279091 `�'790�►�
City of St.Paul COUNCIL F E NO.
I �
Resolution Ratifying and Confirming BY
Condemnation and Awards of Damages 18263-5 '
• and Assessment Therefor File No.
Inthematterof opening, widening, and extending Minnehaha Avenue by condemning
and taking a pexmanent easement for street purposes over the following:
The North 20 feet of Lot 34, Block 7, Warren and Winslow's Addition
Also, in the matter of opening, widening and extending Arkwright Street
by condemning and taking s permanent easement for street purposes over
the following:
All that part of Lots 21, 24, � 25, Block 11, Stinson's Addition
and Lots 4, 5, and the Sast-West alley, Stinson's Subdivision of
Block i0, Stinson's Addition, lying within the arc of a circle having
50 foot radius; the center of the said circle being 33 feet west
of the west line of Block 11, Stinson's Addition and 150 feet north
of the south line of Section 29, Tawnship 29, Range 22. � I
Also, permanent easement for slopes, cuts and fills, including right of
removal of lateral support fram subject land or remainder thereof, oc-
casioned by excavation thereof or construction of slopes in the gradiag ;
and paving of Minnehaha Avenue and Arkwright Street.
under Administrative Order "— a roved "" I
PP
Preliminary Order 2�8562 approved April 12, 1982
FinalOrder 2�8652 approved M�3► 12, 1982
A public hearing having been had upon the taking and condemnation of the lands or easements therein, for the
above improvement, and the award of damages therefor, and also upon the assessment of benefits therefor, and the
Council having duly considered the same, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, That the taking and condemnation of the lands described in the annexed assessment roll, identi�ed i
by the signature of the Director of Finance and made a part hereof, and the awards of damages to the owners of such
lands for said taking and condemnation as set forth in said assessment roll, be and the same is hereby in all respects
ratified and confirmed.
RESOLVED FURTHER, That the said assesslnent of benefits, be a�d the same is hereby in all respects ratified, I
and the same is hereby ordered to be submitted 10 the District Court for confirmation. ',
RESOLVED FtIRTHER, That th►e authority to acquire the following described -
land: The north 25 feet of Lot 34, Block 7, Warren and Winslow's
Addition, per Final Order 278652, adopted May 11, 1982, is hereby
amended to read as follows: The north 20 feet of Lot 34, Block 7,
Warren and Winslow's Addition.
RESOLVED FURTHER. That except as amended �bove all provisions of Council
File llo. 278652 , adopted May 11, 1982, shall remain operative as
adopted.
- a4Li�sE�rt ��u�ntu Mu u N � _-=- �
_
�"790��
City of St.Paul COUNCIL FILE NO.
f �
!�, Report of Director of Finance BY
on Condemnation of Lands 18263-8
File No.
In the matter of op�ains• pideoiag. re►d sntendia$ Kia�eh�b�a Av�n� by Qoada+�iag
aad takia� a pr�aa�nt �a��a� #or •tr��t rurpost� over �th�e follawia�a
!h� North 2� t�st o! Lot 34, alock 7, Marr�n �n++� alaslar'• Addicio�
Also, ia ttu wntter o! oper�iag, �rid�aing and �cteading Arlc+rright Str��t
by coadwaing •ad t�king a ptr�rs�ent ea�sa�eat �or •tsat purposa�s over
the tollerriags
All that part oi Lota �3�, �4, i �ZS� 11oak 11. Stinroa'a Addition
•nd irats 4, 3. aad th« �a�t-iieat •ll�r� =ti�aoa's �bAlYi�ioa o�
Dloett Ip, itiasoa'a Additioo, lyins Mithia th� •r� a! � cisclt having
50 taot r�diw; th� eRat�r ot th� �aid afrcl� b�ic►g 33 fset Mest
oi th� w�tt lin� o� 1Yoak �l, 8tin�on's Adaitio� and 1S0 te�t aosth
o! tIH south liw o! Srction 29, lvr�uhi� Z!. L+tngt 22.
Also, p�rw�wnt eu�at f�r slopss� auts aad lilla. inaludiag risht o!
r�wov�l of l�t�ral suppost tsa� subj�ct la�d or ra�ainder thereoi. oa-
casioa�d b� uca+tvatioa th�acso! or couatruotiau� of •lop►�s ia th� aradin�
aad p+rviog oi 1dlantiutba Aveaw aad A�rkvright �trttt.
under Administrative Order �� approve� "'
Preliminary Order ��$�� approved ♦Pril 12, 1982
FinalOrder Z��6� approved Mal► 12, 1982
TO THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ST. PAUL:
The Director of Finance hereby reports:
That he has fixed and determined the value of the land, lands or easements therein taken and appropriated for the
above improvement and the amounts of the awards of damages therefor to the owners thereof, and the persons to whom
such awards are payable; that he has also fixed and determined the amount of benefits to property, from the making of
said improvement, not exceeding the cost thereof, and that attached is an assessment roll entitled as above and identified
with the signature of the undersigned, containing the undersigned's finding on said matters.
Director of Finance
I
�'79D�1
City of St.Paul COUNCIL FILE NO. ¢
%
��„ Notice of Hearing in Condemnation By � ;�-�ti ��;,�� �rr-.=;��'{�:t-
Proceedings 18�63-8
File No.
In the matter of �A1pg� v;�pipg� apd �ut=�pol,oa Hi�[na wvauw by Qood�ting
•nd takins � p�+ta�tot �s�a�tat �or •tre�t pu�rposs� owr th� tollaMiag:
=h� Morth �O tNt ot Lot 34. S1ook 7, INrr�a �nd 11i�slar'a� wdditioa
�- Also, in tlu MRtirr ot o��taiag, xi�d�nia� �d u�t�aaing Ark��r3,,�ht 3treet
br aa�dMaias �od uki� � pes�n�t ear�t �os •tra�t purpos�s ov�r
th� tolloMia�s
Ai1 thst Part o! Lots kl, a4, f� Z5. �lock �1, gtia�oo'� AAditl�oa
�nd tots 4, S, i�l th� Esst-it�ac ail�►y. lttiasoa'• Subdinisioa o!
'loak 10, st�aaoa'a �ddittoa. l�rias nithia eh� ax� o# � circl� haviag
SO faat x�diw; th� �sateY of �ha saiQ ciral� beia� 33 !Nt wrat
o� t�� w�st iiw at l�l�oak 11, $tiwoa•s wdditioa �ad 1S0 tat aorth
of ttae soueh �ist o! �tiaa 2�1. ta�roahip 29. ll�ng� 22.
Also. pr�nraeat �sswre�t !or slopn, auts aad lill�. ia¢lu�tag ri�bt ot ;
c�ov�� o! I�t�rral •a�port fra� •u���ct lae�d or s�ta�s t1»r�o�', oc-
a�ai�d � niaavatiara th�r�teo! os eo�tstruaEtoa o! �top�s ia th� gra�iag
aod p�viag ot Mia4ehah+� Av�tnw and �rkwrighE lts�t.
�
under Administrative Order " approve�l ��
PreliminaryOrder Za$�� approve� �P�'�1 12� 1982
FinalOrder Z786S� approved llay IZ, 198Z
TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN:
Notice is hereby given that a public hearing will be had before the Council of the City of St. Paul, in the Council
Chamber, in the Court House in the City of St. Paul, on the day of
, at ten o'clock A.M.,upon the report of the Director of Finance
as to the amount of damages to be awarded to the owner or owners of the lands or easements therein, to be appropriated
for the above improvements, and the persons to whom such awards were payable and for the confirmation of such awards,
also upon the assessment of benefits to the property from the making of said improvement.
Objection, to the taking of such lands or easements therein, or the awards of damages therefor must be in writi�g
and filed with the Council at the time herein fixed for said hearing, or with the City Clerk prior thereto.
Dated
Director of Finance
� `��,'�9��1
� � � � , ,.�°, ' �
.
,
City of St.Paul COUNCIL FILE NO.
. i
' Resolution Ratifying and Confirming BY Pf ;'"''�' ��'�""-'"�'`�`"'�
ondemnation and Awards of Damages 18263•8
and Assessment Therefor File No.
In the matter f p��� y���� � �j� �j,��j�, Aq��e yy� ����
�and bakl�g � pes��t�t ��tt Pcpr str�s�t pu�xrpoasi t�vs�r tbe
ollt�r3ag s '
Tbt �`�h 25 �t of Lo� 3�, Blxk 7, W�►�rrlr� ��ad Wi�la�r's
Add#:�ic�t
A�to, ��r m��tez �f cPe�i�S, wi�de�xiag at�l, er���4,�g Arkz�cigY�t 8t.
by ao�d � � taki�g a pe�nt ar►st�rrttt �'vr strss�t p�oeea r
t�N �'all i�g a
A11 t t �►rt o� Lvlss 21, 24, & 2�, ��,1e. 11, St�tsoo's Add. a�ci
L�tts 4, 5, and ��e �►st-ii'�s� alt,ty� �tixacxt's Subdivipiois of .
Z0, Sti op►'s Ac'�ditian, �.Y�3 ���� '�a ara of a efrc].e �ving
� gayt ius z tb� +�sar o� tl�e ��d ei�r�3� bsic� 33 Psst wes
_ o�' tlf�e � linA! of Blk. �.1, B��wMtt�'s Add. a�d 150 f�ett north
of tb�t south li�e af �satic� �, T�iP 29s R Lnge 22.
Also, perd�nieat +�►. � tczr alc�pt�+, +cuts ar�d fllls, ic►eluRl.ir� right af
�1 nf la�ral �'rcro su�a�ct ]�nd cYr r�inder t.bsraof,
eaasio�ad by �cs�vati �Sx+eoP aac ec�ttr�cti� of s2op�e 9.n tk� �d
azrd pa�vi,ng of �l� Arrer�ut a� Arlarrigh� 8�rs�'t.
under Administrative Order �' �i approve� �`
I
Preliminary Order approved A],'�'il ]2��,�2
�
Final Order 27�i5� !, �'�,approved �v L2} 1.982
�
' '�1
`� .
A public hearing having been had upon the taking and condemnati of the lands or easements therein, for the '
above improvement, and the award of damages therefor, and also upon th assessment of benefits therefor, and the
Council having duly considered the same, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, That the taking and condemnation of the lands described in he annexed assessment roll, identified
by the signature of the Director of Finance and made a part hereof, and the awa s of damages to the owners of such
lands for said taking and condemnation as set forth in said assessment roll, be an the same is hereby in all respects
ratified and confirmed.
