The URL can be used to link to this page

276182 WHITE - CITY CLERK CAI�ARY -' DEPA TMENT COUIICII r �` �,.D'� �91�+ BLUE - MAYOR G I T Y O F SA I N T PA U L File N��'�.��1�/ � ' Resolution � Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date WF�REAS, The Cotmcil of the City of Sa.int Paul by Council Resolution C.F. 276081, adapted Deaember 16, 1980, and approved on Dec�nber 18, 1980 did approve the action of the St. Paul Board of P,ppeals and Review with respect to th� public hear- ing held on November 18, 1980; and WI�REAS, sai.d resolution contained. errors whiclz shpuld be corrected.. NOW TI-�REE'ORE BE IT RESOLVED, That Cot�cil Resolution C.F. 276081, adapted December 16, 1980, and approved on Deoember 18, 1980 is hexeby rescinded and is re- plac:ed in lieu thereof by this resolution. BE IT FUR'I��R RESOLVID, That the Council of the City of 5aint Paul hereby certifies and approves the action of the City of St. Paul Board of Appeals and Review pertaining to the follawing listed property and as shown by the Exoerpted Minut�es of said Board of Appeals and Review, dated Novc�nber 18, 1980, and marked E�i�IT A, which is herein incorporated. by referenoe. DATE OF BOARD MINUI'ES CASE NO. PROPIIZTY APPELIANI' 11/18/80 34-80-H 951 W. 7th St. Michael Roach (14 tmits) BoA,RD ACTI�: �renc7�d Council File 275816, wherein varianoe was granted tA permit occupancy of six dwelling tmits, to designat� room rnunbers of those Lmits affected, as follaws: Room Nos. 5-7, 11-12, 14-15, 16-17, 21-22, and 24-25. Property Description: Stinson's Subdivision of Block 25 of Stinson, Brawn and Ramsey's Addition, '.Lots 10 and 11, Block 25 COUNCILMEN Yeas Nays Requestgd by Department of: Hunt Levine [n Favor Maddox McMahon B Showalter - __ Agai[ISt Y Tedesco �Iwn Form Approved by City Attorney Adopted by Council: Date — Certified Yassed by Council Secretary B ~ � � Bv -- Approved by ;Nayor: Date _ Appcoved by Mayor for Submission to Council By _ – BY . � . �t��2 11/18/80 42-80-H 529 Portland Ave. W. J. Uhlenkott (four units) BQARD ACTI�t: Grant�ed variance of St. Paul Legislative Code, Section 54.13, pertaining to bas�nent occ�ancy, to pe.rnut contin�d occupancy of bas��t Lmit nx�re than 50� belaw grade. Property Description: Auditor's Subdivision No. 11. Subject to Eas�.nts, W. 10 Ft. of Lot 16 and all of Lot 15, Block 18 11/18/80 43-8-H 1897 Carroll Av�. Clarence J. C�irley (three tuiits) gpARD AGTI�T: Granted variance of St. Paul Legislative Code, Section 54.11, pertaining tA basic facilities, tA pernlit oocupancy of two lmits sharing one bathroo�n facility, on condition �hat all mn,a;ni�g itams listed in city's lettrer of 9/30/80 be �leted and that occupancy of said units be limited to four persons; said variance to be effective only for the period of awnership by Mr. and/or Mrs. Clarence J. Curley. Property Description: Merriam Park Lot 10, Block 14 11/18/80 45-80-H 1524 Carroll Ave. Nancy & Tcan Kernan (two tmits) Bpp,RD A�TI�t; Granted variance of St. Paul Legislative Code, Section 54.13, pertaining to bas�nent occupancy, tA ��;t use of sleeping rocens more than 50$ belaw grade, on condition that: (1) a smoke door be provic�d lea.ding into the sleeping room, (2) a srbke det�ctor be installed in area iirmediately adjacent to the bedrocen, and (3) an escape windaw be installed opposite the door of the sleep- ing roan, with a sill no more than thirty (30) inches above floor level. Property Description: Adams Addition to the City of St. Paul, Ipt 5, Block 2 -2- -=-�5 /- 8�/ __._ , �l�� 11/18/80 40-80-H 42 So. St. Albans Fillmore-Walter (six cnndcaniniians) Condominiimn Associatian BOARD ACTION: Granted variance of Minnesota. Unifo�n Bui.lding Code, Article 13.03, pertaining t�o use of fire rated materials, to permi.t c�ntinued occ�aricy of six conclomi.ni�n wzits, each equipped with front entrance doors which do not ��ly with fire-safety code requir��ts after having received a signed waiver, a capy of which is marked as E�BIT B and herein incorporat�ed by refer- ence, by the conduninitan c�+mers aclazawledging and assuni.ng the risks created by this yariance. Variance is granted on condi- tion that any future replacenent. of said doors must meet code; said variance tA be recorded on deed of each oondominitun unit placing future purchasers � not�-oe of the variance granted herein and th�e restrictions related th�reto. This variance is al- so c�difia.oi�cl t�on the Hanc.