The URL can be used to link to this page

00-448Council File # C O �� ORIGINAL GreenSheet# (O�{331 RESOLUTTON CITY OF SAINT PAITL, MINNESOTA Presented By Referred To Committee: Date ra 2 RESOLVED, that the Licensee, Liquor Village, Inc. d/b/a Liquar Village (License ID 3 No. 0016242), located at 2289 Ford Pazkway in Saint Paul is hereby ordered to pay a fine of 4 $500.00 for the violation of Sale of Alcoholic Beverages to Underage Persons. 10 11 12 Said fine shall be paid to the Office of License, Inspecrions and Environmental Protection within thirty (30) days of the adoption of this resolution by the Council and signature by the Mayor. This resolution and the action of the Council in this matter are based upon the facts contained in the March 29, 2000, Notice of Violation letter to the licensee and the Police Report CN 00-045344. The licensee did not contest the facts of the violation. Requested by Depar[ment of: BY: `� � /'�� Form Approve by City Attor� B �,:�eU�— � U �.� 0-�, Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council SY: '� ��— I� ,�O . �.. . sY' Appxoved by Mayor: Date �� J t-e.LVQ By: v /� Adopted by Cotssicil: Date '� q-p Adoption Certified by Council Secr asy City Attomey 266-8710 20a0 TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES april z�, 200o I GREEN SHEET o� -yy4� No 1 �4; 31 � u �.,�,�.�.�. � �.� _ F � � CRYATTOAEY ❑ OIYMK ❑wwxnum�veFSae. ❑wtwoua�rxrc ❑ 1MldelatASM��AIIr) ❑ (CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE) Resolution conceining adverse action against the Liquor Off Sale License held by Liquor Village, Inc., 2289 Ford Parkway. (Uncontested) JDAI ION AppfoVe (A) Of HB�eC[ PLANNING COMMISSION C16 COMMITfEE CIViI SERVICE COMMISSION IFAPPROVED NOT AMOUNi OF TRANSACTION SOURCE INPoRMAT70N (IXPWM }ias this pe�coMrtn e✓erv.orketl under a corNact forMis department� vES NO Has tles G�acnfirtn ewxteen a city empbye� rES rio �oes Mis pe'sonlfiim possecs a slull not nwmallypoesessetl by any curteM city employee7 YES NO Ia this persoNfinn a farpete0 ventlaYt YES NO Nain all vec answxrs an seoa2te sheat arM attach to ➢feen sheet COST/REVENUE BUDfiETED (CIRCLE ONE) ACTNRYNUMBER YEE NO ✓ OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY C[ayton M Robiruon, Jr., Ciry Attorney Q �� y� CITY OF SAINT PAUL Norm Coleman, Mayor Apri126, 2000 OwnerlManager Liquor Village 2289 Ford Pazkway Saint Paul, Minnesota 55116 CivilDivision 400 Ciry Hall I'elephone: 651266-8710 U West Kellogg Blvd Facsimile: 651298-56l9 Saint P¢ul, Minnesom 5510? NOTICE OF COUNCIL MEETING ��;�;;� �s��ch Ga�?� ;-: `'s; � � ��'� Re: Liquor Off Sale License held by Liquor Village, Inc. d/b/a Liquar Village, for the premises at 2289 Ford Parkway in St. Pau1 License ID No.:0016242 Dear Sir/Madam: Please take notice that this matter has been set on the Consent Agenda for the Council meeting scheduled for 3:30 p.m., Wednesday, May 10, 2000 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse. Enclosed are copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested matter, in that the facts concerning the sale of alcohol to an under age person have not been denied. The recommendation of the license office will be for a$500.00 fine. If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710. Very truly yours, r �` �''u� ,-r-�- Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary Robert Kessler, Director of LIEP Christine Rozek, Deputy Director of LIEP Gayle Surcuners, Community Organizer, Highland District Council, 1978 Ford Parkway, St. Paul, MN 55116 UNCONTESTED LICENSE MATTER oo -y�4' Licensee Name: Address: Council Date: Liquor Village, Inc. d/b/a Liquor Village 2289 Ford Parkway May 10, 2000 Violation: Sale of Alcohol to an Underage Person Minn. Stat. § 304A.503 (1994) St. Paul Legislative Code § 409.08 Date of Violation: March 14, 2000 Place: Presumptive Penalty $500.00 Fine Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office of License, fnspections and Environmental Protection: $500.00 fine Attachments: 1. Proposed resolution 2. Notice of Violation 3. License Information Report 4. Police Report CN 00-045344 Licensed Premises 5. License information OFFIC F THE CITY ATTORNEY Claylon h.. dobinson, Jr., CiryAttorney aQ �I.i� r CITY OF SAINT PAUL A'orm Colem¢n, Mayor ��r March 24, 2000 Civi! Division 400 Ciry Nal! IS IYestKelloggBlvd. Saint Pau(, biinmesota 5570? NOTICE OF VIOLATION Owner/Manager Liquor Village 2289 Ford Parkway Saint Paul, Minnesota 55116 Telephone: 65! 166-8i10 Facsimile: 6 51298-5619 Re: All Licenses held by Liquor Village, Inc. d/b/a Liquor Vi11a�e, for the premises at 2289 Ford Parkway in St. Paul License ID No.:0016242 Deaz Sir/Madam: The Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection (LIEP) has recommended adverse action against the licenses held by Liquor Village, Inc. d/b/a Liquor Village at the above location. This recommendation is based on the following infonmation: On March 14, 2000 a 19-year old male entered the premises of Liquor Village at 2289 Ford Parkway as part of a compliance check. The youug man was able to purchase a six pack of Michelob Golden Draft without showing any proof of age. Sale of alcohol to an underage person is a violation of Minn. Stat. §340A.503, subd. 2(1) and Saint Paul Legislative Code §409.08, subd. (2)a. Since this is considered a first violation, the licensing office will recommend a$500.00 fine, pursuant to St. Paul Legislative Code §409.26. At this time you have three options on how to proceed: If you do not dispute the above facts and do not wish to have a public hearing, you will need to pay the recommended fine for this violation. If this is your choice, you should make payment directly to the Office of License Inspections and Environmenta3 Protection, Room 300 Lowry Professional Building, 350 Saint Peter Street, Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102. The letter should be directed to Ms. Christine Rozek. Payment of the Page 2 Liquor Village Mazch 29, 2000 fine will be considered to be a waiver of the hearing to which you aze entitled. a o -�l�t.P' 2. Alternatively, if you do not dispute the above facts, but wish to have a public hearing before the Saint Paul City Council, you will need to send me a letter with a statement admitting the violation and requesting a heazin� by