The URL can be used to link to this page

277092 WHITE - CITY CLERK ��p��/ PINK ' - FINANCE .!. t�� CANARY - DEPARTMENT G I TY O F ,SA I NT ��U L COUflC1I ��,. 'BLUE - MAYOR � File N 0. . Resolution Presented By Referred To C , ommittee� Date Out of Committee By Date � BE IT RESOLVED, That the Council of the City of Saint Paul hereby� certifies and approves the action of the City of Saint Paul Board of � Appeals and Review pertaining to the following listed property and as j shown by the Excerpted Minutes of said Board of Appeals and Review, � dated June 9, 1981, and marked EXHIBIT A, and attached hereto and madei a part hereof by reference: DATE OF BOARD � MINUTES CASE NO. PROPERTY APPELLANT 6/9/81 31-31-B 266 E. 7th St. Benjamin C. Rose (commercial) & Marion R. Rose BOARD ACTION: Granted variance of St. Paul Legislative Code provisior� which requires counter-balance section extending to grc}und level on fire escape used as second means of egre5s, or� condition that third and fourth floors of subject comme�cial building be used only for storage purposes. � Property Description: Whitney & Smith' s Addition ' W. 1/3 of lots 1 and 2, Block 6 j � ------------------------------ 6/9/81 33-81-H 1956 Feronia Ave. Thomas Crawford (19 units) ' BOARD AGTION: Granted variance of St. Paul Legislativ� Code, Seetion� 54. 11, to permit occupancy of three second floor dwelling uni�s where tenants share use of one bathroom facility, provided n� more than a total of four persons occupy said units, and to� permit occupancy of one third floor dwelling unit where bathr�om facility is located outside walls of unit; said varian�e granted on condition that all remaining work orders li�ted in � � COUNCILMEN I Yeas Nays Requestgd by Department of: I Hunt Levine In Favor Maddox , McMahon B snowaiter __ Against Y — Tedesco Wilson Form Approved by City Attorney ! Adopted by Council: Date — � Certified Yassed by C�uncil Secretary B 6� �� By — Approved by May,or for Submission to Council I Apprc�ved by ;Nayor: Date — . I By _ _ _ gy _ i � • � - � � ' _ � � � ,� �� q�-- � � w � � � � c� . STATE OF MINNESOTA ) County of Ramsey ) ss. CITY OF SAINT PAUL ) Albert B. Olson I. . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ... . . . . . . . . . . . .City Clerk of tl�e �'' City of Saint Paul, Minnesota, do hereby certify that I have �. �_ � 277092 ,,,s compared the attached copy of Council File No. . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . .�»- �' as adopted by the City Conncil. . . . . ,. July 7.. . . . . . . . . . . . .19.81.. . �' and approved by the Mayor. . . . . . . . . .. . July 9.. . . . . . . . . . . . .19.81 �--- . .. . -� with the original thereof on file in my office. I further certify that said copy is a true and correct copy of said original and the whole thereof. WITNESS my hand and the seal of the City of Saint Paul, I Minnesota this . . . . .9th, , . . . , day of . , July,. . . . , . . . . . .A.D. 19g1. . _ Or d� •; . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ... . . . �. . . - City Clerk. ^�' P. x,: �,> � 5329 � (� O. 00� - A i WMITE - CITY CLERK 8�r��n� i PINi( - FINANCE � � � i) COUt1C1� /r U CANARY i� DE�ARTMENT (� I 1-�' ��' �p I 1� T 1 �U L �� 8�� . . 'MwvoR , File N0. ; , , �ouncil Resolution , � ; � r \ Presented By —• '� � �' � Referred To Committee: Date � Out of Committee By Date � Bg IY �tRSOLVSD, �hat th� Caoocil of tbs Cf tsr of 8aiat taol �rtbr ' � oertifi�s and approvss tl�e actio� ot t� City ot SaiBt pau]. �rd of 7lppeals a4d Revier pertaininq to t�e l3ollwi�g Iisted pro�rtt a� as � ahvra ysr tha $�overptad l�innt�s o� aaid 8oard of lippeals and Renrier, �' date8 Jm� 9, 1981, and �arlo�d EZSIBIT 1►, and attachad b�t� sna �ad� � r(, a p�art bes-+sot b1► referenoa: DaSS OP BQARD KffiD?S6 CSSB �t0. ffi? 71�'P�Lt.�ltili' �` �/'9j81 31-31-a 266 a. Tth st. seajaaia c. � ��ia].