The URL can be used to link to this page

277860 WHITE - CITY CLERK y/� /��e= PINK - FINANCE G SA I NT 1 �U L �� • �J �� CANARY - DEPARTMENT COUIICII BL'J,E �-MAYOR - Flle N O. ncil Resolution Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date WHEREAS, Perry Giles applied to the Board of Zoning Appeals for a variance from the strict application of the provisions of Section 62. 106 (4) of the 5aint Paul Legislative Code pertaining to the size of accessory structures permitted in an R-4 zoning district so as to permit him to construct a garage on his property located at 1635 York Avenue, Saint Paul, Minnesota; and WHEREAS, following a public hearing with notice to affected property owners the Board of Zoning Appeals by its Resolution No. 9012 adopted October 27, 1981 varied the provisions of Section 62. 106 (4) to allow the construction of a 24 foat by 40 foot garage on property located at 1635 York Avenue in accordance with the application for variance and the site plan which was approved by the Board of Zoning Appeals based upon the Board' s findings that the strict application of the regulations would re- sult in exceptional undue hardship upon the owner of the property by reason of the exceptional size of the lot, the variances could be granted without substantial detriment to the public good and without substantially impairing the intent and purpose of the Ordinance, that the variances can be granted without substantial detriment to the neighbors' supply of light, air, health, safety or property values, and that the variance re- quest was not based primarily upon a desire to increase the value or in- come potential of the parcel of land; and WHEREAS, pursuant to the provisions of 64.205, Frank Huberty, 1655 York Avenue, Saint Paul, Minnesota 55106 duly filed with the City Clerk his appeal of the determination made by the Board of Zoning Appeals and requested that a hearing be held before the City Council for the purpose of considering the actions taken by the said Boa?^d; and WHEREAS, acting pursuant to Sections 64 . 205 through 64. 208 and upon notice to Appellant and other affected property owners, a public hearing was duly conducted by the City Council on December 10, 1981 where all interested parties were given an opportunity to be heard; and � COUIVCILMEN Requestgd by Department of: Yeas Nays Hunt Levine In Favor Maddox McMaho� Showalter - __ AgelRSt BY — Tedesco Wilson Form Approved by it At r y Adopted by Council: Date — � Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY A ` Bp Appr�ved by :Vtayor: Date _ Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council BY - – — BY WHITE - CITY CLERK � �!'~ PINK ' FiNANCE ��.`��- CANARY - DEPARTMENT G I TY OF SA I NT ��U L COUflC1I � BLUE �- MAYOR File N O. Council Resolution Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date WHEREAS, the Council having heard the statements made and having considered the variance application, the report of staff, the minutes and findings of the Board of Zoning Appeals, does hereby RESOLVE that the Council of the City of Saint Paul does hereby affirm the decision of the Board of Zoning Appeals in this matter and doe hereby concur in the findings made and determined by said Board; and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the appeal of Frank Huberty be and hereby is denied; and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the City Clerk shall mail a copy of this resolution to Perry Giles, Frank Huberty, the Zoning Administrator, the Planning Commission and the Board of Zoning Appeals . 