The URL can be used to link to this page

277481 WNITE - CITY CLERK `((('''�� PINK - FINANCE TT ��: �� CANAR'j - DEPARTMENT G I T Y O F S A I N T �A V L COUIICII BLUE : MAYOR File N O. � '' Resolution Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date BE IT RESOLVED, That the Council of the City of Saint Paul hereby certifies and approves the action of the City of Saint Paul Board of Appeals and Review pertaining to the following listed property and as shown by the Excerpted Minutes of said Board of Appeals and Review, dated September 8, 1981, and marked EXHIBIT A, and attached hereto and made a part hereof by reference: DATE OF BOARD MINUTES CASE NO. PROPERTY APPELI;ANT 9/8/81 47 -81-H 1488-92 W. Minnehaha Robert P. Kranz (seven units) BOARD ACTION: Granted variance of St. Paul Legislative Code, Section 34.11, to permit tenants of Apts. No. 4 and 7 to continue sharing use of one bathroom, subject to resolution of a zoning problem, on condition that no more than one person occupy each said unit, and that all remaining work orders listed in city' s letter of 7/8/81 be completed. Property Description: McCaskey ' s Rearrangement Lot 10, Block 1 ------------------------------- 9/8/81 50-81-H 2O10 Marshall Ave. S.R. Sturm (six units) BOARD ACTION: Granted variance of St. Paul Legislative Code, 5ection 34. 13, pertaining to sill height of basement sleep- ing room escape windo�as, if adherence to 48-inch code specification is impossible, on condition that a permanent step be installed under each said window to com ensate for the deficienc . COUNC[LMEIV Requestgd by Department oE: Yeas Nays Hunt Levine In Favo[ Maddox McMahon snowaite� - __ Against BY — Tedesco Wilson Form Approved by City Attorney Adopted by Council: Date — Certified }?assed by Council Secretary ""�� sy —_ Approved hy :Navor. Date _ Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council By� : _ _ $Y : WHITE - CITY CLERK ��j�� PINK � - FINANCE / l.f CANARY - DEPARTMENT G I TY O F SA I NT ��u L COUIICII BLUE •- MAYOR File N . 4 � Council Resolution Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date Property Description: Bryant's Park Addition No. 4 Lots 13 and 14, Block 1 -------------------------- 9/8/81 42-81-H 579 Summit Ave. Woodland Park (19 units) Associates By Scott 5eiberlich BOARD ACTION: Granted variance of 5t. Paul Legislative Code, Section 34. 13, to permit continued occupancy of two basement dwelling units where sill heights of sleeping room escape windows do not meet code requirements, on condition that a permanent step be installed beneath each said escape window to compensate for the deficiency. Property Description: Weed and Willius Rearrangement E. 2 of Lot 18 and all of Lot 19 and W. 11 Ft. of Lot 20, Block 23 -------------------------- and be it FURTHER RESOLVED, That upon passage of this resolution the City Clerk is hereby authorized and directed to transmit a copy of this resolution for recording to the Ramsey County Office of the Register of Deeds. -3- COUNCILMEN Yeas Nays Requestgd by Department of: Hunt Levine In Favor Maddox _/ McMahon f✓� B Showalter __ Against Y -- Tedesco Wilson Adopted by Council: Date SEP 2 4 �98� Form Approved by City Attorney Certified a.s y Council S tar B �� sy Approved vor: Date �EP 2 H �gBI Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council By `� BY _ PUBUSHEO 0 C T 3 1981 :, �� Granted variance of Section 34 . 11, to permit tenants of Apts. No. 5 and 6 to share use of one shower facility, on condition that no more than one person occupy each said apartment. Property Description: Merriam Park 5econd Addition Lot 6, Block 5 ------------------------------- 9/8/81 52-81-H 360-62 Fuller Ave. Oscar Valar (13 units) BOARD ACTION: Granted variance of St. Paul Legislative Code, Section 34. 11, to permit three third floor dwell- ing units to share use of one bathroom, on condi- tion that no more than one person occupy each said unit, on condition that all remaining work orders listed in city' s letter of 8/4/81 be complete, effective as long as the appellant, Oscar Valar, lives on the premises. Property Description: Elfelt Bernheimer and Arnold' s Addition Lot 4, Bl.ock 7 -------------------------------- 9/8/81 54-81-H 529 Bl.air Roy & Alta Wallenberg (three units) BOARD ACTION: Granted variance of St. Paul Legislative Code, Section 34.11, to permit continued occupancy of Apt. No. 3 where bathroom facility is located outside wall.s of said apartment, on condition that all remaining items in the city' s letter of 8/11/81 be completed. Property Description� Smith' s Subdivision of Block 3 Lot 8 , Block 3 --------------------------------- 9/8/81 55-81-H 180-186 S. Lexington Donnamae Koppelman (16 units) By Charles 5. Miller, Miller Management Co. , Inc. BOARD ACTION: Granted variance of �t. Paul Legislative Code, Section 34. 