00-551OR�GINA�
Presented By
Referred To
� ��
�. _����� n ��'
�
� � ��
ci� o��
[ON
� SOTA
Council File # DO � SS�
C,ieen Sheet # �. u"133 �
Committee: Date
RESOLVED, that the Licensee, White Lily, Inc. d/bla White Lily
ID No. 0083595), located at 758 Grand Avenue in Saint Paul is hereby or
$500.00 for the violation of Sale of Alcoholic Beverages to Underage P�
aurant (License
to pay a fine of
Said fine shall be paid to the Office of License, Inspections d Environmental Protection
within thirty (30) days of the adoption of this resolution by th Council and signature by the
Mayor.
This resolution and the action of the Council in is matter are based upon the facts
contained in the April 17, 2000, Notice of Violation 1 er to the licensee and the Police Repor
CN 00-055477. The licer.sea did not contest the fact oFthe violation.
Requested by Department of:
Adopted by Council
Adoption Certif' c
&y:
Approved y Mayor:
By:
Date
by Council Secretary
Date
0
By: :���W —
Form Approved b City Attor / J
�.J/ �.' //J
By: K../� /�
Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By:
GREEN SHEET
266-8710
BE ON COIRJCIL /iCiH�IDA 8Y (OATq
hme 7, 2000 - Public Hearing
TOTAL � OF SIGNATURE PAGES
mr,�rnwecroR
Oo -SS►
No � Q�-' ��o
❑ arcwnneEr ❑ arccuu
❑w.r,.�a�soa ❑.w.rr,a.a�.■.cc.a
❑wvoRlw��wtown ❑
(CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE�
Resolution conceiuing adverse acrion against all licenses held by White Lily, Inc., dba White Lily Restaurant,
758 Grand Avenue. (Uncontested)
W
PLANNING CAMMISSION
CIB CAMMITTEE
CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION
Idl,r.,��fl�^�
Cau��s��l �3������,h C��fPr
�1�
dTAGES IF APPROVED
�RAGES IF NOT APPROVED
NOUNT OF TRANSACTION
SOURCE
wFOw.unorv �ocPwM
RSONILLSERVICE CONTRACIS MUSTANSWERiNE FOLLAWIN6 QUESiIONS:
FWs this F���m everwaked under a conkact torthis UepaihnerA?
YES NO
tias Nic pe�eonlfiim ever Deen a cdY empbyce? .
VES MO
Oces thic persoMmm p� e sIdII rot rwrmaltyposaesseC by a'ry Wnerit aty empbyee7
VES Nb
Is ttiia pneoNfi�m a tmpeted veiMM ,
YES NO '
dein all ves ar�aNets an seParate shee[ aM attach to ➢rcen sheet �
COST/REVENUE BUDIiETED (CIRCLE ON�
ACTNITY NUMBER
VES NO _
OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY �b � t�� �
Clnyvon M. Robinson, Jc, C?l}' Allorney .l
sa
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Norm Coleman, Mayor
May 26, 2000
C!V(I DIL'%5f0)f
400 Ciry Hn[[
IS Wut Ke[fog� Blvd.
Saint Paul, Minnesotn 55l01
NOTICE OF WITHDRAWAL FROM COUNCIL HEARING
Owner/Manager
Telephone: 651266-87/0
Facs[mile: 657 ?98-i619
� R�ar�h GF�ter
White Lily Restaurant
758 Grand Avenue �y�Y � �
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55105 � �
Re: All licenses held by White Lily, Inc. d/b/a White Lily Restaurant, for the premises at 758
Grand Avenue in St. Paul
License ID No.:0083595
Dear Sir/Madam:
Since you have now paid the recommended fine identified in the
ir,fuuivU iette� we are
June 7, 2000.
If you have any
call me at 266-8710.
Very hvly yours,
C� i
� � ' L �/Z�.
Peter P. Pangborn
Legal Assistant
matter
9, 2000, NOTICE OF
council a�enda for
cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary
Robert Kessler, Director of LIEP
Christine Rozek, Deputy Director of LIEP
Eilen Biales, Executive Director, Summit Hill Association, 860 St. Clair Ave., St. Paul,
MN 55108
UNCONTESTED LICENSE MATTER °°-SS�
Licensee Name:
Address:
Council Date:
White Lily, Inc. d/b/a White Lily Restaurant
758 Grand Avenue
June 7, 2000
Violation: Sale of Alcohol to an Underage Person
Minn. Stat. § 304A.503 (1994)
St. Pau1 Legislative Code § 409.08
Date of Violation: March 30, 2000
Place:
Presumptive Penalty:
$500.00 Fine
Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office
of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection:
$500.00 Fine
Attachments:
1. Proposed resolution
2. Notice of Violation
3. License Information Report
4. Police Report CN 00-055477
5. Law Enforcement Buy Report Form
Licensed Premises
6. License information
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Norm Colemnn, Mn}�or
�flY 9� z���
NOTICE OF COUI�TCIL HEARING
Owner/Manager
White Lily Restaurant
758 Grand Avenue
�id'.� �e2�3?U�'! �8^,vT
MAY 1 � 20Q0
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55105 , , � � , , _ ,_,. ., ,
Re: All licenses held by White Lily, Inc. d/b/a White Lily Restaurant, for the premises at 758
Grand Avenue in St. Paul
License ID No.:0083595
Dear Sir/Madam:
Please take notice that a hearing concerning the licenses for the establishment identified above
has been scheduled for 5:30 p.m., Wednesday, June 7, 2000 in the City Council Chambers,
Third Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse.
Enclosed are copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to
the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested matter, in that the facts
conceming the sale of alcohol to an under age person have not been denied. You will have an
opportunity at the Council hearing to present oral and/or written remarks as to the penalty, if any,
to be imposed. The recommendation of the license office will be for a$500.00 fine.
If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710.
Very truly yours,
� ���
��
Virginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attomey
cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary
Robert Kessler, Director of LIEP
Christine Rozek, Deputy Director of LIEP
Ellen Biales, Executive Director, Summit Hill Association, 860 St. Clair Ave., St. Paul,
MN 55108
OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY
Clnpton M. Robinson. Jr, Ciry� Attorney C��rs'
Civi[Dirision
400 Ciry� Hn!! Telephone: 65I 266-37/0
/SWestKeltoggBh�A. Fncsinrile:6�1298-56/9
Saint Pnul, hlinxesotn 5510?
OFFIC� 7F THE CITY ATTORNEY
Clayton �. .obinson, 7r., Ciry ASOrney
SAlNT
vwuc
�
Al1AA
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Norm Colem¢n, �41a}•or
E��JIll 17� 2���
Civit Divisian
400 Ciry Ha11
ZS iYest Kellagg Blvd
Saint Por�l, hlinnesota 55102
NOTICE OF VIOLATION
OwnerManager
White Lily Restaurant
758 Grand Avenue
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55105
Telepl:one: 65I 266-8710
Faaimite: 65l 298-5679
Re: All Licenses held by White Lily, Inc, d/b/a White Lily Restaurant, for the premises at 758
Grand Avenue in St. Paul
License ID No.:0083595
Dear Sir/Madam:
The Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection (LTEP) has
recommended adverse action a�ainst the licenses held by White Lily, Inc. d/b/a White Lily
Restaurant at the above location. This recommendation is based on the following information:
On March 20, 2000 an 18-year old female entered the premises
of White Lily Restaurant at 758 Grand Avenue as part of a
compliance check. The young woman was able to purchase
beer without being asked for any proof of age. Sale of alcohol
to an underage person is a violation of Minn. Stat. §340A.503,
subd. 2(1) and Saint Paul Legislative Code §409.08, subd. (2)a.
Since this is considered a first violation, the licensing office will recommend a$500.00 fine,
pursuant to St. Paul Legislative Code §409.26.
At this time you have three options on how to proceed:
If you do not dispute the above facts and do not �vish to have a public hearing, you w�ll
need to pay the recommended fine for this violation. If this is your choice, you should
make payment direcfly to the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental
Protection, Room 300 Lowry Professional Building, 350 Saint Peter Street, Saint Paul,
Minnesota 55102. The letter should be directed to Ms. Christine Rozek. Payment of the
fine will be considered to be a waiver of the heazing to which you aze entitled.
� Page 2
White Li1y Restaurant
April 17, 2000
Oo-SSt
2. Altematively, if you do not dispute the above facts, but wish to have a public hearing
before the Saint Paul City Council, you will nezd to send me a letter �vith a statement
admittin� the violation and requestin� a hearin� by Thursday, Apr3127, 2000. The matter
will then be scheduled before the City Council for a public hearing to determine what
penalty, if any, to impose. You will have an opportunity to appeaz before the Council and
make a statement on your own behaif as to the penalty to be imposed.
If you do dispute the above facts, a hearing �vill be scheduled before an Administrative
Law Judge. At that heazing both you and the City will be able to appear and present
witnesses, evidence, and cross-examine the other's witnesses. The St. Paul City Council
will ultimately decide the case. Please let me know in writing no later than Thursday,
April 27, 2000, how you wish to proceed.
If you have not contacted me by Thursday, Apri127, 2000, I will assume that you are not
contesting the facts and �vili schedule this matter for the St. Paul City Council and have it
placed on the Consent Agenda during which no public discussion is allowed and the
recommended penalty will be imposed.
Tf you have any questions, feel free to contact me at 266-8710.
Sincerely,
�,U-�� L.�-j�.-,.�-,
Virginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attomey
cc: Robert Kessler, Director of LIEP
Christine Rozek, Deputy Director of LIEP
Ellen Biales, Executive Director, Summit Hill Association, 860 St. Ciair Ave., St. Pau1,
MN 55108
ao-sSi
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
) ss.
COUNTY OF RAMSEY
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL
JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says
that on April 18, 2000, she served the attached NOTICE OF VIOLATION
on the following named person by placing a true and correct copy
thereo£ in an envelope addressed as follows:
Owner/Manager
White Lily Restaurant
758 Grand Avenue
St. Paul, MN. 55105
(which is the last known address of said
same, with postage prepaid, in the Uni�
Minnesota. �
on) and depositing the
tes mails at Sr p�ul,
69
Subscribed and sworn to before me
this 18th day o£ April, 2000.
