00-407QRiG�NA�.
Presented By
Refened To
Council FIle # 00 -40�'i
m�Y.�e� _ {�l�� 3 , �-ec o
� Green Sheet # t O 3 Q L�{
SO TION
CITY iTL, TA ar�
Pa e �
Committee: Date
2 RESOLVED, that the Auto Repair Gazage license held by Frank Czaston dfb/a Frank's
3 Auto Service (License ID # 0099687), for the premises at 15Q Concord Street, is hereby
4 suspended for a period of thirty days for outside storage of vehicles and parts in violation of
5 Saint Paul Legislative Code §60.543, and for storage of inoperable vehicles for more than five
6 days, which is prohibited by Saint Paul Legislative Code §60.219.
7
8 FI3RTHER RESOLVED, that 15 days of said suspension sha11 be stayed for a period of
9 eighteen months on the following conditions: 1) that the property is brought into compliance
10 with the conditions on the license within one week from the passage of this Resolution; 2) that
i 1 there be no further violations of the conditions on the license or other code or zoning violations
12
13
14
15
16
17
1&
19
20
21
during the eighteen months; and 3) that the licensee pay a fine of $500.00, said fine to be paid to
the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection within thirty(30) days of the
adoption of this resolution by the Council and signature by the Mayor. For the remauvng 15
days suspension, no business operations shall be pernutted begiiuiiiig at 12:01 a.m, Wednesday,
May 17, 2000, through 11:54 pm., Wednesday May 31, 2000.
-� S`E�S er� �o.r�rar h ( �Yriev�7,mev��� - �a�� 2-.
This Resolution and the action of the Council in this ma#ter are based upon the facts
contained in the OcCober 21, 1999 letter to the licensee from LIEP, the March 21, 2000 Notice of
Violation letter to the licensee, and such arguments as may have been presented to the Council at
the public heazing. The licensee did not contest the facts of the violation.
Reques� by Department of:
4/GrYR�-a JI��
&y:
Form Approved by City Att, ey
By:
Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By:
App�
By:
By:
Adoptied by Council; Date _�\�d Q G
1
Adoption Certified by Council Sec ary
eo -��`f
Insert the following Amendment (on Page 1) (May 3, 2000)
FURTF�R RESOLVED that notwithstandin the for�oin�, if the licensed premises is
broueht into full comnliance with City ordinances relating to outside stora¢e of vehicles and
parts and storage of inoperable vehicles by 4•00 �m on May 17 2000 the entire thirry (30 davs
suspension shall be suspended for thirtv1301 days on conditions (21 and (31 in the fore�m�
"FURTHER RESOLVED" clause.
Office of LIEP/City Attomey
NTACT PQ27.�N & PFIOI�
Virginia Palmer
����
Mazch 31, 2000
TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES
GREEN SHEET
oa.R�rt ona7ae
00 -�o�
Nol G��?�4
uir�ouct
CRYAiTORIEY ❑ OIYCLiRI[
H4MCMifFRNCFJ9R. ❑ RYMWLiFiM4CtT6
II�YOR(OR�V1LLL111l) ❑
iCLiP ALl LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE)
Resolufion concerning adverse action against the Auto Repair Garage License held by Frank Gaston, dba
Frank's Auto Service, 150 Concord Street. (iJncontested)
PLANNING GOMMISSION
CIB COMMITTEE
CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION
Has this persorvhrm e�sx wnrketl uMxa conhact fof thia depaRmeM7
YES NO
Has ttiie peisorJfirtn Caer been a city empbyee?
YES NO
Doesthis De�soM�im o�sesc a s�6n not nrnma9YPOSSessetl bY �P airreM ciiv emWovee?
YES NO
Is thia pe+sorilfirm aU�B�etl vendoYt
YES NO
TRANSACTIOIi S
SOURCE
CAST/REV@7UE BUD6ETED (CIRCLE ONk�
ACTWItY NUMBER
YES NO
INFORMA710N(IXPWln
OFFICE OF TI-IE CITY ATTORNEY
Clayton M Robinson, b., Ciry Attomey
ao ..�{n
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
NormColemun, Mayor
Civi! Division
40Q Ciry Ha11
1 S West Kellogg BJvd
Saint Pau1, Minnesota i5T 02
Tetephone: 651266-8710
Facsimile; 65I298-5619
March 30, 2000
NOTICE OF COUNCIL MEETING
Frank Gaston
Frank's Auto Service
150 Concord Street
Saint Pau1, Minnesota 55107
RE: Auto Repair Garage License held by Frank Gaston, d/bfa Frank's Auto Service for the
premises at 150 Concord Street, Saint Paui
License ID #: 99687
Deaz Mr. Gaston:
P1ease take notice that a hearing concerning the above-named establishment has been scheduled
for 5:30 p.m., Wednesday, Aprii 26, 2000 in the Ciry Councii Chambers, Third Fioor, Saint
Paul City Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse.
Enclosed aze copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to
the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested hearing, in that the facts
concerning the violations of St. Paul Legislative code have not been denied. You will have an
opportunity at the Council hearing to present oral and/or written remarks as to the penalry, if any,
to be imposed.
If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710.
Very truly yours,
���� ��
Virginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary
Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP
Christine Rozek, LIEP
����� ��s��;� c��,f�
t`'"�.a,`� � �. �i��d�
Steve Faust, Community Organizer, West Side Citizens Organization, 127 Winifred St.
W., St. Paul, MN 55107
UNCONTESTED LICENSE HEARING �o _�
Licensee Name
Address:
Councif Date:
Violation:
Frank Gaston d!b/a Frank's Auto Service
150 Concord Street
April 26, 2000
Storage of vehicles and parts outside
St. Paul Legislative Code §60.543
Storage of inoperable vehicles for more than
five days
St. Pauf Legislative Code §60.219
Place:
Licensed Premises
Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf ofi client, Office
of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection:
30 day suspension of license, 15 days of which are stayed for 18
months on 3 conditions:
1. Property brought into compliance within one week
from passage of the reso{ution;
Attachments:
2. no further viotations of license conditions or other
code or zoning vio{ations during 18 months;
3. the licensee shall pay a$500.00 fiine within 30 days
of adoption of the resotution.
1. Proposed resolution
2. Notice of Violation
3. License Information Report
4. 3/14/00 violation memo and photographs from LIEP
5. 10/21/99 letter from Kristina Schweinler to Frank Gaston
Oo-'�oq
6. License information
CITY OP SAINT PAUL
Noim Coleman, iLfayor
March 21, 2000
OFFICF '�F TI-IE CITY ATTORNEY
Clay[on i. �binson, Jr., C+ryAttorney
CivilDivision
40D Ciry Ha11
1 S West Ke(togg Blvd.
Saint Paul, bfinnesafa SSIO2
DO -�{o�
Telephome: 651266-8 i IO
Fatsimile: 651298-5619
NOTICE OF VIOLATION
Frank Gaston
Frank's Auto Service
I50 Concord Street
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55107
RE: Auto Repair Gazage License held by Frank Gaston, d/b/a Frank's Auto Service for the
premises at 150 Concord Street, Saint Paul
License ID #: 99687
Deaz Mr. Gaston:
The Office of License, Inspections and Environmentai Protection has recommended
adverse action against the auto repair gazage license held by you at I50 Concord Street. The basis
for the recommendation is as follows:
On October 21,1999 a letter was sent to you by Kristina
Schweinler, a license inspector, advising you that the premises
at 150 Concord Street were the subject of neighborhood
complaints, and that you were storing vehicles and parfs
outside in violation of Saint Paul Legislative Code §60.543.
You were also advised thaf the storage of inoperable vehicles
for more than five days was prohibited by §60.219 of the Code,
and that vehicles were observed stored on the west and east
sides of the building in violation of that section. You were
given until November 30,1999 to remove the vehicles from the
property and clean the area of any parts or debris. That date
was extended until January 1, 200Q at the request of Gilbert
Delao.
On 1Vlarch 1, 2000 the license inspector again observed the
premises and saw a large amounf of outdoor storage, in
violation of the zoning code.
Page 2
Frank Gaston
Mazch 21, 2000
p0 -'�Oq
If you do not dispute the above facts please send me a letter with a statement to that
effect. The matter will then be scheduled for a hearing before the St. Paul City Council to
determine what penalty, if any, to impose. You will have an opporhulity to appear and speak on
your own behalf, or to have someone appeaz there far you.
On the other hand, if you wish to dispute the above facts, I will schedule an evidentiary
hearing before an Administrative Law Judge (AL,�. If you wish to have such a hearing, please
send me a letter stating that you aze contesting the facts. You will then be sent a"Notice of
Hearing," so you will know when and where to appeaz, and what the basis for the heazing will be.
In either case, please let me know in writing no later than Friday, March 31, 2000,
how you would like to proceed. If I have not heard from you by that date, I will assume
that you are not contesting the facts. The matter will then be scheduled for the hearing
before the St. Paul City Councii.
If you have any questions, feel free to call me or have your attorney call me at 266-8710.
Sincerely,
' v c,�j �, «-1�.-„-c_-�
�
Virginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP
Christine Rozek, LIEP
Steve Faust, Community Organizer, West Side Citizens Organization, 127 Winifred St.
W., St. Paul, MN 55107
eo-�o2
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
) ss.
COUNTY OF RAMSEY
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL
JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says
that on March 2I, 200�, she served the attached NOTICE OF VIOLATION
on the following named person by placing a true and correct copy
thereof in an envelope addressed as follows:
Frank Gaston
Frank's Auto Service
150 Concord Street
St. Paul, MN. 55107
(which is the last known address of
same, with postage prepaid, in the
Minnesota.
Subscribed and
this 21st o
� �
Notary
sworn to before me
f_/F�zrrtl�� 2 0 0 0.
PETER P. PAfVGBORN
WJ7ARY PUBUC - MINNESOTA
A1Y CAMMISSION
EX PIRES.lqN.31,2pp5
said person) and depositing the
Ofl -`��R
�
�
0
X I M W
O � O
O
�- � O
y V N
t6 J N
a o
r
O
a
�
c
O
:.