2. COUIVCIL1+IElV Requestgd by Department of: Yeas Nays Hunt Levine In FavOr Maddox O �`�1°R __ Against BY Showalter Tedesco Wilson DEC 2 2 �Q�� Form Approved by City Attorney Adopted by Council: Date _ Certified a se by Cou cil Se , tary BY � App ov d hy ;Navor: Date �C 2 8 t981 Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council BY — — By USHED �AN 2 1982 , ._ . . . . , . _ . , _ ' f :_� : '� , � ; � , . �`� '��- ,. , . �� , , , , :�< - , ` , }-, . . .: � , A-. . �: i , 5. .; � . ,� : , . _ - , , , :_ ; ,. . . , � , ( � Dec�ssber 3A,-- 29�1 . ' '� ' 3. � . 1 . , . , 'l �/ . . , e J/ " � � . ,. . ' • � , ,� ;�-�/ �. F�a�ic 8ubarty � . - 15�5 Yorle dve. � � _ - _ �yf , $t. P�sul, I�neso� 55106 _ ; � �,, � ' ' , , � 1)et�r Ifr. Huberty t - , : � ; " On Drcasti�r 22�, I981 tha 8t-. ,PaetZ City-Couacil " ,,� '�ted a'resc��nt�,on ` � " ` .drnyiAg y+cu�s appeal to s de�is�,oa of t$e;Bo�r� ��- �o�i.nS APP+�s,�,loc -. � : �' �prapprty� st 1635 Yprk Ave. �clo�ad for�go�r 'i�o�tion 3.s a cop�► ot - C.�.'No. Z7?860. , �\�,�: V, vary trulp q�rs, 1 . ; ` 0. ' " , � :f N , � :.. � . , , �; j� � I� � � • �_� � � ,�� ;': � , ,,�� , ; . � � � � . � � � Albe� ��. �O�aon � � �� , ' � � ' � � � ` ` , '� � � � �'f � � ; � , City�Clerk�� `;� .=, , r, r 1 ��' ' . ` � ' I�l1Q�:Oi11!! � ��:, '. ' ' �`•,� cas �Pe,rry. QMi].aa, 1635 Yart � . # : � �3ng A�dmi�istra�tor . ��` ; PZs�ing Ca�m�srian . , , �. �,o�rd.=ol� �iag App�l�s • , . . ,• , � ,. � ' . �; # ,, � � � ' r "�'�sch. , ,.: . , ' � � , , � ' r, . . a : ,, . � , - ♦ � � � , _ , - . ' , , , , , , , . . ,� . \ , � : , , I +� _ , f�i � � , . ,' f� F . � , , , , • � , .. � : �> , ,.: - . . - . , � , , _ • . , � . • . 1 6 tP ti . , '' �;:r;� ��;� .� ��°°�^�� CITY OF SAINT PAUL __,,,°��*. o.°�, t -�°` '�`'= OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK ?� nium �; ;� " �� ' „�� BUREAU OF RECORDS �''' � � �''a, ,..• ' r 386 Cjty��l��int_PauID, Minnesota 55102 I ''�tmma...or'`` � K � VE GEORCE LATIMER 612-298-4231 , MAYOR i QF� :! � I�B� 'i December �o, 1981 CITY ATTORNEY ; � � , , � i I Mr. Ed Starr I City Attorney I Room 647, City Hall ' The City Council today, after public hearing,��.ted,,, t�o�de�n�v�he a eal e of Frank Huberty to a decision of the Board of Zoing Appeals regar ing a variance granted to Perry Giles for property at 1635 York Street. . i Will you please prepare the proper resolution implementing this action. i�� / i � I Very truly yours, G�"7�'�^M ' '� ...��"�""�� ; Albert B. Olson City Clerk I Attach. i ABO/sch i i j i � � i I i i � i I I � i �O ! I . . .� �.�.�� i �=��*_�.� ' CITY OF SAI NT PAUL ; _R0 7, � �o � DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT ; r 9�ii'ii1tl d a , °�� DIVISION OF PLANNING ; ,,`t! 1�6• I 25 West Fourth Street,Saint Paul,Minnesota,55102 ; GEORGE LATIMER 612-298-4151 ; MAYOR � December 2, 1981 Mr. Albert Olson Room 386 City Hall St. Paul , Minnesota 55102 RE: Zoning File #9012 - Perry Giles City Council Hearing: December 10, 19II1 , Dear Sir: This letter is written in response to the appeal of Frank Huberty to a � decision of the Board of Zoning Appeals granting a variance of the i provision of the Zoning Ordinance which prohibits an accessory buildinn from exceeding the ground floor area of the main building. On October 13, 1981 , the Board of Zoning Appeals conducted a public hearing. Three letters were received in support from residents of 1611 , 1623 and 1641 York. Three persons spoke in opposition; opposition centered on a race car owned by P�1r. Giles. The Board voted 6 to 0 to approve the variance based on findings that (1 � strict application would result in hardship to the owner given the exceptional size of the property (21 ,OCOsq, ft. ) � (2� the variance would not impair the intent of the Ordinance; (3) the variance ' would not impair the neighbors ' supply of light and air, health, safety, or ; property values; (4) the request for the variance was not based on a desire for economic gain. This appeal is scheduled for December 10, 19�1 . Please notify me by December 9 if any member of the Council wishes to have slides of the site presented at the hearing. Sincerely, Y�� a G�� Donna F. P1cNeally Planner - Zoning DFM/mb attachments I �O ; . _ . . � . ' . � ��1 ��'�� I!