13, pertaining to sill height of escape windows in basement sleeping rooms, on condition that a permanent step be installed under each said window where sill height is more than 48 inches, to compensate for the deficiency. -2- �� 9-��i r 9/8/81 - Meeting No. 177 . ° � /1, Y /l!Jl� � .�� ,�. � , , , � .��. MINUTES OF THE MEETING ST. PAUL BOARD OF APPEALS $ REVIEW Tuesday, September 8 , 1981 Room 707 City Hall , 15 ti�'. Kellogg Blvd. ME�IBERS PRESENT: Ron Glassman, Chairman Harold D. Knutson Glenn Gausman � Rudolph Sawyer MED4BERS ABSENT: Lucille Burg William Tilton AGENCIES PRE SENT: Dept. of Community Services - Division of Housing Code Enforcement : Alice Bijjani OTHERS PRESENT : Vicki Hastings Robert P. Kranz S. R. Sturm Charles S. Miller -_-._- _ R.E. � ATta Wallenberg Richaxd Koppelman . Pierre Regnier Pam Jackson Sam Glassman Scott Seiberlich Oscar Valar STAFF PRESENT: Pat Moxness Josephine Palermo Chairman Glassman called the meeting to order at 1 :32 p.m. The minutes of the meeting of August 11 , 1981 , were approved as distrib- uted to the members . Chairman Glassman reported that the City Council has responded to his recent letter requesting the city' s help in easing citizens ' financial burdens when a break in sewer lines occurs on their proner�y and must be repaired. Frank Staffenson of the Housing Code Office has worked out a proposed plan where the city will contract for such repairs and bill the homeowner on his tax assessment, spreading payments out over a ten-year period. The matter is to be heard before the Public Works Committee in the near future. CASE N0. PROPERTY APPELLANT 47- 81-H 1488-92 Minnehaha jV, Robert P. Kranz (seven units) SUBJECT : Rec{uest variance of Section 34. 11 , to germit tenants of Apts . #4 and #7 to share use of ane bathroom facility, because of practical difficulty and cost of prouiding additional bathroom. -2- 9J8/81 - Meeting No. 177 . �;��1�� • ' ,l.,� . ' APPEARA�vCE : Robert P. Kranz PROCEEDINGS : Mr. Kranz explained that in one of the apartments there was a oor lea ing directly into the shared bathroom. The other apartment's tenant , who shared the bathroom, entered by way of a locked door in the common hallway. Mr. Kranz said it has always been his policy to rent these two units only to single persons and he intended to continue the policy. Alice Bijjani said there was a zoning problem that had nat yet been resolved as to the number of units that could legally be operated on the property. BOARD ACTION: DZr. Gausman moved that a variance of Section 34. 11 be granted, to permit tenants o£ Apts . #4 and #7 to continued sharing use of one bathroom facility, subject to �esolution of the zoning problem, on condition ±hat no more than one person occupy each unit, and that all remaining work orders listed in city' s letter of 7/8/81 be completed. Mr. Knutson seconded. MOTION CARRIED AND SO ORDERED. THE VOTE : Ayes - 4 Nays - 0 Abstentions - 0 - - --- - - - - -- -- -- -- -- -- -- - - -- - --- -- -- --- - -- -- -- - - ---- -- -- -- - - ----- - -- ---- - -- � -2- 9/8/81 - Meetin� No. 177 _ �.,�� - - --- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- ---- --- - - - -- - - -- ---- -- - --- --.--- SO- 81-H 2O10 Marshall Ave. S.R. Sturm (six units) SUBJECT : Request variance of Section 34. 11 , to permit shared bathing ac�ility (shower only) by Apts . #5 and #6 (each has toilet and handsink) , __.__ and variances of Sections 34. 13 and 34. 