The URL can be used to link to this page

277343 WHITE - CiTY CLERK � � PINK - FINANCE CANARY'- DEPARTMENT C SA I N T ��U L COURCII �� BLUE - MAYOR File N 0. cil Resolution Presented By _ _- Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date B�E IT RESOLVID, That the Council of the City of Saint Paul hereby eertifies and approves tY� action of the City of Saint Paul Board of Appeals and Rewiew pe�rta.inirig to the follawing listed property and as sha�m by the Excerpted Minutes of said Board of Appeals and Review, dat:�d August 11, 1981, and marked EXf32BIT A, and atta.che.cl heret�o and made a part hereof by reference: DATE OF BUARD MINLFrES CA5E N0. PROPER'I'Y A,PP;Q�ANT 8/11/81 40-81-H 184 S�mit Ave. Anton Dan.i.luk (nine units) BQARD ACTIO�T: Granted six-month ext��sion of time t�o oc�iplete electrieal work, as orclered in city's letter of 5/14/81, an oondition that existing overfusing of the electrical syst�n be oorrect�ed. inmedait�ely, as a t�a�orary safety measure. Property Description: I�Li�1DT'S REARR�IVGE�TI' NWLY 138 FI' OF FOL SWLY '� OF V� ALLEY IN BLOCK 5� DAY'I'ON Al�ID IRVIl�'S ADD TO ST. PAUL ADJ TAT 3 BLOCK 59 IN SD KAT1�N'S RE AND SD I� 3 BIlJCK 59 8/11/81 43-81-H 99 Wintex St. Reinhold Roenmich (private hcene) BCY�RD ACTIC�T: Granted 90-day time extension of city's order to repair brak�n s�w�er line, to perniit tim� for city tA e�lore ways and means of alleviating finaricial hardship to above appellant ax�d other citizens facing siunilar probl�n and e�ense. Proper�tyDescription: FLEICI-�R'5 SUBDIVISION E 45 FI' OF LdTS 15 AND 16, BLOCK 1 and be it COUNCILMEN Requestgd by Department of: Yeas Nays Hunt Levine In Favor Maddox McMahon Showalter - __ Against BY � Tedesco Wilson Adopted by Council: Date — Form Approved by City Attorne Certified Passed by C�uncil Secretary B � �� Bl' -- Approved by 17avor. Date _ Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council sy _ _ By WNITE - CITY CLERK ��y^�A PINK - FINANCE ' /�J •1 CANARY�- DEPARTMENT G I T Y O F S A I N T ��U L COUIICII f� � By.UE - MAYOR File N . Council Resolution Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date 2. F'URTI�R RFSOLVID, That upon passage of this r�7;ution the City Clerk is hereby authorized and directe.cl t� txan�nit a co� of this resolution for recording tA the Ramsey County Office of the Register of Deeds. COU[VCILMEN Requestgd by Department of: Yeas Nays Hunt Levine In Favor Maddox McMahon snowalter - � __ Against BY — Tedesco Wilson SEP i �� Form,Approved by City At ey Adopted by Councii: Date — Certified P� Ssed by Counc� Sec ary B �- d� �! By . - - A d by Mayor: e SGP � Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council � _ By _ _ gY PUBUS�tED S E P 19 1961 � . . � , . �� i ��3�.3 � � c� � � c� � � � STATE OF MINNESOTA ) County of Ramsey ) ss. CITY OF SAINT PAUL ) Albert B. Olson, I. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . .. . . .City Clerk of the m w City of Saint Paul, Minnesota, do hereby certify that I have x `� 277343 � compared the attached copy of Council File No.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . � as adopted by the City Council. . . , September. l:. . . . . . . . . . . 19.81. . . 0 and approved by the Mayor. . . . . . . . , September. 8:. . . . . . . , , . . 19.81 � . . . . W y with the original thereof on file in my office. I I �II I further certify that said copy is a true and correct copy of said original and the whole thereof. � WITNESS my hand and the seal of the City of Saint Paul, i Minnesota this . . .9th. . . . . . . . day of September,. . . . . . . .A.D. 19�1. . I� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . � City Clerk. �' � �..'