� . . � ' f saint aul �' city o p . board of zoning appeals resolut�on zoning file number 9012 date October 27, 1981 � WNEREAS, PERRY GILES has applied for a variance from the strict application of the provisions of Section 62.106(4) of the Saint Paul Legislative Code pertaining 'to the size of accessory structures in an R-4 zoning district; I� and j � WHEREAS, the Saint Paul Board of Zoning Appeals conducted a public hearing II on October 13, 1981 , pursuant to said appeal in accordance with the require- � ments of Section 64.203(a� of the Legislative Code; and , WHEREAS, the Saint Paul Board of Zoning Appeals based upon evidence presented '� at the public hearing, as substantially reflected in the minutes attached I hereto, made the following findings of fact: � i 1 . That the strict application of the regulations would result in exceptional ', undue hardship upon the owner of property located at 1635 York Avenue, ! by reason of the exceptional size of the lot; I 2. That the variances can be granted without substantial detriment to the !,, � public good and without substantially impairing the intent and purpose ' of the Ordinance; ��, 3. That the variances can be granted without substantial detriment to the i, neighbors' supply of light and air, health, safety, or property values; I 4. The variance requests are not based primarily upon a desire to increase ' the value or income potential of the parcel of land. . � �NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, by the Saint Paul Board of Zoning Appeals I that the provisions of Section 62.106(4) be hereby waived to allow the ' construction of a 24'x 40' garage on property described as 1635 York Avenue, '�, in accordance with the application for variance and the site plan attached ' hereto. ' .. �'� , . , m��/ed by Mr. Woods Decisions of the Board of Zoning Appeals are final subject to appe 1 se co n d ed by Mr. Kirk � to the City Council within 30 day in favor 5 by anyone affected by the decisio . � � against o �'� � - � � . , : . . i �; � � . � � 'i , i ' MINUTES OF THE MEETING OF THE BOARO OF ZONING APPEALS IN CITY COUNCIL CNAMBERS, ST, PAUL, MINNESOTA, OCTOBER 13, 1981 PRESENT: Mmes. Morton and Summers; Messrs. Grais, Kirk, Osborn, and Peterson of the Board of Zoning Appeals; Mr. Segal , Assistant City �Attorney; Ms. Lane of the Division of Housing and Building , Code Enforcement; Ms. Beseman, Ms.� McNeally, and Ms. Von Mosch of the Planning Division Staff. ABSENT: Messr. Woods. ' ' � 1 Ttie meeting was chaired by Gladys Morton, Chairman. � PERRY J. GILES (#9012) : Variance request to construct a qarac�e at 1635 York. j ��,` ,;; , 'I The applicant was present•, There was opposition pre�ent at the hearinq. � : J Ms. McNeally showed s1ides of the site and reviewed `the staff report with a i recommendation for approval . Three letters �ere received in support from � . property owners at 1623, 1611 and 1641 York. . I . �� '� Perry Giles, 1635 York, explained that the purpose of the request is to build II a 24'x 40' garage to store his vehicles. , �, Maureen Giles commented that their vehicles have been vandalized and they ; feel they should be covered up. It would also look better if the vehicles I, were parked in a garage. I Fra�k Huberty, 1655 Y�rk, spoke in opposition. He complained about the noise I'! caused from the applicant unloadinq his race car late at niQht. He stated �I that the applicant should have applied for a permit before starting construction. , � Ms. McNeally clarified that the applicant indicated that they contracted with ! a contractor and it was his responsibility to get a building permit which he �, did not do and they were tagged during construction. It was the applicant's � ', understanding that the