85-1336 WH'TE - CITV CLERK
PMK -�FIN,�VCE COUIICII �?
CANAR+1' - DEPARTMENT GIT`� OF SAINT PAUL X
BLVE -MAVOR File �O. " �- j-33��
• � /
indn Ordinance N 0. ���� Y
Present By
�
�.
✓ Referred To L�= Committee: Date l �� 3 ���
Out of Committee By Date
An ordinance amending Chapter 26 of the
St. Paul Administrative Code pertaining
to mandatory retirement for employees
in the uniformed division of the Fire
Department
THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF 5AINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN:
Section l .
That Section 26.02 of the St. Paul Administrative Code
is amended to read as follows :
"26.02. Findings of fact. Based upon evidence and
testimony submitted to the city council , the council
hereby makes the following findings:
(1) `Phe duties of firefighter require that fire-
fighters be in excellent physical condition.
(2) The duties of firefighter require that fire-
fighters periodically must be able to
perform severely strenuous acts in the
course of firefighting and life saving.
(3) The normal operation and primary purpose of
the fire department is to provide for the
safety and protection of the citizens of
the city and would include the duties set
forth above.
COUNCILMEN
Yeas Nays Requested by Department of:
Fletcher
Drew In Favor
Masanz
Nicosfa A gai ns t BY
Scheibel
Tedesco
Wilson
Form prov d by City Attorney
Adopted by Council: Date
Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY �
By
Approved by Mayor: Date Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
gy By
. . . ' . ' oP�' /33�
. , ..
- � . � . ��o y
(4) The failure of a fireman to perform his
duties could mean the difference between -
life and death for the citizens of Saint
Paul .
(5) There is medical evidence that there is a
relationship between advancing age and the
physical inability to respond to the needs
or duties of firemen.
� (6) There is medical evidence that there is a
relationship between advancing age and the
mental inability to respond to the needs or
duties of firemen.
��� A-x�ar��a�e�}-�e���ex�e��-age-e€-6�-€e�-���er�e�
• �s-a-be�a-€�de-eee�ga�}e�a�-Qt�a��€�ea�}e�
�eeessa�}-�e-�i����-p�e�ee�-�ke-p�epe���r-axid
p�b��e-sa€e��s-e€-��e-e����e�s-e€-��ie-e���:
��� �l�e�e-�s-�e-a��e��a���te-pe��e�-wl��e�-eet���
be-es�ab��s�ie�-b�-�l�e-���3�-a�d-s����-�t����
-�.r_- . ----��e�ee�-�l�e-g�e�e��3s-a��-pt�b��e-sa�e�}-e€
��ie-e���se�s-e�-�ke-e��3r�
(7) That the Federal District Court has determined
that a mandatory retirement age of 65 is a
bona fide Occupational Qualification for all city
employees in the uniformed division of the fire
department employed in the position of firefighter,
fire equipment operator, and fire captain, but
that a mandatory retirement age of 65 for fire
• chief and district chief is not a bona fide
Occupational Qualification.
(8) The primary duties of district chief and deputy
chief are that of supervision, but such employee
can be called upon at any time to perform the
duties of firefighter, fire equipment operator
or fire captain, and the judgment and decisions
of a deputy chief or district chief can affect
the safety of fellow firefighters and citizens , �
and a mandatory retirement age of 70 for such
positions would be in the best interest to .
fully protect the property and public safety of
the citizens of the city.
-2-
WHITE - CITV CLERK
PflVK � -rFINANCE GITY OF SAINT PALTL Council �] ,/y
CANARY -DEI�ARTMENT File NO. u�+ - /33�
BLUE - MAVOR
•
O Zn nce Ordinance N 0. `��4�
Presented By `� /
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
(9) There is no alternative policy which could
be established by the city and still fully
protect the pr�perty and public safety of
the citizens of the city.
Section 2.
That Section 26. 03 of the St. Paul Administrative Code is
amended to read as follows :
"26.03. Mandatory retirement age. A mandatory
retirement age of 65 for all uniformed fire
employees in the positions of firefighter, fire
equipment operator, and fire captain, is hereby
established pursuant to the above findings. This
act requires that all employees in said positions
�k�e-r�r�}�e�x�ed-�}�e-�}�}s�e� must retire on the
first day of the month immediately following the
month in which the employee reaches age 65 , �1�}s
p�e�}s}er�-s�a��-be-e��ee���e-as-e�-��ie-e€�ee�}�re
da�e-e�-�1�}s-ekap�e�.- A mandatory retirement age
of 70 for all uniformed fire emplo ees in the
positions of district chief and deputy chief is
hereby established pursuant to the above findings
Thls act requires that a11 employees in said chief
positions must retire on the first day of the
month immediately following the month in which the
employee in said chief positions reaches age 70 "
Section 3.
