The URL can be used to link to this page

280958 WMITE - CITV CLERK ` PINK +�- FINANCE t 1 {, TANARV -DEPARTMENT GITY OF SAINT PAUL COl1IIC11 �� .,C�� BLUE - MAVOR �'-�,� •�� File N 0. . � Z n Ordinance N 0. �� P� Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date An Ordinance amending Chapter 60 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code pertaining to zoning for the City of Saint Paul and the zoning maps thereof. WHEREAS, Pursuant to Minnesota Statutes §462 . 357 and §64.210 of the Legislative Code, Delores and Milton Elliott duly petitioned to rezone Lots 19, 20 and 21, Block 12, W. St. Paul Real Estate and Improvement Syndicate #1, located on the northeast corner of Belvidere and Oakdale, from R-4 to RT-2 to permit construction of three four-plexes, the petition having been certified as having been consented to by at least 67� of the owners of the area of the property to be rezoned, and further having been consented to by at least two-thirds of the owners of the property situated within 100 feet of the total contiguous descriptions of real estate held by the same owner or any party purchasing any such contiguous property within one year preceding the date of the petition; and WHEREAS, The current Zoning Committee on Ju].y 7, 1983 conducted a public hearing for the purpose of considering the rezoning petition, and pursuant to Section 107.03 of the Administrative Code, submitted its recommendation to the Planning Commission that the petition be granted; and WHEREAS, The Planning Commission considered the rezoning petition at its meeting held on July 8, 1983 and recommended that the City Council approve the petition; and WHEREAS, Notice of a public hearing before the City Council on the said rezoning petition was duly published in the official newspaper of the City on July 16, 1983 and notices were duly mailed to each owner of affected property and property situated COUNCILMEN Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays Fletcher �eu« ' In Favor Masanz /�1 Nicosta �/ Against BY Scheibel TedesCo Wfison Adopted by Council: Date Form Appro ed y City Att y Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY By Approved by Mayor: Date Approv d y Mayor fo ubmission to Council By BY WMITE - CITV CLERK 1 `CANARY -DEPARC MENT COl1S1C11 �r�(�T,�C BLUE -MAVOR GITY OF SAINT PATTL . File NO. '''``�' `�`�� Ordin��zce Ordinance N�. � ��D � Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date wholly or partly within 350 feet of the property sought to be rezoned; and WHEREAS, A public hearing before the City Council, having been conducted on July 28, 1983 where all interested persons were heard, and the Council having considered all the facts and recommendations concerning the petition; now, therefore, THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: Section 1. That the zoning map of the City of Saint Paul, Sheet No. 38, as incorporated by reference in Section 60. 301 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, as amended, is hereby further amended as follows : That property located on the northeast corner of Belvidere and Oakdale, being more particu- larly described as Lots 19, 20 and 21, Block 12 , W. St. Paul Real Estate and Improvement Snydicate #1, be and is hereby rezoned from R-4 to RT-2. Section 2. This ordinance shall take effect and be in force thirty (30) days from and after its passage, approval and publication. 2. COUNCILMEN Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays Fletcher �eu� In Favor Masanz Nicosia Q B scneibei Against Y Tedesco w��s� 1983 Adopted by Council: Date OCT 2 � Form Appr ved y City Attor y Certified P sed b Council S tar BY By �` � T '' Appro ed y Mayor for S mission to Council Appr ve y Mayor: D t _,. _ By By PUBL15HE0 OCT 2 9 1983 _ _ _�.____ _ ___ _ ____.__(.BETIIBI�L�9__��1�QM� SEGAL AFTER_ ADOPTION)_____ WMITE( - CITY CLERK • Y PINK � F�NANCE GITY OF SAINT PALTL Counci_1 ��,��Q CANARY - DEAARTMENT ewe —M�roR File �O. itil�i . 0. 'i i�j . Ordin�nce ordinance N0. �7�(O`'7`' Presented By � Referred To . Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date � An Ordinance amending Chapter .60 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code pertaining to zoning for the City of Saint Paul and fhe zoning maps thereof. WHEREAS, Pursuant to Minnesota Statutes �462 . 357 and �64 .210 of the Legislative Code, Delores and Milton Elliott duly petitioned to rezone Lots 19, 20 and 21, Block 12, W. St.. Paul Real Estate and Improvement Syndicate #1, located on the northeast corner of Belvidere and Oakdale, from R-4 -to RT-2 to permit construction of three four-plexes, the petition having been certified as having been consented to by at least 67� of the owners of the area of the property to be rezoned, and further having been consented to by at least two-thirds of the owners of the property situated within 100 feet of the total contiguous descriptions of real estate held by the same owner or any party purchasing any such contiguous property within one year preceding the date of the petition; and WHEREAS, The current Zoning Committee on Ju}.y 7, 1983 conducted a public hearing for the purpose of considering the rezoning petition, and pursuant to Section 107. 03 of the Administrative Code, submitted its recommendation to the Planning Commissian that the petition be granted; and WHEREAS, The Planning Commission considered the rezoning petition at its meeting held on July 8, 1983 and recommended that the City Council approve the petition; and WHEREAS, Notice of a public hearing before the City Council - on the said rezoning petition was duly published in the official newspaper of the City on July 16, 1983 and notices were duly mailed to each owner of affected property and property situated COUNCILMEN Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays Fletcher ceu� In Favor Mase�: Nicosfa B Scheibel Against Y 7edesco Wfison Form Approved by City Attorney Adopted by Council: Date Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY By Approved by Mayor: Date Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council Bv BY : -.. .. ---—------- —----- WHITE - CITV CLERK . � VINK - FINANCE �� /f�� CANAqY -DEPARTMENT C I TY O F SA I NT PAU L Council ��; E �� 91UE -MAYOR Flle NO. i'`��. .��.��' O I��ZI ZGLY�CP. Ordinance N O. � 7 d lo � Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date wholly or partly within 350 feet of the property sought to be rezoned; and � WHEREAS, A public hearing before the City Council, having been con3ucted on July 28 , 1983 where all interested persons were heard, and the Council having considered all tlie facts and recommendations concerning the petition; now, therefore, THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: Section 1. That the zoning map of the City of Saint Paul, Sheet No. 38, as incorporated by reference in Section 60. 301 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, as amended, is hereby further amended as follows: That property located on the northeast corner of Belvidere and Oakdale, being more particu- larly described as Lots 19, 20 and 21, Block 12 , W. St. Paul Real Estate and Improvement Snydicate ' #1, be and is hereby rezoned from R-4 to RT-2 . Section 2. , This ordinance shall take effect and be in force thirty (30) days from and after its passage, approval and publication. 2 . ` COUNCILMEN Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays Fletcher c.n� In Favor Mase�: Nicosfa B scne�bei Against y Tedesco Wilson Form Approved by City Attorney Adopted by Council: Date Cer;ified Passed by Council Secretary BY By Approved by Mayor: Date Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council BY BY �� S �.. ., IY. � '�.. � �• ! j . . t : °" �. �� § :� x.7 �te a . �p J j ( _ ( �.,.��. i :,� d 1 tr i ��f ��'+ �' � § .�r 4° 4� �e�' y�,.�' f " ' �� ' ' � 3�, �', �* �� r � y � �1y { �' ',( t��Y � � t � � � � S 1 �:,h� ra � s�e � �� °��= a��i . � �,�p * �1�� 4 �` � � �� ,,,� {! a - �r � ,� � � � ��-�',��y��+'y �� : -• , , .' ' _ ; �� t v �► rr-� � r,, - �Y (F'�y"'•�� y� '� Cy� � � ��. �� .�� r � � � ° � -f��lfVl� �4��7�t:�4��# ��.R�_�� + � �'ii�� ,, � ` 4 � \ I �t ��YR��/��,.{••.��7��`,I �/1 . ,� �... ..:` �r"s " � � � � � � ��.yfy,�'y;(� , t t _ I t I_ ,�rF t 1� ��'�",��y,7t { � y�. `� i 7 ��Sync .�r.��t��'� �h � i t �t�' T t� � r, r J � F3 _ ,•�� i �r .�. �• .� '� F �rt� -. ;- �.r r '�: � _ t r; i , � � F.l.,y � Y� � �,7 ��, � L 4 � y- r, �'f Y t� � � ,:, _ } � f . $• 1,� � .::�q� � � �' �r ''� 'S r " l� {" f 9 1 T '� I i , F l "� �* ' �i-y�� y ' ' Y�, ��-r L9 � � �,f y� 1�� 111i,�� t-.' J.��.. s �3 � �_� �'. � �t. c i � ��i � : � ,� + ,'�_ 1 _ ` i .,� �/L, Y � t _ � `�:_ f ^� f � ./ { J r�,� S_�. j R 1 �, u: l � - 4 . _� �" el � � _ � � j + � � .:, > r. , ` t . + � + y�:1 eF '` ,�"1✓a�� {fl��r.�'B ��1.�'�.�`�" `� '� t F-�J �� . ._ J � - �`� �� ' '/��t, �: al.;� ,� i ��:� J� �r , Y ,� r+ �,... f�� 7n �', n' �`.,�F�if•Jf,; l t ro .. d• �''� tN� . ,� - H i.'. ; t..' ; y� � Y � s r � i4r�� 4 � ,, i. � � ,-� �' -��J ,a ; � t a r' ' .:,{ .,t� _` t' � ,�i ` � :i; c n•�' ♦ a `: t , y�C. � C\ � ��5�` {' ( �� k i �'I� `!r r• j �� i� :;. l � � -. . Q� , �, ` ,' i �.. � �; �., '> " ! _ � s�S` .y L 2 �► rt�an�i��.� c+�T�� °copi�s a�� .�+', �A�� '�� a�t1 �� €a�' '' ,� � ' � �d� , - "'��€1��`�t"�� . x°�� r��o3u;��i��ex�f;•��t+�l:� �h�: �;' � �y �, .;s r; � `��, :�`t�uutrc�.,� �i:t��c�b�r 2ft��;�.4$�.` ; %�rv ' �. �� l y : � �.? `�, �.. a� I � � t t '` , ,� � SR 2 ? ,. �$E'�'F,��•�;I�1p�,]'Sy a � -f '. f a �. F t � � / '.�� r ,' r �'� + - ° :1 ° � �3 7 �,��.''f��}d'" �d � �. . ,1 � s t ��E✓- '.e . p , x ` �� y � y�, �,/J�� t } Yf 1 IC k .. ' ' {�� .y�♦ .��Fl��Z, *�J- � �� k '� .�� _: r J `�G�� .��'� I / t t ) i ; `��y 1 M � r � � .. �.. S _. ` . � � '�Mi� i � ` ' � '�.� / / {� � �. [ . 'Y. � � i y E� �= � � 1{ r��.�4'1JaW�.'�R,��Q' ( {� J �� # i;r { ' f'� 'l }. �'( ~ � " . .� �' t � {(+. r 3/ , 1'.� I a t �f' _, J �. i � i 1�.' � �� k :� t .°7 � � i _� � �, � � ,� � .iQ. � �� z tt t, � �fi� u �. }• `F `. j .� � i 1 f� � t '�.'S � � f� A, a q.�� F ' t 1 �� E �f f�+�`� �' i *t { � r � ! �, r , . . k �. :3 i . ° �� t f � p � '�'1 �! � I..� }. � � I t - t G 1 � {; ' } • �,t ( � � . e t�'' �P �' f ` a . � �'�� ,r � .... rc i a 1 . . � y, .� . r ��;�� Y.: i � �� l x ��s � F ' ) l�4� �.`. � � ,� � ' � �� ti x T i \ � } t 1, Y � - � �Y' t "_ �'.i p 4 * ��'�� r 5 ;.;� I - t I . ...7 . ^ : r • 7 . � �r � � l�: . 25..��. 1 , � � . �f ti Y � . �� r ' � r e. rti . .d�� i � � a .d�� ,( �r E � � t.� � F � i i ` �:� ; f ,.. , ;. ... .:� �+ a�" � ��.� �t(�. r ,�`:1 .., a^•, > } w �+ '� '� _ i � t�� : . d.. � .t' 3, r s 4 �� i, t A i �1 •� � 1 � � �i� : , • .� ,.. ,- '!�t � . '�-4 '�� y -'J _ �:y q S f''I I i' , f �� I. 'f r - � ,(_ `+ � � .l ��. � i� � '�/ t i � , �. ,', , _, i . t �. � ._i n �. .1 f r lt � � � � r A. r � �' � � f �t 5.�� ,t�' � � \ 5� i�1,�k �. M ��:r - :. . I / ` } .J `_ A {. .}- ,f. - .e . . , .... . :7. .±e�.n�2_. ...e � .. �'S.' .:� . ,....y.. . _ .... ._...y_. ...,.. i � .,�.i�..,a...a ....�.,t .w._ . -, .._ ....1�.a-�.. : «�... -. : . .. .. .� .;........� .,... � STATE OF MINNESOTA ) �fy County of Ramsey ) ss. `,� CITY OF SAINT PAUL ) C'� C�2 Ctit Albert B. Olson. I. . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . .. . . . . . .City Clerk of the � City of Saint Paul, Minnesota, do hereby certify that I have �_` compared the attached copy of Council File No. . 280958. . . . . . . . , . , . `�' as adopted by the City Council. . . . , , October. 20;. . . . . , . . . . 19.83, . . :.�� and approved by the Mayor. . . . . . . . . . , October_ 21:, . . . . . . , . . 19.83. . . ,;�:.� � with the original thereof on file in my office. I further certify that said copy is a true and correct copy of said original and the whole thereof. WITNESS my hand and the seal of the City of Saint Paul, Minnesota this . , , , 17th . , . . , day of . , , ,August. , . . , , , .A.D. 19.$4 . . . . . . . . . . �.� ��-:�. . . .��. .��:!. . . . . . City Clerk. �v , :. � _��°-��. � �- e�.. -., y„ $ .,.� � � rn ' nr � s .� , • i . �.��,�;, �t �� : , _ ^ t ,.�. >>. � �a� ;�.. � � � _. � . . Se; , � � .. _ ( wH�TE � ciTr LLEHK COUfICII •�'^,, �'�F'�Cf PINK ;, - FINANCE GITY OF SAINT PAUL z�.��a �L ;-.n�[AAV - DEPARTMENT ', �`• 1 �B'_V F -'1NA V pp File N O. ' , 0'j'� Zn 'n ''P, Ordinance N O. ��d �'T � � Presented By �- <- - Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date � ,� An Ordinance amending Chapter 60 of the � Saint Paul Legislative Code pertaining to ,.� zoning for the City of Saint Paul and the M zoning maps thereof. (� � WHEREAS, Pursuant to Minnesota Statutes §462 . 357 and §64.210 of the Legislative Code, Delores and Milton Elliott duly petitioned to rezone Lots 19, 20 and 21, Block 12, W. St. Paul Real Estate and � Improvement Syndicate #1, located on the northeast corner of � Belvidere and Oakdale, from R-4 to RT-2 to permit construction of three four-plexes, the petition having been certified as having been consented to by at least 67� of the owners of the area of the - property to be rezoned, and further having been consented to by at least two-thirds of the owners of the property situated within 100 feet of the total contiguous descriptions of real estate held by the same owner or any party purchasing any such contiguous property within one year preceding the date of the petition; and WHEREAS, The current Zoning Committee on July 7, 1983 conducted a public hearing for the purpose of considering the rezoning petition, and pursuant to Section 107. 03 of the Administrative Code, submitted its recommendation to the Planning Commission that the petition be granted; and WHEREAS, The Planning Commission considered the rezoning petition at its meeting held on July 8, 1983 and recommended that the City Council approve the petition; and WHEREAS, Notice of a public hearing before the City Council on the said rezoning petition was duly published in the official newspaper of the City on July � l6 , 1983 and notices were duly mailed to each owner of affected property and property situated COUNC[LMEN Yeas Naps Requested by Department of: Fletcher �,'� �,ii,s [n Favor Masanz Nicosla � Against BY Scheibel Tedesco Wiison Adopted by Council: Date Form Approyed y City Att y i7 � � �/ Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY \ `'"''° , J By � Approved by Mayor: Date Approv d}�y Mayor fot Submission to Council �i By —_ BY -- � . _ WHITE - CITV CLERK � �.>�}p^g�-+ PINK �.� � FINANCE �- COLflC1I �ay � ."��1� -c�•NwRr � DEPARTMENT GITY OF SAINT ��AUL File NO. �'•�v . o 't'� � 9LUE -MAVOR � r � • y�a .y�A y� Q !/ O/ WZ/`�L/I�CG Ordinance NO. � 7C� � 7 Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Daie ,o � � wholly or partly within 350 feet of the property sought to be K rezoned; and � � WHEREAS, A public hearing before the City Council, having been `� conducted on July 28, 1983 where all interested persons were heard, and the Council having considered all the facts and recommendations concerning the petition; now, therefore, THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: Section 1. That the zoning map of the City of Saint Paul, Sheet No. 38, as incorporated by reference in Section 60. 301 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, as amended, is hereby further amended as follows: That property located on the northeast corner of Belvidere and Oakdale, being more particu- larly described as Lots 19, 20 and 21, Block 12, W. St. Paul Real Estate and Improvement Snydicate #l, be and is hereby rezoned from R-4 to RT-2. Section 2. This ordinance shall take effect and be in force thirty (30) days from and after its passage, approval and publication. 2 . COUNCILMEN Yeas Naps Requested by Department of: Fletcher '� ceu� �— In Favor Masenz Nicosta � Against BY Scheibel : Tedesco � W°S°° 1983 QCT 2, � Form Appc ved y City Attor ey � � Adopted by Council: Date � Certified P ssed by Co��l Secretar J (� BY �� `r�� B � ��..... 'a .�...�� Y � CT �6 Appr ve y Mayor: D t Appro ed y Mayor for Su mission to Council � .' � By BY — PUBLISHED OCT 2 9 1983 3 ..;� *� �' � � ? � A� � `z � � � ^' �' �' �� O —1 ► b � � � � � � � � � � � � _ a � C �' 3 `� a �' ° � O '. �1�1 O �T) N � ., a � T o �" �� C '•, O � �rt � � n � Z � C1 � 'O � V`' ,,,�� 1 z �T:iU o Q 3 � N N � � � � ��'�, ' � � � ° F� c°, -* 3 � � � � �� o � . N � � � • -� � �, N A� � � , � • � � N � � 3 ..i v � m4 � ; • � _' � I`7 � .�.2 � c,. '� � • C,r'� N � �,' � �' ' � � �� T �. • � � �..�_. � —G ,... ✓ �. .0 "'�t`.,. +,: . n' r. s .,, r .�. r .,'H: , . .�,r / +��*`�� 4C �C t T T O . . .. a ' • . r . �'+% .p✓� ° � •�� C ITY OF SA I�1��11 L a � i r. ` �__�� a DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT �� DIVISION OF PLANNING � 25 West Fou�th Street,Saint Paul,Minnesota 55102 '"� 612-292-1577 GEORGE LATIMER MAYOR July 26, 1983 Albert Olson, City Clerk Room 386 City Hall St. Paul , Minnesota 55102 RE: Zoning File #9376 - Elliott City Council Hearing: July 28, 1983 PURPOSE: Rezone property at the northeast corner of Belvidere and Oakdale from R-4 to RM-2 to permit construction of 3 four-plexes. PLANNING COMMISSION DECISION: Approve RT-2 (13-0) ZONING COMMITTEE DECISION: Approve RT-2 (4-0) STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Deny RM-2 Approve RT-2 SUPPORT: 1 person testified OPPOSITION: 4 people testified; 4 letters received in opposition Dear Sir: On May 19, 1983, the Zoning Committee of the Planning Commission held a public hearing on this proposed rezoning. The developer was present and explained his proposal . Four people spoke in opposition stating that the property was too small ; there would not be enough parking and that they pre- ferred single family development on that parcel . At the close of the meeting, the Zoning Committee voted to continue the public hearing on June 16, 1983 so that more information could be provided. On June 16, 1983, the Zoning Committee again considered this proposal . Four people again appeared in opposition. The developer was not present. At the close of the public hearing, the Zoning Committee voted to lay the matter over to the July 7, 1983 meeting to give the petitioner time to respond to the proposed rezoning to RT-2. At the July 7, 1983 Zoning Committee meeting, a letter was received from the developer indicating that the RT-2 rezoning would be acceptable. At the close of that meeting, the Zoning Committee voted 4-0 to approve the rezoning to RT-2. On July 8, 1983, the Planning Commission upheld the Zoning Committee's recommendation for rezoning to RT-2 on the vote of 13-0. This rezoning is scheduled to be heard by the City Council on July 28, 1983. Please notify me by July 27 if any member of the City Council wishes to have slides of the site presented at the public hearing. _ �� atricia . �}ames City Planner PNJ:sb Attachments ��C�r-�'�) . . , _ , �.,r.,_, ,�4��9i,1 • . � � � �/ O(Y� MINUTES OF THE ZONING COMMITTEE IN CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS, ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA ON JULY 7, 19E3 PRESENT: Mme. Summers; Messrs. Armstead, Bryan, Lanegran, of the Zoning Committee; Mr. Segal , Assistant City Attorney; Ms. Lane of the Division of Housing & Building Code Enforcement; Ms. Beseman, Ms. James and Ms. McNeally of the Planning Division Staff. ABSENT: Mme. Karns; Messrs. Levy and Pangal . The meeting was chaired by James Bryan, Chairman. DELORES & MILTON ELLIOTT #9376 : Rezone from R-4 to RM-2 to permit cons ruc ion o re�-p exes on property located on the northeast corner of Belvidere and Oakdale. Public hearing was closed on June 16, 1983. Mr. Bryan reported that the applicant submitted a letter stating that he would accept an RT-2 rezoning. Mr. Armstead moved approval of rezoning to RT-2 based on findings l , 2, 4-7, 9, 13, 14 and the staff analysis. Ms. Summers seconded the motion, which passed on a roll call vote ot 4 to 0. Submitted by: Approved by: �--"`_ , �� <. �I j'� ;�-� Patricia N. Jarnes James Bryan, Ch�i-rma� ;,, ., - ,;� �' �,,,.5,'"'"'y�, ; � �' -�.� � , _ ; , , � I �- , . , _. � � � � � 1 . _ � � I � ; j � E ; ' . ; ; 1 , ; , ; . . , � ; � � � ; . : i ; : ; i � � . , . '�;��?�I�� . , �' ''c .�.;` / � , ' ' � / �� / MINUTES OF THE ZONING COMMITTEE IN CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS, ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA ON JUNE 16, 1983 PRESENT: Mmes. Karns; Messrs. Armstead and Bryan of the Zoning Comnittee; Mr. Segal , Assistant City Attorney; Ms. Lane of the Division of Housing & Building Code Enforcement; Ms. Beseman, Mr. Ford, Ms. James and Ms. McNeally of the Planning Division Staff. ABSENT: Mme. Summers; Messrs. Lanegran, Levy and Pangal . The meeting was chaired by James Bryan, Chairman. DELORES & MILTON ELLIOTT #9376) : Rezone from R-4 to RM-2 to permit construction of three 4-p exes on property located on the northeast corner of Belvidere and Oakdale. The applicant was not present. There was opposition present at the hearing. Ms. James showed slides of the site and presented a revised staff report recomnending denial of the RM-2 but supporting a rezoning to RT-2. One additional letter was received in opposition since the meeting of May 19. , Raymond Mishler, 200 Belvidere, stated that he would not object to putting 3 single family homes on the site but would oppose three 4-plexes or two 4-plexes; it would overcrowd the site and lower his property value. Martin Seidl , 235 Belvidere, spoke in opposition because of the parking • situation and the problems that currently exist with vehicles on Belvidere. He stated that he would not object to a couple of nice apartments or 2-family homes. Louis Shields, 245 Belvidere, stated that his only objection was the parking problem and indicated that h� would not be in opposition to the construction of two duplexes. Theresa Bock, 212 Belvidere, testified in opposition because of the con- stant traffic on Belvidere, the narrowness of the street in the winter, and the f act that there is not enough room on the lot to accomnodate three 4-plexes and parking. Hearing no further testimony, Mr. Bryan closed the public hearing portion of the meeting. Mr. Armstead made a motion to lay the matter over to July 7, 1983, to allow time for the developer to respond to the staff recommendation. Ms. Karns seconded the motion, which passed on a unanimous voice vote. Submitted by: Appr. ved by: ^ ' � �-- �..._......_._.�%:Z t�-� Patricia N. James :dames Bryan, C- hairman . � .� � I I i.:�itM.;:� � , � � � . ! ,. _ I i _ ; i _ ; � 1 _ , , . . ; , i ; _ : � , � 1 , �. . I % I , � � � � �� . �• . . � � � l7a� y MINUTES OF THE ZONING COMMITTEE IN CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS, ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA ON MAY 19, 1983 PRESENT: Mme. Summers; Messrs. Armstead, Bryan, Lanegran, Levy, and Pangal of the Zoning Committee; Mr. Segal, Assistant City Attorney; Ms. Lane of the Division of Housing & Building Code Enforcement; Ms. Beseman, Mr. Ford, and Ms. James of the Planning Staff. ABSENT: Mme. Karns. The meeting was chaired by James Bryan, Chairman. DELORES & MILTON ELLIOTT (#9376) : Rezone from R-4 to RM-2 to permit construction of three 4-plexes for property located on the northeast corner of Belvidere and Oakdale. The applicant was present. There was opposition present at the hearing. Ms. James showed slides of the site and reviewed the staff report with a recommendation to lay the matter over to enable petitioners to provide additional information. Two letters were received in opposition. John McQuillan, 415 Selby, developer, reported that the architect is working on the plans. Their proposal is to construct 1-bedroom homes for single people or young couples that will sell for under $40,000. Raymond Mishler, 200 E. Belvidere, spoke in opposition stating that the lots are too small to build three 4-plexes and there would not be enough space to provide off-street parking. Ruth Seidl, 235 E. Belvidere, stated opposition because of the parking situation and the size of the lots. Pat Bruhn, 169 E. Belvidere, stated that her main opposition was parking; there isn't enough on-street parking. She was also concerned about vandalism and the fact that rental property would lower property values in the neighborhood. Mrs. Bock, 212 E. Belvidere, testified in opposition to rental property because of past experiences in the neighborhood. She also stated that parking was a problem. The Committee unanimously voted to continue the public hearing to June 16, 1983. Submitted by: � Approved by: � ' � -� r �r _/�_./ ti, ----. Patricia N. James �a�des Bryan, Ch rman %,. , .,�,,., � � � -, �, `� ; • j i f _ E , . ; _ , � : . ' � �, � a �� . . - ; � � ,I � ; ; . . , ; � � � � , � i f ; I � , : � � � � .. i � ZONING STAFF REPORT +r�,a��t+��+j� � - . . , _. .. � �,,. . . . . • /�D��{ l . APPLICANT: DELORES & MILTON ELLIOTT . DATE OF HEARING 5/19/83 2, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , CLASSIFICATION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . CURRENT PLANNING & ZONING COMMITTEE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS . Rezoning �7 Var�ance ❑ Special Condition Use ❑ Administrative Review ❑ Determination of Similar Use ❑ Other ❑ Change of Nonconforming Use ❑ Other ❑ 3. LOCATION: Northeast corner Belvidere and Oakdale. 4. LEGAL DESCRIPTION: Lots 19, 20, 21 , Block 12, W. St. Paul Real Estate and Improvement Syndicate #1 5. PRESENT ZONING: R-4 ZONING CODE REFEREP�CE: Section 60.450 6. STAFF INVESTIGATION & REPORT: DATE 5/9/83 BY Patricia N. James Rev_ised 6/14/83 A. PURPOSE: Rezone to RM-2 to permit construction of three four-plexes. B. SUFFICIENCY: Petition found sufficient by Planning Division on April 22, 1983. Parcels eligib e: 18; parcels needed: 12; parcels signed: 12. C. PARCEL SIZE: Irregular parcels. Lot 19, 40' (Oakdale) x 120' =� 4,800 square feet. Lot 20, 36' (Oakdale) x approximately 120' (Belvidere) = 5,495 square feet. Lot 21 , 30' (Belvidere� x approximately 127' = 4,963 square feet. Portion of alley = 1 ,907 square feet. Total : 17,165 square feet. D. EXISTING LAND USE: Most of the site is vacant. There is a single family house 4n Lot 21 . The alley is umimproved. The site has irregular terrain, sloping down to the north and below grade along Belvidere. E. SURROUNDING LAND USE: , North: Single family residential (R-4) East: Single family residential (R-4) South: Single family residential (R-4� West: Vacant single family residential (R-4) . Duplexes are located to the northwest (RT-1 ) F. ZONING HISTORY: The site was zoned "B" residence prior to 1975, when it was rezoned R-4. G. FINDINGS: l . Applicants propose vacation of the adjacent alley and consolidation of three lots to create one developable parcel . 2. The development will consist of 12 one-bedroom ownership units in three buildings of 4 units each, for a total of 24 rooms. 3. The RM-2 zoning would permit 28 rooms (14 units) . . 4. Four-plexes are first permitted in the RT-2 district. Fifteen rooms (7 units) would be permitted under RT-2 zoning. With a density variance of 1 room, 8 units would be permitted on the site. 5. Land Use Plan policy 4.1-4 states : "On ,scattered vacant sites in existing neighbor- hoods, the city will establish criteria which willallow new housing development at densities somewhat higher than the existing zoning but compatible with the � general existing pattern of development. " 6. The Housing Policy Plan supports construction of alternatives to single family detached dwellings (1-1 ) , and smaller l , 2, and 3 bedroom ownership housing units (1-2) . 7. Housing Policy Plan policy 1-4 states: Every new development will be planned and designed to enhance and complement existing neighborhood character. New development should not simply add to, but should improve and strengthen what exists." 8. Housing Policy Plan policy 1-5A encourages duplexes and sometimes triplexes suitable for owner occupancy on lower density residential infill sites. � �� • . .. . ,:.j�.�" . a '";. � . . � /�0�� DELORES & MILTON ELLIOTT (#9376) STAFF REPORT Page 2 G. FINDINGS CONT'D. --- 9. Housing Policy Plan objective 2A states: ". . .provide that a major portaon of new owner- ship units will be affordable to moderate income households." 10. The Street & Highway Plan classifies Oakdale as a collector and Belvidere as a local street. 11 . According to the Transit Plan, the nearest bus is on Robert Street, two blocks away. 12. The intent of the RM-2 district is to provide more extensive multiple-family areas and to establish a balance of population concentration as related to major thoroughfares and transit. 13. The intent of the RT-2 district is to provide space for 2-, 3-, and 4-family and townhouse structures and provide for housing that "has many of the amenities of single family dwellings arranged in a low density, multiple-family pattern. " 14. The site's uneven topography may make it advisable to develop this largely vacant site in some other way than individual single family detached lots. 15. The site plan submitted by petitioner shows that three four-plexes could not be built on this site without substantial variances, including parking, mini.mum distance between buildings, and yards. H. STAFF ANALYSIS: This proposal would conform to a number of comprehensive plan housing policies. However, the site plan submitted by the petitioner does not meet zoning code standards in many areas. The proposal appears to overcrowd this site and would not seem to "enhance and complement existing neighborhood character." Two structures of four units each could probably be constructed on this site without such substantial variances. I. STAFF RECOI�IENDATION: Based on findings 1 through 5, 7, 8, 10, 11, 12, 15 and the staff analysis, staff recommends denial of the rezoning to RM-2. Based on findings 1, 2, 4-7, 9, 13, 14 and the staft analysis, staff would support a rezoning to RT-2. %D f e ��a�c..� .-l.�c�L.�L �Z�'� `t��.�.cp-�t, ( 1 . ',� fi y�y� _------- _ lJ�` �-- _.�_ - -�— • � Y �''r�p 3� P9--a-�`�,�, . , � � .� n �.�-°.�' PETITION TO AMEND ZONING CODE � ` CITY OF SAINT PAUL ZONING OFFICE USE ONLY ��s`?��C�a � � __ ,'a �4�.r1 File �i _ _ ___,^ _�.ZQ�� Application Fee $ �.3� � �� Tentative Hearing Date _��f�� Number of Lots or Size of Parcel: 3 TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL DATE ��(�� 19 � 3 c/o Zoning Office, 1100 City Hall Annex St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Pursuant to Section 64.210 of the St. Paul Zoning Ordinance and Section 462.357 (5) of the ' A , , the owner of all Minnesota Statutes, Q� ��c��r��„ __ _ of the land proposed for rezoning, hereby petitions your Honorable Body to rezone the following � • Cc►�- • described property: N� �� '��" � �GG�I�� Street Addres�i-�`.aJ��l�_-�t� ce�-�' _oZ. /-�- �------------l�--��=��s['1'�` Legal nescription:��? l��_� _4Zm� - ---- _--'---------�------ � � � ----�_��----------- from a �= `�' ____�iv�.C�_ , District ----------------------- to a �.�--�----�---�-� - ,-- �-_- ��z2�.d��. __ District for the purpose of � E� _ ___ _�_ _ __�1 . _.__�� ..:...., : r.. � _ ._ . ... _� . .,.. _. q3�_ .b ., i _. _ � _ _. , Subscribed and sw rn to By� -e�� --�---------------- before this ��3 day �c� of � �-�-------19 �.3_ Title: �J--- Petitioner-----------�---------� G�`([-t'�/'r'�iL��/(�� !�/_(�,/�-�"-�'W i.� ....._... . � ._,... '��.; ..�,,,u�',�..,�J� .. _ /y .� ' Notary Publ� APR 1 > ?:::73 � r ROSEMARV FRFCET�E r �+ +' "' �'•� � '' PdKe 1 Gf ' ` �� NOTARV PUBIIC—��11NNESU1'A �� ° '� �.�'h' 9 1 �'�.i:'¢ �`- '3: °�ll➢' RAMSfY COUNTY '_t � t :��fi�'i�d„� flo- ° '_.�r" k*�b��'�� FO�O My Comm L'x�ves f,pril 23, 1987 1�1�82 Y WV��l�J`JWWVVW� + ( l .. �` `�1�snp��/j�Mx.�:.�. .. , 1 . '.. . F � � .. - _ f � � ;: � � , � 4 , .. .. � ; _ , I � '. i � •. ; _ _ i I .. ; , ; � i i .:� . ' � 7 , I � � � � . �II�LAN ,g �� . � rr� Ro a . � S /� ��/ Since 1883 • C� �1��1,� C�r!Cli �� O: c� c � � �i 8'3 /� r 1 I/ � � v � � ��-�-�` � � ' , � � ��, . � �� •--�'4� ' . C�� J'� 1,�.� `�X. , , ��-a'� `� � c� � , � � -: .:::.,'�.. �..;`•,r`'h". , .. :� . . _ �� "' �;� � ..I,. . . ' . �. .:4�ir��: �; .:t_��:�Ul�:7!�:_ ... _'t-�i��'(�j�t��. J� 415 Selby Avenue Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 225-0124 � � � ► ��..--.r , . � . . ` ; ; �� . � ; ; � , . , . _ .. _ ; .. � , � . j � i ` 1 � . , , . . "�---.,�. �. � I�I � (.'' � �� : �� 9 ��i . � . .� �°�� - : � �� :,, , s. �t ` ll� ' �I (1 �� ./�/N , . .�t�y�'�,, 1 g 8 �__ , �� i�Cil� (,C�l"��'�� ,� ��;�� ;.. .::, ;a�,�,�y��i`;u � co�,� j9 3�. !- � . . . . . . ''"r''�/ T�AN ��l f,S�,� . �► :; � . � �.A! �� ;�(/ '�..� f�' flY� �..ii%?�/��/1%� (� ��i,�� - �'f � _�" ' \, M�'�,4�� ,�,� �,...� � • � �� / , '..��- ,.�� !�G'%��L/ •� �'/I LC��vCc�, � ��v�/_�, �� .,%/�1;� ,�.'G',.l'"i',� ��/ ' �`�`�' '��"o!+;.� /`,��{ . r /�t!/ ��/ `~� � �/ �'� {,/�C� ,Y��!�� ;./��.C.�1 j` ��2� ,Gi✓ L/"-�'- � , ,� � ,, . , � /��.-�� i'�?��1`�//''i�l-�� !•�/.Clit`� .�!�sL(/r'-% �G�%t��'.L�'1 ,�"�• � � -�/ ' ��// „ 'n ,.' �� / , > .�� r��f�.["c�'�'�l I ��K=v�GC�J ��,i�J �u.f�(/�r� �Ci 1' �1 ; � �i . '�LL�,�./ �LG`� ��(.:% %�� ,L��...�/'�� L(��j,�w'✓l. �✓ /�i�C..! //,.-��✓�L/ !:� / J � � � ' � i .v`Gl��Y,/�� i`�.,f ijr�:'�� ,% ,/`��!%r�': �f7�� .�(l�' �/i�'"�v?'i �r� �� i�E;��%i�,,;;%�;�:��:,!�;. ,��%r�.:;�, GL'��",,%%�`�r�,v�� j�.i �fr,C G�i ii�:/ ./;%,i�` ,d*:%�� GCf�"�� nn� ✓ i i1�!�-� ,�t�.c'�lr �?''�� „ �,,�:,�. � `�. �{,( r��i .,. ` � -��. ,�' ,�-G��'f�, ..1:'/� ,l./:.��- ; ,..(:: .�,� :,�/"t:-�/f-j C��.�!. ",�� , �./ ��./.,0�:}�� /,/t%.0 °�!��"i .f' (;:G'%;- LL��G� ,C�u�!'i' uU I / . �,/J.1!, r.i%' �j//��.:��' ,/-,�`�` . .��!,�y'r � �j // ' � au%� ✓ CC%'/,l/.�'(_� ��i',�/,�.,�r�.,'� ��%�� •f<,�G�..° � �i�;/_i i.,✓' ;!;/'J �/�� .j!��:��r;/:��j��!',�:� !/ �'� , t' � , � .�w� �<<�-,,'�;�r f% ��,.;�� <� ��- -��.��.� _�;, :, `� � �� = f�'- ,��ifi.1i_- �'r�. ,�t��f.. /�;%�`,% , �`�sj�",� ��,:�� /r/ ��9 � � �/ � t, �f'i/�t-//� ` /�i.�� ;�,L�C'/�j-f,'!• , �' �!.!r ,.�%%�� .�i(i�i ,Y,/i,%�: ��' ( - � � � •` � � �. D� �. `'�� C �f%C%��>"% .G�iy,'�1�, ,��i`� ��.,�;��i , /�/��L�j �"� GLILU f:.�A�/.�L'�1, �L'�`v (," i�✓C /�G .�c� .C��C�/;,:/"i U ✓ ; � :;:�Y�G�` ��.��,� ��,o �C�/�l'i,'`,�' �_�,>>,��.,� �=%�r�� . ✓ C'% �` ��/Y"ii ��G�i ,�/%��,/�ii';�..��i . � ; � � , {.� ��/ /s � i� , � ,� ; �%v.) ��/ :%L� �r.,,,,f.�j _1 L, j� �..- '1 ��L`.-G" �J.- �7 0,��. ✓ /` V✓I% i/ '�l� , � L� .<,l.��r.�'%l�//i,;Y��i� ��'��!-�%�;� ,,i;;./✓� •% C;;; � , � = � � , � : � � � �� f � �:�- �► , ( . , .,; � . ' : ,, �.� � �� ; ; , � ° . . � , . � ► � �� , � � , , : � { � { ; `'i i � , .. � - : , � � � � � �� :��^��: . . � - _ .'a �r� : ,' . . " ��1P�l T0: ZONING COMMITTEE OF ST. PAUL PLANNING COMMISSION FROM: Mark W. Schadegg & Bronwyn M. Mann Schadegg R,�' : Rezoning of Lots 19, 20 & 21, Block 12 W. St . Paul Real Estate & Improvement Synd. #1 . Zoning File No . 9376 Zoning File Name - Elliot To Whom It May Concern : NIy wife and I own the property at 194 E . Curtice . Our property borders in part the lots 19, 20 & 21, Block 12 W. St . Paul Real Estate and Improvement Synd. #1, which is purposed for rezoning from R-4 to RM-2 . My wife and I would like to voice our opposition to this rezoning for the following reasons ! l . The rezoning would allow the construction of 3 four-plex,es for a total of 12 units . This is far too many units for this srnall of an area. 2. In the plans I have seen, there is nb allotment for off- street parking . Nor in my opinion, would there be room for such on these small lots . This poses a major problem in that in these times it is fair to assume that there will be a mimimum of one car per unit and even two cars for some of the units . So it is a fair assumption that there will be 16 or 18 cars to be parked. With Oakdale being a snow emergency route and a very busy street , this conjestion of parked cars could be hazerdouse as well as being a nuisance and eyesore. 3. The neighborhood is a family oriented neighborhood now. I feel that the proposed building will have a detrimental effect on that family orientation. I base that feeling on the size of the units . The plans I saw showed only one bedroom units which is not very conductive with a family environment . 4. The present looks of the home now on one of the lots is in my opinion not very good and because of the looks of this present property I question the management abilities with 12 units . 5. Based on the above mentioned, I believe that construction of these four-plexes will have an adverse affect on the value 's of surrounding property . My wife and I also have unanswered questions that should b� brought up at your hearing : M AY 1�� .i.`,;�,� ' �. . '� �•� �. .: - �5~ �� ` � `.,1 k ':i.��•�� 'rf` .. =:' .',a+..� i.:--• c:.•.�.' . .. ..� � I ��""�"`�� , � � ' � . .. � . ' 4 • � i . '� . .. , .� � � . . ' . I � f , : i � i i I � . j . ; i . i . i ` � , , ; � , , �� ' �� . � ,r='"�`'"�'�r . . . . . .� 1 . Who com rises this ? I��tl p popari of investors . And what experience do they have in this exact field? 2 . Who will own the units upon completion? Will they be rented? Sold as Condo 's? Sold as a whole to other investors? 3. If they keep and rent the units, how long will they own them? 4 . What assurances do we have that they aren't just in this for a fast buck and that they even care about the neighborhood? My wife and I urge you all to deny this rezoning proposal ! Keep the neighborhood as it is ! ! ! We also urge these investors to build single family homes on the lots. I am sure there are profits to Ue made in single family homes . If these investors do build single family homes : 1 . They would make a profit (perhaps not as much as they are counting on with their four-plexes, but a profit just the same) . 2 . The neighborhood would remain unchanged, a nice family oriented neighborhood, Out of state business obligations keep me from attending this meeting in person. I hope this letter will be heard by all per- sons concerned. If there are any further meetings on this matter, I will make every effort to attend. If your committee has any questions of ine, please feel free to call . PLEASE DENY THIS REZONING PROPOSAL! ! ! ! ! Sincerely, Mark W, Sc adegg -�%�� - . Bronwyn M. Mann Schadegg � . t�`� -- 4: � 2,. � -r•• •.� i i . � ' � � i ' � . , � � � t � I � i I ( r ' I I I I � . • � � . .. . . .. � . . �;��'t�� . � � . . , .�� . . . . . f7a�o� May 9, 1983 � ��j ��" �!�� '�' C! �� I� I�! Zoning Committee ;;;,_;�� ; �, ,; ,:� St. Paul Planning Commission �""� ' ��'�� St. Paul, MN 55102 CITY �-'�-i;;;:,��;� �:��ll S:;�n,* �: . ;. �: ,,.,,.:; a _ .., i In regards to the proposed zoning change for Lots 19, 20 & 21 , Block 12 W. St, Paul Real Estate & Improvement S9nd. #1 , Zoning File N � Z6 File Name Elliot. _._.. , .......�.�,....�.�.,�. I as a home owner strongly object to the development of four-plexes in this neighborhood particularly in front of my own home . I have completely remodeled my own home and increased my own property value and the building of these proposed four-plexes on this particular plot would decrease the property value on surrounding properties, add increased traffic levels on moderately quiet residential streets. Increased traffic would also increase noise levels and would be an invitation for vandalism and o ther vises. Having been a home owner here for 10 years, I am strongly going to protest this proposal by letters and petitions, if needed. Thank you. Gregory & Barbara Dalton 236 E. Belvidere St. Paul, MN 55107 _ . �. ' - r . ; . z:. � ( .� �� : � � � . � , � . , , ; . � ; , ; � � � . � .` ; � . � , , � ; , _ ; � � ,. . _ ' ' � . - � �� CLN � � � ` - . . May 19, 1983 j�?��t� �' r�, ,.� .,7 �� / � �/i ! �. � � ��D�v� / f / `�' /t/ ;., ....,. j ` ��,�,,�' � ,� ,,,� � ,'' .� �.,,,,. ;�, �� ,,, � � / � ��" � /'�.. �:•'w.M r;,►.. � � (��..� .� .. ... i.;r. �l , �t� ��` �'�/' -� ff .� � M�, ! � /� �....a�..J .� ..�, h � '�- .� ' ��-�� t _ ._ , � -� � �� , 7� � f ,. , � � ,�a,�� r�,� � � � �� ,��.,.� :,.� :� , .. � � "�^� ..� . L..� / ; 1, � , , // � ,;� t;;,•��; / -,' � � ,.. 1 � �� ' .- / ��,�`��. � �`� f. ,�,� �c 7" ��,br��,.r� `� ,n � �� '�) �' / i: `''1'�L- ,•�' � , � /y �"�;�-,�� ,-� �� -� .�,, ti� � . � � , � >>,_. �;' �, -.�;:.... 5,r...�',�.�-- �.� ,:. � �. ..,,� � �` � ,1, � � , , ,. , � . . . ' i ., i ; . � . , I I ' i � . i � � . � ! I _ _ , , , . , � � . i . � � , ; , , .. I � I �, � � • • � • • • • • • • • • • � , � . � • , • � ' '` • ,� ;�_� � I i l 1 ' ` , � .'�I� � � � � w � �rh� .� :/ � � � � � � �� • s • • • • � • •I� • ��■i ► � r�� N • � • ^ � � � • � • • • • • • • • • • • • �� • � � !�� • • �. • • a � w • • �� • � • . • . • • • • � « . i.`��Ti � � • � ^ . • • � • � • • • • • • . • • . • • . � r ,. r • � r---___.__. _. _ r� v � �� r �� _ - .•1�!� � � i i i �i�' •' � � �� i �i � �1 � r �� .�� : n - _ . � �i� • • • � w � 3 • • • • • • • • � � � A N • I . • ..Q ; �� • 1 � � !� �^� �� i i i � • • � � � � � � • • ' � • • • • ' • + • • • �) ' • a �; -1 . �� • f � /1� • V � • • • • • • � • • • � • • • • • • I f � �'�' � V • • • � • • • • • • • • • • � • � • • • � �'� - • �a .�■� � • , ass� . . . . � . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . - (1 , , , �• . � � � � � � � . . � � � �� L� � � � : • � . - � ■ . %/%i . . , . . . . • ► . .. . • a • • • � • • I� � " .. � / � � � • � � • • � � � � V �_� • � � � � � . � � � ' • i . . . � � - � � � a T� c� � _ �=�"`�- �'�'�',� `v- _ � 3 y9 . �, . . 3� P� y� f � JY�l!"" � � � 1� -�=- -�'`� n �., PETITION TO AMEND ZONING CODE � f Q CITY OF SAINT PAUL ZONING OFFICE USE ONLY ��'�� ;:.... , � �t�!) File �� _�D�0� Application Fee $ a3� OI �—G� Tentative Hearing Date _��/� Number of Lots or Size of Parcel: 3 TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL DATE ��1�_ 19 g 3 c/o Zoning Office, 1100 City Hall Annex St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Pursuant to Section 64.210 of the St. Paul Zoning Ordinance and Section 462.357 (5) of the � I the owner of all Minnesota Statutes, � �s��-r� _� _ � of the land proposed for rezoning, hereby petitions your HQnorable Body to rezone the following �- described property: M� ��°� � � �GU��-�Q� Street Addres�i�J1�7�t7 a�.Q _oZ_./-�- �-----------1 n�-� --��' _. Legal Description:��p J��_� _SLm� a � / ____ ___—__ __.___._—_f__ ___ from a �_�_�__ , ______District ---- - -� ----,------------------ to a ___,__��__�_____ ______ District for the purpose of �,dfi�(�.��___ __3 _ __�.1 _._. _.__ � _�__� --- �r��, �.. e � �,�� 6 �-__. __ ,, ., N � �`� � � .:��. �,%��—a--s�-� ' Subscribed and sworn to By: _____��-�_�_____.______.______ before this �� day � of ____19 �,3_ Title: ___—_ Petltioner---------------------- _ d �' ;4:�,� �?.�� ...k.�. z, _.:�L � � Notary Publ APR 1� ?��3 . . � ROSEMARY FitECETTE p� �� " ^ �w� � Page 1 Of� �—`� � NOTARY PUBLIC—M�NNESOTA f'��' �`�i�� {��Yp� i��g- �f, RAM�Y GOI;NTY �;;�,��ti��igE�� ,:y��'.3b°Eli�i�1 My Comm.Expres Aprii 23, 1987 4080 1�1�g2 Y M . . . . ��'�'�� . - : . . . ,�b �y CONSENT OF ADJOINING PROPERTY OWNERS TO REZONING We, the undersigned, owners of property within 100 feet of the total contiguous descriptions of real estate owned by Petitioner or sold by Petitioner within one year preceding the date of this petition, acknowledge that we have been furnished with the following: 1. A copy of the Petition of __ f�.,,,�� _____-�_ �__ 2. A copy of Sections _�Q,`G�.Sp _through�_�s�__, inclusive, of the St. Paul Ordinance; and acknowledge that we are aware of the uses permitted under a _��•— _a2_______ _^___ District zoning classification; and hereby consent to the rezoning of the property described in the Petition o � _ �,.,/'�L��-U _ to a �jJ District. ---t�1��-�---------- RECORD OWNER SIGIVATURE LOT BLOCK ADDIT[ON ° " �R �'-�-�.�� , , . �, � , , c� i. f , ^ ., � �, J /'�-C.�� /�;,u-ec �;'ji t�, � t`- `� �_ �f�C�.�rL-Q/ ��T� � q ' � ��c--�c% �-�,✓��i��'� :� �' q�k.,"_.c� �> > S � I i r � F;`, • , l r` `� .� : ' rYy� � - p i�. ��c.t, �E,n . � .L.C�,_.C✓1� ; ' ` .,�LL�zi C,2, �, \ G�"/ � I '—/d /°�/ ¢,.rr. �/ ,L}��( �, � ,�- , X v 4' 3.r��.ti>,�." E.. a'y'� � ��` ;� ir,� � f i� -�Z��.. � i �1 � � � ��' j !Y�'.�c—�-1��'^ jy i .;�� i.' � �L�( � /' °Z/ / �,� -`��2_!L � / 1/ t`�'�L_G�-�-�C.�'L� � � _ p �'.n -:�'� ��F�.�.,..�� Cf�Q' �� F ,��--.r-c-L- �` w/_,:�-�-�-�yc/ , e.,.: �_r !�.��'"L�-``"�-.` !� i/ r� e°�� . . .:�:/ ,� ' _ '�/► X �. ;�'c��:z<.t.c-.'�i��.� (/y � �,',� � «.._% E�, �?`. �� /!/fZ zY.L- C. /✓ � �� f'.�+.- L• '� l 7 � '/' � '.�F'k'�.e-{ E:�•(.��- ��,� ,11�_�2�;.��_L- '� � _ ��" � f.�� 1 �� ;«w .. ��: , �J)�L.c �-��; oU.L_��-r-e.�,��'�c'�` ; '.;' i f' ("J� i✓.s i�.�.; ,�.;F� �C E c' -r'.s�� ,. o:s� / .�i f� rr. �!L� �.'Q � 1Lt.�►'�-�.�l�c-'� � N4 �+(� Petitions shall not be considered as officlally.,,fileRd u�rti�:��apse of 7 working days after a petition is received in the Zoning Office. Any signator`'�'f'atiy�pe�'it+�a �ay withdraw his name therefrom bv.�„�. written req�est within that time. - / I /a P R 1 � °- ,?-,.. r, � P �, R A.. �-� � �- p ��!o , � i �"itl �� J I �83 �.� .� � ,� � � � �� '�` `, �`� �� k�,�s'a�t:�i� 2. Page 2 of �' �� I'x ��' . ---- -� � - ��"� w��.��:��t��' . `��t�� . . � I -0'+�� .-� !� . : . . ' ��a�y ' ' STATE OF MINNffiOTA) . ss. COIINTY OF RAMSEY ) � , being first duly sworn, deposes and states that he is the person w o c rc e wi m pe i ion and consent, consisting of / pages; that affiant is informed and believes that the parties described are the owners respectively of the lots placed immediately following each name, that affiant is informed and believes that eaeh of the parties described above is the owner of property which is within 100 feet from any property owned by petitioner or sold by petitioner within one (1) year preceding the date of this petition which is contiguous to the property described in the petition; that except for none of the parties described above has purchased or is purchasing proper y rom pe ioner contiguous to the above described property within one (1) year of the date of the petition; that this consent was signed by each of said owners in the presence of this affiant, and that the signatures are the true and correct signatures of each and all of the parties so described. - �� . �' r,�� `%%��(�—c�� 75�-7�� `ss'o/ e ep one u er Subscribed and sworn t before me thib /.��ey of � , ly�`;3 ry u ic . „ : � ROSEf1e�ARY FRED�TTE "� �' NOTF.RY PUBLIC—MINNESOTA �.;. RNMSEY COU�VTY My Comm.Expires April 23, 1987 Y A . � ,e�+ ��r+� '� � �{ p ��¢6.� �aae g � `3?� ' �,..� � M [, t y!�+ �+ ' a,..,.v '`�.W� �: �`d � F7�� i � l�sv :. .a ._. ... _..�,., .0 Y�_�,J,�9 Approved as to form - Feb. 80 A P R � � ��3 Planning Department Page 3 of 3 ��i'.•.. yy y�. . . ( ��• 'ia�,� E Yi:SV�`YTi��til./ �3 i_�°y',`�;,y'�.,��tt, ��!'"';1'�'�°��l T � c��Q� ��`�- `� � 3 y� . �- . . 3� �� y� � � �rn�P �.� . � . ��-d-�.,' PETITION TO AMEND ZONING CODE � ' �f � CITY OF SAINT PAUL ZONING OFFICE USE ONLY ��'�� File �f � /�D�Q� Application Fee $ a3��0I�-�- Tentative Hearing Date _��f�� Number of Lots or Size of Parcel: 3 TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL DATE ��l�Q��r 19 g 3 c/o Zoning Office, 1100 City Hall Annex St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Pursuant to Section 64.210 of the St. Paul Zoning Ordinance and Section 462.357 (5) of the ' � + , the owner of all Minnesota Statutes, � �s�_ __ _ of the land proposed for rezoning, hereby petitions your Hqnorable Body to rezone the following �vt- described property: �� G�� Street Addres��,s.J1�'�_�v a�.Q _oZ.�._� .�----.------.1�_�� • Legal Description:�tx��_� _Q�'Ir� • � � ------ ------------ ------ from a �_�_Y_�i�_ , __�_�___District -- ------------------ � • _ District toa -----��--�----- - - - — --- --------_------- for the purpose of _ _. _ ___ _3_ __�1 _._. _.__ � -------- - � ��#. � � � '� �� b ,�__. .Y.' J V 61 ti �W �`� y E �,`nq Y:a� ��-�-�-�-U . Subscribed and sw rn to BY� ______________�-�_�_____.______.______ before this �� day �4/ of 19 �,3 Title: U -------- - ------------------------------ -- ,,.,.w- Petitioner G��W t b...�. � _rz,� ��t $..a,� ' �� Notary Pub�� APr2 1� �y�.� , . ROSEMARY FRECETTE p� � y*�, 7 ��•°�°, �.E� � Page 1 of� �� NOTARY PUBUC—MINiVESOTA ,I��'d��{�` `°fP� ��°��$��iy�yg�ya��r �r• RAMSEY COUNTY �;;�_,�;:�'":�t�.-��EE� ��Je°fC1I�,�� 4O$O My Comm.Expi�es April 23, 1987 1�1�g2 Y M . . . . ��''�� :.lyA ., Q � . _ : . � � �7b �y CONSENT OF ADJOINING PROPERTY OWNERS TO REZONING We, the undersigned, owners of property within 100 feet of the total contiguous descriptions of real estate owned by Petitioner or sold by Petitioner within one year preceding the date of this petition, acknowledge that we have been furnished with the following: 1. A copy of the Petition of ' -- ��! ----------- 2. A copy of Sections _�Q,�.�D �through�_�S�__, inclusive, of the St. Paul Ordinance; and acknowledge that we are aware of the uses permitted under a _��—_o�______________ District zoning classification; and hereby consent to the rezoning of the property described in the Petition o , _�,.,�'�L�c1l��-U __ to a �-- District. - --�---�--------- RECORD OWNER SIGNATURE LOT BLOCK ADDITION � - � ,r�r �/, , , /, , ^ , „ r, f, :,A ' ` /lt�G./[� �L��/ V��L'ii,�v'--e�'.G�TI..� �C.c..� l.� I�/ J.� . . - L"I W'� ��%-�t ��,�' �. Q� � � � �� r r��. �i �� :� ��4.,,.�� - S � i � � f F; /� ` ri / /n � rl/h - p ir. 5�c.�7 E n "�L.�,C.�.f✓/'y� ; • � ,7LL�-at L:Z. (/(�/ � \ �/ C'�' � , '—�J /`l/ � ,�v-. �� (�. �^ �,./ .� ,1 it.� ,f c.ti.l f.�„Aa *� � � v_"i!(�,C.. �- .i LL,��' � �'��,'� � `lJ �r�� S ,LCt� � �. I� � / + � � �( ��C' `�'`"�-�--�'- lL 1�-�M��->-, c� �,. 1� �� 'L�l �ed f�_' a,ZJ i �� '�-�.Z ; � � � � � � � �. , � - ��''y�L_ 1 C,�'L...i �' /� t V% ��+�+.-.1 t Gf O. �t . ` _../, 'r 7 w.� c..v� ,fl.7`. rl�./'t'-_�".��--'C_., ��1�S.ti�,/'V # O.i�«`� t .�� .��L� /��/� � // ��1�. E.� , 41L/ � /<C�Zz.,K,f.�. � X r!''.- .i. (l..�i� rCJ �a-r�j.. �1.� ��. . �� '�?'l � , , �. 1L �2 ., ,✓ l� �� <,1L_��1t.�-�_Z_ � '`� � � _ I �: � ��- �- � � >��-�-� � I , ..� � I � �� '=��- � �c'�'- / : , �r . ./ , z ,�.` i .^ -�� 4w.S %r� Ir-.% . , . , , i ,��J�, � ��. aG,�.�.��, � �� ; �. L � � � � ;� � .�. �L. t-� � r.�� E Ji t".' '�EL� 1'� a'� lit.�.ud-C�LI.t.� �vt� N4 �+I�t Petitions shall not be considered as officially.,,filed u�rtil;:� apse of 7 working days after a petition is received in the Zoning Office. Any signatot`"�3'f``ar�j�°p�e`�i�sa��ay withdraw his name therefrom bv_„�,_._.�, written req�est within that time. - 1�/ I ��R 1 . °� � � � � �a �,�. � p � 4 � � �o I �� . r� ��7 � 1�83 �-� �.� � � � � �� ,�.. '� ��` `'- : Page 2 of � � � ` ��'�� % � �-�, �r��ad.;e� �• ----- - �-fi��;'r� ��E�a��d�' 4r .�..� � �a��?ca��3 . . . , .,,., , � v, . : . . ' �'��y � -' 3TATE OF MINNffiOTA) : ss. COIINTY OF RAMSBY ) , being first duly sworn, deposes and states that he is the person w o c rc e wi in pe i ion and consent, consisting of / pages; that affiant is informed and believes that the parties described are the owners respectively of the lots placed immediately following each name, that affiant is informed and believes that each of the parties described above is the owner of property which is within 100 feet from any property owned by petitioner or sold by petitioner within one (1) year preceding the date of this petition which is contiguous to the property described in the petition; that except for none of the parties described above has purchased or is purchasing proper y rom pe ioner contiguous to the above described property within one (1) year of the date of the petition; that this consent was signed by each of said owners in the presence of this affiant, and that the signatures are the true and correct signatures of each and all of the parties so described. � �� z �- r,�� ;�� ss�oi �� 7�-7��/ e ep one u er Subscribed and sworn t before me thib /,��ay of � , ly�`� ry u ic � � ROSEMARYFREDETTE � ��+ NCTI!FY PU6LIC—MI�INESOTA �� RNMSEY COUiVTY My Comm.Expires April 23, 1987 Y N (j re..r f—et., :+. � C9 � R 1"�� .�°� � R � +�-- s ' .�....,, �.�.�' � �, � �� ` � �� _. �..., r t�,��s Approved as to form - Feb. 80 A P R 1 � !`��3 Planning Department Page 3 of 3 ��. 9�i�� 8 i�54 Ylre��9.✓ �t i��."..'��,3��, �fi.�/�..;Ci�%:��".�� " � �' �' o �� ow � � o �n �s�d, c�+ c' �n�'�cn � � �s H � fD ~ F-+ 1--� f/! t!l fD �CO I--� A1 1-�� F-n v, �v a v, �►--�� ►i � � � ow �ag � �sba � - � �� x� � Co 0 � � `�C �� c�n � c~�o � ` �n C � `C � � cr' vq►�i ~+ e� � � C o �1-�+• �v�i ►-+ � O c+ � p, � e�`< rt� t,1� twi� c� $ v, � a�n �-+ o � v� a � o ►°� �yo� ►°i � � v�+ �. � �o� ►�'-� a' ��-+ �' , � � oa � � ��!, �,� ►s v�� fD "d v" P� R (D F� fD u• N �Dt� ao �� ° + o � v � KV, l�-� � � crtn °,� � a o c� �s �d c� �• � � � � ~ o `� g � �� • �� cn w��i a r�-r `* c�pD � � � �• � � A+ .7 ��'"fND "C (�D (�D t~-+ � (�D ►i � e��+ � � O f�D '�. a � � ��o �..a� � `� ��o �'� g � � �+ ° n � ►�t �'o�DCOa.�' ��' � �'" c.� � K �'' w o c�D e�-r c+ w r+ ►�i F�—' � o a`� • �fD �D av�+ o N � a. o ►-+ •�v o �-+ r± v � � � �� w � �• � a� � �� rt � c�o o�o � E� �� KOra. W ;.°+� ►��i � c�n z � `t H � `,.� � � Q� (►iD � � . � O �� ' 6` Ef,� '� � ..� � • . . _ , - ��,�� " • , , .,,�- ,.'u 'y To whom it may concern: � �a r�y I am writing this concerning about the duplexes they want to build on our corner. First of all is there gonna be a back yard. Next, what will the people do to get the kids to school2 Haw can they came up our street if it is slippery. If the cars back up like they do, a lot of people will get hurt and back up in the duplexes. Why do they want duplexes on the corner, because taxes will go up. We do not want any more trouble as we have had enough. Our neighborhood is quiet now. Anybody with common sense would'nt build on a corner because cars turn on a corner and is bad in winter. Cars don't stop for anybody. A car crashes in a duplex an_the insurance will not pay for anything. Nobody wants duplexes on a corner as it is a bad place. F I obj�ct to duplexes on a corner imless nobody ca.res when samebody gets hurt. Mrs. Bessie Ukis 220 E. Belvidere St. St. Paul, Minn. 55107 � • , � . _ Y _ . , - . �� /� ��y �' �T'__ %�_h b �__ i_�' ��%_/ �_61� c�e �t� --- -- __ _ _- - - ' � � ` - -- --� a-rn_ ±�?� � � �_r�� F-z a S _ � a� G e,N�,�� -------__�_�_Q v�'---�_�� n�_�_L_. ��c_�-�----_��.�_�-------- _ .�r�_r��----�--�-�%-��-�� r¢ -�_-�--_�_��-�- � ` � . ��5�__-a �-- ��_C�___ 1 �_�"h ��-�- - -- _��- ��_1� �- �/_�-- -��-� 1�-� l�l ��-� ----_ ___ - _______ ___:�w _fi�_a�--'�c.� _r_C._�... '�-L�-Q� _� .rL_U��.------ - _ _ - --- �- �-�_ ��--� _ __��_`�- fi_�- /�-r��?S -�r� --- � ___ _--_ S G-�-4-� � ��-�_�? Cf-�7�- �� -�-� ��-11�-� � __��-�-�_� r��ZL►- ----�-L-S — . ------`�_�_�� "� - � --�--�-�'-�---- � i ----_ ------�=�--��--u- - --1-----�-��---�--�-��- --��-�-- / ' ----- --`��--�---D___7Lo--Q- - ��1��-`e---�-�LL-'--- --- --- --- �� -�-��--�-�--�-�.�- -��—�- �- - - - � �--- ______ ___L_��_��__�U��-�X��s_,_ _�-� _y________ ------- -- ��-��- -__ ��-�-_ �� x s�S _ ��_ - �-_-� _4� 1�_ �� ,�-c-�- -�_� ---- -�-��_�'�_-w-!--U� �_--v �—� �__� �- � ----------��Q-_-�-� -�� -- �-�-�?a _ �._1� ----1�_��' � -------�-��_��_�-- -� �_- -�- _ _- -- =�---�-� -- _ __ ____ �'__�- �_� -�% � �1, �-r� � �� -l?_ �_�'y_ -- -- --- ---�-�-��_ _�_S E1-� -r E;_. �_� I� t_ __ _ _ - - � . � . .. . , . . �I . . • _ __�n y � � I��" _�-v_ �_� � __�-� rr�= t�_��- - - --� � ; �� w�� (�I�_L�..��%j- 1�___------- -------��—�-�--�--� �- �`�-��--�-�__� a�-_�' �'�_____ --- _- — _ _G � _G�_�__ �_ �-�C v � �1 -a 1� � G �� t-�l)-�t' _ _ �l1 � -! S - -� c� � �+ n_ �_T �� _ __ _ --- ___ �_-��'�_ � ��1�e_ �� - �v � � _---- ----�.�_-� � -{�_ _ � _� ��---- �_��-�� -� ---- i� -- -__ � �_ � �U_�_�.�x'� �s -�-��%r� s� __ _ � . __ L,c1_� _LL— _ � l1 -- �f? � 17Q . � D � --- - ��-�--�-- - � �_� .C) l�_ - - -�u �..h�o.S_ ___ ___ � . �t,-f�_��)(��S _ � � �. C d_�-(� �,� J . � ---�--�---l--�'--�--� �--__�-��__ �,�-�e�-- � _ _ _ c� � �_c_� � -�__ �u .��.._�x S �S . __--- D__�_7___ _�_ G_ CS r-� P� � �-�-_� .� ___-- -_ _ ._ .__. �_.�:..� t? f� . _ C._.� �-.�iS � l,t.,c., � �,� _. _ __. --------'�-1�-CI� -� 6�D _�.� � �- G�� _ _ � � � Mrs. Bessie Ukis ��8-�-.- ��_.� _ - - __ _ St. Paul, Minnesota 55107 � � .ST. P�A��L CITY COUNCIL �� . � �70� � PU6LIC HEARING NOTICE ZONING � T0: Property owners within 350 feet; FIL E N 0. 9376 Representati ves of P1 anni ng Di stri ct 3 pq�E PURPOSE Rezone property from R-4 to RM-2 to permit construction of 3 four-plexes. LOCATION Northeast corner Belvidere and Oakdale PETITIONER DELORES AND MILTON ELLIOTT HEARING �ursaay, �u�Y 2s, �1983 io:oo A.M. Citv Council Chambers, 3rd Floor Cit�• Hall - Court House QU E STION S Zoning 298-4154 (Patri ci a James) Contact the Zoning Section of the Planning and Economic Development Department, Room 1101, City Hall Annex, 25 W. 4th Street; St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Legal Description: Lots 19, 20, 31 , Block 12, W. St. Paul Real Estate and Improvement Syndicate #1 Kotice sent 7/15/83 � � � - . �I ��g . :s � � /�a�� -- -=�.�r- ;�.. � . ,:_� r.:a. � .� ,�„"Rn„ ' �-.�,..�1 ��I�ft�'�re'.r r�:<7 ` •ta.l�rra-�.�ao,R,i�R,��`�r,+g�.1 i .*��.. ��+c�ia�;� ��'rt,r ;,`+��'�,� �8:�r� . <^ _. — —;, � �et�ait8t::pIN1�:13_ �i ' ':as �3�61�asti�ar�trirs�q� �.p!1�'�iNi'33s�i1: : � � � � ,�'9��.��R�1alaA�lb�A�+� , ,� ::��'��tll��l�irl�: F�. �d Ju�+i�l�t. '� � ,�. . �� ., "`� F ,'9P��.�.^� �, � � - ."� �.T� A .��,r��'�� ': ,,� t�'y�4� 'T�a��'MT4i ' .� MA{!�I'1I� wy`''w• � � � .. ��" �.. � b w�17�,t'T��«' .�dit�' �'�'� �. �ft7 t'ki�t . (A�lg`I�`'�j" _: ._..�.. — _ .,_..� , _..�. ,�.__ _.__------ _. __.� _ � ____. ..__ _..�.: ,,, .,......_. _.�._.a,�....,...�.��..� � p� � , 1 s t /� — � �� 2nd �4 — f�'O � 3rd �� ' �,3 'O �j Adopted /� '.ZO ��3 Yeas Nays , FLETCHER GALLES �� ,..•� .. . � MASANZ �7U�� ' - ' NICOSIA SCHEIBII. WILSON � MR. PRESIDENT TIDESCO