99-912oRi��N�� Council File # ���
,
Green Sheet #
RESOLUTION
CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
Presented By
Referred To
T�
. Date
RESOLVED, that the Licensee, 7MS Investments, Inc. 1a Lex Liquor Barrel (License
ID No.13653), located at 451 Lexington Parkway North in Sain aul is hereby ordered to pay a fine
of $200.00 for the violation of the sale of tobacco or tobacco roducts to a minor.
Said fine shall be paid to the Office of License, I pections and Environmental Protection
within thirty (30) days of the adoption of this resolution y the Council and signature by the Mayor.
This resolution and the action ofthe Co�
in the August 11, 1999 Notice of Violation 1�
report, and such azguments as may have been
facts were not contested by the licensee. �
�.3
. ��°�� ��.�
�` �\`�� /
j�fi this matter are based upon the facts contained
to the licensee, the July 28, 1999 Compliance
ented to the Council at the public hearing. The
Requested by Department of:
� ���` .i1v
Adopted by Counc'1
Adoption Cert' ied
By:
Approved y Mayor:
By:
Date Form Approved by City Attorney
by Council Secretary � ' 9 �� p
gY �/VCS� � Q+�(ri4li�
��
Date
Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By:
�
LZEP
1999 Public Hear. ��
RqRWfi
OROER
TOTAL �E OF SIGNATURE PAC,ES
GREEN SHEET
ov�rrrt o.fcrort
q9-9��"
, �,-��;,
No ! 'v "v : U 9
aneawrt
❑ fJ1YATO111EY ❑ OlYMC{�IIK
❑wwwcuuaEaxccane ❑wuicw.mm�ccro
❑ 1110'dtpltAtmtlW1) �
(CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE)
Concerning adverse action against the Cigarette License held by JMS Investment, Inc.,
dba Liquor Barrel, 451 Lexington Parkway North.
a
PLANNING CAMMISSION
CIB COMMITTEE
CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION
IFAPPROVED
AMOUNT OF TRANSACTION
SOURCE
(EJ�WN)
Hac this P�eoMrtn eoer worketl under a contract farthis tleparMerM19
vES NO
Hes fhia Deiawufirm e�er been e dly emvbYee9
YES NO
Doec this P�rm 0� a sldi not normalNP��s�d bY �Y curtent dty empbyee4
YE3 NO
la Min pe(sonlfi'm a ter0eted vmdoR
YES NO
Nain all vea arrevreB m 9eoa2te aheet aM att�h M nfeen sheet
COET/REVENUE BUIXiETm (CIRCI.E ONE)
ACTMTY NUMBER
YES NO
�9-9►�-
UNCONTESTED LtCENSE HEARING
Licensee Name: JMS Investments, Inc. d/b/a Lex Liquor Barrel
Address: 451 Lexington Parkway North
Council Hearing Date: September 22, 1999
Violation: Sale of Cigarettes to a Minor
Minn. Stat. § 609.685
St. Paul Legislative Code § 324.07
Date of Violation:
Place:
Presumptive Penalty:
July 28, 1999
Licensed Premises
$200.00 Fine
Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office
of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection:
$200.00 fine (first offense)
Attachments:
1. Proposed resolution
2. Notice of Violation
3. License information
4. Compliance Report
OFFICr ° T'HE CITY ATTORNEY �� �� ��
Claytan b.. _,obiraax, Jr., Ciry Attorney
CITY OF SA1NT pAUI,
Norm Coleman, Mayor Civil Division
400CiryHall Telephone:651266-8710
ISWestKe!loggBlvd Fauimile:651298-56l9
Saint Paul, bfinnesota 55702 -
August 11, 1999
NOTICE OF VIOLATION
Owner/Manager
Lex Liquor Barrel
451 Lexington Parkway North
Saint Paul, MN 55104
RE: Cigarette license held by JMS Investments, Inc, d/b/a Lex Liquor Barrel for the premises
at 451 Lexington Parkway N. in St. Paul
LicenseID #: 0013653
Dear Sir/Madam:
The Off3ce of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection has recommended adverse
acfion against the cigarette license held by JMS Investments, Inc. d/b/a Lex Liquor Barrel for the
premises at 451 Lexington Parkway North in Saint Paul. The basis for this recommendation is as
follows:
On July 28,1999, an underage person entered the Leg Liquor
Barrel at 451 Lexington Parkway North and asked to purchase
cigarettes. The individual was able to purchase a package of
Marlboro cigarettes without being asked for any proof of age.