This ordinance shall take effect and be in force thirty (30)
days from and after its passage, approval and publication.
COUNCILMEN Requested by Department of:
Yeas ����� Nays
Drew �- in Favor
Masanz a
Nicos�a Against BY
Scheibel
Tedesco
Wilson
N�V — � �g85 Form Approved by City Attorney
Adopted by Council: Date
Certified Pas e by ncil Secre BY
B �
Appr y Mayor: Date / �� �OV`— � �585 Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
�
By BY
PUBIISHEO N0V 16 1985
��,..- �\ ' . . �� l ,� • � � �2"'-�✓� r
�"=i--�.;..:=F�, �I2�'� O 1+� .S.�ZNT �.t1�7"L o.�/7�3
.�:,. . �
~'yi�;` ;�� �,:., �
:,.:_�`.----�=�;�` ��', orrxcr ox�� . _ , „
- ���:._.._�,.:� �l �n�: cx��- coII�c��
=z;, . •::�,:;:
:�, ���,:.�..,.:::�:� ���� . .
_.�;., . :�_.:._;: �ti .
�;�:�• \ - :�,1;/ �d fi e • October 10, 1985
�``�.;��:- _ . . . .
. .:..
-C:O,i�i i�.(�.?' E E� 4�_E__P O �T
T� = SQjn� P� a� I Cifiy Cosa � �il . � . .
F P► � ��} % C O t��3 t��'�� O i�! FINANCE, AIANAGEMENT $ PERSONNEL
� � C N A l P.�� James Scheibel �
i . Approva 1 of mi nutes f rom meet i ng hel d October 2, 1985. �!'�����►�' .
/ � � .
2. Ord i nance amend i ng Cf�apters 369, 37Q, ancf 310 of the Leg i s lat i ve Code perta i n i na to
building trades business licenses and certificates of competency. (Community
Serv i ces) . (La i d over f rom 9/26/85) �P��� .
3. Resolution amending the 1985 budget by transferring $965.00 fram Contingent �;�`��3�4��
Reserve-Specified to General Govt. Accounts-Surety Bond Premiums. (Finance Dept.)
4. Resolution authorizing an agreement with Zimmerman Realty for rental of office space
. at 195�+ University Ave. for Publ ic Nealth Division. (Health Deot.) ��'���
5. Resolution consenting to the issuance of Port Authority lndustrial Development Revenue
Bonds in the amt. of $765,000 to finance construction of an office, manufacturin�
and warehous i ng faci 1 i ty for EMC Corp. at York � Case Ave. P{ED) (�1����'
� 6. Resolution consenting to the issuance of Port Authority I�dustriai Development Reven�E
• Bonds in the amount of $2,4b0,000 to finance construction of an office, production
and storage facility for Merrill Corp, in Energy Park. (PED� ��j���
7. Discussion of financing package for Block L (KTCA) . Jl?'� E�`ct'►T'Ib�•
8. '(}rd'+n�r1�lt.-aaafq�i►c�g Ch�,pter 26 of the Adm i n i s trat i ve Code perta i n i Rg to mandato �� �
r�,���t far �p��yees in tFt� c�niformert d�v'isimn 'of the fire Dept• (�ire' Dept. "'
MOOT ISSIJE TO BE REMOVED FROM COMMIT7EE LIST OF ITEMS TO BE DEALT Wt�TH:
Ordinance pertaining to the hotel-motel tax and use of funds by the Civic
Center Authori ty. _ ��U�',p � ��,�1.l,1V� �p� �.�57`•
CiTY HALL SL•VEN7'H FLOOI: � • � �
SAINT P�1UL, riI�\ESOT�� 55I0_
. . . _ � ��-�--,�.��
• f����
Fr�. ,� � CITY OF SAINT PAUL
�::;;;� � OFFICE OF T33E CI�.'Y COIINCIL
i
Committ�� �epart '
F':i�an��� �Iana�ement. & Personnel C�mmittee.
October 31, 1985
1. Approval of minutes fxom meeting held October 25, 1985. �°PR��
�,
2. Resolution amending the 1985 budget by decreasing $40,000 from Financing Plan
and adding $8,600 to�he�S�pend�g Plan or Alarm Lice�e�A�ctivities � Penalties.
c_���su��o`�
3. Ordinance and accompanying resolution allowing the transfer of benefits, equal
to benefits in St. Paul, from any public system to St. Paul in cases of
unclassified appointments. �(lpV£�,
4. ��q n�',ng Chapter 26 of the Admin. Code pertair�ing to ml�dator � ��
re'Cirem�"t��""�or employees in "�he u�ifor�d. divisfon of th`e Fire Dept:��-�� R��a�?
5. Resolution amending the 1985 budget by adding $1,500 to the Financing Plan and
Spendi.ng Plan for City Clerk!s Office-Elections � Voter Registration. R�+P(�V£t�
6. Resolution amending the 1985 budget by transferring $10,000 from Contingent
Reserve to Public titi'orks-Traffic Operations � Maintenance. ��°��
7. Resolution amending the 1985 budget by transferring $3,600 from Contingent
Reserve to General Govt. Accounts-Citizen Committee Restricted Parking. �'��
8. Resolution amending the 1985 budget by transferring $7,235 from Contingent
Reserve to PED-PED Contribution. ��£O.
9. Resolution amending the 1985 budget by transferring �6 from Contingent
Reserve to Police Dept.-Buildings/Niaintenance. ��ed `� �6�67S.ao �'°����.
10. Resolution authorizing an agreement with the State Dept. of Health ivhereby the
City will administer a WIC Program (Women, Infants F� Children Supplemental
Food Program.) �P�Di1Sc�
CITY HALL SEVENTH FLOOR SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA 5510?
�,g
WHITE - CITV CLERK
PINK - FINANCE GITY OF SAINT �AUL COIIIICII �� � /`AA ^
BLUERY - MAYORTMENT � i�
File N 0.
Valuationsy—tRoom 218 �� /LE "l R so �Z n
(MdsPk)
Presented By
Referred To Committee: Date
�
Out of Committee By Date
RF.SOLVID, that upon the petition of the City of St. Paul for the vacation
of Mounds Park Elementary School Site per file No. 24-1984 that part of the
public property bounded by Fbrest, Pacific, Cypress and McLean hereinafter
described, be and the same is hereby vacated and discontinued as public
property:
Vacated alley accruing and Lots 1, 2 and 3, McLean's
Reservation and Lot 4, Block 6 Kendrick's Rearranc�►nent
of Blocks 4 and 6 McLean's Reservation, St. Paul, Minn.,
also
Lots 21, 22, 23 arx3 24 and vacated alley accruing in
Kendrick's Rearrangement of Blocks 4 and 6, 1�Lean's
R�eservation to St. Paul, Minn.
Subject expressly to the follawing conditions and reservations:
l. That the vacation be subject to all the terms and oonditions of
Chapter 130, codified March l, 1981, of the St. Paul Legislative
Code, as amended.
2. That a specific easement b�e retained within the vacated area
to protect the interest of Northern States Pawer Campany
Flectric Division.
3. That the City as petitioner not be required to pay oanrpensation
for the vacation.
4. That the property be disposed of pursuant to Chapter 51 of the
City of Saint Paul Administrative Code.
CQUNCILMEN Requested by Department of:
Yeas Drew Nays �
Masanz In Favor
Nicosia .�
Scne�bei Against BY �
Sonnen DireC_ to�
�esea ��3
W�ison �CT � � Form Approved by City Attorney
Adopted by Council: Date ie�`�'� � c /� /7 ������
?/1� ( I/
Certified Pa s Council ta BY � 3 �^�
gy,
l� —� ��I � �} 1985 App y Mayor for Submis � n t Council
Approved by Mayor. a —
gY�_�__ ` By �`-�
PUBL9SH�� ��� � :' i��;�
� � �; ,, . s � . . �.�� s
. R� + . S ! . e f ��� �, t' , ,4�. . ''� f ._ . ������, �.
, .. . ��'� d��•� _ ' ' 3 �
i �t
:1 s � \ `. r '�
' �. } • ; ��
. 1 i r i j cs- � y�'�} T �i P
. i� ,�` � ' r�
; . .
" � � i
� - d a. i � 3 a�f
� .,� . . ��� . � � � � � � � � � ��
A i , �
,.� R � �..� r.i� �. " � �
. M' � 1' x E��`. .. F.
' • 1 �,� �� 1, s
� ��/�PlM7/ ��F �� � � ' _ � � y t`h,�. �..t�` ir �`
J ��� � -�� _ _ i� �� �
./, � . Y , ' .y �k' .' � n,� R F.
J � SF� �t �
.. I: .'�i ' �1 � $ � a�.: �/ �'
.. . . ' . -.. -. :
. . '.: x ,y, ._ . .'. ,.:
!. L \ i, �
n'�k" 't `' ' �' � ' ��� �{ ���
�� W• �_`A�4.L��� ��� � ' � w �., ',
,r ���,�,,L�Nr� - � ry r `. � ; . r; � � :` A ,�� �+. y�
�R� ��f��►j� ^�!�1�i � � � ��.; ;'� �"`,
.
i '''i � W i
, , . � ,,.,_
, _ � � •. .