� i l�tario� S. Roso i sO�i�tD seTZO�i: Grantad varian�o� of 8t. 1►anl Leqislativ+e C+oBa provisioo' �rhich reqnis�es ooQntaz--balaavt s�ctio� ezleadinq to qrc��nd lev�e]. an lis�s eseap� n� ss seco�td a�a�s of agxws, o�n ownr�i2io� that third and fo�iloors of sab3ec! oo�ser�£al buildfnq be us�d oalT fo= stozac�e pospoaas. Propert�► Descripti�t: �hita�y i S�ith•e �dditieo� 1t. 1/3 of iota 1 snd 2, Blov� i 6/9/81 33-61-H 1lSi Fercnia 1►�rt. 2ho�as Crarford tl! mits� BO�R1D ACli�: Granted variaac+� a! St. Paol Y.eqislative Coc�e, sectic�a �5�.11, to permit occvpaat� o!� ti�ras second floor dxeilfaq naitls wheze teaants shar� vaa of o�� bathro� fa�ciiity, ps�anri�ed na sos+� thaa a total of famc ptrso�s occup�r said vnit�, snd Eo p�zmit occupaa�c� ot o�s tbird floor dwelliag aait vhes+� bathrao'e facilit? is 3;ocatsd ontsid�s valis of vnitt said var� qranted o� coaditiva tbat all remainiaq wa►rk oraera 1 tad 3.n : COUNCILMEN Yeas Nays Requestgd by Department of: Hunt I . ��oe in Favor ; nneddox McMahon B I " sr,o�ite� Against y Tedesco ; , �Ison � Form Approved by City Attorney Adopted by Council: Date Certif�ed Vassed by Council Secretary B 6� B}� Approved by 1lavor: Date Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council Bt� -- - By � WHITE '- CITY CLERK � � � ��On� I PINK - FINANCE � *` COUflCl� J BI`VE RV� ,MAYOR MENT . ' C; 1 TY.-. O F �A I ��T ■,��? L File N O. - � ' ' Counci� R eselution Presented By " , Referred To — Comrttittee: Date Out of Committee By' Date v) �� S �� 6/9/81 3S-sl-s BS� S�dmmzmd Rlsie �b�nal�, by � �tva,�ant �o�t�� it. ?imottt� lYl�alsbar� �1lt'Y e0A8D AC'tZC�t s tisaated �rai�r of paymeat ot R:caat Ssildi�g Beqistratia� fe+e for tbz�se ��sa�rtt� psriod, a�ter �hic�h period l�ss shel� bogin to aocaonlate and b� as�eaaed agsiast P�?. �'� �: b�o� papebl� opo� �a�e o� saia prapartt. ProQertp Descriptio�ta Vam ooze� Additian f�ot 3, al+oa�c 3 atid be it � �l�R �vSD, T�at upoa pasaaqe of this resolntia� tbe City C1erl� i� herrbq aathorf z�ed aad diracted to traaamit a eaop� of this resolln- tiaas to th� 8ams�p Co�atT Otfie� ot th� lt�eqisbsr o� De�ads. COUNCILMEN Yeas Nays Requestgd by Department of: Hunt �ev�ne In Favor Maddox , I �� r Against BY - Showalter ;' Tedeu:o w'�" 7 1981 �U� Form Approved by City Attorney Adopted by Council: Date Certified as_ed by Counc' Secretary BY ��, I � � By Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council ' � Approved by Vlavor. Date z—�. ' By _ BY :J . � W � o ' � � Y + � lD .�. A � y ? � A —�i • . -_'�� O � �- _.. y -1 O ]'�1 Q '�' ...� • y $ c m � � �� N � `° �. a �, �. p � '�•O 1 � —. ..�. 'r1 � � C� � y c� Q � W � � "`� � � n � o `� c � Z �: 1A l� -C � o -, .+ a m � � � o -. _ o, a �,T �r � v' C► ao � � = a � .. �to N � � °. .. � a �' � t� ia -' �' . � o � t3 f ia f� � � �' « � � . � . mO N _ � _ �� r`� Z c1 " i+, vi . , N � � � � � � .-�i . � � � 3 �' C � �......i \� .�, Q �" 0 Q�I�� t� WHITE � - CITY CLERK � ��921 PINK. - FINANCE T7 C�ANARY - DEPARTMENT G I TY OF SA I NT �� v L COURCII �� BLUE - MAYOR File N Council Resolution ! Presented By Referred To Committee: Date - � Out of Committee By Date -2- ------------------------------ 6/9/81 35-81-B 88� Edmund Elsie Townsley, by ' (vacant house) W. Timothy Malchow, �tt'y BOARD ACTION: Granted waiver of payment of Vacant Building R�gistr�ti n fee for three mpnth period, after which period fees sha�l begin to accumulate and be assessed against property, t� become payable upon sale of said property. Property Description: Van Doren Addition , Lot 3, Block 2 ' ------------------------------- I! and be it I FURTHER RESOLVED, That upon passage of this resolution the City � Clerk is hereby authorized and directed to transmit a copy of this resblu- tion to the Ramsey County Office of the Register of Deeds. ' I COUIVCILMEN Requestgd by Department of: Yeas Nays Hunt ' levine [n Favor Maddox � MeliAel�n Showalter -�-- Against BY Tedesco Wilson ,l�� 7 ��, Form Approved by City Attorney Adopted by Council: Date — Certified • s_ d by Counc� Secretary BY �� _� l� 9 �� Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council I Appro y 17ayor. Date : By _ gy Pug�� D JUL 18 1981 ' � ` � � . 