84-21 WHITE - C�TV CLERK
Council ,/
CLN�RV �'7GP RCTMENT GITY OF SAINT PAUL File NO. � • a� , -
BLUE - MAVOR
c 'l esolution
Presented By
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
BE IT P`ESOLVED� That the Council of the City of Saint Paul
hereby certifies and approves the action o� the City of Saint Paul
Board of Appeals and Review vertaining to the followin; listed
property and as shown by the ExcerPted Minutes of said Board of
Appeals and Review, dated Decenber 13, 1903 , and marked EXHIBIT A,
and attached hereto and made a part hereof by reference :
12-13-53 24-o3-F 1863 E. 7th Street Bernard � Kay
Ostertag
BOARD ACTION ; Granted a waiver in the filing fee for application
as tzere Gias nothing within the jurisdiction of the board that
needed to be acted on. Directed the City Clerk to refund appellant ' s
filing fee.
Property Description: Hazel Park Division 4
East 12 ' of lot 21 ,
all of lot 22 and
west 22 ' of lot 23, Block � .
--------------------------
COUNCILMEN Requested by Department of:
Yeas Fletcher Nays
�S �K�� In Favor
Masanz
�ticosia _ __ Against BY
Scheibel
Tedesco
yyi�sp� Form Ap ved City Attorney
Adopted by Council: Date q
Certified Passed by Council Secretary By � � 2'C
gy,
Approved by Mayor: Date _ Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
gy _ _ By
- .. . ��t-�i
12-13-83 41--83RF 478 .r�arshall Ave , Clarence A, Lindeke
BOARD ACTION: Granted an extension of time until December 31 �
�+ t'o aTTow for installation of a keybox and self�closing doors �
Property Description: Selby 1�ZcClund and Vanmeters Addition
East 16 ' of lot 11 and
all of lot 10� block 1 ,
12-13-83 54-83-F 314 Dayton Aye< Clarence A, Lindeke
(11 units � 3 stories)
BOARD ACTION; Granted an extension of time for one year (12-31�8G)
to��"or installation of a fire alarm system, self-closing doors
and a keybox if b�.ilding is security,
Property Description, Auditors Subdivision No . 5 ,
Lot 23 ,
12-13-83 19-83-F 166 W, George St, Clarence A, Lindeke
(14 units , 3 stories)
BOARD ACTIONc Granted an extension of time until Dece,°nber 31 � 1984
to a o�w o�"r installation of a fire alarm system, a keybox if buildin�
is security and self�closin� doors on all apartments .
Property Description ; Nelson Stevens Kings Addition
Lot 7 , Block 6
2 .
WHITE - CITV CLERK
PINK - FINANCE G I TY OF SA I NT 1,A V L COUILCII ,�/- /�/
4f�7A.RYapEPARTMENT
BLUE - MAVOR File NO. �� �
Council Resolution
Presented By
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
12-]�-83 20-83-F 668�-b74 East 4th St. Clarence A. Lindeke
(13 units � 3 stories)
BOARD ACTION: Granted an extension of time until December 31 , 1954 to
a ow or installation of a fire alarn system, self-closing doors on all
apartment� and a keybox if buildin� is security.
Property Description ; Lyman Dayton' s Addition
Lots 22 and 23, Block 32
CQUNCILMEN � Requested by Department of:
Yeas Nays
Fletcher In Favor
C�a,ll�- p2 E tv
P•7asanz
NiCOSia. � __ Against BY --
Scheibel
Tedesco
�'� JQN - 5 1984 Form Approved by City Attorney
Adopted by Council: Date
Certified Pa se y ouncil S ta BY ` ���C �2�.��
sy
`�AN - 9 1984 Appcoved by Mayor for Submission to Council
Approved Mayor: Da —
�-
✓By _ — BY
PUBLISHED JAN 141984
, . E X H I B I T "A" d �Z/
93-83-H 634 Marshall Avenue Martha Harris/Tom Vasaly
SUBJECT: R uests a chang � in the vacate dat� contained in the
condemnation rder dated �-18-83 , as appella t feels the owner
should be made to make t�2'ie repairs rather than her having to move.
APPEARANCE: � Non�, �'
PROCEEDINGS: This`'�,� atter was not on the agenda a the inspector _
and the attorney f the appellant were working o t the problems -- _
between them. At h� request of Frank Staffenson, city Health �
Department, this att r was discussed. Mr. Staifen o requested
permission to bo rd th building up if the problems re not '
solved by Decem er 21, 983 as he has not heard fro he o�vner.
BOARD ACTION: Lucille C lins moved that permiss ' n bc granted
to board up t e building t 634 Marshall Avenue ' f work 'is not
completed by ecember 21, 83. Glenn Gausman econded the motion.
N,otion carri d.
THE VOTE: yes 4 Nays 0 Abstentions 0
� -------------------- --------
24-83-F 1863 E. 7th Street Bernard & Kay Ostertag
(11 units)
SUBJECT: Request a variance of Fire Code requirements pertaining to
self-closing doors, solid core doors, and a fire alarm system, be-
cause of financial hardship.
APPEARANCE: Bernard & Kay Ostertag '
PROCEEDINGS: Mr. Ostertag explairied they did not know if they
needed a fire alarm system or not. Greg Plante said it was de-
termined their building was not 3 stories so the alarm system was
not required. Mr. Plante also explained they have backed down on
the fire-rated doors and are now allowing 1/2" paneled doors so
�ir. Ostertag meets code on that. He further stated the fire depart-
ment strongly recommend s 2 hinges for the self-closing devices.
BOARD ACTION: Ron Glassman felt that it was not necessary for the
Ostertag's to come before the board, therefore, he moved that they
be granted a refund of their $10. 00 filing fee. William Tilton
seconded the motion. Motion carried. �
THE VOTE: Ayes 4 Nays 0 Abstentions 0
--------------------------------------
Fxhibit "A" ° page 2 "� ��
. ,
41-83-F 478 Marshall Ave. Clarence A. Lincleke
SUBJECT: Requests a variance of fire codes pertaining ta installation
of a key box and self-closing doors, because of financial hardship.
APPEARANCE: Clarence A. Lindeke .
PROCEEDINGS: Mr. Lindeke felt he needed extra time and asked for
an extension. He appealed other properties in November and this one - -
is the same situation, so he now feels he would be able to do the __ -
work and comply. - �
BOARD ACTION: Ron Glassman moved_to deny the variance and work mus-t be
done by one year frorn now (December 31, 1984) . William Tilton seconded
the motion. Motion carried.
THE VOTE: Ayes 4 Nays 0 Abstentions 0
-------------------------------
54-83-F 314 Dayton Ave. Clarence A. Lindeke
� (11 units, 3 stories)
SUBJECT: Request a variance of requirements for self-closing doors, .
installation of a fire alarm system and key box, as stipulated in �
the city' s letter of 7-6-83 , because of financial hardship.
APPEARANCE: Clarence A. Lindeke
PROCEEDINGS: Mr. Lindeke said as he had appeared before the board
in November on similar properties, he was willing to do the work �
required, but would like more time.
BOARD ACTION: R�n Glassman moved to deny, the variance but grant one
yea"r time . _{12-31-84) to allow for campletion of work cited in the
inspector' s report. William Tilton seconded the motion.
THE VOTE: Ayes 4 Nays 0 Abstentior�s 0
--------------------------------
19-83-F 166 W. George St. Clarence A. Lindeke
(14 urrits, 3 stories)
SUBJECT: Requests a variance of fire code requirements for a fire
alarm system and a keybox, because of financial hardship.
APPEARANCE: Clarence A. Lindeke
PROCEEDINGS: t1r. Lindeke stated he is now willing to do the work,
but would like to have some time.
BOARD ACTION: Ron Glassman moved to deny the variance and that the
work be completed by December 31, 1984 . William Tilton secanded the
motion. Motion carried.
� THE VOT�,: Ayes 4 Nays 0 Abstentions 0
, , .
�y�-.�i
Exhibit "A" page 3
20-83-F 668-674 E. 4th St. Clarence A. Lindeke
(13 units, 3 stories) .
SUBJECT: Requests a variance of the requirement for fire doors,
self-closing doors, and a fire alarm system, because of financial
hardship. - -
APPEARANCE: Clarence A. Lindeke � -
PROCEEDINGS: As Mr. Lindeke appeared in November on similar
properties, he agreed to do the work, but requested an extension of
time.
BOARD ACTION: Ron Glassman moved to deny the �ariance and grant period
� of one year (December 31, 1984) at which time the work must be
completed. William Tilton seconded the motion.
THE VOTE: Ayes 4 Nays 0 Abstentions 0 .
------------------------------
.a � "` . --�' ,�3`R�'. .,.�,'k.�t '� 1�.,,g"°'�"�' ';�m�i,'^,�'g�'a' ^'1}C ��,,��4 .��"�`��'c a '�.` '-S •'s�� r�," '�""' -: '� +7-.�s%`
'�.�� a "�' y h' � � 1� �, 'cr' �x"� �� Tm .: � c.,. � ti. �``; �,4��� �*' °�� '� . �,� , ,„ti �� . -. �r* �� .
u'F�� �+,s<. � � ��'�71 ������ 3� "5 * 3 �A. h' S`+, .C��: 5�ls�����.�.a,���A `} � � � Y ���'.
ti F7
�h II �.�5$.;�t� {� � � � �,sSZf. �t� �:`,
,� �.w.�.3�, �- : ��t��� x. �' '�; 4,q.:!
aJ �zk � � ; h r�.a y .v � s � °�y .�:{� �
�� �� �� . �" �` �.� y� ''� t `.rii :�i� j >?�t.&} -
.. ,.�" i �u,�i 9 �: ^s s .;=3 - 3:..s� t"'��.t*-'� . * � �'r�=� �..�.� r � ��` � �� .
}}y,�� ��'t: .,�G�t� '1� `!3. ;C h^�:N,�F 4t� '�`F3?3 k �-� .�_ Sf?+M' t ' S�� 1 �.
�� ���'4 � +'�t�'C -�� ���� � P `� �''�it i ;,s �+: __ � �� +�` ��.�;*�� n ,
rr,a � F,� � �� r r ��„4 ,��4 �,- .�..w t ^S �, ,"�8��'$"a�`��'"` t, t�
���
� �,�.,� ?,� =. , z � -.� ,_: : .: � _.. �� �"`�'` � � :� a�`.„
� �� ' ��s � � R� ���z v' ,� t �';�;r.,.,� � �
s- "'' .i �:�v -�' :_
p�i�.- .,ya 5e ��. ,.. '�. "3 �'.3 ..�, w} _ -�f..�,°��.ly � . �, � �;"�' . -^��-y_.��
g . ' >:x�.r,... �' n.. ��o ; 'k ,.
� �F ."�F ���� ?�k:�� � �'
- �:{` �' o ; .. . .
�' l� 4 5 :d�' S"1��. CT"" Ki, .� .. 4� s�� 3 k't� .
�:. . . �"r �.'i at ..e a°^F� J5. �"'" x .- °'Tr.' �^'2�� � � "Z.
'.�*r�,�, . '^�s�a '�;. x. `"� ,�.`� '� ..: .,� .e..j � e ..k�tr ..2- ?. x x
� �.� ��`+� ��, "�° �- �"� , .� � � . s:�i� �_ ��q��E �: ��,
_�_ � � e`�' : raa� � � - ������� �x .
}��.y'��,w �+7'�r re �a9,. t��� �� � £.�," �` � �'�" �� ■ ^ y�'s'2��`� �a .s k�� .
'�- ��`__ � _ �� z �'�� tt�i',$ `'.t� ���� ����� _ � �.�t,� s T'� c � �'�_�
h ��� '�'t'�f _ .�n ;� � �a �� .� s � �`s�b ��j �•�fi k&�r� ��-�*c
� .t,�„�' .sx' �' � + '
� � _ . � # � � �' �
�` � '��".� � ,�r
`�' �'� � ,�,t - �;d� ����r ,�. �-��''�c�: '� �:;?` .,�^ r �,.��, '�"€��, �
�,., ^`�� '�� a �� -t���`"�t.`� �? -$e at.� `��z4+c��� � ' c ��� ,r�;�'��
r: � ° . , �
� ,
�
. . .. .
;
, --
� � � � �:«tx �a��� x -�—�'_
�,s �- „�
. �
s , . _ ,.,.;
,.
.. ,..7 . ._ .... . . �. . �- - '
'
4 `
v
� , , _.
„ .
�. , . , . . . -_ -: ., ... ,
:
'»5.
"^�*�4 �'"'�� Sit ��4 a.a�t �'+n. ���n i='� ''�`�`*�r � � . i ad4. i:� � � � �i' :- a�.�%R��Ts ?-x��,x�' � ''`�.'�
�#n+ � �r�y, f, ' ,� : �. a r','` '�
��� �?s#�x�^r� x,.x.Yi - 1 e `g; � .^` �„�,--c��($�i'""' ��'�a€�a. � �� a,�^�
��1� as§,s h1:� f°'�, � �#S,��� .
.�� F '
�}�"� `��k ,'�t• $�, ' . ; �� "� � l y�
� '����,�. -e�.*",�' - _"+ �` '���° '�.a �`
� � .. � � �� �
,a� > > � � �� �
� �.,.� �
t �' z x � a �; '. �ku,YS- c`,�.v. .., �� � .�A ' 3 . .. �. � � ,�,y '
1`�a�,. '* �"s • +»�`ti'^v��fi. ' '� �� �. ..� .5 . � k� �Y' 3 . �"az`.� ,�.,r �:- . � �a�'� :
� �, �� '' '�� � � s ��'r � � � � � r• �� '� { : �� ,���,�x
� � � ,.,m w �. -:Y kX; � . ,� .- � ��, a�,�.�� �„_c�a�'�y� �,z.e�.
� x�. �''� � Y, �+-,'�a,� ;1G°: �h; �' '4 '�`"� � �c x 7'v-,kPe� x "`� �� '� '� ���&' -
c _ �� .s� �� �,6`,_ �r �� '� a� t k'.'� ,1' _� � ���*� tu �.. � - � s ; ��.c '� . a r��, '9,
1
x F � K�� ;�i 4�:� �� .� ��� ��_`�w �:. ' �w ,� :. �� '��� ��
�� r� h ,`� �� � , ' r�' ' �. � � :--"'�t 3- ° :s "�'"d'w���.
� �' 9 ~ � _��� +� �t � - *-h :
�°xN. �� ��,�� � �'rz �;'�a.�,"� �� : �TM d ' ,� �� � '�'::�; . r r; -. _j s .. },'�y a� � �x�� `d�� �,
�' . , �. z �a �-�'� +�� �as� _ � � �;n �-e ' :
t J `E•M, 'Y��. �.a �,.� Y� �`- ��� �;A. - �crv, sF S F� � �i'ta � �`_. � .;:1 s ��. �'�' C ` ,'
f-�+t' +, �1 f �x �.'F �"'�.fi 1 a� �x. �' �� ,,� f ,•�1�' _..-r �� +' a'.�-��°� Y � �a.., > �+�" .z�"�'a �
��� � .z ��� � �;.: � �,::[ � �; ���; � � . E � F� y ; .,# � � �� r��� .i �
�� � .. �,,°�e @..�5 ' � {.�„ � b ,���+ a - k. # :� ,f+. � �k...�`s. � �_` � �v����-_s.
�' �� s� �: '3s.z�� ` "� �'�a �' . �� �+-��'°'�' � x»� x,�*�- #`�`���"�'�1��.' ��*L
�, i �a+, , ,�i''«�` Y �;'.s,m �; s � 'a,: '�'L .
'�� � ����'�� �� =� '� *- � � r 2 �I."� �,� ��
� � ��. ,� i � ; � -z�. � � �: '� "�- �
� _� � �qt+¢y��,�,��� 3 F� �� �� �, .�y,d y��5�?.- ��,. _?_ � /`�'�'�^f� v4:.h .a�, , �;'t ' .�k.'�� S'bt'"}�� g:- .
r,�. � °c t� r-q � '!q��� � 4�„�. ����� ,S -�kt�� N �.xc ,..„,.�+-,� i t: 5
�z� �T: -i £-..y "�• '�`� t� ? �� 'Y;,,,� ,}�.�+�� t c �` 1 3' .� �.�.," �.. ,� � �.� r` �.� y.
� ;� � `�' ���'C .�� '°�� ��{ ���'°�'r�`.��°" � �� � � -�'.�r,s 3` _f �'r' i �.` '� ''c p' � x� .� '�'�,�-"��4�
� ,�J� �'6�,� .' y:�R� _'`� �`° i�.�'.,� :�.x �c,�,�,�, �.. �� +`' �� '�, �' : '�S ..e��� �.r-� �, :.
�' , . �"§-�'.. . x ' a.�e ._�r �,'�._..4 �s:.m � �_..z . ti . .� �e�� . "''rn � . -3-.'� �,3
a s , �� t
�_''�,� '.�,�a��,. .• � ri'',.X�� �,,. ,�g .a�`"v = `�'�``'�` � z`tzF��'�c�� s z ? s�x �;; k�i�,��� �.?_"� �°�'�' � � .a.��r
« �+'k�:v,�w r, t .
,�,.tl<°"--�'�'" �,��''ate����a.�.a�aB,�a .�� �� �;.y fi� �..,"�,� � ??S,r �,�?r4^� � � ��� � i' ��� '�:,
� �v{ � `��,� sdt+5�t .�, r : a... i�x� 11 � L�� �`a . � +-� . ,"
�, �.`"i -� "�s 3 �k�'"�.� ;§ +�'� n. .��,Y:�'``�G�� �i�r u�`,��f g _ �. �,;,� :�,.�4 � ::�,�C�"��. �,; t� �a�3::.�.� �,�. a. �
� '*s�� i" s� � `'F' ;���� '4 "`."�'' �a:-c z�' '� � ' : s t 3g,�b �,`'�` b. _
� � ,�,;'����*, ���'�s��a�,�,vr� �� � � �+ �� '�� ..� �� '�� � =x � �� �,��:.
s ��
�^ ,h {��4 ; � � �✓'ae s.�� �-� ��,.' '��r ,��'�� `� ��t '' ` � � � '"T ,�y � . '' ,� 4z ° -'�'+�,��;d.�.
� r�,.�..�,` '' r } .: � � �+��y= � � �,-�"",r^,. 4 f;,� � � 1k�.af- �F: .r .` 2 �.��x t . a �' �. '��� �" �Y'�4� � a.
'r y i �`�'" f r ,r,� .i $ k�% � 7i u`� t t. x +✓��'`R' -�,v- ,p^' ��p �
�"-€.��"'� � �. L'� '4 �'r$� �c �4 :'n y `�^8-� a � � r�$� ' 'e " .^ � x µ. f f�:� ,. �''t�''K "` R t'�- .
"�` , fi ' �- 3 �' � � �'� '�S � � , � ry, , p�� F n res � =� � �z�x Y � L. ,�,.y��r-+
� .:� �,g W�✓�M' .. � # � yt �`r � " :�k:� ,�,*�3. '�`�a' .�.� ��. ,�"' '�m.-P
� � � {�. � y'�� �. 4
�'�'as "`':, �,. t"R.,,� , ::� ...,..� �t �- '4- ..y�j� s.�"`,...s � r 'ty� _� S �_ >�a���. -
"._ �a`�y.�'�„ �,. ���I��� � F � ��, t
ls'2 �,� � � f i�. b«�'W+`� ..` `V ,�Y_ we I ��§4 �y,' S`�:� t�'. s! �N�-t i. .
� � ^c°�" ~ t-� r i'N� . Y � $� S� Y`� $�- Fn � �' �vAf'4`^ s'
�.��fl� '�� �,W,�. � '� '. `� ._.'' "3'�, ,,,x ._. � . .
'�" b.R', da.� ' t Z'c.;� ' ''d .a:=`i 4^ �iM1W1F a'a� 'x ''�% a ��:t"�' �� . ,� � �
4Y'.}� �.+,�'f a , .s�ru � ,u..��. - ''f�'� ':5� T-`. � a t_��>y� �, �
f T�-=� 3. : "�y�� ,�°� 'F �:�.
��` � ��
�> � � � � ��
� �-� �s� � f *� -�� � _ � �
��.. �� � .� � " � _ .
�,,, , ,� K ,� �� � � ,� .�._ . � �
�f"�. � �._ N '��, a,' �5"�* ,:,y � a �� .�, . fx �; � $ �.. r�`R.'� '� - vz.� � �y ,T�`1�Tp'
���4+�*.��� � . .
s ���s � r 'a� . :;��� 4 ~ � Yr ` r � y, ��fl -
i �-�"�4 * A�:��*� g�'s �, a�`
j= ��� '�,�- � ?�''� µ" .T �
�::� � � c� �- ,�.+t� ..w.� �c r :.'� .3 § -� �-=;, "�����p �� � � s �.�' � � y �w �r i ��
�3'_,6�,w.. �. " z �'a,,. -.:
�� �.� "- " :a �� "#. '�"`i`r�'�� �_ '�'3�' .��.,.��"i+`i;r . , � 4 �
�,.�,,_ ��",�� � '� �� ��" p st �'�5��. 7i� �S° � ��-� ���q"� `` ..z�'f 't'� � .a�. �' ��� .:�,'�
�n °�s,' �,.x: s c
., '
�� .�3�, �.�,
,
�,...:r�� , .o , _":.� �;Y' .,. .`�, .. 4,�e. , �. `- "" _ �.t
. � ,. . �� > -
�.
�
"� ^� ��'
� �
� `�� 0. >.N� r�'- �' a;� �`��`"i -�- '�.s �' 'y�rr�.:�t, "a"" °.�.c �"'��'v.` :
. x
�-ti' x � �s °�"� ++. � " s a �� '� ,n,: ,� �, �;� '«� �g
�' rt
< '� 4'ia�'' ��a.'k��.' �.,� �� i ��' '�e �'�s'm'i �as"���r
#' T � .: � j � �„�, �.n " �, �. �a ,"y.�g a�'�- `" �
,� ' tt u r.; 3 �7 �t �� :�r � -� " ��~��j � �. T� ��.
-a,.' " x �i.�-�n+ib . �.-r .�"r .�,i. ..a�+�''�r- �w�. .�-- : � � -' e - : �s� y.
aa. .� �,,� . . . t� `e �� v�.
°�: .r�,;fi� y�:. "' �' ;kr tv��' �*�����a '�r �-c: - ";' "i' � � �',� � �F " �""asc� �' .
-.�,. :t;:. - � :. � ,_,y;,:''�. �_� '� .-`�� '�i� � .}t-'�a'��`� `:t i-. '�` ��`. �,....� �. � �; ^s 2-t,��+.,,:"'
,� �.- ,..,s, :�_�„ �<_ � � ,� . .� � � .. Y r ' : -
y� ��k .' 1 r,.�i � '
. r
.
$: � ' at 'M`S .- �?a�'k�'R` _ £yv� � "
�}$� .,S" 4� .'pW'4�'�`�'�f� " i� �'f" Y+ �,k � ?�"i . . ..
� 4 �
� � � �,-�'a. � . ',��-:. ���`` w �`� � ,�`� > xkt-
�.C-���a°.�"'�+- +at ii� r ,.s�. ( :�. �. ���^�� _ ,€ ,; '-I : `�a�°� �+,s�a���` u -
�J �
��la,�a�m I .7t °fa�, �: '�r�'f� '�i :�'� a�..��� �°--�..� 'x' � .
� x
L r � ,: �:. .:: � '3�- ,� � .?
�,. ;T t$' . # :� . .- � - *c�.z � _
� " { �a�°,. r ti.�.� .��.ic _.�, `�.'.-� � �' _:. .? ;� } �. ;�'"°` `�` �"s `�'�t �"� �, ';N:
, � � �+
t.K_.4S R ?'ua.r.'a': �^ . � .. ..��€. .�_ ..., " .'1.::. � �'S:.� . ..x'` ...�� ,.�..�t b: �`3� &e�_'. '`�,�.���... �'�.�v�,:.�:,�.r..d�., ^'.'� _. . ,.
ir��
, ..�. �_.. .s..,S_�..s..c�� '� •