This sale was in violation of Minn. Stat. §609.685 and Saint
Paul Legislative Code §324.07.
Since this is a first violation, the licensing o�ce will recommend a$200.00 fine.
At this time you have three options on how to proceed:
If you do not dispute the above facts and do not wish to have a public hearing, you wi11
need to pay the recommended fine for this violation. If this is your choice, you should
make payment directly to the Office of License Inspections and Environmental
Protection, Room 300 Lowry Professional Building, 350 Saint Peter Street, Saint Paul,
Minnesota 55102. The letter should be directed to Ms. Christine Rozek. Payment of the
fine will be considered to be a waiver of the hearing to which you are entitled.
Page 2
Lex Liquor Barrel
August 11, 1999
qa _y�a-
2. Altematively, if you do not dispute the above facts, but wish to have a public hearing
before the Saint Paul City Council, you will need to send me a letter with a statement
admitting the violation and requesting a public hearing. We will need to receive your
letter by Monday, August 23, 1999. The matter will then be scheduled before the City
Council for a public hearing to determine what penalty, if any, to impose. You will have
an opportunity to appear before the Council and make a statement on your own behalf.
3. If you do dispute the above facts, a hearing will be scheduled before an Administrative
Law Judge. At that heazing both you and the City wi11 be able to appeaz and present
witnesses, evidence and cross-examine the other's witnesses. The St. Paul City Council
will ultimately decide the case, If this is your choice, please advise my legal assistant,
Peter Pangborn, and we will take the necessary steps to schedule the administrative
hearing. He can be reached at 266-8710.
If we have not heard from you by Monday, August 23, 1999, we will assume that you do not
contest the facts and tivill schedule this before the City Council for hearing.
Please be advised that the clerk who was identified as having made the sale on this date is also
being chazged an administrative penalty pursuant to Minn. Stat. §461.12, subd. 3. This is a
separate action from this license matter. If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me
at (651) 266-8710.
Sincerely,
� ���.,
�
Virginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attomey
cc: Robert Kessler, Director of LIEP
Christine Rozek, Depury Director of LIEP
Christopher Dart, Community Orgainzer, Lexington-Hamline Communiry Council. 1160
Selby Ave., St. Paul, MN 55104
a q-�►�-
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
) Ss.
COUNTY OF RAMSEY )
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL
JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says
that on August 11, 1999, she served the attached NOTICE OF
VIOLATION on the following named person by placing a true and
correct copy thereof in an envelope addressed as follows:
Owner/Manager
Lex Liquor Barrel
451 Lexington Parkway 13orth
St. Paul, MN. 55104
(which is the last known address of said person) and depositing the
same, with postage prepaid, in the Uni�d�aCes mails at St. Paul,
Minnesota. / \ /1 /�1�.
G \ CLEMENTS
5ubscribed and sworn to before me
this llth day�f Augu�t�999.
/ / /
vv l //o � - R P. PANGBOFiN
Notary PUb7.1 NOTARYPUBUC-MINNESOTA
�` ti1Y Comm. E�ires Jan. 37. 20q
qq �°� ►�
� i�
�
a
a
x
M W
O � �
r � O
U N
� J O
1 M
v
'L
�
C
�
C
O
R
�
�
�
L
d
N
C
N
V
J
N
�
w
N
�
N
U �
J ¢
U
N U
a �
� o
m �
N
C
IU N
IJ U
L
� I��
rn �
w ��
Z
iN �
`U M
J �
O
� m
�
a
z
�
�
N
N
d ?
a W �
Q"�
�
V �
J
W
�
�
m
E �
�O
Z =
m �
� W
J
U
Z
H
Z
w
z w
o ?
a g
�
�U
C
O
U
U
.`
N �
o �
d
m
0
Q
X
W
N
C
N
9
E
�
Z
U
a
�
U
C
N
3
N
c
d
�
m
Z
a
c�
m l Q
0
U
c
R
�
N
C
N
a
�
�
Z
N
� n
o �
-� o
a �
N �
N �
G
� LLJ
m�
0
F �
V
�
v
Z
�
Y
a
Z
O
�
a
�
v
� y
N .._I N V m 01
�
C
U7 � f6 O � NN �s `
a �' � � a � a� °' � a� a '� �
f6 c� •�� w(JwLL �� j O Q�
o '� � p 3 Z a 0 �j �, �.- F , �..