Monday, April 10, 2000. The matter will then be scheduled before the City Council for a public heazing to determine what penalty, if any, to impose. You will have an opporiuniry to appear before the Council and make a statement on your own behalf as to the penalty to be imposed. If you do dispute the above facts, a hearing will be scheduled before an Administrative Law 3udge. At that hearing both you and the City will be able to appear and present witnesses, evidence, and cross-examine the other's witnesses. The St. Paul City Council will ulti�ately decide the case. Please let me know in writing no later than Monday, April 10, 2000, how you wish to proceed. If you have not contacted me by Monday, Apri110, 2000, I will assume that you are not contesting the facts and wiil schedule this matter for the St. Paul City Council and have it placed on the Consent Agenda during which no public discussion is allowed and the recommended penalty will be imposed. If you have any questions, feel free to contact me at 266-8710. Sincerely, � ��-��C��..� Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: Robert Kessler, Director of LIEP Christine Rozek, Deputy Director of LIEP Gayle Summers, Community Organizer, Highland District Council, 1978 Ford Pazkway, St. Paul, NIN 55116 0 0 -y�lP' STATE OF MINNESOTA / ss. AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL COUNTY OF RAMSEY JOANVE G_ CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says that on March 30, 2000, she served the attached NO!SCE OF VIOLATIOI3 on the following named person by placing a true and correct copy thereof in an envelope addressed as follows: Owner/Manager Liquor Village 2289 Ford Parkway St. Paul, MN. 55116 (which is the last known address of said person) and depositing the same, with postage prepaid, in the Unit ates mails at St. Paul, Minnesota. S Subscribed and sworn to before me this 30th day aL�M�rc}��000� / i� � PETER P.PANGBORN NOTARY PU811C - MINNESOTA NOtdYy Pub1iC �e� MYCAbSMISSiCNi q � EXPtRE$ dAN. 31.20� 00 - �1't.� n ��i i X M I O �n � e- � IO y V N � J � a u 0 � 0 a � C O .� � � O w C d N L d U J � 3 m �I N I� � J Q O � U aa � N � N C � U @ J�m u� O ` O � N � M 3 z U�� J � a m M �� a � �� v`O a 4rn`° W �-- N Uj W � d J J Iz � I Q � m O I� I_ � J� U Z ll.! � N Q E � z> O � b � a � J U C � O U L o �' ..�+ (6 0 Q w � C N Q � � U O a � G LJ � N C � N Z a C fl. O � U C m � N C N � � 7 Z N = O L ^ a° � N � m � N � C 3 � m� �Q F� � � � ? Y a ❑ � O � � N T 4 J � �� C N - CC 7 J �•_� vU� � y � Y U � N C U=N N N'@ m t c .0 �UW � � N R U � � C c � @� R � Ni_W_(p .��O�O� � O�UL�� M 0 O � V N p � O�U�'� j a �Um�- � (6 - p. �7 ' IL a �oo - Oa"i a�i �(6N V NU "6 �'= N �fl.'D Q � � N'6�� m (0 y� O�p � o� m ai U mm Nommmrn�U �a�rnN�o�m � � t'�'j �? C C�� O�a-WOO(`')V' �i I � i l M W O N I` N p IO d V N 0I _J � a I< 0 r C � � O R � � w C N N C d u .J N' = I �I �i �I Ni> JIQ � �� ' I N �� =I� U:j J�O' J 0 o �, m �i N E� M � zi N�V N � U - O O � � m a ui p m � a � Q � � N � W 3 � J Z 7 m O I� � J U Z W � � g m '� z> O � s � a C� J �U C � O U � r � m � a w � y o C N O N O N � � � Z U O e' d N v U � I� � N � C m 0 � Q m y Z , a � � W Q a U � z c ¢ N � N � � 4 � � � 3 Z � C O O � t 0 a� m � d � C � � � m � � N N � � � � � a n � � m � N N i „ �� I, �I � � -O J � � � U C � � C'C 3 C� y O � i �...�1 UVYN(qC Y UYJ v1 C U C N N N�(` N Q L C V:-,V�N i U � � 01 a3mc��3c N � C ( � � f0 �=� p W °- aEoo 3 v E O N U r O R U L� V T U p O U O"'LV NO � O� U C'j � a m U� a a�i ti a�oo�d ai �NN V NU ' 'a � `� �� av C ��a � m N �o� a LL �mv N i U �'�" U O T � �—� �� N p� , �p�jNNp�(p � q-- <'� N a \-- � N� �.� M V<� C C�� 0��M� o c _yyP' i'; '�, ;�i 0 I �' M 'W � � �IO M � O d V N t�p J M a L�o � O G m � 0 R � � O C d N C N v ..! N � � � d J� I � I .-� � U w UIU O �� 0 O N �I M �I ZI N (�p v � J 0 � N m � a N Q N� a � ¢m� 1 �r L.N � W � Q N � W � z ro � Q = � J U Z W N ¢ £ J Z > C O O � a � J �U C � O � � ro m � : x y c II � 3 Z U O N U C R N C N � m z a c a � 0 U u C @ � � c N � � 3 Z N � O O ^ � O a� N � N � C � � � m � � N F" � � � � d 0 � Q LL rn m N r I' �� i ; ; �� ; � ; I � ?� � 9 ...1 � I� � � � U C + ' 7 C �C 7 i i � N' �� OQ �a. � U C � i U CNNN'Q I N t � L O UW �.`+ U r � tU { � c�i � c� 3 � i � C y l4� � � i I ro� Q �@ f ' a>E�p3 v � j O� U t V � M V �_ U R U I� � � O t �� T I � � O � I �� -G O V C'j ] a I Ua��. 'i f mU. a�,y �i I Q � � V �_ � " (q W_ j I N U-p U Q� 4 N I U I I N O��MW i s�-N�ON��O�i p�j V��CC�lJQ) 07 wOOmv` ac -�t�lY' Saint Pau4 Police Qepartment [NAL OFFENSE / INCIDENT REPORT Page t oc -�k�lP' -� r � ��" �' x Pnmary oKense Date and Time of Re art ��2�!: �y: . P `�,��'��'=`?iY''` LIQUOR LAWS, VIOLATION 03/14/2000 21:28 �°F. �:..� �:�. � f'•'�!Y'�Fd�t9�/h�` ' RICHARD L WACHAL Locaoon ofinadent �$9 FORO PA Primary oXersse detad: P,^,mary sGvadr % 92 ;econcary�apomagct.`,cer. EUGENE P POLYAK c�ura: WESTERN ( PSS-V10E ) Seco.oCar� OC2nse' Pq�ICE PERSONNEL INVOLVED Arrest made on vrew: Arrest made on wa�ant ar previous CN: Wzapons use0 6y polfce: N/ea{wns used by suspect a! trme of arrest. Nameorlocacon/CUmness: LIQUOR VILLAGE Jare d ame ofoccu�ence: p3/'(4(2�0� 19:03 Arrestmade? YcS oare a nme atanesr p3/14l2000 19:04 Pursurt engaged: Ressiance encounieretl: C HAR G E S (NOtiE) i�iR��ES SUSPECT COAN, ROBERTJAMES 118� EDGECUMBE RD STPAUL MN PhysmalDescripuon Phones Sex �q�E Heignt Ha�iColo� �__ 'vVHITE We�9nt N:soarnc Budd DOB 12J16/195� Skn nge 6g Hair Type Ha«LenyKh Facfa/ Hav Hame phone 651-698-5032 Work phone 651-699-7070 Phystca! Conditlon Employment Ccnscousness CONSCIOUS Occupanon CASHIER O��q'alCOho! use Emp�oyer LIQUOR VILLAGE �R1ME SCENE DESCRIPTORS Gime Scene Ty?e RcTAIL DescRpaon MeZhod 8 Painf af EnUy Force used Po�nt ol entry Metbotl PROPER7Y (NCN�; VEHICLE INFORMATION {NONE) PUSLIC NARRATIVE Sai2 of afcohoi to an under aged person at a retail estab{ishment. , Camp'aintNrmrbe� 00-04534? LIQUOR lAWS, VIOLATION 03/14/2000 21:28 tRf2RATIVc Squad 7G2 was assigned to a liauor compliance detail in the highland Park neighborhood on the above ��a_e- ! was workino wiYh Sgt_ Polyak and utilized a person under the age of 21 years in our attempt to tes± the compliance of clerics and servers that sell aicoholic beverages in the city of St_ Paul. The person under 2'1 years reierred to as the undercover (UC) was � 42 and has