276081 WHITE - CITY CLERK � A'' ��" pi
PINK � � - FINANCE COUIICll �) f��l�� �
B�JE RY - MAYOR MENT G I T Y O F S A I N T PA U L �
File N 0.
Co cil Resolution
Presented By ,
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
BE IT RESOLUED, That the Council of the City of Saint Paul hereby certifies
and approves the action of the City of Saint Paul Board of App�als and Review per-
taining to the follvwing listed property and as shcx�m by the Exo�xpted Minutes
of said Board of Appeals and Review, da.ted Nove�nber 18, 1980, and marked EXf-IIBIT A,
and attached hereto and made a part hereof by reference:
I�3TE OF BQARD
MINUI'E.S CASE NO. PROPERTY APP�,TANT
11/18/80 34-80-H 951 W. 7th St. Michael Roach
(14 �.its)
BQARD AGTI�T: Amended Cotmcil File 275816, wherein variance was granted to ��;t
occupaYicy of six dwell�ng units, tA designate rocan nLanbe.rs of those
units affected, as follaws: Rocm Nos. 5-7, 11-12, 14-15, 16-17,
21-22, and 24-25.
Property Description: Stinsan's Subdivision of Block 25 of Stinson, Brawn and.
Ramsey's Addition, Lots 10 and 11, Block 25
----------------------------
11/18/80 42-80-H 529 Portland Ave. W. J. Uhlenkott
(four �its)
�D ACTION: Granted variance of St. Paul Legislative Code, Section 54.13,
pertaining to bas�nent occupancy, tA pernut c�ntinued occLnx�ncy
of basen�nt �it more than 50� belaw grade.
Property Description: Auditor's Subd.ivisian, No 11. Subject to Easements,
W. 10 Ft. of Lot 16 and all of Lot 15, Block 18
----------------------------
COUNCILMEN
Yeas Nays Requestgd by Department of:
Hunt
Levine In Favor
Maddox
McMahon
�,���r __ Against BY
Tedesco
wlson
Form Approved by City Attorney
Adopted by Council: Date
Certified Yassed by Council Secretary �"�"`I� !2'� �
By �
Approved by ;Vlayor: Date _ Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By _ BY
. �.+ ������
� , .
11/18/80 43-80-H 1897 Carroll A�. Clare.nce J. Curley
(three units)
BQ�2D ACTI�T: Granted varianoe of St. Paul Legislative Cod,e, Section 54.11, per-
t-aining to basic facilities, tro permit occupancy of two �its
sharing one bathroom facility, on condition that all remaining
it�ems listed in city's letter of 9/30/80 be oompleted and that
o�ctap�zcy of said tmits be limit�ed to four persons; said varianoe
to be effective only for the period. of awnership by Mr. and/or
Mrs. Clarenoe J. Curley.
Property Description: Mexriam Park
Lot 10, Bloc�c 14
11/18/80 45-80-H 1524 Carroll A�. Nancy & To�n Kernari
(twr� Lmits)
BOARD ACTI�T: Granted varianoe of St. Paul Legislative Code, Section 54.13, per-
ta;n;� tA basen�nt occup�ricy, t�o perntit use of sleeping roans
m�re than 50� belav grade, on o�nd:ition that: (1) a sroke door
be provicled leading into the sleeping roan, (2) a s�ke cletector
be insta.11ed in area in�e3iately adjaoent to the bedroan, and
(3) an escape window be installed op�osite the eloor of the sleep-
ing rocgn, with a sill no mr�re than thirty (30) inches above floor
level.
Property Description: Aci�i� Addition to the City of St. Paul, Lot 5, Block 2
11/18/80 40-80-H 42 So. St. Albans Fillm�re�nlalters
(six condcanini�ns)
BQARD AGTI0�11: Granted varianoe of Minnesota i7ni.form Building Code, Article 13.03,
pertaining t,� use of fire rated materials, to pezmit continued occtr
pancy of six oondc�uni�n units, each equipped with front entranc�e
c�oors which do not ccanply with fire-safety code requirements aftrer
having received a signed waiver, a oopy of which is attached hereto
as Exhibit A and macle a part of this resolution, by the condominium
owners aclmawledging and assiun.ing the risks creat�ed by this variance.
Varianoe is granted on condition that any future replaoement of said
doors must meet code; said varianoe to be recorded on deed of each
condan�nitun tmit placing future purchasers on notice of the variance
granted herein and the restrictions related thereto. This variance
is also conditioned t�on the Hareawners Associatiari posti.ng a oopy
of this resolution for tw� weeks in a oonspic�us and oomron area of
the oond�o�ninitun ca�lex.
2' � /�-9d�
PINKE � - FINANCERK COUQCII � t �
CANARY - DEPARTMENT G I T Y O F S A I N T PA U L �`������
qy.UE - MAYOR File N O.
Cou ' Resolution
Presented By �
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
1/18/80 50-80-H 420 Hersc,hel St. Paul W. Larson
(five tuzits)
BO�I2D ACTI�1: Granted variance of St. Paul Legislative Code, Sectian 54.11, per-
taining to basic facilities, to permi.t occupa�zcy of apart�nt
where handsink is locat�ed outside toilet/shawer room.
Prc�perty Description: Lovering's Addition. Lot 26, Block 1
and be it
FURTf�R RE.SOLVID, That the City Clerk is hexeby authorized and directed to
tr�srnit a copy of this resolution for recording t,o the Ra¢nsey CoLmty Office of the
Registsr of Deeds.
3.
