85-547 WHITE - CITV CLERK �
PINK - FINANCE G I TY OF SA I NT PA U L Council �,,� ���
� CANARV - DEPARTMENT
BLUE - MAVOR File NO.
�
Co cil Resolution
. ,
Presented By
Referred o Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
WHEREAS, Mary C. Schnaith (SBD#153) has submitted the attached
proposed lot split for City Council approval; and
WHEREAS, the Departments of Planning and Economic Development and Public
Works have reviewed the attached lot split at 1165-1167 Bush and 1161 Bush
described as:
Tract A (1165-1167 Bush): "Lot 22, Block 3, Terry's Addition, except
the West 5.55 feet thereof;"
Tract B (1161 Bush): "Lot 21 and the West 5.55 feet of Lot 22, Block
3, Terry' s Addition, except the West 16,587 feet of said Lot 21,
subject to an easement over the West 3.9 feet of the South 82.15 feet
of the above de�cribed tract;" and
WHEREAS, the proposed lot split meets the requirements of Sections 67.304
and 67.406 of the Zoning Code; except for minimum lot width;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the City Council accepts and approves
this lot split, with the following variances: Reduce required lot frontage
for the duplex structure at 1165-67 Bush (Parcel A) from 50' to 44.45' ; a
variance of 5.55' ; and reduce required lot frontage for a single-family
structure at 1161 Bush (Parcel B) from 40' to 38.96' ; a variance of 1 .04' .
COUIVCILMEN Requested by Department oE:
Yeas .�0�1/ � Nays �
°rB1N In Favor ' �`
Masanz /
Nicosia A I
scheibe� � __ Against By �7�
Tedesco
Wilson
JUN 2 0 1985 Form Approv y Att ney
Adopted by Council: Date
Certified Ya se ncil Se r BY
sy
UN � 4 i985 Appr ve Ma or S mis ' n to Council
!#ppr by AAavor. Date
By
PU�t.1S�� J U P� 2 9 1985
PED � DEPARTMENT (.-�`����� ND 1894
L' �iQ,EQ /�tQ�„�Q„ CONTACT
7494, ext. � Lq r PHONE
, �Iv I I DATE �Q��� Q�
ASSIGN NUMBER FOR ROUTING ORDER (Clip All Locations for Signature) : ��
Department Director 3 Director of�nagement/Mayor�t�/��
Finance and Management Services Director � Cit Clerk�`CITY COU CIL EA �NG Er-6l9�
Budget Director '
2 City Attorney � 5 ��Jal �ce-.� ts�� so�
WHAT WILL BE ACHIEUED BY TAKING ACTION ON THE ATTACHED MATERIALS? (Purpose/
Rationale) :
Implementation of subdivision regulations regarding lot splits. Safeguard against
creation of substandard/unbuildable lots. City Council hearing required.
COST/BENEFIT, BUDGETARY AND PERSONNEL IMPACTS ANTICIPATED:
Fee of $20.00 to cover administrative costs.
FINANCING SOURCE AND BUDGET ACTIVITY NUMBER CHARGED OR CREDITED: (Mayor's signa-
ture not re-
Total Amount of Transaction: $20.00 quired if under
$10,00U)
Funding Source: General Fund
Activity Number:
ATTACHMENTS (List and Number All Attachments) :
1. City Council Resolution
2. Copy of staff report
3. Copy of public hearing notice
4. Survey of 1161 and 1165-67 Bush
DEPARTMENT REVIEW CITY ATTORNEY REVIEW
�Yes No Council Resolution Required? Resolution Required? Yes No
Yes �No Insurance Required? Insurance Sufficient? Yes No
Yes X No Insurance Attached:
(SEE REVERSE SIDE FOR INSTRUCTIONS)
Revised 12/84
� � �-�-�`�7
LUT SPLIT STAFF REPORT
----------------------
----------------------
FILE SBU #153
l . NPPLICANT: MARY SCHNAITH DATE OF HEAf2ING: 6/2U/85
2. LOCATIUN: llhl and 1165-1167 Bush
3. LEGAL DESCRIPTION: Ex, the W. 16.59' , Lot 21 and all of Lot 22, Blk. 3, Terry's
Addition
4. PRESENT ZONING: RT-1 ZONING CODE REFERENCE: 67 .3U4, 67.�06
5. STAFF INVESTIGATION & REPQRT: UATE: 6/13/�5 BY: Fred S. Haider
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A. PURPOSE: Consideration of a lot split with variances to allow separate
ownership of the existing structures.
B. SITE & AREA CUNDITIONS: Parcel A: Two-family dwelliny
Parcel B: One-family structure with attached yarage.
C. MINIMUM LOT REQUIREMENTS: Sinyle family: 4U' width; S,OOU sq. ft. area;
4 s�de yar s. Two family: 50' width; 6,UU0 sq. ft, area; 9' side yards.
D. CURRENT WIDTN & AREA: One parcel 83.217' of frontaye; 11 ,234.2y5 sq. ft, of
and area one- a alley included) .