RESOLVED FURTHER, That the said assessment of benefits, be and the same i hereby in all respects ratified,
COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Council: Date
Yeas Nays
��f�����'� Certified Passed by Council Secretary
�.e:��n�
� Masa��� In Favor BY ',
! I
��'C 0 S!?, Against `
`',,{^
.��. �?t�i�; Mayor �
T���.'S�i; ��
�+y;' _"���
,�.._;e:r= �.
� . , . , ,, ,
. ,
,
�
APPROVING ANU RATIFYING �
�
PU$LIC WORK3 COMMITTEE MEETING
July 28, 1982 TO COUNCIL: July 6, 1982
Date of Hearing Description COST
I
I
SLOPES IN M$NNEHAHA AVE. AND ARKWRIGHT STREET i
8/3/82 In the matter of ,;opening, widening, and extending Minne- I
haha Avenue by cmndemning and �aking a permanent ease- ',
ment for street �purposes over the following: i
The North 25 feet of Lot 34, Block 7, Warren �
snd Winslow!s Addition �
Also, in the matter of opening, widening and extending i
Arkwright Streetjby condemning and taking a permanent
easement for str�et purposes over the following: !
Al1 that paXt of Lots 21, 24, and 25, Block 11, �
Stinson's Addition and Lots 4, 5, and the East-
West alley,' Stinson's Subdivision of Block 10, j
Stinson's A�3dition, l,ying within the arc` of a
circle having 50 foot radius; the center of the
said circle being 33 feet west of the west line
of Block 11!, Stinson's Addition and 150 feet
north of thie south line of Section 29, Township
29, Range 2,2.
Also, permanent leasement for slopes, cuts and fills, in-
cluding right of removal of lateral supp�ort from subject
land or remaindelr thereof, occasioned by excavation there-
of or constructi�on of slopes in the grading and paving of !
Minnehaha AvenuQ and Arkwright Street. '
i
COSTS AND EXPEN9ES
Balance to Owne�Cs $4,767.00 I
Benefits - No�+ yet determined ;
Damages - $4�767.00 '
Sheriff's ServiCe Charge 92.00 '
Postal cards 1.20 '
Finance Account#ng Costs 6.00 !
Publications 6.00
Collection Costs �?���
TOTAL EXPENDITUI�ES $4,884.20
i
Charge to PIR F�nd 60000 to be reim-
bursed by Asses�ments of grading and
paving Finance �ile #18263
�
essoLVriox�rrsovavc�ssssse�rr
AND 11EIN(i TIMS OP ■=AtINQ
THEREON AND FI7[IIyd TTME OF H6A16
ING ON?HS AWABD Oi DAMAGSS
Cam�ai Flle No.?18921-87 Chris N�a—
In the matter ot opming,widealnt and ez-
tendin` Minnehapa Armue b�cmdemnin�
�nd 4k1n�a Pvmanmt easement for�tieet
D�+Posn ova the tollowL�:
1�e Nortb xi{eet ot Iat S1,glacic 7,War
rm and Winslow'i Addttlan
N.o.m Uu m.ccar o:o�m�,.iammi.na
�ndln�Arlc..rt�ht St.b�cmdmdns ana
�1��perm�n�t eaaemmt tor rtnet ym.-
Da�+ova the follovrinF ,
All thH p�rt ot Lob 41.I/k tS.Blk.11,
Stlntan's Add and Loty�.S md the ►Ld. -
Wat a114.3dnaon's Subdivtdon ol Blk.
10.3tlnwo's AddiUm, 11in[wlthin tha
ue of a eliele pav[n�Sp t�ndiva;the
center�the uid d�ele bdn�39 het aert
d.th�west Lue ot Hlk.11.Stineony Add.
aod ISOleet.aorth M t6e aouth lla�M 3�
tMe 9Y.TownshlD m.Rac�e Y1.
��.D���t etsemmt lor s(ope�,euts and
81L.lncludln�ei�At od r�oval o!Lteral sup
Dort trom subyect Lad or ismainder t6ereot, I
aocuioned by acavaUon tLaeol or crostn�
Uon ot sloyes in the�adias and pavfo`ot
1�mrhaha Avmue and Arkwd�At gt�t;
undar Prdlmin�ry OMa' 77�E4 appmved I
APd1 1Y. 1981.Flcal Order 7l86SY apprwed
H+�7 S.1982: -
The DiteMor ol Finanae havia�wbmltted
b1+-repo�t in the above mattv aa to the
amount of dam4`p aw�arded tor the tatin�ad
t6e land or asementa thetdn ePD=+�P�ated
to= the above improvenmt �nd W �vham
D89abla�d atso having suhmlttcd hD assess.
mart of bene[ita to pmperty tzom the maklns
of said lmprovemmt,theretore be!t
RTi,50LVED, That Ute said aupmnmt be
and the same is 6oreby Ln eU mpeets approv-
�.
RESULVED FURTH$R.17ut a pubtie hea{•
mg be had betore the Coi�q,cil upoasaid report
�nd tnr+ ¢oafirmatlpy. oL th� award ot
dama�es made b�the Dinrtor of FiRmce and
alan uPm th!x!d a:sea�ent of bmeSts;ac
thr Ca+ncR(-Siambn;ln.the Cwrt Houu io
u�CitY ot St.Paul Oq tba 3td ds oL Au at,
1982.at tm o'eloek A.11L.aod t t t r reeto`r
'�uwn�e be and he is dlncted to Qive aMice
ot eaid hmrin`a�prexriped'by�yr Charter.
File No.1828a-S
�oP�d bX tbe Couecil dulp 1,1D67.
APP+'QVed July 2.198l.
(July t0.19821
. i
' CITY OF �,E1INT PAUL
,�.°':� �-, .. A
� t' OFIZ`ICE OF '.L'IIE CI!L'Y COIINCIL
s� ._,_�!� y '
- ��i;;;��;�*
, .�..,,,,... �'� �
_ -mt+�._�,.�..q. ,
`�- --`v.:. ��3: � . � .
�� ��� Date ; July 28 , 1982
�<5:..:,�, "_;r
ti
C � MMITTEE F� EPO �i •'
�
i
70 : Sain� Pnul Cifi� Council
FROiyi � Commi�tee on PUBLIC WORKS
. �HRIS �ICOSIA , chairman, makes ff�e following
report on C.F. � Ordinance �
(� Resotution
� � Oth�r .
HEARING:
. _
$ 3 82 2. VACATION: Petition of Baillon Company, et aI, for the vaca�ion
of part of �Yest 6th Street, �Vashington Street and Nest 7th :�1ace,
by less than two (2) feet due to the encroach���t of the bu:ilding :
on to public right-of-way.
ACTION: Approval, with certain revisions to be made before public hearir�g .
8/3/�2 3. VACATION: Petition of the Temple Baptist Chur�h, er al , foa� t�e
vacation of portion of alley in Block 26, Ric� �d Trvinets r'�dd.
ACTION: Approval , with certain revisions to be made before public hearin� ..
' 8/3/82 4 . VACATION: Petition of Earl Billings and A. L. ���gold , for �he
vacation of East 8 feet and jVest 8 feet of b�er�ce� Street, lying .
Southerly of West Seventh Street .
ACTION: Recommended approval . 'I
8/3/82 5. VACATION: Petition of' Hennen Development for tF�e vacation of' a
portion of Sims Avenue from the East line �f 6�i��r and riur��iy's
Addition westerly to the proposed cul-de-sac a�c� t�he East an�l .
West alleys in Block 1 and Block 2 of Oliver a�.d ?I�trphy' s Ad�i. -
ACTION: Recommended approval . . _ - . . .
8/3/82 6. VACATION: Petition of Svetlana Oi-Ien, for the �aeation of that . ,
part of Goodrich Avenue that abuts Lot 2, Audi�ors Subdivision
No. 33.
ACTION: . Laid over to August 11 , 1'982 Public Works Meeting.
8/3/82 '7. RATIFICATION OF SLOPE COI�STRUCTION : The right ta acquire la�d
for opening, widening , and extending riinnehaha Avenue ancl A�°�:-
wright Street by condemning and taking a permanent easement
� for street purposes in the construction of slape� in the gr�ding
and pavin� of Minnehaha Avenue and Ark�aright St .
ACTI4N: Laid ov.er ;ta _ugust :L1.,. 1J82 Public Works Meeting_.___
7/20/8� 8 . LAID OVER FOR DISCUSSION from July 14th Public ��'orl;s Commi`tee
hleeting: Ratification of assessments for the improvements �.n
Gabriel. Road and in the utility easement fr6m Gabriel Roaa3 t�o
�Vinthrop Street (Sanitary Sewer, Storm Sel.te3- and tti'ater Rlair.�) .
ACTION : Laid over indefinitely.
9. Sidewalk on the south side of Robert Street from E. I�in�
Street to Concord Street (S-10989) .
ACTION : Recommended withdrawal of order.
Ci:�i ...,. i Sfi'i f;17'li f'LU�)!:
J:�I�:�C i':�(.�L. !t!\t:t•.:+1)"l:l �311?'_
. `�'��:.-�3ti"�t �
...... � - � 'i, . �.. . , . � .
