The URL can be used to link to this page

00-458�� Presented By Refened To RESOLUTION CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA Council File # p � g Green Sheet # I o N 3 3;� "�I Committee: Date 1 RESOLVED, that the second hand motor vehicle dealer license application of Vahid 2 Sedeghat, d/b/a Valor Enterprises, Inc. for premises at 2336 Territorial Road is hereby denied for 3 violation of the terms of the Non-Conforming Use Pernrit. 4 5 This Resolution and the action taken above aze based upon the facts contained in the 6 March 15, 2000 Notice of Intent to Deny License letter sent to the applicant, the applicanYs 7 failure to respond or contest the allegations and such arguments as may have been presented to 8 Council at the time of the public heazing. Requested by Department of: Adopted by Council: Date ;,�-� Adoption Certified by Council Se r tasy By: Approved by Mayor: Date ,��i �S �s.FiC_J By: ��/��f/�/.� _� Form Approved b City Attorn� Bv: V Approved by Mayor for Snbmission to Council By: Attomey 266-8710 May 1, 2000 � �� ROIIfWG TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES GREEN SHEET �. 00 -YSQ' NO 1 U4� vv� u�� u��- ❑ �,.,� ❑ �� ❑ �,��.. ❑ ..,.�,�,,,� ❑wY01t1��MR1 ❑ (CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE) Resolution denying the second hand motor vehicle dealer license application by Vahid Sedeghat, dba Valor Enterprises, Inc, 2336 Territorial Road. (Uncontested) 1Dnr�orv npprove (n) w ne�ett PLANNING CAMMISSION CIB COMMITTEE CNIL SERV{CE CAMM1SSlON When, Has Nie P�Mrm ev�uwrorNed under a cont�act fof thi6 deDartmeM? YES NO Hes ihis D�M�m ever heen a dlY em7bYee4 YES P10 Does this PersoNfirm possess a slali not �wrmeiHP� bY any curreM aitY emPbv� YES NO Is this persorilfirm a tazpetetl oerMaYt YES NO �lain ali Vee an8Nef8 a1 sena2M Sheet alld aHec� to afeen Sheet IF IFAPPROVED 1��A51 AMOUNT OF TRANSACTION INFORMATON (IXPW� COST/REVENUE BUIXiETED (CIRCLE ONk7 ACTIVRY NUMBER YEE NO ✓ CITY OF SAINT PAUL Nonn Coleman, Mayor April 27, 2000 OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY y ClQytonM. Robinson, Jr., CityAttorney QO �ys( CivilDivision 400 Ciry Hall Te7ephone: 651266-8770 ISWestKel[oggBlvd Facsimile:651298-5619 Saint Paul, Minnesota Si10? NOTICE OF COUNCIL HEARING Vahid Sedeghat Valor Enterprises, Inc. 825 Cazleton Street Saint Paul, Minnesota 55124 RE: Application for Second Hand Dealer - Motor Vehicle License for the premises at 2336 Territorial Road in Saint Paul Dear Mr. Sedeghat: Please take notice that a hearing concerning the above-named establishment has been scheduled for 5:30 p.m., Wednesday, May 10, 2000 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse. Enclosed aze copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested matter, in that the facts concerning the violations of the conditions of your Nonconforming Use Pernut, and occupying a building without a Certificate of Occupancy have not been denied. You will have an opportunity at the Council hearing to present oral and/or written remarks as to the penalty, if any, to be imposed. If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710. Very truly yours, � � �� Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: Vahid Sedeghat and Lori Kaye Peterson, 8026 131�' Street, Apple Valley, vIN 55124 Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP Christine Rozek, LIEP Heather Worthington, Executive Director, St. Anthony Pazk Community Council, 890 UNCONTESTED LICENSE HEARING �O�`� Licensee Name: Inc. Address: Occupying a Building Without a Certificate of Occupancy Council Hearing Date: May 10, 2000 Violation: Violation of Restrictions on Nonconforming Use Permit: Valor Enterprises, Inc. d/b/a Valor Enterprises, 2336 7erritorial Road June 10, 1999 - 20 vehicles parked outside in violation of restriction #1 which states "No cars for sale parked on the street or outside the building." Additionally, vehicle being repaired even though there is no license to allow vehicle repair. September 14, 1999 - vehicle being repaired without a license. October 12, 1999 - vehicle being repaired without a license. Place February 15, 2000 Licensed Premises Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection: Denial of License Application Attachments: 1. Proposed resolution 2. Notice of Intent to Deny License 3. License Information Report 4. License notes 5. Violation Information / Chronology form 0 0 -�{S�' 6. Nonconforming Use Permit OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY Cloyton 4obrnson, Jc, CiryAtlorney CITY OF SAINT PAUL Norm Coleman, Mayor civit Division 400 Ciry Hal1 I S West Kellogg Blvd. Saint Paul, .{finnesola 55101 00—ySp' March 15, 2000 Telephone: 651 266-8710 Facsimile: 651298-56! 9 '1 " _ " . 9T M NOTICE OF INTENT TO DENY LICENSE Vahid Sedeghat � - 7f�;1v ValorEnterprises,Inc. �"°='_ _ - - • .. s � r�� .� � : � - 2336 Tenitorial Road " � � '` ' s '^�� °'• - , Saint Paul, MN 55114 RE: Application far Second Hand Dealer - Motor Vehicle License for 2336 Territorial Road, Saint Paul Deaz Mr. Sedeghat: The Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection has recommended denial of your application for a Second Hand Dealer - Motor Vehic�e License for the premises at 2336 Territorial Road. The basis for the recommendation is as follows: The Nonconforming Use Permit approved by the Board of Zoning Appeals which is necessary for your business to operate at 2336 Territorial Road has rivo restrictions, which are that 1) there should be no cars for sale parked on the street or outside the building; and 2) that fifteen off-street parking spaces for use by employees and customers should be provided. This permit only allows the second hand motor vehicle dealer, and does not permit auto repair on the premises. On June 10, 1999 an inspector observed individuals repairing a motor vehicle, and saw twenty other vehicles parked outside. On September 14, 1999 an inspector visited the premises and again observed auto repair being conducted, and advised the owner that they could not do auto repair without a Iicense. On October 12, 1999, a third inspection revealed auto repairs being done on the premises. On February 15, 2000, the business was tagged for occupying a building without a certificate of occupancy. Pa�e 2 Vahid Sedeghat Mazch 15, 2000 The foregoing is a basis for adverse action against your license application under Saint Paul Le�islative Code § 310.06(b)(3). Oo-yS4' If you do not dispute the above facts, please send me a letter with a statement to that effect. The matter will then be scheduled for a heazing before the St. Paul City Council to determine what penalty, if any, to impose. You will have an opportunity to appear and speak on your own behalf, or to have someone appear there for you. On the other hand, if you wish to dispute the above facts, I will schedule an evidentiary hearing before an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ). If you wish to have such a heazing, please send me a letter stating that you are contesting the facts. You will then be sent a"Notice of Hearing," so } will know when and where to appeaz, and what the basis for the hearin� will be. In either case, please let me know in writing no later than Monday, March 27, 2000, how y'ou would like to proceed. If I have not heard from you by that date, I wiil assume that }�ou are not contesting the facts. The matter will then be scheduled for the hearing before the St. Paul City Council. If you have any questions, feel free to call me or have your attorney call me at 266-8710. Sincerely, '/ �� z � `� � � Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP Christine Rozek, LIEP Heather Worthington, Executive Director, St. Anthony Park Community Council, 890 Cromwell Ave., St. Paul, MN 55114 00-45Y STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF RAMSEY AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says that on March 29, 2000, she served the attached NOTICE OF INTENT TO DENY LICENSE on the following named persons and company by placing a true and correct copy thereof in an envelope addressed as follows: Vahid Sedeghat Valor Enterprises, Inc. 2336 Territorial Road St. Paul, MN. 55124 Valor Enterprises 825 Carleton Street St. Paul, MN. 55124 Vahid Sedeghat and Lori Kaye Peterson 8026 131 Street Apple Valley, MN. 55124 (which is the last known addresses depositing the same, with postage mails at St. Pau1, Minnesota. Subscribed and sworn to before me this 29th day � Ma�, 2000. of said s and comnanvl anr3 R P. PANGSORN C • , NOTARY P[iBIJC - MINNESpTp MY CAP,tMISSIpry � � u� £XPIRES JAM. 39, 200.5 Oo-yS� � I � � n x � W O N � � � O y U N � J � R � d N N � � � O � N ul � � C C II C m N O � a R � � O c o m � H ` c � v m "A ry ❑ Q � � m N C � N � U Q J � � � N V � � J Q � � d � W '�aF- ¢ M � N � Z � w � � a � I� F I � z Z W � IQ � � .�- I� � O U C 0 N � :: m � d X W N C � a E 3 Z T� U O U C N � N C � a E � Z N C � o m t � a� y � N � � O C � � � m � i !� � � - ,�� N > .' � - � OlL O �dN Q a s �� 'o ca , 9 3a� �o=o w N�N I � T�T � Ca" � � m p � � i I J � � N,y, N � � 0 � 3 � p O p � y O N � � � l N U � U � �a c c I I wmNm cya�� i p � � � I '6 >. C T � I � II.� OQ � ' Q� N � N � N (6 Q Q.� ; N N N N I � 3 y � � N � O p 0 IC U t� y N °I =�U� a; ma C� �N U1 I �larn o� N OY Ic � � I� N Q�Q � N ... � i� NNyN p � � � � U� �in�in I L j � OI � I � V Z � N � � C Z � C m Q O � d � � Q � � 0 �(n �-- � M ZN �Z a> �� ' a�o Z W c' � W� N O Q Q' (6 x p�p �'7 C O O � � ( p �- i U p�j (6 J N I � �(O i J� a. j C (O OJ W � oo-ysr 825 Carleton 233G Territorial - same pin 292923430048 Heather I� Use Permit approced by BZA for used car sales and car detailing 5/6l99 Per applicant, they are selline vehicles, repairine (including body tic�ork) Larry (with PED/planners) is investigating the Permit and its details, then will inform the applicant of ho�a to proceed with licensing Applicants were defiant in applyin� for a city license. At approximately 4:O�pm, applicants asked Larry and Corinne how lona it �vould take for Cirv inspectors to cite them for operatina without a license because they are in operation now. Licenses required-Second Hand Dealer-Motor Vehicle, Auto Repair Gara�e, and Auto Body Repair Garage. Fire? Spraybooth requirement? 6/11/99 Per Larry Zangs, the referenced property is zoned RiVi-2. On Thursday June 10, 1999 I inspected the property and observed to individuals cvorking on a vehicle. there �vere at least 20 other vehiclzs in this space which occupies approximately southem 1/2 of the building. Many of the vehicles observed were damaged. The vehicle that the rivo men were working on was up on car hoist. There is no licenses issue to this property to do either auto repair or do autobody repair. The Pianning Commission recently granted approval to sell vehicIe with a restriction that they display the vehicles indoor. That License holder, who is also the owner of the building, �vas instructed that they could only sell vehicles not fix them at this location. When I showed the ttvo men working on the car the name of the owner, they did not recoo ize him as the man they worked . The one man( «�hite male) would not talk to me and the other man (a black male) had a language problem., so I wasn't able to get very far with the investigation. The person who is operating the auto repair business will need to go the Planning Commission for a Change of Nonconforming Use permit to operate an auto repair and auto body business. 2336 Territorial Road-PCF99-14, ZF99-016. Dr. Irving Aerman Trust, applicant, Approved to allow for indoor car sales and car detailing, subject to the following conditions: l. There should be no cars for sale parked on the street or outside the building. 2. Fifteen off-street parkin; spaces for use by employees and customers only should be provided. 