7 a 9� _ , _ � � � � _ . � ` � . - � . ; ; , " - • . ' � - i '. , . i: ' , - , I . :.�, � , � � Jaly 9th, 198i _ ; - , ; .. , ; ; . � _ � � - County �wder _ � '� Rcior 155 , - ' Hui].diu� . - - _ , � , _ . � . Xiasr Sir: . _ , - - - . . � . . , � . � � , � . �la�aad for ,fi]�isg in your o f�ce is a csr�iti�d copy of C.F. No, 27Z092. ,Thia rssolutioa �vas opted bR ehe St. 'Pau2�CityY S��u ' . _ on �uly 7. T981. , . , , � - Very, tsuly youse� . � , � - . . _ , l r' ' � ir x.r.! - '. , , _ . ,-.. ` _: _ _ _ . _.. _ . Albert B. 01son��. ` � Citq Clerk � AtCscb. - � : . � • , sab - . , � - , , � i" . , - � . __ ; _ . . _.. . . 4 . - .. . � . . . � - . . . � . . � . . \ . .. � . � . - . � � . . . � � . . - � . . . . . � � � � . . i � � . . � . .. . . . . . . . . . , . ' . . � � . . � . . . . � . � . . � � .. � � � � ..� � - . . �. � � � . � . . . � _.. � . ' . . � . . . . � . _ , � � � , 1 - . .. . � � . � . . . . . . . . � . . . `. .. � , . � . .� � _ . . . , _ i . . _ _ . . . . � . . � � � � . . . . ' . � : . .' .�...� \ �� . I� /�/ d 6/9/81 - Meeting No. 174 EX T � r ��'��9 � � MINUTES OF THE MEETING � ST. PAUL BOARD OF. APPEALS � REVIEW ; Tuesday, June 9 , 1981 Room 707 City Hall , 15 W. Kel.logg Blvd. , , � MEMBERS PRESENT: Ron Glassman, Chairman Harald D. Knutson , � Glenn Gausman Rudolph Sawyer Lucille Burg William L. Tilton � ABSENT: A. Wali Naibi ' AGENC�ES PRESENT: Dept. of Community Services - Division of Housing , Code Enforcement : I, Alice Bijjani !, Je r ry Ke rn Tom Strohkirch ; OTHERS PRESENT: Marion Rose Barbara Crawford Thomas Crawford � _ _.__ _ -- Paul F. Goetz - Elizabeth Adamski ` STAFF PRESENT: Patricia Moxness ; � The meeting was called to order at 1 : 30 p.m. ' Minutes af the meeting of May 12 , 1981 , were approved as distributed td the board members . CASE N0. PROPERTY APPELLANT ' 31- 81-B 266 E. 7th St. Benj amin C. Rose � (commercial) Marion R. Rose SUBJECT: Request variance of St . Paul Legislative Code rec{uirement a� counter- alance section extending to ground on fire escape for second , means of egress. � APPEARANCE: Marion R. Rose PROCEEDINGS : Jerry Kern explained that the building has four stories , ithe irst two o� which are occupied by the Rose' s candy company , and the hird and fourth floors are used for dead storage . The first and second fl ors have three exitways , and the third and fourth have two exitways , one , n enclosed stairway to the outside , and the other, a fire escape which d es not extend all the way to the ground. The code requires two exitways o ground level. As long as the third and fourth floors are use d only fo ; � � _ _ . _ _ __.,.�. .._._,,,_..._.-- I , � -2- 6/9/81 - Meeting No. 1�4 storage, Mr. Kern said the city does not have any strong feelings about this de�iciency. Ms . Rose said that no one worked on the two upper floors , and it was neces- sary to go up there no more than once or twice a month to get materials stored there . � BOARD ACTION : Mr. Gausman moved that a variance of the code be granted to permit occupancy of the four-story building where the second means of egress from the third and fourth floors _does not extend to ground level , so long as these two floors are used only for storage. Mr. Knutson � seconded. • MOTION CARRIBD AND SO ORDERED. � THE VOTE: Ayes - 5 Nays - 0 Abstentions - 0 (Mr. Sawyer had not yet arrived at the meeting. ) -- - - -- --- - -- -- -- -- -- -- -- ---- -- ---- -- ---------- ------ -- -- -- -- ---- -- -------- j � , ' -2- 6/9/81 - Meeting No. 1714 _ . _� . _ . ._ __ . . . . - .. . _ .. �._ ._._ ..,.._.. , _ . .. __ . , � ._ _._. ,...a�. , �.