00-378Council File # pQ _ 3 R g
� p
Presented By
Referred To
Green Sheet # �p� 9 `�j
��
Committee: Date
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
4
10
11
12
13
14
WHEREAS, 7ames Manneh pled guilry to careless driving on Februaiy 1, 2000; and
WI Saint Paul Legislafive Code §376.16(e)(5)a.3. does not permit licensing of
individuals who haue had a careless driving convicfion within the previous three yeazs; now
therefore be it
RESOLVED, that the Taxicab Driver's License held by James Manneh (license ID No.
980004209), is hereby revoked for his Februaiy 1, 2000 misdemeanor conviction for cazeless
driving.
This resolution and the action of the Council in this matter are based upon the facts
contained in the Saint Paul Police reports CN99-214-355 and CN99-214-297, and the March 10,
2000 Notice of Violarion letter to the licensee. The facts were not contested by the licensee.
Requested by Department of:
� t� ��'.�
By:
Adoption Certified by Council Secretary
By:
App:
sy:
RESOLUTION
CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
!
Form Approved by City Att�
!
ay: �.f B/ � I� ti c�-� y
Appmved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By:
Adopted by Council: Date t�\ °�.�;�.L?00
Office of LIEP/City Attomey
vuginia
r��
TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES
Resolurion revoking the Taxicab Driver's License held by James Manneh. (Uncontested)
PLANNING COAAMISSION
CIB COMMITTEE
CNIL SERVICE CAMMISSION
GREEN SHEET
oF..R,�rowrcra�
❑ 41YATlOPIEY ❑ tliYCLiRK �
❑ AYNtMLtERNCF1qR ❑ A4MCLLLfFRNKCTG
❑r�rortlOxnam'rurt� ❑
(CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGPJATURE)
Has this Ger�rm ever Maked untler a Canhact for fhic tlepartmentl
vES NO
Has Nis P�rtn ever Eren a aty emVbYeM
YES Dq
Does this PersonrTrtn P�� a slull not namallYP�etl bY anY curreM citY emPbYee?
YES NO
Is this P�Rrm a tarpetetl vendoR
YES t�
� oo �'��18`
No � �� ;'�J
ancoia�ca
TOTALAMOUNTOF7RANSACTION
COSTIREVENUE BUDGETED IqRCLE ONE�
�
FUNDING SOURCE
AC7IVRY NUMBER
91.ANCIAL INFORMATON (EXPIAIN)
UiVCONTESTED LiCENSE MATTER °�"
Licensee Name:
Add ress;
License:
Council Date:
James Manneh
2419 5 Avenue South, # 909, Minneapolis, MN
Taxicab Driver's License
April 26, 2000
Violation: Conviction for Care{ess Driving
St. Pauf Legislative Code § 376.16(e)(5)a.3.
February 1, 200Q
Date of Violation
Location:
December 18, 1999
While driving cab
Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behaif of ctient, Office
of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection:
Revocation of Taxicab Driver's License
Attachments:
1. Proposed resolution
2. Notice ofi Violation
3. License Information Report
4, Ramsey County Court printout
5. Police Reports CN99-214-355 and CN99-214-297
OFFICE OF TF� CITY ATTORNEY
Clay[onM Robinson, Jr„ CiryAltorney
CITY OF SAINT PALTL CivilDtvision
Norm Colemwt, Mayor 400 Ciry Hall
IS WenKellaggBlvd
Saint Paul, �nnesota 55702
�+�.rn�
March 30, 2000
NOTICE OF COUNCIL MEETING
Mr. James Manneh
2419 5�' Avenue South, # 909
Minneapolis, Minnesota 554Q4
Re: Ta7cicab Driver's License held by James Manneh
License ID No.:98Q004209
Deaz Mr. Manneh:
00-3�18`
Telephone: 651266-871 D
Facsimile: 657 29&5619
Please take notice that this matter has been set on the Consent Agenda for the Council meeting
scheduled for 3:30 p.m., Wednesday, Apri126, 2000 in the City Council Chambers, Third
Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse.
Enclosed are copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to
the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested matter, in that the facts
concerning your careless driving conviction have not been denied. The recommendation of the
license office will be for the revocation of your taxicab driver's license.
If you have any questions, please ca11 me at 266-8710.
Very truly yours,
�v�.`�`"� J \� z �-Y�
Virgima D��Palmer
Assistant City Attomey
cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary
Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP
Rich Jents, LIEP
C���t�� �9�e�zc,'� �e��ter
;°�%�� � � �
CITY OF SA1NT PAUL
Norm Cotemax, Mayor
�1TC�1 1�, 200�
OFFICE "� THE CITY ATTORN£Y
Clayton h binson, Jr., Cify Aitomey
O O -3�,Y
Civi1 Division
400 Ciry Ha1t Telephane: 631266-8710
IS lYest KellaggBlvd. Facsimile: 651 298-5619
Sair:t Poul, Mirutesota 55107
NOTICE OF VIOLATION
Mr. James Manneh
2419 S�' Avenue South, # 909
Minneapolis, Minnesota 55404
RE: Taxicab Driver's License Held by James Manneh
License ID No.: 980004209
Dear Mr. Manneh:
The Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection has recommended
adverse action against your taxicab driver's license. The basis for the recommendation is as
follows:
Saint Paul Legislarive Code §376.16(e)(5)a.3. does not permit
licensing of individuals who have had a careless driving
convicrio» �vithin the last three years. On February 1, 2000,
you pled guilty to a misdemeanor charge of careless driving.
The police reports from the incident indicate that you had been
drinking, and that a breafh test showed your alcohol
concentration to be a.11. The vehicle you were driving on this
occasion was your cab.
If you do not dispute the above facts piease send me a letter with a statement to that
effect. The matter will then be scheduled for a hearing before the St. Paul City Council to
determine what penaity, if any, to impose. You will have an opportunity to appear and speak on
your own behalf, or to have someone appear there for you.
On the other hand, if you wish to dispute the above facts, T will schedule an evidentiary
hearing before an Administrative Law Judge (AL.T). If you wish to have such a hearing, please
send me a letter stating that you are contesting the facts. You will then be sent a"Notice of
Hearing," so you will know when and where to appear, and what the basis for the hearing will be.
Page 2
Mr. James Manneh
Mazch 10, 2000
00 -3�1$'
If you have not confacted me by Monday, March 20, 2000, I wilt assume that you are not
confestiag the facts and will schedule this matter for the St. Paul City Council and have it
placed on the Consent Agenda during which no public discussion is allowed and the
recommeaded penalty will be imposed.
If you have any questions, feei free to contact me at 266-8710.
Sincerely,
i � t`'�
c2 � �i a-p-�,,
Virginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP
Christine Rozek, LIEP
Rich Jents, LIEF
oc -3�t8'
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
) ss.
COUNTY OF RAMSEY
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL
30ANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes ancl says
that on March 14, 2000, she served the attached NOTICE OF VIOLATION
the following named person by placing a true and correct copy
thereof in an envelope addressed as follows:
Mr. James Manneh
2419 S Avenue South, #409
Minneapolis, MN. 55404
(which is the last known address of said
same, with postage prepaid, in the Un�
Minnesota.
Subscribed and sworn to before me
this 14th/day> o€�I arc��000 .
son) and depositing the
ates mails„at St. Paul,
= ' PETER P. PANGBORN
r��' ApiAfYf PUBi1C - AIINRIESOTA
�` 7 �' � � MYCOMMISSION
Notary PUbl� F.XPiRESJAN.31,2005
pc, _��1�'
��
O
a
x
�
� N O
� � N
y U �
R J O
a ,._
O
�
C
C
d
d'
C
O
w
R
�
�
w
C
d
N
C
N
v
1
y
.�+ �
N
N
N
c a�
U 7
J Q
N
N
� '
I� o
N �p
C �
d U
V ���
�'J�
o .n
o �i
�, � o
Z N
N �
G O
V �
_.I �
�
R
�
O
W
N Q
N
'�O F-
a
<Cd�o
� �
N ��lJ
_
W
a� �
E Z
¢
Z �
�
� Q
�
S
�'w
E
m q
Z �
C �
O W
a�
7
'v
c
�
O
U
..L.
N
�
N
N
i
X
N
�
N
�
�
7
Z
U
a
U
C
N
N
�
�
�
�
Z
�,I
�
�.,
E
0
U
U
C
t
N
C
N
�
�
7
Z
N
C
0
� a
N
N
�
�m ^
i
X
R
0
rn
>
4
�
�
�
N
SD2005.0/000330:094350
Activity Display Fi
62-T1-99-101749 Driving Intoxicated Date filed• 12/20/1
The State of Minnesota d� ,���
vs. JAMES BOY MANNEH. (2j1218991
Time Status Crt In- Tr- Continu
Date Activity StarE/End Judge Notice Room trp ied SrvcDa
_ 12/20/99 Case Filed 12:44/12:44 OCCj
12j29/99 Arraigmm�t 01:�0/ S Rosas OCC/ 131A
BOND $500 1ST APP GENERAL BOND WITH T1-99-101752
_ 12/22j99 sona o9:a9/ Administrative occ�
$1000 GOLDBERG BOND PWR #AZB-2Q477 POSTED 12/18 BY
ROBERT YOUNG. CRT DATE ON BOND 12/29. MSL
12/29/99 Bond Rvw / c�j
$1000 ACTIVE BOND MSL
_ 12/29j99 Cert xep io:2�� occ/
CERTIFICATE OF REPRESENTATION FILED BY:
JQH21 AKWUBA ID# 280446 SM
_ 12f29/99 Order 10:28/ OCC/
NO CONTACT ORDER FILED: ASHA BONNAE RALEIGFI SM
_ 12/29/99 Arraigmm�t 01:00/ S Rosas OCC/ 131A
PNG FC S/C 1j18/00 1:30 JUDGE FLINN SM
o�/�s/oo sond xvw � C�J
$1000 ACTIVE BOND MSL
o1/is�oo setti conf oi:so� c�iinn occ/ cx
$1000 BOND, PNG S/C JUDGE FLINN
_ oi/so�oo Doc. Fi1ed �2:22/ occ/
JUDICIAL DETERMINATION OF PC TO DETAIN FILED SN
_ oi/la/oo settl conf oi:so/ c Fiinn occ� cx
FC: TMC 2-1-00 9AM FLINN SAB
02/O1j00
o2/oi/oo
_ 01/18/00
_ 02/O1f00
07/O1/02
_ 02/O1/00
04/01/00
_ 02j02/00
Bond Rvw / ��.7�
$1000 ACTIVE BOND
Mgmt Conf 09:00/ C Flinn CAN/ CH
$1000 BOND NG TMC FLINN
Doc. Filed 05:5�/ OCCj
ORDER SETTING JURY TRIAL DATE AND ORDER TO
REPORT IN DOMESTIC CASES FILED
Sentencing 09:OOf C Flinn OCC/ CH
PG CT 1 AMND CARELESS, OTR CTS DSM MO CA;
30DY &$300 SS PRB 2YR 1)CE/REC FEE IMP 2)NO DL/INS
3)$100+ 4)NO S/S 5)USL CNDjLA 6)NO DRINK/DRV VIOL
Archive / PEN/
Pd in Full 09:47/ OCC/
100 PLIIS FESS PLUS CFEE SIN
Stat Rview / ���
PIF FINES OFFICE AFTER CT CASH $255.
Closed 05:30/ OCC/
MS L
�F7
VIOL
AMP
SIN
Criminal Case Summary
SD1008.Of 000330:094626
00 -'��1 r
62-T1-99-101749 Drivina Intoxicated Date filed• 12/2011
Name: MANNEH, JAMES BOY, [2/121899]
Alias:
DOB: 01/O1/1969 Race:
Sex: Soc Sec #
Dfnt Attrny: JOHN NWABUWANE AICW[TBA
Dfnt Status: On Bond Status Date:
Case Status CLOSED Offense Date:
Location: 1 Continuances: 0 Trial
CCT Plea Charge
001 GUILTY CARELESS DRIVING
002 I30T GUILfiY . OVER .10 <.20 MI
Date Aativity Time
Last 02/02/2000 Closed 5:30
Pending 07/O1/2002 Archive
Type: Retained
12/18/1999 Bail Amount: $
12/18/1999 Warrant Date:
Type: 3urisdiction:
Chap/Sect/SUbd GOC UOC
169.13 2
169.121 1D3B
Judge
500.00
District
Verdict
Guilty.
Dismisse
CRT
IIisposition Date 02/O1/2000
Next FC_ 04 06 08 10
Saint Pauf Police Department Page 7
� ORfGINAL OFFENSE / INCIDENT REPORT oo-3�t
Complarnt Number Reference C N. Pnmary otiense
99-214355 99-214297 AUTO THEFT Dateantl7imeofRepor
12/18/1999 04:53
PnmaryReporL"ng O�cer. GLENN A MCGREGOR Location ofincident: 490 UNIVERSITY AV W
Pnmary offense detaiL � / �
Pnmary squad: 2� 3 Name oflocationlbusiness:
Secondary repo�ting o�cer.
D;stnct: CENTRAL ( CENTRAL DiSTRICT )
Secontlary offense:
Date & fime of occu�ence: '12118/1999 0'I :47
Anest made � YES
Oate & time ofa/rest 12/78/lggg 02:45
POLICE PERSONNEL fNVOLVED
Arrest made on view. YES
A�st made on warrant o� prevrous CM
Weapons used 6y police: .
Weapons used by suspect at time of arrest
Pursuit engaged:
Resistance encounteled:
CHARGES
tyame RALEIGH, ASHA BONNAE
arresr srarus gOOKED Book,n � a at y g
eooking date 12/1 g/1 ggg Booking time Q5:56
Charge AUTO THEFT
Citahonnumber BaiJ Ong�natingagency SPPD
Warrant num6er
Walrant type
�vame GANT, AHMAD KAREEM
chargeclv gg2�a355
ar�esr srarus gOOKEp Booking # dpf` �J�
eooking date 12l18/1999 eooking time 05:17
Charge AUTO THEFT
Citation number Bail Ongrnating a9ency SPPD
Warrantnumber ChargeCN 99214355
Warrant type
�
n�ame RALEIGH, RASHAD AftTHUR Arrest Status BOOKED Book,� # a PY7 �
eooking date 12/18/1999 eooking time 05:12 �
Charge AUTO THEFT
GitaGOn number
Warrant number
Wa(rant type
�AMES
Y�
: NF Z� -t�/c.
2� �. T� �-m
Bail
Originatmg agency
Charge CN 9921A355
cG - `/ �4 u.TO - � Y�c r
/Yt�s�= Du� �f
V �
�����
�
T¢�
_'C PAlii
�
4ULICE
Comp/aint Number
99-214355
Saint Paut Pofice Department Page 2
ORtGlNAL OFFENSE / 1NCIDENT REPORT o
Reference C.N. Pnmary oflense Date and Time of Report
99-214297 AUTO THEFT 12/18/1999 04:53
ARRES7EE RALEIGH, ASHA BONNAE
289 THOMAS AV W STPAUL MN 55104
PhysicalDescription Phones
sex FEMALE xeiynt Hai�COlor Nomephone 65'I-488-4g1g
Race BLACK Weight
Hispanrc
ooa 07/17l�g7g
Age 20
Harr Type
Buifd Hair Leng!h
Skin BROWN-MEDIUM'Facia�Hai�
Physical Conditio� Employment
Consciousness Occupafion
0`ucyalconotuse HAD BEEN DRINKI(dG
Werght
Build
ARRESTEE GAN , AHMAD KAREEM
1540 MISSISSIPPI AV N STPAUL " MN 55101
Physical Descripfion Phones
Sex MALE Height HairColo�
Race BLACK
Hispanic
OOS 03l16f1975
Age 24
Employe�
Hair Type
Nair Length
Skin BROWN - MEDIUM FaciatFiair
Physica! Condifion Emp/oymenf
Consciousness Occupation
oruya�coho�use HAD BEEN DftINKING
Employer
ARRESTEE RALEIGH, RASHAD ARTHUR
289 THOMAS AV W STPAUL MN 55104
Physica! Description Phones
sex MALE Heignr Hai�caor Nome phone 651-488-4919
Race BL,qCK Weight Hai�Type
Hispanic Build Hair Length
ooe 02/15/1976 sxin BROWN - MEDIUM Facial Hair
Age 21
Physical Canditio� Employment
Consci0usne55 Occupation
Drugfalcohof use HAD BEEN DRINKING Emp�oyer
� Saint Paul Police Department Page 4
�� ORIGINAL OFFENSE / INCIDENT REPORT po ..,��.
Comp/aintNumber Reference C.N. Primaryotfense Date and Time ofReport
99-214355 99-214297 AUTO TNEFT 12/18/1999 04:53
lnsurance & owner information Vehicle contents 8 drive�
lnsurance co.
lienholde�
Registered owner
Dnve�slrcense no.
Personal property in veh�cle
Keys in vBh�cle
Owner allowed someone to
use vehicle
Person a/lowed to use vehicle
rres£s ame ress
ge ace ex
aorY RALEIGH, ASHA BONNAE 289 THOMAS AV W, S7PAUL, MN 55104 07/17(1979 20 B F
ao 8 y 6 GANT, AHMAD KAREEM i54� MISSISSIPPI AV N, STPAIiL, MN 55101 03/16/1975 24 g tvt
�� � RALEIGH, RASHAD ARTHUR 289 THOMAS AV W, STPAUL, MN 551Q4 02/15/1978 21 g iJ�
SQUAD 213 (MCGREGOR) WAS SENT TO 490 W. UNIVERSITY ON A�REPORT OF A AUTO
THEFT THAT JUST OCCURftED AT UNIVERSITY AND WESTERN AVE. THE ViCT1M (A
YELLOW CAB DRIVER) HAD TOLD THE TC / POLICE DISPATCH THAT THE CAR TAKEN
WA5 A YELLOW CAB # 95 AND THAT THERE WERE 3 SUSPECTS (TWO MALES AND ONE
FEMALE). THE VECTIM ALSO SAID THAT THE SUSPECTS MAY BE HEADED TO THE AREA
OF 289 THOMAS.
UPON MY ARRiVAL, I MET WITH THE VtCTiM AND HE WAS LATER ID WITH MN DL AS;
MANNEH, JAMES (DOB OF 01-01-69 OF 2419 5TH AVE. SO., MPLS). AS I WAS TRYING TO
SPEAK WITH MANNEH, HE WAS BEING SOMEWNAT UNCOOPERATiVE AND I COULD
SMELL A STRONG ODOR OF AN ALGOHOLIC BEVERAGE COMING FROM HfM AS HE SPOKE.
WHILE SPEAKING WITH MANNEH, I HEARD SQD 624 (K-9 OFFICER BREMMER) ADVISE
DISPATCH THAT HE HAD THE STOLEN CAB AND THE 7HREE SUSPECTS AT WESTERN
AND BLAIR. I THEN TOLD MANNEH TO STAY THERE AND I THEN WENT TO WESTERN
AND BLAIR TO ASSIST SQD 624.
UPON MY ARRIVAL THERE, SQD 215 (CORCORAN) AND SQD 175 {DRUTSCHMAN AND
MARTfN) WERE ALSO ARRIVING AND WE THEN TOOK THE THREE SUSPECTS INTO
CUSTODY (TWO MALES AND ONE FEMALE). ONCE THE SUSPECTS WERE SECURED, !
THEN WENT BACK TO 490 W. UNIVERSITY TO PICK UP MAfVNEH, BUT HE WAS GONE. i
WAS THEN ASLE TO LOCATE HIM ON THE PAY PHONE AT THE NORTH WEST TEAM,
(DALE AND UNfVERSiTY).
I PUT MANNHE iNTO MY CAR AND l"RANSPORTED HIM BACK TO WESTERN AND BLAIR.
WHILE EN ROUTE BACK THERE, MANNEH TOLD ME THAT ONE OF THE SUSPECTS IS A
FEMALE THAT NE HAS SEEN SEEING INTIMATELY BY THE NAME OF; RALEIGH, ASHA
BONNAE (DOB 07-17-79 OF 289 THOMAS).
MAN(VHE SAID THAT HE GOT CALLED BY ASHA TO PICK HER UP AT HER HOUSE, 289
THOMAS, WHICH HE DlD. MANNHE SA(D THAT THEY DROVE AROUND AND THEN SHE
TOLD H{M TO PICK UP HER COUSIN AT A BAR ON SELBY AVE. MANNHE SAID HE QROVE
TO THE BAR AND ASHA WENT INSIDE FOR A WHILE. MANNHE SAID AFTER SEVERAL
MINUTES, HE WENT INSIDE AND TOLD HER HE HAD TO GO.
MANNHE SAID THAT SHE THEN CAME OUTSIDE WITH HEft COUSIN AND ANOTHER
MALE AND THEY THEN GOT INTO THE CAB. WHILE IN THE CAB, MANNHE SAID THAT HE
HAD GOTTEN A PHONE CALL FROM ANOTHER FEMALE AND ASHA THEN GOT MAD AT HIM
AND THEY STARTED TO ARGUE. MANNHE SAID THAT HE THEN PULLED OVER IN FRONT
OF 496 W. UNIVERSITY AND THEY STAR7ED ARGUiNG AND TALKING ABOUT THE PHONE
CALL. -
Saint Paul Police Department Page 5
.� ORiGINAL OFFENSE / INCIDENT REPORT oo-��r
Complaint Number Reference C.K Pnmary offense Date and T�me of RepoK
99-214355 99-214297 AUTO THEFT �2i18/1999 04:53
MANNHE SAID THAT ASHA AND HlM THEN GOT OUT OF THE CAB AND WERE ARGUING
NEAR THE TRUNK OF AREA OF THE CAB WHEN THE TWO OTHER SUSPECTS GOT OUT
AND CAME AT HIM. MANNHE SAID ONE OF 7HE MALES, WHICH HE POINTEQ TO WH(LE
AT WESTERN AND BLA)R, SUDDENLY PUNCHEb HIM IN THE LEFT SIQE OF THE FACE.
THE MALE SUSPECT WAS ID AS ASHA'S BROTHER; RALE{GH, ftASHAD ARTHUR (DOB 02-
15-78 OF 289 THOMAS).
MANNHE SAID AFTER HE GOT PUNCHED, HE GOT SCARED BECAUSE (T WAS THREE
AGAINST ONE AND " JETTED". MANNHE SAID THE THREE THEN JUMPED INTO H{S CAB
AND THEN TOOK OFF. HE SAlD HE THEN CALLED TNE POLfCE AND WE RESPONDED A
SHORT TIME LATER.
WHILE AT WESTERN AND BLAIR, MANNHE LOOKED AT THE OTHER MALE SUSPECT
AND POSITIVELY ID THE SUSPECT AS THE THIRD PARTY INVOLVED IN TAKING THE CAB.
THE THIRD SUSPEGT WAS ID AS ASHA'S COUS4N; GANT, AHMAD KAREEM (DOB 03-16-75
OF 1540 MISSiSSfPPI).
WHILE AT THE SCENE, A BLACK BACK PACK WAS RECOVERED FROM THE THREE
SUSPECTS WHO SAID TNEY TOOK IT FROM THE STOLEN CAB. MANNNE TOLD ME THAT
TNE BACK PACK WAS {IV FACT HIS,
WHILE ON SCENE AT WESTERN AND BLAIR, SGT. INDEHAR, SQD 175, AND SQD 624
ALL TOLD ME THAT THEY COULD SMELL A STRONG ODOR OF AN ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMING FROM HIM AS HE SPOKE. i ASKED MANNHE IF HE HAD ANYTHING ALCOHOLIC
TO DRINK TONIGHT AND HE SAID NO. 1 THEN ASKED HIM IF HE HAD ANYTHING
ALCOHOLIC TO DRINK FROM THE TIME HiS CAB WAS STOLEN TO THE TIME 1 PICKED H1M
UP AT THE NORTH WEST TEAM AND HE AGAIN SA{D NO.
THE THREE SUSPECTS WERE TAKEN TO H.Q. AND BOOKED INTO THE RCJ ANNEX
FOR AUTO THEFT. MANNHE'S CAB # 95 WAS TOWED TO THE C(TY IMPOUND LOT BY SQD
624 AND MANNHE WAS ALSO TRANSPORTED TO H.Q. FOR INVESTIGATION OF DUI.
PLEASE REFER TO SQD 624'S SUPP UNDER 99-214-297.
ALSO SEE SQD 175'S REPORT, WHICH ASHA RALEIGH 1S THE ASSAULT VICTIM AND
MANNHE IS THE ASSAULT SUSPECT, UNDER CN # 99-214-336. MANNHE WAS TAGGED
AND SOOKED FOR THE ASSAULT.
ALSO SEE MY ADDITIONAL REPORT OF DUI SUSPECT, MANNHE, UNDER CN # 99-214-
297, WHlCH MANNHE WAS BOOKED FOR DUT AND DUf OVER .10.
'lease distribute to:
_CHF _Hom
+ Sex _DiC
_CO _Rptr
-..
_Burg
Vice
_Juv - _Oper
_Theft _Prop
_Narco _SIU
_PSC _Lab _Rec
_CAU _F&F _Auto
_T&A �Other
_Team
_DAO
S
C
t� Saint Pau{ Police Department Paoe Z
= SUPPLEMENTAL OFFENSE / INCfDENT REPORT oc_,�r
Complainf Numbei Reference C.N. Pnmary oHense
Date and Time of Repor.
99-214297 DU1 12/18(1999 03:45
Please distribute to:
_CHF _Hom
_Sex _D!C
_CO ^ Rptr
_Rob
_Burg
Vice
_Juv -
_Theft
_Narco
_Oper
_Prop
_S(U
_PSC
_CAU
! T&A
_Lab
F&F
_Other
._Rec
_Auto
�Team
_DAO
Council File # pQ _ 3 R g
� p
Presented By
Referred To
Green Sheet # �p� 9 `�j
��
Committee: Date
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
4
10
11
12
13
14
WHEREAS, 7ames Manneh pled guilry to careless driving on Februaiy 1, 2000; and
WI Saint Paul Legislafive Code §376.16(e)(5)a.3. does not permit licensing of
individuals who haue had a careless driving convicfion within the previous three yeazs; now
therefore be it
RESOLVED, that the Taxicab Driver's License held by James Manneh (license ID No.
980004209), is hereby revoked for his Februaiy 1, 2000 misdemeanor conviction for cazeless
driving.
This resolution and the action of the Council in this matter are based upon the facts
contained in the Saint Paul Police reports CN99-214-355 and CN99-214-297, and the March 10,
2000 Notice of Violarion letter to the licensee. The facts were not contested by the licensee.
Requested by Department of:
� t� ��'.�
By:
Adoption Certified by Council Secretary
By:
App:
sy:
RESOLUTION
CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
!
Form Approved by City Att�
!
ay: �.f B/ � I� ti c�-� y
Appmved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By:
Adopted by Council: Date t�\ °�.�;�.L?00
Office of LIEP/City Attomey
vuginia
r��
TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES
Resolurion revoking the Taxicab Driver's License held by James Manneh. (Uncontested)
PLANNING COAAMISSION
CIB COMMITTEE
CNIL SERVICE CAMMISSION
GREEN SHEET
oF..R,�rowrcra�
❑ 41YATlOPIEY ❑ tliYCLiRK �
❑ AYNtMLtERNCF1qR ❑ A4MCLLLfFRNKCTG
❑r�rortlOxnam'rurt� ❑
(CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGPJATURE)
Has this Ger�rm ever Maked untler a Canhact for fhic tlepartmentl
vES NO
Has Nis P�rtn ever Eren a aty emVbYeM
YES Dq
Does this PersonrTrtn P�� a slull not namallYP�etl bY anY curreM citY emPbYee?
YES NO
Is this P�Rrm a tarpetetl vendoR
YES t�
� oo �'��18`
No � �� ;'�J
ancoia�ca
TOTALAMOUNTOF7RANSACTION
COSTIREVENUE BUDGETED IqRCLE ONE�
�
FUNDING SOURCE
AC7IVRY NUMBER
91.ANCIAL INFORMATON (EXPIAIN)
UiVCONTESTED LiCENSE MATTER °�"
Licensee Name:
Add ress;
License:
Council Date:
James Manneh
2419 5 Avenue South, # 909, Minneapolis, MN
Taxicab Driver's License
April 26, 2000
Violation: Conviction for Care{ess Driving
St. Pauf Legislative Code § 376.16(e)(5)a.3.
February 1, 200Q
Date of Violation
Location:
December 18, 1999
While driving cab
Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behaif of ctient, Office
of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection:
Revocation of Taxicab Driver's License
Attachments:
1. Proposed resolution
2. Notice ofi Violation
3. License Information Report
4, Ramsey County Court printout
5. Police Reports CN99-214-355 and CN99-214-297
OFFICE OF TF� CITY ATTORNEY
Clay[onM Robinson, Jr„ CiryAltorney
CITY OF SAINT PALTL CivilDtvision
Norm Colemwt, Mayor 400 Ciry Hall
IS WenKellaggBlvd
Saint Paul, �nnesota 55702
�+�.rn�
March 30, 2000
NOTICE OF COUNCIL MEETING
Mr. James Manneh
2419 5�' Avenue South, # 909
Minneapolis, Minnesota 554Q4
Re: Ta7cicab Driver's License held by James Manneh
License ID No.:98Q004209
Deaz Mr. Manneh:
00-3�18`
Telephone: 651266-871 D
Facsimile: 657 29&5619
Please take notice that this matter has been set on the Consent Agenda for the Council meeting
scheduled for 3:30 p.m., Wednesday, Apri126, 2000 in the City Council Chambers, Third
Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse.
Enclosed are copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to
the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested matter, in that the facts
concerning your careless driving conviction have not been denied. The recommendation of the
license office will be for the revocation of your taxicab driver's license.
If you have any questions, please ca11 me at 266-8710.
Very truly yours,
�v�.`�`"� J \� z �-Y�
Virgima D��Palmer
Assistant City Attomey
cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary
Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP
Rich Jents, LIEP
C���t�� �9�e�zc,'� �e��ter
;°�%�� � � �
CITY OF SA1NT PAUL
Norm Cotemax, Mayor
�1TC�1 1�, 200�
OFFICE "� THE CITY ATTORN£Y
Clayton h binson, Jr., Cify Aitomey
O O -3�,Y
Civi1 Division
400 Ciry Ha1t Telephane: 631266-8710
IS lYest KellaggBlvd. Facsimile: 651 298-5619
Sair:t Poul, Mirutesota 55107
NOTICE OF VIOLATION
Mr. James Manneh
2419 S�' Avenue South, # 909
Minneapolis, Minnesota 55404
RE: Taxicab Driver's License Held by James Manneh
License ID No.: 980004209
Dear Mr. Manneh:
The Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection has recommended
adverse action against your taxicab driver's license. The basis for the recommendation is as
follows:
Saint Paul Legislarive Code §376.16(e)(5)a.3. does not permit
licensing of individuals who have had a careless driving
convicrio» �vithin the last three years. On February 1, 2000,
you pled guilty to a misdemeanor charge of careless driving.
The police reports from the incident indicate that you had been
drinking, and that a breafh test showed your alcohol
concentration to be a.11. The vehicle you were driving on this
occasion was your cab.
If you do not dispute the above facts piease send me a letter with a statement to that
effect. The matter will then be scheduled for a hearing before the St. Paul City Council to
determine what penaity, if any, to impose. You will have an opportunity to appear and speak on
your own behalf, or to have someone appear there for you.
On the other hand, if you wish to dispute the above facts, T will schedule an evidentiary
hearing before an Administrative Law Judge (AL.T). If you wish to have such a hearing, please
send me a letter stating that you are contesting the facts. You will then be sent a"Notice of
Hearing," so you will know when and where to appear, and what the basis for the hearing will be.
Page 2
Mr. James Manneh
Mazch 10, 2000
00 -3�1$'
If you have not confacted me by Monday, March 20, 2000, I wilt assume that you are not
confestiag the facts and will schedule this matter for the St. Paul City Council and have it
placed on the Consent Agenda during which no public discussion is allowed and the
recommeaded penalty will be imposed.
If you have any questions, feei free to contact me at 266-8710.
Sincerely,
i � t`'�
c2 � �i a-p-�,,
Virginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP
Christine Rozek, LIEP
Rich Jents, LIEF
oc -3�t8'
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
) ss.
COUNTY OF RAMSEY
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL
30ANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes ancl says
that on March 14, 2000, she served the attached NOTICE OF VIOLATION
the following named person by placing a true and correct copy
thereof in an envelope addressed as follows:
Mr. James Manneh
2419 S Avenue South, #409
Minneapolis, MN. 55404
(which is the last known address of said
same, with postage prepaid, in the Un�
Minnesota.
Subscribed and sworn to before me
this 14th/day> o€�I arc��000 .
son) and depositing the
ates mails„at St. Paul,
= ' PETER P. PANGBORN
r��' ApiAfYf PUBi1C - AIINRIESOTA
�` 7 �' � � MYCOMMISSION
Notary PUbl� F.XPiRESJAN.31,2005
pc, _��1�'
��
O
a
x
�
� N O
� � N
y U �
R J O
a ,._
O
�
C
C
d
d'
C
O
w
R
�
�
w
C
d
N
C
N
v
1
y
.�+ �
N
N
N
c a�
U 7
J Q
N
N
� '
I� o
N �p
C �
d U
V ���
�'J�
o .n
o �i
�, � o
Z N
N �
G O
V �
_.I �
�
R
�
O
W
N Q
N
'�O F-
a
<Cd�o
� �
N ��lJ
_
W
a� �
E Z
¢
Z �
�
� Q
�
S
�'w
E
m q
Z �
C �
O W
a�
7
'v
c
�
O
U
..L.
N
�
N
N
i
X
N
�
N
�
�
7
Z
U
a
U
C
N
N
�
�
�
�
Z
�,I
�
�.,
E
0
U
U
C
t
N
C
N
�
�
7
Z
N
C
0
� a
N
N
�
�m ^
i
X
R
0
rn
>
4
�
�
�
N
SD2005.0/000330:094350
Activity Display Fi
62-T1-99-101749 Driving Intoxicated Date filed• 12/20/1
The State of Minnesota d� ,���
vs. JAMES BOY MANNEH. (2j1218991
Time Status Crt In- Tr- Continu
Date Activity StarE/End Judge Notice Room trp ied SrvcDa
_ 12/20/99 Case Filed 12:44/12:44 OCCj
12j29/99 Arraigmm�t 01:�0/ S Rosas OCC/ 131A
BOND $500 1ST APP GENERAL BOND WITH T1-99-101752
_ 12/22j99 sona o9:a9/ Administrative occ�
$1000 GOLDBERG BOND PWR #AZB-2Q477 POSTED 12/18 BY
ROBERT YOUNG. CRT DATE ON BOND 12/29. MSL
12/29/99 Bond Rvw / c�j
$1000 ACTIVE BOND MSL
_ 12/29j99 Cert xep io:2�� occ/
CERTIFICATE OF REPRESENTATION FILED BY:
JQH21 AKWUBA ID# 280446 SM
_ 12f29/99 Order 10:28/ OCC/
NO CONTACT ORDER FILED: ASHA BONNAE RALEIGFI SM
_ 12/29/99 Arraigmm�t 01:00/ S Rosas OCC/ 131A
PNG FC S/C 1j18/00 1:30 JUDGE FLINN SM
o�/�s/oo sond xvw � C�J
$1000 ACTIVE BOND MSL
o1/is�oo setti conf oi:so� c�iinn occ/ cx
$1000 BOND, PNG S/C JUDGE FLINN
_ oi/so�oo Doc. Fi1ed �2:22/ occ/
JUDICIAL DETERMINATION OF PC TO DETAIN FILED SN
_ oi/la/oo settl conf oi:so/ c Fiinn occ� cx
FC: TMC 2-1-00 9AM FLINN SAB
02/O1j00
o2/oi/oo
_ 01/18/00
_ 02/O1f00
07/O1/02
_ 02/O1/00
04/01/00
_ 02j02/00
Bond Rvw / ��.7�
$1000 ACTIVE BOND
Mgmt Conf 09:00/ C Flinn CAN/ CH
$1000 BOND NG TMC FLINN
Doc. Filed 05:5�/ OCCj
ORDER SETTING JURY TRIAL DATE AND ORDER TO
REPORT IN DOMESTIC CASES FILED
Sentencing 09:OOf C Flinn OCC/ CH
PG CT 1 AMND CARELESS, OTR CTS DSM MO CA;
30DY &$300 SS PRB 2YR 1)CE/REC FEE IMP 2)NO DL/INS
3)$100+ 4)NO S/S 5)USL CNDjLA 6)NO DRINK/DRV VIOL
Archive / PEN/
Pd in Full 09:47/ OCC/
100 PLIIS FESS PLUS CFEE SIN
Stat Rview / ���
PIF FINES OFFICE AFTER CT CASH $255.
Closed 05:30/ OCC/
MS L
�F7
VIOL
AMP
SIN
Criminal Case Summary
SD1008.Of 000330:094626
00 -'��1 r
62-T1-99-101749 Drivina Intoxicated Date filed• 12/2011
Name: MANNEH, JAMES BOY, [2/121899]
Alias:
DOB: 01/O1/1969 Race:
Sex: Soc Sec #
Dfnt Attrny: JOHN NWABUWANE AICW[TBA
Dfnt Status: On Bond Status Date:
Case Status CLOSED Offense Date:
Location: 1 Continuances: 0 Trial
CCT Plea Charge
001 GUILTY CARELESS DRIVING
002 I30T GUILfiY . OVER .10 <.20 MI
Date Aativity Time
Last 02/02/2000 Closed 5:30
Pending 07/O1/2002 Archive
Type: Retained
12/18/1999 Bail Amount: $
12/18/1999 Warrant Date:
Type: 3urisdiction:
Chap/Sect/SUbd GOC UOC
169.13 2
169.121 1D3B
Judge
500.00
District
Verdict
Guilty.
Dismisse
CRT
IIisposition Date 02/O1/2000
Next FC_ 04 06 08 10
Saint Pauf Police Department Page 7
� ORfGINAL OFFENSE / INCIDENT REPORT oo-3�t
Complarnt Number Reference C N. Pnmary otiense
99-214355 99-214297 AUTO THEFT Dateantl7imeofRepor
12/18/1999 04:53
PnmaryReporL"ng O�cer. GLENN A MCGREGOR Location ofincident: 490 UNIVERSITY AV W
Pnmary offense detaiL � / �
Pnmary squad: 2� 3 Name oflocationlbusiness:
Secondary repo�ting o�cer.
D;stnct: CENTRAL ( CENTRAL DiSTRICT )
Secontlary offense:
Date & fime of occu�ence: '12118/1999 0'I :47
Anest made � YES
Oate & time ofa/rest 12/78/lggg 02:45
POLICE PERSONNEL fNVOLVED
Arrest made on view. YES
A�st made on warrant o� prevrous CM
Weapons used 6y police: .
Weapons used by suspect at time of arrest
Pursuit engaged:
Resistance encounteled:
CHARGES
tyame RALEIGH, ASHA BONNAE
arresr srarus gOOKED Book,n � a at y g
eooking date 12/1 g/1 ggg Booking time Q5:56
Charge AUTO THEFT
Citahonnumber BaiJ Ong�natingagency SPPD
Warrant num6er
Walrant type
�vame GANT, AHMAD KAREEM
chargeclv gg2�a355
ar�esr srarus gOOKEp Booking # dpf` �J�
eooking date 12l18/1999 eooking time 05:17
Charge AUTO THEFT
Citation number Bail Ongrnating a9ency SPPD
Warrantnumber ChargeCN 99214355
Warrant type
�
n�ame RALEIGH, RASHAD AftTHUR Arrest Status BOOKED Book,� # a PY7 �
eooking date 12/18/1999 eooking time 05:12 �
Charge AUTO THEFT
GitaGOn number
Warrant number
Wa(rant type
�AMES
Y�
: NF Z� -t�/c.
2� �. T� �-m
Bail
Originatmg agency
Charge CN 9921A355
cG - `/ �4 u.TO - � Y�c r
/Yt�s�= Du� �f
V �
�����
�
T¢�
_'C PAlii
�
4ULICE
Comp/aint Number
99-214355
Saint Paut Pofice Department Page 2
ORtGlNAL OFFENSE / 1NCIDENT REPORT o
Reference C.N. Pnmary oflense Date and Time of Report
99-214297 AUTO THEFT 12/18/1999 04:53
ARRES7EE RALEIGH, ASHA BONNAE
289 THOMAS AV W STPAUL MN 55104
PhysicalDescription Phones
sex FEMALE xeiynt Hai�COlor Nomephone 65'I-488-4g1g
Race BLACK Weight
Hispanrc
ooa 07/17l�g7g
Age 20
Harr Type
Buifd Hair Leng!h
Skin BROWN-MEDIUM'Facia�Hai�
Physical Conditio� Employment
Consciousness Occupafion
0`ucyalconotuse HAD BEEN DRINKI(dG
Werght
Build
ARRESTEE GAN , AHMAD KAREEM
1540 MISSISSIPPI AV N STPAUL " MN 55101
Physical Descripfion Phones
Sex MALE Height HairColo�
Race BLACK
Hispanic
OOS 03l16f1975
Age 24
Employe�
Hair Type
Nair Length
Skin BROWN - MEDIUM FaciatFiair
Physica! Condifion Emp/oymenf
Consciousness Occupation
oruya�coho�use HAD BEEN DftINKING
Employer
ARRESTEE RALEIGH, RASHAD ARTHUR
289 THOMAS AV W STPAUL MN 55104
Physica! Description Phones
sex MALE Heignr Hai�caor Nome phone 651-488-4919
Race BL,qCK Weight Hai�Type
Hispanic Build Hair Length
ooe 02/15/1976 sxin BROWN - MEDIUM Facial Hair
Age 21
Physical Canditio� Employment
Consci0usne55 Occupation
Drugfalcohof use HAD BEEN DRINKING Emp�oyer
� Saint Paul Police Department Page 4
�� ORIGINAL OFFENSE / INCIDENT REPORT po ..,��.
Comp/aintNumber Reference C.N. Primaryotfense Date and Time ofReport
99-214355 99-214297 AUTO TNEFT 12/18/1999 04:53
lnsurance & owner information Vehicle contents 8 drive�
lnsurance co.
lienholde�
Registered owner
Dnve�slrcense no.
Personal property in veh�cle
Keys in vBh�cle
Owner allowed someone to
use vehicle
Person a/lowed to use vehicle
rres£s ame ress
ge ace ex
aorY RALEIGH, ASHA BONNAE 289 THOMAS AV W, S7PAUL, MN 55104 07/17(1979 20 B F
ao 8 y 6 GANT, AHMAD KAREEM i54� MISSISSIPPI AV N, STPAIiL, MN 55101 03/16/1975 24 g tvt
�� � RALEIGH, RASHAD ARTHUR 289 THOMAS AV W, STPAUL, MN 551Q4 02/15/1978 21 g iJ�
SQUAD 213 (MCGREGOR) WAS SENT TO 490 W. UNIVERSITY ON A�REPORT OF A AUTO
THEFT THAT JUST OCCURftED AT UNIVERSITY AND WESTERN AVE. THE ViCT1M (A
YELLOW CAB DRIVER) HAD TOLD THE TC / POLICE DISPATCH THAT THE CAR TAKEN
WA5 A YELLOW CAB # 95 AND THAT THERE WERE 3 SUSPECTS (TWO MALES AND ONE
FEMALE). THE VECTIM ALSO SAID THAT THE SUSPECTS MAY BE HEADED TO THE AREA
OF 289 THOMAS.
UPON MY ARRiVAL, I MET WITH THE VtCTiM AND HE WAS LATER ID WITH MN DL AS;
MANNEH, JAMES (DOB OF 01-01-69 OF 2419 5TH AVE. SO., MPLS). AS I WAS TRYING TO
SPEAK WITH MANNEH, HE WAS BEING SOMEWNAT UNCOOPERATiVE AND I COULD
SMELL A STRONG ODOR OF AN ALGOHOLIC BEVERAGE COMING FROM HfM AS HE SPOKE.
WHILE SPEAKING WITH MANNEH, I HEARD SQD 624 (K-9 OFFICER BREMMER) ADVISE
DISPATCH THAT HE HAD THE STOLEN CAB AND THE 7HREE SUSPECTS AT WESTERN
AND BLAIR. I THEN TOLD MANNEH TO STAY THERE AND I THEN WENT TO WESTERN
AND BLAIR TO ASSIST SQD 624.
UPON MY ARRIVAL THERE, SQD 215 (CORCORAN) AND SQD 175 {DRUTSCHMAN AND
MARTfN) WERE ALSO ARRIVING AND WE THEN TOOK THE THREE SUSPECTS INTO
CUSTODY (TWO MALES AND ONE FEMALE). ONCE THE SUSPECTS WERE SECURED, !
THEN WENT BACK TO 490 W. UNIVERSITY TO PICK UP MAfVNEH, BUT HE WAS GONE. i
WAS THEN ASLE TO LOCATE HIM ON THE PAY PHONE AT THE NORTH WEST TEAM,
(DALE AND UNfVERSiTY).
I PUT MANNHE iNTO MY CAR AND l"RANSPORTED HIM BACK TO WESTERN AND BLAIR.
WHILE EN ROUTE BACK THERE, MANNEH TOLD ME THAT ONE OF THE SUSPECTS IS A
FEMALE THAT NE HAS SEEN SEEING INTIMATELY BY THE NAME OF; RALEIGH, ASHA
BONNAE (DOB 07-17-79 OF 289 THOMAS).
MAN(VHE SAID THAT HE GOT CALLED BY ASHA TO PICK HER UP AT HER HOUSE, 289
THOMAS, WHICH HE DlD. MANNHE SA(D THAT THEY DROVE AROUND AND THEN SHE
TOLD H{M TO PICK UP HER COUSIN AT A BAR ON SELBY AVE. MANNHE SAID HE QROVE
TO THE BAR AND ASHA WENT INSIDE FOR A WHILE. MANNHE SAID AFTER SEVERAL
MINUTES, HE WENT INSIDE AND TOLD HER HE HAD TO GO.
MANNHE SAID THAT SHE THEN CAME OUTSIDE WITH HEft COUSIN AND ANOTHER
MALE AND THEY THEN GOT INTO THE CAB. WHILE IN THE CAB, MANNHE SAID THAT HE
HAD GOTTEN A PHONE CALL FROM ANOTHER FEMALE AND ASHA THEN GOT MAD AT HIM
AND THEY STARTED TO ARGUE. MANNHE SAID THAT HE THEN PULLED OVER IN FRONT
OF 496 W. UNIVERSITY AND THEY STAR7ED ARGUiNG AND TALKING ABOUT THE PHONE
CALL. -
Saint Paul Police Department Page 5
.� ORiGINAL OFFENSE / INCIDENT REPORT oo-��r
Complaint Number Reference C.K Pnmary offense Date and T�me of RepoK
99-214355 99-214297 AUTO THEFT �2i18/1999 04:53
MANNHE SAID THAT ASHA AND HlM THEN GOT OUT OF THE CAB AND WERE ARGUING
NEAR THE TRUNK OF AREA OF THE CAB WHEN THE TWO OTHER SUSPECTS GOT OUT
AND CAME AT HIM. MANNHE SAID ONE OF 7HE MALES, WHICH HE POINTEQ TO WH(LE
AT WESTERN AND BLA)R, SUDDENLY PUNCHEb HIM IN THE LEFT SIQE OF THE FACE.
THE MALE SUSPECT WAS ID AS ASHA'S BROTHER; RALE{GH, ftASHAD ARTHUR (DOB 02-
15-78 OF 289 THOMAS).
MANNHE SAID AFTER HE GOT PUNCHED, HE GOT SCARED BECAUSE (T WAS THREE
AGAINST ONE AND " JETTED". MANNHE SAID THE THREE THEN JUMPED INTO H{S CAB
AND THEN TOOK OFF. HE SAlD HE THEN CALLED TNE POLfCE AND WE RESPONDED A
SHORT TIME LATER.
WHILE AT WESTERN AND BLAIR, MANNHE LOOKED AT THE OTHER MALE SUSPECT
AND POSITIVELY ID THE SUSPECT AS THE THIRD PARTY INVOLVED IN TAKING THE CAB.
THE THIRD SUSPEGT WAS ID AS ASHA'S COUS4N; GANT, AHMAD KAREEM (DOB 03-16-75
OF 1540 MISSiSSfPPI).
WHILE AT THE SCENE, A BLACK BACK PACK WAS RECOVERED FROM THE THREE
SUSPECTS WHO SAID TNEY TOOK IT FROM THE STOLEN CAB. MANNNE TOLD ME THAT
TNE BACK PACK WAS {IV FACT HIS,
WHILE ON SCENE AT WESTERN AND BLAIR, SGT. INDEHAR, SQD 175, AND SQD 624
ALL TOLD ME THAT THEY COULD SMELL A STRONG ODOR OF AN ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMING FROM HIM AS HE SPOKE. i ASKED MANNHE IF HE HAD ANYTHING ALCOHOLIC
TO DRINK TONIGHT AND HE SAID NO. 1 THEN ASKED HIM IF HE HAD ANYTHING
ALCOHOLIC TO DRINK FROM THE TIME HiS CAB WAS STOLEN TO THE TIME 1 PICKED H1M
UP AT THE NORTH WEST TEAM AND HE AGAIN SA{D NO.
THE THREE SUSPECTS WERE TAKEN TO H.Q. AND BOOKED INTO THE RCJ ANNEX
FOR AUTO THEFT. MANNHE'S CAB # 95 WAS TOWED TO THE C(TY IMPOUND LOT BY SQD
624 AND MANNHE WAS ALSO TRANSPORTED TO H.Q. FOR INVESTIGATION OF DUI.
PLEASE REFER TO SQD 624'S SUPP UNDER 99-214-297.
ALSO SEE SQD 175'S REPORT, WHICH ASHA RALEIGH 1S THE ASSAULT VICTIM AND
MANNHE IS THE ASSAULT SUSPECT, UNDER CN # 99-214-336. MANNHE WAS TAGGED
AND SOOKED FOR THE ASSAULT.
ALSO SEE MY ADDITIONAL REPORT OF DUI SUSPECT, MANNHE, UNDER CN # 99-214-
297, WHlCH MANNHE WAS BOOKED FOR DUT AND DUf OVER .10.
'lease distribute to:
_CHF _Hom
+ Sex _DiC
_CO _Rptr
-..
_Burg
Vice
_Juv - _Oper
_Theft _Prop
_Narco _SIU
_PSC _Lab _Rec
_CAU _F&F _Auto
_T&A �Other
_Team
_DAO
S
C
t� Saint Pau{ Police Department Paoe Z
= SUPPLEMENTAL OFFENSE / INCfDENT REPORT oc_,�r
Complainf Numbei Reference C.N. Pnmary oHense
Date and Time of Repor.
99-214297 DU1 12/18(1999 03:45
Please distribute to:
_CHF _Hom
_Sex _D!C
_CO ^ Rptr
_Rob
_Burg
Vice
_Juv -
_Theft
_Narco
_Oper
_Prop
_S(U
_PSC
_CAU
! T&A
_Lab
F&F
_Other
._Rec
_Auto
�Team
_DAO
Council File # pQ _ 3 R g
� p
Presented By
Referred To
Green Sheet # �p� 9 `�j
��
Committee: Date
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
4
10
11
12
13
14
WHEREAS, 7ames Manneh pled guilry to careless driving on Februaiy 1, 2000; and
WI Saint Paul Legislafive Code §376.16(e)(5)a.3. does not permit licensing of
individuals who haue had a careless driving convicfion within the previous three yeazs; now
therefore be it
RESOLVED, that the Taxicab Driver's License held by James Manneh (license ID No.
980004209), is hereby revoked for his Februaiy 1, 2000 misdemeanor conviction for cazeless
driving.
This resolution and the action of the Council in this matter are based upon the facts
contained in the Saint Paul Police reports CN99-214-355 and CN99-214-297, and the March 10,
2000 Notice of Violarion letter to the licensee. The facts were not contested by the licensee.
Requested by Department of:
� t� ��'.�
By:
Adoption Certified by Council Secretary
By:
App:
sy:
RESOLUTION
CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
!
Form Approved by City Att�
!
ay: �.f B/ � I� ti c�-� y
Appmved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By:
Adopted by Council: Date t�\ °�.�;�.L?00
Office of LIEP/City Attomey
vuginia
r��
TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES
Resolurion revoking the Taxicab Driver's License held by James Manneh. (Uncontested)
PLANNING COAAMISSION
CIB COMMITTEE
CNIL SERVICE CAMMISSION
GREEN SHEET
oF..R,�rowrcra�
❑ 41YATlOPIEY ❑ tliYCLiRK �
❑ AYNtMLtERNCF1qR ❑ A4MCLLLfFRNKCTG
❑r�rortlOxnam'rurt� ❑
(CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGPJATURE)
Has this Ger�rm ever Maked untler a Canhact for fhic tlepartmentl
vES NO
Has Nis P�rtn ever Eren a aty emVbYeM
YES Dq
Does this PersonrTrtn P�� a slull not namallYP�etl bY anY curreM citY emPbYee?
YES NO
Is this P�Rrm a tarpetetl vendoR
YES t�
� oo �'��18`
No � �� ;'�J
ancoia�ca
TOTALAMOUNTOF7RANSACTION
COSTIREVENUE BUDGETED IqRCLE ONE�
�
FUNDING SOURCE
AC7IVRY NUMBER
91.ANCIAL INFORMATON (EXPIAIN)
UiVCONTESTED LiCENSE MATTER °�"
Licensee Name:
Add ress;
License:
Council Date:
James Manneh
2419 5 Avenue South, # 909, Minneapolis, MN
Taxicab Driver's License
April 26, 2000
Violation: Conviction for Care{ess Driving
St. Pauf Legislative Code § 376.16(e)(5)a.3.
February 1, 200Q
Date of Violation
Location:
December 18, 1999
While driving cab
Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behaif of ctient, Office
of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection:
Revocation of Taxicab Driver's License
Attachments:
1. Proposed resolution
2. Notice ofi Violation
3. License Information Report
4, Ramsey County Court printout
5. Police Reports CN99-214-355 and CN99-214-297
OFFICE OF TF� CITY ATTORNEY
Clay[onM Robinson, Jr„ CiryAltorney
CITY OF SAINT PALTL CivilDtvision
Norm Colemwt, Mayor 400 Ciry Hall
IS WenKellaggBlvd
Saint Paul, �nnesota 55702
�+�.rn�
March 30, 2000
NOTICE OF COUNCIL MEETING
Mr. James Manneh
2419 5�' Avenue South, # 909
Minneapolis, Minnesota 554Q4
Re: Ta7cicab Driver's License held by James Manneh
License ID No.:98Q004209
Deaz Mr. Manneh:
00-3�18`
Telephone: 651266-871 D
Facsimile: 657 29&5619
Please take notice that this matter has been set on the Consent Agenda for the Council meeting
scheduled for 3:30 p.m., Wednesday, Apri126, 2000 in the City Council Chambers, Third
Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse.
Enclosed are copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to
the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested matter, in that the facts
concerning your careless driving conviction have not been denied. The recommendation of the
license office will be for the revocation of your taxicab driver's license.
If you have any questions, please ca11 me at 266-8710.
Very truly yours,
�v�.`�`"� J \� z �-Y�
Virgima D��Palmer
Assistant City Attomey
cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary
Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP
Rich Jents, LIEP
C���t�� �9�e�zc,'� �e��ter
;°�%�� � � �
CITY OF SA1NT PAUL
Norm Cotemax, Mayor
�1TC�1 1�, 200�
OFFICE "� THE CITY ATTORN£Y
Clayton h binson, Jr., Cify Aitomey
O O -3�,Y
Civi1 Division
400 Ciry Ha1t Telephane: 631266-8710
IS lYest KellaggBlvd. Facsimile: 651 298-5619
Sair:t Poul, Mirutesota 55107
NOTICE OF VIOLATION
Mr. James Manneh
2419 S�' Avenue South, # 909
Minneapolis, Minnesota 55404
RE: Taxicab Driver's License Held by James Manneh
License ID No.: 980004209
Dear Mr. Manneh:
The Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection has recommended
adverse action against your taxicab driver's license. The basis for the recommendation is as
follows:
Saint Paul Legislarive Code §376.16(e)(5)a.3. does not permit
licensing of individuals who have had a careless driving
convicrio» �vithin the last three years. On February 1, 2000,
you pled guilty to a misdemeanor charge of careless driving.
The police reports from the incident indicate that you had been
drinking, and that a breafh test showed your alcohol
concentration to be a.11. The vehicle you were driving on this
occasion was your cab.
If you do not dispute the above facts piease send me a letter with a statement to that
effect. The matter will then be scheduled for a hearing before the St. Paul City Council to
determine what penaity, if any, to impose. You will have an opportunity to appear and speak on
your own behalf, or to have someone appear there for you.
On the other hand, if you wish to dispute the above facts, T will schedule an evidentiary
hearing before an Administrative Law Judge (AL.T). If you wish to have such a hearing, please
send me a letter stating that you are contesting the facts. You will then be sent a"Notice of
Hearing," so you will know when and where to appear, and what the basis for the hearing will be.
Page 2
Mr. James Manneh
Mazch 10, 2000
00 -3�1$'
If you have not confacted me by Monday, March 20, 2000, I wilt assume that you are not
confestiag the facts and will schedule this matter for the St. Paul City Council and have it
placed on the Consent Agenda during which no public discussion is allowed and the
recommeaded penalty will be imposed.
If you have any questions, feei free to contact me at 266-8710.
Sincerely,
i � t`'�
c2 � �i a-p-�,,
Virginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP
Christine Rozek, LIEP
Rich Jents, LIEF
oc -3�t8'
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
) ss.
COUNTY OF RAMSEY
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL
30ANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes ancl says
that on March 14, 2000, she served the attached NOTICE OF VIOLATION
the following named person by placing a true and correct copy
thereof in an envelope addressed as follows:
Mr. James Manneh
2419 S Avenue South, #409
Minneapolis, MN. 55404
(which is the last known address of said
same, with postage prepaid, in the Un�
Minnesota.
Subscribed and sworn to before me
this 14th/day> o€�I arc��000 .
son) and depositing the
ates mails„at St. Paul,
= ' PETER P. PANGBORN
r��' ApiAfYf PUBi1C - AIINRIESOTA
�` 7 �' � � MYCOMMISSION
Notary PUbl� F.XPiRESJAN.31,2005
pc, _��1�'
��
O
a
x
�
� N O
� � N
y U �
R J O
a ,._
O
�
C
C
d
d'
C
O
w
R
�
�
w
C
d
N
C
N
v
1
y
.�+ �
N
N
N
c a�
U 7
J Q
N
N
� '
I� o
N �p
C �
d U
V ���
�'J�
o .n
o �i
�, � o
Z N
N �
G O
V �
_.I �
�
R
�
O
W
N Q
N
'�O F-
a
<Cd�o
� �
N ��lJ
_
W
a� �
E Z
¢
Z �
�
� Q
�
S
�'w
E
m q
Z �
C �
O W
a�
7
'v
c
�
O
U
..L.
N
�
N
N
i
X
N
�
N
�
�
7
Z
U
a
U
C
N
N
�
�
�
�
Z
�,I
�
�.,
E
0
U
U
C
t
N
C
N
�
�
7
Z
N
C
0
� a
N
N
�
�m ^
i
X
R
0
rn
>
4
�
�
�
N
SD2005.0/000330:094350
Activity Display Fi
62-T1-99-101749 Driving Intoxicated Date filed• 12/20/1
The State of Minnesota d� ,���
vs. JAMES BOY MANNEH. (2j1218991
Time Status Crt In- Tr- Continu
Date Activity StarE/End Judge Notice Room trp ied SrvcDa
_ 12/20/99 Case Filed 12:44/12:44 OCCj
12j29/99 Arraigmm�t 01:�0/ S Rosas OCC/ 131A
BOND $500 1ST APP GENERAL BOND WITH T1-99-101752
_ 12/22j99 sona o9:a9/ Administrative occ�
$1000 GOLDBERG BOND PWR #AZB-2Q477 POSTED 12/18 BY
ROBERT YOUNG. CRT DATE ON BOND 12/29. MSL
12/29/99 Bond Rvw / c�j
$1000 ACTIVE BOND MSL
_ 12/29j99 Cert xep io:2�� occ/
CERTIFICATE OF REPRESENTATION FILED BY:
JQH21 AKWUBA ID# 280446 SM
_ 12f29/99 Order 10:28/ OCC/
NO CONTACT ORDER FILED: ASHA BONNAE RALEIGFI SM
_ 12/29/99 Arraigmm�t 01:00/ S Rosas OCC/ 131A
PNG FC S/C 1j18/00 1:30 JUDGE FLINN SM
o�/�s/oo sond xvw � C�J
$1000 ACTIVE BOND MSL
o1/is�oo setti conf oi:so� c�iinn occ/ cx
$1000 BOND, PNG S/C JUDGE FLINN
_ oi/so�oo Doc. Fi1ed �2:22/ occ/
JUDICIAL DETERMINATION OF PC TO DETAIN FILED SN
_ oi/la/oo settl conf oi:so/ c Fiinn occ� cx
FC: TMC 2-1-00 9AM FLINN SAB
02/O1j00
o2/oi/oo
_ 01/18/00
_ 02/O1f00
07/O1/02
_ 02/O1/00
04/01/00
_ 02j02/00
Bond Rvw / ��.7�
$1000 ACTIVE BOND
Mgmt Conf 09:00/ C Flinn CAN/ CH
$1000 BOND NG TMC FLINN
Doc. Filed 05:5�/ OCCj
ORDER SETTING JURY TRIAL DATE AND ORDER TO
REPORT IN DOMESTIC CASES FILED
Sentencing 09:OOf C Flinn OCC/ CH
PG CT 1 AMND CARELESS, OTR CTS DSM MO CA;
30DY &$300 SS PRB 2YR 1)CE/REC FEE IMP 2)NO DL/INS
3)$100+ 4)NO S/S 5)USL CNDjLA 6)NO DRINK/DRV VIOL
Archive / PEN/
Pd in Full 09:47/ OCC/
100 PLIIS FESS PLUS CFEE SIN
Stat Rview / ���
PIF FINES OFFICE AFTER CT CASH $255.
Closed 05:30/ OCC/
MS L
�F7
VIOL
AMP
SIN
Criminal Case Summary
SD1008.Of 000330:094626
00 -'��1 r
62-T1-99-101749 Drivina Intoxicated Date filed• 12/2011
Name: MANNEH, JAMES BOY, [2/121899]
Alias:
DOB: 01/O1/1969 Race:
Sex: Soc Sec #
Dfnt Attrny: JOHN NWABUWANE AICW[TBA
Dfnt Status: On Bond Status Date:
Case Status CLOSED Offense Date:
Location: 1 Continuances: 0 Trial
CCT Plea Charge
001 GUILTY CARELESS DRIVING
002 I30T GUILfiY . OVER .10 <.20 MI
Date Aativity Time
Last 02/02/2000 Closed 5:30
Pending 07/O1/2002 Archive
Type: Retained
12/18/1999 Bail Amount: $
12/18/1999 Warrant Date:
Type: 3urisdiction:
Chap/Sect/SUbd GOC UOC
169.13 2
169.121 1D3B
Judge
500.00
District
Verdict
Guilty.
Dismisse
CRT
IIisposition Date 02/O1/2000
Next FC_ 04 06 08 10
Saint Pauf Police Department Page 7
� ORfGINAL OFFENSE / INCIDENT REPORT oo-3�t
Complarnt Number Reference C N. Pnmary otiense
99-214355 99-214297 AUTO THEFT Dateantl7imeofRepor
12/18/1999 04:53
PnmaryReporL"ng O�cer. GLENN A MCGREGOR Location ofincident: 490 UNIVERSITY AV W
Pnmary offense detaiL � / �
Pnmary squad: 2� 3 Name oflocationlbusiness:
Secondary repo�ting o�cer.
D;stnct: CENTRAL ( CENTRAL DiSTRICT )
Secontlary offense:
Date & fime of occu�ence: '12118/1999 0'I :47
Anest made � YES
Oate & time ofa/rest 12/78/lggg 02:45
POLICE PERSONNEL fNVOLVED
Arrest made on view. YES
A�st made on warrant o� prevrous CM
Weapons used 6y police: .
Weapons used by suspect at time of arrest
Pursuit engaged:
Resistance encounteled:
CHARGES
tyame RALEIGH, ASHA BONNAE
arresr srarus gOOKED Book,n � a at y g
eooking date 12/1 g/1 ggg Booking time Q5:56
Charge AUTO THEFT
Citahonnumber BaiJ Ong�natingagency SPPD
Warrant num6er
Walrant type
�vame GANT, AHMAD KAREEM
chargeclv gg2�a355
ar�esr srarus gOOKEp Booking # dpf` �J�
eooking date 12l18/1999 eooking time 05:17
Charge AUTO THEFT
Citation number Bail Ongrnating a9ency SPPD
Warrantnumber ChargeCN 99214355
Warrant type
�
n�ame RALEIGH, RASHAD AftTHUR Arrest Status BOOKED Book,� # a PY7 �
eooking date 12/18/1999 eooking time 05:12 �
Charge AUTO THEFT
GitaGOn number
Warrant number
Wa(rant type
�AMES
Y�
: NF Z� -t�/c.
2� �. T� �-m
Bail
Originatmg agency
Charge CN 9921A355
cG - `/ �4 u.TO - � Y�c r
/Yt�s�= Du� �f
V �
�����
�
T¢�
_'C PAlii
�
4ULICE
Comp/aint Number
99-214355
Saint Paut Pofice Department Page 2
ORtGlNAL OFFENSE / 1NCIDENT REPORT o
Reference C.N. Pnmary oflense Date and Time of Report
99-214297 AUTO THEFT 12/18/1999 04:53
ARRES7EE RALEIGH, ASHA BONNAE
289 THOMAS AV W STPAUL MN 55104
PhysicalDescription Phones
sex FEMALE xeiynt Hai�COlor Nomephone 65'I-488-4g1g
Race BLACK Weight
Hispanrc
ooa 07/17l�g7g
Age 20
Harr Type
Buifd Hair Leng!h
Skin BROWN-MEDIUM'Facia�Hai�
Physical Conditio� Employment
Consciousness Occupafion
0`ucyalconotuse HAD BEEN DRINKI(dG
Werght
Build
ARRESTEE GAN , AHMAD KAREEM
1540 MISSISSIPPI AV N STPAUL " MN 55101
Physical Descripfion Phones
Sex MALE Height HairColo�
Race BLACK
Hispanic
OOS 03l16f1975
Age 24
Employe�
Hair Type
Nair Length
Skin BROWN - MEDIUM FaciatFiair
Physica! Condifion Emp/oymenf
Consciousness Occupation
oruya�coho�use HAD BEEN DftINKING
Employer
ARRESTEE RALEIGH, RASHAD ARTHUR
289 THOMAS AV W STPAUL MN 55104
Physica! Description Phones
sex MALE Heignr Hai�caor Nome phone 651-488-4919
Race BL,qCK Weight Hai�Type
Hispanic Build Hair Length
ooe 02/15/1976 sxin BROWN - MEDIUM Facial Hair
Age 21
Physical Canditio� Employment
Consci0usne55 Occupation
Drugfalcohof use HAD BEEN DRINKING Emp�oyer
� Saint Paul Police Department Page 4
�� ORIGINAL OFFENSE / INCIDENT REPORT po ..,��.
Comp/aintNumber Reference C.N. Primaryotfense Date and Time ofReport
99-214355 99-214297 AUTO TNEFT 12/18/1999 04:53
lnsurance & owner information Vehicle contents 8 drive�
lnsurance co.
lienholde�
Registered owner
Dnve�slrcense no.
Personal property in veh�cle
Keys in vBh�cle
Owner allowed someone to
use vehicle
Person a/lowed to use vehicle
rres£s ame ress
ge ace ex
aorY RALEIGH, ASHA BONNAE 289 THOMAS AV W, S7PAUL, MN 55104 07/17(1979 20 B F
ao 8 y 6 GANT, AHMAD KAREEM i54� MISSISSIPPI AV N, STPAIiL, MN 55101 03/16/1975 24 g tvt
�� � RALEIGH, RASHAD ARTHUR 289 THOMAS AV W, STPAUL, MN 551Q4 02/15/1978 21 g iJ�
SQUAD 213 (MCGREGOR) WAS SENT TO 490 W. UNIVERSITY ON A�REPORT OF A AUTO
THEFT THAT JUST OCCURftED AT UNIVERSITY AND WESTERN AVE. THE ViCT1M (A
YELLOW CAB DRIVER) HAD TOLD THE TC / POLICE DISPATCH THAT THE CAR TAKEN
WA5 A YELLOW CAB # 95 AND THAT THERE WERE 3 SUSPECTS (TWO MALES AND ONE
FEMALE). THE VECTIM ALSO SAID THAT THE SUSPECTS MAY BE HEADED TO THE AREA
OF 289 THOMAS.
UPON MY ARRiVAL, I MET WITH THE VtCTiM AND HE WAS LATER ID WITH MN DL AS;
MANNEH, JAMES (DOB OF 01-01-69 OF 2419 5TH AVE. SO., MPLS). AS I WAS TRYING TO
SPEAK WITH MANNEH, HE WAS BEING SOMEWNAT UNCOOPERATiVE AND I COULD
SMELL A STRONG ODOR OF AN ALGOHOLIC BEVERAGE COMING FROM HfM AS HE SPOKE.
WHILE SPEAKING WITH MANNEH, I HEARD SQD 624 (K-9 OFFICER BREMMER) ADVISE
DISPATCH THAT HE HAD THE STOLEN CAB AND THE 7HREE SUSPECTS AT WESTERN
AND BLAIR. I THEN TOLD MANNEH TO STAY THERE AND I THEN WENT TO WESTERN
AND BLAIR TO ASSIST SQD 624.
UPON MY ARRIVAL THERE, SQD 215 (CORCORAN) AND SQD 175 {DRUTSCHMAN AND
MARTfN) WERE ALSO ARRIVING AND WE THEN TOOK THE THREE SUSPECTS INTO
CUSTODY (TWO MALES AND ONE FEMALE). ONCE THE SUSPECTS WERE SECURED, !
THEN WENT BACK TO 490 W. UNIVERSITY TO PICK UP MAfVNEH, BUT HE WAS GONE. i
WAS THEN ASLE TO LOCATE HIM ON THE PAY PHONE AT THE NORTH WEST TEAM,
(DALE AND UNfVERSiTY).
I PUT MANNHE iNTO MY CAR AND l"RANSPORTED HIM BACK TO WESTERN AND BLAIR.
WHILE EN ROUTE BACK THERE, MANNEH TOLD ME THAT ONE OF THE SUSPECTS IS A
FEMALE THAT NE HAS SEEN SEEING INTIMATELY BY THE NAME OF; RALEIGH, ASHA
BONNAE (DOB 07-17-79 OF 289 THOMAS).
MAN(VHE SAID THAT HE GOT CALLED BY ASHA TO PICK HER UP AT HER HOUSE, 289
THOMAS, WHICH HE DlD. MANNHE SA(D THAT THEY DROVE AROUND AND THEN SHE
TOLD H{M TO PICK UP HER COUSIN AT A BAR ON SELBY AVE. MANNHE SAID HE QROVE
TO THE BAR AND ASHA WENT INSIDE FOR A WHILE. MANNHE SAID AFTER SEVERAL
MINUTES, HE WENT INSIDE AND TOLD HER HE HAD TO GO.
MANNHE SAID THAT SHE THEN CAME OUTSIDE WITH HEft COUSIN AND ANOTHER
MALE AND THEY THEN GOT INTO THE CAB. WHILE IN THE CAB, MANNHE SAID THAT HE
HAD GOTTEN A PHONE CALL FROM ANOTHER FEMALE AND ASHA THEN GOT MAD AT HIM
AND THEY STARTED TO ARGUE. MANNHE SAID THAT HE THEN PULLED OVER IN FRONT
OF 496 W. UNIVERSITY AND THEY STAR7ED ARGUiNG AND TALKING ABOUT THE PHONE
CALL. -
Saint Paul Police Department Page 5
.� ORiGINAL OFFENSE / INCIDENT REPORT oo-��r
Complaint Number Reference C.K Pnmary offense Date and T�me of RepoK
99-214355 99-214297 AUTO THEFT �2i18/1999 04:53
MANNHE SAID THAT ASHA AND HlM THEN GOT OUT OF THE CAB AND WERE ARGUING
NEAR THE TRUNK OF AREA OF THE CAB WHEN THE TWO OTHER SUSPECTS GOT OUT
AND CAME AT HIM. MANNHE SAID ONE OF 7HE MALES, WHICH HE POINTEQ TO WH(LE
AT WESTERN AND BLA)R, SUDDENLY PUNCHEb HIM IN THE LEFT SIQE OF THE FACE.
THE MALE SUSPECT WAS ID AS ASHA'S BROTHER; RALE{GH, ftASHAD ARTHUR (DOB 02-
15-78 OF 289 THOMAS).
MANNHE SAID AFTER HE GOT PUNCHED, HE GOT SCARED BECAUSE (T WAS THREE
AGAINST ONE AND " JETTED". MANNHE SAID THE THREE THEN JUMPED INTO H{S CAB
AND THEN TOOK OFF. HE SAlD HE THEN CALLED TNE POLfCE AND WE RESPONDED A
SHORT TIME LATER.
WHILE AT WESTERN AND BLAIR, MANNHE LOOKED AT THE OTHER MALE SUSPECT
AND POSITIVELY ID THE SUSPECT AS THE THIRD PARTY INVOLVED IN TAKING THE CAB.
THE THIRD SUSPEGT WAS ID AS ASHA'S COUS4N; GANT, AHMAD KAREEM (DOB 03-16-75
OF 1540 MISSiSSfPPI).
WHILE AT THE SCENE, A BLACK BACK PACK WAS RECOVERED FROM THE THREE
SUSPECTS WHO SAID TNEY TOOK IT FROM THE STOLEN CAB. MANNNE TOLD ME THAT
TNE BACK PACK WAS {IV FACT HIS,
WHILE ON SCENE AT WESTERN AND BLAIR, SGT. INDEHAR, SQD 175, AND SQD 624
ALL TOLD ME THAT THEY COULD SMELL A STRONG ODOR OF AN ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMING FROM HIM AS HE SPOKE. i ASKED MANNHE IF HE HAD ANYTHING ALCOHOLIC
TO DRINK TONIGHT AND HE SAID NO. 1 THEN ASKED HIM IF HE HAD ANYTHING
ALCOHOLIC TO DRINK FROM THE TIME HiS CAB WAS STOLEN TO THE TIME 1 PICKED H1M
UP AT THE NORTH WEST TEAM AND HE AGAIN SA{D NO.
THE THREE SUSPECTS WERE TAKEN TO H.Q. AND BOOKED INTO THE RCJ ANNEX
FOR AUTO THEFT. MANNHE'S CAB # 95 WAS TOWED TO THE C(TY IMPOUND LOT BY SQD
624 AND MANNHE WAS ALSO TRANSPORTED TO H.Q. FOR INVESTIGATION OF DUI.
PLEASE REFER TO SQD 624'S SUPP UNDER 99-214-297.
ALSO SEE SQD 175'S REPORT, WHICH ASHA RALEIGH 1S THE ASSAULT VICTIM AND
MANNHE IS THE ASSAULT SUSPECT, UNDER CN # 99-214-336. MANNHE WAS TAGGED
AND SOOKED FOR THE ASSAULT.
ALSO SEE MY ADDITIONAL REPORT OF DUI SUSPECT, MANNHE, UNDER CN # 99-214-
297, WHlCH MANNHE WAS BOOKED FOR DUT AND DUf OVER .10.
'lease distribute to:
_CHF _Hom
+ Sex _DiC
_CO _Rptr
-..
_Burg
Vice
_Juv - _Oper
_Theft _Prop
_Narco _SIU
_PSC _Lab _Rec
_CAU _F&F _Auto
_T&A �Other
_Team
_DAO
S
C
t� Saint Pau{ Police Department Paoe Z
= SUPPLEMENTAL OFFENSE / INCfDENT REPORT oc_,�r
Complainf Numbei Reference C.N. Pnmary oHense
Date and Time of Repor.
99-214297 DU1 12/18(1999 03:45
Please distribute to:
_CHF _Hom
_Sex _D!C
_CO ^ Rptr
_Rob
_Burg
Vice
_Juv -
_Theft
_Narco
_Oper
_Prop
_S(U
_PSC
_CAU
! T&A
_Lab
F&F
_Other
._Rec
_Auto
�Team
_DAO