The URL can be used to link to this page

85-1731 WHITE — CITV CLERK PINK e� FINANCE COUtlC1I �'j E"ANARV —DEPARTMENT GITY OF SAINT PAUL File NO.-.- "�— /�c// BLUE — M-qYOR - w , . : rdin�nce Ordinance N 0. �� Presented By � Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date An Ordinance amending Chapter 60 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code pertaining to zoning for the City of Saint Paul and the zoning maps thereof. WHEREAS, Pursuant to Minnesota Statutes, § 462.357 and § 64.210 of the Legislative Code, Bernard Mersch duly petitioned to rezone Lot 6, Block 1, Davern's Rearrangement located at 1210 Randolph Avenue from B-2 to RM-2 for the purpose of converting two basement offices into two residential apartments the petition having been certified by the Planning Division on October 15, 1985, as having been consented to by at least 67% of the owners of the area of the property to be rezoned, and further having been consented to by at least two- thirds of the owners of the property situated within 100 feet of the total contiguous property within one year preceding the date of the petition; and WHEREAS, The Zoning Committee on November 7, 1985, conducted a public hearing for the purpose of considering the rezoning petition, and pursuant to Section 107.03 of the Administrative Code, submitted its recorrr�nnendation to the Planning Commission that the petition be granted; and WHEREAS, The Planning Commission considered the rezoning petition at its meeting held on November 8, 1985, and recommended that the City Council approve the petition; and WHEREAS, Notice of a public hearing before the City Council on the said rezoning petition was duly published in the official newspaper of the City on November 16, 1985, and notices were duly mailed to each owner of affected property and property situated wholly or partly within 350 feet of the property sought to be rezoned; and (continued) COUNCILMEN Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays Fletcher Drew �Il F'BVOf Masanz Nicosla B scne�be� Against Y Tedesco W ilson Adopted by Council: Date Form Appr e by City Attorney Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY By Approved by Mayor: Date Approve by ayor for Submission to Council By By WMITE - CITV CLERK 1 PINK - FINANCE COl1I1C11 {.ANARV-DEPARTMENT GITY OF SAINT PAUL File NO. �� /��/ BLVE -MAVOR � • Ordindnce Ordinance N 0. �7�°?� Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date WHEREAS, A public hearing before the City Council , having been conducted on December 5, 1985, where all interested persons were heard, and the Council having considered all the facts and recorr�nendations concerning the petition; now, therefore, THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: Section 1. That the zoning map of the City of Saint Paul , Sheet No. 27, as incorporated by reference in Section 60.301 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, as amended, is hereby further amended as follows: That property located on the south side of Randolph Avenue between Edgecumbe and Griggs (1210 Randolph Avenue) being more particularly described as Lot 6, Block 1, Danvern's Rearrangement be and is hereby rezoned from B-2 to RM-2. Section 2. This ordinance shall take effect and be in force thirty (30) days from and after its passage, approval and publication. COUNCILMFN Requested by Department of: Yeas _�:� Nays � Planning and Economic Development �raW In Favor -�asaoz �QETT�� /�� /�� NiCOSIa B - -�i��!!�I�"� �� scne�be� Against Y - , Tedesco YIIdIwR Adopted by Council: Date JAN 1 � 1986 Form Appro d by City torne Certified Pas ouncil Se tary BY 13y Approv y y r: Date 2 � �g�6 Approved Mayor for Submission to Gouncil By By I PpBIISNED !��+ `� � 1986 . � , � . � . �,��=- ��3� ,��``tTT �";, � CITY OF SAINT P UL � ��u � DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT + °° �� DIVISION OF PLANNING o � .ss• 25 West Fourth Street,Saint Paul,Minnesota,55102 GEORCE LATIMER 6�2-292��5�� MAYOR December 17, 1985 Albert B. Olson, City Clerk Room 386 City Hall St. Paul , Minnesota 55102 Dear Sir: Attached per your letter of request dated December 5, 1985, is the proper ordinance for the implementation of the City Council action approving the petition of Bernard Mersch to rezone property at 1210 Randolph Avenue at the southside of Randolph between Edgecumbe and Griggs from B-2 to RP+I-2 for the purpose of converting basement offices into apartments. Please contact me if our office can be of further assistance regarding this matter. Sincerely, �IMKn'��I� -- � D Donna Uatsko Planner II Zoning Section DD:ss Attachment cc: Zoniny File #9798 � = ��-- ��-- ��3 � � � o� � 0 � � STATE OF MINNESOTA ) County of Ramsey ) ss. CITY UF SAINT PAUL ) j� . . . , . . . . Albert, B:. O1son. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .City Clerk oF the City of Saint Paul, tiinnesota, do hereby certify thar I have co:npared the attached copy of Council File Vo. ,85�1731. . _ . . . . , . _ , as adopted by the City Council. . . , , , , ,January.l6:. _ + . . . 1g.86. . . and approved by the Mayor. . . . . . . . .. .. . January.21: . . , . . . , . 19.86. . . with the original thereof on file in my off ice. I further certify that said. copy is a true and currect copy of said original and the whole thereof. WITNESS my tiand and the seal of the City of Saint Paul, Minnesota this , , , Sth . � . . _ . , day of „ February. ,. _ . ,A.D. 1�86. . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . .�. . . .��t� . . . . . . .. City Clerk, .�:. � , i r n'�.�s � i Y'c�F`��:f �r�fi ay,y` y ` . 4yA. �, T� j y,R M1 , _ t �.. i,:. :�� '� �' . y., ,��.� � �� 'v,''t, } ,, �� +�' `t s � � P -F^ . P�,i(�� r ra 9i � .�:��r)F� ._ ,.... . �. . � .°+ � : �e , t,tQY ' ��: .. �. '"'`d � - •- - . . . _ . ..� �?4.i''��(] t�:'+J.:A:.x ti._��L,��,Lih�' !i�a l.t�.l '�. � n��v�3 . . . . J � I P�NK .. FINANCE GITY OF SAINT PAUL Council �`ANARV –DEPARTMHNT . 7 BIUE –MAVOR - Fll@ NO. �— // c�/ � . � ~ ' rdin�nce ��3.�.� �' Ordinance N�. � s Presented By n � Referred To � ' Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date 1 � An Ordinance amending Chapter 60 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code pertaining to zoning for the City p of Saint Paul and the zoning maps thereof. __ �� WHEREAS, Pursuant to Minnesota ,Statutes, § 462.357 and § 64.2I0 of the Legislative Code, Bernard Mersch duly petitioned to rezone Lot 6, Block 1, Davern's Rearrangement located at 1210 Randolph Avenue from B-2 to RM-2 for the purpose of converting two basement offices into two residential apartments the petition having been certified by the Planning Division on October 15, 1985, as having been consented to by at least 67% of the owners of the area of the property to be rezoned, and further having been consented to by at least two- thirds of the owners of the property situated within 100 feet of the total contiguous property within one year preceding the date of the petition; and WHEREAS, The Zoning Committee on November 7, 1985, conducted a public hearing for the purpose of considering the rezoning petition, and pursuant to Section 107.03 of the Administr�ative Code, submitted its recommendation to the Planning Corrrnission that the petition be granted; and ��HEREAS, The Planning Commission considered the rezoning petition at its meeting held on November 8, 1985, and recommended that the City Council approve . the petitian; and - - .___—. �_ - WHEREAS, Notice of a public hearing befiore the City Council on the said rezoning petition was duly published in the official newspaper of the City on November 16, 1985, and notices were duly mailed to each owner of affected property and property situated wholly or partly within 350 feet of the property sought to be rezoned; and (continued) COUNCILMCN Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays , . Fletcher Drew �II F8V0[ Masanz Nicosis B Schetbsl Against y Tedesco Wii�on Form Appr e by City Attomey Adopted by Council: date Certified Passed by Councit Secretary BY sy Approved by Mayor: Date Approve by ayor for Submission to Council By By � wHITE — clrr cLtJ'frc F�iNK — FINANCE GITY OF SAINT PAUL � Council �,_/�c ..nNAR�— DEPARTMENT File �NO. � �/ ]LUE � —MAVOR v ' � Ordin�nce ordinance N�. �7�� Presented By Referred To , Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date � � WHEREAS, A public hearing before the City Council , having been conducted on _ �, December 5, 1985, where all. interested persons were heard, and the Council `J having considered all the facts and recommendations concerning the petition; � now, therefore, � THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: Section 1. That the zoning map of the City of Saint Paul , Sheet No. 27, as incorporated by reference ir� Section 60.301 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, as amended, ' is hereby further amended as follows: That property located on the south side of Randolph Avenue between Edgecumbe and Griggs (1210 Randolph Avenue) being more particularly described as Lot 6, , Block 1, Danvern's Rearrangement be and is hereby rezoned from B-2 to RM-2. Section 2. _ . _ _ Thi s ordinance shall tak� effect and- be in force thi-r�y �30) days from and _ _. after its passage, approval and publication. COUIdCILMEN Requested by Department of: Yeas �.�� Nays -..r�.e�► Planning and Economic Development p�e,,,, In Favor —Masaoz �ETi H� � ��`� Ntcosia Against BY��' �%�'�� Schelbsl Tedesco VMileen� Adopted by Council: Date JAN 1 s 1985 Form Appro d by City ome Certified Pas ouncil Se tary BY F3y Approv y y r: Date � z � j�ab Approved Mayor for Submission to Council By BY pu�tls�i�� ►v � � 1986 : � � 33 s D O 5 —t Cl (!) , , m � �� «..►w 'i v � A Q � � N h � �. C � T --°� Rf Q �.e. C�i _: N- � � � C� tu ,-�- Q C fTl � ,,. „ � Q � � `--- c ..,- � t7 m_. i:; � �-! �' c� �., �C -n � i, � d "�P C� �, G: �.., �, 4'` O � �- � ..:.. .il � ' � (^ �:ti �� .� z � � � ;�y i; ,r �t�`. f? .,;� � W d� �) n•; _7 ,r, C' � Z � � � - N ,? `` ,`� ;;, m � ^� ~';; r, �' aN�> >.. ;� � � � Q � � �� , R� !, E^ � T �-°! t�� 9..,� �' C) � . c� � � �.i � � r' � ;' g �� D ' ' � �'7 � 1� � .,., � ' � �l � � h�: F •a � ca }.