280612 WMITE - CITV CLERK .
PINK - FINANGE GITY OF SAINT PALTL Council
CANARV - DEPAR7MENT ��• , ���
BLUE - MAVOR - Flle NO.
� C u 'l Resolution
�-
Presented By �--
� Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
BE IT RESOLVED, That the Council of the City of Saint Paul hereby
certifies and approves the action of the City of Saint Paul Board of
Appeals and Review pertaining to the following listed property and
as shown by the Excerpted Minutes of said Board of Appeals and Review
dated June 14, 1983, and marked EXHIBIT A, and attached hereto and
made a part hereof by reference:
DATE OF BOARD
MINUTES CASE NO. PROPERTY APPELLANT
6/14/83 35-82-H 108 Pierce St. Charles E. Walsh
(ten units)
BOARD ACTION: Granted extension of time to October l, 1984, to
complete stucco and soffit repairs, as designated in
city' s letter of May ?, 1982 . ,
Property Dewcription: Schroeder' s Addition
Except E. 4 ft. and escept N. 71 6/10 ft. ,
Lot 9, Block 10
---------------------------------
6/14/83 31-83-H 1811 Margaret Walter Schlundt
(single family
residence)
BOARD ACTION: Granted refund of $10. 00 filing fee because subject of
appeal is outside board' s jurisdiction.
Property Description: Robert L. Ware' s Eastern Heights
Lot 32, Block 2
---------------------------------
COUIVCILMEN Requested by Department of:
Yeas Nays �
Fletcher
ceu� in Favor
Masanz �
Nicosia
scnetbet _ Against BY
Tedesco
Wilson
Adopted by Council: Date
JUL 14 1983 Form Approved by City Attorne
Certified a.s Counci cr gY C ,
By
t#pproved by Mav : D e ��� � � �983 Approved by Mayoc for Submission to Council
By �� BY
PUBLISNED JUL 2 3 1983
' DRAFT _ ������
COLNCI L RESOLUTI:ON
BE IT RESOLVED, That the Council of the City of Saint Paul
hereby certifies and approves the action of the City of Saint Paul
Board of Appeals and Revieiv pertaining to the follo��ing listed property
and as shown by tlie Excerpted Minutes of said Board of �lppeals �nd
� Review, dafied June 14 , 1983, and marked EXfIIRIT A, and att�ched
hereto and made a part hereof by reference :
DATE OF BOARD . �
MINUTES CASE N0. PROPERTY ' APPELLANT .
6/14/83 35-82-H 108 Pierce St. Charles E. Walsh
(ten units)
BOARD ACTION : Granted extension of tiine to October 1, 1984 , to complete
stucco and soffi.t repairs , as designated in city' s letter
of May 7, 19 82. -
Property Description: Schroeder' s Addition
Except E. 4 ft. and except N. 71 6/10 ft. ,
Lot 9 , B lock 10
6/14/83 31-83-H 1811 Margaret Walter Schlundt
. (single family residence)
BOARD ACTION : Granted refund of $10. 00 filing fee because subject of'
appeal is outside board' s jurisdiction.
Property Description : Robert L. Ware' s Eastern Heights
Lot 32 , Block 2
. . ������.� . ,
� 6/14/83 - Meeting No. 197 .
MINUTES OF THE MEETING
ST. PAUL BOARD OF APPEALS & REVIEW
Tuesday, June 14 , 1983
Room 707 City Hall , 15 W. Kellogg Blvd.
MEMBERS PRESENT: Ron Glassman, Chairman
Glenn Gausman
Harold Knutson
Rosann Bostrom
Rudolph Sawyer
- Lucille Burg Collins
ABSENT : William Tilton
AGENCIES PRESENT: Department of Community Services - Division of
Housing & Building Code Enforcement
' Ali ce Bi j j ani
City Attorney' s Office
_ ��
John McCormick
OTHERS PRESENT: Henry Brandis
John Magnusson
Charles E. Walsh
Alfred Moxness
STAFF: Patricia Moxness
The meeting was called to order at 1:35 p.m.
The minutes of the meeting of May 10 , 1983, were approved as distributed
to the members.
Chairman Glassman introduced Assistant City Attorney John McCormick who
will soon take over the assignment of legal advisor to our board from
Assistant City Attorney Walter Bowser.
The chairman reported briefly on a meeting of the City Development Com-
mittee he had attended during the past week, at which the conflict between
the Minnesota Uniform Fire Code and the St. Paul Fire Code was discussed.
He said the discussion would be continued at .the June 29 meeting of the
committee. He felt that the ultimate conclusion would mean the city would
have to conform to MUFC regulations, but probably property owners would be
granted a fairly lengthy time period for compliance.
� . .
�������
,, -3- 6/14/83 - Meeting No. 197
�1( H��3 /T �
--------------------------------------------------------------------
35-82-H 10 8 Pierce St. Charles E. Walsh
(ten units)
. _ _ SUBJECT : Request variance on Section 35. 03, pertaining to stairwell
enclosures , because appellant states that the building has always been
classified as a 2 1/2-story structure where such enclosures have not been
required before , because the cost would be a financial hardship. Also,
request varian ce on Section 34. 13, sill heights , to permit continued use
of basement Apt. B where window sill in sleeping area is 60 inches from
floor level, because of practical difficulty and expense. �
Prior He aring 5/10/83 : Appe llant excused from appe aring. Case was post-
poned to June meeting.
APPEARANCE : Charles E. Walsh
PROCEEDING5 : Mr. Walsh said it was his understanding that the matter of
stairwell enclosures was not at issue at this time because the city had
returned to its former basis regarding enclosures in 2 1/2-story buildings
and were not requiring them at this time. In regard to the sill height of
the basement windows , it would be extremely difficult and costly to lower
them because of a massive concrete platform outs�de the windows at ground
level. For the same reason, construction of a window well would be nearly
impossible.
Alice Bijjani conceded that such work would be very difficult and costly,
but suggested that placing a permanent step at least 12 :inches high below
the window in the sleeping room would be an alternative to consid�.<�. She
asked if the stucco repair work and hrickwork repairs had been co�r�leted.
. . . ������
, -4- 6/14/83 - Meeting No. 197
Mr. Walsh said he was requesting a time extension �or these items. The
stucco damage was caused by a leaky roof which has now been replaced. He
planned to replace the defective surfaces on the soffits and under the eaves
where the stucco was breaking up with some type of wood finishing material,
� but the cost would be around $4500 and he could not afford it at this time.
BOARD ACTION: Chairmar� Glassman moved that an extension of time to Oc�ober 1,
1984, be granted to complete stucco and soffit repairs. Mr. Knutson seconded.
MOTION CARRIED.
THE VOTE : Ayes - 6 Nays - 0 Abstentions - 0
BOARD ACTION: Mr. Sawyer moved that a variance of Se ction 34. 13 , pertain-
ing to sill heights , be granted, permitting continued occupancy of Apt. B
where escape window doesnatcomply with sill height requirements , on con-
dition that a permanent step be placed belcsw the window at a minimum
height of 12 inches above f loor leve l. Mr. Gausman seconded. MOTION
CARRIED.
THE VOTE: Ayes - 6 Nays - 0 Abstentions - 0
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
_ ; .
i - _ _ ������
- .
• 6/14/83 - Meeting No. 197 '
MINUTES OF THE MEETING
ST. PAUL BOARD OF APPEALS & REVIEW
Tuesday, June 14 , 1983
Room 707 .City Hall , 15 W. Kellogg Blvd.
MEMBERS PRESENT: Ron Glassman , Chairman
Glenn Gausman .
Harold Knutson
Rosann Bostrom
Rudolph Sawyer
Lucille Burg Collins
ABSENT : William Tilton
AGENCIES PRESENT: Department of Community Services - Division of
Housing & Building Code Enforcement
Alice Bijjani
City Attorney' s Office
John McCormick
OTHERS PRESENT: Henry Brandis
Jahn Magnusson
Charles E. Walsh
Alfred Moxness
STAFF: Patricia Moxness
The meeting was called to order at 1:35 p.m.
The minutes of the meeting of May 10 , 1983, were approved as distributed
to the members.
Chairman Glassman introduced Assistant City Attorney John McCormick who
will soon take over the assignment of legal advisor to our board from
Assistant City Attorney Walter Bowser.
The chairman reported briefly on a meeting of the City Development Com-
mittee he had attended during the past week, at which the conflict between
the Minnesota Uniform Fire Code and the St. Paul Fire Code was discussed.
He said the discussion would be continued at the June 29 meeting of the
committee. He felt that the ultimate conclusion would mean the city would
have to conform to MUFC regulations, but probably property owners would be
granted a fairly lengthy time period for compliance.
.. .. , �.... �
�
-------��< �
.
: - -
„ . °�
.. ._ _. ._ _ . .�
_ . ,__ _
- .. ..w... . _ ._._ .� _�. ,__ .�.._.�....��.... .,., _ _. � _ _ .. �. ,a� ����'��� �_.��
31-83-H 1811 Margaret Walter Schlundt
(single family residence)
SUBJECT: Request variance of city ordinance regulating placement of private
residential swimming pools , to permit continued use of existing swimming
pool in owner' s backyard as presently located.
APPEARANCE: None
PROCEEDINGS : After processing this appeal, Chairman Glassman stated,it had
been determined that the subject of this appeal was not under the juris-
diction of the board. Therefore, the appellant was entitled to a refund
of the fi ling fee.
BOARD ACTION : Chairman Glassman moved that the $10. 00 filing fee should
be refunded to Appellant Walter Schlundt. Mrs. Bostrom seconded. MOTION
CARRIED.
THE VOTE : Ayes - 6 Nays - 0 Abstentions - 0
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The meeting adjourned at 2 :05 p.m. -