99-935ORIGINAL
Presented By
Referred To
Committee: Date
1 RESOLVED, that upon execution and delivery of a release in full to the City of Saint
2 Paul, the proper City officers are hereby authorized and directed to pay out of the Tort Liability
3 Fund 09070-0511 to Shawna Bradlich the sum of $10,000.00 in fiill settlement of her claim for
4 damages sustained November 5, 1997, as a result of an accident with a city-owned vehicle at or
5 near Snelling and Englewood.
f5
Requested by Department of:
Adopted by Council: Date �,�•�_�_ !�,qq
r
Adoption Certified by Council 5ecretary
By: "� . 6 �
Approved by Mayor: Date / � ' /
By:
RESOLUTION
CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
City Attorney
BY: __�<��k�� �
4
Form Approved by Ci�At�ey
By: �
Approved by Mayor for Submission to
Counc' /
By:
Council File # 11 f 3 S
Green Sheet # 101052
rt . "''
City Attorney
Gail Langfield, 266-$748
9/24/99
TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES
q9-935 �
GREEN SHEET
�0 1 � � 052
orrcomo.
❑ atr�naulY � anaNtl[ _
❑ AP1ICI�LfF1eI�CFSUR ❑ N11111C�L�Of.YC
� rva¢(ae�wn _��� ❑
(GUP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATUR�
Approval of resolution settling the claim o£ Shawna Bradlich against the
City of St. Paul for $10,000.
PUWNING COMMISSION
CIB CAMMRTEE
CML SERVICE COMMISSIpN
SEE ATTACHED ADDENDUM
rias mie pe�sonlfirm everwo�ked unaer a w�ad r«rixe depaMientT
rES ao
Fias tlNS Dhea+�m aver bem a dtY emplmiee4
YES ND
DcesUfis P�� P�s a sld4 not �tl b�r �Y �me'R cdY emPbYee't
YES NQ
18 thia Pe�eoMum atmgeted vendd'7
YES I�b
TOTALNNOUNTOFTRANSACTIONS� (1 nn
Fuxouussouace �TOrt Liabilitv
TMnnaa. �oRAwnoN �ocPwwrr�
COST/REVENl/E BUDGETED (CIRFLE ONE) f YEE ( NO
�crtvrnNw�a� 09070 �`-�
;... � .. h�. ..�.
M^
ADDENDUM
9Q- q 3 5
On November 5, 1997, Shawna Bradlich was a passenger in a pick-up truck driven by Jessie
Sutheriand. At the intersection of Snelling Avenue and Engiewood, Sutherland's vehicle struck the
left rear corner of a St. Paul Public Works tandem truck which was driven by Patricia Legato, an
employee of the City of St. Paul. Ms. Legato was traveling eastbound on Englewood which is
controlled by a stop sign at Snelling. Ms. Legato has testified she stopped, but did not observe the
Sutherland vehicle, so she proceeded across the intersection. Jessie Sutherland was traveling
northbound on 5nelling and a witness has reported that Sutherland may have been speeding.
Sutherland did not observe the tandem truck crossing Snelling in front of him until shortly before the
accident. Sutherland's vehicle was also heavily loaded with construction materials which may have
inhibited braking.
Ms. Bradlich claims as a result of this accident she sustained injury to her neck, back, jaw and knees
and has sought medical and chiropractic treatment for these injuries. Her doctors believe Ms.
Bradlich has suffered permanem injuries to her back, neck and jaw. Following the accident, Ms.
Bradlich also claims she could not continue in her job as a roofer, thus she quit and has lost
approximately $50,000 in income because of this. Ms. Bradlich has brought suit in State District
Court against Jessie Sutherland, Patricia Legato and the City of St. Paul.
Following a pretrial conference scheduled in this matter the parties discussed settlement and have
agreed to a proposed settlement of $20,000. The City of St. Faul would contribute $10,000 and
Jessie Sutherland would also contribute $10,000. This office recommends approval ofthe settlement.
ORIGINAL
Presented By
Referred To
Committee: Date
1 RESOLVED, that upon execution and delivery of a release in full to the City of Saint
2 Paul, the proper City officers are hereby authorized and directed to pay out of the Tort Liability
3 Fund 09070-0511 to Shawna Bradlich the sum of $10,000.00 in fiill settlement of her claim for
4 damages sustained November 5, 1997, as a result of an accident with a city-owned vehicle at or
5 near Snelling and Englewood.
f5
Requested by Department of:
Adopted by Council: Date �,�•�_�_ !�,qq
r
Adoption Certified by Council 5ecretary
By: "� . 6 �
Approved by Mayor: Date / � ' /
By:
RESOLUTION
CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
City Attorney
BY: __�<��k�� �
4
Form Approved by Ci�At�ey
By: �
Approved by Mayor for Submission to
Counc' /
By:
Council File # 11 f 3 S
Green Sheet # 101052
rt . "''
City Attorney
Gail Langfield, 266-$748
9/24/99
TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES
q9-935 �
GREEN SHEET
�0 1 � � 052
orrcomo.
❑ atr�naulY � anaNtl[ _
❑ AP1ICI�LfF1eI�CFSUR ❑ N11111C�L�Of.YC
� rva¢(ae�wn _��� ❑
(GUP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATUR�
Approval of resolution settling the claim o£ Shawna Bradlich against the
City of St. Paul for $10,000.
PUWNING COMMISSION
CIB CAMMRTEE
CML SERVICE COMMISSIpN
SEE ATTACHED ADDENDUM
rias mie pe�sonlfirm everwo�ked unaer a w�ad r«rixe depaMientT
rES ao
Fias tlNS Dhea+�m aver bem a dtY emplmiee4
YES ND
DcesUfis P�� P�s a sld4 not �tl b�r �Y �me'R cdY emPbYee't
YES NQ
18 thia Pe�eoMum atmgeted vendd'7
YES I�b
TOTALNNOUNTOFTRANSACTIONS� (1 nn
Fuxouussouace �TOrt Liabilitv
TMnnaa. �oRAwnoN �ocPwwrr�
COST/REVENl/E BUDGETED (CIRFLE ONE) f YEE ( NO
�crtvrnNw�a� 09070 �`-�
;... � .. h�. ..�.
M^
ADDENDUM
9Q- q 3 5
On November 5, 1997, Shawna Bradlich was a passenger in a pick-up truck driven by Jessie
Sutheriand. At the intersection of Snelling Avenue and Engiewood, Sutherland's vehicle struck the
left rear corner of a St. Paul Public Works tandem truck which was driven by Patricia Legato, an
employee of the City of St. Paul. Ms. Legato was traveling eastbound on Englewood which is
controlled by a stop sign at Snelling. Ms. Legato has testified she stopped, but did not observe the
Sutherland vehicle, so she proceeded across the intersection. Jessie Sutherland was traveling
northbound on 5nelling and a witness has reported that Sutherland may have been speeding.
Sutherland did not observe the tandem truck crossing Snelling in front of him until shortly before the
accident. Sutherland's vehicle was also heavily loaded with construction materials which may have
inhibited braking.
Ms. Bradlich claims as a result of this accident she sustained injury to her neck, back, jaw and knees
and has sought medical and chiropractic treatment for these injuries. Her doctors believe Ms.
Bradlich has suffered permanem injuries to her back, neck and jaw. Following the accident, Ms.
Bradlich also claims she could not continue in her job as a roofer, thus she quit and has lost
approximately $50,000 in income because of this. Ms. Bradlich has brought suit in State District
Court against Jessie Sutherland, Patricia Legato and the City of St. Paul.
Following a pretrial conference scheduled in this matter the parties discussed settlement and have
agreed to a proposed settlement of $20,000. The City of St. Faul would contribute $10,000 and
Jessie Sutherland would also contribute $10,000. This office recommends approval ofthe settlement.