o- .-.0 - 6 ��] O � (60 Nf1 � O
� � a Q � m-OI-3rn ❑�� � o ❑ �
U ac.: �.-_� ��rN ����a� >�
� •i � p1 � X�.�2jo _t a) oCR p_ . U ' r O
I > U�C 6 Wtn > p_��ON �N
Y > � � .�.. � "i � �E$ � >+> J �-�-. � � � (4 11-� �
U aUL� ���3Q�N�N �ON�N �O
C Oe LL M'�`N' � 0� �p�7
d C(0 U(ff �' V JO...WM�p. C a"
U a�_ m'V � CO a�~li �t�� �"� �� c -c
a dod� 0 -o_m�ao'oa�;�mrc Urn
� o m m pcn— m o��co,
V tn� N'y: ~ N OG �-� O��O Q ^
O O��U O �r " � �QO UOOMQ(O
c� m� LLo�c��c -
c� m rn� � c�� a�fp Q�vco�...� c�c�
� �'�� a cm Q- Q��O `m �� c �
O (6"6Q'O QN�U1Cn N j a N C NB-C � O
mu �a�iv`�i`�
��Uarnrn� ��vt��a�
�-Ucom��� o- �,Qao'� m�t>c��°O�• o��y
O] �O)� W m C N N—�MC0t0 C p C dU� C
�� ON< ���C� N N7>.VM� fl ' 100a U� 0 '
O�._�-�- '�T�M
N U�� C C N N � O� p j U O f 6 N` p 7 �� a N � j
� moo00c��oU�o�U�co�nc-t/)>a'?a�tn
qq _q�a
�
�
�
Q
x
M W
O N p
N � N
y U �
07 J O
ip M
a v
0
�
O
Q
d'
L
O
i+
R
�
r
w
C
d
N
c
m
e�
J
N
3�
N
�
N
� '.
J Q
�
� �
n�
� o
a� U
U C
� .m
�
a� �
d
� ��
� z I
� �
V �
_1 Q
- o
N
�
�
a
z
f--
N �
�Z
-a p W V
Q J O
� �
V �
J
W
�
�
m
m �
�O
W �
Z
m �
� W
J
U
Z
H
Z
W
m oi
z w
`Z
a�
U
C
�
O
U
�
N
o�
a�
m
0
Q
X
{l.�
N
C
N
Q
E
�
z
�
a
N
U
c
�
�
N
G
m�
�{
ml
Z
T
C
a
E
0
U
c
R
7
�
C
�
�
�
Z
C
o r
t r
a °
N �
N �
C
7 �
m �
0
F� �
�
v
Z
�
a
� ..�J
N J N c1 � 01
� � 7 � ` � � �
N � (60 � NN �y. E
� c� �t � a � a m m
~ � O�
a • �
w
m 'c� �0 �U,�u_ F � o a�
o � rn O� Z�.� C) a. L' o_~ ::
c �� �jmo �OLLVE� t6O
0 �vi.� Qo m �°Frn Q c�o �.