Notary Publ� " -- - - - ' -
°�T�F � PANGBORN
nx�rar?v w �� - rainwESOta
� �v�or�naissiow
�xPfRE: J,�N. 31. 20pg
i�
�, � i
�
i �-�
� 'W
i
o I ai °
� � lo
d IU N
07 �J �
�p O
a i ,o
u
�
0
a
z
C
0
�
e
.
w
c
m
N
L
d
U
J
�
�
�
��
a�
1��>
V U
J 4
�
m
w
d
O
IN �
Inm
a
~ G
N �p
�
�c a
� a� m
U
jJ I�
—�
° o I�
� !a l i
T I�I
� �Z ;
i
I� I�
V I�
! J , o
��N
w
¢
v °
�, Z
a�
a
i a l� o
�Jn �
z
Q
�
Q
�
W
�
� }
�
Z IJ
I m h
� _
�i
U
E �
J
O �
�_
a �
�
c
�
0
U
N
0�
�
m
0
a
w
�
c
�
�
a
�
3
Z
U
0
a
U
c
m
�
CI
N
IZ I
cl
m
n
o�
I I
V
I
N
u y
c
�
m
�
�
3
Z
N
c �
� N
� T
a a ,
N �
� �
c �
Im �
O�
�-- �
n
M
>
Q
�
Z
�
�
�
n
�
��
�
��
��w
i �� a�Q � o_o "
: Qa� J p ip `oJ d c c °» �
��� Nj� �j ON�VLL
c "O N ' C' 6 w5 N �p � OU C Nfn
I � �� �a�5cow7 `oi-O� �w
X �� �n� �
i m �Q �n'm ��'-�- �:o ai c°�iQ - ti aiN
'� �LU c„' 47��U'Z" � �� C�
'��a���m� (na�Q�O�¢om��ti
���c;a�mR p�cQOFrn��ric
oQ��°3 30�_ o�NO���CO_
I �Eoa�om °��n�, ��np_oHoOc�
m p � � c��� Zo. � c ....o �� �.¢
{ yoVlmao LLnU�Xtn��ON'JLLC
I j L�Q�� C�-
O E�- d O � O N � Q U
I. m�� °�Y Qco � m
i p=oom� �Va'��a�oUOo�N°�m
i � qao o m a�m a���iim a� a�i �
I U?�Z� r >= �oQ
I .�� Uco;m � a � o ����
j, O lL <- o_cG O E i Q LL Q�Q �.
oo=c�Urn.� � o c a� c� ct
� , OO�fA���p
�NN�'6^N� ( J(R��6)�2�0 00l
', vofl ��1rnoi� �amm m � �rn�?rn c
: r-c�a'�c'�• x a�mv--� m�.co 0
' vr�a m c cc�,m m° m�nc a�'i�... a`�i m�••
� OOfn O_OON�� �JOOQ'0��� �
ao -SS 1
i I
�
IQ �
l
Ix
M W
N I C I�
d
d U N
{�p � O
a o
<
�
O
a
K
C
O
R
�
�
�
C
d
W
C
N
u
_1
� �
�'
y
a�
a >
V U
.J Q
�
C
0
�
N "'
� "
I �, a�
F-IN
d �
m �
�IO
J I �
0 �-�
n i l� �
v �
z
C �
U �
J �
O
�
N
N
W
Q
w �O
d Q
a �
a
Q � O
� �
ti �
Q
�
Q
�
W
�
� �
m
Z J
m I
u�
U
� Z
m �'
Z "�
J
O F
a =
�
��C
I�
O
U
N �
� �
N
N
�p
a
W o
N �
c a
— N
W
O
O
I
�
7
�z
v
ip �
a N
N
I� O
� u'
�� N
- m
���
i� I�
Z U
�
j� Z
a
V ��
� �
1 c��6 U
3 Q
IC 2
�
4
�
�
Z
N
c �
O N
r
a Q,
N M
m �
� I �
m I�
�
0 m
I� �
N
n
�
w
Q
�
Z
K
�
�
n
�
� ,
� ;
i�
I � .+
>. N � U O O
.Q Q._ �p
Q'op� � � OJ ���� � �
C�'�-'m � �LL'
N 7c � 7 0 tn ��LL lj�� C (�p
I �"6N C'O � N� (6 � � OU N(�
�,, `U O m� ca°�ia��°Qtitic�-�rnp�
m � Q ai'ca �� � > ti a� a �n d o- � c�
>(� U ��q 3 R C�
I 'o���mv� mO�pZ3aaQa�U-rn
� a� �� m� cn� � Qvl�� mo�LL
Y c °� � Q..� o m o tn Q. d
i �c�m�mm p°�cQOF-rn�i�ico-m
C ��
oQ��o 30�= o�NO��mco_
n
i m p� c � � Zo. �� �o ��Q
y otn ma o t i�U ° xui ��� a 3 i �ti =
i a�t�n�� c�=�WO�a�E�m�c°'i
a c �'� � ° -� - o `oh� m o�.: Q.--
I �_ U a .. O_� V LL � mQJ
O��O`V CLLJNi/I�LLCO��f6m
i p�o o d � �U �� 3oU�M c y a3i m
� ' Ua�izUQa-oi a�m�a���tio°'�dm
i _ � �>`-' �oQ� Q �
i omcJ�E'm co omo��Qmo�xs�m
� F- LL �, O O LL O_� � Q E Q LJ.. 0�Q �
. 00'� N���O¢ �>dLL C U�0. �d�
I � NN-�'a�N� U UOO)O� `� �`o�o
d' a�
�� �p� N��.rn6�J._"6toc0 � ���...� C
Na NM�r�._. X NCO�•.• 0�.. O
v c� a m c c c� � m° m in c�o ����� �'
00(A n.00N�� �J002�OK � �
0� �SJ'
�
�I
�
0
a
x
M W
O � p
M � O
y U N
R J O
a O
�
0
G
�
C
0
m
8
�
w
d
N
C
d
c�
J
�
w
�
�
N
ti
U '�
� 4
N
al a�
F
d �
c
N O
v �
J C
�
O i
O
n �
� Z
m m
U �
� O
� 'N
W
4
��
� �¢
V �
a
L � O
W �
��
��
Z
41�
Q
N
W
�
E �
m
Z J
m F
0 S
�
U
� Z
� J
Z J
O �
d >=
7
�
C
�
O
U
� �
N
(6
0
Q
x
W o
N �
� O
�
O
�o
L
�
E
7
2
U
'a �
a "�
�
�� �
�
Ic N
m
�
�O
Z U
a �
I� Z
Q �
I � J
o Q
U
�U �
m U
3 �
C =
�
�
s
�
7
Z
N
o d
L N
a �
N �
N M
N �
G N
�N
m �
�
co
H �
^
c+J
W
Q
�
Z
Q
�
�
�
n
'
II
�
>. a��� Oo�o�
9 Q.� p
Q �p) 0 �O `� �C� � �
U � � �LL y� O Q..00 (6�
N3� C3 �y�VLL X ���M�
�'6N �C'O � N�cO � Q W pU �Nln
0 0 '� � � Q.c�S co �� o t- p � ���
� �
m�Q N'ca ��
octiai�a=ia� m0���'Q-6Q�U�rn
� m �° `m � �aN Q�7 0� �oin Qd
Fn c> = 3 � �
cm��� ��cQOF-rn��iicQ�U
C��
oQ��o 30�_ o�NO��dco_
m p� c � � zo�� � ��Q
y �in m`°`� i pc�i oo X �'�LL y
o a o
a�.c� o_m c c �U�ul` n co � E �m Qa�i
�c°�v�'�� Q'��°`ol�°>�o�.!'°-_�
� Q�� � w�
O � � V CLLJ Nin��y Cp O� cpCO
��.ca� pU��3oU���N3m
O U�Z U O_N O �• Nm•- N��IL� Q� N 7
O(6C����(0 W O(6p��Q�p�a'j C rn
f �,o OtL n�LLO E Qu.p o,0�
o d v �>au`. � � md oa°5
NN�'Ot�CVT U t 4 ��W3�30 Om
VO� N�'�O V'ONOJ (6 NyO��� C
� ND.ulch. - ^ln...XNCOV'+-' N..�WO
� N OJ
V M�. �p C CNr, (6.-• (6�(O Nw N� (6�..
00(n0_OONa � �
Oo-SS�
F:�}
_��
:: pr��E:. _.
Complaint Num6er
00-055477
Saint Paul Police Department
Page t
ORIGINAL OFFENSE / 1NCIDENT REPORT oo -ss�
Reference CN. Pnmary oflense Date and Tme ot Report
LIQUOR LAWS, VIOLATION
03/30/2000 19:09
PnmaryReportngofficer. FELIClA D REILLY
Primary offense detad:
Prrmary squad: 7g$
Secondary repordng otficer.
O;strior WESTERN ( EASTERN DISTRICT)
Secondary offense:
Location afinddent 7�g Gf�AND AV
Name ofloca6orvbusinesr 1 /�JHITE LILY
Date s 6me otoccurence: 03/30/2pp0 16:00
Arzestmade?
Date 8 bme of arrest
POLICE PERSONNEL INVOLVED
Anestmade on view:
Atrest made on wamdnt or previous Cf�l
Weapons used 6y poGce:
Weapons used 6y suspect at ffme of anest
Pursuit engaged:
Resistance encounteied_
CHARGES (NONE)
NAMES
SUSPECT DAVIS, JESSE COLlN
3531 COLFAX AV N
MPLS
MN 55411
PhysicalDescripUon � Phones
sex MALE Neighf S-1� HairCo/or BLOND Home phone
Race WH1TE
Hispanrc
Doe 11/21/1977
Age 22
Weight 140
BuJd SLENDER
Skin
Hairrype STR,4IGHT
HairCength SHORT HAIR
Fadal Hai�
Work phone
612-521-2581
651-2939124
Physical Conditlon Employmenf'
Consdousness Occupah'on WAITER
D�ug/alcoholuse UNKNOWN
Emp�oyer WHITE LILY
CRIME SCENE DESCRIPTORS
PROPEf2N (N ON�
VEHICLE INFORMATION (NONE�
PUBLlC NARRATIVE
The White Lily Restaurant failed a routine liquor compiiance check.
NARRATIVE
On 03-30-00 Squad 795 (F. Reilly) and Squad 791 (Sgt. Ramstad) were conducting liquor compliance
checks of licensed liquor establishments in the city of St. Paui. We used an under aged checker.
We verified that the checicer was under the age of 21. We used checker #45 (DOB 07-19-8�). We
�� R3 �f
��.�:�
ComplaintNUmber
00-a55477
Saint Paul Police Department
Page 2
ORIGINAL OFFENSE I INCIDENT REPORT oo-ss�
Rehrence C.N. Pnmary offense Date and Tme ofReport
LIQUOR LAWS, VIOtAT10N 03/30/2000 19:09
took the checke�s pefsonal property and gave her buy money. The checker was tr�ined on how to
conducY the checks_ The checker was trained that she couid not lie about her age or date of birth.
T( checker h2d no form of identification to snow.
On this date at 1600 hours the checker was sent into the White Lily Res:aurant at 758 Grand Ave.
The checker was seated ai a table. The checker ordered a MGD beer. The checker was served a
bottle of MGD be�r by a waiter who was later identified as DAVIS, Jesse Colin (DOB 1 �-2�-77, of 353�
ColfaxAv. N. Mpts, MN 55411 (N}612-52'1-2581 (U1�85'1-293-9'124).
Sgt Ramstad and I were monitoring the checicer by a microphone and transmitting device thaf the
checker was wearing. The checker gave the signal that she had been served beer. We entered the
restaurant and saw the checker sitting alone at a tabie with an opened bottie of MGD beer in front of
her. Tfie checker pointed to the waiter who had served her the beer. We ide�tified ourselves to
DAVIS and we told him about the violation. DAVIS toid us that he was "in charge" and that the
manager LANG, Ghu was not on the premises. We told DAVIS that a report of the violation would be
forwarded to LIEP and that possible criminal charges would be forthcoming.
DAVIS and the bottle of MGD were photographed together. The MGD beer was leit at the restaurant.