� x::.,E•� �x^ >.e n "s,� �.F '4� .1 �',F�' "�e�j?� t x, �t ; i - x
'� } '�{ �a i '� .,i._ � }k�-�{tAF�.- ��i.R4 ���? �
6 ..s. Z '� "'�5 4 ,�'.$�'+,.3�pt� �{F£�'� �...d"'4
.X �'! � k R t �`;� �
i akb `4� r� �' i � .� "�7f q�i{' k '� � » a. 4� �� p ��v� ;�-:
2. T�Ta,4"i�ya^RR"` R y�.�� .�. ��H S � �.� f s2 � � � Y� }ij;� �t t;�'�r 5�` � 1� w�<
���,p;`� ��a tt f � "� '�d,��._{�I � }.:Y"'��..� f t 1 f t ,,;�r��.r v4 'I ir�°� �'�� + �'`�'���� � _3� � .::�r �y.�,
�,u »€��"� tY,,a:r �rv'j'•ir �� S 4�� : k,s �tY� 1 '� W..` �� ,_}*C r ,�?y.,:s: ifi ? ;1;'"�� pi��e�ry�',.�',�� <�:,� !�
'� e< k k��,A��?-�'� ,°yx3���. 5 u� r�y„, �" :.r r t�,,y -4 i #�'"x s«l �ey�aita �, , ''F"i. �"�+a'�.r��SS.�'�' 1.�" �� #° �.4�:
Se` § '�`j� r,'r� � ! � �' ' �xt�'�,tn Y�t.ry�.<'��'�,�"Y�'�'��.'� q��-*�`"'�'��+ �
�y�' s : �rtiW' $'ii"z�t^ k_it .�1. 1 .y ..� �F' Ir i)p� � � ' 'k : .� 5� 'P�, ,�x. �4i ` . �]��,. lr,� °I :�` sz�'�� : � -
��„'�F", '�� ; �'��.�j���3�4}�� �E�., r 7 � t� -e.. .� � � 'ly v�' �. N"` � ��z, v �,!'� "' " P � �°r �'k¢ �.'. '"aR m J., �" w -.
�� '��� �'4" �!:+A 1 �V F1,F� tlR` 'hSAx�R� 3. ,s,t �'v��r'' L K- '�'ai .' v�`�r�. �j :t ���1��2'�, h�r��,,�� "" 'r.� �r '���� ti+�E-�; �
� 1 '�"" ]N . �T� ` 'k; ✓j�,.�; �, s&�K �r�.... � �` .� .A�e .
�.. l f� � � :� °� .}+' Q��h� � � �� � k. 1 9 ' Y' � '} `)M �5
{ .:J+.� ��'� t �F•�k1<:kr # "d^'�u('+!E �I'. }1 '� y t � s y± c r �- j :st r�� ����� �`.�+�r �.j�J� n �. y� -�.��.
��� �e r x �,. � �,�+'d,,,i "t�� �r C � ' � � h h _- w'. '� t� �?}� p,{ ���'p6 a �„�s1... ,
�5 �� M -� Y' .� � }� ,} ,Y �����5�5 �'$ :Y Y^' ',.7 � �� ri �4� �P'.
ro c�,� �4 i �`.. �� � .��- �� �� �' � ��4 )�,*�is ' .� t �::��� �� � `t� �� 6 L "�'S .f ti�''` ��� � �s� '
� �i � ''� ,�k�3.�3 µT: .,� . . r ° r; � g � � � '�.` .'" .,� �. �, i �„�irv�A �'� 'r ��` ..�
� stE`r� ��# f'^'r' �f,�,F� t �a i� r �"�f „�,r� �.��Ar�'� t:{ �'� ���`� ' �� �� � � �
�„ `t .. � � �� � w�e�� '�s� � � k 1ki, y>I. ''. ���L y�` '� .. 2'�, >yx �`�� �,�.. �w �''Ka �,., t k:.s :� '�
u�r.� ,� t .4- �, �� f ,� �'�r� +,��, `� 41 't � �� � �' +r," `*' Y� a i�r� ���c+'n`i t!'�F y�S+�y� S� �s i
i,.� q #k;'�i4' �� �x� �,"�,��.n s ''Y'�+ k:� w .i.:= :�rt t '� � k ia{'.� a..,r� � �. � s, ..'.'&. R'� � � �*" c��a� ���' �xr
�. . Ir q - r 2 u!
�+�4 �:�.c L� �' �% i 'k' P' ,,,'� � .'�,, '� ..-,r t f�.y��tr s �"' 3�t'..-� 1 5 r 9 � w » . i: � i,� �,, � h, ySF+ F�a 7�e y�,-.
..,f ,{� -s �a'.`� � �s 1 F* xfi, �t g t ati �c a�t�� �P� . ' ' '-�°�. Y��l'�� �i� �L -,' J �,�
�F d �f .A.' �i�'..�r�' � .. 5��,-A:�:.y�.s.*��t�, �� + �� ! 5, :�! �.. . 'J� s F ,!:^s� .r � F ,t ' .
� f ,�,�;:Ml{ *� ?!,��,A� �`i.� � -•y�.� a�: �'1+ y �1�` �r" �,'r, � +� �}. �'S '�',.�.�� St �� �* S`: :i< k xg.F �� �f ti .�^",�, �}'4..�`�� �� ��y ^��,y k.
� �'�1,. ���",� � .� F .�"'���}�2: ��.�h �S a,� ;�� �-.F f '. � �, �.�. � ! �,S � �' x � . Gt �-;3" �� �*.i +� Yf'y„" �'a. a�
z,:k�`M'��`�.���{y�,�,�-y!" .;rF �k,Yk"t '�'�' -;t�i :. � H ',�c 4 ' `r ��� A K�N�.q 5�a:>+, '�a 1 "'�" N S'y-k" ,�5�''�$�Y...��� r '�
.��? a .t " i"a y.v �)`' J :y f k. '��, ^c i c ,,�+ q g,��,;�; '� .. y,q ' '• � � f' � �'��^j �,.
,�,�T �,hR';'� `�f-f*�' 7�i°�,�"��` .�r�"�"�.,�� � i ' , �".:�` t� t"'�C.., k° ?`��'�+���� ' _ � � ,4�°°� <� yryq'�;�,ua°"�� 'a'.ti. f� �k
�µ -;i�� �' �'� ��P 4 `4!:� � �' .;.,},� i4 a �� t J�.i ,,,�:� }� . � . a,� � �`",�rc�.�r`a'' �.�„X. ��$.7�°.!.'�`„H��''a� �,�'���,;,�,��' .
�, �#"��,�6'GY r Sy �� �3. €�i a. � ''4 L ..,-r ��r � �a.��� �.g,r�'r- m� �`�� *, ,�
'�� � E '`F --� ��I� .'� �`�r 4 ' i '�: �,�.%� } y �•§ ��, � $ �+
�s r,�?� '* �S�y� k v; ,�= l'��` �r+a ik,:"`,� S ,�'t �+ �i� �r. �� _;� � , ..r��,� `�
�' ,t`�tt'��.-:-� °�y�,.r '�, �-: .°�1 $� �4.a M�, �� S. �F.'�t�, .. '^ �.;�' �.r",�'` j���s`6 7`�^.ik'`�� £ _.�.���.' �'�""c; �� �,.�
�i��t, j � � z� '� �:.r : / � 4 } N ,� �, .ga-- r�c',� �,y t`u'n fi�F�xa -�Z `'"' Ft, �" �
,y,����I�tl„��r f,, 1y�� �.,'S^�,���o �°* %3��,� � ��.c:�� �'�S �t � � � ^ t7 t Fh��tv y"��:z�l.�t� �g'Fk$Y``�',��aa��SR&'„�.� .°�i
•� 7
y qe. ,i,n r�'` 3 4 1 . � ; +i r' �7 2�' S: ,� }` i� ' : ,t.� Nb �4.. ' ,
3.•( �. � ' ` �C :*z - �-. �'� a 1 � a :ar '�~ 4` _,:� y,�c ��, .M
��t e +:8'f�, 'l `��,��t�a �. f .{ �l �'e -f �., k .�;P �, �..�a. �y� f 'r�t ._a�' f g'A 7' �"�` ,.1��"�ti , �, .,I.
,{ M� p ,`I i,� r�r'� - i t a,. � � lU*,3k��,�'X ;'df� y.. Y if�'+`�� ��iG���y� ;n� 1v� r � .� +�'
��'��Y� �% E��r.r T>��. i'.�. j"� � .� � � � � �X �� �{ � A 'C x�,�s& t i7T �t �a j�� 7.
d �{
� '#�^"' `A' j � ��a � ..� i f . �y , a' . � ,p} ,� 6 . ��q' � ��'�t x��,�'t�;���Y.f�g '���r• �.
��,,"�4;� .�,r.�# a�..:.. � i' �.; y� . : � �r'. t � '4 `� r ; r �`'�.�� �s ��z k {61'������Jp+� r ,�.
bx3+w7 t�.,r ''E ��.+ �'�ir °� lia� . 4� - � ' ��� Fl � �� V �', �t .b� : �'��' .r� � s Y '* w"�o+ �' �.
��m ��"7 x a:��, ��'�,�u ;i �'s r .N5-��' �. •�� t; ' �.€#� «.J3 f�� R x � �.r,,,,.�'�y^���� �1��?� �«r,,,t�z
x��.`b t, '�Y 3 3 � r � t�' �� �� �,i � , } �- '� `#1*,4N .��x �'i��x ��Z� :'#�#�w � ��9 .`,:c'",��' �*'� dy E. ,
`g-K`.� �� �fit F l-�r :i R.� i + �.C�k r, i . � +'s. ��.t '�t k ut r 'r�`"a t�,�f� .�y�,..
'� j°'r •t t�,. r �t � � � F -.+. � ! �. y�, iirS °� �£�. '� �;v a a.'q,�� ,��x
� tE�b �-+ � f �ir,. ,� � r �, �y� h�A��� :r �b,c ,.�i�s`�.�,,, t+ a�'y t.
��.r.�. { � �._ x�? �; �6y..�k����'�'.,f y : �. * '.�"�t x`p�. � :. � ;� ��4 �ptv-�� ,,,5C�9z ti���'� m°' ��' �5..'_ i�'�.
v i r-� �; �,�d �.�'� t ♦< f x w��, ``� �.>�' ,� „�� . � - 3"+ F �'�"•lr�l �'� �.��k1 �����'��t���p, F��--���' F.
a "F S t ^ �'y '. r+? � '+F � E 3
� ,�' a � ! � �.P'S k +B �. `'4 4 '�
� ��. � t 'F�i�., +� YI� �� t � �`�s .,'��S �s `,i�u '� ��, > � x:���' .� .G$tr�t� � � *�f�-
�tY�xi xYr,,,,,� : �, <,�' ,d� � . �', fi t��; � t � �„ t� �, � ,�r t c+� .,�,� � � r r 4..�..� � � � . �.,�-, -s� .
n`' F z:. ♦ �-.. r iy � � `h ,a .�j J' 4 �-.--.k.. � h• ��'�� ���,.j t4�`�" �r�,�,¢�r F�' n n a� �r��..
e�. rt; s -f d f�H.'�t � ��� � t ��,.�+ ft a��t,�C�� Fr*�'Ka t�'c{� tk��,t�k,�,�,�r�"r,�'���-��i������ �a'� ��+
yL +�- � . ` .%� �,�� �:�� ��`�i7 ,��5v`''�i' '��:: t 4:�1�p����:'1'�'�' J' � ':v °� �;;..y�.,_,�.
� � ': �. .. `� �_� '.;� � 4 ,,fi �� #,''1� 7 ;�r�- �. c}« �.$ �`� i�'�F:° �1s..�*s" '�� �
� ,�4 y� � ��` �-7"� 6_�' � r, � � �"`�` �� P �1 3,�7 ;� ""�.1, c s' ,��t: .� .,� � 1:ji.� �R 3f��`��ft:' .°��'� _
✓
i� � '� r�y '� ., s�� s��w � i.'� �: y• t 'r � �� ,� tI� �:;�'"� 1`,����.x . �+��-s���� , t>
� ��, . 1C,R .� ' Y 1`� �. �p p(� � t.'_ �, ,��s.`��x.,q. '� � .i� fi
1._ 4 Y � 3 I � 1 f F' i }y!. �.{ r° � ♦.'
�} � . �t 'r 'A g.1` a 9i`�t�.
) +4 -i k� � 4� �,� �`t �l{�" ..� .,� ,� � . ..:� T� :: E {� '`z � f`� }�' `"�y.�;. n ������''r ,'���'"` a'tY '�"�'� .� �'p�y� Ui'
t 4 . .y i�. �'.�S 'S�I.�,-.
I n''��'.'��,��3 ."".. 4,p � ��'� 3� `�,����� �..#� 'y��� � �' �i�d,,}��, G�aY �Er
# f��, u, �
�� 5 d ��.�y f i"��b t ,T � '� a _, �� _
� � � `a' '�� `� ����qq.'� �°,iw �
^ -;" .E a ^T a�?�,}.Y -t�t`� "',�� #� �,�'M
�a i
q �'1,i �' �'' iL � � � "l� .'Y � '"'( �� �..,h„ �f ��}��� �r
,R��a L � L �^
t�� u r c,. > j a�' ., s � s � fi- .. �t � t t;
ta� 33'` r- '�s a`'� �''k � � 3`(.� �� ;�`S-�f #`� '`n�+ t'S`t» �.°��L�+ �.,;., .
se4 1X' �� r�. 1 +�� ` � � � .::t �,���� ,.St a" `,., �. �.� W,�i;.� ;,�r3� � e}rv_� �*S k.�� �'Y�'����`����
�^?"�i � � a�t i s�'� � � � � f� +, � ` �� �'� 3n � ���t�„r�ks' � a� � �`�� .�4� "��kr�"'�+� ���' �",'�''
a r�a � r .. rf ,. �x:� s�
t� ' ° .i� 1 r �'. ��:� � F1'1.:�'" � e �"5 ^�^ x ; ��:Yt . s-,� r t.k.�.�, f `"v� T` �h� �s ..�i js {t 1�t'4�i i� rz S
� ?r r�,'Y s '�:; ,},, t i -.� i �. i r,�F � �t �t �.+� 9
nF f �'f' �"'� r Sta,� -r �.' A v ' f:: . � i . r � ��'�°� "�r�"$t
� `'� � +��sa 6,r.� � ,4 k i�� � ����� � ✓ x.��YF E �1 .� �d,�'1 t py��,�
,� ��,�. �.ia h r r t fY� aT'; i . r a r. . . �'Y�,t. �. . . �h �. e t .» t
} � & •a ._� y v . ,�Y� 'r x �t 3 l
� ,��` m 'r r � �` �F� "'` a�: �> � :`S t t � � §P�:_" .�..aa� � A��,-.,�, £ -:$ ��,y f`ka�r"r'�i v "�
.t� \� 1 �:r k �'�`3 .' } " ,..4 : � < J t '> e } �;�� t °�� i � �.'�•�n y, .�`C t �.�x ra t +�;,'{`
S ��. v <; � '�q., ' x � h r h/ y '.x 7v 3k� � � -;,�y ?" . if�� r a. t i �sp" � �w"�
�� ,� yx s�r� . 'k .�a-r >t c1' '_a �,#�i i r ` �h r !� �j 'F�m� ��4 i �- � `�Y�.�t �y�¢,} .,� � �, �.,
1}ay q ^�F'� ' r�3' 2 �� t,�' " � �' F�_ r i �. '�+"�& � �R"t : I ���r �s D� K! Y �'
s�� �A w,.:S��� r � °R` "3 ,,.�,t f< r -r s �} *,K `✓'"' � �� '�� ��. '� d s. +�..,fi },r�r,.t��'3ro����' a��'¢` ��- .4
},, �i'a+C.r � -e s ::� b �' "+� '�:, � 1 +�'.r r.u, ���% }�� Z .r�`i y g .� a
�"�'��.?� 3 � � P1',�°� �r' ;l � '� = f ^i. 1�.N '�''... %'r�a�F��.i? +�, ��t F '�j`;{�t1���'''N'��a #��.`r �
-:�r e . � l. yy',c^,a Ma ,�
'�� $t�; � '� a '� s y,# f`�� r+ y.�:-. � 'qr r 't "� �k � $'� ���N��'�.;._ y'�:.f��t`c+� $P�.;�'.�.ei I���'.s x:;w� F`'�*,�'�,`���hN��P ,r�
�z n�r- t ' �' d f �:° �� ' � a �� t � ,� �,Y' ,,�'+� ��
�, r+�ti,� r r4 a �::�� a '� Y x �� Y. yL�w ..p� � �.�, �4 r ` F�`la��; ,,.rd c.3� .�.� �a. 1 �s"� s a�F`�+�w� �.+2i �r
tf ��3,
"S���g v.� � r Y�.-,�i ✓ ��1� �N g � �" r q � �'y x �� ��- ��, v {'t _`k +v�s �� : � �' � s sd`
t,fi 7 .� i 3'� F - � Y; V ' ���x +�e� '�.�r` '� # c � �-�: ,,� +�(''.� ,+�`g� :�� ,� �+; '�
p�,� �' > T �r 1 e k ::� � i x t /+5� ;!` d �aa� �,�`� !sf �}'" ^d �.�` 'a° �'� �.s��'.
a �'- '� �� A,.�;�,d ., {' ..��y' �� rk # ,,'!i:' " �;� " t ` � 's ?` �,4y x.: �,f'�+ �y-�'"c }• �r ��� „�`� �e ���
�� � � ��� �� � . .: .. � � ?} ��* _rf � .'� :e�F �, <.a x },f�.3,� �,{)y"��.�. "�''ir �e.;°'�k"',� S`�+� �E� k�
K 7 ���� ' � � �'���� �
� � :�, ,� & r. '� � � i f t ; h�3`{ vT" r _"`p '�` yE .la S ��e� � �^` � "�"� ���� � ��.
� € z a�vy� ? t `�. +.� h�� �. ��
a ' ; �. '. _ 'ty 3 r �' +� � '� � .a -
�'��`� 4� :�r� �.�-� �✓ b.��,f, � �. � - �✓'��`�`t .'�e :.,���ka �r,�� ��6 �',� y� ^"`.�"��3� -� ..
�� �"�. �t z 1 h ii���r �;'.x ��v.";� � , ti! r � 4 +C� °wo �, x�� "��y�� r��*t� r�s���—��k :�
1'�a� xF.�pt �'S ��s �z:��#.k�. ti� , ���'5�54 ;,��� 1 f '� t.�, ; �i����t" ���''>'��r��4� ;���dt'.�(/�` '���'� ^��� y� �� �r�� _
�.*� `S � .�)'d'y - } �'t ��` � ... � � f,{? �� J� !� �^'� Y `?�i� �4TM'.a�.iq��3 l�.��9.;���� }`�'��i" .
X # q* } �n i l �"tij w R Y"�.�1k�1 .t�'�3.P ;{+. +. � }�\ +i 3 x � ^'. , �i �Lr� y7�` � 'i��:�`y�i 1�{ 4:"S'�;�,.P{k s�, :\.;i'��"`„A4.`a'�-'F,�
,,ff Y
k�^t,�}�'i -z �_� a ,7. d�'-.'�``°5�iyro��£� "�rs,;���� ��. . ',. 'r' ., � ,.,}� � F �.,kN� , k tt �� t�`��'`���" r ,:��. -
�t's�.� s T �s`` �a ° "+�c' L� i���'}1 :{ �. �` r I r' �- �,d �h �'4�� t ,ti�t �" ;;��4E +��,',r� �°W�"".,+� � �.
`+;,#_� >r t!�' 9��-.� �'�F 3.`R � _kf�C"� ,a�,'�M �t "„ �.� �r ir 5- )� a,t ��:� i r�..S v�f' Gv a k�' d%�t"` ���'`c� ��f _x,,
� � �� i �� t WR S`�:�3:J' i ? 5/�. -:'h� 1 4� �� # �3 . j 'a K
^: ,F� t�` � }�: .� �' � �, � R W l� f 1; :.�4 s` �' � "� �r�� 1 r' �p,a a�� i 1` '�m �iv a � �' k ��,�,`
�i,t,` ti=ik r $ -e : i z��`r�e�.�.n �6�'�s �R zr�'"�i r = ,�' �.�'_"-.•Y� �S' xk A�j k�:a � a s� �`y�it e��'
;.�t :�-3� �'".- ,,,d .a-.. t��'�m�n_,F 4 �;�v bk � a;A.R�, .� �t , +�. �+i-1 k +-�, a �Y &s"��'��,,,.�„ �y'� �.� "7�`:�..a ��.�'� g� ... �. ,�
� ��"� s��' x`� � �YT '��K Y '3J } ,LR .�� �.:�,� y Y T�� .#::`�� �"^'(��4�! �,�,``�'wP'�� i� ' t �'��r�`'� .'?�x _
� yr{�y'vt �y,� �:'# 1 ."K J�+,a 4^ �' ' l�r 4 1 �` 'mk't �"�s T� }$y��y `'� ��..:A �^4'��.. � �7� ., o-'X i
�^,�'�'��'.;n� -� y.� 'l .�",r- _�. +f'Y:.'i.� �,;,t � ?�" E^ ,,a� �.�`� ��£ z .'"'�.��n u ; #.��Q1't�. d t'� �, i�� ;.
3� _;.T � ( '. � .4� �� �r s j 4,�- ��.`ma�.. x ," ,��,q-��� sT.������ ��¢;:��4�`� ��.;+,e.t� `� ��..:"1'k � �,��_'�i y :rY t'&s�^..,�? '�'� .�,.�� �pk�� ���� , �
ryr�*�b a s�� ':`xp. � �;i�� r �� p. .,,.� �``:..�"y r sK�d'� � -.),'ir'°� *�,� � ,�.� x� ����-���.v� � �z�.;�,��� .:..��.'� 'i �y�i� n{a� `�,� S ,"�.
;�, a¢1'l. 'Y £�"`' �n.f �lE F. �''i ;;�r .E .s.? .Y �� i ... ,,:,� ��' ?t+;�c'� y ,� a� x JN� 5 t 3�,�" ��{;s�� 'J�'� .
,.2� �.w �� : .� a'�: .S .� r. �'.. a ti.• cs +4 r�,-" � f ;y t r n,-
t
� �f.#�'", t x � �t , an ti w �`� �. ' s "'�� €��,;k"� i�� 3,�'�"a�"r„,�`� n t �k ^'�-r�`•a�� z'�.,.,
f:3'�'"i^'. k Y• � � 'P P� ,,i '�wv`� '^� ��- 1�✓h y,+ �, t �'�t �#'r � Y 1 'aa� �e� ��Y'`r�`� t 1 .�' S�; �YVx- �E
iKt�,� :x ��t �}� +�f r et`r o- -'.f 'j ��F � z�� 's s:� �Z���'�# �ti t � +' �� .'IN
�S ,�� �, �+ Y �'1, s 1' '` :t ��.xr �;� � ����,�}.0 -i x� ��'� ,t�bkr �il. � tb�X � - � �'
"��'� r 1 7'q�. �. :;,"'„ � ., �� '� ,.',a � s�` `ta -f' r�".�Y � s �� � y�.�'.�d'+�°� �� '
�.a s *� `> w' �r r�.. ; r,� Y °r4���c t�r,� �S �,� �`` �'+,a� {;s �s a,`J�� ' � ��,� ��� �z}� i t � �`ee Y.t+
SS �� p _ ✓' M�.f� ! < .,1 �5*`q. +h +`r d�3a�f' `' T R � k F � :
z N �� 1� .� a � ii � a �� ��£ �.�"� ��� � � • �d,1 � Y'ae �.�'s. ��'�kS Mi ty Y }:.'��'f � ����S� �iSy�a �5�.��.
�, £�1'f� r i 3 . y�'4 4 -I� f ��5 .��`
f�,�w��'� � � 14 � b r'I t•�' 'k�' �w- ' / " r .4 '" � �Y� $ � :.Po r S �W s�'�`r` ;.r ��'ae�2r�+ �i
y f p i y,�. ; 1.��aJ 2 �.1 � '�'sx-�� 3'f 1.:�,� 4 r 'F) y r�)��y Y,�. � d^c-'R� :,� r�,�"'�:�x ^rv,�k�`. P
�, �. ,�Y � ��� � - � .. � 1,�: e5 i "t, S � ,� "�''.�� yi
} ��+. y�f '� 1,. o ]��! � � `�`'�+„ Y ^; " �: `' .� �;ik r :L� �-� 1� �3,��' 'y�`�r�;�N`�' �' .Mr'���h yF"� � d�
�.t �j .:/}' s 1 ` .., � .. t t z 4 1 �:,. 'E.vI '�'��z S� �a' � z�` 'ky i
� � �;� ".� a`.�1 s ..,t " .t ;�-.. 1��r �.�� a ��l�r 7� "'�i= �t �. i�,'-,�.�-�-e�,�fhFa�''�£�'f3''�i,,�,'� s'��r,R" "'� > ..t .
'����£�; �"4 �`Er:k �fa ' 2.� 4� '�4 Y'�.'�n �� i n, �7`�.'+� �t�.. ,�,�. a � �,�� .��a��y i ,�x d� ,��v�.'�.»A .� _ :+,
+Y4? �� �^�� r��'��`' a '4 x x�� ��1 � c� � � `,� :r xS, �� 1> �,^s��,� i�'� 3�,F.i `j
�t�, ,� � � �� / ;� 3, �S� ,.f..: �` .:x 's` �. S.�' q . � ;x i �1 �+: + '�y'?._�-�. �.'2 ! !�y "�.ywd�;.�r•�r���,�µ ~�� �
�S` �.`�J,. +".i r t �} -� t _t a�.Y :. f � � � ,�1 g .t kw C � "=s': tN�a,� ��' �S � �3�s�,, � :� * •
y� f � � ,�^s k,�"�rr�y, � r
�',�� ��1+,,s ti� ��.sk9� C t:'�i>- �,t`y l, 4r -e 4 ��- s rt:.- � r � °' � r,� �-'�«f� {�,x, i��'""�'`��"�`� �:�.��� "r . "t` x���CJ.��N^j^�.i ,t;�.;,,;
�t��5 "�� t t}T '� �� ��a,�,� t t � _�- �3f��.. {<„� ,+� a �.. r �+p d�v ,�t�.� :�` �'' .yri � `� :•�`j ftyy�'�hq�s "�.,�
��� �.f 1W �'}. .�.'. i�1� :� ��e. k�'� t,�.- ....;. ,i `�r 'uE y.., 7'��.x,.SC°i�'r"t�`�"R��,'�'��'y-������i'�s:Y'gs"!' t�;. �i wd,.��.,.,i¢53���'�.,,�
,� � � - '`L� �"`}_a.a�4 � i"'`�eE � x s � � ������ � �� �C vi' �l�'J
k as�r r " } S . .+�Y'? ,. a y :
��"�� i. � � � { "�t���n' £�` '��� �-�� ,:i� � ,.��" `�a�g �' v y�, �l3 xq ,�``+��i'F��fi���T '�s��# �'F4 ��Y�'-y a� � a� �, � ,
� � �k � �. ,�� M1 � � '�'F�n �+�`v� � � � �3�� ��R' t..
�'s '. e � � � i-�� � , , ,k � � a �
x .}4¢ �}-
�� '.i r 5 T• H ; y �� } �""d��, � �- �s Tl�i�j� ���r� -0�^"r L...k���' �3So� r+�c,:��,^ .��� �1,���a x 3'���r� �� :w A 4���.,
� ; � : u"' T� :f t ' � ���y �f� �st+� � ,� ���.w^�# 2 'sr a �
R�"�„�'°;;fi �y ` r ,Mut��''' `K . r c,J 4 ;a , : � s i ti t�'�"r ; v�y a�� 4 a:n ��f 1, �r�;� �'�,a��'�` �`i��,x �':,
�t�+ :r.. _ r ��. � � ;� :.�„ 1 x `7 � � �� a,g a,�'' rsr�.'k 3?L '.*st��'� "�� r r a . � i v. `s
sM1 Z s r 'r- t ".l' r �%�3i ic 4 � f'� �'�y +=i.l
� � �'` �.: � ..` y��-.�...� ' }},�{�y �.�` 3 'a. 1 t;�. �> �.,. � w �yC.��}�- �.:.k ��� r � f�'�,�u"+ ��4 ��
�` a =' � �' ,L� �d�� `�Y*�un��'�"'N y,�r 't k#'. ��' � � a�� "� �i�g���` A � � ��,�,w .���' c�4 u�2`� ja-
� 1 : ��'�-a34 � ��.r�., (��,�:! f^ara ���' �A..�`+� WS y � . f '� ,.��i`� �`�x'r �� �� F{�t��.��wV�y�"k`�'F;..j� � aYs+}a'�°'r _ ���..
{#''�.Ft'.N»`y � :;�, � �? 'AP�< .�t,� �'b'� � '�.� �h � b .' ;.Y ��,'f„�"f �h �, A�' ��-�°.F.l ��¢E � 874�r�+y��. ,.
��,`� 't ' .�& �t� .��.,' �'� ��¢�` � �, a � !. i`1`�?;7^ ���`3��'1r�`� � �'���db'� ���'�� E "`�'' t�'
�
,��';�i.._..i�. k. -�:_.�.�.��s�, s �<;4� ..�`,`,;i'�A I�.�b'�;s�....", .�'.,. . . �;;� � �J" -�.. .�� . . . !`.3r,i�Lr .,,..?.S:�3ewi„�. . �'k,.,o:�..ei� .,�..w,Sb,,.��,�^a�e•�i.�.3..�.u..Y.. . ..
. �
�
LAW OFFICES
JOHN E. DAUBNEY
ATTORNEYS AND COUNSELORS AT LAW
304 DEGREE OF HONOR BUILDING
FOURTH AND CEDAR STREETS
JOHN E. DAUBNEY ST. PAUL, MN 55101 16121 224-4345
JANET C.FESLER
August 31, 1982
City of St . Paul
Courthouse NOTICE OF APPEAL UNDER
St . Paul , MN 55102 CHAPTER 13 ST. PAUL CITY
CHARTER
ATTENTION: A1 Olson
Dear Mr. Olson:
Please be advised that the St . Paul Investment Company,
Inc. does hereby appeal from the award of damages for the
taking of its property at the intersection of Minnehaha and
Rivoli Street in Warren and Winslow's Addition at Ramsey
County, Minnesota. The appeal is taken pursuant to Section
13.03.5, St . Paul City Charter. The description of the area
taken is Northerly 20 feet of Lot 34, Block 7, Warren and
Winslow' s Addition. The property is owned by the St . Paul
Investment Company, inc. and it objects to the award upon the
grounds that the same is inadequate.
The St . Paul Investment Company, Inc. will request of
the Clerk of District Court that the matter be set on trial
as jury case pursuant to the provisions of Section 13.03.6
of the Charter.
The St . Paul Investm nt Company, Inc .
J hn E. Daubney
Its ttorney
JED:jw
cc : John Sweeney
Rl: ,
�i�ien rae �y Daubner at the council meet�n� �n
hursds�� �pursuant to s�r�e state law)
Not Dlaceci on anv n�;enda .. -nc�_'_.�-- — ` n I
F -
_. __
ti�. _ - - _ _ _ ._ • _— � �
MS
�
. -
�
.
.
Oh� • M .
�
�- ,�. R � �.
. ,
.� �
. .
� y, a r yP�t� 4 �,r r,�.,yg��i�a r ��'I^ ��'r � , ',xs �F ''���'�"�r r+ „''��..; '�c�c "�V' ° "
�" �y`s 'k c y�.:# k f �',�� �� �� .��,� 'ov`'�,y�L,u 2° � ,r. 3���`��F � -:.s �<�r� �;'�h i�� � �L`�����,.¢�-��'���f��x _l�x�
} Pz ' } 4� ��5�y � � r - t �. . _ ?k i v � > ,"y�°�*f�� r ,�����+ � �y
k ' � +r f �' , 'i 'x�a$ �5
�a 7 ^-� r'�`��1�,„ok£�i��� °� a �-�iq� -' v F� °.ir� ' � ''x"�^` 'st� r ��` '� '�w'', � �;�" r+ ,.� z�
a�-��t�� � ! #t�Cy:���o ,�»`�' � �si� �I ' �" vi S`i�y� ; ,y��k'+a��c A . ��' + � �I��!',�qa.# �,� '�``;� �^ � :'°
n s( . t ��P � � �A � � � ,
;.rd�` W r /� �y�5 J��� �
�� �p Y ` � :*�, � � � t� � y�,��������.� �
S fy )L.1 t :� '1..7.i Lt 4 :� i ��' �i�£ -.\ -� , �Y'2�1��`' k ( t,,�.�t ;v *k3G� ��,�ry`b
� X �,�r�� � � '
,� �t ` � � � s�� �.� e�r °'v"°7��y,r'� �?� s ^��c � $�y��* �`���'ld� r`:� �
�
e /} � W `� �" ! i�C:�..: 14 "y 4 `�ni9 i 1 X. ✓- � y, -d.# ° s i � '�4' �fi P
i �"4 {''� y �{f� -' J ,�wc,,e.� �v,* £� 9 4 /4�' ss s ?
�- .- �..i�>�` 1 '"' k ."�{^�y 'i ro'v* 4 '� g�.1!x+�"y5i'$,'C 7 y�,'M S �F '� T y A'�c X� ��k,`���� ��i. �q� '�R
{���-p . v $'' St 4 tll w�k,` `�"5 - - .t: 'h :4. SI �^��" y .� 'Y��� '� �!'`� � Ssg•h����n'z�5-�'k�p�,� ���'�, '�"_.
,p�'�g=F' }2" �'��' # �.;} < � F rt � �,.� f ,.14 �y i x � � �ti .! � '� � �w .7^" ��,+Sfi��f �t^yI�°'�'���_+,�,�' it ; 1r'�'�
�"'�"� i`� '�` -;.�'�;- E?x �.k�Na��q+'�S"'�_,y."' �' � ��-. '�.� � _ ti ��Sr`:'.., � 4��m.a�,m�'-'r��. e�Z:�,,��t n.�"ip��.���T� 1.���.� �� .3�5°'��t
`�' ,r,'r �K'S �}�. # A '�° ,j- a, �'t ! x -,�. �i 4 pra 0 ca:''��' i +1�: i`51,�j ��'
: x�� X �r:. � � � �f� F .,,*'�1r��,� � -�f Y' ,c..`"i: n m�
�+�.f o-'�a��✓� .£;'4 r�,�„'fl S',�.��, a r .W r p�.:�'�'r- i ti � - f' ' S`�+DT � �����„'�'�' 7.... a��`�j� ,,., �r,tt+;.. ,�y�,k.� .:i„so,'�tdsr �i
�z . ,�F��,^{ �""'�� � ' .�� � c �:R' �'s r , firi��� � �. S �j,,��+ '�, � �x, �.�y,.
�x., £ f % � :�r f ��: i.. 9' ...t� tx;t� s 'f:, +.� �354;�,:r.a s.�"�f h o �. -.��<r � ,,� i .�
is"y ''�'j�V.'- �:>a�.r�t� �. -� ti;v. �'�: y�y. �� �.C t �:� {rSE � � } � n. �s -v .MM vR !'6, x� �n.F _
i�s'�".� �� '€ 4 � i,-� w 5 4., st�`t p J'� �: '� �-.'�^ e; »���x "&w ew R�.' '`'�'9rv �`�;��r�,�,� .._.
'.Y� ii':_�z}f .;� �+� yb ��,�7 a„ ::� � ,�+1� �[�c\x�{" ..�`� F� �. �f�' !?' r! f ' �����°��"; �.y1, �`�y�a,���'y����N�e�.X� Y�a({�„h�T � �� „t�u. ::q
�7� ~� � 5�7 f� `e'y�„�,�'�� r�y, � 'N,: x � � �. �� ., ��` �tr�at,� '� �1,k � t �.'' 3�7 � ` .€ � ry� �✓ �„ �it
��$,> j> t �+ g � �� ��,'h'"� �. t.�`� 's :�2 �5��� ;i Y �..' '�` r '�:�L t�' 1}b e`k���e"RZ�?' '�.
.f, �i ,��,� �" t � t° +a . �� +� s� .S:z �' ��a:�' °2.Y'' �� � +*�`'i ti .�`V``.x�..� ..�. ° � a+ �� s"'.,. .
` ��i�ti Y �3 i1t�� �:`.e f�� �.,-{e 7�;�} f Z 1z���y+t ! ^r lf .Y y� � �..`�d� :�k �.n� -�.'� ���'�`�^.�� ���? s � �.�} `�"����F� a ;... , w�.
�ry c :, r � z �o k "'�, � '� c ay r.. " y -.:�x `�,�b}ad� �`'�l' ca57�'�'y%^r�� � � '�.-r.�.. ��.
�'�' k �,`.c r a . -°'e` ., g.;,�, e �:x �3�.q. 4 3. t a� �'w �,.y,a k.s�j &.�ad ,r }e a�. .;
��"�s�`"'�^ ...�� *Y .i.� 'E"�4' �9"'�u Y''..."� x c�.n�Ad.�s,�., �t �'14 1at f� . k �;��� F�j������°�k�f�.`��'a3 ..x�"�'r�$ L�`L��� �""�.�K���fl`�... ,i;.
.�f'�'. �^ ��bt����t, 1; � �xr��:;J� .,�`to ', �.���y�..:r., �S ,,� ,t �',:i`�i J$r1r *��r,dY'�""3,�s+ri d�,,,,,,k y, �M,:�� �ec� �C``+ � . i!
+L� �`P{�< +�� ��y� 2� i„� �� �F'� !. 1 ?.st f �'+r #� �`{. u A�;� � c. a �C�,�� �:�..� ., d T P... ir,�,`�€�j'�* a���'��' y� ,� n� a
4, a Y�� ro.� ,g,� �� �, nrr. �F�' ,�'� F a�� � � r�' � � �'r�.,,+a�,T �' �s i.�`��
�K 3��i kYiW�s$ n ��}. �t�ft+�l,�yt��,� "'S:' 4 �y+r ":'2�,,��'� � S'+�e�,'. ��ti ��� ;:?t'�S�� a t ..;,�`�-.,x,�t•���p�.�p,p �ye...d„n `�.`� .��`°x'��6�.k a"Y. .:�� .
� �.A'it t 4' C-i ��i l ""t i1 ¢.: ��•., �t -. �' �% :.�.f �d ��',!'..2•�S Y{�'1 t '. 1'drs 4t !��
r�:�..a�� �`�-� "�� � �r^ 4 ; '��"1 S �f� w �*' * �, } , t^�.��+-�� �..� � 4
.a�D.,� x.r�NKKT„k�,d,-"dt�1r-�*.a�ti���„�;y� ��{. .�y� i ,tl '�y' 4 a ;t t � � ��. x�� : �c"��� �� ,��� �'.�Z r 4�t'�t',�^�y',.�� c3,� .�.�t �
���"2 a .�� a s� � a � • '�, ,� t �V,, t r t ���a ,' '�.�` �c = � i�c � �„q
� ,� ,e�� ��r�r �, �q sa..�',m�(� � r��. � . -7 Y �� � �E t `n er�� .s" �" "� �ry��y`a ��i '��i?=y d�t,"���
�, r ,: �'" ��"�����*
, � n ^r �'� �»- a�hf � fi r Y. : :1
?'�„ �t._,.Z� "" ?Y �§,�•�•y 'r "� :� 6 �� t �e t �` �('{ ly�,�a�t x �' �r i ��'�.:;�+.rr s. ��� �'�+�
k 146 � e¢ xa! ��,•� e ,� �.._ � �- �, �q ��, y�,l am.�.f�xf � t �2�X � . � ^�
^� d
w.�y�zA3 t'��� �' �r�,'��:���i''� '�h'+w� t .T��,' � 3�:,� >r -ti` - 0 '� .^ A �}`'h��r�4� �� �.. x` rv ��y. � �+�t-�T.{ e 'N�y', � :�+�r .. g .:
tirl' ., x�P ri.kfif d. y�y�..� z d � r x� a F - fi �; �: .s `��. ,+�'� ,� �'���' �-i`� '1,. ��.'t'r ,«� a ' ;
q,�y����'?i��.� :d .a� - '�/� = >,� -.:� ;'�'� . i ,�F y, "r.�«t � I i``- m ,-R` t Y''�?s' k ��0� i �� 4.�'krd"4m= aS � .�:�1 .£ '��t,. �i
-� i'� -s P� /�' ; � _ �� ��,}� �'i Y '�r „� :-. + �-�.�'A+.�, % ,��r+� f {�e a � �f�, �.,n.r ��1 � ..�.
�C'�S x k ?i � �w � .t I`'3 � 4� �k r �� ,� ����'� ° � k +'T.���t� ,trs�`�°",�ti �'. x�y;, �?�'�� �
�.�t �:;.x � ,-���R;tt� '�,'t {d� t L,.�'� 1.''�,Y � � n�� ��`X S C .; n� . '"tx t -�''t Y�'��{ ��,°'�y .,c c t� � � � �a.a, � i��' �, 4K �k ��& ,,�.
r
� ti s-� � ,�z4 � �r k',� �` 2
'3' � �� x S� -�v, >� ` 1 a �- �S, ���^ ( :: 4 .�i x� . �r��., 't't� ,�- k .t S;s � {t.�r �+. `��.:`��� .
� g�' � kXs v s i? xj�, r, : t '� �'�i x -'� i'�,t �,�7 t"c e''+`x " �� �
��.� � � `� �� 1�+yX`� �h
� ,� 2 ,� ;y � .�?i�` �: �� ..,i ��' j '� �� + �. - � '§.,: �!'�",�, � i �sx, �"r�,#` ��� r,
: : v���� !. ,�' id. .1': x �w <`. Q' z f�r i x . �'� �?�Fr �t� .�.
��'�}'...4� � _,t.�',}" s�} - �r i.'.��aK'��.'�*S"iu.,�.�*'�'� � ` "" FF;� pnr - � '�:�' �`"� �e%.i_�c���' t i�r;��$� f��j� �at�v`�X;�"�`�.�`�'f `�� � i:
1 �.. ?- �f xw-j �. t �� .. $ ._��'�C� t h r:� ��'~+ r . � �;` � ��',��F. r�t�n .�'f q :� y .9' �.' : �� � � �� �-�,
��: k e .?, r �, � Y .� 7p;.,t �fk :}'_ r �fi r Tr� �i r d:�� � � � ,t ��r > i� ,5,�,s "t�ay� '^�i
4 � a+i Jw��..,, v� '� I..;° �� {�„�° .F�,'.. � ....7' 3t r. ;4 ��T �..'� � �az k�. 4'�m
�, �..b+sa�r��a� �..�s A 1,'*'S:.� y��3'T''�"� -.t�i' �.. �' + .:4�� -�:,�2%�,'"�c �3•, �`1`� T �} 4�'y G�t,7�..,z
+ - � ,�yx t��� �' -� �z"�'++°e � � � �;t .�rs. f _' }' '� / , :.� ..,'� J�a k
"�t 4� � � �'� �*'` i`k"3" .y fi�t o�i` .;;,�x�9 :;��'� �i��g �`'� �� , a��' � �.�t�' '�.'�u� '� a�' ��' I .��d.7?t T'2 >'4Y_�'�g.�l,I` 'tl'."c,�,Y
��, 1�t tii r�f's.T. f"�� �� � ,. m � _.p4'� � .�5 T" �� :. ��-= y a ^v.M a f..�'" t y�'��`a`�j`'�"p e- �c � � r�;'�-�
�-1V -�r-x .sje�' '�� Eat x:-� I� .w i��.� �t'.> '�.�.. •''t.. ^�."L...;f , ����xd. �,� 4 �, µ�� �r;+ ,r.�',:,-tts�r. .�,°�y "�r^t p�.. � � ':�d �tkP :�r
�,c��°,�.o- �-�re�.��) �y'�'id� � ': '±� S : ��rt. � @ qf {g� �=� j� 'f �� ���. .
� `l� � c �m{.. �e y-�y�5t ,�,§ N.S�''r
�d � „ t',• p Y �.�' R�'� Kk � p7'.��'�. . t �c.�3Y+ S ',�..
� ���;x yw'�f!".,a"'hA�� ��� re .;.. .... -- . . : .. . .._, 's�1�. r 'i'' �s�.,."� ��.: �� :"`ry; ':s.s,. 1��,.,`� ��'a'�' y,1M�; .
a �
� <� t� �� t� ' dL ; �+ �F� ,r` 3"i`�,�c��,�l�M�������` �d�s�� ������� �� "
� , � q�c
r.��l y�:
4
�'4 '�t�"��e �ri���' R�e�J Y � � �� P r;�. �.�,� :; ��� � ,:.����yytr�� � ". �y�..� ����vy a1r'��., .d4�� ,��c..
y�� a, "� � � :;� c t ;t �,; t � a t� ,�1� �y;� ���rs�°�x �Jn�SFY s r , ���, 'v"�r �
` f ' �1 -�:y� Yr.- ! .`1.. �y.4� ".., �.? (�' '�`� �T� .�.��'�� 9'F 9 "£ 'a'f M+�" 4 .. �.
* a,r�"v'�r£ Y�.rF 1�'��� �r�. r,.� �'{k'� r ;X� 1 7 ,✓ � '� r.���"� �t- ��. � f� .� 3�c},.'�y" }, ,N �' "�,��e, *«�+
� '.:.r .� re.� � :�. � �- �y. -0. ,thr�SfifFS,;,, �:.}a r yq��;y y�. n yr, r £ `i. y�:'.,��a�._ ��s?����a fi.�'�+��'jr- ��a�'{'��,"�7'� y:a4��7'�'t'r����j�i k�*�,�� r`,�� ..A.
.� ` b
r
4 ;. ',� ��
�4ra�,�. a „i e��,�3.�.�.`V°`�c., �„ #... -., .�.�. .0 .,. :.. 3 ��,� � � :s�fi3�i..�,,�'s�� °Y��.�w/t�.,�- �t' � a�.':,K3'�Y��•-.� ����,• .
�: s �s �� + � r. t � ��� . q ��-��- v ��1sa � ,* ` �
y` � 3 f S4' K d:•:y ��. °'Y 1.y $` 3
�'.�'. �, � �.�r #s l`r'4 � �'����y'�'��"r },�^�c� x i., � -�,,r» � K :'._ {{ . .��i �i�r� 4 � �" S.a.�S � �i�,+� +}� �`�;--.�.����?�'�n°�`,� -�'�v':
��"+,. n�, � � -�.-S �t� �z. is � ?5� '� c ', a y� l' �.� �F����'t�F�,
,� `.r, ti:
�ik��� X�";y�+". ) � .y�f'��; ,YC7,�' t'� • ��� .,. �J . � ��4 �n '.
1
�''�q,�� � ) .�{ ? i J sr _•1 +c 'c" .,: ! ?6!B ,�* i'h� �� "���� *Y "
�u��y k V � � �� ., t 1 ?: � t �r �+�+ :g,� ? ��: 'i`'t�° �t
SH.H: �V) ��jry, -tak ��y R�t L'y�� F��� tW- �G S� Y 1 �� b� k� E �.{ } i ��'�r
�t� ��;, d ���'li� 7�+�7' �� ..�'. . 4 �N;��°1� '� '�w 4R5. a�y�A'� �. t� a4.�,t'�' � 't�ti 3�h
�, �,i� ♦�t�`r.+'�.��w�f t yr � �f`� :� l., ,s R:. +,-; ���� ,��. r � �� r Mw6�tY y�y5i. -r..,� f'�;�'y�Y ^�, S. � .,A �2'� 3�" ab�F '�i p �.
��t� '"�'�,�e_ �� � ,{ tL'� �.4 'c�;���`� r c" � �` �� I t �.��.� c., w �, n.f-�-'� �` _ >''�..�.`;- ���. � °p ����'�������P a.�7 ,
�� � x ���� y . � ,... ..t :-. i� y �,
� y�
y�� t �` 4i � t ��
1 -, ` � ,�
3;�u ; -,
k.�1� 1�'�1��,'�q,yt.�r4�����'�� 'CG�s C � ,e { e�����f�"��^C �s N �
_; , : , ,
r� '�* s'•`� r���•}#'����y.'.f�� S�v °` �� � ��� 4� �� �� 7�`
+ � � �� i
�k�'�'"_�2 y. x�:� �",. ,;;�� S � � � - � t 4: �S�!=�..�^�.�,�€�;
1^`U�.`� �y�q'�'ati"§'r�'.Ert r��,`'6'`Y§'1'�F� v+�^�, /-., '. � Z 1�r��"`�`� ..�
� a�i w�`�� `R'���,,�..t ' ��'�'����i�r`w ��:. � �v� , ��� '�- 5 y , �����¢� � r�
�faa�y � t , ''�+ ���. �,F °��'; '�` + � 6 � �ri��t������ �'��;
d � 7 �' ; � +� 7 t �a �
p � # K �.��,t kr+�. �'n, �;�� '� � '��+ '� s � .�`,2l�� � '�kr �.,:.pvs � �i�;'�`�a�i�'s,� „� ��
. . ; � .a w � � �s
ti �(�X§ . # . �. �^ :.s :."� � a �' �'£
3
� � s ��ip�wrK�' �Y' +f: � � *S,� � � ��♦ � .�,F w �'��� • �'�+'��� -�u� t x�lt M X �'�.F -�.
� . �- ,� X �§3 '4� �. `r�. 1 F � ` � ff.a � �„' s s`..�� A e.. � �;( y;.'" ts�� -r`" ^*'9�5`'�°�f� '�
�'� 4�� � 6,�" 7 : f! ��f�„ i .k' :+, a.y e. ' w a., � �r , �$r.:;4 � e�, �:� �' * h,Y�� ��y i
���} i`Y�� a��,� � `���+�3 t i �� . ��1 � '; � �s"`��''��'�s
�
,� � „� �_'`�k �. �j.. �. � p 7 F .p� �... �v�,��a�t�w�"S� .
.t ��C�7�s.'. � �s -� '7..�Y"(J ., n ��_. & '� ,� '���-'�'�S '�b %�'��; x
� �� �` �'?'�i ry, �'z � :v ' �.: '� i b 0. r"s:�`�r " -. a ���'�t �a.y � �'.
y ��fi�"a� � r fi f k�`,' r� ^«�* , xn�J.r"a�, l�i i w'� ,� �"��+rw�. R � "a a�"i'r t '°.# r:
�� �y�-�.'t� f y � ':s x �� �x.� � `. ` 'S t _ - 1 t ��. t �. y e 5.= 'p2 r.. »� �?,�. t � � P a 7�F::.�yr ,�e+ y �}{` .
3 ✓ f` Y q'"Z A `�y '4� d., e " y r'•-.. �Si 4'i' s. � 9 .. £ . 1�W r�'� '�'=�
"'S ��,p�.:t� �1.���' i� �,� E_ � �§ f f4� � �. e�t y P ` �' :. x F r�" �. 'x,.*�y #'� �'" it„�,5?� '� '� r�: � � :ti:, o- �F�#�,rc� � .
� ;a.� .. .. . .t�,,
�a'4�4��" �"r- ..'�M'� ! q ��'�, Kf� �t.s� �. `�#'.
�,X ��, ��y' � p s,...,R ��2"t.r��+��� � 1. + , .::�r � . �,`�'w�X�`� 5 *�„
7 u � �y�
•;` ky;},.' �$. p' _y � Y-f �a'^`r:�i t �����s � >" �` .�} � ,q� ky
4'� i: � i � + � i �'� ��j3 f���� A' �. v��� � � # { rt�-krT Y j' +�s+, k x
� �� �+ t'a � � r,.: r x �1 '�`�:j ;� fi,�x`�;t� { x�::5� �'� ���,y"Y"`+ ,��' �`#"i�,k � a s�',,,�it `��-� .�,��f e� � �.
ic �.�: !t .L � n.. '' �y s 4� � �, .; t $ . �',�m r , �. =i.. ...�. j -3��s�' �.�r t,�,��"' .: �q+:` l.,
�.;�3'�,�? a �i:f .F` .2g., s I -��f j �. 3�` . � ,t j""$ 'Y �k.'st '`�it�a"���{�'� i" � � -�r�v". ' �.
� �: ,� . A r r �,� �':.
�. c � _�� � � ::� r ,} ��� �,.rr � �x $ .e s a. � r 3 l.a'�:w `�+���:;
r i m r. n Er .. ,_ .�.°'�4s :`F� �i� �x;. -�u�' �
ie�c"',n'��', �"i: i7t^ F�.< f ¢�i'.��, �' u .;c �( ���, x t y��fiy:,� � yt,�',+.sr<�x.���'�'`*n}i�a ? r �'�,,5.
q��'s4'�y;:.c �a ij,. ty;� ta'tq� ... �Y` ;.T ,cy�`+>4�:'• $�� #. . � j,.., �t�,,.��s"X�1� {,� �.�p:;� ; x ry�.:��v,�,��i<�}Y'� ¥}f.4'4�:y`x� t�t3 `k�,,,+.�.�.4'�.�� .,�.t?�,
6�-�K<�}'�3` � •,a �,t c.{' ti.'���r ,n3F r'...3 ��� c f .,_ _��R t� A s � n?,.Y fY ,dr� ?,'�.r �. �M` �; �,a�y.��; ���.
4
y � 'rE � rk '4�F l "s.,1u '.2,.Y " ,� >qlG A �R"' "�
� �'� �"� ./i��p��. � jy..�:�ts��rv��o'rw� .�h � -�;,C a� ��. F .P: � . >/m.. ,�"`� �'�, A2� .°jr y�+'�`�.4 t� i' .jaGt`A �k+'`'���� 1����,�� 3 ��� ..
�i+, aE a r,� r '''� '�°Y x c S�§� S `�" �; y�i, t�a w t
�' '�' �7' �^ e�.e.,��.ka �..:x r R T�. t �� �'yi..�,'",� c .'r� �� ' 7'Fr}a � n'r`';,6 ,c#.0 ,�p,.-��',y�� �� �.'v"ti� „y� ..'#r�"r"��d��; ,� �, ��.�Y..
-�� :h � t� w � �s { �� t � + , �t ; �t ut n� @J�'� �''u'�'��i�' s�� t ,��*t�.��"#`" , ,t'� '
y � r ti, . �. dr ':' �F � ,� � Mc x
�� �.. 1 yu tR :ri� fi , t f t C � ��"�� !sr'yb�" �. +d' ^k ��. <s,� '� jt x �'3,n ,f#r�., '.
;� w ;� �,� F �� i , �.�; �"t��,s ,..� y ��,,,�,r, � �z�
�, a ,'� � �,�' � Y M { i r [ * �r :i�� . at.v'v: .!���,.t ,��''k "� 3,'�ir aa�` "�`'J'k�' :y. �`ja
i ��M i s �a �� 3t i:' � '�A�R.'� '� �n} : ' . j x�� W. �,,7�L K x .�'fl`,��t; 7��'��3.�' : ��.,.
a;,'��"„ .." '� {.�i*��' ?'.�.`��0 f .. !+�,. ; '�t t � ��� + �n-�, '��� r Y'� Y `�)�k.t � c ' f'�� .a � ��. `w L ..
:�� e � t� s�<• ,{bta i• 'x` t`.y 3, Ve '�a � ,t� � 5*� y...,r �d%s�{�i• w r";`U � ,{ 3, f"'���'� ,:�}k'S ��:Sr+ ��. d, .
y ��`a it+���f °r \� a'E� ^` , A � �h?;'�*.�3-`t 9 (�A+��e '�,�+ � �n ^Yy� r'4 `� '}
a�=L� � -,r �'.� � ,�y";��°' �� ' d e� t '-t ��§ '� ���,°�7��� ,�.�,N �rnw?+�,�.�.'�1"���"�.'�'1' y' - ..�.�'x"¢;?i�",�'�s ^•�tsi��`� ��.
`�77 :L"kS''� �4 y`s�, � t ii � t . �a +�'S 3��'dra�#�:* �k. �. ,,.y. r�vx ���f �`ii 4 {�� < .
�f.' ! w� �.: 47t� "s j�y,�``i f p e !Y� �� r -z��3� k �,a.� $ ,� '� ;�. }�,�ii�p� �,�.,�n ;�
``1v F Cr a w+, t ';vs`, R .k Cp 3�a y SF s� x�.�� �� 4:���'S-` e � ^4'� .
�k&,�f �'�d'' ,�AR�� r .i � .� .r..�Ry '�t,.� g y �" `��, '� y U* � r�, �>t� .. � f" '��,?��+j,y`�t �,,."��,"' n qi �'�� F�.w f�'� ���{.
$ `, „ ',�
# 1��#��6{� ����� \�'�:Lt f r�`•,�'S. �'� �P � �'-�` i°�;n. F.��`,�I 1 �4�.� �' `5;` N{`'��;1 ,�OAk��i^�.y�..Y�R��,�"'��y'�y ��tiH�� "1.��3X� �., fln;_'' #�,
' £ � �� 1 �. y� a�'M'F3�^at 4 S +M P "�
� �. r s, � � G�� �,� ��f� �� �, '`� '` s � k `�« M t �$ M t F.n e �t �� �
R ..,Y's y ��"�ti �� `�`.��y - � �!`� �t� 2 ,� 'r� � �.�, r � �t �' � �f �' � }�b� *��7 1 �� Fr a �"4� :.�`"�S�'��.��'"" 1+
"� �'`t; ,�� �� " j�. �� f r ��"Cs+..w,F�,ax, .±4�xa .,,,f�.x zr�^g�. r�.t t '�1� F {:, "�
��9yt'"s -: W s� o ° �i�� l j#��e7 ._a� a_y '" �� � � r ::� '��t.'ae��?/ta^-� i'` '' � �3. ��s.,.�,'r:`� ° '{.,'�� �` "�y���'•'h
�y it . 6;��t S i d � ={1 4�' r�`�° '* #-�:�'x^ �s�` �y �,"�«�� ' ti t a ' `�, J
a' � ,� Y■, sq= 1 � f '� x x o .,a
`�,�{ ,-s. . 7� ��- � �� � � � i�^.���,� '��` t � ��". ��"�+�.�,r�^"r�' �:��� �-S: �'iJ v a_rj t� , .y .+.;.
''�" �'-� ��; a " - � ��.v�: ynt, ' c" a . '�," '�€' '� r��°��5�. � �'� '� y�.t'� .i M'-
..:� i �3 t*K t �.4� �. 'A � '5�:.. µ'+ a� F � T- r C r ^+ ��.y�, �'r, �„
AX '1� t �'t?� ! a' r d� _ 1 'i . pY r ��A" f'§'Z �1 �y : s y � ' yi� '^
x M� ; � 1; .� . h� rq" Ya.. .� .�f,5 �i P i�� � j,�y` � �x�`��i��4 �k �� � �^�f,�.+T��{�..� �p .[� '��[' �+�''� ..c�' .
p� �_ :Y � -"Y 54�Y f � ,GyY L�� :ti t-� I 4 ,�` 2: � W .:�},!� i`� �^ � .t.1'i,�M '� T� {x� '��''. .
k' # e :�; �2 �� � i� �'� - �°� 1 i �i- ` '��'f�''"�'�C�`�'L C �r ur,y u,�� '� �w{r* ,�fr� ��� e �; �e � ��_�.� '_`at
C ft +-T' {. � "+. � #� � . ." z ! f 11'S. i 5� N`:x` t'd�"�� '� 5 �s G.;v i r
�"�t �`:� 1�' � � � � �c i y .' ''�'� �..�,��.,� a:"�s r ' e s .�.�'�' ..��'" Rr,���`� ��'���•P` ;� S �' .:j; �M �`;�wa6 i�4 '�.,t � �zt
�' 3° �*I � 4 `: �1'. ' �' } �4 T rr 7 � �
���q�':' � �7s��..�'�'.��.t t�t.-'': � tS �,".;�F�m � �F 1� � �. 7 "��} �fy„�A,.�.`' i ��VM�� ��{���� ��3'-.�,�.��}'''^� r': �u�A 1,`.s�,��� �3?s� � ��;fs
H," .��, ,� � � "�``i � }& f ,� q.„ N ��a7P .���X ,��- �
. fi � .' ��. j ,�P .✓ ya:;� �Sr-�j. .a e �av`x, .:t"` P�. �'�&{�t � v'�
�,,F 2�''.�: '� f �;° Y., -�` �°°i � 'c`,tv v.�, �:. ° , n � _ fi � .wys r g``
c � � '� � '�+u ;. �$ �"'i` �:.. o ' t � � �,� a.+�wf� :� t t:�a�` n !� 1 � � �`�,.,
t��"'� }'X �h -f'^ .NF� k.. ,yak �g ;�+,-,at�,t t�w.k f ��-��rx� ��'�.�r �i t��s � . °x �f� v�' '��� ,�1 a
� x.�� �- '� :.r 7 at = � w.:�`fY k� �` *- 4 : r' �, �: � tn�r� a ,�q.� � �'•�.*" s � � �ls r � 1`��'>��';�,
�� �`i:. �i� f�,.� '� r. 'w w,� ., r� k 'a �t � ��t e .: L r rc-- .Y`. �.+�r^s J�'f.:,.,,�
', N ... .,.�.`> .; . ,'-f'F`si�. '�,. .1._iv7c..4 a_;� ,�..,.,< �,...... n�'.. r.e .. t'',tPk!�w .... . . ,'���.�l>_'.A:?��g,fer „'�r'k.. ..�...�i�'c.�1..�r!^�,��;a�4Yu"+.�e ?s.�«�-r.a,�,�.TA°,i,#,aa n. . .,