� � L�ww ��
U ac� p� �a��.N- c ��� c �c >
O y'�� � �NOQ�-p_ i��"'
y' �.0 N i JJ< a'S �>,> �F� 111�
V -)U—(p N f6W � Q i N
� a, mL 3 c6'a� O�� �MN �O c�0 EN �O
. C 0= ��V- O• � �� p)
� C U(6 ``G O �JJ c7 N LL rn � 6
U N�(0 �U O Cf CJ _1 F"' O �� Q"� N f0 J
f0 � Q U'� `•- C � N � LL m 1 � � E>'CO � c U(O
• y O� C �- Q c6 L a �'o . � .0 rn
� d � � � 'tUQC� ��F.?�cOV)'o Qo���
° y � N' ~J NOa N O'2LL QN O d�O QI�
� ��` c `oE�o�" � -6Q � c �� ocn4m
a�
c�a @ ��L � �� �pa�c°�or
� j'U � V d -p C(6 O_ O_Q N� Q l6 p�� N
o mv °- a�i Qv�ir.a���Q�coO�aE'c�_ico�
-o rnr ca=iN�F��-�N3o°> c°3��°�0
��Uarnrn.� ��vL � � a � rnu:�w °� E� c
�Umm°�n'°'p a `mQo-o� m�tUU�°O� ° o��O
m �O) O) Q� C N�_ C O' �Um C
�O��CVc-�W�C�NG �NV'C7�0'NCna U�Q'
� U67� C CNN� O�� U O NN�O �� d �O 3
r �00000wr-oU....o�UOco�n�tn>a Na.-v7
qq_q
�
`� i0
n
M `W I
�r � N ��
O vll
M � O
d ti'N
lp� I J �
a L�o
0
d
�
C
O
R
�
Y
W
C
d
N
c
m
u
.J
y
ml
��
�I N
N >
J IQ
L i�
T ��
�
C O
N `'
U �
�
_li�
�iJ
m �:
m �
� ��
W �''
Zi
�I�
C � (�p
U � a�-
J j 0
�
m
�
�
a
Z
O
�
�
�X
aWv
¢ '"'� O
� �
V �
J
W
�
�
m
E �
N �
Z �
Q �
� W
J
U
z
N
Z
W
Z W
O Z
d �
U
C
7
0
� c-
�
m
�
�
0
�o
�o
— N
O
M
O
L
�
�
�
�
Z
U
a
U Z
I�6 �
� W
- a
d
� �
Z ?
T �
� W
QQ
o �
= U
N �
N �
_ Q
�
�
�
�
z
N
C �
o r ,
L O
V'
N �
N �,
N �
c
.
� �
m �
�
H �
�
v
�
.
i
.
� �
N J y � �p m
L C
N �' (6 O � N N N y �`
,' m c a .c i � �°' °' �°''° .�
� ��a 'o'`m � F�- o.> 0 0�
o ' m °' p� Z � ,O U ao m•rF �..
�`„ �N C 'O UC� O (6 LL - O� C (60
O y c co a3c� � c O�-
U ac� a � c��� ���cN� >p
o Y�� �X�.m2 0 �NOQaQ �i�f
y L�` �J`i���N m.C��L� '�(p
�� o ,� a� �o,xf._ T> ��� ��cn w�
c a�� fn���Q�N�N�ONON c°'`o
� Oe lL a Mlt N�y� � m p�3
d CN V m '� �� o �Wch�N c v
U N'_ (6 J
� N � - �p� C� N � E am � C L CO
�E�o O-Qm.ca a m 3 U
� � c � '`CC�atn °�F a�a�fn'o � oco0o
p N��' F"_INQQ�O�LLp_cOpy(O�p,�
0 0� o `oE�rn a��n , �Q�oOOC�Qco
� m-°� � - >om�
� m° 'a"�i cLi o. c m� o_n.¢� �p� m��N
o mv na nN a�a� d 3°'a�`- c��= c o
�a��°� ¢cmmoN�
a m�no'm cm�n�H� 30°�' �(Acrno
��Q�a��� O`'6t � J Ty mLL OO� � EU O
u-Ucom��o a ��ao (pKUU'N > o
O) ��rN� � C¢N N.-�M(O(O C O C�Um C
�� `-ON � .\.• ��MC EN N 3>,VMmO"f00�'UC�O D'
W._[-a-
N UO>oDC=NNOOO�p U O t6N�0 j � yQ ld� j
n moo00c��oU...o�U�co�n.-tn>a!�a v�
qg-q �a-
M
w
O
M
N
�
N
a
�
0
c
d
�
c
0
«
m
E
�
0
w
c
d
N
C
d
t�
...I
�
�
o�i
m
OFFICE OF LICEAISE, [�SPECTIOVS AilD
ENVIRONMENTALPROTECTIOY
Ro6ert Kec:lu. Direc�or