�a
E
�
w
_
d
N
C
d
c�
..I
m
�
m
�
�
�
U �
J U
Q
a
c
N
�
Q �
H �E
N �
�a
U �
�J �
Q
d I��
r �s
N 7£
M I�
Iz
I c c
1 J O
�
N
N
F-
�
�
�
�n O
°i U
N z
a �
a
U�
¢ o°
� u�'�
W
U
�
W
�
�
� _
m ¢
Z Y
Qz
0 �
tl.
Z
O
m q
Z �
= Y
O Z
a �
LL
�� �
7
O
V
�
N M
0
�
m
�
a
tu
N
c
�
m
�
E
�
2
UI
O
a
U
c
�:
�
N
C
E�
�I
Z
c;
n�
UI
m
U
c
N
7
�
_
`m
s
�
�
Z
N
C �
� N
a °'
rn
N N
N N
w ^
C
m�
0
�
H N
�
F-
�
�
�
�
U
Z
�
U
0
�
�
� ":
m
C� �yN R
U = c �-= w o
N (n O Q'a �p !n y
Na Y Y a�Y X �
� C 0 C 7 3��� O
@ ; rn
o.� w V- c>.aa�rn 'o
OQ• N f4Y
0
UQ � _�oNONO��
oa� � yQrn��a, m=
L � (nUN��p, ��
�w � Y'Q�"O ��
� � 0 Y" �p,U L 'O
LC �.. t��4�Nc-�NN� ON�
p � "'�' �� C',. ?� w "d N
OL � ��'C � N N N 3
N" rn �mmrnm°'3 ��
� �°' °o3>��a�i� �o
M i Y � C O_O LTy'C � 0�
�Ufn4iN �N - p' -
�oY�a ��ca ���
�� `m a� m w
ai
�3CpOO V QOJ � p�l��
F- oU"a o Y
Uv�iF- a c�rnm v�Na Q,
00 �007.�"00 C� � N N^ �� Q
00 00' �w�
NO � ENOw� dN U� fn
t t N O N f�� M N O. N N� O 1� k a t O.L ..
ir omc� ��r �0 3 0° ��
a�_., aa._v o
�
�
0
a
x
M W
O � I�
d U �
8I J m
N
0. N
�
C
�
C
O
y
R
�
L
w
C
d
c
d
U
J
N
3
�
�
d
U �
J Q
N
Q
F'� E
� Q
V �
N
J �
LL.
O �
O �
r I�I
M I
Z
C (�p
V �
.J �
�
�
N
F-
�
�
a
�o
�U
a Z
Q O O
O �
u) t{7
� �
W
V
�
W
�
�
E Q
Z U7
Y
�4
I �
LL
Z
O
m Q
C7
O Z
n �
U
C
�
O
U
�
N M
�
d
m
�
Q
w
y
C
�
�
�
�
Z
U
a
�
C
�
�
N
C
Z�
�
(6
Q
�
0
v
a�
U
N
7
C
N
9
E
�
Z
N
O �
� N
a °'
rn
N N
N N
� ^
C
'N r-
m �
�
� N
�
�
�
�
�
O
U
Z
�
U
O
�
I�
I�
I'.
i
�
i
i'
¢ R N Y � N
C�- C o-=. O
N (J) O Q � - p (n y
�a Y Y a��c Y
Y � � a3omrn `o
rn
�� O O � N ���2' 7
O a o ot� c�i��C�c �
U o � m
Q , m mY Oaioyo�a�
oa> � �u�arn��p��m�
� � t�tim o�
p � � Y'�.yMt �t in C
O�. � �Y' � Lp �- V i " O
�-O � �ON O�
pw 4 = ..." ca?w� a d
o °� °-' � =�c°ama� o`
N � JN�Old7� C
�c0 � p0_C C� �'N C
M N �� O 3>� N L 7 O
v-m Y c- �`n_orn�-�m ��
�oYmo a���a �
m a� � o�
Cr 41'6=ln TN.fl YQ
N N � � � ��a�-�� T UI���U
o->. c� N"a Y N Q .
ro� C O O U QO ��• m � ° '�'-c
t- ° -'-- o �rn °Y
°� � �rn o� Ni: a Q
O O O O
00 00' �� UV= N N"'�
NO Q 'ON ENOr.-� N � �1 �` N
'V N O N 1� C M N dN (6 L Ln� p_uJ .
� N Q�� @� M� O 3 0�� C� C
Mc�J_MNr�� n.c-_�+LLd.�V' O
60 -`��`t
0 0—'fo�t
I�`
i@
0
lal W
O N ��
O
M � O
y V N
A J �
�- N
�
O
a
�
c
0
R
�
�
w
c
d
N
C
d
U
�
N
w
�6
�
�
a�i >
U +-�
-' a
N
rn
��f6
�I�
N
���
0 0
J �
Q
O
o ��
N �I
I
` Z I
c i c�p
U �
1 O
�
f6
N
F-�
�
N O
a `z
O
�
Q U o
O �
��
W
U
�
W
�
�
a� ]
� Q
I � �
a Y
Z
'O �
LL
i� O
t-
�Z �
c
o Z
a�
.n C
�
O
U
C
N
� O
�
m
:
X
�
c
�
�
E
3
Z
U
a
U
C
�
�
N
C
d
E
W
Z
a
C
d
�
0
U
c
m
7
N
C
�
�
7
Z
Q1
C �
O N
s �
a a ,
N �
y N
� N
m �
0
� �
�
F �
�
�
F"
�
0
�
�
U
Z
O
U
O
�
a �p 'C N '-' Ol
n�,x � m
V = c °�— � `o
Y� Y ,.� °'�y Y �
� � O � �'� �:�p� O
�.�` „' O � N �._�O�O_' �
O n � ��s' °
Qa ±n mY�^'
U`oa � =�°a
D N � jp p_O� �._ � � _
y� i (n U d�2 O-N O a1
� o c
� � � Y YV� rnfl-c�i 'nv
RO � �Od��y� Oa1
p r''-. � C'. Z.��.'. '6 �l
Nw � o, �
� �mmrnd - oc
�m rn o nc��°-w c3
cnN �� o3> �o
r-� Y r CQO�dL� 0�
� rn-��-ca��i� �
�-Y3r �t4N (6 N
'� G U DO N�� N TT� �Q
m �� , ' g a m �_o d tn �' a U
�om am ° c��w � Y ��.a�i
� �
O NO � UW C O N �-p6> O
° o ° o �' � �� NN�'rn �-
NOfl-ONENOu �NN�7c-N
' 1' N O N f�- C M N O.N N�L„ �ik O.�f .�.-
M Y N Y �� ��m�03� LN�C
(h �MN+-.�-� Q. Q.d Cst O
CITY OF SAINT PAUL �� 4 ��
INTERDEPARTMENTAL MEMORANDUM
DATE: 3/14/2000
TO:Ginger Palmer
�� ,
FROM:Kris Schweinler 0 \
RE:150 Concord St. Frank's Auto Service
CTinger,
Attached are some photos taken on 3/1/Z000 of the above repair shop. The property continues to
violate the zoning ordinance with the large amount of outdoor storage. I have attempted to try
and work with this location for over a year and he is either unable or unwilling to bring the
property into compiiance.
Let me know if there is anything else you need in order to proceed.
Cc: Christine Rozek / Deputy Director
S .q !�, P ��, e, ..�F .o �- € x� ,� �q.,..;1
� � � . . ii �� y4� <
'� � y� ,�� � - '� 3 �I St � .a� .. r •
� s�,���� � � _ , �.,� � �: . �s,. a . �� . �
�
� :.'.k:: !. . . . .
�
.._�' i .��� ��rl _. - . .
.� � � , - -'. ._ .
x �� r :
, �. . , � � ;�. . ' ` — � .
. � - i - . � . �.
' � i
. - � I � , � � . . �
4
� � � �� �_i ` � . �*>�� - '� �
.. . ._ -- f; � . � � .
�v�� b�r�� . ��p;--�=' .
< ti Y.A.{ @ i ���
.. -t.;r� � � , � ... +" �-
� � � 4�9 �_. ,s�� _. .
M � ] •. ' " 2 . <` b ;S
' ��'-� ����" ��'sa: � .. 6 _ ... . .
y � := ��: �� �,; -,!+°- � �i>rrrr$%AU 0 S[RVIC�
M1 � l .. � 4.� ( �
� E
i
i -
� � . • :. _. � ..
. .... '� v..���� . .
. \ � . . . . . . . . .
f :
�� �� P� .,
~ � � �'� �y / ..i u Y
4 (.
1 �� r;�1. �,,:�� �i i . a5 ,3�sr.Q�R-",a. 3
� s� 4
� • � �''� ���� , � ' �
. . s a, fi ���� '�� � �'. - �'- ` . . . . .
�`�?" � - � ���! ...!„ I i �. . . I � .
- _E:.. ..-.. . � ..
I '1�'"'\.,-.�_.. ._ . Q . .
. . .. . .: �.,.,�, .. , . . _ - - _ . , .
__-
. �� =cT`-.w�>-, s:.; s � � -
„_ �_
--� ' . � ^''�'.' ., :.._ "' . . .
�. � '�"s:i ' _ �_ .
�
OFFICE OF LICENSE, LYSPECI'fONS A,�ID
ENVIRONMENTALPROTECTION
XobenKessler, Dvector
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Norm Coleman, Mayor
! A W R Y P R O F FS S! O NA L B UQ D I N G
350 Sc PetesStreet, Suite 300
SairttPaul,Minnesata SSIQ2-1510
Oct.21,1999
Mr. Frank Gaston
645 Robert St.
St.Paul,Mn.55107
Re: 150 Concord St. Frank's Auto Service
Mr. Crnston,
oa -��t
Telephane: 651-266-9090
Facnmile: 65]-1669099
651-266-912i
On April 15,1999 I spoke with you regarding the condition of your property at 150 Concord St.
We have again received complaints about the condition ofthe property, specifically the storage of
vehicles and parts. `Iou are located in a B-3 commercial zone. This does not allow outdoor
storage of motor vehicles or parts. St.Paul Leg. Code 60.543. (Copy attached)
An inspection on Oct.20 showed that you still have vehicles stored out of doors behind the fence
on the west and east sides of the buiiding. Most of these ve�icles appear to be inoperable. St.Paul
Leg. Code 60.219 does not ailow for the storage of vehicles for more that 5 days. (Copy
attached)
This letter is to notify you that you have until Nov. 30, 1999 to remove the vehicles from the
property and to clean the area of any parts or debris. Failure to do so may result in adverse action
being taken against your license.