contractor was going to take care of all permits. !, Mr. Kane, 1635 York, stated that his bigqest objection was the nois e from the applicant's race car. �', Korlyn Gooder, 1653 York, expressed concern with the aesthetic appearance of ' the buildinq. The garage is 2 to 3 stories high and is very huge. �I, Mr. Giles responded that the garaqe will have green siding on it and will be � a nice looking building. Hearing no further testimony, Ms. Morton closed the public hearing portion of �'� the meeting. Ms. Sur►�ners made a motion to approve the variance request based on findinqs ��, 1 through 5 of the staff report. Mr. Osborn seconded the motion. The motion I� passed on a roll call vote of 6 to 0. - Submitted by: - Approved by: ' � , I ' G .� ��,-` .`,��,� ��'�K'''t,A,� - ``-- �/=� �� il • Donna F. McNeally Gladys Morton, Chairman � - i , i i I . . � � . I i , � �� ' i , . . . . � � . � �� - % � . �,� � I�CJ� �,l.C� /�,y.,�,d..Pr�:�`� /!�// �r�� Qt-� ' ', � /G� .� � . -.��:. .•��C�/�.��-��.c"�'-J /.�c- u �✓4- �.�'';�,c� ��l�c-tt��: �fZ-cti-C� �`�-- 21�.�iZi%G� (,� �2'/'niva�c-� r ,�c._ "� � � L<� ,�iC"-h��2lt.t�_ ��' �,7,,�.e1 °.t2t�� I I o�`�` �� ,G,�� - ,�=��-�� i� Q.' � ..�:t�,-Q� �`'" `� i�i�-E./ �Ct� . i � � �� Z �� I'I i� � �� ,�'� ' ,�.� '� � ' �� . ' - � � ' ; �� ;�� ( 4�� j ! I �� i '� � i � � � � , � � �� , � I' � � ; '!I ; . .. ! . �� . - , � � : '� . � . . i . � � . , il • , ' . � , , ��lj�� October 8, 1981 ' Board of Zonin� Appeals � 25 ti7est Fourth Street � I st. Paui, MN 55102 ' � ,� , ZOIdIIdG FILE N0. 9012 _ ��< °` � ` F ZOI:II�TG FII,E I�bIE Giles �� ,. i Hr^�itII1G DATE Tuesd�y, October 13, 1981 at 1:00 p.m.`� � � � . � . �. � �I To 1`ihoa It l�i�y Concern: I' I am crritin this letter in su I � pport of Perry Giles� application for a variance � to conatruct a garage at 1623 York Street. I�jy mother, Dorothy Carlson, viho i resides at 1623 Yorlc Street, and ttyself aE co—ormer of that property, have no � objections to the �arage being built. ltJe feel that the garaoe is set well back I frora the street, th�t good construction techniques are being used, and that mhen the garage is completed, it ti7i11 not be unsi�htly or a distraction to the li neighborhood. ! � As next—door nei?;hbors to Perry Giles, ne r,rould like it to be a part of the , record at the hearing that vre support his application. ' Sincerely, I �/._..` I .��'-_� � „ i �-�-:�,� ��,� ` , Thonas B. Carl�on '� l�23 �b�,K � �'; ', , � I i . ii - I � � i , � . � � . ' • • . Fvr� b (�;�,,T� ' ' PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE . CtTY OF SAINT PAUL BOARD OF ZONINO APPEAL'S • _ _ �_ . r..-. 70 Property Owners Within 350 feet; , , • Representatives of Planning District 2 � APPUCANT PERRY GILES I -- PURPOSE • •Variance to construct 24' x 40' garage. Zoning Ordinance ' � prohibits square footage of garage from exceeding that of �he house; in this case, total garage area = 1440 sq. ft. and ; house = 720 sq. ft. , ' I OF PROPERTY 1635 York Street (North side York bet. Germain & Kennard) ��, I Legal Description: Fairchild's Subdivision of Lots 1 , 2, a�d 3 of Chruickshank's Garden Lots. � TIME OF HEARING Tuesday, October 13, 1981 at 1 :00 P.M. �� PLACE OF HEARING City Council Chambers , 3rd F1oor City Hall , St. Paul ' HOW TO PARTICIPATE 1 . You may attend hearing and testify. �, 2. You may send a letter before the hearing to the Board '� of Zoning Appeals , 25 West Fourth St. , St. Paul , MN. 55h02� , � i ANY QUESTIONS . Call the Zoning office at 298-4154 (Donna McNeally) or th� ; District Council (738-0489) with the following information:�l � �� `�" � Zoning File No. 9p12 . �� ,� -�-�:�- . i . �� Zoning File Name �t� FS ; � • , -/ I --" ��- �```� �'��`�'°"� . . Mai 1 ing Date 10/2/81 I - i�i�� /�l�...E�s�2�./ �. s� �� ,��"p' . 'I � � . , . � .