The URL can be used to link to this page

276805 WHITE - CITY CLERK ��5�� PINiC - .FINANCE COUIICII � CANARY �''DEPARTMENT � GITY OF SAINT PAITL BLUE - MAYOR File N O. t rdin�nce orainance N 0. 1 (�7�� Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date An Ordinance amending Chapter 60 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code pertaining to zoning for the City of Saint Paul and the zoning maps thereof. WHEREAS, Pursuant to Minnesota Statutes �462 .357 and �64.210 of the Legislative Code, Richard Varberg duly petitioned to rezone Lot 1, Block 2, Lake Park Addition, located on the southwest corner of Arona and Como from B-3 to RM-2 for the purpose of using an existing structure as an apartment building, the petition having been certified by the Department of Finance and Management Services on November 14, 1980 as having been consented to by at least 67� of the owners of the area of the property to be rezoned, and further having been consented to by at least two-thirds of the owners of the property situated within 100 feet of the total contiguous descriptions of real estate held by the same owner or any party purchasing any such contiguous property within one year preceding the date of the petition; and WHEREAS, The current Planning Committee on December 18, 1980 conducted a public hearing for the purpose of considering the re- zoning petition, and pursuant to Section 107 .03 of the Administra- tive Code, submitted its recommendation to the Planning Commission that the petition be granted; and WHEREAS, TYie Planning Co�nznission considered the rezoning petition at its meeting held on December 19, 1980 and recommended that the City Council approve the petition; and WHEREAS, Notice of a public hearing before the City Council on the said rezoning petition was duly published in the official COUNCILMEN Yeas Nays Requested by Department of: Hunt l.evine I[1 FBVOt Maddox McMahon Showalter Against BY Tedesco wlson Form Approved y City tto ne Adopted by Council: Date / f Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY By Approved by Mayor: Date Approved ayor or Submission to Council By BY WHITE - CITY CLERK �µ� ./�p PINK -� FINANCE COUt1C1I •�,/'�� *"• CANARY - DEPARTMENT G I TY OF SA I NT PAU L ^� ' �� `"� � BLUE - MAYOR File N O. � � Or ZIZGLIZCP. Ordinance N O. l � 7�� Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date newspaper of the City on April ll, 1981 and notices were duly mailed to each owner of affected property and property situated wholly or partly within 350 feet of the property sought to be re- zoned; and WHEREAS, A public hearing before the City Council, having been conducted on April 23, 1981 where all interested persons were heard, and the Council having considered all the facts and reeommendations concerning the petition; now, therefore, THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: Section l. That the zoning map of the City of Saint Paul, Sheet No. 2, as incorporated by reference in Section 60 .401 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, as amended, is hereby further amended as follows: That property located on the southwest corner of Arona and Como, being more particularly described as Lot l, Block 2, Lake Park Addition, be and is hereby rezoned from B-3 to RM-2 . Section 2 . This ordinance shall take effect and be in force thirty (30) days from and after its passage, approval and publication. -2- COUIVCILMEN - Yeas Nays Requested by Department of: Hunt � �� evine In Favor Maddox McMahon sewwaE� O Against By Tedesco Wilson MAY 2 6 1981 Form Approved b Cit A ney Adopted by Council: Date Certified P ed by Council ecretar BY f B l. Appr by Mayor: a AY 2 9 � Approved by yor f ubmission to Council By BY UBLISNED ,1 UN s i981:= � � � � �� . �� .� CITY OF SAINT PAUL �a;~ . a� DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT r iiii�i t'i � -,,° ^ DIVISION OF PLANNING �+ +ea• 25 West Fourth Street,Saint Paul,Minnesota,55102 GEORGE LATIMER 612-298-4151 MAYOR March 27, 1981 Rose Mix, City Clerk Room 386, City Hall St. Paul , Minnesota 55102 RE: Zoning File No. 8781 - Richard Varberg City Council Hearing: April 23, 1981 Dear Madam: This letter is written in response to the petition of Richard Varberg to rezone property at 1195 Arona Street from B-3 (General Business District) to RP1-3 (_High-Density, High-Rise Multiple Family Residential District) in order to allow the owner to continue to use it as an apartment building. On December 18, 1980, the Current Planning and Zoning Committee conducted a public hearing on this case, at which time the applicant requested an Rh1-3 zoning but also indicated that an RM-2 (Medium Density, Low Rise f�lultiple- Family Residential District) zoning would be acceptable. Two letters were received; one in support of the RM-3 zoning and one from Como Community Council in opposition to the RM-3 zoning but in support of RM-2 zoning for this property. The Committee recommended denial of the requested RM-3 rezoning but approval of the RM-2 rezoning on a vote of 4 to 0. The Planning Commission considered the Current Planning and Zoning Committee's recommendation on December 19, 1980, and denied the RP1-3 rezoning petition but recommended an RP�1-2 rezoning for 1195 Arona Street on a vote of 19 to 0. The matter of the requested rezoning is scheduled to be heard by the City Council on April 23, 1981 . Please notify me at least by April 22, 1981 , if any member of the City Council wishes to have slides of the site presented at the City Council public hearing. Sincerely, . � � Marvin R. Bunnell City Planner - Zoning ��1RB/mb attachments O KULL LHLL llUlt - YLHi(iYlIVV �Utlt"1lJ51UIV � , � - � aATE� o� �9 �� $��5 . . _ � �;' �%t�'��. •�+L'`�Gk •ts t,'�p c�uvsen► UflRBFR(� �"isT,C•2.5' Zr�t SriR�.7: � "''�,�s /�a=. �c� !�. # �7�'/ � 97 � I 2 3 4 5 6 - � YES NO A* YES NQ A* YES NO A* YES NO A* YES NO A* YES NQ A* A�IDERSON � � ✓ t/ � V ARMSTEAD BRYA�� ✓ ✓ �/ s/ ✓ � - - cocH�aN� -� ✓ � ✓ ✓ � - � FITzGIBBON ;/ t� 1/ t/ ;✓ ►� . Gfi�AIS ✓ I,/ ✓ � ✓ HANGG I ✓ �/ ✓ i/ t/ ✓ HUBER � / ✓ � t� ✓ t/ HYDUKE ✓ �� ✓ 1/ � E KAnl�IE �% �� ✓ ✓ - 1/ / KAR,'JS :� �� V i/ ✓ � / LANEGRAN � �� / �l / E.EVY �/ ,,/ / � t/ !f McDO�lELL � iYELSOtJ i/ if !/ ✓ _ � �% ;; �. / , PANGAL !��°' -- SCHMIDT �/ t� !/ ✓ :,/ � SU�y1�lERS V ✓ � � ✓ � - TAYLOR �/ 1/ ✓ ,/ ;/ ✓ . TOSLER �/ � �;' ,/ t/ � �, �,V . L . VAiV NOcF 1!�% � � v i TOT�LS � Moti on 1 ��.,u ,�� Y�y�/U��^-� /G � o Moti on 4 8�Lc.,;. /lj!';ir��.�/,J; /1 —U _ (��1rJ�10?� 2 /1��n j� ,�" � ,.r r ;1 �/��.. � �'�Ot10C! rJ j^' �',t-,..• j f �� .,>a.,_ /Cl Q i'IO�IOYI 3 .i_. _ � ��:• ! �ij.�,.J ' i- i'�OtTCF) 6 �' ��=''�y� � _ .; :Y�,,�� '� -- � �, __ _ __ _ . __. . . �.,_ ,4. � �,=.Q:a, __�-.,�r.�...�„�_�.. .�.�,.,Y..,.,�,,,._. ... ..�..--.,.....,.�.,.�•.,...-. ..--,�.r -..-.._..,..---.._..�..�-„a�r� � r °�- . . �,•. - r � _ , _ :._,�..,.. - . . ., . ,�, �_ , ;_. . . . .. - . ..: . . . � � � .. . .� ,. , . . " .'��.. ,...�`:.�� ..�.'" . .. . . . . . . . _... . .. . . . . }z r^:?� �*{' i':�=a+-.'�_+...�. . � � . .. . . . . . . ,�,. . . � . 4 ;#1 ;y . , ... . . , . _ f�:q`u �''.,t�tl.Y t Y" � . � • � . . .. - . � . ��,4'c t t !-,,,�'t, r� � . . - 1 -.. ,�"s�+ ^a�' � ,.,*.. ,. � ... ,_ : .. � _ y�� y p�,- +e d � ,�� Y'� 4� 4,. �. l A �y�} +� 1 , - . i. . ,�-�T i *{f.°t:'^t �'��. �.., � %��. .� ' .. `., � _• '. ' . . . . � .�. S7.. PAUL PLAtVNIN6 COMMISSION : z ' ,� ra . - •-. ` ' ` ' � z� � ��s . . .�..�. . . . , .. �, �) ..,� ..�� ....� . - _. .. �;,k. , . -. r� � N �y � k � xAT��' .?C . i ..� 4 , #' � �� ., : ,.a � 'w �, ^q'-�� F+7 •y v;1 ,_,T. � �,�, . . .. - � �' � '��,� i f3„ ` . ^ r - , .. . � _ ^ ,., .. :: .... , * •. TO• DeparLnent of Finance+�a � : . � nd Management Services `� ` �� ( 4 � i� Qivision of�.Assessments and Valuat�ans �� ' a��= �� „r , � , � � ��f ��,a - '11 Y�'�.�3 �'i � y 5 Y d�W��ANA4_§. c ' _.. '-� .,.wi`yC.� ,.a."c ; _...'r '. % ' .;r. : '., .. �: � .: :k c,�;a c . ya xr . � f?his .1s ^to announce that .the St. Pau1 Plann�ing Car�misslon has :acted�o» �,�: �� p� : �� _ the matter descrfibed below=and is prepared �� submit its reconmendat1ons to t°�"�" �`° om �t't` a Ci ty Counci 1 publ ic hearing � ` � £ � �;� ' } '%�h� y�Y '� .4;+ � ; �i'` , .��A�;� ; .;. . .- ..F�+-�k i-� t i�G.!"'�' * 1 i h #�� : y� b ' 4 S ..; F� �.:f'NE _ f Y ��+� �� ,f�+ � X2514 � ��'.�� „ �, .� a .�.",a� Yfyt'�� _:«� f,�4� ]'� ~ y g �� g _'.SVN..eL,... � f ��^w'� { �:yvtyt'N-�Y�1e.�� Y � ntLR.�� *x '� '� . �. : � � � [ h. � � . {��;: Date r' - � , : �. December 22, 1980 .7��;� �r' s-�� ' , , .- �' � ' �' e v ,�� , t .� �" <<. ; . ., . �y� s�;� Fe f� N . . . ...z,-��.._ � ., ._� , � �.. �_ . . �_ � . . ... '.. . . . ..- � �. r� - ��a . .��y. ::� . . � � � � ��'-., � w`�'�� ` �`�' Zoninq rF1le number � 8781 - ��.��`�'�;�� a ��`� �) � A � �� 7�� ' :� LA�L.'J". 'i ..fr . i4"Y T� i � . . �. . - . .' ; 4 , �R F,.:�+ ., .. .. � � . ur. �� ' .�yt, � �'t,� - APPI ficant's nam� • Richar� Yarberg � ' .� �� # `��` �� ,t ., _� � � ��^ .. . T 1t.� �1' h' . �� '� 'Rf�,.�.�i�� s s _-� x �m Zi ,;,„�� ,,N��-�`1f' . «c,:�Rt`t� � .ti" �<��u�, x �+e. �.::� .'-. ..'^r;�:g� P� �_�.�4 . �. '.` 4'"`. 1r'i`..t,,�� "}:. -'�R."�'l�x��Y � � ��"�s` � P.0 aox ]72�9 39�t� ��the1 Dr=��y 5t Pau� `,455112 ,�� , ��.� Y� �� ; � �.; � ��„< �. � ,� '� _ �` # �� ;,�.r� �� "" � . . .N'a'f� �'y`�f �.°a'�.� ,� 't' � � Purpose�� . Rezone r'rom B-3 to Ri�3-3 to a1`�c�w continued �use� of . � ` � `' 6 'unit apartment bui�ding � .. �°� X �,�° r 2 i . { . ; ., - . . .. , _ >, � � , . F -., . � � '�� .. . . �.. , �[�'A�f�`7 � �'w :: . '. . . ,_ .. : .-.. .._ �i '. L � ° � Gi ` Locati on . ; : . ' 11�5 Arona (S�:i corr�e�r �lrona aa�d C�rra) ' � t = �, •' ., ... , '� � £.. Y� ..: ;�Y h�.��r4`° �� . '#�... �+ Y � aY tt.a �'�S '' ,e,,,.0 �l k,�� `� .. � " 4 " "EY :-T'^�``�'� F :G�'�i��_ a-�.�; }} .: . . . t �.:?T y . ..`�y h. {� R`. t . ' _ .. ~ -,j� 4�?'�`'d.� +?'�j�� -., ' [ R '�"� . . ��. y . . .� �. . 'F'^Y 4 ty�#sia'� rJ�' f� ,�\ �Y �� fi Legal descr�ption : �.Qt 1 , 81ock 2, Lake Park Add1tion, Th3rd�,Divi�ion�{$,�� ° ''� � . � � 1. �• ,w ,,.• m.� ae.� tw = *��"� ��♦ � � � +'��.+�. , ,�; _ .. ..�.. �. t � � k.. , ., P. �.,, . ... : . , - A¢ ._ i � ,�_ _ . ..' ,. . � ..�, : ._'. -,' . , ��-5 . ..'. _ . , ., . ' " ... 5 �; �r y�`:� �:�� r,. ': . . 3 F ��t� ,� _ , �-. '� �': �., .` '� �i k t ,. . , p T` �� „ �;, � .. .. � �� 4�� ,y. � ��+'�.�V�I�:R(�r�� w t � J� . 4 I'��3 _ . 4_Y �Y:�j�"5 - l�i �,��,Y y��y"'�4N'� \� �A . _ . . � '� t �,�bet.�� f �'rt�� . . � ct d��Z'.k'�.,�- .r;.� R 7° -t: . . L "i t..,� 4 F� �,1'3'1 � . . .: '. . S f �E")F ! y� . +� �r' tfx `+1 4 J 11�Y kF.C#�'w��' In.addition, lease include the following interested parties, � .Y �� A� �;'. , p . ; {h�, �3� . - . ; . . . _ ' � . , r �x�� D�Stric� 10 . "� r� f�:�� : � �� x � r{� � � , �,,�r��.�e+� , ,� �-,.� .� - � f � z t a- i '� d,Y,..+�+„ - � i'� i s �}�,,x,.,,r:�C� ,�,�� .�i r �n_� � 4f+� ,m ' -, _ � 4�4,.:, , �� s � �� s � . �.k �� `.i �* �,�.M��,.- yu+{r ��p" ,� � � Ui�� 'AiF - ;+�� .r - ^'' iW'�� a.d i ' � *._. - 1�� %Y +� f �j� �f � ..�i` J��+f�� ;i�.: � "�`. . ' , .. �� .. 'c� Ni'e� �v.�M°w� �: y. ` REQUEST FOR COUNCIL HEARING � ��<,A ew��;� z� � �� { ti ,� � �. "� � �H � £ � �, ° f bE ;T �4 Yt� �'s '+p� ��,f�'i�,�� ,". q� �i �. �r �r � . �'. t� t . ,�:�`s�#" Y ..f � .�',�,fa� �`��T�� .: x , � � . ., , .�: , , . , � .•..�� , - � '� � ,: :: ;'5��'�� rF»� '». �'� z'�.M1 �`�r� �. � .: � .. . . __:._�_.�„�.,,,,,�,._ •- . / . �' ,.. - ' " ` ' " .` . " . .. �� - � ,. �.,�.,., .,. "z ,•: � . o .. . ., �� , . ., . .'2t�y „_ -� . . .:. .. . ::. q� . . ' . ."c. :. .ra � . .-..... �d�d[�1Yqq.'8�rYif--'. 3:si�', _ �,.�=. . .. -. � . � ��5 MINU�fES OF TIIE PtEETING OF THE BOARD OF ZONIPIG APPEf�LS IN CITY COUNCIL CfiAM�ERS, ST. �AUL , P�IINNESOTA, DECEMBER 23, 1980 PRESENT: h1�ne. t�lorton; �•tessrs. Grais , Peterson and t•Joods of the Board of . Zoning Appeals ; �ir. Jerome Segal , Assistant City Attorney; . Ms. Lane of the Division of Housing and Building Code Enforcement; Ms. Beseman, P�r. Bunnell , Mr. Tedesco and Mr. Torstenson of the Planning Division Staff. , : �_ ,�� ABSEMT: Mme. Summers; Messrs. Kirk and Osborn. �,� The meeting was chaired by Gladys Morton, Chairman. . DANIEL WARaERG (#8647) : �t request for variance of 3,412 sq. ft. lot ar�a and density variance of 3 rooms on property located at 1195 Arona. The appellant was represented. There was no opposition at the hearing. ��ir. Bunnell showed slides of the site and reviewed his staff �~eport witr� a recommendation for approval contingent upon the rezoninq to RM-2. A letter was received from the District 10 Como Co►�nunity Cauncil supporting the variances irr comt�ina�ion with an Rt�-2 re�or°�ing. In addition, the Zoning Com�nittee and Planning Con�nission supported the RM-2 rezoning appiicatian. Paui Varberg, 1466 Como, representing the appellant, stated that he has been managiny the propert;y for the last 2 y�ars. �!e said they have applied for an RM-2 rezoniny to allow for the 6 unit apartment building and are now request�rig � density and area variance. Hearing no further testimony, Ms. P1orton closed the p�blic h�aring portit�n of the meeting. , Mr. Grais made a motion to approve the �ariances req�ested based on ' , • findings 7 through 10 of the staff report and contlnaent upon the RM- " rezonina. Mr. Peterson seconded the motion. The motion passed on a roll ;� call vote of 4 to 0. • � e = Submitted by: Approved by: f . � , � / .�L.J U'-'� � G' _ ��_,�,��- � ,,�,�lc�'z o�'�— Marvin R. Bunnell Gladys M6rton, Chairman ' . . _ :'a � 7VV� U l. 1.114 � Vy�A�.J v� . .�v� � .. �... �J " . �.. �. ; ,aY:"� - �' '3-k`-`'..+ !, - - w+`�.�.kLA.�Cl,G.t3.�.J.Q.�c�kl,.►t a,�.�r�„ ''")''� y��p��L�„qA� � . . . :� . � . . . '� . . . . . ..w . .�k��"_��iy,.. . M.;�. _. . . ;,� / l- �'c�.� :=r��°'T,' °'a`�: CITY OF SAINT. PAUL _� *-,. :,, ' '' `�� DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT , ;� ; �` .� au��ruw ,- :� '.m1 11��q ;.�' ;.• `''`-,,„, •... - DIVISION OF PLANNING ��ativa:•w�''��: 25 West Fourth Street,Saint Paul,Min�esota,55102 GEORGE LATIMER ' 612-298-4151 MAYOR December 22, 1980 Richard Varberg P.O. Box 1728 3900 Bethel Drive St. Paul , Minnesota 55112 RE: Zoning File No. #8781 , • Dear Mr. Varberg : - On December 18, 1980, the Zoning Committee of the Planning Corrgnission considered your petition to rezone 1195 Arona Street from B-3 {General Business District) to R�1-3 (FEigh Density, High-Rise Mu7tip7e-�Fan�ily Resider�tial Dis�rict) in ord�r to ailow you to continue to use the property as a six-unit apartment building. The Como Corrununity District 10 Council supports the rezoning of this property to RM-2, but not RM-3 due to their desire to avoid the possibility of a high ris� on this site which would be allowed with an RM-3 re�on;ng. The Zoning Committee agreed with this position and rationale and voted to deny the RM-3 rezoning but to approve an RM-2 r�zoning for this property. On December 19, 1980, the Planning Canmissivn considered the Zoning Corr�nittee's recommendation and denied the RM-3 rezoning petition but recornmended an RM-2 re2oning for ]195 Arona Street on a vote of 19-0. � The City Council will schedule another public hearing on this matter and you wi11 be notified of the hearing date. Sincerely, � � . �• � Marvin R. Bunn�ll � City Planner-Zoning � ,. MRB/cc cc: District 10 ' . � :`; .v� 4,�,�,,�--..._,.�._.;.�.,....�.�T ;��w„„�.. � r,� � _ s .. '�. -.- . _ _.�`r _ . . _��-'?��..-��, ,,e„ . �1 .' �,, � �J � ' h1INUTES OF THE CURRE�JT PL/1NNIP�G AND ZONIMG COMMITTEE IN CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS, ST. PAUL, MIPJfJESOTA, ON DECEPI3ER 18, 1980 PRESENT: P�essrs. Bryan, Hanggi , Levy and Pangal of the Current Planning and Zoning Committee; Mr. Jerome Segal, Assistant City Attorney; Ms. Lane of the Division of Housing and Building Code Enforcement; Ms. Besemarr, Mr. Bunnell , Ms. Daykin and Mr. Grochala of the Planning Oivision Staff. ABSENT: Mmes. Karns and Summers ; Messrs. Armstead and lanegran. The meeting was chaired by James Bryan, Chairnan. RICHARD VARBERG (#8781 ) : a request to rezone from g--3 to RM-3 property located at 95 rona Street. The applicant was represented. There was no opposition present at the h�aring. t�lr. Bunnell showed slides of the site and reviewed his staff r�port w�th a recommendation that the requ�sted rezoning to RM-3 be denied but that th� property instead be given strong consideration for rezoning to RM-�2. Two letters were received; one in support and on� in op�osit;is�n to the RM--3 but favoring an RP1-2 rezoning. The District 10 Community Council submit�ed a letter changing their original ,position on this matter. They stated that they were against the RM-3 but would support an RP�i-�2 rezoninr. PauT Uarberg, 146b Como, representi ng the appl icant, st��:d the,y wo�Ici T�i ke to have the property r�ezoned to R�^�1-3 but that they had talked with staff about the RM-2 rezoning and would be in favor if the 8oard decided on that.' He said that basically their request is to have the property rezaned to allow the use of 6 apartments which would be 13 rooms ir� the building. They also talked with the neighbors and only one iridicated that he wc��ld r�th�r t;av� 7t rezanecf ta R41-2. Hearing no further testimony , I�Ir. Bryan closed the public hearing portion of the meeting. t1r. Segal exp 1 ai ned the probl em that exi sted at the ti m� thF appl i car�t wi tl-idrew his request for an RM-2 rezoning. Mr. Bryan clarified that the applicant wauld have ta get t;wo var•iances for the requirement on the square footage and the number of rooms. Mr. Bunnel l corr�ented that the variance reyuests hac9 beE:n ::;ubmi tted a€��f are scheduled for public hearing. Mr. Pangal made a motion to recommend approval of the RM-2 rezoning based on finding 12 of the staff reoort. ^�r. Levy secos�ded th� r,;nrion. The motion passed on a rall call vote of 4 to 0. Submitted by: ApprQve by: , � � �a�.. � . 3 �__-.___-''�� . „� ,��i�.�- ---��' Marvin R. Bunnell �� ;�� e�i s Bryan, C rman i � � � -, ,,_......,...__.,._�._. T r, -> -_-.,��,�,�.�,,. ..,._. - _ ,.��..,,� --�,-„-�..,�.'�v""'� �� .�_r_.�..�. . ..; ._.�. r�,.�._,.,..,.�.__ _ _ _ .�,�;, •:�. ,-- . . / / C^�;� , � ;;: CQMO COMMUNITY COUNCIL DISTRICT 10 ;,, 1339 No. Pascal Avenue - St. Paul, Mn. 55108 r� � 3�, ,� � � . xnc...y. . . �� . � . . .;:r,��`� - . - � . i,4`'��'. December 17, 1980 � - _ � TO: Zoning Committee �' Board of Zoning Appeal '� St. Paul Planning Commi,ssion Attn: Marvin Bunnel]. �, -�; -•�r � FROM: Mike Fritz j RE: Zoning File No. 8781 - Varberg On December lfi, 1980 th� Cc��c� Communi.�y Council I7istxict 10 reconsidered �he Varberg Zoni.ny matter because of new zn� , formatione According to Zoni.ng Ordinance� 61.101 (j)��In an RM--3 District, multiple-family resident�. buildings five (5) storzes or less in height shall. con�orr� to the requi.rements of the RM-2 SCHEDULE OF REGULATIONS, SECTION 61.10I RESI- DEtiT�L DISTRICTS:� Since tk:e�e is no apaarent advantage of zoning this property RM-3 we withdraw our support af a re-zoning to RM-3, but do support rezoning to RM-2 and the density variance as requested by Mr. Varherg. Sincerely yours; � �� _ Nlike Fri.tz Chairman, Como ommunity Cauncil Distr.i.ct 10 MF/md cc: Mr. Paul Varberg � � � � �� 7 � �� --�.�.. _ .�_ ..___.._._� ..._ . . . _ �...�...__�.T.. �..� ._�....�.._�.�...�.�-�.�:�,.�..�,.ro_�.��..�� . , �� -- ... ��.__._ . �'�`' *��< � � . . �'�� s�s� � , � • ZONING STAFF REPORT 8637 � , aPPLICANT: RTCHARD VARBERG DATE OF H£ARING 12/18i80 ry C L A S S I F I C A T I 0 N . . • � . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . GURRcIiT PLANNING & ZONING COMMITTEE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS f:ezoning � Variance ❑ Special Condition Use ❑ Administrative Review ❑ Detcrmination of Similar Use ❑ Other ❑ Change of Nonconforming Use ❑ �t.her � 3. L(1CATION: 1195 Arona Street (Southwest carner of Arona and Como) . 4. LCGAL DESCRIPTION: Lot l , Block 2, Lake Park Addition, Third Division. 5. PRESEPdT ZONING: S-3 ZONING CODE REFEREP�CE: Sections 64.210 & 60.461 G. STAFF INVESTIGATION & REPORT: DATE 12/8/80 gy Marvin R. Bunnell A. SUFFICIENCY: The application was filed on a consent petition subscribed and sworn to before a notary public on October 17, 1980; declared sufficient by the Finance D�part- ment on November 14, 1980; and received in the Planning Office on November 24, 1980. Eight parcels were eligible, five parcels were needed, and seven were obtained. The purpose of the rezoning from B-3 (General Business District) to RP�1-3 (High Densityg High-Rise Multiple-Family Residential District) was stated on the petition as: allowing us to continue to use it as an apar�ment building. B. FRONTAGE & AREA: This corner site is rectangular in shape with a 120 foot frontage on Arona Street and a 54.9 foot frontage on Como Avenue, for a total area of 6,588 sq. ft. C. SITE/AREA CONDITIONS: The site is occupied by a 2-story white stucco building set at- grade on the north and east property lines. The part of the site not occi�pied by the building is level and contains a parking lot in the rear of the structure surrounded b,y a chain link fence. Tc the west is a parking lot for the Midtown Raquetball G1uk� located across the street. Further toward the west are t�ro houses and a community business district which also extends across Como just north of the site. To the e�st and south are single farnily and duplex housing units. Ther,e are RM-2 Muliiple Family Districts a blocic south of the site, a hal�-block to the east of the site and three blocks north of the site. I� is lacated adjacent to a Community Business District with a grocery stor� only 1? block away and on two bus lines. D. ZONING NISTORY: On February 29, 1980 Dale Uarberg, brother of the applicant, filed a consent petition seeking a rezoning to RM-2 for this properi:y. On May 6, 1980, Daniel Varberg, son of the applicant, filed for a density variance for this property. On h1ay 15, 1980, the Current Planning and Zoning Committ�� laid over the rezoning request until June 5, 1980 at the request of Dale Varberg and his att�rney. At th��t. t�r�rt� there was some question whether density variances of this type could in fact be legally c�ranted by the Board of Zoring Appeals. �n May 27, 19�s0, the Board of Zoning Ap�euls laid over the requested variance until September 23, 1980 at the request of Daniel Varberg based on the understanding that Varberg would seek the variance following the needed rezoning. On J!�ne 5, 1980, the CurrE>nt Planning and Zoning Committee laid over the rezoning request until Septemb:er 18, 19�0 at the request of . �I7 Nf��NA�� ttnrncv .Cln CAfI'FPC1}1PN 7 7_ 19Af] the� P7 anni na .Off i ce recei ved a l etter from . . ��; _ • . .J � �Ci.J� RICHARD VARBERG (rr8781 ) STAFF REPORT PAGE 2 E. FINDINGS CONT'D. 4. In 1975 the site, along with both sides of Como between Snelling and Arona, was rezoned B-3 (General Business District) as part of the citywide zoning change. The site was not considered for RP�-2 zoning in 1975 in part because a dentist office still functioned at 1195 Arona. 5. The building is eligible for legal nonconforming status for four apartments since the nonconforming use of the building was in existence when the 1975 Zoning Ordinance went into effect. 6. The Building Department, after an inspection requested b,y Richard Varberg in August 1978, issued a Certificate of Occupancy for four units. Dal� Varberg indicated that Richard Varberg acquired the property immediately following this inspection. Dale Varberg also claimed that the current zaning situation was not explained or clarified for the new owner at this time. 7. The Building Department, based on an inspection in September 1979, found two additional units had been added over the previous year. Since four units ir� this structure were deemed legal nonconforming, the two additional units were found to be in violation of the Zoning Ordinance. In addition, no permits were taken out in either 1978 or 1979 for the installation of two additional units in this structure. 8. According to Dale Varberg, the changing economic conditions and a high demand for small rental units prompted him to alter the structure through dividxng up the unoccupied first floor commercial space into two one-bedroom apartments. 9. The District 10 Como Community Council supports the requested rezoning to R��-3 for this property but would have preferred an RP1-2 rezoning in order to avoid any possibility of a high rise on this site in the future. 10. The Oistrict 10 Plan calls for maintaining the low and medium density of the residential community as svell as incorporating energy considerations into housing in the at�ea. A rezoning to RM-2 would help this existing medium density residential structure to blend better into the residential character of the area and allow its residents to reap the benefits of its compactness as an energy saver. A rezoning to RP9-3 could introduce the possibility of very high density development in a generally low, to medium density area, and would be in conflict with the District 10 Plan. 11 . With several RM-Z Multiple Family Districts in the immediate vicinity, a rezoning to RM-2 wauld help to preserve the residential character of the immediate neighborhood and is generally in keeping with the housing policy and energy gvals of the city. Uses permitted under an RM-2 rezoning are not substantially different from the nature of the prevailing uses in the surrounding area and would not result in disharmony. Uses permitted under an RM-3 rezoning are in f'act substantially different from the nature of the prevailing uses and might result in disharmony. - 12. The applicant originally applied for a rezoning to RM-2 and based on the advice that a density variance could only be granted for an RM-3 rezoning, the applicant t.iithe�iv.��.i +h.� i.,i,�..�r»l DM_'7 ,..e.�..,�.��,.., n..+:�1--0...� n�...-. .�a .... ..�..._.__.�i t.L_i 1—.��ti-' _. . • �� ,� i �- i� . � C.: �J`�.. »":'°`:'�' � CITY OF `�AINT PAUL +`�L1TY QliC� . . ��4 S� • ;�� t��"� y;� DEPARTMENT OF PLANNiNG AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT :�v ��n i!u u ^� �� = DlVISION OF PLANNING I(��1�l�J 25 West Faurth Street,Saint Paul,Minnesota,55102 GEORGE LATtMER 612-298-4�51 MAYOR MEMORANDUM DATE: September 16, 198Q T0: Current Planning & Zoning Comnittee FROM: Marvin Bunnell , Zoning Section �'� SUBJECT: Sta�us of Continuance of Varb�rg Rezoning Request from Current Planning & Zoning Committee Hearing -� Zoning File #8637 On March 26, 1980, a petition to rezone pr�p�rty at 1195 Arona Street from B-3 to RM-2 was received b,� the Ci�y. On April 16, 1980, the petition a�as deemed suffic;ent by the Department of Finance and Management. On May 15, 1980, the Curren� Planning and Zon�ng Committee first heard the case. At that time, the applicant's request for a density variance from the Board of Zoning Appeals was in doubt as to its legality and it was continued to - June 5, 1980. At the June 5y 1980 Current Planning and Zoning Committee hearing, the attorney for Mr. Uarberg request�d and received a con�cinuance on the r�zQr.ing matter until September 18, 198Q. On Friday, September 12, 1980, Paul Varberg, the nephew of Dale Uarberg, the rezoning a�plicant, cr�ntacted me and I revievaed the situation with him. He indicated tnat he and his brother, Daniel Varberg, are leaning toward seeking a rezoning t� RN�-3 instead of ti�e previously requested RM-2 zone to allow the 13 rooms in the illegally converted apartmeni� structur�, but th,at they have not fully decided what ta do. I mentioned to him that seeking a RM-3 rezoning wi11 require a new petition, another notice ofi` sufficiency, and a withdrawal of their previously applied for rezonirig to RM-�2 from B-3. Today, Paul Varberg contacted me and informed me that they will be attempting to rent out the bottom space fr�r office use ar business uses acceptablc in a B-3 zone. ihey interid to advertise for abaut 10 days , until approximateiy October 1 . If they ar� unable to rent it auf; for busir�ess purposes, then they will reapply for an RM-3 (High Density High-Rise Multi-Family District) zone. In any case, he will be submitting a letter withdrawing their original request for a rezoning to RN!-2. A copy af his letter �hould be available at the September 18, 1980 Current Planning and Zoning Corrmittee hearing. MB/cc - � �^\ �' �t 1 � .� j ' .�y . .. . . / � • »"/ � t'� ':,! � '�j u u u '�'�� • ' t .�-t �� ! � �� .1 .1 ....^] �,:a -- . . . . . w�. . . �v � . . � � . .. . . y . �-:.:... ...- ,...+:..n rn.-. . .�...�'£- P� t.:n- .m'r4':nM'' ,.y .,��„p�r,_ . ... . � . .... '�M. "51 ��#.�, � • ^�:vp+'i,x;A _:e w-�.-:- ..>: . �.y..w.4n�r�.s'�,niiw ...y�y��.'H�'I� . '^� �'2,MV�lY .� . _ . . . e � J ... - `} r ,C':�..�� f ,F �� : � � r'•-.�,'�� ''-:?''J 8 i� �7_°. �..'�' - � , �.�� ..-��the? Dr. ��', �_;: at, P�.±zl, 55?12 �� ?,/�c/`�,� � k; ;: � . �J� � G�� ..�1011�Ll. LO�y1 U ..• •�•��.� ,. � � . � j�xr�f !S��?-L� S� � ��'�t. ' � � � w _ , � :•�_�rV BIlTIriBZ� �.,,, �''�' x �.� ° � � } � �� .�',�,`��,`:'�.,�s�y.;�. � � ��;` �7 � � ��.�,�t � � .°„��,,� �. ''_�°�_T' J�=', Y;. � �:. , i ... r '� 4�',� ~ .�`$X��" �e I ^.:;� requ�s�in� t�at cur peti�i�n for an R:��-2 .��nin� R �- }. 7� ��C15 �e""t?:'?3 Jt. C?° �T'O��8�`� i}°��5° of the i'2'°°�I'.� z�?possibi?it� �� recei•ai�g � �ensit�r ;rarianca. :.. :�t ��sen� Ta� �r� try�n� ta ?��nt the ls� �"?�ar �u` _:s bua�*_:e�s off; ^s� t,� r�otn�1� ��ith t^� 3-3 zo?�irs�. �f ��s are �.z�aole to finci businass rente�s, as has oeer_ the - �°3�3 i: ;:ic' �'�?S v, w@ ?,.li 7 , ',a��=�� f'J;. � _ _�i"_—r' ,�r:�!"liilo. �f� 3i;e�;ta �_ fi:l° C?3c' T�:: '-�1'_�'_ ��.�':�i�:l JO�J. � � = ai' ?'_1�., .�cjt'.S() r � .. ... � J:_.iv.��'.:�!�� . - ,� <� �.�� Ns�5. ��a5c3 .:.72�OT'?Tl. �i13 'J��'i?.:ZCC3 �0�.1`?Lt? �J.i f�1.S� _: . � - _ ,,.� . � . .. ��" �F .. �� ktM S `,;�. .' ��il � ` �� y n+ . 4� � _ 4 +�, e �� k :. � � 7 �� y� �_}� t� P.Si � W ,f a . .. � ,}laU�� :/� � -3 �� .��`� � '1� �� . � � �r��e �r _ ,•` x ,�c . t_ , . t�_ ..d-�i- '1 - ��-' '"_,"-� °""�wh�`�+ �"'''� _, _..._._ .-......� ,�;_.» �,... ..,. _ .,,... . _ - .� . w-^ �tC� h�, .. ... ..�...... ...__. .. . � . . . . . � . . . . . . .... ,:'V:: .. , . `!:�('�_`t' .. ..,.__ -`�� . , � � �e�� - • C�TY O� �r` � CITY �F SAINT PAUL ` • �� " DEPARTMENT O� COMMUNITY SERVlCES � �.� - : - ; ,` "c DtVIStON OF HOUSING AND BUILOING CODE ENFORCfMENT •.• City Hafl,Saint Pauf,Minnesota 55102 George Latimer - 6�2�298-4r2 Mayor I necemher 13, 197�� - ^Ir. "i�t�ard Varberg itti : I521) Como Bo� �1 aka : I19� rlrona �lzsbate, �tasbate 5101 �fl 1 1 �. 1�) L il L S I)ear 1�1r. Varberg : I �flt IIt reccipt of your letter dated r{ovcinhcr 1 � , I97� , of c��hich I ►�ill respond to later in tiiis ie.t.ter. U��on revie�ving this Ei"Le ,. I noticed our Department inadvertently failecl to notil'y you oE a �oning ��iolat.ion at this address . '1'hc Cct•ti£ic{tte af �ccupancy wc3s i :;tiucd �or fotir unit5 irt �`tinlitiC c� t� 1 ��75 . Ul�ott �in irttcr.im in�iscct� i �n in S��tcmhcr, 1�17� , [ Co��nct two aclditional units had laeen �ddeci 111 L�iolatio�� of �he Zoning Code . '['he zoni.nfi For this acl�3resti is 1:--3 an�l ti�e �oninn status for fo�r .�nit� ��.i� 1e,;11 -noilLC�� fOrinin� . �1i)OI1 checking out° records , no I�eri�i.ts �4ei•e fo�.incl in 1978 �r 19?� Cor tf�e installat ion of t�,�o acl�lition,il �rnits in this struccure. Yoii ai•c herehv c�t�cierec� �o do citl�c,r of tl�c ti,�o o��tions Iis��ci hclo►:: 1 . I)e-canvert the huild-ilz�? to �it�t j�rcvioi-i�; �_isc ��s a �our un�it building . ' . Obtain a rezonin� lrom thc St . Paul City Cc�uricil and a _ ��ariance fi•om t}le �.ori�,n`, tioard of� �1�>pc<<Is . lrotc ;,i<<y appeal thi s C�eClti:l011 to the Lo�t i rt�; f�oarcl o f �1Pp�al s h�� contacting Larr}' Young at 295-4] 54 . 'Chis aj�real must he Ciled �cithin thirty (�0) days of receipt af this letter. !' le�i�c he remindc�d that in orcler to chrin{�e the i��e oC an exi �tinu tirri�ctt�rc or to install ��ciciiti�nal an;�rtmc�n; tjnit� to an exi �;ting hui l�ling , permission r�ust first he ohtainecl from th.is Department . :1t t in�es , a rezon in� , or a va r iance i� ncedecl to ohta in tha t anprova2 . lf i�erm:its have heen a.�pliccl i�or i�rior to the inst�► llati.on oE the t�:o tinit� t11 c}ue�t.ioti, you i�ot11c1 h<tve heen izotific?cl , ��t thttt time , r}�at t}}c�c iS�lle� t,�o��ld hr��c tc? hc resolved . i �� $�� _ .�..__ .._..._.�._�._�,.�.�T_r ._....�.�.._,T�,...w...T.�. �_�� . �__��.�...�..�_...�.,.�__�...._.. �.,..�... . . ��....-_�� .� � � _ .....t �-- � . ..� �.,. . � . . C� �I �f;''�,,�,� ��7 llecember 13 , 1979 - 2- Re : 15"L� Como - �' . Iil re�arc� to your letter of Novemi�er IJ, 1�79 : Item �I , 13. 06 - - To clarify this m�tter Eor yot.i, the statement s oul e correctecl to rezcl "make ncedecl repairs to obtain a one- hour fire separation beti►teen dwelling unit and the rest of the basement" This means that the common ��all of the first floor 4outh apartment should have S/8" shcetrock instal.led on both sides of the wall to provide a one hoiir fire seraration . ; :�l.�o at the time af insJ�ection in Set�temher, I�J79, i.t �das diffi- cult for the inspector to ascertain i�hether the common lJSll het«een the al�ar•tment ;it 11J5 111•o►ici , cliviclecl to �rtake an addi.rional apartment in the northwest cot•ner of t}ie l�t Floor, has a one-hot�r fire rated ��all bet�reen the t��o units . I [ there is not 5/8" sheet- rock on both sicles of this cornmon �aa3. i , thc ►,�all �hould i�e made one-hour fire rated. Items 10, 11 , IZ : 54 . 12 PLBG: t1t t}�c� time �f irsPection in Septem er, 1 _ , c �ec e�ome of ti�e drains in question and tound that tl�cy clo syp}7on , ��hich is a healti� hazard . I also spoke to Plr. Gehan, one of our pinmhinfi insPectors , and s1io�Jeci l�i��i yotir di��rar.i of ho�.� you �iccom�l:ished ventinR of these fixtures . lie sai.J th�it the in5t�ill�r ian �� i llustratec� w.�s i�ot j�roperly vented� '1'lic vcilt ��s ::ristallccl �-�:ou.lci nr�t r,r•event s�•r�}ion,isae � tt'a�te and vent 511�ii !c1 he insta 1 l ecl �iccorcl i n"<.� to the 1? 1 timhinn Cocie on these fixture5 . ' Item �8 . Sa . 12 I'f.I3(�; According to �ir� �ehsln , �he auto►natic vent valve ias not een .iccepted as Cocie h�� St . Paul , tp'a�;te anc� vent sl�ould be inst��1 leci on tF�i� f ixture in �3ccardanc.c �vi t}� thF Pli��lI�:L11� Code. • �il repairs and t�ci� installatic�ns mus* he mzde in accordance ►�ith the api�ro�riate c��aes . 1'erm.i.ts mtitit he obtainecl wiiere requirecl . :1 permit is rc�c�uix•ed for an�� rePair or n�iti� installa�ion . Perr�it�� m.��• bc obtainecl from t12e D.i.vision of [(c�usir�g artd Ruilding Code Fnforcement , Room �i��5 , City flall . If you feel the corrections i•eqtiirccl :�re iini•easanahle or ti�i1l ��eate a financial h��i•dship, yo;i may m�ke ��pnlicatio� to the 1�u;ird ot� :1f>��c:i ls lJ.l t�i 111 tc�n cl�ay� altct• ��c�cc ii�t c� f� this nat ice. �'ou may contact the Board af AP�eals by callin�= (�fil2) - 2J3-�1I63. � iF you have any c�uestions , contac� ,7eanne lJ. Sh,ii,r hetiveen 3 : 0� ancl �: UO a.m. , or A1 i.ce [ii j j:�ni hetj�een 9 : �� ;� . rn . ancl 4 : 5(1 � .m. 1'he phone. numher *o call is ?JS -4215 or Z�)4-5(,4� , 1'ours tr}�1y, ,.;��::;�• �� ,i;:-=.�_r � . ,,1c;inne V. Sh�� • : U,in ti��rhers� �� --� �°�� Ror 1724 �J00 Bethel I)r . St . Paul , �IN 5SI12 _� . , , _ .� �p��i�y� --- ---- -- - -- �; �,-,"�'^R�^-.... '" .i. �-'/WI�W..la:i��"+.LY1�"'�'3�..�3Fti��."�� 'S'.._ � . . ��]� . . . . . . . . . . '(K R� . ... .. ..�ef'rnRTirR.+i!.'i.'s�T'�f"?�,A�!�'`11�"4'�:.:s �'w�i..�.^ :��'T.��'� � � . . �`�s8+�� CITY OF SAINT PAUL DEPARTMENT OF FfNANCE AND MANAGEME�•.IT SERVICES DIVISION OF ASSESSMENTS AND VALUATIONS + November 14, 198a ,; To zhe Council - - ' City of St. Paul I have checked the attached amended petition oF Richard V�rberg filed in the matter of rezoning Lot 1, Bl.ock 2, Lake Park Addition,. Third Division, from a B-3 district to a ItM-3 district and find that said petition is sufficient. Yours very truly ,�� -�- .�.� . �� U �"J. W. bonovan �-�' Valuation & Asses�ment Bngineer Re: X 2514 cc: Buildin� pepartmeat Zoning Board File J. W. Donovan Parcels Eli�i.ble _ 8 Parcels Needed - 5 , Parcells Sigr►ed - 7 JWD:VP:dal , � fff'''''�� ' P� ��,t.t � 3 ' .. ., i� ^ T' �.�I� . . �. 1 1 S _� ,.� '� 7 .. ' ' 1 ��.c.��r,.a 218 City Ha ( [ , Saint Pauf, Minnesota 55102 � a -,� .u.4.��.—..r,s..------�.° -...,�,,.�.,�..�h.,,.,. .�,�. _ � �� r" _ - _ � -�C ��.a.t��'��.,..ia� . .. ��. f��, �1..✓�.. ��°�^��.� � CITY OF SAINT PAUL . _��+..G`T T O, ',+r'!'i �� *•* ,; OFFICE OF THE CiTY CLERK :o , a; :� i�nionw ,; �+ `'"" �'� " ,s� BUREAU OF RECORDS ,,. _ ''�a„� ....�.-�''_ 386 City HaN,Saint Paul,Minnesota 55102 �-�,,,,,...� � t� •a -: r�',�, ,� i,;�.�,.h 612-298-4231 GEORGE LATIMER � • � �� MAYOR �� i� 1 Lt") t'�� .•..,,� " � � :.,_: N D�'p� ._,� .�� FI�AN�� ';�f � �Q,, ; ,�;,% �=f�.�-,-,' �- � JI!}i,-,�J% - i November 6, 19$0 Mr. Paul Desch Finance .Department Room 218, Ci.ty Hall Deax Sir• The City Council referred to the �'i�iar�c� Department sor check as to sufficiency, the attached amended petition of Richard ---�-----_ Varher$ to rezone from B-3 to R�'�-3 property at 1195 Arona St., aka Lot 1, Block 2, Lake Pa.�rk Addi�ion, 2;zi.rd Division. A pr�vious petition already found s4af.fi.c:ient, rezoning the , property from �-3 to RM-2, has been withdrawr�;` ` Very� �ruly yours, � Rose Mi.x City Clerk � Attach. ABO:i 4 � --- .�.�....._.._ � � �� T I , .' _4 � pi !�.��.,.it_L_ + ,: r� . „ � .:; , '•�, -.� ��O . ..._.._r_ . _ ._ _..�.,.__ .__�,_....�..�.,_. _�.w,�.--.,. _._�-�._.� _ ..-.v..,�,—�,�.,- -,,.,�,-�..- . ---�.,�.a..�„��,.,....,....�,.,3_�,.,�.,.•...,,..,.�,.,..,...,....,•-...,�»�:..�.,,�.� . `� .. , ...� _.�.. . -. . ...�.��_� :��. � , , Y �' - . • . PETITION TO AMEND ZONING CODE , , , , ` -�� - � CITY OF ST. PAUL. MINNE90TA �_�' _ TO THE HONORABLS MAYOR AND CITY CUUNCYL DATE 10-17 1980 c/o City C2erk, Room 386 City Hall -- St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Pursvant to Section 64.210 of the St. Paul Zoning Ordinance and Section 462.357 (5) of the Minnesota Statutes, , Richard N. Varber� , the oNner of all of . the land proposed for rezoning, hereby petitions your Honorable Body to rezone the following described property: . Street Address: 1195 Arona St . Legal Description: _�t l. B lock �. Lake P�rk Addition Third Divis�on -from a _ �3_3 District tio � ��-� District for the purpose of _ al2owinsr us to continu� to use it as an apartment building» „ -,: _ _ -� Subscribed and sworn to �y; �!�� before this �"� deyr ? • � � of_ ��.-Fp` ,t!'�-- 19� 'i'itle: �o,.�,-�e� ��X e ��; �� +�, � C�� Petitioner �.� t,ti �"! D �nnnnnnnn�i+n�tgnnnn�nP�Gtl�X��. �vv�.+.vvy�n� 1 �,r,� .iEANtVlE Ail.OL�ON � � �r� ; ' �� j � � `� � �Q 'Q j A.✓�� ' 7UINN�-SATA � � ' `,:v� i , •x NOFARY PUfJIiC— 'i \'•"�' � ' � -� --�'�—�Q s �� P,A?viSEY COUNI`1' � .--� _�.�._ A�y fammi5uon Expires Auq, ld, 13aa � , ti � Page 1 of _ _... . ._.._..�. __.,...m_..�...�w.,-._..._„�.;,.,�_„�,.,,.,,,..,�,r..._.._,.,.a„sx�.�.,..�,.....�...--•,.�...�,��..,-•.�, ,��x,;�.�� ' .. �� . � . . . � . - � . . ' . . . , ._ . �,,.7:.5'°.`,^.`x` - . ..�:°:�,;, � ,{ a.v�.��. j Vl tiilelV11711r17 rn.vr�aa vnrr�sc� tv tsts�vivittv , � � u��.�' ��,. . _ ' &Ve, the unclersigried, owr�ers of.property within 100 feet of the total contiguous descriptions - of reaT estate owned by Petitioner or sold by Petitioner within one year Qreceding the date of this petition, aeknowledge that we have been furnished with the following: 1. A copy of the Petition of Da1 e VarhPr� � - a 2. A copy of Sections 60.460 through �,p_t�6ti, , inclusive, of the St. Paul Ordinance; and acknowledge that we are aware of the uses permitted under a �_� District zoning classification; and hereby consent t� the rezoning of the property described in the , ; Yetition of Dale Varoer� � to a �g_� Distrieto RECORD OWNER ` SIGNATURE LOT BLOCK ADDITION Nicholas J. Johnson . � ;: ' ` ' - Lake Park Bernice D John on �� '�;`"-ti�t��. . .= '�;�-''�, :�.-�_ 2 2 Third D'v' ion J. B. Schwartzbauer �� ,� ta pd Lake Park C. iKar Schwartzbauer --�%' �� 2 Third Div�sion ' Lake Park Rose C. Vina.n ��/�� 2 Third Divi ion '�iilliam H. Jt�liri'te � � •, ��.;�' Lake Park Mar L. Juhnke .,G� 12 1 'on Ronald J. Peschel �;;, 1��e I.aks Park Geor ina Peschel 12 '� Thir Div' on James T. Defiel � � � �, -�, t�p' Lake Park Bett e R. Lefiel 1 1 2 Third D�vision '` � ��• `��` Lake Park �, , Louis Lipsc;�ultz r`J � .� � � ry u-L.�/ 2 2 Third llivisio:x ° Lake Park Josepn L. Dudovitz k. ..,� , � ��= 2 2 Thi.r�. Divisio� apto,^ ll. ros (�, i'~� La:�e Park Como Investments - "� 2 2 Third �ivision Petitions shall not be considered as officially filed with the city clerk until the lapse of 7 working dr�ys after a petition is received in the office of the city clerk. Any signator of any petition may withdraw his name therefrom by written request withtn that time. �,��, � -� � .:nR ,.1 � � �� .�a ��, � , ' �, , ��n ..��!-L.�!_ Page ? of � , _.. . . _,... __ ____ _,._...,�,.,x.�,�..��,A ..�,r.,�. � �..,. ,�. .._„.., ,:,. ._,�m�. ,.,�.. �.�........, �„w v.�..� , , � , • , _ . � . > �.�, ,. ,...,: , . _ _. ... . �_._ .::��._,r.�:.:�_.J,�.,�.:.�., , ---�.,. .,,..; -.--.,.�� , , �_ �.�,��' � �= — .—. — � � � �—_-�� - .. � .. .. . �o ,. . .. �o � . °oj �07 ��6!I °n °�' oa� °07 oi ! o e � � � • �-;" Sl� °� 01 � ��- �'� � sTi►D RF.ra yv�,,vc- (,A�i.v,u✓ A�"►F�� "` �. 6 5 4 2 { � - f E�� giuG rr' �` 7 S : 8 7 5 4 3 2 I � � son/ . ..,. �� , � ,., �T. �� ; i .i� i ,� : . a'F � �: � o L � h � � � �' o:o y K I � � . /�9/X o 7 0 �, , �7 eS?F� � 1 � o°7� �0 7 I t� "' f�'I'� £�� co F F K I � ��ya�i� Y �' ' � i $ �B i I 0 I 1 � 12 �: �/ ,,o a,°� ' E s � t5 Z3 � u 6 ,� / /^{ \ I t � J- 1�/ ' � � � �.. � rl �'.� �• / • •• Sa S4. � 4 a �. . 4� So M �:a . .. � ..�_ ,. ,, . . " • - . _. ta - �a - -• �- -,.- �� ,�¢ f � • � �, il r "t . ' ,#ua,�� i , . .. - . � r`S> 2 S� - � , .� ,. ,. ;/�S�'/o�. sQ S 0: . .� . . .. � �3.�., `�J YY �,/'r�C� .� 0�0 .. .. �#'. � �� " �: ld��J�p OZ � Oi/ 020 � . . IZD, ��0• °� 4: �,(/ 070 02 D� s � ` • 0+ . �� 49� 080 p%D � ,�'C:�y�.Tr , �3o t,' p` : �, � ff- dV :�� _ 0/ , � � ' c{t �, �y�/ .r� �ta �,tl b" � � ' Gl.�SER fiUf�+�'� k.UStt�Et.� i UPSM C,�.!� 'o''"`� µ"rJ�" .[� �� Itft�uY l�oY� r! ! �Z �a�!�y� �S . +: /�� , ' �� [� i. � e � �. .z9 s � •�zYils' , ,fl ae � � � ��K� us�A�Os�F�hs I ��,r.w.� .� � - r,D �aF�nO o�� HP,R4+S OSD p�2 � �, 1'O DZ I oi/ N �n p;� n►�. 08! .,�a� z o1 �� R"� ,�r,cz+� �� ,��'�' r p�/ 06( � � QZ , � � Qy� Oz oZ > , - - - oi� �9/ 0%�! . V�r��L , __ � �5 rs �� - �, �. o. 4.9 � a. � � ��. �Y. ��"`�' __.�_.,,.,�__�� F 1.��+9' . .:� •��. > ��_s y T � ,; . . ., � . 3 9. 4-o. 4-o. 3 9� .,- � ,. ,� � . ; - �D � �' \ i e Sti � �' A� trt:e- �}'L {�t',i .+�r'� ��' V� �';. Y{ ��` � � ErR`-. h' � 5dr✓ f'�I Sil•�✓ � 5� ,s,o �� ` , ►�I , f J9 �� 7 6 ,5 4 `i 3 2 � 1 �13 /4 /3 /2 / l�'" l v 9 � 4 'Y � ^ : � M� � � N 4�k: .M I'�� . i � � � � _ i_ � � �. � . � �: / "'''�• _ o �__ _ __ .... Lb.N- �" ��Kl� �� rE/ - sy- sa�/ �� r533 =U= L/A�'D ,� ` ; .5' 26 27 Z g 2 9 ,30 31 3Z 33 34 35� � �16 17 /8 19 ZO 2 I 22 23 , ` � / �� K�'� � �,��' J d " _9. � � 9. 4 a- � � _ = %r Kwi w l+.s �r• r- . 't2S 2�1 L��Y� ? y � � d�,.o n . - . �� st� n�- � ,.._., -�.,.e. .-....�,...��.�,,,.,�-,-,,�. �-... � . . . .. . . T[z!^�w�s.,•.�.o.+a�e�.--�..�.. . . .... °°T"^^',,-�n�_-i3' _ ".�.-.'�.�.a.�x�qy y... � .�� ... \1 � ,. � . - . .� . �� . . . . . . � . . . ._. ...�- ."'.,R �Y'SL.M�✓s�.&fP fl'u 1 ' � ~ , �-_ ��`�i ��*.� _ �9 � --.�.,� _ _ � • i �_ -----� T"" - _+r � � T . i---�-� — � SE,�� ; ; - - , , ; � ; ; ' ' ' R : o � ¢ ,o �o � oo � o �ooio BCOG. _. S i � �- --; , i � � � � �� _: - -� a ' rHE a aE -- ' � . �---�----� ;----1 ' ; ! , i i ' ` � _ ^ - 1 ! � � � p � p � i jOlO; 10 � � � i � � � , � � I `_ i F � � , . � CA �fF � ELD S� � 23 � i �oU0o0 � 0000 o � Oc� oo0o0000 C� j � � � � � � � �; I -- � -�- -- � i �• --- - �''_ (,�„ T � � -p--- � v I =�- o00 0'o DOO O 0400{C3 00000 ��00 ,�TA avE. � -- � aLM�N D �v�- , U� OOOO T�LDEN ppOOOOOOOOQ � 4 t - � � - rr � � O OOQO s-zi � 04000 � 000OOOOC�`O � A� eAr� � � , ; , � o ;000 � � o � ''" o00000 � ' � � , 5 A VAT/ N Y � � ; �� , � i i � � � ; H IT l. '� � � � � i� � O . � � � � �il � t � � O • �+ �G� ° � , �v I ---- --� '� r, ,. � � .�c i r v � -- - -_�_____ — �; ��1$ ---- ii � v : + P -,n �, : �,' 0O � 000 OC� 00 � 0 �' � �� ::�.:::: y; , �; � l."_ _ � c� 00000 � oo � � � �� o0000 {3 � , � _ BREDA A�U�- � � � � a o00 000 000 � o � � :� •�o � � � a _ � � ' � __1_1_ i _ _._1 - ` _ ' . -. --.. __ _ t - -- --- : - -- i � �---- .? . i ' ' y (j� � � +�er'' ,, ,,�- -,I 'O O O I `+-'' � ' ' �� ' � vtJ�c� 00 0 �� i �� , io � � � NN � �a A��,�� °°�^�� - CITY OF SAI�1T PAUL __:`�.T• o,��,�. ;� ,�_, OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK ;e a: %� i�iii�i ti�i C: ;,,.� „� BUREAU OF RECQRDS '`fo„�amR••��,\°' �,� 3�6 City Hali,Saint Paul,Minnesota 55102 r�i��f c'i,��'�� 612-298-4231 GEORGE LATIMER Qj ` F� MAYOR �� 'r� � Ha��BO.,� �.��,� e� �,�;��'�� _ ; �F �., .3 �-' D�Q�� ^ �, � .> F��PNC �:,� � �, ,�,;,i ; ��7�.�, . -,�, � �� -'l��.` -�`� _ November 6, 1980 Mr. Paul Desch Finance Department Room 218, City Hall Dear Sir: The City Council referred to the Finance Depaxtment for check as to sufficiency, the attached amended petition of Richard Varberg to rezone from B-3 to RM-3 property at 1195 Arona St., aka Lot 1, Block 2, Lake Paxk Addition, Third Division. A previous petition already found sufficient, rezoning the property from B-3 to RM-2, has been withdrawn. Very truly yours, Rose Mix City Clerk � Attach. ABO:la �t� �^ � � � �, .� L'�.t�-.c. � � „ . �� _ � _�l_!LL .� 0 . �3 , � � � � ��'�� CITY OF SAINT PAUL DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND MANAGEMEP��T SERVICES DIVISION OF ASSESSMENTS AND VALUATIONS + November 14, 1980 To the Council City of S t. Paul I have checked the attached amended petition of Richard Varberg filed in the matter of rezoning Lot l, Block 2, Lake Park Addition, Third Division, from a B-3 district to a RM-3 district and find that said petition is sufficient. Yours very truly ! � �- �J. W. Donovan �-�� Valuation & Assessment Engineer Re: X 2514 cc: Building Department Zoning Board File J. W. Donovan Parcels Eligible - 8 Parcels Needed - 5 . Parcells Signed - 7 JWD:VP:dal �;, �. > - �. . . , �: ��$ 1 �r:' i i ��.� n i, , L�.�;:±`a.«._ . . �_ A r. . r .:J�'...,. 218 City Hall , Saint Paul , Minnesota 55102 '.� , . . � � . . �'��8�� ,. _ , PBTITION TO AMEND ZONING CODE • CITY OF ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA TO THE HONORABLB MAY08 AND CITY COUNCIL DATE 10-17 1980 c/o City Clerk, Room 386 City Hall — St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Pursuant to Section 64.210 of the St. Paul Zoning Ordinance and Section 462.357 (5) of the Minnesota Statutes, . Richard N. Varber� , the owner of all of the land proposed for rezoning, hereby petitions your Honorable Body to rezone the following described property: Street Address: 1195 Arona St. Legal Description: yout 1� B lock 2,_ Iake P�rk Addition. Third I}ivis�on from a g_3 District to a RM-3 District for the purpose of allawinA us to continue to use it as an apartment building. � Subscribed and sworn to T3y; 0.'�o�lC.� VG�t�.� before this � day � � � � of 19�0 'Pitle: �o..v� �:�.d�c...kY �� „ , - C;Y,_� Petitioner vul�,wt c>v� ' Notar k - -- M JEANNIE M.OL ON � ��``•�"' � � �' �`A� '�': � �'� �Q/ '�� NOTARY PUBUC--MIfJN�gOTA : � j r,,�ti' � � r'+ '�3 .�'�!°-. RAMSEYCOUNTY «. - — .._ -....._ __...____.._.._...____..__.__�. My Commiwon Expires Aul lA, I�Id� � � � Page 1 of ' , , � CONSBNT OF ADdOINI1�1G PAOPER,TY OWNEl.t3 'I'O RBZONING ,�" ' We; the un�ersigned, owners of property within 100 feet of the total contiguous descriptions of real estate owned by Petitioner or sold by Petitioner within one year preceding the date of this petition, acknowledge that we have been furnished with the following: 1. A copy of the Petition of nai e Varber� � 2. A copy of Sections 60.46o through �,p_4�. , inclusive, of the St. Paul Ordinance; and acknowledge that we are aware of the uses permitted under a �_� District zoning classification; and hereby consent to the rezoning of the property described in the Yetition of Dale Varbere to a �_� District. . RECORD OWNEft ' SIGNATURE LOT BLOCK ADDITION Nicholas J. Johnson � ' � Lake Park Bernice D J hn n "� '�"��+ L'ry- �'�%' i. 2 2 Thi d D' on J. B. 5chwartzbauer �L�� 1 Lake Park C. Mar Schwartzbauer 2 Third Divi ion Lake Park Rose C. Vini � � 4 2 Th d Divi ion liilliam H. Juhnke � ', ��0' Lake Park Mar L. Juhnke 2 ' n Ronald J. Peschel �c�. i�� Lake Park Geor ina Peschel 12 hird v on James T. Defiel " ' �, �� tap' Lake Park Bett e A. ITefiel 1 2 Third Divi ion ;� !1 D. av' Lake Park Louis Li schultz � � 2 2 Third Division ,Q Lake Park Joseph L. I�.idovitz o� . 2 2 Third Division ap os . ros Lake Park Como Investments 2 2 Third Livision Petitions shall not be considered as officially filed with the city clerk until the lapse of ? working days after a petition is received in the office of the city clerk. Any signator of any petition may withdraw his name therefrom by written request within that time. -----�.._._._._..._,_._ __ _�.__�_____ � �'�"�� R � � �K" � Q7Q' � �� ..::� ' � i o� Page 2 c�f � � v �� aW3 . �- .�� `1 � fJ ✓ � —�.—�_,.,_-_. �tOTlC$�V�ss�RII�iG . ��O�R�.�a:� t6!�V 's'Y!. t3'�iYGi.:�_. �, �` ��t �.,_ _ �.M#�l�l.'�'aul. to �^� _.� itt;119ti. ��tl - , tiaa �c�d t is YM� • � said C!lf;/ rpd�1(:i ��t�ii�`�Ii�iE�t6e . Councii'��l��y�f a��jeo. e3a�s �d,�j�,;�tPM1:te tht ➢��141�1i1�E1l.� . ` ��Mi�lM�:�-� ��,: ��°��ez>��sL`1t`i'� -.4 'N1 i39,yiY�� .. . Y� '.�'" �Aprll�l�1881�. ^�@aany'"': � ' � � . ` �� S �. ��► � i� C � T `� C � UN �I � PU ��. 6 � � EARlN � NOTICE � ZONING � City Clerk N ' 3s6 c�ty Ha�� F I L E N 0. X 2514 st. Paul, r� 55�oz PAGE 1 P U R P 0 S E Rezone from B-3 district to RM-3 district to allow continued use of a 6-unit apartment building located at 1195 Arona. (Southwest corner Arona and Como) . PETtTfONER Richard Varber H E A R I N G Thursday, April 23, i9si, .�:n� �.��. Citv Cotincil Chambers, 3r� Floor Cit�� Fiall - Court ;aouse QUESTIONS 7.ONING 298-415� Contact the Zoning Section of the Planning and Economic Development I)epartment, Room 1101, City F�.11 Annex, 25 W. 4th Street, St. Pa.ul, Minnesota. 55102. Notice sent April 3, 1981, bv the ��aluation and Assessment Division Department of Finance and Mana�ement Services Room 21$ Citv Hall - Court House St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 \ , � � , ; lsc __,�- �— 2na 9 .��—�/ / . . . . / 3rd S �9"� Adopted �p<l-- d / � ;' Yeas Nays '� � .HUNT //, ,%./� � LEVINE M��o� �'��5 � SHOWALTIIt TEDESCO I WILSON . .� - PRESIDENT (MADDOX) . <:.> , �'�`