Please distribute to:
_CHF _Hom
_Sex _D/C
_CO _Rptr
_Rob _Juv
_$llLa l ZIlCf2
_Vice _Nazco
_Oper ^ PSC
_Prop _CAU
_SN _T&A
_Lab _Rec
_F&F _Auto
_Other
_Teazn
_DAO
Law EnforcEment Buy Report Form
ao-ss�
19971089 Licanse �: 8'3595 BuyerlD Today'sDate•
_, Type oY ssles: 1.Ut!-5ALE � �'�,�
---- WH1TE LILY k�SYAU3ANY
u 58 fikAt{U AVE yy 4q �, v ,, �. B er
T. PAUL 1U5 61"?'..,.1..4 �Y 9ender. 2'rme:
'I �Male I I'--t I; � �� AM
i_��
'-- CHECKHE9E
Age I IfNoPurchaseAttemQted�ANDSIClP Z�Female '0 2�pM
; �_ ;2 TO #13
" 3. Was a security person stationed at ffie door?
6. What did you try to purchase?
a(check one; otf-sale only) h. (check one)
1 ❑ 6-pack qns
2❑ 12-pack pns
3❑6-pacK bottles
4� Quart bottle
7. Seller/server's gender.
1� Male 2 C Female
��
8. Sellerlserver's estimated age:
1❑ Budweiser l
Caors c (�lreck onel
3 Miiler 1❑Lite
4❑ Other 2� Regular ',9
so
��Less than 2'I
2 2't-30
3❑31 arolder
'10. How many people were standing in litte
behind you at the time you were at the
cash register? m
$ASS
12. What was the noise level?
Nortnal � Raised
conversation 1y\ ( voices 21� Shouting 3� 62
/�T
si
1❑Yes
� No
!F NO,
SKIP TO
#S
If yes, gender of person at door.
Male 2� � Femate
1�Admitted with no question
2❑ Admitted after sfating age
3❑ Purchased after state date of birth
4 Admitted after stating ID not on me
5 Admitted after explaining ID in car
6� Not admitted STOP HERE
�.1
9. How crowded was it7
Seatin No seatin No seating/ (�
9 g/
availabl few standing2 many standing3i�
��. Purchase attempt outcome: (checx a�l that appry)
�Purchased with no questions
Z❑Purchased aRer stating age
3❑Purchased after state date af 6irth
� Purchased after stating ID not on me
5 Purchased after explaining ID in qr
6❑No purchase
as;a
39
m
�
�3. If no purchase attempted, explain beiow: (checkone)
Ot ❑ Ctosed, out of business OS I Unsafe (exp/aiy
02 C Closed, seasonal haurs ' 09 Buyer inappropnately dressed 6 �
03 � I Ciased, limited hours 10 I Out of beer
u
04� I C:osed temporaniy (repairs, remodel, etc) 11 �id not have time to comofete
L!
OS � I Closed to public, private party 72 I Dodt (or no longer) seii alcohol
d6 L I Private club, pubiic not admitted
13 Reservations necessary
07 Unable to Iocate Ofher (specr(y) �
FPUCMDAW4Ver.t it198ttott)
License Group Comments Text
Licensee: WHITE LILY INC
�BA� WHITE LILY RESTAURANT
License #: 0083595
04/�4/2000
�D —,� �
04It4/2000 To CAO for adverse action. $500 matrix fine. CAR
03/20/2000 Failed UM aicohol compliancs check conducted by SPPD/Reilly. CN 00-055-477. Second failure. CARtOl2�/99 passed second alcohoi
compliance chedc-DL
On 3!7/99 Completed required alcohol avrareness training-DL
On �l2t/99 Failed check;'unofRcial" vraming-trafiing due?l27/99-DL
1'1859. 027187 Ph On Appn For New On Sale Wine & On Sale Malt Lic. Approved C.F. 87-�72. 050388 Ph On Request For M Intox�cating Malt Bev. Lic.
In Conj. W/On Sale Wine & Rest Lic - Layed Over For 1 Week. 05'1088 """'App'D C.F. 88-64g. 05'1689 Ph On Request For Extension Of Service Area
For 060489 From 10:00 A.M. To 5:00 P.M. To Outside Front Area Of Restau2nt- App'D C.F. 89-858. 052990 Request For Extension Of Service qre2 For
On Sale Malt To Area Adjacent To Front Of Restaurant For 060390 From 10:OOam-S:OOpm App'D Cf90-908. �21890 Ph On Appn For Renewal Of On Sale
Wine, On Sale Malt (Strong) & Reshaurant-B License App'D C.F. 90-2238. '1218g0 Ph On Renewal Appn For On Sale Wine, On Sale Malt (Strong) &
Restaurant-B License App'D C.F. 90-2238
Ob -SS �
Typf�
Stre t
S(re F
Stre �
Dire�;
{
Undm
Cny: �
1
3
�
-'- - " " - DBA �Ai1TE LILY RESTAURANT
License � �icensee � Uc. Types I Nsurence i Band l RequiremeMs �
f• Property C? Licensee C' Unofficial I Projec[FacSRator. MAftTENS,CORWNE 'x
Sireet d. 56 t Ativerse Adion Commerds
Street Name RPND �
Slreet TYpe.
Unit Ind
Ciy.
stffie:
Ward:
Dist Councif
Licensee
DBA
Seies Tax Ia:
�1�_ ....efiype
RestaWarit (E
Naft On Sele (
lNne On Sale
ense # �
DirecGOn'
Und #:
Zp: 55105 I AR4R000 To CAO for ativerse achan $500 matrix fnz
�,a'v�isey ' 3f202000 Pailed UM alcohol campliance check
' onduqetl by SPPDA2eilly. CN 00-�55-477. Secontl
________ ailure.CAR70R759pessedsecondekoholcompliance
CammeMs
�
Save
Footl
tl
p0 -SS!
-` .""'°""", "'°"a w"'.�°" �_°^ a�°�'az' DBA �N`A7E LIIY REST!
��
� � License �censee
Stre e ! Lia Types l Insuraroe ' Bond , Requiremerils �
" SUeE LicenseePdame: ELILYWC
= Dire `- DBA RE LILY RESTAUfiAM
� UnR � Seles Tax I�k 725963 Non-Profrt; r Worker's Comp; /OOiD000
' C � Y j AA Cordred Rec'0: OIDOrt7000 Aq Treming Rec'@ OAOf0000
: AA Fee Co�ectetl AW0000 Discourd Rec'd r'
�� fN"`.aE:`�^
�*�"��.:�"
°-,� .
Flnencial Holtl Rsasons
S.#�as ' : e: ��"'-{s�#iXe �Affie ; �:„:
8eckground Check Required r
license #
�'� aa;gt� -��
Save Chenaes ta Ffst�vv �
Meq License Ta. --
� � Msii To CaMact
� � License Adtlress .
i
�-Mail Invoice To ---,
r Maii Ta Cordact
- fi �icense Adtlress ,
po-ss�
P.dtlress � �K�see 1 Corrtqd 1 I�cense � Cartlholder �
� Type. t' Praperty C` �i�nsee �' UnofM1Cial r AII
�� �: 58
� StreEt Name: RqND
�� StreetType: ��
i Directiort <Aib °'.
,� UnM1 #: r
.� C2Y. <Alb
'�.; Fn8 NoGv
�' �r�=?i;•"::..•
#'RC`-.-e.m.. _�r.'..'F-°
'���e
�
�' � .5e.44,�n
F E, �
�
OR�GINA�
Presented By
Referred To
� ��
�. _����� n ��'
�
� � ��
ci� o��
[ON
� SOTA
Council File # DO � SS�
C,ieen Sheet # �. u"133 �
Committee: Date
RESOLVED, that the Licensee, White Lily, Inc. d/bla White Lily
ID No. 0083595), located at 758 Grand Avenue in Saint Paul is hereby or
$500.00 for the violation of Sale of Alcoholic Beverages to Underage P�
aurant (License
to pay a fine of
Said fine shall be paid to the Office of License, Inspections d Environmental Protection
within thirty (30) days of the adoption of this resolution by th Council and signature by the
Mayor.
This resolution and the action of the Council in is matter are based upon the facts
contained in the April 17, 2000, Notice of Violation 1 er to the licensee and the Police Repor
CN 00-055477. The licer.sea did not contest the fact oFthe violation.
Requested by Department of:
Adopted by Council
Adoption Certif' c
&y:
Approved y Mayor:
By:
Date
by Council Secretary
Date
0
By: :���W —
Form Approved b City Attor / J
�.J/ �.' //J
By: K../� /�
Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By:
GREEN SHEET
266-8710
BE ON COIRJCIL /iCiH�IDA 8Y (OATq
hme 7, 2000 - Public Hearing
TOTAL � OF SIGNATURE PAGES
mr,�rnwecroR
Oo -SS►
No � Q�-' ��o
❑ arcwnneEr ❑ arccuu
❑w.r,.�a�soa ❑.w.rr,a.a�.■.cc.a
❑wvoRlw��wtown ❑
(CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE�
Resolution conceiuing adverse acrion against all licenses held by White Lily, Inc., dba White Lily Restaurant,
758 Grand Avenue. (Uncontested)
W
PLANNING CAMMISSION
CIB CAMMITTEE
CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION
Idl,r.,��fl�^�
Cau��s��l �3������,h C��fPr
�1�
dTAGES IF APPROVED
�RAGES IF NOT APPROVED
NOUNT OF TRANSACTION
SOURCE
wFOw.unorv �ocPwM
RSONILLSERVICE CONTRACIS MUSTANSWERiNE FOLLAWIN6 QUESiIONS:
FWs this F���m everwaked under a conkact torthis UepaihnerA?
YES NO
tias Nic pe�eonlfiim ever Deen a cdY empbyce? .
VES MO
Oces thic persoMmm p� e sIdII rot rwrmaltyposaesseC by a'ry Wnerit aty empbyee7
VES Nb
Is ttiia pneoNfi�m a tmpeted veiMM ,
YES NO '
dein all ves ar�aNets an seParate shee[ aM attach to ➢rcen sheet �
COST/REVENUE BUDIiETED (CIRCLE ON�
ACTNITY NUMBER
VES NO _
OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY �b � t�� �
Clnyvon M. Robinson, Jc, C?l}' Allorney .l
sa
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Norm Coleman, Mayor
May 26, 2000
C!V(I DIL'%5f0)f
400 Ciry Hn[[
IS Wut Ke[fog� Blvd.
Saint Paul, Minnesotn 55l01
NOTICE OF WITHDRAWAL FROM COUNCIL HEARING
Owner/Manager
Telephone: 651266-87/0
Facs[mile: 657 ?98-i619
� R�ar�h GF�ter
White Lily Restaurant
758 Grand Avenue �y�Y � �
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55105 � �
Re: All licenses held by White Lily, Inc. d/b/a White Lily Restaurant, for the premises at 758
Grand Avenue in St. Paul
License ID No.:0083595
Dear Sir/Madam:
Since you have now paid the recommended fine identified in the
ir,fuuivU iette� we are
June 7, 2000.
If you have any
call me at 266-8710.