14 , to permit occupancy of ttao _ basemen� apartments where windows to not meet code specifications for escape windows in sleeping rooms and light and ventilation reQuirements , because of financial considerations . APPEARANCE : S. R. Sturm PROCEEDINGS : Mr. Sturm explained that Apts. #5 and #6 each h.ad private toilets and handsinks , but tenants of these two units shared use of a shower room located off the common hallway. In regard to escape windows and light and ventilation, he said it would be quite expensive to put in larger windows in the two basement apartments , and it would require con- struction of windowwells outside each of them. He then recalled thati there were unused openings on another wall of each unit, used as coal chutes in the original construction when there were no basement apartments , which might be used to place escape windows . Alice Bijjani said this appeared to be a good solution , that it would not only provide the needed escape windows , but would also add light and venti- lation. She suggested, however, that if for some reason the coal chute openings were not feasible, and if the existing window openings had to be used, it would be necessary to include a variance on sill height because of the difficulty of complying with the 48-inch specification. She proposed that a step under each escape window be provided no more than 48 inches from the sill height. Mr. Gausman asked about the fire separation of the boiler area from the dwelling units in the basement. Mr. Sturm said he proposed to install a sprinkler system above the boiler as an alternative to shee�rock, which would interfere with the boiler. , � -3- 9/8/81 - Meeting No. I77 � �,`�'�"`��.�1 .:. , Alice Bijjani said a sprinkler system was an acceptable alternative, but it �,rould be necessary to get permission from the city Water Dept. Chairman Glassman read a letter from Merriam Park Community Council , in which they requested the board to postpone the hearing on this case until after the September 14 meeting of their Housing Committee. Mr. Knutson said he personally did not feel the board should have to wait for a community organization to meet before hearing an appeal. If the community organization had a strong interest , they should call a special meeting prior to the date when an appeal was scheduled to be heard by the Board of Appeals. The other board members concurred. BOARD ACTION: Mr. Knutson moved to grant a variance of Section 34. 11 , to permit tenants of Apts . #5 and #6 to share use of one shower facility, on condition that no more than one person occupy each dwelling unit. Also, Mr. Knutson moved to deny a variance of Section 34. 13 , pertaining to escape windows in sleeping rooms , except that, if the required window is more than 48 inches from the floor, a variance be granted on the sill height, provided that a permanent step be installed under each escape window � to compensate for the discrepancy. Mr. Sawyer seconded. MOTION CARRIED AND SO ORDERED. THE VOTE: Ayes - 4 Nays - 0 Abstention - 0 -- - --- -- - - - -- -- - - - - -- ---- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- ---- -- -- ---- -- -- -- - - ---- -- 9/8/81 - Meeting No. 177 MINUTES OF THE MEETING ST. PAUL BOARD OF APPEALS $ REVIEW � Tuesday, September 8 , 1981 Room 707 City Ha11 , 15 �. Kellogg Blvd. MEbIBERS PRESE�v'T: Ron Glassman , Chairman Harold D. Knutson Glenn Gausman Rudolph Sawyer MEDiBERS ABSENT: Lucille Burg William Tilton � AGENCIES PRESENT : Dept. of Community Services - Division of Housing Code Enforcement : Alice Bijjani OTHERS PRESE�TT : Vicki Hastings Robert P. Kranz S. R. Sturm Charles S. Miller - - -- ----- R.E. � Alta Wallenberg Richard Koppelman Pierre Regnier Pam Jackson , Sam Glassman Scott Seiberlich Oscar Valar STAFF PRESENT : Pat Moxness Josephine Palermo Chairman Glassman called the meeting to order at 1 :32 p.m. � The minutes of the meeting of August 11 , 1981 , were approved as distrib- uted to the members. Chairman Glassman reported that the City Council has responded to his recent letter requesting the city' s help in easing citizens ' financial burdens when a break in sewer lines occurs on their property and must be. repaired. Frank Staffenson of the Housing Code Office has worked out a proposed plan �ti�here the city will contract for such repairs and bill the homeoianer on his tax assessment, spreading payments out over a ten-year period. The matter is to be heard before the Public Works Committee in the near future. _ CASE N0. PROPERTY APPELLANT 47- 81-H 1488-92 Minnehaha W. Robert P. Kranz (seven units) SUBJECT: Request variance of Section 34. 