COUNCILMEN
Yeas Nays Requestgd by Department of:
Hunt
Levine In Favor
Maddox �
McMahon B
snowaiter __ Against Y
Tedesco
wlson
DEC � g �ggp Form Approved by City Attorney
Adopted hy Council: Date
Certified P s-e by Counci ec ry B, ��'g'�D
E • � 8 �� Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
App by :Wayor• —
By BY
�t1�.tSKEO 0 E C 2 71980
�. ' � �
, ' � � �(
�
!"�
� STAT� 0� MINN�SOTA )
PI Coun,ty os Ramaey ) be.
� CI7y 0� SAINT PAUL )
�
�`Z Rose Mix,
I. . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . .. . . .. . . . . .. . . .. .. . . . .Ci�y C.eetc(z
o� xhe Ci.ty o� Sa,in� Pau.e, M�i,nne6o.ta., do heneby ceh,t,i.�y �ha�
1 have compcviced �he a.tt.a.ched copy o� Counai.e �.iQe fVo??6081 . . . .
a.a adop�ed 6y �he Ci.ty Counc,i,2 .. .Dec;.16: . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1980 . . .
and appnoved 6y #h.e Mayon .. . . .. . .Dec:.�8: . .. . . .. . . . 1980. . .
. . .
w,i.th �he ar,c:g�.nn.e �he�ceo� on. �.i.2e �.n my o���.ce.
C'-'y .
�.�=7 .. . . . . .. • . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. .. . . . . . . . • .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . • . . • . . • . •
'"'"b^ •� � � • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • � • • • � • • • • • � � � • • •• . • .• • • . • • • � • • • • � • •
L`? �
s�
_^' , • • • • •� • • • • • • • • • • • • • � • •� • • • � � • • • •• • • • • • • • • • • • • • �• • • • • • � • • � • •• • •
C3") •� • • �• • • • • • • • • • • • • � • •• • � • • • • • • �� � • • • �• • � • • • • • • • • • • • • � � � � . � � � � •
CJ
W
�� • .• • • � � • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • . • • . • • • • • • . • • • . • • • • • • • • • •
• � • • • . • � • • • • • � • • • • • . • • • • • • • • • • • • . • • • � • • . • • • • � • • . • • • • •. • • •• • . • •
- • • . • • . • . . • . • . • • • • • • • • • . • • • . • . • • • • • • • • . • . . • . • • • • • • • • • • . . • • . . . • •
• • . • • . • . • • • • • • • . • • •• • • . • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • . • . • • • . • • •• • • • • • • • •
- . • . • • • • • • • • • . . . • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • ••• •• . •• • • • • • . • • • • •. . • • • • • • •• • •
• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •• • • •• • • •• • � • • • • • • • • • �• •• • • • • • • • • • •
I bwr.th.e�r. ce�r�',i.�y �'hcct bcu.d copy .i,a a �cue and co�vicec,t copy
a� e cu,d o�u,g.i,nna,Q, and �he who.�e �'he�ceo�.
��a � � r
�� '` � UlI7N�SS my hand and �;he aeu.e o� �h.e Ci�y a� Sa.i.n,t P�,
--.� , u,
, �
;- s ��. �.� 18th �y �� December . A D. �80
t . .. . . . . . . .. .. . . .
, .. . . . . . . . . . . . .
�eo
:, ;� � , o
� �
�
�r �w'° • • . . . . . . .. . �. . . .. . . .. . . d. . . . . .
' ' C(�;y �2h.FL. °�
0
- - ._ o
Q
�
;
�
� _ _ . �
�
yyM�'. • . ' CITY CLERK � ^ � � . , ' , �
/'IMK '• FINANCE� � �����['��
,��A�t •� ' DEPARTM ENT •� G I T Y O F �S A�I N T PA U L COUflC1I
BLUE ' - - MAYOR � • File N 0. ��
• •
_. _.
� Coun:cil Re_solut�on__ _ _ - - - -
� �_ ;�, � _., :>> �.,.._
Presented By �i� � �1 .. �• .�R-:
_,,,_��„ _._�
- - -� -- Referred 'f`o;�'`'�'-_:,._ . �._ .-- - - - - - _Committee:.' _.Date `�''
.�Y'� `"• Y,��� 'R .
Out of Committee By �Date �y�'�`'
��
���k. : t...�. � . �. . . � ', , : �-;t� .
� '"' �6�Y't �� '1'l��t tha Oaadl C! #bs Cit�► O� �etfstt Pae�l � �e�.'tif3M�'�
aod �pp�es t3�e act3on o� tbs Citp c� Sia3aoR Ae�l �d o� App�sls am Aenrirer p�� .
�-.�, t��i� b� t�s �o�]a�ri�g 13sl�ed pmopa�t� amd as � bp the l500� l�fnon�r �
� o[ eaid Hast+3 t�` llppsals aod Aertr3�r, tlsb�d liv� 18, ]980, aod �o�loied ��,
. C`� �_ aed at#ac�ad 1��a6o ae�d ascla a p�rt � Ly r�ecr�:
� � Q� �� ; .
� t�1� �. P�'t �
� � �
.,. _
l�/18,/�0 ._ �: �. 3i�t1-8 . :951 )!. � �t. M�d�l Lo�ch .
- �1� �nib� _, _ -
,. . .