Very hvly yours,
C� i
� � ' L �/Z�.
Peter P. Pangborn
Legal Assistant
matter
9, 2000, NOTICE OF
council a�enda for
cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary
Robert Kessler, Director of LIEP
Christine Rozek, Deputy Director of LIEP
Eilen Biales, Executive Director, Summit Hill Association, 860 St. Clair Ave., St. Paul,
MN 55108
UNCONTESTED LICENSE MATTER °°-SS�
Licensee Name:
Address:
Council Date:
White Lily, Inc. d/b/a White Lily Restaurant
758 Grand Avenue
June 7, 2000
Violation: Sale of Alcohol to an Underage Person
Minn. Stat. § 304A.503 (1994)
St. Pau1 Legislative Code § 409.08
Date of Violation: March 30, 2000
Place:
Presumptive Penalty:
$500.00 Fine
Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office
of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection:
$500.00 Fine
Attachments:
1. Proposed resolution
2. Notice of Violation
3. License Information Report
4. Police Report CN 00-055477
5. Law Enforcement Buy Report Form
Licensed Premises
6. License information
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Norm Colemnn, Mn}�or
�flY 9� z���
NOTICE OF COUI�TCIL HEARING
Owner/Manager
White Lily Restaurant
758 Grand Avenue
�id'.� �e2�3?U�'! �8^,vT
MAY 1 � 20Q0
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55105 , , � � , , _ ,_,. ., ,
Re: All licenses held by White Lily, Inc. d/b/a White Lily Restaurant, for the premises at 758
Grand Avenue in St. Paul
License ID No.:0083595
Dear Sir/Madam:
Please take notice that a hearing concerning the licenses for the establishment identified above
has been scheduled for 5:30 p.m., Wednesday, June 7, 2000 in the City Council Chambers,
Third Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse.
Enclosed are copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to
the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested matter, in that the facts
conceming the sale of alcohol to an under age person have not been denied. You will have an
opportunity at the Council hearing to present oral and/or written remarks as to the penalty, if any,
to be imposed. The recommendation of the license office will be for a$500.00 fine.
If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710.
Very truly yours,
� ���
��
Virginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attomey
cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary
Robert Kessler, Director of LIEP
Christine Rozek, Deputy Director of LIEP
Ellen Biales, Executive Director, Summit Hill Association, 860 St. Clair Ave., St. Paul,
MN 55108
OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY
Clnpton M. Robinson. Jr, Ciry� Attorney C��rs'
Civi[Dirision
400 Ciry� Hn!! Telephone: 65I 266-37/0
/SWestKeltoggBh�A. Fncsinrile:6�1298-56/9
Saint Pnul, hlinxesotn 5510?
OFFIC� 7F THE CITY ATTORNEY
Clayton �. .obinson, 7r., Ciry ASOrney
SAlNT
vwuc
�
Al1AA
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Norm Colem¢n, �41a}•or
E��JIll 17� 2���
Civit Divisian
400 Ciry Ha11
ZS iYest Kellagg Blvd
Saint Por�l, hlinnesota 55102
NOTICE OF VIOLATION
OwnerManager
White Lily Restaurant
758 Grand Avenue
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55105
Telepl:one: 65I 266-8710
Faaimite: 65l 298-5679
Re: All Licenses held by White Lily, Inc, d/b/a White Lily Restaurant, for the premises at 758
Grand Avenue in St. Paul
License ID No.:0083595
Dear Sir/Madam:
The Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection (LTEP) has
recommended adverse action a�ainst the licenses held by White Lily, Inc. d/b/a White Lily
Restaurant at the above location. This recommendation is based on the following information:
On March 20, 2000 an 18-year old female entered the premises
of White Lily Restaurant at 758 Grand Avenue as part of a
compliance check. The young woman was able to purchase
beer without being asked for any proof of age. Sale of alcohol
to an underage person is a violation of Minn. Stat. §340A.503,
subd. 2(1) and Saint Paul Legislative Code §409.08, subd. (2)a.
Since this is considered a first violation, the licensing office will recommend a$500.00 fine,
pursuant to St. Paul Legislative Code §409.26.
At this time you have three options on how to proceed:
If you do not dispute the above facts and do not �vish to have a public hearing, you w�ll
need to pay the recommended fine for this violation. If this is your choice, you should
make payment direcfly to the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental
Protection, Room 300 Lowry Professional Building, 350 Saint Peter Street, Saint Paul,
Minnesota 55102. The letter should be directed to Ms. Christine Rozek. Payment of the
fine will be considered to be a waiver of the heazing to which you aze entitled.
� Page 2
White Li1y Restaurant
April 17, 2000
Oo-SSt
2. Altematively, if you do not dispute the above facts, but wish to have a public hearing
before the Saint Paul City Council, you will nezd to send me a letter �vith a statement
admittin� the violation and requestin� a hearin� by Thursday, Apr3127, 2000. The matter
will then be scheduled before the City Council for a public hearing to determine what
penalty, if any, to impose. You will have an opportunity to appeaz before the Council and
make a statement on your own behaif as to the penalty to be imposed.
If you do dispute the above facts, a hearing �vill be scheduled before an Administrative
Law Judge. At that heazing both you and the City will be able to appear and present
witnesses, evidence, and cross-examine the other's witnesses. The St. Paul City Council
will ultimately decide the case. Please let me know in writing no later than Thursday,
April 27, 2000, how you wish to proceed.
If you have not contacted me by Thursday, Apri127, 2000, I will assume that you are not
contesting the facts and �vili schedule this matter for the St. Paul City Council and have it
placed on the Consent Agenda during which no public discussion is allowed and the
recommended penalty will be imposed.
Tf you have any questions, feel free to contact me at 266-8710.
Sincerely,
�,U-�� L.�-j�.-,.�-,
Virginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attomey
cc: Robert Kessler, Director of LIEP
Christine Rozek, Deputy Director of LIEP
Ellen Biales, Executive Director, Summit Hill Association, 860 St. Ciair Ave., St. Pau1,
MN 55108
ao-sSi
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
) ss.
COUNTY OF RAMSEY
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL
JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says
that on April 18, 2000, she served the attached NOTICE OF VIOLATION
on the following named person by placing a true and correct copy
thereo£ in an envelope addressed as follows:
Owner/Manager
White Lily Restaurant
758 Grand Avenue
St. Paul, MN. 55105
(which is the last known address of said
same, with postage prepaid, in the Uni�
Minnesota. �
on) and depositing the
tes mails at Sr p�ul,
69
Subscribed and sworn to before me
this 18th day o£ April, 2000.
Notary Publ� " -- - - - ' -
°�T�F � PANGBORN
nx�rar?v w �� - rainwESOta
� �v�or�naissiow
�xPfRE: J,�N. 31. 20pg
i�
�, � i
�
i �-�
� 'W
i
o I ai °
� � lo
d IU N
07 �J �
�p O
a i ,o
u
�
0
a
z
C
0
�
e
.
w
c
m
N
L
d
U
J
�
�
�
��
a�
1��>
V U
J 4
�
m
w
d
O
IN �
Inm
a
~ G
N �p
�
�c a
� a� m
U
jJ I�
—�
° o I�
� !a l i
T I�I
� �Z ;
i
I� I�
V I�
! J , o
��N
w
¢
v °
�, Z
a�
a
i a l� o
�Jn �
z
Q
�
Q
�
W
�
� }
�
Z IJ
I m h
� _
�i
U
E �
J
O �
�_
a �
�
c
�
0
U
N
0�
�
m
0
a
w
�
c
�
�
a
�
3
Z
U
0
a
U
c
m
�
CI
N
IZ I
cl
m
n
o�
I I
V
I
N
u y
c
�
m
�
�
3
Z
N
c �
� N
� T
a a ,
N �
� �
c �
Im �
O�
�-- �
n
M
>
Q
�
Z
�
�
�
n
�
��
�
��
��w
i �� a�Q � o_o "
: Qa� J p ip `oJ d c c °» �
��� Nj� �j ON�VLL
c "O N ' C' 6 w5 N �p � OU C Nfn
I � �� �a�5cow7 `oi-O� �w
X �� �n� �
i m �Q �n'm ��'-�- �:o ai c°�iQ - ti aiN
'� �LU c„' 47��U'Z" � �� C�
'��a���m� (na�Q�O�¢om��ti
���c;a�mR p�cQOFrn��ric
oQ��°3 30�_ o�NO���CO_
I �Eoa�om °��n�, ��np_oHoOc�
m p � � c��� Zo. � c ....o �� �.¢
{ yoVlmao LLnU�Xtn��ON'JLLC
I j L�Q�� C�-
O E�- d O � O N � Q U
I. m�� °�Y Qco � m
i p=oom� �Va'��a�oUOo�N°�m
i � qao o m a�m a���iim a� a�i �
I U?�Z� r >= �oQ
I .�� Uco;m � a � o ����
j, O lL <- o_cG O E i Q LL Q�Q �.