09/14/99 License Inspector, Kris Schweinler, visited ]ocation to remind them of the need for a business license and ]eft her business card. Business owner (651-603-8934) spoke with Inspector and was ��ery hostile. Steve Roy did follow-up call, also very hostile. Later in the evening, Property owner contacted Kris, (612-540-9404) will �vork on the rezoning of the property and will be the mediator benveen licensing and the business owner (Valor Enterprises Inc M-F 8:30-6, Sat 9-5, Sun closed). October20, 1999 G:\USER$V�(pRTENSC\WPDATA�PROJFAC7ENFCOORD.WPD I Q ILp� N L,1j x (�r I�EcrtEfevenrh Streer rclephonr. 61242d_ Na�m Cofeman, Mcyo� ��+t Pm.l, MNYSI01 `- �"' '"-'" " Fcer-i(c 612-22d-: VIOLATION ZNFORMAm�n� l�J l�l i � 1 t. v1UL.S'1'. T�ATA Tag Nu +�+bcr: �� 3 � � l i Yi o l acor N azac: v �, } �( � D �' � pQ � Violxtion Addross: � `� � �1 �� Violatioa of Codo Scccioa: �� Violation: G��U,a�/�.NG� �. OWI�IEF/AGE�i'I' VERIFICATIOI�l Owner: J�� ,�(e,TN1=P5f-T� Owccrs fiddrcss, Ci[}•, S�itc, Zip; '�� How Do You };now? �'� /v � � lT T.;x P.a:ord: • ^ M � Acdr:ss, Cic}', Sc:�.c, Zip: '. P ec¢�s .4ddress, Ciry, Stace, Zip: Agaat Rclacions,�,ip to Ownr.: � s ia � � � Chronoiogy on b T2�TSPHCTOR'S NAME (print) . �� ) l,v� c� PHONE n":G�� /"' � D'cPARTh:s7 OF FLLE A1hD S/.F`"I'y.S�ytCc� T�.++oA�y Y FuI4r, Fv< Ovicf � oo-ys� Drvtscox oF r� a�v� - - . . Srcvcn 7<e<ard, Firc Me'nhal 1�sv�� cro x�y: o `� �a -c _�� . 11 � 3�- 5� . . I � �C�3 33 � D5 .0 s � �_r7 �c.c�--c_. O� �GGU�Y�C � ��'�" �G�� /tl{ I t�� ✓ 6Ca,� ( Q r�./� . � � �!3(� F-f /�rc � h 5 o L-�� (:�GS (GC,-"(� • /'_ —1'-LI c_ �i—. CFIROIQOLOGX (Date, Z��ion Activity, Outcome): , • oo-ys�' �� c � � r / t I - ' . . �� 1 :`l�) 7 /��1 - ic� _r.-.Yl..�-� �� •�. .li � �• �� _at -O � v� ' _. e � CITY OF SAtNT PAUL, MINNESOTA NONCONFORMlNG USE PERMtT ZONING FILE NO: APPLICANT: PURPOSE: LOCATION: 99-016 Dr. Irving Herman Trust 0 O-�LS�' Nonconforming Use Permit to 21lovr for indoor car sales and car detailing. 2336 Terriforial Road; between Carieton and Raymond. LEGALDESCRIPTION: HOWARD'SSUBDIVISIONOELOT19,HEWIl NWLY 20 FT OF CHARLES AVE VAC ADJ AND FO� LOT 9 AND SELY 40 FT OF LOT 8 AND TNAT PART OF LOT 90 NELY OF kND ADJ LOT 9 AND ABOVE DESC PART OF LOT 8 ZONING COMMITTEE ACTION: PLANNWG COMMISSION ACTION: CONDITIONS OF THIS PERMI7: Recommended approvai wlconditions Approval w/conditions 1. There should be no cars for sale parked on the street or outside fhe building. 2. Fifteen off-street parking spaces for use by employees and customers only should be provided. APPROVED BY: Litton Field, Commission Chairperson I, the undersigned Secretary to the Zoning Committee of the Planning Commission for City of Saint Paui, Minnesota, do hereby certify that I have compared the foregoing copy with the original record in my office; and find the same to be a true and correct copy of said origina( and of the whole thereof, as based on minutes of the Saint Pau( Planning Commission meeting heid on February 18, 1999, and on record in the Saint Paul Planning Office, 25 West Fourth Sireet, Sa+nt Paul, Minnesota. This permit wiU expire one year from the dafe of approval if the use heretn permitted is noi established. 7he decision to grant this permitby the Planning Commission is an administrative action subject to appeal to the Ciry Council, Anyone affected by this action may appeal this decision by fling the appropriate application and fee at tfie Zoning Office, 140D City HallAnnex, 25 WestFourth Street. Any such appeai must befiled within 15 calendar days of the mailing date noted helow. Viotation of the conditions of this permit may result in its revocation. �A.O-/ � . //ZGA,/� �a aLY,G�J Carol A. Martineau Secretary to the Saint Paul Zoning Committee Copies to: Applica�t pr. Irving Herman Trust File No. 99-016 Zoning Administrator Wendy lane License Inspector Christine Rozek District Council 12 �� r ' .�' i � ♦ .o ��•% �1 ' � , . 1 � , ' � � ., ; + � , � � a � ' i . �1 .. i � � � � i 1 � , i1 i�' / Mailed: March 2, 1999 �� Presented By Refened To RESOLUTION CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA Council File # p � g Green Sheet # I o N 3 3;� "�I Committee: Date 1 RESOLVED, that the second hand motor vehicle dealer license application of Vahid 2 Sedeghat, d/b/a Valor Enterprises, Inc. for premises at 2336 Territorial Road is hereby denied for 3 violation of the terms of the Non-Conforming Use Pernrit. 4 5 This Resolution and the action taken above aze based upon the facts contained in the 6 March 15, 2000 Notice of Intent to Deny License letter sent to the applicant, the applicanYs 7 failure to respond or contest the allegations and such arguments as may have been presented to 8 Council at the time of the public heazing. Requested by Department of: Adopted by Council: Date ;,�-� Adoption Certified by Council Se r tasy By: Approved by Mayor: Date ,��i �S �s.FiC_J By: ��/��f/�/.� _� Form Approved b City Attorn� Bv: V Approved by Mayor for Snbmission to Council By: Attomey 266-8710 May 1, 2000 � �� ROIIfWG TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES GREEN SHEET �. 00 -YSQ' NO 1 U4� vv� u�� u��- ❑ �,.,� ❑ �� ❑ �,��.. ❑ ..,.