� � °�° �'� � cc�a� � `� "` ' �1 s� !S—"e (f 'V, Li5 � �' � � �� •—� �� `(7 4"�' � :ti� R � O ( f4 � �/'"� [- ,y _.� � d /�� , j � y S� !� . ti:' M f_'. � �. Z7 (") W C'7 (') � a �� o � � � (D � *r� ►� Z � -G -< � �� * i� � o- -� ° � � � � � � � � � � N Sy—1 7� -s v' �.i�,.a r o ! � r "� � D N N N ��p C r o O O O � n � � � � oo c�n oo aD �' �P "C ln I lZ� 1,� c* � II+ vF� i!+ � �' �l W �l �1 � �P W N I�'�+ � ci� � :� :n :C1 xl fD fD fD (D N N N N � � � � � � fD (D (D (D N n "O 'L3 "O "t7 'S O O O O � . . . . �� 1V � J � � � � � rt rr ct rr "C '�C "C "C- \ � �' aawa � � rrrtrrrt m � Nao � � �1 � rnw � � Q ° � � n � � z � C O � O � � � � � m � m c� � . ° ; �' y,. � o c m rt ;° � . , V .�^� W \ \ � � T O�i � � O� O c,� m ro � � ' _ _ � �� s� � _ _ _ _ - , � .. �. �' � - '.�.4' h 3.,s r. hs �y p �w � � i � S , .e.,, ��a }yy, 7 � . � ' �� ` �W4�r� a � � �i �°ys',; l. r ��'f"'+�`l� r �°�Yy � V � }�`�' �� - )' Sa w k,g� � t" / � ` �1 t, t r "' ' ' l' � N � 1 k ��i��My�j t k �'�`f, F � � �� - r �G�,'�; a a b � ' `� 1 e � ` �r 4,r. ,ta �" � s` a i � +; �� i �� w �E y '� '� � f �! 4 z { �> ,,��:� " � a s , �'( � ,r �'. ' '��n �t .Y` t i� .. ' ! �fr F „� ;, i `' ' f � i !� t g c, t � �' `' �',��,�ji �� + � �.,�F � � b}. i r ` ' � y 'j: ! _Att'.T'��,v c � , :c' + � ? y ,, s� r� ..�- ; , ' 1 4 � , � 1� ��'`x rvt7 �i� �- F ] f . ?I � ' { { � �. . .?� , � 1 A A j.f, V � � .. � 1i'f '�.;V, i :�e- ";P� i;,1- - � i r � i' � � � �' �� k � ,- ' a� � ' �{?. `� ) �� fe ! £ t � 5 t � �.� 'F�,',i,� '�1 f } � �� -�� ' �. k A t�-. E� .� � ts t j '}� �:�I d` .�I + ��t ♦�� J ,.f r yi. �J ` _ _ . ." F � u � 7� �X � f �, t J .. + ' .Y i': 3 ! '` � � • � 1 J'R �y,- o^Y �4� ` . ' ? � � 1 } .. �� ,: . ' �. „` t ' ( ,. 3 g ` ,: I �JR�� i�i �` '4 ' }� 'c ..l >h; F '� � � �� ;., ` ',,. , y� � $�`r':��r � �C � � ,;, �'� � y' � ��f ��f� ? .�l�,�� / � L 1�a N H + �' ` `f b+�,�� r �'I` � .t f } � '� t t � �',z �3. `:� } � - r� ; � ,` {.. - � -A i 'L�� rd :R µY .� �i�k�� s�l'r:,�. .� �.�� % � ' 7 '�b � I11 �i�3�$+�,-� � �,�aapa!'1�.�r�i6b��' A� �;�` 1 ..`�+ �,.��ix �� $ k ` ' �: ��"�>i�` ��.�1 �I��:�6��'`�s��• � 4A � °�' ` , , _ ; . t� � � 9 � i. , :� r �< ,�i � ' - � ��.��"f� r,, t s t � `��I'*�!'„"' � C�� ) � � _ �� i Y t � �� 1�� , � 3 � 4� Y P 5' ��.�� t�' T ?:1 � �I `�,w�.,.�� r ' F 7 �..:: �'6 +- .:.x � ' . 1�_ ;� � r z�ca �y�'�` '� i � � �, � ` � .r . . v ,, , � , ; ��, �' y ' ry ; : 4 :. � �� ' �.�� - F- r� � Y 17 '' t' ) �. . . . , n , .: � � �;� � r v M , � ,j��, i '��> f� �� '�',.� t 4 + ,a Y� � I� �', r � � , � � Y , _ � ' � " F � . , �{ { � _y. ' - ✓ �Y 1�� y- �.:I �a, ; N ry�:. 5 � f �'. �y � . ^� r r 'Y `i p � t' 'c .i ' . . ) i "•� .„'.t� . . ' � ' .� .�5 a •v`x� .y � �� .. } �wlt ( s�.1 . . � :i % 1' 9 x.� � c n r 1°' y v 7 ' I Il � `� },� � '� . ,_ i� ' 't �- .. . , .. �.: . .. . . .. , . - . ) ,:. . . ., '�� :,. , „ 'y` 'i �. � .,i� R . , � r ��:.,� a Y J Y, � ' ��' M $ �� t ? I " � � �r �� t �� x(� ��'` �� ` r.: � < , �" �� ` `� 7 ,� y .Yc � - k � + � '{ - � � t,+ e'4 �t � � � � � -� � + �t � s � ; ;R s � � � a r . .- . . . ::' .' ' '° '-. � ' �x . ,� . -. . �,, . , . 4 �'�f ' . , t. , . . � �,, i - . 9 � i,U� ��.r' �, . , . �,. . � . . . ' , , _ J � � � � � � � . �'��;�� ,�+"`t ! �r�, � CITY OF SAINT PAUL a „niium � DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT � 1°� �� DIVISION OF PLANNING O � �ss. 25 West Fourth Street,Saint Paul,Minnesota,55102 GEORGE LATIMER 612-292-1577 MAYOR November 26, 1985 Albert Olson, City Clerk Room 386 City Hall St. Paul , Minnesota 55102 RE: Zoning File #9798 - Bernard Mersch City Council Hearing: December 5, 1985 PURPOSE: Rezoning for property located at 1210 Randolph Avenue to convert a mixed-use building to an all residential use buildinc� by refurbishing 2 basement offices to apartments. PLANNING CUMMISSION DECISION: Approve (unanimous voice vote) ZONING COMMITTEE DECISION: Approve (6-1) STNFF RECOMMENDATION: Approve SUPPORT: 1 person testified OPPOSITION: 2 letters received, 3 people testified Dear Sir: On November 7, 1985, the Zoning Committee of the Planning Commission held a public hearing on this rezoning. The petitioner testified. At the close of the public hearing, the Committee voted 6 to 1 to approve the rezoning based on staff findings. On November 8, 1985, the Planning Commission upheld the Zoning Committee' s � recommendation on a unanimous voice vote. This rezoning is scheduled to be heard by the City Council on December 5, 1985. Please notify me by December 3, 1985, if any member of the City Council wishes to have slides of the site presented at the public hearing. Sincerely, �r�`v�`.��'��,-�'- - , �::> Donna Datsko Planner II , T � r- Zoning Section - - v UD:ss .:. � �; ,:� - Attachments " e_x-� cc: Zoning File #9798 .. ' . . ��3-�7�/ . . f�'3� 3 _ - city of saint paul pia _r�ng commission resolution � f�e number 85-94 . �te, N�vpmhpr R� 1 Q_ A� WHEREAS, Bernard Mersch File �9198 has petitioned to rezone 1210 Randolph Avenue, situated on south side of Randolph between Edgecumbe Road and Griggs, � from B-2 to RM-2 for the purpose of converting a mixed-use building to an all residential use building by refurbishing 2 basement offices to apartments; and WHEREAS, the Zoning Committee of the Planning Commission, on November 7, 1985 - held"a public hearing at,which all persons present were given an oaportunity to be heard pursuant to said petition in accordance with the requirements of Section 64.400 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code; and WHEREAS, the Saint Paul Planning Commission, based on the evidence presented to the Zoning Committee at the public hearing as substantially reflected in the minutes, made the following findings of fact: 1. The City's Comprehensive Plan states: a) A major housing challenge for the 1980s is that "we don't have enough housing units to meet the demand." b) "Through its land use policies, controls and incentives, the city will promote the clustering of compatible land uses...to meet land use demand in the 1980s". Policy 3.2-1. c) "Medium density housing consisting of townhouses, walk-up condominiums and rental apartments should be developed on sites adjacent to neighborhood commercial areas, traffic corridors and on large vacant or underutilized sites with both built-up and developing city neighborhoods". Policy 1.56. d) It will "ensure that a major po�tion of rental units constructed are affordable to moderate income households" (defined as monthly rental of $350-$479) Affordable Housing Obj . 2. 2. The intent of the RM-2 district is to provide fo� more extensive . � multiple family development. .. (continued) moved by, Panaal . 5ecanded by Morton � in fav�or ��nanimni►c voice vote against— � � � � � . � �s�� 73�3 . ��ty of saint paui �lanr�ng commission resolution �e number � iate 3. To the east of applicant's property are two single family homes. 4. Applicant will create two apartments, one renting for E300/month and one renting for �400/month. 5. The applicant's lot area is 5,356 square feet. Minimum lot size - required is 10,000 square feet. The total number of zoning rooms permitted in an RM-2� zone of this size is 9. After convrrsion, the building would contain 17 rooms. Variances must be obtained from the Board of Zoning Appeals in order to proceed with this conversion. 6. The applicant be required to receive a variance for density from the Board of Zoning Appeals and that the Board of Zoning Appeals makes sure the requirement of 6 parking spaces is met. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, by the Saint Paul Planning Commission that the petition of Bernard Mersch to rezone property at 1210 Randolph Avenue more particularly described as Lot 6, Block 1, Davern's Rearrangement from a RM-2 zoning classification to a 6-2 zoning classification is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan for the City; and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Saint Paul Planning Commission does hereby � recommend to the Council of the City of Saint Paul that property located at 1210 Randolph Avenue be rezoned from RM-2 to B-2 in accordance with the petition for rezoning on file with the Saint Paul Planning Division. noved by �econded by _ . _ n fav�or- � - �gainst- � . __ . _. __ - _ - _._�_.�_��_�. _- _ _ �.�_ __ _ _ :_r.... .. .�.. -- . . P�= �5 i�.�`i�: •*• �. . . �. " � CITY Of SAINT PAUL / 7�'°� 3 : ��i�„= ; DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT "° DIVISION OF PUNNING "" 25 Wat Fourth Street,Saint Paul,Minnesota,55102 3E UTIMER ii�-2�2-1577 UYOR - -- 14RANDUM 'E: November 8, 1985 Planning Commission M: toning Committee Results of November 7, 1985 Hearing of the Zoning Committee ' RECOMMENDATION , Sta f Comm�ttee THOI�IAS LUNZER (#9816) Approve Approve Rezoning for property located at 123 Manitoba (7_p� to develop a community use parking lot. District Comment: Uistrict 6 voted in support their meeting �Su o�rt: 2 people testified p�sition: 1 person testified MUTION: (tecommend approval based on findinys 1 through 5 provided that (1) a 19 foot r�ont yard along Manitoba be established or a variance be yranted by the BZA fo� a 4 foot yard, (2) the alley be vacated; and (3) the site is developed in accordance with a site plan approved by the Planning Division. RAYMOND OLSON (#9824) Approve Approve Special Condition Use Permit for property located (7_p) at 868 Rice Street to establish an outdoor used car lot. District Comment: Uistrict 6 voted in support at their meeting �Su o�rt: 2 people testified p�position• None MOTION: Recommend approval based on findinys 1 , (a) through (c) ; and staff ��J`� recommendations 1, 2 (a) through (e) BERNARD MERSCH (�9198) Approve Approve Reton�ng�or property located at 1210 Randolph (6-1) Avenue to convert a mixed-use building to an all Summers residential use building by refurbishing 2 basement � offices to apartments. _ District Comment: None Support: 1 person testified �pNosition: 2 letters received, 3 people �testified � MOTI�N: Reco�rmend approval based on findings 1 through 5 on the condition that the appT�cant appear before the Board of Zoning Appeals to request a density variance and . that the Board of Zoning Appeals make sure the requirement of 6 parking spaces is met. . � _._...._,.__,.__�._,._w,.�..-�_ _. __ . . _._ _ ___. _�.____.�,_. .. _ . . _ .__ , .., -- .: .. C�" ��-/�`� f . � /J�� 3 . . - tesults of Novembe� 7, 1985 Hearing RECOMMENDATION ta ommi ttee � �� t. BRUCE NOYES (#�9822) Approve Approve Non-Conforming Use Permit for property located (6-0) � � at 143 N. Snelling to expand an accessory use of a non-conforming use. District Comment: Merriam Park Land Use Committee voted in support at their meeting Support: 1 letter received Opposition: 1 person testified MOTION: Recommend approval based on findings 1 through 2 of the expansion of an accessory use of a non-conforminy use. i. JACK WUSSLER (#9820) Deny Deny Non-Conforminy Use Permit for property located (6-0) at 1393 Hewitt to re-establish a carriage house. District Comment: District 11 sent letter in support upport: None Opposition: 3 letters received MUTIUN: Recommend denial based on findings 1, 2c, 2d, 2h and the staff analysis. i. Initiate a 40 acre study to consider a special Approve Approve district sign plan for Highland Village (6-0) . MUTION: Zoning Comnittee voted in support of the 40 acre study. � , -. __. .. . . _ . _ __.._;�,;:_--- _ _ ,. __ _ _ ,. .. _._._ _ .... _ � ,, .. _ : �- �,�_ �?3l _ / 7(3,�3 MINUTES OF THE ZONING COMMITTEE ( IN CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS, ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA ON NOVEMBER 7, 1985 PRESENT: Ntnes. Morton, Summers, Tracy and Zieman; Messrs. Galles, Levy and - Pangal of the Zoning Comnittee; Mr. Segal , Assistant City � Attorney; Ms. Lane of the Division of Housing and Building Code Enforcement; Ms. Synstegaard, Mr. Ryan, Ms. Datsko and Mr. McGuire of the Planning Division Staff. ABSENT: Mr. Lanegran The meeting was chaired by Joseph Pangal , Chairman. The applicant was not present. There was opposition present at the hearing. BERNARD MERSCH (#9798) : Rezoning for property located at 1210 Randolph Avenue to convert a mixed-use building to an all residential use building refurbishing 2 basement offices to apartments. Donna Datsko showed slides of the site and reviewed the staff report with a recommendation for approval . She also stated that the zoniny history was that the property was zoned commercial and that the former owner was going to put up 5 unit apartment building. The applicant withdrew his petition so the case never went through. Larry Lendway, 94U Rogers Street, applicant's representative, stated that Mr. Mersch would like to convert the offices into apartments so they would be easier to rent. He stated that Mr. Fink (the former owner) had a hard time getting renters for office space. Rosella Peterson, 1211 Juno, stated that she lives directly across the alley from the building. She does not believe there will be enough parking if the offices are converted into apartments as there is already a serious parking problem now. John Truestill , 1211 Juno Avenue, stated that the biggest problem in the area is parking. When there is a snow storm it is a d.isaster. There is one gentlemen who parks in front of his home everyday and that there is - also a new business coming into the area. Mike McQuillan, 1199 Juno Avenue, stated that he is concerned with the traffic and extra cars belonging to tenants in the area if the offices are converted into apartments. He stated that Mr. Mersch has not submitted a site plan to the area residents. He asked the Committee how they come to a decision as to how to zone an area. Mr. Pangal stated that they look at each site very carefully before deciding. It was asked what could go into the building according to what it is zoned now. Mr. McGuire answered that an eating and drinking establishment, workshop, etc. could yo in for that particular zone. .. , � . . � ��_�� ,��3.�3 ( BERNARD MERSCH (#9798) PAGE TWO The Committee discussed what would be better for the area: apartments or cortmercial use going into the basement of the building, the space available in the basement, parking spaces, parking restrictions on the street, and that Randolph is a snow emergency route. Hearing no fu�ther testimony, Mr. Pangal closed the public hearing portion of the meeting. Mr. Levy moved approval based on findings 1 through 5 on the condition that the applicant appear before the Board of Zoning Appeals to request a density variance and that the Board of Zoning Appeals make sure the requirement of 6 parking spaces is met. Ms. Morton seconded the motion, which passed on a roll call vote of 6 to 1 (Summers). Submitted by: Approved by: i�iv�hu ��Si�� '. .�.L.. Donna Datsko Jo e h Pan al Chairman P 9 � � � , �.. . r� �.�-i7.� i ' � � �73 a 3.��.�_ � 'ITION TO AMEND ZONING CODE CITY OF SAIN7 PAUI ZONING OFFICE USE ONLY • ��.. File � . Application Fee � � D - �. � Tentative Hearing Date - �y'�_ - . Number of Lots or Size of Parcel: ---=--====-=---==--==-====-====--=-=--== THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCII DATE 19 � Zoning Office, 1100 City Hall �lnnex nt Paul, Minnesota 55102 Pursuant to Section 64.210 of the St. Paul Zoning Ordinance and Section 462.357(5) the Minnesota Statutes, _ _ � ��s�/I � %�iyvr��, , the owner . - all of the land proposed for rezoning, hereby petitions your Honorable Body to :one the following described property: . Street Address: �s�/�� LZL�L��-�.� aziPilc+tc' Legal Descri ption: v`�� (Y ,�,� �► �d,�,,,2, /��a,��,,,.�.,n;t�' �m a Q � Zoning District a ��- 2 Zoning District • the purpose of ' � �► � � � ,t,.�v _ /Z�Q.C�'1�1c�Tdn.� /�t.J� �'Iw�� _ _. �scribed and sworn �ro By: a z�-I— c��Lt � . _ `ore me this ao� rv da _ . _ iQr�T� rT 19� Title: �� _ P age 1 of Notary Pub��,�,�,,,M, . , 4080 OUANE R.NORLANDER 2�85 _. +=' NOTARr PUBIIC—M�NNESO�A DAKOtA COUNTY MY COtAM.EXP�RES OEC.2.19M . ;vNNyvw�`M`^ ' ' - = . .---- - '- --- - ---- � �-._-____� _.,..... ..•--•.....�:.., .�._�-- . _ _ - --- --- .. _ _ __-- ___.._, _ - .. . ,._. ._ _ _ ._ . - -- - .. . ... , _ --_. r- - -- � �'�—/�.� / ' . � /�3�� iTATE OF MINNESOTA) SS �� I ' �1=fVG F{LE � �� :OUNTY OF RAMSEY ) � 1 /��u v�"l� bein first d 1 r ��. �- _, g u y swo n, deposes and states that he is the �er�,6n who circulata�' the within petition and consent, consisting of pa es; that iffiant is informed and believes that the parties described are the ners respectively �f the lots placed immediately before each name, that affiant is informed and believes :hat each of the parties described above is the owner of property which is within 10� feet from any property owned or purchased by petitioner or sold by petitioner �ithin one (1 ) year preceding the date of this petition which is contiguous to the �roperty described in the petition; that except for ione of the parties described above has purchased or is purchasing property from �etitioner contiguous to the above described property within one (1) year of the date �f the peti�ion; that this consent was signed by each of said owners in the presence of :his affiant, and that the signatures are the true and correct signatures of each and ill of the parties� so �escribed. / �(J �.� SS�O„� Address ��-�'- 0l3/ Telephone Number ;ubscribed and sworn to before �e thisa�?,,,o� day of �vrT___, 198,T � � --- ----- lotary Public - . •rrn/�1nvVVNv,n�r.•�nti• ....�N:..•• C:Ititic u N�JF.�'�:.�= S ;�"� .apv F,,3,;�—s,,•.!�E��•'a � i��yy �.�S.V,�JTO C'%:''•?� 1 3 41Y CC!•1M :�L�tlE�D�_�.2.1� � � r ti, l�1h1.YN�M'".■ ►��,^:d�•`.Y:.1 ti�V W�•� �p�roved as to form - Feb. 85 Page of lanning Department . , - . , . . � 79� �= �� :.i��/ .. �ONI�IG� FILE �----- i73.�3- .� CONSENT OF ADJOINING PROPERTY OMNERS TO REZONING � We, the undersigned, owners of property Nithin 100 feet of the total contiguous scriptions of real estate owned, purchased, or sold by Petitioner Mithin one year � ecedinq the date of this petition, acknowledge that we have been furnished Nith the - llowing: 1. A copy of the P et i t i on of ��/��C f name of petitioner 2. A copy of Sections �p�, y�0 through GD. ��'Y , inclusive of the . St. Paul Zoning Code; and cnowledge that we are aware of all of the uses permitted under a 2 /�'1 ^�C �trict zoning classification and we are aware that any of these uses can e :ablished upon City Council approval of the rezoning; and we hereby consent to the !oning of the property described• in t e tition of " ��t,r� , - �.%.�c-�� to a �• Z. Oistrict. name of petitioner � BLOCK ADDITION RECORD OWNER IGNATURE DATE �}'�G"2''`''/L l (�,, � , , �. +*�G �J.��.. V� ��^.SI �,��._. P�}L'CLA.�S ' I � �,C �.i.�t ( KE►JwcTH o9rrw✓ .� � �j/e� � -. _ �. � Pc�•�t. R v►�R�D �t��w�,l s ; � � � �"/_ � � � � �� • _�� ._ ' S��E A 77 �N c �' p� ' �, � �+�• � See" /}Tr/�cNEO � W.�KNc��L ��f� v�• �i��/�, EN i r'R P�t�s�r � ��/�� ` r v � �� 'IG. � '�/� ��u'G'� L. �i.�11,r.rA� S c'c ��T T�L, 1 / Il�rer/JS . ' r�E�;t: a`c�c/hE,�'i �l � f-� . /��I�, ' '.-7��% �-�- G_. . i y/�"f'� . ��ti��,� �:��y J_ � 1 �'E�K,�ati+ � - �:o��..,��ti ScT" •9c�/�7� � -j �• �t e�ccF ocsc� � .d�S" � ��,.� L R. G/�� S t r �.� . . _ Y � ,��,��., � � .7,,� ; - �-• S � - I'1�4�►�i�,�i c ' " ' / "� �` �,�,�.�,,+.y /)1«�{A�L ��u�.c� , • . � �" �i � �� r L/�{ ( 1JL �� ,VL �� , -f� �c�-�+�...; ,��..,� G�4�cE �r� .1�- «, � ' ! ��a C l��l i� !c�c cus c i��C ��-- ��.�..,(' . :itions shall not be considered as officially filed until the lapse of 7 working days . :er a petition is received in Lhe Zoning Office. Any signator of any petition may :hdraw his name therefrom by written request within that time. � P age 2 of . _._��.. ...��.____---.�Y_�___��...,:� � --- . �- � � , . . � �.s-��.�� . � ��3�.� . CONSENT OF ADJOINING PROPERTY OrMERS TO REZONING Ne. the undersigned, owners of property Nithin 100 feet of the total contiguous criptions of real estate owned, purchased, or sold Dy Petitioner Nithin one year � cedinq the date of this petition. acknowledge that we have been furnished Nith the lowing: 1. A copy of the Petition of f name of petitioner 2. A copy of Sections through , inclusive of the St. Paul Zoning Code; an � �owledge that we are aware of all of the uses permitted under a /2 /�'l �� trict zoning classification and we are aware that any of these uses can e ablished upon City Council approval of the rezoning; and we hereby consent to the ming of the prope�-ty described •in the ition of � to a District. name of petitioner BLOCK ADDITION RECORD OWNER IGNATURE DATE °,.�"�. �, C�vw�. , , . �r � � � � � ' ` �i rS� 3 (��,�, � � , . � _ ,� � _ �� ,, � ; .�: , t �, �r ; . -� � �� :. , , . . ,. � ' � �1( � " ±,. �� tions shall not be considered as officially filed until the lapse of 7 working days � �r a petition is received in the Zoning Office. Any signator of any petition may �draw his name therefrom by written request within that time. Page2of _ - . , �� . � : . - . , � �s-��.�i - � � /7��3 CONSENT OF ADJOINING PROPERTY OWNERS TO REZONING We. the �mdersigned, owners of property within 100 feet of the total contiguous descriptions of real estate owned, purchased, or sold by Petitioner within one year precedinq the date of this petition, acknowledge that we have been furnished with the following: - - . - 1. A copy of the Petition of /� name of petitioner 2. A copy of Sections through , inclusive of the St. Paul Zoning Code; and �cknowledge that we are aware of all of the uses permitted under a /Z I�'l '� )istrict zoning classification and we are aware that any of these uses can be �stablished upon City Council approval of the rezoning; and we hereby consent to the �ezoning of the property described in the 'etition of to a District. name of petitin►�ar .OT BLOCK ADDITION RECORD OWNER IGNATURE DATE 3 ,�,�a,..�,�,�� --�-, C�,'�r►�.�_ ' � �1s -�'�-� -- - - �l�/�.r� 5 � A� � �. �nlc��r � KE►�u��►f D•9�'Ton1 .T � �� 9 3 o�c. , Rv��RLO •��i�c.��lS � � � �� 3 K �' _ _G��'�`_r'�? . -� s<<E A rr � c -- N s'` a` � ��._ ---� s t r sr rrAc,�E4 � wG�N��l� �__��_l_ ENir��sFt Q� O/�.j �� 8 3 ) � � -� ---I�=� Geo�� e C. 1�,11.a.�3 c- i � — �— `- �S i — ------�------ i �� . +---- — --�— - � -- etitions shall not be considered as officially filed until the lapse of 7 working days fter a petition is received in the Zoning Office. Any signator of any petition may � ithdraw his name therefrorn by written request within that time. . P age 2 of _.._ ___.____�--- .._._. _ _- ---�. ._.._ . _.__ .,..._._..._._ _ .. , ��.s��3� - . � � � � � , -�.�� CONSENT OF ADJOINING PROPERTY OWNERS TO REZONING WP. the ��ndersigned, owners of propert,y within 100 feet of the total Contiguous escriptions of real estate owned, purchased, or sold by Petitioner within one year �recedinq the dat� of this pPtition, acknowledge that we h3ve been furnished with the � 'ollowing: 1. A topy of the Petition of /� name of petitioner 2. A copy of Sections through , inclusive of the St. Paul Zoning Code; an cknowledge that we are aware of all of the uses permitted under a /z I�'l —�C istrict zoning classifir_ation and we are aware that any of these uses can e stablishe:i upon City Council approval of the reioning; and we hereby consent to the ezoning of the property described in the etition of to a District. name of petitinner 07 BLOCK ADDITION RECORD OWNER IGNATURE DATE � a,r."'"`/„ �..,�. `Jv'v�. , ./��I�- ,r � v�4�cc.Js - - / � ,c�a�.� r K�►��r►+ o�9>ron! .r � i �d 9 3 Pa�. Ro►►!!��o ,t��`,�ls ' � �� S r 3 � G�r.fl-ta / . -- - . --_ •S<<E A rT �H c s,` � �; ,� A 'j ��,�� L!_ C�C�Y�Vp'ti'�/ S e E �TT/��NEO � / W��N�sKt �y/ � ��_�c�__�ENi��'f�r � � O �.j/�} g 3--1�=��` ��s�o��r C_l�,ll,��rs __ - F 'r �-�� E '�/�ytii"' B�6'c`�C� Y �i �_�u �'^r ��,ti. ' _ I'd` I � --}- --�—---- — ----- --- -------- -- - .,_ ---f---�------ ----�-•- t ---+-- --•-------- — -- I -1---�------- - --- 'etitions shall not be car.�idere� as officially filed until the lapse of 7 working days � �fter a petition is re�eived in the Zoninq Office. Any signator of� any petition may � �• �ithdraw his name therefrocn by written request within that time. , P age 2 of .. _ �^��',��7�/ . ' �'7� CONSENT OF ADJOINING PROPERTY OWNERS TO REZONING We. the �mdersigned, owners of property within 100 feet of the total contiguous descriptions of real estate owned, purchased, or sold by Petitioner within one year precedinq the date of this petition, acknowledge that we have been furnished with the following: � 1. A copy of the Petition of � name of petitioner 2. A copy of Sections through , inclusive of the St. Paul Zoning Code; and acknowledge that we are aware of all of the uses permitted under a 2 I�'l ��C District zoning classification and we are aware that any of these uses can be estabiished upon City Cour�;:il approval of the re2oning; and we hereby consent �o the rezoning of the property described in the Petition of to a District. name of petitinner LOT BLOCK ADOITION RECORD OWNER IGNATURE DATE �3 `�� --�-, G►'vh.s�- • .�� 5 v��;�s� � �c,c �� r K��►��r►+ 0�9 rrow .T � �j 8 � � � �� 9 3 P�t. Ro��!��o ,t�G`��s � _ ' 3 /� �� _ � _ .�!�"ftit'�7_ _._ � S<<E A 7T �H c- ys� � � Q�� `1•��._ s r-r" /�rr/1 c NEo 3 / W��CrVc�CL �y � �:_�i«It,_ _�_ ENi r!��'sF S._ � 0/�.j/�} g J----1� `�_��s�_v_/': c� C_ ltJ,ll.a�� Sc�` 77 C�/FD �'Q'1��x/t.� �—— - ---- � . -� —�----��',,'t�� R.Kl�v`'. _ � �7 � � ` � --�--------�------ ---- --- � � � I �_..---- ----._._-- - - ; Petitions shall not be considered as officially filed until the lapse of 7 working days after a petition is received in the Zoning Office. Any signato'r of any petition may withdraw his name therefrorn by written request within that time. , P age 2 of _ . ��:: __. , �� : CONSENT OF ADJOINING PROPERTY OWNERS TO REZONING Je. the ��ndersigned, ovm ers of property within 100 feet of the total contiguous iptions of real estate owned, purchased, or sold by Petitioner within one year iinq the dat�: of this pPtition, acknowledge that we have been furnished with the .� ring: I. A copy of the Peti tion of �� name of petitioner '. A copy of Sections �o� y�� through ��1 y3� , inclusive of the St. Paul Zoning Code; and rledge that we are a�yare of all of the uses permitted under a 2 /�1 �� ct zoning classifir_ation and we are aware that any of these uses can be - ;ished upon City Council approval of the rezoning; and we hereby consent to the ing of the p�operty described in thF ion of % �"�,tic. 2�' - '�.z:z�� to a ,�/i� -� District. name of petitinn�r —' BLOCK ADDITION RFCORD OwIVER IGIVA7URE DATE � M�.wvt/ r •�,'U'�K� 4 �.k ,.�t,��. Vv�V1�L_ _.�,... _ � Q�}�EL��S • - - - ,�,� ��.� � KE►�w��►t oq rro�✓ .r � �3/� �� l^�- R v�V�+-D �f/�`��/S �� ` "t� �� --- , 3 � �• ��'�-t''W � S�{E A 7T c N c � �( �LL.�.- ------- -�'�-� -•- - SEr' �TT/��1E0 3 ..1_ ' W��.N��CL �y °�G�_��`.��ENi��C�,C�srt � . D/�,j/�� 3_ o�-�c_i�.IE �Geo�� c. 1�,,�,�.�s ._.�� .L �� . — �---- _——��}�.z srt.� ---- —— ' � t. u��..-.T � [��/�c_�i ni�� ,I� �'L� 9'� 1 yr"�,s � ' -�------�--------- ------------ -- — I -- ----� -- -- �- -- ----�_._..._--- -----_.--- - � ; � �-----�_ --�---- —� -- ions shall not he cor.sidered as �fficially filed until the lapse of 7 working days a petition is received in the Zoning Office. Any signator of any petition may raw his name therefrorn by written request within that time. Page 2 of 1 . . �� . . ��,�- �.�--��i • ' l��a23 CONSENT OF ADJOINING PROPERTY OWNERS TO REZONING Wp. the ��ndersigned, o��mers of pro�erty within 100 feet of the total contiguous descriptions of real estate owned, purchased, or sold by Petitioner within one year precedinq the date of this petition, acknowledge that we have been furnished with the following: 1. A copy of th� Petition of ��'U�� f 5��L� . / name of petitioner 2. A copy of Sections �D�• �'� through �� . y Sy , inclusive of the St. Paul Zoning Code; and acknowledge that we are aware of all of the uses permitted under a 2 I�'l �� District zoning classification and we are aware that any of these uses can be established upon City Council approval of the rezoning; and we hereby consent to the rezoning af the property described i thF . Petition of �.ti ' 1`! . � � ;� -�. L. to a c / District. name of petitinn�r L07 BLOCK ADDITiOr� RECORD OwNER IGNATURE DATE 1� �j1a,r.cti� �..��.. �Jv��/hfZ_ ` J�,� 5 � P�f c1CL�.�S • — — — — - �,� ��c•�: r KE,�►��r►+ 0�1 rro�J .7 � �7�g . ,� � 9 � Pr ��,v��-o ,t��`,�s , < < ,«, � �S j 3 � :, � - -----n� -.. � S<<F A 7T c y c ys` °� �� _ �_�? str �rrAcrlEo 3 w�,e N�� v�l•_�a�� _�ENir�r��f�t � . O/�.j �� 8 3_ o��c_ f�IE Ceo�: � c. �,1,,�,�.�s —, --�---- ��-1�. �, – ! � Q.t,<<ui c:�,2,�;�t �c' — / / ��„�'�I.i� =i\1� �/�/� .� �4 /� ��ii��'�� /�� , � . , � ��.��i��"� ��_..�.�� , _ --i -- ----�-- -- -- -- ----�--- _----- ---.--.-.__ --- - _ _ : t -----�---- -�—.--._--- ---- Petitions shall n�t be cor.siciered as officially filed until the lapse of 7 working days after a petition is received in the Zoning Office. Any signator of any petition may withdraw his name therefro,n by written request within that time. • Page 2 of _. ' , � �-'�-/7�i /73� 3 _ _ �� . _ . �� - �� ..�.- ��.Q., ��►� - �6�► . � - - �.�J� c�� . �� . _ � . . . _ �� `'"`.� �.a. � � -� ,�..�.�.� �.,L.;r,��, - �L.�. C`� .a.`�,2 � �.� — �.\.,-r� � ,c� lt�, '� � � � �� - �� - � � �� * -�-° � � �.� � - , �� ; �. � � � �� l 0�`-- --- �l-�_ ��1� , ��-�G��.� `J � �� , , �o� � � Il� _ i_. . .... . _ ._ -.::.- .- --- ... .- :_ . _ _ � . , , , , . . - �/�` �.5--�7.�/ � 173.�3 . i�ov. 4, 1985 Zoning Cammittee Re; Zoning File 9798 Zooiag File Name Merech,Bernard NOV 5 1985 Firat, thang you for affording me t�he opoortunity of � � e�ressing �� feelings in a letter. Because of phqaical disabilities it xould be very difficult to attend the hearing. I recall sigaing a petition about 23 years ago when the bu?ld- ing at I2I0 Randolph was being built. The complex was not to have more apartments than they had off the street� parking f�r. A permit for four (4) apart�ments was granted . Why now when the parking a►�d tr�ffic is a far greater problem, should a permit for two (2) more apar-tments be gra�ted2 I do n�t� approve. r:ost working couples have 2 cars, so 2 more apartments could generate 4 more c�rs. I count� 28 car•s belonging to r•esi�ents i� the bloc'a now. r�t least when the space in question t�as us�a for offices, tr:�r=� w�.s only sp�,smodic parki!�g on the street , during the d=�.y. Parkin3 on Randolph is a real problem. It is a rare occasion wh�n my daughter can fi�d a sp�ce in front of our home. There �ave re�n times krhen visitors of ours, have had to park on Juno. And ther-e is not much space on Juno either. Randolph is a snow emergency route, so we do get plotaed out fast. But even so ti•:tth parking on roth sides of the street , there ar-e times w'�en vehiclAS travding in opposite directions ca!�not pass one another, one waits. The alley too becomes a zoo. The alley bears a lot of traffic, m�ny trucks, store customers, dental staff and patients, trash ��.ulers etc . The alley is in ��lo��.ble condition, it should be resurfaced. I r°enorted it #o the street depart�ment last spring so we did get a few shovels of tar in the worst holes. . I am sure if the N;erschs were to reside in the apartment build- ing, they would �etter understand why many of us feel as we do. That any more traffic or parking woiald be intolerable. Thank you, Sincerely, .,.'�i.r l.�.<. � :L. -._ .� . J . LUCILLE J. OLSEN IIgB Randolph Ave. St. Paul,Nllv 55105 . . � '� (,o��.�—�� . . � ,�� ZUNING COMMITTEE STAFF REPURT F�ILE #9798 1 . APPLICANT: Bernard Mersch DATE OF .HEARING: 11/7/85 2. CLASSIFICATION: Rezoniny to RM-2 3. LOCATION: 1210 Randolph Avenue (south side of Randolph between Edyecumbe Road and Griggs) 4. LEGAL DESCRIPTION: Lot 6, Block 1, Davern's Rearrangement • �� 5. PRESENT ZONING: B-2 ZONING CODE REFERENCE: 60.450 6. STAFF INVESTIGATIUN & REPORT: DATE: 10/29/85 BY: Donna Datsko as�assssaa====a===c======a=====-------=====a=o=o===a==o==:a========oa=a=c===o====ac=====o asssa:asasoao=aaaa=co====ac=====a==oo=====cc=o======a====a==o=====�:_=====aaa===�=�aa=asa UC. PURPOSE: Applicant wishes to convert his mixed-use building to an all residential use building by refurbishiny 2 basement offices to apartments. B. SUFFICIENCY: The petition was declared sufficient by the Planniny Division on ctober 15, 1985: parcels eligible: 17, parcels needed: 12, parcels signed: 12. C. PARCEL SIZE: Forty feet of frontage on Randolph Avenue x 123.9 feet = 4,956 square eet. Area of parcel including one-half the alley = 5,356 square feet. ,-fl. EXISTING LAND USE: The site is occupied by a 2 1/2 story brick building. The upper two f oors contain four 2 bedroom apartments; the lower floor contains two offices. The back 1/3 of the lot is unimproved surface parking for four cars. E. SURROUNDING LAND USE: North: dry cleaners and restaurant East: dentist offices South: sinyle-family residential West: coffee supply business and beauty parlor F. ZONING HISTORY: None. . G. FINDINGS: ._._.� 1. The City's Comprehensive Plan states: ' . ' � ��.5^-i7ji , . � , . . ��,�� ZONING FILE #9798 PAGE TWO 5. The applicant's lot area is 5,356 square feet. Minimum lot ,size required is 10,000 square feet. The total number of zoning rooms permitted in an RM-2 zone of this size is 9. After conversion, the building would contain 17 rooms. Variances must be obtained from the Board of Zoning Appeals in order to proceed with this conversion. H. STAFF RECOMMENDATIUN: Based on findings 1 through 4, staff recommends approval of the rezoning to RM-2 , l. . � � � .� • • • • • • � �� I • • • • • • • • • � p � �I ; � �� !�! L7 .:rl 0 , , • . . . . . . � . �� o . . . . . . . . . .. � � . . . . . s,� . . . . . � o . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . � � o t� _ _ _ , �� _ _ , • !1� � � �,,,,, ^ "� ��, . . . • . . . . . . . . . . . . . . • �•�� ; ,; r �J II .�� . ►� _�'i ■� �•a � �� . _ . v�� , ��i►�+iri�'i'�. ,, , . . . . . . = a a �:r ��. � �� , � . . . : ; ; : .,� ;a ,� • _ _ � � � . . . . . . . . . . . . . ,� . . • � � � � � � � . . . . � . . .�: . . . . . �, , ��; y � , . • � . � ,�� 11 , � � • • � • • • � • � • • � • • • • � � � • , • • � � • • • • • • • • • � • � • • - � • - . � J' • • �� • • � • • � • • • • I � • .� � � � � � � i • � • � . '�. C��s-i�.�� . � � ST. PAUL CITY COUNCIL �� 3 PUB�IC HEARING NOTICE ZONING To: Property owners within 350 feet; Representatives of Planning District 15 FII.E N 0. 979g PAGE PURPOSE To consider a rezoning from B-2 to RM-2 for the purpose of converting two offices to apartments in a mixed use building. LOCATION 121(1 Randolph Avenue (South side of Randolph between Edgecumbe and Griggs) PETITIONER BERNABD MERSCH H E A R IN G Thursday, December 5, 1985 lo:oo a.M. Citv Council Chambers, 3rd Floor City Hall - Court House Q U E S TIO N S Zoning 298-4154 (Donna Datsko) Contact the Zoning Section of the Planning and Economic Development Department, Room 1101, City Hall Annex, 25 W. 4th Street, St. Paul, Minnesoia 55102 Legal Description: l_ot 6, Block l , Davern's Rearrangement Notice aent 11-22-85 � . � . . �,�-�.5--/7�3/ • � �7�3 PETITION TO AMEND ZONING CODE CITY OF SAINT PAUL ZONING OFFICE USE ONLY File # Application Fee $ 3 ZS �D -�, Tentative Hearing Date — ��y'�s Number of Lots or Size of Parcel: TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL DATE ��,i4M#�� 19 -r � ��._ a „� c/o Zoning -0ffice, 1100 City Hall Annex . Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 , , 1 ' '`,' '„ , , ,...�.� r, �1 ��' �: _ .0 _. Pursuant to Section 64.210 of the St. Paul Zoning Ordi_n�d�;:.a�d ��c�i�r� °�5�:357(5) of the Minnesota Statutes, _ � �G.ti�2r�, . . , the owner of all of the land proposed for rezoning, hereby petitions your Honorable Body to rezone the following described property: Street Address: �.�/0 /�t�p�� ,�r��yc(� Legal Descri pti on: o`�a..-� �f ,C�+�/� / ��MP�r,.a. �� from a � -t� � Zoning District to a ��1�2 Zoning District for the purpose of i�r,�rt� �� .�� Subscribed and sworn t,o By: before me thi s aa N 0` day _ _ of L�� ,�T 198� Title: -T P age 1 of N o t ary P u b l i �N�,�,,,,,,,,,,,�, 40 80 * OUANE R.NORLANDER 2I85 -=' NOTARY PUBLiC—MINNESOTA DAKOTA COUNTY MY CObAM.EXPIRES DEC.2.1�8 . . . , . ��S -i7.�/ . � . i 7.3a23 STATE OF MINNESOTA) . SS �� LE � � ��+ COUNTY OF RAMSEY ) , being first duly sworn, deposes and states that he is the per n who circulat the within petition and consent, consisting of � pages; that affiant is informed and believes that the parties described are the owners respectively of the lots placed immediately before each name, that affiant is informed and believes that each of the parties described above is the owner of property which is within 100 feet from any property owned or purchased by petitioner or sold by petitioner within one (1 ) year preceding the date uf this petition which is contiguous to the property described in the petition; that except for _ _ none of the parties described above has purchased or is purchasing property from petitioner contiguous to the above described property within one (1 ) year of the date of the petition; that this consent was signed by each of said owners in the presence of this affiant, and that the signatures are the true and correct signatures of each and all of the parties so described. ��1� ss�o� Address o2�--d� Ol3/ Telephone Number Subscribed and sworn to before me thisa�NO� day of �ys�'___, 198.� -� ��- - Notary Public -17� ��nnnnnn.ti^,n�wvv.f."' r nnnnnnn/�/`n�' DUANF R� NORL;�ra�ER � ��J�NOTARY PUBL�C—MINNESUT� � � ]��` DAKOTP COUNTY `�� MY COMM.CXPI�ES DEC.2,1988� r wvwv�"nr.�nr.-�v�r/wvv`nnn'�^�```■ Apnroved as to form - Feb. 85 Page of Planning Department � . � � �� FtLE `�� ,. , ,��N�NG CONSENT OF ADJOINING PROPERTY OWNERS TO REZONING �� f�7`3� �7�?3 We, the undersigned, owners of property within 100 feet of the total contiguous descriptions of real estate owned, purchased, or sold by Petitioner within one year preceding the date of this petition, acknowledge that we have been furnished with the following: 1 . A copy of the Petition of � name of petitioner 2. A copy of Sections �Q, 'y�0 through Gp, S[�'�/ , inclusive of the St. Paul Zoning Code; and acknowledge that we are aware of all of the uses permitted under a /Z I�'l "� District zoning classification and we are aware that any of these uses can be established upon City Cauncil approval of the rezoning; and we hereby consent to the rezoning of the property described in t e Petition of � to a �• Z. District. name of petiti�ner LOT BLOCK ADDITION RECORD OWNER IGNATURE DATE �3 �,"`�"',� .J� C`�v� � �'�- P,��c�1s 5 � '�rr� � K�N��rN o�rrow .�` � �� 9 � Pa^�- R o iil��D !t I G Gl�/S ' ` � �� 3 � ��'ZD'W �SEE A TT �H c `�s�' � /< C'Y.�e�1. i�- __. S Er �TTfI�KEO � W4'K N��C Cz "�"� �-- o�- �� ENT��°R�s�'S �s.� � �.3 t�� g .� p�G- �� i�or 2 C. l��1 j,ar�S 5 Ec �TT9c �v6�n'S /� �J g � tiE ��r CtJ'�" . /y1 v , 1�U�x,US QFv�2`y f0 � RE�4��4�kk �or<s�Ein! S'� -4c-/��"z7 `� � °�- �L%�l, L C'lLt�.o�s6/� � �� ,s� � �`1 a.''O L �. G/n1 c. s�� 1 l �� s -s Y�4�i��i , / �,,,�,,,,,�' m��r��c��h� uw� �----- - �x� D � f d�.,� Gc.�4rl� �d ,S-�R- a,�t��,� 1 ` C{�As- !C",r�usc�� -- �1-,p Pe itions shall not be considered as officially filed until the lapse of 7 working days after a petition is received in the Zoning Office. Any signator of any petition may withdraw his name therefrom by written request within that time. P age 2 of � . � . � ��-/�3� ` � � � � �� CONSENT OF ADJOINING PROPERTIf OMINERS TO REZONING We, the undersigned, owners of property within 100 feet of the total contiguous descriptions of real estate owned, purchased, or sold by P et�tioner within one year precedinq the date of this petition, acknowledge that we have been furnished with the following: 1. A copy of the Petition of /' name of petitioner 2. A copy of Sections through , inclusive of the . St. Paul Zoning Code; and acknowledge that we are aware of all of the uses permitted under a 2 I�'l "�C District zoning classification and we are aware that any of these uses can e established upon City Council approval of the rezoning; and we hereby consent to the rezoning of the property des�ri'bed in the Petition of � to a District. name of petitioner LOT BLOCK ADDITION RECORD OWNER IGNATURE DATE 1� �.`"�,°' ..� C�v�.�. � �I�- 5 � t .r � � � 9 � ` ' �' � �S 3 � G�� ,,__�,� � � ��,` ��3 �� ys� � '' �,,r�,�-�_e �� /�-�� Petitions shall not be considered as officially filed until the lapse of 7 working days after a petition is received in the Zoning Office. Any signator of any petition may withdraw his name therefrom by written request within that time. P age 2 of � � . � ��s-��.�� /7�� 3 CONSENT OF ADJOINING PROPERTY OWNERS TO REZONING We. the ��ndersigned, owners of pro�erty within 100 feet of the total contiguous descriptions of real estate owned, purchased, or sold by Petitioner within one year precedinq the date of this petition, ar.knowledge that we have been furnished with the following: 1 . A copy of the Petition of ��'!��'� � name of petitioner 2. A copy of Sections through , inclusive of the St. Paul Zoning Code; and acknowledge that we are aware of all of the uses permitted under a /Z /�'1 �� District zoning classification and we are aware that any of these uses can be established upon City Cauncil approval of the rezoning; and we hereby consent to the rezoning of the property described in the Petition of to a District. name of petitinner LOT BLOCK ADDI7ION RECORD OWNER IGNATURE DATE �3 ,�a�� C��v� , f� ' 5 P��,�s � � ac.�e�� K�r�n�cr�f o•9 rro� .7' � �j 8 / � �cx^l�. R v rJ/��D i f I ti�G-1 ti/S ~ . .� ` ,�..,+� � �� -p '� � - -C�y�?-¢c� --- ' -S��F A TT �H c y S,�. � ��, � - ,�� S c r �TT1��NEQ � - -JN��L'N�i1.[:--- — �._��'_,_Eh!%r�2PR�S�S � d/�.j/�� `�_/ I � 8 3_ o"'�Y.��IE G�'aP� N c. �,��,aHrs , � S� —� ------ --- ----t-- -- -- _ � -----�-----_ _-- --- - -- I � ' -� -- — -- --- -- -- ---�--------- --•--•---- - - � Petitions shall not be cor,sidered as officially filed until the lapse of 7 working days after a petition is received in the Zoning Office. Any signator of any petition may withdraw his name therefrorn by written request a�ithin that time. P age 2 of ' ' . � �5- i73 � • � � i7.��3 CONSENT OF ADJOINING PROPERTY OWNERS TO REZONING We. the undersigned, owners of pra�ert,y within 100 feet of the total contiguous descriptions of real estate owned, purchased, or sold by Petitioner within one year precedinq the date of this petition, acknowledge that we have been furnished with the following: 1 . A copy of th� Petition of ��'� /- name of petitioner 2. A copy of Sec,tions through , inclusive of the St. Paul Zoning Code; and acknowledge that we are aware of all of the uses permitted under a /Z I�'l —� District zoning classifiration and we are aware that any of these uses can be established uoon City Colan�ll approval of the rezoning; and we hereby consent to the rezoning of the property described in the Petition of to a District. name of petitioner LOT BLOCK ADDITION RECORD OWNER IGNATURE DATE �3 °,�""'�' �, C')„�v�,.� . �.t�-�rt- ' 5 �R��,�s � �ac.�e�r K�►�n��rFt o�Yron1 .r � �j d ^ � � �S 9 3 ��c. R��v��n �f��.,,�s E _ ' 3 a� ��, i . - - -- ---. �SEF A TT �H c �5`Y � �� (,C-a�a�. �' s c r •4 TT/1�NEO -� �: ��_�_ EN��eP,e�s�s � _ �/�.jl�� g -3 o`�G- � ,G�o�� c_ tJ,�l,o,�s � __A � �c� ---- �-- --�- �' �� BEV��cz y � � _ �s�E��1 � _ �� i � �.____-- ----- -- - --- � � _---�--------- ---------- - - - � i ------- - ------___.__..___— ------- — ) i _.,------_-------_1___----__----_-- -- Petitions shall not be corsider�d as officially filed ur,til the lapse of 7 working days after a ��etition is received in the 7_oning Office. Any signator of any petition may withdraw his r.ame theref��orn by written request within that time. P age 2 of � � � . . ��-��.�� ' � /�3.�3 CONSENT OF ADJOINING PROPERTY OWNERS TO REZONING We. the �indersigned, owners of property within 100 feet of the total contiguous description.s of real estate owned, purchased, or sold by Petitioner within one year preceding the date of this petition, acknowledge that we have been furnished with the following: 1 . A copy of the Petition of �� /� name of petitioner 2. A copy of Sections through , inclusive of the St. Paul Zoning Code; and acknowledge that we are aware of all of the uses permitted under a � I�'l ^� District zoning classification and we are aware that any of these uses can be estab�isned upon Ci�y Cuuncil approvai of trre rezoning; ard we hereby consent �o th� rezoning of the property described in the Petition of to a District. name of petitioner LOT BLOCK ADDITION RECORD OWNER IGNATURE DATE 1� °�`.e�t"`Q� L, �,,��,,� • �✓V'�-- ' . �.J_ 5 � �R�� ,e,�n�N�e�r K�i�a��r►t o�1 rTon� ,7 � i� d ` ; � ��" 9 � ��. Rd,v��n ,t�G��,�S .. � - ; j _ � ._ _C�y��'�'!� _.__ _A �� ScF A 77 �H e �s`� � �� • (�� S t r �TT/��HEO n � W��ivc�lL ;� � �--_ �:_�a�__�_ EN T�,e P,e�s�s-- '� ' —,�,.L . �/�.3/r�} S 3_--�°�'!�--�•�'r — ,G�o�� t_c; �J,►l,a,�s ----S�� ?�,� ��/� � r � l�� .,��- � _ S� 1? �- , � � -i--------�--------- ----------- ---- � � � , ___�-__..------ ----.-.---- - - � Petitions shall not be considered as officially filed until the lapse of 7 working days after a petition is received in the Zoning Office. Any signator of any petition may withdraw his name therefrorn by written request within that time. P age 2 of � ` . ��,5 /7.�� - � � ' � /7.3-✓ CONSENT OF ADJOINING PROPERTY OWNERS TO REZONING We. the ��ndersigned, ov�ners of pro�Frt,y within 100 feet of the total contiguous description.s of real estate owned, purchased, or sold by Petitioner within one year preceding the date of this petition, ar.knowledge that we have been furnished with the : following: 1 . A copy of th� Petition of ��%��'� /� name of petitioner 2. A copy of Secti ons �o- y�"� through �� . �/S� , i ncl usi ve of the St. Paul Zoning Code; and acknowledge that we are aware of all of the uses permitted under a /� I�1 "� District zoning classifiration and we are aware that any of these uses can be established upon City Council approval of the rezoning; and we hereby consent to the ' rezoning of the property described in the Petition of .- . to a _�,�//Y�.—�- District. ' name of pet�tinner LOT BLOCK ADDITION RFCORD OWNER IGNATURE DATE �� µa^..e'�"",i.,.�+��',,� Vv�V1�SL_ ,�/U"�.� � PR c/C��.�S Jr �. ,e,e ,�c.cr�e�� K�►��t��i o�YToi,1 .7' � �j �y I 'J �c�. Rvi�1�Ln �tlU�.��ls , � �c..� � �� . --- ,`��':— _t— � �. -- ---C�yn-t'-� _._ _ � �S<E A rT �H c y S� � /C Ci.�. '' r.� _�___ St r �Tr/�cHEO � w.�r n,��1.� �y �__��_,_.ENi��PR�S�S � - D/�.�/�� g 3 � � I��o/'�' � C_1t��1/.�.�g �_ ___1� �- �--- - � _!_ ��?E��,✓�c �,��-- -�,�.,� _ q i� �s �------�--------- ------------___�_---- � , -- ' --�---- -------�--- -- -- --- -- _----�------ -------- -------.----- - ` - - � � --------� __`_ ----____------ ------ ____ — � Petitions shall not tie cor.sidered as officially filed until the lapse of 7 working days after a �etition is received in the Zoning Office. Any signator of any petition may withdraw his name therefrorn by written request within that time. P age 2 of � � � (�-=-�5 -��i�� . . � ' � i7�� 3 CONSENT OF ADJOINING PROPERTY OWNERS TO REZONING We. the ��ndersigned, o�r�ners of propert,y within 100 feet of the total contiguous descriptions of real estate owned, purchased, or sold by Petitioner within one year preceding the date of this petition, acknowledge that we have been furnished with the following: 1 . A copy of the Petition of ��'� � 2. A co of Sections name of petitioner py (O(1. �� through �p. c�s� , inclusive of the St. Paul Zoning Code; and acknowledge that we are aware of all of the uses permitted under a � I�'l -� District zoning classification and we are aware that any of these uses can be established upon City Council approval of the rezoning; and we hereby consent to the rezoning of the propert,y described i the Petition of to a �f�l '02- District. name of petitinn�r � LOT BLOCK ADDITION RECORD OWNER IGNATURE DATE , �3 �� ,� C�,�v� � �� ' 5 � ��.,�s . - - - -- - �. �,� �c•�e�r K�r��r►, o�rro�,� .7` � �j � l � �"CSNC. �U Il��?-D i f l(i�Gl ti/S ��7��"�; . .� ` �t.....� `�/ 'J � - ; � C�j!%� i � _ -.. _.__ � S<E ArT �He �s� °� �� _ �� st r .�rr/�c��EO � ,./_ ' p w�r�v��L� �y o'-�W�_�7 C��_l_.Fhl;��P��s�S � _ 0/�.�/r� � 8 3__�0`�-�_��_ G�o�.c t� L_��.arfiS Y � � — — � . , S I �.�"�` ''`� - — - - - —�----- - - -_ � d �� . �--------�--------- ---�----_--_._.------ � + , ------ ---�--�—_.__._------ ----�---------- - ; ' � ------_.L.�_��_ - �.______.___ ------ -,� Petitions shall not be cor.sidered as officially filed until the lapse of 7 working days after a petition is received in the Zoning Office. Any signator of any petition may withdraw his name therefrorn by written request within that time. P age 2 of r 5�M � p �:��y �'Y"g �' 4 '. 1 d6 .: L��„°f`'� t� F�'�"y� '"mx;�., � a � .e �^. i n�:rr' x �.(� �� `'r � 1 : x t� �� °"-J$+.'+,.'i�'.'�' 3�vr.'S��'��`�`"`��.� ��.� r , a .�r y . �" ,:� Y � R Sltr i 4 .`!�n ' �.-. b '� `r� r��Y"' . �°S ��*�� k 7.'PS t b��.'�. r `' - +� �. � .� '� ��. , � F,;.. x: �.�-'�-� � '�3: �•'n L� r ♦ .: �IF:c�I� ° �:.S K �ar 1. ' ,,,i.��' n t pr . . , x' ` S ' .`�,��..f°�.-! .��J��.�� . . _ r �.�„ �.>i�-.. . 4 � a. s- �L ,y;�'�.f�4 , t �'Y � - ..,, .�u i * �a s .Jt � � � . .,�. s ,'�.�..atr^�f��;��. . . -r+ "�', ,'.' ' .._ . - '� �_''_+,x''� z�' '-• . - `- ;- '= NOTiCE OF HEARING . - � �' h S fi f" ?`PS�v � ' Y � , . � � . �i"'�it 1'a� .as. ' � f '1 !f . T �`, ' ��:..,. . - �Ye �..,"F � +'� � � ` �°� Petition .to Rezone �� , •x � t��Y� - � � k°l z�� +,.l, - r ' ' � ,`J �s'fq,*.j..s� .-.`, •;: :i .. ., � ��• .;:�• ,�. �. . . . . ; . . . :. � .,�. .... . �..:_._ .�:�: . �_` � . �, �,� �... �_... ,x.,_s�.a� . A petition having�been�fil2d _requesting.. that the Zoning Ordinance of �'r : "4�d � the City of St: Paul;.;be�amended,:so as to rezone from B-2 to RM=2, �property - � �" '�= described:as Lot 6,:.Block°l;��Davern's Rearrangement: � The property is ' "� �-_� � '. ....At �yx:: . . .. . .. .�.. .. .:'. �- . '.. '. � located at:1210' Randalph Avenue-;.(south side between Edgecumbe and Gri s) - x '� '� 9 -The Council`of"the City of_St �Paul has f ixed the,� �j ��,�„� - ' � ;�'`� ` in_the~Council,-_Chambers-in the:.Cit�y�E�� said" - �' '-°��,.�.;` �� '+��,�s-� City� ::and�.at:`said t�.me� and ;place;Y`the Council will hear a1T persons`=� : v�� , �: �; ° and all- ob�ectiohs and� recommendations relative to the proposed amenc7�ent � . � �_ ..� . 4 * .�, ��.. .�. . ._ .a ..� ,> .a,+ar �� Y � .s w _1�-„ i-�,*�� .�- . Dated 6 LY�CliLLJC� lY;/ I985 � j r ! ,. • r �f 4 #'7 '.y, �- � . �^ y_'. "'-'"� •4 �s .,._,y3,`' . ..:- y.�`y+w'� '�'s,• <„ � +� �nT •�`.�. p^�Y' . J ..a ir�+.,s .� �J,,.�h.s .-w..�� f r�"y"� , = .."+C-. f 4T R d"�L 2�FPtr : ..0 �N f- �' d �$ � ��!4+� - -: :_.- ... .. -t -t.+. -+t.� � Y-v t`�� s' S� i� �Yn� �" �. �� t �""'�riT�y"'�R -.A�.}J2L'� B 0130CE `� `S'�`� �r e� ' ,� +� ��",� -, _ + ,`�`'�.'�s<r�"�"' ;, °" a.. - Ciy��=Clerk y �2��:�, � �, p f _ �"�`,f;.�.�.�.t � = f `��` � �` ��:s�� .Ly . �:. 45'fi�,,��,ri.:�' R'4��. .�� J,'kf�'.'Ze�M aa � �.v^'i,. s.y� ay 'a 5 s.e. � , ,ij.. 3.1 �(y„ � ;y 4 � "aN"'St�. .��,{'°+'e4'�i . t �'� 41 � ` .�2' ., .. - „�F'��'.F�,,,�,�,� �� f,�.,� �S a�""�AR��-�� + �` '�;- �� '��s 2 -+ ; � a,� ,�, .�� l ,� j�•a s�r ., .kj e��s..Y � :� -��_ � � �(November�� 16, ��1985 a''' - -�R3 ; -�.��.��,�-- ,�� , . .a � �P '4r: "� _, f3 .�� •. �-�� ;,,. �*z r.t�'�r _ ��'R�T:, y a�t'� t�w-��-� _ '�� : - �✓ - � e�.'�.'� ' .�.r �. �r ri �� t r.�' � ��'�a, � 4 w.. f�ati � .� :C�+c��.�'�+ " .j a k t�-�k��a ' ��"{- � ��.-�'-�'.. �- "€si.'�'�°`Yv'�f . , 1-��•y�zyG'l1 �. �'�r` .�'SHCi''k .�j�..4a�.y S i �_ '�w+.�1Et�'-k.k �'�'�� i� 5 i4�' ' 9�'�«±.�._ .' �X�t�,�� .,�'y� � �'L�� : i�.'�+�t.��- � .s �hy�"`Z y�* �h� �„ �� . � �.� '� � �� . � �� 1} d�� ,- �'Mi.r'i�'�.1 *r^,` � +�� y rz s �" �t i. �' ' r�,",� -.,�' v+ wt+�,`t�''�'�'��i�v: .r`�, s'V, ',�5�,*.�v 7�'�''��o..z �i a �? :-�" .aY � �c" '""� �'� 'S"�- _ �"' � _ y.� 1 � r' t.,:7 x • � r4�'i'�.� ��R«��:� }' f.-��, ' i i � , '' 4 ��i.�� `` .�.i�_ -.. `: 'k -�""'�f �''i} G t :r � � �� r "`y. �,t -C k13; ��r � -�-7.� ��"� �n..� � � c�.f�? � _�-� �" .` � _ �:.. . +� /1�„� . 4 i �.. $ 1Yf#b. �4 R+ �� ';YiK�µ., r '�+�� . �, -:_ys it'. L +yc1 dv�+r a�,R,�.^"'ow ;�.ti. � �s`Y s �, +„c > r � YF-!@ �' �`. ''D� „� �� c v�-'�_ti q .. —'r� :�,y, n .� �,rv�.yr3 r.�..�{Jt4 . � � '�ty �'c �,.� � r�'� ."RY•'v'�-r"�'^""�" '# �Y +�a�'�i .. z'r �^a 'Y,hf��i[. a �'� .� ,�' rcLa�:��w . � ... ,.�4 ;� ,y d��<< ati, ,r+� -Y� t °.'x �i �:c 'a�"'�y�'7.�w' � }. c�l +a,i"#T � ,:,� �..�,q- AyL .`t siu.'b:.t.� �° S:a9,. il,�y r, .� ,z�g '— _ 1 ' b t� 4 'l�, .�.aY ,bi�7[�FL'rK! � � M�4 �f� ��:tCG�� ,O, �'� . �.�'t't �aY G, 7 y �A.bif,� i: 3 T� y i sF 7*��._+4+k 3K. r��a � T1Ru, �� t."�'.%R-wYY. a Y i:N1. k i`Qk ac•- : .E e ��-e:+ 't- 4 .Y �-"'�.�'�L a: .e� ��''�}, . a,J s. r _: -_+. � '-h�� z - st �. -r a ^a � :' S - t�ey�>': . :r �'-a"',r ..3f 4'°yi �c.' �� Ti94-y '�� .t rs.' .i, A > t �s'.a�y',�'1;Y �'�!. _ � .� ,a�:y,X'`'�� .3` : � '? E} �'ca�t y.�r-�.s�y�g`4#e yy _ c�Y��, t�p y�� iY'"T�-1' .� <.ti � . .G.. `<r....�'a.;_•�. 3-`"i'�y,° , . r .aa:b�'��,'"�Y � � a .�e � 3�� .iu. �... �� , n e i, � �� c, „y,. ��„�,Se 's �° '�'a..� '''�'r�r>'�» �.� -. �, . c s _: x. A 'n a z^t� �� s re.n�S�. '-, .�v ti.a -r ��,: y M i fw r n�_� �'�'�s'u a�z�. F t ��a'4„�ja�3ia�.a�i�� 4� s� �"-.�'• -� S�.r� �'r, � }, , ,� -..�5'a-e r+."" 4, y�.t�.') � �Y�^e.; 1-'�f a �'' ��"i }� �� - �-r'' � -' �'SK'�,1't �` � "' ��i5�� '�- �c„�t'i. 'l. '� . . . � iS'eF'ye,}.' �. ""' :��'�1'-�E ,��. ff .L h'�' �.,,�',+ + �3'4�"'Y'�* : yn �� , ya:'�.T��' �, ..-,e�.,�C' � '�-��''„��E _ �'d',ti�",� T .; ;.y�''s��"as� .,x�`�r 5 �t-� r�,r� ,� � "�w'' ` z '',� ,�`^ 1� n'�'�s . .,�'.. z-� V � �.. t}� .lt,f A.at�� ^�'�p"' , � M E.� t} . g.�� ,?"��a-Y...�, k� ,.y � b� �C�'.h ' Z . -S L "S .5 t �._lr.s� �� ,�`�['.�h�ida.t . Z * 'N � _� '-a ,F,_�' � �� $' .,�4 ✓ h}.1��: k �„ r`:.. � j„'.Y a..,�..,,��.aruia'+: � ,^ � '�.. � v .o¢.,yti. - �sL 3...:=.s+t. r _ 1 r,,. J � _ y �� * }�,., S � �',�� _ .,,e „y.pr Y ^r .y �"" `�-- `'y;L;"' y''^Ya,��, r75 '9 ' '^ , �� ..s-� _ , y„,`ti'�t. � - � - T :rg .b� ..�.�',�& '4 ' - . �'�-Oi"'�w. i ��fr�t5'3� �'_?.-yt 4�` r �� . �� i�- ..a.F,�` .. .r ,Ser�Y ya �. �.,r* t r -- , � �4�"��, �� S _ '�,T _ � �". - } '��`y'�"i"r-"'3 s�, i .�e._ - ,� ,. � iL � .. � ,:t.,�4- . �k1 .. -s.�' n �� >s p a ' �, 4 .`� '� � . �s rc 'ztiv{`Fn, F�� i .Y � ��a. _ ., P .a "M r � . �3.c�. ��< " � - _ . -' !: �� '�i' c , ; '� : 0. : r _ ,� '. +T �.� �: .. .. �� - . _hf.°k 'y .�•}�� . �...` .: z �"_1i�. .r '' Y A T� S , l. t . �... . ,.�. . . .,� �. _. . �' t.- . . .. . .. . � '_„ ' 'I— ...;: . ,..� .. . ,. �. .. .... _ .r. . " _ _.. .... . ,� n. .,.` ,. :..- ��. ._• . � _ ' ' : .�._ . . .:• . .. .,.. ( ,:.:� . ._ _... �.. ' .,",..- .. . �._. . � "-�,t _'. -1.,. � :.-'. -�:. . . ._,�. . . i.-, - _ - � . 3- ..� . . .� # , �.�>:' ' - - ' . �G t ; _ �r_ .� '�� «, �x o-.,� �'. `"". � '- ,� � �-� 7•• ' :� '_ : Y �� -ii$'L°`eL ' .f'4�1' r` 3 V . �.f,.;Y `1:: { .gY P y � t � y ... � - 1.i tN i� - t�'� 1� �• . < � r T. .T'�P4+5 y$.y.:f�i y�y..g.^ �,� : - '� �:� ir�e_�+`nh�-�`k 4' J .i,.'9«y .-a.' �'^� f�F� . . z �x_ i{ �.�4'e�`"A.. 7°'"�,e,�� -� V � ��•�1 a a 1 •+ Z r A`�b4r��e, � �'�wrr4�--7r"y. ,�.w�irh� i a t � i �. ��, � .-'i 1 R t�'�1'S:� 'S Yi �� . _ � �a. . .. T N � ,:^�. [°�'f.s� > . C p"t'. . .�`F+5"� a s� > � �� tc?i,�A� a at.- 'L. s _ �� .� ' � �'+�IP �j�]S�M.t�".Y�-n 5F 1•..: � ' Y�� ( �.X Y.ti�,,,��,,,��Y � � .. . . .. � ,,. Y` �s -�� iS rd'' � ,.°�. '� - - t �._ `` y' �_' ' -'='��i . �r i - ai.��' _ ` �zs� ?��,�° ¢�.., �. x ,r_ ��. x;w� �� `".,� �Y �' ` � � - �t � f �..xlr-.�4' -,-a l Hr....ca-7��r-�,��'.+�r i au � : ` .; * ��..r �: 4, �..b� ;- .F.",-'it ay...�t,; � ' f�*s hE r+, . � '�i�+r+•ji��` ��F"k `t'�r�s�f,� +;,:i dy�� .+. 2 �.' ''-. _. , -t r tr �: � e �•"§ x r�A .ki� 't n 'r�s -�w 7 4 - �a+s's!t- . t�...,�k`r`'a`R�� 'F+.� .�. �c�C�rr t,+c ryfwl+ ��F�yy +r�t`" -� '�y i _ ,.- -� �: � ^i :� �L� 's._f . -r��''�*3. �. iw w � . „}.:..'y -��d'�Ja�� _^��'A�-� -,i f .. J Y � .. \� S � - �� ,.,�+ ;tv s 'a :� z�'� rs 'qy"`C`. sµ '�'"; °s s •� Yc J'�`�Y��"°i� r�'.r'�`�.f°'�� rJ ! r ^`+j�`��ry�?� �' yr '3 bX* 'S _: � ,` ;' �.4�•,.sY �,��,�,Y "";�� ;. ' . _ _' s` d.-'+�. .. .. ._.'.g,....C� T�.,,��e ,.� -�'.' .,x ..,::: -✓ .�..�..� . ,.�. , ...�G'�,��_k�' x . .'!c`�#�.. __.ac..F-. - w . �'�:�> -i�"� � /,�--�a? 3 _ _ ,,_----- --� -- -- - � , s . _ .. . . . ., i ... j N�E�F�AQNG �E_•, - . .. . , �a- � ��,.7��Z41x8 . � . _ � �:[3:-:":<,-.".� ". ' A petition haviag been filed r�est�th�y't�e�ing 03^dinance o!t�e City I of St.Pat�1,be am�ded ao as to t�tme �-�l to'AM-Z.PropertY deacribed as ♦ Lot 6, Block 1, Dsvern's P�e�rrang�t� T!�'Pr��eG Y ia 1� at 1210 . R�dolph Avenue(south side rlgga) Council oi � the Gtty of 8t.Paul has fixed- , _` ��r.1985,at 10� .in the Council Chambgra in the City of . � p- ar:� � Council will hear all Persons and all c�i��s�. -�a ��P�,'��118t](�n�ft;..� ,f __� '-r . . 3 � t� i � �'.�RlY1t1lC!'��y ��E 'a �t; :_. _ . � AI.SERT�B:'t�I�NrGlt�.:Cl�irk ' t ..'_-, •�r � . _ � � - ,. � (xoveaab��d� � -;.: t . . ,s�r:: . . _ .. � • • • ..:--- .___..._.,..::.._._._�._�, .,,_�..........:�.,.,.. . . u.�..�.....� ,..�..,��..�,�...�.��, �. _ - ; � - _ °�� i , . - : . . . � f, - - � lst /� - e3r- ��'- . Z��u � � ��- 7-�(� -,. - 3rd / - j� - �� -7�dopted �-/(� -�(,�, : � - Yeas :Iays - DR��J �~�_ L��=�..�=�r.�� ' �� _�� S�Z � .� � . �,�#� �i.�� : � � � NICOSIA . SCHEIBEL �� n - � � 3, " _ SONNEN _ _ �:,y WILSON _. _ MR. PRESIDENT TEDESCO _ . . � . : - �--�:-=-z�x.�: _ c-,.�...�,,.-,�-�R�,._�.....�_.�-�..-�.�.�..., ,.�...��.. .�,..� . . ____ _ \ __ ___---m �_ - : ;;--. _ __ : ___-- ---- - - � . .� t � �� ,: �� - � ��, �� : �� .�; . .w: � - �:.. . _. _. - �=�: WHITE - CITV CLERK 1 PINK - FINANCE COl1I1C11 �j CANARV -OEPARTMENT GITY OF SAINT PAUL File NO. �� /�✓� BIUE i-..MAVOR A / dindnce Ordinance N�. / �3�� r Presented By Referred o Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date An Ordinance amending Chapter 60 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code pertaining to zoning for the City of Saint Paul and the zoning maps thereof. WHEREAS, Pursuant to Minnesota Statutes, § 462.357 and § 64.210 of the Legislative Code, Gerald and Sally Elert duly petitioned to rezone Lot 11, Block 17, Summit Park Addition located at 844 Grand Avenue from RM-2 to B-1 for the purpose of operating an antiques store the petition having been certified by the Planning Division on September 3, 1985, as having been consented to by at least 67% of the owners of the area of the property to be rezoned, and further having been consented to by at least two-thirds of the owners of the property situated within 100 feet of the total contiguous property within one year preceding the date of the petition; and WHEREAS, The Zoning Committee on September 19, 1985, conducted a public hearing for the purpose o� �onsidering the rezoning petition, and pursuant to Section 107.03 of the Administrative Code, submitted its recommendation to the Planning Commission that the petition be denied; and WHEREAS, The Planning Commission considered the rezoning petition at its meeting held on September 27, 1985, and recommended that the City Council deny the petition; and WHEREAS, Notice of a public hearing before the City Council on the said rezoning petition was duly published in the official newspaper of the City on October 5, 1985, and notices were duly mailed to each owner of affected property and property situated wholly or partly within 350 feet of the property sought to be rezoned; and WHEREAS, A public hearing before the City Council , having been conducted on October 17, 1985, where all interested persons were heard, and the Council having considered all the facts and recommendations concerning the petition; now, therefore, COUNCILMEN Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays Fletcher ��eW In Favor Masanz Nicosia B scnetbe� Against Y TedesCo Wllson Form Approved b ity Attorney Adopted by Council: Date Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY By Approved by Mayor: Date Approved by r for Submission to Council By By WMITE - CITV CLERK t PINK - FINANCE COUIICll / CANARy -DEP TMENT GITY OF SAINT PAUL '} BLUE f MAVO� File NO. �v /�� . O/ indnce Ordinance N 0. �7 3�� Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: Section 1. That the zoning map of the City of Saint Paul , Sheet No. 27, as incorporated by reference in Section 60.301 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, as amended, is hereby further amended as follows: That property located on the south side of Grand between Avon and Victoria (844 Grand Avenue) being more particularly described as Lot 11 , Block 17, Summit Park Addition be and is hereby rezoned from RM-2 to B-1. Section 2. This ordinance shall take effect and be in force thirty (30) days from and after its passage, approval and publication. COUNCILMEN Requested by Department of: Yeas s'��MrY�r Nays Planning and Economic Development Drew [n Favor . �A� �, �� h�� Against BY Tedesco 1Alileon Adopted by Council: Date JAN � E �� Form Approv by City At ney Certified Pas b uncil S tar BY By Approv Mayor: Date JAN 2 i )g86 Approved by ayor for Submission to Council By By PUBIl�HED ��a r� � , 1986 . . � � C�� -�7.3-=< R�6�t=! �A�. /� � 1 CITY OF SAINT P�UL a ��;��u � DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT +o ,.� DIVISION OF PLANNING +.s. 25 West Fourth Street,Saint Paul,Minnesota,55102 GEORGE UTIMER 612-292-1577 MAYOR December 17, 1985 Albert B. Olson, City Clerk Room 386 City Hall St. Paul , Minnesota 55102 Dear Sir: Attached per your letter of request dated December 4, 1985, is the proper ordinance for the implementation of the City Council action approving the petition of Gerald and Sally Elert to rezone property at 844 Grand Avenue at the southside of Grand between Avon and Victoria from RM-2 to B-1 for the purpose of establishing an antiques store. Please contact me if our office can be of further assistance regarding this matter. Sincerely, �OW hw.��.'{'S�t/ Donna Uatsko Planner II Zoning Section DD:ss Attachment cc: Zoning File #9786 � q�}x'.f �xy �.v�,P1-�� pF �x K+ �3� � �� A ? g "'ki f�` l..,� �al��` r" . � .,�. � �� T�r,�? .t's�� . ,�f�'S, ss`�+ � r�'�� ,y,�Y'�-�'��fsF �,� � F�#x�� `� NZ � � .�` d s . F YMS .� A ef ." �I: ,�c, 1 • �.�ra%,�yar��+�c�. y �.a't�` 'h.� . �;�� ., �, a:�•� .. f f �� f I y � �P�{�i� z�,p '�� ' -�r r..,,�z"� '��s.�''u: �+ �3' �' �"� :�'s��; '+ B � �",� �� „� `��yt ��1 qt,�'.aa� �y�6«'ii �. �-'� t�,�,�:`� e? ' %ry. , ',�' ` � 3w y� ��i��z*��'-c. � "k`�r,4 � � _�� .�� ,��'�t�� - � ` `i . . d �,:. '< +� � ,� � ' . � � 5 � � r . J:�� .0�t � � al�q�1 � �Y��{(� � �; �t�-µ3 Y+Y'+� . � 4 �L � . m��h. +E ,3� �� 1 .._'�, ..a. �"'��., '"ia�e�'� ,;�� Y,._- °"�,jJX�� ,. � t., � , G� � ,��`" a��.E��'�. .* S1-�� h A�y� ��1i-.. � �. �� .'�,f ":4-d #'3. � � ai'� k � "+'4�*F...,�� 3 '� t..� ��ri� � `��'��.�.� ,�c'is'� °e'3i''g� _"�.�`-.�'��,F"�� .,. .�.'� �, µ�c;'�+ . ,�s ti �� ; � ��",.� � � ;��..�^' �` e � �,� .a�' � °�.��`� �, '�.�s� �� w- ' ' �� ,� Y'��;`�'�'� ,E�"•'� s a t �� +l�„+.q�pr.. �, s ��S+n k �n . �, �„�3 ... �'� R �y , ,,� : x ' p �� 5;�`�' '�r5�'��{� �i%'� ', {�+tY,., ��.��Q',�r'it, ; � Y ��§k t f ': .?t c, �;ipp, r� {. ,P�±d �k,g� ''� . �� 7 r rt *�#�'�` ` ��'r'� 1 ' � ++ a �7 � �j{ J�i��"��"`�� '�/`�``£�?,�^`'zs`�'� i„n "'`" -rw* `�"� �• +�'-: t :� ` � �� . � "� � +�. � ��,.� "�+� r� �''. t� �'�� t.: e i a ,-. ,� : : e,� : , '. . .�.., ,.<,_ '��{� �;'f�'� � Y+. 3 V� � � �,L 7� i� �p��z�� ..� f _. �. 'e �F� k - ,9t�. '• �� '�. � ��,� � ��'�'p``P °� :.,� -•5. '� •,hr , Kr•l• -$ 4j11 �h. �' -'�[ � ��"V�� Y ? F ��$� �� .:�&L � �Y � ,, t ,�,7i� ��r� �tz'��.3'tv `� ��a t �e ';,'4 i �� s >b^S _ ,�"'� c�` � �' 3 ' . xa y,;e '� �� ,r �� s��h[3:`�k �,,�;�.�.. � ,P� �� s?�.,�'*} _ $.� �� + ,.r m �rv. �F. Z � T��., �{� :� " ��.•* ..- rv F ' ,�4� �. 3L.. � �� Y 9 1 �,g��M�? e�* '� Ty�yt � / k �{ .b� �' �. 4"�r �� "�' ��v ."�'F'fa"` �.. � �. r�` �� .5, °�'��.'a�� • ��,� i„t,� �� §,,}� . �� y .5�� .�'� �4� � 4 :� �< � ��{� �;�� M � � ' y ,�, '}��y 'nox g a�� ,�.� ..:� � ' �'�� r7 G ��"�"*'�t �y x� �'�g�. � �,z�� r c,. �� Y°� �i r��.y� �` �4�� d.� :�- ��,, i y,'� �,�:�: xe �'��.`'��a�,,� �:�r. �� 1 �� '� .8 � � : � 2. �i Q' ,5 Q.. . � t � .� '?C Yc � .{2 .�p, ? : <,y� 4��ir6a.la �In^i �i`s'y p � , �� "`� p, . . +,�'� .# �. � `M',�ii '$'�-��? . 1 �+" � �c� ,y y. . r� y�'#�� '`�� rt7 � ,a Y,,.k, :.r.ir a�`�'� _�,«,� y� 3A',,� 1J ;.: �` € ��xs� �� , � i��, �� { i a ._� �� ;�.�ty � � �r'�'��.�}�r �a � ��,`�, t �'� � y � '� .' $ .°�t,� 6 3..�h.��' '3�ar�,' � r t�'° � i��a��.q'�"it�- � y'.?+ r�s �.. -i..• �� t i., k �. y ,_,� fi 4 ea�R z �Y . ,y.�, .ry ,w ''�- �:"�'� La F # �Tint � ,�t��3�� z,(''"R �r ' .n � �' t��., � . 4�l"rF, .: � r�' .¢s ..£+ X �� . L a � ,� �;j .t 1, `�. x s s��a,-k . +..ysj" . Y 1 . � � 3r' .� .,rE+ �,„ g ,� ,t � 4., �`� �� `a �"3��sQw .i� . ��A 3 �'n '��"�k`t+'�i�� £ i�,"�dc.�.��}.��'� a��..q. .:E�s "� r . � � !. ��'�� a "�°x��ik� ��',��', `� '�y��s.�3 _ � �vt��°.�.�'�w'`��.�.,� ¢ '"t�`�' �� . A �' �' �'- , ran,fi �,x� �� !"9`�r ' b a. �,-,f a ,f, :t'�a.�t�' � e ��..� ' , ',�c.a -!��' �< � ��' a �,�'�' � �;;?x��`,y �, , r;,�{ � r,. ,•1�,� � +'� ��°�'� �r�� `r� ? t;•' � F�,�i�x"S _ ,'vy. r+. .1�. '.r„° 3,"Y�w` R �� mk ��?�. t� '`'4;. � �+. . � ,{- � „w�} � a, f� '� �'�3' i,�. .� it�h*-�n.��i �..,,P�.4?�,' y r ..?x r� �"�'y � � , , 7� � � , a. t rs ^` r� '"�;L,��$�� , 'y� �'��i�t„�t �� c.. d��'> 5z '� ^ ��y i�F t • �,' .., t '�,,., :s�� r K�� . ° 'ak ��'�^}., �n�.�.,��?�x �J v..� ��w�r';.�� " � *�.'. ��nz�. � � �+3� 3� i rK .._ � �� _ y. � � � ��" � ,� �y-,+ �, r n„m�r n,... � . i�+ .�T7:� � � kT J �y" '" t a'��L 4'x''�c. �"��-0 �.q��*f �4 ,��'�� "� �� T � ^ t . x � � ? u a t . 9l f � '� � ,� r� "t .��,T � �i.c�, � � �tt .,s� '�';"s •y . `� Y,��,�'9�'i��k�V�.,+ h �- a �i"�y��"�� til' � m l +��"w r `_ �i+ �,+q�� <° ,n, ' " ..k -sy` ,,� '��",r.'' �t �> u��r ��`'i�"-n��S�,�� m.y* a$` ;,� a 'T ,¢y, a � � ':� � ; - �;,74 "��`�+.;`�� y�,��r � � � � .� "�r �, ��`, $°� � i . * �` � � '� "�`a�,�ar �.�n� ��"��.rF"�� - � . r�jpi` z�y�� ,�. � � Y�>�„ g� ��{�,�� _'� "�� .t'�s�,.:� �,�, .n '��s � fi��X�`� y.� �� .�T,.,x .wa � �'�y. � � �d - � h f x 5..�;;; ''S, y� � �"^ ,4} �i�✓ .�y 4t'r'a� �.��F , '� ,. �� _ z"�.. . }' � �'"�x�f'�'��'.'`�',,��, �w`',�"k�y �` � � �+ � � �k a-�: �i� `,. / ' " x � i ., a ,. t 3t F�. a x � L ��' ��.- �P � '�' �- a � x � � ��•� �"� �. � � � �,,;�''�-�u"�^�� "��: �� ri� ' "�� ''< e"'� r `�' '' '�S.`r�f�� ` � r�.',l�-''% "� .< � :x � . . # f - � ae`w; ��itir�'�6 "�°#�� ;�,�,�.x�r'�a�, � p`,tiv +� '� � � t £ P . �,r r 1'��'�d�4' �d � �'`+ #-..- l' g�'!': � ��':- t1 F# �y,xn ,r . sr' ,:.g+. ., w, . . . � t :.t a F�� '�, y � ' +t`' ,� iy`� �, , '4- ' �� » .� w . <<r�y`(r.�, }� , rxy�q,��!f�.. � ,� �5 we �....� �' � , K^� �. v�`3 y r ^{_5 y��r�j�q�y.' �,� .NVY e'�r � Y x .r� s .� t , �� '�., ; ��.r'�xX s�. .,.f � - q z:q�' : r � .nt^ � 3i, �. ar!n � 5 _ r .. � .�.�x y ' f - �. �-t..�. � ��,�}i ��u,,. �i�y r �� ` �,.t �o�'�' ..,..h� rt��..• �� 1 .Z' ,�. "�x z F 1 , '"� q4� . �,� Y � �Yz '� �'*q 4 �7' { -, - +k ^.ti�i� k� °r9'�i �,�� K �"`�s�l� �s,t'� - r� _ ^3� �X �P . ��` �. �.�`� �,� .r . .�kv�,,�c. . �'�t�'.r ;�'`�� ;* , � y �' � � b ��„��'�' �y;r� � v � y 2 ,. , '�. � .�+v� f J,; • < � � s �w t,� �r 'n � i � .. '>'�'z�� -�'��` ' ��'�'-�� a 4as��`��i S a t�r� �� '"K '� .7#E �..- � � i �' G•, - .. k � �«. �� . 3 '�7 r �v �ttii'`� �, x� � r c�y�� -��b �� yn `��, '� � t�� z '�'' �s �: _ §'�.� �.;,,+� � -�.. 5`�?�. � .� r�t d > r � .�, �-., .�� w� � �� r„ �t"�� r. ,,�SRz '.}'7- s� �.;'� fi" >'i ti�� r 7', .� � '# i "#�i ' � w-� z �,`�'�„�`�°�: '7' a t� ",�9 �' x �.} �k.nr�e° r„�a.!� �' •r �� Y � � ,� 5'��s �'e 4 � � � ;"s x x.'� � ,�" °',� �� = �F#"--x*.� �4,w. F r�t�MF'Y��_+��„'r.,d�� p.n�'�� ,.3+"��,°��#��,� .�" ��..n�'�' ��+,,�, .�• , •, . •' h. +.Y� . �� ,�w: f � �� uX"�ti.r� k�q� rt � }, . �,�a 'fi��t� r.. ,h �,a.� ; �, rp! � . � K� .�fr., }� ..y { � µ t ��:�> f °4 � � 1C.. d �, 3. �:, ,� � � s f �.M a v C �a ::I�q� {' ,� r9�' r2�f' �' . �� . .� �,•"cx�°��^F a � ."9,� d � « . j f � � �'�.� � '� � T ?.�` ,y,' ° 7 'q' z, s+i�'3�5�� tW"r� r �,'4 C 7 ��. k��¢- 'v �.yk - �,4f' Y�'�i,t` a� � '�:9^s �? �� w � �� 1 R t,�' y y �;� F v4y F�y:".� �fcK ��".�r�$�Iy�. �ti r �`1��+3''C�'*€+.,y `�� r '�' �� t�'Ei��4 r r �� f� �,� � �� k x.'f{ t �c�„p '` �%t 4�..:. ��i.� � �;�y�i,'�� `�"�y¢ ��,;,fl a;t `:� .+�� t'y�;y .. . y�� t'��t k ��r�.��:='�a i�tF�fl� .� �. r ��'`s � a�a�, .k-�'`kM ;3r"� ,�,�� ., y,i�,�rR. �'�S.` t � a° t � �v x � ., o p�^�i X��& +.`"�,�"�, x � �4.eF.� L .# �`�... f � �"� �� ' �Y''. 1 � ��..FS `��;� t"'° ,�� x`��"�S� � i�.�� R�` �` � `x ".�'�'g`s t ' ,S� �r :� � ;.. .'�r,,�^ � �. s�k x ' �, �` - / � �'r� h F�':r t'"+${° r �°� -c s.. 't� ra,�. �,.G ��'`��.,�<�. �'y . �i ��.� �t�;�€^� d:i„ tray°.�y`�.1`��;-,�,,� �„` �� a .,.�r ry � � a �.,,�dhh > � � ^„h ,�A � x,�, sa � ��. , �,_�. . '� ry' ,ya�!iY Y..i7 $� / � k �.t. � +L4 'Y 5 ff-1 s'f �'s� L �", m{f =a� �'�`'�.�'� r �'',� �''� *3 x Ns�;*5 +�, :r "`,� ?'�. s � ��'S'� '. '�, �� > 4 �� '^f �. � � � � � y.,,i � . . , . :_. °s �' � �V.. �y Y �a�c ,��4 'r e e 'r'e £ �"�_� '� iy�� t . ��,r�.,�� +,� �._� .,;r+.�3..� . , . � s.� �.�5 .. � �" �,." ' � s y�'� �y��r �"�� r :�6` P �,' �- .�y��e x.,� &c=�,r . v" .� � 4 .4�'''��'� ,�� +�`` "1 tt d. , b . . �s s ; �� S 5� � � t F�$''• � � _ .. f ��, +. � • �� g ' r �y� ��' h�{��e xgn a � t,. � S�aJ,TT" y(7 � . n" � 4 � � `'k n �i � �y� � I�Iy.,'�� , '� 'fj �d`y . � .� .L . � � K ry� ''��_ '2 k`� ��.,�.r: � ,�+��A �: � �� `"y��'�ri"i��.��1�'7`w� �.-��' x'�,'�!"'�'e� �` �e ,� � +��p.,� 1��. �w a. Ye� : � v�, T"a, a c« ��','.a �'ant� .'r .t �,,s ,, .y �.� .� �}� � ; �t }1} � � �� '��`'�, t .. • ,,.' °. " � �� " +f�. �,�,q� : �� " � a`tMY x � k,��c ��, �� ,�:� �. � � � y � 9?�,, .y�. ,,�t,� a'"�a" � r� p `li�R "'� Mp.� r �'z.�� tt�'u �'�2"� ,� _�,�.. sE?f.. . .�` � ' `�c...:,j' :aE ��:.��. ..r� �:�' , �..`'.�.<!..'�aT•,wrr�u."`�.�'taEB,a .:. :,1,'�.+e�'c�+','.:�,a`.'i1�,:.z�;s. .+.�.:��.�:1��ta��' „r� . . . .. . . � . � ��- ��.� �� ; C� '�, STATE OF MINNESOTA ) County of Ramsey ) ss. CITY OF SAIIJT PAUL ) �� Albert B. Olson I, • • • • • • • • • . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .City Clerk of the City of Saint P�ul, Minnesota, clo hereby certify that I have 85-1732 compared the attached cop�T of Council File No. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . - as adopted by the City Council. . . . . , , ,January.l6� . . . . . . _ .ig �6 . . . and approved by the Mayor. . . . . . . . . . . . .January.21: . . . . . . . . 19 86 . . . with the original thereof on file in my office. I further certify that said copy is a true and correct copy of said original and the whole thereof. WITNFSS my hand and th2 seal of the City of Saint Paul, Minnesota this . . . . . .��}. . . . . day of . . . . ,Februar�, , , , ,A.D. 19 86 . . . . , . . .��C��. .�. . ��. . . . . . . . . City Clerk. �, ,:: � �:.. . , • �:�� :� � r , p7 3 V t ') I �j �'' ' �? s � it" 1 I C.�� 1-.-_�_. .,. ' f.,,. f ,-� ;r� � w'. bf _ . F r 3i.� � _�:•.�f�tiC f�'."_J 'l:;.'— L�l�.,.c+,7�r .iC�..'tRl `