11 , to permit tenants of Apts . #4 and #7 to share use of one bathroom facility, becausE of practical difficulty and cost of providing additional bathroom. r -3- 9/8/81 - Meeting No. 177 ��r�"-'`��. y � � � � �� _ � � � � � �� '� �� ---- 52- 81-H - 360- 362 Fuller Ave. Oscar Valar � (13 units) SUBJECT: Request variance of Sec�ion 34. 11 , to permit tenants of thr�e t ir oor apartments to share one bathroom facility, because of financial hardship and practical difficulty. APPEARANCE : Oscar Valar Pierre Regnier, Attorney at Law FROCEEDINGS : Mr. Regnier reviewed a board decision made in March, 1977 , on an appeal filed by Mr. Valar, whereby a variance had been granted for tenants of five second floor units in this same building to share use of tztio bathroom facilities. Since that time , Mr. Valar had put into operation four dwelling units on the third floor. One of these units had its own private bathroom, but the remaining three shared a bathroom facility. The ot�ner was willing to accept the same restrietions placed on _the 1977 variance for the dwelling units on the third floor if the board decided in his favor, the conditions being that no more than one person occupy each of the units sharing a bathroom, and that the variance be in effect as long as Mr. Va1ar lived in the building. Mr. Regnier told the board that D4r. Valar' s daughter cleaned the shared bathroom daily, and the entire building was kept in excellent condition. Mr. Valar agreed to do all the remaining work rec{uired by the city in their letter of 8/4/81. BOARD ACTION: Mr. Sawyer moved to grant a variance of Section 34. I1, to permit t ree third floor d�aelling units to share one bathroom facilityi 9/8/81 - Meeting No. 177 � ' , MINUTES OF THE MEETING ST. PAUL BOARD OF APPEALS � REVIEW Tuesday, September 8 , 1981 Room 707 City Hall , 15 `V. Kellogg Blvd. MEMBERS PRESENT: Ron Glassman, Chairman . Harold D. Knutson Glenn Gausman Rudolph Sawyer MEMBERS ABSENT: Lucille Burg tiVilliam Tilton AGENCIES PRESENT: Dept. of Community Services - Division of Housing Code Enforcement : Alice Bijjani OTHERS PRESENT : Vicki Hastings Robert P. Kranz S. R. Sturm Charles S. Miller - --- -- R.E. F� Alta Wallenberg Richard Koppelman . � Pierre Regnier Pam Jackson Sam Glassman Scott Seiberlich Oscar Valar STAFF PRESENT : Pat Moxness Josephine Palermo Chairman Glassman called the meeting to order at 1 :32 p.m. The minutes of the meeting of August ll , 1981 , were approved as distrib- uted to the members . Chairman Glassman reported that the City Council has responded to his recent letter reauesting the city' s help in easing citizens ' financial burdens when a break in se�aer lines occurs on their property and must be repaired. Frank Staffenson of the Housing Code Office has worked out a proposed plan where the city will contract for such repairs and bill the homeo��ner on his tax assessment, spreading payments out over a ten-year period. The matter is to be heard before the Public Works Committee in the near future. CASE N0. PROPERTY APPELLANT � 47- $1-H 1488-92 Minnehaha j�J. Robert P. Kranz (seven units) SUBJECT : Request variance of Section 34. 11 , to permit tenants of Apts . #4 and #7 to share use of one bathroom facility, because of practical � difficulty and cost of providing additional bathroom. 9/8/81 - Meetin� No. 177 � , MINUTES OF THE MEETING ST. PAUL BOARD OF APPEALS $ REVIEW Tuesday, September S , 1981 Room 707 City Hall , 15 tiV. Kellogg Blvd. MEMBERS PRESENT: Ron Glassman, Chairman Harold D. Knutson G1enn Gausman Rudolph Sawyer . MER4BERS ABSENT: Lucille Burg William Tilton AGENCIES PRESENT : Dept. of Community Services - Division of Housing Code Enforcement : Alice Bij j ani OTHERS PRESENT : Vicki Hastings Robert P. Kranz S. R. Sturm Charles S. Mi11er --- -- R. E. � Alta Wallenberg Richard Koppelman . Pierre Regnier Pam Jackson Sam Glassman Scott Seiberlich Oscar Valar STAFF PRESENT : Pat b�ioxness Josephine Palermo Chairman Glassman called the meeting to order at 1 :32 p.m. The minutes of the meeting of August 11 , 1981 , were approved as distrib- uted to the members . �hairman Glassman reported that the City Council has responded to his � recent letter requesting the city' s help in easing citizens ' financial burdens when a break in sewer lines occurs on their pronerty and must be repaired. Frank Staffenson of the Housing Code Office has worked out a proposed plan where the city will contract for such repairs and bill the homeowner on his tax assessment, spreading payments out over a ten-year per�od. The matter is to be heard before the Public Works Committee in the near future. CASE N0. PROPERTY APPELLANT 47-81-H 1488-92 b�innehaha W. Robert P. Kranz (seven units) SUBJECT : Request variance of Sectian 34. 