-�zers Association posting a copy of this resolution for two weeks in a oonspicv,ous and ooniron area of the condominitun cam�lex. Property Description: Stmtit Park Additian Apartznent Ownership No. 25 Knawn as Fillnx�re and Walter Condcanini�ns, Being W. 30 Ft. of Lot 15 and All of Lot 14, Block l, Sumlit Park Additian Apartm�it Nos. 1B, 2B, 3B, 4B, 5B and FaB, and an Undivided 1/12 11/18/80 SO-80-H 420 Hersch�l St. Paul W. Iarson (five tu�its) " gpARp A�.`I'IC�T; Granted varianoe of St. Paul Legisla.tive Code, Section 54.11, pertaj.riirig tr� basic facilities, to pern�it occupancy of apart- ment where handsink is located outsid,e t�oilet/shawer room. Property Description: Lovering's Addition. Lot 26, Block 1 -3- -�A� /-c��'/ WMITE - CITY CLERK PIN7C - FINANCE f ' CANARY � DEPARTMENT COUIICII l�� BLUE - MAYOR GITY OF SAINT F�AUL File NO. � � Council Resolution Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date and be it FURTf�R RESOLVID, That the City Clerk is hereby authorized and directed tc� transmit a copy of this resolution fo recording t� the i�nsey Co�ty Office of th�e Register of Deeds. -4- COUNCILMEN Yeas Nays Requestgd by Department of: Hunt Levine In Favo[ Maddox McMahon B snowa�ter � __ Against Y Tiwk.es �I JAN 13 1g8� Form Approved by City Attorney Adopte y Coun il: Date C ified Y• - ed by Cou .il Secre ry . � �� ♦ B� App b 1�lavor. t �AN t-� 1��1 Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council By – — BY �� JA�J 2 � 1981 . . -. � ,��t �� :;� , . . f - - � � . - , - , r , , , - � i Jaauarq 16, 1981 . , , , -- • , . , , ; ' .,; • . - `- . � _ �. . - , , � - _ , , - . _ � Co�mtq �Lecarder � " .- � , � R�oom 15S `_ , , - � Buildin� , � _ � -; _� `; Deiar Sir: , - _ . . , _ ; . ` I �leo�a f�r fillug in yrnir cffice a,aopy of Couacil File' No. 276182. - � _ � - , Very t�ly.yours, . - - ,- �� ._ � ' . , �� ^'__ __-��'J +--�' _ - Ro�e�Mia ,•� . ' . City Clexk � - .�lttach. � - - . _ , sch ' - . - , � , - . - , , , - \ . � " <_ ._ . _ , _ , � . , � � �. . _ _ ; , . - _ . . - - � . ��:- , - S- 11/18/80 - Nleeting No. 167 ;�1�.�t�� CASE N0. PROPERTY . APPELLANT 40- 80-H 42 So. St. Albans Fillmore-Walter Homeowners (six condominiums) Association, by. Beverly Vavoulis SUBJECT : Request re-opening hearing on appe al to vary Section 13.03 , of the Uniform Building Code , pertaining to fire-rated doors , as designated in city' s letter of 9/16/80 , to permit continued use of wood p anel doors with decorative glass in entrances of all six condominiums , because of their beauty and compatability with architectural style of building. Prior Hearing 10/14/80 : Motion to grant appeal failed for lack of a majority vote. APPEARANCE : Beverly Vavoulis - 6- 11/18/80 - �leeting No . 167 . PROCEEDINGS : Mrs . Vavoulis asked that the case be re-opened on the basis of further details she had provided, namely, a detailed diagram of the layout of each floor, illustrating the location of the back door' s distance from the front door in each unit, and showing how all other safety recom- mendations of the housing code office had been followed, including the installation of fire extinguishers , smoke alarms , and door closures on each landing. In addition, she presented a declaration, signed by all condominium owners , stating their willingness to accept the risk inherent in the decorative panelled front doors . The board agreed to re-open the case . There followed a discussion of �he various aspects of the situation relative to the fire safety of the building. Ms . Bijjani requested the board, if it should consider granting a variance on the entrance doors , to specify that, if the glass panels should ever in the future need replacement , a fire-rated door be required, and that it be so recorded on the deed to be sure that any future owner would be aware that he was not protected by the normal means . BOARD ACTION: Mr. Glassman moved to grant a variance of Section 13. 