� � �� ',, � � �� - � ��i�L ZONING STAFF REPORT l . APPLICANT: PERRY J. GILES , DATE OF HEARING 10/13/81 2. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . CLASSIFICATION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . CURRENT PLANNING & ZONING COMMITTEE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS � Rezoning ❑ Variance � � Special Condition Use ❑ Administrative Review � Determination of Similar Use ❑ Other Change of Nonconforming Use ❑ Other ❑ 3. LOCATION: 1635 York (.North side York between Germain and �Kennard). � 4. LEGAL DESCRIPTION: Fairchild's Subdivision of Lots 1 , 2, & 3, of Cruickshanks Garden � 5. PRESENT ZONING: R-4 ZONING CODE REFEREN�:;, �ection 62.106(4) ' — , .� � 6. STAFF INVESTIGATION & REPORT: � DATE 10/5/81 ��• BY Donna F. McNeally II ===========-=====================-==--==-===-===================--=-====-====-============== � '� I A. PURPOSE: Constr.uct a 24'x 40' Garage. � . `:. B. PARCEL SIZE: 75' on York x 280' •= 21 ,000 square feet. C. EXISTING LAND USE: Single lot with single family house and detached single stall garage � set ac approximately 30' from York; 24'x 40' garaae under construction and setback approximately 223' from York. �� i D. SURROUNDING LANO USE: Single family (.R-4�. I� E. ORDINANCE CITATION: Section 62.102(4� permits an accessory building to occupy "not i more than 25% of a required rear yard, plus 40� of a non-required rear yard, provided that in no instance shall the accessory building exceed the qround floor area of the main building." � The appiicant's two garages total 1 ,440 sq. ft. exceeding the main building (24'x 3Q' ) b 720 square feet. !, . F. FINDINGS: I; I 1 . The variance is based on the exceptional size of the lot (.21 ,000 sq. ft. ) and the �� relatively small main structure (720 sq. ft.l. I Using the Zoning Code formula for accessory structures (.25� of required rear yard li, plus 40� of non-required rear yard� a garage in excess of 7,000 sq. ft. would result.l In this case the hardship results from the comparatively small size of the principal ' structure. If the main structure were enlarged, then the garage could also be enlarged. . 2. Without variances the owner would incur hardship. Given the size of the house, the owner would be limited to either expanding the existing garage by 8' or demolishin� �, the old garage and constructing a 24'x 30'garage. ' The applicants state that they need off-street parking for two trucks, an antique I, car, and an automobile. There is no alley and on-street parkinq is limited. , � 3. The variance can be granted without substantial detriment to the community or to I the intent of the Ordinance. � Given the size of the parcel , the intent of the Ordinance to limit excessive lot � coverage is maintained. � !, - i 4. The variance can be granted without substantial detriment to the neighbors' supply �''� of light and air, health. safety and property values. , � The garage will be set back a distance of at least 50' from buildings on adjacent i properties. All trees will be maintained. . ,, . �i 5. The variance is not based on a desire for economic gain. ' G, STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Based on findings 1 through 5, staff recommends approval of the I, variance. ' . � � I . . ;,. - � .v ._ . 1. - � � � . .. �� . � : - . . , � � . � � a � � - ZONING BOARD ' . � APPLICATION FOR ZONING ORDINANCE V1�1R�AA�C� C� 5 CITY OF SAINT PAUL A VARIANCE OF ZONING CODE CHAPTER �� ,SECTION �O6 PARAGRAPH � II IS REQUESTED IN CONFORMITY WITH THE POWERS VESTED IN THE BOARD OF ZONING AP— PEALS TO PERMIT THE ro�"'S?RUrtt o►v eF C�'tqCr� ON PROPERTY , DESCRIBED BELOW. A. Applicant; NAME: P� � ��J L`P S { ADDRESS �� YO�K l� S/ . yl,l� I4F7�R r� i � 0�..� . DAYTIME TELEPHONE NO. /7I ��3 ZIP CODE S� 1. Property interest of applicsnt: (o��r,oontract purchaser,etc.) . 