The URL can be used to link to this page

276929 WHITE - CITY CLERK � r'"" �-` DE ARTMENT G I TY O F SA I NT PA U L Council *�� CANARV BLINE ' r1NAYOR . . F1Ie N O. � � : , � . ♦ • / i- -, O/ ZI ZGII ZCP. Ordinance N O. � 1= �- �- -" Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date important to the house' s appearance and should be preserved; symetrical fenestration, stone frieze, front entrance side lights and transom, corner quoining, stone sills and headers and original hip -. roof shape. If the house is restored the City � encourages removal of painting from limestone, � restoration of front and rear porches based on � photographic evidence, and restoration of original Q; six over six windows. � t"'� Section 3. � This ordinance shall take effect and be in force thirty (30) days from and after its passage, approval and publication. -2- COUNC[LMEN Yeas Nays Requested by Department of: Hunt � �"'"e In Favor �ddoX McMano� snoN►aite� � Against By Tedesoo wiw� JUN 1 8 �gg� Form Approved � ttorn �� Adopted by Council: Date Certified ssed by Cou '1 Secretar BY � " Y , X./�� , . C JUN 19 1981 Approved by Maqor for Submission to Council Appro e by Mayor. t By By � - � � � � �� W A � C7 � in' ? � (7 D . , ' ' , .� '•,�. �/�1 � � � y �,,,, � - j�• W = Ri v � � N � `fl �, � rt � O .:. Q � N � NO n S O � y -� (D ID Y�i � �: C1 .� z � zZ ° ��.o� � .� g � z °o �� z o I�0'` a � ° � N � t�; � oapO _, � � � � � � �S n � .* 7� 9 � (� � 1:�{ � �� t� � � � � � , � Cf n �� ' � � � � CD � `' � �� ° °' W 7t� ~ 3 ' �. � vw N � `�° '• ~V N � �a m �, � � °: N �'� :i► Z a � . , �n. N "' � `� =' 3 � . � � � � -rC � � `�� - \ WHITE - CITY CLERK w F.NK ♦� FINANCE COUI1C11 �% B�VE�r - sMAYORMENT GITY OF SAINT PAiTL �' � � ''� ; . . - File N 0. O� • C • Ordinance P1 U. /��' '�' � � Presented By Leonard W. Levine Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date An Ordinance designating the Joseph Brings House as a Heritage Preservation Site. THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: Section 1. Pursuant to the authority contained in Chapter 73 of the Saint � Paul Legislative Code and upon the request of the Heritage Preser- � vation Commission of the City of Saint Paul, and after having duly � considered the matter at a public hearing held in accordance with � the said ordinances, the Council of the City of Saint Paul does r-•' hereby designate the following described property to be a Heritage �j Preservation Site: Joseph Brings House, 314 North Smith, Saint Paul, Minnesota, on property legally described as Lot 1 of Thomas Daly Subdivision of Lots 4, 5, 6 and 7, Block 50 of Dayton and Irvine's Addition to Saint Paul. Section 2 . The Preservation Program for this Heritage Site is stated as follows: JOSEPH BRINGS HOUSE Preservation Program The exterior of the Joseph Brings Hause should be preserved in a manner consistent with the original design intent. The following design elements are COUNC[LMEN Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays Hunt Levine (R F8V0[ Maddox McMahon Showalter Against By Tedesco wlson Form Approved by C' y tt y Adopted by Council: Date I � Certified Passed by Council Secretary By I BY , Approved by Mayor: Date Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council gy BY � .. . . - � .. . C��! OI� Sr��l� �'c�U� - �3��l�ll� C��OS��J�1 I'�SO�U�10�'i �� ,�j�l�� R1-04 �� February 27, 1981 RESOLUTIO��! OF APPROVAL OF HERITAGE �P.ESERUATIOId DESIGilATIO?t OF TNE JOSEPH BRIPJGS HOUSE � l-JHEREAS, the Heritac�e Preservation Commission has notified the Planning Commission that it is recommending the designation of th� Joseph 6rings House as a Heritac�e Preserva�ion sit�; and . ��1HEREAS, the Joseph Brings House meets the criteria for designation as a � Heritage Preservation site �y virtue of its �•�ide recognitiorr as an excellent example or a t�r�o-story stone residence from the Civil !�lar/ _ Pioneer _era, and as a rare representaiive o� the transitional phase in P�inn�sota architecture bet�veen th� Federal .and th� Gree'c. Revival sty7es, and has been neighborhood landmarl:; and tJHEREAS, the designation will serve to project and preserve tnis structure; and I�JHEREAS, the 61est Seventh Str2et Federation has nor�inat2d tne Joseph 6rirgs House far designation as a Heritage Preserva�ion site; and L�aHER�AS, the Planning Commission has revie�;rad the recomnlende� d�signation evith respect to ti�� Comprehensive Pian, including the District 9 Plan, and other pla�ning .considerat�ions; i�101�l, THEREFORE, 6E IT RESOLVED, that the Planning Cor;unission finds the designation consistent �vith the Compreh�nsive Plan and other planning con- siderations; and - : �E IT FURTHER �;ESOLVED, th�t the Planning Co�mission recorrmends approval of the proposed designation by the Cit,� Councii . �,�� ,, Anderson � � 5�� Lenegran �� +�� 6 �� Q , �VV�i� ' . - - � , --� . , - � ' � . . � , . • _ • ,. , . , � , �'i� 9, 198]. _ . � , _ . , � t. _ idr.• P�uI Desch � Fiasuce �Depart,weat , � -- ' , Rovro 218� City �all % . _ _ _ - Dear 8irs � _ - . Tba C�.ty' Council aet a date�of 2�aripg !or Pls,y 14t,2�t �982 � _ � at �0 t04 A.t�I. in �he CbunCi2 t�smbers to cansisler the , recom�endation of the Heritage Pre�ervation G�o�mmfasian t.ba� _ t,he .Toaepb Hars�gs_ H�duee at 334 �o. Smith �e aasignated as ` a Iierftage Pr�eervstion site.. Mi11 you please�s+e�d noLioes . - to property ah►aers twent�r dyra� iu a,dvanae of 'l.be- heariag - - aa Fequ3red by l:ai+. . - ' _ Y�=y tr�tlY Yours, ' - . � , � � , - . !ll Olson � . . City G1er� , .. ABfJ:la _ _ � : cci Terry Ptouta, �eritage 'PreseFVStion Go�i�sioa Statf _ �_ • � ; , , _ ;- - � _ � - . � - _ � _ , �+--� '�' CIT�Y' fl�' �.�lII'��' �,.A.UL . _ .. . 1 �� s'��N, . � � � ' . . . �i, I�ii ,:;: , OF'F*?.C� O.� 'TtiL CZTX C0��7'•_1'C_*L ��'�� , s `�, . � �' . ' �� n.'•;►t':] : � - ' �^� !�i'.•i=i�;' � i._; _ . `� • ' • r�. lsy.r� �� t t �r po t e : Apri Z 7= 1981 ;� �_„ � . . . � .�`''..+`�, . Ci � �o� R31 � .� �� .�.. � � � � � � . - ._ TO : � Soin# Pcrui Cit� Cour�cil . - �- =-� -" _ �R O�'� = COtT�i?fi��E� Oi1 CITY DEVELOPMENT AP�D .TRAPtSPORTATION - - - � . �.teonar.d 41.; Levirte; chvirman, makes �he folEo�r�ing � : ' �_ � � ' � �report on � .C.F. , � . - [� Ordinnnce - _ - '_. . • � . �� :. . � C7 ResoTu#�ion � _ . � . . ' �� • � . � . . . . � . '. � O�tter� • _- � _- ._ -.,._... "�'�"�'�� • Letter of the Heri tage .Preservati on Cor�ni ssi on . • ._ - ' . � . � recorr�nendi ng the Joseph Bri ngs House at 31�4 Nor�h =- � � � Smith be designated a Heritage Preservation site. - - . ,� . : . . � � . - . . . . --- . • � . . ' � . � �..,. _ . - - - - _ _ . . . � � " .Th� .C�ommi ttee. r.ecorr�nends approvaT. � � - . • _ - .. . . . , • . . . .. • . . � . � - . � . =1= � � • � . . . . � . ' .. � � . . . � . _ . � .4`� r _ . . -• . '. �' . .� . . . '_ - � . _ . . . . �.. � . �ti j_- . . . � . � . �. . � � • ' . �- � �? �. • . ' . •, . . ' • _� � ' - - • � ' _ . _ �. �_ t �i�' -Zf . . � . . �. . . . . ' � " • • � y • . . _ . � �.`� . _ _:_ _ - _. • ��j . •- � - ' �� CtTY H11LL , SEYE:ti''I�i FtOO:Z � SA�\T P1►UL,�iI�;4ESJT1 S�Lfl_ � . . . r,*=�, � . . : - - - . . ` ..,� . � � , � t� ' . . _ . , � - � . �� , � , - . . , , , \ � . . Ma,rch 19, 1981 . � � . . , - � Gbwacil�sn Leonsrd I".�vine � t�+►ir�ea, Cit,Y Dewlopmsnt d� Trst�sporta��iin.f'o�ittea. . - 7`th !"locr, City' Het].l - � , , ,_ � • . Aee►�r t�ur�cilmnn Lev��s � , '�a Cit,y� Coqncil referred to the C3ty De�rlopoeAt b Trana- � portatian Co�it� tor consid+�rat� aad !'or�rAtto�ndstion ' , s letter of t.2� 8eritags Preseiwatioa Comsi�aion reco�e�di�g that th� Joapeb Hri�}gs �ouse at 31k �o. ,Smith be`desi;at►ted aa - e 8aritage Pretervat3�n site. , : . ' Vcr�r Lritly yotirs, _ . �. , , . , _ , � , Ross M#�t _ , Cit,y t�erk . _ ; _ , . ;; - . , " ;. . . , � ABi�sla . _ . � . _ ,, �'``; �c s :. Heri�ag� Preservst.ion Qasioission StaPY , ' � � , ' , . ; . � � � / � . � - ;J . a � . � . , . i � i - ' - - - . � - - t .; � i � ' , _ � . ! . . i ' - "'s, .. ; . , f t — _ 'i , � , i ; > . , /% _�,,._ ��r�'c. r�j`.�.".'>"�`.„-�-- � ST. PAU � CiTY COUNCIL. ��9 i ' PUB� IC HEARING NOTICE HERITAGE PRESERVATION SITES File X 2613 Page The Council of the City of St. Paul will hold a public hearing in the Council Chambers of City Hall and Court House (third floor) at 10:00 A. M.. Thursday, May 14, 1981 to consider the recommendation of the Heritage Preservation Commission that the Joseph Brings House at 314 No. Smith; leg�lly described as Lot 1, Thomas Daly's Subdivision of Lots 4, 5, 6, and 7, Block S0, Dayton and Irvine's Addition, be designated as a Heritage Preservation site. If you would like further information about this hearing, contact the Heritage Preservation Commission, llth floor, City Hall. Annex, 25 W. 4th Street, St. Paul, Minnesota 55102. Telephone No. 292-61+1+0. While the City Charter req uires that we notify you of the hearing, we want to help you to learn fully about any improvement that could affect you or your community. Therefore, I sincerely hope you can attend this hearing, so that you can make your views about it known to the City Council, whether for or against. Notice sent April 24, 1981 by the Valuation and Assessment Division Department of Finance and Management Services �I Room 218 City Hall - Court House St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 � �,..:R,��.� NO?lC�t�!l�.�, , >:,«,+,..:-�-rw-: Not[ee b heu!Ng�,�Mla�hat the CitT4'aW�ci1 .�tf+e C'itY o(�iY��l.Iwld�,l�blic pd1�,�t7yC/ii�YlitCbe�,'s+l�litC�- 'ty EIaH atl��8ar�.fe 1A:90 JM�i.on - �� t�•�.�.�.� 81fe�s �� ,,i, � ��. :. .. . �&1�!Ilt. . : '��a�� .�lwrwe fj�h� 3 �r of I�»�. -�7ton d�2.. . �� - ` , .. ,� �615'PreOMy`lGOI�,�r�t�Nti��' f1oe.9ti pty�a,�isMly�� of q�t�;�. : Dkvelopne�t iocat�i e�R f�le�Fqt lIOPt .T Ha1l Mnac apd+nq M'�Y�a+�° quest. ?.n,. ":r Dated Ayril IMh.1Y�1.��r::5.' ;i; ..l4I,D�'f`8.QL80N, Cft�Clerk � lApd�1A:1991) x a:�.: �� Tr f�� ' `;Ni� , tli� k'� � '�Y i bt rro W' A,- iE' �L , ..� . � ir i •'�R:. (�` . � ��. 1 .� : . illd j Y �Ifl�d.. .� � � . . ��,�,.. �� Pnd 7 kpr.lt,nbll�► . . AFFIDAVIT OF PUBLICATION �� STATE OF MINNESOTA � COUNTY OF RAMSEY Geraldine C. Lynch , being duly sworn on oath, says: that he is, and during all times herein stated has been, Clerk of the Northwest Publications, Inc., publisher of the newspaper known as the St. Paul Dispatch, St. ��u.' ,.,� � Paul Pioneer Press, St. Paul Sunday Pioneer Press, a newspaper of general circulation within ` i` the City of St. Paul and the County of Ramsey. ''�f.�':, ; �' That the Notice hereto attached was cut from the columns of said newspaper and was printed ; `- � and published therein on the following dates: � '"; 18th day of April 1981 � �. � �� `� ` �- dayof , 19 � day of , 19 dayof , 19 d ay of , 19 dayof , 19 day of , 19 � c Subs ibed and sworn to before me this 20th day �►f Apri1 19 81 , � Notar�• Public Ramsey County, Minnesota My commission expires March 13, , 19 82 "��.:�a.,,:-.._ - �: p� -•� �r i yxe: � . �� :i :� MF � �� „� �.... NOTARY 1^l.::tL�,'.; 4cF�,..:—r-�_„ t M►'CONMi�Brov [xr�:^�Tfl r,n:,, ; '� �',�''.,r'.,�5�.+'�._'+,.�.,.�,qr..-., ,, a.�_ .�. if:s.:. Furm 236 �, v�. .j . . . . . . . � ;. . . . . . . . . � . .. .. C . . �" � /� . .: .. � .. �. F ��;. . _- � . . - - . . ,� •.w . .. _ .. . . � � .� . .. . ._. � . . . � ' ." � ' " , . . . . . . � _ . i� _ . .. _ . . . . . . • . . . . . . . .- � � . . - .. � . . . . . , , . , , . i:� _ _ , ' : - . - � • � - -_ , i , _ �I�� t . ,, _ . _ . � - . � - : - � . _ . , - , _ . . , , , April 14. 19DI _ , ' � � S�. Pau2 Dispatttt�-Pioneer Preea � , 53 ,E. Foa�th 3t. - - _ 'St. Pwl, Mi�anasoLa 55101 . ATTB�ITIO�s Jaas - • - , . - Daa�c Jaoa: , : - - ✓ ; `' W�.31 ��ese� have 't� attach�d N�atice of-Pnblic H�ariag pabl..ist�d f.n _. • .. L`hs Clasaifi�d 3ect3on og the �St. Panl. Mepatsh—Fioua�� Brs�s on $ate�sdaey, ' .Ap�tl 18th, sad c�argi Ca aaaount �6$2. Pl�es� fo�tward`�u sffida�vit o� : � pab�icatfoa to' the �d�tsiga�d aad if thare azs aa� qtal�at�crne�.¢alI - � ' - Al Olso� at 29&-4231. " _ - . ` � - . Vsry tsul.y yoars,'_ , , , � - - . A1b�rt dlsda. _ .:,�; ` - . City Clerk ' _ -` :� � - : A�sdcr ' • , . tlTtsait. _ - ` � � _ - '. • � . i . - ; " , ' _ � _ . , �I " � PuBt►sriEO APR l 81981 , - , ; �,� , • ; - �l--` _ _ _- - . � � � . _ - , . �;:, _ - . . . _ ; _ � . � � - , — . . . - , , - . -- . . , . , _ _ � .. � . . . ...\ . , . . . ; ,. •. . . _ ' _ . _ - - �• �, �� _ _ . . , `� , , - ;.. _ : ; . ,. . ; , _ � , , � , �� , , �, . . :, :' . . - Jume 2b.<;1981 . . _ _- � _ , � • . � . „ _ � . , � , � , - , 'ta � . - —. \ . . . . ` : — ,_ . d\� — — . . — ' _ : . � . . _;. �?#f ice o� Cou�!# B,acordur � ', �o�'-�SS, City Hall . _ _ _ � � �i]�diaa � _ ; , . _ ; . ; , � � Bea�r Sirt . . . j ` . _ _ I �, �clos��_for• fiifng in �p�our offi;ca is.s capy of Co�il Fila !b. , 1 � 27b929. _ - _- _ � - . . _ : �. , �, Vqrp truly youry _ ,� . � � � "R ; ;C",.,, . , . - � `' . 1 ',�;� t..�x.�'"�,{ - . ,,�: : ' _ - _ �].bert B; Q3�so� , ; � , ' " ` Cttp C]�lik - � , � � _ � ` = � ' �loa{ire . � , - _ , - � ach � , ' . . -.= � _ - , , • - - -, j J � , _ _ .. a _ . � ' . J , ' � � , . ,. i' . . I- . ; � / . '.. ` i " _ _ J , !I ' , , , � i;. . . . . ,. � � � . ; -... . . . . . _.. 1.. �� . � . � � .. � . � �'�„ . � .-{ �/. �. � . . . ... . ,. • . � - . . . - . . .. _ � A. � � . - � . ' . . - _ . , r . .. .. �� . . _ . _ ._ . . .� . . . . .� � . ., . . .. . � . �- � - . .;' . . , . , .. , .. . . . . . . , . :�.t � ' . . . � _ . .. . . _ _ . . . . . � � , . . , � . . . . . ' . . r . . � � . . � - � ' . - . - � . - � � - . � . � . i .. j~ . � . . � . . . . . . . _ � . . .'f . . , . . . . . . � . .. . � . .�i " -` . . �. ' . _ , � ' . �. . - . . � . � � � � .' , � t. . . .. � . . . . . ' . . . . . _ . . . � . . . � �':� ' . . ` T . . ' _ . .. - , � , - . . � : ; . ' � � . , . . . _ _, � . . .. ... . . }� • '• y • / �• � 6 � . . ` ' � : � . STAT� OF -MINN�SOTA ) . ' � Couri.ty o6 Ramdey ) �a• . � - CITY OF SAINT PAUL ) Q� ' � . Albert B. Olson, .�y �� I. . . . . . . .. . .. . . . .. . . . . . . . .. . . . . .. .. . . .. .. . C\t . oS #he Cit�y o� Sa.i_nt Pau.�, NLi.►vie.bo�.a, do heneby ce��i.�y �ha-� I iuive compa�ed �he a.LtAChed copy o� Counc.,i,L F-i.P� No276929. . . ab adop�ed 6y �he Gi.t� Counc.i.,L _, _ June.18: .. .. .. .. . . . . . l 9 81. June 19,' . �9 81 and a,pp�coved 6y �he Juayoh . . . . .. . . .. .. .. . . . . .. .. .. .. .. - _„_ - w.i th �he oh,i.g.�na.0 �`heneo� on_ �.i.Le �.n my o��,i.ce. ao � �_ • , ' .. . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . .. . . . . .. . . . .. . . . ... .. . . . . . . . . . . .¢ . 'r"* . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . • . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . .. .. . . . . -- - - - - � . � : . . . . . : . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . v�a ' ' • e�.r • . � . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..s . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . .. _ . . . . . . . . . . . . . "'� • _ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . �. . . . . . .. .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . .. . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . • T �cui.theh ce�c�sy #hcLt aa,i.d copy .ia a #lu.ce and connec�t co� o� ba.i..d on.i.g�,nn,� and #he who�e ��eheo�. . ,_ , , . '' � ' ` WITNESS my hnnd and �he ae�-e o� �he C�.ty o� �a.i-►Lt Pau,L, � � ' �' ''.. �' ^ik 1� .,25th. . � o� . . . . .June. . .. . . . . . .. . .A.�. 1981_ _ , ;:,:r. ..�:� : . nn. #Ju.6 . . . , �; .., , ' �� a . . r _ . �� _ . . . . . _ _ . . . - - - - � l�� . . . . . . . . . . . �- , . . Ci.t� C�ch f�. ..: �,' � 8gs � 00.40 — A �. . �.. � _ , _. � _ ��i� , of sair�t p�ul. . . . � � " , ' � � Y . � ��-� � . �� °�r�tage pr�servation commiss�on resolu�ion file nurnber #,3_ da�e October 23, 1980 • WHEREAS, the Neritage Preserva�ion Comnission is authorized by the Heritage Preservation Ordinance (Saint Paul Ordinance 16006) to recommend buildings to the City's list of Heritage Preservation Sites; and WHEREAS, the� West 7th/Fort Road Federation and Joan Lisi , owner, asked the Neritage Preservation Commission to considzr nomination of the Joseph Brings House as a Neritage Preservation Site; and i�1HEREAS, the Commission has determined that the Joseph 8rings House, built about 1865, at 314 North Smith Avenue, (Lot i of Thomas Daly Subdivision of Lo�s 4, 5, b, and 7 , B1ock 50 of Dayton & Irvine Addition to Saint Paul) meets the criteria specified in Paragraph B , Section 4 of the heritage Preservation Ordinance in that: 1 . The Brings House is one of the feti•r examples in Saint Paul of a t�ro-story Pioneer era stone residence. It is b�ilL of localiy quarried limestone, featuring unusual decQrative elenents . . 2. The Brir�gs House is a rare example of the transitiona1 p�ase in htinnesota architecture bet�,�een thz Federal and G��eek P,eviva; sty'Ies. 3. 7he Brings House is valuable in the "de�:2lopment ; heritage , and cultural characteristics of the City of Sain� Paul " because i� is a rerr,n�nt of resi- dential archi tecture of the working cl ass corrrnuni ty ��ani cn settled the 1•lest Seventh area. It was originally buil� by a Ger��ar irm-igrant, L��hose zamil; . remained in the area until about riftec^ years ago. �vHEREAS, the Neri tage Preser�vati on Cormi s s i or held a publ �i c f�eari ng on tF�e pro�osed designation of the Joseph Brings HouSe on S�ptember il , 19$0. Pursuant to Paragraph E, Section 4 of the Heritage Preservation Qrdinance, notice of this hea�ing ti�as published in the Saint Paul Pioneer Press cn August 21 , 1980, anc� notice aras sent to the site o�m er and property owners ►��i�hin 350 feet; and 1�lNEREAS, this site's nomination is consist�n� t�fith the Corr�mission policy on individual designation during the time a survey is coneucted . � NO'.�1, TH�REFORE, BE IT RESOLUED, by the Sain� Paul Heritage Preservation Commission that the Joseph Brings Nouse is hereby reco"�.�ended to City Council as a Neritage Preservation Site tiJith preservation progra,� as follo,�s : . mOVed b � � second� by . �n favor agalnst � . . .. � , � �� .. � . � � ��t��- `° - . , . city of sair�t paul ' h�r►tage preservation cornrn�ss�on resolut�on file num��r 13 _ . . - date _, October 23 , i 980 The exterior of the Joseph Brings House should be preserved in a manner consistent with the original design intent. The following design elements are important to the hous�'s appearance and should be preserved: symmetrical fenestration, stone frieze, front entrance side lights and transom, corner quoining, stone sills and headers , and original hip rooT shape. If the house is restored the Corr,mission encourages removal of pain�i:�g from lirr.estone (by the gentlest reans oossible) , restoration of firont and rear porches based on photographic evidence , and , restoration of or?ginal six over six windok�s . move�I b Toscano seconde [Jy Langford � ln favor � a�ainst o � . . . �� ! ::� r�;: ' ,, � SAINT PA�1L HERITAGE PRESEaVATION CCNMISSION SITE NOMINATION FORM I NANE f�ISTORIC: The Joseph Brings House �q�'�10N: I I LOCATION Q�DRESS: Lot 1 of Thomas Daly Subdivision LEGAL DESCRIPTION: of� Lots 4 5 6 and 7 Block 50 - Ijj P�� of Dayton�Irvine Addition to St. Paul �� Joan Lisi ADDRESS: 314 N. Smith Ave. IV L�V`� USE LOCATIaJ MAP RAR�fSE Y ��DSA Y � � PL�YG'D SCHDaL i ; -s7 ' � ♦ ,,t,,� � � C!) =1{_: OL � . ` ( -� �' ( O � � ;H 9 , , � , , , ; . Q < ti � �i �� • , ; s � 'R � � ,�' �•� �lj�' � � p� A .,,�'� ; . �i� , � �� E� �� `� / � i q ' , , � , � i�i C19 ° X.� , �. /'� :-� � � � �� -.� i( ) /o ,' � � �/ V F(�M PREf'ARID BY �s 9 ._,- r�.�� I�� Susan Vogel ,Intern ADDRESS: 25 W, Fourth Street �UPERVISOR: Terry Pfoutz DATE: July 2, 1980 VI DOCUP�ENTATICiV ON FILF � HISTORIC SITE EVA UATION FORM X . BUILDI1�G PERMIT�S� SLIDES/PHOTOGRAPHS OF STRUCTURE � UTHER�ILIST��SCRIPTIVE MATERIAL �LIST) � • ' F��}s.�.�r�..'' SAIP�T PAUL HERITAGE PRESERVATION COP�(�ISSION SITE �0�1IN�1TIOid FORf�� VII � NARRATIVE : HISTORY AND SIGNIFICANCE OF SITE The Joseph Brings House, built about 1865, is a fine example of a two-story stone residence from the Civil War, Pioneer era. Its architectural character is significant because it is a rare representative of the transitional phase in Minnesota architecture between the �ederal and Greek Revival styles, and also hints at the Italianate style soon to follow. Common characteristics of this transitional style were simplicity, sparse exterior detail , and a formalized symmetrical appearance. This style was practical for the early settlers because it fit their life style, limitations of material shortages, and rapid construction necessary during the Pioneer era. The Brings House is a remnant of the residen�ial architecture built by the working community which settled the West Seventh area. Few examples o-P this type of architecture exist today in St. Paul . The only other examples of such two-story stone residences are the David Luckert House at 480 Iglehart Avenue, and the Waldman House at 445 Smith Avenue. Smaller one and one-half story stone structures also exist. They are the Mar�tin Weber House at 202 McBoal and the Justus Ramsey House at 252 West Seventh Streete The building material is locally quarried limestane. Corner quoining accents the smoothly finished front facade and the roughly finished side and back facades. There are a few simple elements of decoration unusual to limestone houses constructed in this era. Underscoring the low hipped roof is a row of underlined widespread modillions. The windows are six over six, double hung with smooth limestone lintels and sills. The three bay arrangement is symmetrically dispositioned on the flat, proportioned facade. The entrance is beneath the upper right window. Surrounding the door are flanking side- lights and a rectangular transom. The original owner of this house was Joseph Brings. He was a German immigrant who arrived in St. Paul in 1863 with his wife and children. He operated a coopery business out of his house until he moved in 1871 . In 1879 he switched over to a feed business called "The Brings Feed Store." His business was passed down through his family and ran at the same spot at 316 West Seventh Street until about fifteen years ago. The Brings House has had many owners. From 1883-i888 Major John Kelliher owned the house. He was a director of the Seven Corners Bank, a life member of the Chamber of Commerce, and interested in real estate in the city and vicinity. Additions to the original design included shutters and a three bayed front porch, with an upper row of spindles , modillions, and simply capped columns wi�ich was added sometime before 1900. Alterations included removal of the front porch, one of the two chimneys located on the east exterior wall , and replacement of the wooden shingles with asphalt shingles . Also removed was the two-floored back porch which completed the symmetry and regularity of the plan originally ' , ' , ., r j � -2- designed. The exterior limestone facades have been painted a light yellow color with brown trim. The nouse is structurally very sound with its solid eighteen inch thick walls of limestone. However, there is a crack in the east exterior wall which extends from the roofline to half way down the wall . This was caused from a water leak in the chimney because there u�as na liner in the chimney. Although the house needs restoration to return it to its original condition, total restoration is economically feasible. .; �t� ,�� .y� . a, w , _ .�.. � c�;1,; j � `�•w .�Cj +� ,�, r S� a«� ir. "�j /! ,��' ��`�. �� ' y i� �� ' • � ��- - �1.�+� � 1► ��..r. � i�► �'7 ` t, '� . ' � � '►�.� r 1 a... ' . � ." ♦ !ii� G��4 4' t't ..�[�: t.,.- -* ' ,.; � .,, �r , �':'.,��4"..e'�� " . �: �' �� r_ r.. .-•-.-� �r. ' >-+„�+�;�_y .. :.•tt •c ,,K:► �' '�.y_�� .� � �. 4,j, , � !� ^ K� ' qy�y , - � �. ,+�'Y'"�� - -.� �i�s_' }. r ':�'�i ,� ,��"'�,," -�� .,K ` + y�%s,�j� �� ?'1.. .R� �?' ,r �'t� ' .�'�� '•'.�•�+�'' a � —��.J�l', � v'v..;i .Tti•�s 's".�"�.; ' ��j�� _ . �'4�•�>>'tt'r" x'-�� '�,�' `= .� �-�� : ' �''`�f1 _'`` '''`-' �r s'�•'� ._ ..-- � ,�/ . t.`.� .. A�� • f �' T -.r�Y�� ..._ � � -.°r' �. : .�S' -,i►r:a� -_ ':��...�;.. !=A , _� �"ti ��t w�` _#'y.► .r.�hiT..�r_ �.�� '' •. �`"-- . . K.-k � �eC-: �...-` �`� �^ /^1�.,. � �� '-„+af'• - �`- s � '�-.`� - �,,,�•�' _� �+.+_ �,� , � � �a,�� ! � _ �, , r,�.. r , � � ,. . ,�� ". :��` � � ^��` � �I �C'�' y� ';�� ,..� �... ��. �� . � � ! � '�: � . _ ..... . ...r . . .��, 1 At �' , ��?��.. 1 . J�F . _.�• . ''I s�. ;� k.��"� �� '. `�. ��r�.1C�- ""� jr f;a>'r�1i�:iz. `t; 1: ';: ':; ��1`� ��l.��^ i�t "" _ _ .q . . •j�,i � � f ,� � � " 't 'y 'b k �.� L�� '�c'�'��r��`�''. < : � '4 > '��'t �as-c 3':,c 1: �,.� �.-. �., �ya'�._'.�kY��°��i�r'�,�Y� i'� ,+,v�'.� _ : � �� .��,�.. � � - ,�W �u r y �• . �c,�i, y :E'�� ' w 4_ ' `,.`t � � '� R��"'�t� �c�r.��tii�i. �;s��'. .y..�.Y,.� �l� �rY� �„�. � �lT=� ••�°` � �• �. ��#}-�;'�f �� :a,�.y.�.�► -`� ?� $��.�`� .� . x'1��r'��j.i�3,�6'�ty '�� '� ,� 4'v�a�e+•E ,,. �r- '��'- _ -_:.?��. e..� .,�'s s�,��'C'�°rr. .� �. ��.f � . _- ...� ^ . �;J��t�-=.� ''�.L.:_' _ � � "f��, �,��.��}�• '�':"�-�-�'''" ''� "'� � ` �.,zc; .: !` 3`�=.: t �, g1? ,;�' �. . �C�j+ , ,,,�x �+�:.^� �.► . . i i�;��u.�� „��_�+�,�«��7�.�`,`- �''�`'��.i-_ • Y 6'"ri ✓�•� �� L ��{!y� '�� t�i� _ r�'� �1R W. � . � �.: � t[�. =2�m. .� � '...,.�,, r� ��? -�s� ..:°� �v,� �r,�y,..f' ::�z�. � ,.. , , �, "f y :.� '' ! �<�� r � ,,�� i �1 a' �,,,�,,i,�� ,. • 'd 1_� �� '�'iYi'Yi�� ix'I llf� ..'�'ar'�`^.p .� w�.� ��s �� 'y�{ ... '��e�rjS%;� N � � }■)_� ��"''./'„ f �'�u��.a�" �.'1K �` � `T � ~��r'`'`'`y�y�. �•� �- l ��-��..y,^�.T"•F•.✓,. S��i"._q �: �; �.� � �`` � :��Z 1R# ��r�l j � ' �� w1. ti�t �'� �'� !��.��a �Y:�� t�, . .. .. . /�1��_~� �,. �Y.. �.{.YeT� �^�zS r ' �^•.�. �r.i�: � :�.��.: aI '��.� �'-�,�n`� `'``� �. � �.�. "�. '- I �,;�� v''�d. �. .. ' �t 4+`i�,T s � -. y� '� r, +�,^, a f° ,j ?rFr a ,�1 • _ � � �;"t. .��!"g l+r• -,1' �`' �t�y r ,: J ,� " r. 9 '_ � '='� , �3�t'��►'•►'�' �w:�• •^�".F°`�,.�.rc-- . �- ��f �.•/: �. a-��;,,..i� �."-^ '""'j ,.- • �� • '�'d�y, vF"` w } M '�{'� . ♦'�M � .-.t�T'��,4 t �4, 'i% + ��.,�i .:-��'� r k�?'�`�".�.�.�;.° ��"�.;.�t, � �` � •.._ •..z�„ti`�.i r '�. a .aX+� �" "Y`> '�'. �! — t: - `�_71, -;sti` �+ t � . r�•�' _ .. I �!�''Tw'��„'�.`�.. -'�` �-r' '� -s .�i '�� y �` hi�j+l�s-�]F�_y ��^�`� � I.�-�►-' ' �. ��-: �, -� . r „�, .. . ., . . -- r«.-=+�y�jE , '-r' , _.;•,..s��r"' •- _ ,. :.:�' • _ ._ _ _ _ _. . _ _:.. . __ _.. .. .... .. w� .. . ... ..��. ..._. _ �_. .. _, . .�... �. . . ,�. ..�.„_ :`��.�9 , _ . 3 ' '""'vc"�R� �q ` - ClTY OF SAINT PAUL =��'��lrr ��+:'�j � ""' HERITAGE PRESERVATlON COMMISSION °; �,: ,a �u�u�mu ,- p ��i� ru u ^_� ' ° � 25 West Fourth Street,Saint Paul,Minnesota,55102 '"_T;m','�° 612-292-u"L2y GEORGE LATIMER MAYOR March 5, 1981 yj� Mr. Ron Maddox, Council President, and Members of the Saint Paul City Council 704 City Ha11 Saint Paul , Minnesota 55102 Dear Mr. Maddox and Council Members: The Heritage Preservation Commission respectfully recommends that the Joseph Brings House, 314 North Smith, be designated a Heritage Preservation Site. The Brings House is one of the few remaining examples in Saint Paul of a two-story, Pioneer, stone residence. It is a rare example of the transitional phase in Minnesota architecture between the Federal and Greek Revival styles. The house is a remanent of the original working class neighborhood of the West Seventh area . The site u�as jointly nominated by the owner, Joan Lisi , and the West Seventh Street Federation. The Commission held a public hearing on the proposed designation, with proper notice published and mailed to adjacent property or�rners. No opposition was heard. I have enclosed the resolution of recommendation , nomination form, preservation program, and Planning Commission resolution of approval . Thank you for your consideration. Sincerely, `� ,.�.;,�'�"� � i � •,• :_);a,? , i��',�� l�`"��'�' / � Jud�th McLaughlin, Chair Heritage Preservation Commission JM/TP/cc cc: Mayor Latimer Rose Mix, City Cl.erk Jerome Segal , City Attorney James Bellus, Director, PEO Peggy Reichert, Director, Planning yINITE - CITY CLERK PINK� �` - FINANCE COUI1C11 +��y.aJ{ CANARY - DEPARTMENT G I TY O F SA I N T PA U L � ,� BLUE , � MAYOR � Flle N O. '�"� ° �� + 0rdindnce Ordinance N�. � �� Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date important to the house' s appearance and should be preserved; symetrical fenestration, stone frieze, front entrance side lights and transom, corner quoining, stone sills and headers and original hip roof shape. If the house is restored the City encourages removal of painting from limestone, restoration of front and rear porches based on photographic evidence, and restoration of original six over six windows. Section 3. This ordinance shall take effect and be in force thirty (30) days from and after its passage, approval and publication. -2- COUNCILMEN Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays Hunt � Levine In Favor Maddox McMahon Showaiter � Against BY Tedesco �Ison JUN .� 8 �gg� Form Approved y ttorn Adopted by Council: Date Certified ssed by Cou '1 Secretar BY Y t �UN 1 9 �9 I Approved by M or for Submission to Council Appro e by Mayor: By BY PUBtiSHfD ,1UN 2 7 �gg� WHITE - CITY CLERK � �• y/ rINK •� - FINANCE COUIICll � A� CANARY - DEPARTMEfJT G I TY OF SA I NT PALT.L a' BLUE ^" MAYOR File N O. , . � O r C Ordinance N�. /(O U�� Presented By Leonard W. Levi ne Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date An Ordinance designating the Joseph Brings House as a Heritage Preservation Site. THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: Section l. Pursuant to the authority contained in Chapter 73 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code and upon the request of the Heritage Preser- vation Commission of the City of Saint Paul, and after having duly considered the matter at a public hearing held in accordance with the said ordinances, the Council of the City of Saint Paul does hereby designate the following described property to be a Heritage Preservation Site: Joseph Brings House, 314 North Smith, Saint Paul, Minnesota, on property legally described as Lot 1 of Thomas Daly Subdivision of Lots 4, 5, 6 and 7, Block 50 of Dayton and Irvine' s Addition to Saint Paul. Section 2 . The Preservation Program for this Heritage Site is stated as follows: JOSEPH BRINGS HOUSE Preservation Program The exterior of the Joseph Brings House sYiould be preserved in a manner consistent with the original design intent. The following design elements are COUNCILMEN Yeas Nays Requested by Department of: Hunt Levine [n Favor Maddox McMahon Showalter A gai n s t BY Tedesco wison Adopted by Council: Date Form Approved by C' y tt y Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY By � Approved by Mayor: Date Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council By BY i f'.8.c'f'� � .. .� g:7 �F _ .,� J�O�Y OP,HtAilht�i . .-'` 'S --`--rr,,-- . .� ..`�QK�� . . . � . . c .�5�s..`x - -�...�._yfl+i._�:.. � � _ . . A pditian b�vle�beeqlHed xe�ja�stin�tihRh the Zonie�:t�tklln�nee.c[91��p 4b9t.;Feal, be au�ndad'ao.�to't�t4�-}�'_,$M-2 . a4d R�t-A�Y��s�s�ti±n�to�tOn. ,�aR�;�Tb�ty!,o#��oute- ! ao3$QUth b�rtinslnn 1loeWtoP.�ad ' 1�ac�rs.1'�et3�anotiot2�ept�,��'I��Pintl;h� �#A��heYsd � � + ip �4l�1�Elambe:s in� „ _ '°f p� dt7 #ad at s�id time� i�eil ��ar sti'�ar acd a�t'otr)teEteee atd rero�q¢��an r�tive 1�*�p�ered ��"� ,�.�;��-��_ Datid�2�U419�1. . : � w``'=�1LSE1Cf B.OL13E1K C{h Cle�!!t _ tl(t7 5�.�19dIt b / lst �� / � 2nd ((":' �C� T_ � , j . �, ,� 3rd �'' i/ � ( Adopted !; �� ; �� y e83 Nays HUNT / , �, ` ^ (� , C.' �� LEVINE McMAHON � ,�'�� SHOWALTIIt TEDESCO WILSON PRESIDENT (MADDOX) v- o.. . :,F !� �;''- � , -� � �r � : " 'I! . � - I' l ! � �i 1 --1 ..9° �. ;Y _ c..crt�� `�Y= Z m ��' _ �I �. i—.J I I I I i r -}- _ �l.I, � Z �'��1 re• s - � r-- � : � � � >�?s?>, . --- • .. �� ` ; �I �^i �,; ` �� `��" t.�;:_ p � ��; ; � �! �� r- � ra� sr z �i �,i , , I �m � �- ,. ±j r .. : 1, � N -- � -- --- -�� m t� ; � ' � C �m -µ�—'_� i -�\ ��.�;_i L�� ' �� .�. o wl.__�/_ _.� ��- __ � �� • .�f. _ _ _ c� ____, ' �-� ° - - �,-.� �. O I :O • '' !r� c+ 3 � % ,� �^ c 2 .� .: �'. ^ � � i � � `�A C� � i, � —.:� � 1 w� � o � g t � 1 �R l9ff.G V : � N r , ; :aF � � �� i�� (�n � �SeuRr 5 � r-I �,(� �4 � . �. �i � r--� r----� �--i '� �� , � -� , � � � � � �` �� }� 'i � . � i � ' - _ �['�" e � � ° � FL �-1I° . �� - �b �7 `-' J. m N I YM ` sT, k ' 'S�..�J l._� L�J T' - u, c-� ' � „ _. i ! I . '1 �:.i'�1� L'� .1 I�. I� � ' ti ' ._ - � ;1 i •' � �3 j � ,I �.I �l � 1 �J _ ' I `J m � � ,�- . � J ' � �.p � � `�JTL_�J �� L-� * �r----,_ r�o z � � II � N P�5 A L ' : _ . -� � N ITJ 1 I �J ,� � ` 1 �' 4 ' . ..' . �.J. � (n E• R 5T , I ; —� : � a3m � o •; � � � - � . -- . - � fD 1 Z �� , :�o � - L I 1 4 I NOl ON _ � N ""'� �J I ' _ � i, � :i � � / '1' O• � N ' J ES ST 1 i!" �� -_� � � .A, '_�-� � •o•�" � � ` [ � I N eIeEPT .. . T � I. V�.._. . �. °n ` - J � �.. i 1 �' � " ��' � i: �FI r �� I � :� � �a aT � ��77'7 .� ; �� I � N�I 1 # . � � '�� D ;� � � > o ?r, F� � �'p"¢-.�-r - r' _' .:. J � L�` �� ' " ` `� Gs - � ��=��-' ;;� ; � N wau�nK vE ��'�.. -- � VE.... >� �t c..�1.� • o � ' �> z _ z 1�_ z .i:: c ,� �� J� 0 F M , , t:� •� s` 6 0 . s .,. ��" , 91 ; �- + o �, � , �'�( �� CC (D r OJ �� . .i—, - � _ -- ° ' �°t � ��' m j �' - .� ZI � ' ; � � J �:c-' , ;; o �° � 4 � . o �. . � L �.�. 3 'i. o0 N. N�'.TE � � -�— `-�- -- . .. � m . • '� . 1 . � � -- . •� ' '1. ..� ' � � . :� � _ . . � j.... � �_. �i. . . _. - - /F � ,.q� • _ ' ' �l1 �I �-- �I_. - �. .�= -�� :. . :� . .• •��U."� ;.��,. :r; ':I �•y t� . NI �.��7 =�� 7G : � . tp i m �:. '< �� < <-_= < --- < - - < � �� + iv tn ' � �• i- � — -- -- � ,� F= < .. m °' 1\ �? �i < �� -„ - - ' �� [�D� ap -Z-I r ::�: :T � ^ ; 1t ` �t o -S � r— ;� l k � 3 N-G �� -�`-_ -�+rF-- -�� r�� `_. -� �;' ��„�N � �' �� • uN •v i � W O '� ki -' iC �. � _ i V� � Z ' (� ��_ _ _,� � i � �,v,:m t . - ��_ = _ _� � ; ��'� �' _ : 'F: � ��: �� i _ �� i co �--� : ' `' (7��m '� -s v, � � " i;��';,}:. III;W "'1• 1�1� �,' ^� fD N. N. al I ; �j 'd i�.. �+ y `�...- i— '1: � . LEfaMiOM _ _pAPKYm� . ._— -_ .�.�.... •.... LEftINlTOq�A�11.KMA—� � � . � !I t �� ' '' � � '� � � �� _l L�.�,.,...1.J I.y :�... j . � .� 3 - �- - : � i .: :� ._ . _ . : � _ ,. r � '.�F �C_ -- - � t'F GJ "�. , ' � ' o � _ _ _ � � - 1 _ �. vm � '� -� �` 1 � -- '�' • _. , � , - .. �-:- --- _- F --_ �- f : �w 3 ', _'^� - r r � ._.. ... . �.; _ r F fi: � ' - 1� -t _ �} i.. �� _ � ,�. �. , �._ � :r I I, -- _ _--- -- -_. _. _-------- __ - ---- �. p`m G'�V1 � WN-+ Q �TAWN�N y �� C N� � O IrWN� � O � . ��/ �x n tCil � � W tJ-� �'b ��1 11 '. .�1. �. � (/1 fD � ' � _ ° 3 � y � c3 � � � � o �i �� .0 � � v � •°- Q2 � � � � a � ti - . 1��:.�td�,.,� � . ';�<� "� ST. PAUL C-ITY COUNCII. PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE ZONING FILE N0. x Z�is PAGE P u R P�S E To rezone that certain property more specifically set out on the attached map, as part of Energy Park, to "-� Li�ht industrial B-2 Business � - -� RM-3 Heavier density Please no r��idential this i tem tand ha t the public develo Works �o�ittee of �Y 27th meetinp e rec°r°�enda on Wednes y� _ g• Pleas tion_�o the full City Council will da -- _ e brin Cit discuss May 27.y 1981,.. _ _ in g anY concerns you Y Council at their ' Room 707 City $all�at 10 pp A• this meeting M. QUESTIONS Zoning 298-4154 Vacation �7� , __ Notice sent May 8, 1981, by the Valuation and Assessment Division Department of Finance and Mansgement Services Room 218 City Hall - Court House St. Paul� Minneaota 55102 = F . , CONS�NT OF ADJOINII�TG PBOPERTY OWNERS 7'O RB�ONING ' ` � ;�'_� c We, the undersigned, owners of property within 100 feet of the total contiguous descriptions • of real estate owned by Petitioner or sold by Petitioner within one year preceding the date of this petition, acknowledge that we have been furnished with the following: 1. A copy of the Petition of Amendment to Zoning Ordinance City of St. Paul 2. A copy of Sections 60.450, 60.460 through 60.490 , inclusive, of the St. Paul Ordinance; and acknowledge that we are aware of the uses permitted under a R'M-2, RM-3 and B-2 llistrict zoning classification; and hereby consent to the rezoning of the property described irt the �etition of Amendment to Zoni��Ordi nance Ci tv of St, to a RM-2, RM-3, B-2 District. Paul RECORD OWNER SIGNATURE LOT BLOCK ADDITION P1 at �BURLINGTON NORTHERN IN 340 02 Sec.2 7_2g 2302700 � ' Vice Pres' ent � Ma 1 1981 Yetitions shall not be considered as officially filed with the city clerk until the lapse of 7 working ciays after a petition is received in the office of the city clerk. Any signator of any petition may withdraw his name therefrom by written request within that time. . �� 5889 Page 2 vf . • � ,- , CONS$PiT OF ADJOINING PROPERTY OWNERS TO REZONING , . �,,, . • , We� the undersigned� owners of property within 100 feet of the total contiguous descriptions , of real estate owned by Petitioner or sold by Petitioner within one year preceding the date of this petition, acknowledge that we have been furnished with the following: 1. A copy of the Petition of Amendment to Zoni ng Ordi nance of Ci ty of St. Paul 2. A copy of Sections 60.450, 60.460 i#�h 60.490 , inclusive, of the St. Paul Ordinance; and acknowledge that we are aware of the uses permitted under a RM-2, RM-3 and,�-2 llistrict zoning classification; and hereby consent to the rezoning of the property describec} in the Yetitior� of Amendment to Zoni n�Ordi nance Ci ty of St. to a RM-2, RM-3. B-2 District. ItECORD OWNER SIGNATURE LOT BLOCK ADDITION P1 at 4 700 '�CITY OF SAINT PAUL � O10 O1 Sec. 27-29-23 � PORT AUTHORITY OF THE 030 50 SE4 ec 27-29-23 � CITY OF SAINT PAUL NW4 020 28 Sec 27-29-23 Yetitions shall not be considered as officially filed with the city clerk until the lapse of 7 working aays after a petition is received in the office of the city clerk. Any signator of any petition may withdraw his n�me therefrom by written request within that time. � ^ � - -�= � � � � $8 �9 � I �' � .�- Page 2 vf � �t ._. � �; .._. � �. CONSBNT OF ADJOINING PROPERTY OWNERS Ti0 RTs?ONING - � • .. . � � ' ' + • We, the �ndersigned, owners of property within 100 feet of the total contiguous descriptions of real estate owned by Petitioner or sold by Petitioner within one year preceding the date of this - petition, acknowledge that we have been furnished with the following: 1. A copy of the Petition of Amendment to Zoni nq Ordi nance Ci ty of St. Paul 2. A copy of Sections 60.450, 60.460 -�hr�cagh 60.490 , inclusive� of the St. Paul Ordinance; and acknowledge that we are aware of the uses permitted under a RM-2, RM-3 and B-2 llistrict zoning classification; and hereby consent to the rezoning of the property described in the YetitioT� of Amendment to Zoni nc�Ordi nance Ci ty of St. to a RM-2, RM-3, B-2 District. Paul ItECORD OWNER SIGNATURE � LOT BLOCK ADDITION Plat 4 02700 � COLUMBIA TRANSIT � 200 26 Sec. 27-29-23 4 � 100 26 Sec. 27-29-23 , NW4 210 26 Sec. 27-29-23 Yetitions shall not be considered as officially filed with the city clerk until the lapse of 7 working dr�ys after a petitio►1 is received in the office of the city clerk. Any signator of any petition may withdraw his n�me therefrom by written request within that time. � � �_ _ °� pw � g.$� q ��- � Page 2 uf� �} ' � , � �_ �'. �• . CONSBNT OF ADJOINING PROPERTY OWNERS 'TQ REZONING ,, � � � �. . , . We, the u�ndersigned� owners of property within 100 feet of the total contiguous descriptions , of real estate owned by Petitioner or sold by Petitioner within one year preceding the date of this petition, acknowledge that we have been furnished with the following: 1. A copy of the Petition of Amendment to Zoni ng Ordi nance Ci ty of St. Paul _ ��C 2. A copy of Sections 60.450, 60.460 �#reag-� 60.490 , inclusive� of the St. Paul Ordinance; and acknowledge that we are aware of the uses permitted under a RM-2, RM-3, and B-2 llistrict zoning classification; and hereby consent to the rezoning of the property described in the Yetitiori of Amendment to Zoni r�cLOrdi nance Ci tv of St. to a RM-2. KM-3 and B District. Paul �i,ECORD OWNER SIG U LOT BLOCK ADDITION P1 at , NW 4 02700 � C. G. REIN � 150 26 Sec 27-29-23 ` ° NW4 20 26 Sec. 27-29-23 . Yetitions shall not be considered as officially filed with the city clerk until the Iapse of 7 working aays after a petition is received in the office of the city clerk. Any signator of any petition may withdraw his name therefrom by written request within that time. } $$O� . ! , , `I t.�._ �..:. . i �`�° _ . ` Page 2 uf � r - ;''�. - � ' , + • � � �r t=; "%� � � � STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF�� 4-" - Kenneth G. Dzugan, being first duly sworn, deposes and states that he is the person who circulated the within petition and consent, consisting of pages; that affiant is informed and believes that the parties de- scribe ad re the owners respectively of the lots placed immediately following each name, that affiant is informed and believes that each of the parties described above is the owner of property which is within 100 feet from any property owned by petitioner or sold by petitioner within one (1) year pre- ceding the date of this petition which is contiguous to the property de- scribed in the petition; that except for transactions described in the affidavits of ownership none of the parties described above has purchased or is purchasing �property from petitioner contiguous to the above described property within one (1 ) year of the date of the petition; that this consent was signed by each of said owners in the presence of this affiant, and that the signatures are the true and correct signatures of each and all of the parties so described. - Port Authority of the City of Saint Paul � 25 West 4th Street, Suite 1305 S . Paul h1n. 55102 ress 224-5686 e ephone Number Subscribed and sworn to before me this �.� da�y of , , 1981 . �� . �� Notar u ic "�� J�WEL M. OLSON ,� . �T,�.w.��.�� 's$9-- � ` � WASHINC3TON COUNTY __ ._,._,, My Commiw�on Expirss Sept.16,19l� ' % �. STATE OF MINNESOTA ) May 1 , 1981 ) �. COUNTY OF RAMSEY ) CITY OF SAINT PAUL J. C. Kenady, being first duly swom, deposes and states that he is Vice President of Burlington Northern Inc., the owner of the property to be rezoned, and has authority to lawfully bind the owner of the property t+o be rezoned, which is described as fo I lows: The property, shown within the heavy dashed and dotted line on the afitached Zoning Map, indicating proposed zoning changes from I-1 and I-2 to RM-2, RM-3 and B-2 being requested by Burlington Northern Inc.; that affiant says that Burlington Northern Inc. is the owner of said property, subject to an agreement of intent to sell the greater portion thereof i�o the Port Authority of the City of St. Paul except portion along the northerly side thereof. This Affidavit and accompanying Petition to Amend Zoning Code and Consent of Adjoining Property Owners are executed on behalf of Burlington Northern Inc. on the express condition that if the proposed Energy Park proposals of the Port Authority of the City of St. Paul and/or the City of St. Paul and the contractors, nominees, successors and assignees of both or either do not materialize and said sale from Burlington Northern Inc. to the Port Authority does not proceed for whatever reason, then the Port and City will immediately proceed to initiate steps to reinstate the 1-1 and I-2 zoning thereof as exists as of this date without any conditions or requirements for special use restrictions. That Burlington Northern Inc. ,� :-��n�v�.•.;��:�- is not in the act of purchasing any land contiguous b the property sought to be rezoned s � t' j � `� � � and that it is the owner of lands immediately adjoining on the north of said lands � � � _�� - , ,._ . ... . �• R ..-,. .. � �., � _ � `� � petitioned i�o be rezoned. � ' _�'�� w � a � J �" Q i.i c� > �r'�u > � °- � • > � � � � � Subscribed and sworn to before _ � � m� day f 19 . Vice President � � Burlington Northern Inc. . . �'�`� Notary Public k ~�i^./,,rJJd� � 0 0 . O n .-. � r__...,.._ _.. „ �. _,_ _ .._.-_ o --_.___� ... �, � _ j� ._.. - _� � � � 1 �/ ' .._.. ... ... R� � �j . �V'`7� . • . -_ . .� �. +� V �� p G � C a 10 Q � �� E o °.�.,m.�. E f o V +.. C m Rt � o o' t G� ro c '� 'O ll �L C '-N q,� *'N M C T y ��j X c ►�� rNC9�d 3 � ��,: J ro �.�g j (JITtVM�� b rNC9 4 (n�-G �O �if y N O ocacoco't �-F- acac �� acrtrs cv Omaomcmao ; --- c� wdd Sa �� _� � �'�`� � ' ;� � --'E - - i� _ �; � _ . w .,: i; i --• ' .. - �e i- i � � - �.-.-� � M�'�.irl ..t... -.� __ :i i ' � _ � :,�. ' _ It O _ !: . _ . � i � is � I N • oiwaxo ;.�' . , s ad e t .. .. � � �-- � � - - i i _,_:.c . . _! ; ._ .. � ; . - - i � i _ ' - , ; � � ; � < < ., N .r r�- � _ - t � - �...- ri , � � - �I� -�� ; -/; �. ' _ � n � -_;� , - �� -- _ ^ ' . � � '_ � . ,� . � � (�l � ! —_._ �� i:_..1[ .�:i� �, — :i i: � l_._J � i j I �i'_"- 1: �,� i � 11MRtl��NO1flN{%3l � .-. —_ _. . AVMNtltld- � �NOIBKX31 . t��`.�� • �� ' I ' I i� :I 11� a(I'�i t�i.I 1JJ ' t. 1�1 �� I tt ; �'� ► I _� '� � ��- F .� ;�,, ��: . , � � � - � ��, � __ � �� ; � �� , , - ,�' ' _ � - ,� �- _ - - ��_ ,�. �`�� ,��`�� dr Nna. ilk - � \ , ' — - C- - �? ?rE' � � •� �' r {I. ,\\ \�. �I, {� 1� p� 1... ___ � . .�r-... .�� i �{ 1'�. ,� �\ �. , — � � _ � _- �� 'i .i1 m f ,: � �, � ;�i ;� �� x: �' �� ,� �F� "'E a �� , I ` . � ..�.QI4� 1f1�`� i\ . I . . 1 ( .`i f �� 't� b[ a a a� _' _¢ . �` � ._C-.>`` � •"� > > 4 .:0 Y!�' � : l .. -�1.._ 4 . al .,, � . q v u . � f --7 1 9 .Q � ' � ._ - ' _� ❑ ,r/ .� '� ; � �'1�( - { C"- C t .I ` � . L � - - � ��r Il. f Y ' .� '. �, .i / ; ( .,. _ _ _ -r /� . �� ';.� ��4�� : � �' : ' '' . �: ��- ;r � �,i I � ii '' ;:r �/��. �: if ; 1 ' I I . Vb.: - y � ..� _ .) .�� :> � . 31Y �IONAS �N �� ;� � �� .{; � 'i -� r--� _ -- - � -- ��o _ I` � ° : : ' I i �r ' �� r -j , < � F. ... . � '. ' . o �-. ..i LJ . � � .' • �.. ' �� W �,_,,. Z� , � Z w :_— • � . � ,. . � . i . w I �w ° m ' ¢' o - � , � a ��Y� . ... �! ir�.�� , ,1 . 3 i, . .; � _._w i. _" Q .. " I. a _ i . [D� �� a . 1 I � ��u '_,34- _. ./'_�i.�� \,, . � � � . _ ; ' >L-�'_m � � �.. J"� .-.. , � 1 ' I ��- �y� �3� 34ilwON N � ' � . l� . •'/ �J' .-1 1� .�. . l�/ /� . i � a, I �I I � ! t ;! � ;,� ; j� L= --- �. N l ' � � � ; • is ia3eiv � I( , � io! � — _ ,P ` ; -I -- E— � � •. .___ l I �� Vf.J �� 1liBli N r . `� � � �—� �� is_ _ o_N s,�or 1 � � I_� L '_� , � I ` W � c�+ ` � �� 15 i ; ^� _ � w �� : , � , .r � � � l—_ �� J �1 �, I . _ __ r- _ ls a3nd3s � �! L.-1_J � '; � I� �. r—_____ � ; � j �� i � �% � ��'`' ;: �-I--; � r�. � � : • t :_'t�w, p 'i j _ � � , �� t i- z I � ', � ��- ' � .. � - � �, x '� o � > G � � o . � � i-- ` t+w��i �"'� � !� , � ��Ct ¢ . . . a, O '15 W� i � L �j ` � I� . . 4 u � 2 �.. �r1J � Q � . l: I ts r�� z a, �I - - � � , o � �� ¢ � ^ , , nt � f � Z � '�i' I i: � � d n , _.__ , , -- : _---�— ^-/L _�� I f �� r . ._. . .� J.i__ �.. �, .'.�. i � � --r�..T- �\�. ,.... �' . � � � .. �� - a �� I��_ O Z a ' ' I� L�� _i � r.i �.�..i ¢ � � i's` Aai g� � � � � �� _—, I � .�tl a�r ' - . . . . + , _; , t j (�_l �� --, � . I I� : � �� : - „ � I ' is_��3iioianH� I� ,665 1 . _ f I, I i i I,--� . � + I �� ; � ; I; � . I �__; �_ J J ;. �i . . - --- - - . - -� - : C/ �/ � . . fi� • • •� ' . • �4 � . , . � PETITION TO AMEND ZONING CO�E �'� .r `f �°��`� ..�. - . . , _ - �;/ J . . • ' , CITY OF ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA l) � , � j '� �v T'O THE HONOI�ABLE MAYO$AND CITY COUNCIL DAT � eto City Clerk, Room 386 City Hall E May 1, 19 81 . St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Purs��ant to Section 64.210 of the St. Paul Zoning Ordinance and Section 462.35? (5) of the Minnesota Statutes, _. Burl i ngton Northern Inc. , the owner of all of .