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
A'orm Colem.an, May'or
LOWRYPROFESSIO.'��AL BUlLDI.YG
Suite 300
350 Sc Peter S:reei
Sain1 Paul, Minnuota Si102-I510
TOBACCO C0�IPLLA.1 CE CHECK FOR1I
�9�q�a�
Telephor.e: 672-? 66-9090
Facsimile: 612-266-9G99
61?-?66-91?4
DATE: ��� TLVIE: �� Q� LICENSE I.D. rUNIBER:
NAME OF C0�4PLLANCE CHECKER L..K e
NAME OF ADUI,T SUPERVISOR: �; ra-I LEX LIQUOR BARREL
NAME & ADDRESS OF LICEA'SED VE?�'DOR: 451 LEXINGTON PKWY N
ST PAUL, MN 55104
LicenseType: License»
Cigarettel�obacco 00�3653
TYPEOPESTABLISI�IENT: �ic��^ S�t-
�VAS THE TOBACCO: SELF-SERVE?_ ASSISTED?!r MACHLNE?_
WHERE WAS THE MACHI!VE LOCA3ED? -----'
DOES THE ESTABLISHME N MINORS? ��o
SALE WAS MADE• YES t � NO
WAS AN I.D. REQUESTED? Y'eS
1�'AME OF CLERK: ve �•tew
SEX: M F ��
DRIVER'S LICENSE �I OTHER I.D. TYPE OF I.D. �� J� �J I.D. # �-Loo - 75�r oG`7 -142
AMOUNT SPENT ON PURCFIASE 3•�'s
IF A SALE WAS NOT MADE: REAS�V (CHECK ONE)
I'��
�
1) I.D. WAS CHECKED
2> BUSINE,SS CL�S£D
j'� �N��`� G�P�� -r
lNc� S S�1r2 B�Q�
�- ���-
rn�v ss��-�
�°� 3'�"
� 3) OUT OF BUSIIVESS
�li� BQN EyPs
� 4) UIQSATISFACTORYCONDITIQNS �� / i
7 6 S
� 5) WERE NOT ALLd�VED TO ENTER THE ESTABLISI-LtifENT
License Group Comments Tezt
Licensee: �MS INVESTMENTS !NC
�BA� LEX LIQUOR BARREL
License #: 0013653
08/04/'Ig9g
qg �q I a�
7l28199 Failed tohacco complia�ce check. To CAO for adverse aetion. CAR
09/17/98 Cong2tulations �etter sent. PJW
OS/�0/98 Passed cigarette compliance check. PJW
On 21�7/99 Completed required alcohol awareness training-DL
On 'I/21/99 Failed check; 'unofficial" waming -training due Z24/99-DL
12185
083189 Ph On P.ppn For Trtr QF Off Sale Liquor And Original ConNainer License From L.G., Inc. - Dba LEx Liquor Warehouse (Same Address) Id 16�72
App'D C.F. 89-1548
092292 Ph Suspending Off Sale Liquor 8 Original CoNtainer License Due 7o Sale Of Alcohol To A Minor Heard By City Council, Licenses Suspended For
3 DAys With Two Of The Days Stayed. Suspension To Be Effecfive 101292 - C.F. 92-1451
6/24/93 Renew App'D - Mailed 7/13/93
5/� 3/96 Cig Code Added Fdld �E65222—Lap-Lic
10/9/96 C.F. #96-1268 App'D Imposing Three (3) Day Suspension W/One(1) Day Stayed For 18 Months For The Viola6on Of "Sale Of Alcoholic Beverage
To An Underage Person". Grounds For Departure From The PresumpGve Penalry Is A Previous Similar Violation In � 992. Suspension To Take Place
Commencing 10/30/96.