,.
,. . . �
. �.r� _ ''S��'� �. ,a,�
���+,1�• � .\ x_ � _ E� y
` . �- � : . :� t `. :
` �� C�.t�.,y��'ti�A4�`'�� 3��r��',�•�1K t'����'S,p� � t �
`" �����`���► � s�c�' t`e�1c>� v�9�ti.w� � �s � P�,' ,� t:
, � _
` � �i'��i�i�.M {.,� x r' �') sf�l �4
.
r ,
.
, ,, .� ,� ., y .: " :
. . � . .. .. ,� �
.1 ..
.
. . � ,.. r��. �� .. . ,. .
"
, � „ . .�. �.� , d � 'r t
.
;: '�.... �. :'.
� �'.. � . ..-��. . .�.:: � �. ,.. .
� ��.���.���' �y 4 -" r t '�� r 1-'� h� y 8
_
'
,.
z
1. � ,�;, , ... .-' - � y2 �.�
�.
. :. . . . ..-,.,: -. ,. . . .: . . .,...
�
; .., . �,,. � .: .�F� �
..
.;.;. . , . ; : . , . . : r.t� - ���
. . :� _� _ ��.
.. . -., ,., . , ,
� .
..� , _ �, . .. _
, . ti
. � . ��, , a . .
,�.
- .
. �.; . �- � - - =�::,
, ��. . . w �.s , �-, �
- �> . ..�. . �_ N, ti� � � -�k
. , . . ... „ , ..
.. _ �5r 6� �r fl �z
'T�"'"'�� �i..� w = � l � � �t:� y.• i � x t �.r
�� ��; �� y � 4
ti i �'� � + '��
., 1 :
• }. i t , � � < <� a�'i
' �. �, r
� �1t�c,y'. '} � t 1 r
.,.. :: ... ,.. ; , E
�.
.
. � . .. '
.
��.. ' ., .. . , �,.
7 � �Y f .I � ` * , �..
� p:r ' �[��y���� { - �' � � a r c r �, ...,1
— �� � �y�RM� 1 >b i �S
' �.�F y � ; � Mt ' �S � 2 x r �a
. x t .l�," i� +. yx a;
a� ;� x 1 v z-: r � •'
i x �'�* � t ',� .� �ti
1" i '�.� a� � �' :r
� / ar' h'r' i�,
I . ' .' n(� F.:.
, ,' .i ti � 3 � � �` A ' � �� r � � 4, �'
,�. `�� • . ' r, r` ;
•�'�_. �� � _ t f 1Y" Y�.
't'.. i a w;,-.. �'..' . � ,�i'
�. -
� _
-, ., �,� „ ., s .j.. ..- ,. �,
� � ���� :�L �"� � �i 4 W� ` �r,
� � . . _ 1� .� ,�, ,.r
> � � '' > � r r ,��� � ,xs �,`
; -
, , . .,. ;.
• , : . � s�
I 1^ �. R 6
.. . `� . \ '}. ^.7 ,�.. � +..i
� "
4 . ''�.,_ ; ��;..
�' , � µ t :yi � , � f. � p_
'�� � . �
i
. . .. . .. . . .
.
_
_
i .
... . - . . . . .
. � � . . .. . . .
i , . �7� ._,. . . .
, .
.
. .
.
.. . .. .. .. . . . . . . . .. . .
. .
_ .. . . . . . . . .. � . .
. . _ . . . .. . .
. �;,, _ .l y, 7�?
, ,
� � �� ��:` r
:
,; :
�( �-' . � � � � ����
� � y� 4r� t ' }' r. � �r;
� � � r ;�r t t i; � .
i�' � k i. x 1, 'nl
, ; `gx' ,�., e � , '1'� n,
: � � t � t{
� � � , i � `.�+ P + " � t ,
. : . . . ..; P: .:r
. . . • .. __, � , - ,._ �: r . . G. _ .. �..-:`� �. , _ _t . . , ti a., , .. _. _ u-,,r.
�.�=�3.�3-
• � �- I a�
,,�I''��.� CITY O1�' SAINT PAUI. ���� , �
�
~ � y OFFICE OF THB MAYOR � ���
� 's a
o a
t � .. ` ����!���;.�� : \�
'' Zii�i t t�u � P
::� ` 10
�o „Q - ,���N 2 —
+sa• 347 CITY HALL " --
SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA 55102 � T; > >985�► '"
GEORGE LATIMER (612) 298-4323 � �/�0��/ T��$N , 'j
MAYOR
� CC��
June 26 , 1985 n; �
re: Vacation o nds Park
Elementary School Building
Council President Victor J. Tedesco
and Members of the City Council
7th Floor City Hall
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102
Dear Council Members:
���e Saint: Pa.u� City �ou�cl rec -'��e�c3 to my .office
�"`p��ipos��i �re�so�n��.o�t- whi� would autMc�'�ize`'th�:C�.ty to .p��eec�
w''�'th -tk�� ,uaGation• a�,d dis sition of the Mon�ds Park Elemen-tar�
�__
'�'ch�aa� sa.te._.;�I., have_ s.�gne � �es�o�.ution,� 3z��-��.th the,�
�OZ�i�W2�'1CJ ��SE�'VFdt7.0325. r
I have visited the facility many times . As you know, the con-
dition of the structure is substandard in the extreme. I
have reviewed the inspection reports prepared by Community
Services' Housing and Building Code Division, and preliminary '
estimates on the scope of �he �aork necessary to insure building
code compliance and provide structural and physical safety to
the users.
After reviewing these items, I believe that the reuse of the
structure as an educational and/or neighborhood facility is
questionable. The structure is both antiquated and physically
deteriorated. The location is not central to either neighborhood
or citywide access. The overall cost, including the fair market
value of the building, land and repairs would represent a
formidable obstacle to a potential developer.
I do, however, recognize the fact that there has been considerable
discussion between the neighborhood residents, Red School House
staff, staff of various City departments, and a public hearing
has been held on the matter by the City Council. I, therefore,
believe that it would be inappropriate to delay the vacation
and disposition process at this time . In light of the above-
referenced condition of the building, I also encourage the Red
School House to continue to explore alternative locations should
the Mounds Park building prove to be infeasible.
V ry trul ours,
Geor e La imer
May
Attachment
��.�e
Finance & Mgmt Services DEPARI�MENT � �'33'� N� 2179
.
Dick McCann ' CONTAaT
298-531:] � PHONE j
May 29, 1985 DA7E � 1 e�� e�
ASSIGN NUMBER FOR ROUTING ORDER Cli Al1 cations for Si nature :
�Department Director �' 2 Director of Management/Mayor
Finance and Management Services Director 4 City Clerk
Budget Dil^eCtor I 3 Councilman Nicosia
City Attorney �
WHAT WILL BE ACHIEVED BY TAKING ACTION ON T E ATTACHED MATERIALS? (Purpose/
� Rationale) :
Adopt resolution vacating Mounds Park E1 �CVSchpol site approved by the
Csuncil on May 16, 1985 , c u
AY 3 �:� i985 �� � �'�.�
���YGR S OFFiCE
�
I
COST/BENEFIT, BUDGETARY AND PERSONNEL IMPAC�'S ANTICIPATED: ,,,,,,_ REC�II�FD ..r
To be offered for sale by the Cfty at a m�nimum price of $90,600. M AY 2 9 198i
�
i OFFICE OF THc DI�?FCtOR
' DEPARTMENT nF Fi��A^��'E
I '1�1ND MANAGEbiEN7 SEr24'1„iS
�
FINANCING SOURCE AND BUDGET ACTIVITY NUMBER �CHARGED OR CREDITED: (Mayor's signa-
ture not re-
Total Amount of Transaction: quired if under
i $10,000)
Funding Source: '�
Activity Number: 00250-2833-000 �
ATTACHMENTS List and Number All Attachment
1. Resolution
�
. i
I
�
i
DEPARTMENT REVIEW I� CITY ATTORNEY REVIEW �
x Yes No Council Resolution Required? � Resolution Required? Yes No
Yes x No Insurance Required? i Insurance Sufficient? Yes No
Yes X No Insurance Attached:
(SEE REVERSE SIDE F�R INSTRUCTIONS)
Revised 12/84 II
• - . 1 ' .. � .. .._... .
��� ��
� .t
; re _
, . __
, .
_. . _ �°
_ .__.. . . _ --
�!
_ � _ . _ , _
_ .._ _ ..._ ....__.. ............
��t �`�/,� ��,�g ._ � . �� •� �
-2nd, � Q�-�'�._� _.�.�s�-. .
3rd• � �D --a�-�S Adopted /O - 02 D
�`dJ
Yeas Nays
DRLW
MASANZ
NICOSIA
�- � `���
SCHEIBEL l7�Q�
SONNEN
. � jJILSON _. --- -
MR. PR�SID�NT TED�SCO '
,f����� '_
1� �j :
<,.�
/,��� `
J �
,:�J��