� the land proposed for rezoning, hereby petitions your Honorable Body to rezone the following described property: � Street Address: See attached map ._ Legal Description:__As fi 1 ed wi th the Zoni nq Admi r�i strator.1100 Ci Hal l Annp;,� 25 West Fourth Street, Saint Paul , Minnesota 55102 from a I-1 and I-2________________________ District to a RM-2, RM-3 and 62 * -------------------------------------- - --- Distriet for thepurpose of constructinq housinp, commercia7 and nffira �tr��+��ras ,�r.g�t Park � *The attached map shows three areas as both RM-2 and B-2. Only one of those classifi- aations will be submitted to City Council , but the developer - Wilder Foundation- has not determined, as of this date, exaetly which buildings will be residential uses and which will be commercial uses. BURLINGTON NORTHERN INC. Subscribed and sworn to H before�fhis �_day y�v , � �' af Ma r 19$1 Title: ^ Vice President Petitioner . � �otary Public Y • R. H: BROKOPp ��J�� l�� - NOTARY PUBUC- Af�ryN�gOTA ��} RAMSEY COt�NTY `� �Y Comm.Expires April 12,1983 W1M/VVy�,,��„i°,��,�^✓WV✓' r'W.^eVyyt•u ��'� Page 1 of � ��. � ,-_ r � . -. �g�� :... 4�_.� . _ . :. ��'�., . �-,,, �� - �-;," ± . M1 . Q�o t V �] f � 4� �crt �� Yr '�~ i Y' �!�,:.:.�7:'yr��^�k\ �.` ;, �r+k+^,yt�yt]�--�_l�l� �'�'��/" �:Ji I��a � _ � � � I�� f 1 �i J_r�.�� ti ii'� l�3 � "''"""' :1 — � �_�V�`�4�.�e. ��....( ( Z - -� . ( _� � �� - . . ^... � . �f �,,, � � __ , . ,�'� _ �_ � �. _ . , �, . .. _ � � `T •� l�l,i � 1. �,. ��'�� !"`c � - -�E�11� �� r ti�!...i �� J.,.� � y , �.� \ � ,eja� � ,t I - r I �; , � --- -�'---�� -;- .� ll I�,� I ��,� irly� �`. {��,� + ^i ' � ...._._ --: s�-�' t i' �:z / '� � 1�:1 �� _ � �` �h,. �''�`� .'� �.�.. \ .�' t_�. .f a �� , ; ` i� +� � .' ,lr 1 t � � � . .. �/ !� � �' �i` � t �/. ' .,�� I•, ..�� `�\, � � ,� l� � �• �\ . ._.. .. , . r�' •��!� ,�+.........�....rr..,.^+.,r�� I i. • � � � `I+ � °�.�I ^ �I�� , �:: . _ ---- -- — -_ -- ; � `�� 1 - ,� � �r� - � ,, :l� , ,;� , .��i_= . =— ,i � �,�s ,�� Q� � , � � ` � � �`�, � � 1j , � ' , ' ; ��• i « '� � � , � - � _�. , � � � � � � �. ,3� � � � � O'0 �. �� ,e�, Q '' � � � �� ' 'o ��$ ' v� �0' � y .�� ; � � // l � // � � I i/ � • � '� �,7 ` :�e' ' / J�-�- � � .� 7/ t. I 1 _ ) •, i '� �". �- i i- � // ��'- t � � ; E•�� ?� • - -� i� i j, �� J�� --, a,t/ . f�1 '1� .e � �" � I � F7 I f�/ R �f ��{ i �,�, S� �< �� • . ;� �� ! �' � � � . ��, � � ; � � �k' � i,l�� % ._t � . �.•`;;;k � ; �+`� ; � .� t �• � �� -,, =�i # ' ' ' � `t..✓�.�� I1 � � i '�1: � � �`.\ ,' !t 't�� a \ `j 'i_�}_— -I- � ( �� .�• .,' i •F�'T.� .1 � _ j i I I� �� •�7� / � �� 1 ' _ 'r .Q j; � � t�� -•t � �� _i _�� l � �;� f �� ' �- � ;��I� �: � � o `, �'; a- � �. .. �.;_ , .,� 1. :f�� ._ry .�--, ; 1,10 �, t_ .6, ,� �_, 1, '�' � _ �) _ �x c � �,4•1•f •. , '� , �` �` + �✓� 1 .. • ��'• ii \ �\ 1,��• �� •.S� ', � � . - ... ,, � ' � � 1 �� 1] I1 n / � �� ! "� � ^� � . o �....i... . � . . .i � .� �� . It� '.�` .} - . . _. ... • : r � i'y '1 � � \� � �� •� � j , r '� i• �° � In 1•, M 7 +� � � � ... �i M� ��. �, �'n 1�. .� � '�� I � 1!'. . f � - . : 4 I . � ! : . s � � p J � !' J � � Y t �:� �'�_E' , � tg. �� G �, .�//^ ` / •� co �. 't `w. s, .�..I _ Za o t � ��'j . Qi •o�i'al I� � !�� ti/P-�E�' � •� 7-� a! f �3 Q1� -_,__� � � �j � ' 'k r ;�� . �-�^ _„� -;� ��i�a.=i p f� � � , � l �o��; � { � ��, �,�. -.�, , : �n. �'3', ' ` � � u. i [t�P;n ..�: i � o { Q � ��,'� 1 ! _a �,�-�-`l] I- ..- -� �♦ � Y• } 8 '�• 1 Ir �� Du ; '.;� 1 . �� y. 1� � � _ '..a$ :� z �'�� 8 ' �tl�l/;f�r{ � �I ; 7 � ` � '' � a f �' ` _1 q.,p� �� •�� '� � • 'I�� 8 � � �� i l �J 4 � � ,. + � i � F �t • ��_ � sli j?_ �• �� Il,��I�;, ) �; �, � j {� '(.� � a-�, ra ��.rl��':� �sF•� �O.a � 'i.'�"Il . c` i � II � ! . :2 �,'.! �i�,1 `,f+ " o � ,.a = � Q ,:�'i i'�,ti ` �,J I � i _ , � . . ' �£ �E � � � !' V � ! l� ��. [t � n �o i —�`f �r ��' �� '��• F, i ��: i:�' •� � �I � s� � . e e •'l,, • •� _ '� f'� � tI ;� • '• '�g • '. ':i��. b c� '� " � :y :1 'tl£� # .i� ��'_��• � �� ° ��, �,,.�y �� `� o � ,j r t'�f�' � i •p� _'_J � - � � Of'`.:��' R $� i :r � 1 0� t '��Y'I' f I i j --^ � � �QJ. r u �.��(9��1'� �� t �. } II I,I I � .tL ! � �j� � °� �' / �� J E 1•� � _e � .I m _��1��i� � � I ! t ��E _� •� '�a � � �f�� '� L I�Gi�,:.i� � � _� f �`" � ° ' f ll' J A :�� __� • � ,....... , ti : � � I� �' �; -. � ,' r� _s '� �' Y = +�. �_'� I �! '�-'•° '! _- � r.;,, Y t i �i a e � ,!` . �' t `c � � � I � � � �' �r. � � 'S� � ��" r�',r` � �\ i I i �`� (]� I(� �q _ .g:C�+�: _ �y . :� � '�� 'E /` '�(:� l E q t ' I � /j 1O r� ' I a �'¢�� Q ��' � F � i_ ��-.'' f��s, 1 �I�,.s }, c '1-��s`�}-� }. ►� `�,�,,,', € " � �IL ; 'ri/ _.` l; s i \=i '' � ' r `.'.�P� ''• ` rLJj��1 [�-' ,- - „1� �•�� ', � !�' t�f. ��, .'� �_ ' � �� :�i, q _ _ E� °(•�` �-_�_ _ �� t_..� '!� i rs�/� �J� '•� � ;, �-�,'�� j�` � ':r a` - ,� I� �^ �, / �/�� :.t� ��,ti _?, i� -�/ �! �; �,� �� :i � �, �I � { tL''� %'_ ' ,:r�v �r--5.. '`� \'. I � + `� C ��}. �. j..°l ] ` Jl�� S J � t. � �¢; 7�� ' �j � �' ,, . � �" .'t0 �� '� �� , t � �~ _�,. _�, , - �� i' ; �-.- "� � �, �. . � � �, � ,� i ::�� "�� — ' ',� i. �•' �� ..: _ � �� ; •� ' " F l 1 ° - _,;:�-- - _ ,� /�'�' � % :� a .1�;�� e t _J / ^ e- _-• . . - �.�i :1' � /.. � j a ,� ' �� f' 1 � , t I' : ` ' ��'�i � I I' , iD�i f�.. . „ �� ' i / �r � . �ia� � i L� t� i�.i•, , O� � : � ( ; � � � - � _ � ' �' �. I�� `� f' .� � f . /� . � � i � ,' ; .' ; � � � i�' '; ' i• �`� 3 ' '�'� � sr = . 1� � �. �.� .�� ;�,.,�. • � - 1 °� �. �. . ` . � � �' •" '� J ' . _. '- `; � '`.i ! t �."�¢_ , _ R----� `}�}� � 1 i� ! � .1._`_ I �. o' ♦. _ ��: � ' �� .t i ; . ,�� ii �. I J'J tI .�i A . . - ( � � . - 1;I�.!I--..1•_- - ---_..�f�Dn..n ,,,, �.z�. ; :�� ..'. . _.--.. _ ,, { � � 1 _ � ,� _ � �ik y � . - ;' � • i i , � .� . . + �' ,� I Y i q.� '' � ¢ �.' , 1 ,. •I 1, ' t , � � —_�� ! � �! M • ! � �t • • �, ' � 1 - f:. • � r�, � ! ! ! . •!. !�� ' ' '. O�� .�;�, i: I �. i � • '. • � i t �j. ;-� � �LL. ^ �• � I(�� • ' �� Z ? N } �- �. ' ,, f--r►-r . � . 4� 11� �� •� �. } � LL! J �g , if - '. • !' O� L� QOG �' � � :" 'i� ;E .j � � � , '` .;� 1, v� m o°c o _ � � � �� , , j I , , -, 1 W �t-- ` _.. . ;� �� • t . I � 1 ' ► l• ' zm¢c�, j. . � . ,. � . � . .: � �,. = o �� ' - - �' 1 � E�: � -=` _ :• . !';� c.�� v~Wi w z°�' ` ' r, z � =¢m _: " ., _1 , ; "� :6; ' l �--� � F- �; . ��• � z o-oc.-� o - �; ��: ► owo i z 1: _ , �. � � i N � Z►-� Q I- i . i - ' . i ;^1 � . . . . . ,. ,,. � , a i . . � , - a • ' _ . . • I1 � f � i�4 � -- -- � . t_ � _ � _ _ _ • � , �' � ` .� � G ,�•-..� , � � _�. ' ' � _ � f.� �' , �. � E. �:' � i � . !t t . `` �� _• +! � 'I'� ? J _ - __ ,�� 1 ; �� '�__�� i_ �7�� ',j: i: "'� ��i .��!� �:.:,•Ji ` �'.,—_< <.# �;; t�ii�i � � . _.� �� c- � , . .,T��.� .. � ` ' C - � � ,.�� '' � �'�' " � . � ' 1 � ,�- =�1�`�Y� �r.�-�-�'�--^� �� _�f�y_ a,-e�. p t• _)' .f f i � r d .. � . . f j� -� �.w� ry _' 1 • , .\. t-'• •(� t . . . � _ �/��} ,��,�,,,,`�"�."!^"-f s> � -_..�.. - .. _�. _ � f . ' '_"`�' � j�'� . .-...�. . �`: '_.' i • .: � '� - ,_. . .�... . . ..,; .„ . . _. 1�. t. .� . , . :. :. . . � : � .. ., _ -._..... 3 _ �