03, o t e Uni orm Building Code , to permit continued use of the present entrance doors , on condition that, if there should be a need for replace- ment of the doors in �he future , a fire-;rated door be required; and, fur- ther, that the variance be recorded on the deed of each condominium to insure that any future buyer would be awa�e -�of the risk inherent to tenants of the building. A copy of the declaration signed by the tenants should also be attached to the deed of each condominium. Chairman Tieso seconded. MOTION CARRIED AND SO ORDERED. THE VOTE : Ayes - 4 Nays - 1 (Peake) Abstentions - 0 =:`ovembar 1980 ^he undersigneci, beiY�; �11 0_ tize six iee a:-?ners livir_� in the si� unit� of the co^c?o�~:inium '�u?ldi?�L; a•t �2 �out4? �-E. fi?ba.nU� here st��e th.at t'�ey '_�r.o?�rir_gl�• assuMe the ris?� inherent in r�tenticr_ of t�?e original decor�.tiva glz.ss in the fro�.-� doors of tll�ir ur:its� �rd FrilZingl�= c��oose to do s�riti�out tne �rotection of s�rire—z.r�nr�gr_ated fil ° ��!�s. r�l ��;2.x'y ;::;. `�.'i 1 s o�z � W�(�'l/L- �� , ` ,�2 r aa^en Grirs�c�.d �� LI � �f.LS tti-�C.� �'3 I�i2,i�r u.110. i'fuG�lO �lc:.� �� /,_ _ /� �-� /��,� 1? / �/�J �i�� 0� �i �V �r�- �everl�r ar_d Geor�^� jravo ,?i.s (� � 1 '1 ' /t \1�4.�� , S �{�j i � � J ;;'S 1lzeodora _,. hhr�� s � ' �� . Tb ?enee Porte C . ��, � �� This in��ru�ent T�,as �re��red b;�: 5ubscribed and sworn to � , before me this 1 th ay i�_�,1 ^�r�J�� . M1��_ November,19 8 4. � y `1-� `7 � t ��,�� l �� `�,� �-. , � .�.._._._. ��:1�1.T._..�. �c�.� o y ub 'ic � . � :�" �- JEFFREY G. LALLA � .,. ' r__, � WUSAY.1 •U6Ci:•MIf.NE�OiA � i =6��••. RAh1,-T 40V�•IY ' i /�y .omm�ssion expiros tdov. "L4,ti36 �.�.r..-...�� 11/18/80 - �leeting �o. I67 MINUTES OF THE MEETING ST. PAUL BOARD OF APPEALS � REVIEW Tuesday, November 18 , 1980 City Council Committee Room 707 City Hall and Court House 1 : 30 p.m. MEMBERS PRESENT : Arthur Tieso , Acting Chairman . Estyr B. Peake Glenn Gausman A. Wali Naibi Ron Glassman ABSENT: D.D. Wozniak, Chairman Thomas Reiter AGENCIES PRESENT: Community Services Dept. - Division of Housing and Building Cod� Enforcement Al.ice Bij jani � �`� OTHERS PRESENT : Edward Wittenberg Richard A. Nelson Harry Steinb auer Jerome Wlymcyzk Tom Kernan W.J. Uhlenkott Paul W. Larson A.W. Uhlenkott � Leroy L. Meyersen Craig Miller Beverly Vavoulis Thomas J. McNamara Mr. � Mrs . Clarence Curley Shirley Martinek Ann Copeland STAFF PRESENT: Patricia Moxness The meeting was called to order by Acting Chairman Tieso at 1 :50 p.m. The minutes of the meeting of 10/14/80 were approved as distributed to the members . CASE N0. �ROPERTY APPELLANT 34- 80-H 951 W. 7th St . Michael Roach (14 units) SUBJECT: Request by St. Paul Division of Public Health to add more specific wor� ing to motion passed at meeting of 9/9/80 and subsec{uently ratified by City Council (C. F. 275816) , as proposed in letter of 10/9/80 from William McCausland. APPEARANCE : None ,_ .__. __ _ ___ ..__ _ _ ._._--__ ..m_. ._ _...._,�..r..�r_..,..,,„.�. , � �X l� � (31 T � _��ove:�ber I;��;C� ^he undersi€ned, '�ain� ^11 0? t��e six_ iee or,ners i ivir_� ir_ tY:e si� t�ni.ts of the co•r_�Ao�^ini.u:ri i�uildi-r_�; at _ �2 �out'_� ;�t. ;1.b�ns, here �t�,�� trat t'?ey �no�<;ir_�1�� ssurn° the r�s?L inherent in r�tentiar of t�e ori�a.nal decor�tiv� �la.ss in -�he fron� doors of treir urits� �.�d �•rillingly c.�oose -to do �ritl�out t's�e 3�rot.ecticn of s�rire—irnnr��•r_�ted � fire �?ass. , ,l , �� a�j/L !l I'�i2�`�r :;�. :'T1.?S O?2 � � V' C� r� r / "�' ' YrG T_�^.?i?Tl CI'1Ti'�S Lc.� �� ,�' /. -r a .�(,� 73 i<:�.r�- s��.nd ITt�,cho �i�� s��..� s��'.��`" �!� � � J � ;jr4 iever?�r ar_�z ireorg� �r-a JOl' is (� , , � ' , . \J � � i ;r5 l.zeodora �. i�h?'�: s � � rb �enee Porte �� , �� J ,'"-�, This ins�ru^�ent �-;as pre;�.�.red ��r: Subscribed and sworn to , before me this 1 th ay �; � � �� November,1980. _._...__l�d''� � �, . . . . -%7 j �� 1y:.�v,,� ��1 ��.��}_ o y ub 1 i:c' `r -•''"� JEFFREIf G. LALLA � � .,. . • �-. NG1Ar.� .U5[tG-rtilhN.SJiA � =�� RAr.,;.� c.e�,�rr c � MY ��mmission expires Nov.29,IS36 ' ...�..,�.