E. PROPUSED WIDTH & AREA: Parcel A (1165-67 Bush) : 44.45 frontage, 6,OU7.5 sq, ft.
ot area one- a a ley included) ,
Parcel B (1161 Bush) : 38.96 frontage, 5,'L59.6 sq, ft, of lot area (one-half alley
included) .
F. FINDINGS:
l . The parcels will conform to the schedule of regulations for minimum lot area,
setback, and density.
2. N variance of minimum frontaye is required as follows.
Reduce required lot frontage for the duplex structure at 1165-67 Bush (Parcel A)
from 50' to 44.45' ; a variance of 5.55' .
Reduce required lot frontage for a single-family structure at 1161 Bush
(Parcel B) from 4U' to 38.96' ; a variance of 1 .04' .
3. The request for variance is based on the existiny physical conditions of the
property and additional lot frontage is not available. Grantiny a variance of
reyuired lat frontage is therefore consistent with the spirit and intent of the
Zoniny Code.
4. Grantiny a variance of rninimum lot frontage would not impair tfie reasonable use
or enjoyment of adjacent property.
5. Residential structures occupy the site in a manner that is consistent with the
yeneral development of the area. Strict application of minimum lot frontage
reyuirements would deprive the landowner of riyhts commonly enjoyed by other
property owners in the same zoniny district.
G. STAFF REC�MMENDATION: Based on the above findinys, staff recommends the lot split
be approved with variance as reyuired.
" , �c C�/`"��_��.1
': p"��s�
-:�:»`
C17Y Of SAINT PAUL
lNTERDEPARTMENTAL MEMORANDUM
DAT�: June 4, 1985 �
T0: President Victor Tedesco
City Council Members
City Clerk
FROM: Charles L. McGuire, Zoning 0-Ffi
RE: City Council Hearing: June 6, 1985
Mary C. Schnaith - Lot split at 1161 and 1165-1167 Bush -
A public hearing is scheduled for June 6, 1985 to consider the above
referenced proposal .
At that time staff will recommend the matter be laid over to June 20, 1985,
to allow the applicant additional time to submit a revised survey.
CLM:sb
- � � � � � �.�=���
,
NOTICE OF pUBCIC HEARING
The Sai.nt Paul City Counci.l will conduct a public hearina to consider
the request a.f Mat^y C. Schnaith for a lot split and variances at 1161 and
1165-1167 Bush on �����'��'�:e0 a.m. in the City Council Chambers ,
3rd floor, City Hall .
;
Albert B. Olson, City Clerk
City of Saint Paul
(May 25, 1985) _
, � , � �%--�f5--��/�'
� . � .R��'�a�_ � _ � .
3_��.r .. . <:,�
t �. t Pa C��t���ronduct a '� � �� , �;�r,. .
" ��S�ary c���l�i►fEh rbr''i�:jot 1it �.��i to caosliaer�the ;
� �Il��-iud�i�-2�
j F��iL°�'��ae 6.1�at i,q:oo q�n��ttl,e+Lqtg Co�t "�l�o�`n;� �
ALB�lI'�'-�:OLSON, .<r%�:,� ���ti�� �
�Cfty ot 3aint Paui� ��Clr.�� . , � . -�.a�:
�. . . . . . �. y�y,jy,_ �_v r ;,;J;, � � .
. . taa�c,7'jJ.1�) , r}v�`�3, _a. ` :;�
:.:. ,, .; .:
. . _ _._._ . ;+J- � . .:. .' .. . :.ci_.l1�.z�S• ' �i�..r.9..£6 _2= .,..,. : ." .
.. .___. . . ...:;r:. �. ' �..:i�� .�,
1
� __
. ' ;i
, __
` �
_. ,
, + • i�
lst � - :� C - �f''�_l 2 � � �.� _�� J t _
nd �
3rd � -� -� - d'S Adopted '7 ` CT -c��� ;
� "�
f ,,
Yeas r �:�� _
Nays ;
� �
DREW ���.
s
�-�� "��� ;� �� �
r�s�vz , _, :; �� : _
��-��5 � �:__
NICOSIA - �-`�`,-��;�"';
. .,�.._.,�,..._�-
S . _
� SCHEIBEL , ' �
� ;
SONNEN
WILSON
MR. PRESIDENT TEDESCO
� --
. _�.__�
, ,�.,,�- --
�
i9•��Ajq
i
:
;� ��s� a..
t
� � ����
„ .;,�
1���`��i���.�"���.
'�_
i •
_j
_ W. LINE LOT 21 � �_ � 6
�
it �
� �
i,
� : �
�N �
v
I� �
� — 1 ; I
i ; �
_ � i
I �
W i ... �
_. I �� �• --
, '��� �E. LIN� W. 16.587FEET LOT 21 1
� .