oo=c�Urn.� � o c a� c� ct
� , OO�fA���p
�NN�'6^N� ( J(R��6)�2�0 00l
', vofl ��1rnoi� �amm m � �rn�?rn c
: r-c�a'�c'�• x a�mv--� m�.co 0
' vr�a m c cc�,m m° m�nc a�'i�... a`�i m�••
� OOfn O_OON�� �JOOQ'0��� �
ao -SS 1
i I
�
IQ �
l
Ix
M W
N I C I�
d
d U N
{�p � O
a o
<
�
O
a
K
C
O
R
�
�
�
C
d
W
C
N
u
_1
� �
�'
y
a�
a >
V U
.J Q
�
C
0
�
N "'
� "
I �, a�
F-IN
d �
m �
�IO
J I �
0 �-�
n i l� �
v �
z
C �
U �
J �
O
�
N
N
W
Q
w �O
d Q
a �
a
Q � O
� �
ti �
Q
�
Q
�
W
�
� �
m
Z J
m I
u�
U
� Z
m �'
Z "�
J
O F
a =
�
��C
I�
O
U
N �
� �
N
N
�p
a
W o
N �
c a
— N
W
O
O
I
�
7
�z
v
ip �
a N
N
I� O
� u'
�� N
- m
���
i� I�
Z U
�
j� Z
a
V ��
� �
1 c��6 U
3 Q
IC 2
�
4
�
�
Z
N
c �
O N
r
a Q,
N M
m �
� I �
m I�
�
0 m
I� �
N
n
�
w
Q
�
Z
K
�
�
n
�
� ,
� ;
i�
I � .+
>. N � U O O
.Q Q._ �p
Q'op� � � OJ ���� � �
C�'�-'m � �LL'
N 7c � 7 0 tn ��LL lj�� C (�p
I �"6N C'O � N� (6 � � OU N(�
�,, `U O m� ca°�ia��°Qtitic�-�rnp�
m � Q ai'ca �� � > ti a� a �n d o- � c�
>(� U ��q 3 R C�
I 'o���mv� mO�pZ3aaQa�U-rn
� a� �� m� cn� � Qvl�� mo�LL
Y c °� � Q..� o m o tn Q. d
i �c�m�mm p°�cQOF-rn�i�ico-m
C ��
oQ��o 30�= o�NO��mco_
n
i m p� c � � Zo. �� �o ��Q
y otn ma o t i�U ° xui ��� a 3 i �ti =
i a�t�n�� c�=�WO�a�E�m�c°'i
a c �'� � ° -� - o `oh� m o�.: Q.--
I �_ U a .. O_� V LL � mQJ
O��O`V CLLJNi/I�LLCO��f6m
i p�o o d � �U �� 3oU�M c y a3i m
� ' Ua�izUQa-oi a�m�a���tio°'�dm
i _ � �>`-' �oQ� Q �
i omcJ�E'm co omo��Qmo�xs�m
� F- LL �, O O LL O_� � Q E Q LJ.. 0�Q �
. 00'� N���O¢ �>dLL C U�0. �d�
I � NN-�'a�N� U UOO)O� `� �`o�o
d' a�
�� �p� N��.rn6�J._"6toc0 � ���...� C
Na NM�r�._. X NCO�•.• 0�.. O
v c� a m c c c� � m° m in c�o ����� �'
00(A n.00N�� �J002�OK � �
0� �SJ'
�
�I
�
0
a
x
M W
O � p
M � O
y U N
R J O
a O
�
0
G
�
C
0
m
8
�
w
d
N
C
d
c�
J
�
w
�
�
N
ti
U '�
� 4
N
al a�
F
d �
c
N O
v �
J C
�
O i
O
n �
� Z
m m
U �
� O
� 'N
W
4
��
� �¢
V �
a
L � O
W �
��
��
Z
41�
Q
N
W
�
E �
m
Z J
m F
0 S
�
U
� Z
� J
Z J
O �
d >=
7
�
C
�
O
U
� �
N
(6
0
Q
x
W o
N �
� O
�
O
�o
L
�
E
7
2
U
'a �
a "�
�
�� �
�
Ic N
m
�
�O
Z U
a �
I� Z
Q �
I � J
o Q
U
�U �
m U
3 �
C =
�
�
s
�
7
Z
N
o d
L N
a �
N �
N M
N �
G N
�N
m �
�
co
H �
^
c+J
W
Q
�
Z
Q
�
�
�
n
'
II
�
>. a��� Oo�o�
9 Q.� p
Q �p) 0 �O `� �C� � �
U � � �LL y� O Q..00 (6�
N3� C3 �y�VLL X ���M�
�'6N �C'O � N�cO � Q W pU �Nln
0 0 '� � � Q.c�S co �� o t- p � ���
� �
m�Q N'ca ��
octiai�a=ia� m0���'Q-6Q�U�rn
� m �° `m � �aN Q�7 0� �oin Qd
Fn c> = 3 � �
cm��� ��cQOF-rn��iicQ�U
C��
oQ��o 30�_ o�NO��dco_
m p� c � � zo�� � ��Q
y �in m`°`� i pc�i oo X �'�LL y
o a o
a�.c� o_m c c �U�ul` n co � E �m Qa�i
�c°�v�'�� Q'��°`ol�°>�o�.!'°-_�
� Q�� � w�
O � � V CLLJ Nin��y Cp O� cpCO
��.ca� pU��3oU���N3m
O U�Z U O_N O �• Nm•- N��IL� Q� N 7
O(6C����(0 W O(6p��Q�p�a'j C rn
f �,o OtL n�LLO E Qu.p o,0�
o d v �>au`. � � md oa°5
NN�'Ot�CVT U t 4 ��W3�30 Om
VO� N�'�O V'ONOJ (6 NyO��� C
� ND.ulch. - ^ln...XNCOV'+-' N..�WO
� N OJ
V M�. �p C CNr, (6.-• (6�(O Nw N� (6�..
00(n0_OONa � �
Oo-SS�
F:�}
_��
:: pr��E:. _.
Complaint Num6er
00-055477
Saint Paul Police Department
Page t
ORIGINAL OFFENSE / 1NCIDENT REPORT oo -ss�
Reference CN. Pnmary oflense Date and Tme ot Report
LIQUOR LAWS, VIOLATION
03/30/2000 19:09
PnmaryReportngofficer. FELIClA D REILLY
Primary offense detad:
Prrmary squad: 7g$
Secondary repordng otficer.
O;strior WESTERN ( EASTERN DISTRICT)
Secondary offense:
Location afinddent 7�g Gf�AND AV
Name ofloca6orvbusinesr 1 /�JHITE LILY
Date s 6me otoccurence: 03/30/2pp0 16:00
Arzestmade?
Date 8 bme of arrest
POLICE PERSONNEL INVOLVED
Anestmade on view:
Atrest made on wamdnt or previous Cf�l
Weapons used 6y poGce:
Weapons used 6y suspect at ffme of anest
Pursuit engaged:
Resistance encounteied_
CHARGES (NONE)
NAMES
SUSPECT DAVIS, JESSE COLlN
3531 COLFAX AV N
MPLS
MN 55411
PhysicalDescripUon � Phones
sex MALE Neighf S-1� HairCo/or BLOND Home phone
Race WH1TE
Hispanrc
Doe 11/21/1977
Age 22
Weight 140
BuJd SLENDER
Skin
Hairrype STR,4IGHT
HairCength SHORT HAIR
Fadal Hai�
Work phone
612-521-2581
651-2939124
Physical Conditlon Employmenf'
Consdousness Occupah'on WAITER
D�ug/alcoholuse UNKNOWN
Emp�oyer WHITE LILY
CRIME SCENE DESCRIPTORS
PROPEf2N (N ON�
VEHICLE INFORMATION (NONE�
PUBLlC NARRATIVE
The White Lily Restaurant failed a routine liquor compiiance check.
NARRATIVE
On 03-30-00 Squad 795 (F. Reilly) and Squad 791 (Sgt. Ramstad) were conducting liquor compliance
checks of licensed liquor establishments in the city of St. Paui. We used an under aged checker.
We verified that the checicer was under the age of 21. We used checker #45 (DOB 07-19-8�). We
�� R3 �f
��.�:�
ComplaintNUmber
00-a55477
Saint Paul Police Department
Page 2
ORIGINAL OFFENSE I INCIDENT REPORT oo-ss�
Rehrence C.N. Pnmary offense Date and Tme ofReport
LIQUOR LAWS, VIOtAT10N 03/30/2000 19:09
took the checke�s pefsonal property and gave her buy money. The checker was tr�ined on how to
conducY the checks_ The checker was trained that she couid not lie about her age or date of birth.
T( checker h2d no form of identification to snow.
On this date at 1600 hours the checker was sent into the White Lily Res:aurant at 758 Grand Ave.
The checker was seated ai a table. The checker ordered a MGD beer. The checker was served a
bottle of MGD be�r by a waiter who was later identified as DAVIS, Jesse Colin (DOB 1 �-2�-77, of 353�
ColfaxAv. N. Mpts, MN 55411 (N}612-52'1-2581 (U1�85'1-293-9'124).
Sgt Ramstad and I were monitoring the checicer by a microphone and transmitting device thaf the
checker was wearing. The checker gave the signal that she had been served beer. We entered the
restaurant and saw the checker sitting alone at a tabie with an opened bottie of MGD beer in front of
her. Tfie checker pointed to the waiter who had served her the beer. We ide�tified ourselves to
DAVIS and we told him about the violation. DAVIS toid us that he was "in charge" and that the
manager LANG, Ghu was not on the premises. We told DAVIS that a report of the violation would be
forwarded to LIEP and that possible criminal charges would be forthcoming.
DAVIS and the bottle of MGD were photographed together. The MGD beer was leit at the restaurant.
Please distribute to:
_CHF _Hom
_Sex _D/C
_CO _Rptr
_Rob _Juv
_$llLa l ZIlCf2
_Vice _Nazco
_Oper ^ PSC
_Prop _CAU
_SN _T&A
_Lab _Rec
_F&F _Auto
_Other
_Teazn
_DAO
Law EnforcEment Buy Report Form
ao-ss�
19971089 Licanse �: 8'3595 BuyerlD Today'sDate•
_, Type oY ssles: 1.Ut!-5ALE � �'�,�
---- WH1TE LILY k�SYAU3ANY
u 58 fikAt{U AVE yy 4q �, v ,, �. B er
T. PAUL 1U5 61"?'..,.1..4 �Y 9ender. 2'rme:
'I �Male I I'--t I; � �� AM
i_��
'-- CHECKHE9E
Age I IfNoPurchaseAttemQted�ANDSIClP Z�Female '0 2�pM
; �_ ;2 TO #13
" 3. Was a security person stationed at ffie door?
6. What did you try to purchase?
a(check one; otf-sale only) h. (check one)
1 ❑ 6-pack qns
2❑ 12-pack pns
3❑6-pacK bottles
4� Quart bottle
7. Seller/server's gender.
1� Male 2 C Female
��
8. Sellerlserver's estimated age:
1❑ Budweiser l
Caors c (�lreck onel
3 Miiler 1❑Lite
4❑ Other 2� Regular ',9
so
��Less than 2'I
2 2't-30
3❑31 arolder
'10. How many people were standing in litte
behind you at the time you were at the
cash register? m
$ASS
12. What was the noise level?
Nortnal � Raised
conversation 1y\ ( voices 21� Shouting 3� 62
/�T
si
1❑Yes
� No
!F NO,
SKIP TO
#S
If yes, gender of person at door.
Male 2� � Femate
1�Admitted with no question
2❑ Admitted after sfating age
3❑ Purchased after state date of birth
4 Admitted after stating ID not on me
5 Admitted after explaining ID in car
6� Not admitted STOP HERE
�.1
9. How crowded was it7
Seatin No seatin No seating/ (�
9 g/
availabl few standing2 many standing3i�
��. Purchase attempt outcome: (checx a�l that appry)
�Purchased with no questions
Z❑Purchased aRer stating age
3❑Purchased after state date af 6irth
� Purchased after stating ID not on me
5 Purchased after explaining ID in qr
6❑No purchase
as;a
39
m
�
�3. If no purchase attempted, explain beiow: (checkone)
Ot ❑ Ctosed, out of business OS I Unsafe (exp/aiy
02 C Closed, seasonal haurs ' 09 Buyer inappropnately dressed 6 �
03 � I Ciased, limited hours 10 I Out of beer
u
04� I C:osed temporaniy (repairs, remodel, etc) 11 �id not have time to comofete
L!
OS � I Closed to public, private party 72 I Dodt (or no longer) seii alcohol
d6 L I Private club, pubiic not admitted
13 Reservations necessary
07 Unable to Iocate Ofher (specr(y) �
FPUCMDAW4Ver.t it198ttott)
License Group Comments Text
Licensee: WHITE LILY INC
�BA� WHITE LILY RESTAURANT
License #: 0083595
04/�4/2000
�D —,� �
04It4/2000 To CAO for adverse action. $500 matrix fine. CAR
03/20/2000 Failed UM aicohol compliancs check conducted by SPPD/Reilly. CN 00-055-477. Second failure. CARtOl2�/99 passed second alcohoi
compliance chedc-DL
On 3!7/99 Completed required alcohol avrareness training-DL
On �l2t/99 Failed check;'unofRcial" vraming-trafiing due?l27/99-DL
1'1859. 027187 Ph On Appn For New On Sale Wine & On Sale Malt Lic. Approved C.F. 87-�72. 050388 Ph On Request For M Intox�cating Malt Bev. Lic.