a DOB of 7-2480. UC .t42 had been trained by LIEP and the SPPD Vice Unit in how to conduct himseiflherself in this operation. :,t �503 hours, we sznt the UC into Liquor Village located at 2289 Ford Parkway. He was instructed to atterd to purchase a 6 pack of beer onc2 inside. We listened to hislher activity with a body bug h2!she camed on his person. A few minutes later he/she gave us a signai with the monitor that in�icated helshe had made a purchase. We went inside aYer he/she met us at the door and aescnbed vrhat the seiler looked like. He/She aiso gave us the six pack of Michelob Golden Draff and cnange from the SS bill he was provided with. He/she said the seller was an older male at the cash register. ; Iccated that person and told him that he had jusi sold the beer to a person that was 19 years old I gave �ack the beer after it was photogr2phed by Sgt. Polyak. The party did not refute that he nad sold the beerjust moments ago. Ttie se!(er was idenlified with his Minnesota DL as: COAN, ROBERT JAMES DOB 12-�6-50. He said he never checked for ID from the UC. He went on to say: "You realize aIl the IOs I check everyday and the first 6me I dcn't check, this happens." T�'�e manager was not present and could not be advised by us in person. sv?r. Coan was advised of ihe complaint proc2ss he was about to undergo. He, along with the six pack of Michelob Goiden Draft was photographed and released at the scene. Piease disiribuie to: ____CHF _Hom _Sex _D!C ____CO l Rotr Saint Paul Police Department Page 2 OR1GiNAL OFFENSE I 1NCiDENT REPORT oc-y�,r Refi/ence CN. Pnmary ottense Date and Time ot Report ;.. _Bur; V ice �)uv _Oper ,PSC _Theic _Prop _CAU �arco SIU T&A _Lab _Rec _Team _F&F _Auto _DAO Other L icense Group Comments Text Licensee: LIQUOR VILLAGE INC �BA= LIQUOR4ILLAGE License #: 0016242 03��4/2000 Failed DPS alcohol compliance check conducted by Vice PolyaklVJachai. To CAO for adverse action. CAR � 1/17/99 passed second afcofiot comptiance check-DL 8/10/99 passed cig compliance check, 9/�4/9g letter sent SS On 2/23/99 Completed required alcohol awareness training-DL On 1/29/99 Failed check;'unofficiai' waming-training due 3/5/99-DL 4/9/96 Cig Code Added Fdld# 173t4 03/27/2000 00 -��4�' 00 —yyY Atltlress Licensee ��o� 1 License � �e��,o��, � Licensee Name� OBA (1UOR VILLAGE Saies Tax Itl' r� ,.FN,1d'�°w�+.? "��.":�a=��^��-' x s °�`�_ ; 4n;�i� '`�r. � .�.�ti ,... - ; e � ' �� t Tc..:;..�e� i �o8.�,�e"s�;; 980005000 h 698 �GEORGIA SCHEU UQUOR VILLAGE WC 00 - �{ �lY L�ce p�',� ��p� ��,�.�� Licensee IQUOft VILLAGE INC - DBA IQUOR VILLAGE DBA Sale: Lipe�se � �w¢nsee j Lic Types , Insurance ' Hond , Reqwremerrts � '�` Property �' Licensee �` UnofSpal Pro�ect Fau@ffior MARTENS, CORINNE q SYteet #: 289 ' Ativerse Action Commards ' Street Name� ORD ; Street �P}NVY Direkion: � � E� Und Ind �— Und #: � � CRY T PFUL , �m�s' �-- � r -- � --------...-. _ ..... _ . �_� . ._______._ ,, ._._� � �e� }�+�� Zn' S511 S �`03J142000 Failed DPS elcohol wmpliance check ;'tcontluctetl by Vice PolyakNVachal. To CAO for . � Wartl' 3r � �� "`� `fadverse action. � �� Dist CouncA: 75 (11 f11 i99 passed secand aicohol campliance . 4icensee. �I�UOftVILLAGEINC CammeMS: , DBA I�UOR VILLAGE -' Sales Tax Id 6&5492 Bus Phone: 65116� 1731 i; � License #�16242 - Save Changes to History au94sS Lkeasr'�ee :{ ich:. .. ; � N ( $Zp0 00: 9972259 F�. N __ i _ _ _$377 D0� � :¢ � N _ � OPI2289Fi 001 2289 R OOOj2289 Ft �� -�+'� :_ � 0002239F( 0 0 -y�tY Lroe '� ` `� q �'� �T Licensee �.IQUOR VILLAOE INC ,??Y :� FP�v¢ ct5;px „�Noc,. „swn'mx D8A IQUOR VILLRCE DBP Sale� License �icensee � Lic Types , �nsurance � Bontl 1 Requireme(rts l i Licensee Name: IOUOR VILLAGE WC Er6k;�v�' �`45:: -c:h'•�.-udd„pj ; DBA IOUOR VILIAGE +SalesTa�id. 585492 Nan-Prof&�WOrkersCwnp: N72001 '-?roper�5esfi« € AA CorQrect Rec'd 0.1aN960 AA Trairnng Rec'd 7,J0�0000 ; AA Fee Collected: 0f00N000 Discowrt ftec'd: r [ O[her A enc Licenses Financisl Flold Reasons ' ERhec�jcensin� SePCI�" �tea'son �'r "' � � �g �]^�+;w�• .�,,..e �"'t§'s'��?.dtYe �"0 e .;,s� v i License To: �lail To CoMact xense Adtlress� J I hvoice To. —� 4zA Ta Corrtact !cense Address M Save Changes to History Background Check ftequired (�" t"" - �=� � � a�Ft�°Qp,'e,..e5:�.M Council File # C O �� ORIGINAL GreenSheet# (O�{331 RESOLUTTON CITY OF SAINT PAITL, MINNESOTA Presented By Referred To Committee: Date ra 2 RESOLVED, that the Licensee, Liquor Village, Inc. d/b/a Liquar Village (License ID 3 No. 0016242), located at 2289 Ford Pazkway in Saint Paul is hereby ordered to pay a fine of 4 $500.00 for the violation of Sale of Alcoholic Beverages to Underage Persons. 10 11 12 Said fine shall be paid to the Office of License, Inspecrions and Environmental Protection within thirty (30) days of the adoption of this resolution by the Council and signature by the Mayor. This resolution and the action of the Council in this matter are based upon the facts contained in the March 29, 2000, Notice of Violation letter to the licensee and the Police Report CN 00-045344. The licensee did not contest the facts of the violation. Requested by Depar[ment of: BY: `� � /'�� Form Approve by City Attor� B �,:�eU�— � U �.� 0-�, Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council SY: '� ��— I� ,�O . �.. . sY' Appxoved by Mayor: Date �� J t-e.LVQ By: v /� Adopted by Cotssicil: Date '� q-p Adoption Certified by Council Secr asy City Attomey 266-8710 20a0 TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES april z�, 200o I GREEN SHEET o� -yy4� No 1 �4; 31 � u �.,�,�.�.�. � �.� _ F � � CRYATTOAEY ❑ OIYMK ❑wwxnum�veFSae. ❑wtwoua�rxrc ❑ 1MldelatASM��AIIr) ❑ (CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE) Resolution conceining adverse action against the Liquor Off Sale License held by Liquor Village, Inc., 2289 Ford Parkway. (Uncontested) JDAI ION AppfoVe (A) Of HB�eC[ PLANNING COMMISSION C16 COMMITfEE CIViI SERVICE COMMISSION IFAPPROVED NOT AMOUNi OF TRANSACTION SOURCE INPoRMAT70N (IXPWM }ias this pe�coMrtn e✓erv.orketl under a corNact forMis department� vES NO Has tles G�acnfirtn ewxteen a city empbye� rES rio �oes Mis pe'sonlfiim possecs a slull not nwmallypoesessetl by any curteM city employee7 YES NO Ia this persoNfinn a farpete0 ventlaYt YES NO Nain all vec answxrs an seoa2te sheat arM attach to ➢feen sheet COST/REVENUE BUDfiETED (CIRCLE ONE) ACTNRYNUMBER YEE NO ✓ OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY C[ayton M Robiruon, Jr., Ciry Attorney Q �� y� CITY OF SAINT PAUL Norm Coleman, Mayor Apri126, 2000 OwnerlManager Liquor Village 2289 Ford Pazkway Saint Paul, Minnesota 55116 CivilDivision 400 Ciry Hall I'elephone: 651266-8710 U West Kellogg Blvd Facsimile: 651298-56l9 Saint P¢ul, Minnesom 5510? NOTICE OF COUNCIL MEETING ��;�;;� �s��ch Ga�?