Bt�t�D�: `�]�eocLd Ciowcil �#]s 2'lSSl.6, �3a va¢3amoo w,�rao�sd tc� �t
aoc�es� ai' si�c x�rel2itiq u�ts, �o �at� �x�ao�e�cs o� tl�or
� mitr a�ctisd, aus �olyo�,ss aoad�os. �-7►�2i�12. 14-15,.2b-1?, � �
� �2, a�d ?�2S. . � : , � .
. _ ,. . _
- �'�l► �s'=-"';-�� 8ti�soo's �div3�si+ab +o� S�+nit�c 2S aE �3a�oo, e�+a�n at�d �: ,- + .`:
�'• 1�e3�lil3�a, 3rols�'10 aod 11, H�o� 25 , , - .
. ��.
.,R;: , _ .
' 1�/1�/80 �2-�SG-H 329 Pa�tlmtd i�w. , � J. t�l�tt _. '"
.�, t�o�a mit�j - j � �.
... - .•�y-L
8� ALTi�i G�ffitied varS�oa CcE 8't. Paul Lagi�lettfVle tbde, 9eCl3�OD 5�.13, -
b� batsenent oowpanop, b� peaonit ao�t�sd ooca�pe�p
o� bneemeat unit a�oa� t3�e�t S� belov qra�. ,
�� �� R�10 !'t.s a� IAtPi]��ud all o� � BSroah�R ��
. . ��:
� . . .. •v'.� r
: . .. . . . ,� -ae'..
_ � �., -�-�;
COUNCILMEN `� �
Yeas Nays Requestgd by Department of: � " ;.�> ,
Hunt > �``: +s.�`„;;'
��e In Favor
Maddox
�� ; Against BY
Tedaoo -
Vlfilson .
Adopted by Council- Date ` Form Approved by City Attorney
Certified Passed by•Council Secretary ��t't- ��� y��a
B}• . ,;.,
Approved by �layor. Date Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council '.���`
. BY BY
� . . _ - -...
« � , .
` ^ � r
, . . . �1�:��.��_�
„�: 11/18/80 43-80 H 1897 Carroll Ave. Cl.arenoe J. Curley
,.�' (three w�i.ts)
�
� BOARD AL'rICt�I: Granted varian�e of St. Paul Iegislative Coc7e, Secti� 54.11, per-
� taining to basic facilities, to perndt occUpancy of tw� tmits
�# sharing � bathrocgn facility, on conditian that all r�naining
� items list�ed in city's letter of 9/30/80 be vcc�ipleted and that
occ�t�ancy of said tmi.ts be l�mi.ted to four persons; said varianoe
to be effective only for the period of ownership by Mr. and,/ar
Mrs. Clarence J. C�rley.
Praperty Descripti�: Merriam Park
I�t 10, Block 14
11/18/80 45-80-H 1524 Carnoll Ave. Nancy & 'I'o�n Kernan
(two imits)
� BQARD ACTI�T: Grantsd variance of St. Paul Legislative Code, Sectiari 54.13, per-
taining to base�nesit oocupancy, to permit use of sleeping roo�tis
mc�re than 50� belaw grade, ori o�ndition that: (1) a smke cloor
be provicied leading into the sleeping roan. (2) a s�ke detect,or
be installed in area i�mediately adja�nt to the bedroan, and
(3) an escape winclow be installed apposite the door of the sleep-
ing roan, with a sill no mc�re than thirty (30) inches abave floor
l,evel.
Prr�perty Description: Adams Addition to the City of St. Paul, Lot 5, Block 2
11/18/80 40-80 H 42 So. St. Albans Fillmore�nTalters
(six �ondaniniisns)
B�ARD ACTI�i: Grant�ed varianoe of Minnesota Ik�iform Builcling Code, Article 13.0�,
pertain?ng to use of fire rated materi.als, to permit oontinued occtr
pancy of six oonc�xnini�n Lmits, eaGh equipped with front entrance
doors which do not c�a�ly with fire-safety code requirem�nts after
having reoeived a signed waivex, a c�opy of which is attached hereto
as Exhibit A and made a part of this resolution, by the oondomini�n
vwners aclmowledging and assuming the risks created by this variance.
Varianoe is granted an oondition that any future replaoement of said
doors must meet oode; said varianee to be reo�rded oaz deed of each
aondaninii.ml tmit placing future purchasers on notioe of the variance
granted herein and the restricti�s related thereto. This vaxiance
is also coaiditioned �on the Har�eounlers Associatice� posting a vopy
of this resolution for twn weeks in a oonspicuous and ooqmr�n area of
the oondaniniLan caitplex.
2.
3 �� i�-4-w
ryMt�E „_,' �GITYCLERK � ' �� �� . W 1E YZ�.
�A�V - DEPARTMENT G I T Y O F S A I N T � PA U L COUflC1I � �t�i ��� _
s�ue .J ,- MwroR File N 0.'
, .
y Council Resodut�on �
Presented ��`^' �{ ':��, , � :t . ' �, - ,���
.
,� ,
By , ' ' - -- --- - _
_.
. � _._. __�...� _.__y--..�_ --------._._ . _ _ ._� _ ____--
_-—----- - .�=r.... ----- -- __--. __.r , �:�^ �,,, -
_ __ , � � . , �. _. ,
Referred To � . ` Comr�ittee:�;', ; DaEe �
^� '
' Out of Committee. By � Date
�. ,_ � - ��<
�1 ],/1$/�0 5G'8�'$ t�0 Hat7d�l1 �t.��: �� A�i.1�. LarsCe� �:;�
:� lfiv�s mits� � , . r � . _.... ,
:: .
