The URL can be used to link to this page

280160 WHITE - C1TV CLERK COUIICII �7�y��.�� PINK - FINANCE G I TY OF SA I NT PAU L �. � CANARY - DEPARTMENT BLUE = MAVOR File NO• " Cou cil Resolution Presented By � � Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date BE IT RESOLVED, That the Council of the City of Saint Paul hereby certifies and approves the action of the City of Saint Paul Board of Appeals and Review pertaining to the following listed property and as shown by the Excerpted Minutes of said Board of Appeals and Review, dated March 3, 1983 , and marked EXHIBIT A, and attached hereto and made a part hereof by reference: DATE OF BOARD MINUTES CASE N0. PROPERTY APPELLANT 3/8/83 06-83-H 617 Dayton Ave. Floyd M. Hartwig (5-unit condominium) BOARD ACTION: Granted variances of St. Paul Legislative Code, Section 34 .13, pertaining to basement occupancy, and 5ection 34 .14, pertaining to light and ventilation, to permit continued occupancy of condominium Unit #5, in which ceiling height is one-half inch under minimum standards , windows in sleeping roams do not meet code specifications for escape windows, and there is a deficiency of light and ventilation, on condition that a hallway between sleeping rooms with a stairway leading directly outside at ground level be constructed. Property Description: Woodland Park Addition Apartment ownership No. 56, The Dayton Condominium, except the following: beginning 44.10 ft. South of N.E. corner; the West 1.5 ft. ; the North 38 . 3 ft. the West 0.8 ft. ; the North 5. 8 ft. ; the South to be- ginning Lot 12, Block 2, Woodland Park Addition Apartment No. 5 and an undivided 15.82g interest in common areas and facilities . ------------------------------------------------------------------------ COUNCILMEN Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays Fletcher Levine [n Favor Masanz Nicosia scheibe� __ Against BY Tedesco Wilson Form Approved by City Attorney Adopted by Council: Date Certified Passed by Council Secretary B �� gy, Approved by Mavor: Date Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council By — BY . . , ��,��,� 3/8/83 08-83-H 1555 Carroll Dale M. & Fay R. (four units) Johnson BOARD ACTION: Granted variance of St. Paul Legislative Code, Section 34.11, pertaining to basic facilities, to permit continued occupancy of Apts. #2 and #3 where occupants share use of one bathroom, on condition that no more than one person occupy each said unit, said variance effective for the lifetime of the structure. Granted variance of St. Paul Legislative Code, Section 34 .11, pertaining to basic facilities, to permit con- tinued occupancy of Apt. #4 where bathroom lacks tub or shower, said variance effective only for period of occupancy by current resident, Evelyn Lovaas. Property Description: Snelling Park Lot 14, Block 2 --------------------------------------------------------------------- 3/8/83 07-83-B Grandendale Pharmacy Harold A. Moe & 619 Grand Ave. James R. Miller SOARD ACTION: Granted variance of Minnesota Uniform Building Code, Section 4507 , pertaining to doors, to permit pro- jection of entrance door more than one foot beyond property line. Property Description: Terrace Park Addition, Block 1 thru 8 and Block 12 Lots 11 and 12 , B7.ock 4 --------------------------------------------------------------------- -2- � 3_.�J'3 WHITE - CITV CLERK ^��.^ � A L' PINK - FINANCE COUIICII CANARV - DEPARTMENT GITY OF SAINT PAUL �� n�..� BLUE - MAVOR File NO. � ' Council Resolution Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date and be it FURTHER RESOLVED,That upon passage of this resolution the City Clerk is hereby authorized and directed to transmit a copy of this resolution for recording to the Ramsey County Office of the Register of Deeds. -3- COUNC[LMEN Yeas Na� Requested by Department of: �e11 n�_ In Favor Mas z � Nico a Gallec Sch i el Masanz _ � __ Against BY - Ted s o Nicosia Wi on Scheibel Tedesco ppR 1 2 1983 Form Approved by City Att Adopted by Council:4,��n Date Certified P�s e b ounc.il et 3 �� #pp v by 17avor. te _ Approved by Mayor for Submission to Councii By — BY UBLISHED APR 2 3 1983 � C � ��"sG� � c� ��^�� CITY OF SAINT PAUL ,_....��.. o.°�, -�•` �.�"''�= OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK ;� �; _;� ii�i'1�� '' •;,�� „� ALBERT B. OLSON, CITY CLERK �''��,,�im^,..o�,.-`� 386 City Hall,Saint Paul,Minnesota 55102 612-298-4231 GEORGE LATIMER MAYOR April 18, 1983 County Recorder's Office Room 155 City Hall Dear Sir: I am transmitting a certified copy of C.F. No. 280160 for filing in your off ice. This resolution, approving actions of the St. Paul Board of Appeals & Review,,was adopted by the City Council on April 12, 1983. Very truly yours, Albert B. Olson City Clerk Attach. sch �O . • , � jl • , t V , • . �; � I �� r; �r c� � � � � � � � STATE OF MINNESOTA ) County of Ramsey ) ss. CITY OF SAINT PAUL ) I . . . . . . .Albert .B: .Olson,. . . . _ , .'. . . . . . . . , ,.City Clerk of the . c-�—: !" City of Saint Paul, Minnesota, do hereby certify that I have � m—r 280160 '�; compared the attached copy of Council File No. . . .. . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . �w � , as adopted by the City Council. . . . . . .A�ri1 .12�, , , ,, , , . , _ „ 19. . $3. . `�,�; and apprwed by the Mayor. . . . . . . . . . . .�8��.�. .�.4�. . . . . . . . . . . . 19. . 83. . c� nL. � with the original thereof on file in my office. I further certify that said copy is a true and correct copy of said original and the whole thereof. WITNESS my hand and the seal of the City of Saint Paul, Minnesota this . , _ ,18th . . . . , , day of . , April:. . . . . . . . , ,A.D. 19.83 . , . . . .. . .. . . . . . . .. ,. • • . • • . • • • . • • City Clerk.� • �'��"�'�.�,�°'`' !�"{� � ��'''� ' � ��.. � r ��x > . . l�bz ,� r �'-' r ' � �� ^� �+r. i' � �� .•j � . . s � ,� 4 y [ .�\ a S��k� ' �' . `=''r,,w��lS�N�n<::.� � "��' � . �.. , .. . ` ,. - � --- .�. � � 5 : ; 4 i,. . .. . .. . - ._- . Z,_ - t '.: �.. - ... . . . . _ __. __ � ^ �� R41TE -�U7Y CLERK , � ' � COUl1C1I PINK - FINANCE GITY OF SAINT PAUL f CANA�Y - DEP4RTMEN T � Bll.; - MAV�OR Flle NO. ` . Co cil Resolutio� . �� l , Presented By _�- .... Referred To ` � Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date � BS ZT R$SOLVSD, That ths Conncil of the Citp o! Saiat Panl hereb7 certitiea and approves th� action of the City of Saint Panl Board of rAppeals aad Review pertaininq to th� lollawing liated propertp an8 as — sho�ra bp tha Bscerpted P�iautes of said Board of App�als aad Review, � dat�d l�arch 3, 1983, aad �aarked BYHIBIT A, and attached hereto and made a part hereof hp zeferences DATB OF BOARD ��T83 Cl�SE �IO. PROPBRTY aPPBLS�NT 3/8/83 06-83-H 617 Dayton �ve. Flagd I�. Hartwfq �3-unit condominium) � `'"'� BO�ARD ACTZO�s Granted variances ot St. Paul Leqislative Code, Section r 34.13, pertaininq to bas�eat occupancy, and Sectioa s;` 34.14, pertaiainq to light and ventilatian, to pesmit �" oontinned occnpancY of condc�iniwa IInit #5, in ahich ceiling 2laiqht is oae-half iach nader minim�a standards, - -� �rindo�s in aleepinq roo�s c�o aot aeet code specificstfons �or escape vindovs, and there fe a def�feaey of liqht and veutilation, on conditioa that a hallvaY Detveen �leepinq rooma �►ith a atairray leadfnq dfrectly outside at qronad leve2 be conatructed. . , Property Deacriptions �Poodland Park addition Apartseent oxnerahip m1o. 56, Tha Dayto�a Coadc�iniva�, azcept the follovinq: beginning 44.I4 ft. South of �i.S. cornert, the 1Peat l.S tt.1 th� gorth 38.3 ft. � the ll�st 0.8 tt.j the Horth 5.8 ft.� the South to be- qianinq Lot 12, Block 2, Koodlan8 Park Additioa Apartment b1o. S and an n�divided 1S.82� iaterest in oo�on' areaa � ar�d faci lities. � ____ ____+_.._. .�- ---------� �_________ _�-------- COU[VCILMEN - Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays Fletcher �s�tne In Favor Masanz Nicosis schetbei Against BY � Tedesco Wllson . Adopted by Council: Date Form Approved by City Attorney Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY "�" ✓�� 7�� gy, — ,�ppruved by �lavor. Date Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council BY' ---_______ _. __ _ __--------- __ __ - BY —.--------- ------- _._----------.._ _ �± � �- � ��.s� _ a � � � � � H[ D av 3/8/83 08-83-H 1555 Carroll Dale M. & Fay R. (four units) Johnson BOARD ACTION: Granted variance of St. Paul Legislative Code, Section 34 . 11 , pertaining to basic facilities , to permit continued occupancy of Apts . #2 and #3 where occupants share use of one bathroom, on condition that no more than one person occupy each said unit, said variance effective for the lifetime of the structure. Granted variance of St. Paul Legislative Code, Section 34 .11, pertaining to basic facilities, to permit con- tinued occupancy of Apt. #4 where bathroom lacks tub or shower, said variance effective only for period of occupancy by current resident, Evelyn Lovaas . Property Description: Snelling Park Lot 14, Block 2 ------------------------------------------------------------------ 3/8/83 07-83-B Grandendale Pharmacy Harold A. Moe & 619 Grand Ave. James R. Miller BOARD ACTION: Granted variance of Minnesota Uniform Building Code , � Section 4507 , pertaining to doors , to permit pro- jection of entrance door more than one foot beyond • property line. Property Description: Terrace P.ark Addition, Block 1 thru 8 and Block .12 . Lots 11 and 12 , Block 4 -------------------------------------------------- . -2- 3 � �, . �> , • ,. WMI'rE - CJTV CLERK � ' � � � P�NK - FINANCE GITY OF SAINT PAUL Council ^ (� CAN�Rt y.OEPAR�TMENT •/,Rl{]) Bl},�E - MAYOR File �O• ` „ '"�� W ' Council Resolution Presented By Referred To Committee: Date � Out of Committee By Date � and ba it � FtJI�PHEA RBSOLVED,That upoa passaqe of this resolution the Citp � Clerk is hereby authorized a�d directed to transmit a copy of this � resolution For recordinq to the Ramsey Coantp Office of the Reqiater of Deeds. � - -3- COUIVCILMEN Yeas Nays � Requested by Department of: Le in -�'`' _� [n Favor M s z (�diles N eibel Masa� c� AgainSt BY T esco Nicosia son Scheibsl - T�� APR 1 2 1983 Form Approved by City Attor Adopted by Council:�ison Da�e w c:L--i.. nt��-�-t�- �`'}�' �3 Certified Pa s'Cd by uncil , t y - < � B}� '�t �'v-�^� �.� � �'�pproved by Vlavor: Date APR � 4 1983 Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council B� _---- ---– By —.. ------- ---– -- __---_ _._ _. _ I'i I � . + � � M 4 ��._.._-..-._.._...._....,_.�_.��_�� • W � � � C� (� tJ) �u i'' J v i - ` n � CJ cn ;.. _; :�'' Ci —ti � � :'> >--�� .:a� .71 �;-� � S Ui (� � �a ��"�• � � . 7 .• "p° . , . �.' `! • ; �� '_� I , n C� r, �„ , . � , I ;� E. C� �;��, Y ' � J ! i� � ��1 ,. �• �, �� n ��:� • � � � E� ' � , ��) �` � U P 1� b � • � ; ._ , r., � �, c�r � �� ' �� ; � � a :. N:�� , , r} � � � �� . = t � _, �� - : , �,, t� 13 � � � �. ,�.... , � � � � ;� , h � � � N �T (E) }/ o --�- � 3 �' ` � r ,�� . �t� ' • `G ni � '�" , c r+ � � 3/8/83 - Meeting No. 194 . �_ L-�X f-� I �8 � �T f� �� A4INUTES OF THE �IEETING ST. PAUL BOARD OF APPEALS � REVIEW Tuesday, March 8 , 1983 Room 707 City Hall , 15 �+1. Kellogg Blvd. MEP�IBERS PRESENT : Ron Glassman, Chairman Glenn Gausman Harold Knutson Rosann Bostrom Lucille Burg Collins ABSENT : William Tilton Rudolph Sawyer AGE?�CIES PRESENT: Department of Community Services - Division of of Housing $ Building Code Enforcement : A1ice Bijjani Housing Information Office : Lowell Yost Chris �reamer OTHERS PRESENT: Harold A. Moe Donald Carlson Dale Ni. Johnson Anne Stafstrom Fay R. Johnson Michael Harris Floyd Hartwig Dale Paulson Lorraine Hartwig Daniel Goodell Heidi Hartwig Lara Seven Barry L. Bengts STAFF PRESENT : Patricia Moxness Josephine Palermo The meeting was called to order at 1 : 35 p.m. The minutes of the meeting of February 8 , 1983, were approved as dis- tributed to the members . CASE N0. PROPERTY APPELLANT 06- 83-H 617 Dayton Ave . Floyd M. Har�twig (condominium - (owner of Unit #5) five units) Request variance on Section 34. 13, pertaining to cellar occupancy, and Section 34. 14 , pertaining to light and ventilation, to nermit continued occupancy of Unit #5 where violations of ceiling height , light and ventilation , and escape window rec{uirements exist, because of �ractical difficulty and financial consideratiions . z��.b� _ ' ' -2- 3/8/83 - Meeting No. I94 APPEARANCE : Mr. F� Mrs . Floyd Hartwig PROCEEDINGS : Mr. Hartwig, otivner of basement Unit #S , pronosed to install an interior stairway outside of the sleepin g rooms leading directly to the outside in lieu of altering the existing windows in each bedroom to comply with escape window reQuirements . Alice Bijjani said �his type of access would not meet code , but was better than one that required passing through the apartment in order to reach it . Mr. Hartwig noted that other violations cited by the inspector concerned ceiling height and lack of light and ventilation in the kitchen and living room. The ceiling height was 83z inches , one-half inch short of code . There was no window in the kitchen , but .there were two 20 sq . ft. openings , one to the dining room, the other to the living room. � There was also a deficiency of window area in the living room. Alice Bij j ani explained that the cade required window area equal to 8 0 of floor area for Zight and 40 of floor area openable window for venti- lation. The existing window area in the apartment was 7$ of floor area. BOARD ACTION: Chairman Glassman moved that variances of Section 34. 13 an 34. 14 , pertaining to light and ventilation , be granted, to permit continued use of Apt . #5 where the kitchen lacked a window and where there was a deficiency of light and ventilation in the kitchen an d the living room. Mrs . Bostrom seconded. MOTION CARRIED. THE VOTE : Ayes - 5 Nays - 0 Abstentions - 0 BOARD ACTION: Mr. Knutson moved that a variance of Section 34 . 13, per- taining to ceiling height, be granted, to permit continued use of Apt. #S where ceiling height is 1/2 inch under minimum req_uirements . Mrs . Col- lins seconded. MOTION CARRIED. THE VOTE : Ayes - 5 Nays - 0 Abstentions - 0 In further discussion on the relative merits of providing an additional stairway to the outside of the building in lieu of escape windows within each sleeping room, Mr. Hartwig pointed out that the proposed stairway would need to rise only five feet to an existing door that opened directly outside . There had been such a stairway in the original con- struction of the building, but at some time in the past when the property was remodeled, it had been removed. Restoring them would not be a difficult matter and would be far less expensive th an tearing out thick cement walls to enlarge the bedroom windows . BOARD ACTION : Mr. Knutson moved that a variance of Section 34. 13, per- taining to escape windows in sleeping rooms of b asement occup ancies , be granted, on condition that a stairway leading directly outside be con- structed near the sleeping room area of Unit #5 . Mrs . Collins seconded. MOTION CARRIED. THE VOTE : Ayes - S Nays - 0 Abstentions = 0 - - - - - - - - -- - -- - - -- - -- - -- - - -- -- -- -- - - --- --- --- - - ---- --------- - - - - -- -- -- - --- �� - 3- 3/8/83 - Meeting No. 194 . 08- 83-H 1555 Carroll D�le M. � �ay R. Johnson (four units) SUBJECT : ReQuest variances of Section 34 . 11 , pertaining to basic facilities , to permit continued use of Apt� . #2 and #3, where single occupants share use of one bathroom, and �1��t . �4 , ti�here fiathroom lacks tub or shotiaer, because of financial considerations . APPEARANCE : Dale M. � Fay R. Johnson PROCEEDINGS : Mrs . Johnson said Apts . #2 and #3 are never rented to more t an a single person and there has ne�-er been a problem in sharing use of one b athroom by the two tenants . Apt . #4 has been occupied by Evelyn Lovaas for 30 years . It has its O�JIl half-bath , but Ms . Lovaas can use a full bathroom on second floor or a shoiaer facility in the basement . If the Johnsons had to install a tub or shower wi�thin her ap artment , they would be compe�led to raise her monthly rent from the $90 she now pays and this would create a financial hardship for her. Mrs . Johnson read the contents of a letter ioritten by Ms . Lovaas , in which she requested the board to permit continued occupancy under the existing circumstances . She further wrote that she had a very limited income and finding similar living quarters at this cost would be im- possible , aside from her feeling about her apartment as a home after living there for so many years . Alice Bijjani felt it might be appropriate to permit the situation to continue for as long as Ms . Lovaas lived there , but require compliance _ after that time . BOARD ACTION : Mr. Glassman moved that variances of Section 34. 11 be grante , permitting the continued occupanc�- of Ants . #Z and �3 on a permanent basis , on condition that no more than one person occupy� each of the units , and that continued occupanc�- be permitted in Apt. .#4 where the bathroom lacks bathing facilities as long as tFie present occupant resides there . Mr. Knutson seconded. D�OTION CARRTED. THE VOTE : Ayes - 5 Nays - 0 Abstentions - 0 - - -- - - - --- - - - - - - - - - --- - -- -- -- -- ---- - - -- -- - - -- -- ---- - - -- -- -- - - -- -- -- -- - 3/8/83 - P4eeting No. 194 . . . � A4TNUTES OF THE MEETING ST. PAUL BOARD OF APPEALS � REVIEW Tuesday, March 8, 1983 Room 707 City Hall , 15 t1i. Kellogg Blvd. MEP�IBERS PRESENT : Ron Glassman, Chairman Glenn Gausman Harold Knutson Rosann Bostrom Lucille Burg Collins ABSENT : William Tilton Rudolph Sawyer AGE'�CIES PRESENT: Department of Community Services - Division of of Housing �, Building Code Enforcement : Alice Bijjani Housing Information Office : Lowe 11 Yos t Chris Creamer OTHERS PRESENT :� Harold A. Moe Donald Carlson Dale 1�1. Johnson Anne Stafstrom Fay R. Johnson Michael Harris Floyd Hartwig Dale Paulson Lorraine Hartwig Daniel Goodell Heidi Hartwig Lara Seven Barry L. Bengts STAFF PRESENT: Patricia Moxness Josenhine Palermo The meeting was called to order at 1 : 35 p.m. The minutes of the meeting of February 8 , 1983, were a�proved as dis- trihntPri tn tha mamhPr� _ , � - . - 3- 3/8/83 - Meeting No. 194 �� -- -- -- - -- - - - - - -- - -- - - - - - - - - -- - - ---- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- - - -- -- --- - ---- -- -- -- - 07- 83-B Grandendale Pharmacy Harold A. Moe � 619 Grand Ave . James R. Miller SUBJECT : Request variance on Section 4507, Minnesota.Uniform Building Code , pertaining to doors , to permit projection of entrance door more than one foot beyond property line when opened, because of practical considerations . APPEARANCE : Harold A. Moe PROCEEDINGS : Mr. Glassman questioned whether the board had jurisdiction in t is su ject. He noted that the apnellants also requested a variance on a matter concerned with access specifications for handicapped persons , which was not within the board' s purview, but a problem that should lie referred to the Mayor' s Advisory Committee on Handicapped People , ��.��:�� . � , -4- 3/8/83 - Meeting No. 194 Board Secretary Pat Moxness reported that she had met with Richard Amey and Don Wagner from the Building Code Enforcement Division and they jvere of the opinion that the projection of the door over the sidewalk was a subject that should properly come before the board. Mr. Moe explained that the owners pronosed to place doors on the corner exit area of their building which would create a vestibule, making for better energy conservation . ._ One door would face on Grand and would swing inward. The other would face on Dale and would swing outward in order to avoid conflict with the inner entrance door. Swinging outward would necessarily mean that it would project more than one foot beyond the p ronerty line , contrary to the building code. After discussion and a study of a sketch of the proposed construction, Mr. Knutson asked how far the door would swing out over the walk. Mr. Moe said it would project outward three feet , and the sidewalk was ZO feet to the curb . � BOARD ACTION : Mrs . Bostrom moved that a variance on Section 45Q7, Minne- sota .Uni orm Building Code , be granted, to permit projection of door more than one foot beyond the property line . Mrs . Collins seconded. MOTION CARRIED. THE VOTE : Ayes - 4 Nays - 1 (Gausman) Abstentions - 0 - - - -- - -- - - ---- - - --- --- - - - - - - - ---- ------ -- ---- -- --- - -- -- ---- -- ---- -- ------ - 3/8/83 - P4eeting No. 194 . 1�4INUTES (1F THE MEETING ST. PAUL BOARD OF APPEALS � REVIEI�I Tuesday, Nlarch 8 , 1983 - Room 707 City Hall , 15 1V. Kellogg Blvd. MEP4BE�RS PRESENT : Ron Glassman, Chairman Glenn Gausman Harold Knutson Rosann Bostrom Lucille Burg Collins ABSENT : William Tilton Rudolph Sawyer AGE:�CIES PRESENT: Department of Community Services - Division of of Housing � Building Code Enforcement: Alice Bijjani Housing Information Office : Lowell Yost Chris Creamer - OTHERS PRESENT :� Harold A. Moe Donald �Carlson Dale M. Johnson Anne Stafstrom - Fay R. Johnson D4ichael F-iarris Floyd Hartwig Dale Paulson Lorraine Harttaig Daniel Goodell Heidi Hartwig Lara Seven Barry L. Bengts STAFF PRESENT : Patricia Moxness Josenhine Palermo The meeting was called to order at 1 : 35 n.m, The minutes of the meeting of February 8, 1983, were approved as dis- trih�itP�l tn tha mPmharc . � `,`i� � `��0 . ST. PAUL B011RD OF EIPPEl1LS � R�iVI�:�V 70511 Czty Hall St . Paul , ?�iinnesota 551.02 (612) 298-4163 March 23, 1983 T0: Walter Boti,rser ' Assistant City Attorney � I FROM: Pat Moxness (��`''�'l �I � RE : Draft Resolutions pertaining to Board Actions at Meeting of 3/8/83 Attached are two draft resolutions pertainin�g to board action taken at the March 8 meeting. CASE N0. PROPERTY APRE LLANT � 03- 83-H 1090 Thomas C. Jess Madland 10- 83-H 705 Summit Ave . . James Crockarell - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - -- -- - - -- -- - - - - -- - - - - -- -- -- -- -- -- - - - - - - - -- - -- - -- - 06- 83-H 617 Dayton Ave .. Floyd M. Hartwig . 08-83-H 1555 Carroll Dale M. �, Fay R. .Tohnson Q7- 83-H 619 Grand Avenue Harold A. Moe and . James Miller Tf you have any auestions , please call me on . 4163.