279527 WHITE - GTV CLERK COUI1C11 2�9�►�
PINK - FINANCE
CANARV..- DEPARTMENT G I T�Y OF SA I NT PAU L
BLUE - MAVOR File NO.
�
.
Resolution
Presented By
•
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
WHEREAS, Kurt Schwichtenberg and John McQuillan have applied
for building permits to move two existing houses to 302 Exchange
Street and to construct a carriage house and garages at 302
Exchange Street; and
WHEREAS, Acting pursuant to Chapter 73 of the Saint Paul
Legislative Code, the building permit applications were reviewed
by the Saint Paul Heritage Preservation Commission for the purpose
of determining whether the proposed development was consistent
with the Irvine Park Heritage Preservation Program; and
WHEREAS, The Heritage Preservation Comznission by its Reso-
lution No. 273 adopted August 12, 1982, approved the issuance of
the building permits based upon the following findings of fact:
(1) The eight proposed garages along the alley at the rear
of the site will not adversely affect vehicular circulation.
(2) The proposed setback requirements are in compliance
with New Construction Guideline V (Site) .
(3) The proposed carriage house is approximately 30 feet
high. In this respect, it conforms to New Construction Guideline I
(Massing) . However, the proposed structure does not relate in
massing to the surrounding neighborhood buildings as outlined in
the New Construction Guidelines.
(4) The design of the carriage house was arrived at in
cooperation with the Historial Resources Committee of the American
Institute of Architects.
COUNCILMEN �
Yeas Nays Requested by Department of:
Fletcher
�evine [n Favor
Masanz
Nicosia
scne�bei _ __ Against BY
Tedesco
Wilson
Form Approved y i ttorne
Adopted by Council: Date
Certified Yassed by Council Secretary BY
By
Approved by ;Vlavor: Date _ Approved by o or Submission to Council
By _ — BY
WH17E - CI7V CLERK COUflC1I •�(���
p".NK - FINANCE GITY OF SAINT PAUL
4NARH- DEPARTMENT
�!'E - MAVOR File NO.
Council Resolution
Presented By
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
(5) The proposed foundation of the two houses to be moved
onto the site meet the requirements of Rehab. Guideline I (Masonary
and Foundations) .
WHEREAS, Acting pursuant to Section 73. 07 (8) Lois M. Geiwitz
appealed the Heritage Preservation Commission ruling to the City
Council and the City Council having held a public hearing on
November 4, 1982 for the purpose of considering the actions of
the Heritage Preservation Commission and the grounds for appeal
as stated by Lois M. Geiwitz, does hereby
RESOLVE, That the Council of the City of Saint Paul does
hereby affirm the decision of the Heritage Preservation Commission
in this matter and does hereby concur in the findings made and
determined by said Coznmission; and, be it
FURTHER RESOLVED, That the appeal of Lois M. Geiwitz be and
is hereby denied; and, be it
FURTHER RESOLVED, That the City Clerk shall mail a copy of
this resolution to Lois M. Geiwitz, the Heritage Preservation
Commission and the building official.
-2-
COUNCILMEN
Yeas Nays Requested by Department of:
fielieF�er�
�eV1"e [n Favor
Masanz
Nicosia
9e�,elbsh � __ A ga i n s t BY -
1'edB�SCa^
Wilson
(��aQ�
NOV 3 '' Form Approved i ttorn
Adopted by Council: Date —
Certified a �e Coun I , t BY
By
Approved by , a r: Date Approved by yo or Submission to Council
sy /.� - BY
� �UBUSN�D D t C 11 1982
c � a �95a �
�� �°�°��,� CITY OF SAINT PAUL
`�`�C�Ti O��i� .
=4'` '-��"'�- OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK
'• � ;:
�;,� iiii�i',i�u ��
,`� _ ALBERT B. OLSON, CITY CLERK
'``��, �... ' 386 City Hall,Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102
"imn��.....c°���
612-298-4231
GEORGE LATIMER
MAYOR
December 6, 1982
�
e
Lois M. Geiwitz
297 Ryan Ave.
St. Paul, Minnesota 55102
Dear Ms. Geiwitz: �
On November 30, 1982 the St. Paul City Council adopted a resolution
�ienying your appeal to a decision of the Heritage Preservation Commission
regarding 302 Exchange Street: Enclosed for your information is a copy
of C.F. No. 279527.
Very truly yours,
Sh!_
� Albert B. Olson
City Clerk
Enclosure
cc: Heritage Preservation Commission
Glenn Erickson, Building Official
sch
���
� . � - � �' 2"7952'7
• ST. PAUL CITY COUNCIL
� PUBLIC HEARiNG N �TICE
70: Property owners within 350 feet;
representatives of District 9 FIL E N 0. HPC 273
PAGE
P V R P�S E Appeal of Heritage Preservation Commission decision t�
approve development of property at 302 Exchange St.
LOCATION 302 Exchange st.
P�TITIQNER �ois M. Geiwitz
HEARING Thursday, ��ovember �4, �9s2 lo:oo a.rt.
Citv Council Chambers, 3rd Floor Citti• Hall - Court House
Q��S��0 N�J Heritage Preservation Corrmission 292-1577 Ext. 297
��ntac� th-� Her�ta^� preservat;or: �Q"1T3 5S 1�n i r.
Room 1101, City Hall Annex,
25 W. 4th Stree[; St. Paul, Minnesota 55102
Legal Description: Lot 1 excluding the SEIy 8' thereof and the
E 2 of Lot 2 except the SEIy 8' thereof all in Block 30, Ric� and
Irvines Addition to St. Paul and all that part of the NEIy 2 of
vacated Sherman Street lying between extending across it of the NWiy
line of Lot 6, Block 31 , Rice and Irvines and a line drawn 8' NWIy
of the SEIy line of said Lot 6, and all that part of the SWIy 2 of
�.w��±ori Chcrmar CtrQat 1�in� IJet�.ican a�(ta�cjnl� ��rn�5 jfi nf the �W�V
line of Lot l , Block 30, Rice and Irvines Addition to St. P�ul and
a line drawn 6` NWIy of the SEIy line of said Lot 1 .
rotiCe sent
, , . : ,
: , ' : � . `
. � � , �
� � � . . • . IIy . _ � . . \. . � . . . ' . �
. .� + . . . . . . . . � . - � �� � .. .
'.. - . � .` ' � . . . .. . . . �. . .1 . � , .. ' �. . . .,
. � . . . . ' 4 ' , . ' � ' ` � � . . ' � . . �
i ' _
. ' octobsr 5, ,1982 ,
, , •
. . � � , . _;
, , � • , ; �
� � , � .
_ � Y. . : ' , � . .. � . � . , � . � - . .
Tom�Z,a#�n � -
Hezi�age' Prea,ervatfoa Stsff � ` ' �
- `�llt� Fldory City !l�nn�x ,
_ • , _ ,
�� bear S ir:
' , _
Thl� City, Coiur'ci],��tAdsY• a$read 'that the fler�tg� Pr�a#rvxtioin S�atf ,
ahoeila tal�a the n�caaurq at�p`s to: set a 4at,e a� public I��s�cing to
' - canlid�r t� appeal'of Loi� (�;eiwitz to a dacisiaa of th� Heritage � , ;:
Pr�a.eraatibn Co�tieaiom coacerning prope�tq a��`3�2� �,ic�hange Street. � � ' .
, -
, ; , ,
, . , . Very trulq yours. . �
t
;� .• , ' � Albar� B. Olsoa ,
, , :
City Cl�rk ! �
• , . l
�
, , ' -
; ' - . , �
. � , ,
, . � ; � � � � � � ,:�� ..
• _ ' , � '
\ , � , ` i. .
, � . , � 1
, _ , � _ _
� -
, , • � . �, �
• . ,
: , ; _ � . , .
� ,
, 1 , _ .
� - � ' , , �
.,,i . ,. . ' .. , . . , . . . . . . . . . . .... . . . , - . , .. . . . .
. �� . . ' . . . . . . . .
.. . -� . . . � , : 1 i. . � � . I , . . ' . '
. _ � : r , . � ,. � . .. . � � . . . .. . . . � � � . . �
. . .. . � . . ' . . . ' , . .. .. ' .. . '. �'..� .. . .
.. . � � �� . . . � . , � . . . . . .. - . �_ . . . . . . � _. � ' . .� . . .�l . . .. .�. . . �. .. � .. .. _ .
CITY OF SAINT PAUL G � ���
= � ' ; OFFIC� OF Z`HE CITY COIINCIY. �'�952'7
_ ....,... .
.�,,,...�,••
• '��'��+`
D o t e : September 24,. 1982
COMNi (7'T � E REPORT
TO = _ Sa�nt Paui City Councit
" F R O M = C o m m ir t e e O h C ITY DEVELOPMENT AND TRANSPORTATION
CF�A i R Leonard W. Levine
The Committee referred back to the City Gouncil
an appeal of Lois Geiwitz to a decision of the .
- Heritage Preservation Commission concerning
property at 302 Exchange Street.
Date for public hearing to be set.
. ;
CITY HALL SEVENTH FLOOR +
SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA 55102
. ..�,.�, �
a
�
i
_ ,
s- . � _ _ � , - , � '��
-�
. � .
. �
- � : y
. , �
, _ .
Septembar 7, l983
. ,
,
' � " , ,
f � • ,
Ccruncflmsn Lboos�d L�vitss, Chaix'man ,
� Gf�� DAn►elv�e�t � Tfc�asportatian Ctrmm�. ,
� ' Room 71$, C3ty Ha].I '
St. Pau�:r Hiim�esola ;
, ,
�. Dear Cona�ail�an L�vias: � .
The City Couaeil �e�errr�d to tht City Da�rslopment and Tr�ago�tdtioa ,,
" � Ca�ittee i`or ro�c►eic�rat3cnt sad re�r�ne�dativa ao appea2 0! Lois-Gaf ts
�o a deeietoa .o� th� Hsritaga Preaervatioa Co�m�i�oi.oa ee�acaacning
property a� 302 $s�hange Straet.
• V�ry tre�lg yumcs, -
. � � _
, � A1b�rt_B. Olsan ;
i . - City G3.sY� � _ . _
A$t}ttth. � . _
�
ASOadq�
,
aae Aeritags Pac�arvstion Sta!`f. .
�
- �
_ , . �
,r
_ , _ �
. , �,
. ,�
_ �, _
, � � _
„
. � � `.
, �
, ;.
, ' - : ' ��:
. . , . .�
� • . - , , � ��� !
y
• ,. �
. ;
�
FILEp �
�uc Zp ��27�� ��;
crrr cc�RK,� �
�T PdUC, MIH����
r
r
August 20, 1982 j
:
SUBJECT: Appeal Heritage Preservation Commission �
Ruling for File Number 273. 302 Exchange Street. '
�
G
We are appealing the HPC ruling of August 12, 1982 �
because our problems with the variances granted for
�xchange Street weren't even considered in the ;:
decision. '
We are oppoeed to variances granted f or the setback
of the carriage house and the placement of the visitor j
pQrking next to the carriage house. �
1. OUA PROPERTY WILL BE DEVALUED. Driscoll �
Place is our street. We have eight residences �
on it. It is our. only street access. Instead �
of remaining residence oriented it will be- �
come ga.ra.ge oriented with the eight garages
and four parking sp�ces for the 302 S. F
Eachange Street pro�ect.
2. OUA VIEW IS GREATLY DIMINISHED. Fzpecially
for 29? Ryan Anenue. This house will have �
three perked cars in front of the front '
window. �
�
3. DESTROYS OUH QUIET. All the automobile �,
parking is very close to our houses. - I'
:€
4
r
S12�C@T 1 �
�
�
.
is M. Geixitz k
297 Ryan Avenue .;
3t. Paul, MN 55102
29?-864�
' �E
;�
�
;,
;.
;.
� i
�
!
4
�
6
N , . 4 ' _ , ' �JV� f
. •
,' FlLED
�uc ZO 10 za ��; 's2 ,. F�c.a
��J,= �� r� ..-. -., :,,
C17Y Cl_CRK'S OFFiCE < < ;;,, ��
�T �',L�, t-;{h1�V. C17Y ;. -
� ��F���S ��
S� r'„y,� -`�'IC�
�. ��,i;�rr.
August 20� 1982
SUBJECT: Appeal Heritage Preservation Commission
Ruling f or File Number 2?3. 302 Exchange Street.
We are appealing the HFC ruling of August 12� 1982
because our problems with the variances granted f or
�xchange Street weren't even considered in the
decision.
We are opposed to variances granted f or the setback
of the carriage house and the placement of the visitor
parking next to the carriage house.
1. OUA PROPERTY WILL BE DEVALUED. Driscoll
Flace is our street. We have eight residences
on it. It is our only street access . Instead
of remainin.g residence oriented it will be-
come garage oriented with the eight garages
and four parking spaces for the 302 S.
Exchange Street pro�ect.
2. OUA VIEW IS GREATLY DI�INISHED. Expecially
for 297 Ryan Anenue. This house will have
three parked cars in front of the front
window.
3. DESTROYS OUR QUIET. All the automobile
parking is very close to our houses. �
Sinoer �l .:;'- �� -
! ; ,�' i� ,�(i,,1�'
� � / , -
� is Ai. Geiwitz
297 Ryan Avenue
St. Faul , T".N 55102
297-864�
WHITE - CITV CLERK ��u[�C(1 �/�� 9528
PINK - FINANCE
CANARV r DEGARTM TY OF SA I NT PA LT L
BLUE -- MAVOR File NO.
' Council Resolution
Presented By
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
BE IT RESOLVED, That the C�uncil of the City of Saint Paul hereby
certifies and approves the action of the City of Saint Paul Board of
Appeals and Review pertaining to the following listed property and as
shown by the Excerpted Minutes of said Board of Appeals and Review, dated
November 9, 1982, and marked EXHIBIT A, and attached hereto and made a
part hereof by reference:
DATE OF BOARD
MINUTES CASE NO. PROPERTY APPELLANT
11/9/82 71-82-H 797 E. Maryland Nan Jacobson
(two units)
BOARD ACTION: Granted variance of 5t. Paul Legislative Code, Section
34. 11, pertaining to basic facilities, to permit continued
use of bathroom which lacks handsink, on a�ndition that
remaining deficiencies listed in city' s letter of 10/20/82
be corrected.
Property Description: Oakville Park
Lot 14, Block 12
-------------------------------
11/9/82 74-82-H 256 Marshall Ave. Thomas H. & Margaret
(1,2 units) ` R. Best
BOARD ACTION: Granted variance of St. Paul Legislative Code, Section
34. 11, pertaining to basic facilities, to permit bathroom
facilities to be located outside walls of two apartments ,
as proposed in rehabilitation plan submitted by appellants,
on condition that security system shall be provided in
building.
COUNCILMEN
Yeas Nays Requested by Department of:
Fletcher
�ev�ne In Favor
Masanz
Nicosia
Scheibel _ __ Against BY
Tedesco
Wilson
Form Approved by C' y
Adopted by Council: Date
Certified Yassed by Council Secretary �� 'f�� G��'�'�
By
Approved by Mavor: Date _ Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By — — BY