�,�,,,� ❑wY01t1��MR1 ❑ (CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE) Resolution denying the second hand motor vehicle dealer license application by Vahid Sedeghat, dba Valor Enterprises, Inc, 2336 Territorial Road. (Uncontested) 1Dnr�orv npprove (n) w ne�ett PLANNING CAMMISSION CIB COMMITTEE CNIL SERV{CE CAMM1SSlON When, Has Nie P�Mrm ev�uwrorNed under a cont�act fof thi6 deDartmeM? YES NO Hes ihis D�M�m ever heen a dlY em7bYee4 YES P10 Does this PersoNfirm possess a slali not �wrmeiHP� bY any curreM aitY emPbv� YES NO Is this persorilfirm a tazpetetl oerMaYt YES NO �lain ali Vee an8Nef8 a1 sena2M Sheet alld aHec� to afeen Sheet IF IFAPPROVED 1��A51 AMOUNT OF TRANSACTION INFORMATON (IXPW� COST/REVENUE BUIXiETED (CIRCLE ONk7 ACTIVRY NUMBER YEE NO ✓ CITY OF SAINT PAUL Nonn Coleman, Mayor April 27, 2000 OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY y ClQytonM. Robinson, Jr., CityAttorney QO �ys( CivilDivision 400 Ciry Hall Te7ephone: 651266-8770 ISWestKel[oggBlvd Facsimile:651298-5619 Saint Paul, Minnesota Si10? NOTICE OF COUNCIL HEARING Vahid Sedeghat Valor Enterprises, Inc. 825 Cazleton Street Saint Paul, Minnesota 55124 RE: Application for Second Hand Dealer - Motor Vehicle License for the premises at 2336 Territorial Road in Saint Paul Dear Mr. Sedeghat: Please take notice that a hearing concerning the above-named establishment has been scheduled for 5:30 p.m., Wednesday, May 10, 2000 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse. Enclosed aze copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested matter, in that the facts concerning the violations of the conditions of your Nonconforming Use Pernut, and occupying a building without a Certificate of Occupancy have not been denied. You will have an opportunity at the Council hearing to present oral and/or written remarks as to the penalty, if any, to be imposed. If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710. Very truly yours, � � �� Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: Vahid Sedeghat and Lori Kaye Peterson, 8026 131�' Street, Apple Valley, vIN 55124 Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP Christine Rozek, LIEP Heather Worthington, Executive Director, St. Anthony Pazk Community Council, 890 UNCONTESTED LICENSE HEARING �O�`� Licensee Name: Inc. Address: Occupying a Building Without a Certificate of Occupancy Council Hearing Date: May 10, 2000 Violation: Violation of Restrictions on Nonconforming Use Permit: Valor Enterprises, Inc. d/b/a Valor Enterprises, 2336 7erritorial Road June 10, 1999 - 20 vehicles parked outside in violation of restriction #1 which states "No cars for sale parked on the street or outside the building." Additionally, vehicle being repaired even though there is no license to allow vehicle repair. September 14, 1999 - vehicle being repaired without a license. October 12, 1999 - vehicle being repaired without a license. Place February 15, 2000 Licensed Premises Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection: Denial of License Application Attachments: 1. Proposed resolution 2. Notice of Intent to Deny License 3. License Information Report 4. License notes 5. Violation Information / Chronology form 0 0 -�{S�' 6. Nonconforming Use Permit OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY Cloyton 4obrnson, Jc, CiryAtlorney CITY OF SAINT PAUL Norm Coleman, Mayor civit Division 400 Ciry Hal1 I S West Kellogg Blvd. Saint Paul, .{finnesola 55101 00—ySp' March 15, 2000 Telephone: 651 266-8710 Facsimile: 651298-56! 9 '1 " _ " . 9T M NOTICE OF INTENT TO DENY LICENSE Vahid Sedeghat � - 7f�;1v ValorEnterprises,Inc. �"°='_ _ - - • .. s � r�� .� � : � - 2336 Tenitorial Road " � � '` ' s '^�� °'• - , Saint Paul, MN 55114 RE: Application far Second Hand Dealer - Motor Vehicle License for 2336 Territorial Road, Saint Paul Deaz Mr. Sedeghat: The Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection has recommended denial of your application for a Second Hand Dealer - Motor Vehic�e License for the premises at 2336 Territorial Road. The basis for the recommendation is as follows: The Nonconforming Use Permit approved by the Board of Zoning Appeals which is necessary for your business to operate at 2336 Territorial Road has rivo restrictions, which are that 1) there should be no cars for sale parked on the street or outside the building; and 2) that fifteen off-street parking spaces for use by employees and customers should be provided. This permit only allows the second hand motor vehicle dealer, and does not permit auto repair on the premises. On June 10, 1999 an inspector observed individuals repairing a motor vehicle, and saw twenty other vehicles parked outside. On September 14, 1999 an inspector visited the premises and again observed auto repair being conducted, and advised the owner that they could not do auto repair without a Iicense. On October 12, 1999, a third inspection revealed auto repairs being done on the premises. On February 15, 2000, the business was tagged for occupying a building without a certificate of occupancy. Pa�e 2 Vahid Sedeghat Mazch 15, 2000 The foregoing is a basis for adverse action against your license application under Saint Paul Le�islative Code § 310.06(b)(3). Oo-yS4' If you do not dispute the above facts, please send me a letter with a statement to that effect. The matter will then be scheduled for a heazing before the St. Paul City Council to determine what penalty, if any, to impose. You will have an opportunity to appear and speak on your own behalf, or to have someone appear there for you. On the other hand, if you wish to dispute the above facts, I will schedule an evidentiary hearing before an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ). If you wish to have such a heazing, please send me a letter stating that you are contesting the facts. You will then be sent a"Notice of Hearing," so } will know when and where to appeaz, and what the basis for the hearin� will be. In either case, please let me know in writing no later than Monday, March 27, 2000, how y'ou would like to proceed. If I have not heard from you by that date, I wiil assume that }�ou are not contesting the facts. The matter will then be scheduled for the hearing before the St. Paul City Council. If you have any questions, feel free to call me or have your attorney call me at 266-8710. Sincerely, '/ �� z � `� � � Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP Christine Rozek, LIEP Heather Worthington, Executive Director, St. Anthony Park Community Council, 890 Cromwell Ave., St. Paul, MN 55114 00-45Y STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF RAMSEY AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says that on