In Conj. W/On Sale Wine & Rest Lic - Layed Over For 1 Week. 05'1088 """'App'D C.F. 88-64g. 05'1689 Ph On Request For Extension Of Service Area
For 060489 From 10:00 A.M. To 5:00 P.M. To Outside Front Area Of Restau2nt- App'D C.F. 89-858. 052990 Request For Extension Of Service qre2 For
On Sale Malt To Area Adjacent To Front Of Restaurant For 060390 From 10:OOam-S:OOpm App'D Cf90-908. �21890 Ph On Appn For Renewal Of On Sale
Wine, On Sale Malt (Strong) & Reshaurant-B License App'D C.F. 90-2238. '1218g0 Ph On Renewal Appn For On Sale Wine, On Sale Malt (Strong) &
Restaurant-B License App'D C.F. 90-2238
Ob -SS �
Typf�
Stre t
S(re F
Stre �
Dire�;
{
Undm
Cny: �
1
3
�
-'- - " " - DBA �Ai1TE LILY RESTAURANT
License � �icensee � Uc. Types I Nsurence i Band l RequiremeMs �
f• Property C? Licensee C' Unofficial I Projec[FacSRator. MAftTENS,CORWNE 'x
Sireet d. 56 t Ativerse Adion Commerds
Street Name RPND �
Slreet TYpe.
Unit Ind
Ciy.
stffie:
Ward:
Dist Councif
Licensee
DBA
Seies Tax Ia:
�1�_ ....efiype
RestaWarit (E
Naft On Sele (
lNne On Sale
ense # �
DirecGOn'
Und #:
Zp: 55105 I AR4R000 To CAO for ativerse achan $500 matrix fnz
�,a'v�isey ' 3f202000 Pailed UM alcohol campliance check
' onduqetl by SPPDA2eilly. CN 00-�55-477. Secontl
________ ailure.CAR70R759pessedsecondekoholcompliance
CammeMs
�
Save
Footl
tl
p0 -SS!
-` .""'°""", "'°"a w"'.�°" �_°^ a�°�'az' DBA �N`A7E LIIY REST!
��
� � License �censee
Stre e ! Lia Types l Insuraroe ' Bond , Requiremerils �
" SUeE LicenseePdame: ELILYWC
= Dire `- DBA RE LILY RESTAUfiAM
� UnR � Seles Tax I�k 725963 Non-Profrt; r Worker's Comp; /OOiD000
' C � Y j AA Cordred Rec'0: OIDOrt7000 Aq Treming Rec'@ OAOf0000
: AA Fee Co�ectetl AW0000 Discourd Rec'd r'
�� fN"`.aE:`�^
�*�"��.:�"
°-,� .
Flnencial Holtl Rsasons
S.#�as ' : e: ��"'-{s�#iXe �Affie ; �:„:
8eckground Check Required r
license #
�'� aa;gt� -��
Save Chenaes ta Ffst�vv �
Meq License Ta. --
� � Msii To CaMact
� � License Adtlress .
i
�-Mail Invoice To ---,
r Maii Ta Cordact
- fi �icense Adtlress ,
po-ss�
P.dtlress � �K�see 1 Corrtqd 1 I�cense � Cartlholder �
� Type. t' Praperty C` �i�nsee �' UnofM1Cial r AII
�� �: 58
� StreEt Name: RqND
�� StreetType: ��
i Directiort <Aib °'.
,� UnM1 #: r
.� C2Y. <Alb
'�.; Fn8 NoGv
�' �r�=?i;•"::..•
#'RC`-.-e.m.. _�r.'..'F-°
'���e
�
�' � .5e.44,�n
F E, �
�
OR�GINA�
Presented By
Referred To
� ��
�. _����� n ��'
�
� � ��
ci� o��
[ON
� SOTA
Council File # DO � SS�
C,ieen Sheet # �. u"133 �
Committee: Date
RESOLVED, that the Licensee, White Lily, Inc. d/bla White Lily
ID No. 0083595), located at 758 Grand Avenue in Saint Paul is hereby or
$500.00 for the violation of Sale of Alcoholic Beverages to Underage P�
aurant (License
to pay a fine of
Said fine shall be paid to the Office of License, Inspections d Environmental Protection
within thirty (30) days of the adoption of this resolution by th Council and signature by the
Mayor.
This resolution and the action of the Council in is matter are based upon the facts
contained in the April 17, 2000, Notice of Violation 1 er to the licensee and the Police Repor
CN 00-055477. The licer.sea did not contest the fact oFthe violation.
Requested by Department of:
Adopted by Council
Adoption Certif' c
&y:
Approved y Mayor:
By:
Date
by Council Secretary
Date
0
By: :���W —
Form Approved b City Attor / J
�.J/ �.' //J
By: K../� /�
Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By:
GREEN SHEET
266-8710
BE ON COIRJCIL /iCiH�IDA 8Y (OATq
hme 7, 2000 - Public Hearing
TOTAL � OF SIGNATURE PAGES
mr,�rnwecroR
Oo -SS►
No � Q�-' ��o
❑ arcwnneEr ❑ arccuu
❑w.r,.�a�soa ❑.w.rr,a.a�.■.cc.a
❑wvoRlw��wtown ❑
(CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE�
Resolution conceiuing adverse acrion against all licenses held by White Lily, Inc., dba White Lily Restaurant,
758 Grand Avenue. (Uncontested)
W
PLANNING CAMMISSION
CIB CAMMITTEE
CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION
Idl,r.,��fl�^�
Cau��s��l �3������,h C��fPr
�1�
dTAGES IF APPROVED
�RAGES IF NOT APPROVED
NOUNT OF TRANSACTION
SOURCE
wFOw.unorv �ocPwM
RSONILLSERVICE CONTRACIS MUSTANSWERiNE FOLLAWIN6 QUESiIONS:
FWs this F���m everwaked under a conkact torthis UepaihnerA?
YES NO
tias Nic pe�eonlfiim ever Deen a cdY empbyce? .
VES MO
Oces thic persoMmm p� e sIdII rot rwrmaltyposaesseC by a'ry Wnerit aty empbyee7
VES Nb
Is ttiia pneoNfi�m a tmpeted veiMM ,
YES NO '
dein all ves ar�aNets an seParate shee[ aM attach to ➢rcen sheet �
COST/REVENUE BUDIiETED (CIRCLE ON�
ACTNITY NUMBER
VES NO _
OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY �b � t�� �
Clnyvon M. Robinson, Jc, C?l}' Allorney .l
sa
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Norm Coleman, Mayor
May 26, 2000
C!V(I DIL'%5f0)f
400 Ciry Hn[[
IS Wut Ke[fog� Blvd.
Saint Paul, Minnesotn 55l01
NOTICE OF WITHDRAWAL FROM COUNCIL HEARING
Owner/Manager
Telephone: 651266-87/0
Facs[mile: 657 ?98-i619
� R�ar�h GF�ter
White Lily Restaurant
758 Grand Avenue �y�Y � �
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55105 � �
Re: All licenses held by White Lily, Inc. d/b/a White Lily Restaurant, for the premises at 758
Grand Avenue in St. Paul
License ID No.:0083595
Dear Sir/Madam:
Since you have now paid the recommended fine identified in the
ir,fuuivU iette� we are
June 7, 2000.
If you have any
call me at 266-8710.
Very hvly yours,
C� i
� � ' L �/Z�.
Peter P. Pangborn
Legal Assistant
matter
9, 2000, NOTICE OF
council a�enda for
cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary
Robert Kessler, Director of LIEP
Christine Rozek, Deputy Director of LIEP
Eilen Biales, Executive Director, Summit Hill Association, 860 St. Clair Ave., St. Paul,
MN 55108
UNCONTESTED LICENSE MATTER °°-SS�
Licensee Name:
Address:
Council Date:
White Lily, Inc. d/b/a White Lily Restaurant
758 Grand Avenue
June 7, 2000
Violation: Sale of Alcohol to an Underage Person
Minn. Stat. § 304A.503 (1994)
St. Pau1 Legislative Code § 409.08
Date of Violation: March 30, 2000
Place:
Presumptive Penalty:
$500.00 Fine
Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office
of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection:
$500.00 Fine
Attachments:
1. Proposed resolution
2. Notice of Violation
3. License Information Report
4. Police Report CN 00-055477
5. Law Enforcement Buy Report Form
Licensed Premises
6. License information
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Norm Colemnn, Mn}�or
�flY 9� z���
NOTICE OF COUI�TCIL HEARING
Owner/Manager
White Lily Restaurant
758 Grand Avenue
�id'.� �e2�3?U�'! �8^,vT
MAY 1 � 20Q0
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55105 , , � � , , _ ,_,. ., ,
Re: All licenses held by White Lily, Inc. d/b/a White Lily Restaurant, for the premises at 758
Grand Avenue in St. Paul
License ID No.:0083595
Dear Sir/Madam:
Please take notice that a hearing concerning the licenses for the establishment identified above
has been scheduled for 5:30 p.m., Wednesday, June 7, 2000 in the City Council Chambers,
Third Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse.
Enclosed are copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to
the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested matter, in that the facts
conceming the sale of alcohol to an under age person have not been denied. You will have an
opportunity at the Council hearing to present oral and/or written remarks as to the penalty, if any,
to be imposed. The recommendation of the license office will be for a$500.00 fine.
If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710.
Very truly yours,
� ���
��
Virginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attomey
cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary
Robert Kessler, Director of LIEP
Christine Rozek, Deputy Director of LIEP
Ellen Biales, Executive Director, Summit Hill Association, 860 St. Clair Ave., St. Paul,
MN 55108
OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY
Clnpton M. Robinson. Jr, Ciry� Attorney C��rs'
Civi[Dirision
400 Ciry� Hn!! Telephone: 65I 266-37/0
/SWestKeltoggBh�A. Fncsinrile:6�1298-56/9
Saint Pnul, hlinxesotn 5510?
OFFIC� 7F THE CITY ATTORNEY
Clayton �. .obinson, 7r., Ciry ASOrney
SAlNT
vwuc
�
Al1AA
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Norm Colem¢n, �41a}•or
E��JIll 17� 2���
Civit Divisian
400 Ciry Ha11
ZS iYest Kellagg Blvd
Saint Por�l, hlinnesota 55102
NOTICE OF VIOLATION
OwnerManager
White Lily Restaurant
758 Grand Avenue
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55105
Telepl:one: 65I 266-8710
Faaimite: 65l 298-5679
Re: All Licenses held by White Lily, Inc, d/b/a White Lily Restaurant, for the premises at 758
Grand Avenue in St. Paul
License ID No.:0083595
Dear Sir/Madam:
The Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection (LTEP) has
recommended adverse action a�ainst the licenses held by White Lily, Inc. d/b/a White Lily
Restaurant at the above location. This recommendation is based on the following information:
On March 20, 2000 an 18-year old female entered the premises
of White Lily Restaurant at 758 Grand Avenue as part of a
compliance check. The young woman was able to purchase
beer without being asked for any proof of age. Sale of alcohol
to an underage person is a violation of Minn. Stat. §340A.503,
subd. 2(1) and Saint Paul Legislative Code §409.08, subd. (2)a.