_„•' � ,w yR �cw'� �,�, ' •, . �' f'�;�''��, "'�'�� r; 1;, r �� y� ��"� �t s� " �' : �� e�, . : ri �� ,°�t ti � .+�� .,�, � � e�x �F^"#^t _ .,,1�' ��' ,��.�.� . ti ' � ,f aQ ,�,�� , tn ��°.�y �5��.�,� aE,.,a� ,-_��- �_. . :,,=� . � � � aoi3 $ � 0. 0 � — � B y- : RINANCER� , _ COUOCI� ��4 • DEPARTM6NT G I.T Y O F S A I 1�'T PA U L -;,,Mwrow - ,�-- File N 0. � �� f �'o�ncil R esolution �'� � � - � Presented By � � �• _`�, �.,�"'""' ti •. � Referred To Committee: . ' Date Out of Committee By Date s a I�ODVJ�. S�at efi. �owd1 c� ti�s cstt c� salnt Amt ��. �o�L,; ,ad appmvvas tlr aetlm a� !� Citt o� Sa.t� Pis�]. Hoetsxl a� l�ppsaL ad f�1�ar p�a� ta t�t lfal]orl�g lisbd � � as �l�m b� t�e bcecpbed lf3a�t�r c� said Dae�ad c� �PP� � ��i �� 7�9nst 11. 1981� aod sie�Oad��' !l, a�d attaal�d�Leqoe6D aad sdr a part L�c� by � � Q� B�iHD , . � � �t? �' _�. __..r� $/1�/al �t0-8Z-�t I� �odt 11vl. _ l�ain Da�tlxit � _ insae e�ts� , �BL�liifl AL�: t�cao�ea � � ��`!� � � t� �D �,% ' �II C�.1=�t I� G� �i/l�f$1� � ��t'1RS ffi�t� OY�t�t�S�q � � � � � � ��b��►i � i '� ��B�` ' .C�ti2picpaact�► �cr3p�3au 7�t1�m8'8 , ' II�.T L�8 1R Q� 1R'� S�.Y � t1!' v1lC ALiSi 2� Ht� � fl� �'`"` l� �E'81ilm ZO �'. P�. 11D►7 L0�' 3 ffi� � I!� 8D �4I�l�'8 �� !� ba tL� 3 BLOG'� 'S! _ . . �;�. .. �/Y.]/�1 .�:�'' ��fl �91�etl, A�o�d �ic�d+c5 . , , �� ,� � ;. POl�t� 1lCZ'�Ls �aonted 90-� t3ae eoct�edron o� cit�►'s � bo �pet3s� se�eAC . �o pasit ti�a �or dt� bc� ��oece raya and amrr a�a ��t� at�o�o a�p�rllant �end ot�c c��s�os �ed� a3ad2ar p�o�,ea� !'I�'8 �NIS� � . - _ � _ E 45 !T �.ID18 15 At�? 16. I�C'.[ 1 . - , - aod be it COUNC[LMEN - Yeas Nays Requestgd by Department of: '` Hunt . ��e In Favor� - . r�sadox . . McMahon • � - , s.; snowa�ter : Against�' �:BY . , Tsdssco Yllilson . '. ` Adopted by Council: Date . - Form Approved by Cit'y Attome • � Certified Passed by Council Secretary . :� � B ?/_ By - Approved by Mavor. Date � • A.pproved by Mayor for Submission to Councii B}• By - . _ , � `� � ' ••��a � GIT�'GLERK C j TY O F .SL� , �� CA AR�- �O PARTMENT � 1�� i�, COU/1CII ` ��E, ' MAYOR � I ♦� T 1 L1 U L File N�O. � �- ~ � � . Council Resolution � Presented gy _ � - R�ferred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date 2. _ . . ' . � II�80[�V�, 9l�et upoa p�sse�e a� tl�f s z�svo� !!r CitY Csea� is bedi��► aAd dir�c�ed !a �dt a ao�y a� t�is soaoSu�l3aa �oec s�a�diag �t�e �' Ou�.y O�at o� t!� ll�gl.sbec c� Drs�. . . ��, :a � . � . . � LD .. _- C� � , - � � _.:,.�.:- � s, . . . . . . . . ... , �yic�':�..� . . � . . . . . , �� . � . . � .. '�C1:`.... . . . .. COUNCILMEf�i _ Requestgd by Department of: Yeas Nays FM�t �.��e � In Favor � '., � M.adox , - McMahon - ., .. snowa��e► -� Against BY _ T.des�o _ YVilson • � f�` SEP � IgA� . Form Approved by City A� ' ' Adopted by Council: Date ' . - ' • - -g . �/• Certified P•csed by Council Secr tary- . BS� ��r�� . ' . . . .� . .,. - - . Approved by �layor: Date SEP 8 1981 � Approved by Mayor for Sebmission to Council' � By By 3 . • � . `t-� ' ' '` " - � � � � � Do �. � � o fD v � ti s � -�i cn s v' C� � nC � � � � � � � � � �' m n� � Q. '* o � � O � �, o -« .-« p m � -� -., � zz �� ' Q � � ° � �1 t� '�RI o o��c o �-,' � n�i m �T • �"�' � � 3 z �j ,= a � o a v ,�. � cn � � t�1 Q, p � ,� � `� D , � � (� c� .+ �. �� "^ � �' N cp �A � � � � n �• a � �' C.