2. Name of owner (if diffaront) I 6. Property Oescriptio�: ADDRESS �6�r Y�? S � s�-� ,� rrr�� o�Y 1. Legal description: LOT �1�*3 BLOCK ADD. II z. Lot:�:e: `7S �' o�� 'I — $!w�(.� R � L, I 3. Present Use F�►+�+i1.Y Present Zoning Oitt. , Reasons for Request: I 1. Proposed use I . s,�v G�r c at'Z, CrK1w�(rE To awiwl.l.. . I [� 2 What physical characteristics of the property prevent iu being used for any of the permitted uses � in your zone? (topography,soil conditiona,size and shape of lot,etc.) � x.a I� F� �-'a ��tp��,D � �1°�' �!�� -�' �'� �'�, State the speci ic vanation requested,givinp distances where a pro �at� I � � :--.-,. 02 C� (? g�r�• pF. WKE9�1 C+�c��3rW G ?'NE G Rovw!� , !� -_•- , _ , �- r"i.00►e J��7a oF �►�,arw �u��A�ivG- i - � Expiain how Your esse conforms to each of the followinp: � a. That the ctrict application of the provisions of the Zoning Ordiance would result in peeuliar �I ` or exceptional practical difficulties,or exceptional undue har�bipc. i _-� C��°�' OF TN� 3r^�L StZE dF J��`✓ i-lovSE i '' v,.►pr�� ro c�r3-�iw s�FF��T or-� Sr�2t-sr' PprUtih/� . j � CASHIERS USE ONLY � b. That the grantiny of a variance will • not be a substantial detriment to �` , ; public pood or a substantial impsir- __� _:,., I ment of the intent and purpose of . _. -- -� -= '" �, the Zonin9 Ordinpnce. ': ._ .. . _ c�•`�='• I ;�c�:use �r 1,oaariow l�lwd --�_�~ =':.. _ I >;�zE or G-�=�'�- Lvr, ._=_ .G'.�'�_ ' ��.��.� �� w0 IJ►1��K Ch.I T/-�� _ ;Ir:i' ;�: l �I h� r'r C F3d 2 Nt�o c7. NOTE: THIS WILL NOT BE PROCESSED WITHOUT A COMPLETE SITE PLAN! . I Signature I�� Date Received � � - � I i'I i . I �I ' � . '� .. _ � i ; . � ; f . ^ !, i ' i . i + ` I � � � 57' ; ' ; ; � i � - - , , � + � I� _ u�:� � � II � , :� ;` � . : � �� :c��D � ', � � • C�r��►1L1 C � � t ` i ZS� Z4� , ZG' ' -� , I ' I i � j � I � II � � ( � . � , i : � II� ��Cl , � ; � ' 8� � � � � '� ± Q Ro�os�L a� N�v`j C�►4_�f��_ �_.___._. � � . , : , � � ��1�w�y_ __�-r- _-�{� ��s��►�c� aF ; � ; j � i ; � �� , � M�. ��y �. c� ��S � ; � � � � 1�3� a�k ST��EZ' � 5T• �f3UL �1►Nt� � i O � , � / � : � �c ibx30 � _T�-:._- _ _771 3D�3_ � � � EXlST ► � � AR�� I G , 1 � , �5�11" ,� . � I�! ; -s��- rto -r� .� �s r�r' b �` ; S %2 p� S p� �,�� o� �- % I . 18' ', , ,,, ? � I �; c� , , �` I , y,� , a z� �c3o . . EX isTi�aC- '.��, ` v�— Hoc�'�E� _ LDT `��Z E �S� x Z�� -- � Z , �''�." � I i � 3 pr � ( �at'if1f�%� 0� Sc; FZ' o� r�� t.�,C��?::�� ' I , � I -C�` FILoU►-�D �l..�x� �P��. e`f ��'`{�'t�� '��'ri :.�' 7 --- -- — - - 7S� -____ ----------�J_ �j- G-��L� II S I D � �J P� !,._ !-� �._zs/ � .� ,,p.;w�;4j � Y-'. s'y��'.4t �SQ� �.� : � � , x •1 ' . � � � ~�� 'a� Y i/ � � �s:�.+�-3�.fi't[�:i'Fi�e'.�'7?'fVf.9k'�. . , _;a"rt<'yA!s�#'-�'�;.."5."�S' .'?" Z � � ,+,'�,yrtv:,: , 'i:m` k^'',1:3'S'.i.�!F'2,1 + 4� � � 1 � ri � ' �� . �, . . . ,. „ . . . . . .. 3 A � _ � � <L�:�2 r 9 . . �t��+h�p�1t . � � Y • • � • • � • � • • -;:,; ,,.<.�_ U • � � • .. .}+'.� .--_":;,,:`:::,-� '� 51 i � � • �� ,.._t_r.-+_ ' � � ;'� 4 �� • ♦ � � � � � � � � � � � � �� i � �� u • • O • I • � • • � • � • U A • • • • • • � • �� ♦ � • ��' • • • • • 11 • • • • • � • • � • • �� I • • • • • � • w �� ,�,��,V�. .. .w' "-�,.-..2 :.'Y r' �'.pj�::''� ♦' ,��.y ...� "xi� �,�. i`GD:-to ➢E� '..?';(c .4��4� I � '' � C ��# • � � �4' � I�� e � • � r �+i,1�; • • d • • �� • • • • • �� • ��a..�. � ':��y�� . ,. � k • • � 1 � � U � • • • • • • • • • • • • • • _► �► � � � : : , .�.:��7�5. �s`a�.+tc� }��t'i,'w - ^%i';,�'ki;Wl�' '::7 c•'> �ay-'�°�" � �. ' � ' � i � �� • • • r � u � � � � � � � N � � � �� t, ti �� , �� `'�4 yy.` � 9y''e� 7� � • • • • �i� • • ' � � • • ' • �. . b `� � • � � � • • . • • � • � • .� �I �, j __�� i� � r � <=.,,:.r_;..;.,.�-.��.:t:�.��[�:�,� _,F�:z 'U � .=.1�0l�. -Y�v'ti k • � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � /� r I� � � � � � - • � � � � . - %/%/ = - , . - - • . .