ORIGINAL
Presented By
Referred To
Committee: Date
1 RESOLVED, that upon execution and delivery of a release in full to the City of Saint
2 Paul, the proper City officers are hereby authorized and directed to pay out of the Tort Liability
3 Fund 09070-0511 to Shawna Bradlich the sum of $10,000.00 in fiill settlement of her claim for
4 damages sustained November 5, 1997, as a result of an accident with a city-owned vehicle at or
5 near Snelling and Englewood.
f5
Requested by Department of:
Adopted by Council: Date �,�•�_�_ !�,qq
r
Adoption Certified by Council 5ecretary
By: "� . 6 �
Approved by Mayor: Date / � ' /
By:
RESOLUTION
CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
City Attorney
BY: __�<��k�� �
4
Form Approved by Ci�At�ey
By: �
Approved by Mayor for Submission to
Counc' /
By:
Council File # 11 f 3 S
Green Sheet # 101052
rt . "''
City Attorney
Gail Langfield, 266-$748
9/24/99
TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES
q9-935 �
GREEN SHEET
�0 1 � � 052
orrcomo.
❑ atr�naulY � anaNtl[ _
❑ AP1ICI�LfF1eI�CFSUR ❑ N11111C�L�Of.YC
� rva¢(ae�wn _��� ❑
(GUP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATUR�
Approval of resolution settling the claim o£ Shawna Bradlich against the
City of St. Paul for $10,000.
PUWNING COMMISSION
CIB CAMMRTEE
CML SERVICE COMMISSIpN
SEE ATTACHED ADDENDUM
rias mie pe�sonlfirm everwo�ked unaer a w�ad r«rixe depaMientT
rES ao
Fias tlNS Dhea+�m aver bem a dtY emplmiee4
YES ND
DcesUfis P�� P�s a sld4 not �tl b�r �Y �me'R cdY emPbYee't
YES NQ
18 thia Pe�eoMum atmgeted vendd'7
YES I�b
TOTALNNOUNTOFTRANSACTIONS� (1 nn
Fuxouussouace �TOrt Liabilitv
TMnnaa. �oRAwnoN �ocPwwrr�
COST/REVENl/E BUDGETED (CIRFLE ONE) f YEE ( NO
�crtvrnNw�a� 09070 �`-�
;... � .. h�. ..�.
M^
ADDENDUM
9Q- q 3 5
On November 5, 1997, Shawna Bradlich was a passenger in a pick-up truck driven by Jessie
Sutheriand. At the intersection of Snelling Avenue and Engiewood, Sutherland's vehicle struck the
left rear corner of a St. Paul Public Works tandem truck which was driven by Patricia Legato, an
employee of the City of St. Paul. Ms. Legato was traveling eastbound on Englewood which is
controlled by a stop sign at Snelling. Ms. Legato has testified she stopped, but did not observe the
Sutherland vehicle, so she proceeded across the intersection. Jessie Sutherland was traveling
northbound on 5nelling and a witness has reported that Sutherland may have been speeding.
Sutherland did not observe the tandem truck crossing Snelling in front of him until shortly before the
accident. Sutherland's vehicle was also heavily loaded with construction materials which may have
inhibited braking.
Ms. Bradlich claims as a result of this accident she sustained injury to her neck, back, jaw and knees
and has sought medical and chiropractic treatment for these injuries. Her doctors believe Ms.
Bradlich has suffered permanem injuries to her back, neck and jaw. Following the accident, Ms.
Bradlich also claims she could not continue in her job as a roofer, thus she quit and has lost
approximately $50,000 in income because of this. Ms. Bradlich has brought suit in State District
Court against Jessie Sutherland, Patricia Legato and the City of St. Paul.
Following a pretrial conference scheduled in this matter the parties discussed settlement and have
agreed to a proposed settlement of $20,000. The City of St. Faul would contribute $10,000 and
Jessie Sutherland would also contribute $10,000. This office recommends approval ofthe settlement.