The URL can be used to link to this page

276750 WHITE - CITY CLERK �] CF� PINK � - FINANCE COLI1C11 J dV /50 CANARIf - DEPARTMENT C I TY OF SA I NT PAiT L M� a vd� BLUE - MAYOR File �N O. � �. � / p�Q dnce Ordinance N�. I (D�b / Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date An Ordinance amending Chapter 60 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code pertaining to zoning for the City of Saint Paul and the zoning maps thereof. WHEREAS, Pursuant to P�iinnesota Statutes �462 .357 and §64.210 of the Legislative Code, Richard Glatch duly petitioned to rezone the North 190 feet of Lots l, 2 and 3, Block 18, Summit Park Addition, located on the southwest corner of Avon and Summit from R-2 to RT-1 for the purpose of allowing conversion of the third floor of the principal structure for use as a third unit, the petition having been certified by the Department of Finance and Management Services on December l2, 1980 as having been consented to by at least 670 of the owners of the area of the property to be rezoned, and further having been consented to by at least two-thirds of the owners of the property situated within 100 feet of the total contiguous descriptions of real estate held by the same owner or any party purchasing any such contiguous property within one year pre- ceding the date of the petition; and TnhIEREA5, The current Planning Committee on February 5 and 19, 1981 conducted a public hearing for the purpose of considering the rezoning petition, and pursuant to Section 107. 03 of the Adminis- trative Code, submitted its recommendation to the Planning Commission that the petition be granted; and WHEREAS, The Planning Commission considered the rezoning petition at its meeting held on February 27 , 1981 and recommended that the City Council approve the petition; and WHEREAS, Notice of a public hearing before the City Council on the said rezoning petition was duly published in the official COUNCILMEN Yeas Nays Requested by Department of: Hunt Levine In Favor Maddox McMahon sno�iter Against BY Tedesco Wilson Form Approved b it tor Adopted by Council: Date Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY � By . Approved by Mayor: Date Appr y a for Su to Council By BY � WHITE - CITY CLERK (� PINK - FINANCE � �, CANARY - DEPARTMENT G I TY O F SA I NT PA U L COl1t1C1I �/_ ��, , BLUE - MAYOR File N O. M > `f` Ordindnce Ordinance N0. / �� U ! Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date newspaper of the City on March. 28, 1981 and notices were duly mailed to each owner of affected property and property situated wholly or partly within 350 feet of the property sought to be rezoned; and WHEREAS, A public hearing before the City Cauncil, having been conducted on April 9, 1981 where a11 interested persons were heard, and the Council having considered all the facts and recommendations concerning the petition; now, therefore, THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: Section 1. That the zoning map of the eity of Saint Paul, Sheet No. 29, as incorporated by reference in Section 60.401 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, as amended, is hereby further amended as follows: That property located on the north side of Concord Street and south of Delos, being more particularly described as vacated street aceruing, and Lot 2 except the easterly quadrangle part measuring 98 .8 feet on the north line, and Lot 3 except the easterly quad- rangle part measuring 94 feet, Block 35, West St. Paul Proper, be and is hereby rezoned from RM-1 to P-l. Section 2 . This ordinance shall take effect and be in force thirty (30) days from and after its passage, approval and publication. -2- COUNCILMEN Yeas Nays Requested by Department of: Hunt � Levine In FavOr Maddox McMahon snoweite� � Against BY ��esee wlson MAY 14 198� Form Appr v d ity orney Adopted by Council: Date Certified Pa Council retar BY By Approved by Mayor: Date MAY 19 Ap e y M yoc for i i n to Ceuncil By B PUBLISHED MAY 2 31981 w�� w� .. a � ?�' r ��°�^�� CITY OF SAINT PAU� `�..S�ti p�4(� �°`� '-`- OFFICE OF THE CITY CL�RK ?° inm �, ';� _'��° � „�� BUREAU OF RECORDS ,,. _ '`�o ,..• 386 City Hall,Saint Paul,Minnesota 55102 11j�1TR\\\\��OC\\\`'� 612-298-4231 GEORGE LATIMER MAYOR December 30, 1g80 Planning Staff, Zoning Section llth Floor, City Hall Annex St. Paul, Mn. Dear Sirs: The City Council referred to the Plannin� Commission for rec- ommendation, the attached petition of Richaxd Glatch to rezone Lots l, 2 and 3, Block 18, Summit Park Addition at 808 Summit Avenue. ___._ _ � . V y truly yours, �`� U''yQ Rose Mi�c City Clerk � Attach. ABO:la � t c .�,�. � �� ', �� .�.9�. I ■� u. . ,• ��a� �;:� s ,,�;� ; ;� �� O ' ., � g �a �� `,,,.,.,,,,,,�,R =-��`tT' ''�°''� CITY OF SAINT PAUL -4� i'��'. �� = DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND MANAGEMENT SERVICES ;: ri'inii �� `��' = ASSESSMENT DIVISION '��'G�i I��• "�m�,,.•.�•••°°```` 218 City Hall GEORGE LATIMER Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 MAYOR 612-298-5125 December 12, 1980 To the Council City of St. Paul Members of the Council: I have checked the attached petition of Richard Glatch filed in the matter of rezoning, from an R-2 district to an RT-2 district, the following property: Lots 1 ,2 and 3, Block 18, Summit Park Addition. The petition, as submitted, is sufficient. Sincerely, r' � . . �. - � J. W. Donovan Valuation & Assessment Engineer Re: X 2704 cc: Building Dept. Zoning Div. J.W. Donovan File Parcel Eligible 14 parcels Needed 10 Parcels Signed 10 JWD:VP:dal � 'Q'�;y#,,>� �� r�a r, f � �� '� �L..[-SL. J , :,.s � P' � � �:'f 3 �S �`':.�. ,.al .. � � .. .�.._...."_"...........:.:....,.`._�-�.—..�_ �� . � -��i �� .� , ��°�� CITY OF SAINT PAUL =��`��** ��•;'��-, ;� s; OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK ;o �; s� ii�ilm ,, ;,,.� „�� BUREAU OF RECORDS ,,,r ; °"'lm�...o�,�' 386 City Hall,Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 612-298-4231 GEORGE LATIMER MAYOR December 4, 1980 Mr. Paul Desch Finance Department Room 218, City Hall Dear Sir: The City Council referred to the Finance Department for check as to sufficiency, the attached petition of Richaxd Glatch to rezone property at 808 Summit Avenue, aka Lots l thru 3, Block 18, Summit Park Addition. Ver truly yours, , ��.� Rose NLix City Clerk Attach. ABO:la �g��" C'_�� j�t t�1i�'►"11.� �� n�� a� �� , � �, _ _.._.._.__a._._ - — l � ,.-� A r. �..� ^ 'aw 'c . �' : � r.�;i 4f �:r,: � �� f � ;, �� e� '�a c� � •W L�: G u �c�.�� _��=.—i--�—� i f �; � % V � O \ � . � � � � lst �� :a' �� _2nd1 .� — S 0 � 3rd `� - � ,5�� Adopted �I7 - (� / _ Yeas � Nays HUNT - . LEVINE �J �, � � -�/ ! I M cMAH ON S1�OWALTER ��"�f-°O TEDESCO , WILSON PRESIDENT (MADDOX) . � � ; R : . - • � ; �' '`� ��7�'�� 3a� � , , : � , . � , , � '`, :,;�; /a -�-g� =; � � _'., � .�,,�'{� PETITION TO AMEND ZONING CODE . �$0,Od - CITY OF ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA � TO THE HONOftABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL DATE ' oZ, 19 �U c/o City Clerk, Room 386 City Hall — St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Pursuant to Section 64.210 of the St. Paul Zoning Ordinance and Section 462.357 (5) of the Minnesota Statutes, i C,Vl.A1"� \ • i r ��-�} , the owner of all of the land proposed for rezoning, hereby petitions your Honorable Body to rezone the following described property: Street Address: �g � �,�, yy��,y� a I �� Legal Description: �,��, �, , aj f�� IS, �(.tmm �i �.A+^k .A •% ,��`rJ from a }� - �, District to a �,��a., District for the purpose of__��i;�,�� r,,��( ;1 i�,,,�A! i.l�l�1 Orv -3D E�J�,ST�rv� � r�l ��f�b v T. �1u. �('n A+ ►� �-}0 uSc� �.l o�l hAJ e. :� -TU Le.I o � C o� ) 1,( Y1 1 i S . I I�tm�T ��e`�- �t,r�•-� t�.t.�h �c,h � t C ��w' �7�i��i�� c.�. Subscribed and sworn to gy; �c%�� before this /�T day of �� 19�d Title: Petitioner . � otary Public �� JU�l7H H, KLlNK 9� �,� � �� ''° �� _$�9g - NOTANY FU9l.IC•MINP�E50TA �� G 4i;;� �� -'��;�`�' PoA�..+.`�EY ::iJUNTV —�- MYOOMMIft10N RX►IWRW JULY 10�199b � Page 1 of • � �� `� , " CONSENT OF ADJOINING PBOPERTY OWNEftS TO REZONING � We, the undersigned, owners of property within 100 feet of the total contiguous descriptions of real estate owned by Petitioner or sold by Petitioner within one.year preceding the date of this petition, acknowledge that we have been furnished with the following: 1. A copy of the Petition of `��W„� '� �.V,�1�- 2. A copy of Sections (ab, ��1 through �p .. �31 , inclusive, of the St. Paul Ordinance; and acknowledge that we are aware of the uses permitted under a '�"� - � District zoning classificatian; and hereby consent to the rezoning of the property described in the Petition of��y,,.�� • S (.U�TZ_►1• to a (p (�.1-] 3� �Z District. RECORD OWNER SIGNATUR LOT BLOCK ADDITION . . �.a,_3 � ty .�s �� P -i��, � � � �, P�� :...ti s-� _� i�� j �� QAr/� X � C_. �.^ � �� LV13!'T�K@ � ttGC � � P?^p �+rTle L G/. � ' � �,� � �. s Po.�( '€ ` � � �' �� -J 1 �� ' � � :� � c�,N,.,,,�t A�, . � � � l� � �� ; .;. ' � ,l° ,t° ,c,�:�. ►� .-7`i��'�` ` � � p1 �� .�"}� v��c .:��. ��///� �� /j r:--` �,�j �� : . t �.. 1� �� • � ��`� //�•!/ v'�� R i'. � � _ �; `/, Petitions shall not be ennsidered as officially filed with the city clerk until the lapse of 7 working days after a petition is received in the office of the city clerk. Any signator of any petition may withdraw his name therefrom by written request within that time. �� :�� p� �� _.�222� Page 2 of ' ' ' ��, ��;�� a �;.r .,. . , . STATE OF MINNFSOTA) ` �4`� : ss, a; 3 : ' `� COUNTY OF RAMSEY ) � -�� (� . � °!,' `� :'�� 1��''�� `��— , being first duly swr�rn, �epo`ses'and states that he is the person w o circ�ate� t—f�e wit iFi'n petition and consent, consisting of� pages; that affiant is informed and believes that the parties described are the owners respectively of the lots placed immediately following each name, that affiant is informed and believes that each of the parties described above is the owner of property which is within 100 feet from any property owned ►�;� petitioner or sold by petitioner within one (1) year preceding the date of this petition which is contiguous to the property described in the petition; that except for /v� CE�X(+�pj/U✓1/S none of the parties described above has purchased or is purchasing property r�om pe i ioner contiguous to the above described property within one (1)year of the date of the petition; that this consent was signed by each of said owners in the presence of this affiant, and that the signatures r�re the true and correct signatures of each and all of the parties so described. � � s - � d ress ��/- �/S / e ep one umber �ubscribed and sworn t efore me this �day of �,(��. ,, 19 ��J otar ub ic JUDITH H. KLINK ➢� +'�°' NOi'P,RY FUBLIC-MINNESOTA � RA��1�F_Y COUNTV M1'QOMMI�tION tgryqb JULY 1-6,igBa Approved as to form - Feb. 80 Planiiing Department Page�of �� i� �� 2�. ��"�� ST. PAUL CITY COUNCIL PU �LIC HEARING NOTICE ZC? NING City Clerk — 386 City Hall F i L E N 0. x z�o4 St. Paul, MN 55102 PA G E 1 Zoning File r o. P U R P 0 S E Petition of Richard Glatch to rezone, from an R-2 district to an RT-2 district, property at 808 Summit Ave. , additional living unit to the 3rd floor, legallly descr�tied as Lots 1, 2 &. 3, Block 18, Summit Park Addition. I ( �E�,T��N E R Richard Glatch HEARIN� �ursday, April 9, 1981, 1�.0� a.•". - i Citv Cotincil Charnoers, 3rc�! Floor Cit�• ?Ia1� - Court 'iouse QUESTIQNS Zoninp� ?9�i-G15�: C^^tact the Zonin� Section oi t�e P�an*�in� ard ��:�o^�� "!evelonment Denar.�ment, ?oo-� 11�1, Cit�• i'.nll .�nnex, � 'S ?:. ;t�� St-eet, St. Pa��l, "innesot� ��:�� \ot�ce sent March 20, 1981, b-: t7e '.'aluation arc? Assess�ert Di:�isi•,r. De�artment of �'inance anc', ",ar.a�e^�ent �e-vices Roor�: 218 Cit•.• 'r,al1 - Court ?',ouse �t . ?=�:;1, u1;1:leSCC� ��'n�' �'�� . _ - ns�ra�.zp�qa�s A,v�ston n�n+i�bwa��;�; . cne Zo�tna c�a�w�ce�e�e L^�or sc.ra�. • beamendai�tote�are[re�+enR-l�dtstrict ta�fe'�d"�ti�E`.ptoy�e�t:��'i�Ots � � 1 2 asd 3 B1o�`�a #�feod!!t�l+kls�t�}it1m+. � �� Tpe_.�9p�it';�tfd af'1��=�it r� Ave�lYe;�t�oun¢iI dd�E4e'Cit�ot 9k Pa»1 '��i � 6ssli�ced�o0th iu;n�Aoefil�iNBt;�t,r2@�4 ', A.lI.in t�eCouocil Chambas f4ll�e Cdty Fte11 � uf�}Cft�,a�d At eaid t3mc a��' e:t4R Co�3ne�!�eilt. a11 P�s sud a'$ob]ee� tio�a�!x�de�Ons l#1�ivF1 to i�a P�t�l�ent. . _ '�rted l�ieh'43ed '�9b1r ` xe �;._ - R<'�A�;t�t4YCkrk pisrch�,l4�Eu A � �� 4�= o. ,, CITY OF SAINT PAUL �o � DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT r �ii'i i'n a� %° ^ DIVISION OF PLANNING ��'6'n„ ,.e. 25 West Fourth Street,Saint Paul,Minnesota,55102 GEORGE LATIMER 612-298-4151 MAYOR March 31 , 1981 Albert Olson, City Clerk Room 386 City Hall St. Paul , Minnesota 55102 RE: Public Hearing April 9, 1981 Glatch Zoning File ��o. 8798 Dear Sir: The Planning Commission has completed its review of the rezoning petition of Richard Glatch to rezone 808 Summit to RT-2 (4 units) from an R-2 (single family). The applicant desires a rezoning to allow creation of a second housing unit on the third floor of his house. The house contains over 6,000 square feet of space. The third floor unit will have over 2,000 square feet of space. The Zoning Conimittee of the Planning Commission held a public hearing on February 5, 1981 , to consider public testimony. At that meeting the Committee heard testimony from representatives of the District 16 Planning Council and from staff regarding the potential problems with rezoning to 4 units. The applicant testified that he wished only for one additional unit. If that could be accomplished with a more restrictive zoning, he would agree to that. The Committee laid over the matter directing staff to meet with District 16 and the applicant to agree to the appropriate zone. The matter was again considered by the Zoning Committee on February 19, 1981 . The amended staff recommendation at that meetinq was to rezone the north 190 feet of � e property to RT-1 . This zone would only alloN� two un�ts in t e main ouse. e remain er of the property would remain in a single family zone allowing only one housing unit. Presently, a legal unit exists in the carriage house on this portion of the property. The Zoning Committee voted 6 to 1 to recommend approval of the rezoning to RT-1 . The Planning Commission concurred voting 12 to 1 to approve at their February 27, 1981 , meeting. The Planning Commission's recommendation to the City Council is : to ap�rove a rezoning of the north 190 feet of 808 Summit to RT-1 . This is a more restrictive rezoning than originally proposed. This recommendation has the support of the applicant and the District 16 Planning Council . A public hearing has been scheduled for April 9, 1981 , before the City Council to hear this petition. Please let me know if any Council members wish to see slides of the site at the meeting. I can be reached at 292-6183 Sneely, / l ) Steph Grochala �o ;;��TT °= ;, �� i �r vr �hi tv t rf�UL , 'o�� ''' ';'; DEt ARTMENT O; PLANNING AND ECONOMtC DEVELOP�+t�NT ;; �� ,� ;: -�:_�� }.� - DIV1510N OF PlANN1NG ''``l.••'`.�::••i��JJ`. . . 25 West FourEh Sireet,Saint Paul,Minnesota,551D2 GEORGE L.A7IMER 8-4151 ,�fAYOR ��r�� February 27, 1981 Richard Glatch 80� Summit Avenue St. Paul , P-1i nnesota 55105 Dear f�lr. G1 atch: At the P7anning Commission meetinc� on February 27, 1°E1 , the Commission voted 12 to 1 to approve a recommendation to rezone th� north 190 feet of your property at 808 Sumnit to RT-2. I have requested that a public hearing be scheduled �efore the City Council and you will be notified of the date and time of that hearing. Si�cerely, � ,_� (, ,i�� . I . � _ �--�� ., ' --c- � �<�. ,r_= �� .� \_ Stephen Grochala Senior Planner SG/mb ^ �---.��.-. � - � _ _ _________ _ _ � � ' � !�A�� 8 98 ZONING STAFF REPORT l . APPLICANT: RICHARD GLATCH DATE OF HEARING_ �, / 8 CLASS I F I CAT I ON �euiscd{row. ol��?� �. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . CURRENT PLANNING & ZONING COMMITTEE � BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS O �Rezoning Variance Special Condition Use ❑ Administrative Review Q Detcrmination of Similar Use ❑ Other Change of Nonconforming Use a 0#.her — 3, l(1CATION: 808 Summit Avenue. 4. LEGAL DESCRIPTION: Lots 1 , 2, and 3, Block 18, Summit Park Addition. 5. PRESENT ZONING: R-2 ZONING CODE REFEREP�CE: Sections 60.430-60.444 6. STAFF INUESTIGATION & REPORT: DATE 1/26/81 BY �t.Pnh�n C1^nrhala__ A.y SUFFICIENCY: The application was filed on December 1 , 1980, by consent petition, subscribed and sworn to before a notary public on December 1 , 1980, declared sufficient by Finance Department on December 12, 1980, and received in the Planning Office on January 2, 1981 . Fourteen parcels were eligible to sign; 10 were required; 10 were obtained. 6. PURPOSE: The applicant proposes to rezone to RT-2 to allow conversion of the third floor of the principal structure for use as a third unit on the zoning lot. C. SITE & AREA CONDITIONS: The applicant's site consists of three lots at the southwest corner of Avon and Summit. The site has an area of 35,000 square feet. The principal structure has approximately 6,000 square feet of floor area. The area to the south is part of the Grand Avenue mixed use strip with apartments , single family houses , and commercial. uses. The site itself holds one of the significant large houses on Summit surrounded by similar buildings. To the northeast, across Summit, is the House of Hope Presbyterian Church. D. FINDINGS: 1 . The St. Paul Land Use Plan identifies this area as part of an existing residential neighborhood. 2. The Land Use Plan Policy 4.1-5 states that the City will establish criteria to allow sensitive re-use of existing large residential structures. While no formal criteria has been established, the proposal at this site would meet even the most stringent criteria for lot sizes , structure size, and housing unit size. 3. The Summit Nill District 16 'Plan identifies this portion of Surnmit Avenue as low density residential land use. This proposal for 3 units on the site would meet that criteria. The site would have a lower density than the single family blocks of housing in the core of District 16. The site will have a density of 3.75 dwelling units per acre. 4. The proposed rezoning to RT-2 would limit the site to a maximum of 4 units and a 31-room density count. The two structures on the site will contain 3 units and 24 rooms , meeting the criteria for RT-2 zoning. 5. RT-1 zoning of a portion of the lot would allow exactly the density and use requested by the applicant without creating the potential for additional subdivision or new construction of more units on the site at a future date. E. STAFF ANALYSIS: Conversion to 3 units on the site would be an appropriate adaptive re-use to preserve significant architectural monument on Summit Avenue. The resulting housing density will still be lower than that allowed in the City's most restrictive single family zoning district. The proposal is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan of St. Paul . RT-2 zoning for the entire site would allow more units potentially than the applicant wishes and more than would be appropriate for this site on Summit Avenue. Rezoning the main house to RT-1 would allow the duplex requested by the applicant and at the same time it would limit the change in land use to those exactly expressed by the applicant. F. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Based on findings 1 through 5, staff recommends approval of rezoning the north 190 feet of the site to RT-1 . . ____. , ` � : � : � � �,,�'��{��' . __ -_.. i . APf'LICAf;T: R1�CHARD GLA��CFI DATE OF HFARING 2/5/81 _ � •� C L A S S I F I C A T I 0 N . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . L. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ---�-- CIIRKkNT PLANNIfJG & LONING COMMITTEE BOARD OF ZO"�ING APPEALS Rezoning � � Variance � Spec:ial Condition Use ❑ Administrative Review ❑ Detcrmination of Similar Use ❑ Other � Change of Noncoriforming Use a �ther __ 3. L(1CATION: $08 Summit Avenue. �. LEGAL DESCRIPTION: Lots 1 , 2, and 3, Block 18, Summit Park Addition. 5. PRESE�VT ZONING: R-2 ZONING CODE REFEREPdC�: Sections 60.430-60.444 G. STAt�F INVESTIGATION & REPORT: DATE �/26/g� BY �+Q�n �rnrh�l,� A. SUFFICIENCY: The application was filed on December 1 , 1980, by consent petition, _. subscribed and sworn to before a notary public on December l , 1980, declared sufficient by Finance Departrnent on December, l2, 1980, and received in the Planning Office on January 2, 1981 . Fourteen parcels were eligible to sign; 10 were required; 10 were obtained. 6. PURPOSE: The applicant proposes to rezone to RT-2 to a11ow conversion of the third floor of the principal struct�;re for use as a third unit on the zoning lot. C. SITE & AREA CONDITIONS: The a?plicant's site consists of three lots at the southwest corner of Avon and Summit. ThE� site has an area of 35,000 square feet. The principal structure has approximately 6,G00 square feet of floor area. The area to the south is part of the Gr•and Avenue mixed use strip with apartments , single family houses , and commercial uses . The site itself holds one of the significant large house� on Sunxnit surrounded by similar buildir�ys. To the northeast, across Summit, is the House of Hope Presbyterian Church. D. FINDINGS: l . The St. Paul Land Use Plan identifies this area as part of an exis�ing residential neighborhood. , 2. Tne Land Use �la„ Policy 4.1-5 states that th,e City will es �abl :sh cr;teri;. to allow sensitive re-use of existing large residential structures . tJhile no formal criteria has been established, the proposal at this site would meet even the most stringent criteria for lot sizes , structure size, and housing unit size. , 3. The Summit Hill District 16 Plan identifies this portion of Summit Avenue as low density residential land use. This proposal for 3 units on the site would meet that criteria. The site would have a lower density than the single family blocks of housing in the core of �i�trict 16. The site will have a density of 3.75 � dwelling units per acre. 4. The proposed rezoning to RT-2 would limit the site to a maximum of 4 units and a 31-room density count. The two structures on the site ovill contain 3 units and 24 rooms , meeting the criteria for RT-2 zoning. � �5. RT-1 zoning of a portion of the lot would allo�v exactly the density and use requested by the applicant without creating the potential for additional subdivision or new construction of more units on the site at a future date. E. STAFF ANALYSIS: Conversion to 3 units on the site would be an appropriate adaptive re-use to preserve significant architectural monument on Summit Avenue. The resulting housing density will still be lower than that allowed in the City's most restrictive single family zoning district. The proposal is consistent with the Coniprehensive Plan of St. Paul . RT-2 zor�ing for the entire site �,rould allow more units potentially than the applicant wishes and rnor�e ti�an would be appropriate for this site on Summit Avenue. Rezoning the main house to RT-1 would allow the duplex requested by the applicant and at the same time it wuuld limit the change in land use to those exactly expressed by the applicant. F. STAFF RECO��i�l�fif)ATIOfI : Qased on findinq; 1 through 5, staff recomrneilds approval of rez��iiny th� ewrti� 19� F`et nF i.h�� sit�� to {?i-1 . � � �"�'6��9 . . . summ�t h�ll summit hiii association February 18, 1981 To� Steve Grochala Senior Planner From� Swnmit Hill Association/District 16 Planning Council Re� 808 Summit Avenue At it's February 12, 1981 Board Meeting� the above Board passed a resolution recommending to the Zoning Committee that the north 190 feet at 808 Summit be rezoned to RT-1 allowing use of the main house as a duplex . The south 60 feet of the property will remain in an R-2 zone allowing use of the carriage house as a single family residence. _. � � r+,.._--.. �� C� Bob Casselman � Zoning Chair BC/tr cc� Planning Commission Richard Glatch �i;il�liifl tlVl?11tJt: Cd�11S8Y S�iflrt`C .;� � e�i�triCt i6 ��}`, y, ,},_� � ,��,�� V ,,,. ,� � a n�n•profit corporatic�� t�un�i��t t<,rnr�int�in and develop the residenri�l i;h�r,�c�tcr af th�sun��m�t hill r�e�yhhurhuud ' return address: 10fi7 goodrich avenue, saint paul, minnesota 55105 . . �tc�� T� �: CI�fY OF SAfNT PAUL �� • '. "� y ';, �a �"' �s, , DEf',�R l MEN f OF }'l_ANNING AND ECONUMIC DEVELC7F'MEN � `�� 'iii±�iiiii, ;' �,� 1 . L o�; DIVISION OF PLANNING �,�.� 25�tic•.� fuurth St�eet, SJI/l[ PdUI, Minne�ota, 55102 C:EUKGE L.1TIMtK 612-29tl-4151 MAYUK February 12, 1931 � Richard Glatch 808 Summit Avenue , St. Paul , P4innesota 55105 Dear ��r. Gl atch: Thank you for the opportunity to meet ��ith you, Elberta P1atters , and Bob Casselman of the Suminit Hill Land Use Committee on February 11 . As a result of our agreement at the n�eeting, I will recommend to the Zoniny Committee that the north 190 feet of your property be rezoned to RT-1 allowing use of tl�e n�ain house as a duplex. The south 60 feet of your pr•operty wi11 re�nain ir� an R-2 zone allowing use of the carriage house as a single farnily residence. The Loni ng Conuiii ttee wi 11 actai n c�ns i�er your appl i r_a t ion at thei r February 19th meeting. I expect this ayreement to be acceptablE to them. S 'ncerely, - i �,_.t,1L��_. � �� _ ` Stepheii Gr•ocliala Senior Planner SG/mb • cc: Zoning Conunittee Elberta htatter•s Bob Casselman Oistrict 16, Tally Rhame 1 EI NM HI 1 Ilk:!I��'!;�'�!l:;:;'�� I : �� 1 °��.�`I�KiI�C�y N � •II Y I 1�I�J .v, INNINI I � I bll I MI I IIIIII A III 11111 N . NIN�M 1.'i 1�'. � � ir:� 1111 WIM 1 :.IIWNIIIIN.". q111111N111 tMI11N11Y11" � ��a �nun�a � i ii i iN�ni ii e� �::i �nii�iiu �i NII MNlllli�uui nuN��un :. r� � iw��u iuN iim iba n�n �NUii� ui��i�ia imnuiiuu � ��N � II�� rl 111 flH Y!IUUIII IIYbNN11IN 1 Illfllll 1111111 NIIIII IINIIININIIi INIII Ip'. INI 1 . UI Iql! 1 1 � � <' t � . �NNII 1 IIN 1 II�INI �IIIIIII IIIIIIillll :�c� ._.. _ - � �� '�' 1 I 1 I IIIIIUIIIIIIiI 1 11 N �N •, .�Q � ! �a � ,: 1 M�NIIIH�NNNNNMNI�NNI �� .� � ;��_:._ � -� ..��_ �i �• •�7T� � •� i �j� � �� r Y �.' 1 . : � �� 11 � � _ . � � � _ �� .__ �II ��_ �� i�_.. : . , �' , .•,. ,, y� , a: i.a �: �i• l•�.i•iF. R. �� ._._ � s � 1 1111 � I',,';Y' ■ � _i� � 111 ill -I�� — :��' waa�a��iu�� 111111 ��►i .. �. dIW ��`_. �+''� �� , i.11Y ��i''iri.�. ■ �I �I IA�� I �H,I� � 1 1 -'�j' ��A � �%�WN�� Rii � . � � y � �I �l.J� � ' ` �, I Illilii�, l�li i:�. ':� fl�ilo�� , t�� =�► :�j[=a�� q�� it=��i�-.�y�■ �n ��11 11�_"��IM;::�: ,.� i� 'y _ w. _ ��: :�..�� are�t uiiu�u�i N�w�i� ��iu�iiuuEau rn��uui _ �i � ,-„ . i:�: . .T . -.a �'" �� u ' Nl �!! �� !•`•�� N�N I �: : .i1� - Y�Ip�;. C � " -�..:��"a ueii� a � N �i.L,�� 1� NI�IHql�ll N� � � '�� 1 �: IIINN�1 � � °"• � ,� � �` �. w: i � �-1� �III�MIII ��I � +� � uN aN�■u a :� M �ia��Mn�dn j. � .i � ;�1l�� ' � � ��".:�� ' " ��(i�� "� �U � ' • �r � � � � . �1 ��N� �� t; �' (� - �" � ';�,=" _ _ _ �I�l�� M "�l�i;:�',T*:,,�111 ' �� 1� � ll�� 1��i�� "�1��!!G7C�`C1--- �� i1^r�r�_ ,1��: � � a�� A •""N��=�� !'� .. __ -.� �..• •,� �.. � ��iNl 1 � N�,1� �i�� u a� .. �r �`" �� u�a _ ► - �,e�■ � � :�. � :� � _ . , l�r. • ' -- f`� p�' w�"� - M. �� .. _ �� .�� • � � � � . � • , • � � � � � : • � • - • �� ' ' ' �� . . � . • • � , � . • . • • � • • • • : � • • � . � - . •: , • � � • • • ' � � � • . � � , . •