March 29, 2000, she served the attached NOTICE OF INTENT TO DENY LICENSE on the following named persons and company by placing a true and correct copy thereof in an envelope addressed as follows: Vahid Sedeghat Valor Enterprises, Inc. 2336 Territorial Road St. Paul, MN. 55124 Valor Enterprises 825 Carleton Street St. Paul, MN. 55124 Vahid Sedeghat and Lori Kaye Peterson 8026 131 Street Apple Valley, MN. 55124 (which is the last known addresses depositing the same, with postage mails at St. Pau1, Minnesota. Subscribed and sworn to before me this 29th day � Ma�, 2000. of said s and comnanvl anr3 R P. PANGSORN C • , NOTARY P[iBIJC - MINNESpTp MY CAP,tMISSIpry � � u� £XPIRES JAM. 39, 200.5 Oo-yS� � I � � n x � W O N � � � O y U N � J � R � d N N � � � O � N ul � � C C II C m N O � a R � � O c o m � H ` c � v m "A ry ❑ Q � � m N C � N � U Q J � � � N V � � J Q � � d � W '�aF- ¢ M � N � Z � w � � a � I� F I � z Z W � IQ � � .�- I� � O U C 0 N � :: m � d X W N C � a E 3 Z T� U O U C N � N C � a E � Z N C � o m t � a� y � N � � O C � � � m � i !� � � - ,�� N > .' � - � OlL O �dN Q a s �� 'o ca , 9 3a� �o=o w N�N I � T�T � Ca" � � m p � � i I J � � N,y, N � � 0 � 3 � p O p � y O N � � � l N U � U � �a c c I I wmNm cya�� i p � � � I '6 >. C T � I � II.� OQ � ' Q� N � N � N (6 Q Q.� ; N N N N I � 3 y � � N � O p 0 IC U t� y N °I =�U� a; ma C� �N U1 I �larn o� N OY Ic � � I� N Q�Q � N ... � i� NNyN p � � � � U� �in�in I L j � OI � I � V Z � N � � C Z � C m Q O � d � � Q � � 0 �(n �-- � M ZN �Z a> �� ' a�o Z W c' � W� N O Q Q' (6 x p�p �'7 C O O � � ( p �- i U p�j (6 J N I � �(O i J� a. j C (O OJ W � oo-ysr 825 Carleton 233G Territorial - same pin 292923430048 Heather I� Use Permit approced by BZA for used car sales and car detailing 5/6l99 Per applicant, they are selline vehicles, repairine (including body tic�ork) Larry (with PED/planners) is investigating the Permit and its details, then will inform the applicant of ho�a to proceed with licensing Applicants were defiant in applyin� for a city license. At approximately 4:O�pm, applicants asked Larry and Corinne how lona it �vould take for Cirv inspectors to cite them for operatina without a license because they are in operation now. Licenses required-Second Hand Dealer-Motor Vehicle, Auto Repair Gara�e, and Auto Body Repair Garage. Fire? Spraybooth requirement? 6/11/99 Per Larry Zangs, the referenced property is zoned RiVi-2. On Thursday June 10, 1999 I inspected the property and observed to individuals cvorking on a vehicle. there �vere at least 20 other vehiclzs in this space which occupies approximately southem 1/2 of the building. Many of the vehicles observed were damaged. The vehicle that the rivo men were working on was up on car hoist. There is no licenses issue to this property to do either auto repair or do autobody repair. The Pianning Commission recently granted approval to sell vehicIe with a restriction that they display the vehicles indoor. That License holder, who is also the owner of the building, �vas instructed that they could only sell vehicles not fix them at this location. When I showed the ttvo men working on the car the name of the owner, they did not recoo ize him as the man they worked . The one man( «�hite male) would not talk to me and the other man (a black male) had a language problem., so I wasn't able to get very far with the investigation. The person who is operating the auto repair business will need to go the Planning Commission for a Change of Nonconforming Use permit to operate an auto repair and auto body business. 2336 Territorial Road-PCF99-14, ZF99-016. Dr. Irving Aerman Trust, applicant, Approved to allow for indoor car sales and car detailing, subject to the following conditions: l. There should be no cars for sale parked on the street or outside the building. 2. Fifteen off-street parkin; spaces for use by employees and customers only should be provided. 09/14/99 License Inspector, Kris Schweinler, visited ]ocation to remind them of the need for a business license and ]eft her business card. Business owner (651-603-8934) spoke with Inspector and was ��ery hostile. Steve Roy did follow-up call, also very hostile. Later in the evening, Property owner contacted Kris, (612-540-9404) will �vork on the rezoning of the property and will be the mediator benveen licensing and the business owner (Valor Enterprises Inc M-F 8:30-6, Sat 9-5, Sun closed). October20, 1999 G:\USER$V�(pRTENSC\WPDATA�PROJFAC7ENFCOORD.WPD I Q ILp� N L,1j x (�r I�EcrtEfevenrh Streer rclephonr. 61242d_ Na�m Cofeman, Mcyo� ��+t Pm.l, MNYSI01 `- �"' '"-'" " Fcer-i(c 612-22d-: VIOLATION ZNFORMAm�n� l�J l�l i � 1 t. v1UL.S'1'. T�ATA Tag Nu +�+bcr: �� 3 � � l i Yi o l acor N azac: v �, } �( � D �' � pQ � Violxtion Addross: � `� � �1 �� Violatioa of Codo Scccioa: �� Violation: G��U,a�/�.NG� �. OWI�IEF/AGE�i'I' VERIFICATIOI�l Owner: J�� ,�(e,TN1=P5f-T� Owccrs fiddrcss, Ci[}•, S�itc, Zip; '�� How Do You };now? �'� /v � � lT T.;x P.a:ord: • ^ M � Acdr:ss, Cic}', Sc:�.c, Zip: '. P ec¢�s .4ddress, Ciry, Stace, Zip: Agaat Rclacions,�,ip to Ownr.: � s ia � � � Chronoiogy on b T2�TSPHCTOR'S NAME (print) . �� ) l,v� c� PHONE n":G�� /"' � D'cPARTh:s7 OF FLLE A1hD S/.F`"I'y.S�ytCc� T�.++oA�y Y FuI4r, Fv< Ovicf � oo-ys� Drvtscox oF r� a�v� - - . . Srcvcn 7<e<ard, Firc Me'nhal 1�sv�� cro x�y: o `� �a -c _�� . 11 � 3�- 5� . . I � �C�3 33 � D5 .0 s � �_r7 �c.c�--c_. O� �GGU�Y�C � ��'�" �G�� /tl{ I t�� ✓ 6Ca,� ( Q r�./� . � � �!3(� F-f /�rc � h 5 o L-�� (:�GS (GC,-"(� • /'_ —1'-LI c_ �i—. CFIROIQOLOGX (Date, Z��ion Activity, Outcome): , • oo-ys�' �� c � � r / t I - ' . . �� 1 :`l�) 7 /��1 - ic� _r.-.Yl..�-� �� •�. .li � �• �� _at -O � v� ' _. e � CITY OF SAtNT PAUL, MINNESOTA NONCONFORMlNG USE PERMtT ZONING FILE NO: APPLICANT: PURPOSE: LOCATION: 99-016 Dr. Irving Herman Trust 0 O-�LS�' Nonconforming Use Permit to 21lovr for indoor car sales and car detailing. 