�, 11/18/80 - hieeting No. Iti7 � '= XN �Q �7 A . � , --, � �� MINUTES OF THE MEETING ST. PAUL BOARD OF APPEALS � REVIEW Tuesday, November 18 , 1980 City Council Committee Room 707 City Hall and Court House 1 : 30 p.m. MEMBERS PRESENT: Arthur Tieso , Acting Chairman Estyr B. Peake Glenn Gausman A. Wali Naibi Ron Glassman ABSENT : D.D. Wozniak, Chairman Thomas Reiter AGENCIES PRESENT: Community Services Dept. - Division of Housing and Building Code Enforcement Alice Bijjani OTHERS PRESENT: Edward tiYittenberg Richard A. Nelson Harry Steinbauer Jerome Wlymcyzk Tom Kernan W.J. Uhle�nkott Paul W. Lars on A.W. tihlenkott Leroy L. Meyersen Craig Miller Beverly Vavoulis Thomas J. McNamara Mr. � Mrs . Clarence Curley Shirley Martinek Ann Copeland STAFF PRESENT: Patricia Moxness The meeting was called to order by Acting Chairman Tieso at 1 : 50 p.m. The minutes of the meeting of 10/14/80 were approved as distri.buted to the members . CASE N0. �ROPERTY APPELLANT 34- 80-H 951 W. 7th St . Michael Roach (14 units) SUBJECT: Request by St. Paul Division of Public Health to add more specific wor i�ng-to motion passed at meeting of 9/9/80 and subsequently ratified by City Council (C. F. 275816) , as proposed in letter of 10/9/80 from �Villiam McCausland. APPEARANCE : None .... ...... .._. ._. .. ... .. . .. . . .. . . . .. ........ .._.. .. . .:, . .,. .. . ._._. . .. _ ..... . . .. .._. .,..-...___..-.�.._ma...,....w..___.,,�--.:r<... , . _Z_ � 11/18/80 - Meeting Ajo. 167 PROCE�DINGS : Chairman Tieso called attention to the HeaZth Department's written request that the room numbers of the units affected by the variance granted on 9/9J80 be listed in the resolution. BOARD ACTION: Mr. Glassman moved to amend the resolution passed on � 0 an later approved by the City Council in Council File 275816 to specify that the variance applied specifically to the following six two- xoom sleeping units : Room #5- 7, Room #11-12 , Room #14- 15 , Room #16-17, Room #21-22 and Room #24-25. Mrs . Peake seconded. MOTION CARRIED AND SO ORDERED. THE VOTE: Ayes - 4 Nays - 0 Abstentions - 0 . _2_ 11/18/80 - Meeting No. I67 ��rb1�� CASE N0. PROPERTY APPELLANT 42- 80-H 529 Portland Ave. W. J. Uhlenkott (four units) SUBJECT : Request variance of Section 54. 13, pertaining to basement occupancy, to permit continued use of apartment more than SOo below grade , because of economic considerations . APPEARANCE : W.J. Uhlenkott , Art Uhlenkoft -�-- PROCEEDINGS : Mr. Uhlenkott stated that all the work orders listed in the city s letter of 11/8/80 had been completed, with the exception of the order to discontinue occupancy of the basement unit. Alice Bijjani confirmed Mr. Uhlenkotts ' statement , noting that provision had been made for escape in an emergency and all life safety recommenda- tions had been fulfilled in a satisfactory manner. BOARD ACTION: Mr. Glassman moved to grant a variance of Se�ction 54. 13, pertaining to basement occupancy, to permit continued use af the unit. Mr. Gausman seconded. MOTION CARRIED AND SO ORDERED. THE VOTE : Ayes - 4 Nays - 0 Abstentions - 0 Board member Naibi arrived at this time. - -- -- -- ---- -- -- -- --- 11/18/80 - hleeting No. 157 . MINUTES OF THE MEETING 5T. PAUL BOARD OF APPEALS $ RBVIEW Tuesday, November 18, 1980 City Council Committee Room 707 City Hall and Court House 1 : 30 p.m. MEMBERS PRESENT: Arthur Tieso , Acting Chairman Estyr B. Peake Glenn Gausman A. Wali Naibi Ron Glassman ABSENT : D.D. Wozniak, Chairman Thomas� Reiter AGENCIES PRESENT: Community Services Dept. - Division of Housing and Building Code Enforcement Alice Bi j j ani �`Y OTHERS PRESENT: Edward Wittenberg Richard A. Nelson Harry Steinb auer Jerome Wlymcyzk Tom Kernan W.J. Uhlenkott Paul W. Larson A.W. Uhlenkott Leroy L. Meyersen Craig Mi11er Beverly Vavoulis Thomas J. McNamara � Mr. � Mrs . Clarence Curley Shirley Martinek Ann Copeland STAFF PRESENT: Patricia Moxness The meeting was called to order by Acting Chairman Tieso at 1:50 p.m. The minutes of the meeting of 10/14/80 were approved as distributed to the members . CASE N0. �ROPERTY APPELLANT 34- 80-H 951 W. 7th St . Michael Roach (14 units) SUBJECT: Request by St. Paul Division of Public Health to add more specific wor�ing to motion passed at meeting of 9/9/80 and subsequently ratified by City Council (C. F. 275816) , as proposed in letter of 10/9/80 from Williain McCausland. APPEARANCE : None __ _ _._ _ _ .. _ . _ _ _. . _ __ �_.._ ____ __. ._ � .. _ ___._.._,.,,._._.,�..,-.�...- t _ 2_ 11/18/80 - 1�leeting No. 167 ; i .. :��ul�S� CASE N0. PROPERTY APPELLANT 43- 80-H 1897 Carroll Ave. Clarence J. Curley (three units) SUBJECT : Rec{uest variance of Section 54. 