1 � O —
� o �
? c�'p W Q
D , �. �
- '� r c°
;'.. �- a �
w
..... � m �i � � N � g
f� � r � a r � nm
w N
� � C �. ? � Otn
N "� .�+ N :� C -1
i � � � j� �
O � ? Z 70
rn � ; � N �
D
z
� °��' � �
� a � � �
W. LINE LOT 22 - � � � �' �
� � � r' s
� d c° �
--- -- �— � �
I � � � o. o
c� i � N � rn �'
cn � � � c �, �� �
U� I Q � � � D� ��
---, .,w �ic �1_
-� � `� F
� N �
.
� 1"� (� T r
. at ��
� r--, I l?D O C �>'°.�
,•"•, \ � 1 C�n ..
'•..� ' - E. LINE 1A+. 5.55 FEET �.OT 22 cn j � �_C � 3- „nq� � S` _-- :
_ I � � � Z z'"m
`° a � ��`" 7
...�•� I � -�i. � "n_+ j i y aZ �
37 � � � N nc• �•��
� j� p � o� �
� � Z � �' � "' °;
0 0 � � �
z d � �m � aD ;
V1 � N A
;. � � �-7 �° � x o
' ' Z � G t3p "' mZ 7DC .
•. m y• r��► � -1 �
� D � � v � ❑ � m
O
ro � � � p a � z
� N d
l0 �
N v N �� � �
m d p "
. � ,• m
< N
� . — �
m � 3 -A-«'
I w 1 p„ g.
i � c p
i� � � '
�
a .� ,
� �
� � � J
.�` � � Z�
LINE LOT 22 " � 12.2 � ; ''��. ---14.0--------••.
- �o"--- - - - - -- ----�
--- -- � �� i
D I ►
� 6 � �
� � _ ,
N D �
� N I �
m � �
I °�
� �
�2.2
I �
� I
N '
D I
rrn — � �—
� 4
�
O �
�'
�
,
,
c°''� '
o�'��
o� �
?
_
O
C
--�— —d�—
, m
�
' - w
� i,+
5.5 �
:. rn N �; 12.1 A „� 6.0
♦.IV � •O O
� ; 8.2
` N —]� _ �a�
C - ' ' - - � -- - - -- - --- - - -- - -
� ��
r ��;—
z w ; :
m _ �; � URIVEWAY EASEMENT
� r ; �-- W -- 82.15- --
o ,
� , � ORIVEWAY EASEMENT
TN —'— - - - ---- - -- - - �— — — - - - - - - - -
i �l 3 9.0
\
`
� N
� �
� = W
� i .
�' C11 U�
D � N
o (D N D r -I � r --I Qo � , !`� C
-�, a x o O � �+ O �. � O
tn c� � c+ � � c+ D�• � p u'' (n
�+ rn c� r• c� s� � a� .°D f�l
�' � �o -i rv -i (D iv -I C m � �
kD (n c+ ►-. -� `� rv m m o'
�
a c+ �-r z w � c�� n � ° � i
p- � 3 0 ¢� ,
ooio -� a � �
� < o � o . ' 22.4 '
fD (D � r* c+ n � , �'' '
�-s � -1 � � � ''• 3 3 4. I �''
a N rZ � ° �',
cn c+ �+ m w �
cn �- � �- '
n (D ^' C_'� (D ,''• j-
"S Ql r. N � -1 Q - —j--- �W — - —
r. g• -1 c-r � m ,p v, �cn
Ul -G � (D .Z7 �(� � CT ' i
fD N 00 (jl N) � � � �
d c-t V O • O -t '
� ��
`n Cfi c+ .- ���, �` --- � 17.7 --
--t w-+� (1� c� cn ---- --- 25.6--- ---
,.,s • �p N � i _''�� i''
w 1a rD --i� D
C� `+ • (� f� Q �� 1� F,9 �
�t �o (D X O
• (D O '� c+ l� I-' �
�D -fi D f� '-� �� �-
�
c�r C o "� ►'' 'A
N r'-b r+ O � �U
O W � z ^
�-iv r. 1" c+ � ,'�\ � .
cLVO � -I � � 34.4
rr a c+ o � <n � � w
sr � '� �
iv o in rv � --� �
c+ cU N (n � Z 14.0
� � � v� m � m
O N �
� � � � c� C r
�,,. o � � ,...., o �
s c o --� � � '
� _
V1 � n � "'� � N p A
O�C c+ 7r V�O N A W N C
N¢'�C p g
. c�.� W '-fi T � Cn N (n
�J� � � .
�,� 3� coN ' w rn
�+ r. � �-+ ---i '
--�, � m •
� � � � � D
� o � � �-�
�+ � � rov /
o� o - �s c `
� r+ cn t� r'
o, o � rn �''
,. --a � " ' I 7.2 3.3-
• �� �� 5.5 �4.
tiq�C ,f
' -�7. 8 -.
, ' --- ' � 2.8 � 2
� .4
�
2 6.O
!
G� '
D N
N � O
, � D O
1 , ° G)
� tD m
� �
�o °
� o
� �
r m 26.0 �
DD -------.._
� N
. v �
s�,
o I
OGF
�
i y� �•G',�
