Loading...
00-1100QR1GI�lAL Presented By Referred To Council File # �� � �� � O Green Sheet # ��,59��i RESOLUTION OF SAI�IT PAUL, MINNESOTA � Committee: Date RESOLVED, that the Licensee, Apple American Limited Partnership of MN d/b/a Applebee's Neighborhood Grill & Baz (License ID No. 0017244), located at 1600 TJniversity Avenue West in Saint Paul is hereby ordered to pay a fine of $200.00 for the violation of the sale of tobacco or tobacco products to a minor. Said fine sha11 be paid to the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection within thirty (30) days ofthe adoption of this resolution by the Council and signahue by the Mayor. This resolution and the action ofthe Council in this matter are based upon the facts contained in the October 2, 2000 Notice of Violation letter to the licensee, the Tobacco Compliance Check Form, and such arguments as may have been presented to the Council at the public hearing. The facts were not contested by the licensee. Requested by Department of: B U�-�.�.o,� A--�2,e.�i Adopted by Council: Date �`��,\S ��a Form Approved by City Attorney Adoption Certified by Council Secretary // BY: � �' . �rr-7�ei...� � By: � . G�' Approved by Mayor: Date rW�f (,�� Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council BY = � � ���'�/' � By : ao-\Ioa UNCONTESTED LICENSE HEARING Licensee Name: Address: Council Hearing Date Wednesday, November 15, 2000 Violation: Sale of Cigarettes to a Minor Minn. Stat. § 609.685 St. Paul Legislative Code § 324.07 Date of Violation Place: Presumptive Penalty: $200.00 Fine Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection: $200.00 fine (first offense) Attachments: 1. Proposed resolution 2. Notice of Violation 3. License Information Report 4. Tobacco Compliance check Form Apple American Limited Partnership of MN d/b/a Applebee's Neighborhood Grill & Bar 1600 University Avenue West September 27, 2000 Licensed Premises 5. License information CITY OF SAINT PAUL .- Norm Colem¢n, Mayor October 2, 2000 OFFICF - F THE CITY ATTORNEY Claytors A. �binson, Jc, Ciry A[torney civit Division 400 Ciry Nal! I S R'est Kellogg Blvd. Saint Pavl. hlirsnuota 55102 Q0���0� Telephone= 657 266-87/0 Factimile: 65! 298-5619 NOTICE OF VIOLATION Owner/Nlanager Applebee's Neighborhood Grill & Bar 1600 University Avenue West Saint Paul, MN 55104 RE: Cigarette/Tobacco License held by Apple American Limited Partnership of MN d/b/a Applebee's Neighborhood Grill & Bar for the premises at 1600 University Avenue �Vest in St. Paul License ID #: 0017244 Deaz Sir/Madam: The Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection has recommended adverse action against the Cigarette/Tobacco License held by Apple American Limited Partnership of MN d/b/a Applebee's Neighborhood Grill & Baz for the premises at 1600 University Avenue West. The basis for this recommendation is as follows: On September 27, 2000, a minor entered the premises of the Applebee's Neighborhood Grill & Bar at 1600 University Avenue West as part of a compliance check and asked to purchase cigarettes. The individual was able to purchase a package of Newport cigarettes without being asked for identification. It is a violation of Minn. Stat. §609.685 and Saint Paul Legislative Code §324.07 to sell tobacco to a person under the age of 18. Since this is a first violation, the licensing office will recommend a$200.00 fine. At this time you have three options on how to proceed: If you do not dispute the above facts and do not wish to have a public hearing, you will need to pay the recommended fine for this violation. If this is your choice, you should make payment directly to the Office of License Inspections and Environmental Protection, Room 300 Lowry Professional Building, 350 Saint Peter Street, Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102. The letter should be directed to Ms. Christine Rozek. Payment of the fine will be considered to be a waiver of the hearing to which you are entitled. _. � Page 2 Applee's Neighborhood Grill & Baz October 2, 2000 Oa-\\oo 2. Altematively, if you do not dispute the above facts, but wish to have a public hearing before the Saint Paul City Councii, you will need to send me a letter with a statement admitting the violation and requesting a public hearing. We will need to receive your letter by Friday, October 13, 2000. The matter will then be scheduled,before the City Council for a public hearing to determine what penalty, if any, to impose. You will have an opportunity to appeaz before the Council and make a statement on your own behal�: 3. If you do dispute the above facts, a hearing will be scheduled before an Administrative La�v Judge. At that hearing both you and the City will be able to appear and present witnesses, evidence and cross-examine the other's wimesses. The St. Paul City, Council wili ultimately decide the case. If this is your choice, please advise my legal assistant, Peter Pangbom, and we wili take the necessary steps to schedule the administrative hearing. He can be reached at 266-8710. If we have not heard from you by Friday, October 13, 2000, we will assume that you do not contest the facts and will schedule this matter for the St. Paul City Council and have it placed on the Consent Agenda during which no public discussion is allowed and the recommended penalty will be imposed. Please be advised that the clerk who was identified as having made the sale on this date is also being charged an administrative genalty pursuant to Minn. Stat. §461.12, subd. 3. This is a separate action from this license matter. If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me at (651) 266-8710. Sincerely, � � �.zc�.C�� � cL�'.-vv� Virginia � Palxner Assistant City Attorney cc: Robert Kessler, Director of LIEP Christine Rozek, Deputy Director of LIEP Christopher Dart, Community Organizer, Lexington-Hamline Community Council, 1160 Selby Ave., St. Paul, MN 55104 OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY C[aytan M Robinson, Jc, Ciry Attorney CITY OF SAINT PAUL Norm Colemarz, Mayor civit Division 400 Ciry Ha[I I S West Kellogg Blvd. Saini Pau[, hlinnesota 55l02 Q� ���d0 Telephone: 65! 266-8710 Fncsimile: 651298-5619 October 30, 2000 NOTICE OF COUNCIL HEARING Owner/Manager Applebee's Neighborhood Grill & Baz 1600 University Avenue West Saint Paul, MN 55104 '�,'(, ��S23rC� v@:^.d2t �d� �� .`_ �QQ� RE: Cigarette/Tobacco License held by Apple American Limited Partnership of MN d/b/a , Applebee's Neighborhood Grill & Baz for the premises at 1600 University Avenue West — in St. Paul License ID #: 0017244 Deaz Sir/Madam: Please take notice that a hearing concerning the above-named establishment has been scheduled for 5:30 p.m., Wednesday, November 15, 2000 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse. Enclosed aze copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested hearing in that the facts contained in the report concerning the unlawful sale of cigarettes have not been disputed. You will have an opportunity at the Council hearing to present oral and/or written remarks as to the penalty, if any, to be imposed. The recommendation of the license office will be for a$200.00 fine. If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710. Very truly yours, (/ U�-� �� V'o---(''�^-r� U Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP Christine Rozek, LIEP Christopher Dart, Community Organizer, Lexington-Hamline Community Council, 1160 Selby Ave., St. Paul, MN 55104 po_ ��ec STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF RAMSEY ) AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says that on October 3, 2000, she served the attached NOTICE OF VIOLATION on the following named person by placing a true �nd correct copy thereo£ in an envelope addressed as follows: Owner/Manager Applebee's Neighborhood Grill & Bar 1600 University Avenue West St. Paul, MN. 55104 (which is the last known address of said person) and depositing the same, with postage prepaid, in the UnitecLBtat�s mails at St. Paul, Minnesota. / \ �. Subscribed and sworn to before me this 3rd day of �Octob�r, 2000. Notary PETER P PANGBORN NOTARY PUBL7C - MINNESOTA MY CppAp�lSSiON EXPIRES JAk_ 31, 2005 � p _ ��oo j i �Q � Ix � W � o y (°� rn c V � OJ J � 0. N O C d � C O • R � L YY� C d N C d V J N I� N > V U ..J Q N N U_ y F E N N c Q IU N y IJ I LL o � o � N ��I i � I' � i Z� I N I� U r :j I O , !o v � V W a � � � N W � Z � = V a O O � � .-- � � m 2 � W Z N � W Z W m 00 a �a Q F � � Z U d � i� W Z Q �� ma I la i ¢ �U C � 0 U � 0 � N � d X W NI C I CI � Z U O a V cl m� LJ C m1 �j �, z; c aj �I O I c' I�I � h: c � � � � � Z N C r o ,� L ^ a o , N N h � m � C �v1 N m � p I� i~ � I o l � � I a � (A � � ; w I V � a � �¢ � C � � � N d � ' U L � p 7 N� � C � � �LL @ Y � � - pm i �� C jt U� N� m am inii v° ��"-�da .�eC �' � `m rnLL �... oQ � � ac- Qa"i� Q c a ym QU �y mQ a�rn- t� � G C 6 � m � > N � U V .� � j�U3 JO_ �¢ LQ _IWrnlLC� cda �o. ' da�m m >m � �� om �c' a�i E °� .c�'o m ��y �� ��i;� U(0 fA O � C�� !n y �J = LLl y(O�QM � Q O i V N N• O � C �Y 'O N� �� N N �� y W C L p �� W(p� N NE� � L���7 co�U vy �� rn�a ��`c' y c E c �mJ rn3 ° c' ma>p N C 0 C(0 � i U L ry1 G � y NV� O � �m� N L �"O-�UC��C ` mma�n�p�� ��m Um ����omUr � >tn� .yma�� rnc� ° om�SEmo�fl� Q' �Y NL" U" N 0 0_ . N C❑ U N C N p� G.J m N �a>o� �d�Q o'mm�otm�rn�wH r c� rno�o��c�mor�ma�i� i-��VU � o.� o md °'O � c�- ��2cn �6U•� c°'� o,' OOi ONO O �L � CH� dm� 0o m o �o'�oUdrn d a � '� ��n �' E E EY oom�o�o>'c°\�rnrn°� �r�� � p � �a�� NN���._NR f �l� O� N m N �'(j� O Va' � N� �Or' �� N. O on0"�O PnN� p.� N N � ood�oc�io>0000�a�o°rna¢ �¢°a¢�UaO� � � w 0 N N m R a � 0 a d � c 0 .� E L � W � � � � d d N y d � U � J — � � U� J N nr m o J ' ' Y r U N m V N �N Xk U a� �o .� U V m Q Q V p N'6 N UOr�i1 O J U � � � mQ �U� ��r 3 m"� J l[) p Oo _ I lua n oi Q �, x � W o No � �o m V N R J c� O. i+ O � O C � C O .� � � O ... c d w c m a J N 7 N � C N N � C ZT U C J � 0 w c y � o_ „ � E N � �a � � U � @ Q O ` O N � o E� � � IZ V r J p � R V W � Q � � � N N� Z � � � a O O � � � � � Q m 2 C� w Z � �w Z W m ma �° a Q F � J Q I � U � �w �Z Q I � J Ia Q .� � � 0 U � � M � N N � d X ll.� h C � � � � Z U 0 a m U C m 5 �u �� !�I IZ I TI �I m ��I �a� UI I�I � �i (� � � E � Z N �n o ,� L r a a , y N N � � � c 7 � r m � n o �� �F � i � �O w 6 F k C ', � � � c a m - N � � '�. � U L— p 3 U w .c "a �n w . � o Q � Y � m � U � m M `� u. � � `N� o� c y �� �# a`� � �.J o � o c � � a mo.cu� � U � p • y � m a m �ii vLL H o`�-!a Q� y Q a�i � o- c�i °- d m a U � ai d� a> rn-� d Q w� � t� � c c a� rn m� > �a o m �a c'�i 3 �'�a_ �,Q �O '���rnu o c ° cv ° a�i E ° .c�io m o �� �c��y?� � m� fn � ° c�� � y �J �2 w ycn�Qo'� 3 da d NNO_C �C� WC L1' 'OTiNWfO�N �O� � O r"470� �OJ N N �H C� ��Z "�60"o C U � N V C n dp �N � i UrtD��Jy m @ V i 0 (6 � �Z � t6J 16-O-�UCy{6C—(0 O�� i6fnd� � p N U � O� (� N aC ��� @CJ t�i1 O f6 � o'� �m0 . N�m rn� ��� o y .y� ��� o m�� Qv @YNLw7U� rna� �p �j�ca`�og��d N N� � V m UN l6"6 N N � - y � N m� i N� U=� CN(Al6miNN I�Qa' NECEyNN_CNtp�"O o mmK o.c m rn ui c aiO m o� � c- m rn� � m u i-tL�QU�a� ��nm a� v � �� m��ma��>� V o � a �o � �tL. c � o o �c�i m .cQ ��d��m �dm EY 00 ��o coi'oo�mrn �a �V E-'�d °?�n � E� E� d� NN— C l6N O . N O N � Wh���O_�d<c��O��i�0�t6 WN�p�j`V(`�1)L�tOILUCN NN N�c-N��ZW��O C_O N pNd_m— N N �6)NN�O(hUN�W �NLNC�N�O�.=CypN d� (4Ey N oOacs�pUO>o000�ar�Orrnn.Q �Q�O_Q�UQO� �_�\aa � � w 0 v m m n a � 0 a m � c 0 :. m E � � ° � c _ � m m N N V 'J J � 6� � U� J N Q @ O J ' i Y n V N �U N �N Xk U � � _ N LL �- y O . V � � 0 Q �V O � � N U O N O J U � C ' QJ Q � U rn rn ��� 3tO� m�� JtqO �� _��oa � Ip Q iO w O h I� y U � R '� M a N � 0 a � c O i=� N � O w c m N C V J N 3 � � a��i > J Q h a� Q y F E a� `m C Q U � N J �p LL � R V W � Q � � � I W a? � Z ��v I u� � d' O m _ � W Z N y � W � W Z m '°� a ° a Q IU c � U �� N N 0 a w N c � E 3 Z U 0 a U C m � N C d � � 3 Z N c ^ o � L r a a, y N N d d� C �m N 7 � m � N � E y � � TI I N � Z � (m ' Q ° � U EI I N.fl Im� o � m ° � I@�w UI i ' W z z � �v� 0 � C �O W �' �X � i.. dr � � �� 0.� o jma w �,F-m � J O a a � p j � O Q �-- U a C .� � a . � � ' U L O 3 U � L � � N .-. V O Q �- Y� l6 �"� U J l6M ln� N C � Y � v `- rn c �t m � � Y �° cx d d coin vL a� @�° U� � U C� a� tn LL � LL F- Q"� 6' na y o a�- Q a�i� °- c�i °- �`m aU � y a�� a� rn-�aa� � Utrn � c c �.c 3 6 � rna m� > a� co o m� G1� �O (6 j� Ua J d N VO UJ�p)LL C C OU� C �' � NQ >� � N� �t�? m .0 U � '�Cn`+ ��� N $ � c m� � m �� �S ul Nco�Qr� 3 �.O ` p� NN—O �C� 4l.IC L �� NE� L � E 7 CO�U "6y �O Wj.�"6� Z L��n °� o °' o � � 3 rnt- c o a� �� I jU y V �" V O r � � C f6Np�JM`y 'O t0 i��C � �J �� ��LN R fAp� m c° ° lqtnmc' s ��� .cm ��Q o�a ���a� o m� �o� Um c�°OmUv�om �r.�� �Cn� .N�.(UL M�� 0"G fl-m�G CO3�� Q"6 �.Y NLw 3U m�-� CO �N C GJD�CJd N d� �c� m c>m%v d c� fl-� � U � m rn� � m�Q Hti�QU�a.� a��� ��c�i���mV � Wa�i�o� � �LL._LLSln °o°oa�U�c�i°om°oUa� �rQ m�m��y��dm��EY NN��N�NONW�� U M� V aon� o_�a�co�n�o °°��m�°� ��°� y ochp, a���i � c`m o Q '6 tn � fl. ��(ONV O(`7UNW�CN d�(6ENN OOdERO UO�000��--dhO�-maQ<�Q'-4Q�C„)QQJ Do-�\oa � r w 0 � m � R a r 0 a d � c 0 « R � � � w � C � � d � y y C � V '_' J � � � V� J N a� �o �� i Y h � � U N Xk U � c _ N � O . U � � � Q �V p N 'O N U O m o�U� � 'rna �CU� ��� ��� 3 m"r J�nO I� �� i m i0 � � W r 0 N O n � I N U R � M d N � O C. � c 0 w m E O w c m N L v J y 3 @ � d a��i > :� Q N d a t�' E IN N N a d U y � � LL a N V li! � Q �� � v� liJ N� Z '��v a0 m� K O m 2 � W Z d� m Z � m ma ° a Q .� 7 O U N� 0 � N N � di X W h c � a � 3 Z U a U C m � � c ` � � � Z N c r o � � r a a , N N N � Ic � !�vi N m � N� v � H � � � I � c W � T vi Q C � m I O Q O.I I o ,d V i N�.cz n� o I I, � o '� I � W � �I I W � Z Q I I ��I I m y�� C `I � W i ' �� N O J I i I � j J '� i°v"� I�m�Ia ��'n� ''F- � 0.� o L.� Q U o �'�Q � � i �, i ;'� i; DO-1�o 0 T c � m � . � � '� � U � - O � C.),�N t 'o N .. V O Q � Y i (6 Y U J N M � W C .0 °>LL � � Y �O c� a a� min o= d�°- c�� • � m a m r'n�i vLLL°, i s - o n °� N �c Q m Q �� QU �y p �s`mQoy U�� c c��3 °�� rn�' m� » U� O (6 j� Uc J Q �a LQ " J�m C C N� a a U U ��LL O � °c� a�i E o,,;�'� my �u �� �o�;�v U t0 N O � C@� � N `�J S W y(O,�QC'') 2� � ,r U NN�.G �CC W C L' ' yW (6�N v L w�E� coOV a�°, �o o��a-o� Z °'$'n °—' c E''c r3.J o�3 c ( � U� O m (6 y �� �?� (6J (0- OJU C y` f0 C y t�6 oWa ���a��OOdc tf�o@ Um �c���c OOj �CA� . �C� �N p'NJ�� N�1 _ (� '616�rt6.��U ��..J CQ V NC ND� O_ (n mQ o'iomKo�m�rnrnoiy �c� a�o�o��c��rn��a HLL�QU�a� cfnm mp ��-�ti2cA� 'U � O Nd !!I C �U'� C�� O 00� OUON�Ud LQ �=N CN �d@ �Y oo��oco?`omwrn � ��j�-�'y����`�, Ecm� �I+� O_d'�-�COIl��t� O� (6 O�i C yp��i � UMa � U � N ��NNV O('7UNW�CNtNCpNLdNCNON d� (OEN N OOdERO UO�OOOO�df�O��dQ��Q�d. Q�UQOJ �pfl_ ��oo � T W Q � d � R a r 0 a m � c 0 « m £ L � W � C � � d � y N V � J � � � V �\- J N Q � O J ' � y � � � � N V Xk U V � !1 Q y O - U � � O Q V O �� N CJ Ot�ii o�U� `- 'rna �Urn � � ��� 3 m�'� JlnO t�o-\�pO � � �W I � O h o m �o d V N a J M n 0 � 0 a � C O i7 16 � L 0 W N c u J � �� d U � J Q U � U T � t- � N � N �I� VIN ;J Im 'i_ (U � �� o � N �I O I I � I � �I Z i ��m'v C �N I I J V I U O � N v w 4 r � �, w a? z a�� a O O � � � � 1.1� W 2 � W Z E � m W Z W m W p a Q r � J Q U � � � W Z Q i m a d Q . I� C I �I U U .� N o� � � ❑ a x w N � � � E � Z U O a U G m 3 N C I i I I Z � a c m n I�i i I d �mj i� N C � a E � ,Z � C � o ,� r a IN N N ^ m � � ❑ � �x � F � � O . w �.� C� �� r .� � C � � � . � � 'i � U �- o � U ;o s 'a tn.. V O Q � yi N Y U J NM L �LL. C L LL � � � � Y �� � ik N <o in c� 3 U� .y � m d� !4 LL 7 LL �- ¢-� ° o-a tn � �� Q � a �� Q U � N O �� Y d Q o� 0 J L m ULrn � ��s 3 �- rnQ m� > a �`o ic � c aUi� o m �a �- J Q °J �� •����'�' o 3 � -O O y E °' .�� m 'c� �� ����y?� � m� w � ° � R� tn y �� � W�°co�Qc� 3 �o.o � yv rn�� Wc ro �3Nwm ��u� � t ,���� co - o,°� �o o��a O O J F' i j V� y U � UO �`� � � Ly��JMp) N C � (0 � � U C i y �c�c0 � fn�NC��c �?C .c� ��JU����D�c o�� �iotna��o�y �i°m Um �c 03 ��O .m��� rnc� °d o � Q �Y�L� S��.a rn°-- �!] U� c a� o� �� a�Q U�o o��ai�mm-oa� NQ� a�E�E�dm� `my�a 0f6 ~ C mQ(60� V C—�p�� N U F��VU � o_� o ma d0 � �w.�ii2tn�U � c�� o� 00 o�o �rQ m-m cw �a�m� EY oo��0�02�oo�mrn �d �UE�'m��n�E�Eca» NN—�� (ON ONO)m� ' M� V QN rn (60�LQ O �d' � �I�� Q7aa-cD�fJ�h O� f0 QJ � N� � Uc`�� N�IL C N NN j�� � V��N � O Q�"O mN n �_ N N OOd�OUO�pOO� �a�o°rna¢°r�¢°a¢ �UQ�J p _ ��o a � � w 0 0 � m m � a L � W � C � � d d y N C �. d d V � �.1 — m m U� J N d� � O _1 � � y r V a-- d � L N V 7k U � � i— LL a ao � U � a � O a V o ma N V O t�n o: � rna �Urn rn ��� �rnv 3`°� m�n JtnO � � l a i � :w O �N� � C O � �o q U R J M d � r 0 � O Q � C O i=� A � O w C m W d V .J l I� I � N U � J Q c N N `o C N �+ T m iN � N � j N N iU � � O "I N �� I o , i��N � r J O � � v w > ¢ IN � � Z � = C Q 0 O �� � K � m 2 C7 W Z � � �W � W Z m ma � a Q H � J Z Q �I U j� �w IZ Q �IJ I L a _�la IUI C 3 O U � N � � � I d m � Q W N C � � 7 Z U a U C c � C �I I Wq IZ , ICI �Q', '�i IU j ��'' ci I �I I =� y, U i� � � Z N c r o � t � a �, N N N ��I� I �i� I m � � F I � i� �O �� �N 3 !c w I y! � m' Q , � � � I W � W m j W I a � d _ n I� ,� _�`eo � c .n m a .� � � ' U L 3 O 3 U m .c "a � � N.-. V O Q � i� @ Y � � �� i O]LL C �L U� -y L m a a� c�ti �LL F �Q�a a u�i � � a �_ � c Q d o_ � E QU � y Q �Y NQL � c6 V�� o����3 JQ rnQ L� >d�co`om� C N� �p_ �d - 0. > N U� U i��++0 f °- cv ° a�i E o..:�� my ��� �� �o^�y�� U(6 f0 O r-. C f6 � � m `� J � S W N CO � Q(`'I 3 �oQO � U Nmp.0 rnC� Wc L� �3inWm�N ���n m s °,�'� E 7 �� U a,°� �F a>��a y\? j V � (n U � V � �NJ �3 � NNpO> � i� C � C(0 - i ULt� C� @U� O @ (6 y (6J R y(OC (�0 o�� ���d��omcYi tn`o� Vy �c�°�mUNO� „O j �7,fn� .N ��L �C� O d O C � l�6w Q v= m �a c� Uyc U �� �a�i ai 2 mrn � a� y �Q� `m E � E� � m � d�� F-IL�QC� UO.C��Nf6 N�'O (6 0Up m V ���� CR ; U 00 - Vo moYO ° � 0 d �n0 � c�- -�2cn�U•c c�� o-� oom o�omoUa LQ �°=d�ch ya�m Es NN m�N NN ON��� V M � 7�Qtn y(6�LQ� O V� NN j� �� N��N��Z���p C �p ��N ��LL N N� �� VNm�CNLNC�NLQNCNONQ�(OE NN OOdfHO UO�OOOOrn.I�O�--�dQc�-�Q�dQ�(,�QOJ 00- �loo � � w 0 N � d m 10 a r 0 a m � c 0 :: R E � � ° � c _ _ m d w N d d c> � J — � � U� J N Q � O J ' i Y � � � L N V �k U a � �O � U a �rn O a V O ,� � N U Ovl O J (,.) � "'rna �Urn `�rn �rnv 3 � m�r� J�O �j ��; 'O i � IW o ' a� r . T I � �O d Ip N R I J I� IM a _io � O a � C O .� � L Q W C d N c d e� J h � i� I � d I� � I V �V J a T N a � � � m m a � � � c ;_ � I� o U _I O' � 0 o �! N �' O Z I y i� V I� J � N v w ¢ � i� Nw N� Z a�� a O O �� I.L � m 2 C� w Z � � @ W Z W ,m Im I� I�'a `i Q H � J Z �U �� ���W z ;Q I �IJ �a �a �IQ I Uj C', �O U! U L N � l I� ;�' o) a� y�0 � o — N O � �O LI � � 7 I Z U a io �� N I c;� � N C �l -,� N I Z ' 7 � T F" c � IQ,� i�:� �a z U .Q V'� �C � im,W IC � LI� � 4 � ZI N' o � L � a;� N N N � N � � m N � ; m � � � F � rn � O �� IN; � N I iNi � I m I Q i �� W ' m W ��Q To �- ; i; a� - ��o 0 � C Q � � 'y � d '- U L � p 3 U c,�o o " � � �C � l0 y U J l6 M p� U- C L �� � � Y �� �� d a� coin �r m�Q� �� �N U � dm �� �� � �J ��a � � a ��� QU °�YdQo� U�� � � ��t3 s� �`� �O ?m cda o m >a�= �Q d VO �UJ�WLLOC N N N ° -� -° o a�i E o�:�'� m� ��� �� �o^�oi�� � M U "'-C�c� �(/� � �= LLIyCO�QM�? � < � o � y'a L � C c W c .c Y � 3 N W c¢ � a� ��in m r w�E� o�c �y � m���o�^? d U� O O� 1�3J �3 �~ �N ��JM "�00'O C V �� �� C(0 iV =N���y� �U(0 � fnNN � LN �N C p�� �CAn.Nyp�� ��c U�n ac@�OmUyom Qa � wtn� .w@�� ��� o�� o.�����o��� Q"O �Y NL U'6 � din C � U�� N O� CJ N H U ����NyNm�NN �a� �ocE�a��imLL�d� F� �p� ct+ �ii=��Cj°�� 00 N O UO (ODUd LQ m= N�- C N � N�� NN � CN �N ON��� V M � d' (6 � �Q� O NN��� O_V ��cO���Z���� C N� p� pMd d�LL �� �o� �� ���N n � rn° o a�v mN .. n- �O) ( ONV' OM.-N�W C CpNL O.� C NO N i].� (6 ooau>o c�o>0000�-a�.O�a�a¢.-�¢�a¢.-U N U OJ � � C N ai 3 � J bo-l4o0 � � w 0 v T d � � a r 0 a m � c 0 Y R � L �'^ W v/ � C Q� Q� N N d d l�t � J � � U� J N Q � O J ' � y n � � L N 6'1 �N � U � C _ [6 Li °- �o . U a rn O a V O �'a N U O N o�U� � o� a �Urn , � ��� 3'� � m r' r JlnO r; '; �'i � ; � p� —t\cv � �� '�i '`�I 0 � iXi < W I p iy � C O � � N d V � (�p J M a ' o � 0 Q � C O R � � w C N c m u J � � m I� N y U � J Q N O O N > O N N �� F, � c I� � iU � � J O' J O `� O ,y� N .Q I ° � Zi y �� Ul JO VJ � v w ¢ � i IN!w �Z � � � a O O � � � � m 2 C7 ua Z � @w Z W m ma ��I Q F-� � J Q l � ', U i�;� �z a �'J ��N:d �� Q r—, IC i� i �C> . �� N� �� � I � o� a w 0 �'N i� �� � N � 3I Z: r V' OiN n' !M U � � N � V �o � '� � I m � J l� Z� �I� � @ � ' O � U Z i Q iU � i t W I� � �J � I Z I N C r t lA a;� N �p i� m �v1 ; N im'� � O� � F�- I � I� �O I C�� W . i � Im i Q � i � i m � �Q � i � I C � @ � N d � I .0 � O 3 I �` _ � � � ='-- � o Q � � i L � U V -� �M i m� C Y d�- rn u Y �� �# d � � o Y'�° y � � a �' v�u; � F' � - O .- � � L �o � � K�� oa � fl- c ¢ nin O�m'xa�Qo` L d �,� ( � C C �L �i �� � N f�6'� > NJ(p p@ N i tJ O (6 �' U J O. �Q LQ ' J�p�LL C C ;o�a a�i E oa�v m� �� �� �o��y?g 2 W �� no N �� d m``� `h� �n �� m y�°�¢� 3 � °: �wa rnc� wc ro �3Nwm�a� ��u> d t w�E co�� - oy F"o a��.QV�=? >�� �n U E Uo r' °'3 c' mdpa��c+� "00"6 C � C Q CN i ULN C � y� �, O�� (6lndln�pNU fnON U,��n �C�w�l6Uu�i OQj �fn� . �C� �N p�y� CE f00��� , Q.6S N y _�Lw7U. 0 ��-y �O U� CNO�CJd y U �� �NrA(17��NN f� ��CE�N�IO omm�osm c� o�o�o��c@mo��@a�� � I-��¢�U � o_ o� �p � cLL.`iixcn�U `cp�'o� o o �.cQ ��m�cw da�m Es 'NN��NR�NONO�]6�]� V ch� � �I��p� O_�n'�(Otn�� OW (6� W C ym � U�a y�LL V C N ' �� OMUNO)� ypN Q�(6E NN j OOREAO UO�OOOO�d1�O.--�dQ��Q�a.Qc-(.,)QOJ ao - � �ov � � w 0 � � d m R a � � ° � c _ � d � y N � L d � V � J � � U � J N fl-O J � � y r U N � U N N N # U � � �O � U � � � O Q f> O � � N UOVI o�U� � o�a �U� ��� 3 �n . m�r= J�O OfFiCE OF LtCEvSE, INSPECTiONS AND 8JV1ROTl11EtiTAL PROTEGTION Robert Kess(v, Dirrlur CITY O� SAINT PALTL. Norm Coleman. dlayor LOiYRY PftOF'cSSIO;VdL BU1LDlNG Suite 300 350 St Peter Svea Saint PauC Minnesam i5102-lSIO roaacco co��vcE c�cx Fox:« -�x zoao '� O � \�O'Q Telephonc 611-2fi6-9p9p Facsiadlc 6/Z16E-9099 6I2-266-91?; c.rr. DATE: Z b TL�: �-! � n 1 LICE�ISE I.D. �O�iX�L�i —� <JbEL�� .c -lj c lYAitiLE. OF CD�iPLIA1vCE CXECKER �' J v � �� °( ! NAMEOF ADULT SUPERVISOR P- �[%_�,./ NAi�lE & ADDRESS OF LICENSED VENDOR:_ APPLEBEE'S NEIGHBORHOOD GRILL 1600 UNIVERSITYAVE W —ST PAUL, MN 55104-3898 D� License Type: license # TYPE OF ESTABLtSF�YtEi t'�l'��- Cigarettelfobacco 00172as WAS THE TOHACCO: SELF-SERVE?_ WHE:tE `.�'AS THE MP,CHII�E LOCATED? DOES THE E� SALE WAS M �VAS AN I.D. ASSISTED?� NP.i�tE OF CLERK: ��E'1�,_L�y�r� �9�LC/� ��/J'�� � CLERK'S HOME ADDRESS // s DESCRIPTION OF CLERK � /� �� �GX��• i�2 ��� , DRIVER'S LICENSE �/ OTHER I.D. � E OF I� I.D. � S' ����1� ��� �( � AMOUNT SPENT ON PURCHASE.� , IF A SALE WAS i�IOT MADE: REASON (CFiECSC ONE) . ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑ i� i.D. wns c�cx� Z} BUSINESS CLOSED 3) OUT OF BUSL`IESS 4) UNSATISFACTORY CONDI'I'IONS —�,Q,� ���/ -dti�n YfACHINE7— License Group Comments Text Licensee: pppLE AMERICAN LIMITED PARTNERSHIP OF MN �BA= APPLEBEE'S NEIGHBORHOOD GRILI & BAR license #: 0017244 09/28/2000 OQ ���0'� 09�28/2000 To CAO for adverse acBon. CAR 09/27/2000 Faiied tobacw compiiance check. Clerk is Christian Paul Siater, 1650 Hubbard, 55104, dob 9/14f/6. First failure, $200 fine. CAR 04/11/2000 Congratulations tetter sent for passing aicohol compliance eheck. SS 03/14/2000 passed DPS alcohol compliance check eonducted by Yce Poyak/Wachal. SS 02/t �/2000 � 998 faise alarm fees forgiven per BK CAR 09/16/98 Congretulations lettersent. PJW 08/25l98 Passed cigarette compliance check. PJW ' On t/7/99 Passed check; no "unofficial" waming-DL �2707 . Ph Notice Set 7/29/93 Sent 716/93 7/29/93 Ph On Appn For New On Sale Liq-A, Sunday On Sale, And Restaurant-D License App'D C.F. #93- 1098 9l20l94 Manager Info Changed EfEecive 9l7194 Per Phone Call From Denise Lawson-Legal Asst For Apple American , 1/20/95 Ltr From Corp Stating That Michael Understein Has Resigned — Took Him Off Of The Associates Screen—Lap-Lic 10-23-95—Manager Info Changed Effedive 70-16-95 Per Phone Call From Denise Lawson - Legal Asst For Apple American—Manager pob Is 6-7-59—Lk—Lic 1-4-96—Manager info Changed Eff 111196 Per Phone CaII From Denise Lawson - Legal Asst For Appie American—Manager pob Is 3/17/63—Jonathon Paul Olsen Removed As Manager—New Manager Is John M. Lawler—Lk—Lic 5/15/97 Cig Code Added Fdld #82917—Lap-Lic 07P14/99 passed cig compliance check - 07/27/99 Ietter sent SS 00 - �.00 Address �nsee �ad License Cartlhdder - - -- -- - - -- - — Licensee Neme: DBA PPLE SalesTaxltl: r—v _. __..__�..___._.�.w._. 15160 BJC Sale a � Canceled 314198 Closed due to Canceled 314f98 Closed dueto Canceled 3lC58 Closed due W 03l31t1998' 03f3'171998' R001`160Q � l2001 �160a � License Prirrted oo-boo Lice ; License ' Licensee � Lia Types � Property C� Licensee C: UnoHiciel StreEt #: 60 � Street Name: .1NIVERSITY StreetType: AVE pirediorc �! Und Ind � �Uryt #: � Cdy: T PAUL State: �i1 �' Zip: � Ward: � Dist Coundl: Ir3 — Licensee: DBA: Saies Tax Id: 'slse Alarms # Bus Licensee PPLE AMERICAN LIMITED PRRTNERSHIP OF DBA PPLEBff'S NEIGH80RHOOD GRILL 8 BAR l Insurance � Bontl , Requiremerrts � Projeet Facil3ator. ASUNCION, COPoNI� Adverse Action Comments J � i License Group Comments: 55t04 �82000 To CAO for adverse adion. CAR -- 7R000 Failed tobacco compliance check. Clerk is hristian Paul 51ffier,1650 Hummard, 55104, dob f14176. Fast failure, $200 fine. CAR04I112000 onqrffiulations letter serit for passinq a�ohol 2TNERSHIP Of Licensee r.a�n i u AnR� CommeMs: ��—.~.— € O7l01 f2000 12l31 f1000 N $0.00` Save Changes to Ffistory Canceled . 998;3651 99fr3651 �998:�3651'�': nw..o-vn :;�. A01 �160Q -, DD1i160�=:; � .— ,,. '001+1600 :=`- ._._� 998i1600 � �'��" � PE+�;�; 00 _���0 License ____ Licensee Licensee Name: PLE DBA: PLEi Sales Tax Itl: 0895f AA CoMrad Rec'd OiDOR AA Fee Coileded: Oi00tt Licersee PLE AMEftICAN LIMITm PARTNERSHIP OF DBA PPLEBff`S NEIGHBORHOOD GRf�L 8 BAR ___..__. . __ ._ ___ -----` --- - -----�--------- Lic. Types _ Ins�rance � Bond I RequiremeMS' Non-Profit [' Worker's Comp: iD0J0000 � AA Training Rec'd ONOA000 Discourd Rec'd r � � �n�i��" Other A enc Licenses Financial Hold Reasons r �,!�C�� C`� ',�� ������ �i4!w!� BackgroundCheckRequired � fli5i �License# 7244 , _._,.�____ 82917 9 ;APPLE AMEWCAAAPPLEB�'S Changes to History Mail License To: C•: Ms� To Corhact �-9757= {'; ��nse Address �-A000 , , ..�� _- � - (, � MaA Invoice To: � � � �� �'� Ma� To CoMad 99 �65 �`" � t`-+ License Address 99&`�651'= k . :? 998 �_ 001 160Q 001.'1604 _ . . ,,.„,. . ,,.,_� 001?1600 Canceled - __ ---- _ --------- - QR1GI�lAL Presented By Referred To Council File # �� � �� � O Green Sheet # ��,59��i RESOLUTION OF SAI�IT PAUL, MINNESOTA � Committee: Date RESOLVED, that the Licensee, Apple American Limited Partnership of MN d/b/a Applebee's Neighborhood Grill & Baz (License ID No. 0017244), located at 1600 TJniversity Avenue West in Saint Paul is hereby ordered to pay a fine of $200.00 for the violation of the sale of tobacco or tobacco products to a minor. Said fine sha11 be paid to the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection within thirty (30) days ofthe adoption of this resolution by the Council and signahue by the Mayor. This resolution and the action ofthe Council in this matter are based upon the facts contained in the October 2, 2000 Notice of Violation letter to the licensee, the Tobacco Compliance Check Form, and such arguments as may have been presented to the Council at the public hearing. The facts were not contested by the licensee. Requested by Department of: B U�-�.�.o,� A--�2,e.�i Adopted by Council: Date �`��,\S ��a Form Approved by City Attorney Adoption Certified by Council Secretary // BY: � �' . �rr-7�ei...� � By: � . G�' Approved by Mayor: Date rW�f (,�� Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council BY = � � ���'�/' � By : ao-\Ioa UNCONTESTED LICENSE HEARING Licensee Name: Address: Council Hearing Date Wednesday, November 15, 2000 Violation: Sale of Cigarettes to a Minor Minn. Stat. § 609.685 St. Paul Legislative Code § 324.07 Date of Violation Place: Presumptive Penalty: $200.00 Fine Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection: $200.00 fine (first offense) Attachments: 1. Proposed resolution 2. Notice of Violation 3. License Information Report 4. Tobacco Compliance check Form Apple American Limited Partnership of MN d/b/a Applebee's Neighborhood Grill & Bar 1600 University Avenue West September 27, 2000 Licensed Premises 5. License information CITY OF SAINT PAUL .- Norm Colem¢n, Mayor October 2, 2000 OFFICF - F THE CITY ATTORNEY Claytors A. �binson, Jc, Ciry A[torney civit Division 400 Ciry Nal! I S R'est Kellogg Blvd. Saint Pavl. hlirsnuota 55102 Q0���0� Telephone= 657 266-87/0 Factimile: 65! 298-5619 NOTICE OF VIOLATION Owner/Nlanager Applebee's Neighborhood Grill & Bar 1600 University Avenue West Saint Paul, MN 55104 RE: Cigarette/Tobacco License held by Apple American Limited Partnership of MN d/b/a Applebee's Neighborhood Grill & Bar for the premises at 1600 University Avenue �Vest in St. Paul License ID #: 0017244 Deaz Sir/Madam: The Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection has recommended adverse action against the Cigarette/Tobacco License held by Apple American Limited Partnership of MN d/b/a Applebee's Neighborhood Grill & Baz for the premises at 1600 University Avenue West. The basis for this recommendation is as follows: On September 27, 2000, a minor entered the premises of the Applebee's Neighborhood Grill & Bar at 1600 University Avenue West as part of a compliance check and asked to purchase cigarettes. The individual was able to purchase a package of Newport cigarettes without being asked for identification. It is a violation of Minn. Stat. §609.685 and Saint Paul Legislative Code §324.07 to sell tobacco to a person under the age of 18. Since this is a first violation, the licensing office will recommend a$200.00 fine. At this time you have three options on how to proceed: If you do not dispute the above facts and do not wish to have a public hearing, you will need to pay the recommended fine for this violation. If this is your choice, you should make payment directly to the Office of License Inspections and Environmental Protection, Room 300 Lowry Professional Building, 350 Saint Peter Street, Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102. The letter should be directed to Ms. Christine Rozek. Payment of the fine will be considered to be a waiver of the hearing to which you are entitled. _. � Page 2 Applee's Neighborhood Grill & Baz October 2, 2000 Oa-\\oo 2. Altematively, if you do not dispute the above facts, but wish to have a public hearing before the Saint Paul City Councii, you will need to send me a letter with a statement admitting the violation and requesting a public hearing. We will need to receive your letter by Friday, October 13, 2000. The matter will then be scheduled,before the City Council for a public hearing to determine what penalty, if any, to impose. You will have an opportunity to appeaz before the Council and make a statement on your own behal�: 3. If you do dispute the above facts, a hearing will be scheduled before an Administrative La�v Judge. At that hearing both you and the City will be able to appear and present witnesses, evidence and cross-examine the other's wimesses. The St. Paul City, Council wili ultimately decide the case. If this is your choice, please advise my legal assistant, Peter Pangbom, and we wili take the necessary steps to schedule the administrative hearing. He can be reached at 266-8710. If we have not heard from you by Friday, October 13, 2000, we will assume that you do not contest the facts and will schedule this matter for the St. Paul City Council and have it placed on the Consent Agenda during which no public discussion is allowed and the recommended penalty will be imposed. Please be advised that the clerk who was identified as having made the sale on this date is also being charged an administrative genalty pursuant to Minn. Stat. §461.12, subd. 3. This is a separate action from this license matter. If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me at (651) 266-8710. Sincerely, � � �.zc�.C�� � cL�'.-vv� Virginia � Palxner Assistant City Attorney cc: Robert Kessler, Director of LIEP Christine Rozek, Deputy Director of LIEP Christopher Dart, Community Organizer, Lexington-Hamline Community Council, 1160 Selby Ave., St. Paul, MN 55104 OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY C[aytan M Robinson, Jc, Ciry Attorney CITY OF SAINT PAUL Norm Colemarz, Mayor civit Division 400 Ciry Ha[I I S West Kellogg Blvd. Saini Pau[, hlinnesota 55l02 Q� ���d0 Telephone: 65! 266-8710 Fncsimile: 651298-5619 October 30, 2000 NOTICE OF COUNCIL HEARING Owner/Manager Applebee's Neighborhood Grill & Baz 1600 University Avenue West Saint Paul, MN 55104 '�,'(, ��S23rC� v@:^.d2t �d� �� .`_ �QQ� RE: Cigarette/Tobacco License held by Apple American Limited Partnership of MN d/b/a , Applebee's Neighborhood Grill & Baz for the premises at 1600 University Avenue West — in St. Paul License ID #: 0017244 Deaz Sir/Madam: Please take notice that a hearing concerning the above-named establishment has been scheduled for 5:30 p.m., Wednesday, November 15, 2000 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse. Enclosed aze copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested hearing in that the facts contained in the report concerning the unlawful sale of cigarettes have not been disputed. You will have an opportunity at the Council hearing to present oral and/or written remarks as to the penalty, if any, to be imposed. The recommendation of the license office will be for a$200.00 fine. If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710. Very truly yours, (/ U�-� �� V'o---(''�^-r� U Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP Christine Rozek, LIEP Christopher Dart, Community Organizer, Lexington-Hamline Community Council, 1160 Selby Ave., St. Paul, MN 55104 po_ ��ec STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF RAMSEY ) AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says that on October 3, 2000, she served the attached NOTICE OF VIOLATION on the following named person by placing a true �nd correct copy thereo£ in an envelope addressed as follows: Owner/Manager Applebee's Neighborhood Grill & Bar 1600 University Avenue West St. Paul, MN. 55104 (which is the last known address of said person) and depositing the same, with postage prepaid, in the UnitecLBtat�s mails at St. Paul, Minnesota. / \ �. Subscribed and sworn to before me this 3rd day of �Octob�r, 2000. Notary PETER P PANGBORN NOTARY PUBL7C - MINNESOTA MY CppAp�lSSiON EXPIRES JAk_ 31, 2005 � p _ ��oo j i �Q � Ix � W � o y (°� rn c V � OJ J � 0. N O C d � C O • R � L YY� C d N C d V J N I� N > V U ..J Q N N U_ y F E N N c Q IU N y IJ I LL o � o � N ��I i � I' � i Z� I N I� U r :j I O , !o v � V W a � � � N W � Z � = V a O O � � .-- � � m 2 � W Z N � W Z W m 00 a �a Q F � � Z U d � i� W Z Q �� ma I la i ¢ �U C � 0 U � 0 � N � d X W NI C I CI � Z U O a V cl m� LJ C m1 �j �, z; c aj �I O I c' I�I � h: c � � � � � Z N C r o ,� L ^ a o , N N h � m � C �v1 N m � p I� i~ � I o l � � I a � (A � � ; w I V � a � �¢ � C � � � N d � ' U L � p 7 N� � C � � �LL @ Y � � - pm i �� C jt U� N� m am inii v° ��"-�da .�eC �' � `m rnLL �... oQ � � ac- Qa"i� Q c a ym QU �y mQ a�rn- t� � G C 6 � m � > N � U V .� � j�U3 JO_ �¢ LQ _IWrnlLC� cda �o. ' da�m m >m � �� om �c' a�i E °� .c�'o m ��y �� ��i;� U(0 fA O � C�� !n y �J = LLl y(O�QM � Q O i V N N• O � C �Y 'O N� �� N N �� y W C L p �� W(p� N NE� � L���7 co�U vy �� rn�a ��`c' y c E c �mJ rn3 ° c' ma>p N C 0 C(0 � i U L ry1 G � y NV� O � �m� N L �"O-�UC��C ` mma�n�p�� ��m Um ����omUr � >tn� .yma�� rnc� ° om�SEmo�fl� Q' �Y NL" U" N 0 0_ . N C❑ U N C N p� G.J m N �a>o� �d�Q o'mm�otm�rn�wH r c� rno�o��c�mor�ma�i� i-��VU � o.� o md °'O � c�- ��2cn �6U•� c°'� o,' OOi ONO O �L � CH� dm� 0o m o �o'�oUdrn d a � '� ��n �' E E EY oom�o�o>'c°\�rnrn°� �r�� � p � �a�� NN���._NR f �l� O� N m N �'(j� O Va' � N� �Or' �� N. O on0"�O PnN� p.� N N � ood�oc�io>0000�a�o°rna¢ �¢°a¢�UaO� � � w 0 N N m R a � 0 a d � c 0 .� E L � W � � � � d d N y d � U � J — � � U� J N nr m o J ' ' Y r U N m V N �N Xk U a� �o .� U V m Q Q V p N'6 N UOr�i1 O J U � � � mQ �U� ��r 3 m"� J l[) p Oo _ I lua n oi Q �, x � W o No � �o m V N R J c� O. i+ O � O C � C O .� � � O ... c d w c m a J N 7 N � C N N � C ZT U C J � 0 w c y � o_ „ � E N � �a � � U � @ Q O ` O N � o E� � � IZ V r J p � R V W � Q � � � N N� Z � � � a O O � � � � � Q m 2 C� w Z � �w Z W m ma �° a Q F � J Q I � U � �w �Z Q I � J Ia Q .� � � 0 U � � M � N N � d X ll.� h C � � � � Z U 0 a m U C m 5 �u �� !�I IZ I TI �I m ��I �a� UI I�I � �i (� � � E � Z N �n o ,� L r a a , y N N � � � c 7 � r m � n o �� �F � i � �O w 6 F k C ', � � � c a m - N � � '�. � U L— p 3 U w .c "a �n w . � o Q � Y � m � U � m M `� u. � � `N� o� c y �� �# a`� � �.J o � o c � � a mo.cu� � U � p • y � m a m �ii vLL H o`�-!a Q� y Q a�i � o- c�i °- d m a U � ai d� a> rn-� d Q w� � t� � c c a� rn m� > �a o m �a c'�i 3 �'�a_ �,Q �O '���rnu o c ° cv ° a�i E ° .c�io m o �� �c��y?� � m� fn � ° c�� � y �J �2 w ycn�Qo'� 3 da d NNO_C �C� WC L1' 'OTiNWfO�N �O� � O r"470� �OJ N N �H C� ��Z "�60"o C U � N V C n dp �N � i UrtD��Jy m @ V i 0 (6 � �Z � t6J 16-O-�UCy{6C—(0 O�� i6fnd� � p N U � O� (� N aC ��� @CJ t�i1 O f6 � o'� �m0 . N�m rn� ��� o y .y� ��� o m�� Qv @YNLw7U� rna� �p �j�ca`�og��d N N� � V m UN l6"6 N N � - y � N m� i N� U=� CN(Al6miNN I�Qa' NECEyNN_CNtp�"O o mmK o.c m rn ui c aiO m o� � c- m rn� � m u i-tL�QU�a� ��nm a� v � �� m��ma��>� V o � a �o � �tL. c � o o �c�i m .cQ ��d��m �dm EY 00 ��o coi'oo�mrn �a �V E-'�d °?�n � E� E� d� NN— C l6N O . N O N � Wh���O_�d<c��O��i�0�t6 WN�p�j`V(`�1)L�tOILUCN NN N�c-N��ZW��O C_O N pNd_m— N N �6)NN�O(hUN�W �NLNC�N�O�.=CypN d� (4Ey N oOacs�pUO>o000�ar�Orrnn.Q �Q�O_Q�UQO� �_�\aa � � w 0 v m m n a � 0 a m � c 0 :. m E � � ° � c _ � m m N N V 'J J � 6� � U� J N Q @ O J ' i Y n V N �U N �N Xk U � � _ N LL �- y O . V � � 0 Q �V O � � N U O N O J U � C ' QJ Q � U rn rn ��� 3tO� m�� JtqO �� _��oa � Ip Q iO w O h I� y U � R '� M a N � 0 a � c O i=� N � O w c m N C V J N 3 � � a��i > J Q h a� Q y F E a� `m C Q U � N J �p LL � R V W � Q � � � I W a? � Z ��v I u� � d' O m _ � W Z N y � W � W Z m '°� a ° a Q IU c � U �� N N 0 a w N c � E 3 Z U 0 a U C m � N C d � � 3 Z N c ^ o � L r a a, y N N d d� C �m N 7 � m � N � E y � � TI I N � Z � (m ' Q ° � U EI I N.fl Im� o � m ° � I@�w UI i ' W z z � �v� 0 � C �O W �' �X � i.. dr � � �� 0.� o jma w �,F-m � J O a a � p j � O Q �-- U a C .� � a . � � ' U L O 3 U � L � � N .-. V O Q �- Y� l6 �"� U J l6M ln� N C � Y � v `- rn c �t m � � Y �° cx d d coin vL a� @�° U� � U C� a� tn LL � LL F- Q"� 6' na y o a�- Q a�i� °- c�i °- �`m aU � y a�� a� rn-�aa� � Utrn � c c �.c 3 6 � rna m� > a� co o m� G1� �O (6 j� Ua J d N VO UJ�p)LL C C OU� C �' � NQ >� � N� �t�? m .0 U � '�Cn`+ ��� N $ � c m� � m �� �S ul Nco�Qr� 3 �.O ` p� NN—O �C� 4l.IC L �� NE� L � E 7 CO�U "6y �O Wj.�"6� Z L��n °� o °' o � � 3 rnt- c o a� �� I jU y V �" V O r � � C f6Np�JM`y 'O t0 i��C � �J �� ��LN R fAp� m c° ° lqtnmc' s ��� .cm ��Q o�a ���a� o m� �o� Um c�°OmUv�om �r.�� �Cn� .N�.(UL M�� 0"G fl-m�G CO3�� Q"6 �.Y NLw 3U m�-� CO �N C GJD�CJd N d� �c� m c>m%v d c� fl-� � U � m rn� � m�Q Hti�QU�a.� a��� ��c�i���mV � Wa�i�o� � �LL._LLSln °o°oa�U�c�i°om°oUa� �rQ m�m��y��dm��EY NN��N�NONW�� U M� V aon� o_�a�co�n�o °°��m�°� ��°� y ochp, a���i � c`m o Q '6 tn � fl. ��(ONV O(`7UNW�CN d�(6ENN OOdERO UO�000��--dhO�-maQ<�Q'-4Q�C„)QQJ Do-�\oa � r w 0 � m � R a r 0 a d � c 0 « R � � � w � C � � d � y y C � V '_' J � � � V� J N a� �o �� i Y h � � U N Xk U � c _ N � O . U � � � Q �V p N 'O N U O m o�U� � 'rna �CU� ��� ��� 3 m"r J�nO I� �� i m i0 � � W r 0 N O n � I N U R � M d N � O C. � c 0 w m E O w c m N L v J y 3 @ � d a��i > :� Q N d a t�' E IN N N a d U y � � LL a N V li! � Q �� � v� liJ N� Z '��v a0 m� K O m 2 � W Z d� m Z � m ma ° a Q .� 7 O U N� 0 � N N � di X W h c � a � 3 Z U a U C m � � c ` � � � Z N c r o � � r a a , N N N � Ic � !�vi N m � N� v � H � � � I � c W � T vi Q C � m I O Q O.I I o ,d V i N�.cz n� o I I, � o '� I � W � �I I W � Z Q I I ��I I m y�� C `I � W i ' �� N O J I i I � j J '� i°v"� I�m�Ia ��'n� ''F- � 0.� o L.� Q U o �'�Q � � i �, i ;'� i; DO-1�o 0 T c � m � . � � '� � U � - O � C.),�N t 'o N .. V O Q � Y i (6 Y U J N M � W C .0 °>LL � � Y �O c� a a� min o= d�°- c�� • � m a m r'n�i vLLL°, i s - o n °� N �c Q m Q �� QU �y p �s`mQoy U�� c c��3 °�� rn�' m� » U� O (6 j� Uc J Q �a LQ " J�m C C N� a a U U ��LL O � °c� a�i E o,,;�'� my �u �� �o�;�v U t0 N O � C@� � N `�J S W y(O,�QC'') 2� � ,r U NN�.G �CC W C L' ' yW (6�N v L w�E� coOV a�°, �o o��a-o� Z °'$'n °—' c E''c r3.J o�3 c ( � U� O m (6 y �� �?� (6J (0- OJU C y` f0 C y t�6 oWa ���a��OOdc tf�o@ Um �c���c OOj �CA� . �C� �N p'NJ�� N�1 _ (� '616�rt6.��U ��..J CQ V NC ND� O_ (n mQ o'iomKo�m�rnrnoiy �c� a�o�o��c��rn��a HLL�QU�a� cfnm mp ��-�ti2cA� 'U � O Nd !!I C �U'� C�� O 00� OUON�Ud LQ �=N CN �d@ �Y oo��oco?`omwrn � ��j�-�'y����`�, Ecm� �I+� O_d'�-�COIl��t� O� (6 O�i C yp��i � UMa � U � N ��NNV O('7UNW�CNtNCpNLdNCNON d� (OEN N OOdERO UO�OOOO�df�O��dQ��Q�d. Q�UQOJ �pfl_ ��oo � T W Q � d � R a r 0 a m � c 0 « m £ L � W � C � � d � y N V � J � � � V �\- J N Q � O J ' � y � � � � N V Xk U V � !1 Q y O - U � � O Q V O �� N CJ Ot�ii o�U� `- 'rna �Urn � � ��� 3 m�'� JlnO t�o-\�pO � � �W I � O h o m �o d V N a J M n 0 � 0 a � C O i7 16 � L 0 W N c u J � �� d U � J Q U � U T � t- � N � N �I� VIN ;J Im 'i_ (U � �� o � N �I O I I � I � �I Z i ��m'v C �N I I J V I U O � N v w 4 r � �, w a? z a�� a O O � � � � 1.1� W 2 � W Z E � m W Z W m W p a Q r � J Q U � � � W Z Q i m a d Q . I� C I �I U U .� N o� � � ❑ a x w N � � � E � Z U O a U G m 3 N C I i I I Z � a c m n I�i i I d �mj i� N C � a E � ,Z � C � o ,� r a IN N N ^ m � � ❑ � �x � F � � O . w �.� C� �� r .� � C � � � . � � 'i � U �- o � U ;o s 'a tn.. V O Q � yi N Y U J NM L �LL. C L LL � � � � Y �� � ik N <o in c� 3 U� .y � m d� !4 LL 7 LL �- ¢-� ° o-a tn � �� Q � a �� Q U � N O �� Y d Q o� 0 J L m ULrn � ��s 3 �- rnQ m� > a �`o ic � c aUi� o m �a �- J Q °J �� •����'�' o 3 � -O O y E °' .�� m 'c� �� ����y?� � m� w � ° � R� tn y �� � W�°co�Qc� 3 �o.o � yv rn�� Wc ro �3Nwm ��u� � t ,���� co - o,°� �o o��a O O J F' i j V� y U � UO �`� � � Ly��JMp) N C � (0 � � U C i y �c�c0 � fn�NC��c �?C .c� ��JU����D�c o�� �iotna��o�y �i°m Um �c 03 ��O .m��� rnc� °d o � Q �Y�L� S��.a rn°-- �!] U� c a� o� �� a�Q U�o o��ai�mm-oa� NQ� a�E�E�dm� `my�a 0f6 ~ C mQ(60� V C—�p�� N U F��VU � o_� o ma d0 � �w.�ii2tn�U � c�� o� 00 o�o �rQ m-m cw �a�m� EY oo��0�02�oo�mrn �d �UE�'m��n�E�Eca» NN—�� (ON ONO)m� ' M� V QN rn (60�LQ O �d' � �I�� Q7aa-cD�fJ�h O� f0 QJ � N� � Uc`�� N�IL C N NN j�� � V��N � O Q�"O mN n �_ N N OOd�OUO�pOO� �a�o°rna¢°r�¢°a¢ �UQ�J p _ ��o a � � w 0 0 � m m � a L � W � C � � d d y N C �. d d V � �.1 — m m U� J N d� � O _1 � � y r V a-- d � L N V 7k U � � i— LL a ao � U � a � O a V o ma N V O t�n o: � rna �Urn rn ��� �rnv 3`°� m�n JtnO � � l a i � :w O �N� � C O � �o q U R J M d � r 0 � O Q � C O i=� A � O w C m W d V .J l I� I � N U � J Q c N N `o C N �+ T m iN � N � j N N iU � � O "I N �� I o , i��N � r J O � � v w > ¢ IN � � Z � = C Q 0 O �� � K � m 2 C7 W Z � � �W � W Z m ma � a Q H � J Z Q �I U j� �w IZ Q �IJ I L a _�la IUI C 3 O U � N � � � I d m � Q W N C � � 7 Z U a U C c � C �I I Wq IZ , ICI �Q', '�i IU j ��'' ci I �I I =� y, U i� � � Z N c r o � t � a �, N N N ��I� I �i� I m � � F I � i� �O �� �N 3 !c w I y! � m' Q , � � � I W � W m j W I a � d _ n I� ,� _�`eo � c .n m a .� � � ' U L 3 O 3 U m .c "a � � N.-. V O Q � i� @ Y � � �� i O]LL C �L U� -y L m a a� c�ti �LL F �Q�a a u�i � � a �_ � c Q d o_ � E QU � y Q �Y NQL � c6 V�� o����3 JQ rnQ L� >d�co`om� C N� �p_ �d - 0. > N U� U i��++0 f °- cv ° a�i E o..:�� my ��� �� �o^�y�� U(6 f0 O r-. C f6 � � m `� J � S W N CO � Q(`'I 3 �oQO � U Nmp.0 rnC� Wc L� �3inWm�N ���n m s °,�'� E 7 �� U a,°� �F a>��a y\? j V � (n U � V � �NJ �3 � NNpO> � i� C � C(0 - i ULt� C� @U� O @ (6 y (6J R y(OC (�0 o�� ���d��omcYi tn`o� Vy �c�°�mUNO� „O j �7,fn� .N ��L �C� O d O C � l�6w Q v= m �a c� Uyc U �� �a�i ai 2 mrn � a� y �Q� `m E � E� � m � d�� F-IL�QC� UO.C��Nf6 N�'O (6 0Up m V ���� CR ; U 00 - Vo moYO ° � 0 d �n0 � c�- -�2cn�U•c c�� o-� oom o�omoUa LQ �°=d�ch ya�m Es NN m�N NN ON��� V M � 7�Qtn y(6�LQ� O V� NN j� �� N��N��Z���p C �p ��N ��LL N N� �� VNm�CNLNC�NLQNCNONQ�(OE NN OOdfHO UO�OOOOrn.I�O�--�dQc�-�Q�dQ�(,�QOJ 00- �loo � � w 0 N � d m 10 a r 0 a m � c 0 :: R E � � ° � c _ _ m d w N d d c> � J — � � U� J N Q � O J ' i Y � � � L N V �k U a � �O � U a �rn O a V O ,� � N U Ovl O J (,.) � "'rna �Urn `�rn �rnv 3 � m�r� J�O �j ��; 'O i � IW o ' a� r . T I � �O d Ip N R I J I� IM a _io � O a � C O .� � L Q W C d N c d e� J h � i� I � d I� � I V �V J a T N a � � � m m a � � � c ;_ � I� o U _I O' � 0 o �! N �' O Z I y i� V I� J � N v w ¢ � i� Nw N� Z a�� a O O �� I.L � m 2 C� w Z � � @ W Z W ,m Im I� I�'a `i Q H � J Z �U �� ���W z ;Q I �IJ �a �a �IQ I Uj C', �O U! U L N � l I� ;�' o) a� y�0 � o — N O � �O LI � � 7 I Z U a io �� N I c;� � N C �l -,� N I Z ' 7 � T F" c � IQ,� i�:� �a z U .Q V'� �C � im,W IC � LI� � 4 � ZI N' o � L � a;� N N N � N � � m N � ; m � � � F � rn � O �� IN; � N I iNi � I m I Q i �� W ' m W ��Q To �- ; i; a� - ��o 0 � C Q � � 'y � d '- U L � p 3 U c,�o o " � � �C � l0 y U J l6 M p� U- C L �� � � Y �� �� d a� coin �r m�Q� �� �N U � dm �� �� � �J ��a � � a ��� QU °�YdQo� U�� � � ��t3 s� �`� �O ?m cda o m >a�= �Q d VO �UJ�WLLOC N N N ° -� -° o a�i E o�:�'� m� ��� �� �o^�oi�� � M U "'-C�c� �(/� � �= LLIyCO�QM�? � < � o � y'a L � C c W c .c Y � 3 N W c¢ � a� ��in m r w�E� o�c �y � m���o�^? d U� O O� 1�3J �3 �~ �N ��JM "�00'O C V �� �� C(0 iV =N���y� �U(0 � fnNN � LN �N C p�� �CAn.Nyp�� ��c U�n ac@�OmUyom Qa � wtn� .w@�� ��� o�� o.�����o��� Q"O �Y NL U'6 � din C � U�� N O� CJ N H U ����NyNm�NN �a� �ocE�a��imLL�d� F� �p� ct+ �ii=��Cj°�� 00 N O UO (ODUd LQ m= N�- C N � N�� NN � CN �N ON��� V M � d' (6 � �Q� O NN��� O_V ��cO���Z���� C N� p� pMd d�LL �� �o� �� ���N n � rn° o a�v mN .. n- �O) ( ONV' OM.-N�W C CpNL O.� C NO N i].� (6 ooau>o c�o>0000�-a�.O�a�a¢.-�¢�a¢.-U N U OJ � � C N ai 3 � J bo-l4o0 � � w 0 v T d � � a r 0 a m � c 0 Y R � L �'^ W v/ � C Q� Q� N N d d l�t � J � � U� J N Q � O J ' � y n � � L N 6'1 �N � U � C _ [6 Li °- �o . U a rn O a V O �'a N U O N o�U� � o� a �Urn , � ��� 3'� � m r' r JlnO r; '; �'i � ; � p� —t\cv � �� '�i '`�I 0 � iXi < W I p iy � C O � � N d V � (�p J M a ' o � 0 Q � C O R � � w C N c m u J � � m I� N y U � J Q N O O N > O N N �� F, � c I� � iU � � J O' J O `� O ,y� N .Q I ° � Zi y �� Ul JO VJ � v w ¢ � i IN!w �Z � � � a O O � � � � m 2 C7 ua Z � @w Z W m ma ��I Q F-� � J Q l � ', U i�;� �z a �'J ��N:d �� Q r—, IC i� i �C> . �� N� �� � I � o� a w 0 �'N i� �� � N � 3I Z: r V' OiN n' !M U � � N � V �o � '� � I m � J l� Z� �I� � @ � ' O � U Z i Q iU � i t W I� � �J � I Z I N C r t lA a;� N �p i� m �v1 ; N im'� � O� � F�- I � I� �O I C�� W . i � Im i Q � i � i m � �Q � i � I C � @ � N d � I .0 � O 3 I �` _ � � � ='-- � o Q � � i L � U V -� �M i m� C Y d�- rn u Y �� �# d � � o Y'�° y � � a �' v�u; � F' � - O .- � � L �o � � K�� oa � fl- c ¢ nin O�m'xa�Qo` L d �,� ( � C C �L �i �� � N f�6'� > NJ(p p@ N i tJ O (6 �' U J O. �Q LQ ' J�p�LL C C ;o�a a�i E oa�v m� �� �� �o��y?g 2 W �� no N �� d m``� `h� �n �� m y�°�¢� 3 � °: �wa rnc� wc ro �3Nwm�a� ��u> d t w�E co�� - oy F"o a��.QV�=? >�� �n U E Uo r' °'3 c' mdpa��c+� "00"6 C � C Q CN i ULN C � y� �, O�� (6lndln�pNU fnON U,��n �C�w�l6Uu�i OQj �fn� . �C� �N p�y� CE f00��� , Q.6S N y _�Lw7U. 0 ��-y �O U� CNO�CJd y U �� �NrA(17��NN f� ��CE�N�IO omm�osm c� o�o�o��c@mo��@a�� � I-��¢�U � o_ o� �p � cLL.`iixcn�U `cp�'o� o o �.cQ ��m�cw da�m Es 'NN��NR�NONO�]6�]� V ch� � �I��p� O_�n'�(Otn�� OW (6� W C ym � U�a y�LL V C N ' �� OMUNO)� ypN Q�(6E NN j OOREAO UO�OOOO�d1�O.--�dQ��Q�a.Qc-(.,)QOJ ao - � �ov � � w 0 � � d m R a � � ° � c _ � d � y N � L d � V � J � � U � J N fl-O J � � y r U N � U N N N # U � � �O � U � � � O Q f> O � � N UOVI o�U� � o�a �U� ��� 3 �n . m�r= J�O OfFiCE OF LtCEvSE, INSPECTiONS AND 8JV1ROTl11EtiTAL PROTEGTION Robert Kess(v, Dirrlur CITY O� SAINT PALTL. Norm Coleman. dlayor LOiYRY PftOF'cSSIO;VdL BU1LDlNG Suite 300 350 St Peter Svea Saint PauC Minnesam i5102-lSIO roaacco co��vcE c�cx Fox:« -�x zoao '� O � \�O'Q Telephonc 611-2fi6-9p9p Facsiadlc 6/Z16E-9099 6I2-266-91?; c.rr. DATE: Z b TL�: �-! � n 1 LICE�ISE I.D. �O�iX�L�i —� <JbEL�� .c -lj c lYAitiLE. OF CD�iPLIA1vCE CXECKER �' J v � �� °( ! NAMEOF ADULT SUPERVISOR P- �[%_�,./ NAi�lE & ADDRESS OF LICENSED VENDOR:_ APPLEBEE'S NEIGHBORHOOD GRILL 1600 UNIVERSITYAVE W —ST PAUL, MN 55104-3898 D� License Type: license # TYPE OF ESTABLtSF�YtEi t'�l'��- Cigarettelfobacco 00172as WAS THE TOHACCO: SELF-SERVE?_ WHE:tE `.�'AS THE MP,CHII�E LOCATED? DOES THE E� SALE WAS M �VAS AN I.D. ASSISTED?� NP.i�tE OF CLERK: ��E'1�,_L�y�r� �9�LC/� ��/J'�� � CLERK'S HOME ADDRESS // s DESCRIPTION OF CLERK � /� �� �GX��• i�2 ��� , DRIVER'S LICENSE �/ OTHER I.D. � E OF I� I.D. � S' ����1� ��� �( � AMOUNT SPENT ON PURCHASE.� , IF A SALE WAS i�IOT MADE: REASON (CFiECSC ONE) . ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑ i� i.D. wns c�cx� Z} BUSINESS CLOSED 3) OUT OF BUSL`IESS 4) UNSATISFACTORY CONDI'I'IONS —�,Q,� ���/ -dti�n YfACHINE7— License Group Comments Text Licensee: pppLE AMERICAN LIMITED PARTNERSHIP OF MN �BA= APPLEBEE'S NEIGHBORHOOD GRILI & BAR license #: 0017244 09/28/2000 OQ ���0'� 09�28/2000 To CAO for adverse acBon. CAR 09/27/2000 Faiied tobacw compiiance check. Clerk is Christian Paul Siater, 1650 Hubbard, 55104, dob 9/14f/6. First failure, $200 fine. CAR 04/11/2000 Congratulations tetter sent for passing aicohol compliance eheck. SS 03/14/2000 passed DPS alcohol compliance check eonducted by Yce Poyak/Wachal. SS 02/t �/2000 � 998 faise alarm fees forgiven per BK CAR 09/16/98 Congretulations lettersent. PJW 08/25l98 Passed cigarette compliance check. PJW ' On t/7/99 Passed check; no "unofficial" waming-DL �2707 . Ph Notice Set 7/29/93 Sent 716/93 7/29/93 Ph On Appn For New On Sale Liq-A, Sunday On Sale, And Restaurant-D License App'D C.F. #93- 1098 9l20l94 Manager Info Changed EfEecive 9l7194 Per Phone Call From Denise Lawson-Legal Asst For Apple American , 1/20/95 Ltr From Corp Stating That Michael Understein Has Resigned — Took Him Off Of The Associates Screen—Lap-Lic 10-23-95—Manager Info Changed Effedive 70-16-95 Per Phone Call From Denise Lawson - Legal Asst For Apple American—Manager pob Is 6-7-59—Lk—Lic 1-4-96—Manager info Changed Eff 111196 Per Phone CaII From Denise Lawson - Legal Asst For Appie American—Manager pob Is 3/17/63—Jonathon Paul Olsen Removed As Manager—New Manager Is John M. Lawler—Lk—Lic 5/15/97 Cig Code Added Fdld #82917—Lap-Lic 07P14/99 passed cig compliance check - 07/27/99 Ietter sent SS 00 - �.00 Address �nsee �ad License Cartlhdder - - -- -- - - -- - — Licensee Neme: DBA PPLE SalesTaxltl: r—v _. __..__�..___._.�.w._. 15160 BJC Sale a � Canceled 314198 Closed due to Canceled 314f98 Closed dueto Canceled 3lC58 Closed due W 03l31t1998' 03f3'171998' R001`160Q � l2001 �160a � License Prirrted oo-boo Lice ; License ' Licensee � Lia Types � Property C� Licensee C: UnoHiciel StreEt #: 60 � Street Name: .1NIVERSITY StreetType: AVE pirediorc �! Und Ind � �Uryt #: � Cdy: T PAUL State: �i1 �' Zip: � Ward: � Dist Coundl: Ir3 — Licensee: DBA: Saies Tax Id: 'slse Alarms # Bus Licensee PPLE AMERICAN LIMITED PRRTNERSHIP OF DBA PPLEBff'S NEIGH80RHOOD GRILL 8 BAR l Insurance � Bontl , Requiremerrts � Projeet Facil3ator. ASUNCION, COPoNI� Adverse Action Comments J � i License Group Comments: 55t04 �82000 To CAO for adverse adion. CAR -- 7R000 Failed tobacco compliance check. Clerk is hristian Paul 51ffier,1650 Hummard, 55104, dob f14176. Fast failure, $200 fine. CAR04I112000 onqrffiulations letter serit for passinq a�ohol 2TNERSHIP Of Licensee r.a�n i u AnR� CommeMs: ��—.~.— € O7l01 f2000 12l31 f1000 N $0.00` Save Changes to Ffistory Canceled . 998;3651 99fr3651 �998:�3651'�': nw..o-vn :;�. A01 �160Q -, DD1i160�=:; � .— ,,. '001+1600 :=`- ._._� 998i1600 � �'��" � PE+�;�; 00 _���0 License ____ Licensee Licensee Name: PLE DBA: PLEi Sales Tax Itl: 0895f AA CoMrad Rec'd OiDOR AA Fee Coileded: Oi00tt Licersee PLE AMEftICAN LIMITm PARTNERSHIP OF DBA PPLEBff`S NEIGHBORHOOD GRf�L 8 BAR ___..__. . __ ._ ___ -----` --- - -----�--------- Lic. Types _ Ins�rance � Bond I RequiremeMS' Non-Profit [' Worker's Comp: iD0J0000 � AA Training Rec'd ONOA000 Discourd Rec'd r � � �n�i��" Other A enc Licenses Financial Hold Reasons r �,!�C�� C`� ',�� ������ �i4!w!� BackgroundCheckRequired � fli5i �License# 7244 , _._,.�____ 82917 9 ;APPLE AMEWCAAAPPLEB�'S Changes to History Mail License To: C•: Ms� To Corhact �-9757= {'; ��nse Address �-A000 , , ..�� _- � - (, � MaA Invoice To: � � � �� �'� Ma� To CoMad 99 �65 �`" � t`-+ License Address 99&`�651'= k . :? 998 �_ 001 160Q 001.'1604 _ . . ,,.„,. . ,,.,_� 001?1600 Canceled - __ ---- _ --------- - QR1GI�lAL Presented By Referred To Council File # �� � �� � O Green Sheet # ��,59��i RESOLUTION OF SAI�IT PAUL, MINNESOTA � Committee: Date RESOLVED, that the Licensee, Apple American Limited Partnership of MN d/b/a Applebee's Neighborhood Grill & Baz (License ID No. 0017244), located at 1600 TJniversity Avenue West in Saint Paul is hereby ordered to pay a fine of $200.00 for the violation of the sale of tobacco or tobacco products to a minor. Said fine sha11 be paid to the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection within thirty (30) days ofthe adoption of this resolution by the Council and signahue by the Mayor. This resolution and the action ofthe Council in this matter are based upon the facts contained in the October 2, 2000 Notice of Violation letter to the licensee, the Tobacco Compliance Check Form, and such arguments as may have been presented to the Council at the public hearing. The facts were not contested by the licensee. Requested by Department of: B U�-�.�.o,� A--�2,e.�i Adopted by Council: Date �`��,\S ��a Form Approved by City Attorney Adoption Certified by Council Secretary // BY: � �' . �rr-7�ei...� � By: � . G�' Approved by Mayor: Date rW�f (,�� Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council BY = � � ���'�/' � By : ao-\Ioa UNCONTESTED LICENSE HEARING Licensee Name: Address: Council Hearing Date Wednesday, November 15, 2000 Violation: Sale of Cigarettes to a Minor Minn. Stat. § 609.685 St. Paul Legislative Code § 324.07 Date of Violation Place: Presumptive Penalty: $200.00 Fine Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection: $200.00 fine (first offense) Attachments: 1. Proposed resolution 2. Notice of Violation 3. License Information Report 4. Tobacco Compliance check Form Apple American Limited Partnership of MN d/b/a Applebee's Neighborhood Grill & Bar 1600 University Avenue West September 27, 2000 Licensed Premises 5. License information CITY OF SAINT PAUL .- Norm Colem¢n, Mayor October 2, 2000 OFFICF - F THE CITY ATTORNEY Claytors A. �binson, Jc, Ciry A[torney civit Division 400 Ciry Nal! I S R'est Kellogg Blvd. Saint Pavl. hlirsnuota 55102 Q0���0� Telephone= 657 266-87/0 Factimile: 65! 298-5619 NOTICE OF VIOLATION Owner/Nlanager Applebee's Neighborhood Grill & Bar 1600 University Avenue West Saint Paul, MN 55104 RE: Cigarette/Tobacco License held by Apple American Limited Partnership of MN d/b/a Applebee's Neighborhood Grill & Bar for the premises at 1600 University Avenue �Vest in St. Paul License ID #: 0017244 Deaz Sir/Madam: The Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection has recommended adverse action against the Cigarette/Tobacco License held by Apple American Limited Partnership of MN d/b/a Applebee's Neighborhood Grill & Baz for the premises at 1600 University Avenue West. The basis for this recommendation is as follows: On September 27, 2000, a minor entered the premises of the Applebee's Neighborhood Grill & Bar at 1600 University Avenue West as part of a compliance check and asked to purchase cigarettes. The individual was able to purchase a package of Newport cigarettes without being asked for identification. It is a violation of Minn. Stat. §609.685 and Saint Paul Legislative Code §324.07 to sell tobacco to a person under the age of 18. Since this is a first violation, the licensing office will recommend a$200.00 fine. At this time you have three options on how to proceed: If you do not dispute the above facts and do not wish to have a public hearing, you will need to pay the recommended fine for this violation. If this is your choice, you should make payment directly to the Office of License Inspections and Environmental Protection, Room 300 Lowry Professional Building, 350 Saint Peter Street, Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102. The letter should be directed to Ms. Christine Rozek. Payment of the fine will be considered to be a waiver of the hearing to which you are entitled. _. � Page 2 Applee's Neighborhood Grill & Baz October 2, 2000 Oa-\\oo 2. Altematively, if you do not dispute the above facts, but wish to have a public hearing before the Saint Paul City Councii, you will need to send me a letter with a statement admitting the violation and requesting a public hearing. We will need to receive your letter by Friday, October 13, 2000. The matter will then be scheduled,before the City Council for a public hearing to determine what penalty, if any, to impose. You will have an opportunity to appeaz before the Council and make a statement on your own behal�: 3. If you do dispute the above facts, a hearing will be scheduled before an Administrative La�v Judge. At that hearing both you and the City will be able to appear and present witnesses, evidence and cross-examine the other's wimesses. The St. Paul City, Council wili ultimately decide the case. If this is your choice, please advise my legal assistant, Peter Pangbom, and we wili take the necessary steps to schedule the administrative hearing. He can be reached at 266-8710. If we have not heard from you by Friday, October 13, 2000, we will assume that you do not contest the facts and will schedule this matter for the St. Paul City Council and have it placed on the Consent Agenda during which no public discussion is allowed and the recommended penalty will be imposed. Please be advised that the clerk who was identified as having made the sale on this date is also being charged an administrative genalty pursuant to Minn. Stat. §461.12, subd. 3. This is a separate action from this license matter. If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me at (651) 266-8710. Sincerely, � � �.zc�.C�� � cL�'.-vv� Virginia � Palxner Assistant City Attorney cc: Robert Kessler, Director of LIEP Christine Rozek, Deputy Director of LIEP Christopher Dart, Community Organizer, Lexington-Hamline Community Council, 1160 Selby Ave., St. Paul, MN 55104 OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY C[aytan M Robinson, Jc, Ciry Attorney CITY OF SAINT PAUL Norm Colemarz, Mayor civit Division 400 Ciry Ha[I I S West Kellogg Blvd. Saini Pau[, hlinnesota 55l02 Q� ���d0 Telephone: 65! 266-8710 Fncsimile: 651298-5619 October 30, 2000 NOTICE OF COUNCIL HEARING Owner/Manager Applebee's Neighborhood Grill & Baz 1600 University Avenue West Saint Paul, MN 55104 '�,'(, ��S23rC� v@:^.d2t �d� �� .`_ �QQ� RE: Cigarette/Tobacco License held by Apple American Limited Partnership of MN d/b/a , Applebee's Neighborhood Grill & Baz for the premises at 1600 University Avenue West — in St. Paul License ID #: 0017244 Deaz Sir/Madam: Please take notice that a hearing concerning the above-named establishment has been scheduled for 5:30 p.m., Wednesday, November 15, 2000 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse. Enclosed aze copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested hearing in that the facts contained in the report concerning the unlawful sale of cigarettes have not been disputed. You will have an opportunity at the Council hearing to present oral and/or written remarks as to the penalty, if any, to be imposed. The recommendation of the license office will be for a$200.00 fine. If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710. Very truly yours, (/ U�-� �� V'o---(''�^-r� U Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP Christine Rozek, LIEP Christopher Dart, Community Organizer, Lexington-Hamline Community Council, 1160 Selby Ave., St. Paul, MN 55104 po_ ��ec STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF RAMSEY ) AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says that on October 3, 2000, she served the attached NOTICE OF VIOLATION on the following named person by placing a true �nd correct copy thereo£ in an envelope addressed as follows: Owner/Manager Applebee's Neighborhood Grill & Bar 1600 University Avenue West St. Paul, MN. 55104 (which is the last known address of said person) and depositing the same, with postage prepaid, in the UnitecLBtat�s mails at St. Paul, Minnesota. / \ �. Subscribed and sworn to before me this 3rd day of �Octob�r, 2000. Notary PETER P PANGBORN NOTARY PUBL7C - MINNESOTA MY CppAp�lSSiON EXPIRES JAk_ 31, 2005 � p _ ��oo j i �Q � Ix � W � o y (°� rn c V � OJ J � 0. N O C d � C O • R � L YY� C d N C d V J N I� N > V U ..J Q N N U_ y F E N N c Q IU N y IJ I LL o � o � N ��I i � I' � i Z� I N I� U r :j I O , !o v � V W a � � � N W � Z � = V a O O � � .-- � � m 2 � W Z N � W Z W m 00 a �a Q F � � Z U d � i� W Z Q �� ma I la i ¢ �U C � 0 U � 0 � N � d X W NI C I CI � Z U O a V cl m� LJ C m1 �j �, z; c aj �I O I c' I�I � h: c � � � � � Z N C r o ,� L ^ a o , N N h � m � C �v1 N m � p I� i~ � I o l � � I a � (A � � ; w I V � a � �¢ � C � � � N d � ' U L � p 7 N� � C � � �LL @ Y � � - pm i �� C jt U� N� m am inii v° ��"-�da .�eC �' � `m rnLL �... oQ � � ac- Qa"i� Q c a ym QU �y mQ a�rn- t� � G C 6 � m � > N � U V .� � j�U3 JO_ �¢ LQ _IWrnlLC� cda �o. ' da�m m >m � �� om �c' a�i E °� .c�'o m ��y �� ��i;� U(0 fA O � C�� !n y �J = LLl y(O�QM � Q O i V N N• O � C �Y 'O N� �� N N �� y W C L p �� W(p� N NE� � L���7 co�U vy �� rn�a ��`c' y c E c �mJ rn3 ° c' ma>p N C 0 C(0 � i U L ry1 G � y NV� O � �m� N L �"O-�UC��C ` mma�n�p�� ��m Um ����omUr � >tn� .yma�� rnc� ° om�SEmo�fl� Q' �Y NL" U" N 0 0_ . N C❑ U N C N p� G.J m N �a>o� �d�Q o'mm�otm�rn�wH r c� rno�o��c�mor�ma�i� i-��VU � o.� o md °'O � c�- ��2cn �6U•� c°'� o,' OOi ONO O �L � CH� dm� 0o m o �o'�oUdrn d a � '� ��n �' E E EY oom�o�o>'c°\�rnrn°� �r�� � p � �a�� NN���._NR f �l� O� N m N �'(j� O Va' � N� �Or' �� N. O on0"�O PnN� p.� N N � ood�oc�io>0000�a�o°rna¢ �¢°a¢�UaO� � � w 0 N N m R a � 0 a d � c 0 .� E L � W � � � � d d N y d � U � J — � � U� J N nr m o J ' ' Y r U N m V N �N Xk U a� �o .� U V m Q Q V p N'6 N UOr�i1 O J U � � � mQ �U� ��r 3 m"� J l[) p Oo _ I lua n oi Q �, x � W o No � �o m V N R J c� O. i+ O � O C � C O .� � � O ... c d w c m a J N 7 N � C N N � C ZT U C J � 0 w c y � o_ „ � E N � �a � � U � @ Q O ` O N � o E� � � IZ V r J p � R V W � Q � � � N N� Z � � � a O O � � � � � Q m 2 C� w Z � �w Z W m ma �° a Q F � J Q I � U � �w �Z Q I � J Ia Q .� � � 0 U � � M � N N � d X ll.� h C � � � � Z U 0 a m U C m 5 �u �� !�I IZ I TI �I m ��I �a� UI I�I � �i (� � � E � Z N �n o ,� L r a a , y N N � � � c 7 � r m � n o �� �F � i � �O w 6 F k C ', � � � c a m - N � � '�. � U L— p 3 U w .c "a �n w . � o Q � Y � m � U � m M `� u. � � `N� o� c y �� �# a`� � �.J o � o c � � a mo.cu� � U � p • y � m a m �ii vLL H o`�-!a Q� y Q a�i � o- c�i °- d m a U � ai d� a> rn-� d Q w� � t� � c c a� rn m� > �a o m �a c'�i 3 �'�a_ �,Q �O '���rnu o c ° cv ° a�i E ° .c�io m o �� �c��y?� � m� fn � ° c�� � y �J �2 w ycn�Qo'� 3 da d NNO_C �C� WC L1' 'OTiNWfO�N �O� � O r"470� �OJ N N �H C� ��Z "�60"o C U � N V C n dp �N � i UrtD��Jy m @ V i 0 (6 � �Z � t6J 16-O-�UCy{6C—(0 O�� i6fnd� � p N U � O� (� N aC ��� @CJ t�i1 O f6 � o'� �m0 . N�m rn� ��� o y .y� ��� o m�� Qv @YNLw7U� rna� �p �j�ca`�og��d N N� � V m UN l6"6 N N � - y � N m� i N� U=� CN(Al6miNN I�Qa' NECEyNN_CNtp�"O o mmK o.c m rn ui c aiO m o� � c- m rn� � m u i-tL�QU�a� ��nm a� v � �� m��ma��>� V o � a �o � �tL. c � o o �c�i m .cQ ��d��m �dm EY 00 ��o coi'oo�mrn �a �V E-'�d °?�n � E� E� d� NN— C l6N O . N O N � Wh���O_�d<c��O��i�0�t6 WN�p�j`V(`�1)L�tOILUCN NN N�c-N��ZW��O C_O N pNd_m— N N �6)NN�O(hUN�W �NLNC�N�O�.=CypN d� (4Ey N oOacs�pUO>o000�ar�Orrnn.Q �Q�O_Q�UQO� �_�\aa � � w 0 v m m n a � 0 a m � c 0 :. m E � � ° � c _ � m m N N V 'J J � 6� � U� J N Q @ O J ' i Y n V N �U N �N Xk U � � _ N LL �- y O . V � � 0 Q �V O � � N U O N O J U � C ' QJ Q � U rn rn ��� 3tO� m�� JtqO �� _��oa � Ip Q iO w O h I� y U � R '� M a N � 0 a � c O i=� N � O w c m N C V J N 3 � � a��i > J Q h a� Q y F E a� `m C Q U � N J �p LL � R V W � Q � � � I W a? � Z ��v I u� � d' O m _ � W Z N y � W � W Z m '°� a ° a Q IU c � U �� N N 0 a w N c � E 3 Z U 0 a U C m � N C d � � 3 Z N c ^ o � L r a a, y N N d d� C �m N 7 � m � N � E y � � TI I N � Z � (m ' Q ° � U EI I N.fl Im� o � m ° � I@�w UI i ' W z z � �v� 0 � C �O W �' �X � i.. dr � � �� 0.� o jma w �,F-m � J O a a � p j � O Q �-- U a C .� � a . � � ' U L O 3 U � L � � N .-. V O Q �- Y� l6 �"� U J l6M ln� N C � Y � v `- rn c �t m � � Y �° cx d d coin vL a� @�° U� � U C� a� tn LL � LL F- Q"� 6' na y o a�- Q a�i� °- c�i °- �`m aU � y a�� a� rn-�aa� � Utrn � c c �.c 3 6 � rna m� > a� co o m� G1� �O (6 j� Ua J d N VO UJ�p)LL C C OU� C �' � NQ >� � N� �t�? m .0 U � '�Cn`+ ��� N $ � c m� � m �� �S ul Nco�Qr� 3 �.O ` p� NN—O �C� 4l.IC L �� NE� L � E 7 CO�U "6y �O Wj.�"6� Z L��n °� o °' o � � 3 rnt- c o a� �� I jU y V �" V O r � � C f6Np�JM`y 'O t0 i��C � �J �� ��LN R fAp� m c° ° lqtnmc' s ��� .cm ��Q o�a ���a� o m� �o� Um c�°OmUv�om �r.�� �Cn� .N�.(UL M�� 0"G fl-m�G CO3�� Q"6 �.Y NLw 3U m�-� CO �N C GJD�CJd N d� �c� m c>m%v d c� fl-� � U � m rn� � m�Q Hti�QU�a.� a��� ��c�i���mV � Wa�i�o� � �LL._LLSln °o°oa�U�c�i°om°oUa� �rQ m�m��y��dm��EY NN��N�NONW�� U M� V aon� o_�a�co�n�o °°��m�°� ��°� y ochp, a���i � c`m o Q '6 tn � fl. ��(ONV O(`7UNW�CN d�(6ENN OOdERO UO�000��--dhO�-maQ<�Q'-4Q�C„)QQJ Do-�\oa � r w 0 � m � R a r 0 a d � c 0 « R � � � w � C � � d � y y C � V '_' J � � � V� J N a� �o �� i Y h � � U N Xk U � c _ N � O . U � � � Q �V p N 'O N U O m o�U� � 'rna �CU� ��� ��� 3 m"r J�nO I� �� i m i0 � � W r 0 N O n � I N U R � M d N � O C. � c 0 w m E O w c m N L v J y 3 @ � d a��i > :� Q N d a t�' E IN N N a d U y � � LL a N V li! � Q �� � v� liJ N� Z '��v a0 m� K O m 2 � W Z d� m Z � m ma ° a Q .� 7 O U N� 0 � N N � di X W h c � a � 3 Z U a U C m � � c ` � � � Z N c r o � � r a a , N N N � Ic � !�vi N m � N� v � H � � � I � c W � T vi Q C � m I O Q O.I I o ,d V i N�.cz n� o I I, � o '� I � W � �I I W � Z Q I I ��I I m y�� C `I � W i ' �� N O J I i I � j J '� i°v"� I�m�Ia ��'n� ''F- � 0.� o L.� Q U o �'�Q � � i �, i ;'� i; DO-1�o 0 T c � m � . � � '� � U � - O � C.),�N t 'o N .. V O Q � Y i (6 Y U J N M � W C .0 °>LL � � Y �O c� a a� min o= d�°- c�� • � m a m r'n�i vLLL°, i s - o n °� N �c Q m Q �� QU �y p �s`mQoy U�� c c��3 °�� rn�' m� » U� O (6 j� Uc J Q �a LQ " J�m C C N� a a U U ��LL O � °c� a�i E o,,;�'� my �u �� �o�;�v U t0 N O � C@� � N `�J S W y(O,�QC'') 2� � ,r U NN�.G �CC W C L' ' yW (6�N v L w�E� coOV a�°, �o o��a-o� Z °'$'n °—' c E''c r3.J o�3 c ( � U� O m (6 y �� �?� (6J (0- OJU C y` f0 C y t�6 oWa ���a��OOdc tf�o@ Um �c���c OOj �CA� . �C� �N p'NJ�� N�1 _ (� '616�rt6.��U ��..J CQ V NC ND� O_ (n mQ o'iomKo�m�rnrnoiy �c� a�o�o��c��rn��a HLL�QU�a� cfnm mp ��-�ti2cA� 'U � O Nd !!I C �U'� C�� O 00� OUON�Ud LQ �=N CN �d@ �Y oo��oco?`omwrn � ��j�-�'y����`�, Ecm� �I+� O_d'�-�COIl��t� O� (6 O�i C yp��i � UMa � U � N ��NNV O('7UNW�CNtNCpNLdNCNON d� (OEN N OOdERO UO�OOOO�df�O��dQ��Q�d. Q�UQOJ �pfl_ ��oo � T W Q � d � R a r 0 a m � c 0 « m £ L � W � C � � d � y N V � J � � � V �\- J N Q � O J ' � y � � � � N V Xk U V � !1 Q y O - U � � O Q V O �� N CJ Ot�ii o�U� `- 'rna �Urn � � ��� 3 m�'� JlnO t�o-\�pO � � �W I � O h o m �o d V N a J M n 0 � 0 a � C O i7 16 � L 0 W N c u J � �� d U � J Q U � U T � t- � N � N �I� VIN ;J Im 'i_ (U � �� o � N �I O I I � I � �I Z i ��m'v C �N I I J V I U O � N v w 4 r � �, w a? z a�� a O O � � � � 1.1� W 2 � W Z E � m W Z W m W p a Q r � J Q U � � � W Z Q i m a d Q . I� C I �I U U .� N o� � � ❑ a x w N � � � E � Z U O a U G m 3 N C I i I I Z � a c m n I�i i I d �mj i� N C � a E � ,Z � C � o ,� r a IN N N ^ m � � ❑ � �x � F � � O . w �.� C� �� r .� � C � � � . � � 'i � U �- o � U ;o s 'a tn.. V O Q � yi N Y U J NM L �LL. C L LL � � � � Y �� � ik N <o in c� 3 U� .y � m d� !4 LL 7 LL �- ¢-� ° o-a tn � �� Q � a �� Q U � N O �� Y d Q o� 0 J L m ULrn � ��s 3 �- rnQ m� > a �`o ic � c aUi� o m �a �- J Q °J �� •����'�' o 3 � -O O y E °' .�� m 'c� �� ����y?� � m� w � ° � R� tn y �� � W�°co�Qc� 3 �o.o � yv rn�� Wc ro �3Nwm ��u� � t ,���� co - o,°� �o o��a O O J F' i j V� y U � UO �`� � � Ly��JMp) N C � (0 � � U C i y �c�c0 � fn�NC��c �?C .c� ��JU����D�c o�� �iotna��o�y �i°m Um �c 03 ��O .m��� rnc� °d o � Q �Y�L� S��.a rn°-- �!] U� c a� o� �� a�Q U�o o��ai�mm-oa� NQ� a�E�E�dm� `my�a 0f6 ~ C mQ(60� V C—�p�� N U F��VU � o_� o ma d0 � �w.�ii2tn�U � c�� o� 00 o�o �rQ m-m cw �a�m� EY oo��0�02�oo�mrn �d �UE�'m��n�E�Eca» NN—�� (ON ONO)m� ' M� V QN rn (60�LQ O �d' � �I�� Q7aa-cD�fJ�h O� f0 QJ � N� � Uc`�� N�IL C N NN j�� � V��N � O Q�"O mN n �_ N N OOd�OUO�pOO� �a�o°rna¢°r�¢°a¢ �UQ�J p _ ��o a � � w 0 0 � m m � a L � W � C � � d d y N C �. d d V � �.1 — m m U� J N d� � O _1 � � y r V a-- d � L N V 7k U � � i— LL a ao � U � a � O a V o ma N V O t�n o: � rna �Urn rn ��� �rnv 3`°� m�n JtnO � � l a i � :w O �N� � C O � �o q U R J M d � r 0 � O Q � C O i=� A � O w C m W d V .J l I� I � N U � J Q c N N `o C N �+ T m iN � N � j N N iU � � O "I N �� I o , i��N � r J O � � v w > ¢ IN � � Z � = C Q 0 O �� � K � m 2 C7 W Z � � �W � W Z m ma � a Q H � J Z Q �I U j� �w IZ Q �IJ I L a _�la IUI C 3 O U � N � � � I d m � Q W N C � � 7 Z U a U C c � C �I I Wq IZ , ICI �Q', '�i IU j ��'' ci I �I I =� y, U i� � � Z N c r o � t � a �, N N N ��I� I �i� I m � � F I � i� �O �� �N 3 !c w I y! � m' Q , � � � I W � W m j W I a � d _ n I� ,� _�`eo � c .n m a .� � � ' U L 3 O 3 U m .c "a � � N.-. V O Q � i� @ Y � � �� i O]LL C �L U� -y L m a a� c�ti �LL F �Q�a a u�i � � a �_ � c Q d o_ � E QU � y Q �Y NQL � c6 V�� o����3 JQ rnQ L� >d�co`om� C N� �p_ �d - 0. > N U� U i��++0 f °- cv ° a�i E o..:�� my ��� �� �o^�y�� U(6 f0 O r-. C f6 � � m `� J � S W N CO � Q(`'I 3 �oQO � U Nmp.0 rnC� Wc L� �3inWm�N ���n m s °,�'� E 7 �� U a,°� �F a>��a y\? j V � (n U � V � �NJ �3 � NNpO> � i� C � C(0 - i ULt� C� @U� O @ (6 y (6J R y(OC (�0 o�� ���d��omcYi tn`o� Vy �c�°�mUNO� „O j �7,fn� .N ��L �C� O d O C � l�6w Q v= m �a c� Uyc U �� �a�i ai 2 mrn � a� y �Q� `m E � E� � m � d�� F-IL�QC� UO.C��Nf6 N�'O (6 0Up m V ���� CR ; U 00 - Vo moYO ° � 0 d �n0 � c�- -�2cn�U•c c�� o-� oom o�omoUa LQ �°=d�ch ya�m Es NN m�N NN ON��� V M � 7�Qtn y(6�LQ� O V� NN j� �� N��N��Z���p C �p ��N ��LL N N� �� VNm�CNLNC�NLQNCNONQ�(OE NN OOdfHO UO�OOOOrn.I�O�--�dQc�-�Q�dQ�(,�QOJ 00- �loo � � w 0 N � d m 10 a r 0 a m � c 0 :: R E � � ° � c _ _ m d w N d d c> � J — � � U� J N Q � O J ' i Y � � � L N V �k U a � �O � U a �rn O a V O ,� � N U Ovl O J (,.) � "'rna �Urn `�rn �rnv 3 � m�r� J�O �j ��; 'O i � IW o ' a� r . T I � �O d Ip N R I J I� IM a _io � O a � C O .� � L Q W C d N c d e� J h � i� I � d I� � I V �V J a T N a � � � m m a � � � c ;_ � I� o U _I O' � 0 o �! N �' O Z I y i� V I� J � N v w ¢ � i� Nw N� Z a�� a O O �� I.L � m 2 C� w Z � � @ W Z W ,m Im I� I�'a `i Q H � J Z �U �� ���W z ;Q I �IJ �a �a �IQ I Uj C', �O U! U L N � l I� ;�' o) a� y�0 � o — N O � �O LI � � 7 I Z U a io �� N I c;� � N C �l -,� N I Z ' 7 � T F" c � IQ,� i�:� �a z U .Q V'� �C � im,W IC � LI� � 4 � ZI N' o � L � a;� N N N � N � � m N � ; m � � � F � rn � O �� IN; � N I iNi � I m I Q i �� W ' m W ��Q To �- ; i; a� - ��o 0 � C Q � � 'y � d '- U L � p 3 U c,�o o " � � �C � l0 y U J l6 M p� U- C L �� � � Y �� �� d a� coin �r m�Q� �� �N U � dm �� �� � �J ��a � � a ��� QU °�YdQo� U�� � � ��t3 s� �`� �O ?m cda o m >a�= �Q d VO �UJ�WLLOC N N N ° -� -° o a�i E o�:�'� m� ��� �� �o^�oi�� � M U "'-C�c� �(/� � �= LLIyCO�QM�? � < � o � y'a L � C c W c .c Y � 3 N W c¢ � a� ��in m r w�E� o�c �y � m���o�^? d U� O O� 1�3J �3 �~ �N ��JM "�00'O C V �� �� C(0 iV =N���y� �U(0 � fnNN � LN �N C p�� �CAn.Nyp�� ��c U�n ac@�OmUyom Qa � wtn� .w@�� ��� o�� o.�����o��� Q"O �Y NL U'6 � din C � U�� N O� CJ N H U ����NyNm�NN �a� �ocE�a��imLL�d� F� �p� ct+ �ii=��Cj°�� 00 N O UO (ODUd LQ m= N�- C N � N�� NN � CN �N ON��� V M � d' (6 � �Q� O NN��� O_V ��cO���Z���� C N� p� pMd d�LL �� �o� �� ���N n � rn° o a�v mN .. n- �O) ( ONV' OM.-N�W C CpNL O.� C NO N i].� (6 ooau>o c�o>0000�-a�.O�a�a¢.-�¢�a¢.-U N U OJ � � C N ai 3 � J bo-l4o0 � � w 0 v T d � � a r 0 a m � c 0 Y R � L �'^ W v/ � C Q� Q� N N d d l�t � J � � U� J N Q � O J ' � y n � � L N 6'1 �N � U � C _ [6 Li °- �o . U a rn O a V O �'a N U O N o�U� � o� a �Urn , � ��� 3'� � m r' r JlnO r; '; �'i � ; � p� —t\cv � �� '�i '`�I 0 � iXi < W I p iy � C O � � N d V � (�p J M a ' o � 0 Q � C O R � � w C N c m u J � � m I� N y U � J Q N O O N > O N N �� F, � c I� � iU � � J O' J O `� O ,y� N .Q I ° � Zi y �� Ul JO VJ � v w ¢ � i IN!w �Z � � � a O O � � � � m 2 C7 ua Z � @w Z W m ma ��I Q F-� � J Q l � ', U i�;� �z a �'J ��N:d �� Q r—, IC i� i �C> . �� N� �� � I � o� a w 0 �'N i� �� � N � 3I Z: r V' OiN n' !M U � � N � V �o � '� � I m � J l� Z� �I� � @ � ' O � U Z i Q iU � i t W I� � �J � I Z I N C r t lA a;� N �p i� m �v1 ; N im'� � O� � F�- I � I� �O I C�� W . i � Im i Q � i � i m � �Q � i � I C � @ � N d � I .0 � O 3 I �` _ � � � ='-- � o Q � � i L � U V -� �M i m� C Y d�- rn u Y �� �# d � � o Y'�° y � � a �' v�u; � F' � - O .- � � L �o � � K�� oa � fl- c ¢ nin O�m'xa�Qo` L d �,� ( � C C �L �i �� � N f�6'� > NJ(p p@ N i tJ O (6 �' U J O. �Q LQ ' J�p�LL C C ;o�a a�i E oa�v m� �� �� �o��y?g 2 W �� no N �� d m``� `h� �n �� m y�°�¢� 3 � °: �wa rnc� wc ro �3Nwm�a� ��u> d t w�E co�� - oy F"o a��.QV�=? >�� �n U E Uo r' °'3 c' mdpa��c+� "00"6 C � C Q CN i ULN C � y� �, O�� (6lndln�pNU fnON U,��n �C�w�l6Uu�i OQj �fn� . �C� �N p�y� CE f00��� , Q.6S N y _�Lw7U. 0 ��-y �O U� CNO�CJd y U �� �NrA(17��NN f� ��CE�N�IO omm�osm c� o�o�o��c@mo��@a�� � I-��¢�U � o_ o� �p � cLL.`iixcn�U `cp�'o� o o �.cQ ��m�cw da�m Es 'NN��NR�NONO�]6�]� V ch� � �I��p� O_�n'�(Otn�� OW (6� W C ym � U�a y�LL V C N ' �� OMUNO)� ypN Q�(6E NN j OOREAO UO�OOOO�d1�O.--�dQ��Q�a.Qc-(.,)QOJ ao - � �ov � � w 0 � � d m R a � � ° � c _ � d � y N � L d � V � J � � U � J N fl-O J � � y r U N � U N N N # U � � �O � U � � � O Q f> O � � N UOVI o�U� � o�a �U� ��� 3 �n . m�r= J�O OfFiCE OF LtCEvSE, INSPECTiONS AND 8JV1ROTl11EtiTAL PROTEGTION Robert Kess(v, Dirrlur CITY O� SAINT PALTL. Norm Coleman. dlayor LOiYRY PftOF'cSSIO;VdL BU1LDlNG Suite 300 350 St Peter Svea Saint PauC Minnesam i5102-lSIO roaacco co��vcE c�cx Fox:« -�x zoao '� O � \�O'Q Telephonc 611-2fi6-9p9p Facsiadlc 6/Z16E-9099 6I2-266-91?; c.rr. DATE: Z b TL�: �-! � n 1 LICE�ISE I.D. �O�iX�L�i —� <JbEL�� .c -lj c lYAitiLE. OF CD�iPLIA1vCE CXECKER �' J v � �� °( ! NAMEOF ADULT SUPERVISOR P- �[%_�,./ NAi�lE & ADDRESS OF LICENSED VENDOR:_ APPLEBEE'S NEIGHBORHOOD GRILL 1600 UNIVERSITYAVE W —ST PAUL, MN 55104-3898 D� License Type: license # TYPE OF ESTABLtSF�YtEi t'�l'��- Cigarettelfobacco 00172as WAS THE TOHACCO: SELF-SERVE?_ WHE:tE `.�'AS THE MP,CHII�E LOCATED? DOES THE E� SALE WAS M �VAS AN I.D. ASSISTED?� NP.i�tE OF CLERK: ��E'1�,_L�y�r� �9�LC/� ��/J'�� � CLERK'S HOME ADDRESS // s DESCRIPTION OF CLERK � /� �� �GX��• i�2 ��� , DRIVER'S LICENSE �/ OTHER I.D. � E OF I� I.D. � S' ����1� ��� �( � AMOUNT SPENT ON PURCHASE.� , IF A SALE WAS i�IOT MADE: REASON (CFiECSC ONE) . ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑ i� i.D. wns c�cx� Z} BUSINESS CLOSED 3) OUT OF BUSL`IESS 4) UNSATISFACTORY CONDI'I'IONS —�,Q,� ���/ -dti�n YfACHINE7— License Group Comments Text Licensee: pppLE AMERICAN LIMITED PARTNERSHIP OF MN �BA= APPLEBEE'S NEIGHBORHOOD GRILI & BAR license #: 0017244 09/28/2000 OQ ���0'� 09�28/2000 To CAO for adverse acBon. CAR 09/27/2000 Faiied tobacw compiiance check. Clerk is Christian Paul Siater, 1650 Hubbard, 55104, dob 9/14f/6. First failure, $200 fine. CAR 04/11/2000 Congratulations tetter sent for passing aicohol compliance eheck. SS 03/14/2000 passed DPS alcohol compliance check eonducted by Yce Poyak/Wachal. SS 02/t �/2000 � 998 faise alarm fees forgiven per BK CAR 09/16/98 Congretulations lettersent. PJW 08/25l98 Passed cigarette compliance check. PJW ' On t/7/99 Passed check; no "unofficial" waming-DL �2707 . Ph Notice Set 7/29/93 Sent 716/93 7/29/93 Ph On Appn For New On Sale Liq-A, Sunday On Sale, And Restaurant-D License App'D C.F. #93- 1098 9l20l94 Manager Info Changed EfEecive 9l7194 Per Phone Call From Denise Lawson-Legal Asst For Apple American , 1/20/95 Ltr From Corp Stating That Michael Understein Has Resigned — Took Him Off Of The Associates Screen—Lap-Lic 10-23-95—Manager Info Changed Effedive 70-16-95 Per Phone Call From Denise Lawson - Legal Asst For Apple American—Manager pob Is 6-7-59—Lk—Lic 1-4-96—Manager info Changed Eff 111196 Per Phone CaII From Denise Lawson - Legal Asst For Appie American—Manager pob Is 3/17/63—Jonathon Paul Olsen Removed As Manager—New Manager Is John M. Lawler—Lk—Lic 5/15/97 Cig Code Added Fdld #82917—Lap-Lic 07P14/99 passed cig compliance check - 07/27/99 Ietter sent SS 00 - �.00 Address �nsee �ad License Cartlhdder - - -- -- - - -- - — Licensee Neme: DBA PPLE SalesTaxltl: r—v _. __..__�..___._.�.w._. 15160 BJC Sale a � Canceled 314198 Closed due to Canceled 314f98 Closed dueto Canceled 3lC58 Closed due W 03l31t1998' 03f3'171998' R001`160Q � l2001 �160a � License Prirrted oo-boo Lice ; License ' Licensee � Lia Types � Property C� Licensee C: UnoHiciel StreEt #: 60 � Street Name: .1NIVERSITY StreetType: AVE pirediorc �! Und Ind � �Uryt #: � Cdy: T PAUL State: �i1 �' Zip: � Ward: � Dist Coundl: Ir3 — Licensee: DBA: Saies Tax Id: 'slse Alarms # Bus Licensee PPLE AMERICAN LIMITED PRRTNERSHIP OF DBA PPLEBff'S NEIGH80RHOOD GRILL 8 BAR l Insurance � Bontl , Requiremerrts � Projeet Facil3ator. ASUNCION, COPoNI� Adverse Action Comments J � i License Group Comments: 55t04 �82000 To CAO for adverse adion. CAR -- 7R000 Failed tobacco compliance check. Clerk is hristian Paul 51ffier,1650 Hummard, 55104, dob f14176. Fast failure, $200 fine. CAR04I112000 onqrffiulations letter serit for passinq a�ohol 2TNERSHIP Of Licensee r.a�n i u AnR� CommeMs: ��—.~.— € O7l01 f2000 12l31 f1000 N $0.00` Save Changes to Ffistory Canceled . 998;3651 99fr3651 �998:�3651'�': nw..o-vn :;�. A01 �160Q -, DD1i160�=:; � .— ,,. '001+1600 :=`- ._._� 998i1600 � �'��" � PE+�;�; 00 _���0 License ____ Licensee Licensee Name: PLE DBA: PLEi Sales Tax Itl: 0895f AA CoMrad Rec'd OiDOR AA Fee Coileded: Oi00tt Licersee PLE AMEftICAN LIMITm PARTNERSHIP OF DBA PPLEBff`S NEIGHBORHOOD GRf�L 8 BAR ___..__. . __ ._ ___ -----` --- - -----�--------- Lic. Types _ Ins�rance � Bond I RequiremeMS' Non-Profit [' Worker's Comp: iD0J0000 � AA Training Rec'd ONOA000 Discourd Rec'd r � � �n�i��" Other A enc Licenses Financial Hold Reasons r �,!�C�� C`� ',�� ������ �i4!w!� BackgroundCheckRequired � fli5i �License# 7244 , _._,.�____ 82917 9 ;APPLE AMEWCAAAPPLEB�'S Changes to History Mail License To: C•: Ms� To Corhact �-9757= {'; ��nse Address �-A000 , , ..�� _- � - (, � MaA Invoice To: � � � �� �'� Ma� To CoMad 99 �65 �`" � t`-+ License Address 99&`�651'= k . :? 998 �_ 001 160Q 001.'1604 _ . . ,,.„,. . ,,.,_� 001?1600 Canceled - __ ---- _ --------- -