11 , pertaining to basic facilities , to permit continued occupancy of two apartments sharing one bathroom, because of financial considerations . APPEARANCE : Mr. $ Mrs . Clarence J. Curley - 3- 11/18/80 - �leetino No. I67 � PROCEEDINGS : Chairman Tieso noted that two letters had been received advocating the granting of the requested variance with a limit ont�eeffective period to the lifetime of the present owners . T he letters had come fram the Nierriam Park Community Council and the Merriam Park Neighborhood Housing Services organizations . Mr. Curley said he would not mind the limitation pronosed by the community groups . He told the board that he and his wife were retired and needed the income from the two units on the second floor which shared one bath- room facility. Ms . Bijjani reported that all remaining work orders listed in the city' s letter of 9/30/80 had been taken care of except for the installation of automatic closure devices for smoke doors leading into the kitchen from the basement. She explained the importance of this requirement. BOARD ACTION: Mr. Naibi moved to grant a variance of Section 54. 11,, per- taining to basic facilities , to permit continued occupancy of two units sharing one b athroom, provided th at all. remaining items in city' s letter of 9/30/80 be taken ca� of, and provided that no more than four occupants be permitted to share one bathroom facility , said variance to be effective for the period of ownership by either Mr. or Mrs . Clarence Curley. Mr. Gausman seconded. MOTION CARRIED AND SO ORDERED. THE VOTE: Ayes - 5 Nays - 0 �` Abstentions - 0 -- - - -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- 11/18/80 - �Ieetina No. 167 , . . MIiVUTES OF THE MEETING ST. PAUL BOARD OF APPEALS � REVIEW Tuesday, November 18 , 1980 City Council Committee Room 707 City Hall and Court House 1 : 30 p.m. ME�IBERS PRESENT : Arthur Tieso , Acting Chairman Estyr B. Peake Glenn Gausman A. Wali Naibi Ron Glassman ABSENT: D.D. Wozniak, Chairman Thomas Reiter AGENCIES PRESENT: Community Services Dept. - Division of Housing and Building Code Enforcement Alice Bijjani �`� OTHERS PRESENT : Edward Wittenberg Richard A. Nelson Harry Steinbauer Jerome Wlymcyzk Tom Kern an W.J. Uhlenkott Paul W. Larson A.W. Tihlenkott Leroy L. Meyersen Craig Miller Beverly Vavoulis Thomas J. McNamara Mr. � Mrs . Clarence Curley Shirley Martinek Ann Copeland STAFF PRESENT: Patricia Moxness The meeting was called to order by Acting Chairman Tieso at 1 : 50 p.m. The minutes of the meeting of 10/14/80 were approved as distributed to the members . CASE N0. �ROPERTY APPELL.ANT 34- 80-H 951 W. 7th St . Michael Roach (14 units) SUBJECT: Request by St. Paul Division of Public Health to add more specific wo�to motion passed at meeting of 9/9/80 and subsequently ratified by City Council (C. F. 275816) , as proposed in letter of 10/9/80 from tiVilliam McCausland. APPEARANCE : None " -4- 11/18/80 - Meeting No. Y67 �`�� CASE N0. PROPERTY APPELLANT 45- 80-H 1524 Carroll Ave . Nancy and Tom Kernan (two units) SUBJECT: Request variance of Section 54. 13, pertaining to basement occupancy, to permit owner to use room in basement as a bedroom on an occasional basis for family visitors , because remodeling costs would be a financial hardship. APPEARANCE : Tom Kern an PROCEEDINGS : Mr. Kernan explained that he had two children from a previous marriage w o spent every other weekend with him. He therefore needed the space in the basement , formerly a recreation room, for them to stay over- night when they visited. Ms . Bijjani said the mother of the children was concerned about this arrangement and had asked the Fire Prevention Bureau to inspect it . The bureau had referred the matter to the Housing Code Division. Mr. Kernan proposed to install larger windows that would reach to abaut two feet above floor level and construct a windowwell outside it to provide an escape route. He said he would also apply 5/8" sheetrock ta the door into the sleeping room to provide fire separation from the furnace area. Mr. Gausman advised that a smoke detector be placed in the area ad}acent to the sleeping room, in addition to the one existing within the room. BOARD ACTION: Mr. Gausman moved to grant a variance of Section 54. 13, pertaining to basement occupancy, provided that a fire door into the room from the rest of the basement area be installed, that a smoke detector be installed in the area adjacent to the sleeping room, and that an escape window be installed opposite the door to the room, with a sill not more than 30" above the floor. Mr.. Naibi seconded. MOTION CARRIED AND SO ORDERED. THE VOTE : Ayes - 5 Nays - 0 Abstentions - 0 11/18/80 - i,leeting No. 167 , MINUTES OF THE MEETING ST. PAUL BOARD OF APPEALS $ REVIEW Tuesday, November 18 , 1980 City Council Committee Room 707 City Hall and Court House 1 : 30 p.m. MEbIBERS PRESENT : Arthur Tieso , Acting Chairman Estyr B. Peake Glenn Gausman A. Wali Naibi Ron Glassman ABSENT : D.D. Wozniak, Chairman Thomas Reiter AGENCIES PRESENT: Community Services Dept. - Division of Housing and Building Code Enforcement Alice Bijjani OTHERS PRESENT : Edward Wittenberg Richard A. Nelson Harry Steinb auer Jerome Wlymcyzk Tom Kernan W.J. Uhlenkott Paul W. Larson A.W. Uhlenkott Leroy L. Meyersen Craig Miller Beverly Vavoulis Thomas J. McNamara Mr. $ Mrs . Clarence Curley Shirley Martinek Ann Copeland STAFF PRESENT: Patricia Moxness . The meeting was called to order by Acting Chairman Tieso at 1: 50 p.m. The minutes of the meeting of 10/14/80 were approved as distributed to the members . CASE N0. �ROPERTY � APPELLANT , 34- 80-H 951 W. 7th St . Michael Roach � (14 units) � SUBJECT: Request by St. Paul Division of Public Health to add more specific wo�i g to motion passed at meeting of 9/9/80 and subsequently ratified by City Council (C. F. 275816) , as proposed in letter of 10/9/80 from William McCausland. APPEARANCE : None _ _ .. , _ »_._--_-�---..-T,�.-. , - 7- 11/18/80 - Meeting No. 167 �� CASE N0. PROPERTY APPELLA1vT SO- 80-H 420 Herschel St . Pau1 W. Larson and (five units) Leroy L. Peterson SUBJECT: Request variance of Section 54. 11 , pertaining to basic facilities , to pe m t handsink outside toilet-shower room, because of practical difficulty. APPEARANCE : Paul W. Larson PROCEEDINGS : Mr. Larson stated that his firm was completely redoing the property an had installed bathrooms in a11 five units . However, in one of the units there was no space for a handsink, so they ha�d put in a vanity just outside the bathroom. Ms . Bijjani reported that mos � of the work on the building had been inspected and approved. She said that many bathrooms in new construction were set up in this manner and, since this was not a case where a kitchen sink had to serve as a substitute for a bathroom handsink , there was no objection to such an arrangement. Chairman Tieso said that Merriam Park Community Council had written a letter to the board stating that they approved the granting of a variance in this case. BOARD ACTION : Mr. Glassman moved to grant a variance of Section 54. 11, to permit occupancy of an apartment where the bathroom handsink was located outside of the bathroom facility. Mr. Naibi seconded. MOTION CARRIED AND SO ORDERED. � THE VOTE : Ayes - 5 Nays - 0 Abstentions - 0 11/18/80 - 14eeting No. 157 � � �G /�.�� -___� MINUTES OF THE MEETING ST. PAUL BOARD OF APPEALS � REVIEW Tuesday, November 18 , 1980 City Council Committee Room 707 City Hall and Court House 1 : 30 p.m. MEMBERS PRESENT : Arthur Tieso, Acting Chairman Estyr B. Peake Glenn Gausman A. Wali Naibi Ron Glassman ABSENT: D.D. Wozniak, Chairman Thomas Reiter AGENCIES PRESENT: Community Services Dept. - Division of Housing and Building Code Enforcement Alice Bi j j ani �`� OTHERS PRESENT : Edward Wittenberg Richard A. Nelson Harry Steinbauer Jerome ti9lymCyzk � Tom Kernan W.J. Uhlenkott Paul W. Larson A.W. Uhlenkott Leroy ,L. Meyersen Craig Miller Beverly Vavoulis Thomas J. McNamara Mr. $ Mrs . Clarence Curley Shirley Martinek Ann Copeland STAFF PRESENT: Patricia Moxness The meeting was called to order by Acti�g Chairman Tieso at 1: 50 p.m. The minutes of the meeting of 10/14/80 were approved as distributed to the members . CASE N0. �ROPERTY APPELLANT 34- 80-H 951 W. 7th St . Michael Roach (14 units) SUBJECT: Rec{uest by St. Paul Division of Public Health to add more specific wor ing to motion passed at meeting of 9/9/80 and subseQuently ratified by City Council (C. F. 275816) , as proposed in letter of 10/9/80 from William M�Causland. APPEARANCE : None �. �� b •� I �� STAT� 0� MINN�SOTA ) � Coun,ty os Rameey ) ad. � CITy 0� SAIN7 PALIL ) � �j Rose Mix: .