11 , to permit tenants of Apts . � #4 and #7 �o share use of one bathroom facility, because o£ practical difficulty and cost of providing additional bathroom. -4- 9/8/81 - Meeting No. 177 � ��,�� 54- 81-H 529 Blair Roy � Alta Wallenberg (three units) SUBJECT: Request variance of Section 34. 11, to permit occupancy of Apt. , w ere bathroom is located outside wa11s of unit , because of financial hardship. APPEARANCE : Roy and Alta Wallenberg PROCEEDINGS : Mr. Wallenberg said the tenant of Apt. #3 had the exclusive use o a -bathroom located off the common hallway. He explained that put- ting a bathroom inside the apartment would require tearing out stairways and electrical work. BOARD ACTION : h4r. Knutson moved that a variance of Section 34. 11 be grante , to permit occupancy of Apt. #3 where the bathroom facilities are located outside the walls of the unit , on condition that all remaining items in the city' s letter of 8/11/81 be completed. r�r. Gausman seconded. MOTION CARRIED AND SO ORDERED. THE VOTE : Ayes - 4 Nays - 0 Abstentions - 0 -4- 9/8/81 - Meeting No. 177 ` , ��, . - - - - -- -- -- -- -- -- -- - - - - -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- ---- -�----- ----- - --- --------- ---- -- - 55- 81-H 180- 186 S. Lexington Donamae Koppelman (,16 units) by Charles �S. Miller, Miller Management Co. , Inc. SUBJECT: Rec{uest variance of Section 34. 13, to permit occupancy of base- ment apartments where window sill heights exceed 48 inches , because of practical difficulty and expense. APPEARANCE : Charles S. Mi11er Richard Koppelman PROCEEDINGS : Mr. Miller stated that his firm manages this property. T e appeal involves four basement apartments where the windows in each of the sleeping rooms are larger than required for use as escape windows , but the sill heights are several inches higher than the 48 inches required by code. Mr. Glassman suggested putting in a permanent step up toward �each of the sleeping room windows in the basement units , high enough so that the sills would be no more than 48 inches above the step level. Alice Bijjani noted that the escape windows were double-hung, ti�rhich meant that only half of the window area would be openable in an emergency, but the window area was larger than the usual basement window. 9/8/81 - Meeting No. 177 MINUTES OF THE MEETING ST. PAUL BOARD OF APPEALS � REVIEW Tuesday, September 8 , 1981 Room 707 City Ha11 , 15 W. Kellogg Blvd. ME�IBERS PRESENT: Ron Glassman, Chairman Harold D. Knutson Glenn Gausman Rudolph Sawyer MED9BERS ABSENT: Lucille Burg jJilliam Tilton AGEi�CIES PRESENT: Dept. of Community Services - Division of Housing Code Enforcement : Alice Bijjani OTHERS PFLESENT : Vicki Hastings Robert P. Kranz S. R. Sturm Charles S. Miller _ _._ _... R. E. �, Alta Wallenberg Richard Koppelman _ Pierre Regnier Pam Jackson Sam Glassman Scott Seiberlich Oscar Valar STAFF PRESENT : Pat Moxness Josephine Palermo Chairman Glassman called the meeting to order at 1 : 32 p.m. The minutes of the meeting of August 11 , 1981 , were approved as distrib- uted to the members . Chairman Glassman reported that the City Council has responded to his recent letter rec{uesting the city' s help in easing citizens' financial burdens when a break in sewer lines occurs on their property and must be repaired. Frank Staffenson af the Housing Code Office has worked out a proposed plan where the city will contract for such repairs and bill the homeowner on his tax assessment, spreading payments out over a ten-year period. The matter is to be heard before the Public Works Committee i.n the near future. CASE N0. PROPERTY APPELLANT 47- 81-H 1488-92 Minnehaha ��1. Robert P. Kranz (seven units) SUBJECT : Request variance of Section 34. 