Since this is considered a first violation, the licensing office will recommend a$500.00 fine,
pursuant to St. Paul Legislative Code §409.26.
At this time you have three options on how to proceed:
If you do not dispute the above facts and do not �vish to have a public hearing, you w�ll
need to pay the recommended fine for this violation. If this is your choice, you should
make payment direcfly to the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental
Protection, Room 300 Lowry Professional Building, 350 Saint Peter Street, Saint Paul,
Minnesota 55102. The letter should be directed to Ms. Christine Rozek. Payment of the
fine will be considered to be a waiver of the heazing to which you aze entitled.
� Page 2
White Li1y Restaurant
April 17, 2000
Oo-SSt
2. Altematively, if you do not dispute the above facts, but wish to have a public hearing
before the Saint Paul City Council, you will nezd to send me a letter �vith a statement
admittin� the violation and requestin� a hearin� by Thursday, Apr3127, 2000. The matter
will then be scheduled before the City Council for a public hearing to determine what
penalty, if any, to impose. You will have an opportunity to appeaz before the Council and
make a statement on your own behaif as to the penalty to be imposed.
If you do dispute the above facts, a hearing �vill be scheduled before an Administrative
Law Judge. At that heazing both you and the City will be able to appear and present
witnesses, evidence, and cross-examine the other's witnesses. The St. Paul City Council
will ultimately decide the case. Please let me know in writing no later than Thursday,
April 27, 2000, how you wish to proceed.
If you have not contacted me by Thursday, Apri127, 2000, I will assume that you are not
contesting the facts and �vili schedule this matter for the St. Paul City Council and have it
placed on the Consent Agenda during which no public discussion is allowed and the
recommended penalty will be imposed.
Tf you have any questions, feel free to contact me at 266-8710.
Sincerely,
�,U-�� L.�-j�.-,.�-,
Virginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attomey
cc: Robert Kessler, Director of LIEP
Christine Rozek, Deputy Director of LIEP
Ellen Biales, Executive Director, Summit Hill Association, 860 St. Ciair Ave., St. Pau1,
MN 55108
ao-sSi
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
) ss.
COUNTY OF RAMSEY
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL
JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says
that on April 18, 2000, she served the attached NOTICE OF VIOLATION
on the following named person by placing a true and correct copy
thereo£ in an envelope addressed as follows:
Owner/Manager
White Lily Restaurant
758 Grand Avenue
St. Paul, MN. 55105
(which is the last known address of said
same, with postage prepaid, in the Uni�
Minnesota. �
on) and depositing the
tes mails at Sr p�ul,
69
Subscribed and sworn to before me
this 18th day o£ April, 2000.
Notary Publ� " -- - - - ' -
°�T�F � PANGBORN
nx�rar?v w �� - rainwESOta
� �v�or�naissiow
�xPfRE: J,�N. 31. 20pg
i�
�, � i
�
i �-�
� 'W
i
o I ai °
� � lo
d IU N
07 �J �
�p O
a i ,o
u
�
0
a
z
C
0
�
e
.
w
c
m
N
L
d
U
J
�
�
�
��
a�
1��>
V U
J 4
�
m
w
d
O
IN �
Inm
a
~ G
N �p
�
�c a
� a� m
U
jJ I�
—�
° o I�
� !a l i
T I�I
� �Z ;
i
I� I�
V I�
! J , o
��N
w
¢
v °
�, Z
a�
a
i a l� o
�Jn �
z
Q
�
Q
�
W
�
� }
�
Z IJ
I m h
� _
�i
U
E �
J
O �
�_
a �
�
c
�
0
U
N
0�
�
m
0
a
w
�
c
�
�
a
�
3
Z
U
0
a
U
c
m
�
CI
N
IZ I
cl
m
n
o�
I I
V
I
N
u y
c
�
m
�
�
3
Z
N
c �
� N
� T
a a ,
N �
� �
c �
Im �
O�
�-- �
n
M
>
Q
�
Z
�
�
�
n
�
��
�
��
��w
i �� a�Q � o_o "
: Qa� J p ip `oJ d c c °» �
��� Nj� �j ON�VLL
c "O N ' C' 6 w5 N �p � OU C Nfn
I � �� �a�5cow7 `oi-O� �w
X �� �n� �
i m �Q �n'm ��'-�- �:o ai c°�iQ - ti aiN
'� �LU c„' 47��U'Z" � �� C�
'��a���m� (na�Q�O�¢om��ti
���c;a�mR p�cQOFrn��ric
oQ��°3 30�_ o�NO���CO_
I �Eoa�om °��n�, ��np_oHoOc�
m p � � c��� Zo. � c ....o �� �.¢
{ yoVlmao LLnU�Xtn��ON'JLLC
I j L�Q�� C�-
O E�- d O � O N � Q U
I. m�� °�Y Qco � m
i p=oom� �Va'��a�oUOo�N°�m
i � qao o m a�m a���iim a� a�i �
I U?�Z� r >= �oQ
I .�� Uco;m � a � o ����
j, O lL <- o_cG O E i Q LL Q�Q �.
oo=c�Urn.� � o c a� c� ct
� , OO�fA���p
�NN�'6^N� ( J(R��6)�2�0 00l
', vofl ��1rnoi� �amm m � �rn�?rn c
: r-c�a'�c'�• x a�mv--� m�.co 0
' vr�a m c cc�,m m° m�nc a�'i�... a`�i m�••
� OOfn O_OON�� �JOOQ'0��� �
ao -SS 1
i I
�
IQ �
l
Ix
M W
N I C I�
d
d U N
{�p � O
a o
<
�
O
a
K
C
O
R
�
�
�
C
d
W
C
N
u
_1
� �
�'
y
a�
a >
V U
.J Q
�
C
0
�
N "'
� "
I �, a�
F-IN
d �
m �
�IO
J I �
0 �-�
n i l� �
v �
z
C �
U �
J �
O
�
N
N
W
Q
w �O
d Q
a �
a
Q � O
� �
ti �
Q
�
Q
�
W
�
� �
m
Z J
m I
u�
U
� Z
m �'
Z "�
J
O F
a =
�
��C
I�
O
U
N �
� �
N
N
�p
a
W o
N �
c a
— N
W
O
O
I
�
7
�z
v
ip �
a N
N
I� O
� u'
�� N
- m
���
i� I�
Z U
�
j� Z
a
V ��
� �
1 c��6 U
3 Q
IC 2
�
4
�
�
Z
N
c �
O N
r
a Q,
N M
m �
� I �
m I�
�
0 m
I� �
N
n
�
w
Q
�
Z
K
�
�
n
�
� ,
� ;
i�
I � .+
>. N � U O O
.Q Q._ �p
Q'op� � � OJ ���� � �
C�'�-'m � �LL'
N 7c � 7 0 tn ��LL lj�� C (�p
I �"6N C'O � N� (6 � � OU N(�
�,, `U O m� ca°�ia��°Qtitic�-�rnp�
m � Q ai'ca �� � > ti a� a �n d o- � c�
>(� U ��q 3 R C�
I 'o���mv� mO�pZ3aaQa�U-rn
� a� �� m� cn� � Qvl�� mo�LL
Y c °� � Q..� o m o tn Q. d
i �c�m�mm p°�cQOF-rn�i�ico-m
C ��
oQ��o 30�= o�NO��mco_
n
i m p� c � � Zo. �� �o ��Q
y otn ma o t i�U ° xui ��� a 3 i �ti =
i a�t�n�� c�=�WO�a�E�m�c°'i
a c �'� � ° -� - o `oh� m o�.: Q.--
I �_ U a .. O_� V LL � mQJ
O��O`V CLLJNi/I�LLCO��f6m
i p�o o d � �U �� 3oU�M c y a3i m
� ' Ua�izUQa-oi a�m�a���tio°'�dm
i _ � �>`-' �oQ� Q �
i omcJ�E'm co omo��Qmo�xs�m
� F- LL �, O O LL O_� � Q E Q LJ.. 0�Q �
. 00'� N���O¢ �>dLL C U�0. �d�
I � NN-�'a�N� U UOO)O� `� �`o�o
d' a�
�� �p� N��.rn6�J._"6toc0 � ���...� C
Na NM�r�._. X NCO�•.• 0�.. O
v c� a m c c c� � m° m in c�o ����� �'
00(A n.00N�� �J002�OK � �
0� �SJ'
�
�I
�
0
a
x
M W
O � p
M � O
y U N
R J O
a O
�
0
G
�
C
0
m
8
�
w
d
N
C
d
c�
J
�
w
�
�
N
ti
U '�
� 4
N
al a�
F
d �
c
N O
v �
J C
�
O i
O
n �
� Z
m m
U �
� O
� 'N
W
4
��
� �¢
V �
a
L � O
W �
��
��
Z
41�
Q
N
W
�
E �
m
Z J
m F
0 S
�
U
� Z
� J
Z J
O �
d >=
7
�
C
�
O
U
� �
N
(6
0
Q
x
W o
N �
� O
�
O
�o
L
�
E
7
2
U
'a �
a "�
�
�� �
�
Ic N
m
�
�O
Z U
a �
I� Z
Q �
I � J
o Q
U
�U �
m U
3 �
C =
�
�
s
�
7
Z
N
o d
L N
a �
N �
N M
N �
G N
�N
m �
�
co
H �
^
c+J
W
Q
�
Z
Q
�
�
�
n
'
II
�
>. a��� Oo�o�
9 Q.� p
Q �p) 0 �O `� �C� � �
U � � �LL y� O Q..00 (6�
N3� C3 �y�VLL X ���M�
�'6N �C'O � N�cO � Q W pU �Nln
0 0 '� � � Q.c�S co �� o t- p � ���
� �
m�Q N'ca ��
octiai�a=ia� m0���'Q-6Q�U�rn
� m �° `m � �aN Q�7 0� �oin Qd
Fn c> = 3 � �
cm��� ��cQOF-rn��iicQ�U
C��
oQ��o 30�_ o�NO��dco_
m p� c � � zo�� � ��Q
y �in m`°`� i pc�i oo X �'�LL y
o a o
a�.c� o_m c c �U�ul` n co � E �m Qa�i
�c°�v�'�� Q'��°`ol�°>�o�.!'°-_�
� Q�� � w�
O � � V CLLJ Nin��y Cp O� cpCO
��.ca� pU��3oU���N3m
O U�Z U O_N O �• Nm•- N��IL� Q� N 7
O(6C����(0 W O(6p��Q�p�a'j C rn
f �,o OtL n�LLO E Qu.p o,0�
o d v �>au`. � � md oa°5
NN�'Ot�CVT U t 4 ��W3�30 Om
VO� N�'�O V'ONOJ (6 NyO��� C
� ND.ulch. - ^ln...XNCOV'+-' N..�WO
� N OJ
V M�. �p C CNr, (6.-• (6�(O Nw N� (6�..
00(n0_OONa � �
Oo-SS�
F:�}
_��
:: pr��E:. _.
Complaint Num6er
00-055477
Saint Paul Police Department
Page t
ORIGINAL OFFENSE / 1NCIDENT REPORT oo -ss�
Reference CN. Pnmary oflense Date and Tme ot Report
LIQUOR LAWS, VIOLATION
03/30/2000 19:09
PnmaryReportngofficer. FELIClA D REILLY
Primary offense detad:
Prrmary squad: 7g$
Secondary repordng otficer.
O;strior WESTERN ( EASTERN DISTRICT)
Secondary offense:
Location afinddent 7�g Gf�AND AV
Name ofloca6orvbusinesr 1 /�JHITE LILY
Date s 6me otoccurence: 03/30/2pp0 16:00
Arzestmade?
Date 8 bme of arrest
POLICE PERSONNEL INVOLVED
Anestmade on view:
Atrest made on wamdnt or previous Cf�l
Weapons used 6y poGce:
Weapons used 6y suspect at ffme of anest
Pursuit engaged:
Resistance encounteied_
CHARGES (NONE)
NAMES
SUSPECT DAVIS, JESSE COLlN
3531 COLFAX AV N
MPLS
MN 55411
PhysicalDescripUon � Phones
sex MALE Neighf S-1� HairCo/or BLOND Home phone
Race WH1TE
Hispanrc
Doe 11/21/1977
Age 22
Weight 140
BuJd SLENDER
Skin
Hairrype STR,4IGHT
HairCength SHORT HAIR
Fadal Hai�
Work phone
612-521-2581
651-2939124
Physical Conditlon Employmenf'
Consdousness Occupah'on WAITER
D�ug/alcoholuse UNKNOWN
Emp�oyer WHITE LILY
CRIME SCENE DESCRIPTORS
PROPEf2N (N ON�
VEHICLE INFORMATION (NONE�
PUBLlC NARRATIVE
The White Lily Restaurant failed a routine liquor compiiance check.
NARRATIVE
On 03-30-00 Squad 795 (F. Reilly) and Squad 791 (Sgt. Ramstad) were conducting liquor compliance
checks of licensed liquor establishments in the city of St. Paui. We used an under aged checker.
We verified that the checicer was under the age of 21. We used checker #45 (DOB 07-19-8�). We
�� R3 �f
��.�:�
ComplaintNUmber
00-a55477
Saint Paul Police Department
Page 2
ORIGINAL OFFENSE I INCIDENT REPORT oo-ss�
Rehrence C.N. Pnmary offense Date and Tme ofReport
LIQUOR LAWS, VIOtAT10N 03/30/2000 19:09
took the checke�s pefsonal property and gave her buy money. The checker was tr�ined on how to
conducY the checks_ The checker was trained that she couid not lie about her age or date of birth.
T( checker h2d no form of identification to snow.
On this date at 1600 hours the checker was sent into the White Lily Res:aurant at 758 Grand Ave.
The checker was seated ai a table. The checker ordered a MGD beer. The checker was served a
bottle of MGD be�r by a waiter who was later identified as DAVIS, Jesse Colin (DOB 1 �-2�-77, of 353�
ColfaxAv. N. Mpts, MN 55411 (N}612-52'1-2581 (U1�85'1-293-9'124).
Sgt Ramstad and I were monitoring the checicer by a microphone and transmitting device thaf the
checker was wearing. The checker gave the signal that she had been served beer. We entered the
restaurant and saw the checker sitting alone at a tabie with an opened bottie of MGD beer in front of
her. Tfie checker pointed to the waiter who had served her the beer. We ide�tified ourselves to
DAVIS and we told him about the violation. DAVIS toid us that he was "in charge" and that the
manager LANG, Ghu was not on the premises. We told DAVIS that a report of the violation would be
forwarded to LIEP and that possible criminal charges would be forthcoming.
DAVIS and the bottle of MGD were photographed together. The MGD beer was leit at the restaurant.
Please distribute to:
_CHF _Hom
_Sex _D/C
_CO _Rptr
_Rob _Juv
_$llLa l ZIlCf2
_Vice _Nazco
_Oper ^ PSC
_Prop _CAU
_SN _T&A
_Lab _Rec
_F&F _Auto
_Other
_Teazn
_DAO
Law EnforcEment Buy Report Form
ao-ss�
19971089 Licanse �: 8'3595 BuyerlD Today'sDate•
_, Type oY ssles: 1.Ut!-5ALE � �'�,�
---- WH1TE LILY k�SYAU3ANY
u 58 fikAt{U AVE yy 4q �, v ,, �. B er
T. PAUL 1U5 61"?'..,.1..4 �Y 9ender. 2'rme:
'I �Male I I'--t I; � �� AM
i_��
'-- CHECKHE9E
Age I IfNoPurchaseAttemQted�ANDSIClP Z�Female '0 2�pM
; �_ ;2 TO #13
" 3. Was a security person stationed at ffie door?
6. What did you try to purchase?
a(check one; otf-sale only) h. (check one)
1 ❑ 6-pack qns
2❑ 12-pack pns
3❑6-pacK bottles
4� Quart bottle
7. Seller/server's gender.
1� Male 2 C Female
��
8. Sellerlserver's estimated age:
1❑ Budweiser l
Caors c (�lreck onel
3 Miiler 1❑Lite
4❑ Other 2� Regular ',9
so
��Less than 2'I
2 2't-30
3❑31 arolder
'10. How many people were standing in litte
behind you at the time you were at the
cash register? m
$ASS
12. What was the noise level?
Nortnal � Raised
conversation 1y\ ( voices 21� Shouting 3� 62
/�T
si
1❑Yes
� No
!F NO,
SKIP TO
#S
If yes, gender of person at door.
Male 2� � Femate
1�Admitted with no question
2❑ Admitted after sfating age
3❑ Purchased after state date of birth
4 Admitted after stating ID not on me
5 Admitted after explaining ID in car
6� Not admitted STOP HERE
�.1
9. How crowded was it7
Seatin No seatin No seating/ (�
9 g/
availabl few standing2 many standing3i�
��. Purchase attempt outcome: (checx a�l that appry)
�Purchased with no questions
Z❑Purchased aRer stating age
3❑Purchased after state date af 6irth
� Purchased after stating ID not on me
5 Purchased after explaining ID in qr
6❑No purchase
as;a
39
m
�
�3. If no purchase attempted, explain beiow: (checkone)
Ot ❑ Ctosed, out of business OS I Unsafe (exp/aiy
02 C Closed, seasonal haurs ' 09 Buyer inappropnately dressed 6 �
03 � I Ciased, limited hours 10 I Out of beer
u
04� I C:osed temporaniy (repairs, remodel, etc) 11 �id not have time to comofete
L!
OS � I Closed to public, private party 72 I Dodt (or no longer) seii alcohol
d6 L I Private club, pubiic not admitted
13 Reservations necessary
07 Unable to Iocate Ofher (specr(y) �
FPUCMDAW4Ver.t it198ttott)
License Group Comments Text
Licensee: WHITE LILY INC
�BA� WHITE LILY RESTAURANT
License #: 0083595
04/�4/2000
�D —,� �
04It4/2000 To CAO for adverse action. $500 matrix fine. CAR
03/20/2000 Failed UM aicohol compliancs check conducted by SPPD/Reilly. CN 00-055-477. Second failure. CARtOl2�/99 passed second alcohoi
compliance chedc-DL
On 3!7/99 Completed required alcohol avrareness training-DL
On �l2t/99 Failed check;'unofRcial" vraming-trafiing due?l27/99-DL
1'1859. 027187 Ph On Appn For New On Sale Wine & On Sale Malt Lic. Approved C.F. 87-�72. 050388 Ph On Request For M Intox�cating Malt Bev. Lic.
In Conj. W/On Sale Wine & Rest Lic - Layed Over For 1 Week. 05'1088 """'App'D C.F. 88-64g. 05'1689 Ph On Request For Extension Of Service Area
For 060489 From 10:00 A.M. To 5:00 P.M. To Outside Front Area Of Restau2nt- App'D C.F. 89-858. 052990 Request For Extension Of Service qre2 For
On Sale Malt To Area Adjacent To Front Of Restaurant For 060390 From 10:OOam-S:OOpm App'D Cf90-908. �21890 Ph On Appn For Renewal Of On Sale
Wine, On Sale Malt (Strong) & Reshaurant-B License App'D C.F. 90-2238. '1218g0 Ph On Renewal Appn For On Sale Wine, On Sale Malt (Strong) &
Restaurant-B License App'D C.F. 90-2238
Ob -SS �
Typf�
Stre t
S(re F
Stre �
Dire�;
{
Undm
Cny: �
1
3
�
-'- - " " - DBA �Ai1TE LILY RESTAURANT
License � �icensee � Uc. Types I Nsurence i Band l RequiremeMs �
f• Property C? Licensee C' Unofficial I Projec[FacSRator. MAftTENS,CORWNE 'x
Sireet d. 56 t Ativerse Adion Commerds
Street Name RPND �
Slreet TYpe.
Unit Ind
Ciy.
stffie:
Ward:
Dist Councif
Licensee
DBA
Seies Tax Ia:
�1�_ ....efiype
RestaWarit (E
Naft On Sele (
lNne On Sale
ense # �
DirecGOn'
Und #:
Zp: 55105 I AR4R000 To CAO for ativerse achan $500 matrix fnz
�,a'v�isey ' 3f202000 Pailed UM alcohol campliance check
' onduqetl by SPPDA2eilly. CN 00-�55-477. Secontl
________ ailure.CAR70R759pessedsecondekoholcompliance
CammeMs
�
Save
Footl
tl
p0 -SS!
-` .""'°""", "'°"a w"'.�°" �_°^ a�°�'az' DBA �N`A7E LIIY REST!
��
� � License �censee
Stre e ! Lia Types l Insuraroe ' Bond , Requiremerils �
" SUeE LicenseePdame: ELILYWC
= Dire `- DBA RE LILY RESTAUfiAM
� UnR � Seles Tax I�k 725963 Non-Profrt; r Worker's Comp; /OOiD000
' C � Y j AA Cordred Rec'0: OIDOrt7000 Aq Treming Rec'@ OAOf0000
: AA Fee Co�ectetl AW0000 Discourd Rec'd r'
�� fN"`.aE:`�^
�*�"��.:�"
°-,� .
Flnencial Holtl Rsasons
S.#�as ' : e: ��"'-{s�#iXe �Affie ; �:„:
8eckground Check Required r
license #
�'� aa;gt� -��
Save Chenaes ta Ffst�vv �
Meq License Ta. --
� � Msii To CaMact
� � License Adtlress .
i
�-Mail Invoice To ---,
r Maii Ta Cordact
- fi �icense Adtlress ,
po-ss�
P.dtlress � �K�see 1 Corrtqd 1 I�cense � Cartlholder �
� Type. t' Praperty C` �i�nsee �' UnofM1Cial r AII
�� �: 58
� StreEt Name: RqND
�� StreetType: ��
i Directiort <Aib °'.
,� UnM1 #: r
.� C2Y. <Alb
'�.; Fn8 NoGv
�' �r�=?i;•"::..•
#'RC`-.-e.m.. _�r.'..'F-°
'���e
�
�' � .5e.44,�n
F E, �
