The URL can be used to link to this page

278479 WHITE � - CITY CLERK ��("k PINK - FINANCE 6� CANARY - DEPARTMENT COUIICII �� 6i_UE - MAYOR GITY OF SAINT PAUL File NO. ou 'l Resolution Presented By � Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date BE IT RESOLVED, That the Council of the City of 5aint Paul hereby certifies and approves the action of the City of Saint Paul Ba�-�rd of Appeals and Review pertaining to the follawing listed. property ar�d as shawn by the Excerpted Minutes of said Boa.rd of Appeals and Review, dat:ed March 9, 1982, and marked. E��iIBIT A, and atta.ched hereto and made a part hereof by reference: nAmF OF BC�ZD D�IINUTE5 CASE NO. PROPEI�`1'Y PiPPET'TANT 3/9/82 2-82-H 807 I�olly Ave. Thoanas R. Zahn (three un.its) BoARD ACTION: Granted variance of St. Paul Legislative Code, Section 34.14, pertain- ing to light and ventilation, t,� permit continued. occupancy of third floor unit where light is slightly deficient. Property Description: Bryant's Addition Lots 29 and 30, Block 2 3/9/82 9-82-H 107-115 N. Fairview Fairview Terrace Co. (12 units) By GaYy T. Reynolds, Pm�Y ��g�' BQARD ACTION: Granted variance of St. Paul Legislative Code, Section 34.11, pertaining to ba.sic facilities, t�o ��;t continued occupancy of Apts. #9 and #10 whose occupa.nts share use of one ba.throam facility, on condition that such shared use be lunited tr� occupants of said units only, that no more than four pexsons reside in said units, and that all r�..ining �rk orders listed in city's letter af l/27/82 be camplet�l. in timely fashion. Property Description: Merriam Park '1'hird Addition Lot 7 Block 6 COU[VCILMEN Requestgd by Department of: Yeas Nays Hunt Levine (n Favot Maddox McMahon snowaite� __ Against BY Tedesco Wilson Adopted by Council: Date — Form Approved by City Attorney Certified Vassed by Cauncil Secretary ,' 3�! ^ BY -- . Approved by Mayor. Date: _ Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council By _ By WHITE � - CITY CLERK �M�[�� PINK - FINANCE /Jt C NARY - DEPARTMENT G I TY O F SA I NT ��U L COUflGl � s� v �UE - MAYOR File N O. Council Resolution Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date and be it FU� RESOLVED, That upon passage of this resolution the City Clerk is hereby authorized. ar�d directed to trar�smit a copy of this resolution for reoording to the Ramsey County Office of the Register of Deeds. -2- COUNCILMEN Yeas Nays Requestgd by Department of: Hunt Levine � In Favor Meddo� McMahon B Showalter __ Against Y — Tedesco � Adopted by Council: Date — MAR 2 J 1982 Form Approved by City Attorney B �.�L�,.i.t Certifi assed b C ncit . Cretary ' By � T p�.� " MAR 2 � '"^[ Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council Ap ov by :Nayor. t — By _ gy _ PUBUS�fD APR 3 1982 , , . ; ,�: ��- ,�� . � . }r : � - �. . , r ` � _ ' ` . . � ' � �:.3� i . . . . . . - � - . F � . � . . . . . � . . . ' . � 1 .' . ... . � . .. i . . . . ' . . V� . ' . , " `�� ' .. . . ' . . . � . . . r��, . . . . - � � ♦ �, - r�r�� zb., isaa � . , � ' - . , � , . � � - ; ,,: . . . ' ' � ' . . .., -�. . h e. . . �. . �. . - .. '�.-. . . 1 . . . . ' � � . .. � � .' ,� � �/// - . " " ' � . � . � � . . . , . . ...♦ ;�i . ' � . . '. , . . .. � �,i . . , ' . . , . � . . . . . . .. . N�` C�aunty $�ecorder . - ; ', a ' Room. 155 „� , . City A,all . .. , - � � ' � Dear Sir: , , , �� I am transmitting to q�iu for filin� in yonr office a cer�ified copy . � � '� � of C.F.No. 276479 adop�ed �y the St.