Please contact me if you have any questions at (651)266-9110
Respectfully,
,�.�5�� .
I{ristina Schweinler
Sr. License Inspector
Cc: Christine Rozek, Deputy Director
Larry Zangs, Zoning Specialist
Ginger Palmer, Asst. City Atty.
License Group CommeMS Text
Licensee: FRANKGASTON
�BA� FRANK'S AUTO SERVICE
License #: 0099687
02/09/2000
C10 -�£a2
Pic.given to lZfoc tag,tli3lOoKS.lnspected the prop. on'l/3l00 took pic.stift alot of junk on prop.fence now fa0ing down and needs repair.KS.Lette sent
10/21/g9 giving until 1'I/30/99 to clean up prop.was contacted by Gilbert Delao(Neigh.HOUSe.) they would Iike to the first of the year to help get this prop.
into shape. ok'd that if progress is made before the weaiher changes. Gilbert's Ph.#227-9297.KS
�``'��,�
�
00 -Ltoq
bo-�-to?
�, z�-.:� �::.. � ., r.:
�$� �� �� :� � ��
. Typti Ea��..,. i .,^�.c..RNtx. �''t :� �: -. Y
i�'s,,.��avce :a:,.�mv. ;��:x.... .a�':
i Stre� .._. ...
, � License ucensee : Lic. Types
_�___r�.._
: r; .... ...................:.........................
' SYre!;i f C'• praperty (� Licensee � Unofficiel
- .., •
:.
; Diret;< Street#: �W
...................
�� Unit i?; �eet Name: ONCORD
....... ....... .. ........ .........................
� �� �; Street Type: �ST ! Diredion: �
� 3r Und Ind � ; Unit S: �
r..
; ;� CdY _T.PAUI ...............
.......................
�,
` :p+ Stste: IN � Zip: r
�; � Ward �[
� ii Dist Couri: �]3 i
Licensee:
DBA:
Sales Tax
6us
DBA
Insurance ,: Band � RequiremeMs �
.......................... ...................................................................................
i Projed Facilitator. GUNTHER, V4ILLIAM (BILL)
: Adverse AcGon CommeMs
: : ......................................................................................................:
.......r--:=_��- .
. [ Commerrts:
,>.yv
`�;BFfl..W.S��
Comments.
10N511999 E 1
. _. _ ................. �....
09t14M 998 ` t
.......................P....
torzonss� € �
# �99687 ; Save Changes to History
�
ge From D7 To ff2 On 4109/92
Change From Rich To Denver - t �E�2
ORlG�NAL
�
Presented By
Referred To
r��M�
Council File # p0 -�k0''t
Green Sheet #( O 3 q�. �
a�
2 RESOLVED, that the Auto Repair Gazage license held b�
3 Auto Service (License ID # 0099687), for the premises at I S�ox
4 suspended for a period of thirry days for outside storage of v cle
5 Saint Paul Legislative Code §60.543, and for storage of in erable
6 days, which is prohibited by Saint Paul Legislative Code,�0.219.
10
11
12
� 3
4
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
�rank Gaston d/b/a Frank's
�ord Street, is hereby
; and parts in violation of
vehicles for more than five
FURTHBR RESOLVED, that I S days of said suspension sha11 be stayed for a period of
eighteen months on the following conditions: 1) that�the properly is brought into compliance
with the conditions on the license within one weekiCrom the passage of this Resolution; 2) that
there be no further violations of the conditions o�the license or other code or zoning violations
during the eighteen months; and 3) that the licerisee pay a fine of $500.00, said fine to be paid to
ihe Office of License, Inspections and Envirota Protection within thirty(30) days of the
adoption of this resolution by the Council at�� signature by the Mayor. For the remaining 15
days suspension, no business operations� shj� 1 be permitted beginning at 12:01 a.m., Wednesday,
May 17, 2000, through 11:59 p.m., Wedn�sday May 31, 2000. �, N
This ResoluYion and the action
contained in the October 21, 1999 I
Violation letter to the licensee, and
the public hearing. The licensee di�
, /�
t
E'the Council in this matter aze based upon the facts
to the licensee from LIEP, the March 21, 2000 Notice of
azguments as may have been presented fo the Council at
contest the facts of the violation.
Reques��t by Dep��art��ment — of:
4/tkU�.. X' G�1�'ESiv.
By:
Adopted by Council: Date
Adoption Certified by Council Secretary
$Y�
�pproved by Mayor: Date
Hy:
Form Approved by City At�ey
Bv: 1�� <._ � � �, c�,/,-.,��
Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
8y:
Office of LIEP/City Attorney
Virginia Palmer
Mazch 31, 2000
TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES
GREEN SHEET
oi.,.naruwQe,aR
Oo -�{o�
.� ��.,.. ,
No V� � V�
anaauct
`OIYAiiO�ItY ❑OIVCtflll[
I NI�IIOLL�YCp0�1. ❑ AI�111CYLYIIVGCCTC
I rro�tp��wnwn �
(CUP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE�
Resolution conceming adverse action against ffie Auto Repair Garage License held by Frank Gaston, dba
Frank's Auto Service, 150 Concord Street. (LTncontested)
PLANNING COMMISSfON
C16 COMMfTTEE
CML SERVICE CAMMfSS10N
ihe Nis G� r.erraNetl under s cvdact tarMis tlepaM�nC7
YES NO
FMS th's D� auer Eeen e e'dy empbyce7
YES WO
OoecUiis PasoMmm 9�en eak� not � bY �Y a�eM �ily emPlQYee'1
YES NO
k M's pdwnlfum amrpeted�varitldt
YES NO I
TRANSACTIONf
NNDMG SOURCE
fASTIREVENUE BUDQETm (GRCLE ONE)
ACTIVRV NUI�ER
YEE NO
Hrr.^:!m�_•',:rr_�� ,.Tr��`1
p ���k
� � �
5 �3)°
:L, .
J
�! `` � . R6�'Wl{�Is�wsW�('�ll'� � .
� �'EGIZ- �GII�'iD� �:GZt�P.aC
. �
�'G�cccSVe is �r�r� t��kl � �41�6/�u� �ard�wcauccs
�► +�tl � �ffiaQ2 �4'Yl �e -l�e�li� ����.tts �Q
�
�fa�'�e r�t��e�ble t�.Gtr� �f: P�h < tM /�'� 2�;
�u r� � s s� � � �tialf �e �us f�r
d oK ca���/� s z 3 c� � �
3o s �n � ) C )
. ��w��.0 ��-s�lv�D` �f . �
�
�..
,
�
QRiG�NA�.
Presented By
Refened To
Council FIle # 00 -40�'i
m�Y.�e� _ {�l�� 3 , �-ec o
� Green Sheet # t O 3 Q L�{
SO TION
CITY iTL, TA ar�
Pa e �
Committee: Date
2 RESOLVED, that the Auto Repair Gazage license held by Frank Czaston dfb/a Frank's
3 Auto Service (License ID # 0099687), for the premises at 15Q Concord Street, is hereby
4 suspended for a period of thirty days for outside storage of vehicles and parts in violation of
5 Saint Paul Legislative Code §60.543, and for storage of inoperable vehicles for more than five
6 days, which is prohibited by Saint Paul Legislative Code §60.219.
7
8 FI3RTHER RESOLVED, that 15 days of said suspension sha11 be stayed for a period of
9 eighteen months on the following conditions: 1) that the property is brought into compliance
10 with the conditions on the license within one week from the passage of this Resolution; 2) that
i 1 there be no further violations of the conditions on the license or other code or zoning violations
12
13
14
15
16
17
1&
19
20
21
during the eighteen months; and 3) that the licensee pay a fine of $500.00, said fine to be paid to
the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection within thirty(30) days of the
adoption of this resolution by the Council and signature by the Mayor. For the remauvng 15
days suspension, no business operations shall be pernutted begiiuiiiig at 12:01 a.m, Wednesday,
May 17, 2000, through 11:54 pm., Wednesday May 31, 2000.
-� S`E�S er� �o.r�rar h ( �Yriev�7,mev��� - �a�� 2-.
This Resolution and the action of the Council in this ma#ter are based upon the facts
contained in the OcCober 21, 1999 letter to the licensee from LIEP, the March 21, 2000 Notice of
Violation letter to the licensee, and such arguments as may have been presented to the Council at
the public heazing. The licensee did not contest the facts of the violation.
Reques� by Department of:
4/GrYR�-a JI��
&y:
Form Approved by City Att, ey
By:
Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By:
App�
By:
By:
Adoptied by Council; Date _�\�d Q G
1
Adoption Certified by Council Sec ary
eo -��`f
Insert the following Amendment (on Page 1) (May 3, 2000)
FURTF�R RESOLVED that notwithstandin the for�oin�, if the licensed premises is
broueht into full comnliance with City ordinances relating to outside stora¢e of vehicles and
parts and storage of inoperable vehicles by 4•00 �m on May 17 2000 the entire thirry (30 davs
suspension shall be suspended for thirtv1301 days on conditions (21 and (31 in the fore�m�
"FURTHER RESOLVED" clause.
Office of LIEP/City Attomey
NTACT PQ27.�N & PFIOI�
Virginia Palmer
����
Mazch 31, 2000
TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES
GREEN SHEET
oa.R�rt ona7ae
00 -�o�
Nol G��?�4
uir�ouct
CRYAiTORIEY ❑ OIYCLiRI[
H4MCMifFRNCFJ9R. ❑ RYMWLiFiM4CtT6
II�YOR(OR�V1LLL111l) ❑
iCLiP ALl LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE)
Resolufion concerning adverse action against the Auto Repair Garage License held by Frank Gaston, dba
Frank's Auto Service, 150 Concord Street. (iJncontested)
PLANNING GOMMISSION
CIB COMMITTEE
CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION
Has this persorvhrm e�sx wnrketl uMxa conhact fof thia depaRmeM7
YES NO
Has ttiie peisorJfirtn Caer been a city empbyee?