� ;-: `'s; � � ��'� Re: Liquor Off Sale License held by Liquor Village, Inc. d/b/a Liquar Village, for the premises at 2289 Ford Parkway in St. Pau1 License ID No.:0016242 Dear Sir/Madam: Please take notice that this matter has been set on the Consent Agenda for the Council meeting scheduled for 3:30 p.m., Wednesday, May 10, 2000 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse. Enclosed are copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested matter, in that the facts concerning the sale of alcohol to an under age person have not been denied. The recommendation of the license office will be for a$500.00 fine. If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710. Very truly yours, r �` �''u� ,-r-�- Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary Robert Kessler, Director of LIEP Christine Rozek, Deputy Director of LIEP Gayle Surcuners, Community Organizer, Highland District Council, 1978 Ford Parkway, St. Paul, MN 55116 UNCONTESTED LICENSE MATTER oo -y�4' Licensee Name: Address: Council Date: Liquor Village, Inc. d/b/a Liquor Village 2289 Ford Parkway May 10, 2000 Violation: Sale of Alcohol to an Underage Person Minn. Stat. § 304A.503 (1994) St. Paul Legislative Code § 409.08 Date of Violation: March 14, 2000 Place: Presumptive Penalty $500.00 Fine Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office of License, fnspections and Environmental Protection: $500.00 fine Attachments: 1. Proposed resolution 2. Notice of Violation 3. License Information Report 4. Police Report CN 00-045344 Licensed Premises 5. License information OFFIC F THE CITY ATTORNEY Claylon h.. dobinson, Jr., CiryAttorney aQ �I.i� r CITY OF SAINT PAUL A'orm Colem¢n, Mayor ��r March 24, 2000 Civi! Division 400 Ciry Nal! IS IYestKelloggBlvd. Saint Pau(, biinmesota 5570? NOTICE OF VIOLATION Owner/Manager Liquor Village 2289 Ford Parkway Saint Paul, Minnesota 55116 Telephone: 65! 166-8i10 Facsimile: 6 51298-5619 Re: All Licenses held by Liquor Village, Inc. d/b/a Liquor Vi11a�e, for the premises at 2289 Ford Parkway in St. Paul License ID No.:0016242 Deaz Sir/Madam: The Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection (LIEP) has recommended adverse action against the licenses held by Liquor Village, Inc. d/b/a Liquor Village at the above location. This recommendation is based on the following infonmation: On March 14, 2000 a 19-year old male entered the premises of Liquor Village at 2289 Ford Parkway as part of a compliance check. The youug man was able to purchase a six pack of Michelob Golden Draft without showing any proof of age. Sale of alcohol to an underage person is a violation of Minn. Stat. §340A.503, subd. 2(1) and Saint Paul Legislative Code §409.08, subd. (2)a. Since this is considered a first violation, the licensing office will recommend a$500.00 fine, pursuant to St. Paul Legislative Code §409.26. At this time you have three options on how to proceed: If you do not dispute the above facts and do not wish to have a public hearing, you will need to pay the recommended fine for this violation. If this is your choice, you should make payment directly to the Office of License Inspections and Environmenta3 Protection, Room 300 Lowry Professional Building, 350 Saint Peter Street, Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102. The letter should be directed to Ms. Christine Rozek. Payment of the Page 2 Liquor Village Mazch 29, 2000 fine will be considered to be a waiver of the hearing to which you aze entitled. a o -�l�t.P' 2. Alternatively, if you do not dispute the above facts, but wish to have a public hearing before the Saint Paul City Council, you will need to send me a letter with a statement admitting the violation and requesting a heazin� by Monday, April 10, 2000. The matter will then be scheduled before the City Council for a public heazing to determine what penalty, if any, to impose. You will have an opporiuniry to appear before the Council and make a statement on your own behalf as to the penalty to be imposed. If you do dispute the above facts, a hearing will be scheduled before an Administrative Law 3udge. At that hearing both you and the City will be able to appear and present witnesses, evidence, and cross-examine the other's witnesses. The St. Paul City Council will ulti�ately decide the case. Please let me know in writing no later than Monday, April 10, 2000, how you wish to proceed. If you have not contacted me by Monday, Apri110, 2000, I will assume that you are not contesting the facts and wiil schedule this matter for the St. Paul City Council and have it placed on the Consent Agenda during which no public discussion is allowed and the recommended penalty will be imposed. If you have any questions, feel free to contact me at 266-8710. Sincerely, � ��-��C��..� Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: Robert Kessler, Director of LIEP Christine Rozek, Deputy Director of LIEP Gayle Summers, Community Organizer, Highland District Council, 1978 Ford Pazkway, St. Paul, NIN 55116 0 0 -y�lP' STATE OF MINNESOTA / ss. AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL COUNTY OF RAMSEY JOANVE G_ CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says that on March 30, 2000, she served the attached NO!SCE OF VIOLATIOI3 on the following named person by placing a true and correct copy thereof in an envelope addressed as follows: Owner/Manager Liquor Village 2289 Ford Parkway St. Paul, MN. 55116 (which is the last known address of said person) and depositing the same, with postage prepaid, in the Unit ates mails at St. Paul, Minnesota. S Subscribed and sworn to before me this 30th day aL�M�rc}��000� / i� � PETER P.PANGBORN NOTARY PU811C - MINNESOTA NOtdYy Pub1iC �e� MYCAbSMISSiCNi q � EXPtRE$ dAN. 31.20� 00 - �1't.� n ��i i X M I O �n � e- � IO y V N � J � a u 0 � 0 a � C O .� � � O w C d N L d U J � 3 m �I N I� � J Q O � U aa � N � N C � U @ J�m u� O ` O � N � M 3 z U�� J � a m M �� a � �� v`O a 4rn`° W �-- N Uj W � d J J Iz � I Q � m O I� I_ � J� U Z ll.! � N Q E � z> O � b � a � J U C � O U L o �' ..�+ (6 0 Q w � C N Q � � U O a � G LJ � N C � N Z a C fl. O � U C m � N C N � � 7 Z N = O L ^ a° � N � m � N � C 3 � m� �Q F� � � � ? Y a ❑ � O � � N T 4 J � �� C N - CC 7 J �•_� vU� � y � Y U � N C U=N N N'@ m t c .0 �UW � � N R U � � C c � @� R � Ni_W_(p .��O�O� � O�UL�� M 0 O � V N p � O�U�'� j a �Um�- � (6 - p. �7 ' IL a �oo - Oa"i a�i �(6N V NU "6 �'= N �fl.'D Q � � N'6�� m (0 y� O�p � o� m ai U mm Nommmrn�U �a�rnN�o�m � � t'�'j �? C C�� O�a-WOO(`')V' �i I � i l M W O N I` N p IO d V N 0I _J � a I< 0 r C � � O R � � w C N N C d u .J N' = I �I �i �I Ni> JIQ � �� ' I N �� =I� U:j J�O' J 0 o �, m �i N E� M � zi N�V N � U - O O � � m a ui p m � a � Q � � N � W 3 � J Z 7 m O I� � J U Z W � � g m '� z> O � s � a C� J �U C � O U � r � m � a w � y o C N O N O N � � � Z U O e' d N v U � I� � N � C m 0 � Q m y Z , a � � W Q a U � z c ¢ N � N � � 4 � � � 3 Z � C O O � t 0 a� m � d � C � � � m � � N N � � � � � a n � � m � N N i „ �� I, �I � � -O J � � � U C � � C'C 3 C� y O � i �...�1 UVYN(qC Y UYJ v1 C U C N N N�(` N Q L C V:-,V�N i U � � 01 a3mc��3c N � C ( � � f0 �=� p W °- aEoo 3 v E O N U r O R U L� V T U p O U O"'LV NO � O� U C'j � a m U� a a�i ti a�oo�d ai �NN V NU ' 'a � `� �� av C ��a � m N �o� a LL �mv N i U �'�" U O T � �—� �� N p� , �p�jNNp�(p � q-- <'� N a \-- � N� �.� M V<� C C�� 0��M� o c _yyP' i'; '�, ;�i 0 I �' M 'W � � �IO M � O d V N t�p J M a L�o � O G m � 0 R � � O C d N C N v ..! N � � � d J� I � I .-� � U w UIU O �� 0 O N �I M �I ZI N (�p v � J 0 � N m � a N Q N� a � ¢m� 1 �r L.N � W � Q N � W � z ro � Q = � J U Z W N ¢ £ J Z > C O O � a � J �U C � O � � ro m � : x y c II � 3 Z U O N U C R N C N � m z a c a � 0 U u C @ � � c N � � 3 Z N � O O ^ � O a� N � N � C � � � m � � N F" � � � � d 0 � Q LL rn m N r I' �� i ; ; �� ; � ; I � ?� � 9 ...1 � I� � � � U C + ' 7 C �C 7 i i � N' �� OQ �a. � U C � i U CNNN'Q I N t � L O UW �.`+ U r � tU { � c�i � c� 3 � i � C y l4� � � i I ro� Q �@ f ' a>E�p3 v � j O� U t V � M V �_ U R U I� � � O t �� T I � � O � I �� -G O V C'j ] a I Ua��. 'i f mU. a�,y �i I Q � � V �_ � " (q W_ j I N U-p U Q� 4 N I U I I N O��MW i s�-N�ON��O�i p�j V��CC�lJQ) 07 wOOmv` ac -�t�lY' Saint Pau4 Police Qepartment [NAL OFFENSE / INCIDENT REPORT Page t oc -�k�lP' -� r � ��" �' x Pnmary oKense Date and Time of Re art ��2�!: �y: . P `�,��'��'=`?iY''` LIQUOR LAWS, VIOLATION 03/14/2000 21:28 �°F. �:..� �:�. � f'•'�!Y'�Fd�t9�/h�` ' RICHARD L WACHAL Locaoon ofinadent �$9 FORO PA Primary oXersse detad: P,^,mary sGvadr % 92 ;econcary�apomagct.`,cer. EUGENE P POLYAK c�ura: WESTERN ( PSS-V10E ) Seco.oCar� OC2nse' Pq�ICE PERSONNEL INVOLVED Arrest made on vrew: Arrest made on wa�ant ar previous CN: Wzapons use0 6y polfce: N/ea{wns used by suspect a! trme of arrest. Nameorlocacon/CUmness: LIQUOR VILLAGE Jare d ame ofoccu�ence: p3/'(4(2�0� 19:03 Arrestmade? YcS oare a nme atanesr p3/14l2000 19:04 Pursurt engaged: Ressiance encounieretl: C HAR G E S (NOtiE) i�iR��ES SUSPECT COAN, ROBERTJAMES 118� EDGECUMBE RD STPAUL MN PhysmalDescripuon Phones Sex �q�E Heignt Ha�iColo� �__ 'vVHITE We�9nt N:soarnc Budd DOB 12J16/195� Skn nge 6g Hair Type Ha«LenyKh Facfa/ Hav Hame phone 651-698-5032 Work phone 651-699-7070 Phystca! Conditlon Employment Ccnscousness CONSCIOUS Occupanon CASHIER O��q'alCOho! use Emp�oyer LIQUOR VILLAGE �R1ME SCENE DESCRIPTORS Gime Scene Ty?e RcTAIL DescRpaon MeZhod 8 Painf af EnUy Force used Po�nt ol entry Metbotl PROPER7Y (NCN�; VEHICLE INFORMATION {NONE) PUSLIC NARRATIVE Sai2 of afcohoi to an under aged person at a retail estab{ishment. , Camp'aintNrmrbe� 00-04534? LIQUOR lAWS, VIOLATION 03/14/2000 21:28 tRf2RATIVc Squad 7G2 was assigned to a liauor compliance detail in the highland Park neighborhood on the above ��a_e- ! was workino wiYh Sgt_ Polyak and utilized a person under the age of 21 years in our attempt to tes± the compliance of clerics and servers that sell aicoholic beverages in the city of St_ Paul. The person under 2'1 years reierred to as the undercover (UC) was � 42 and has a DOB of 7-2480. UC .t42 had been trained by LIEP and the SPPD Vice Unit in how to conduct himseiflherself in this operation. :,t �503 hours, we sznt the UC into Liquor Village located at 2289 Ford Parkway. He was instructed to atterd to purchase a 6 pack of beer onc2 inside. We listened to hislher activity with a body bug h2!she camed on his person. A few minutes later he/she gave us a signai with the monitor that in�icated helshe had made a purchase. We went inside aYer he/she met us at the door and aescnbed vrhat the seiler looked like. He/She aiso gave us the six pack of Michelob Golden Draff and cnange from the SS bill he was provided with. He/she said the seller was an older male at the cash register. ; Iccated that person and told him that he had jusi sold the beer to a person that was 19 years old I gave �ack the beer after it was photogr2phed by Sgt. Polyak. The party did not refute that he nad sold the beerjust moments ago. Ttie se!(er was idenlified with his Minnesota DL as: COAN, ROBERT JAMES DOB 12-�6-50. He said he never checked for ID from the UC. He went on to say: "You realize aIl the IOs I check everyday and the first 6me I dcn't check, this happens." T�'�e manager was not present and could not be advised by us in person. sv?r. Coan was advised of ihe complaint proc2ss he was about to undergo. He, along with the six pack of Michelob Goiden Draft was photographed and released at the scene. Piease disiribuie to: ____CHF _Hom _Sex _D!C ____CO l Rotr Saint Paul Police Department Page 2 OR1GiNAL OFFENSE I 1NCiDENT REPORT oc-y�,r Refi/ence CN. Pnmary ottense Date and Time ot Report ;.. _Bur; V ice �)uv _Oper ,PSC _Theic _Prop _CAU �arco SIU T&A _Lab _Rec _Team _F&F _Auto _DAO Other L icense Group Comments Text Licensee: LIQUOR VILLAGE INC �BA= LIQUOR4ILLAGE License #: 0016242 03��4/2000 Failed DPS alcohol compliance check conducted by Vice PolyaklVJachai. To CAO for adverse action. CAR � 1/17/99 passed second afcofiot comptiance check-DL 8/10/99 passed cig compliance check, 9/�4/9g letter sent SS On 2/23/99 Completed required alcohol awareness training-DL On 1/29/99 Failed check;'unofficiai' waming-training due 3/5/99-DL 4/9/96 Cig Code Added Fdld# 173t4 03/27/2000 00 -��4�' 00 —yyY Atltlress Licensee ��o� 1 License � �e��,o��, � Licensee Name� OBA (1UOR VILLAGE Saies Tax Itl' r� ,.FN,1d'�°w�+.? "��.":�a=��^��-' x s °�`�_ ; 4n;�i� '`�r. � .�.�ti ,... - ; e � ' �� t Tc..:;..�e� i �o8.�,�e"s�;; 980005000 h 698 �GEORGIA SCHEU UQUOR VILLAGE WC 00 - �{ �lY L�ce p�',� ��p� ��,�.�� Licensee IQUOft VILLAGE INC - DBA IQUOR VILLAGE DBA Sale: Lipe�se � �w¢nsee j Lic Types , Insurance ' Hond , Reqwremerrts � '�` Property �' Licensee �` UnofSpal Pro�ect Fau@ffior MARTENS, CORINNE q SYteet #: 289 ' Ativerse Action Commards ' Street Name� ORD ; Street �P}NVY Direkion: � � E� Und Ind �— Und #: � � CRY T PFUL , �m�s' �-- � r -- � --------...-. _ ..... _ . �_� . ._______._ ,, ._._� � �e� }�+�� Zn' S511 S �`03J142000 Failed DPS elcohol wmpliance check ;'tcontluctetl by Vice PolyakNVachal. To CAO for . � Wartl' 3r � �� "`� `fadverse action. � �� Dist CouncA: 75 (11 f11 i99 passed secand aicohol campliance . 4icensee. �I�UOftVILLAGEINC CammeMS: , DBA I�UOR VILLAGE -' Sales Tax Id 6&5492 Bus Phone: 65116� 1731 i; � License #�16242 - Save Changes to History au94sS Lkeasr'�ee :{ ich:. .. ; � N ( $Zp0 00: 9972259 F�. N __ i _ _ _$377 D0� � :¢ � N _ � OPI2289Fi 001 2289 R OOOj2289 Ft �� -�+'� :_ � 0002239F( 0 0 -y�tY Lroe '� ` `� q �'� �T Licensee �.IQUOR VILLAOE INC ,??Y :� FP�v¢ ct5;px „�Noc,. „swn'mx D8A IQUOR VILLRCE DBP Sale� License �icensee � Lic Types , �nsurance � Bontl 1 Requireme(rts l i Licensee Name: IOUOR VILLAGE WC Er6k;�v�' �`45:: -c:h'•�.-udd„pj ; DBA IOUOR VILIAGE +SalesTa�id. 585492 Nan-Prof&�WOrkersCwnp: N72001 '-?roper�5esfi« € AA CorQrect Rec'd 0.1aN960 AA Trairnng Rec'd 7,J0�0000 ; AA Fee Collected: 0f00N000 Discowrt ftec'd: r [ O[her A enc Licenses Financisl Flold Reasons ' ERhec�jcensin� SePCI�" �tea'son �'r "' � � �g �]^�+;w�• .�,,..e �"'t§'s'��?.dtYe �"0 e .;,s� v i License To: �lail To CoMact xense Adtlress� J I hvoice To. —� 4zA Ta Corrtact !cense Address M Save Changes to History Background Check ftequired (�" t"" - �=� � � a�Ft�°Qp,'e,..e5:�.M Council File # C O �� ORIGINAL GreenSheet# (O�{331 RESOLUTTON CITY OF SAINT PAITL, MINNESOTA Presented By Referred To Committee: Date ra 2 RESOLVED, that the Licensee, Liquor Village, Inc. d/b/a Liquar Village (License ID 3 No. 0016242), located at 2289 Ford Pazkway in Saint Paul is hereby ordered to pay a fine of 4 $500.00 for the violation of Sale of Alcoholic Beverages to Underage Persons. 10 11 12 Said fine shall be paid to the Office of License, Inspecrions and Environmental Protection within thirty (30) days of the adoption of this resolution by the Council and signature by the Mayor. This resolution and the action of the Council in this matter are based upon the facts contained in the March 29, 2000, Notice of Violation letter to the licensee and the Police Report CN 00-045344. The licensee did not contest the facts of the violation. Requested by Depar[ment of: BY: `� � /'�� Form Approve by City Attor� B �,:�eU�— � U �.� 0-�, Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council SY: '� ��— I� ,�O . �.. . sY' Appxoved by Mayor: Date �� J t-e.LVQ By: v /� Adopted by Cotssicil: Date '� q-p Adoption Certified by Council Secr asy City Attomey 266-8710 20a0 TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES april z�, 200o I GREEN SHEET o� -yy4� No 1 �4; 31 � u �.,�,�.�.�. � �.� _ F � � CRYATTOAEY ❑ OIYMK ❑wwxnum�veFSae. ❑wtwoua�rxrc ❑ 1MldelatASM��AIIr) ❑ (CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE) Resolution conceining adverse action against the Liquor Off Sale License held by Liquor Village, Inc., 2289 Ford Parkway. (Uncontested) JDAI ION AppfoVe (A) Of HB�eC[ PLANNING COMMISSION C16 COMMITfEE CIViI SERVICE COMMISSION IFAPPROVED NOT AMOUNi OF TRANSACTION SOURCE INPoRMAT70N (IXPWM }ias this pe�coMrtn e✓erv.orketl under a corNact forMis department� vES NO Has tles G�acnfirtn ewxteen a city empbye� rES rio �oes Mis pe'sonlfiim possecs a slull not nwmallypoesessetl by any curteM city employee7 YES NO Ia this persoNfinn a farpete0 ventlaYt YES NO Nain all vec answxrs an seoa2te sheat arM attach to ➢feen sheet COST/REVENUE BUDfiETED (CIRCLE ONE) ACTNRYNUMBER YEE NO ✓ OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY C[ayton M Robiruon, Jr., Ciry Attorney Q �� y� CITY OF SAINT PAUL Norm Coleman, Mayor Apri126, 2000 OwnerlManager Liquor Village 2289 Ford Pazkway Saint Paul, Minnesota 55116 CivilDivision 400 Ciry Hall I'elephone: 651266-8710 U West Kellogg Blvd Facsimile: 651298-56l9 Saint P¢ul, Minnesom 5510? NOTICE OF COUNCIL MEETING ��;�;;� �s��ch Ga�?� ;-: `'s; � � ��'� Re: Liquor Off Sale License held by Liquor Village, Inc. d/b/a Liquar Village, for the premises at 2289 Ford Parkway in St. Pau1 License ID No.:0016242 Dear Sir/Madam: Please take notice that this matter has been set on the Consent Agenda for the Council meeting scheduled for 3:30 p.m., Wednesday, May 10, 2000 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse. Enclosed are copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested matter, in that the facts concerning the sale of alcohol to an under age person have not been denied. The recommendation of the license office will be for a$500.00 fine. If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710. Very truly yours, r �` �''u� ,-r-�- Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary Robert Kessler, Director of LIEP Christine Rozek, Deputy Director of LIEP Gayle Surcuners, Community Organizer, Highland District Council, 1978 Ford Parkway, St. Paul, MN 55116 UNCONTESTED LICENSE MATTER oo -y�4' Licensee Name: Address: Council Date: Liquor Village, Inc. d/b/a Liquor Village 2289 Ford Parkway May 10, 2000 Violation: Sale of Alcohol to an Underage Person Minn. Stat. § 304A.503 (1994) St. Paul Legislative Code § 409.08 Date of Violation: March 14, 2000 Place: Presumptive Penalty $500.00 Fine Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office of License, fnspections and Environmental Protection: $500.00 fine Attachments: 1. Proposed resolution 2. Notice of Violation 3. License Information Report 4. Police Report CN 00-045344 Licensed Premises 5. License information OFFIC F THE CITY ATTORNEY Claylon h.. dobinson, Jr., CiryAttorney aQ �I.i� r CITY OF SAINT PAUL A'orm Colem¢n, Mayor ��r March 24, 2000 Civi! Division 400 Ciry Nal! IS IYestKelloggBlvd. Saint Pau(, biinmesota 5570? NOTICE OF VIOLATION Owner/Manager Liquor Village 2289 Ford Parkway Saint Paul, Minnesota 55116 Telephone: 65! 166-8i10 Facsimile: 6 51298-5619 Re: All Licenses held by Liquor Village, Inc. d/b/a Liquor Vi11a�e, for the premises at 2289 Ford Parkway in St. Paul License ID No.:0016242 Deaz Sir/Madam: The Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection (LIEP) has recommended adverse action against the licenses held by Liquor Village, Inc. d/b/a Liquor Village at the above location. This recommendation is based on the following infonmation: On March 14, 2000 a 19-year old male entered the premises of Liquor Village at 2289 Ford Parkway as part of a compliance check. The youug man was able to purchase a six pack of Michelob Golden Draft without showing any proof of age. Sale of alcohol to an underage person is a violation of Minn. Stat. §340A.503, subd. 2(1) and Saint Paul Legislative Code §409.08, subd. (2)a. Since this is considered a first violation, the licensing office will recommend a$500.00 fine, pursuant to St. Paul Legislative Code §409.26. At this time you have three options on how to proceed: If you do not dispute the above facts and do not wish to have a public hearing, you will need to pay the recommended fine for this violation. If this is your choice, you should make payment directly to the Office of License Inspections and Environmenta3 Protection, Room 300 Lowry Professional Building, 350 Saint Peter Street, Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102. The letter should be directed to Ms. Christine Rozek. Payment of the Page 2 Liquor Village Mazch 29, 2000 fine will be considered to be a waiver of the hearing to which you aze entitled. a o -�l�t.P' 2. Alternatively, if you do not dispute the above facts, but wish to have a public hearing before the Saint Paul City Council, you will need to send me a letter with a statement admitting the violation and requesting a heazin� by Monday, April 10, 2000. The matter will then be scheduled before the City Council for a public heazing to determine what penalty, if any, to impose. You will have an opporiuniry to appear before the Council and make a statement on your own behalf as to the penalty to be imposed. If you do dispute the above facts, a hearing will be scheduled before an Administrative Law 3udge. At that hearing both you and the City will be able to appear and present witnesses, evidence, and cross-examine the other's witnesses. The St. Paul City Council will ulti�ately decide the case. Please let me know in writing no later than Monday, April 10, 2000, how you wish to proceed. If you have not contacted me by Monday, Apri110, 2000, I will assume that you are not contesting the facts and wiil schedule this matter for the St. Paul City Council and have it placed on the Consent Agenda during which no public discussion is allowed and the recommended penalty will be imposed. If you have any questions, feel free to contact me at 266-8710. Sincerely, � ��-��C��..� Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: Robert Kessler, Director of LIEP Christine Rozek, Deputy Director of LIEP Gayle Summers, Community Organizer, Highland District Council, 1978 Ford Pazkway, St. Paul, NIN 55116 0 0 -y�lP' STATE OF MINNESOTA / ss. AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL COUNTY OF RAMSEY JOANVE G_ CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says that on March 30, 2000, she served the attached NO!SCE OF VIOLATIOI3 on the following named person by placing a true and correct copy thereof in an envelope addressed as follows: Owner/Manager Liquor Village 2289 Ford Parkway St. Paul, MN. 55116 (which is the last known address of said person) and depositing the same, with postage prepaid, in the Unit ates mails at St. Paul, Minnesota. S Subscribed and sworn to before me this 30th day aL�M�rc}��000� / i� � PETER P.PANGBORN NOTARY PU811C - MINNESOTA NOtdYy Pub1iC �e� MYCAbSMISSiCNi q � EXPtRE$ dAN. 31.20� 00 - �1't.� n ��i i X M I O �n � e- � IO y V N � J � a u 0 � 0 a � C O .� � � O w C d N L d U J � 3 m �I N I� � J Q O � U aa � N � N C � U @ J�m u� O ` O � N � M 3 z U�� J � a m M �� a � �� v`O a 4rn`° W �-- N Uj W � d J J Iz � I Q � m O I� I_ � J� U Z ll.! � N Q E � z> O � b � a � J U C � O U L o �' ..�+ (6 0 Q w � C N Q � � U O a � G LJ � N C � N Z a C fl. O � U C m � N C N � � 7 Z N = O L ^ a° � N � m � N � C 3 � m� �Q F� � � � ? Y a ❑ � O � � N T 4 J � �� C N - CC 7 J �•_� vU� � y � Y U � N C U=N N N'@ m t c .0 �UW � � N R U � � C c � @� R � Ni_W_(p .��O�O� � O�UL�� M 0 O � V N p � O�U�'� j a �Um�- � (6 - p. �7 ' IL a �oo - Oa"i a�i �(6N V NU "6 �'= N �fl.'D Q � � N'6�� m (0 y� O�p � o� m ai U mm Nommmrn�U �a�rnN�o�m � � t'�'j �? C C�� O�a-WOO(`')V' �i I � i l M W O N I` N p IO d V N 0I _J � a I< 0 r C � � O R � � w C N N C d u .J N' = I �I �i �I Ni> JIQ � �� ' I N �� =I� U:j J�O' J 0 o �, m �i N E� M � zi N�V N � U - O O � � m a ui p m � a � Q � � N � W 3 � J Z 7 m O I� � J U Z W � � g m '� z> O � s � a C� J �U C � O U � r � m � a w � y o C N O N O N � � � Z U O e' d N v U � I� � N � C m 0 � Q m y Z , a � � W Q a U � z c ¢ N � N � � 4 � � � 3 Z � C O O � t 0 a� m � d � C � � � m � � N N � � � � � a n � � m � N N i „ �� I, �I � � -O J � � � U C � � C'C 3 C� y O � i �...�1 UVYN(qC Y UYJ v1 C U C N N N�(` N Q L C V:-,V�N i U � � 01 a3mc��3c N � C ( � � f0 �=� p W °- aEoo 3 v E O N U r O R U L� V T U p O U O"'LV NO � O� U C'j � a m U� a a�i ti a�oo�d ai �NN V NU ' 'a � `� �� av C ��a � m N �o� a LL �mv N i U �'�" U O T � �—� �� N p� , �p�jNNp�(p � q-- <'� N a \-- � N� �.� M V<� C C�� 0��M� o c _yyP' i'; '�, ;�i 0 I �' M 'W � � �IO M � O d V N t�p J M a L�o � O G m � 0 R � � O C d N C N v ..! N � � � d J� I � I .-� � U w UIU O �� 0 O N �I M �I ZI N (�p v � J 0 � N m � a N Q N� a � ¢m� 1 �r L.N � W � Q N � W � z ro � Q = � J U Z W N ¢ £ J Z > C O O � a � J �U C � O � � ro m � : x y c II � 3 Z U O N U C R N C N � m z a c a � 0 U u C @ � � c N � � 3 Z N � O O ^ � O a� N � N � C � � � m � � N F" � � � � d 0 � Q LL rn m N r I' �� i ; ; �� ; � ; I � ?� � 9 ...1 � I� � � � U C + ' 7 C �C 7 i i � N' �� OQ �a. � U C � i U CNNN'Q I N t � L O UW �.