� Pau1 Cit Councif on Msrch 23 1982. �� v � � � This resplution certifies and approvei action of the�St, laul�Bonrd of - �' �' �� Appeal and Review regarding property at $41 Holly Ave. and 107-115 No. ' ' `,�,� Fairniavr. � � � . �_': ,,; " • Very truly yours, . _ � - - ' 's � • .�` #`: { � _ �r.:�_-�. , __ - a. �; , . Al.bert B. Olson -"�`�•�/. �� City Cler� . : . ' � Attach. . sch . ; � , � . _ , .- .. .. . . . . . . . , . ;� , . . - . . . . ' � . i � . ' - . � .. . , . . . � . . . . �\� . . . . . . ' . . . . , • . ' . .. � : � . - , � . . . . � . � � . . :1`3 . . � � , - � . � � � � . . ' . . � . . ... .� _ � , . . . . .. . , . .. . '..;� . . . . . . . ' . '.� . . . . . . . . - • . ' .... . .'k . .. ' . . . � � . . � - ' �.� . . � - . . . . � �� .. . , . . ' � ��'81 . , .. .e� • ' . ... . ' , � .. ., . � . . . . � , . � - . . . � . � � . . � � . . � •'i . . ...�� ';� . . � � - . . . �� .�� . � h 1 . . . . . . � . . ./ ' . � . . .��1��. ti . . '`F . . _ ; � �, • � ,, �.� . ', ; . � ',:�, �, _ . ' EX� �8/l ,� �'��79 , � /9/82 - Meeting No. 183 MINUTES OF THE MEETING � ST. PAUL BOARD OF APPEALS $ REVIEtiV Tuesday, March 9 , 1982 Room 707 City Hall , 15 W. Kellogg Blvd. MEI�BER5 PRESENT: Ron Glassman, Chairman Harold Knutson William Tilton Ros ann Bos trom MEMBERS ABSENT: Rudolph Sawyer Lucille Collins Glenn Gausman AGENCIES PRESENT: Dept. of Community Services - Division of Housing � Building Code Enforcement : Alice Bijjani Frank Staffenson Jeanne V. Shaw OTHERS PRESENT: Darlene J. Bergquist Gary T. Reynolds Steve Skalbeck Thomas Zahn STAFF PRESENT: Patricia Moxness Chairman Glassman called the meeting to order at 1 :30 p.m. The minutes of the meeting of February 9 , 1982 , were anproved as dis- tributed to the members . � Alice Bijjani introduced Jeanne Shaw, of the housing code office , who would represent Ms . Bijjani at board meetings in the event the latter �tas unable to attend. CASE N0. PROPERTY APPELLANT 2- 82-H 807 Holly Ave . Thomas R. Zahn (three units) SUBJF.CT: Request time extension to complete Item #7 , as listed in . the city' s letter of 1/6/82 , requiring fire separation of heating plant , and request variance of Item #10 , requiring self-closing devices on all apart- ment doors within stair enclosure , because devices would detract from glass paneling of the doors . APPEARANCE: Thomas R. Zahn � -2- 3/9/82 - Meeting No. 183 PROCEEDINGS: Mr. Zahn stated that zoning for three units had been approved y the Zoning Board recently. He lived on the first floor and rented out the five-room second floor and three-room third floor units . He wished to retain the architectural features of the house in their original state as much as possible . If required to put wire-glass panels and self-closing devices on the entrance doors , he felt it would detract from their distinc- tive appearance . Another item he wished to appeal , which he had not listed in his original application, was for a variance on window area in the living room of the third floor unit. Under code , 80 of floor area was req�ired, an d the room had 7. 5a . He intended to put in a skylig;�t within the nex� couple of years , but it was costly and he did not feel he could afford to at this time. As to the fire separation of the heating plant , he planned to put in a sprinkling system above the boiler area and install a fire-door, but asked for an extension of time until fall of 1982 . Alice Bijjani explained the need for self-closing devices and said there were some types which were less obtrusive than others . She said the glass panels in the entrance doors were plate glass , not particularly decorative , and the use of wixe-glass panels would not spoil their appearance, particul- arly if applied to the outside face of the doors and finished off �rith some type of molding. BOARD ACTION: Mr. Tilton moved that a variance of Section 34 . 14, pertain- ing to lig t and ventilation , be granted, to permit continued occupancy of thir3 floor unit where light is slightly deficient. r7r. Knutson seconded. MOTION CARRIED. THE VOTE: Ayes - 4 Nays - 0 Abstentions - 0 BOARD ACTION: Mr. Tilton moved to grant an extension of time to Sept . 15 , 1 8 , or installation of a sprinkler system and fire-doors separating the heating plant from the occupied areas of the property. Chairman �lassman seconded. MOTION CARRIED. THE VOTE : Ayes - 4 Nays - 0 Abstentions - 0 BOARD ACTION: Chairman Glassman moved that a variance of Section 35 .03, pertaining to the rec{uirements of self-closing devices an d wire-glass panels in entrance doors , be denied. Mr. Tilton seconded. MOTION CARRIED. THE VOTE: Ayes - 4 Nays - 0 Abstentions - 0 - -- - -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- --�-- -- - - -- --- --- -- -- -- -- -- ---- -= -- -- -- -- ---- -- -- - �'�t#4`l� ' -2- 3/9/82 - Meeting No. 183 9- 82-H 107-115 N. Fairview Fairview Terrace Co. (12 units) By Gary T. Reynolds , property manager SUBJECT: Request variance of Section 34. 11 , pertaining to basic facili- ties , to permit continued use of Apts . #9 and #10 , whose tenants share use of one bathroom facility, because of economic considerations . APPEARANCE : Gary T. Reynolds PROCEEDIIdGS : Mr. Reynolds stated that all units in the building had private bathroom facilities except for the two units on third floor, which shared a bathroom. He said these units are never rented to more than one person. . � . ' —3— 3/9/82 - Meeting No. 183 Mr. Reynolds said the monthly rents for the two units were very reasonable , $145 for one and $155 for the other, making them attractive to college students with limited resources . Except for the shared b athroom situation , all remaining work listed in the city` s letter of 1/27/82 would be done. BOARD ACTION: D4r. Tilton moved that a variance o£ Section 34. 11 be granted, perinitting residents of Apts . #9 and #10 to share use of one bathroom, on condition that occupants of no other units be permitted to share its use , �Chat no more than four persons occupy the two units , and that all remain:- ing work orders be comnleted in timely fashion. Mr. I�nutson seconded. MOTION CARRIED. THE VOTE : Ayes - 4 Nays - 0 Abstentions - 0 - -- - -- - - -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- ---- -- -- ---- -------- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- ---- --- � ,j/9/82 - Meeting No. 183 � � • . MINUTES OF THE MEETING ST. PAUL BOARD OF APPEALS � REVIE�Y _ , Tuesday, March 9 , 1982 Room 707 City Hall , 15 W. Kellogg Blvd. MET�BERS PRESENT: Ron Glassman, Chairman Harold Knutson William Tilton Rosann Bostrom MEMBERS ABSENT: Rudolph Sawyer Lucille Collins Glenn Gausman AGENCIES P RESENT: Dept. of Community Services - Division of Housing f� Building Code Enforcement : Alice Bijjani Frank Staffenson Jeanne V. Shaw . OTHERS PRESENT: Darlene J. Bergquist Gary T. Reynolds Steve Skalbeck Thomas Zahn STAFF PRESENT: Patricia �Ioxness Chairman Glassman called the meeting to order at 1 : 30 p.m. � The minutes of the meeting of February 9 , 1982 , were a�proved as dis- tributed to the members . �� Alice Bijjani introeluced Jeanne Shaw, of the housing code office , who zaould represent Ms. Bijjani at board meetings in the event the latter was unable to attend. CASE N0. PROPERTY APPELLANT 2- 82-H 807 Holly Ave . Thomas R. Zahn (three units) SUBJECT: Rec{uest time extension to complete Item #7 , as listed in the city' s letter of 1/6/82 , reauiring fire separation of heating plant , and request variance of Item #10 , requiring self-closing devices ori all apart- ment doors within stair enclosure , because devices would detract from glass paneling of the doors . � APPEARANCE: Thomas R. Zahn . . . ��:i� ��4'�� ST. PAUL BO�IRD OF APPEALS F� REVIF��' 7Q5A City Hall � Sfi. Paul , P�tin�ie�ota 55102 (612) 298-4163 March 11 , 1982 T0: Walter Bowser _ Assistant City Attorney , . FROM: Pat Moxness • RE : � Draft Resolutions nertaining to Board Actions of 3/9/82 Attached are two draft resolutions pertaining to board actions taken at the meeting of March 9 , 1982 , on the following cases : � CASE N0. PROPERTY � APPELLANT 2- 82-H 807 Holly Ave . Thomas R. Zahn � __ ._ _ . _ __.:___.__. -- 9- 82-H 107- 115 N. Fairview Fairview Terrace Co. by Gary T. Reynolds -- - - -- - --- -- - - - - -- --- - -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- ---- -- -- -- -- -- -- 2- 82-H 807 Holly� Ave . Thomas R. Zahn 10- 82-H 1705 E. 7th St. Darlene Bergauist � Michael Bergquist 11- 82-H 1627 Marshall �1ve . Steven E. Skalbeck F Charles T. Skalbeck -- - -- -- -- -- -- -- - - -- ---- -- -- -- -- -- ---- -- -- -- -- -- ---- -- -- -- ------ --- Tf you need any further information, please ca�l me on 4163. � o � °� �`� �� y � � � � � �� STATE OF MINNESOTA ) County of Ramsey ) ss. .�, . CITY OF SAINT PAUL ) � .. � � a� � Albert B. Olson, � I. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . .City Clerk of the vs e.a City of Saint Paul, Minnesota, do hereby certify that I have �;_.., compared the attached copy of Council File No. . 278479 as adopted by the City Council. . . , March 23.. . . . . . . . . . . . . .19 82. . . . and approved by the Mayor. . . . . . , , . March 25.. . .. . . . . . . . . . . 19$?. . . . with the original thereof on file in my office. I further certify that said copy is a true and correct copy of said original and the whole thereof. WITNESS my hand and the seal of the City of Saint Paul, Minnesota this „?6th. . . . . . . , day of . , March,. _ . . . . . . . .A.D. 19. 82. ��: .�� ; � �' �� C�"�� '�� j . . . .L✓.L+/t✓Y.:�!L-. `:,�j.�r�:�L. . . . . . . . . . . . . `µ�' .�-� `�� x,��'a. City Clerk. �� _ � � � � � `� � � � � �s,�,�. � ,, �}�.t ��+�` � Y � 1 lil � � �7 ' ,, � � ,.,;;.» . . �, �� , ,� ': , � � < �,; �, � '� �# 4 9 ? W , ��. : ,. ;�'�y'� -. � WMIT6 - CITY CL6RK [�(1��(� rINK - RINANC6 � C011t1C1I "1 �� c��H�^- DEPARTMENT ,. G I TY O F SA I NT PA U L File N0. f� � �� v + •LU! MAYOR � ' � . Council Resolution � .