 North Wabasha) That part of Lots ll and 12, in Block 2, Bazil & Guerins Addition to St. Paul, Ramsey County, Minnesota according to the original plat thereof on file and of record in the office of Register of Deeds in and for said Ramsey County, Minnesota described as follows: Beginning at the Southeasterly Corner of said Lot 12 in Block 2, thence north- erly along the Easterly line of said Lot 12 (being a westerly line of Wabasha Street in the City of St. Paul) , a distance of 149. 82 feet to a point; thence westerly and parallel to the southerly line of S��id Lots 11 and 12 (being the same a northerly line of Tenth Street) , a distance of 74.5 ft. to a point; thence southerly and parallel with the easterly line of said Lot 12, (being the westerly line of Wabasha Street) , a distance of 99.74 ft. to a point; thence easterly and parallel with southerly line of said Lots 11 and 12, a distance of 9.5 ft. to a point; thence southerly and parallel with the said easterly line of said Lot 12 a distance of 25.29 ft. to a point; thence easterly and parallel with the southerly line of Lots 11 and 12 aforesaid; a distance of 6.16 ft. to a point; thence southerly and parallel with the said easterly line of said Lot 12, to the southerly line of sai�. Lot 11, thence easterly along said southerly line of Lots 11 and 12 to the place of beginning. Parcel 04-�.4000-110-08 (10 West Exchange) The N 1/6 of Lots 1 and 2, Block 8, Bazille and Guerin's Addition, Ramsey County, Minn. , according to the recorded plat thereof; also the Northerly 2/3 of Lot 3, Block 8, Bazille and Guerin's Addition to St. Paul, according to the recorded plat thereof; also the South 25 feet of the North 75 feet of Lots 1 and 2, Block 8, Bazille and Guerin' s Addition to St. Paul, according to the recorded plat thereof; also the South 25 feet of the North 50 feet of Lots 1 and 2, Block 8, Bazille and Guerin's Addition to St. Paul according to the recorded plat thereof; also the Northerly 2/3 of the Southerly � of Lots 1 and 2, both in Block 8, Bazille and Guerin' s Addition to St. Paul, all according to the plat thereof on file and of record in the Office of the Register of Deeds in and for Ramsey County, Minnesota. � � _ � . - -2- 3. The assessments are made upon mistakes of fact and law. 4 . The assessments constitute an uncons�itut�onal taking without compensation. Dated: October 20, 1981. _ L�!"GG2v CHERYL P. COUG AN Attorney for the Public Housing Agency of the City of Saint Paul 647 City Hall Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 , � � . � � -�J� C �-'� �? �f `� STATE OF MINNESOTA DISTRICT COURT C`f1iI�TTTY !1�' i2DMCFY C�r�r�rin .Tru�rnTaz nremnznm _ ' . � ` , � � i � � � �� . : . • . . � . � . . . • - . r . . � . . . . . , � . . � I . . .,' . . . " . . ' . . , October 27, 1981 � • , _ _ Mr. Bd 3tarx . City Attorney' � Room b47, Citiy 8su ' - � �'' ' Dssr sirs . , Attachad for your iafornstion is a copy,of an apyeal of . . , (�ioera Tluatre Comp�qy, Inc. to tha special taaessments and service chsrg�$ for Town Sqw►re as rstit'led by C.F. 27'T�+9S. � , s vsry truly yours, , , � Alber��t�. Olsoa • Ci�ty Cl.erk � Attacb. , ; • . ABO s].a . , • cc: Yaliastion �gin�er � , � � ,:, - , , „' , , . ,; .i . . ' ��- � � 2. Appellant further appeals on the ground that because the assessments and service charges are -in the nature of a property tax, such assessments and charges were illegally and improperly imposed on property owned by Appel2ant when Appellant' s ownership and use of such property has already been determined to be exempt from property taxation. 3. Appellant has previously objected to Respondent in writing to the assessments and service charges , in a letter to Respondent, a copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit � A. WHEREFORE, Appellant prays that the Court make its Order and Decree declaring said assessments and service charges void and invalid, and for such other relief as may be deemed equitable and just and as may be provided by law. DOHERTY, RUMBLE & BUTLER PROFESSIONAL ASSOCIATION � . . By .C��!'l illiam J Co B ��CiALe�� . Y Lucinda Hruska-Claeys Attorneys for Appellant E-1500 First National Bank Building Saint Paul, Minnesota 55101 Telephone : (612.) 291-9333 Dated: (.eG�Z�""`�v � , 1981 2. � , "`� � ^ ` EXHIBIT A . - '� , MINNES01'A PUBLIC RADIO 45 EAST EIGHTH STREET, ST. PAUL, MIN:�'ESOTA SS101 612 Z21-1500 � October 21, 1981 � • ' � Mr Albert Olson ' •. City Clerk City of Saint Paul � � Room 386 City Hall � Saint Paul MN 55102 � NOTICE OF APPEAL FROM SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS AND SERVICE CHARGES � � To Whom It May Concern: . Minnesota Public Radio Inc, owner of property located at 45 East Eighth Street in St Paul, hereby gives notice � -of its intent to appeal the "special assessments and service charges" made by the City of Saint Paul on October 1, 1981, for financing the operation -and maintenance of Towri . , Square Park. � ' We believe that this char e is not g properly an assessment or service charge, and actually represents a property tax. � � Such a tax cannot be imposed solely on selected pieces of property within the taxing district. Indeed, such . a tax cannot be imposed upon property owned and used by . a nonprofit corporation, when the ownership and use has already been determined to be exempt from property taxation. Even if this charge were properly an assessment, we believe , � .� that there is no particular benefit, as a result of the improvements ma3e by this charge, which causes the value of the real estate being assessed to increase. We are prepared to file our Notice of Appeal to the Clerk of District Court within ten days of this letter. Sincerely, , �� r � � c� J � � I � . Thomas J Kigin • Vice President and General Counsel . Minnesota Public Radio he .... ,,,,.,<<.. ... . .. . .. .. . ......... . .. .. „ . ... . ........,.. . .. . . .. ........_. - --. .. ..- ---- - -- --- - - �'��yi�� i�.��d"`d'� �+'4y�,�.'w9R'� �� ` .� i.r��R ��'�,I�� ,: y��A� �K�G�ry�T� � F � `,. . .�. ,�,(.l9,� `.fT.-71.., v .. ' �• � a [4 ... �r` f.t.�:, .K� ..�' > t `'K'$C 4 9r�t r,a.�y `{ 's1 C 1 4.�! . ._ .. , . ♦1.iiR'a,. `.f✓ ... .... rLL. .. , .. .:�`sd� . JYIy�:� . .. . . . . v '{ n.. av r / �% y.�G-',11i � . .. ,.. ..5� .�."Y1 X'. ..i:.9.r' ��".'. 2. That the assess�ents au�� ►de upon deen�wn,�trable m#.e�ake�s o� law and �act. , 3. That the ass�aemant i�t iz� the exc.�s� of tha actuml benefit to ths grope�cty b�ctause ��e benetit is xero.. � 4. Tha �saessment constitut�s an tinoonatitutional taking ' �ithout comnensa��ion. „ � ' S. That tha mpecial aas0esme�nt ie in violat�.on oP Chapter 429, Minne�ota Stat�t�a � that the aeseaaaaent 3s for � opera�imq eos�� ra�her tt�,an a aapital imps4v�ement. ; 6. That the assesa�nt �$ i� :viqlation o� Article 1 of the ; ;; Unit�d State� Cona�itutic�. 4 = 7. 'The a�$esement i� in vio�,mtion of Article X, Section � � 1, ot the ConBtitution o�, the 3tate of Mir�neeota. � � � 8. The a��e�sm�nt is in vio]�mticn a� A�tic3.e I, 6ection � �; 16, oP the Constitution Qf th� State of Minne�ota. � �: :� � � � WktEREFORE, Appellants pray that the Court set aside said ' as�essrnent against the above prop�rty vr c3etermine that there s is no e�anomic benefit to said property as a reault ef sai.d � � "improvsment" and order that aald prope�ty not be s�seseed � � � in any aunount for �aid "improvem+ant". i ,: � Da�ed: October 30, 1981 ;� Davi G. Jo nson ' � Attorney �or Appellant � 247Z E. 7th Avenue � � �� North St. Paul, MN 55109 " .�4l�W,+: (612) 777-2407 �. � l;, � � � T �N� r�zr� �%� :'l ��. ,�, . � r� ��°t Y .1�,,:..' � p, M �1 ��+� - 3 - � � � � �i J . . . ... . . . Finc�nce k ile Na. ].f3I13-F31 ASSI;�SMI:h'T RQLL i;�: 1r�e costs of cperuting anc3 ma�.ntai.nin�; the "T(�;ar1 SQUARI:" public spaces Cor a pericc3 from Ju1y 1 , 19�31. t.o J`l.le 30, 1S'u2. AMf)ITNT ? 5-�; '�t�c I'irst I3:�pt:�,t Ctiu�ch and Con�;re�;r�tion of St. T'aul C13..75000-OHO--O�J $115.<<�3 Nort?�ea�tezl.y ? fe�t af Lat 7 r�ctd exce{�t Sauthe�sterly � � � 1��0 feeC of Soutt��aesCerly 30 fer_t: of Lot 8, Iiorace Tlrr�:rtp�oz�is ;;ubd�.vzsfon ot T3locic �r of IIuyC'> naai�xon. T��e assessment �f benefi_ts , cost> �and ex�en�es 1�r�ve 1>c>en filec3 �n Cl,� U�fice oE r_hc lle��>artment o� rinan�� f�nd P'la�t�f;c>rr;ent Serv9.ce�. C�J�.tl�i.n �r�enry �lc�y3 aft_er r.l�e ox-�ier �da�cinf; t�.hc� �:ar��-�„ment, or � � R:`'-11C�[1(� � Y('_tlEiGC:3GIl1�L411t � CI fLCW t7:i:l('.F:�If1�lll:a OT' .3U�"7��.f'1llGI"ILtI� Q^u3f'S3° r�enr., nr�y per,c:�n may ry��cal tc� �lie 1)3�trict (;ourC I>y fi) i.n�; {a noCi.r.e oF apper�l cait;h kl�e (;icy (;l.crlc �at:atin�; t}ir� �round:� upcan c��hich the ct��c�aA i.; kal�tan. Suel�i no��.ce ,1�a11 be fil.�ci 4iith the � C1exlc o� 1)�`�triet Court wit}�in ten ciays r�fter tl�e tilin�; cli_ttt ei�e f;ity (;?erlr. � t- ��, ,� � �' , .. ,�J.�� ( � �` �yi..ia�� w�i�J a J . ��, �"� �� d��- d� � � t �,, a�-�� ;' ,, �: