The URL can be used to link to this page

276758 �� .�Gf� LC.�.� .� .�C�� - �� .�� a��c =c�e.�° �m-� .r� ��.� � �' ��-- . � . .. 7 � c� s.�,��.�.�. �i'v� . �� - , � �� . �.�� -�--- - � �� z -r� sa��. �a� �,, ,��, .-�'?:�- �� 2�� .��/�- Y�� - .`� . � J J � , �� . �� / 9 8/ • r C��rLZ��y�- ��Z.�.��t,� �� `�-u2� �t�On .(�rL c� � � - / /, /� .V �j GG/�'� ��J � a ,� /� ��L4 .{��L 't;�'�e°�`-'t. ��L��(ll.. ��Q�, � , � '��`��-' / �' � - �D�C ^ .�� /.�-� . � � �� , , ,S �/ �� t�,�t. �� S-��yrc,o � r� ✓� � F . C� , .�� GZ�'t-l/L . , ilp � �' '��p-� � 1��.C.�- �Q�r�7�!!'j'L � 4 ��? C',�r2�� v✓t,o' ��2,� ��2-G� S G� J � �2�t�%�- � . �� o�- S , , �Z�,uz,-, G"�� Gutit,,a.. �� . � � � 3yv � � s�� ` G�fi2o-�aa ��S- / .��, �� .�i�?X,C�iuQ�'�'" '��-G'Zt� ' �c,-C�' i - _� . �� , CITY OF SAINT PAUL OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK BUREAU OF RECORDS 3H6 City Hall, Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 612-298-4231 February 24, 1981 ♦ hearing for March 26th, 1981 : Garrett to a decision oP the ing property at 35o w. George. > property owners as required Very truly yours, Rose Mix City Clerk ction sion �•O , . � � . f � �/\ ' \/ --.--- j . -, I,�: -- . . � �� L L � ( , � � ` � � /,' s/ � L--��'�Z.�--t � � �-1 Sr ---. ; � /� ��C �`G'`-�� <-�� 'S ��z % '�L>�'� �ry� - r /� �� v�' _ �-�" '� C�--1�C/Zl�� iG�t_�'�. `�'� � � � �� - , � :� ��_' � �� -��_��`�� .� , �� —��-�-,�-2 z��.�c.i� �,��' � �,y� �,�y�� -�'�¢-�✓ ��- �3 , ��-�v� � �� -�� . , � � y��-�� , � lh�� f�— , � .�C � �/ / /A/ �._-y� 6- � i/�� -`-� V Y'%.-.�{� � �777 J / `� /� �G /c-- L�� L�-� C��2/L� -_ � �: � � �� _ —+� -� z,r .rn -n `_� — r ra m �cn � v '� :� �T �� _..� m ,_ ' / • i `� �� 117�/�—AHidavlt o�S�rvtc• !y M�11, (R�vf��d 1972) ��ADY-MAIIGUl15 CO. ST.►AUL,M�NN. �tate of �ti�t�e�ota, _ . _.. ss. County of__ -.._.RamSey_ _---__.. .. -- _..Donna---C��.__QdY.k111.. .. _ __ _ . -- --- -.- -- . ---- .. - .-- -_ -- _ _ , being �irst duly sworn, deposes and says thai on ....�_�n.u.d..rY._2� _ --- - , 19 $-�---, ------.he seraed the occa�h�d . Res.ol uti_on._#.8Z84---------------------------------------------------- -�- - - . ... �-��- ---- --- --- -- - - •- -- - - --- upon_ - -t'!YL I.E GARRETT - - - .. . _ - - ---- --- -- ----------------------- ----------------�--••---- attorneY-- Jor. -- --- � - -�----_ _ -- __.. . .. - ---- -•---•----. .by placing a true and correct copy thereu/ in u�a envelof�e addressed as follows: bdylie Garrett, 350 W. George, St. Paul , P�innesota 55107 (which u the last k�town address of said attorney) and defiositing the same, with fiostuge prepaid, in the United States mails at_ -- - .St.....Pd_ul.- ._ _ ... __ _-� - - - -- -__ ., Minnesota. Subscribed an�l sworn to before me this ._28th �� ' - - -- day o/.......January-- -- -----. .. , 19 .81..- - (,�1/1��-. � '_ �- � - ...._...-- -------------� �----•------ , . _ ...__ � , � � �- ,, ,, . . � , �( �,� � •.�, r�� r, ��. �, '� -��'� . r ., � �:��,� �/f�/G��L"GG N � y , .. _ _.. �.. .--- �- ----�-�---�------ ---• �- - o ar ti V\`.��::•�.V'. . . I... l I , � �, '�� . .' . ♦ J ��`� / -"C Y f 1 , � • .. .,\ I, i � v � . ' . r . I f • � � � � .-, �'� �I o"��,.J city of saint paul board of zoning appeals res�lution zoninc� file number �,�� dal�; _ Janu�,r•y 21 , I981 WHEREAS, WYLIE GNRRETT ha5 aNplied for• a variaiice tr•uu� thE si.rict application of the provisioiis of Sections 62. 1(►1 (d) and 62. 113 of the Saint Paul Le9islative Code pertaining to 6'6" privacy fei�ces constructed within requir�d firont and side yards , as well as , coriier clearance height restrictions , in an RT-1 zoning district; and WHEREAS, the Saint Paul B�ard ofi Zoning Appeals conducted a public hearing on January 13, 1981 , pursuant to said appeal in accordance with the requirements of Section 64.2113(a) of t��e Leyislative Cude; and WNEREAS, the Saint Paul Board of Loniny Appeal�. based upon evidence presented at ti�e public h�aring, as substantially refleci.ed in the minutes attached hereto, made the folluwing findinys of fact: 1 . That the strict application of tr�e regulations enacted would not result in peculiar or exceptional practical difficulties to tt�e owner of property at 350 W. Georye as distinyuished f��om mer�e ii�conv�ni��►�ce by reason of the _ existing physical conditions ofi the property. 2. lhat the va� iance cannot be yrar�ted without substanCial detriment to the public good and without substantially impairing t��e intent and purpose of the Ordinance. 3. That granting the variance will diininish or� i�n�air established property values within the Surrounding area, and imNair �ublic health , safety, and welfare of the inhabitants of the City oi� St. I�aul . NOW, TIIEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVE�, by the Saint Paul (3uar•d ut Zoning Appeals that under authority of the City's Legislative Code, Ciiapter 6�4.206, the variance to permit maintenance of an illegally built 6'6" obscurin�� fence within the required front and side yards and a 3'6" fence within the corner clearance area be denied, for �roper•ty described in the leyal de,cription of the application for variance and the site plan attached heret�. m Q�� b�/ _ Mr._Grais__ _, __ Decisions of the Board of Zoning seco nded b Appeals are final subject to appeal �/ Mr. Woods____. _,_ to the Ci ty Counci 1 wi thi n 30 days in favor � ____ by anyone affected by the decision. against _ � . _ _ , � . � . � ��^.�� IINUTES OF IIIE ��iLE f1NG �I THE BUARU �F LOfJ1NG APPEALS IN c1TY COU�JCIL ciiAP�I�ERS, Sf . ��l1UL , MIP�rlESOTA, I)E.CEr�16ER 23, 1980 PRESENT: �1me. Morton ; Messrs . G��iS , I'�terson ��ncl Wuods of the Board of ^ Zonin�� Appeals ; f�lr. Jerun�e Segal , Assistant Ci ty Attorney ; Ms . Lane of the Division uf Ilousiny ancl Guildiny Coc1e Enfiorcement; Ms . Beseinar� and hir. Tedesco of the Planniny Division Staff. ABSENT: Mme. Suirnners ; Plessrs . Kirk ancl Osborn. The �neeti ng was cha i red by Gl adys ttorton , Cha i rivan. WYLIE GARRETT��8�784� : A reyuest for variances ufi fr•ont and si�e yard setbacks in order to build a 6 fuut high Nrivdcy fence on Nr�operty located at 350 W. George. The appellant was present. There was no opposition present at the hearing. 1�1r. Tedesco showed slides of tlie site and reviewed his staff report with a recorrnnendation for denial . One letter was received in opposition. Wylie Garrett, 350 W. George, presented a petition fron� residents in the neigh- borhood stating they have no objection to the fen�e. He explained that when he constructed the fence he did not know a building peri�iit was needed. The corner of the fence has been chanyed so that it is no lonaer obst:ructing the view. He said the fience looks good and the adjoining proF>erty owne►•s have no objection, and did nut feel there was any ��eason to take it down. Hearing no further testimony, Ms . Morton closed the public hearinn portion of the n�eeting. • Ms. Lane stated that the City Council passed an Urdinance which states that fences cannot be placed in a required front yard unless they are 6'6" or smaller. There is also a section on corner clearance which state5 that a fence cannot be any higher than 2 feet. She explained that the Zoning Ordinance is ver,u unclear about fences and the Buildiny Uepartiiient has been applyir�g the Ordinance passed by the City Council to the Zoning Ordinance treating it as an accessory structure. Mr. Peter•son asked Ms. Lane if the appellant would need a variance if he lo4�ered the fence to 42" and had the fence 2 feet on the corner? Ms. Lane indicated that would be perniissible. She also mentioned that dirp,ctly west of the clwelling there is a garage with a driveway that could be a ha2ard if someone were backir�g out if the fence is 6 feet high. On business property when a 6 foot fence is put up, they are asked to place the fence 10 feet in from each of the property lines just for• safety purposes . Mr. Peterson made a n►��tion to deny the variances based on findings 2 through 5 of the staff report. Mr•. Grais seconde�l the motion. The rnotion failed for lack of �t affirmative votes on a roll call vote of 3 to 1 with Mr. I�Joods voting a�ainst the motion. Mr. Grais then made a motion to lay the matter over until January 13, 1981 . ��Ir, bJoods seconded the motion. The motion passed on a vote of 4 to 0. Subrni tt by: ,� �l Approved by: , -- L� � �'k � ��'�'"�4le:l,�-• �:�f'-�� -f. ' �j'�c �, -_ �� . R ony F.- fedesco Gladys P�orton Chairman , . / � I � � ��'� . . MINUIES 01� illl M�L11Ni, Uf I�IIE L�UAIIU UI� lUfll�l(a l�l'PEI\LS I��! C1TY CUUNCIL l;li/1f�llilllS, ', I . I'AUL , M1NflLS�JI{1, J/1Pl1111RY 13, 1981 f'RESEP�T: Mmes . P1ortoii uii�l Suininer•�. ; hiessr•s . Osburn , I'e(.c��sur� and lJoods of the E3oarc� of Zon i i�� 11p��•�i I s ; f�1r. Sega 1 , 115s i s tan t Ci ty Attorney; Ms. Lane of the Di v i� io�� ot Iluus i►�y and l>u i 1�1 i�� Coc1e Enforcement; Ms . l3eseniaii , h1s . U,�ykin , Mr. Tedesco anct Mr•. furstenson of the Plar�ning Uivisiun St,afr . ABSENT: Mess rs. Gra i s dild K i rk. The nieeti ng was cha i red by Gl aclys Morton , Cha i ru�a��. WYLIE GAkRETT �7£34� : A reyuest for variances of frunt and side yarcl setbacks in order to permit an existing 6 Foot hic�h Nrivdcy fence on pronerty located at 350 W. Geroye. The appellant was not present. This matter was laid over froin th� nieetiny on Deceniber 23, 1980, for lack of 4 affi rrnati ve votes. Mr. Tedesco showedslides of tl�e site and reviewed his staff report with a recommendation for denial . One letter was receivecl in opposition. . Mr. Peterson stated that as indic�ated in the minutE•s uf the meeting of Uecember 23, 1980, Ms . Lane fr•om tl�e Buildiny Uepar•tmeiit ��ointed out t:hat the erection of the fence coulci b� a hazard because c�f it� closeness �:o the driveway, and cJue to Mr. ��arr�tt' S r•eluctance to take ar�y kind of sugyestion from the E�oa rd as to huw he cuul�i aiuend the fence t o kE�eE� i n con�pl i ance wi th the law, and due �� hi5 r�.�luc�aiice to co�nply with the cour�t order which was issued in Npril of 19ti��, ayaiii made a niotiun tu den.y the variances requested based or� findirig 2 throuyl� 4 uf the staff reNo��t. fis. Suuiruers seconded the niotion. l�he motion passe�i on a roll call vote of 4 tu �). Subrni tted by ; {1NNr•ovecl Ly: ' / r / . �I ��f' �i ��L- ' 1 ,'� �; �� .� �S�' �( _4�,�f'�l'- � � T Tf�f c <'�.j� � Anthony F��'fed�sco Gladys P•lor ton , Chai nnan k � , � � I\ �� ' ZONING STAFF REPORT l . APPLICANT: WYLIE GARRETT DATE OF HEARING 1/13/81 �, . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C L A S S I F I C A T I 0 N . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . CURI2ENT PLANNING & ZONING COMMITTEE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS Rezoning ❑ Variance � Special Condition Use ❑ Administrative Review ❑ Detcrmination of Similar Use ❑ Other_ � Change of Nonconforming Use Q Ot.her _ 3, Lf1CATI0N: 350 W. George Street. �l. LEGAL DESCRIPTION: Lot l , Black 10, Olivier's Addition. 5. PRFSENT ZONING: RT-1 ZONING CODE REFEREPJCE: Section 61 .101 (d) & 62. 113 6. STAFF INVESTIGATION & REPORT: DATE 1/13/81 __ BY Anthony F. Tedesco .---------------------------------------- A. PURPOSE: Applicant requests variances of required front and side yard setbacks, as well as variance of corner clearance, in order to retain an illegally built 6'6" obscuring privacy fence. B. FRON7AGE & AREA: This rectangular lot has 50 feet fronting George Street and 62.5' fronting Orleans Street, for a total area of 3,125 square feet. � C. SITE/AREA CONDITIONS: An older two story house occupies this site. The lot is level and �t sidewalk grade. There is no alley access . Fencing surrounds the lot (see site plan for height and location) . Surroundin� land use is basically one- and two- family residential with some commercial along George Street. D. VARIANCE: Section 61 .101 (d) requires all accessory structures to meet front and side yard setback requirements that apply to the district. Division of Building and Housing Code Enforcement interprets the Zoning Ordinance and City Ordinance #16253 (pertaining to obscuring fences mn corner lots , see attachment) to allow for construction of obscuring fences of only 3'6" within required front yards , and side yards fronting streets . In order to build obscuring fences of greater heiqht than allowed, variance of required yardage, not variance of height, must be granted. The Division of Housing and Building Code Enforcement has determined the front yard on George Street to be 10'10" ; the side yard along Orleans Street, 8 feet. The applicant proposes to con- struct a 6'6" high privacy fence along both George and Orleans . Uariances of 10'10" and 8 feet are requested. Section 62.113 states , no fence above 2 feet from the established street grades shall be permitted within the"triangular area formed at the intersection of any street right of way lines by a straight line drawn between said right-of-way lines at a distance along each line equal to the minimum setback lines from their point of inter- section." The applicant proposes a fence of 3'2 feet within this triangular (corner clearance) area. A variance of a 1'-2 foot corner clearance is requested. E. FINDINGS: 1 . The Division of Building and Housing Codes Enforcement building permit files show that on July 25, 1979 a building inspector discovered an illegally built 6'6" obscuring fence at this site. (Building Division staff contends that the applicant was informed prior to the construction of the fence that it would be illegal ; the applicant built the fence illegally, none-the-less) . On April 16, 1980, Ramsey County Judge P1arket ordered the applicant to remove the fence or get a proper building permit. On August 7, 1980, the applicant got a building permit for the fence, however, the permit allows for only a 3'6" obscuring fence. On October 27, 1980, a building inspector noted that the 6 6 obscuring fence had not been altered � �� to comply with the building permit. On november 7, 1980, Judge Market gave the applicant 60 days to remove the fence or get a variance. 2. The strict application of the regulations enacted would not result in peculiar or exceptional practical difficulties to the owner of property as distinguished from mere inconvenience by reason of the existing physical conditions of the property. 3. Granting the variance, and thus allowirig for the maintenance of the illegally built fence, could impair the vision of autornobile drivers approaching the street intersection and thus impair public health and safety. The fence could also diminish surrounding property values. . � �� WYLIE GARRETT #8784) STNFF _REPORT Page 2 E. FINDINGS CONT'D. 4. The variance cannot be granted without substantial detrirnent to the public good and without substantially irnpairin� the intent and purpose of the Ordinance. 5. The request for variance is not based primarily on a desire for economic gain. F. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Based upon required findings 2 through 4, staff recommends denial of the variance request. . ,,. _ ��,. �C _ . - � " ' C� r �i• �' ' �� --�i�.1�I':�� I',� LJr, , � ,� i , � ;. - , ��A A• 1•�N��A[N i ' �lV( ..� MI`'SON � / ' �`1�L ��0.� _ __�- i �1..�t� • ,,..- 'V �6��L��l�G brdin.�ncc Zv�Q. �; r��`�..�> -- . ' � � � , , r d ay , -� s ��_._.. I., i . Referred To _– — Committee: Date – --- . �,. �r�. • Out of Committee By _ .______� � ____ -------- Date — --- -_ �_, . , . � I�.n ordinanco am�nding Ordin�ncQ 2:0. 1573�J • � �clopt�d rlovciY�er S, 1974, pertaining to • . . • � builcling canstruction and tence requircments. '�;'. � TH.L CaUI.�CSI, (J? 7.ZiE CITY OF SAI�T PAUL DO�S ORDAINs a, , , , , , SeCtion 1. � , .� • That 6ee��o:�-?-r Paraqraph 1, Subsectxon � .09, E?}ettee-�p �.; , Section 1 of ordinanco No. 15730, Council Filo �io. 26�414 aclop�ed ! � i �� , November 5. 1979,�, nro�ently encodod as Section 25.G9 (1) of the ,;:,. ,, � � Saint Paul I,c,gislativQ G�ode,_ bo and tho salun is hereUy amended as a follawss ;,,� , ,, . ,' r89-i�eRee�---Re��ner��e r� 1. HCigh� of Fences. ' 2do fencc� shall ba erected excceding six � ;,,,. feot� six incheF (6' G") in h�ight �ave t�zQ sid�ti•�alk or. f3.ni�hed grade of any l.at in a residenca district or an any lot occupied for xesidential�� uz'poses_ Fenceg and all suppoLtinc� ��tructures �hal.l °. ' . be compl�toly t��ithin tho l:>ound�ries of such IoL•: A�.1 fencea r�" .' � erectad betwaen tho front �arQpe�cty 1in� and �a��i:��-��ne--�1�2a�� :,;;�_, . . ; � � eera��y-ti�t�.�t-6eel��ea�G9�A�-e��-�3e-6��-�ab�--�e�ra�c�L�:�r�--�o�t�rn:,thU� ... .:��',.. % . -'•�� • � � �ror�b front 3etback 1i:�e as de.£�nnd in �ction, G0.336�of the St. =. . � :.;� ; . - ' � � Saint P�-zul ]'F�Rislativc: Cocic� shall bc� no mor�e� thzn threa feet six " •',1 inchQS (3' 6"� in hei� ht. e:�P��L.�t+k�e-1xek�i:�t�;�-?��►--�:l�e-be��o?-�t�rve .1� �� . eeeleT-S�eL�efl-6�,°��3r x3xo�x�er�-4:��-�'=�e�3 Fence.=.; not obstructin� �•,� , vision to an extent �n c.YCes� o£ �4 20 p�zccnt r�ov� a'hei ht of tlireo � . £eet six inchaB (3' G"� ahall. ba exeinnt froru th�� rc�txi.ctfone ticrein. COUNCILMEN Requested by Department of: . 'eas � Neys � nu�ter � � Cor�uni� S�rvices � . ._._. Houa ' , In Favor � --.- •_ - ;f Ilunl ' ► _,- .�;.. � , LeY(ne � Agalnst �� ;E`-jZ-��- - -.•- -... Roedler � � Sylvcster � ; ' . TeJeuo ' � ' ' Form Approved by City Attorney � � b� Council: ' Date T_ J,Passed by Council Secretery . ` By — gy — . �proved by Mpyor: Datc � Approved by Mayor for 4ubmis�,i,on to Council B �Y •\L_��_,(�i�_�n `-.�. :f�:1�' .� y �_c.. � ' 1 � . . . 4 ♦ • • .. .._ .a--......_.-� _- �---'-----_...�_.._. _ .__ . ___ _.._.. _ . _ . � - r rr, . . ��C.��G,.��`,,l)t!`!> . .,,c.,� t� I 't'Y n �r .��'� T :�'1' ��11 [_T r. Cuuncil . ' � • • - �" F�i� N0._ ' , ��Z�C��.� Ordinancc N O. __ �__ t n�� J� v,,.y.) ,i • .'resented Dy --___ ------ Refe�ced To ��r'� � � -- Committce: Uate Out of Commitlee Dy -.-_._—_�. Uate 2. . � • ., Fences erect�d on a corner lot shall «lso be sub-i�ct to the pro— visions of Seetion G2. 113 of tho Saint P�ul Le; i�lative Code.~ xf aftar investigation it is t'ouncl that sita or t�rzain con— d�.tions mako it ne�es�ary to exceed tho abo�re hefght rostri�tion�a, ' the Duilci.ing ,O�Eicial inay vary tha 'liiait�tions accordingly. i . . � ' � .. .• . � . .. � . . ; ` , . , , . . ._ . '. . _ � , � .. . ' . _ . _ . �..� ��• t : : , ,.; - •.� _ . . . . . . . ; . . .. � . . . '. . . , . .� .� - . � ; . . , ... . . . � . . � _ :.,.�.� ra:° �'_ . -'� � . ,. . . • .. ' , � • �•� • . :` . • ° ` , � �. . .. . _ . � - "'� �... .. . .:. ... �,+ ��' `. • J , � . ' _ t', •, • , , . , ' , ' . — , ! , '' � • ' , . � . . . . i � ..". ... ,. �� , , ' , � ' . . . • , , ' 1 .I ... ''- ' .,,, I,,'�,, (,,; ', _ ; . . . . - . , . . , , . . ..►t:�A arti , ' �. � . ' :' . ' . , , , . . , 1: � �.+r. - • v:.�+...,�: COUNC[LMEN ' � � � ' . , eas Nays . , , � Requested Uy Department of: ' ' � Dullcr CORYilU� SC't'V�CeS ' Hozia � . • In Fevor .. �� Hunt ' • � t Roedle� � � Against �,. �C-r' ��• Sylve�ter - ' � --�� r►1AY 12 �9T7 ,.led by Council: Date � Form Approved by City Attorney . � � :rtified Passed Council Secretar B / '�f�'�'''�.� � y . . Y--, �'� ��-f•��r..-.. i • _ � t3y � � ' :proved by Alayor. DAIe l,�:AY 1 9 197.71 � Approvcd by M�yor [or Submission Co Council' . . . � }� , � �' . , ! ! � , � � ., �. . ; -----_ -----__-- _ _. — -.__ _. • . n, „ • � , _ A , • � . ,\ t �6 . ,-� .- . -� � �;�� . , . ^ � � � PLAN CHECK � APPLICATlQI1► FOR ZONING ORDIN��/�R�A�E _ • � CITY OF SAINI�AUL ' - � 4 i l A.VARIANCE OF ZONING CODE CHAPTER�_,SECTION�,?y PARAGRAPH � IS REnUESTED IN CONFORMITY WIT�POW�VESTED IN TF(�BOARD OF ZONING AP— � r , � PEALS TO PERMIT THE �� "•� ' �� " � �1 1`- �� «� `�=`-�N PROPERTY � �, QESCRI6ED BE�OW. i • � A. Applicant; NAME: W u l!F C'�C!�r P� .� .% :r' ADDRESS��1 �.Y3 t1�X";J �`F� f,y t' (it ��`lll.7�- .e,:f. ip, ? 'T— , . pAYTIME TELEPHONE N0. L-��. ��-'�.��`� 21P CODE ' � �! . '�'��` 1. Propsrty interest of applica�t: (owner,contract purchaser,etc.) � 4 � ��I �' ¢. ; ` . � 1. Name of ownor (if diffennt) �"""� ,. '� . 8. Property Description; AODRESS ��,+Sl'' l.L,) i,,�'{ �, ;� `;: . ,,. � .r. ' 1, lApaldeacrfption: LOT ,� $LOCK ��,.� ADD.�J,1V�i` Ir�S t ^. � � � (�• �t f�1ie� \ �� u��f� • ,�� i � , ' 's r�.� 3, Pre�ent Use r�r>t<t!''i��1�.� Present 2o�ing Oi:t. �� ' �, .�,. K'�, Reason�fqr Requost: . =� 1. ProPOSed use � �� '- jj` � � ' 1 C � �� f � � (� s,� c_:�i t r ��. ,r i, �d� �r '(;� � " tf' � rlUf4tl.� ? 19�0 "'.� 2. What phYSical charecteri�ticc of the property prevent i�s beiny used for any of the pe m�u� s (n You►zonei (toPOgraphy,soil conditions�ir�pn¢��p!pf Ipt,et�.) , ar+.;.J . .. . .0 . :. i .�.w+� _� :rit f.� �:;�:.� : . . . �p f` � � I 3. State tha�ific veriation�equested,giving distances whera aPpropriate. � l � "� ��; ��; � �,'i ,t;i ��,; c �t r�r� '. ; � i ,, ; � ,. , , r ,�,_ . •�, fL ;: ;� !�� :i ..w�.: _ � . � 4. Expiain how YOUr cete Co�formt to eech of the following: �'�� i . { • . . p. Thpt th�itriCt qpplicstion of th�provisione of the Zoning OrdianCe would result i r ( ,�f .:,, or exception,l practical difficulties,or exceptional undue hardships. � � 4� y.lti't1 •y� � li.;l tS �; 'i j t ;� ! : j � Uil , � 11 ' y� �� , ;� _ { . ! t �", �lr v� -- �,'��t,.f`� F �i�:'``..`l'. , �*._\r.)...Ll,�` ; `C.. `;�'r i.i 1 f 1 �_ l . � � � . CASHIERS USE ONLY b. Thst tht prantinp of a vpriance v�ill -��,� : �,., r , y.?< < ,�. , i?_' ;$, ,� not be • subMantial detriment to , ' -,�: ��;-�, ,� , - �w� . `riN�#i..C.�� '�' !•'< public poqd or s aubstant(el impair- ' mq�t of th� int�ant and purpose of =;,"Jt«! ` f_� y+ i.�''`�:�I- �:i(; tha 7,{�niny O►din�nCS. ' �{ tr''1W.� � : ,'1l1lJf i J t�ft t t.' �C.t . � S � ' � ,�; (9��t••.1.� 1± ~ �,� ;'k.�rt' �i4 T' r�r4�j , ,�� . � < . ,��t . �,•�-� h6k'1 �� ``l�ti.0 � �:i'�lf� 1 r� ?'� , .< 4` :' Q7d . .. '� ra,�, ` � NOTE: TMIS WILL NOT BE RROCESSED WITHOUT A COMPLETE SITE PLANI � � � �`� , ' , ��.1/l rC!'�C� (.l(`.f �lti.l� . { � 'L14i{�Zi � �t1��k 1,:'�:''�i�+'�` �, � � �' '�r $I,q�1�LYre � ' � � � � �� `� , r • � �F.� i ,. q,� t �t� t,u 4�1�� t�r:��rt� U �v { � �; ' \ . Dat�Received �S�AtJ Y!� , I # 7 Y �• 1 ..,Y � wt:': :� t...`X f•'iCbli.x:� .�4'h-:;'2 b � . . �' � - . '. ,. � . 4 v:�Irtati:�. � . ,,� �' .� . . .'? .. �� - � . � r •. 1.�� d -. . � . . \ � � � . S� �� . . , . . . . . + • • . � � � � � � � � � � . +7��. . f• �y . � � � \ �� .r „ � -.... ^ �, t 1 r 1 Z . � ,��r;,�,�.�� ,. , . . � . � � ;�, f� - � . . • �;a�'� �l��;' . . , �Q � . op �,�,��i`- - '�" �,1, , a � r � .,.' �':.R- .. _` . ___, �+ ' v"' � .. �� I��i, �r.w� Y�� ia� ---j:C_.JL-fi,L / ' � � _ � _ _ ..___ _—�----- �-- i � � ` J Q � Q � � \ ,\ , � � `� �° . a � � � �� . \ h �� ' ,� . � � � � -� :,,� � � �, '� , � � �r ; : � � , � � � � � .� � `�� .� `c ; ° Vti � � � � � , � � � � � �; � i I I f v r' ) I � , I I J i \A �� \ J ` �/ • / � , `� ,J � � —_ �� / N!? 'r"� :i?� .� , i�o�. �'/f✓/,l �c:.. � � � ; / ,' ,q :/� ..�e,i,_I/ , ,;•.�,y � ,-��/,�� `�,,,,v L � �U � -_ . , � ----- �o �o � ` � ��' � �- � � y _ .______r..------_ ,;, . . -_ _—____.__. � _— �,� ,,� .. - -_a____. � �- � G / C..a -�? 6 *- c;� c V, .:.,�,,,, / e , • � . � . • ' '_��-�a,.�'1FJ � � �� .. a"'�"'.�, �., . ..�. . � . // E.-�' r � ` � ��- �, , �� , iy .s�� - � w /r--- " � .a i / r)1 / / ,/�� // ' l.l�."��r'2i�� ' ! o ` '?'K-' L� /� ��L� � � �.+ ,t� ,.L./C.Go � ' GL.`: '/ � f c.' `��C�!'fG l.(i j�'-�c[e'-�C,G�-, .-j2sc' I 2. J.�- �/ � � � ' / , l /, �� /. ="C�+v" Q'LL- ' `�-�v � it�0..e.G/ � %/�� /�/ � Y � [ � //�/ �C Z- c.-�- fr'C�� ' L.C.(..r...�� U -�' Z' � / � !G LY1"t-" 7 � � ��t�jr�L� ��,;.�-�.1.rt/ �/- /I i� ' ` .�%' ��% r �/' . /J ��"__ .ti v-t.i �i -��-��/ �''L.� �'L" .�L�` ��`rC� _/� �.. .. _,'� `��c��- � . � � � / ��./ �'i(,�'C-6aG u.sr //�1 .J � , j;�, , �`i ��'G.C.�,,.,� ��Z�Lt::yj�- � � � � /��/f,JG�C,� 7�-L.:yc 2'��- ! ` i /I ' . ,�/ `/ ' �� .� L Icr /. n ,i L.�,' �Cl..'_ ` ,:�- c. ::� .CC � Ccy?LLt�' ;��2 L^,r,,!,' F��CGC ' � .i� - -� �� '�'.' 4 C�'!f / r �l.j r�t�1��',.. / C:.X'�.� .� .��G`ZC C Ll-��' V'�'2-' �L `C"i r � ,1 � �`.' �� t,� / �''c:C �� , �� ' � �.. ' � �, � . : , �� L �_..L�L - �.� ,.�'��c..a a . I �' • %L c Y' . ��'—�i �o /-. .y., .... ,�_' L. f �� ! _ � � � �+ A w Y' • / � ' • � \y � , �� , .�•,.,.�,.�-' `��` ��..,..:....� �f`�," •.�.,+*� �'�►.a,...�. 1�n r� %�.�/ 1 / � F'/ ,,;��. -�.,,_.�. ��--c�-�E �� . C �l-t�(.-.1.c l� y- ��/ � ( a / � � �J ..,��L ,��'�C�%�.�� . ��v�� ) / ; c� � �,F%��<� �"c �� f t C�,t.,� �2�� -.��,e-�L � ,5 � L ' 'J� �-z �____ �t� � �. �,�(,� Q� ��.c:-�- -'Y�-{;--� d G' � r � � �, � � r �...� �`�� . � �� .�.�1 � � � � �-� -.. �� ,.�_.� �L, �� .�.{.�_ , �,� ` ._ __� _ . �, �l � � �_�� , . _ . _ � ;� �, . ,%`l L 2; � ��z�<�,)Z��, (n�� l � ' � S�.� ��' ( c'��,�_.� � f— � ��«< i � ��-t.�ti��y� �� s ' d 7 * � .. - . . i �`� . , i ; ± i • � � + (n 'i �� ,� � � �� . I r ,,/ `.� �,� ,,� .,1 � '� � � � (.� -- / � �.} '" � � /� l�ti .` ♦/� •-..; ' � P'� ' r` � .�:}t 1`' ' � l -y • �. �', '" `�� `.�� j ��. y�,;�.:•� ,, r'q' � „� j (�I � ,; ` (�, '' r � , �' a� ��.' . E. l`� � (, \ � �`'�i�i�� i3``� � ��f � �l, r ��Y ', \ \ .: � ��iL';' •.i��;•, t. �� ti � � \ \ + . � ' ' r ti: '.' C� '� � � � � ,.��; � � �� A ` � � , •�J I .l� .!� �y } �.� ` (v�•� � \\� \ �\ O 1 �, ,� (, � � h + 'I��K' ry ��, 1�. � r � \ � � _ /'r (� �� , �}-� ,''{�y. (/ p' b. � ,�'w v ,y� ` , � ,�+ J ` " � Q O ' e. � � ,� �, '• �m ��'� (Y'0' . O � � .. �:• w I � O '� ``, A �� ' �� t"'� Z� � � _ L - '�L � �J'� ¢ , '' �:; � � T- , I f . ,� � � r�.� . , � o � , , � �. ,,� . � . J� � -�- --__ . ,,, . _ - � '"' " �, t'� Q � � `� -(�- 5 � � " ., . . ` � � � _.�. . __-+�^_ _Q p =P' - _ � � � O � � • C� � ' :�� o ---Q- � O_ -- � � � . i � � ---o O � � ' _ I I I i � __ , - - bp b - , - - O -�- ► 1 T � � �ro�w�a � �� 4_o W . � RO�IE ' ,►o � �- � p t� � O O (,� -o- � .� ... _____ .. _ ,�i � �� l�, ---- 0 � v v � v 1�- _ -- -O r I �� _.. o � �+ � ;•, �,_,_ �_f� - - �- -'{I I I I � Q — � I -v . �1 _ . ..� .. ' ....��.._�_ ... � r � <� _ � _d 0 -- � ' � !� �. - CJ ti. _g a - � O OI � II, O 0 � t��r� _ _ � � � � � � , , W . G ORG � o � - - � ; -�- o� � oi�o o ' - ' _ o 0 0 �� o - -�- o o ' ' � ------ -- -- � ..1 �" - LL j � � � , =.C� -- - > o o �,.: � � _ ' _ � �_ �-= _ ___ � ' M- �. �' "� O v � O � O V) O__ � I � . Q�' f�'� - + -tr �^ _ � ° -° � o �o� o,� � o —�°- o- o � o 0 0 ; -� o 0 0 0 � , . W . � Sfi VENS � � � � - Z o Q o � ;o -�- -a- o 0 0 0 0:� �,� , _, ,� � � � ___o _o---1 _ � ►� 1._�^r�. -' - ----__.__ _.. � 1 I � � � � 0 0 � � � � i 1 i.. _ � � _ _o .,,, � _ -� - ---�o � o .Q ,., � � Q _ ___ 4 ,;, i __ __a � � � � � �4 0 � � o + q ___..�.. _ _ oo 00 0 W . � KING � c,' _o_ o___ � oo -� o � c� oo _��__-- a � � � � '. o ; � � i __ � � o ; ; � � � =�_� _ -�--- � v P - - - - --�----�- + . -C,- ( � �i.F �. � ° °=--_ � ! I � ; __ . ,_ �° 1_ F f `��-+ ��1 � l 1 1 � 1 _ _ r�..__ „ - �,.- � _ _ AREA MAP APPI.ICANT �.,L��.Zr LEGEND — -- ZONING O�STRICT BOUNDARY ��p� ��'LLLd SUBJECT PROPERTY P U R POS E �!'�b[�NG� TO � O UNE FAMILY PLANNING ..� ,r OISTRIC�T FI�E N0. ��(��' Y TWO FAMILY � ��- � MULTIPLE FAMILY D AT E --1 Z�J�►��- ' � ; • • � connnnERCia� � $CA�E � �� = ZO'O� �"-, � � .�I► ':, ',LI�Tq�AI. MAP N0 � � NC'� � �� nw�ur nw�u n� .,rsw��wir [anw��t� �/ V�1...i-��i� i PIN�E _ FINANCERK �.� /�� CAIVFR'' _ DEPARTMENT G I TY OF SA I NT PAU L Council � F.i��i" � � �� °��a _�+�'-'- MAYOR File NO. Co ' Resolution Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date WHEREAS, Wylie Garrett applied to the Board of Zoning Appeals for a variance from the strict application of the provisions of Sections 62 .101(d) and 62 .113 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code pertaining to the 6 ft. 6 in. privacy fences constructed within required front and side yards as well as corner clearance height restrictions in an RT-1 zoning district for his property located at 350 W. George; and W�iEREAS, Following a public hearing with notice to affected property owners, the Board of Zoning Appeals by its resolution No. 8784 adopted January 27, 1981, denied the said application for variances based upon the following findings of fact: (1) That the strict application of the regulations enacted would not result in peculiar or exceptional practical difficulties to the owner of the property at 350 W. George as distinguished from mere inconvenience by reason of the existing physical conditions of the property. (2) That the variance could not b�e granted without substantial detriment to the public good and without substantially impairing the intent and purpose of the zoning ordinances. (3) That granting of the variances would di�ninish or impair established property values within the surrounding area, and impair public health, safety and welfare of the inhabitants of the City of Saint Paul; and, WHEREAS, Pursuant to the provisions of Section 64.204 Wylie Garrett duly filed