2336 Terriforial Road; between Carieton and Raymond. LEGALDESCRIPTION: HOWARD'SSUBDIVISIONOELOT19,HEWIl NWLY 20 FT OF CHARLES AVE VAC ADJ AND FO� LOT 9 AND SELY 40 FT OF LOT 8 AND TNAT PART OF LOT 90 NELY OF kND ADJ LOT 9 AND ABOVE DESC PART OF LOT 8 ZONING COMMITTEE ACTION: PLANNWG COMMISSION ACTION: CONDITIONS OF THIS PERMI7: Recommended approvai wlconditions Approval w/conditions 1. There should be no cars for sale parked on the street or outside fhe building. 2. Fifteen off-street parking spaces for use by employees and customers only should be provided. APPROVED BY: Litton Field, Commission Chairperson I, the undersigned Secretary to the Zoning Committee of the Planning Commission for City of Saint Paui, Minnesota, do hereby certify that I have compared the foregoing copy with the original record in my office; and find the same to be a true and correct copy of said origina( and of the whole thereof, as based on minutes of the Saint Pau( Planning Commission meeting heid on February 18, 1999, and on record in the Saint Paul Planning Office, 25 West Fourth Sireet, Sa+nt Paul, Minnesota. This permit wiU expire one year from the dafe of approval if the use heretn permitted is noi established. 7he decision to grant this permitby the Planning Commission is an administrative action subject to appeal to the Ciry Council, Anyone affected by this action may appeal this decision by fling the appropriate application and fee at tfie Zoning Office, 140D City HallAnnex, 25 WestFourth Street. Any such appeai must befiled within 15 calendar days of the mailing date noted helow. Viotation of the conditions of this permit may result in its revocation. �A.O-/ � . //ZGA,/� �a aLY,G�J Carol A. Martineau Secretary to the Saint Paul Zoning Committee Copies to: Applica�t pr. Irving Herman Trust File No. 99-016 Zoning Administrator Wendy lane License Inspector Christine Rozek District Council 12 �� r ' .�' i � ♦ .o ��•% �1 ' � , . 1 � , ' � � ., ; + � , � � a � ' i . �1 .. i � � � � i 1 � , i1 i�' / Mailed: March 2, 1999 �� Presented By Refened To RESOLUTION CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA Council File # p � g Green Sheet # I o N 3 3;� "�I Committee: Date 1 RESOLVED, that the second hand motor vehicle dealer license application of Vahid 2 Sedeghat, d/b/a Valor Enterprises, Inc. for premises at 2336 Territorial Road is hereby denied for 3 violation of the terms of the Non-Conforming Use Pernrit. 4 5 This Resolution and the action taken above aze based upon the facts contained in the 6 March 15, 2000 Notice of Intent to Deny License letter sent to the applicant, the applicanYs 7 failure to respond or contest the allegations and such arguments as may have been presented to 8 Council at the time of the public heazing. Requested by Department of: Adopted by Council: Date ;,�-� Adoption Certified by Council Se r tasy By: Approved by Mayor: Date ,��i �S �s.FiC_J By: ��/��f/�/.� _� Form Approved b City Attorn� Bv: V Approved by Mayor for Snbmission to Council By: Attomey 266-8710 May 1, 2000 � �� ROIIfWG TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES GREEN SHEET �. 00 -YSQ' NO 1 U4� vv� u�� u��- ❑ �,.,� ❑ �� ❑ �,��.. ❑ ..,.�,�,,,� ❑wY01t1��MR1 ❑ (CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE) Resolution denying the second hand motor vehicle dealer license application by Vahid Sedeghat, dba Valor Enterprises, Inc, 2336 Territorial Road. (Uncontested) 1Dnr�orv npprove (n) w ne�ett PLANNING CAMMISSION CIB COMMITTEE CNIL SERV{CE CAMM1SSlON When, Has Nie P�Mrm ev�uwrorNed under a cont�act fof thi6 deDartmeM? YES NO Hes ihis D�M�m ever heen a dlY em7bYee4 YES P10 Does this PersoNfirm possess a slali not �wrmeiHP� bY any curreM aitY emPbv� YES NO Is this persorilfirm a tazpetetl oerMaYt YES NO �lain ali Vee an8Nef8 a1 sena2M Sheet alld aHec� to afeen Sheet IF IFAPPROVED 1��A51 AMOUNT OF TRANSACTION INFORMATON (IXPW� COST/REVENUE BUIXiETED (CIRCLE ONk7 ACTIVRY NUMBER YEE NO ✓ CITY OF SAINT PAUL Nonn Coleman, Mayor April 27, 2000 OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY y ClQytonM. Robinson, Jr., CityAttorney QO �ys( CivilDivision 400 Ciry Hall Te7ephone: 651266-8770 ISWestKel[oggBlvd Facsimile:651298-5619 Saint Paul, Minnesota Si10? NOTICE OF COUNCIL HEARING Vahid Sedeghat Valor Enterprises, Inc. 825 Cazleton Street Saint Paul, Minnesota 55124 RE: Application for Second Hand Dealer - Motor Vehicle License for the premises at 2336 Territorial Road in Saint Paul Dear Mr. Sedeghat: Please take notice that a hearing concerning the above-named establishment has been scheduled for 5:30 p.m., Wednesday, May 10, 2000 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse. Enclosed aze copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested matter, in that the facts concerning the violations of the conditions of your Nonconforming Use Pernut, and occupying a building without a Certificate of Occupancy have not been denied. You will have an opportunity at the Council hearing to present oral and/or written remarks as to the penalty, if any, to be imposed. If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710. Very truly yours, � � �� Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: Vahid Sedeghat and Lori Kaye Peterson, 8026 131�' Street, Apple Valley, vIN 55124 Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP Christine Rozek, LIEP Heather Worthington, Executive Director, St. Anthony Pazk Community Council, 890 UNCONTESTED LICENSE HEARING �O�`� Licensee Name: Inc. Address: Occupying a Building Without a Certificate of Occupancy Council Hearing Date: May 10, 2000 Violation: Violation of Restrictions on Nonconforming Use Permit: Valor Enterprises, Inc. d/b/a Valor Enterprises, 2336 7erritorial Road June 10, 1999 - 20 vehicles parked outside in violation of restriction #1 which states "No cars for sale parked on the street or outside the building." Additionally, vehicle being repaired even though there is no license to allow vehicle repair. September 14, 1999 - vehicle being repaired without a license. October 12, 1999 - vehicle being repaired without a license. Place February 15, 2000 Licensed Premises Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection: Denial of License Application Attachments: 1. Proposed resolution 2. Notice of Intent to Deny License 3. License Information Report 4. License notes 5. Violation Information / Chronology form 0 0 -�{S�' 6. Nonconforming Use Permit OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY Cloyton 4obrnson, Jc, CiryAtlorney CITY OF SAINT PAUL Norm Coleman, Mayor civit Division 400 Ciry Hal1 I S West Kellogg Blvd. Saint Paul, .