�` 4" Presented By ��,� ��-�---'� -- Y Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date '�,° � ea Tt �, Tbst t� tl�meil �' �e Citp a� Saiat P■�tl �eac+� a�3,es a�d � a�aao�es ttts act�oo o� !�e Cit�r c� 8siat Paonl Ho�d c� �Is and Asvl,er � � t�s �atloMfng lt�tsd pcop�cl� �d as � bp tht �pCad � o� ssid Hutsd c� — �pposls aod A�vf+�r► d�ttiad !� �, I902, aoc3 mea�oed �Z? 21, a�d atlsc�ed beteta a�d � �ct�s a pa�t becat'� br �e+�o�s: �� '8 C! BO!ltiD . . � �-.., 1�Tffi _ � ll�� pi�'i At�Pl�'![�� • �/g/�2 �-82-8 �07 H�Il? l�ve. 'i'ha�e R. =a� ; �� uaits) r ' B� AL't�I: tYant�ed varferxae o! St,. paat Leg3alative Coae, �eet3,00 34.I�, P�' ing � Iic�tt �d ventil+ati�al, b� pe�dt contiaued ooa�p�y' vf thizd i�I,00c �adt �eTe light is s�lightly dcf3,�Lerntt. � - paop�t� D�script3cn: Biy�ant'a �itian Lots 19 a�d �, H1+oclr 2 .. . - ; .� �,� �. " `�. " IA��S tN i�iT'V�lN � - t�i.L�i� �! �` r . �7/°s ''' 7�v� " El2 tmit8} � �Y '�'• ��r - . " �? �9'� Bo�t� �!G'�s f�ed �3aa�ore o� S�t. Pau2. Iegislati�e Cio�de, �9ect3,m 3t.11. P�e�tsinin3 to bss3c l�dliti,�, � pca�sit coatinu�d ooa�pe�q c� Apla. �9 aAd #10 � - rbpee ocr�upa�ts s�are t�e o� c� ba� facility, m aoadit3,cn ti�nt soc� s6�ed uae b� l�ndt�ed b� ooc�enla a� eeid ts�ts cnly, thett m � ao��e t�n �ouc pecsoc� s+ss3de- 3n es3d t�its, a�d t�at all za�faq . � ' �!� ac�cl�e�s listiad 3n dtp•s letbez a� 1,/�?/�2 bs ao�I,a'bsd 3a`l�a�,T . � `M_ '' r•�' prapa�tt D�sac-si�ti°°= �`�� Addition _ COUNC[LMEK °� `�" " - Yeas Na si ` RequestFd by Department of: �. Hurit y �' - ' . �r,e ' [n Favor Meddox ' � F._: ,. , ' ` �O� A ainst BY ' ° shows�m g .. . ` Tedstco . ' � . . , _ > ; � - , �: .- -- . . :+ -, Yllibon " , , � ` z." {, , ` . � . ,. . . � �. .� _ _ .. - '� " •+ .-w;:i:.- . . . - ... . - •_ �..`.,. Form Approved by City Att rne � ' Adopted by Council: � Date Certified Passed by Council Secretary � 3 2� � By Approved by 14avor. Date � "" Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council ' sy By � W/TtTE._ - CiTYCLERK . � J /RA' /\l PINK � —� .FiNANCE �. COUflCll F.,� �V a /J CAN/letV - DEPARTMENT � ` G I TY O F SA I NT PA U L � ._BLUE -�MAYOR . F11C N O. � ' � Council Resolution ; Presented By R�ferred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date � O �6 ' � and b� it � � ltII�'it �. 'lbnt �oo pa�eag� a� thts s�esosnticn !�e'Cy.ly C�earl� !s be��eby ant��cdsd aad e�fs�cbed � �dt s c�opr o� t�s z+e�o�lntLon �ot reoa�ditq tu tbe .R.::Y Ra+�ay Oota�j* dit3,ae o�' t2� Reyi�bt o� D�s. .� . .., . � . . _. . . . . �. -.�K'-: .. �� ... � . ... COUNCILMEN Yeas Nays Requestgd by Department of: Hunt ��e � in Favor �++w�- � tNcManoe snowai� .,� Against BY T� . '�`'°�.. .. MAR 2 3 t9B7 : ; r=: � �- �-� . _ Form Approved by City Attorney Adopted by Councii ` Dafe.. __ . Certifi assed Co nciI , ccefary B , �-�� •r� r B}. /� . Approved by Mavor: Date �R 2 5 �981 Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council By - BY 3 � .._�.._.�.._ '__...,�._r.,.__.ry . . � -• � o � t� v? � � C�i � �' _ ,,, ��' _. (� > � . , O �. � N� p :� � nC � � � .J Q. w -+• � O N 3 ,-« o /� m CD O � � °� � lE J t� Z p n T O �'I C ITI � � � � (�p � "�` � �'� p v� � ,� � — ^"t Z A � � n � � � z � � „� � z �� •-� � N n'I fM O -s O O �- � ,� cp � � � _, � � �• .+ `G O � �a�� o .� 7° � � . � ,, � � y � ��' � � � a , � � � � � � �.Z7� p d /�� .t � '+ W �-g9 v � � ' �+.�. �„! � d� � � � �v r� � !� �� SS) � • I``C. _ ,� � � a r` � � � � o � � � � v � �� • � � � � � �� ,� �_ . z �