with the City Clerk his appeal from the determi- nation made by the Board of Zoning Appeals, requesting that a hearing COUNC[LMEN Yeas Nays Requestgd by Department of: Hunt �evine [n Favor — Maddox McMahon sr,owaite� _ Against By Tedesco Wilson Form Approved by C' y ney Adopted by Council: Date Certified Yassed by Council Secretary BY By Approved by :Vlayor: Date _ Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council sy _ By WHITE - CITY CLERK � '(/tK, w µ{ PlNKp� - FINANCE COUIICII O ° ""� BLUE�'- MqypRMENT GI�TY OF SAINT PALTL File NO. Council Resolution Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date be held before the City Council for the purpose of considering the actions taken by the said Board; and WHEREAS, Acting pursuant to Sections64.204 through 64.207 , and upon notice to appellant and other affected property owners, a public hearing was duly conducted by the City Council on March 26, 1981 wherein all interested parties were given an opportunity to be heard; and WHEREAS, The Council having heard the statements made, and having consid�red the variance application, the report of staff, the minutes and findings of the Board of Zoning Appeals, does hereby RESOLVE, That the Council of the City of Saint Paul does hereby affirm the decision of the Board of Zoning Appeals in this matter and does hereby concur in the findings and conclusions made and determined by said Board; and, be it FURTHER RESOLVED, That the appeal of Wylie Garrett be and is hereby denied; and, be it FURTHER RESOLVED, That the City Clerk shall mail a copy of this resalution to Wylie Garrett, the Zoning Administrator, the Planning Commission and the Board of Zoning Appeals. -2- COUNCILMEN Yeas Nays Requestgd by Department of: Hunt Levine In Favor Maddox � McMahon B sr,o,�,aite� __ Against Y — Tedesco wlson APR 2 8 1981 Form Approved by ity A orney Adopted by Council: Date — Certified P s uncil ,e reta BY B � App by lNayor: t APR 3 0 1981 Approved by Mayor or Submission to Council gy BY PUBLiSHED MAY 91981 � �r�� `..�*fo. � � CITY OF SAINT PAUL '1t0y �7 �e a DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT � utiwi� . �� nu �� ; " " DIVISION OF PLANNING , '��IR, i s s• � 25 West Fourth Street,Saint Paul,Minnesota,55102 GEORGE LATIMER 612-298-4151 MAYOR March 18, 1981 � � t�s. Rose Mix, City Clerk / Room 386 City Hall /� /— St. Paul , Minnesota 55102 �� E: Zoning File �Jo. 8784 - Wylie Garrett ;� _ u�`` City Council Hearing: March 26, 1981 A ' Dear Madam: G��`` �f�F This letter is written in response to the appeal of ��Jylie Garrett of a decision of the Board of Zoning Appeals denying his request for variance of setback and corner clearance requirements in order to construct a 6'6" privacy fence along the George Street and Orleans Street sidewalks on this corner lot. " The 6oard of Zoning Appeals received one letter opposed to the variances; the Zoning Office has recently received one letter in favor of the variances (see attachments) . The Board of Zoning Appeals cond�lcted a public hearing on the variance requests on December 23, 19�1 . A motion for denial , which requires four affirmative votes , failed on a 3 to 1 vote. On January 13, 1981 , a motion for denial passed on a 4 to 0 vote. The r�ain concerns expressed were that the fence would impair traffic visibility and the lack of proven hardship. The appeal is scheduled for City Council public hearing on P�arch 26, 19�1 . Please notify me by March 25, 1981 , if any member of the City Council wishes to have slides of the site presented at the public hearing, or requests additional information. Sincerely, � � � A c%�� T d nthony F. e esco City Planner AFT/mb attachments �o __ __._._ _ , . �� ., r " " � `./ . ..c..� ' . t::�',� �'_. �,.__.__. ST. PAUL CiTY CaUNCIL `� ��'��s� PUBLIC HEARI�NG N4TICE ZONING APPE�AL . F��E No. x2�o9 PAGE PURPOSE To consider an appeal to a decision of the Board of Zoning Appeals regarding the application for-a variance from the height limits for a 6 foot privacy fence at 350 W. George Street. i � PETITtONER Wylie Garrett HEARING Thursday, March 26, 1981, at 10:00 A.M. City Coiincil Chambers, 3rd Floor Citv Hall - Court T�?ouse QUESTIONS Zoning 298-4154 Contact the Zonin� Section of the Planning and Economic Development Depar*_ment, ?:oom 11�1, Cit�� Hall Annex, 25 �d. 4tt� Street, St. Paul, *tinnesota 75102 Notice sent March 6, 1981, bv the Valuation and Assessment Division Department of Finance and '�ana�ement Services Room 21$ Citv Hall - Court House St. Paul, .M,innesota 5�102 � " -� : ' ^ . �� `�';�` �� ,r .— ; _ _ . _ . . ' w . .. � .i. . . . �� . . . " . . . . � . _ - . . . . ' . s �,� �S . �. � ':- �,. . . .. �. . .. , .:� . . . . . . . .•. ' .V;;�:".' . � �: -'' - � -� ,:..,.... .� . ' . . . . . . . . . � . .. � . � . . :�^ ' - � . � . . � .. � . . . � � . . " . .. , ��, .. . . , � . .� �. . � . � � . � � �.. . . . � . � . � h � _ � J . . . . . � ' �� . � � �� .. . , . . �. ' . . .. . . . ..� . . �. . ..�� ':-.' '� �_�'' .�- � � . . .. . - � . . . . . . ' . . � ��j .. . ... x� . . . ' . . ' ` ' ,�( �� . . . � . . i . � . - .. " ' . . . 't - . . � . . � . . . . . . . . , . . .. . . _ ' . �. . . . .. . , . T .. . . . ,. _ � `-�F ,u�. . . _ . _ � . . . - . �. .. . . . - . . . .. . � . . . ' ��,�� ' �. � " � � . - . .. . . . . . . . =,k ' '.�'°:� . . . . : . . . . . . � �. � � . . . . .. � .. .,.Y ' . : ti , r — . _ . . . � � � � .. . . , � , ' � � ' . � l. ' , � . � . . .. . . . 1, s$i . ��1'ti�lLt'�I' 2�� ,� � - ? - �,* . _ - " � - -�_ , ; - - 1�6r'. Pst11 Dei�h . � . ` T�epartmeat of Finaacs , ,_:s -,:, Room 2L8, Cfty Hall . � ' -��►r 8ir:_ � ,=1 - - _ ,_� `� � `;T�e �iLy Ct�i�nei3 set ai date of 2�earing for �larch, �6Lh, 1981 �� •., , to �conaic�ar th� aPpea�l ot Wy21e (iarrett to a_ 8ecis#o�:.�f �t'he; - ' f� , Board ,oP�oning App�ala regardiag proper�,jr at 350 :�t. (ieorg�e, ' •. , r will you please send �dotices to propei-ty oxmsrs as required ; , . 1; . . .,.by law? - , r , � �. _ -� Yery truly youra, -� -, � � ; � . ', -� �:, , , : - Rose Mix ;. - : - -i� � .. , � City Clerk �_ . � _ r � . � - � - . � . . . � . . � .y . /�BO;,7.a - � . - - ;.;' c�: Plsaniag Stalt, 7soning 'Sfatioa . Rowi,ng b'll1d6. Cod� Divisi�n ' , . : . , � :� , _ ,;,'i_ . �:_. . . ,r. - � " � ' � . . . - . . � ,, ' . l �� . �. � : � . - . . . . . ' . . . � _ � . . - � � . - /' �E:_ , � f �� - • - - � °, _ � � _ � - .> - � - , i`, _ . _ . , . , -,: �:, • , - _ . ' ,��. . C� . � ' -. . . . � � � ' j . �' ,. , .. . .. . ` . ' .. , � . ��t': . ' ' 1 <� , � - � � �_, '} i . � . .. . ... .. ' ... .�q.� . �� . . , - . . - . ' .. . •.�} . -. - . ' Y. ' . .. .� . � . ' . . . . . - . ' . . � . , . .. . . . . , . i _ I� . � / � • �� , • ,� c.' ✓ � °' G C'� °t �r''� � �� `� G �G �� - �� , �� C-�;�� Z� � ��- � �� ,� r � �� o �� G� �� , �- �.�c� �.�� , � �� : � � �� _ �� -v r T.rn -n c� — � r� rn �� N � �a �r-. �� ._ n C...:� f'r'1 _.._ �- / �' — �/ �'� z�, � �,� ��-,� �"%'�'�� c��,��. w� �.� � a�-� �� s� �� "� ��----� --� �� --.,�_ � ..2.�z� � d � " �� ` ` �%� �� o a-,..� Q ' a �..`� "� ��` .�. '�-�°"`�` � � � ��,�� l�"�` // -� � -�-�� Q:CL``L'�K 4 �i,� �-�.� �'�..E, �-e�� -z�,-�_.� �a-�� -�-� -�'� �� -�-�,,� � � - �; ��+.� �`�° c�' � ��.u�.,.,__ �� "�-� —`° �,��i' �. � -� �� a~�� ` , '.�-� ' � � z�"�,� �-e�� - �' �� d� �. ° �� ?�,�.. ° �� - ,��,,� �� , � � ;� -�-�-. �L �� '�' �� / c � �`l� /i(�C � s p L �^+�' �v - �� .} �^—!i vi// �+�L.J� �-�J �� fiLCts�l.s��/!�/�i1.-//_..r` � ' � `.a ��'�� /- �� r %��/ �-�' � -�� --y�.-�ti- � . t..e�-z�, ��/ � � � �� w �'� � . �n2� � ��. c � ,�- ��Zo�-(� � .-t� �� . �� z�,z�—. � � � � � � � ��, .�� -�-� G .. � .� . .. -, , �.., .�, (7 J . . � / - i � - �/ %o , � .�'z°� �• �� z'�' • .�� -- � y,�,�„ . . � � � � � , � ��..� `�� . . � �— "�e� .�a�`-°e� � Gt� �,�--� °`,,� . � ` �`.°`-� � ��' �-n-42_ _�Z`� � � �_ �.,�ci �� '"'`�w� ` ' `�4�Lo-�-ct--- � � ' � �s�cJ a� (�4io � ''Z�—l�,c� .�� . . �� J � ✓2'i'°�'�� `�-� L� ,./f� e L2.� . � a.�l � '�- � / _C�� . ��1� � �� S-� n L _ o�' l �O Q�iJ Q� . ' .�//�7' «iC�C/ � � � ) CJ�'� • � , (/Y� n ' �T'�� . � t�. � U �.v .�—� �.�—e�„�`� � �'`�` ' � G�°--c�..L � � �� `'F `Y�1 /� � � � l ��J � . �5'� W , ...,,� . � , f ti. � f ! E + A-+��v_t�� 1 � � ' � " . ,... ,r- : � � �. � _ . .. /• _" ... .. r . -. . �, i-, / - ._...... ... .. . y _� . � `L-! � �....fL� �� 1j_.1.f�_... `-��`'G� .��'(�G +.�� . � ,1 � � - . . . // .. . / � . � -. '.� ' .. ....�f!�./,��/ t'�— /,�-<.i-... /�-�=�•%._-.:--/ ./� -,�� a�;� :� � /� � � � � p, fi- �' -, ,� I', . ... . _�,.(�./�.�'.'i i��_r y G<.�f �?�� c.� ��,�; �/ � .i..,.t�-...�'./"��. . . `I "`�� :_ � . / , �s� - ---_ _ _- - _. . , I � �� ._..__.. _ _.___ .�. :_. .. . .. _. . . . �.. � . _ . ` �./�� G� � 1��1��v � _ .>'�-�- � ; -�� . � - � � � � . _ -a�'-�� ,7-=�r��G�; /�/ ".�.J�c�� t. , � -- - --- - �� /_ ��f�� ,S—o?� -- �-'c"' � ; `� ; — _ __. ; ; _ : � % ,� / ; �� .�.�/�'` . -� .l, ! _ • / . � j ��, i�,��"� ��:� ��. �z �:�...—� .=� �_ � ; . ; _ _ __ .., , ; _ . . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ �� , , . .� � , ,� _ ��•�.�?`�. •-�� ; � -- � �' vL� � �C-�L _ _ " � � � \ -- ; �� / ,%�� . ..._ ._.. ...� r._ :..�� .._. .. . __�.. . _ .. � ' ..,�f�i r!/( G%�� ... C _ ' � /- " _. , �-� 1 (� :_— __ � � ti � _ � ;�,,��,�j�� sic, % � __ .. _ - .� a �- Yq 7� - s-� � -�o -�. - - - - �� _ _ . , �n - � - _ ;- . � _ %" ..��. ��%c��r,,��i� � ��^ , � � i �_ ' . �, _ t �-� �-c�` //C�'6 ��i�-e� r;,::�� ._�.� �`�.l.�-+" ' �-J ' � i . � ' . � , _ `, �i �t / ��` '��—�k/ � % �K:L�.�—/ - G `y�c_.�.Gi [/l/ '_.� _ ; �� [��:..��✓'L . �..7Z�., ` ��.2�J , �/ � s` �L ' �v'G ' �.. _ � . : . � _t : . .. �' .. ] , . � � . _._ __ __ �