The URL can be used to link to this page

00-208ORfG1i��fl Presented By Referred To � ,�-, �--i 2 KESOLVED, that the Auto Repair Gazage license held by Phuoc Huu Lieu d/b/a 3 Wabasha Auto Repair (License ID # 990001579) , for the premises at 411 Wabasha Street South, 4 is hereby suspended for a period of tlurty days for violation of conditions placed on the license. 6 FURTF3ER RESOLVED, that 15 days of said suspension shall be stayed for a period of 7 eighteen months on the following conditions: 1) that the properry is brought into compliance 8 with the conditions on the license within one week from the passage of this Resolution; 2) that 9 there be no fiurther violations of the conditions on the license or other code or zoning violations 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 during the eighteen months; and 3) that the licensee pay a fine of $500.00, said fine to be paid to the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection within thirty(30) days of the adoption of this resolution by the Council and signature by the Mayor. For the remaining 15 days suspension, no business operations shall be permitted beginning at 12:01 am., Wednesday, Mazch 22, 20Q0, through 11:59 p.m., Wednesday Apri15, 2Q00. This Resolution and the action of the Council in this matter are based upon the facts contained in the December 2, 19991ettez to the licensee from LIEP, the January 25, 2000 Notice of Violation letter to the licensee, and such arguments as may have been presented to the Council at the public hearing. The licensee did not contest the facts of the violation. Requested by Department of: Adoption Certified by Council Secretaxy BY: Appz By: Council File # lJ�— a 2 Dlf / � i %i//. � i�L Form Approved by City Attorney �� $Y � ��S�n��_ � � ��"`c. Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council BY: Adopted by Council: Date ,.�y� l�.p Ga �- l�/�-ZD�' Office of the City Attomey 266-8710 - Public TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES Febniary 17 20o GREEN SHEET No � ��? j 7 wmuwd timrio.c. �,.,,��s.,�. �� acx .�eecae �••caaEr ana.a�c ure�c � ❑wuuio��me�sow_ w+w�t�ro ❑ WYptI�AtOfl111f) � (CLJP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATUR� - — -- - — - Resolution concerning adverse action against the �Auto Repair Garage License held_by Phuoc Huu Lieu, Wabasha Auto Repair, 411 Wabasha Street South. (Uncontested) PLANNING CAMMISSION CIB COMMRTEE CML SERV{CE CAMMISSI00! NHOUNT OF TRANSACTION Fi� ntis pe�aoMUm e�e.�arlo� �ntle. a �aa�aa a.mis ae�mnenn YES NO Hes mis peramRrm euer baen a cdY empbyee4 YES P�O Does 1hi6 D� D� a sldl no[ rarm�y'OOSeessM bY �Y wfrent atY emPbY�? YES NO Is dtis pneauhrm a terpeted oarbort YES MO COST/REVQIUE BUDOETm (CIRCLE ON� 1�9Y71i/`D YEE NO (e%PwM OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY Clayton M. Robinson, Jr., City Attorney � _�� CITY OF SAINT PAUL Norm Colemax, Mayor Civil Division 400 City Ha!! /5 West Xellogg Blvd Saint Pau1, Minnesota 55702 Telephone: 651266-8i ]0 Facsimile: 65I 298-5619 February 16, 2000 NOTICE OF COUNCIL HEARING Mr. Phuoc Huu Lieu Wabasha Auto Repair 411 Wabasha Street South Saint Paul, Minnesota 55107 �VYL�'diP �vti'l`P��i 14 ,�r� ., �:Y . � �� b � �� RE: Auto Repair Garage License held by Phuoc Huu Lieu, d/b/a Wabasha Auto 32epair, for- the premises at 411 Wabasha Street South License ID #: 990001579 Dear Mr. Lieu: Please take notice that a hearing concerning the above-named establishxnent has been scheduled for 5:30 p.m., Wednesday, March 1, 2000 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City Hali and Ramsey County Courthouse. Enclosed are copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested hearing, in that the facts concerning the violations of your license conditions have not been denied. You wili have an opportunity at the Council hearing to present oral and/or written remarks as to the penalty, if any, to be imposed. If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710. Very truly yours, �/ti�.�J�� Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP Christine Rozek, LIEP Steve Faust, Community Organizer, West Side Citizens Organization, 127 Winifred St. W., St. Paui, MN 55107 UNCONTESTED LICENSE HEARING oo -ao�r Licensee Name: Council Date: Phuoc Huu Lieu d/b/a Wabasha Auto Repair March 1, 2000 Violation: Violation of license condition #2 requiring that a post and chain or a guardrail shall be installed and maintained along the property line at Wabasha Street to prevent vehicles from parking over the public sidewalk. Violation of license condition #3 restricting the number of vehicles parked outdoors on the lot to a maximum of 7. Place: Licensed Premises Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection: 30 day suspension ofi license, with 15 days stayed for 18 months on 3 conditions: 1. Properiy brought into compliance within one week from passage of the resolution; Attachments: 2. no further violations of ficense conditions or other code or zoning violations during 18 months; 3. the licensee shati pay a$500.00 fine within 30 days of adoption of the resolution. 1. Proposed resolution 2. 1/25/00 Notice of Violation 3. License Information Report 4. 1/4/00 memo re 1/3/00 inspection 5. 12/29/99 Citizen Complaint form 6. 12/2/99 letter from Kristina Schweinler to Phuoc Huu Lieu �� -ao� 7. License information and conditions CITY OF SAINT PAUL A'ormCo(einan, �Ltay�or January 25, 2Q�0 OFFIC" �F 7'HE CITY ATTORNEY C(aylon . _tob+rzsox, Jc, CityA[lorney O Q aQ � c;vrt o;v;s,on 400 Ciry Hal[ 1 S fFesl Kellogg Blyd. Saint Paul, ,tlinnesota S.i! 02 Telep/rone: 65f 266-8 Facsimile: 6S I 293-5619 NOTICE OF VIOLATION Mr. Phuoc Huu Lieu Wabasha Auto Repair 411 Wabasha Street South Saint Paul, Minnesota 55107 RE: Auto Repair Gazage License held by Phuoc Huu Lieu, d/b/a �Vabasha Auto Repair, for the premises at 411 Wabasha Street South License TD #: 990001579 Dear Mr. Lieu: The Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection has recommended adverse action against the auto repair gaza�e license held by you at 411 Wabasha Street South in Saint Paul. The basis for the adverse action is as follows: It is a condition of your business license that no more than seven vehicles can be parked on your lot outdoors. You were sent a letter dated December 2,1999 advising you that a recent inspection showed eleven vehicles parked on your lot. Another condition on your license required a post and chain or guardraii to be installed and maintained along the property line at Wabasha Street. The December 2, 1499 letter gave you until December 17, 1999 to bring your lot into compliance «�ith the conditions. An inspection on January 3, 2000 showed 12 cars parked on your property and still no guardrail instalied. If you do not dispute the above facts please send me a letter w7th a statement to that effect. The matter will then be scheduled for a hearin� before the St. Pau1 City Council to determine �rhat penalty, if any, to impose. You w�ill have an opportunity to appear and speak on your own behalf, or to have someone appear there for you. Page 2 Mr. Phuoc Huu Lieu January 25, 2000 t�C� -�� On the other hand, if you wish to dispute the above facts, I will schedule an evidentiary hearing before an Administrative Law Jud�e. If you �vish to have such a hearins, please send me a letter stating that you are contestin� the facts. You will then be sent a"Notice of Hearin�," so you will know when and where to appear, and what the basis for the hearing c��ill be. In either case, please let me I:no�v in writing no later than Monday, February 7, 2000, how you �vould like to proceed. If I have not heard from you by that date, I`viil assume that you are not contesting the facts. The matter �vill then be scheduled for the hearing before the St. Paul City Council. If you have any questions, feel free to call me or have your attomey call me at 266-8710. Sincerely, C � �utcz� � � Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP Christine Rozek, LIEP Steve Faust, Community Organizer, West Side Citizens Organization, 127 Winifred St. W., St. Paul, MN 55107 Oc7-3o� STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF RAMSEY AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says that on January 26, 2000, she served the attached NOTICE OF VIOLATION on the following named person by placing a true and correct copy thereof in an envelope addressed as follows: Mr. Phuoc Huu Lieu Wabasha Auto Repair 411 Wabasha Street South St. Paul, MN. 55107 (which is the last known address of said person) and depositing the same, with postage prepaid, in the Unite ates mails at St. Paul, Minnesota. � /� /) G. C1�M�T5 Subscribed and sworn to before me this 26th day of January, 2000. i%` �%�2�`l'//�� COMMl39 Notary Publa r �� .F�p��EB�AN.31,20� I� �: iQ' i ,.� �W I � �yIO I�;o N 'iU iN � IJ ,c A � a ��, I�O '� O ¢ � C O .� � � .� c m N c m U J IN � i� � I� : INI C�� . 0 I J'.Q d � � i � I Q� �T L I Q iC � �U O I � �Q O — 0 � � N I � O� r i�,� Z � c ° o U'� �� I �a , I�� N � � � N I � N Q � IQ � I ,� o r � �� a W K � I � � �IQ I I � �Q Z I,= ! m'a �,Q _ � � _ W N' N'� O10 ;�;� I� a � C., 3 I�i U �I I I IM �O N i �I Q I W N c L I �� EI ZI U� la i � V I C, N' �, ICi �`. � �Z I I� N d O' I N cl, NI 3I C+ Li � � � I Z N C � j L � a a , I � N I C � N �� m I� n I� � I 0 X �N 'u� I�' I�i i� ', O C � £ i o' U t I I � � � S ! ¢ i � i� �� F � . . � v� � a a m � W o � � - o .� n T > 3 v� s � � y � � 3 c�i o a_ - � m a� �3 � � � X N t N � .t � R ( N � � C � � C � �w : Q �Y U Q O � O Q � a o V � � - � O N QU C Uw.Q"6 N"6 (p_ CO..��•N �� S3O'-'._ � L '6 O_ � (E � f�/1 C N �N �p.�N O� @ L� p_� -a- ��j� � C � O N � C @ t9 ..�. O'a �!!�= �om c a�Y�a�3 C � �nrn �'�n�>E �� aN.�.. y,� OC LN� CN(p �O NU'V OU_ �G L'�N,CE 3 � N j p N m � o - o > „_, p > �s � � oa `o Y`n m>�OCO m � a �y N m`� `o �Q .6oc�E:: Q'C L".' E Q. N U� _� UN� 3 N �� E N aO tA� �(n�X U a � m� L O� p N�>� U � L `� VI �Q @�"'Q �� r� YY L� � 3o a�'a�i �� = o� � �� N m UOtn �J N f� Q� N '�'6 � fl-.. � ` � � Q R � N C � y � UNC� C� �� U C �U� N ln `�- a y N Y o � c N O c c � � � � N N �OOy p_�f6 C �� Q � = U 0 � N Y � 0 U'J C O�pU'o ��O O U� j � � - oco'3 0 � � m� Ca � Q >U' �� @ C N U N O W w �p.� � QNV N N O_C ? �iR'S N�Ea mao� � o �0.�2 cZ� .� m c � o O � O�'�� (D6J� o m��m.,c�rnrn O ��'p�.'�NN M � N�N �NN c�- 3� in (Q �fJ C'7 V oo-�� i� i� 0 jQ , x M W �r N � O v1 N � 6) y U � {�p IJ !M a �j� � O G d � C O R G � V�-� C N N c d V J ��, �', � N I� j U /U �J Q I IQ . N F" � I�N',`m C Q IU N N I � ` LL O — o ' N � N I � p1 <- � � I� j�,o G O � U p�j L � I�I i�l ��N � � :N N � 2 � Q N la Q ,Q � O � � -�V � � Q a W � �� I�I¢ ' � IQ VZ �� Q Q m � I Q �i � � _ W � J m ,I� z :_ � I� � IS �a Vi �I O U, i' N I 'M � O m� � X �I N; �i �I n N 9 i �; �, U' O d i' a� � U C' m', �- N C, � I� � � I Z a C N I� 0 U U' f L' m � Nt Gi � N � � �I � 2 N C � O r t � a � N N N N N ^ C IO] W I �X O m j� M i � � i l im' �� 10' U! NI N; C' m ' I i ' J � � � Q S Q m V l i� C � �= la , c 0 IN I�' �O, U l l i �� F � � � � a d Q N "'L N W O C C " O J o_ � > � in �a ., v'o � ..m � ma� � 3 a� o_ a.Q a�m ° a °' i � 3 d w N � X N N (p CJ] � � � � O.� � O?` F N Q (pY U Q 0 N �Q �� O U 'o O Q O � N O O_ N� N D..0 C U .Q'p a c �� a�i� E� � = N � .0 � fl. L N N Oy �-y � a a - a -o -° � `° o 0 �C � � Oin=C N N N Q- � t� '6 N C �i � N 3 � Q '�Y � p � Vl rn� � �-N�N � m m- t mw. � d Vj N . � C � N U O C N N U'_ U _ .'�... C 'LL N L � C O '6 �,� O� N o.c � � oa `o �" �� 50�= Y@ O��sO 'p N f/j aa �°-�°�`�� ocYE�. -�� .c�EQ��i - N U N �t��p� . �iN a�`.ENp, N9 ��. U T Qd N"6 16�L'O .cOyO�� `� �Q � � � � �N>ri[t �tn.. N �� s J - O 3 0 u�i � .°_' o � � � � m �47 m UOrq �J 'f� N d� N "� - � p:wU-. y W� U7 � 0 rna�a� y�c U N C C C C O) �� N... � NO� �CnwQ �UN N �Y� ��rn u> >. � �OOy p_�!6 U C � � � � fl-'-C U Y V� O- �� c O � V'6 � O O V � d ��` O_� N - p (0 �30 �N�` C - a `p_ > (7 cG a� C f0 U N�M y N N � �� a° u� a:wUS yco"a mvo� c �UO�2 CZ� p)�� O o� �rn>rn � pt6 (6�V�� O N�D�""NN M C N�N pNN � �� a� ao -ao� � N Q d W M O M �� O m d !p N R J � a i � _O � 0 i7. � C O « m E 1 0 w c d N _ a� u �.1 N I� i 'N � �� `V C J � _a r � 'N 2 N iQ I� �� N � �a U � J N �Q O — 0 v� 's N � r iJ � Z Iai'O iV � �� ^ I I � I R ��N � F �� N I f� N ",-o a a Q o �V t�Ci � a W K O N = , IQ z �i ¢ Q � I Q I� � W �J �� Z j2 ;� IU I� � �� _ a I U C I 0 U I N m IQ o � � d IQ IW iN I� � I� E I I O °- � I� ;� N i C � z T C Q. Io U IU Im `� . �C � �I s 3� Z i � �� L � a I � N � N 'N = N I�;� m'� I � IF �. - � � M V u� I ' I Vi �� I NI I �I C �N 7 I �m I I I I I I � � 'r � Q _ Q Q � � �C � � c N G l � U N T ' N C H � � � � � n;'n a� -- .c � W o � _" o � `o_ �� > 3 �n t � � y � s 3 m o. a s = � m o a � - 3 _ Q � N a� � m � �� m � Q.- p) O >` {- N Q (q Y U O_ N `p N �Q ��oo a Op_ "6� 3 � O QN m�N Q _U C V Q"Oa N'6 N-CO�� N C � � � � � � iL 'O Q� � � � C O � � O , L , � s � o_ �'� a ��a�oo � � _ N O N � C N N �0 �.� 3 am cm.Y�a� ' C Q � Ntn QiQ �� (0� -QNL N� � C L N� C�� N� N U U � V L .'_.. � �(0 �' N N L �- d N N C O "O > ..�-. O �! � .c � � o a `o a v ' � a� � o�— � �n rn> � o c o � N � N y (6� O a�Q �OCmE�. � � L'�' � aN 41 = y U � � N � � �i N �... � � fl.Qw fn� ��X �? T a� � m � .c a °-� Q. :co�o��»�E r > NY °>-° m �a m d � � Ec�i�riv E�ri� y YY � � -° �a � � p� � ��fp � E > �N O) U�N �', �.J t� N p_� (D J "6 �L, a'.- rn�a� �o (pN f�ll C � N C U� C N �r U � LA�� d(nw Q y UN =yNO �� U p.� C .�. � Q G � U � � N YNO_ U�C p �U O p O U..'�-. N C �`fl"J - �a�m� �"O � p_ >� C ^ 2 a�C(6 UN�M a? d m.- � �mv U'0=0 N U N N QC N+�� > m :_. ,�c o� ma o� CO�OJSCZ� . p� � i O � ,,, o � �rn �rn �rnrn i M � �N � �, o,_ _, c-3vJ�nmu��vv 00 -ao� Ginger Palme - 411 Wa Paqe 1 From: Kristina Schweinler �a -a� � To: Palmer, Ginger Date: 1/4/00 10:31AM Subject: 41� Wabasha t inspected the properiy yesterday 1/3/2000 and took pictures the property is still out of compliance. I have entered notes into the file and have the pictures being developed.There were 6 cars on the side of the bldg.and 6 cars in the front parking also there was a tow truck loading or unioading i didn't stay to see but they were already in trouble so it wouldn't have mattered. I aiso got a comp. from Citizen Service saying there were 16 veh. at that time. i send you a copy. Let me know if you need anything else. CC: Rozek, Christine CITY OF SAINT PAUL MAYOR & COUNCZL INFORMATSON and COMPLAINT OFFICE CZTIZEN SERVICE PROGRAM 170 CITY HALL 55102 266-8989 (Phone) 266-8689 (Fax) ID NiJMBER: 28424811687LEP 00 -�� ORIGZNAL CMPLT DATE: 12-29-99 TO: CHRISTINE ROZEK LICENSE, INSPECTIONS & ENV. PROTECTION 3 � FR: BETTY DAY INFO AND COMPLAINT OFFICE LOCATION OF COMPLAINT: 411 WABASHA ST S WARD 02 DISTRICT 03 CENSUS 37100 LICENSE Fee Owner THE FOLLOWING IS STATED BY THE COMPLAINANT.... FREDS TIRE CO INC . THIS IS THE AUTO TECH. SERVICE: THERE ARE 16 00519 UNIVERSZTY AVE W VEFIICLES ON THE LOT WFIICH IS A VZOLAITON OF THE ST PAUL MN 551031938 CITY'S LSCENSES/PERMIT TO OPERATE. THE TOW TRUCK IS USUALLY PARKED OVER THE SZDEWALR. Tax Owner MOHAMMED FAYYAZ HAYAT ROOHI FAYYAZ 02210 F200SEVELT ST NE MINNEAPOLIS NIN 554184035 Complainant Znformation Also Sent to: ANONYMOUS Respond within 4 working days. Send response to 170 CITY HALL. RESPONSE BY: RESPONSE DATE: FOLLOW-UP DATE: CLOSED DATE: �* Eithex FOLLOW-UP OT CLOSED date MUST be eRteTed ** THE RHSPONSIT YOII $NTER CF�L7 BE DISCLOSED TO THS PIISLIC. OFFICE OF LICENSE, IYSPECTIOVS AND ENVIRONMENTALPROTECTION Ro6ert Kess(er, Directo� CITY OF SAlNT PAUL Norm Colemars. bfnyor Dec.2, 1999 Mr.Phuoc Huu Lieu Wabasha Auto Repair St.Paui, Mn. 551Q7 Mr. Lieu, LOWRYPROFESSlONdL BUlLDING 350 Sc Peter So-eet. Suite 300 S¢intPauLHlinnuota 55t02-I.i10 oo-�oY TelepF.one: 657-?66-9D90 Faaimi(e: 65 /-266-9099 651-366-97?4 A recent inspection of your licensed establishment show you to be out of compliance with the conditions of your license. The maximum number of vehicles parked outdoors on the lot cannot exceed seven(7). At the time of my inspection I counted 11 vehicles on your lot and 3 on the street that appeared to be customers of your establishment. The lot was to be striped and a post and chain or guardrail installed at Wabasha St. This has not been done. Vehicle parts, tires, oil or similar items will not be stored out doors. There were car doors, tires and an engine lift along with numerous other part outdoors this is not allowed. Also at the time of my inspection it appeared that auto body work was bein� done on a vehicle in the garage. Auto body repair is not allowed in this zoning district. I have attached a copy of the conditions of your license. You have until December 17` to bring your establishment into compliance with the conditions and to clean the area of any parts or derris. Failure to do so may result in adverse action being taken against your license. Please contact me if you have any questions at (651)266-9110. Re pectfully, � .-��,�.�, ��.�. Kristina Schweinler Sr. License Inspector Cc: Christine Rozek., Deputy Director Larry Zangs, Zoning Specia(ist Ginger Palmer, Asst. City Atty. :i=`� �`� �.�� = ?' .,_.__._? (7� _�� P q I Pn�m _;: I H� Su� ` License � Licensee � Lic. Types , Insurancc r Frc,�erty t' Licensee �` Unofficial Street #: 11 StreEt Name: NABASHA ! Street Type: ST Direction: �— � Unit Ind: �— Unit #: �— � City: T PAUL S1ate: 1N Zip: 55107 j Ward: L� Browse i Disi Councii: 3J� I Licensee: � DBA: $5�85 T&X �(�: License Type Flarm Permit ( Auto ftepair C False Alarms License # 90i Licensee HUOC HUU LIEU GH€. lVABFSHA RU7U kEPAIR 1 Bonci l FequiremEnts l Project Facild�,tor: Ia1ARTEtdS, COP.INNE � � Adverse Action Comments I , CammErhs: t/3NG reinspected and took �ic.countEd 6 cars �nd a ' owtruck unloadingon side �nd 6 cars in I rar�t.KS.12IZP39 - Letter from Kris S re non-camplisnce j iih conditions of IicenselJL �'t25�39 - Did not approved license to prird - need siqned Camments: Class � Effective 2 � �7N1 M 999 � OSM 1 I1999 =�— Z I OSM 9M 999 OSM 1 t2�00 ' hS OSM 1 f2400 IV 12r1M999 ! N HUU LIEU 43680 Bus Phone:K651)222-8615 579 Save Changes to History License Fee 7 Cancel �s -J Heip 7 "�GroupWise... �ECLIPS Ap... 8. ECLIPS Lic... �) License qu... � Propertie_.. � License Group Conditions Text 01/24/2000 Licensee: pHUOC HUU LIEU �BA- WABASHAAUTO REPAIR OO '�,�� License#: �9g90001579 1. Vehicles will 6e parked on the lot as indicated on the approved site plan file with LIEP. The lot should be striped, as shown on this plan and the handicapped parking space appropriately marked. 2. A post and chain or guardrail shall be installed and maintained along the property line at Wabasha Street to prevent vehicle parking over the public sidewalk. 3. The maximum number of vehicles, parked outdoors on the lot, cannot exceed seven (7). 4. All vehicies parked outdoors on the lot must appear to be wmpletely assembled with no major body parts missing. Vehicle salvage is not pertnittetl. � 5. Vehicle parts, tires, oil or similar items will not be stored outdoors. Trash wiii be stored in the dumpster. ORfG1i��fl Presented By Referred To � ,�-, �--i 2 KESOLVED, that the Auto Repair Gazage license held by Phuoc Huu Lieu d/b/a 3 Wabasha Auto Repair (License ID # 990001579) , for the premises at 411 Wabasha Street South, 4 is hereby suspended for a period of tlurty days for violation of conditions placed on the license. 6 FURTF3ER RESOLVED, that 15 days of said suspension shall be stayed for a period of 7 eighteen months on the following conditions: 1) that the properry is brought into compliance 8 with the conditions on the license within one week from the passage of this Resolution; 2) that 9 there be no fiurther violations of the conditions on the license or other code or zoning violations 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 during the eighteen months; and 3) that the licensee pay a fine of $500.00, said fine to be paid to the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection within thirty(30) days of the adoption of this resolution by the Council and signature by the Mayor. For the remaining 15 days suspension, no business operations shall be permitted beginning at 12:01 am., Wednesday, Mazch 22, 20Q0, through 11:59 p.m., Wednesday Apri15, 2Q00. This Resolution and the action of the Council in this matter are based upon the facts contained in the December 2, 19991ettez to the licensee from LIEP, the January 25, 2000 Notice of Violation letter to the licensee, and such arguments as may have been presented to the Council at the public hearing. The licensee did not contest the facts of the violation. Requested by Department of: Adoption Certified by Council Secretaxy BY: Appz By: Council File # lJ�— a 2 Dlf / � i %i//. � i�L Form Approved by City Attorney �� $Y � ��S�n��_ � � ��"`c. Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council BY: Adopted by Council: Date ,.�y� l�.p Ga �- l�/�-ZD�' Office of the City Attomey 266-8710 - Public TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES Febniary 17 20o GREEN SHEET No � ��? j 7 wmuwd timrio.c. �,.,,��s.,�. �� acx .�eecae �••caaEr ana.a�c ure�c � ❑wuuio��me�sow_ w+w�t�ro ❑ WYptI�AtOfl111f) � (CLJP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATUR� - — -- - — - Resolution concerning adverse action against the �Auto Repair Garage License held_by Phuoc Huu Lieu, Wabasha Auto Repair, 411 Wabasha Street South. (Uncontested) PLANNING CAMMISSION CIB COMMRTEE CML SERV{CE CAMMISSI00! NHOUNT OF TRANSACTION Fi� ntis pe�aoMUm e�e.�arlo� �ntle. a �aa�aa a.mis ae�mnenn YES NO Hes mis peramRrm euer baen a cdY empbyee4 YES P�O Does 1hi6 D� D� a sldl no[ rarm�y'OOSeessM bY �Y wfrent atY emPbY�? YES NO Is dtis pneauhrm a terpeted oarbort YES MO COST/REVQIUE BUDOETm (CIRCLE ON� 1�9Y71i/`D YEE NO (e%PwM OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY Clayton M. Robinson, Jr., City Attorney � _�� CITY OF SAINT PAUL Norm Colemax, Mayor Civil Division 400 City Ha!! /5 West Xellogg Blvd Saint Pau1, Minnesota 55702 Telephone: 651266-8i ]0 Facsimile: 65I 298-5619 February 16, 2000 NOTICE OF COUNCIL HEARING Mr. Phuoc Huu Lieu Wabasha Auto Repair 411 Wabasha Street South Saint Paul, Minnesota 55107 �VYL�'diP �vti'l`P��i 14 ,�r� ., �:Y . � �� b � �� RE: Auto Repair Garage License held by Phuoc Huu Lieu, d/b/a Wabasha Auto 32epair, for- the premises at 411 Wabasha Street South License ID #: 990001579 Dear Mr. Lieu: Please take notice that a hearing concerning the above-named establishxnent has been scheduled for 5:30 p.m., Wednesday, March 1, 2000 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City Hali and Ramsey County Courthouse. Enclosed are copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested hearing, in that the facts concerning the violations of your license conditions have not been denied. You wili have an opportunity at the Council hearing to present oral and/or written remarks as to the penalty, if any, to be imposed. If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710. Very truly yours, �/ti�.�J�� Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP Christine Rozek, LIEP Steve Faust, Community Organizer, West Side Citizens Organization, 127 Winifred St. W., St. Paui, MN 55107 UNCONTESTED LICENSE HEARING oo -ao�r Licensee Name: Council Date: Phuoc Huu Lieu d/b/a Wabasha Auto Repair March 1, 2000 Violation: Violation of license condition #2 requiring that a post and chain or a guardrail shall be installed and maintained along the property line at Wabasha Street to prevent vehicles from parking over the public sidewalk. Violation of license condition #3 restricting the number of vehicles parked outdoors on the lot to a maximum of 7. Place: Licensed Premises Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection: 30 day suspension ofi license, with 15 days stayed for 18 months on 3 conditions: 1. Properiy brought into compliance within one week from passage of the resolution; Attachments: 2. no further violations of ficense conditions or other code or zoning violations during 18 months; 3. the licensee shati pay a$500.00 fine within 30 days of adoption of the resolution. 1. Proposed resolution 2. 1/25/00 Notice of Violation 3. License Information Report 4. 1/4/00 memo re 1/3/00 inspection 5. 12/29/99 Citizen Complaint form 6. 12/2/99 letter from Kristina Schweinler to Phuoc Huu Lieu �� -ao� 7. License information and conditions CITY OF SAINT PAUL A'ormCo(einan, �Ltay�or January 25, 2Q�0 OFFIC" �F 7'HE CITY ATTORNEY C(aylon . _tob+rzsox, Jc, CityA[lorney O Q aQ � c;vrt o;v;s,on 400 Ciry Hal[ 1 S fFesl Kellogg Blyd. Saint Paul, ,tlinnesota S.i! 02 Telep/rone: 65f 266-8 Facsimile: 6S I 293-5619 NOTICE OF VIOLATION Mr. Phuoc Huu Lieu Wabasha Auto Repair 411 Wabasha Street South Saint Paul, Minnesota 55107 RE: Auto Repair Gazage License held by Phuoc Huu Lieu, d/b/a �Vabasha Auto Repair, for the premises at 411 Wabasha Street South License TD #: 990001579 Dear Mr. Lieu: The Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection has recommended adverse action against the auto repair gaza�e license held by you at 411 Wabasha Street South in Saint Paul. The basis for the adverse action is as follows: It is a condition of your business license that no more than seven vehicles can be parked on your lot outdoors. You were sent a letter dated December 2,1999 advising you that a recent inspection showed eleven vehicles parked on your lot. Another condition on your license required a post and chain or guardraii to be installed and maintained along the property line at Wabasha Street. The December 2, 1499 letter gave you until December 17, 1999 to bring your lot into compliance «�ith the conditions. An inspection on January 3, 2000 showed 12 cars parked on your property and still no guardrail instalied. If you do not dispute the above facts please send me a letter w7th a statement to that effect. The matter will then be scheduled for a hearin� before the St. Pau1 City Council to determine �rhat penalty, if any, to impose. You w�ill have an opportunity to appear and speak on your own behalf, or to have someone appear there for you. Page 2 Mr. Phuoc Huu Lieu January 25, 2000 t�C� -�� On the other hand, if you wish to dispute the above facts, I will schedule an evidentiary hearing before an Administrative Law Jud�e. If you �vish to have such a hearins, please send me a letter stating that you are contestin� the facts. You will then be sent a"Notice of Hearin�," so you will know when and where to appear, and what the basis for the hearing c��ill be. In either case, please let me I:no�v in writing no later than Monday, February 7, 2000, how you �vould like to proceed. If I have not heard from you by that date, I`viil assume that you are not contesting the facts. The matter �vill then be scheduled for the hearing before the St. Paul City Council. If you have any questions, feel free to call me or have your attomey call me at 266-8710. Sincerely, C � �utcz� � � Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP Christine Rozek, LIEP Steve Faust, Community Organizer, West Side Citizens Organization, 127 Winifred St. W., St. Paul, MN 55107 Oc7-3o� STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF RAMSEY AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says that on January 26, 2000, she served the attached NOTICE OF VIOLATION on the following named person by placing a true and correct copy thereof in an envelope addressed as follows: Mr. Phuoc Huu Lieu Wabasha Auto Repair 411 Wabasha Street South St. Paul, MN. 55107 (which is the last known address of said person) and depositing the same, with postage prepaid, in the Unite ates mails at St. Paul, Minnesota. � /� /) G. C1�M�T5 Subscribed and sworn to before me this 26th day of January, 2000. i%` �%�2�`l'//�� COMMl39 Notary Publa r �� .F�p��EB�AN.31,20� I� �: iQ' i ,.� �W I � �yIO I�;o N 'iU iN � IJ ,c A � a ��, I�O '� O ¢ � C O .� � � .� c m N c m U J IN � i� � I� : INI C�� . 0 I J'.Q d � � i � I Q� �T L I Q iC � �U O I � �Q O — 0 � � N I � O� r i�,� Z � c ° o U'� �� I �a , I�� N � � � N I � N Q � IQ � I ,� o r � �� a W K � I � � �IQ I I � �Q Z I,= ! m'a �,Q _ � � _ W N' N'� O10 ;�;� I� a � C., 3 I�i U �I I I IM �O N i �I Q I W N c L I �� EI ZI U� la i � V I C, N' �, ICi �`. � �Z I I� N d O' I N cl, NI 3I C+ Li � � � I Z N C � j L � a a , I � N I C � N �� m I� n I� � I 0 X �N 'u� I�' I�i i� ', O C � £ i o' U t I I � � � S ! ¢ i � i� �� F � . . � v� � a a m � W o � � - o .� n T > 3 v� s � � y � � 3 c�i o a_ - � m a� �3 � � � X N t N � .t � R ( N � � C � � C � �w : Q �Y U Q O � O Q � a o V � � - � O N QU C Uw.Q"6 N"6 (p_ CO..��•N �� S3O'-'._ � L '6 O_ � (E � f�/1 C N �N �p.�N O� @ L� p_� -a- ��j� � C � O N � C @ t9 ..�. O'a �!!�= �om c a�Y�a�3 C � �nrn �'�n�>E �� aN.�.. y,� OC LN� CN(p �O NU'V OU_ �G L'�N,CE 3 � N j p N m � o - o > „_, p > �s � � oa `o Y`n m>�OCO m � a �y N m`� `o �Q .6oc�E:: Q'C L".' E Q. N U� _� UN� 3 N �� E N aO tA� �(n�X U a � m� L O� p N�>� U � L `� VI �Q @�"'Q �� r� YY L� � 3o a�'a�i �� = o� � �� N m UOtn �J N f� Q� N '�'6 � fl-.. � ` � � Q R � N C � y � UNC� C� �� U C �U� N ln `�- a y N Y o � c N O c c � � � � N N �OOy p_�f6 C �� Q � = U 0 � N Y � 0 U'J C O�pU'o ��O O U� j � � - oco'3 0 � � m� Ca � Q >U' �� @ C N U N O W w �p.� � QNV N N O_C ? �iR'S N�Ea mao� � o �0.�2 cZ� .� m c � o O � O�'�� (D6J� o m��m.,c�rnrn O ��'p�.'�NN M � N�N �NN c�- 3� in (Q �fJ C'7 V oo-�� i� i� 0 jQ , x M W �r N � O v1 N � 6) y U � {�p IJ !M a �j� � O G d � C O R G � V�-� C N N c d V J ��, �', � N I� j U /U �J Q I IQ . N F" � I�N',`m C Q IU N N I � ` LL O — o ' N � N I � p1 <- � � I� j�,o G O � U p�j L � I�I i�l ��N � � :N N � 2 � Q N la Q ,Q � O � � -�V � � Q a W � �� I�I¢ ' � IQ VZ �� Q Q m � I Q �i � � _ W � J m ,I� z :_ � I� � IS �a Vi �I O U, i' N I 'M � O m� � X �I N; �i �I n N 9 i �; �, U' O d i' a� � U C' m', �- N C, � I� � � I Z a C N I� 0 U U' f L' m � Nt Gi � N � � �I � 2 N C � O r t � a � N N N N N ^ C IO] W I �X O m j� M i � � i l im' �� 10' U! NI N; C' m ' I i ' J � � � Q S Q m V l i� C � �= la , c 0 IN I�' �O, U l l i �� F � � � � a d Q N "'L N W O C C " O J o_ � > � in �a ., v'o � ..m � ma� � 3 a� o_ a.Q a�m ° a °' i � 3 d w N � X N N (p CJ] � � � � O.� � O?` F N Q (pY U Q 0 N �Q �� O U 'o O Q O � N O O_ N� N D..0 C U .Q'p a c �� a�i� E� � = N � .0 � fl. L N N Oy �-y � a a - a -o -° � `° o 0 �C � � Oin=C N N N Q- � t� '6 N C �i � N 3 � Q '�Y � p � Vl rn� � �-N�N � m m- t mw. � d Vj N . � C � N U O C N N U'_ U _ .'�... C 'LL N L � C O '6 �,� O� N o.c � � oa `o �" �� 50�= Y@ O��sO 'p N f/j aa �°-�°�`�� ocYE�. -�� .c�EQ��i - N U N �t��p� . �iN a�`.ENp, N9 ��. U T Qd N"6 16�L'O .cOyO�� `� �Q � � � � �N>ri[t �tn.. N �� s J - O 3 0 u�i � .°_' o � � � � m �47 m UOrq �J 'f� N d� N "� - � p:wU-. y W� U7 � 0 rna�a� y�c U N C C C C O) �� N... � NO� �CnwQ �UN N �Y� ��rn u> >. � �OOy p_�!6 U C � � � � fl-'-C U Y V� O- �� c O � V'6 � O O V � d ��` O_� N - p (0 �30 �N�` C - a `p_ > (7 cG a� C f0 U N�M y N N � �� a° u� a:wUS yco"a mvo� c �UO�2 CZ� p)�� O o� �rn>rn � pt6 (6�V�� O N�D�""NN M C N�N pNN � �� a� ao -ao� � N Q d W M O M �� O m d !p N R J � a i � _O � 0 i7. � C O « m E 1 0 w c d N _ a� u �.1 N I� i 'N � �� `V C J � _a r � 'N 2 N iQ I� �� N � �a U � J N �Q O — 0 v� 's N � r iJ � Z Iai'O iV � �� ^ I I � I R ��N � F �� N I f� N ",-o a a Q o �V t�Ci � a W K O N = , IQ z �i ¢ Q � I Q I� � W �J �� Z j2 ;� IU I� � �� _ a I U C I 0 U I N m IQ o � � d IQ IW iN I� � I� E I I O °- � I� ;� N i C � z T C Q. Io U IU Im `� . �C � �I s 3� Z i � �� L � a I � N � N 'N = N I�;� m'� I � IF �. - � � M V u� I ' I Vi �� I NI I �I C �N 7 I �m I I I I I I � � 'r � Q _ Q Q � � �C � � c N G l � U N T ' N C H � � � � � n;'n a� -- .c � W o � _" o � `o_ �� > 3 �n t � � y � s 3 m o. a s = � m o a � - 3 _ Q � N a� � m � �� m � Q.- p) O >` {- N Q (q Y U O_ N `p N �Q ��oo a Op_ "6� 3 � O QN m�N Q _U C V Q"Oa N'6 N-CO�� N C � � � � � � iL 'O Q� � � � C O � � O , L , � s � o_ �'� a ��a�oo � � _ N O N � C N N �0 �.� 3 am cm.Y�a� ' C Q � Ntn QiQ �� (0� -QNL N� � C L N� C�� N� N U U � V L .'_.. � �(0 �' N N L �- d N N C O "O > ..�-. O �! � .c � � o a `o a v ' � a� � o�— � �n rn> � o c o � N � N y (6� O a�Q �OCmE�. � � L'�' � aN 41 = y U � � N � � �i N �... � � fl.Qw fn� ��X �? T a� � m � .c a °-� Q. :co�o��»�E r > NY °>-° m �a m d � � Ec�i�riv E�ri� y YY � � -° �a � � p� � ��fp � E > �N O) U�N �', �.J t� N p_� (D J "6 �L, a'.- rn�a� �o (pN f�ll C � N C U� C N �r U � LA�� d(nw Q y UN =yNO �� U p.� C .�. � Q G � U � � N YNO_ U�C p �U O p O U..'�-. N C �`fl"J - �a�m� �"O � p_ >� C ^ 2 a�C(6 UN�M a? d m.- � �mv U'0=0 N U N N QC N+�� > m :_. ,�c o� ma o� CO�OJSCZ� . p� � i O � ,,, o � �rn �rn �rnrn i M � �N � �, o,_ _, c-3vJ�nmu��vv 00 -ao� Ginger Palme - 411 Wa Paqe 1 From: Kristina Schweinler �a -a� � To: Palmer, Ginger Date: 1/4/00 10:31AM Subject: 41� Wabasha t inspected the properiy yesterday 1/3/2000 and took pictures the property is still out of compliance. I have entered notes into the file and have the pictures being developed.There were 6 cars on the side of the bldg.and 6 cars in the front parking also there was a tow truck loading or unioading i didn't stay to see but they were already in trouble so it wouldn't have mattered. I aiso got a comp. from Citizen Service saying there were 16 veh. at that time. i send you a copy. Let me know if you need anything else. CC: Rozek, Christine CITY OF SAINT PAUL MAYOR & COUNCZL INFORMATSON and COMPLAINT OFFICE CZTIZEN SERVICE PROGRAM 170 CITY HALL 55102 266-8989 (Phone) 266-8689 (Fax) ID NiJMBER: 28424811687LEP 00 -�� ORIGZNAL CMPLT DATE: 12-29-99 TO: CHRISTINE ROZEK LICENSE, INSPECTIONS & ENV. PROTECTION 3 � FR: BETTY DAY INFO AND COMPLAINT OFFICE LOCATION OF COMPLAINT: 411 WABASHA ST S WARD 02 DISTRICT 03 CENSUS 37100 LICENSE Fee Owner THE FOLLOWING IS STATED BY THE COMPLAINANT.... FREDS TIRE CO INC . THIS IS THE AUTO TECH. SERVICE: THERE ARE 16 00519 UNIVERSZTY AVE W VEFIICLES ON THE LOT WFIICH IS A VZOLAITON OF THE ST PAUL MN 551031938 CITY'S LSCENSES/PERMIT TO OPERATE. THE TOW TRUCK IS USUALLY PARKED OVER THE SZDEWALR. Tax Owner MOHAMMED FAYYAZ HAYAT ROOHI FAYYAZ 02210 F200SEVELT ST NE MINNEAPOLIS NIN 554184035 Complainant Znformation Also Sent to: ANONYMOUS Respond within 4 working days. Send response to 170 CITY HALL. RESPONSE BY: RESPONSE DATE: FOLLOW-UP DATE: CLOSED DATE: �* Eithex FOLLOW-UP OT CLOSED date MUST be eRteTed ** THE RHSPONSIT YOII $NTER CF�L7 BE DISCLOSED TO THS PIISLIC. OFFICE OF LICENSE, IYSPECTIOVS AND ENVIRONMENTALPROTECTION Ro6ert Kess(er, Directo� CITY OF SAlNT PAUL Norm Colemars. bfnyor Dec.2, 1999 Mr.Phuoc Huu Lieu Wabasha Auto Repair St.Paui, Mn. 551Q7 Mr. Lieu, LOWRYPROFESSlONdL BUlLDING 350 Sc Peter So-eet. Suite 300 S¢intPauLHlinnuota 55t02-I.i10 oo-�oY TelepF.one: 657-?66-9D90 Faaimi(e: 65 /-266-9099 651-366-97?4 A recent inspection of your licensed establishment show you to be out of compliance with the conditions of your license. The maximum number of vehicles parked outdoors on the lot cannot exceed seven(7). At the time of my inspection I counted 11 vehicles on your lot and 3 on the street that appeared to be customers of your establishment. The lot was to be striped and a post and chain or guardrail installed at Wabasha St. This has not been done. Vehicle parts, tires, oil or similar items will not be stored out doors. There were car doors, tires and an engine lift along with numerous other part outdoors this is not allowed. Also at the time of my inspection it appeared that auto body work was bein� done on a vehicle in the garage. Auto body repair is not allowed in this zoning district. I have attached a copy of the conditions of your license. You have until December 17` to bring your establishment into compliance with the conditions and to clean the area of any parts or derris. Failure to do so may result in adverse action being taken against your license. Please contact me if you have any questions at (651)266-9110. Re pectfully, � .-��,�.�, ��.�. Kristina Schweinler Sr. License Inspector Cc: Christine Rozek., Deputy Director Larry Zangs, Zoning Specia(ist Ginger Palmer, Asst. City Atty. :i=`� �`� �.�� = ?' .,_.__._? (7� _�� P q I Pn�m _;: I H� Su� ` License � Licensee � Lic. Types , Insurancc r Frc,�erty t' Licensee �` Unofficial Street #: 11 StreEt Name: NABASHA ! Street Type: ST Direction: �— � Unit Ind: �— Unit #: �— � City: T PAUL S1ate: 1N Zip: 55107 j Ward: L� Browse i Disi Councii: 3J� I Licensee: � DBA: $5�85 T&X �(�: License Type Flarm Permit ( Auto ftepair C False Alarms License # 90i Licensee HUOC HUU LIEU GH€. lVABFSHA RU7U kEPAIR 1 Bonci l FequiremEnts l Project Facild�,tor: Ia1ARTEtdS, COP.INNE � � Adverse Action Comments I , CammErhs: t/3NG reinspected and took �ic.countEd 6 cars �nd a ' owtruck unloadingon side �nd 6 cars in I rar�t.KS.12IZP39 - Letter from Kris S re non-camplisnce j iih conditions of IicenselJL �'t25�39 - Did not approved license to prird - need siqned Camments: Class � Effective 2 � �7N1 M 999 � OSM 1 I1999 =�— Z I OSM 9M 999 OSM 1 t2�00 ' hS OSM 1 f2400 IV 12r1M999 ! N HUU LIEU 43680 Bus Phone:K651)222-8615 579 Save Changes to History License Fee 7 Cancel �s -J Heip 7 "�GroupWise... �ECLIPS Ap... 8. ECLIPS Lic... �) License qu... � Propertie_.. � License Group Conditions Text 01/24/2000 Licensee: pHUOC HUU LIEU �BA- WABASHAAUTO REPAIR OO '�,�� License#: �9g90001579 1. Vehicles will 6e parked on the lot as indicated on the approved site plan file with LIEP. The lot should be striped, as shown on this plan and the handicapped parking space appropriately marked. 2. A post and chain or guardrail shall be installed and maintained along the property line at Wabasha Street to prevent vehicle parking over the public sidewalk. 3. The maximum number of vehicles, parked outdoors on the lot, cannot exceed seven (7). 4. All vehicies parked outdoors on the lot must appear to be wmpletely assembled with no major body parts missing. Vehicle salvage is not pertnittetl. � 5. Vehicle parts, tires, oil or similar items will not be stored outdoors. Trash wiii be stored in the dumpster. ORfG1i��fl Presented By Referred To � ,�-, �--i 2 KESOLVED, that the Auto Repair Gazage license held by Phuoc Huu Lieu d/b/a 3 Wabasha Auto Repair (License ID # 990001579) , for the premises at 411 Wabasha Street South, 4 is hereby suspended for a period of tlurty days for violation of conditions placed on the license. 6 FURTF3ER RESOLVED, that 15 days of said suspension shall be stayed for a period of 7 eighteen months on the following conditions: 1) that the properry is brought into compliance 8 with the conditions on the license within one week from the passage of this Resolution; 2) that 9 there be no fiurther violations of the conditions on the license or other code or zoning violations 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 during the eighteen months; and 3) that the licensee pay a fine of $500.00, said fine to be paid to the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection within thirty(30) days of the adoption of this resolution by the Council and signature by the Mayor. For the remaining 15 days suspension, no business operations shall be permitted beginning at 12:01 am., Wednesday, Mazch 22, 20Q0, through 11:59 p.m., Wednesday Apri15, 2Q00. This Resolution and the action of the Council in this matter are based upon the facts contained in the December 2, 19991ettez to the licensee from LIEP, the January 25, 2000 Notice of Violation letter to the licensee, and such arguments as may have been presented to the Council at the public hearing. The licensee did not contest the facts of the violation. Requested by Department of: Adoption Certified by Council Secretaxy BY: Appz By: Council File # lJ�— a 2 Dlf / � i %i//. � i�L Form Approved by City Attorney �� $Y � ��S�n��_ � � ��"`c. Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council BY: Adopted by Council: Date ,.�y� l�.p Ga �- l�/�-ZD�' Office of the City Attomey 266-8710 - Public TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES Febniary 17 20o GREEN SHEET No � ��? j 7 wmuwd timrio.c. �,.,,��s.,�. �� acx .�eecae �••caaEr ana.a�c ure�c � ❑wuuio��me�sow_ w+w�t�ro ❑ WYptI�AtOfl111f) � (CLJP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATUR� - — -- - — - Resolution concerning adverse action against the �Auto Repair Garage License held_by Phuoc Huu Lieu, Wabasha Auto Repair, 411 Wabasha Street South. (Uncontested) PLANNING CAMMISSION CIB COMMRTEE CML SERV{CE CAMMISSI00! NHOUNT OF TRANSACTION Fi� ntis pe�aoMUm e�e.�arlo� �ntle. a �aa�aa a.mis ae�mnenn YES NO Hes mis peramRrm euer baen a cdY empbyee4 YES P�O Does 1hi6 D� D� a sldl no[ rarm�y'OOSeessM bY �Y wfrent atY emPbY�? YES NO Is dtis pneauhrm a terpeted oarbort YES MO COST/REVQIUE BUDOETm (CIRCLE ON� 1�9Y71i/`D YEE NO (e%PwM OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY Clayton M. Robinson, Jr., City Attorney � _�� CITY OF SAINT PAUL Norm Colemax, Mayor Civil Division 400 City Ha!! /5 West Xellogg Blvd Saint Pau1, Minnesota 55702 Telephone: 651266-8i ]0 Facsimile: 65I 298-5619 February 16, 2000 NOTICE OF COUNCIL HEARING Mr. Phuoc Huu Lieu Wabasha Auto Repair 411 Wabasha Street South Saint Paul, Minnesota 55107 �VYL�'diP �vti'l`P��i 14 ,�r� ., �:Y . � �� b � �� RE: Auto Repair Garage License held by Phuoc Huu Lieu, d/b/a Wabasha Auto 32epair, for- the premises at 411 Wabasha Street South License ID #: 990001579 Dear Mr. Lieu: Please take notice that a hearing concerning the above-named establishxnent has been scheduled for 5:30 p.m., Wednesday, March 1, 2000 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City Hali and Ramsey County Courthouse. Enclosed are copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested hearing, in that the facts concerning the violations of your license conditions have not been denied. You wili have an opportunity at the Council hearing to present oral and/or written remarks as to the penalty, if any, to be imposed. If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710. Very truly yours, �/ti�.�J�� Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP Christine Rozek, LIEP Steve Faust, Community Organizer, West Side Citizens Organization, 127 Winifred St. W., St. Paui, MN 55107 UNCONTESTED LICENSE HEARING oo -ao�r Licensee Name: Council Date: Phuoc Huu Lieu d/b/a Wabasha Auto Repair March 1, 2000 Violation: Violation of license condition #2 requiring that a post and chain or a guardrail shall be installed and maintained along the property line at Wabasha Street to prevent vehicles from parking over the public sidewalk. Violation of license condition #3 restricting the number of vehicles parked outdoors on the lot to a maximum of 7. Place: Licensed Premises Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection: 30 day suspension ofi license, with 15 days stayed for 18 months on 3 conditions: 1. Properiy brought into compliance within one week from passage of the resolution; Attachments: 2. no further violations of ficense conditions or other code or zoning violations during 18 months; 3. the licensee shati pay a$500.00 fine within 30 days of adoption of the resolution. 1. Proposed resolution 2. 1/25/00 Notice of Violation 3. License Information Report 4. 1/4/00 memo re 1/3/00 inspection 5. 12/29/99 Citizen Complaint form 6. 12/2/99 letter from Kristina Schweinler to Phuoc Huu Lieu �� -ao� 7. License information and conditions CITY OF SAINT PAUL A'ormCo(einan, �Ltay�or January 25, 2Q�0 OFFIC" �F 7'HE CITY ATTORNEY C(aylon . _tob+rzsox, Jc, CityA[lorney O Q aQ � c;vrt o;v;s,on 400 Ciry Hal[ 1 S fFesl Kellogg Blyd. Saint Paul, ,tlinnesota S.i! 02 Telep/rone: 65f 266-8 Facsimile: 6S I 293-5619 NOTICE OF VIOLATION Mr. Phuoc Huu Lieu Wabasha Auto Repair 411 Wabasha Street South Saint Paul, Minnesota 55107 RE: Auto Repair Gazage License held by Phuoc Huu Lieu, d/b/a �Vabasha Auto Repair, for the premises at 411 Wabasha Street South License TD #: 990001579 Dear Mr. Lieu: The Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection has recommended adverse action against the auto repair gaza�e license held by you at 411 Wabasha Street South in Saint Paul. The basis for the adverse action is as follows: It is a condition of your business license that no more than seven vehicles can be parked on your lot outdoors. You were sent a letter dated December 2,1999 advising you that a recent inspection showed eleven vehicles parked on your lot. Another condition on your license required a post and chain or guardraii to be installed and maintained along the property line at Wabasha Street. The December 2, 1499 letter gave you until December 17, 1999 to bring your lot into compliance «�ith the conditions. An inspection on January 3, 2000 showed 12 cars parked on your property and still no guardrail instalied. If you do not dispute the above facts please send me a letter w7th a statement to that effect. The matter will then be scheduled for a hearin� before the St. Pau1 City Council to determine �rhat penalty, if any, to impose. You w�ill have an opportunity to appear and speak on your own behalf, or to have someone appear there for you. Page 2 Mr. Phuoc Huu Lieu January 25, 2000 t�C� -�� On the other hand, if you wish to dispute the above facts, I will schedule an evidentiary hearing before an Administrative Law Jud�e. If you �vish to have such a hearins, please send me a letter stating that you are contestin� the facts. You will then be sent a"Notice of Hearin�," so you will know when and where to appear, and what the basis for the hearing c��ill be. In either case, please let me I:no�v in writing no later than Monday, February 7, 2000, how you �vould like to proceed. If I have not heard from you by that date, I`viil assume that you are not contesting the facts. The matter �vill then be scheduled for the hearing before the St. Paul City Council. If you have any questions, feel free to call me or have your attomey call me at 266-8710. Sincerely, C � �utcz� � � Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP Christine Rozek, LIEP Steve Faust, Community Organizer, West Side Citizens Organization, 127 Winifred St. W., St. Paul, MN 55107 Oc7-3o� STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF RAMSEY AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says that on January 26, 2000, she served the attached NOTICE OF VIOLATION on the following named person by placing a true and correct copy thereof in an envelope addressed as follows: Mr. Phuoc Huu Lieu Wabasha Auto Repair 411 Wabasha Street South St. Paul, MN. 55107 (which is the last known address of said person) and depositing the same, with postage prepaid, in the Unite ates mails at St. Paul, Minnesota. � /� /) G. C1�M�T5 Subscribed and sworn to before me this 26th day of January, 2000. i%` �%�2�`l'//�� COMMl39 Notary Publa r �� .F�p��EB�AN.31,20� I� �: iQ' i ,.� �W I � �yIO I�;o N 'iU iN � IJ ,c A � a ��, I�O '� O ¢ � C O .� � � .� c m N c m U J IN � i� � I� : INI C�� . 0 I J'.Q d � � i � I Q� �T L I Q iC � �U O I � �Q O — 0 � � N I � O� r i�,� Z � c ° o U'� �� I �a , I�� N � � � N I � N Q � IQ � I ,� o r � �� a W K � I � � �IQ I I � �Q Z I,= ! m'a �,Q _ � � _ W N' N'� O10 ;�;� I� a � C., 3 I�i U �I I I IM �O N i �I Q I W N c L I �� EI ZI U� la i � V I C, N' �, ICi �`. � �Z I I� N d O' I N cl, NI 3I C+ Li � � � I Z N C � j L � a a , I � N I C � N �� m I� n I� � I 0 X �N 'u� I�' I�i i� ', O C � £ i o' U t I I � � � S ! ¢ i � i� �� F � . . � v� � a a m � W o � � - o .� n T > 3 v� s � � y � � 3 c�i o a_ - � m a� �3 � � � X N t N � .t � R ( N � � C � � C � �w : Q �Y U Q O � O Q � a o V � � - � O N QU C Uw.Q"6 N"6 (p_ CO..��•N �� S3O'-'._ � L '6 O_ � (E � f�/1 C N �N �p.�N O� @ L� p_� -a- ��j� � C � O N � C @ t9 ..�. O'a �!!�= �om c a�Y�a�3 C � �nrn �'�n�>E �� aN.�.. y,� OC LN� CN(p �O NU'V OU_ �G L'�N,CE 3 � N j p N m � o - o > „_, p > �s � � oa `o Y`n m>�OCO m � a �y N m`� `o �Q .6oc�E:: Q'C L".' E Q. N U� _� UN� 3 N �� E N aO tA� �(n�X U a � m� L O� p N�>� U � L `� VI �Q @�"'Q �� r� YY L� � 3o a�'a�i �� = o� � �� N m UOtn �J N f� Q� N '�'6 � fl-.. � ` � � Q R � N C � y � UNC� C� �� U C �U� N ln `�- a y N Y o � c N O c c � � � � N N �OOy p_�f6 C �� Q � = U 0 � N Y � 0 U'J C O�pU'o ��O O U� j � � - oco'3 0 � � m� Ca � Q >U' �� @ C N U N O W w �p.� � QNV N N O_C ? �iR'S N�Ea mao� � o �0.�2 cZ� .� m c � o O � O�'�� (D6J� o m��m.,c�rnrn O ��'p�.'�NN M � N�N �NN c�- 3� in (Q �fJ C'7 V oo-�� i� i� 0 jQ , x M W �r N � O v1 N � 6) y U � {�p IJ !M a �j� � O G d � C O R G � V�-� C N N c d V J ��, �', � N I� j U /U �J Q I IQ . N F" � I�N',`m C Q IU N N I � ` LL O — o ' N � N I � p1 <- � � I� j�,o G O � U p�j L � I�I i�l ��N � � :N N � 2 � Q N la Q ,Q � O � � -�V � � Q a W � �� I�I¢ ' � IQ VZ �� Q Q m � I Q �i � � _ W � J m ,I� z :_ � I� � IS �a Vi �I O U, i' N I 'M � O m� � X �I N; �i �I n N 9 i �; �, U' O d i' a� � U C' m', �- N C, � I� � � I Z a C N I� 0 U U' f L' m � Nt Gi � N � � �I � 2 N C � O r t � a � N N N N N ^ C IO] W I �X O m j� M i � � i l im' �� 10' U! NI N; C' m ' I i ' J � � � Q S Q m V l i� C � �= la , c 0 IN I�' �O, U l l i �� F � � � � a d Q N "'L N W O C C " O J o_ � > � in �a ., v'o � ..m � ma� � 3 a� o_ a.Q a�m ° a °' i � 3 d w N � X N N (p CJ] � � � � O.� � O?` F N Q (pY U Q 0 N �Q �� O U 'o O Q O � N O O_ N� N D..0 C U .Q'p a c �� a�i� E� � = N � .0 � fl. L N N Oy �-y � a a - a -o -° � `° o 0 �C � � Oin=C N N N Q- � t� '6 N C �i � N 3 � Q '�Y � p � Vl rn� � �-N�N � m m- t mw. � d Vj N . � C � N U O C N N U'_ U _ .'�... C 'LL N L � C O '6 �,� O� N o.c � � oa `o �" �� 50�= Y@ O��sO 'p N f/j aa �°-�°�`�� ocYE�. -�� .c�EQ��i - N U N �t��p� . �iN a�`.ENp, N9 ��. U T Qd N"6 16�L'O .cOyO�� `� �Q � � � � �N>ri[t �tn.. N �� s J - O 3 0 u�i � .°_' o � � � � m �47 m UOrq �J 'f� N d� N "� - � p:wU-. y W� U7 � 0 rna�a� y�c U N C C C C O) �� N... � NO� �CnwQ �UN N �Y� ��rn u> >. � �OOy p_�!6 U C � � � � fl-'-C U Y V� O- �� c O � V'6 � O O V � d ��` O_� N - p (0 �30 �N�` C - a `p_ > (7 cG a� C f0 U N�M y N N � �� a° u� a:wUS yco"a mvo� c �UO�2 CZ� p)�� O o� �rn>rn � pt6 (6�V�� O N�D�""NN M C N�N pNN � �� a� ao -ao� � N Q d W M O M �� O m d !p N R J � a i � _O � 0 i7. � C O « m E 1 0 w c d N _ a� u �.1 N I� i 'N � �� `V C J � _a r � 'N 2 N iQ I� �� N � �a U � J N �Q O — 0 v� 's N � r iJ � Z Iai'O iV � �� ^ I I � I R ��N � F �� N I f� N ",-o a a Q o �V t�Ci � a W K O N = , IQ z �i ¢ Q � I Q I� � W �J �� Z j2 ;� IU I� � �� _ a I U C I 0 U I N m IQ o � � d IQ IW iN I� � I� E I I O °- � I� ;� N i C � z T C Q. Io U IU Im `� . �C � �I s 3� Z i � �� L � a I � N � N 'N = N I�;� m'� I � IF �. - � � M V u� I ' I Vi �� I NI I �I C �N 7 I �m I I I I I I � � 'r � Q _ Q Q � � �C � � c N G l � U N T ' N C H � � � � � n;'n a� -- .c � W o � _" o � `o_ �� > 3 �n t � � y � s 3 m o. a s = � m o a � - 3 _ Q � N a� � m � �� m � Q.- p) O >` {- N Q (q Y U O_ N `p N �Q ��oo a Op_ "6� 3 � O QN m�N Q _U C V Q"Oa N'6 N-CO�� N C � � � � � � iL 'O Q� � � � C O � � O , L , � s � o_ �'� a ��a�oo � � _ N O N � C N N �0 �.� 3 am cm.Y�a� ' C Q � Ntn QiQ �� (0� -QNL N� � C L N� C�� N� N U U � V L .'_.. � �(0 �' N N L �- d N N C O "O > ..�-. O �! � .c � � o a `o a v ' � a� � o�— � �n rn> � o c o � N � N y (6� O a�Q �OCmE�. � � L'�' � aN 41 = y U � � N � � �i N �... � � fl.Qw fn� ��X �? T a� � m � .c a °-� Q. :co�o��»�E r > NY °>-° m �a m d � � Ec�i�riv E�ri� y YY � � -° �a � � p� � ��fp � E > �N O) U�N �', �.J t� N p_� (D J "6 �L, a'.- rn�a� �o (pN f�ll C � N C U� C N �r U � LA�� d(nw Q y UN =yNO �� U p.� C .�. � Q G � U � � N YNO_ U�C p �U O p O U..'�-. N C �`fl"J - �a�m� �"O � p_ >� C ^ 2 a�C(6 UN�M a? d m.- � �mv U'0=0 N U N N QC N+�� > m :_. ,�c o� ma o� CO�OJSCZ� . p� � i O � ,,, o � �rn �rn �rnrn i M � �N � �, o,_ _, c-3vJ�nmu��vv 00 -ao� Ginger Palme - 411 Wa Paqe 1 From: Kristina Schweinler �a -a� � To: Palmer, Ginger Date: 1/4/00 10:31AM Subject: 41� Wabasha t inspected the properiy yesterday 1/3/2000 and took pictures the property is still out of compliance. I have entered notes into the file and have the pictures being developed.There were 6 cars on the side of the bldg.and 6 cars in the front parking also there was a tow truck loading or unioading i didn't stay to see but they were already in trouble so it wouldn't have mattered. I aiso got a comp. from Citizen Service saying there were 16 veh. at that time. i send you a copy. Let me know if you need anything else. CC: Rozek, Christine CITY OF SAINT PAUL MAYOR & COUNCZL INFORMATSON and COMPLAINT OFFICE CZTIZEN SERVICE PROGRAM 170 CITY HALL 55102 266-8989 (Phone) 266-8689 (Fax) ID NiJMBER: 28424811687LEP 00 -�� ORIGZNAL CMPLT DATE: 12-29-99 TO: CHRISTINE ROZEK LICENSE, INSPECTIONS & ENV. PROTECTION 3 � FR: BETTY DAY INFO AND COMPLAINT OFFICE LOCATION OF COMPLAINT: 411 WABASHA ST S WARD 02 DISTRICT 03 CENSUS 37100 LICENSE Fee Owner THE FOLLOWING IS STATED BY THE COMPLAINANT.... FREDS TIRE CO INC . THIS IS THE AUTO TECH. SERVICE: THERE ARE 16 00519 UNIVERSZTY AVE W VEFIICLES ON THE LOT WFIICH IS A VZOLAITON OF THE ST PAUL MN 551031938 CITY'S LSCENSES/PERMIT TO OPERATE. THE TOW TRUCK IS USUALLY PARKED OVER THE SZDEWALR. Tax Owner MOHAMMED FAYYAZ HAYAT ROOHI FAYYAZ 02210 F200SEVELT ST NE MINNEAPOLIS NIN 554184035 Complainant Znformation Also Sent to: ANONYMOUS Respond within 4 working days. Send response to 170 CITY HALL. RESPONSE BY: RESPONSE DATE: FOLLOW-UP DATE: CLOSED DATE: �* Eithex FOLLOW-UP OT CLOSED date MUST be eRteTed ** THE RHSPONSIT YOII $NTER CF�L7 BE DISCLOSED TO THS PIISLIC. OFFICE OF LICENSE, IYSPECTIOVS AND ENVIRONMENTALPROTECTION Ro6ert Kess(er, Directo� CITY OF SAlNT PAUL Norm Colemars. bfnyor Dec.2, 1999 Mr.Phuoc Huu Lieu Wabasha Auto Repair St.Paui, Mn. 551Q7 Mr. Lieu, LOWRYPROFESSlONdL BUlLDING 350 Sc Peter So-eet. Suite 300 S¢intPauLHlinnuota 55t02-I.i10 oo-�oY TelepF.one: 657-?66-9D90 Faaimi(e: 65 /-266-9099 651-366-97?4 A recent inspection of your licensed establishment show you to be out of compliance with the conditions of your license. The maximum number of vehicles parked outdoors on the lot cannot exceed seven(7). At the time of my inspection I counted 11 vehicles on your lot and 3 on the street that appeared to be customers of your establishment. The lot was to be striped and a post and chain or guardrail installed at Wabasha St. This has not been done. Vehicle parts, tires, oil or similar items will not be stored out doors. There were car doors, tires and an engine lift along with numerous other part outdoors this is not allowed. Also at the time of my inspection it appeared that auto body work was bein� done on a vehicle in the garage. Auto body repair is not allowed in this zoning district. I have attached a copy of the conditions of your license. You have until December 17` to bring your establishment into compliance with the conditions and to clean the area of any parts or derris. Failure to do so may result in adverse action being taken against your license. Please contact me if you have any questions at (651)266-9110. Re pectfully, � .-��,�.�, ��.�. Kristina Schweinler Sr. License Inspector Cc: Christine Rozek., Deputy Director Larry Zangs, Zoning Specia(ist Ginger Palmer, Asst. City Atty. :i=`� �`� �.�� = ?' .,_.__._? (7� _�� P q I Pn�m _;: I H� Su� ` License � Licensee � Lic. Types , Insurancc r Frc,�erty t' Licensee �` Unofficial Street #: 11 StreEt Name: NABASHA ! Street Type: ST Direction: �— � Unit Ind: �— Unit #: �— � City: T PAUL S1ate: 1N Zip: 55107 j Ward: L� Browse i Disi Councii: 3J� I Licensee: � DBA: $5�85 T&X �(�: License Type Flarm Permit ( Auto ftepair C False Alarms License # 90i Licensee HUOC HUU LIEU GH€. lVABFSHA RU7U kEPAIR 1 Bonci l FequiremEnts l Project Facild�,tor: Ia1ARTEtdS, COP.INNE � � Adverse Action Comments I , CammErhs: t/3NG reinspected and took �ic.countEd 6 cars �nd a ' owtruck unloadingon side �nd 6 cars in I rar�t.KS.12IZP39 - Letter from Kris S re non-camplisnce j iih conditions of IicenselJL �'t25�39 - Did not approved license to prird - need siqned Camments: Class � Effective 2 � �7N1 M 999 � OSM 1 I1999 =�— Z I OSM 9M 999 OSM 1 t2�00 ' hS OSM 1 f2400 IV 12r1M999 ! N HUU LIEU 43680 Bus Phone:K651)222-8615 579 Save Changes to History License Fee 7 Cancel �s -J Heip 7 "�GroupWise... �ECLIPS Ap... 8. ECLIPS Lic... �) License qu... � Propertie_.. � License Group Conditions Text 01/24/2000 Licensee: pHUOC HUU LIEU �BA- WABASHAAUTO REPAIR OO '�,�� License#: �9g90001579 1. Vehicles will 6e parked on the lot as indicated on the approved site plan file with LIEP. The lot should be striped, as shown on this plan and the handicapped parking space appropriately marked. 2. A post and chain or guardrail shall be installed and maintained along the property line at Wabasha Street to prevent vehicle parking over the public sidewalk. 3. The maximum number of vehicles, parked outdoors on the lot, cannot exceed seven (7). 4. All vehicies parked outdoors on the lot must appear to be wmpletely assembled with no major body parts missing. Vehicle salvage is not pertnittetl. � 5. Vehicle parts, tires, oil or similar items will not be stored outdoors. Trash wiii be stored in the dumpster.