� I'!7 3 � � ? � m f� �. `_ � �i�� :'.� n/ 7 �G � ,I � n Q .��.' v�i r; •+ ,� � 7 � C N 5 d \ l , � � � � C � � 1 � � � _ �, . � � � C. F. � � y _ - � . . , . . _ . , _ - . �. , . - , . , , ., . , . , ` . . . . ., : � . , � , . � � � • Septe�oiie� 9y Y981 . ` ' . � . �'; , _ . � - J - , ,, , , . _ � : . ` . . . _ - � . , �� . � � . , Cout�ty Recordor's.0£�ice • , R�ooa 155 . � Ci��► Ha].� . � , . . < . � ' D+�ar j Sir�t : . � � �. Attac'hed ta�r fil�ag in yo�x oftlas is a asrti�iad �copy of C.F. No. �7734� �rhieh `►as adopCad by the Cit�► Couztcil on Septe�bar 1;]981. . 9e�► trul.y. ,pours;. , � _ , . { : ,<'�+.._..-1. � _. , : ' � �_ �;��--��-' �lbert B. ��llon . j�,/. , Gity Clexk • r _ . � , Attach. , � ' - sch - _ . . `:� � : - - � . �' � , � , . , � . . . .�, � _ • . � y . " � , , ' �� , � , ,., � `� , , . . , • ' ; � , , . � � ', ;� _ . , - " , , _ . . - � , , , . . ' � . , , ' . � ��`!� � - -5- 8/11/81 - Meeting No. 176 43- 81-H 99 Winter Reinhold Roemmich (private home) SUBJECT: Request waiver or extension of time to repair broken sewex in3�e, as ordered by the city, because of financial h�rdship. APPEARANCE : Mr. $ Mrs . Reinhold Roemmich PROCEEDINGS : Earl Conley, supervisor of pest control for the City of St. Paul , spoke on the problem of rat infestation. Until recently, when evidence of rat�s became apparent the city has used poison application in their attempts to control the problem. Now, with a new foggingtech- nique , it is possible to determine if there is a break in a sewer line near infested sites, supplying a continuing source of food to the rat population. While the exact location of the break cannot be pinpointed, the building connected to the broken sewer line can be proven when fog appears from its ventstack, and the city then orders the sewer repaired. The homeowner is responsible for the cost of repair and must hire a contractor for the work. Along with the advance in technique which makes it possible to be certain there are breaks in sewer lines , there has been a large increase in the number found, and many of these homeowners find the repair costs beyond their means . The costs vary, depending on how much digging is necessary to find the breaks , but it could be anywhere from $700 to $3,000. There are no funding programs to ease the financial hardship nor are there any provisions for stretching out payment over a long period of years . �"�- After a discussion among the board members , the consensus was that the � City Council should be notified of the situation and that they be asked to consider ways and means of alleviating the financial hardship it is causing to elderly citizens and othersof limited incomes. Chairman Glassman said there was no question that broken sewer lines must be repaired, but he felt the city should be able to come up with some answers to ease the burden on those who cannot afford such an expense. As a start , he said he would address a letter to members of the City Council explaining the serious problem that has developed and will ask their assistance in finding a solution. BOARD ACTION: Mr. Knutson moved to postpone hearing on this �case and � ot er appeals involving the same problem for a period of 90 days , during which period an effort to find a solution will be made by the board in consultation with the City Council. Mrs. Burg seconded. MOTION CARRIED AND SO ORDERED. THE VOTE: Ayes - 4 Nays - 0 Abstentions- 0 . . 