277394 WHiTE - CITY CLERK ������
PINK - FINANCE COUfICll
CANARY - DEPARTMENT G I T Y O F S A I N T �A U L
BLUE - MAYOR File N O.
RETURN COPY TO � •
VALUATTON BUREAU ouncil Resolution
Presented By ' �
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
WI�REEIS, The City Council by Council Resolution, Council File
No. 277172, adopted July 21, 1981, did vacate a certain portion
of Stewart Avenue near Homer Avenue at the request of Webb
Company, et al; and
WHERF,AS, The City Council has reconsidered the amount of
compensation as set forth in said resolution;
NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, That Condition #9 in said Council
File No. 277172 be amended by establishing the compensation to
be paid at $15,000.00; and
BE IT F[JI�CHER RE5 OLVID, That all other conditions remain as set
forth in said Council File.
COUNGLME[V Requestgd by Department of:
Yeas Nays
Hunt � Finance and Mana �ment Services
Levine In Favo[
Maddox
McMahon �
snowa�ter - __ Against
Tedesco �'K �� ���i/� �LJ/�_ �rec or
wilson l`6,e�• �liV
SEP g �9�� Form Ap 't Atto
Adopted hy C�uncil: Date _
Certified � -s d by Council Sec ry
a,(,�c, �"c3`'..O/
t
Ap d by ;Nayor. te
� S�p � O 1��' Appr y Mayor for Su is n to Councit
By� _ — BY
u$t�sHE� S E P 19 1981
- , �
. . � . �'�"`13�
_ ;
Un1 U1: 12/1975 t
- . Rev. : 9/8/7'6 �
,� Rev.; ' S/7/80
EXPLANATION OF ADMINISTR�TIVE ORDERS, P.�v. : 4/3Q/8I `
RESOLUTI0�3S A�J� CRDI�l�:ZCES '
+
. ._ ,,.,.. � �
Date: gugust 31, 1g81 , .
. A -
_ _
TO: �,yor George .�+atimer . . .
_ __ , . .
FRO:�: . J. �Im: Donrnran, Va1:"�o A�smt. �ag3.neer, Dept. of Finance & Management Services (Ext� `�Olg)
�� Vacation of Stewart Avenue for The Web'b Compa,n.y �
• � j
ACTION REQUESTED: • �
}
. _ _ G
I+�yor's sigaature on resolution to brin� to City Council. � t;
PURPOSE AND,RATIONALE FOR THIS ACTION:
_ , f
The Web'ti �omapany has requested th.e C3ty Cauncil to recor�sider the co�qpensation con tion '
in the vAcation original.].y e�pproved by City Cc�uncil on July 21, 1981 (see a�tached e�ter). �
_ � .
. }
- 1
; . �
_ ;
+
, f
;
: #
,
. i
FiN�,N�3AL ID�PACT; �
�educt3on oP co�qpensaticm Prc� $23,000.00 to $15,000.00, �
$8,000.00 net loss to GF:nexal Fund. I
�
' � I
ATTACHI�NtS; �
�
_ � �
l. Council �eaolution for signature � , i
2. August 3 letter f'raan John A. Carlaon, The T�'eb'� Coa�ra�r ;
3. Resolution ,�277172 approving the vacation Jul�r 21, i 8g �. (aee Caadit3c�n �9� �
. . )
, �
- . • �
� : ,�
�� ► ���'�'� c�"��-.�
� ,�� � �r �_ � �
, t� ',i''...':...��i'..,� �f `
� l.�iM.l•I�11♦ ; M` , ' '�
V`
l�)���) `�I �. :��c_.a,�:_� f'c�c��:;1. �►.f'c:.,�.�►, M�r�� ��;��OiC� J�)I ll.� .
, r�
l )Ir)�� ��% �. 1i 1 !
i_ )' / !t_i� i � 0
�u�.���st 3, 19II1 _ � r � �� g �
h9r. �'ictor `1'edesco, Chaa.rman f:.�.,;=�°��;�,'i:.��;��M� .
Publ�.c �dor.}cs Co;n[i�5_tl:c�e -
^ .
city of st�. Z�aul �;l_I� `T ►98� .
Couri� I�ot�se .