11 , to permit tenants of Apts . #4 and #7 to share use of one bathroom facility, because of practical diffi,culty and cost of providing additional bathroom. , � ;! A`:�,'�?.!. , -S- 9/8/81 - Meeting No. 177 - - - - - - - -- - - - -- - - -- - - - - -- -- -- - - -- - - - - -- -- -- -- - - -- -- - - -- -- -- -- -- -- -- ---- ---- 42- 81-H 579 Summit Ave . Woodland Park Associates (19 units) by Scott Seiberlich SUBJECT : Request variance of Section 34. 13 , to permit occupancy of two basement units where window sill heights do not meet code requirements , because of fin ancial considerations . Prior Hearing 8/11/81 : No one appeared to represent appellant. Case was eontinued to September meeting. -6- g/8/81 - Meetin �77 ��. APPEARANCE : Scott Seiberlich PROCEEDINGS: Mr. Seiberlich stated that the two basement apartments have large windows , more than adec{uate in size for use as escape windows . Alice Bijjani agreed that light and ventilation was more than adequate , but sill heights were 54 inches from the floor and the code specifies that escape windows be no more than 48 inches . BOARD ACTION: Mr. Knutson moved to grant a variance os Section 34�. 13, to permit continued occupancy of two basement dwelling units where si1l heights of the sleeping room windows do not meet code requirements , on condition that a permanent step be installed beneath each sleeping room window to compensate for the deficiency. Mr. Gausman seconded. MOTION CARRIED AND SO ORDERED. THE VOTE: Ayes - 4 Nays - 0 Abstentions - 0 - - - - - - - - - -- -- - - -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- ------ ------ -- --- - -- -- - - -- g/g/81 - Meeting No. 177 MINUTES OF THE MEETING ST. PAUL BOARD OF APPEALS � REVIEW Tuesday, September 8, 198I Room 707 City Hall , 15 W.. Kellogg Blvd. MEI�iBERS PRESENT: Ron Glassman, Chairman Harold D. Knutson Glenn Gausman . Rudolph Sawyer MEb1BERS ABSENT: Lucille Burg William Tilton AGENCIES PRESENT : Dept. of Community Services - Division of Housing Code Enforcement : Alice Bijjani OTHERS PRESENT : Vicki Hastings Robert P. Kranz S.R. Sturm Charles S. Miller ----- - - R.E. $ Alta Wallenberg Richard Koppelman Pierre Regnier Pam Jackson Sam Glassman Scott Seiberlich Oscar Valar STAFF PRESENT : Pat Moxness Josephine Palermo � Chairman Glassman called the meeting to order at 1 :32 p.m. The minutes of the meeting of August 11 , 1981 , were approved as distrib- uted to the members . Chairman Glassman reported that the City Council has responded to his recent letter requesting the city' s help in easing citizens ' financial burdens when a break in sewer lines occurs on their property and must be repaired. Frank Staffenson of the Housing Code Office has worked out a proposed plan where the city will contract for such repairs and bill the homeowner on his tax assessment, spreading payments out over a ten-year period. The matter is to be heard before the Public Works Committee in the near future. CASE N0. FROPERTY APPELLANT 47- 81-H 1488-92 Minnehaha W. Robert P. Kranz (seven units) SUBJECT: Request variance of Section 34. 11 , to permit tenants of Apts . #4 and #7 to share use of one bathroom facility, because of practical difficulty and cost o£ providing additional bathroom. �� -LoF�►.�.,��W'}W� ) '�j� �f{ //f d� . . l'7` =' m � . �+ ST. PAUL BOARD OF APPEALS � REVIE�ti' 7Q5A City Hall St. Paul , Minnesota 55102 (612) 298-4163 September 15 , 1981 T0: Walter Bowser Assistant City Attorney . . FROM: Pat Moxness RE : Draft Resolution - Board Actions of September 8 , 1981 Attached is a draft resolution pertaining to board actions taken at the meeting of September 8 , 1981 , on the following cases : CASE N0. PROPERTY APPELLANT 47- 81-H 1488-92 W. Minnehaha Robert P. Kranz 50-_81=H_.:__.._ ____ 2010 Marshall Ave. S. R. Sturm - � 52- 81=H 360- 362 Fuller Ave. Oscar Valar 54- 81-H 529 Blair Roy F� Alta Wallenberg 55- 81-H 180- 186 S. Lexington Donan►ae Koppelman By Charles ,S. Miller 42- 81-H 579 Summit Ave. l�Toodland Park Associates By Scott Seiberlich If you h ave any questions , please call me at 4163. ti � t � � � � � % l � W M! `� � � � STATE OF MINNESOTA ) � County of Ramsey ) ss. CITY OF SAINT PAUL ) Albert B: Olson: I, • • • • • • • • • • • . • . . . . . . . . . . . . .City Clerk of the ars " City of Saint Paul, Minnesota, do hereby certify that I have � � 277481 a compared the attached copy of Council File No. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . �, as adopted by the City Council. . , , .Sept: .24: . . . . . . . . . . . . 19.