� � • • • • . . i • • ' • � - — r � . • • • • . � � - . � • � - o � � � � - � • � • � . - � � � S �`. ��l� L C � TY CCJ �1 (� Cf� �� 7� � 1�� . 1 � HEAR � �VG NOTICE � � i� I � G �► P �'E� L. P a in C uncil ��2 F!L E N 0. x9oi2 Dear Property Owner: PAGE � LOCATION 1635 York (North Side between Germain and Kennard). It is legally described as: Fairchild's Subd. of Lots l, 2 and 3 of ' Cruickshanks Garden Lots subject to sewer easement, the E 75 feet of S� of Part S of Case Avenue of Lot 4. PURPOSE To appeal a decision of the Board of Zoning Appeals affecting the property at 1635 York Street. P E T i T I O N E R Perry Giles, 1635 York H E A R I N G Thursday, December 10, 1981, 10•OO. A.M. Citv Council Chambers, 3rd Floor Citv ,Hall. - Court House Q U E S T!0 N S Zoning 298-4154 Contact the Zoning Section of the Planning and Economic Development Department, Room 1101, Cit_y Hall Annex, 25 W. 4th Street, St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Notice sent November 20, 1981, by the Valuation and Asaessment Division Department of Finance and Management Services Room 218 City HaZl - Court House St. Paul, Minneaota 55102 � , � . . . � . .. . . : . . . . � . � . _ . , . 4' . . ... . . . � ` . .. �. ., � . , � e � . . . � . .M� . ... . . . . � . . . . .. . . .. , . . ,y .. . , - . . ..� . . . . �. ' - .. � ..� . . , � . . . . . . ., . :�,. .� ::. � � � . ' . . . . . ' • � . � � ,. . ' .. ,. �\. � � . � � � � � - . - . . . _ �.. . . .. � . . . . � . . ' �. . ►. '`�.;zR '• . . . . �. c .. _ ,� . . . � . .. . . � , - .. . . , . � , � '{ ' � . . � . . . . , . . . '. - . �. : � _ �' �: ."(, .. � .. . . . .. . ' � � . _ . . . . �.� . . _ � . -!� . . . ' . . .. � . � .. . .�'� . . � � . . . . �. . . . � . �.� '- . � . . . . . . . � � : . � � . � � . , . . . . . . . . . � .. _. . � �. , � . . . . � . - � � � . .. , �.•�'� � I. , . �. , � \ - l ' . � � • ' _ . , i \ _ _ A01FlI�JOAb!�3' 3� �7'�+ � . , �. . i , i , ,s �'• PaU�. `pf�tQ�Y ' - . D�p#►rt�ent o! T1e�sDa! .. i , _ Roo� 218, City Atlt � D�ar $irt / ' �_ , _ Tb� Cit�jr C�uttQil set a datv o! h�ariag.`�'or I�saaibsr I4, 1981. � to oansi+d�rr ��1 �pptsl ot Fraa� �uberty. to a dra3�iion ot th� . , �tieation Dr'op�ztr st•1635 7ork St. Boird of �g Appssls.st , , (Zooiag Fil� �9t312 � Mill.yau pUas+e �e� po'tia�s to prop�rty � o�ratrs u r�quind by 1�alY _ . � - . .; a - v�Y"�3.1r Y��'s, s _ � � Al�rt B. 41t�oi�� , , . G#�ty CUrk � � ' , �` : � _ ,� A�O:'].� � � . : . � cc s Plsne►iqg,8tatt, Y�sing Stettion • � iiow3og b Bldg. t�c�. int�ea�nt Division { , . . �. � . , `'� , . _ . _ • � , . � . � ' , � � : � . t • . . � t � �r! �� , - . � "' PUBLIC HEARINQ NOTICE �� "7 CITY OF SAINT PAUL � � � BOARD OF ZONINO APPEALS � � ;- ; - .�_T� -�=: ___--- - -, --- '� �_,�,a,ti.-�- �-1�-�-�- — _ �___ �'1 .�.,_ ' 1 t�S 5��c`'��' -' -- -- —� --yYL,vtin.�-��. �. �. <�, �� . �,...;�:�, �� 1,�L1�, ��..,�.�..� C�� .�-'� , ,, � i ,�. � , Q �-�J � $I � P nance �-�` � � � p � 'J��' �at of th � ,,� , `� � I�� I -- and �T � �-"'� �� -=:� � � �'�/.� � " �• . f ", � �-�.. 1�0-�-,,-'"'�c'`-�'��'�"�� -r�-- �.h�_ t'- � �,l,,.�,,e�..c�-�- � ( �.�o,,,�.� � �,,,� � ;1.�_ i na rd) �j c�`�-r� �cY�u'� ��''`,�m.-�.�C�p I� `�. v l� cr1�_ V G ��y.�: � � . —��.,,�,��- �y„ 1 , 2, a n ,�,..,t.�.�� -�-��-�- �' � � �� _ � � � �� - �� TII �J ,.,o� �- � , _�- �''�''� - �.� � �:,�... �,,,�,�� x 1.,�... . PL� �''��I1'��-�-`� —e��-`' . -�'"'c� �-c�'�`��!�-'� � �'�� i--�� J,,,��, . � 1 HO� -�`'��`" `�.'��-�.,t�,�.� �''�`" �� ..�-��-�.�.�.. ' �-,,'Y'-'c��"�.. � 4. �� `.�--b- �'�'.� �� '�r�- Board _ J r, --�-'.'�-~ �.� ' NW. 551 2• ..�`n'� , ...l��`�—_ — ,�•�,_9-�.� e �� i � � � .— ---�� ,��.,�- ANY � �,� y) or the ; �� ,��_� �� i��,�� 'rmati on: : �,�-� .�-- . ��— �. "e�'a`�U�- , ; �� . ; ..��I��. o--� ,�'�.'�".'"2�..� �'�- � , � �� ,�,q,� 2 81 . �. �..