`+ U r � tU { � c�i � c� 3 � i � C y l4� � � i I ro� Q �@ f ' a>E�p3 v � j O� U t V � M V �_ U R U I� � � O t �� T I � � O � I �� -G O V C'j ] a I Ua��. 'i f mU. a�,y �i I Q � � V �_ � " (q W_ j I N U-p U Q� 4 N I U I I N O��MW i s�-N�ON��O�i p�j V��CC�lJQ) 07 wOOmv` ac -�t�lY' Saint Pau4 Police Qepartment [NAL OFFENSE / INCIDENT REPORT Page t oc -�k�lP' -� r � ��" �' x Pnmary oKense Date and Time of Re art ��2�!: �y: . P `�,��'��'=`?iY''` LIQUOR LAWS, VIOLATION 03/14/2000 21:28 �°F. �:..� �:�. � f'•'�!Y'�Fd�t9�/h�` ' RICHARD L WACHAL Locaoon ofinadent �$9 FORO PA Primary oXersse detad: P,^,mary sGvadr % 92 ;econcary�apomagct.`,cer. EUGENE P POLYAK c�ura: WESTERN ( PSS-V10E ) Seco.oCar� OC2nse' Pq�ICE PERSONNEL INVOLVED Arrest made on vrew: Arrest made on wa�ant ar previous CN: Wzapons use0 6y polfce: N/ea{wns used by suspect a! trme of arrest. Nameorlocacon/CUmness: LIQUOR VILLAGE Jare d ame ofoccu�ence: p3/'(4(2�0� 19:03 Arrestmade? YcS oare a nme atanesr p3/14l2000 19:04 Pursurt engaged: Ressiance encounieretl: C HAR G E S (NOtiE) i�iR��ES SUSPECT COAN, ROBERTJAMES 118� EDGECUMBE RD STPAUL MN PhysmalDescripuon Phones Sex �q�E Heignt Ha�iColo� �__ 'vVHITE We�9nt N:soarnc Budd DOB 12J16/195� Skn nge 6g Hair Type Ha«LenyKh Facfa/ Hav Hame phone 651-698-5032 Work phone 651-699-7070 Phystca! Conditlon Employment Ccnscousness CONSCIOUS Occupanon CASHIER O��q'alCOho! use Emp�oyer LIQUOR VILLAGE �R1ME SCENE DESCRIPTORS Gime Scene Ty?e RcTAIL DescRpaon MeZhod 8 Painf af EnUy Force used Po�nt ol entry Metbotl PROPER7Y (NCN�; VEHICLE INFORMATION {NONE) PUSLIC NARRATIVE Sai2 of afcohoi to an under aged person at a retail estab{ishment. , Camp'aintNrmrbe� 00-04534? LIQUOR lAWS, VIOLATION 03/14/2000 21:28 tRf2RATIVc Squad 7G2 was assigned to a liauor compliance detail in the highland Park neighborhood on the above ��a_e- ! was workino wiYh Sgt_ Polyak and utilized a person under the age of 21 years in our attempt to tes± the compliance of clerics and servers that sell aicoholic beverages in the city of St_ Paul. The person under 2'1 years reierred to as the undercover (UC) was � 42 and has a DOB of 7-2480. UC .t42 had been trained by LIEP and the SPPD Vice Unit in how to conduct himseiflherself in this operation. :,t �503 hours, we sznt the UC into Liquor Village located at 2289 Ford Parkway. He was instructed to atterd to purchase a 6 pack of beer onc2 inside. We listened to hislher activity with a body bug h2!she camed on his person. A few minutes later he/she gave us a signai with the monitor that in�icated helshe had made a purchase. We went inside aYer he/she met us at the door and aescnbed vrhat the seiler looked like. He/She aiso gave us the six pack of Michelob Golden Draff and cnange from the SS bill he was provided with. He/she said the seller was an older male at the cash register. ; Iccated that person and told him that he had jusi sold the beer to a person that was 19 years old I gave �ack the beer after it was photogr2phed by Sgt. Polyak. The party did not refute that he nad sold the beerjust moments ago. Ttie se!(er was idenlified with his Minnesota DL as: COAN, ROBERT JAMES DOB 12-�6-50. He said he never checked for ID from the UC. He went on to say: "You realize aIl the IOs I check everyday and the first 6me I dcn't check, this happens." T�'�e manager was not present and could not be advised by us in person. sv?r. Coan was advised of ihe complaint proc2ss he was about to undergo. He, along with the six pack of Michelob Goiden Draft was photographed and released at the scene. Piease disiribuie to: ____CHF _Hom _Sex _D!C ____CO l Rotr Saint Paul Police Department Page 2 OR1GiNAL OFFENSE I 1NCiDENT REPORT oc-y�,r Refi/ence CN. Pnmary ottense Date and Time ot Report ;.. _Bur; V ice �)uv _Oper ,PSC _Theic _Prop _CAU �arco SIU T&A _Lab _Rec _Team _F&F _Auto _DAO Other L icense Group Comments Text Licensee: LIQUOR VILLAGE INC �BA= LIQUOR4ILLAGE License #: 0016242 03��4/2000 Failed DPS alcohol compliance check conducted by Vice PolyaklVJachai. To CAO for adverse action. CAR � 1/17/99 passed second afcofiot comptiance check-DL 8/10/99 passed cig compliance check, 9/�4/9g letter sent SS On 2/23/99 Completed required alcohol awareness training-DL On 1/29/99 Failed check;'unofficiai' waming-training due 3/5/99-DL 4/9/96 Cig Code Added Fdld# 173t4 03/27/2000 00 -��4�' 00 —yyY Atltlress Licensee ��o� 1 License � �e��,o��, � Licensee Name� OBA (1UOR VILLAGE Saies Tax Itl' r� ,.FN,1d'�°w�+.? "��.":�a=��^��-' x s °�`�_ ; 4n;�i� '`�r. � .�.�ti ,... - ; e � ' �� t Tc..:;..�e� i �o8.�,�e"s�;; 980005000 h 698 �GEORGIA SCHEU UQUOR VILLAGE WC 00 - �{ �lY L�ce p�',� ��p� ��,�.�� Licensee IQUOft VILLAGE INC - DBA IQUOR VILLAGE DBA Sale: Lipe�se � �w¢nsee j Lic Types , Insurance ' Hond , Reqwremerrts � '�` Property �' Licensee �` UnofSpal Pro�ect Fau@ffior MARTENS, CORINNE q SYteet #: 289 ' Ativerse Action Commards ' Street Name� ORD ; Street �P}NVY Direkion: � � E� Und Ind �— Und #: � � CRY T PFUL , �m�s' �-- � r -- � --------...-. _ ..... _ . �_� . ._______._ ,, ._._� � �e� }�+�� Zn' S511 S �`03J142000 Failed DPS elcohol wmpliance check ;'tcontluctetl by Vice PolyakNVachal. To CAO for . � Wartl' 3r � �� "`� `fadverse action. � �� Dist CouncA: 75 (11 f11 i99 passed secand aicohol campliance . 4icensee. �I�UOftVILLAGEINC CammeMS: , DBA I�UOR VILLAGE -' Sales Tax Id 6&5492 Bus Phone: 65116� 1731 i; � License #�16242 - Save Changes to History au94sS Lkeasr'�ee :{ ich:. .. ; � N ( $Zp0 00: 9972259 F�. N __ i _ _ _$377 D0� � :¢ � N _ � OPI2289Fi 001 2289 R OOOj2289 Ft �� -�+'� :_ � 0002239F( 0 0 -y�tY Lroe '� ` `� q �'� �T Licensee �.IQUOR VILLAOE INC ,??Y :� FP�v¢ ct5;px „�Noc,. „swn'mx D8A IQUOR VILLRCE DBP Sale� License �icensee � Lic Types , �nsurance � Bontl 1 Requireme(rts l i Licensee Name: IOUOR VILLAGE WC Er6k;�v�' �`45:: -c:h'•�.-udd„pj ; DBA IOUOR VILIAGE +SalesTa�id. 585492 Nan-Prof&�WOrkersCwnp: N72001 '-?roper�5esfi« € AA CorQrect Rec'd 0.1aN960 AA Trairnng Rec'd 7,J0�0000 ; AA Fee Collected: 0f00N000 Discowrt ftec'd: r [ O[her A enc Licenses Financisl Flold Reasons ' ERhec�jcensin� SePCI�" �tea'son �'r "' � � �g �]^�+;w�• .�,,..e �"'t§'s'��?.dtYe �"0 e .;,s� v i License To: �lail To CoMact xense Adtlress� J I hvoice To. —� 4zA Ta Corrtact !cense Address M Save Changes to History Background Check ftequired (�" t"" - �=� � � a�Ft�°Qp,'e,..e5:�.M