�� T, . ... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . o� �'he Ci.ty ob Scr„i..n,t Pau,2, M.i.nneao�a., do he�ce6y ceh.ti.�y zha,t I have compcviced �'he ai',t.a.ched copy o� Caunc.i.2 F.i.ee No.?�6182 . . aa adop�ed by �he C.i�y Counci,2 ,,January.l3: .. .. . . , , . . . ��1 . . and a�pnoved by �h.e Mayon . . , , ,, ,January.l5: .. .. .. .. , . . 1981 . . w�.#h �he ar,i.g�.na,e �heneo� on �.i.ee �.n my o��.ice. � .:. . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . .. . . . . .. . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . ^ � „� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . �� N . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . � � • • . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . CTZ . . . . . . . . . . . • . . . . . . . . . . .� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . ... . . . . . . . . . i +T� -7'Q • � • • • • • � • � • � • • • • • •• • . • • • • • � • . • � • • • • • . • � • • • • • • • • . • • • • . • • • • • . • . � . � • . • .. . . . . . . . • • . • . . • . • . . . . • . . . •. • . . . . • . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . � - . . . . . . . . . . . .. .• .. . . .. . . . . . . • . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . • • . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . • . . . . . .. .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . • . . . .. . . • . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . •. . . . . • ., . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . • .. .. . . . . . . . . . . . . • • . . • . . .. . � . . • • . . . . . .. . . . . • . . . . . • . . . . . . • . . . • • . • .. . • . . . . I �w�'he�c centi.�y �hcr.t aa.id copy .i,s a �tcue and ca�vice.c,t copy °�� _ ` o� 6 cr,i,d on,i.g.i,vi.a.0 and �he who.�e �heh.eo S. r � ,, � �;.. � '.` '`��y' V wI TN�SS my hand and �he e ea.e o� �he Ci�y o� Scci.r►,t Pau,e, � �� 5y 1�: , r�, �,z, '/- �.I- , 15th J_ ` Ja ary .A.,�. �981 �,. .., y..�� .;�,r., IW(.{�.h.• �L7LCA . �. • . . �. UU./� �U.. ..�. . • . . . . • . . . . . • . . . .. . . .r< �* t�}��{ ,� � �,,,,..�. ..�. G: ' . . . .J. .G.'. .�. . . .. . . . . .. . . . . . . . . � Y Vlit.� 4L K• � 7b3� �$ 0 Q::Q 0 — A WMITE�� - CITY CLERK � � PINK - . FINANCE �� i .tANARY - DEPARTM6NT G I TY O F SA I NT PA LT L Council BLUL+' � - MAYOR � - - . , ._ , - - -— _ File N 0. �, . : Council Resolution Presented By � . - � Referred To Committee: Date. Out of Committee By Date �r '� DOw�dI o! t8s Citp G�` l3�it P�, by C7oaa�2 Pesolutf+aat C.F. .Z�6tt81� a�dc�d D�o�ml�e� 1B� 198Q, �1 a�p[�d CR D�o�eaC lS� 1980 dLd a�sv� tl'le a�ctf�aa o�! tbs St. PaulBoa�od o� ]1�xr�]s aad �v3er rith �ct b� ti�e p�a13c ha�r- ' fag 3�eld cn � 18, I980f aod ' �S, ',�aid smcaiut3on acntaf�eci � � ehoy2d bi aaaraa�cb�d. " b1Q+t � BB TT R�.VBl, �s! Q�il l�esoit�d,oa C.P. 2�6081, adr�bed Deoa�est 16, 1981}, a�d a�p�a�cl cn Dao��be�r 1�, 14SQ is I�a�eby z�esGinci�d aaad 3s z�e�- p2acaed in I3��u � by t-hfs zeso6lt�ti��on. e� IT � �.YEa, '�at �et Coa�Cil of �ae CYtp o! Sa1nt P�tl l�re?�y ceztifies and � tt� actiron o� the Citg o� St. P�I Boerd o+i �tppeal9 a�yr3 Re�vigw b� tbe �o1l,a+ing listaci pac�ty and as sh�aa� 2�y the Daoe�pbed Mfn�a ot ssta aoara of �ts a�a �evs�., aa�ea �o�+�,c is, ssao, afla �r�ea �rr �,, � is he�esn suvocpo�at�ed b� r�. '� � 0!' B�f� � � � � AP�LAt� � C7� . !C 12,/18�80 34-� 951 K. 7th S't. , l�hael Aoach � tla mits� Bt�►liD X��: �m�cied �1 Fi�a 275816, �d�eta variarioo wes granbed b� pexarit ooca}�r�c.y o� ais dwellir�g vait�, i�a d�sf�gaats rood rn�rs � t�a mi.ts af�ectbd, as Satla+s: tir�os�a�s. S�7, II-12, 1t--15, 1�-17, 2I-22, and 24-25. PrcpmacttY D,ecrfpti,on: S'tfa�ean's St�bdivfsicn cT Bl�oc'!t 25 of 8'tis�aa, Hroaat aad Fa�ey's �it�on, -I�at� lb aod 11, B�c�Ic 25 COUNCILMEN . Requestgd by Department of: Yeas Nays Hunt Levine IIl FBVOf Nleddox �i� Against BY Tadesoo wi�� Adopted by Council: Date Form Approved by City Attorney Certified Passed by Council Secretary BI"��`��`�" �� gy, . Approved by Ylavor: Date App�oved by Mayor for Submission to Council By _ By , � � ).