�-C��- -�a-- U �ti : �� ,� � �- .,c�� °�. � - - — , � . . . ' �yf��Bl.l �"'�'y'' � CITY OF SAINT PAI�I e' � a�: o r ��'� � DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMEf�T -- �� iiii�i il ii Q E .�� -�,,� ,... DIVISION OF PLANNI G iEj'°�� 25 West Fourth Street,Saint Paul,Minnesota,55 02 GEORGE LATIMER 612-298-� 51 MAYOR i October 16, 1981 ' Mr. Frank Huberty � 1655 York Avenue ' St. Paul , Minnesota 55106 I � Dear Mr. Huberty: , Councilman McMahon asked that I write to explain the process for appealing � the decision of the Board of Zoning Appeals relative to the Perry Giles variance. On October 27, 1981 , the Board will adopt a resolution approving the garage ' variance for Perry Giles. You, or any affected party, will then have 30 days to appeal the decision to City Council . This is done by writing a letter outlining the basis for your appeal and filing it together with a $50.00 fee with the City Clerk, Room 386 of the City Hall/Courthouse. The Council will schedule a public hearing and notify all property owners � within 350' of the Giles property. I will send you a copy of the Board of Zoning Appeals resolution after it �� is adopted on October 27th. If I may be of any further help, please call me at 292-6225. Sincerely, , onna McNeally City Planner ; DM/cc cc: Councilman McMahon �I I i i i � i �O . - . . � .,r�! 0 (:;�V • J _ _ lU �_�GH ao�� w �4�o R C� ��i _ �'�G�� o .�,t-lc ��IR►RC7� � ��r ti �� yor�K . . __ _ __ N q�_� ��;.... _� ---- _ _ �'wow� ,�.�_ ��:. n , .... . � . . ��`�' � �?�/�� 2�� L!,L� � L��a L �-,� �� / '�•�y�� l'�� - �� -� � �7� r1�--/ , n ` - :,�_,�i�:� _ �,.-r�r - / " . . _ ; � - - - � �� _ . , ��_ � �� . � � �� ,�,< < � � - 1�� _ _ __ _ _ _ _ y�- � i /dos— � ��-- �J/ — � d�� , ,� r � r E ,� a � , , ` � ,: ! �1 � � � "* � ` _....... � ✓ , -� � , . ..fi / `� � , _ �...` . .. , _... , - � -- -- : _.. r . _. _. _ __. __.. . _.._. _. ___ __.. __ ___. —----- --_. t � � � �� . �� rs C� . ��c� -� o a � _ . � . , �f��,�,. , '�`��5�- C� �5�.�. �_ s �-� �.��. _ -� � � _ ��, �.� . 'Y�'L'� �-�� .,e.�� cfi-�. �-<- - 7 ��- G, �� -_ __ : . . � -i r . � � . " .r " [�l .. .... ... . . . . . . . ��a � �.. TO WHOM TT l�fAY CONCERN: WE TBB UNDERSIGNSD ASi+� AGAI�ST �1'HS TOLB BARN TO B� U3ED:A8 A GAAAGE AT 1635 YORK AYBNtJB, � 9T. PAUL. W$ QUB3TION TI� U3� OF S�AID BUTLDING AND P'S$L IT L�3 T� P�iOPSRR7 VALUES IN T8E 3URROUNDING AREA, ' , NA1�E ,ADDR�gg . ,.: � `�`` `�o-°'c�'`'� i(� S-r.��! .. . a`L`+�`''" 53 tr�- �c�. ,. �1 � �+► ,. � �� r� �b�3 c��2a¢. �, S� �w►�, 5SL0 . � - ,��. � .,, i 6-4 S' Yo�� R�,E- �i� �,9 u�4 �`�'� �Gy�y�� s� �� n �� t >� �L y�� . ��...� ss� � s �� . � �3�� /6 �6 ��°�'� �c° , Sft�� s . ,�� ; �,.�x �Y�� _ � . � , � � �� , P F �/��'� `'�i�i / � .�/ , �(� ��' 1� /!i-C� i//".��,!'. �`` t ' � ; � � � � 1 � �a -� ��...� � ,�� "• .a �� r �.; � - �:, .��!� l 6 �� r,�, �.`F�`-. . ��>, ,�. � - _ � ,� a � f � � ,,', � ; k ` � � /�a� � �r=t--�'.,�"~��} �� .� . � � s , ; -�: .�� 15'9� �ar�c. o.� 5�'!Q6 � f_-4 ` " :` ��rw. � a�� J 5 9� or 0.J� '� �' � 5"S'1C?f� '`; � � ��„_ /� � . :�� U+ � �� ,` - �,�fl�vs_ �.�.,c.. /!c o � l.�r�- �-s'„/a-�` _ y�� /�o �/7G! � 'c��'� S c�'"'�'�f . 1'� `�� /� ��'�� "" +.'S� / � � ;i � ��s.S �J .►�" , _ � /,�,d s-sy� , f��s'" - . � ,� �j_�.,�,ti,.,�.f`� �,�c� s'��,+�►. ,� f f (� �� , �:� � , ��-1 w ��'�`.�` ��. y:s �r�� . �1 �3 � �� / � �,v-�C ,5".�"�� , �� . � , �. �� .f� ; �� ' �� S�'-�'�'� � .�'s'i� � f n , �� /� �'� -�.�.'��w� ��- �s i�� ; � 4 � �� / �rt•�f �-�... �w`'�- �S"f�� . S�� ,.� � .� �/ '�''�" � I ,.�',ua� . �-,/�� /�� ,�,�k �v� 5��a��6 , _ � y ; . � y '.J I�� l.J�� 1F-'x. - - _ � �_ TO W80M �T MAY CONC�: W� TH$ UNDB83IGNED ABE AGAIN3T , , TAB POLB HARN T0 ffi USED AS A GA1�AG8 AT 1635 YOFiK AVSNUE, ST. PAUL. WE QUE3TTON T�iS US8 OF 3AID BUILDING AND FEEL� IT LOWE�R3 T$S PROPERTY VALUES IN THE 3IJI;ROUNDING A�A. ' NAME ADDxP:39 -� � .� pa 3 ��vsY:v� -. s��-�� oa �� -i��6 � �o �� " �'�',js ,� _ � . . � � _ � :