YES NO
Doesthis De�soM�im o�sesc a s�6n not nrnma9YPOSSessetl bY �P airreM ciiv emWovee?
YES NO
Is thia pe+sorilfirm aU�B�etl vendoYt
YES NO
TRANSACTIOIi S
SOURCE
CAST/REV@7UE BUD6ETED (CIRCLE ONk�
ACTWItY NUMBER
YES NO
INFORMA710N(IXPWln
OFFICE OF TI-IE CITY ATTORNEY
Clayton M Robinson, b., Ciry Attomey
ao ..�{n
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
NormColemun, Mayor
Civi! Division
40Q Ciry Ha11
1 S West Kellogg BJvd
Saint Pau1, Minnesota i5T 02
Tetephone: 651266-8710
Facsimile; 65I298-5619
March 30, 2000
NOTICE OF COUNCIL MEETING
Frank Gaston
Frank's Auto Service
150 Concord Street
Saint Pau1, Minnesota 55107
RE: Auto Repair Garage License held by Frank Gaston, d/bfa Frank's Auto Service for the
premises at 150 Concord Street, Saint Paui
License ID #: 99687
Deaz Mr. Gaston:
P1ease take notice that a hearing concerning the above-named establishment has been scheduled
for 5:30 p.m., Wednesday, Aprii 26, 2000 in the Ciry Councii Chambers, Third Fioor, Saint
Paul City Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse.
Enclosed aze copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to
the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested hearing, in that the facts
concerning the violations of St. Paul Legislative code have not been denied. You will have an
opportunity at the Council hearing to present oral and/or written remarks as to the penalry, if any,
to be imposed.
If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710.
Very truly yours,
���� ��
Virginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary
Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP
Christine Rozek, LIEP
����� ��s��;� c��,f�
t`'"�.a,`� � �. �i��d�
Steve Faust, Community Organizer, West Side Citizens Organization, 127 Winifred St.
W., St. Paul, MN 55107
UNCONTESTED LICENSE HEARING �o _�
Licensee Name
Address:
Councif Date:
Violation:
Frank Gaston d!b/a Frank's Auto Service
150 Concord Street
April 26, 2000
Storage of vehicles and parts outside
St. Paul Legislative Code §60.543
Storage of inoperable vehicles for more than
five days
St. Pauf Legislative Code §60.219
Place:
Licensed Premises
Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf ofi client, Office
of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection:
30 day suspension of license, 15 days of which are stayed for 18
months on 3 conditions:
1. Property brought into compliance within one week
from passage of the reso{ution;
Attachments:
2. no further viotations of license conditions or other
code or zoning vio{ations during 18 months;
3. the licensee shall pay a$500.00 fiine within 30 days
of adoption of the resotution.
1. Proposed resolution
2. Notice of Violation
3. License Information Report
4. 3/14/00 violation memo and photographs from LIEP
5. 10/21/99 letter from Kristina Schweinler to Frank Gaston
Oo-'�oq
6. License information
CITY OP SAINT PAUL
Noim Coleman, iLfayor
March 21, 2000
OFFICF '�F TI-IE CITY ATTORNEY
Clay[on i. �binson, Jr., C+ryAttorney
CivilDivision
40D Ciry Ha11
1 S West Ke(togg Blvd.
Saint Paul, bfinnesafa SSIO2
DO -�{o�
Telephome: 651266-8 i IO
Fatsimile: 651298-5619
NOTICE OF VIOLATION
Frank Gaston
Frank's Auto Service
I50 Concord Street
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55107
RE: Auto Repair Gazage License held by Frank Gaston, d/b/a Frank's Auto Service for the
premises at 150 Concord Street, Saint Paul
License ID #: 99687
Deaz Mr. Gaston:
The Office of License, Inspections and Environmentai Protection has recommended
adverse action against the auto repair gazage license held by you at I50 Concord Street. The basis
for the recommendation is as follows:
On October 21,1999 a letter was sent to you by Kristina
Schweinler, a license inspector, advising you that the premises
at 150 Concord Street were the subject of neighborhood
complaints, and that you were storing vehicles and parfs
outside in violation of Saint Paul Legislative Code §60.543.
You were also advised thaf the storage of inoperable vehicles
for more than five days was prohibited by §60.219 of the Code,
and that vehicles were observed stored on the west and east
sides of the building in violation of that section. You were
given until November 30,1999 to remove the vehicles from the
property and clean the area of any parts or debris. That date
was extended until January 1, 200Q at the request of Gilbert
Delao.
On 1Vlarch 1, 2000 the license inspector again observed the
premises and saw a large amounf of outdoor storage, in
violation of the zoning code.
Page 2
Frank Gaston
Mazch 21, 2000
p0 -'�Oq
If you do not dispute the above facts please send me a letter with a statement to that
effect. The matter will then be scheduled for a hearing before the St. Paul City Council to
determine what penalty, if any, to impose. You will have an opporhulity to appear and speak on
your own behalf, or to have someone appeaz there far you.
On the other hand, if you wish to dispute the above facts, I will schedule an evidentiary
hearing before an Administrative Law Judge (AL,�. If you wish to have such a hearing, please
send me a letter stating that you aze contesting the facts. You will then be sent a"Notice of
Hearing," so you will know when and where to appeaz, and what the basis for the heazing will be.
In either case, please let me know in writing no later than Friday, March 31, 2000,
how you would like to proceed. If I have not heard from you by that date, I will assume
that you are not contesting the facts. The matter will then be scheduled for the hearing
before the St. Paul City Councii.
If you have any questions, feel free to call me or have your attorney call me at 266-8710.
Sincerely,
' v c,�j �, «-1�.-„-c_-�
�
Virginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP
Christine Rozek, LIEP
Steve Faust, Community Organizer, West Side Citizens Organization, 127 Winifred St.
W., St. Paul, MN 55107
eo-�o2
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
) ss.
COUNTY OF RAMSEY
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL
JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says
that on March 2I, 200�, she served the attached NOTICE OF VIOLATION
on the following named person by placing a true and correct copy
thereof in an envelope addressed as follows:
Frank Gaston
Frank's Auto Service
150 Concord Street
St. Paul, MN. 55107
(which is the last known address of
same, with postage prepaid, in the
Minnesota.
Subscribed and
this 21st o
� �
Notary
sworn to before me
f_/F�zrrtl�� 2 0 0 0.
PETER P. PAfVGBORN
WJ7ARY PUBUC - MINNESOTA
A1Y CAMMISSION
EX PIRES.lqN.31,2pp5
said person) and depositing the
Ofl -`��R
�
�
0
X I M W
O � O
O
�- � O
y V N
t6 J N
a o
r
O
a
�
c
O
:.
�a
E
�
w
_
d
N
C
d
c�
..I
m
�
m
�
�
�
U �
J U
Q
a
c
N
�
Q �
H �E
N �
�a
U �
�J �
Q
d I��
r �s
N 7£
M I�
Iz
I c c
1 J O
�
N
N
F-
�
�
�
�n O
°i U
N z
a �
a
U�
¢ o°
� u�'�
W
U
�
W
�
�
� _
m ¢
Z Y
Qz
0 �
tl.
Z
O
m q
Z �
= Y
O Z
a �
LL
�� �
7
O
V
�
N M
0
�
m
�
a
tu
N
c
�
m
�
E
�
2
UI
O
a
U
c
�:
�
N
C
E�
�I
Z
c;
n�
UI
m
U
c
N
7
�
_
`m
s
�
�
Z
N
C �
� N
a °'
rn
N N
N N
w ^
C
m�
0
�
H N
�
F-
�
�
�
�
U
Z
�
U
0
�
�
� ":
m
C� �yN R
U = c �-= w o
N (n O Q'a �p !n y
Na Y Y a�Y X �
� C 0 C 7 3��� O
@ ; rn
o.� w V- c>.aa�rn 'o
OQ• N f4Y
0
UQ � _�oNONO��
oa� � yQrn��a, m=
L � (nUN��p, ��
�w � Y'Q�"O ��
� � 0 Y" �p,U L 'O
LC �.. t��4�Nc-�NN� ON�
p � "'�' �� C',. ?� w "d N
OL � ��'C � N N N 3
N" rn �mmrnm°'3 ��
� �°' °o3>��a�i� �o
M i Y � C O_O LTy'C � 0�
�Ufn4iN �N - p' -
�oY�a ��ca ���
�� `m a� m w
ai
�3CpOO V QOJ � p�l��
F- oU"a o Y
Uv�iF- a c�rnm v�Na Q,
00 �007.�"00 C� � N N^ �� Q
00 00' �w�
NO � ENOw� dN U� fn
t t N O N f�� M N O. N N� O 1� k a t O.L ..
ir omc� ��r �0 3 0° ��
a�_., aa._v o
�
�
0
a
x
M W
O � I�
d U �
8I J m
N
0. N
�
C
�
C
O
y
R
�
L
w
C
d
c
d
U
J
N
3
�
�
d
U �
J Q
N
Q
F'� E
� Q
V �
N
J �
LL.
O �
O �
r I�I
M I
Z
C (�p
V �
.J �
�
�
N
F-
�
�
a
�o
�U
a Z
Q O O
O �
u) t{7
� �
W
V
�
W
�
�
E Q
Z U7
Y
�4
I �
LL
Z
O
m Q
C7
O Z
n �
U
C
�
O
U
�
N M
�
d
m
�
Q
w
y
C
�
�
�
�
Z
U
a
�
C
�
�
N
C
Z�
�
(6
Q
�
0
v
a�
U
N
7
C
N
9
E
�
Z
N
O �
� N
a °'
rn
N N
N N
� ^
C
'N r-
m �
�
� N
�
�
�
�
�
O
U
Z
�
U
O
�
I�
I�
I'.
i
�
i
i'
¢ R N Y � N
C�- C o-=. O
N (J) O Q � - p (n y
�a Y Y a��c Y
Y � � a3omrn `o
rn
�� O O � N ���2' 7
O a o ot� c�i��C�c �
U o � m
Q , m mY Oaioyo�a�
oa> � �u�arn��p��m�
� � t�tim o�
p � � Y'�.yMt �t in C
O�. � �Y' � Lp �- V i " O
�-O � �ON O�
pw 4 = ..." ca?w� a d
o °� °-' � =�c°ama� o`
N � JN�Old7� C
�c0 � p0_C C� �'N C
M N �� O 3>� N L 7 O
v-m Y c- �`n_orn�-�m ��
�oYmo a���a �
m a� � o�
Cr 41'6=ln TN.fl YQ
N N � � � ��a�-�� T UI���U
o->. c� N"a Y N Q .
ro� C O O U QO ��• m � ° '�'-c
t- ° -'-- o �rn °Y
°� � �rn o� Ni: a Q
O O O O
00 00' �� UV= N N"'�
NO Q 'ON ENOr.-� N � �1 �` N
'V N O N 1� C M N dN (6 L Ln� p_uJ .
� N Q�� @� M� O 3 0�� C� C
Mc�J_MNr�� n.c-_�+LLd.�V' O
60 -`��`t
0 0—'fo�t
I�`
i@
0
lal W
O N ��
O
M � O
y V N
A J �
�- N
�
O
a
�
c
0
R
�
�
w
c
d
N
C
d
U
�
N
w
�6
�
�
a�i >
U +-�
-' a
N
rn
��f6
�I�
N
���
0 0
J �
Q
O
o ��
N �I
I
` Z I
c i c�p
U �
1 O
�
f6
N
F-�
�
N O
a `z
O
�
Q U o
O �
��
W
U
�
W
�
�
a� ]
� Q
I � �
a Y
Z
'O �
LL
i� O
t-
�Z �
c
o Z
a�
.n C
�
O
U
C
N
� O
�
m
:
X
�
c
�
�
E
3
Z
U
a
U
C
�
�
N
C
d
E
W
Z
a
C
d
�
0
U
c
m
7
N
C
�
�
7
Z
Q1
C �
O N
s �
a a ,
N �
y N
� N
m �
0
� �
�
F �
�
�
F"
�
0
�
�
U
Z
O
U
O
�
a �p 'C N '-' Ol
n�,x � m
V = c °�— � `o
Y� Y ,.� °'�y Y �
� � O � �'� �:�p� O
�.�` „' O � N �._�O�O_' �
O n � ��s' °
Qa ±n mY�^'
U`oa � =�°a
D N � jp p_O� �._ � � _
y� i (n U d�2 O-N O a1
� o c
� � � Y YV� rnfl-c�i 'nv
RO � �Od��y� Oa1
p r''-. � C'. Z.��.'. '6 �l
Nw � o, �
� �mmrnd - oc
�m rn o nc��°-w c3
cnN �� o3> �o
r-� Y r CQO�dL� 0�
� rn-��-ca��i� �
�-Y3r �t4N (6 N
'� G U DO N�� N TT� �Q
m �� , ' g a m �_o d tn �' a U
�om am ° c��w � Y ��.a�i
� �
O NO � UW C O N �-p6> O
° o ° o �' � �� NN�'rn �-
NOfl-ONENOu �NN�7c-N
' 1' N O N f�- C M N O.N N�L„ �ik O.�f .�.-
M Y N Y �� ��m�03� LN�C
(h �MN+-.�-� Q. Q.d Cst O
CITY OF SAINT PAUL �� 4 ��
INTERDEPARTMENTAL MEMORANDUM
DATE: 3/14/2000
TO:Ginger Palmer
�� ,
FROM:Kris Schweinler 0 \
RE:150 Concord St. Frank's Auto Service
CTinger,
Attached are some photos taken on 3/1/Z000 of the above repair shop. The property continues to
violate the zoning ordinance with the large amount of outdoor storage. I have attempted to try
and work with this location for over a year and he is either unable or unwilling to bring the
property into compiiance.
Let me know if there is anything else you need in order to proceed.
Cc: Christine Rozek / Deputy Director
S .q !�, P ��, e, ..�F .o �- € x� ,� �q.,..;1
� � � . . ii �� y4� <
'� � y� ,�� � - '� 3 �I St � .a� .. r •
� s�,���� � � _ , �.,� � �: . �s,. a . �� . �
�
� :.'.k:: !. . . . .
�
.._�' i .��� ��rl _. - . .
.� � � , - -'. ._ .
x �� r :
, �. . , � � ;�. . ' ` — � .
. � - i - . � . �.
' � i
. - � I � , � � . . �
4
� � � �� �_i ` � . �*>�� - '� �
.. . ._ -- f; � . � � .
�v�� b�r�� . ��p;--�=' .
< ti Y.A.{ @ i ���
.. -t.;r� � � , � ... +" �-
� � � 4�9 �_. ,s�� _. .
M � ] •. ' " 2 . <` b ;S
' ��'-� ����" ��'sa: � .. 6 _ ... . .
y � := ��: �� �,; -,!+°- � �i>rrrr$%AU 0 S[RVIC�
M1 � l .. � 4.� ( �
� E
i
i -
� � . • :. _. � ..
. .... '� v..���� . .
. \ � . . . . . . . . .
f :
�� �� P� .,
~ � � �'� �y / ..i u Y
4 (.
1 �� r;�1. �,,:�� �i i . a5 ,3�sr.Q�R-",a. 3
� s� 4
� • � �''� ���� , � ' �
. . s a, fi ���� '�� � �'. - �'- ` . . . . .
�`�?" � - � ���! ...!„ I i �. . . I � .
- _E:.. ..-.. . � ..
I '1�'"'\.,-.�_.. ._ . Q . .
. . .. . .: �.,.,�, .. , . . _ - - _ . , .
__-
. �� =cT`-.w�>-, s:.; s � � -
„_ �_
--� ' . � ^''�'.' ., :.._ "' . . .
�. � '�"s:i ' _ �_ .
�
OFFICE OF LICENSE, LYSPECI'fONS A,�ID
ENVIRONMENTALPROTECTION
XobenKessler, Dvector
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Norm Coleman, Mayor
! A W R Y P R O F FS S! O NA L B UQ D I N G
350 Sc PetesStreet, Suite 300
SairttPaul,Minnesata SSIQ2-1510
Oct.21,1999
Mr. Frank Gaston
645 Robert St.
St.Paul,Mn.55107
Re: 150 Concord St. Frank's Auto Service
Mr. Crnston,
oa -��t
Telephane: 651-266-9090
Facnmile: 65]-1669099
651-266-912i
On April 15,1999 I spoke with you regarding the condition of your property at 150 Concord St.
We have again received complaints about the condition ofthe property, specifically the storage of
vehicles and parts. `Iou are located in a B-3 commercial zone. This does not allow outdoor
storage of motor vehicles or parts. St.Paul Leg. Code 60.543. (Copy attached)
An inspection on Oct.20 showed that you still have vehicles stored out of doors behind the fence
on the west and east sides of the buiiding. Most of these ve�icles appear to be inoperable. St.Paul
Leg. Code 60.219 does not ailow for the storage of vehicles for more that 5 days. (Copy
attached)
This letter is to notify you that you have until Nov. 30, 1999 to remove the vehicles from the
property and to clean the area of any parts or debris. Failure to do so may result in adverse action
being taken against your license.
Please contact me if you have any questions at (651)266-9110
Respectfully,
,�.�5�� .
I{ristina Schweinler
Sr. License Inspector
Cc: Christine Rozek, Deputy Director
Larry Zangs, Zoning Specialist
Ginger Palmer, Asst. City Atty.
License Group CommeMS Text
Licensee: FRANKGASTON
�BA� FRANK'S AUTO SERVICE
License #: 0099687
02/09/2000
C10 -�£a2
Pic.given to lZfoc tag,tli3lOoKS.lnspected the prop. on'l/3l00 took pic.stift alot of junk on prop.fence now fa0ing down and needs repair.KS.Lette sent
10/21/g9 giving until 1'I/30/99 to clean up prop.was contacted by Gilbert Delao(Neigh.HOUSe.) they would Iike to the first of the year to help get this prop.
into shape. ok'd that if progress is made before the weaiher changes. Gilbert's Ph.#227-9297.KS
�``'��,�
�
00 -Ltoq
bo-�-to?
�, z�-.:� �::.. � ., r.:
�$� �� �� :� � ��
. Typti Ea��..,. i .,^�.c..RNtx. �''t :� �: -. Y
i�'s,,.��avce :a:,.�mv. ;��:x.... .a�':
i Stre� .._. ...
, � License ucensee : Lic. Types
_�___r�.._
: r; .... ...................:.........................
' SYre!;i f C'• praperty (� Licensee � Unofficiel
- .., •
:.
; Diret;< Street#: �W
...................
�� Unit i?; �eet Name: ONCORD
....... ....... .. ........ .........................
� �� �; Street Type: �ST ! Diredion: �
� 3r Und Ind � ; Unit S: �
r..
; ;� CdY _T.PAUI ...............
.......................
�,
` :p+ Stste: IN � Zip: r
�; � Ward �[
� ii Dist Couri: �]3 i
Licensee:
DBA:
Sales Tax
6us
DBA
Insurance ,: Band � RequiremeMs �
.......................... ...................................................................................
i Projed Facilitator. GUNTHER, V4ILLIAM (BILL)
: Adverse AcGon CommeMs
: : ......................................................................................................:
.......r--:=_��- .
. [ Commerrts:
,>.yv
`�;BFfl..W.S��
Comments.
10N511999 E 1
. _. _ ................. �....
09t14M 998 ` t
.......................P....
torzonss� € �
# �99687 ; Save Changes to History
�
ge From D7 To ff2 On 4109/92
Change From Rich To Denver - t �E�2
ORlG�NAL
�
Presented By
Referred To
r��M�
Council File # p0 -�k0''t
Green Sheet #( O 3 q�. �
a�
2 RESOLVED, that the Auto Repair Gazage license held b�
3 Auto Service (License ID # 0099687), for the premises at I S�ox
4 suspended for a period of thirry days for outside storage of v cle
5 Saint Paul Legislative Code §60.543, and for storage of in erable
6 days, which is prohibited by Saint Paul Legislative Code,�0.219.
10
11
12
� 3
4
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
�rank Gaston d/b/a Frank's
�ord Street, is hereby
; and parts in violation of
vehicles for more than five
FURTHBR RESOLVED, that I S days of said suspension sha11 be stayed for a period of
eighteen months on the following conditions: 1) that�the properly is brought into compliance
with the conditions on the license within one weekiCrom the passage of this Resolution; 2) that
there be no further violations of the conditions o�the license or other code or zoning violations
during the eighteen months; and 3) that the licerisee pay a fine of $500.00, said fine to be paid to
ihe Office of License, Inspections and Envirota Protection within thirty(30) days of the
adoption of this resolution by the Council at�� signature by the Mayor. For the remaining 15
days suspension, no business operations� shj� 1 be permitted beginning at 12:01 a.m., Wednesday,
May 17, 2000, through 11:59 p.m., Wedn�sday May 31, 2000. �, N
This ResoluYion and the action
contained in the October 21, 1999 I
Violation letter to the licensee, and
the public hearing. The licensee di�
, /�
t
E'the Council in this matter aze based upon the facts
to the licensee from LIEP, the March 21, 2000 Notice of
azguments as may have been presented fo the Council at
contest the facts of the violation.
Reques��t by Dep��art��ment — of:
4/tkU�.. X' G�1�'ESiv.
By:
Adopted by Council: Date
Adoption Certified by Council Secretary
$Y�
�pproved by Mayor: Date
Hy:
Form Approved by City At�ey
Bv: 1�� <._ � � �, c�,/,-.,��
Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
8y:
Office of LIEP/City Attorney
Virginia Palmer
Mazch 31, 2000
TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES
GREEN SHEET
oi.,.naruwQe,aR
Oo -�{o�
.� ��.,.. ,
No V� � V�
anaauct
`OIYAiiO�ItY ❑OIVCtflll[
I NI�IIOLL�YCp0�1. ❑ AI�111CYLYIIVGCCTC
I rro�tp��wnwn �
(CUP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE�
Resolution conceming adverse action against ffie Auto Repair Garage License held by Frank Gaston, dba
Frank's Auto Service, 150 Concord Street. (LTncontested)
PLANNING COMMISSfON
C16 COMMfTTEE
CML SERVICE CAMMfSS10N
ihe Nis G� r.erraNetl under s cvdact tarMis tlepaM�nC7
YES NO
FMS th's D� auer Eeen e e'dy empbyce7
YES WO
OoecUiis PasoMmm 9�en eak� not � bY �Y a�eM �ily emPlQYee'1
YES NO
k M's pdwnlfum amrpeted�varitldt
YES NO I
TRANSACTIONf
NNDMG SOURCE
fASTIREVENUE BUDQETm (GRCLE ONE)
ACTIVRV NUI�ER
YEE NO
Hrr.^:!m�_•',:rr_�� ,.Tr��`1
p ���k
� � �
5 �3)°
:L, .
J
�! `` � . R6�'Wl{�Is�wsW�('�ll'� � .
� �'EGIZ- �GII�'iD� �:GZt�P.aC
. �
�'G�cccSVe is �r�r� t��kl � �41�6/�u� �ard�wcauccs
�► +�tl � �ffiaQ2 �4'Yl �e -l�e�li� ����.tts �Q
�
�fa�'�e r�t��e�ble t�.Gtr� �f: P�h < tM /�'� 2�;
�u r� � s s� � � �tialf �e �us f�r
d oK ca���/� s z 3 c� � �
3o s �n � ) C )
. ��w��.0 ��-s�lv�D` �f . �
�
�..
,
�
QRiG�NA�.
Presented By
Refened To
Council FIle # 00 -40�'i
m�Y.�e� _ {�l�� 3 , �-ec o
� Green Sheet # t O 3 Q L�{
SO TION
CITY iTL, TA ar�
Pa e �
Committee: Date
2 RESOLVED, that the Auto Repair Gazage license held by Frank Czaston dfb/a Frank's
3 Auto Service (License ID # 0099687), for the premises at 15Q Concord Street, is hereby
4 suspended for a period of thirty days for outside storage of vehicles and parts in violation of
5 Saint Paul Legislative Code §60.543, and for storage of inoperable vehicles for more than five
6 days, which is prohibited by Saint Paul Legislative Code §60.219.
7
8 FI3RTHER RESOLVED, that 15 days of said suspension sha11 be stayed for a period of
9 eighteen months on the following conditions: 1) that the property is brought into compliance
10 with the conditions on the license within one week from the passage of this Resolution; 2) that
i 1 there be no further violations of the conditions on the license or other code or zoning violations
12
13
14
15
16
17
1&
19
20
21
during the eighteen months; and 3) that the licensee pay a fine of $500.00, said fine to be paid to
the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection within thirty(30) days of the
adoption of this resolution by the Council and signature by the Mayor. For the remauvng 15
days suspension, no business operations shall be pernutted begiiuiiiig at 12:01 a.m, Wednesday,
May 17, 2000, through 11:54 pm., Wednesday May 31, 2000.
-� S`E�S er� �o.r�rar h ( �Yriev�7,mev��� - �a�� 2-.
This Resolution and the action of the Council in this ma#ter are based upon the facts
contained in the OcCober 21, 1999 letter to the licensee from LIEP, the March 21, 2000 Notice of
Violation letter to the licensee, and such arguments as may have been presented to the Council at
the public heazing. The licensee did not contest the facts of the violation.
Reques� by Department of:
4/GrYR�-a JI��
&y:
Form Approved by City Att, ey
By:
Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By:
App�
By:
By:
Adoptied by Council; Date _�\�d Q G
1
Adoption Certified by Council Sec ary
eo -��`f
Insert the following Amendment (on Page 1) (May 3, 2000)
FURTF�R RESOLVED that notwithstandin the for�oin�, if the licensed premises is
broueht into full comnliance with City ordinances relating to outside stora¢e of vehicles and
parts and storage of inoperable vehicles by 4•00 �m on May 17 2000 the entire thirry (30 davs
suspension shall be suspended for thirtv1301 days on conditions (21 and (31 in the fore�m�
"FURTHER RESOLVED" clause.
Office of LIEP/City Attomey
NTACT PQ27.�N & PFIOI�
Virginia Palmer
����
Mazch 31, 2000
TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES
GREEN SHEET
oa.R�rt ona7ae
00 -�o�
Nol G��?�4
uir�ouct
CRYAiTORIEY ❑ OIYCLiRI[
H4MCMifFRNCFJ9R. ❑ RYMWLiFiM4CtT6
II�YOR(OR�V1LLL111l) ❑
iCLiP ALl LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE)
Resolufion concerning adverse action against the Auto Repair Garage License held by Frank Gaston, dba
Frank's Auto Service, 150 Concord Street. (iJncontested)
PLANNING GOMMISSION
CIB COMMITTEE
CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION
Has this persorvhrm e�sx wnrketl uMxa conhact fof thia depaRmeM7
YES NO
Has ttiie peisorJfirtn Caer been a city empbyee?
YES NO
Doesthis De�soM�im o�sesc a s�6n not nrnma9YPOSSessetl bY �P airreM ciiv emWovee?
YES NO
Is thia pe+sorilfirm aU�B�etl vendoYt
YES NO
TRANSACTIOIi S
SOURCE
CAST/REV@7UE BUD6ETED (CIRCLE ONk�
ACTWItY NUMBER
YES NO
INFORMA710N(IXPWln
OFFICE OF TI-IE CITY ATTORNEY
Clayton M Robinson, b., Ciry Attomey
ao ..�{n
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
NormColemun, Mayor
Civi! Division
40Q Ciry Ha11
1 S West Kellogg BJvd
Saint Pau1, Minnesota i5T 02
Tetephone: 651266-8710
Facsimile; 65I298-5619
March 30, 2000
NOTICE OF COUNCIL MEETING
Frank Gaston
Frank's Auto Service
150 Concord Street
Saint Pau1, Minnesota 55107
RE: Auto Repair Garage License held by Frank Gaston, d/bfa Frank's Auto Service for the
premises at 150 Concord Street, Saint Paui
License ID #: 99687
Deaz Mr. Gaston:
P1ease take notice that a hearing concerning the above-named establishment has been scheduled
for 5:30 p.m., Wednesday, Aprii 26, 2000 in the Ciry Councii Chambers, Third Fioor, Saint
Paul City Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse.
Enclosed aze copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to
the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested hearing, in that the facts
concerning the violations of St. Paul Legislative code have not been denied. You will have an
opportunity at the Council hearing to present oral and/or written remarks as to the penalry, if any,
to be imposed.
If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710.
Very truly yours,
���� ��
Virginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary
Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP
Christine Rozek, LIEP
����� ��s��;� c��,f�
t`'"�.a,`� � �. �i��d�
Steve Faust, Community Organizer, West Side Citizens Organization, 127 Winifred St.
W., St. Paul, MN 55107
UNCONTESTED LICENSE HEARING �o _�
Licensee Name
Address:
Councif Date:
Violation:
Frank Gaston d!b/a Frank's Auto Service
150 Concord Street
April 26, 2000
Storage of vehicles and parts outside
St. Paul Legislative Code §60.543
Storage of inoperable vehicles for more than
five days
St. Pauf Legislative Code §60.219
Place:
Licensed Premises
Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf ofi client, Office
of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection:
30 day suspension of license, 15 days of which are stayed for 18
months on 3 conditions:
1. Property brought into compliance within one week
from passage of the reso{ution;
Attachments:
2. no further viotations of license conditions or other
code or zoning vio{ations during 18 months;
3. the licensee shall pay a$500.00 fiine within 30 days
of adoption of the resotution.
1. Proposed resolution
2. Notice of Violation
3. License Information Report
4. 3/14/00 violation memo and photographs from LIEP
5. 10/21/99 letter from Kristina Schweinler to Frank Gaston
Oo-'�oq
6. License information
CITY OP SAINT PAUL
Noim Coleman, iLfayor
March 21, 2000
OFFICF '�F TI-IE CITY ATTORNEY
Clay[on i. �binson, Jr., C+ryAttorney
CivilDivision
40D Ciry Ha11
1 S West Ke(togg Blvd.
Saint Paul, bfinnesafa SSIO2
DO -�{o�
Telephome: 651266-8 i IO
Fatsimile: 651298-5619
NOTICE OF VIOLATION
Frank Gaston
Frank's Auto Service
I50 Concord Street
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55107
RE: Auto Repair Gazage License held by Frank Gaston, d/b/a Frank's Auto Service for the
premises at 150 Concord Street, Saint Paul
License ID #: 99687
Deaz Mr. Gaston:
The Office of License, Inspections and Environmentai Protection has recommended
adverse action against the auto repair gazage license held by you at I50 Concord Street. The basis
for the recommendation is as follows:
On October 21,1999 a letter was sent to you by Kristina
Schweinler, a license inspector, advising you that the premises
at 150 Concord Street were the subject of neighborhood
complaints, and that you were storing vehicles and parfs
outside in violation of Saint Paul Legislative Code §60.543.
You were also advised thaf the storage of inoperable vehicles
for more than five days was prohibited by §60.219 of the Code,
and that vehicles were observed stored on the west and east
sides of the building in violation of that section. You were
given until November 30,1999 to remove the vehicles from the
property and clean the area of any parts or debris. That date
was extended until January 1, 200Q at the request of Gilbert
Delao.
On 1Vlarch 1, 2000 the license inspector again observed the
premises and saw a large amounf of outdoor storage, in
violation of the zoning code.
Page 2
Frank Gaston
Mazch 21, 2000
p0 -'�Oq
If you do not dispute the above facts please send me a letter with a statement to that
effect. The matter will then be scheduled for a hearing before the St. Paul City Council to
determine what penalty, if any, to impose. You will have an opporhulity to appear and speak on
your own behalf, or to have someone appeaz there far you.
On the other hand, if you wish to dispute the above facts, I will schedule an evidentiary
hearing before an Administrative Law Judge (AL,�. If you wish to have such a hearing, please
send me a letter stating that you aze contesting the facts. You will then be sent a"Notice of
Hearing," so you will know when and where to appeaz, and what the basis for the heazing will be.
In either case, please let me know in writing no later than Friday, March 31, 2000,
how you would like to proceed. If I have not heard from you by that date, I will assume
that you are not contesting the facts. The matter will then be scheduled for the hearing
before the St. Paul City Councii.
If you have any questions, feel free to call me or have your attorney call me at 266-8710.
Sincerely,
' v c,�j �, «-1�.-„-c_-�
�
Virginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP
Christine Rozek, LIEP
Steve Faust, Community Organizer, West Side Citizens Organization, 127 Winifred St.
W., St. Paul, MN 55107
eo-�o2
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
) ss.
COUNTY OF RAMSEY
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL
JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says
that on March 2I, 200�, she served the attached NOTICE OF VIOLATION
on the following named person by placing a true and correct copy
thereof in an envelope addressed as follows:
Frank Gaston
Frank's Auto Service
150 Concord Street
St. Paul, MN. 55107
(which is the last known address of
same, with postage prepaid, in the
Minnesota.
Subscribed and
this 21st o
� �
Notary
sworn to before me
f_/F�zrrtl�� 2 0 0 0.
PETER P. PAfVGBORN
WJ7ARY PUBUC - MINNESOTA
A1Y CAMMISSION
EX PIRES.lqN.31,2pp5
said person) and depositing the
Ofl -`��R
�
�
0
X I M W
O � O
O
�- � O
y V N
t6 J N
a o
r
O
a
�
c
O
:.
�a
E
�
w
_
d
N
C
d
c�
..I
m
�
m
�
�
�
U �
J U
Q
a
c
N
�
Q �
H �E
N �
�a
U �
�J �
Q
d I��
r �s
N 7£
M I�
Iz
I c c
1 J O
�
N
N
F-
�
�
�
�n O
°i U
N z
a �
a
U�
¢ o°
� u�'�
W
U
�
W
�
�
� _
m ¢
Z Y
Qz
0 �
tl.
Z
O
m q
Z �
= Y
O Z
a �
LL
�� �
7
O
V
�
N M
0
�
m
�
a
tu
N
c
�
m
�
E
�
2
UI
O
a
U
c
�:
�
N
C
E�
�I
Z
c;
n�
UI
m
U
c
N
7
�
_
`m
s
�
�
Z
N
C �
� N
a °'
rn
N N
N N
w ^
C
m�
0
�
H N
�
F-
�
�
�
�
U
Z
�
U
0
�
�
� ":
m
C� �yN R
U = c �-= w o
N (n O Q'a �p !n y
Na Y Y a�Y X �
� C 0 C 7 3��� O
@ ; rn
o.� w V- c>.aa�rn 'o
OQ• N f4Y
0
UQ � _�oNONO��
oa� � yQrn��a, m=
L � (nUN��p, ��
�w � Y'Q�"O ��
� � 0 Y" �p,U L 'O
LC �.. t��4�Nc-�NN� ON�
p � "'�' �� C',. ?� w "d N
OL � ��'C � N N N 3
N" rn �mmrnm°'3 ��
� �°' °o3>��a�i� �o
M i Y � C O_O LTy'C � 0�
�Ufn4iN �N - p' -
�oY�a ��ca ���
�� `m a� m w
ai
�3CpOO V QOJ � p�l��
F- oU"a o Y
Uv�iF- a c�rnm v�Na Q,
00 �007.�"00 C� � N N^ �� Q
00 00' �w�
NO � ENOw� dN U� fn
t t N O N f�� M N O. N N� O 1� k a t O.L ..
ir omc� ��r �0 3 0° ��
a�_., aa._v o
�
�
0
a
x
M W
O � I�
d U �
8I J m
N
0. N
�
C
�
C
O
y
R
�
L
w
C
d
c
d
U
J
N
3
�
�
d
U �
J Q
N
Q
F'� E
� Q
V �
N
J �
LL.
O �
O �
r I�I
M I
Z
C (�p
V �
.J �
�
�
N
F-
�
�
a
�o
�U
a Z
Q O O
O �
u) t{7
� �
W
V
�
W
�
�
E Q
Z U7
Y
�4
I �
LL
Z
O
m Q
C7
O Z
n �
U
C
�
O
U
�
N M
�
d
m
�
Q
w
y
C
�
�
�
�
Z
U
a
�
C
�
�
N
C
Z�
�
(6
Q
�
0
v
a�
U
N
7
C
N
9
E
�
Z
N
O �
� N
a °'
rn
N N
N N
� ^
C
'N r-
m �
�
� N
�
�
�
�
�
O
U
Z
�
U
O
�
I�
I�
I'.
i
�
i
i'
¢ R N Y � N
C�- C o-=. O
N (J) O Q � - p (n y
�a Y Y a��c Y
Y � � a3omrn `o
rn
�� O O � N ���2' 7
O a o ot� c�i��C�c �
U o � m
Q , m mY Oaioyo�a�
oa> � �u�arn��p��m�
� � t�tim o�
p � � Y'�.yMt �t in C
O�. � �Y' � Lp �- V i " O
�-O � �ON O�
pw 4 = ..." ca?w� a d
o °� °-' � =�c°ama� o`
N � JN�Old7� C
�c0 � p0_C C� �'N C
M N �� O 3>� N L 7 O
v-m Y c- �`n_orn�-�m ��
�oYmo a���a �
m a� � o�
Cr 41'6=ln TN.fl YQ
N N � � � ��a�-�� T UI���U
o->. c� N"a Y N Q .
ro� C O O U QO ��• m � ° '�'-c
t- ° -'-- o �rn °Y
°� � �rn o� Ni: a Q
O O O O
00 00' �� UV= N N"'�
NO Q 'ON ENOr.-� N � �1 �` N
'V N O N 1� C M N dN (6 L Ln� p_uJ .
� N Q�� @� M� O 3 0�� C� C
Mc�J_MNr�� n.c-_�+LLd.�V' O
60 -`��`t
0 0—'fo�t
I�`
i@
0
lal W
O N ��
O
M � O
y V N
A J �
�- N
�
O
a
�
c
0
R
�
�
w
c
d
N
C
d
U
�
N
w
�6
�
�
a�i >
U +-�
-' a
N
rn
��f6
�I�
N
���
0 0
J �
Q
O
o ��
N �I
I
` Z I
c i c�p
U �
1 O
�
f6
N
F-�
�
N O
a `z
O
�
Q U o
O �
��
W
U
�
W
�
�
a� ]
� Q
I � �
a Y
Z
'O �
LL
i� O
t-
�Z �
c
o Z
a�
.n C
�
O
U
C
N
� O
�
m
:
X
�
c
�
�
E
3
Z
U
a
U
C
�
�
N
C
d
E
W
Z
a
C
d
�
0
U
c
m
7
N
C
�
�
7
Z
Q1
C �
O N
s �
a a ,
N �
y N
� N
m �
0
� �
�
F �
�
�
F"
�
0
�
�
U
Z
O
U
O
�
a �p 'C N '-' Ol
n�,x � m
V = c °�— � `o
Y� Y ,.� °'�y Y �
� � O � �'� �:�p� O
�.�` „' O � N �._�O�O_' �
O n � ��s' °
Qa ±n mY�^'
U`oa � =�°a
D N � jp p_O� �._ � � _
y� i (n U d�2 O-N O a1
� o c
� � � Y YV� rnfl-c�i 'nv
RO � �Od��y� Oa1
p r''-. � C'. Z.��.'. '6 �l
Nw � o, �
� �mmrnd - oc
�m rn o nc��°-w c3
cnN �� o3> �o
r-� Y r CQO�dL� 0�
� rn-��-ca��i� �
�-Y3r �t4N (6 N
'� G U DO N�� N TT� �Q
m �� , ' g a m �_o d tn �' a U
�om am ° c��w � Y ��.a�i
� �
O NO � UW C O N �-p6> O
° o ° o �' � �� NN�'rn �-
NOfl-ONENOu �NN�7c-N
' 1' N O N f�- C M N O.N N�L„ �ik O.�f .�.-
M Y N Y �� ��m�03� LN�C
(h �MN+-.�-� Q. Q.d Cst O
CITY OF SAINT PAUL �� 4 ��
INTERDEPARTMENTAL MEMORANDUM
DATE: 3/14/2000
TO:Ginger Palmer
�� ,
FROM:Kris Schweinler 0 \
RE:150 Concord St. Frank's Auto Service
CTinger,
Attached are some photos taken on 3/1/Z000 of the above repair shop. The property continues to
violate the zoning ordinance with the large amount of outdoor storage. I have attempted to try
and work with this location for over a year and he is either unable or unwilling to bring the
property into compiiance.