£il . . . 0 � and approved by the Mayor. . . . . . . . , ,Sept: .28: . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19 81 . . . ,W (u/� with the original thereof on file in my office. I further certify that said copy is a true and correct copy of said original and the whole thereof, i WITNESS my hand and the seal of the City of Saint Paul, Minnesota this . 28th . . . . . . . . day of . September:. . . . . . ,A.D. 19.�1 . i, .C�:� � , . . . . . ., . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ,a �; � � . City Clerk. ,�- 1 : t'' � �f�. � �..� . _ .�` , ` h,�, y ryr . u'k� . ,�1 � r��'� f f i E t4 4�` '�.; i a116 � 00. 00 — A � � WHITE �- CITY CLERK PINK - FINANCE ^ i ' �� CANAR� - DEPARTMENT �'I IT Y \1 F SA I N T l,L�U L COUIICII �� BIwUE - MAYOR File N O. a � � _�Resolution Presented By Referred To Committee: D'ate Out of Committee By Date � BE IT RESOLVED, That the Council of the City of Saint Paul hereby certifies and approves the action of the City of Saint Paul Board of Appeal�s and Review pertaining to the following listed property and as shown by� the Excerpted Minutes of said Board of Appeals and Review, dated �eptember 8 , 1981, and marked EXHIBIT A, and attached hereto and made a part hereof by reference: � DATE OF BOARD MINUTES CASE NO. PROPERTY APPEL?�ANT 9/8/81 47 -81-H 1488-92 W. Minnehaha Robert P. Kranz � (seven units) . � BOARD ACTION: Granted variance of St. Paul Legislative Code, Section ' 34.11, to permit tenants of Apts. No. 4 and 7 to � _ continue sharing use of one bathroom, subject to � resolution of a zoning problem, on condition that no � more than one person occupy each said unit, and that � all remaining work orders listed in city's letter of 7/8/81 be completed. • Property Description: McCaskey ' s Rearrangement Lot 10, Block 1 ------------------------------- � 9/8/81 50-81-H 2O10 Marshall Ave. S.R. Sturm (six units) BOARD ACTION: Granted variance of St. Paul Legislative Code, Section 34 . 13, pertaining to sill height of basement sleep- ing room escape windows, if adherence to 48-inch code specification is impossible, on condition that a permanent step be installed under each said window � to com ensate for the deficienc . COUNC[LMEN Yeas Nays Requestgd by Department of: Hunt Levine In Favor Maddox nn�nneno� A gai n s t BY Showalter — Tedesco �Ison Form Approved by City Attorney Adupted by Council: Date . _ -�' CertiEir•d F'assed by Council Secretary E3 ti' -- ,1��{�r�..r�i h� �1awr: Date _ Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council 11� - —__--- - — BY - � .. . . _' ��V� Granted variance of Section 34 . 11, to permit tenants of Apts. No. 5 and 6 to share use of one shower facility, on condition that no more than one person occupy each . � said apartment. Property Description: Merriam Park Second Addition y � � Lot 6, Block 5 �'/ 9/8/81 52-81-H ; 360-62 Fuller Ave. Oscar Valar .�.:� i (13 units) � BOARD ACTION: Granted var'i�ance of St. Paul Legislative Code, � . Section 34 . 11, to permit three third floor dwell- � ing units to share use of one bathroom, on condi- t,,,� tion that no more than one person occupy each said � unit, on condition that all remaining work orders listed in city' s letter of 8/4/81 be complete, effective as long as the appellant, Oscar Valar, lives on the premises. Property Description: Elfelt Bernheimer and Arnold's Addition � Lot 4, Block 7 -------------------------------- 9/8/81 54-81-H 529 Blair Roy & Alta Wallenber (three units) BOARD ACTION: Granted variance of St. Paul Legislative Code, Section 34. 11, to permit continued occupancy of Apt. No. 3 where bathroom facility is located outside walls of said apartment, on condition that all remaining items . in the city ' s letter of 8/11/81 be completed. Property Description: Smith' s Subdivision of Block 3 Lot 8 , Block 3 --------------------------------- 9�g/gl 55-81-H 180-186 S. Lexington Donnamae Koppelman (16 units) By Charles S. Millez Miller Management Co. , Inc. BOARD ACTION: Granted variance of �t. Paul Legislative Code, Section 34 . 