� �r= , �.``'
� H0►RD !!C`�: �bad vat3aooa a�E b`t.. Paul L�g3s1at3ae Gbc�s;`_S'�c�3+on �t.l1, �x�- -..
� t�iaq t� be�s3,c facilit3res� b� paadt oowps� o� a�t
� ��t�e �lsdak Ls ]+oaat3rd oa�t��ddt bo�il+art,/at�oMe� �oc�a�.
Pi+ap�t�p Drc�ip�dran: taveac3r�q*s l�ditim. Lat Z6, 81cx3� 1
and b� iL � .
Ft�t �. �ltat t,I�a Cit? C1�eocl� 3ait Le�Lp �osi�rd �od di�cted.:tip_. _
tsaamdt a ac�y o� t�is s�s�o�on �r r+�ooa�die�g to tbs R�rey tso� O�e:�:�t���.�.
Hag'isbe � Die�s• . . `
� . .. � . . . '' , � l,-.'. . .
, . . . / . . . . . . " . . . .. .
� . . ,-_ .. .. . ... .
, .. . .:. . - ... _ . . ... . .
. . . . c...'. . ,; ,.�� : . . . ,,�.. . , :
. . . . . ., . ..., ,. ... . . . .
' . �. . . , . . .. ._.�t. �. � .. . :_.. '. ... . � � ,.:. . . . '
� ` � . � �i '.. � .
.� .. .. .. . . . ' � _ _�u� � � .
� COUNCILMEN . - :
Yeas Na s ' Requestgd by Department of: - -
Y � : , _ . �-'�� .
Hunt �
��e In Favor �
�adox . �
McManon °
snowai�e� � Against . BY . . .
Tsdesoo
�Ison .
� �L' � s �580 � Focm Approved by City Attorne ,
• Adopted by Council: Date
Certified P'ass d _ ounc' e etaryt y � � /� y_�
�`���� �./`�'`�"'r�, • .
Hy •
' j 8� 1��n ` Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council .
Approved by Mayor: Date -
By BY
. . _. � . . . . . .. _�L.
� ` • F
W � ? D = � � � � �
'� �D o '.. N �, �• � v
r
m � � � � � �; � � ��
nC �, 3 `° � -* °. � o
� �►' � -« ° -« �
m � � o � � o.� t'�
-Zlm � � � � o � � ` � m � �
'( o�j -, " � cn � �
� _ � ��poo � � � � O i1' �
.. � D � I"�
n � '� .
,� _ � in' � o �
a �. a � �
� � �
� o .� � �
� � v�, � • � � .....r
Z r'� � � _.
N � na � � �, �
o � � � �
� i � � � �-7�
. � � �
� c ''
\� ;
�
. � <,
., ,
. ' � r" , , ` _ C, F.'�'7�iQ'�:! �
� .
� . i, . - . � _. . ,_. : . , ,,._ .
;. , , . , � ,
_ .
,
. . ,
., .
; . ..
; � . ,, . � -
- _ .. , s
, ,
� w : ,�� . .
.
, , i _ - _ , � �
`', � ,` _ , � '�.,
. , . , �- ... ; '�.�
. ' ' . ' e.�.r� �a, i9go ' ; : ; , , k
, . . . ;
� ; ' � .. i
� ' � ` -
' ,. _,. _ ` .
, . '�'
' , �
. . �'
, , : :
� .
i , . �
� $i8$��dtSl Ca� I1413t�i • +f I. '
� 'fS�, '� _
� . - ;:�luildin$ , _ .
� • . , � , , - i_
` Dae�r"'�ir� � ' - ;, . •
, , .. . ,, . ' _
� , . , , .
; ,
; , . .
��� � � r�a��itting�a certified:-copy of C.F. lio. 2�`.d�81 for s�eord�ttg� ,
I .:
, , �.n your Office. A ,� ; � .
_ ,
� • .
. , : . ,: .
. .
• _ ' - � � . 9eryr tru�y :gcria�a, , ', � �
� , �
� ; , . �.: ,^ . . , .
' \ , ' � , ,; ; \ `!: �'� , � -
� Roen�1K�" ��. ' . . t
_ �. ' ,{ City �Cler�rk `� '�
. � , , ;. , `
�. At��ch. � ! ` ' ' r .
'
ach � . �
, . , , . � �
. � \ � � , - � � , -
, - . , , ' .
. . . _
�,
. : , . � � _
� - � , . . , : _ ,
,, ,. . . - ; . . , r
,. .�� . . . � . . ` ' . . � � - . - .. .' .. . , , . F.
.
, . ._� .. . . . . . . .
% .. , . .. . .i . � , . "' . � .j i . � .. � .. . . . ' . .
�1 � . ' . . . . . . � . . � . � . , �1. .� �
. . . . . . . . . �. . . ... .:
_ . � ` .. � . . '. . _ 1 � . .`. . .. � . . . . ` .:'�
�\,�. ' � . � . � .. ' . . . ' . � , , � .
. ,. . . . . ' � I ' - � ., ' . . . ... � I . ' .
. • . . ! 3 " ' ./ . . . .. . , � . .. . . . . ��� .. . - . �p\:.. . . .
. � .. � . . . . , . ' . . � .
- _
, . . . . . . , . � . . . � . � . � .
.
_l
. . . . . � . .. . . \� ..
. . . � . . . . ..