-_ ��r�1092 � --_____. � Mr. Sawyer joined the meeting during the discussion of the following case. --------- ---- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- ---------- ---- -------- -- -- ---- ---- -- -- ---�-- 33- 81-H 1956 Feronia Ave. Thomas Crawford � � (19 units) SUBJECT: Request extension of time or variance of Section 54. 11, to pe�mit occupancy of three units on second floor sharing one b at}�room facility �nd one -third floor unit where the bathroom facility is loca�ed outside of the unit , because of financial hardship. APPEARANCE: Thomas Crawford PROCEEDINGS: Mr. Crawford said there were several items he was required to complete b efore the city would "renew the Certificate of Occupancy, and he was complying with all work orders except those listed in his appeal. He said the apartments in question were small , never occupied by more than one person. Chairman Glassman called attention to a letter he had re�ceived from Mer�iam Park Community Council , wherein the council recommended that a variance be granted to allow no more than four persons in three second floor units !to share one bathroom facility, and there was no objection to the third flpor apartment where the bathroom was located outside its walls . Alice Bijjani reported that the inspector had �ound the building to be well- maintained. BOARD ACTION: Mr. Tilton moved that a variance of Section 54. 11 be : grante to permit occupancy of three second floor units where one bathroom facility is shared by no more than four persons , and to permit occupancy o� one third floor unit where the bathroom facility is located outside� its walls , on condi�ion� that. al'l remaining work orders li,sted� in city'si letter of 4/20/81 be completed. Ms . Burg seconded. MOTION CARRIED. � THE VOTE: Ayes - 6 Nays - 0 Abstentions - 0 { 6/9J81 - Meeting No. 174 t1 i ' �. MINUTES OF THE MEETING ST. PAUL BOARD OF APPEALS � REViEW Tuesday, June 9 , 1981 Room 707 City Hall, 15 tiY. Kellogg Blvd. MEMBERS PRESENT: Ron Glassman, Chairman Harold D. Knutson � Glenn Gausman Rudolph Sawyer Lucille Burg William L. Tilton ABSENT: A. Wali Naibi AGENCIES PRESENT: Dept. of Community Services - Division of Housing Code Enforcement : Alice Bijjani Je rry Ke rn . Tom Strohkirch OTHERS PRESENT: Marion Rose Barbara Crawford Thomas Crawford .. .�. _ __ Paul F. Goetz - - Elizabeth Adamski STAFF PRESENT: Patricia Moxness The meeting was called to order at 1: 30 p.m. Minutes of the meeting of May 12 , 1981 , were approved as distributed to the board members . CASE N0. PROPERTY APPELLANT 31- 81-B 266 E. 7th St. Benjamin C. Rose $ (commercial) Marion R. Rose SUBJECT: Rec{uest variance of St . Paul Legislative Code rec{uirement o$ counter- alance section extending to ground on fire escape for second means of egress . APPEARANCE: Marion R. Rose PROCEEDINGS : Jerry Kern explained that the building has four stories , the first two of which are occupied by the Rose 's candy company , and the tkhird and fourth floors are used for dead storage. The first and second fl ors . have three exitways , and the third and fourth h ave two exitways , one , �n enclosed stairway to the outside , and the other, a fire escape which d�es not extend all the way to the ground. The code requires two exitways to ground level. As long as the third and fourth floors are used only fo� , _ ____. ..___ _�-- ._ .T..��,_. r -4- 6/9/81 - Meeting No. 74 �`r'�Q�► 35- 81-B 884 Edmund Elsie Townsley (vacant house) By W. Timothy Malchow, Att'y SUBJECT: Request waiver of Vacant Building Registration fees until property is olc�, bec�ause of financial hardship. APPEARANCE: W. Timothy Malchow PROCEEDINGS : Mr. Malchow stated that Elsie Townsley was a 79-year-oid wi ow w o ias lived in a subsidi2ed high-rise building since moving out of her house in 1979. She has income of about $400 per month and is in quxte poor health. Attempts had been made to se11 the house in the past, but Mrs . Townsley was mot the sole owner and there were objections by some