S t.. P au 1 � T�1?Q. 5 510?. �:t' ,.;`i:-_ �.,.�-- .�_
s'; '�, ,,�t—4';�.�.`
SUI3JFCT: Evaluation of Stuart Avenue vacation
Dear I�ir_ . Tedesco:
We }iave reviet•�ed Mr. Dor�ovan' s evaluation and assessment of �he
,p�i�ition o� Rob�r_t and Laura �kstrand and The WeU.b Company for vaca-
tion of part of Stuart Avenue. We agree ���ith all specific require-
ments ii7clt�ding: rc�stri.ctions within water und sewer case�nents, re-
si:ri.ct�.ons on gradit�R, restrictiozls on surf_acing, r�strictions on
buil.di.iiqs, structures and trees, as well as, paying for sign removal.
FTot��ever, please coi�sider_ this 1e�ter_ as our official request for
youu �Lo revieca your compensation �requirements �or vacation of this
pr_operty. •
The portion o� Stuart nvenue identi�ied in the petition has
been a mai.n access road for The ti�7eUb Company. tVe intend to continue
usi.nq it as a main access road for the Company. The webb Co;npar.y
�ai_ll not receive substantial value by acquiring this road and, zn
�iact, �•7ill be assu�ning the responsibilifi.ies associat�d with owner-
ship.
� Considc�r_inq ihe numerous restrictions placed on the vacation •oi
ihe la»d in question and the limited useful purpose of the Iand, ��:e
believe t.hat the assessed m�rket value of $23, 000 is unreasonable
and docs ilot represent a true fair mar}�et val.ue o� the properi:y.
I �ti�ould ]iope the assessm��i�t v�luc could be reduced to a value
more in liiie �aith t.11e V�l�_L1C'_ obL-aS_iled by `i'lze 64ebb ComPany anc� the
fair valuc o� th� property.
znce�cly yours,
,�.C�p�..�.�'�.,^~-------`
. ,�
,ohn n. Carlson
. ContiolJ_cr, Corp�rate Secy.
J�'�C/sj t '
cc: . . �'l(��8! ,�-�,�
� ...
. , .. .. .... ... . . .,._. ..:.__., ...._..-„.�.:... . _ .. . .. _. .. . . .. .. . ' ' . . .... � t�sY.tsFM`,���n:
�' �
.. .. . . ... ., ..:: _.._. .. .. . >-... .._ry.....
� �:�'��;,;;�� �`������
2:��n
��
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
INTERDEPARTMENTAL MEMORANDUM
August 2$, 1981
Mr. Walter Bawser
A ssistant City Attorney
Room 6�+7
BUILDIl�
Re: Council Resolution for a change in the amaunt of campensation
Council File C.F. 277172 (Stewart Street)
Dear Mr. Bowser:
Please review the attached resolution for char�e in the amount of
compensation to be paid to the City in C. F. 277172.
If this meets with your approva.l, please eaecute and return same to
this office.
Very truly yours,
�
1/V w�,
J. William Dono n
Valuation and A%ssessment Engineer
G
JWD:WPJ:d.m
Attach.
� :=¥�.:,:,
PiNK • FINANCE ` A COUflCI� , �
CANARV • DEi'ARTMeNT G I T 1� O� SAI Pr�T �L1UL �- ��J
BLUE .� MA'YOR �
, �. F;le N 0.
' � � �' �� � � � �t - �Council. Resolution ��_ � � , �����-�
'�� , �
' Presented By �` � � �� � � �'" �
. ,. _ . ,. �. .
.: � 1 ..� ..i.s,.-y...� ,..•�+�,"..}.' _
. aeferred To � Committee: Date �
� � . . . �, .��. .�� .. . .
Out of Committee By Date
�.fsD� �'hit +�0�! t� pit�tiO�lt O� ?i�u'a aa�d �Obrrt ,;.
�c�tra� aad ti�o �[�bD C��'. Ll�rL �ctLoa �! Po3�iLe stsNrt
Mrtia��l�s itscrib�l, b� arad #� sais 6�s� is i+raosbad sa�
dis�ontis�s�d aa a psblie stsat: . -
,�
. ' � ,F a ,}�r r . y ..
�M �� �� � �� ��e'� .���'.n' ... .. . .
cie�diaq �1-d�-�aa �yi�g b�rw #�� _= >_:
sout.�etdY 1i.as o! 3ot 3. !. ?. trstso�'a
Sob nri�risi�t o! Lot 22 0� �vact O�tLot� �'bo
st. la�ti, ss ast��d soarthvast�r� a�so�s -
Stwast 71� a� '�r �tst�ar7,t boms�asr -; , .
o! �a�..r str�.t �ti�ch is`: si� b.tw.s t�. . .. -
soot�st ea�ovc:o! tiot �A lba��t Str�rt Ortt �' :
Lots sad tl� aoatth,�st c�ro�r o Starart �
. i��aue asd eo�r StrMrt ss o�
sabjact �zpr+tssll �o tbi �ollovie�q o�diti.oa�s sa�d rts�rvations:
l. ?le�t t1r �a�tivo b� s�ab�set to all th� t�ats '
aa�d c�o�sdf,ti+oss o! l�ap�ae 130, oodf!#�d ,i6�zeb l..
1981 a! t� 8t,. Pasl Z�is3�tirr� Coa�,�`as _
a�. i�rclndiag th� s�t�tloa Qf all pnbll�c
ntilitia �sar�ts. .. : �--�� . _ .
2. ?hat s .pes�sns�tt eas�eat b� grasttad fio '!�
v�+n�ra o! Lo! I.B� l�oart 8ttsst t�nt :�.ots, �oar `` .
avcass ar�r aaa scross �racated p�st o� St�art �
av�m�s fou �qr�ra a�t�o �z 7►wn�s. Sa id
asao�sat vill 3� t�aisitaiaed by 1�arbb Coa�a�
and th�ir wcet�ioss ancVor as�igns.
.
COUNCILMEN " ' ' ° -,
Yeas Nays Requestgd by Department of: ;
Munt .. . ' '
t.��e ,,, In Favoi;' ,; -. . . •
�ddox
��. ` . . = •.Against _ BY
Tedesco . . ..w '
Wilton
Adopted by Council• Date Form Approved by City Atforney .
; . ,
Certified Passed by Council Secretary
By :: . t,� �. ;
. .�_,.: �-;.�„«., -
Approved by Maya�c fot'Submissioa to-Cauncil
Approved bp 1+layor. Date A,. -
BS' --- _,. By � . . . .
,,�1'11��'1
•° , B�
, � �'�
.- , �
' .� • �7
�
�
2 '
, 3. That a specific easement be retained ta protect
the existing Northern .States Power Company dis- �
tribution line presently located on the south
: side of Stewart Avenue =and also that a specific
easement be retained to protect the Northern • '
States- Power 'Company. :;four-inch high pressure gas
"� ��' main located 11 feet:north of the south line of
Stewart Avenue.
����: � �
�� �' 4. That a specific easement be xetained to protect -
the existing Northwes.texn .Bell Telephone Company
�
aer�.al cable now located within 'the limits of
��'. ' Stewart Avenue�;.sought to be vacated.
� � . � ;
., ;,. � �
_.. �.�
�� " 5. That the petitioners '�will gay the cost of removing
the existing City 'stop"sign, ;and the relocation of
the street °<name sigri." �
�ih - r� � . . . ,; . ,�.. ,. . � ,.: .... .. .
�'k� 1 '�" �..i.aa: . . . . . . �. i , .. : s �..:. . .. . .
s �.� 6. That�..a. tha.rty "'(30) �too,t �w.ide permanent sewer ease- .
���?� j' � ment be reta ined .cen�ered�on 'the existing sewer the
full length of the`vacation area, subject to the
��£" '. n,�•� restrictions in #S.below,
�.-�.. . .
7. That a permanent water -utility easement criust be re-
�" �5 " s feet°� of sa'id •streeross `the North thirty-three (33)
y� � � _
.; ,
ta ined over a nc1 a c
��� -• : � r t��°£or�� continued access to a 12 :in+ch
�� � ��. � �
... .
���Mr : �aater :main �,and:�-�fire�hydrant, °subject to the restric�-
�� � -���� � �,4�.
t ,� ions in #8 .below. `
t �> . _
�.�,_
r
" A 8,. .: That the;;restrictions �within the above sewer and
u S '
� t x� �A�',tp . .. .:t� ' '� ?�d .YC�''., 4�-,4., ., • . ..t ;.: . , . . -.
� � �, : - wafer.;�ea semerits �be a s.�ollows: ,
1'r�"�s� � - � �r�' � �
�s� � iy � � I' �: � : . . .
�`,irv ..� d�y,. � si � �6 i M*¢,W" "�` fYh
b#V�� _ "r i •.'C�,� T�r�� �rt .. .
e� v
� .�,. . ' . � �� � � . . . .... �
ry 1 �F . .. � .. . .
?;� s
� - �' S.. � � � _ � .. , . . .
t �,� � �
. .. y�. _r'+ �' .�.i ...- .n 1--n
� , ., , ; � . . v
; i,M .. '" :i:i . lt,�.'�_�' � '� rr,� „ . �,� ,. . . . . �� . . .
.� . . � . . . . . �
��. . ... . . . .. , . . .
,��e . , . . . ..
,.. .. . . . . . .
�.- . .. . . . . . . . ..
� z
� ���
�� ��., e �+�*a s'4��y,� ;@�f�'�t� . ..? .� i .
� a s�
'� f�' +��s :i e��'"�> �.R � �I��+r. t ��..t��.TSE".4.si'".N�c`a ��� � k
'�' st x v�, v^:'�..
�M� �o� � �� '� t �'�t,��� R c " ����,�c y � � . . � _
� �
�' " �� .:'�� _ t .,�;I �ti � iT' �1'�'d r� . :�p�dr� °e. .. _ . __ _ . .
�. .. . ' .,; y _ . . , _ . . .
: �71'7�
��� . . . ,
. , �
► r
� . �_ �; - :� . .
�
\
rl:
3
a . That no buildings, structures, or trees
are permitted within the easement areas
or any temporary structure, material
storage, fixture or other objects that
will prohibit normal access to proposed '
or existing sewer or water facilities for
maintenance purposes.
b. That no change in grade over any existing
sewer or water main is permitted without •
written permission from the City of St. Paul
Sewer Engineer or the Water �Jtility.
c. That no change in surfacing within the ease-
ment areas ia permitted without written
permission from the City of St. Paul Sewer
Engineer and the water Utility.
d. That the petitioners, their successors and
assigns, by acceptance of the terms and
conditions of this vacation, agrees to fully
indemnify, defend and save harmless the City
of Saint Paul and the Board of Water Commis-
sioners, its officers, agents, emplojrees,
and servants from all suits, actions or claims
, which shall arise from any injuries or damages
.�. _ _ received or sustained by any break in any
�� service pipe, water ma in, or connection in said
- reserved easements, arising out of or resulti.ng
from any action or negZigence of the petitioners,
their employees, agents or business invitees. _
�.
��,� � r��,��� �- 9. That the petitioners pay to the City as market value the
� �-
�� �- " sum of '$23,000.00 as compensation for the vacation.
�.� �. :.;
� �� .
��'�--_ ` � - 10. That the petitioners furnish the Gity with a bond in the
`�t�F�'�� � ", �� amount of $5,000:0�6 and in addition thereto, by accept-
ance of the terms and conditions of this vacation, agrees
to indemnify, defend and save harmless the City of
�� ; � x
r. y � _
iT'�`T +�t���. . .., h..-'� . .
tk � ir ' � `:: � �
��� j� �,¢; �
� �WilIT!-_.,.• CITY CLERK . ,•K.. ,� �, . ..,._.,._ ._ ^ . .
� t1NK. �- �FWANGE l a. � � ` �� � x � �� 1�� ♦ � �7� ."�-CQUflC1�1 '.
GANARY - OErARTMEMT `G I TY �uO F� �SA I 1�T T �L1 U�L �t��� ` '�� �r
SLUR r�`r� �MAYOR _ � .. . . FYl@� �NL�.. � � �:
�. . : � , e� , , }.
��'�`� � � � �Council` ��R esolution ������� � ��� � �
. � 7��� .
Presented By .
a
f: ,, - . .
-. .. .;,,, ... ...
Referred To � �,�. ��.: . ' '.�,'Commi�Eee: - Date -- `
.,: y.:,,,�
. _
�Out of Committee By ' -��,�Dafe . '
. ,
.. .,:.��� ,,
_ ., .. �. �;
... .
, ,. .,
� 8ais+t i►adl, itar ottic� a� ��o�MS�#s�or a11 . _
� �it�� aeti,oes,� ot �lsi�s o�f aa� cfitssct�ac,, ; ' '
ioelodinq, bnt �o�t �lfait�l !�, s a3aia �t ' � -
�c�nw � a�:.:it�ticri�s, or �sg�s r�i�+�d os� ,�..: .
,..
sastsi�d bg.a�' .passo�. pr�os� �ar ��ac+oprrt?+ �e . .
accomat o� �lhis �wea�ti�o�af oor b� �t sa� s�t < ' �.
oz a�iss3,��rt, �t �c �lscando�t�� ariid� ; ., . , .:
p�titia�a�a� oar b�emea� o! aa� r�ati� oar;�.iabilitY � . . �
., �zi�iug� fs+o� oc °'l�ssd � a� �o�t3�a�s � a� ;3a� , ,
, _ es �gnlati�oet srith t1w l�w• �; L� tbr-�t.ir- ; ,..
� � oar a�► +m�' t�it sg�ts vr . � �:_ _
' . il. S6at t!u Citr of ,lxrlo t �anl astboris� saa dfr+�ct t1�s
psoq�sz Citp s�tie,��is tQ r�l�s� br Qnit CLti� ��d :
aa vs�t grantid .lor �ts+est p�cpos�eea. sa1A �rrar- ' : ..
, _
• � . ar�t b�i�q .3L+1ge.I3� �sib� ss �1�ov�: - . :M . :
. ..
. ,. , ,
_ ,.
� . . . � .. �� �. '.. _ t..
�111 lbON pil�s O3'.Lo2.t 19 i Z0, 11DS'! ,,.
8ts�t t�t3�o►ttt ��and -l�ota 1'ir .2 -N�,�::�'. .£ ' � .
s ," .
_ ,.
. .
_
.
.
� t�tsoet'a �vb..,.0�':=+ot 33,� lOZt..9t,s�t . _
O�ttlots 11►i� irithin #� ase of s ciscl�r
bav3ng s .r�dias +�' 30 f�sL, � c�b�c. .�� �''
of said cfsvl.s l,yinrq �a th� �t+�arlia� � - � - �
. Qf Sts+�rt �� an�! tt�e E'2,p� �ast paz�t ;: .' - . _ .
. of t� ��c of �rsis circle bsi�q taagaatt � �
- °� � � !� tbe ��'�1,� �oct��s�n ot �'th� IRS'1� .ii�r;
o! Lot `3, z'. '!.�;�atso�•s S�b. orf I.o�L"22. - ,
,, . . ' . �ast 8trs�t �tla�+s= ,
u ,
4 �+C?. � ' . � '���� , . . ..� .. .. , . '' . . . .
COUNCILMEN 55 ti,;�� � � .Requestgd by.Department�of�
Yeas Nays ��`� ` : ;°` ,`
Y'J
.� . ., . :. ,
,, H� , , . � ', w x t
.
. Y . '�' � ���,+ , ��.
; t�w . In Favor .�
�Msddox '
k�ry fi� �
.,. _. ... . ,
�����:�� � x� � .: A�gainst BY �
._� -�Tl�iCO ��� � - � �. :ro• r � :"� .. , .,� �y a a a ,:
� _1
wlwn . , h.: : � . - s ?� �,> ?
n
. •!�� '� � ���� Form APproved by:City,Attorney `., �``` � �
Adopted by Council; Date „� � `, '*
,. , f -: � ;:
.
, , s -
, , . . , ,. �<
Certi[ied. ed.by Cbunc cret� z � �. � 7 �3� � '_
,�w ��; � , . . � :�
��� _ 3�,"`r�"'%',�rx yr�"�`�rsr�'� "�• F s. "s�' �'�4� .'' � �;�. � "" ��r '
i.By ��'� . } � t � �s �'.. �; x a. ' ^i �'`"�'�. _' ' .�'� '` o ��:{ ,*�..d '�'a"`°'�` �:
a }? �7 � �"���'s, .4I�"`' r a'A�p[OVCd'bjl Mfl}IOL f0[�llblBl$$10[t f0 C.01111C11 �5••a '� 7
' APProved by Mavor: •���ate JUL{��.r� ;�Q�1 , �, ..: ..� �. �
. � � � . . . - . � .. .�.t ��, - � .� X •�.r�`.� �_�
' ' .,.. � F�, . . . .�.» , ..
�;
._ . ,., . p . . .. . . _ ....., �
. . � ,�� �. . �. .,... � :., , -Oy . _ . ... . ...
B�' _
� 4 � _
T / �, �� '� �
' � � �
±� •' ' ' � � I 1. Q r'
r ; ` I
C� � ��p�Ji---•�_ • � I- � I ,- �'�, �}� �
i ' v � ` t,
�
. � � .y, S, c a -- ___ ' a► � \ � � �,� ` 1� � p. '
C ` �
- , � � . r ' � � IC I�� �
� � I
� _ W— _�" ' b ' �, '� f � ' I 1 I ' � �
, � t`�'. _---• � ,� W "'� _� _ _ . _ � ` c� �' -� t,� �
w � . ` 'i ;
�`� _- N w ` - - �� _' '� t '� � I
r �.� ��
` �� � 1 °' •►r.
_ y,� � `� a` �F _` �� ��� J�/;r
� ~'� t�
.y '•6 s,c � �+- �
y � o � �, (� ', f., F .7 /7
� � � � �.,
�, � �
T _ \r �l , N W •\ � � I I
. , \ w��'1 �
J �.ti
�� �
; � o�� N°�a � 1� `� � �
4 q, �
,
�� � �• ��,� �a ��,��\ '�a �+' I � �
\J I:',�` _ N - 1 �� \ 'I�
I� �� S8/ �
TC�" -�.'�--�
1 ° ` � '�
i �---1_ � (�t .,
-�
1 `� � �^ '�, I
� =_ � � �I
,,4 I`, ' � , � C N a I �
i t � � �;1 '_' ^� � '� • �
'�� - _ `� � � �� �� � �
"��+r 7. - � � '" .�� �`., �~ o`\ h
-.�- T , , . A e�
i U �
� � ^ � R� " �, � I � ��' '
- - `' � � ' C � .., �W
� O�.
� � � ,^ � i � � �,t- � � p _
—� � � ^1 '� 1� `� 1
-9' _ . '� ' ' � ^.
� ' ,, ± 1 ',, � �. �.'
� �' �. `"� �. `�' `� '.
;� � ,� "� � �_` w � . (� � �,� �� � ,�� �
� � � <
�� - - - - .� � � � a � C
� h �
' ---�,_ .� •
l� �
1� � . �
i � � � �J
�� � ��� �
r '� "' ��� r � ,�, �.�� � •1-;r
� -
� � ''£. 9 � �^ W � , n � 9►�p �.11
� I� �. 1 •i h ._ � �r t�!
:��, e b :i � e jc � � � [�f � 9 �`
�1- 5 �� `` - f'' '.�'-', 2 ~ �l M1 •• rd ..�
�� -� �� �^ � � . . I � � � r,� � H n H ,�—
:� ; _�.� \ ..,` , V � 9 H �
t \ � � ., � `•' - fD y FI
i ' \ \ � 'I 4 1,` � ��d O
/ A�� __ c� � p c S, �,R G d � �..--�
/��; � � a� . '10�� �
�� ;_-_ ��`., , � ^ � �'� f , ; , � � a ,
` '� , a
� - '° - 1 � W ` � � -z.o '
r � 1 l D ��,^ ' � ��
:, -_}-" • �' � � `
�_ _ - s�"'..S-� _ q'L �` �y'!— p ,
� :i+.�,�� ° _ N � ��.}. '1 G� •1 �n ' ----
�� _� _ N � � � �y?� ` ��° . � b �II. (
•.� -� ` m '� _ �`. ' ;?
„: _ �.J ` _ � � `:. '
� `� ;e' oy
�� ��� p� � � � ;n � � t:_' b o
�.. � �;�i s � } o � fI f Qc '. ��
�% i ,i � '� �-' " _ �S'
�"- " �- ��=�'' "' ` ,-` ��' 4 - ��� ��i �} 1 , `�� .
� � r� � � 1 � f �.�.
1 . . - a. . •`4. .. . . . . . .