� . . , . . , . • �� .. . . : . a�� � . �
. • . . . . . � � . . � . . . . . . . .. ' �. � � . � . .. �o` . . /
' . � ' . . ' . - � . . . � � - . .. ��
.. . .. . . S�. . . ' • . . . � � , � - . .. � I . .. . � '
I _ i �\ �,`
. � � ,�� .i.;`
I + \ , ; I '�`:
� , � «
i ` , i , . ' ' "'* � v 's
\.. -,t � . . / ' • ' � , t
_ \. - ± - _ � . , . ., r ., .
11/18/80 - �1eet:ing No. 16 i
.0 l� I� l l � ���6�s�
X
MIi�UTES OF TIiE T4EETING
ST. PAUL BOARD OF APPEALS �, REVIEW
. Tuesday, November I8 , 1980
City Council Committee Room 707
City Hall and Court House
1 : 30 p.m.
MEMBERS PRESENT : Arthur Tieso , Acting Chairman
Estyr B. Peake
Glenn Gausman
A. Wali Naibi
Ron Glassman .
ABSEiVT : D.D. Wozniak, Chairman
Thomas� Reiter
AGENCIES PRESENT: Community Services Dept. - Division of Housing
and Building Cod� Enforcement
Alice Bijjani � -"�
OTHERS PRESENT : Edward Wittenberg Richard A. NeXson
Harry Steinbauer Jerome Wlymcyzk
Tom Kern an W.J. Uhlenkott
Paul W. Larson A.W. Uhlenkott
Leroy L. Meyersen Craig Mi11er
Beverly Vavoulis Thomas J. McNamara
Mr. � Mrs . Clarence Curley
Shirley Martinek Ann Copeland
STAFF PRESENT: Patricia Moxness
The meeting was called to order by Acting Chairman Tieso at 1 : 50 p.m.
The minutes of the meeting of 10/14/80 were approved as distributed to
the members .
CASE N0. �ROPERTY APPELLANT
34- 80-H 951 W. 7th St . Michael Roach
(14 units)
SUBJECT: Request by St. Paul Division of Public Health to add more specific
wo�r ing to motion passed at meeting of 9/9J80 and subsequently ratified by
City Council (C. F. 275816) , as proposed in letter of 10/9/80 from �Villiam
McCausland.
APPEAR.ANCE : None
_ ,:_ �.._. .. . ... .... .. ___.. _ .. t__..._....r,�..._._.,...,,,,r
• -2- 11/18/80 - 1�leeting �`����
' PROCEEDINGS : Chairman Tieso called attentio� to the Health Department's
wrltten request that the room numbers of the units affected by the
variance granted on 9/9/80 be listed in the resolution.
BOARD ACTION: Mr. Glassman moved to amend the resolution passed on
8 an later approved by the City Council in Council File 275816 to
specify that the variance applied specifically to the following six two-
room sleeping units : Room #5- 7, Room #11- 12 , Room #14-15 , Room #16-17,
Room #21-22 and Room #24-25. Mrs . Peake seconded. MOTION CARRIED AND SO
ORDERED.
THE VOTE: Ayes - 4 Nays - 0 Absfientions - 0
_2_ 11/18/80 - �teeting No. lfi7
� • `}���.��p
�G 1
CASE N0. PROPERTY APPELLANT
42- 80-H 529 Portland Ave . W. J. Uhlenkott
(four units)
SUBJECT : Request variance of Section 54. 13, pertaining to basement
occupancy, to permit continued use of apartment more than S0� below grade ,
because of economic considerations .
APPEARANCE: W.J. Uhlenkott, Art Uhlenkott
PROCEEDINGS : Mr. Uhlenkott stated that all the work orders listed in the
city s letter of 11/8/80 had been completed, with the exception of the
order to discontinue occupancy of the basement unit.
Alice Bijjani confirmed Mr. Uhlenkotts ' statement , noting that provision
had been made for escape in an emergency and all life safety recornmenda-
tions had been fulfilled in a satisfactory manner.
BOARD ACTION: Mr. Glassman moved to grant a variance of Section 54. 13,
pertaining to basement occupancy, to permit continued use of the unit.
Mr. Gausman seconded. MOTION CARRIED AND SO ORDERED.
THE VOTE: Ayes - 4 Nays - 0 Abstentions - 0
-- - -- ------ -- ---- ---
Board member Naibi arrived at this time.
11/18/80 - �leeting No. 167
MINUTES OF THE MEETING
ST. PAUL BOARD OF APPEALS $ REVIEW
Tuesday, November 18 , 1980
City Council Committee Room 707
City Hall an3 Court House
1 : 30 p.m.
MEMBERS PRESENT : Arthur Tieso , Acting Chairman
Estyr B. Peake
Glenn Gausman
A. Wali Naibi
Ron Glassman
ABSENT : D.D. Wozniak, Chairman
Thomas Reiter
AGENCIES PRESENT: Community Services Dept. - Division of Housing
and Building Code Enforcement
A1ice Bijjani
OTHERS PRESENT : Edward Wittenberg Richard A. Nelson
Harry Steinb auer Jerome Wlymcyzk
Tom Kernan W.J. Uhlenkott
Paul W. Larson A.W. Uhlenkott
Leroy L. Meyersen Craig Miller
Beverly Vavoulis Thomas J. McNamara
Mr. � Mrs . Clarence Curley
Shirley Martinek Ann Copeland
STAFF PRESENT: Patricia Moxness
The meeting was called to order by Acting Chairman Tieso at 1 : 50 p.m.
The minutes of the meeting of 10/14/80 were approved as distributed to
the members .