Let me know if there is anything else you need in order to proceed.
Cc: Christine Rozek / Deputy Director
S .q !�, P ��, e, ..�F .o �- € x� ,� �q.,..;1
� � � . . ii �� y4� <
'� � y� ,�� � - '� 3 �I St � .a� .. r •
� s�,���� � � _ , �.,� � �: . �s,. a . �� . �
�
� :.'.k:: !. . . . .
�
.._�' i .��� ��rl _. - . .
.� � � , - -'. ._ .
x �� r :
, �. . , � � ;�. . ' ` — � .
. � - i - . � . �.
' � i
. - � I � , � � . . �
4
� � � �� �_i ` � . �*>�� - '� �
.. . ._ -- f; � . � � .
�v�� b�r�� . ��p;--�=' .
< ti Y.A.{ @ i ���
.. -t.;r� � � , � ... +" �-
� � � 4�9 �_. ,s�� _. .
M � ] •. ' " 2 . <` b ;S
' ��'-� ����" ��'sa: � .. 6 _ ... . .
y � := ��: �� �,; -,!+°- � �i>rrrr$%AU 0 S[RVIC�
M1 � l .. � 4.� ( �
� E
i
i -
� � . • :. _. � ..
. .... '� v..���� . .
. \ � . . . . . . . . .
f :
�� �� P� .,
~ � � �'� �y / ..i u Y
4 (.
1 �� r;�1. �,,:�� �i i . a5 ,3�sr.Q�R-",a. 3
� s� 4
� • � �''� ���� , � ' �
. . s a, fi ���� '�� � �'. - �'- ` . . . . .
�`�?" � - � ���! ...!„ I i �. . . I � .
- _E:.. ..-.. . � ..
I '1�'"'\.,-.�_.. ._ . Q . .
. . .. . .: �.,.,�, .. , . . _ - - _ . , .
__-
. �� =cT`-.w�>-, s:.; s � � -
„_ �_
--� ' . � ^''�'.' ., :.._ "' . . .
�. � '�"s:i ' _ �_ .
�
OFFICE OF LICENSE, LYSPECI'fONS A,�ID
ENVIRONMENTALPROTECTION
XobenKessler, Dvector
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Norm Coleman, Mayor
! A W R Y P R O F FS S! O NA L B UQ D I N G
350 Sc PetesStreet, Suite 300
SairttPaul,Minnesata SSIQ2-1510
Oct.21,1999
Mr. Frank Gaston
645 Robert St.
St.Paul,Mn.55107
Re: 150 Concord St. Frank's Auto Service
Mr. Crnston,
oa -��t
Telephane: 651-266-9090
Facnmile: 65]-1669099
651-266-912i
On April 15,1999 I spoke with you regarding the condition of your property at 150 Concord St.
We have again received complaints about the condition ofthe property, specifically the storage of
vehicles and parts. `Iou are located in a B-3 commercial zone. This does not allow outdoor
storage of motor vehicles or parts. St.Paul Leg. Code 60.543. (Copy attached)
An inspection on Oct.20 showed that you still have vehicles stored out of doors behind the fence
on the west and east sides of the buiiding. Most of these ve�icles appear to be inoperable. St.Paul
Leg. Code 60.219 does not ailow for the storage of vehicles for more that 5 days. (Copy
attached)
This letter is to notify you that you have until Nov. 30, 1999 to remove the vehicles from the
property and to clean the area of any parts or debris. Failure to do so may result in adverse action
being taken against your license.
Please contact me if you have any questions at (651)266-9110
Respectfully,
,�.�5�� .
I{ristina Schweinler
Sr. License Inspector
Cc: Christine Rozek, Deputy Director
Larry Zangs, Zoning Specialist
Ginger Palmer, Asst. City Atty.
License Group CommeMS Text
Licensee: FRANKGASTON
�BA� FRANK'S AUTO SERVICE
License #: 0099687
02/09/2000
C10 -�£a2
Pic.given to lZfoc tag,tli3lOoKS.lnspected the prop. on'l/3l00 took pic.stift alot of junk on prop.fence now fa0ing down and needs repair.KS.Lette sent
10/21/g9 giving until 1'I/30/99 to clean up prop.was contacted by Gilbert Delao(Neigh.HOUSe.) they would Iike to the first of the year to help get this prop.
into shape. ok'd that if progress is made before the weaiher changes. Gilbert's Ph.#227-9297.KS
�``'��,�
�
00 -Ltoq
bo-�-to?
�, z�-.:� �::.. � ., r.:
�$� �� �� :� � ��
. Typti Ea��..,. i .,^�.c..RNtx. �''t :� �: -. Y
i�'s,,.��avce :a:,.�mv. ;��:x.... .a�':
i Stre� .._. ...
, � License ucensee : Lic. Types
_�___r�.._
: r; .... ...................:.........................
' SYre!;i f C'• praperty (� Licensee � Unofficiel
- .., •
:.
; Diret;< Street#: �W
...................
�� Unit i?; �eet Name: ONCORD
....... ....... .. ........ .........................
� �� �; Street Type: �ST ! Diredion: �
� 3r Und Ind � ; Unit S: �
r..
; ;� CdY _T.PAUI ...............
.......................
�,
` :p+ Stste: IN � Zip: r
�; � Ward �[
� ii Dist Couri: �]3 i
Licensee:
DBA:
Sales Tax
6us
DBA
Insurance ,: Band � RequiremeMs �
.......................... ...................................................................................
i Projed Facilitator. GUNTHER, V4ILLIAM (BILL)
: Adverse AcGon CommeMs
: : ......................................................................................................:
.......r--:=_��- .
. [ Commerrts:
,>.yv
`�;BFfl..W.S��
Comments.
10N511999 E 1
. _. _ ................. �....
09t14M 998 ` t
.......................P....
torzonss� € �
# �99687 ; Save Changes to History
�
ge From D7 To ff2 On 4109/92
Change From Rich To Denver - t �E�2
ORlG�NAL
�
Presented By
Referred To
r��M�
Council File # p0 -�k0''t
Green Sheet #( O 3 q�. �
a�
2 RESOLVED, that the Auto Repair Gazage license held b�
3 Auto Service (License ID # 0099687), for the premises at I S�ox
4 suspended for a period of thirry days for outside storage of v cle
5 Saint Paul Legislative Code §60.543, and for storage of in erable
6 days, which is prohibited by Saint Paul Legislative Code,�0.219.
10
11
12
� 3
4
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
�rank Gaston d/b/a Frank's
�ord Street, is hereby
; and parts in violation of
vehicles for more than five
FURTHBR RESOLVED, that I S days of said suspension sha11 be stayed for a period of
eighteen months on the following conditions: 1) that�the properly is brought into compliance
with the conditions on the license within one weekiCrom the passage of this Resolution; 2) that
there be no further violations of the conditions o�the license or other code or zoning violations
during the eighteen months; and 3) that the licerisee pay a fine of $500.00, said fine to be paid to
ihe Office of License, Inspections and Envirota Protection within thirty(30) days of the
adoption of this resolution by the Council at�� signature by the Mayor. For the remaining 15
days suspension, no business operations� shj� 1 be permitted beginning at 12:01 a.m., Wednesday,
May 17, 2000, through 11:59 p.m., Wedn�sday May 31, 2000. �, N
This ResoluYion and the action
contained in the October 21, 1999 I
Violation letter to the licensee, and
the public hearing. The licensee di�
, /�
t
E'the Council in this matter aze based upon the facts
to the licensee from LIEP, the March 21, 2000 Notice of
azguments as may have been presented fo the Council at
contest the facts of the violation.
Reques��t by Dep��art��ment — of:
4/tkU�.. X' G�1�'ESiv.
By:
Adopted by Council: Date
Adoption Certified by Council Secretary
$Y�
�pproved by Mayor: Date
Hy:
Form Approved by City At�ey
Bv: 1�� <._ � � �, c�,/,-.,��
Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
8y:
Office of LIEP/City Attorney
Virginia Palmer
Mazch 31, 2000
TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES
GREEN SHEET
oi.,.naruwQe,aR
Oo -�{o�
.� ��.,.. ,
No V� � V�
anaauct
`OIYAiiO�ItY ❑OIVCtflll[
I NI�IIOLL�YCp0�1. ❑ AI�111CYLYIIVGCCTC
I rro�tp��wnwn �
(CUP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE�
Resolution conceming adverse action against ffie Auto Repair Garage License held by Frank Gaston, dba
Frank's Auto Service, 150 Concord Street. (LTncontested)
PLANNING COMMISSfON
C16 COMMfTTEE
CML SERVICE CAMMfSS10N
ihe Nis G� r.erraNetl under s cvdact tarMis tlepaM�nC7
YES NO
FMS th's D� auer Eeen e e'dy empbyce7
YES WO
OoecUiis PasoMmm 9�en eak� not � bY �Y a�eM �ily emPlQYee'1
YES NO
k M's pdwnlfum amrpeted�varitldt
YES NO I
TRANSACTIONf
NNDMG SOURCE
fASTIREVENUE BUDQETm (GRCLE ONE)
ACTIVRV NUI�ER
YEE NO
Hrr.^:!m�_•',:rr_�� ,.Tr��`1
p ���k
� � �
5 �3)°
:L, .
J
�! `` � . R6�'Wl{�Is�wsW�('�ll'� � .
� �'EGIZ- �GII�'iD� �:GZt�P.aC
. �
�'G�cccSVe is �r�r� t��kl � �41�6/�u� �ard�wcauccs
�► +�tl � �ffiaQ2 �4'Yl �e -l�e�li� ����.tts �Q
�
�fa�'�e r�t��e�ble t�.Gtr� �f: P�h < tM /�'� 2�;
�u r� � s s� � � �tialf �e �us f�r
d oK ca���/� s z 3 c� � �
3o s �n � ) C )
. ��w��.0 ��-s�lv�D` �f . �
�
�..
,