{finnesola 55101 00—ySp' March 15, 2000 Telephone: 651 266-8710 Facsimile: 651298-56! 9 '1 " _ " . 9T M NOTICE OF INTENT TO DENY LICENSE Vahid Sedeghat � - 7f�;1v ValorEnterprises,Inc. �"°='_ _ - - • .. s � r�� .� � : � - 2336 Tenitorial Road " � � '` ' s '^�� °'• - , Saint Paul, MN 55114 RE: Application far Second Hand Dealer - Motor Vehicle License for 2336 Territorial Road, Saint Paul Deaz Mr. Sedeghat: The Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection has recommended denial of your application for a Second Hand Dealer - Motor Vehic�e License for the premises at 2336 Territorial Road. The basis for the recommendation is as follows: The Nonconforming Use Permit approved by the Board of Zoning Appeals which is necessary for your business to operate at 2336 Territorial Road has rivo restrictions, which are that 1) there should be no cars for sale parked on the street or outside the building; and 2) that fifteen off-street parking spaces for use by employees and customers should be provided. This permit only allows the second hand motor vehicle dealer, and does not permit auto repair on the premises. On June 10, 1999 an inspector observed individuals repairing a motor vehicle, and saw twenty other vehicles parked outside. On September 14, 1999 an inspector visited the premises and again observed auto repair being conducted, and advised the owner that they could not do auto repair without a Iicense. On October 12, 1999, a third inspection revealed auto repairs being done on the premises. On February 15, 2000, the business was tagged for occupying a building without a certificate of occupancy. Pa�e 2 Vahid Sedeghat Mazch 15, 2000 The foregoing is a basis for adverse action against your license application under Saint Paul Le�islative Code § 310.06(b)(3). Oo-yS4' If you do not dispute the above facts, please send me a letter with a statement to that effect. The matter will then be scheduled for a heazing before the St. Paul City Council to determine what penalty, if any, to impose. You will have an opportunity to appear and speak on your own behalf, or to have someone appear there for you. On the other hand, if you wish to dispute the above facts, I will schedule an evidentiary hearing before an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ). If you wish to have such a heazing, please send me a letter stating that you are contesting the facts. You will then be sent a"Notice of Hearing," so } will know when and where to appeaz, and what the basis for the hearin� will be. In either case, please let me know in writing no later than Monday, March 27, 2000, how y'ou would like to proceed. If I have not heard from you by that date, I wiil assume that }�ou are not contesting the facts. The matter will then be scheduled for the hearing before the St. Paul City Council. If you have any questions, feel free to call me or have your attorney call me at 266-8710. Sincerely, '/ �� z � `� � � Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP Christine Rozek, LIEP Heather Worthington, Executive Director, St. Anthony Park Community Council, 890 Cromwell Ave., St. Paul, MN 55114 00-45Y STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF RAMSEY AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says that on March 29, 2000, she served the attached NOTICE OF INTENT TO DENY LICENSE on the following named persons and company by placing a true and correct copy thereof in an envelope addressed as follows: Vahid Sedeghat Valor Enterprises, Inc. 2336 Territorial Road St. Paul, MN. 55124 Valor Enterprises 825 Carleton Street St. Paul, MN. 55124 Vahid Sedeghat and Lori Kaye Peterson 8026 131 Street Apple Valley, MN. 55124 (which is the last known addresses depositing the same, with postage mails at St. Pau1, Minnesota. Subscribed and sworn to before me this 29th day � Ma�, 2000. of said s and comnanvl anr3 R P. PANGSORN C • , NOTARY P[iBIJC - MINNESpTp MY CAP,tMISSIpry � � u� £XPIRES JAM. 39, 200.5 Oo-yS� � I � � n x � W O N � � � O y U N � J � R � d N N � � � O � N ul � � C C II C m N O � a R � � O c o m � H ` c � v m "A ry ❑ Q � � m N C � N � U Q J � � � N V � � J Q � � d � W '�aF- ¢ M � N � Z � w � � a � I� F I � z Z W � IQ � � .�- I� � O U C 0 N � :: m � d X W N C � a E 3 Z T� U O U C N � N C � a E � Z N C � o m t � a� y � N � � O C � � � m � i !� � � - ,�� N > .' � - � OlL O �dN Q a s �� 'o ca , 9 3a� �o=o w N�N I � T�T � Ca" � � m p � � i I J � � N,y, N � � 0 � 3 � p O p � y O N � � � l N U � U � �a c c I I wmNm cya�� i p � � � I '6 >. C T � I � II.� OQ � ' Q� N � N � N (6 Q Q.� ; N N N N I � 3 y � � N � O p 0 IC U t� y N °I =�U� a; ma C� �N U1 I �larn o� N OY Ic � � I� N Q�Q � N ... � i� NNyN p � � � � U� �in�in I L j � OI � I � V Z � N � � C Z � C m Q O � d � � Q � � 0 �(n �-- � M ZN �Z a> �� ' a�o Z W c' � W� N O Q Q' (6 x p�p �'7 C O O � � ( p �- i U p�j (6 J N I � �(O i J� a. j C (O OJ W � oo-ysr 825 Carleton 233G Territorial - same pin 292923430048 Heather I� Use Permit approced by BZA for used car sales and car detailing 5/6l99 Per applicant, they are selline vehicles, repairine (including body tic�ork) Larry (with PED/planners) is investigating the Permit and its details, then will inform the applicant of ho�a to proceed with licensing Applicants were defiant in applyin� for a city license. At approximately 4:O�pm, applicants asked Larry and Corinne how lona it �vould take for Cirv inspectors to cite them for operatina without a license because they are in operation now. Licenses required-Second Hand Dealer-Motor Vehicle, Auto Repair Gara�e, and Auto Body Repair Garage. Fire? Spraybooth requirement? 