00-33QRiG1�AL
Presented By
Referred To
t v`c�e_v�,, �- t� l�. � a a
RESOLUTION
CTTY OF SAINT PAUL, NIINNESOTA
Committee: Date
31
2 RESOLVED, that the Licensee, Paul Kamp d!b/a Kamp's (License ID No. 44113),
3 located at 1059 Western Avenue North in Saint Paul is hereby ordered to pay a fine of $500.00� -4 -�
4 for the violation of Sa1e ofAlcoholic Beverages to Underage Persons, aso.E
5 w.}�-��
6 Said fine shall be paid to the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protec on �` ��
7 within thirty (3�) days of the adoption of this resolufion by the Council and signature by the -�
S M2yoY. r ema t ni
9 �135c,a �r
10 This resolution and the acrion of the Council in this matter are based upon the facts F- w�-r ��&
11 contained in the December 10, 1999, Nofice of Violation letter to the licensee, the Police �� ���'���}ks
12 Report CN 99-204788, and such azguments as may have been presented to the Council at the
13 pubiic hearing. The facts were not contested by the licensee.
Requested by Department of:
BY:
C�
By:
By: k:�.[LC+d . � CSI�
Form Approved by City Attorpeq-�
�� �
By: (� /
Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By:
Council File # �O — Z3
GreenSheet# 1�4496
Adopted by Council: Date CSS.a„� \,�.,�.pOa
C �—�—
Adoption Certified by Counci � Secxetary
�,
GREEN SHEET
William Gunther
p0 -33
No 10449�
� u �.�,�.�.a. u �,.�—
� ❑ �.� ❑ ��
❑ wuraa�aQVr.�son. ❑ n+weu�aaw.�ccro
❑ raoieP�aar+� ❑
(CUP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE�
12, 2000 _ P.
TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES
Resolution concerning adverse action against Ma1C Off-Sale License held by Paul Kamp,
dba Kamp's, 1059 Western Avenue North.
lonr�orv ,4pprove (n) w �telett
PLANNING COMMISSION
CIB COMMITfEE
CNIL SERVICE CAMMISSION
Ha6 Ni6 P��Rn everraMed uMer a conheCt for Ihis tlepartment?
vE5 No
Has Mis 7�K�m ever been a dlY empbyee7 .
vES No
Daes Mie Oe�swYGrm poasess a sldll not nwma��YP�essetl by anY currerR city employee?
YES I�
Is thi6 pe1sonfifm a talpetetl VendoY7 � ,
VES NO
sheet anE attach to areen sheet
R�Y��S:i•7�as7
TRANSACTIONf
SOURCE
INFORMATION (IXPWln
COST/REVENUEBUD6ETED(GRCIEON� VEf
��iPlY 7'C�!'.1$3_l
NO
✓
OFFICE OF Tf� CITY ATTORNEY
Clay[on M Robinson, Jr., Ciry Atforney f�/� ! 2�
V�/ �l
Cl� �F `S`�INT PA� Civil Division
NormColeman,Mayor 40UCiryHa11 Telephone:651Z66-8i10
IS West Ke!logg B[vd Facsimile: 65l 298-56I9
Saint Paul, Minnesota S.i10?
December 22, 1999
;O ,r ✓`�r;iQ
NOTICE OF COUNCIL MEETING � :,-�- = _
Paul Kamp � `� � A
nr���;��
Kamp's
1 �59 Westem Avenue North
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55117
RE: Malt Off-Sale License held by Paui Kamp d/b/a Kamp's for the premises at 1059 Westem
Avenue North Saint Paul
License ID #: 44113
Dear Mr. Kamp:
Please take notice that a fieaxing concerning the above-named establishment has been scheduled
for 5:30 p.m., Wednesday, January 12, 200Q in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint
Paul City Hall and Ramsey Counry Courthouse.
Enclosed aze copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to
the City Council for their considerafion. This is an uncontested hearing, in that the facts
concerning the sale of alcohol to an under age person have not been denied. You will have an
opporiunity at the Council hearing to present oral and/or written remarks as to the penalty, if any,
to be imposed. The recommendation of the license office will be for a$500.00 fine.
If you have any questions, please ca11 me at 266-8710.
Very truly yours,
J/�� C��.�
Viiginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary
Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP
Christine Rozek, LTEP
Kathy Cole, Executive Director, District 6 Planning Council, 1061 Rice St., St. Paul, MN
55117
UNCONTESTED LICENSE MATTER o0-33
Licensee Name
Address:
Council Date
Paul Kamp d!b/a Kamp's
1059 Western Avenue West
January 12, 2000
Violation: Sale of Aicohof to an Underage Person
Minn. Stat. § 304A.503 (1994)
St. Paut Legislative Code § 409.08
Date of Violation: December 2, 1999
Place:
Licensed Premises
Presumptive Penalty:
$500.00 Fine
Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office
of License, Inspections and Environmenta{ Protection:
$500.00 fine
Attachments:
1. Proposed resofution
2. Letter from licensee admitting violation and asking for a
council hearing
3. Notice of Violation
4. License Information Report
5. Violation memo
6. Law Enforcement Buy Report Form
7. License information
O�
December 19, 1999
Virginia D Patmer
Assistant City Attorney
This letter is in reference to a letter of violation I received from your office dated
December 10, 1999 and charging my grocery store with selling alcohol to a minor.
Please find a copy enclosed.
I would like to pursue step two of the three options listed in your letter. I do admit
that my cashier soid alcohol to a minor, but there were extenuatiug circumstances
that led to the indiscrerion that I believe are valid and do involve our police
department,
Please contact me with any information as to a hearing before the City Council.
_, .. �_-�
Kamp's Food Market
1059 Western Ave. N
ST Paul ,MN 55117
OFFI� �F THE CI"IY ATTORNEY
Cloylon .... Robinson, Js., Ciry Atmmey
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Norm Caleman, MayOr
C!Y[I DN(S[OR
400 Ciry Hal!
I S Wesr Kellogg Blvd
Saint Pau1, bfinnesota Si102
pp -33
Telephoxe: 65! 266-8: /0
Facsimile: 651298-5619
December 10, 1999
NOTICE OR VIOLATION
Paul Kamp
Kamp's
1054 Western Avenue North
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55117
RE: Malt Off-Sale License held by Paul Kamp d/b/a Kamp's for the premises at 1059 �Vestem
Avenue North Saint Paul
License ID #: 44113
Dear Mr. Kamp:
The Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection has recommended
adverse action against the licenses held by you d/bia/ Kamp's far the premises at 1059 Western
Avenue North in Saint Paul. The basis for this recommendation is as follows:
On December 2,1999 the Saint Paul police conducted a follow-
up liquor compliance check at Kamp's, located at 1059
Wesfern Avenue North. Two individuals, one 18 years old and
the other 20 years old, entered Kamp's and purchased a 12-
pack of Miller Genuine Draft, went to the register and paid for
it. The clerk did not ask either party for identification. It is a
violation of Minn. Stat. §340A.503, subd.2 to sell or furnish
alcohol to a person under the age of 21, and Saint Paul
Legislative Code § 410.04(a)(1) prohibits a licensee or agent or
employee thereof from delivering intosicating or
nonintoxicating malt liquor to any person under the age of 21.
Since this is considered a first violation, the licensing office will recommend a�500.00 fine,
pursuant to St. Paul Legislative Code §404.26.
At this time you have three options on how to proceed:
Pa�e 2
Kamp's
December ld, 1999
00 -33
If you do not dispute the above facts and do not �vish to have a public hearin„ you will
need to pay the recotnmended fine for this violation. If this is your choice, you should
make payment directly to the Office of License Inspections and Environmental
Protection, Room 300 Lowry Professional Building, 350 Saint Peter Street, Saint Paul,
Minnesota 5> 102. The letter should be directed to Ms. Christine Rozek. Payment of the
fine will be considered to be a waiver of the hearing to ��hich you aze entitled.
Alternatively, if you do not dispute the above facts, but wish to have a public hearing
before the Saint Paul City Council, you will need to send me a letter with a statzment
admitting the violation and requesting a hearinQ by Monday, December 20, 1999. The
matter will then be scheduled before the City Council for a public hearing to determine
what penalty, if any, to impose. You will have an opportunity to appear before the
Council and make a statement on your own behalf as to the penaity to be imposed.
3. If you do dispute the above facts, a hearing will be scheduled before an Administrative
Law Judge. At that hearing both you and the Ciry wili be able to appear and present
witnesses, evidence, and cross-examine the other's witnesses. The St. Paul Cin� Council
will ultimately decide the case. Please let me know in writing no later than Monday,
December 20, 1999, how you wish to proceed.
If you have not contacted me bp Monday, December 20,1999, I will assume that }•ou are
not contesting the facts and will schedule this matter for the St. Paul City Council and have
it placed on the Consent Agenda during which no public discussion is allowed and the
recommended penalty will be imposed.
If you have any questions, feel free to contact me at 266-8710.
Sincerely,
� � v� � = J v � r �'.-,� ti
Virginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Robert Kessler, Director of LIEP
Christine Rozek, Deputy Director of LIEP
Kathy Cole, Executive Director, District 6 Planning Council, 1061 Rice St., St. Paul, Mi`T
55117
00 -33
STATE OF MII�SNESOTA
COUNTY OF RAMSEY
ss. AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL
JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says
that on December 13, 1999, she served the attached NOTICE OF
VIOLATIOI3 on the following named person by placing a true and
correct copy thereo£ in an envelope addressed as follows:
Paul Kamp
Kamp's
1059 Western Avenue No.
St. Paul, MN. 55117
(which is the last known address of
same, with postage prepaid, in the I
Minnesota.
Subscribed and sworn to before me
this 13"' day of Dec�er, 1999.
c� ' �i � PEtER P. PANGBORN
�-f ,� � � QTARYPUBIIC
Notary Public :' Mv��m Exa��=��-'
said person) and depositing the
�
l ,
+i
�
i ,
�
�I
�I
�°�
M
w
'� � O
� N O
a- d IO
d U N
� J I`
w
0. M
O
�
0
a
�
�
�
.�
�
�
C
d
N
C
N
�
J
�
�
m
�
�
�
U �
J Q
0
�I U
IF I�
�
ININ
� C,�
��,L
UIl9
IJi�
!_U
� �
rn �i
N Ej
r I�
Z;
I��M
Wi�
ICi�
UIV
I �O
�� ' 6
�� �
Z
W
�
Q
Z
i� �
N
;� �
i�
��
�a
!Qrn�
j �� <
� t!)
i�
I�
z�
m la
� �I Y
�f
Z I�
cIY
I
iy J
a �¢
�
�U
C
3
O
U
�
N �
. O
�
N
N
a
W
c
N
�
�
3
Z
U
O
I�
U
I��
��
I
I� I
I�I
m
Iz
{
I��
1
Q�
I�i
IU i
iVi�
c�
R
��i
U
�
N
�
�
3
Z
N
C �
� M
L �
IN �
N �
�C �
N
I3 �
m �o
�
o �
F N
�
0
M
z
L17
Q
Z
�
W
N
�
�
�
� _
U N @
Q � � N
Q U � � �
� O � a �
� �
N
c'o� � m�i �
� �� > � �� �
� �
� a O N� N
G�V y O] ��'k rn
i
�c\� � � �U �
�� �' U U U N V
m, ca a� °�_,a
Y
O (6 C...: � �N � � U
L'() W � (p N O � �
V�i ��IlC U
�a ° c � a`� E 3 � E:° c°�i
- a ��cw o a� m �
�- �a��' ZUoWa�
_ ` oQa � i � °o°-
� VY�N Cfl-�
N a� QQ �' � V
� � V yU Q N(`"6H3�
o.�>ia� �
��''� CN � U y N N
p°'- ��a�L°:u�
c�°�a�Ua a��wm�o
��UCOW �wa�_IQ
��7WWc'�W ��ml��
N G �Nc O�<p�j�CO
v0 c
eo-33
�
i
,
,i
�
i
li
�
�I
o�
Q!
w�
M �
Q C �O
� U N
LSi J ��
A
a ��
r
0
a
�
C
O
R
�
V
w
C
N
N
c
m
0
�
��
�I d
N
U �' V
.J Q
N�
Q
F-- N
N I�
N .�
C'O
U �'=
J �
m �
rn
m Q
N I�
r �
I���
N ;a—
C s—
m v
I U , ;tT
I� O
I�
�
z
W
Q
��
I y'F
�
a `W
��
'Q � c�-
O �!J
� �
im
iZ
�m a
� �
JY
z ��
�o I�
��
l a I,a
�I
3
O
Ui
i
U
`�
N
� �O
I
.. I
�
a
Wo
y o
� o
_ �
M
O
N
Q
�
7
z
T �
f
0
a
IN J
N I �
C I �
�j
�z I
��
m
fl-iK
��'W
o �
U
f� ��
U �
C �
��
iC Q
_ �
N
�
�
�
z
m
��
O M
s�
a �
N �
N �
C �
�N
m �
� �
F N
W
O
M
z
7
2
Z
�
H
�
�
�
O
�f C
U N R
� Y � �
Q � � � �
a �
� � �� N
.� �° o n L
���� � � `�� �
NLL� � O N� �
Na,` �- arn rn
��V Y C� ��# �
NN� U Z. mU N
3���U U V N V
m, ca d °�-�a '
s
O (6.�t;� �o �� V
��V cp C� NN p.. N
V� i N p_ � p� IL C U
mcc�E 3��Ea�
V � �W �
�'�m°'� ?V �o�
����� o ��� o �
N�Y�� �Q2'c�0
a ° mo� nQ�O o
� � �� � Q m �Da�'�
°�'m � � a_ c Q a
n-�y >+� N Q U� t 11 �
p �� O N L.._t NLr (n
o��c..>a a�,�ymm
�� U N N � 7 J fl-
rn��6rnrnrrnNrnC�1�rn
c�o��°rnm�'"r `m�ncornrn
N C ON`N� ���`c0
vOon�.-.-Ur��nr
6a-3�
1
f�
��,
,',
�
n
�
�
��
o;
�a
M
W'
O � ip
M � �O
y U ��
R � �M
a I ;;
0
�
�
Q
�
G
O
e�
�
O
C
d
N
C
m
U
J
�i
m�
�I
�
clm
UIU
J �Q
N
N�
���
0
N'
� U
U
I� O
�
rn
m �
ao �',
N E',
� �:
2
�,r
N V
��U ;[{
LJO
�
;� �
Z
W
7
Q
� Z
� �
N I W
N ~
� W
� � r
Q o .-
�
__ l�l�
�
m
Z ��
m la
�' �¢
_'Y
Ni
Z I�
a iY
J
aa
Ja
�I
c
O�
UI
N�
�
I '
N
m
l o
Q
W
N
G
I
�J
N
4
�
3
Z
U
a
' ci
��
y�
���
��
,�i
IZ l
i��
i
�al
i�;
O
U I
N
V
INI
3
��
�
m
Q
I�
3
Z
N
C �
� M
t�
d �
N �
� �
{���
J�
�
I
� �
�� N
W
O
M
I Z
�
I Q
�� Z
I� F
Y �
W
I >
i' �
�a o
�
�
Y � C
V N �p
d � � �
Q � � � �
�p'.J � a �
c_p � �, y
�C� i �
N (0� � � (,� N
�'_ rn
�ti� a o a��
��V Y m ��k rn
�c\ � � � �U �
� r ��� V � i V
N c " =�a N �p .Y
O(0 C..: � �N E N N
t UmC I6 N i O (6 L
[�J� � Q. �p)LL C U
(6 CC�N� �j�a�,a U
�'�a�� zciowa�
j V 3m� ` p��U�Q
av � a� u. o_��
v� y°` m c o-�c�po
m rn o_Q y O� c�
N� V�7, U ¢ N�-oe»rn
�(0 �� N C C �QN U
a LLa rn � � N LL
p 6) .� O(6 .0 ..� N L.-�� N
�°'mUa d���mm
��UCOC� 73JQ
61` 76�0)�-W �m0]I`-6�
(D CW(n,.�vrV ����Q�
N C ON�N� �����
vO Vi-r-r-�UM�tiv
a e - 33
'° < cain# r aui Pclice Deperiment
` ��: _:� _
:__ _�� O-�clG1�AL flFF�I'�SE I 1NCIDENT REP�� i
oa-33
Ca,-��sm�,VUr,.��� ,.,,. � �� �nm�rvc:�e.�sa _a.> i. _ -,,,.eo. =�_a..
�c-2�L' � 88 � l�UOF 'u"-.WS. VIGL� 1 iO�i i�%G�'1 �SS 2C:��
c,r.a:��e_or,."r,__-s. JL�UIE�'�Nr[A.i•�ISi:aD
? .r„ar� c;:e sa c_:�rr
—.,,; _..,.�.. -� �
_accnea-� rpor...-_ c=ce,.
.y.S./IC: i���J t CR�I � P.Q.J��IIC� j
Scconca^; �r,'an<_?.
___srcn oi:nc:cecr. 1 C�� �N��T==\ .=`�J V
'.'a.;^ec,.,,c2acmcus:r.ass� �(r..?hFS
.i_=L�.,9oTOG^L•;2.^.C2: i�'v��..��'.�� G'�..�)
rirres[ mac3 �
De:z � cme o; ar.�asr
rCLiCc P�;tSvNNEL 1NVCL�/��
Pnar, maca on �nevr ?vrsurt enoegeo�
nrrzs: maoe :.- :va;rao, o�,,re�ncus G.V
Neaoons usec c� ooiice�
i✓ezoo,os �sza : c su=cec, zr nm= o; errasr
Re��s,ance enccur:erea.
CH,�^,RG�j ;NCNE)
iVAiVlES
SUS?�CT �'__!S. uAWN MARLENE
i 132 WESTGYN AV N S7PAUL >!1N c� �' ;
?hysical Description ?hones
sex ,-��ALE =�e�gnr ra��coior Home �none 551--88-'8��
�=c� �NHITE lPe 'No�kpn,ane „�1-�8?-33�"0
Weicnt Hav P
H�sper„c
.imr.�
ocs 05i24l� 934 swR
Ac= CJ
?hysical Conoi.ron
Consc:��sness
�ruda�c„nol use
HavLength
Faciz� Hau
cmploymenz
Occucavan
�mpro/er
�tME �C�VE �E�C�i1PTCft5
G Scene
'_.' ,RE-;;1L
�=_scr,c: cn ��;GCcRY/SUPERPJAF.KE �
.Nethod & Pomt of EntN
=o�ceusea 'JOT =C��=�
�pm. G%entr/
dzchoo
GP�R�f .��1oNE1
=ifCLE INF:,RP4A+lON (NONEj
3UC NARRATIVE
�ps i�iied a iiauor comeli2nce chec'�
rr_._.°°
-=, ,-;
•'2{ <9
CnmClsm: ; Jc ,r.�a!
ea_20�' � 85
Sa+ni °aui °ciice De�arne��t
�_�_ :
O�1�I�AL O�'�ENS� 1 li�CIDLN i R�POR i oo -a�
�E.`c -.-__ :.;J : .ama/J c4"e��e ..a._ =_nc iime a "2_.,.,
L!QUOR L��'-,�>>/S. V�GL��, � iC��!
i 2!G%!" ccc �r, � �
NA.rc.�c,'=.'i VE
�i'(1 i�'<� i G.�`^..,. �. �'-c^S�cC. CO(1CUC:ct7 _.CUOf �C�uCliciiCH ��.`IEC:<<_ ci i.w: iScC i;CUCC
`e ... � c -, .,. _ . . ,
�cCil..iifiE."r.� 1�l :f15 ..�iV .^.� C'�..i �ci:l. � L'Sc� �..OT^ul�c^C: C�ioC:CdS il?c: 2fc U�1C8f :I"�c .-Cc: cCc :.�
aL'CC;'.GS: c!CO;�C�. `�V(1:C:i ,.. L�. I VE;'li(c� :Rc; iilE!f 4J�i:..�S aCE .,r�7��QR i cCC ��:,�iGl C. I fl$:' �iVBCc
;1Y1'c�JIE :O .^,�CCUC; ci �;: - CG;i O; :CB^ililCcilCll. I ilv`J `NBfc CIY°C:cC :�ici :ii: f �OL'iC ^Ci �fc cCCUi :Nc:f cCB
CT'�CE. �lE`: `;JC(2 � ;JifQ ��. ± COW� i�lOfilLCf :h:2:f CO^VB*SciC � _ ;; ^ � r;
. 1� i, l i ic: ',`J8! �� E.'l v Cc: ililc. i DUV
IT1Cilc,� :C (1'1c:Cc ir1E :_:,'C: �cScS.
hS 2CCUt LQ.�'.Q f7C1:�9. :ilc f�N2f S2!lt Iil LO �oIT,CS ci "C7.�^.� �/��ESiEfil nVc V. ^IS '�NcS 'c : 8-C,^.cC:<
17ECcUS2 LFE SICCC � ICI�� �CII .! lG:l I cSi COfT7CIlGC1C� C:�IECR. 1(lE C�ECXE�S ��NE�.: .("i and �ici<=d UC c i L
(�cC�< 01 �/�1IIE( L`�j8^Ulfic :.ifc: 1 fiEf `N2?lt iC :fiE 'E�ISi'cf. T(12 C.�.'1cC;<cC �{/"I �,�"C� i � [:Ui :Cic �E=,' Cfi :[lE
coun*.er and CcVEC SVI:`1 i�'iE ;Ll�f (T1Cf78�f. I f70 WCt71c� c�h0 f3CiSiEt ilE'JCf :i?GU1rc� 'cCCL'I che aae cf _he
checR�rs. Tne cner,<ar came out and tumed over the �e=r and �he cnanc�. J
I�NE;Ii iCl cf1C IC2!1tILtcC iilE ScN2f. .�., was cilis. D cWYI I�af18i18 0l��- �9�='. 1?�2 We=,�m ,iVE �.
50117 �;ivl� �8&^84'. `n,�tC T 488-6036.
iI�IS SiciA� tf1cT Si12 @ItiVcVS GR2C�{5 W{lBR �CIqS t(`� TO CUy 2�COfiCI. .Sfl@'�fG�fl�i ;CUcy v8^=U52 SilB W2S
Yl'cfBSSc� py ?11CI(iEr CJSiOr'i2f Sa'fGB( 8ft4 WcS SiI�� UCSc;.
c Jil2 `Nc5 cq`I158C :flci _:t� `,VCUIa D@ ic{CIGl4 cCi1C(1 Wlifl :�lE:f �IC:=:1S2 GIIC :ilci'NE WCL`�C 76 iCil,VciGl(1C�
t�'7B !'@pOfi ?O ifl2 J� i='ci:l �i�:Y r'�tfOR1B`f�S Cifi1C° �Of (JOSSID�B CfiIT,IRfl� C:ic!C�ES.
?i9250 �iSiitDUtO iD:
CI-- -om
vB.: Jl
CC Rc�r
:too 1u� �Jncr
3urc Thr!c ?,on
"�'ice ��rco SI(1
n�r !_ib
C.1C Fc:F
T�2.� Oti:er
?cc Tc..:::
-uto D�U
{v0-��f)C " — ___ _""____
�.�\iPS
I p; � �t'E� . _a�"E �
S�.?.aCL��iI7
`� �i -- - _ ' F ..
^� �`. . ,. . '
Layj� �„oT�sm�n� Buy Rapor Form
—" 3uver?D
�
• ' G::°.'.:{.—=t
ace � IiYo?�roiasz.>Y,e:nazea� ;:C-.�;'
�- =, V
5. 'Nh�� did you .ry io purciase? d
a (cr.�cxene: oiiss�e oniy) o. (u^ec:cen��
Y c-�^<ck c.=ns 11 :6uCweisar
2'��12-pacx cans 2! Coors
3' 6-;�acX botYles 31 ��Miiier
��� Cuzrz bottle d; Gthe�
7. Seilerrsz^�er's gender:
— —
� �412ie 2 ' � � Fema�e
3. 3atferr=_erv=r's 2s�imated aae:
i L��s than 2t
2' Z'-30
3' . 31 or older
00 -33
TOCcY`S ..f)'ai9:
1 ,. _ �
„ 1 ��� /'- }°
�. 3uyer _eaczr: _. i i
' � � _ ` +
nrli
_ �F�m2;a -' c?A
.,.',Vas a secarir� �e�cn s�cicr,_a �t'_he ccer?
-.:f ye�. _e.^.car oi cere� ac docr:
.. `(es - 3 = —
Y � ddale 2: =�maie
_ ,�o
,.. i yes. �,vere ycu: ,c �ecx ad fi�r acpry�
1,� a.emiitza wi[h no cues.ien
L .�.emlrt2O c'c! si2iiro ZCje
31 P��rcnasea aftzr 5.�:= c�te o� birth
�� .�.omirt°� ��e* stanr,a ID not on me
Si� i+CTiiiieC cL2� exnia�mno ID in c&r
o' Not sdm�rtec 6TOP uE3�
�
e
iF:VO.
— SiCiP ,
.-g
c Ic.;ack or,e
1: `Lite
��
_N
L' 'r(E:L'75f _q
�
t0. How many peooie were sanding in line
oenind you ac t time you were at the
casn raaister? ' I � �
12'Nhat was the noise ievel?
Nomzi — Rais2d —
ccnversat�on 1' � vo�ces 2_ ghouting 3_ --
,... )f no ourcnase artemniea, exolain beiow::c,-=cx cn=�
7? '^ J:os?^ out cr cus�r,ess
iZ. �IGS°7 SBd50l!ci bOClS
J� ..'CScC I{rt1RE�'.O11'S
.+ ''..:OSE� Ia�ppOf2:OV L'E9Bif5. ;C.R10CB! 3._.
�5� �:oseatoouo:ic �nva,ecarzy
']"o � ?^va:e cWG pu�:ic ^o[ �c,�niCao
J7' l;r.aD:e to IoG;te
cP�)GITOACJ:':2' . •158�1 :"1
�
�. HoLV crowded •Kas it? .
Seatir.g � ' No saarnaf — No ;eatma/ —
ava:iaole 1_ fesv s;andino2_ mzr� stanaina3
tt ?urchase 3rt2mo2 outcome: ;c,.=_cx a1( tr,;r appri�
.'� �?urcnasza wrth no cuesnons
2: Purchaseo after s«ung Gge
., Purc�as�a c��� =_czce dats o` �irtn
-. Purcnased aYer r,aana !D nc� on m�
Purcn�s_=o aft2r exc'?�� _^ �� c_.
„ Vo purc^ase
_3 � Ursase iexcarni
.S °U`iEf 1(1d09f�Lff2lSY C:ESSEO
. � J: C! 6?9'
.. �,0 f0[ he'Y'? ,�me U �:.,...�:2r�
12 �Jon t (or no :onaen =__�I z�ccno:
_ ?.eszrvauor.s : ecess�rv
Other (spea^q
i
License Group Comments Text
Licensee: pqUl. KAMP
DBA: KqMP'S
4icense #: 00441i3
4/26199 completetl required alcohot awareness training-DL
On 37�8799 Failed check; "unofficial" waming-training tlue 4/18/99-DL
7/29/98 Congratulations letter sent. PJW
7/�3198 Passed cigarette compliance check. PJW
52497
111491 Ph On Appn For New At2 Grocery-B, Off Sale Maft 32 8 Cigarette License App'D C.F. 91-2097
3(16l94 Restaurant Removed From License Per Gary Pechmann.
5/98 Butcher Add-On Lic Eliminated Per Gf #95-'1457
7/V97 Late Fee $'181.00 Paid.
4!6/99 passed cig compliance cfieck - 4!1?J99 lettec sent SS
12/06f1999
aQ -33
oa -3�
�
_ F _
�S � Licensee l Corrtact 1 License 1 Cardhalder,
� Property t' Licensee �' Llnofficial r All
t #: D59
t hlame: lyESTEP.N
t Type: .�
tion: <All> ►�
<All} ►�
� T—°,�,���,__�i -���l�..`°`��°`��'�a�""" �
VYUUK]._ S�18tN Tett¢] i,iYf�_. COji)+ r�i� a.lp Add License...
Licensee Na�ne DBR
3ERALD 44AMP IK.4MP'S
KAMP
License Tvae I Status
ery - A2
Off Sale
�_nd r.�;:;.,.
``' ` I
�=.:rn. e!
t:;�.,_ .- � .. clt
Help
�
6tt 990
6t1990
8M 986
M5911f
M9911(
�15911C
M9871[
� { {Grocery {D) �Active Ucensa Printed �04N1 M 991 �03f31 f2000i1 C
� itv1att Off Sale IActive LicensE Frirned �04l01/1991 �03t31lZOO 1 C
i287 �1919 jPAUL A F(AMP �!{AMPS S7RR MARKE1Alarm Permit (Rene�Acti�e 08M 111992 I09M 3�10�]G:1 [
_ �
�G�ouptNise... �ECLIPSA ... � ECLIPS Li... � C25.com-... i� License _.. r Pro erties... `�' "� � �'�`
_� � a ��{L•� ! L� a N�������:�.�
1. ��
d0 -�33
,�. • ��- � - t ❑ x
I Licensee �,UL kAMP
.� P$ I P� ���iiram I H � � S �� i
DBA AMP'S
License � Licensee } Lic.lypes
r Pro�erty �' Licensee r Unofficial
1 Insurance l Bond 1 Requiremerrts,
—� ProjECt Facilitator: ROZEF{, CHRISTINE J
Street #: �59
Street Name: STERN
Street Type: AVE Diredion: �
Unit Ind: � Urirt #: �
City: T PAUL
Adverse Aciion Cammer�ts
CammerQs:
State: v1N Zi�: 55117 �6hJ9 completed required alcahuf rwareness
raining-DL
�tard: � BroHrse n 3M 5�39 Failed check; "unofficial" ,12C2hJ9 Failed
Dist Council: �b iq.comp.ck conclucted by vicE.FtS.warninq-tr�ining due
, M SP39-DL
Licensee: AUL FtAMP Commer�ts:
D6A: AMP'S
s T a x Id: � Bu s P 651 } 488-663H
License Type � Class � Effective � Expiration
t41�tt Off S�4e �C � �4N1 M 891 � �3C31 f2���
�4r171 M 991 I �3f31 f2�0�
License # �44113
Save Changes to Histary
i287 11919 !PF,UL �. KAMP iKAtv1PS STAR MARKE1Alarm Fermit
�icen5e Fee I �
N $317.�0 —�
N $SOQ.00� �
r
Cancel � Hel�
; j08(11t199� Q9t13tZOGG'
�
r _ l'�� iG:1- , c
�GroupWise... �ECLiPSAp... (�ECLIPSLic... ��]CBS.com•... �jLicEnseRu... uPcopertie._. N,,D;;�����
JAN-12-00 02:29 AM KAMPS FOOD MRRKET 1651488bb76 P.61
.r �
�31
Fax to: Jim Reiter
From: Paui Kamp — Kamp's Food Market
(651) 488-6636 stoze
(651) 4$8-3376 fax
RE: Letter to Cowncil about hearing for alcohol sale to minor on
Dec. 2, 1999
Thanks Jim
Paul
fl
��-33
_ �
�Hn-12-00 02:30 qM KAMPS FOOD MRRKET 1651488�076 P_02
., J
���33
S� Paui Ci Council
MY name is Pau1 Kamp and I am the owner of Kaznp's Food
Market located at 1459 Western Ave. in St. Paul, MN. My family
has been in tYie grocery business here in St. Paul since the turn of
the century. We take great pride in the Iong history and integxity in
which we have done husiness for nearly 100 years.
The reason for this Ietter is on December 2, 1999 one of my
cashiers sold alcohol to a minor, a young lady who at the time was
20 years and 10 months old. Now, I understand, that anybody
under 21 is illegal, I believe some circumstances led to my
cashier's indiscretion.
We were assisting the St, Paul Police Department at that time by
notifying our customers about a level 3 rapist, Greg Welsh, who
had moved into our neighborhood. In fact we were told that he had
openly refused any treatrnent while in prison and had openly stated
that he woutd commit these crimes again upon his release. We
were giving handouts to ow customers and we had the notice
posted in our store. The contact person, Sergeant Chris Nelson, of
the St. Paut Police Dept. has contacted Mr. Reiter in reference to
this matter as well. I also will tell you that Mr. Welsh is back in
prison, where he should be thanks to Sergeant Nelson's persistence
and hatd work.
Approximately %s hour prioz to the compliance check Mr. Welsh
came into our store and upan seeing his picture posted began
screaming at Dawn Ellis, our cashier. He stated that "he would get
her" along with many other derogatary comments. Ms. Ellis is a
60+-year-old woman who does not drive and is well known
throughout our neighborhood because she walks from hear house on
Westem ta Rice St. and also to the Como Lake area regulazly. She
was visibly shaken, but hecause I was attending a Winter Cazruval
event that night and another employee had called in sick we weze
JAN-12-00 02:�6 AM KAMPS FOOD MRRKET 16514880376 P.O�
y
bb- 33
short staffed. She was not able to either take a break or just go
home for the evening to rel�. I say adamantly that Ms. Ellis is the
best cashier that I've seen in my years in. the grocery business and
even a better person. She takes great pride in her work and has a
reputatian as "The lady that "cazds" (or checks the ID) of
everyone".
To be honest, we sell very little beer at our store and have
considered eliminating it totally. If the council sees fit to either
reduce or suspend the $500 suggested fine I would not object to
eliminating it from my store if you deemed necessary. 'We have
had a tough couple af months including a break-in, in which
cartons of cigarettes were stolen and an armed robbery as well. I
planned on presenting this myself today, but the passing of my
mothez tlus week made it too tough time- wise.
I appreciate the consideration and wish you all well.
Sincerely,
Paul Kamp
`�� �
r �
Council File # OQ — Q3
o���iNa�
�
Presented By
Refened To
RESOLUTION
CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
Committee:
1
2
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
�
RESOLVED, that the Licensee, Paul Kamp d/b/a
located at 1059 Western Avenue North in Saint Pau] is her�
for the violation of Sale of Alcoholic Beverages to Undera;
Said fine shall be paid to the Office of I
within thirty (30) days of the adoption of this
Mayor.
Green Sheet # 104496
31
's (I,icense ID No. 44113),
ordered to pay a fine of $500.00�
Persons.
�ections and Environmental Protection
�uy the Council and signature by the
This resolution and the action of the ouncil in this matter are based upon the facts
contained in tl�e December 10, 1999, Notic of Violation ietter to the licensee, the Police
Report CN 99-204788, and such argume s as may have been presented to the Council at the
public hearing. The facts were not cont ted by the licensee.
i
� ``D �Qy f2�= Lil��u.�.c
� �S � G.0 eP S�u�c� �
��►$�� �-��� u �,,,�
� �� ���,
Requested by Department o£:
i �.
sy: k..1.t�.l.a; � . ,r�� �
Adopted by Council: Date
Adoption Certified by Council Secretary
By:
proved by Mayor: Date
Form Approved by City Attorp�
$Y � �i�a -.�c.cf.� �� � C� y ,�rc
Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
Hy:
GREEN SHEET
William Gunther
12, 2000 _ P.
rn�e wie
aourrw
onom
TOTAL # OF SIt3NATURE PAGES
04 -33
No 10!t4 �'b
� ev,u�ae�.aemae U arcca�r+c `
❑ aer�rrowiar ❑ rnewnc _
❑ �tanmeoaw. ❑ wuicM��nmuKra
❑M'IORI�Y�ifNlf) ❑
(CUP ALL LOCATlONS FOR SlGNATURE)
Resolution concerning adverse action against Malt Off-Sale License held by Paul Ramp,
dba Ramp's, 1059 Western Avenue North.
<
PLANNING CAMMISSION
CI8 COMMlTiEE
CML SERVICE CAMMISSION
AYOUM OFTRAN.SACTION
SOURCE
Hsttis pdsaJfirm ererwkN utlers wrmactbUssdepvm�eN?
YES No
Hr tlis v�� ewrbem a alYa�4bl^��
YES HO
Ooea Mie P�m P� a alal not mma0ypo�eE M anY �a�A cily empoYeeT
YES NQ
h th's P�+wNf+m e WpeteC venda�
� � �
COlTAtEVENYEBU00ETED(GRCLECMk7 YEE
ACTIVITY NtMBER
�,.]''
JAN-12-60 02:29 HM KAMPS FOOD MpRKET 1651488ee76 P.01
'$�' 3!
�� ��3
F� to: Jim Reiter
From: Paul Kamp — Kamg's Food Mazket
(651) 488-6536 store
(651) 4$8-3376 fa�
RE: Letter to Council about hearing for alcohol sale to minor on
Dec. 2, 1999
Thanks Jim
Paul
f �
wnn-12-00 02:00 aM KpMPS FOOD MARKET 16514S8o376 P.02
�
�
St. P�ul Ci Council
My name is Pau1 Kam}� and I am the owner of Kamp's Food
Market located at 1059 Westem Ave. in St. Paul, MN. My family
has been in the grocery business here in St. Paul since the turn of
the century. We talce great pride in the long history ar�d integrity in
which we have done business for nearly 100 yeazs.
The reason foz this Ietter is on December 2, 1999 one af my
cashiers sold alcohol to a minor, a young lady who at the time was
20 years and 10 months old. Now, I understand, that anybody
twder 21 is illegal, I believe some circumstances led to my
cashier's indiscretion.
We were assisting the St. Paul Police Department at that time by
notifying our customers about a level 3 rapist, Greg Welsh, who
had moved into our neighborhood. In fact we were told that he had
openly refused any treatment while in prison and had openly stated
that he woutd commit these crimes again upon his release. We
were giving handonts to ow customers and we had the notice
posted in our store. The contact person, Sergeant Chris Nelson, af
the St. Paul Police Dept. has contacted Mr. Reiter in reference to
this matter as well. I also will tell you that Mr. Welsh is back in
prison, where he should be thanks to Sergeant Nelson's persistence
and hard work.
Approximately %z hour prior to the compliance check Mr. Welsh
came into our store and upon seeing his picture posted began
screaming at Dawn Ellis, our cashier. He stated that "he would get
her" along with many other derogatory comnnents. Ms. Ellis is a
60+-year-old woman who does not drive and is well known
throughout owr neighborhood because she walks from her house on
Western to Rice St, and alsa to the Como Lake area regularly. She
was visibly shaken, but because I was attending a Winter Carnival
event that night and another emplayee had cal.led in sick we were
JAN-12-90 92:a0 AM KAMPS FOOD MRRKET 16514883e76 P.Oe
�0-33
short staffed. She was not able to either take a break ar just go
home for the evening to relax.l say adamautly that Ms. Ellis is the
best cashier that I've seen in my years in the g�'ocezY business and
even a better person. She takes great pride in her wozk and has a
reputation as "The lady that "cards" (or checks the ID} of
everyone".
To be honest, we sell very little beer at aur store and have
considered eliminating it totally. If the council sees fit to either
reduce or suspend the $500 suggested fine I would not object to
eliminating it from my store if you deeraed necessary. We have
had a tough couple af months including a bre�k-in., in which
oartons of cigarettes were stolen and an armed robbery as well. I
planned on presenting this myself today, but the passing of my
mather this week made it too tough time- wise.
I appreciate the consideration and wish you all well.
Sincerely,
Paul Kamp
�..�6� ..�---
I
QRiG1�AL
Presented By
Referred To
t v`c�e_v�,, �- t� l�. � a a
RESOLUTION
CTTY OF SAINT PAUL, NIINNESOTA
Committee: Date
31
2 RESOLVED, that the Licensee, Paul Kamp d!b/a Kamp's (License ID No. 44113),
3 located at 1059 Western Avenue North in Saint Paul is hereby ordered to pay a fine of $500.00� -4 -�
4 for the violation of Sa1e ofAlcoholic Beverages to Underage Persons, aso.E
5 w.}�-��
6 Said fine shall be paid to the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protec on �` ��
7 within thirty (3�) days of the adoption of this resolufion by the Council and signature by the -�
S M2yoY. r ema t ni
9 �135c,a �r
10 This resolution and the acrion of the Council in this matter are based upon the facts F- w�-r ��&
11 contained in the December 10, 1999, Nofice of Violation letter to the licensee, the Police �� ���'���}ks
12 Report CN 99-204788, and such azguments as may have been presented to the Council at the
13 pubiic hearing. The facts were not contested by the licensee.
Requested by Department of:
BY:
C�
By:
By: k:�.[LC+d . � CSI�
Form Approved by City Attorpeq-�
�� �
By: (� /
Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By:
Council File # �O — Z3
GreenSheet# 1�4496
Adopted by Council: Date CSS.a„� \,�.,�.pOa
C �—�—
Adoption Certified by Counci � Secxetary
�,
GREEN SHEET
William Gunther
p0 -33
No 10449�
� u �.�,�.�.a. u �,.�—
� ❑ �.� ❑ ��
❑ wuraa�aQVr.�son. ❑ n+weu�aaw.�ccro
❑ raoieP�aar+� ❑
(CUP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE�
12, 2000 _ P.
TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES
Resolution concerning adverse action against Ma1C Off-Sale License held by Paul Kamp,
dba Kamp's, 1059 Western Avenue North.
lonr�orv ,4pprove (n) w �telett
PLANNING COMMISSION
CIB COMMITfEE
CNIL SERVICE CAMMISSION
Ha6 Ni6 P��Rn everraMed uMer a conheCt for Ihis tlepartment?
vE5 No
Has Mis 7�K�m ever been a dlY empbyee7 .
vES No
Daes Mie Oe�swYGrm poasess a sldll not nwma��YP�essetl by anY currerR city employee?
YES I�
Is thi6 pe1sonfifm a talpetetl VendoY7 � ,
VES NO
sheet anE attach to areen sheet
R�Y��S:i•7�as7
TRANSACTIONf
SOURCE
INFORMATION (IXPWln
COST/REVENUEBUD6ETED(GRCIEON� VEf
��iPlY 7'C�!'.1$3_l
NO
✓
OFFICE OF Tf� CITY ATTORNEY
Clay[on M Robinson, Jr., Ciry Atforney f�/� ! 2�
V�/ �l
Cl� �F `S`�INT PA� Civil Division
NormColeman,Mayor 40UCiryHa11 Telephone:651Z66-8i10
IS West Ke!logg B[vd Facsimile: 65l 298-56I9
Saint Paul, Minnesota S.i10?
December 22, 1999
;O ,r ✓`�r;iQ
NOTICE OF COUNCIL MEETING � :,-�- = _
Paul Kamp � `� � A
nr���;��
Kamp's
1 �59 Westem Avenue North
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55117
RE: Malt Off-Sale License held by Paui Kamp d/b/a Kamp's for the premises at 1059 Westem
Avenue North Saint Paul
License ID #: 44113
Dear Mr. Kamp:
Please take notice that a fieaxing concerning the above-named establishment has been scheduled
for 5:30 p.m., Wednesday, January 12, 200Q in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint
Paul City Hall and Ramsey Counry Courthouse.
Enclosed aze copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to
the City Council for their considerafion. This is an uncontested hearing, in that the facts
concerning the sale of alcohol to an under age person have not been denied. You will have an
opporiunity at the Council hearing to present oral and/or written remarks as to the penalty, if any,
to be imposed. The recommendation of the license office will be for a$500.00 fine.
If you have any questions, please ca11 me at 266-8710.
Very truly yours,
J/�� C��.�
Viiginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary
Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP
Christine Rozek, LTEP
Kathy Cole, Executive Director, District 6 Planning Council, 1061 Rice St., St. Paul, MN
55117
UNCONTESTED LICENSE MATTER o0-33
Licensee Name
Address:
Council Date
Paul Kamp d!b/a Kamp's
1059 Western Avenue West
January 12, 2000
Violation: Sale of Aicohof to an Underage Person
Minn. Stat. § 304A.503 (1994)
St. Paut Legislative Code § 409.08
Date of Violation: December 2, 1999
Place:
Licensed Premises
Presumptive Penalty:
$500.00 Fine
Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office
of License, Inspections and Environmenta{ Protection:
$500.00 fine
Attachments:
1. Proposed resofution
2. Letter from licensee admitting violation and asking for a
council hearing
3. Notice of Violation
4. License Information Report
5. Violation memo
6. Law Enforcement Buy Report Form
7. License information
O�
December 19, 1999
Virginia D Patmer
Assistant City Attorney
This letter is in reference to a letter of violation I received from your office dated
December 10, 1999 and charging my grocery store with selling alcohol to a minor.
Please find a copy enclosed.
I would like to pursue step two of the three options listed in your letter. I do admit
that my cashier soid alcohol to a minor, but there were extenuatiug circumstances
that led to the indiscrerion that I believe are valid and do involve our police
department,
Please contact me with any information as to a hearing before the City Council.
_, .. �_-�
Kamp's Food Market
1059 Western Ave. N
ST Paul ,MN 55117
OFFI� �F THE CI"IY ATTORNEY
Cloylon .... Robinson, Js., Ciry Atmmey
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Norm Caleman, MayOr
C!Y[I DN(S[OR
400 Ciry Hal!
I S Wesr Kellogg Blvd
Saint Pau1, bfinnesota Si102
pp -33
Telephoxe: 65! 266-8: /0
Facsimile: 651298-5619
December 10, 1999
NOTICE OR VIOLATION
Paul Kamp
Kamp's
1054 Western Avenue North
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55117
RE: Malt Off-Sale License held by Paul Kamp d/b/a Kamp's for the premises at 1059 �Vestem
Avenue North Saint Paul
License ID #: 44113
Dear Mr. Kamp:
The Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection has recommended
adverse action against the licenses held by you d/bia/ Kamp's far the premises at 1059 Western
Avenue North in Saint Paul. The basis for this recommendation is as follows:
On December 2,1999 the Saint Paul police conducted a follow-
up liquor compliance check at Kamp's, located at 1059
Wesfern Avenue North. Two individuals, one 18 years old and
the other 20 years old, entered Kamp's and purchased a 12-
pack of Miller Genuine Draft, went to the register and paid for
it. The clerk did not ask either party for identification. It is a
violation of Minn. Stat. §340A.503, subd.2 to sell or furnish
alcohol to a person under the age of 21, and Saint Paul
Legislative Code § 410.04(a)(1) prohibits a licensee or agent or
employee thereof from delivering intosicating or
nonintoxicating malt liquor to any person under the age of 21.
Since this is considered a first violation, the licensing office will recommend a�500.00 fine,
pursuant to St. Paul Legislative Code §404.26.
At this time you have three options on how to proceed:
Pa�e 2
Kamp's
December ld, 1999
00 -33
If you do not dispute the above facts and do not �vish to have a public hearin„ you will
need to pay the recotnmended fine for this violation. If this is your choice, you should
make payment directly to the Office of License Inspections and Environmental
Protection, Room 300 Lowry Professional Building, 350 Saint Peter Street, Saint Paul,
Minnesota 5> 102. The letter should be directed to Ms. Christine Rozek. Payment of the
fine will be considered to be a waiver of the hearing to ��hich you aze entitled.
Alternatively, if you do not dispute the above facts, but wish to have a public hearing
before the Saint Paul City Council, you will need to send me a letter with a statzment
admitting the violation and requesting a hearinQ by Monday, December 20, 1999. The
matter will then be scheduled before the City Council for a public hearing to determine
what penalty, if any, to impose. You will have an opportunity to appear before the
Council and make a statement on your own behalf as to the penaity to be imposed.
3. If you do dispute the above facts, a hearing will be scheduled before an Administrative
Law Judge. At that hearing both you and the Ciry wili be able to appear and present
witnesses, evidence, and cross-examine the other's witnesses. The St. Paul Cin� Council
will ultimately decide the case. Please let me know in writing no later than Monday,
December 20, 1999, how you wish to proceed.
If you have not contacted me bp Monday, December 20,1999, I will assume that }•ou are
not contesting the facts and will schedule this matter for the St. Paul City Council and have
it placed on the Consent Agenda during which no public discussion is allowed and the
recommended penalty will be imposed.
If you have any questions, feel free to contact me at 266-8710.
Sincerely,
� � v� � = J v � r �'.-,� ti
Virginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Robert Kessler, Director of LIEP
Christine Rozek, Deputy Director of LIEP
Kathy Cole, Executive Director, District 6 Planning Council, 1061 Rice St., St. Paul, Mi`T
55117
00 -33
STATE OF MII�SNESOTA
COUNTY OF RAMSEY
ss. AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL
JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says
that on December 13, 1999, she served the attached NOTICE OF
VIOLATIOI3 on the following named person by placing a true and
correct copy thereo£ in an envelope addressed as follows:
Paul Kamp
Kamp's
1059 Western Avenue No.
St. Paul, MN. 55117
(which is the last known address of
same, with postage prepaid, in the I
Minnesota.
Subscribed and sworn to before me
this 13"' day of Dec�er, 1999.
c� ' �i � PEtER P. PANGBORN
�-f ,� � � QTARYPUBIIC
Notary Public :' Mv��m Exa��=��-'
said person) and depositing the
�
l ,
+i
�
i ,
�
�I
�I
�°�
M
w
'� � O
� N O
a- d IO
d U N
� J I`
w
0. M
O
�
0
a
�
�
�
.�
�
�
C
d
N
C
N
�
J
�
�
m
�
�
�
U �
J Q
0
�I U
IF I�
�
ININ
� C,�
��,L
UIl9
IJi�
!_U
� �
rn �i
N Ej
r I�
Z;
I��M
Wi�
ICi�
UIV
I �O
�� ' 6
�� �
Z
W
�
Q
Z
i� �
N
;� �
i�
��
�a
!Qrn�
j �� <
� t!)
i�
I�
z�
m la
� �I Y
�f
Z I�
cIY
I
iy J
a �¢
�
�U
C
3
O
U
�
N �
. O
�
N
N
a
W
c
N
�
�
3
Z
U
O
I�
U
I��
��
I
I� I
I�I
m
Iz
{
I��
1
Q�
I�i
IU i
iVi�
c�
R
��i
U
�
N
�
�
3
Z
N
C �
� M
L �
IN �
N �
�C �
N
I3 �
m �o
�
o �
F N
�
0
M
z
L17
Q
Z
�
W
N
�
�
�
� _
U N @
Q � � N
Q U � � �
� O � a �
� �
N
c'o� � m�i �
� �� > � �� �
� �
� a O N� N
G�V y O] ��'k rn
i
�c\� � � �U �
�� �' U U U N V
m, ca a� °�_,a
Y
O (6 C...: � �N � � U
L'() W � (p N O � �
V�i ��IlC U
�a ° c � a`� E 3 � E:° c°�i
- a ��cw o a� m �
�- �a��' ZUoWa�
_ ` oQa � i � °o°-
� VY�N Cfl-�
N a� QQ �' � V
� � V yU Q N(`"6H3�
o.�>ia� �
��''� CN � U y N N
p°'- ��a�L°:u�
c�°�a�Ua a��wm�o
��UCOW �wa�_IQ
��7WWc'�W ��ml��
N G �Nc O�<p�j�CO
v0 c
eo-33
�
i
,
,i
�
i
li
�
�I
o�
Q!
w�
M �
Q C �O
� U N
LSi J ��
A
a ��
r
0
a
�
C
O
R
�
V
w
C
N
N
c
m
0
�
��
�I d
N
U �' V
.J Q
N�
Q
F-- N
N I�
N .�
C'O
U �'=
J �
m �
rn
m Q
N I�
r �
I���
N ;a—
C s—
m v
I U , ;tT
I� O
I�
�
z
W
Q
��
I y'F
�
a `W
��
'Q � c�-
O �!J
� �
im
iZ
�m a
� �
JY
z ��
�o I�
��
l a I,a
�I
3
O
Ui
i
U
`�
N
� �O
I
.. I
�
a
Wo
y o
� o
_ �
M
O
N
Q
�
7
z
T �
f
0
a
IN J
N I �
C I �
�j
�z I
��
m
fl-iK
��'W
o �
U
f� ��
U �
C �
��
iC Q
_ �
N
�
�
�
z
m
��
O M
s�
a �
N �
N �
C �
�N
m �
� �
F N
W
O
M
z
7
2
Z
�
H
�
�
�
O
�f C
U N R
� Y � �
Q � � � �
a �
� � �� N
.� �° o n L
���� � � `�� �
NLL� � O N� �
Na,` �- arn rn
��V Y C� ��# �
NN� U Z. mU N
3���U U V N V
m, ca d °�-�a '
s
O (6.�t;� �o �� V
��V cp C� NN p.. N
V� i N p_ � p� IL C U
mcc�E 3��Ea�
V � �W �
�'�m°'� ?V �o�
����� o ��� o �
N�Y�� �Q2'c�0
a ° mo� nQ�O o
� � �� � Q m �Da�'�
°�'m � � a_ c Q a
n-�y >+� N Q U� t 11 �
p �� O N L.._t NLr (n
o��c..>a a�,�ymm
�� U N N � 7 J fl-
rn��6rnrnrrnNrnC�1�rn
c�o��°rnm�'"r `m�ncornrn
N C ON`N� ���`c0
vOon�.-.-Ur��nr
6a-3�
1
f�
��,
,',
�
n
�
�
��
o;
�a
M
W'
O � ip
M � �O
y U ��
R � �M
a I ;;
0
�
�
Q
�
G
O
e�
�
O
C
d
N
C
m
U
J
�i
m�
�I
�
clm
UIU
J �Q
N
N�
���
0
N'
� U
U
I� O
�
rn
m �
ao �',
N E',
� �:
2
�,r
N V
��U ;[{
LJO
�
;� �
Z
W
7
Q
� Z
� �
N I W
N ~
� W
� � r
Q o .-
�
__ l�l�
�
m
Z ��
m la
�' �¢
_'Y
Ni
Z I�
a iY
J
aa
Ja
�I
c
O�
UI
N�
�
I '
N
m
l o
Q
W
N
G
I
�J
N
4
�
3
Z
U
a
' ci
��
y�
���
��
,�i
IZ l
i��
i
�al
i�;
O
U I
N
V
INI
3
��
�
m
Q
I�
3
Z
N
C �
� M
t�
d �
N �
� �
{���
J�
�
I
� �
�� N
W
O
M
I Z
�
I Q
�� Z
I� F
Y �
W
I >
i' �
�a o
�
�
Y � C
V N �p
d � � �
Q � � � �
�p'.J � a �
c_p � �, y
�C� i �
N (0� � � (,� N
�'_ rn
�ti� a o a��
��V Y m ��k rn
�c\ � � � �U �
� r ��� V � i V
N c " =�a N �p .Y
O(0 C..: � �N E N N
t UmC I6 N i O (6 L
[�J� � Q. �p)LL C U
(6 CC�N� �j�a�,a U
�'�a�� zciowa�
j V 3m� ` p��U�Q
av � a� u. o_��
v� y°` m c o-�c�po
m rn o_Q y O� c�
N� V�7, U ¢ N�-oe»rn
�(0 �� N C C �QN U
a LLa rn � � N LL
p 6) .� O(6 .0 ..� N L.-�� N
�°'mUa d���mm
��UCOC� 73JQ
61` 76�0)�-W �m0]I`-6�
(D CW(n,.�vrV ����Q�
N C ON�N� �����
vO Vi-r-r-�UM�tiv
a e - 33
'° < cain# r aui Pclice Deperiment
` ��: _:� _
:__ _�� O-�clG1�AL flFF�I'�SE I 1NCIDENT REP�� i
oa-33
Ca,-��sm�,VUr,.��� ,.,,. � �� �nm�rvc:�e.�sa _a.> i. _ -,,,.eo. =�_a..
�c-2�L' � 88 � l�UOF 'u"-.WS. VIGL� 1 iO�i i�%G�'1 �SS 2C:��
c,r.a:��e_or,."r,__-s. JL�UIE�'�Nr[A.i•�ISi:aD
? .r„ar� c;:e sa c_:�rr
—.,,; _..,.�.. -� �
_accnea-� rpor...-_ c=ce,.
.y.S./IC: i���J t CR�I � P.Q.J��IIC� j
Scconca^; �r,'an<_?.
___srcn oi:nc:cecr. 1 C�� �N��T==\ .=`�J V
'.'a.;^ec,.,,c2acmcus:r.ass� �(r..?hFS
.i_=L�.,9oTOG^L•;2.^.C2: i�'v��..��'.�� G'�..�)
rirres[ mac3 �
De:z � cme o; ar.�asr
rCLiCc P�;tSvNNEL 1NVCL�/��
Pnar, maca on �nevr ?vrsurt enoegeo�
nrrzs: maoe :.- :va;rao, o�,,re�ncus G.V
Neaoons usec c� ooiice�
i✓ezoo,os �sza : c su=cec, zr nm= o; errasr
Re��s,ance enccur:erea.
CH,�^,RG�j ;NCNE)
iVAiVlES
SUS?�CT �'__!S. uAWN MARLENE
i 132 WESTGYN AV N S7PAUL >!1N c� �' ;
?hysical Description ?hones
sex ,-��ALE =�e�gnr ra��coior Home �none 551--88-'8��
�=c� �NHITE lPe 'No�kpn,ane „�1-�8?-33�"0
Weicnt Hav P
H�sper„c
.imr.�
ocs 05i24l� 934 swR
Ac= CJ
?hysical Conoi.ron
Consc:��sness
�ruda�c„nol use
HavLength
Faciz� Hau
cmploymenz
Occucavan
�mpro/er
�tME �C�VE �E�C�i1PTCft5
G Scene
'_.' ,RE-;;1L
�=_scr,c: cn ��;GCcRY/SUPERPJAF.KE �
.Nethod & Pomt of EntN
=o�ceusea 'JOT =C��=�
�pm. G%entr/
dzchoo
GP�R�f .��1oNE1
=ifCLE INF:,RP4A+lON (NONEj
3UC NARRATIVE
�ps i�iied a iiauor comeli2nce chec'�
rr_._.°°
-=, ,-;
•'2{ <9
CnmClsm: ; Jc ,r.�a!
ea_20�' � 85
Sa+ni °aui °ciice De�arne��t
�_�_ :
O�1�I�AL O�'�ENS� 1 li�CIDLN i R�POR i oo -a�
�E.`c -.-__ :.;J : .ama/J c4"e��e ..a._ =_nc iime a "2_.,.,
L!QUOR L��'-,�>>/S. V�GL��, � iC��!
i 2!G%!" ccc �r, � �
NA.rc.�c,'=.'i VE
�i'(1 i�'<� i G.�`^..,. �. �'-c^S�cC. CO(1CUC:ct7 _.CUOf �C�uCliciiCH ��.`IEC:<<_ ci i.w: iScC i;CUCC
`e ... � c -, .,. _ . . ,
�cCil..iifiE."r.� 1�l :f15 ..�iV .^.� C'�..i �ci:l. � L'Sc� �..OT^ul�c^C: C�ioC:CdS il?c: 2fc U�1C8f :I"�c .-Cc: cCc :.�
aL'CC;'.GS: c!CO;�C�. `�V(1:C:i ,.. L�. I VE;'li(c� :Rc; iilE!f 4J�i:..�S aCE .,r�7��QR i cCC ��:,�iGl C. I fl$:' �iVBCc
;1Y1'c�JIE :O .^,�CCUC; ci �;: - CG;i O; :CB^ililCcilCll. I ilv`J `NBfc CIY°C:cC :�ici :ii: f �OL'iC ^Ci �fc cCCUi :Nc:f cCB
CT'�CE. �lE`: `;JC(2 � ;JifQ ��. ± COW� i�lOfilLCf :h:2:f CO^VB*SciC � _ ;; ^ � r;
. 1� i, l i ic: ',`J8! �� E.'l v Cc: ililc. i DUV
IT1Cilc,� :C (1'1c:Cc ir1E :_:,'C: �cScS.
hS 2CCUt LQ.�'.Q f7C1:�9. :ilc f�N2f S2!lt Iil LO �oIT,CS ci "C7.�^.� �/��ESiEfil nVc V. ^IS '�NcS 'c : 8-C,^.cC:<
17ECcUS2 LFE SICCC � ICI�� �CII .! lG:l I cSi COfT7CIlGC1C� C:�IECR. 1(lE C�ECXE�S ��NE�.: .("i and �ici<=d UC c i L
(�cC�< 01 �/�1IIE( L`�j8^Ulfic :.ifc: 1 fiEf `N2?lt iC :fiE 'E�ISi'cf. T(12 C.�.'1cC;<cC �{/"I �,�"C� i � [:Ui :Cic �E=,' Cfi :[lE
coun*.er and CcVEC SVI:`1 i�'iE ;Ll�f (T1Cf78�f. I f70 WCt71c� c�h0 f3CiSiEt ilE'JCf :i?GU1rc� 'cCCL'I che aae cf _he
checR�rs. Tne cner,<ar came out and tumed over the �e=r and �he cnanc�. J
I�NE;Ii iCl cf1C IC2!1tILtcC iilE ScN2f. .�., was cilis. D cWYI I�af18i18 0l��- �9�='. 1?�2 We=,�m ,iVE �.
50117 �;ivl� �8&^84'. `n,�tC T 488-6036.
iI�IS SiciA� tf1cT Si12 @ItiVcVS GR2C�{5 W{lBR �CIqS t(`� TO CUy 2�COfiCI. .Sfl@'�fG�fl�i ;CUcy v8^=U52 SilB W2S
Yl'cfBSSc� py ?11CI(iEr CJSiOr'i2f Sa'fGB( 8ft4 WcS SiI�� UCSc;.
c Jil2 `Nc5 cq`I158C :flci _:t� `,VCUIa D@ ic{CIGl4 cCi1C(1 Wlifl :�lE:f �IC:=:1S2 GIIC :ilci'NE WCL`�C 76 iCil,VciGl(1C�
t�'7B !'@pOfi ?O ifl2 J� i='ci:l �i�:Y r'�tfOR1B`f�S Cifi1C° �Of (JOSSID�B CfiIT,IRfl� C:ic!C�ES.
?i9250 �iSiitDUtO iD:
CI-- -om
vB.: Jl
CC Rc�r
:too 1u� �Jncr
3urc Thr!c ?,on
"�'ice ��rco SI(1
n�r !_ib
C.1C Fc:F
T�2.� Oti:er
?cc Tc..:::
-uto D�U
{v0-��f)C " — ___ _""____
�.�\iPS
I p; � �t'E� . _a�"E �
S�.?.aCL��iI7
`� �i -- - _ ' F ..
^� �`. . ,. . '
Layj� �„oT�sm�n� Buy Rapor Form
—" 3uver?D
�
• ' G::°.'.:{.—=t
ace � IiYo?�roiasz.>Y,e:nazea� ;:C-.�;'
�- =, V
5. 'Nh�� did you .ry io purciase? d
a (cr.�cxene: oiiss�e oniy) o. (u^ec:cen��
Y c-�^<ck c.=ns 11 :6uCweisar
2'��12-pacx cans 2! Coors
3' 6-;�acX botYles 31 ��Miiier
��� Cuzrz bottle d; Gthe�
7. Seilerrsz^�er's gender:
— —
� �412ie 2 ' � � Fema�e
3. 3atferr=_erv=r's 2s�imated aae:
i L��s than 2t
2' Z'-30
3' . 31 or older
00 -33
TOCcY`S ..f)'ai9:
1 ,. _ �
„ 1 ��� /'- }°
�. 3uyer _eaczr: _. i i
' � � _ ` +
nrli
_ �F�m2;a -' c?A
.,.',Vas a secarir� �e�cn s�cicr,_a �t'_he ccer?
-.:f ye�. _e.^.car oi cere� ac docr:
.. `(es - 3 = —
Y � ddale 2: =�maie
_ ,�o
,.. i yes. �,vere ycu: ,c �ecx ad fi�r acpry�
1,� a.emiitza wi[h no cues.ien
L .�.emlrt2O c'c! si2iiro ZCje
31 P��rcnasea aftzr 5.�:= c�te o� birth
�� .�.omirt°� ��e* stanr,a ID not on me
Si� i+CTiiiieC cL2� exnia�mno ID in c&r
o' Not sdm�rtec 6TOP uE3�
�
e
iF:VO.
— SiCiP ,
.-g
c Ic.;ack or,e
1: `Lite
��
_N
L' 'r(E:L'75f _q
�
t0. How many peooie were sanding in line
oenind you ac t time you were at the
casn raaister? ' I � �
12'Nhat was the noise ievel?
Nomzi — Rais2d —
ccnversat�on 1' � vo�ces 2_ ghouting 3_ --
,... )f no ourcnase artemniea, exolain beiow::c,-=cx cn=�
7? '^ J:os?^ out cr cus�r,ess
iZ. �IGS°7 SBd50l!ci bOClS
J� ..'CScC I{rt1RE�'.O11'S
.+ ''..:OSE� Ia�ppOf2:OV L'E9Bif5. ;C.R10CB! 3._.
�5� �:oseatoouo:ic �nva,ecarzy
']"o � ?^va:e cWG pu�:ic ^o[ �c,�niCao
J7' l;r.aD:e to IoG;te
cP�)GITOACJ:':2' . •158�1 :"1
�
�. HoLV crowded •Kas it? .
Seatir.g � ' No saarnaf — No ;eatma/ —
ava:iaole 1_ fesv s;andino2_ mzr� stanaina3
tt ?urchase 3rt2mo2 outcome: ;c,.=_cx a1( tr,;r appri�
.'� �?urcnasza wrth no cuesnons
2: Purchaseo after s«ung Gge
., Purc�as�a c��� =_czce dats o` �irtn
-. Purcnased aYer r,aana !D nc� on m�
Purcn�s_=o aft2r exc'?�� _^ �� c_.
„ Vo purc^ase
_3 � Ursase iexcarni
.S °U`iEf 1(1d09f�Lff2lSY C:ESSEO
. � J: C! 6?9'
.. �,0 f0[ he'Y'? ,�me U �:.,...�:2r�
12 �Jon t (or no :onaen =__�I z�ccno:
_ ?.eszrvauor.s : ecess�rv
Other (spea^q
i
License Group Comments Text
Licensee: pqUl. KAMP
DBA: KqMP'S
4icense #: 00441i3
4/26199 completetl required alcohot awareness training-DL
On 37�8799 Failed check; "unofficial" waming-training tlue 4/18/99-DL
7/29/98 Congratulations letter sent. PJW
7/�3198 Passed cigarette compliance check. PJW
52497
111491 Ph On Appn For New At2 Grocery-B, Off Sale Maft 32 8 Cigarette License App'D C.F. 91-2097
3(16l94 Restaurant Removed From License Per Gary Pechmann.
5/98 Butcher Add-On Lic Eliminated Per Gf #95-'1457
7/V97 Late Fee $'181.00 Paid.
4!6/99 passed cig compliance cfieck - 4!1?J99 lettec sent SS
12/06f1999
aQ -33
oa -3�
�
_ F _
�S � Licensee l Corrtact 1 License 1 Cardhalder,
� Property t' Licensee �' Llnofficial r All
t #: D59
t hlame: lyESTEP.N
t Type: .�
tion: <All> ►�
<All} ►�
� T—°,�,���,__�i -���l�..`°`��°`��'�a�""" �
VYUUK]._ S�18tN Tett¢] i,iYf�_. COji)+ r�i� a.lp Add License...
Licensee Na�ne DBR
3ERALD 44AMP IK.4MP'S
KAMP
License Tvae I Status
ery - A2
Off Sale
�_nd r.�;:;.,.
``' ` I
�=.:rn. e!
t:;�.,_ .- � .. clt
Help
�
6tt 990
6t1990
8M 986
M5911f
M9911(
�15911C
M9871[
� { {Grocery {D) �Active Ucensa Printed �04N1 M 991 �03f31 f2000i1 C
� itv1att Off Sale IActive LicensE Frirned �04l01/1991 �03t31lZOO 1 C
i287 �1919 jPAUL A F(AMP �!{AMPS S7RR MARKE1Alarm Permit (Rene�Acti�e 08M 111992 I09M 3�10�]G:1 [
_ �
�G�ouptNise... �ECLIPSA ... � ECLIPS Li... � C25.com-... i� License _.. r Pro erties... `�' "� � �'�`
_� � a ��{L•� ! L� a N�������:�.�
1. ��
d0 -�33
,�. • ��- � - t ❑ x
I Licensee �,UL kAMP
.� P$ I P� ���iiram I H � � S �� i
DBA AMP'S
License � Licensee } Lic.lypes
r Pro�erty �' Licensee r Unofficial
1 Insurance l Bond 1 Requiremerrts,
—� ProjECt Facilitator: ROZEF{, CHRISTINE J
Street #: �59
Street Name: STERN
Street Type: AVE Diredion: �
Unit Ind: � Urirt #: �
City: T PAUL
Adverse Aciion Cammer�ts
CammerQs:
State: v1N Zi�: 55117 �6hJ9 completed required alcahuf rwareness
raining-DL
�tard: � BroHrse n 3M 5�39 Failed check; "unofficial" ,12C2hJ9 Failed
Dist Council: �b iq.comp.ck conclucted by vicE.FtS.warninq-tr�ining due
, M SP39-DL
Licensee: AUL FtAMP Commer�ts:
D6A: AMP'S
s T a x Id: � Bu s P 651 } 488-663H
License Type � Class � Effective � Expiration
t41�tt Off S�4e �C � �4N1 M 891 � �3C31 f2���
�4r171 M 991 I �3f31 f2�0�
License # �44113
Save Changes to Histary
i287 11919 !PF,UL �. KAMP iKAtv1PS STAR MARKE1Alarm Fermit
�icen5e Fee I �
N $317.�0 —�
N $SOQ.00� �
r
Cancel � Hel�
; j08(11t199� Q9t13tZOGG'
�
r _ l'�� iG:1- , c
�GroupWise... �ECLiPSAp... (�ECLIPSLic... ��]CBS.com•... �jLicEnseRu... uPcopertie._. N,,D;;�����
JAN-12-00 02:29 AM KAMPS FOOD MRRKET 1651488bb76 P.61
.r �
�31
Fax to: Jim Reiter
From: Paui Kamp — Kamp's Food Market
(651) 488-6636 stoze
(651) 4$8-3376 fax
RE: Letter to Cowncil about hearing for alcohol sale to minor on
Dec. 2, 1999
Thanks Jim
Paul
fl
��-33
_ �
�Hn-12-00 02:30 qM KAMPS FOOD MRRKET 1651488�076 P_02
., J
���33
S� Paui Ci Council
MY name is Pau1 Kamp and I am the owner of Kaznp's Food
Market located at 1459 Western Ave. in St. Paul, MN. My family
has been in tYie grocery business here in St. Paul since the turn of
the century. We take great pride in the Iong history and integxity in
which we have done husiness for nearly 100 years.
The reason for this Ietter is on December 2, 1999 one of my
cashiers sold alcohol to a minor, a young lady who at the time was
20 years and 10 months old. Now, I understand, that anybody
under 21 is illegal, I believe some circumstances led to my
cashier's indiscretion.
We were assisting the St, Paul Police Department at that time by
notifying our customers about a level 3 rapist, Greg Welsh, who
had moved into our neighborhood. In fact we were told that he had
openly refused any treatrnent while in prison and had openly stated
that he woutd commit these crimes again upon his release. We
were giving handouts to ow customers and we had the notice
posted in our store. The contact person, Sergeant Chris Nelson, of
the St. Paut Police Dept. has contacted Mr. Reiter in reference to
this matter as well. I also will tell you that Mr. Welsh is back in
prison, where he should be thanks to Sergeant Nelson's persistence
and hatd work.
Approximately %s hour prioz to the compliance check Mr. Welsh
came into our store and upan seeing his picture posted began
screaming at Dawn Ellis, our cashier. He stated that "he would get
her" along with many other derogatary comments. Ms. Ellis is a
60+-year-old woman who does not drive and is well known
throughout our neighborhood because she walks from hear house on
Westem ta Rice St. and also to the Como Lake area regulazly. She
was visibly shaken, but hecause I was attending a Winter Cazruval
event that night and another employee had called in sick we weze
JAN-12-00 02:�6 AM KAMPS FOOD MRRKET 16514880376 P.O�
y
bb- 33
short staffed. She was not able to either take a break or just go
home for the evening to rel�. I say adamantly that Ms. Ellis is the
best cashier that I've seen in my years in. the grocery business and
even a better person. She takes great pride in her work and has a
reputatian as "The lady that "cazds" (or checks the ID) of
everyone".
To be honest, we sell very little beer at our store and have
considered eliminating it totally. If the council sees fit to either
reduce or suspend the $500 suggested fine I would not object to
eliminating it from my store if you deemed necessary. 'We have
had a tough couple af months including a break-in, in which
cartons of cigarettes were stolen and an armed robbery as well. I
planned on presenting this myself today, but the passing of my
mothez tlus week made it too tough time- wise.
I appreciate the consideration and wish you all well.
Sincerely,
Paul Kamp
`�� �
r �
Council File # OQ — Q3
o���iNa�
�
Presented By
Refened To
RESOLUTION
CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
Committee:
1
2
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
�
RESOLVED, that the Licensee, Paul Kamp d/b/a
located at 1059 Western Avenue North in Saint Pau] is her�
for the violation of Sale of Alcoholic Beverages to Undera;
Said fine shall be paid to the Office of I
within thirty (30) days of the adoption of this
Mayor.
Green Sheet # 104496
31
's (I,icense ID No. 44113),
ordered to pay a fine of $500.00�
Persons.
�ections and Environmental Protection
�uy the Council and signature by the
This resolution and the action of the ouncil in this matter are based upon the facts
contained in tl�e December 10, 1999, Notic of Violation ietter to the licensee, the Police
Report CN 99-204788, and such argume s as may have been presented to the Council at the
public hearing. The facts were not cont ted by the licensee.
i
� ``D �Qy f2�= Lil��u.�.c
� �S � G.0 eP S�u�c� �
��►$�� �-��� u �,,,�
� �� ���,
Requested by Department o£:
i �.
sy: k..1.t�.l.a; � . ,r�� �
Adopted by Council: Date
Adoption Certified by Council Secretary
By:
proved by Mayor: Date
Form Approved by City Attorp�
$Y � �i�a -.�c.cf.� �� � C� y ,�rc
Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
Hy:
GREEN SHEET
William Gunther
12, 2000 _ P.
rn�e wie
aourrw
onom
TOTAL # OF SIt3NATURE PAGES
04 -33
No 10!t4 �'b
� ev,u�ae�.aemae U arcca�r+c `
❑ aer�rrowiar ❑ rnewnc _
❑ �tanmeoaw. ❑ wuicM��nmuKra
❑M'IORI�Y�ifNlf) ❑
(CUP ALL LOCATlONS FOR SlGNATURE)
Resolution concerning adverse action against Malt Off-Sale License held by Paul Ramp,
dba Ramp's, 1059 Western Avenue North.
<
PLANNING CAMMISSION
CI8 COMMlTiEE
CML SERVICE CAMMISSION
AYOUM OFTRAN.SACTION
SOURCE
Hsttis pdsaJfirm ererwkN utlers wrmactbUssdepvm�eN?
YES No
Hr tlis v�� ewrbem a alYa�4bl^��
YES HO
Ooea Mie P�m P� a alal not mma0ypo�eE M anY �a�A cily empoYeeT
YES NQ
h th's P�+wNf+m e WpeteC venda�
� � �
COlTAtEVENYEBU00ETED(GRCLECMk7 YEE
ACTIVITY NtMBER
�,.]''
JAN-12-60 02:29 HM KAMPS FOOD MpRKET 1651488ee76 P.01
'$�' 3!
�� ��3
F� to: Jim Reiter
From: Paul Kamp — Kamg's Food Mazket
(651) 488-6536 store
(651) 4$8-3376 fa�
RE: Letter to Council about hearing for alcohol sale to minor on
Dec. 2, 1999
Thanks Jim
Paul
f �
wnn-12-00 02:00 aM KpMPS FOOD MARKET 16514S8o376 P.02
�
�
St. P�ul Ci Council
My name is Pau1 Kam}� and I am the owner of Kamp's Food
Market located at 1059 Westem Ave. in St. Paul, MN. My family
has been in the grocery business here in St. Paul since the turn of
the century. We talce great pride in the long history ar�d integrity in
which we have done business for nearly 100 yeazs.
The reason foz this Ietter is on December 2, 1999 one af my
cashiers sold alcohol to a minor, a young lady who at the time was
20 years and 10 months old. Now, I understand, that anybody
twder 21 is illegal, I believe some circumstances led to my
cashier's indiscretion.
We were assisting the St. Paul Police Department at that time by
notifying our customers about a level 3 rapist, Greg Welsh, who
had moved into our neighborhood. In fact we were told that he had
openly refused any treatment while in prison and had openly stated
that he woutd commit these crimes again upon his release. We
were giving handonts to ow customers and we had the notice
posted in our store. The contact person, Sergeant Chris Nelson, af
the St. Paul Police Dept. has contacted Mr. Reiter in reference to
this matter as well. I also will tell you that Mr. Welsh is back in
prison, where he should be thanks to Sergeant Nelson's persistence
and hard work.
Approximately %z hour prior to the compliance check Mr. Welsh
came into our store and upon seeing his picture posted began
screaming at Dawn Ellis, our cashier. He stated that "he would get
her" along with many other derogatory comnnents. Ms. Ellis is a
60+-year-old woman who does not drive and is well known
throughout owr neighborhood because she walks from her house on
Western to Rice St, and alsa to the Como Lake area regularly. She
was visibly shaken, but because I was attending a Winter Carnival
event that night and another emplayee had cal.led in sick we were
JAN-12-90 92:a0 AM KAMPS FOOD MRRKET 16514883e76 P.Oe
�0-33
short staffed. She was not able to either take a break ar just go
home for the evening to relax.l say adamautly that Ms. Ellis is the
best cashier that I've seen in my years in the g�'ocezY business and
even a better person. She takes great pride in her wozk and has a
reputation as "The lady that "cards" (or checks the ID} of
everyone".
To be honest, we sell very little beer at aur store and have
considered eliminating it totally. If the council sees fit to either
reduce or suspend the $500 suggested fine I would not object to
eliminating it from my store if you deeraed necessary. We have
had a tough couple af months including a bre�k-in., in which
oartons of cigarettes were stolen and an armed robbery as well. I
planned on presenting this myself today, but the passing of my
mather this week made it too tough time- wise.
I appreciate the consideration and wish you all well.
Sincerely,
Paul Kamp
�..�6� ..�---
I
QRiG1�AL
Presented By
Referred To
t v`c�e_v�,, �- t� l�. � a a
RESOLUTION
CTTY OF SAINT PAUL, NIINNESOTA
Committee: Date
31
2 RESOLVED, that the Licensee, Paul Kamp d!b/a Kamp's (License ID No. 44113),
3 located at 1059 Western Avenue North in Saint Paul is hereby ordered to pay a fine of $500.00� -4 -�
4 for the violation of Sa1e ofAlcoholic Beverages to Underage Persons, aso.E
5 w.}�-��
6 Said fine shall be paid to the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protec on �` ��
7 within thirty (3�) days of the adoption of this resolufion by the Council and signature by the -�
S M2yoY. r ema t ni
9 �135c,a �r
10 This resolution and the acrion of the Council in this matter are based upon the facts F- w�-r ��&
11 contained in the December 10, 1999, Nofice of Violation letter to the licensee, the Police �� ���'���}ks
12 Report CN 99-204788, and such azguments as may have been presented to the Council at the
13 pubiic hearing. The facts were not contested by the licensee.
Requested by Department of:
BY:
C�
By:
By: k:�.[LC+d . � CSI�
Form Approved by City Attorpeq-�
�� �
By: (� /
Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By:
Council File # �O — Z3
GreenSheet# 1�4496
Adopted by Council: Date CSS.a„� \,�.,�.pOa
C �—�—
Adoption Certified by Counci � Secxetary
�,
GREEN SHEET
William Gunther
p0 -33
No 10449�
� u �.�,�.�.a. u �,.�—
� ❑ �.� ❑ ��
❑ wuraa�aQVr.�son. ❑ n+weu�aaw.�ccro
❑ raoieP�aar+� ❑
(CUP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE�
12, 2000 _ P.
TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES
Resolution concerning adverse action against Ma1C Off-Sale License held by Paul Kamp,
dba Kamp's, 1059 Western Avenue North.
lonr�orv ,4pprove (n) w �telett
PLANNING COMMISSION
CIB COMMITfEE
CNIL SERVICE CAMMISSION
Ha6 Ni6 P��Rn everraMed uMer a conheCt for Ihis tlepartment?
vE5 No
Has Mis 7�K�m ever been a dlY empbyee7 .
vES No
Daes Mie Oe�swYGrm poasess a sldll not nwma��YP�essetl by anY currerR city employee?
YES I�
Is thi6 pe1sonfifm a talpetetl VendoY7 � ,
VES NO
sheet anE attach to areen sheet
R�Y��S:i•7�as7
TRANSACTIONf
SOURCE
INFORMATION (IXPWln
COST/REVENUEBUD6ETED(GRCIEON� VEf
��iPlY 7'C�!'.1$3_l
NO
✓
OFFICE OF Tf� CITY ATTORNEY
Clay[on M Robinson, Jr., Ciry Atforney f�/� ! 2�
V�/ �l
Cl� �F `S`�INT PA� Civil Division
NormColeman,Mayor 40UCiryHa11 Telephone:651Z66-8i10
IS West Ke!logg B[vd Facsimile: 65l 298-56I9
Saint Paul, Minnesota S.i10?
December 22, 1999
;O ,r ✓`�r;iQ
NOTICE OF COUNCIL MEETING � :,-�- = _
Paul Kamp � `� � A
nr���;��
Kamp's
1 �59 Westem Avenue North
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55117
RE: Malt Off-Sale License held by Paui Kamp d/b/a Kamp's for the premises at 1059 Westem
Avenue North Saint Paul
License ID #: 44113
Dear Mr. Kamp:
Please take notice that a fieaxing concerning the above-named establishment has been scheduled
for 5:30 p.m., Wednesday, January 12, 200Q in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint
Paul City Hall and Ramsey Counry Courthouse.
Enclosed aze copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to
the City Council for their considerafion. This is an uncontested hearing, in that the facts
concerning the sale of alcohol to an under age person have not been denied. You will have an
opporiunity at the Council hearing to present oral and/or written remarks as to the penalty, if any,
to be imposed. The recommendation of the license office will be for a$500.00 fine.
If you have any questions, please ca11 me at 266-8710.
Very truly yours,
J/�� C��.�
Viiginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary
Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP
Christine Rozek, LTEP
Kathy Cole, Executive Director, District 6 Planning Council, 1061 Rice St., St. Paul, MN
55117
UNCONTESTED LICENSE MATTER o0-33
Licensee Name
Address:
Council Date
Paul Kamp d!b/a Kamp's
1059 Western Avenue West
January 12, 2000
Violation: Sale of Aicohof to an Underage Person
Minn. Stat. § 304A.503 (1994)
St. Paut Legislative Code § 409.08
Date of Violation: December 2, 1999
Place:
Licensed Premises
Presumptive Penalty:
$500.00 Fine
Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office
of License, Inspections and Environmenta{ Protection:
$500.00 fine
Attachments:
1. Proposed resofution
2. Letter from licensee admitting violation and asking for a
council hearing
3. Notice of Violation
4. License Information Report
5. Violation memo
6. Law Enforcement Buy Report Form
7. License information
O�
December 19, 1999
Virginia D Patmer
Assistant City Attorney
This letter is in reference to a letter of violation I received from your office dated
December 10, 1999 and charging my grocery store with selling alcohol to a minor.
Please find a copy enclosed.
I would like to pursue step two of the three options listed in your letter. I do admit
that my cashier soid alcohol to a minor, but there were extenuatiug circumstances
that led to the indiscrerion that I believe are valid and do involve our police
department,
Please contact me with any information as to a hearing before the City Council.
_, .. �_-�
Kamp's Food Market
1059 Western Ave. N
ST Paul ,MN 55117
OFFI� �F THE CI"IY ATTORNEY
Cloylon .... Robinson, Js., Ciry Atmmey
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Norm Caleman, MayOr
C!Y[I DN(S[OR
400 Ciry Hal!
I S Wesr Kellogg Blvd
Saint Pau1, bfinnesota Si102
pp -33
Telephoxe: 65! 266-8: /0
Facsimile: 651298-5619
December 10, 1999
NOTICE OR VIOLATION
Paul Kamp
Kamp's
1054 Western Avenue North
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55117
RE: Malt Off-Sale License held by Paul Kamp d/b/a Kamp's for the premises at 1059 �Vestem
Avenue North Saint Paul
License ID #: 44113
Dear Mr. Kamp:
The Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection has recommended
adverse action against the licenses held by you d/bia/ Kamp's far the premises at 1059 Western
Avenue North in Saint Paul. The basis for this recommendation is as follows:
On December 2,1999 the Saint Paul police conducted a follow-
up liquor compliance check at Kamp's, located at 1059
Wesfern Avenue North. Two individuals, one 18 years old and
the other 20 years old, entered Kamp's and purchased a 12-
pack of Miller Genuine Draft, went to the register and paid for
it. The clerk did not ask either party for identification. It is a
violation of Minn. Stat. §340A.503, subd.2 to sell or furnish
alcohol to a person under the age of 21, and Saint Paul
Legislative Code § 410.04(a)(1) prohibits a licensee or agent or
employee thereof from delivering intosicating or
nonintoxicating malt liquor to any person under the age of 21.
Since this is considered a first violation, the licensing office will recommend a�500.00 fine,
pursuant to St. Paul Legislative Code §404.26.
At this time you have three options on how to proceed:
Pa�e 2
Kamp's
December ld, 1999
00 -33
If you do not dispute the above facts and do not �vish to have a public hearin„ you will
need to pay the recotnmended fine for this violation. If this is your choice, you should
make payment directly to the Office of License Inspections and Environmental
Protection, Room 300 Lowry Professional Building, 350 Saint Peter Street, Saint Paul,
Minnesota 5> 102. The letter should be directed to Ms. Christine Rozek. Payment of the
fine will be considered to be a waiver of the hearing to ��hich you aze entitled.
Alternatively, if you do not dispute the above facts, but wish to have a public hearing
before the Saint Paul City Council, you will need to send me a letter with a statzment
admitting the violation and requesting a hearinQ by Monday, December 20, 1999. The
matter will then be scheduled before the City Council for a public hearing to determine
what penalty, if any, to impose. You will have an opportunity to appear before the
Council and make a statement on your own behalf as to the penaity to be imposed.
3. If you do dispute the above facts, a hearing will be scheduled before an Administrative
Law Judge. At that hearing both you and the Ciry wili be able to appear and present
witnesses, evidence, and cross-examine the other's witnesses. The St. Paul Cin� Council
will ultimately decide the case. Please let me know in writing no later than Monday,
December 20, 1999, how you wish to proceed.
If you have not contacted me bp Monday, December 20,1999, I will assume that }•ou are
not contesting the facts and will schedule this matter for the St. Paul City Council and have
it placed on the Consent Agenda during which no public discussion is allowed and the
recommended penalty will be imposed.
If you have any questions, feel free to contact me at 266-8710.
Sincerely,
� � v� � = J v � r �'.-,� ti
Virginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Robert Kessler, Director of LIEP
Christine Rozek, Deputy Director of LIEP
Kathy Cole, Executive Director, District 6 Planning Council, 1061 Rice St., St. Paul, Mi`T
55117
00 -33
STATE OF MII�SNESOTA
COUNTY OF RAMSEY
ss. AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL
JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says
that on December 13, 1999, she served the attached NOTICE OF
VIOLATIOI3 on the following named person by placing a true and
correct copy thereo£ in an envelope addressed as follows:
Paul Kamp
Kamp's
1059 Western Avenue No.
St. Paul, MN. 55117
(which is the last known address of
same, with postage prepaid, in the I
Minnesota.
Subscribed and sworn to before me
this 13"' day of Dec�er, 1999.
c� ' �i � PEtER P. PANGBORN
�-f ,� � � QTARYPUBIIC
Notary Public :' Mv��m Exa��=��-'
said person) and depositing the
�
l ,
+i
�
i ,
�
�I
�I
�°�
M
w
'� � O
� N O
a- d IO
d U N
� J I`
w
0. M
O
�
0
a
�
�
�
.�
�
�
C
d
N
C
N
�
J
�
�
m
�
�
�
U �
J Q
0
�I U
IF I�
�
ININ
� C,�
��,L
UIl9
IJi�
!_U
� �
rn �i
N Ej
r I�
Z;
I��M
Wi�
ICi�
UIV
I �O
�� ' 6
�� �
Z
W
�
Q
Z
i� �
N
;� �
i�
��
�a
!Qrn�
j �� <
� t!)
i�
I�
z�
m la
� �I Y
�f
Z I�
cIY
I
iy J
a �¢
�
�U
C
3
O
U
�
N �
. O
�
N
N
a
W
c
N
�
�
3
Z
U
O
I�
U
I��
��
I
I� I
I�I
m
Iz
{
I��
1
Q�
I�i
IU i
iVi�
c�
R
��i
U
�
N
�
�
3
Z
N
C �
� M
L �
IN �
N �
�C �
N
I3 �
m �o
�
o �
F N
�
0
M
z
L17
Q
Z
�
W
N
�
�
�
� _
U N @
Q � � N
Q U � � �
� O � a �
� �
N
c'o� � m�i �
� �� > � �� �
� �
� a O N� N
G�V y O] ��'k rn
i
�c\� � � �U �
�� �' U U U N V
m, ca a� °�_,a
Y
O (6 C...: � �N � � U
L'() W � (p N O � �
V�i ��IlC U
�a ° c � a`� E 3 � E:° c°�i
- a ��cw o a� m �
�- �a��' ZUoWa�
_ ` oQa � i � °o°-
� VY�N Cfl-�
N a� QQ �' � V
� � V yU Q N(`"6H3�
o.�>ia� �
��''� CN � U y N N
p°'- ��a�L°:u�
c�°�a�Ua a��wm�o
��UCOW �wa�_IQ
��7WWc'�W ��ml��
N G �Nc O�<p�j�CO
v0 c
eo-33
�
i
,
,i
�
i
li
�
�I
o�
Q!
w�
M �
Q C �O
� U N
LSi J ��
A
a ��
r
0
a
�
C
O
R
�
V
w
C
N
N
c
m
0
�
��
�I d
N
U �' V
.J Q
N�
Q
F-- N
N I�
N .�
C'O
U �'=
J �
m �
rn
m Q
N I�
r �
I���
N ;a—
C s—
m v
I U , ;tT
I� O
I�
�
z
W
Q
��
I y'F
�
a `W
��
'Q � c�-
O �!J
� �
im
iZ
�m a
� �
JY
z ��
�o I�
��
l a I,a
�I
3
O
Ui
i
U
`�
N
� �O
I
.. I
�
a
Wo
y o
� o
_ �
M
O
N
Q
�
7
z
T �
f
0
a
IN J
N I �
C I �
�j
�z I
��
m
fl-iK
��'W
o �
U
f� ��
U �
C �
��
iC Q
_ �
N
�
�
�
z
m
��
O M
s�
a �
N �
N �
C �
�N
m �
� �
F N
W
O
M
z
7
2
Z
�
H
�
�
�
O
�f C
U N R
� Y � �
Q � � � �
a �
� � �� N
.� �° o n L
���� � � `�� �
NLL� � O N� �
Na,` �- arn rn
��V Y C� ��# �
NN� U Z. mU N
3���U U V N V
m, ca d °�-�a '
s
O (6.�t;� �o �� V
��V cp C� NN p.. N
V� i N p_ � p� IL C U
mcc�E 3��Ea�
V � �W �
�'�m°'� ?V �o�
����� o ��� o �
N�Y�� �Q2'c�0
a ° mo� nQ�O o
� � �� � Q m �Da�'�
°�'m � � a_ c Q a
n-�y >+� N Q U� t 11 �
p �� O N L.._t NLr (n
o��c..>a a�,�ymm
�� U N N � 7 J fl-
rn��6rnrnrrnNrnC�1�rn
c�o��°rnm�'"r `m�ncornrn
N C ON`N� ���`c0
vOon�.-.-Ur��nr
6a-3�
1
f�
��,
,',
�
n
�
�
��
o;
�a
M
W'
O � ip
M � �O
y U ��
R � �M
a I ;;
0
�
�
Q
�
G
O
e�
�
O
C
d
N
C
m
U
J
�i
m�
�I
�
clm
UIU
J �Q
N
N�
���
0
N'
� U
U
I� O
�
rn
m �
ao �',
N E',
� �:
2
�,r
N V
��U ;[{
LJO
�
;� �
Z
W
7
Q
� Z
� �
N I W
N ~
� W
� � r
Q o .-
�
__ l�l�
�
m
Z ��
m la
�' �¢
_'Y
Ni
Z I�
a iY
J
aa
Ja
�I
c
O�
UI
N�
�
I '
N
m
l o
Q
W
N
G
I
�J
N
4
�
3
Z
U
a
' ci
��
y�
���
��
,�i
IZ l
i��
i
�al
i�;
O
U I
N
V
INI
3
��
�
m
Q
I�
3
Z
N
C �
� M
t�
d �
N �
� �
{���
J�
�
I
� �
�� N
W
O
M
I Z
�
I Q
�� Z
I� F
Y �
W
I >
i' �
�a o
�
�
Y � C
V N �p
d � � �
Q � � � �
�p'.J � a �
c_p � �, y
�C� i �
N (0� � � (,� N
�'_ rn
�ti� a o a��
��V Y m ��k rn
�c\ � � � �U �
� r ��� V � i V
N c " =�a N �p .Y
O(0 C..: � �N E N N
t UmC I6 N i O (6 L
[�J� � Q. �p)LL C U
(6 CC�N� �j�a�,a U
�'�a�� zciowa�
j V 3m� ` p��U�Q
av � a� u. o_��
v� y°` m c o-�c�po
m rn o_Q y O� c�
N� V�7, U ¢ N�-oe»rn
�(0 �� N C C �QN U
a LLa rn � � N LL
p 6) .� O(6 .0 ..� N L.-�� N
�°'mUa d���mm
��UCOC� 73JQ
61` 76�0)�-W �m0]I`-6�
(D CW(n,.�vrV ����Q�
N C ON�N� �����
vO Vi-r-r-�UM�tiv
a e - 33
'° < cain# r aui Pclice Deperiment
` ��: _:� _
:__ _�� O-�clG1�AL flFF�I'�SE I 1NCIDENT REP�� i
oa-33
Ca,-��sm�,VUr,.��� ,.,,. � �� �nm�rvc:�e.�sa _a.> i. _ -,,,.eo. =�_a..
�c-2�L' � 88 � l�UOF 'u"-.WS. VIGL� 1 iO�i i�%G�'1 �SS 2C:��
c,r.a:��e_or,."r,__-s. JL�UIE�'�Nr[A.i•�ISi:aD
? .r„ar� c;:e sa c_:�rr
—.,,; _..,.�.. -� �
_accnea-� rpor...-_ c=ce,.
.y.S./IC: i���J t CR�I � P.Q.J��IIC� j
Scconca^; �r,'an<_?.
___srcn oi:nc:cecr. 1 C�� �N��T==\ .=`�J V
'.'a.;^ec,.,,c2acmcus:r.ass� �(r..?hFS
.i_=L�.,9oTOG^L•;2.^.C2: i�'v��..��'.�� G'�..�)
rirres[ mac3 �
De:z � cme o; ar.�asr
rCLiCc P�;tSvNNEL 1NVCL�/��
Pnar, maca on �nevr ?vrsurt enoegeo�
nrrzs: maoe :.- :va;rao, o�,,re�ncus G.V
Neaoons usec c� ooiice�
i✓ezoo,os �sza : c su=cec, zr nm= o; errasr
Re��s,ance enccur:erea.
CH,�^,RG�j ;NCNE)
iVAiVlES
SUS?�CT �'__!S. uAWN MARLENE
i 132 WESTGYN AV N S7PAUL >!1N c� �' ;
?hysical Description ?hones
sex ,-��ALE =�e�gnr ra��coior Home �none 551--88-'8��
�=c� �NHITE lPe 'No�kpn,ane „�1-�8?-33�"0
Weicnt Hav P
H�sper„c
.imr.�
ocs 05i24l� 934 swR
Ac= CJ
?hysical Conoi.ron
Consc:��sness
�ruda�c„nol use
HavLength
Faciz� Hau
cmploymenz
Occucavan
�mpro/er
�tME �C�VE �E�C�i1PTCft5
G Scene
'_.' ,RE-;;1L
�=_scr,c: cn ��;GCcRY/SUPERPJAF.KE �
.Nethod & Pomt of EntN
=o�ceusea 'JOT =C��=�
�pm. G%entr/
dzchoo
GP�R�f .��1oNE1
=ifCLE INF:,RP4A+lON (NONEj
3UC NARRATIVE
�ps i�iied a iiauor comeli2nce chec'�
rr_._.°°
-=, ,-;
•'2{ <9
CnmClsm: ; Jc ,r.�a!
ea_20�' � 85
Sa+ni °aui °ciice De�arne��t
�_�_ :
O�1�I�AL O�'�ENS� 1 li�CIDLN i R�POR i oo -a�
�E.`c -.-__ :.;J : .ama/J c4"e��e ..a._ =_nc iime a "2_.,.,
L!QUOR L��'-,�>>/S. V�GL��, � iC��!
i 2!G%!" ccc �r, � �
NA.rc.�c,'=.'i VE
�i'(1 i�'<� i G.�`^..,. �. �'-c^S�cC. CO(1CUC:ct7 _.CUOf �C�uCliciiCH ��.`IEC:<<_ ci i.w: iScC i;CUCC
`e ... � c -, .,. _ . . ,
�cCil..iifiE."r.� 1�l :f15 ..�iV .^.� C'�..i �ci:l. � L'Sc� �..OT^ul�c^C: C�ioC:CdS il?c: 2fc U�1C8f :I"�c .-Cc: cCc :.�
aL'CC;'.GS: c!CO;�C�. `�V(1:C:i ,.. L�. I VE;'li(c� :Rc; iilE!f 4J�i:..�S aCE .,r�7��QR i cCC ��:,�iGl C. I fl$:' �iVBCc
;1Y1'c�JIE :O .^,�CCUC; ci �;: - CG;i O; :CB^ililCcilCll. I ilv`J `NBfc CIY°C:cC :�ici :ii: f �OL'iC ^Ci �fc cCCUi :Nc:f cCB
CT'�CE. �lE`: `;JC(2 � ;JifQ ��. ± COW� i�lOfilLCf :h:2:f CO^VB*SciC � _ ;; ^ � r;
. 1� i, l i ic: ',`J8! �� E.'l v Cc: ililc. i DUV
IT1Cilc,� :C (1'1c:Cc ir1E :_:,'C: �cScS.
hS 2CCUt LQ.�'.Q f7C1:�9. :ilc f�N2f S2!lt Iil LO �oIT,CS ci "C7.�^.� �/��ESiEfil nVc V. ^IS '�NcS 'c : 8-C,^.cC:<
17ECcUS2 LFE SICCC � ICI�� �CII .! lG:l I cSi COfT7CIlGC1C� C:�IECR. 1(lE C�ECXE�S ��NE�.: .("i and �ici<=d UC c i L
(�cC�< 01 �/�1IIE( L`�j8^Ulfic :.ifc: 1 fiEf `N2?lt iC :fiE 'E�ISi'cf. T(12 C.�.'1cC;<cC �{/"I �,�"C� i � [:Ui :Cic �E=,' Cfi :[lE
coun*.er and CcVEC SVI:`1 i�'iE ;Ll�f (T1Cf78�f. I f70 WCt71c� c�h0 f3CiSiEt ilE'JCf :i?GU1rc� 'cCCL'I che aae cf _he
checR�rs. Tne cner,<ar came out and tumed over the �e=r and �he cnanc�. J
I�NE;Ii iCl cf1C IC2!1tILtcC iilE ScN2f. .�., was cilis. D cWYI I�af18i18 0l��- �9�='. 1?�2 We=,�m ,iVE �.
50117 �;ivl� �8&^84'. `n,�tC T 488-6036.
iI�IS SiciA� tf1cT Si12 @ItiVcVS GR2C�{5 W{lBR �CIqS t(`� TO CUy 2�COfiCI. .Sfl@'�fG�fl�i ;CUcy v8^=U52 SilB W2S
Yl'cfBSSc� py ?11CI(iEr CJSiOr'i2f Sa'fGB( 8ft4 WcS SiI�� UCSc;.
c Jil2 `Nc5 cq`I158C :flci _:t� `,VCUIa D@ ic{CIGl4 cCi1C(1 Wlifl :�lE:f �IC:=:1S2 GIIC :ilci'NE WCL`�C 76 iCil,VciGl(1C�
t�'7B !'@pOfi ?O ifl2 J� i='ci:l �i�:Y r'�tfOR1B`f�S Cifi1C° �Of (JOSSID�B CfiIT,IRfl� C:ic!C�ES.
?i9250 �iSiitDUtO iD:
CI-- -om
vB.: Jl
CC Rc�r
:too 1u� �Jncr
3urc Thr!c ?,on
"�'ice ��rco SI(1
n�r !_ib
C.1C Fc:F
T�2.� Oti:er
?cc Tc..:::
-uto D�U
{v0-��f)C " — ___ _""____
�.�\iPS
I p; � �t'E� . _a�"E �
S�.?.aCL��iI7
`� �i -- - _ ' F ..
^� �`. . ,. . '
Layj� �„oT�sm�n� Buy Rapor Form
—" 3uver?D
�
• ' G::°.'.:{.—=t
ace � IiYo?�roiasz.>Y,e:nazea� ;:C-.�;'
�- =, V
5. 'Nh�� did you .ry io purciase? d
a (cr.�cxene: oiiss�e oniy) o. (u^ec:cen��
Y c-�^<ck c.=ns 11 :6uCweisar
2'��12-pacx cans 2! Coors
3' 6-;�acX botYles 31 ��Miiier
��� Cuzrz bottle d; Gthe�
7. Seilerrsz^�er's gender:
— —
� �412ie 2 ' � � Fema�e
3. 3atferr=_erv=r's 2s�imated aae:
i L��s than 2t
2' Z'-30
3' . 31 or older
00 -33
TOCcY`S ..f)'ai9:
1 ,. _ �
„ 1 ��� /'- }°
�. 3uyer _eaczr: _. i i
' � � _ ` +
nrli
_ �F�m2;a -' c?A
.,.',Vas a secarir� �e�cn s�cicr,_a �t'_he ccer?
-.:f ye�. _e.^.car oi cere� ac docr:
.. `(es - 3 = —
Y � ddale 2: =�maie
_ ,�o
,.. i yes. �,vere ycu: ,c �ecx ad fi�r acpry�
1,� a.emiitza wi[h no cues.ien
L .�.emlrt2O c'c! si2iiro ZCje
31 P��rcnasea aftzr 5.�:= c�te o� birth
�� .�.omirt°� ��e* stanr,a ID not on me
Si� i+CTiiiieC cL2� exnia�mno ID in c&r
o' Not sdm�rtec 6TOP uE3�
�
e
iF:VO.
— SiCiP ,
.-g
c Ic.;ack or,e
1: `Lite
��
_N
L' 'r(E:L'75f _q
�
t0. How many peooie were sanding in line
oenind you ac t time you were at the
casn raaister? ' I � �
12'Nhat was the noise ievel?
Nomzi — Rais2d —
ccnversat�on 1' � vo�ces 2_ ghouting 3_ --
,... )f no ourcnase artemniea, exolain beiow::c,-=cx cn=�
7? '^ J:os?^ out cr cus�r,ess
iZ. �IGS°7 SBd50l!ci bOClS
J� ..'CScC I{rt1RE�'.O11'S
.+ ''..:OSE� Ia�ppOf2:OV L'E9Bif5. ;C.R10CB! 3._.
�5� �:oseatoouo:ic �nva,ecarzy
']"o � ?^va:e cWG pu�:ic ^o[ �c,�niCao
J7' l;r.aD:e to IoG;te
cP�)GITOACJ:':2' . •158�1 :"1
�
�. HoLV crowded •Kas it? .
Seatir.g � ' No saarnaf — No ;eatma/ —
ava:iaole 1_ fesv s;andino2_ mzr� stanaina3
tt ?urchase 3rt2mo2 outcome: ;c,.=_cx a1( tr,;r appri�
.'� �?urcnasza wrth no cuesnons
2: Purchaseo after s«ung Gge
., Purc�as�a c��� =_czce dats o` �irtn
-. Purcnased aYer r,aana !D nc� on m�
Purcn�s_=o aft2r exc'?�� _^ �� c_.
„ Vo purc^ase
_3 � Ursase iexcarni
.S °U`iEf 1(1d09f�Lff2lSY C:ESSEO
. � J: C! 6?9'
.. �,0 f0[ he'Y'? ,�me U �:.,...�:2r�
12 �Jon t (or no :onaen =__�I z�ccno:
_ ?.eszrvauor.s : ecess�rv
Other (spea^q
i
License Group Comments Text
Licensee: pqUl. KAMP
DBA: KqMP'S
4icense #: 00441i3
4/26199 completetl required alcohot awareness training-DL
On 37�8799 Failed check; "unofficial" waming-training tlue 4/18/99-DL
7/29/98 Congratulations letter sent. PJW
7/�3198 Passed cigarette compliance check. PJW
52497
111491 Ph On Appn For New At2 Grocery-B, Off Sale Maft 32 8 Cigarette License App'D C.F. 91-2097
3(16l94 Restaurant Removed From License Per Gary Pechmann.
5/98 Butcher Add-On Lic Eliminated Per Gf #95-'1457
7/V97 Late Fee $'181.00 Paid.
4!6/99 passed cig compliance cfieck - 4!1?J99 lettec sent SS
12/06f1999
aQ -33
oa -3�
�
_ F _
�S � Licensee l Corrtact 1 License 1 Cardhalder,
� Property t' Licensee �' Llnofficial r All
t #: D59
t hlame: lyESTEP.N
t Type: .�
tion: <All> ►�
<All} ►�
� T—°,�,���,__�i -���l�..`°`��°`��'�a�""" �
VYUUK]._ S�18tN Tett¢] i,iYf�_. COji)+ r�i� a.lp Add License...
Licensee Na�ne DBR
3ERALD 44AMP IK.4MP'S
KAMP
License Tvae I Status
ery - A2
Off Sale
�_nd r.�;:;.,.
``' ` I
�=.:rn. e!
t:;�.,_ .- � .. clt
Help
�
6tt 990
6t1990
8M 986
M5911f
M9911(
�15911C
M9871[
� { {Grocery {D) �Active Ucensa Printed �04N1 M 991 �03f31 f2000i1 C
� itv1att Off Sale IActive LicensE Frirned �04l01/1991 �03t31lZOO 1 C
i287 �1919 jPAUL A F(AMP �!{AMPS S7RR MARKE1Alarm Permit (Rene�Acti�e 08M 111992 I09M 3�10�]G:1 [
_ �
�G�ouptNise... �ECLIPSA ... � ECLIPS Li... � C25.com-... i� License _.. r Pro erties... `�' "� � �'�`
_� � a ��{L•� ! L� a N�������:�.�
1. ��
d0 -�33
,�. • ��- � - t ❑ x
I Licensee �,UL kAMP
.� P$ I P� ���iiram I H � � S �� i
DBA AMP'S
License � Licensee } Lic.lypes
r Pro�erty �' Licensee r Unofficial
1 Insurance l Bond 1 Requiremerrts,
—� ProjECt Facilitator: ROZEF{, CHRISTINE J
Street #: �59
Street Name: STERN
Street Type: AVE Diredion: �
Unit Ind: � Urirt #: �
City: T PAUL
Adverse Aciion Cammer�ts
CammerQs:
State: v1N Zi�: 55117 �6hJ9 completed required alcahuf rwareness
raining-DL
�tard: � BroHrse n 3M 5�39 Failed check; "unofficial" ,12C2hJ9 Failed
Dist Council: �b iq.comp.ck conclucted by vicE.FtS.warninq-tr�ining due
, M SP39-DL
Licensee: AUL FtAMP Commer�ts:
D6A: AMP'S
s T a x Id: � Bu s P 651 } 488-663H
License Type � Class � Effective � Expiration
t41�tt Off S�4e �C � �4N1 M 891 � �3C31 f2���
�4r171 M 991 I �3f31 f2�0�
License # �44113
Save Changes to Histary
i287 11919 !PF,UL �. KAMP iKAtv1PS STAR MARKE1Alarm Fermit
�icen5e Fee I �
N $317.�0 —�
N $SOQ.00� �
r
Cancel � Hel�
; j08(11t199� Q9t13tZOGG'
�
r _ l'�� iG:1- , c
�GroupWise... �ECLiPSAp... (�ECLIPSLic... ��]CBS.com•... �jLicEnseRu... uPcopertie._. N,,D;;�����
JAN-12-00 02:29 AM KAMPS FOOD MRRKET 1651488bb76 P.61
.r �
�31
Fax to: Jim Reiter
From: Paui Kamp — Kamp's Food Market
(651) 488-6636 stoze
(651) 4$8-3376 fax
RE: Letter to Cowncil about hearing for alcohol sale to minor on
Dec. 2, 1999
Thanks Jim
Paul
fl
��-33
_ �
�Hn-12-00 02:30 qM KAMPS FOOD MRRKET 1651488�076 P_02
., J
���33
S� Paui Ci Council
MY name is Pau1 Kamp and I am the owner of Kaznp's Food
Market located at 1459 Western Ave. in St. Paul, MN. My family
has been in tYie grocery business here in St. Paul since the turn of
the century. We take great pride in the Iong history and integxity in
which we have done husiness for nearly 100 years.
The reason for this Ietter is on December 2, 1999 one of my
cashiers sold alcohol to a minor, a young lady who at the time was
20 years and 10 months old. Now, I understand, that anybody
under 21 is illegal, I believe some circumstances led to my
cashier's indiscretion.
We were assisting the St, Paul Police Department at that time by
notifying our customers about a level 3 rapist, Greg Welsh, who
had moved into our neighborhood. In fact we were told that he had
openly refused any treatrnent while in prison and had openly stated
that he woutd commit these crimes again upon his release. We
were giving handouts to ow customers and we had the notice
posted in our store. The contact person, Sergeant Chris Nelson, of
the St. Paut Police Dept. has contacted Mr. Reiter in reference to
this matter as well. I also will tell you that Mr. Welsh is back in
prison, where he should be thanks to Sergeant Nelson's persistence
and hatd work.
Approximately %s hour prioz to the compliance check Mr. Welsh
came into our store and upan seeing his picture posted began
screaming at Dawn Ellis, our cashier. He stated that "he would get
her" along with many other derogatary comments. Ms. Ellis is a
60+-year-old woman who does not drive and is well known
throughout our neighborhood because she walks from hear house on
Westem ta Rice St. and also to the Como Lake area regulazly. She
was visibly shaken, but hecause I was attending a Winter Cazruval
event that night and another employee had called in sick we weze
JAN-12-00 02:�6 AM KAMPS FOOD MRRKET 16514880376 P.O�
y
bb- 33
short staffed. She was not able to either take a break or just go
home for the evening to rel�. I say adamantly that Ms. Ellis is the
best cashier that I've seen in my years in. the grocery business and
even a better person. She takes great pride in her work and has a
reputatian as "The lady that "cazds" (or checks the ID) of
everyone".
To be honest, we sell very little beer at our store and have
considered eliminating it totally. If the council sees fit to either
reduce or suspend the $500 suggested fine I would not object to
eliminating it from my store if you deemed necessary. 'We have
had a tough couple af months including a break-in, in which
cartons of cigarettes were stolen and an armed robbery as well. I
planned on presenting this myself today, but the passing of my
mothez tlus week made it too tough time- wise.
I appreciate the consideration and wish you all well.
Sincerely,
Paul Kamp
`�� �
r �
Council File # OQ — Q3
o���iNa�
�
Presented By
Refened To
RESOLUTION
CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
Committee:
1
2
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
�
RESOLVED, that the Licensee, Paul Kamp d/b/a
located at 1059 Western Avenue North in Saint Pau] is her�
for the violation of Sale of Alcoholic Beverages to Undera;
Said fine shall be paid to the Office of I
within thirty (30) days of the adoption of this
Mayor.
Green Sheet # 104496
31
's (I,icense ID No. 44113),
ordered to pay a fine of $500.00�
Persons.
�ections and Environmental Protection
�uy the Council and signature by the
This resolution and the action of the ouncil in this matter are based upon the facts
contained in tl�e December 10, 1999, Notic of Violation ietter to the licensee, the Police
Report CN 99-204788, and such argume s as may have been presented to the Council at the
public hearing. The facts were not cont ted by the licensee.
i
� ``D �Qy f2�= Lil��u.�.c
� �S � G.0 eP S�u�c� �
��►$�� �-��� u �,,,�
� �� ���,
Requested by Department o£:
i �.
sy: k..1.t�.l.a; � . ,r�� �
Adopted by Council: Date
Adoption Certified by Council Secretary
By:
proved by Mayor: Date
Form Approved by City Attorp�
$Y � �i�a -.�c.cf.� �� � C� y ,�rc
Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
Hy:
GREEN SHEET
William Gunther
12, 2000 _ P.
rn�e wie
aourrw
onom
TOTAL # OF SIt3NATURE PAGES
04 -33
No 10!t4 �'b
� ev,u�ae�.aemae U arcca�r+c `
❑ aer�rrowiar ❑ rnewnc _
❑ �tanmeoaw. ❑ wuicM��nmuKra
❑M'IORI�Y�ifNlf) ❑
(CUP ALL LOCATlONS FOR SlGNATURE)
Resolution concerning adverse action against Malt Off-Sale License held by Paul Ramp,
dba Ramp's, 1059 Western Avenue North.
<
PLANNING CAMMISSION
CI8 COMMlTiEE
CML SERVICE CAMMISSION
AYOUM OFTRAN.SACTION
SOURCE
Hsttis pdsaJfirm ererwkN utlers wrmactbUssdepvm�eN?
YES No
Hr tlis v�� ewrbem a alYa�4bl^��
YES HO
Ooea Mie P�m P� a alal not mma0ypo�eE M anY �a�A cily empoYeeT
YES NQ
h th's P�+wNf+m e WpeteC venda�
� � �
COlTAtEVENYEBU00ETED(GRCLECMk7 YEE
ACTIVITY NtMBER
�,.]''
JAN-12-60 02:29 HM KAMPS FOOD MpRKET 1651488ee76 P.01
'$�' 3!
�� ��3
F� to: Jim Reiter
From: Paul Kamp — Kamg's Food Mazket
(651) 488-6536 store
(651) 4$8-3376 fa�
RE: Letter to Council about hearing for alcohol sale to minor on
Dec. 2, 1999
Thanks Jim
Paul
f �
wnn-12-00 02:00 aM KpMPS FOOD MARKET 16514S8o376 P.02
�
�
St. P�ul Ci Council
My name is Pau1 Kam}� and I am the owner of Kamp's Food
Market located at 1059 Westem Ave. in St. Paul, MN. My family
has been in the grocery business here in St. Paul since the turn of
the century. We talce great pride in the long history ar�d integrity in
which we have done business for nearly 100 yeazs.
The reason foz this Ietter is on December 2, 1999 one af my
cashiers sold alcohol to a minor, a young lady who at the time was
20 years and 10 months old. Now, I understand, that anybody
twder 21 is illegal, I believe some circumstances led to my
cashier's indiscretion.
We were assisting the St. Paul Police Department at that time by
notifying our customers about a level 3 rapist, Greg Welsh, who
had moved into our neighborhood. In fact we were told that he had
openly refused any treatment while in prison and had openly stated
that he woutd commit these crimes again upon his release. We
were giving handonts to ow customers and we had the notice
posted in our store. The contact person, Sergeant Chris Nelson, af
the St. Paul Police Dept. has contacted Mr. Reiter in reference to
this matter as well. I also will tell you that Mr. Welsh is back in
prison, where he should be thanks to Sergeant Nelson's persistence
and hard work.
Approximately %z hour prior to the compliance check Mr. Welsh
came into our store and upon seeing his picture posted began
screaming at Dawn Ellis, our cashier. He stated that "he would get
her" along with many other derogatory comnnents. Ms. Ellis is a
60+-year-old woman who does not drive and is well known
throughout owr neighborhood because she walks from her house on
Western to Rice St, and alsa to the Como Lake area regularly. She
was visibly shaken, but because I was attending a Winter Carnival
event that night and another emplayee had cal.led in sick we were
JAN-12-90 92:a0 AM KAMPS FOOD MRRKET 16514883e76 P.Oe
�0-33
short staffed. She was not able to either take a break ar just go
home for the evening to relax.l say adamautly that Ms. Ellis is the
best cashier that I've seen in my years in the g�'ocezY business and
even a better person. She takes great pride in her wozk and has a
reputation as "The lady that "cards" (or checks the ID} of
everyone".
To be honest, we sell very little beer at aur store and have
considered eliminating it totally. If the council sees fit to either
reduce or suspend the $500 suggested fine I would not object to
eliminating it from my store if you deeraed necessary. We have
had a tough couple af months including a bre�k-in., in which
oartons of cigarettes were stolen and an armed robbery as well. I
planned on presenting this myself today, but the passing of my
mather this week made it too tough time- wise.
I appreciate the consideration and wish you all well.
Sincerely,
Paul Kamp
�..�6� ..�---
I