of the heirs . The house has remained vacant. Mr. Malchow had recently ob�tained a court order to allow sale of the property. It was appraised at $10 ,000 , although the city' s assessed value is carried at $34,000 and he has filied an appeal for an abatement. He asked that payment of the registration fees be waived and the filing fee of $10 for the appeal be returned. Chairman Glassman said that in past cases of this type , the board has s�ome- times granted a temporary waiver of fee payments until a property is soild, at which time the fees are to be paid from the proceeds . Another way tlo h andle it might be 'to waive payment of the $45 quarterly fee now due far the first three months , but if the property is not sold by that time , tihe amount of the fees due could be assessed against the property. ' BOARD ACTION: Mr. . Sawyer moved that nayment of the registration fees qf . � 45 ue at t�iis time for the ensuing three months be waived. If the property is not sold during that period, registration fees shall be assessed against the property and become payable at the time it is sold. Mr. Tilton sectonded. MOTION CARRIED AND SO ORDERED. THE VOTE: Ayes - 6 Nays - 0 Abstentions - 0 � BOARD ACTION: Mr. Sawyer moved that the $10 filing fee be refunded. r. Tilton seconded. MOTION DID NOT CARRY. THE VOTE: Ayes - 2 (Sawyer, Tilton) Nays - 4 (Glassman, Burg, Knutson and Gausman) Abstentions - 0 - - - - - -- -- - - ---= -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- ------ -- ------ --------- - -- ---- ------ -- -- ---- The meeting adjourned at 2 : 15 p.m. I 6/9/81 - Meeting No. 174; ' i ' I . MINUTES OF THE MEETING ST. PAUL BOARD OF APPEALS F� REVIEW . Tuesday, June 9 , 1981 Room 707 City Hall , 15 W. Kellogg B1vd. MEbiBERS PRESENT: Ron Glassman, Chairman Harold D. Knutson � Glenn Gausman Rudolph Sawyer Lucille Burg William L. Tilton ABSENT,: A. Wali Naibi AGENCIES PRESENT: Dept . of Community Services - Division of Housing Code Enforcemerit : Alice Bijjani Je rry Ke rn Tom Strohkirch OTHERS PRESENT: Marion Rose Barbara Crawford Thomas Crawford � _ _ Paul F. Goetz . Elizabeth Adamski STAFF PRESENT: Patricia Moxness The meeting was called to order at 1: 30 p.m. Minutes of the meeting of May 12 , 1981 , were approved as distributed to the board members . CASE N0. PROPERTY APPELLANT 31- 81-B 266 E. 7th St. Benjamin C. Rose � (commercial) Marion R. Rose SUBJECT: Rec{uest variance of St . Paul Legislative Code requirement of count—er-balance section extending to ground on fire escape for second means of egress. APPEARANCE: Marion R. Rose PROCEEDINGS : Jerry Kern explained that the building has four stories , the first two of which are occupied by the Rose' s candy company , and the third and fourth floors are used for dead storage . The first and second fl�ors have three exitways , and the third and fourth have two exitways , one , �n enclosed stairway to the outside , and the other, a fire escane which dbes not extend all �Che way to the ground. The code requires two exitways to ground level. As long as the third and fourth €loors are use d o�ly fo� ___ __ __. _ . _. ._..._��,...___...__..�... . ° %�� . �`1`70�2 ST. �AUL BOARD OF APPEALS $ REVIEW 7Q5A City Hall St . Paul , Minnesota 55102 � (612) 298-4163 i June 17 , 1981 ' T0: Walter Bowser Assistant City Attorney � FROM: Pat Moxness RE : Draft Resolution - B�ard Actions of June 9 , 1981 Attached is a draft resolution pertaining to board actions taken at the meeting of June 9 , 1981 : GASE N0. PROPERTY APPELLANT 31- 81-B 266 E. 7th St . Benjamin C. Rose (commercial) $ Marion C. Rose 33- 81-H 1956 Feronia Thomas Crawford . (19 units) 35- 81-B 884 Edmund Elsie Townsley, by (vacant house) W. Timothy Malchow, Att 'y - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - --- -- -- -- - - -- -- - - -- - - - - -- -- -- -- - - - - -- -- -- - --- -- -- If you h ave any questions , please call me at 4163.