6/11/99 Per Larry Zangs, the referenced property is zoned RiVi-2. On Thursday June 10, 1999 I inspected the property and observed to individuals cvorking on a vehicle. there �vere at least 20 other vehiclzs in this space which occupies approximately southem 1/2 of the building. Many of the vehicles observed were damaged. The vehicle that the rivo men were working on was up on car hoist. There is no licenses issue to this property to do either auto repair or do autobody repair. The Pianning Commission recently granted approval to sell vehicIe with a restriction that they display the vehicles indoor. That License holder, who is also the owner of the building, �vas instructed that they could only sell vehicles not fix them at this location. When I showed the ttvo men working on the car the name of the owner, they did not recoo ize him as the man they worked . The one man( «�hite male) would not talk to me and the other man (a black male) had a language problem., so I wasn't able to get very far with the investigation. The person who is operating the auto repair business will need to go the Planning Commission for a Change of Nonconforming Use permit to operate an auto repair and auto body business. 2336 Territorial Road-PCF99-14, ZF99-016. Dr. Irving Aerman Trust, applicant, Approved to allow for indoor car sales and car detailing, subject to the following conditions: l. There should be no cars for sale parked on the street or outside the building. 2. Fifteen off-street parkin; spaces for use by employees and customers only should be provided. 09/14/99 License Inspector, Kris Schweinler, visited ]ocation to remind them of the need for a business license and ]eft her business card. Business owner (651-603-8934) spoke with Inspector and was ��ery hostile. Steve Roy did follow-up call, also very hostile. Later in the evening, Property owner contacted Kris, (612-540-9404) will �vork on the rezoning of the property and will be the mediator benveen licensing and the business owner (Valor Enterprises Inc M-F 8:30-6, Sat 9-5, Sun closed). October20, 1999 G:\USER$V�(pRTENSC\WPDATA�PROJFAC7ENFCOORD.WPD I Q ILp� N L,1j x (�r I�EcrtEfevenrh Streer rclephonr. 61242d_ Na�m Cofeman, Mcyo� ��+t Pm.l, MNYSI01 `- �"' '"-'" " Fcer-i(c 612-22d-: VIOLATION ZNFORMAm�n� l�J l�l i � 1 t. v1UL.S'1'. T�ATA Tag Nu +�+bcr: �� 3 � � l i Yi o l acor N azac: v �, } �( � D �' � pQ � Violxtion Addross: � `� � �1 �� Violatioa of Codo Scccioa: �� Violation: G��U,a�/�.NG� �. OWI�IEF/AGE�i'I' VERIFICATIOI�l Owner: J�� ,�(e,TN1=P5f-T� Owccrs fiddrcss, Ci[}•, S�itc, Zip; '�� How Do You };now? �'� /v � � lT T.;x P.a:ord: • ^ M � Acdr:ss, Cic}', Sc:�.c, Zip: '. P ec¢�s .4ddress, Ciry, Stace, Zip: Agaat Rclacions,�,ip to Ownr.: � s ia � � � Chronoiogy on b T2�TSPHCTOR'S NAME (print) . �� ) l,v� c� PHONE n":G�� /"' � D'cPARTh:s7 OF FLLE A1hD S/.F`"I'y.S�ytCc� T�.++oA�y Y FuI4r, Fv< Ovicf � oo-ys� Drvtscox oF r� a�v� - - . . Srcvcn 7<e<ard, Firc Me'nhal 1�sv�� cro x�y: o `� �a -c _�� . 11 � 3�- 5� . . I � �C�3 33 � D5 .0 s � �_r7 �c.c�--c_. O� �GGU�Y�C � ��'�" �G�� /tl{ I t�� ✓ 6Ca,� ( Q r�./� . � � �!3(� F-f /�rc � h 5 o L-�� (:�GS (GC,-"(� • /'_ —1'-LI c_ �i—. CFIROIQOLOGX (Date, Z��ion Activity, Outcome): , • oo-ys�' �� c � � r / t I - ' . . �� 1 :`l�) 7 /��1 - ic� _r.-.Yl..�-� �� •�. .li � �• �� _at -O � v� ' _. e � CITY OF SAtNT PAUL, MINNESOTA NONCONFORMlNG USE PERMtT ZONING FILE NO: APPLICANT: PURPOSE: LOCATION: 99-016 Dr. Irving Herman Trust 0 O-�LS�' Nonconforming Use Permit to 21lovr for indoor car sales and car detailing. 2336 Terriforial Road; between Carieton and Raymond. LEGALDESCRIPTION: HOWARD'SSUBDIVISIONOELOT19,HEWIl NWLY 20 FT OF CHARLES AVE VAC ADJ AND FO� LOT 9 AND SELY 40 FT OF LOT 8 AND TNAT PART OF LOT 90 NELY OF kND ADJ LOT 9 AND ABOVE DESC PART OF LOT 8 ZONING COMMITTEE ACTION: PLANNWG COMMISSION ACTION: CONDITIONS OF THIS PERMI7: Recommended approvai wlconditions Approval w/conditions 1. There should be no cars for sale parked on the street or outside fhe building. 2. Fifteen off-street parking spaces for use by employees and customers only should be provided. APPROVED BY: Litton Field, Commission Chairperson I, the undersigned Secretary to the Zoning Committee of the Planning Commission for City of Saint Paui, Minnesota, do hereby certify that I have compared the foregoing copy with the original record in my office; and find the same to be a true and correct copy of said origina( and of the whole thereof, as based on minutes of the Saint Pau( Planning Commission meeting heid on February 18, 1999, and on record in the Saint Paul Planning Office, 25 West Fourth Sireet, Sa+nt Paul, Minnesota. This permit wiU expire one year from the dafe of approval if the use heretn permitted is noi established. 7he decision to grant this permitby the Planning Commission is an administrative action subject to appeal to the Ciry Council, Anyone affected by this action may appeal this decision by fling the appropriate application and fee at tfie Zoning Office, 140D City HallAnnex, 25 WestFourth Street. Any such appeai must befiled within 15 calendar days of the mailing date noted helow. Viotation of the conditions of this permit may result in its revocation. �A.O-/ � . //ZGA,/� �a aLY,G�J Carol A. Martineau Secretary to the Saint Paul Zoning Committee Copies to: Applica�t pr. Irving Herman Trust File No. 99-016 Zoning Administrator Wendy lane License Inspector Christine Rozek District Council 12 �� r ' .�' i � ♦ .o ��•% �1 ' � , . 1 � , ' � � ., ; + � , � � a � ' i . �1 .. i � � � � i 1 � , i1 i�' / Mailed: March 2, 1999