�' f y.. ' i. . . ��d'} . /G� , � 11/18/80 42-80-H 529 Portland Ave. W. J. Uhlenkott (four �its) BC�RD AC.TICN: Granted varianoe of St. Paul Legislativ�e Code, Section 54.13, pP�.a i n�g to basHt�ent o�upanCy, t�o permit cantinued occ�ncY � of bas�it. imit nx�re than 50$ belvw grade. Praperty Description: A�ditor's Subdivision No. 11. Subject to Easgrents, W. 10 Ft. of Lot 16 and all of Lot 15, Block 18 ll� ------------- -------��_ � � 11/18/80 43-8-H 1897 Carroll Ave. Clarence J. Clarley �' (three units) � �"� � BQARD ACTICi�i: Granted variance of St. Paul Legislative Code, Secti� 54.11, pertauzing t�o basic facilities, to permit occupancy of two imits sharing one bathroan facility, � condition that all mmaininq itens listed in city's letter of 9/30/80 be �let�ed - and that occ-�x-�ncy of said i.mits be limit�ed to four persons; said variance to be effective �ly for tt� period of ownership by Mr. and/or Mrs. Clarenae J. Curley. ' praperty Description: Merriam Park • Lot 10, Block 14 11/18/80 45-80-H 1524 Carroll Ave. Nancy & Tan Kernan (t�ro im.its) BOARD AC.TICIV: Granted variance of St. Paul Legislative Code, Sectian 54.13, pertaining to basa�it oa.-upancy, to permit use of sleeping rocn�s mr�re than 50$ belaw grade, on oondition that: (1) a smoke door be provided leading into the sleeping ro�n, (2) a smoke detector be installed in area inmediately adjacent to the bedroan, and (3) an escape windaw be installed opposite the door of the sleep- ing roan, with a sill no more than thirty (30) inches above floor lev�l. Property Description: Ada¢n.s Addition to the City of St. Paul, Lot 5, Block 2 -2- � � � o ' - ti��i:.`.��:�i� � � 11/18/80 40-80-H 42 So. St. Albans Fillm�re-Walt�ex' (six v�ndaniniuns) �ndceninitun Association BpARD AGTI�T: Granted varianoe of Minnesota Unifonn Building Code, Article 13.03, pert.aining to use of fire rated mat�esials, to permit continued occup�ncy of six ooa�c7c$niniun imits, each equipped with frc�nt entrance doors which do not ocn�ly with fire-safety code r�nts after ha.ving reveived a sic�ed waivpx�, a capy of which is marked as �IIBTT B and herein inoorporat�ed by refer- enoe, by the condaniniun c�mers acJmc�wledging and assixning the � risks created by this varianoe. Varianoe is granted on c�ndi- � tian that any future replaeement� of said doors imast meet oode; ,� said varianoe to be reoorcied ari d�eed of each o�rx�aninitnn imit � placing future purchasers � notic� of the varianoe granted C. Y�erein and the restrictions relat,ed theretA. This varianoe is al- ry so c�o�i�Ei�1 Upon the HaY��v�mers Associatioa� posting a wpy �2 of this resolutiari for twn wee.ks in a o�nspicuous and �emm� area of the oatxkxni.ni.tan ��plex. Praperty Descriptian: Stmtit Park �..itiari Apart�nt Ownership No. 25 Krxx�m as Fil].more and Walter . Condanini�, Being W. 30 Ft. of Lot 15 and All of Lot 14, - Block l, S�nit Park Ac�dition Apartireizt Nos. 1B, 2B, 3B, 4B, 5B and 6B, and an Undivic�ed 1/12 11/18/80 50-80-H 420 Hersc�el St. Paul W. Iarson (fiv� units) gC�,RD p,CrICN: Granted varianc�e of St. Paul Legislative Coc�e, Section 54.11, �r+aining t�p basiC faciLities, ta pexmit occupancy of apart- ment where handsink is located outside t�oilet/shawex rooan. Property Descriptiari: Lovering's Addition. Lot 26, Block 1 _} �/ -��`�3 i-� d'i WHITL•� - CITY CLERK � (']� !� P�NK� - FINANCE n COU[1C11 ��j�� GANAftY. - DEPARTMENT C I TY O F SA I NT 1 A LT L �.� . ��BLU6 �- MAYOR File NO. � Council Resolution Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date and bs it F� RESOG�, That �s City CL�ic ia h�y av�o�f�d a�d df.recGe�i t� � � �� this se�alutl�a �o �eaa�dl�q �o th� Ren�ay C1�nLy Off3�oe cat' th� � C'� Cit � � C� r--I C� -�- COUNCILMEN Yeas Nays Requestgd by Department of: Hunt Levine �Q FaVO[ Maddox McMahon V Against BY Showalter � wi�� JA N 1 3 �, Form Approved by City Attorney Adopted by Council: Date .; �.,� "�, '�� . f/ Certified Passed by Council Secretary B� l �-` - __.. By Approved by Mayor: Date _ Approved by Mayor Eor Submission to Council By _ BY � � � 7�' 0 � . .,, . m �� . � . • � ~ � �_ � o� � � �� . Z� � � � �, � -�m � '� � � o � N ' ; m = � ' -* �. � � M�► c� . p� � . � � � °� �' � o �o y _ � � t� �� ' .... C!i � � �, � . � �� J � �� _ � . ,