SE N 0. �ROPERTY APPELLANT
34- 80-H . 7th St . Michae ach
(14 units
SUBJECT: Request by St. Paul D' " on ublic Health to add more specific
wo�ing to motion passed eeting of 9/9/8 ubsequently ratified by
City Council (C. F. 16) , as proposed in letter of 0 from William
McCausland.
AF CE : None
_ ., _. _ .... ___ _ ....,�._,._.,..,.._
w.�.w,.,�..�
. _ 2_ 11/18/80 - Meeting No. 167 S
� �
�
. �`�����.
CASE N0. PROPERTY APPELLANT
43- 80-H 1897 Carroll Ave. Clarence J. Curley
(three units)
SUBJECT Request variance of Section 54. 11 , pertaining to basic facilities ,
to permit continued occupancy of two apartments sharing one bathraom,
because of financial considerations .
APPEARANCE : Mr. $ Mrs . Clarence J. Curley
- 3- 11/18/80 - Meeting No. 167
�����':��
PROCEEDINGS : Chairman Tieso noted that two letters had been received
advocating the granting of the requested variance with a limit ont�eeffective
period to the lifetime of the present owners . T he letters had come from
the Nierriam Park Community Council and the Merriam Park Neighborhood
Housing Services organizations .
Mr. Curley said he would not mind the limitation pronosed by the community
groups . He told the board that he and his wife were retired and needed
the income from the two units on the second floor which shared one bath-
room facility.
Ms . Bijjani reported that all remaining work orders listed in the city' s
letter of 9/30/80 had been taken care of except for the insta�lation of
automatic closure devices for smoke doors leading into the kitchen from
the basement. She explained the importance of this requirement.
BOARD ACTION : Mr. Naibi moved to grant a variance of Section 54. I1, per-
taining to basic facilities , to permit continued occupancy of two units
sharing one bathroom, prc�vided that all remaining items in city' s letter of
9/30/80 be taken care of, and provided that no more than four occupants be
permitted to share one bathroom facility , said variance to be effective
for the period of ownership by either Mr. or Mrs . Clarence Curley.
Mr. Gausman seconded. MOTION CARRIED AND SO ORDERED.
THE VOTE: Ayes - 5 Nays - 0 Abstentions - 0
-- - - -- -- -- -- -- -- -- --
11/28/80 - �2eeting No. 167
,
.
MINUTES OF THE MEETING
ST. PAUL BOARD QF APPEALS $ REVIEW
Tuesday, November 18 , 1980
City Council Committee Room 707
City Hall and Court House
1 : 30 p.m.
MEMBERS PRESENT : Arthur Tieso , Acting Chairman
Estyr B. Peake �
Glenn Gausman
A. Wali Naibi
Ron Glassman
ABSENT : D.D. Wozniak, Chairman
Thomas Reiter
AGENCIES PRESENT: Community Services Dept. - Division of Eiousing
and Building Code Enforcement
Alice Bijjani
OTHERS PRESENT : Edward Wittenberg Richaxd A. Nelson
Harry Steinb auer Jerome Wlymcyzk
Tom Kernan W.J. Uhlenkott .
Paul W. Larson A.N. Uhlenkott
Leroy L. Meyersen Craig Miller
Beverly Vavoulis Thomas J. McNamara
Mr. $ Mrs . Clarence Curley
Shirley Martinek Ann Copeland
STAFF PRESENT: Patricia Moxness
The meeting was called to order by Acting Chairman Tieso at 1 :50 p.m.
The minutes of the meeting of 10/14/80 were approved as distributed ta
the members .
CASE N0. �'ROPERTY APPELLANT
/
34- 80-H th St . Mic oach
(14 units)
SUBJECT: ReQuest by St. Pa ivision lic Health to add more specific
wo�Trcing to motion pa at meeting of 9/9/80 an sequentiy ratified by
City Council . 275816) , as proposed in letter of 1 0 from William
McCausla .
EARANCE : None
� -4- 11/18/80 - Meetin� No. 167
�y�����
CASE N0. PROPERTY APPELLANT
45- 80-H 1524 Carroll Ave . Nancy an d Tam Kernan
(two units)
SUBJECT: Request variance of Section 54. 13, pertaining to b asement
occupancy, to permit owner to use room in basement as a bedroom on an
occasional basis for family-visitors , because remodeling costs would be
a financial hardship.
APPEARANCE : Tom Kern an
PROCEEDINGS: Mr. Kernan explained that fie -�ad two children £rom a previous
marriage w o spent every other weekend with him. He therefore needed the
space in the basement , formerly a recreation room, for them to stay ove.r-
night when they visited.
Ms . Bijjani said the mother of the children was concerned about this
arrangement and had asked the Fire Prevention Bureau to inspect it. The
bureau had referred �he matter to the Housing Code Division.
Mr. Kernan proposed to install larger windows that would reach to about
two feet above floor level and construct a windowwell outside it to provide
an escape route. He said he would also apply S/8" sheetrock to the door
into the sleeping ro�m to provide fire separation from the furnace area. �
Mr. Gausman advised that a smoke detector be placed in the area adjacent
to the sleeping room, in addition to the one existing within the room.
BOARD ACTIOV: Mr. Gausman moved to grant a variance of Section 54. 13,
pertaining to basement occupancy, provided that a fire door into the room
from the rest of the basement area be installed, that a smoke detector
be installed in the area adjacent to the sleeping room, and that an escape
�rindow be installed opposite the door to the room, with a sill not more
than 30" above the floor. Mx. Naibi seconded. MOTION CARRIED AND SO
ORDERED.
THE VOTE : Ayes - 5 Nays - 0 Abstentions - Q
11/18/80 - ��I�etin� No. 15?
MINUTES OF THE MEETING
ST. PAUL BOARD OF APPEALS F� REVIEW
Tuesday, November 18 , 1980
City Council Committee Room 707
City Hall and Court House
1 : 30 p.m.
MEMBERS PRESENT : Arthur Tieso , Acting Chairman
Estyr B. Peake
Glenn Gausman
A. Wali Naibi
Ron Glassman
ABSENT : D.D. Wozniak, Chairman
Thomas Reiter
AGENCIES PRESENT: Community Services Dept. - Division of Housing
and Building Code Enforcement
Alice Bijjani --
OTHERS PRESENT: Edward Wittenberg Richard A. Nelson
Harry Steinb auer Jerome Wlymcyzk
Tom Kernan W.J. Uhlenkott
Paul ti9. Larson A.W. Uhlenkott
Leroy L. Meyersen Craig Miller
Beverly Vavoulis Thomas J. McNamara
Mr. $ Mrs . Clarence Curley
Shirley Martinek Ann Copeland
STAFF PRESENT: Patricia Moxness
The meeting was called to order by Acting Chairman Tieso at 1 : 50 p.m.
The minutes of the meeting of 10/14/80 were approved as distributed to
the members .
E N0. �ROPERTY APPELLANT
34- 80-H 95 . h St . Michael Roach
(14 units)
SUBJECT: Request by St. Paul Divis ' lic Health to add more specific
wo�rci g to motion passed at ing of 9/9/80 an uently ratified by
City Council (C. F. , as proposed in letter of 10/9 William
McCausland.
ARANCE : None •
_ .._ � _..4,�..rt ..w,,.�..�.._
' - 5- 11/18/80 - Meeting vo. 167
' �������
CASE N0. PROPERTY . APPELLANT
40- 80-H 42 So. St. Albans Fillmore-Walter Homeowners
(six condominiums) Assoeiation, by Beverly Vavoulis
SUBJECT : Request re-opening hearing on appeal to vary Section 13. 03 , of
the Un form Building Code , pertaining to fire-rated doors , as designated
in city' s letter of 9/16/80 , to permit continued use of wood panel doors
with decorative glass in entrances of all six condominiums , because of
their beauty and compatability iaith architectural style of building.
Prior Hearing 10/14/80 : Motion to grant appeal failed for lack of a
majority vote.
APPEARANCE : Beverly Vavoulis
-6- 11/18/80 - Meeting No. 167
- . - �������
PROCEEDINGS : Mrs . Vavoulis asked that the case be re-opened on the basis
of further details she had provided, namely, a detailed diagram of the
layout of each floor, illustrating the location of the back door� s distance
from the front door in each unit , and showing how all other safety recom-
mendations of the housing code office had been followed, including the
installation of fire extinguishers , smoke alarms , and door closures on
each landing. In addition, she presented a declaration, signed by a11
condominium owners , stating their willingness to accept the risk inherent
in the decorative panelled front doors .
The board agreed to re-open the case • iveeto the�fi.re safetyuoflthe�building.
various aspects of the situation relat
Ms . Bijjani requested the board, if it should consider granting a variance
on the entrance doors , to specify that, if the glass panels should ever
in the future need replacement , a fire-rated door be required, and that
it be so recorded on the deed to be sure that any future owner would be
aware that he was not protected by the normal means .
BOARD ACTION: Mr. Glassman moved to grant a variance of Section 13.03,
o t e Uni orm Building Code , to permit continued use of the present
entrance doors , on condition that, if there should be a need for replace-
ment o£ the doors in the future , a fire-rated door be required; and, fur-
ther, that the variance be recorded on the deed of each condominium to
insure that any future buyer would be aware of the risk inherent to
tenants of the building. A copy of the declaration signed by the tenants
should also be attached to the deed of each condominium. Chairman Tieso
seconded. PdOTION CARRIED AND SO ORDERED.
THE VOTE • Ayes - 4 Nays - 1 (Peake) Abstentions - 0
� . , ��������
_�<os,�e;:�ber 1980
The under�igned� bein� a.l� oi tiie six, fee o�•Tners
livir_� ir_ the si� units of the c�:^ra.:�iniun �uildir_�; �.-t
�.2 �out'� �t. :,lb�ns� here stw-�v that they '-_noc�;ir.gl�* �ssuMe
the ris=� inherent in retentior. of the ori�i.n�.l decorativ�
gl�.ss in the front doors af the?r ur.its� �..:�d s•rillingl��
c�:.00se to do without. the protection of T,�rire—ir.:pre��ated
:fire �?ass.
, � lJ�' "'�'�'
;�1 ���ary ::�. `.�ilson �� I�`'l�'
�, �
�2 ��.aren Grirs��.� �i�(G+';��,,,� � �q,t...S�..�,�
�3 I�i2ry :�nd. I�T�.cho �iaz N �E!�j, �
��� 'r�j� f
��'��.E.�. ���-
�
�`rd,- Bever?� anr�. George �Iwvo � is e � �
1 U J
� 1
,�5 Theo3ora :'�. Aiir� s ' �
,l
;r'-b �enee Yorte C _ j/
� �°��---------,�,�
This ins�ru:�ent *.�as grep�re� by: Subscribed and sworn to
� before me this 1 th ay
�r.,�4�� _` s,v.��.k.�� . . _�.__... November,19 8 0. �,�
1 ��? ' ,
��'�`,�L;:v�.�'.�__1�....1 r'1�t'..�_ tr o y ub '�:c
........�...�..
� �^"� � JEFFREY G. LALlA �
� �..
' r.�Y4'�� NUTAY.Y -Ch[tC•MIhV:�OTk �
� ''�#� RAh1�.Y Cl?Livtr f
� My .ommissio�expira Nov."t9,1y36 +
11/18/30 - �'�ieeting :Jo. 167
MINUTES OF THE MEETING
ST. PAUL BOARD OF APPEALS � REVIEW
Tuesday, November 18 , 1980
City Council Committee Room 707
City Hall and Court House
1 : 30 p.m. -
MEMBERS PRESENT : Arthur Tieso , Acting Chairman
Estyr B. Peake
Glenn Gausman
A. Wali Naibi
Ron Glassman
ABSENT : D.D. Wozniak, Chairman
Thomas Reiter
AGENCIES PRESENT: Community Services Dept. - Division of Housing
and Building Code Enforcement
Alice Bijjani
OTHERS PRESENT: Edward Wittenberg Richard A. Nelson
Harry Steinbauer Jerome Wlymcyzk
Tom Kernan W.J. Uhlenkott
Paul W. Larson A.W. Uhlenkott
Leroy L. Meyersen Craig Miller
Beverly Vavoulis Thomas J. McNamara
Mr. F� Mrs . Clarence Curley
Shirley Martinek Ann Copeland
STAFF PRESENT: Patricia Moxness
The meeting was called to order by Acting Chairman Tieso at 1: 50 p.m.
The minutes of the meeting of 10/14/80 were approved as distributed to
the members .
SE N0. �ROPERTY APPELLANT
34- 80-H th St . ' c ael Roach
(14 units
SUBJECT: Request by St. Division o Health to add more specific
wo�rcing to motion sed at meeting of 9/9/80 and s uently ratified by
City Council . . 275816) , as proposed in letter of 10/9 William
McCausla .
ARANCE • None
_ _ _ ._ _ _ . _. . __ _ _ ... ._. ._ _,_ ... ._.,.s._.�..�.�..,.,,.,�,._
11/18/80 - iLleeting No. 167
r _
MINUTES OF THE MEETING
ST. PAUL BOARD OF APPEALS F� REVIEW
Tuesday, November 18, 1980
City Council Committee Room 707
City Hall and Court House
1 : 30 p.m.
MEMBERS PRESENT : Arthur Tieso , Acting Chairman
Estyr B. Peake
Glenn Gausman
A. Wali Naibi
Ron Glassman
ABSENT : D.D. Wozniak, Cha-irman
Thomas Reiter
AGENCIES PRESENT: Community Services Dept. - Division of Housing
and Building Code Enforcement
Alice Bijjani
OTHERS FRESENT : Edward Wittenberg Richard A. Nelson
Harry Steinb auer Jerome Wlymcyzk
Tom Kernan W.J. Uhlenkott
Paul W. Larson A.W. tThlenkott
Leroy L. Meyersen Craig Mi11er
Beverly Vavoulis Thomas J. McNamara
Mr. � Mrs . Clarence Curley
Shirley Martinek Ann Copeland
STAFF PRESENT: Patricia Moxness
The meeting was called to order by Acting Chairman Tieso at 1 : 50 p.m.
The minutes of the meeting of 10/14/80 were approved as distributed to
the members .
EASE N 0. �ROPERTY APPELLANT
34- 80-H W. 7th St . ael Roach
(14 u
SUBJECT: Request by St. P ' on of Public Health to add more specific
worcTing to motion pa at meeting o 80 and subsequently ratified by
City Council . 275816) , as proposed in le of 10/9/80 from William
McCausla .
EARANCE : None
_ .. . . . ., ,___- -- ,........ ._....._-�.
. - �X+��T3►T A► " • �
���t���
?,�ove:�ber 1980
^he undersigned, 'oein� all oT the six f ee o��.*ners
living in tre sig units of tfle cor_do�-:iniu:n ouildir_z; at
42 �outh at. �lb�.ns� here sta,te t�a�,t the;� '�nos�rirgl�,� a.ssume
the risl� inherent in r�tentiar. of t?�e origi.nal decorative
gZ�ss in the front doors of their ;zr.its� �.nd crillingly
ct;.00se to do �rit��out the pratection of *,vire-ir,:pregr_ated
fire �1_�,ss.
��l Iiary �. r�ilson � __ _ �� �-
��
� .
#2 Kaaren Crims�w� �U�,.� � ��,��
� �3 I��zry �tind I�I�:cho �iaG �/�`� .���`" id • i'�- .�
/�' � �j
V
�'r4 Beverl;r ar_d George �javo �i is ,
`Q .
� U J
�
,�`5 T:�eodore '�. hhre. s
i
,*
�-`b i�enee Porte �� -
�
This ins�rument *.a�,s prepured b�r: Subscribed and sworn to
before me this 1 th ay
�,`' 1 � �� November,1980. /,
�,,;=-� _ .;�:z., --,. -- . . __.___.._ ,� /.
1 . � ,
��a����-:.1._._ 1 H �.��L� ` o y ub 'ic '
_._..("
. : �'_� �, JEFFREY G. CALLA �
.,..
• r�y��� 1kUiAV.� �l:5UC•fA1;.N:50iA
i �° �� RAr.�';_r COU�.Tr
�
� My .�mmissioi expires Nov. 19,ly 36
� �......«.�....