13, pertaining to sill height of escape windows in basement sleeping rooms, on condition that a permanent step be installed under each said window where sill height is more than 48 inches , to compensate for the deficiency. -2- `3 - - wMITEr� - CITY CLERK ��1� PINM�, - FINANCE � i �� d G�►NARY - . DEPARTMENT � i �� O F SA I NT l,L�U L COUflCII �LUE - MAVOR File �O. � �' Council Resolution Presented By Referred To � Committee: Date OuE of Committee By �Date Property Description: Bryant's Park Addition No. 4 Lots 13 anc� 14, Block 1 � : _ _ 9/8/81 42-81-A . 579��.SUminit �,ve: �, Woodland Park (19 units) Associates By Scott Seiberlich BOARD ACTION: Granted variance of St. Paul Legislative Code, Section 34,. 13, to permit continued occupancy of two basement dwelling units where sill heights of sleeping room escape windows do not meet ' code requirements, on condition that a pe�manent step be installed beneath each said escape window to compensate for the deficiency. Property Description: Weed and Willius Rearrangement C', . E. � of Lot 18 and all of Lot 19 ' � and W. 11 Ft. of Lot 20, Block 23 :� � -------------------------- � and be it FURTHER RESOLVED, That upon passage of this resolution the City Clerk is hereby authorized and directed to transmit a copy of this resolution for recording to the Ramsey County Office of the Register of Deeds. -3- COUNC[L�tEN � Yeas Nays Requestpd by Department of: Hunt � �evine �fl FBVOC Maddox _/ McMahon �� BY snoWaicer A gai n s t Tedesco Wilson Adupted by Council: Date SEP 2 4 1981 Form Approved by City Attorney Ccrtif�ed E a. � y Council S • ar B �' � � �-�--,-� �' _ y. � � +vor: Date SEP 2 8 1961 Approved by 14ayor for Submission to Council A�,pruvcd�y=-�r�� ,i/`// '�'LC�—L�!2`� ' -- B E3y __ L -- - r – . `� � � . � ' .� �.,�\```� W ` f� � � � N 7 � -i � N ..« v� C') D � � � n� � � � N W � m a n C � � fl- o °• ,� O � O � --w n � '�l � � � � C � 0 N � � � � � � �D�� \ Z � o N ro � n � z � `� � � � zo ° � ° � � N m � � , � � � � � = o °' o o � '"' � � � m • � s -� � � � n � � � ? � o � ... N � � • � � q °' � ° � � G� . v � �, _ � � �.,... � T1 � � N Z � Q � ,yy„ � � � � � � C � �t � � . � t � � � . .. I C � � !��', � \ � �� i�o� �. , „ _ : . , - , r, � � . _ , .-� - ,;: . 4 � � . � ; � � ��`� : � ;; r _ ; � _ . , � � , : , , _ . . . .;.� . ' .^ . .... �.��. . . �� ' _ � . , C.. : .. . . � � . . . . . �. ' �,: � ...� 'i��'i _ . . . . .� .. �, . ..� ... .., . .,.:. . . _ . . . � ��, .._'�; . . . .: . f)�.� . . ��. . . . .. �. . . . . . . , � � � . .. � .. . . ;. .�. . \�;: .. .... , _,', .. � - .. . �. . . . � � . - � � � . , � � �. . . . � , . , 1 E / ` , '. t ,, ,.;� , - ' . : Septeanbe� 28� 148t j . � . , . , : ; , , , . k' , , . � • . . . � . - .. . . , ; . l. ' . . .. . . . � A . I , � � � . .� . , ". . ' . . . . 1' .. . . � . . ., '� . . , . . � . . ' . ' .. ;� R,�ffiistez of �s � , &� 155 , , c:s�y ��i - , , , , ,' � ' Dear'Sirs• ' r � , 4 I Craastait s .celr�ifl,�d �ogq of ��'. N�. 277481, �tdogted by the ;St. Pau�. , �` . ; Ci�+q Co�acil .on Sept. 24, 1981. for filing: dn your of'fi�t , ' ' � � . ; � Ver� Crvtl�r :youxs. ! � ,= �'fi ,5�,�_ , . . � �, . • � ; �..,c�`— . � . �5.� . �. , . , ' —,�,'r �..'ti.,,; �; ,r �. � ;�. � . Albert B. alsom .:.� � Ciry Cl��k . � . . Attactl. . , ech . , � t " , , tl ,, _ � • � ' � - . , I . . ' . . , . . . . . ' . . � . , . . . . . � � `/�. F l� .. - . . ; ;..� � ., . � • . � ' . � � , � .. . . . . . . . � . " .. . . . . ' . . � ' . ' � ; �. . . . , ' ' . . . .. ., ! y / . . ' . . � ' . � . � . . � . . . � .y.� . . . . . � . . . .. � � . �.. . � ., � '. . . . � . . � . . . r � � � � � � . � . - . . • ,. - � � . . . , ... � I , , ..' . . . ' . ' � . . � ��, � � � � ' / � '.� . �� . . � ' � . .� � . , 1 . � . 9 . _ , . . . ,. . . . .. . . ' . . . . .. � , �.�t � � � . .. . . . ' . _ . . , � �i � i . . � . . . , _. . .. ' ' .. � . . � . . • � ' .. , � �_ . � I . . . � . : '. ' i. v.. k,.. - . � , .. � .. . . - . . . . . _ " / ... . .j, . , ., . . ;.�'y. . . . � . . � . � - . ' . . . ' ti ; 1. .. . . .. . ... . . . - . � . . . ,1 . � .. ' . .. .. . '� , ' . . . . . .. . r _ . . . . ' . . . . ). . . . . . . . , . . . ,. . . .. . �. S.�'. . . . . . i - � � . �,�. 4 S • , . , . . � � .. - . ' � 1 . .. . � . . , �� ^ix_ - . � � . . . . � ' . � � . - '. .� . ' - ' . � . ; c -: � . ' � � , . . . . . . . . � i�..'^� . ,� � . . � . - . . � . . . .l� . . . .. . t.; . ,. ,. , . . . � . . �� . . . � - � . . . , . 5 }:y�$� . - . � . . ' ' . � � ' . . . l R . . ' - . . .. . . � . . . _1 . . . , �. ' ' ' , , ' • \, .. . � � . � . _ ... . . ,. _ . .. u_ :��LY?