8/11/81 - Meeting No. 176 ' , MINUTES OF THE MEETING . ST. PAUL BOARD OF APPEALS � REVIEW Tuesday, August 11 , 1981 Room 707 City Hall , 15 W. Kellogg B1vd. MEMBERS PRESENT : Ron Glassman, Chairman Harold D. Knutson Lucille $urg Glenn Gausman MENIBERS ABSENT : William Tilton Rudolph Sawyer AGENCIES PRESENT: Dept. of Community Services - Division of Housing Code Enforcement : Jerry Kern Earl Conley OTHERS PRESENT : William D. Huestis Anton Daniluk ___ __ Larry Rantapaa Donald Moe _ Jane McEvoy Ann Copeland Mr. � Mrs . Reinhold Roemmich STAFF: Patricia Moxness Chairman Glassman called the meeting to order at 1 : 32 p.m. Minutes of the meeting of July 14 , 1981 , were approved as distributed to the members. CASE N0. PROPERTY APPELL.ANT 40- 81-H 184 Summit Ave. Anton Daniluk �(nine units) SUBJECT: Request variances of Section 34. 11, to permit occupancy of five dwell g units where bathroom facilities are located outside the walls (one bathroom shared by all five units) ; occupancy of Apt. #1 where kitchen sink is located away from cooking area, and Apt. #3 where bath- � room lacks handsink. Also, rec{uest variance of Section 34. 14, pertaining to light and ventilation, for Apts . #1 and #3 where kitchens have no tiaindows . Request two-year extension of time to complete electrical work , as designated in city' s letter of 5/14/81. Appeal is for reasons of financial hardship. . APPEARAIVCE : Anton Daniluk Sen at or Roge r Moe . ' ( / j 8/11/81 - Meeting�TT"o�� j( � e � MINUTES OF THE MEETING ST. PAUL BOARD OF APPEALS � REVIEW Tuesday, August 11 , 1981 Room 707 City Hall , 15 W. Kellogg Blvd. ME�iBERS PRESENT : Ron Glassman , Chairman Harold D. Knutson Lucille $urg Glenn Gausman I rtEMBERS ABSENT : William Tilton I Rudolph Sawyer AGENCIES PRESENT: Dept. of Community Services - Division of Housing Code Enforcement : Jerry Kern Earl Conley 1 OTHERS PRESENT : William D. Huestis Anton Daniluk j __ _ : _ . _ _____.._ Larry Rantapaa Donald Moe _I� Jane McEvoy Ann Copeland � Mr. � Mrs . Reinhold Roemmich I STaFF: Patricia Moxness �I � Chairman Glassman called the meeting to ordex at 1 : 32 p.in. hiinutes of the meeting of July 14 , 1981, were approved as distributed to the members . � Cr�SE N0. PROPERTY APPELLANT 40- 81-H 184 Summit Ave. Anton Daniluk '(nine units) SUBJECT: Request variances of Section 34. 11, to permit occupancy of five welling units where bathroom facilities are located outside the walls (one bathroom shared by all five units) , occupancy of Apt. #I ��rhere kitchen sink is located away from cooking area, and Ant. #3 where bath- room lacks handsink. Also, request variance of Section 34. 14, pertaining to light and ventilation , for Apts . #1 and #3 where kitchens have no ��indows . Request two-year extension of time to complete electrical work, �as designated in city' s letter of 5/14/81. Appeal is for reasons of financial hardship. . APPEARAIVCE : Anton Daniluk Senator Roger Moe - 2- 8/11/81 - Meeting No. 176 � � � . �'��4 PROCEEDINGS: Senator Moe � stated that Mr. Daniluk emigrated to this country a ter World War II from Ukrainia, bought this property in 1958 and is now retired. His income consists of social security and the pro- ceeds of the less than $900 monthly income from rents . He lives in Apt. 1 and charges very modest rent for the remaining eight units because his tenants have limited incomes . He asked the board to give consideration to these circumstances. Mr. Knutson noted that the 30-amp electrical service was severely inade- quate. He recommended that the overfusing be corrected immediately as a temporary safety measure , and that the service be upgraded to code within six mant}rs . Heestimated the cos�C , roughly, to be around $5 ,000. BOARD ACTION: Mr. Knutson moved that a six-month extension of time be granted to complete the electrical work required, on condition that the present overfusing of the sysfem be corrected immediately as a temporary 'I safety measure. Mrs . Burg seconded. MOTION CARRIED AND SO ORDERED. � THE VOTE : Ayes - 4 Nays - 0 Abstentions - 0 �i, � Mr. Daniluk said there were five bathrooms in the building. Four units '�� had private baths , and four remaining units and a sleeping room shared i one bathroom. He took the responsibility for maintaining the shared � bathroom in clean condition. He lived in Apt. #1 , where violations were �i cited by the city because there was no window in the kitchen and the , sink was located in the dining room instead of the kitchen. Apt. #3 I also had no kitchen window and the bathroom lacked a handsink, there being� � no space. I Jerry Kern explained that the housing code had recently been revised and i had taken effect since the original inspection, at which time the old i code applied. He questioned whether the sink in the dining room was a violation of code, and a handsink no longer needed to be within the room Hthere the toilet facility was located, F�ut could be outside in an adjacentl area. � �i � Chairman Glassman said the sharing of one bathroom by five persons gave I him some concern. He suggested that a variance, if granted, should be i limited to the period of Mr. Daniluk' s ownership or so long as he lived i in the building, whichever period was shorter. If at some future time Mr. Daniluk found it within his means to add one more bathroom, he might � again appeal to the board for a variance effective for the lifetime of the structure. ' Mr. Knutson suggested that Mr. Daniluk install mechanical ventilation in the two kitchens where there were no tivindows to provide natural ventilation. BOARD ACTION: Chairman Glassman moved that a variance ot Section 34. 11 e grante to permit the sharing of one bathroom by tenants of four d��relling units and one sleeping room on condition that no more than one person occupy each unit, limited to the period of Anton Daniluk' s owner- ship or his residency on the premises , whichever period was shorter. Mrs . Burg seconded. MOTION CARRIED AND SO ORDERED. THE VOTE: Ayes - 4 Nays - 0 Abstentions - 0 8/11/81 - Meeting No. 176 , . � -3- �'��3 BOARD ACTION: Mr. Knutson moved to grant a variance of Section 34. 14, � pertaining to light and ventilation, to permit occupancy of Apts . #1 and #3 where kitchens lack natural ventilation, on condition that approved mechanical ventilation be installed. Mrs . Burg seconded. MOTION CARRIED AND SO ORDERED. THE V�TE: Ayes - 4 Nays - 0 Abstentions - 0 BOARD ACTION: Mr. Gausman moved that Mr. Daniluk be required to install a an sinc as near as possible to the bathroom in Apt. #3: Mr. Knutson seconded. MOTION CARRIED AND SO ORDERED. _, , THE VOTE : Ayes - 4 Nays - 0 Abstentions - 0 BOARD ACTION: Mr. Gausman moved that a variance of Section 34. 11 be grante or Apt. #1 , to permit use of a dwelling unit where the sink I used in connection with kitchen facilities is located in the dining area. Mrs . Burg seconded. MOTION CARRIED AND SO ORDERED. I . THE VOTE : Ayes - 4 Nays - 0 Abstentions - 0 - - - - - - - - - -- -- - -- - - - - - -- -- -- -- -- -- -- ---- - - -- -- ------ ---- ---- ---------- -- � I