�0/16/96 C.F. 96-1323 App'D Changing Effec6ve Date Of Suspension To �0/23/967l30l96 Liquor Sale To Minor: Warning
�q -g �a�
Address ( Licensee � CoMect � License, �grtlhpltlec 4
Typc C p�operty �' Licensee r Unofficial T All
Street #: 57
Street Name EXINGTON
Street Typc �—�
Directiarc C_�.,
UnR # r �
CAy eAtl>
���
,'.`"��'!-�7J�.-Now
�
�,t,,.�-_'�
• �;+J'�
— �
�
�_ � ..?�N i� " 3ditlac " '� ° � tjse�.i'e�is
IARD HOANGBILLIARD r H�OAN�G
�L�I
I..tL �y �S
INC ' �p( LIQUOR WAR
i
CJJN_ S70RE'NWVALSI(1'S COu
�� -q� �
��,
�
Atltlre
7ypE � J'� 3Sd Y2�-� 3- „z uwnseeNrvuuvvt�imnviJWC:
�`� '-`�� �'� ` �� ���"' DBA EX LIQUOft BARREL
SYre =
Stre+ License � �jcensee � Lic.Types � Insurance � Bond � Requiremerds �
Stre' !•` propedy � Licensee �' Unofficisl � ProjectFactlrtator. GUNTHER,VNLLIAM(BILL)
Dire�3 Street #: 51 ; Adverse Action Commen[s
und ' �reet Name. EXINGTON ! �
�� � SYreet Type: PkVW Direc[iort �
Und Ind: � Unit #: r
f Cdy iPAUL CammeMs:
� Stffie. �4N — Zip: i5104 `F7n8/99 Failedto6acca compliance check. To CAO
� �,for ativerse ac[ion. � �
� Ward l� ;�09M 1AB Congratulations letter sent. P,IVV -
° Dist Counal: 13 ;�08A Oi98 Passetl cigarette compliance check. P,fW "
€ l
Licensee: �IMSWVESTMENTSMC Cammerrts:
DBA: EX LIQUOR BARREL
Sales Tax Itl� 544207 Bus Phone: 651) 696-4077
N
Off Sale
�i
23 ttems Found
qq .q �a�
TypE .� �.' �t�. � � . x uccnsectu�au�v�aimoviaw�.
�� ��" r=-^w �' - DBA EX LIQUOR BARREL
SYre � 7
SYre; �icense Licensee � �ia Types � Insurence I Bond � Requiremet8s �
Stre� UcenseeName: MLSWVESTMENTSWC '^;�r�,��
Dire�� DBA EX UQUOR BARREI
` Sales Tax Id: 544201 �
� Non-ProfM1: [— iNOrker's Comp: 4ROR000 ����!eS_�'�
Un� ;- � CoMred Rec'tl. OfJ0ID000 AA Treining Rec'Q OAOrt1000
�� j AA Fee Colleded ONON000 DiscouM Rec'd: r
�Mail Licefue To: —
r Mat To CoMact
�' License Atl 'uess
-Meil Invoice Ta: —
r Mail To Contact
�` License Atltlress
Backgro�mtl Check Required �
Lieense #
History
54517
OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY
C!¢yton M Rabrnson, Jr., City Anorney
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Norm Cvlemon, Mtryar
Civi! Division
400 Ciry Hall
I S West Kellagg Blvd
Sain! Paul, Minnesata 5510?
q°I -9 i�--
Telephone: 651266-87l0
Facsi�ile: 651298-56! 9
September 8, 1999
NOTICE OF COUNCIL HEARING
OwnerlManager
Lex Liquor Barrel
451 Lexington Parkway North
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55104
RE: Cigazette license held by JMS Investments, Inc. d/bia Lex Liquor Barrel
for the premises located at 451 Lexington Pazkway N. in St. Paul
License ID No. : 13653
Our File Number: G99-0282
Dear Sir/Madam:
Please take notice that a hearing conceming the above-named establishment has been scheduled
for 5:30 p.m., Wednesday, September 22, 1999 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor,
Saint Paul City Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse.
Enclosed aze copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to
the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested hearing in that the facts
contained in the report concerning the unlawful sale of cigazettes have not been disputed. You
will have an opportunity at the Council hearing to present oral and/or written remazks as to the
penalty, if any, to be imposed. The recommendation of the license office will be for a$200.00
fine.
If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710.
Very truly yours,
� Lcc� �U VZLC r.�.c-ti
Virgima`D. Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary
Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP
Christine Rozek, LIEP
Christopher Dart, Community Orgainzer, Lexington-Hamline Community Council, 1160
Selby Ave., St. Paul, MN 55104
oRi��N�� Council File # ���
,
Green Sheet #
RESOLUTION
CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
Presented By
Referred To
T�
. Date
RESOLVED, that the Licensee, 7MS Investments, Inc. 1a Lex Liquor Barrel (License
ID No.13653), located at 451 Lexington Parkway North in Sain aul is hereby ordered to pay a fine
of $200.00 for the violation of the sale of tobacco or tobacco roducts to a minor.
Said fine shall be paid to the Office of License, I pections and Environmental Protection
within thirty (30) days of the adoption of this resolution y the Council and signature by the Mayor.
This resolution and the action ofthe Co�
in the August 11, 1999 Notice of Violation 1�
report, and such azguments as may have been
facts were not contested by the licensee. �
�.3
. ��°�� ��.�
�` �\`�� /
j�fi this matter are based upon the facts contained
to the licensee, the July 28, 1999 Compliance
ented to the Council at the public hearing. The
Requested by Department of:
� ���` .i1v
Adopted by Counc'1
Adoption Cert' ied
By:
Approved y Mayor:
By:
Date Form Approved by City Attorney
by Council Secretary � ' 9 �� p
gY �/VCS� � Q+�(ri4li�
��
Date
Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By:
�
LZEP
1999 Public Hear. ��
RqRWfi
OROER
TOTAL �E OF SIGNATURE PAC,ES
GREEN SHEET
ov�rrrt o.fcrort
q9-9��"
, �,-��;,
No ! 'v "v : U 9
aneawrt
❑ fJ1YATO111EY ❑ OlYMC{�IIK
❑wwwcuuaEaxccane ❑wuicw.mm�ccro
❑ 1110'dtpltAtmtlW1) �
(CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE)
Concerning adverse action against the Cigarette License held by JMS Investment, Inc.,
dba Liquor Barrel, 451 Lexington Parkway North.
a
PLANNING CAMMISSION
CIB COMMITTEE
CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION
IFAPPROVED
AMOUNT OF TRANSACTION
SOURCE
(EJ�WN)
Hac this P�eoMrtn eoer worketl under a contract farthis tleparMerM19
vES NO
Hes fhia Deiawufirm e�er been e dly emvbYee9
YES NO
Doec this P�rm 0� a sldi not normalNP��s�d bY �Y curtent dty empbyee4
YE3 NO
la Min pe(sonlfi'm a ter0eted vmdoR
YES NO
Nain all vea arrevreB m 9eoa2te aheet aM att�h M nfeen sheet
COET/REVENUE BUIXiETm (CIRCI.E ONE)
ACTMTY NUMBER
YES NO
�9-9►�-
UNCONTESTED LtCENSE HEARING
Licensee Name: JMS Investments, Inc. d/b/a Lex Liquor Barrel
Address: 451 Lexington Parkway North
Council Hearing Date: September 22, 1999
Violation: Sale of Cigarettes to a Minor
Minn. Stat. § 609.685
St. Paul Legislative Code § 324.07
Date of Violation:
Place:
Presumptive Penalty:
July 28, 1999
Licensed Premises
$200.00 Fine
Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office
of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection:
$200.00 fine (first offense)
Attachments:
1. Proposed resolution
2. Notice of Violation
3. License information
4. Compliance Report
OFFICr ° T'HE CITY ATTORNEY �� �� ��
Claytan b.. _,obiraax, Jr., Ciry Attorney
CITY OF SA1NT pAUI,
Norm Coleman, Mayor Civil Division
400CiryHall Telephone:651266-8710
ISWestKe!loggBlvd Fauimile:651298-56l9
Saint Paul, bfinnesota 55702 -
August 11, 1999
NOTICE OF VIOLATION
Owner/Manager
Lex Liquor Barrel
451 Lexington Parkway North
Saint Paul, MN 55104
RE: Cigarette license held by JMS Investments, Inc, d/b/a Lex Liquor Barrel for the premises
at 451 Lexington Parkway N. in St. Paul
LicenseID #: 0013653
Dear Sir/Madam:
The Off3ce of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection has recommended adverse
acfion against the cigarette license held by JMS Investments, Inc. d/b/a Lex Liquor Barrel for the
premises at 451 Lexington Parkway North in Saint Paul. The basis for this recommendation is as
follows:
On July 28,1999, an underage person entered the Leg Liquor
Barrel at 451 Lexington Parkway North and asked to purchase
cigarettes. The individual was able to purchase a package of
Marlboro cigarettes without being asked for any proof of age.
This sale was in violation of Minn. Stat. §609.685 and Saint
Paul Legislative Code §324.07.
Since this is a first violation, the licensing o�ce will recommend a$200.00 fine.
At this time you have three options on how to proceed:
If you do not dispute the above facts and do not wish to have a public hearing, you wi11
need to pay the recommended fine for this violation. If this is your choice, you should
make payment directly to the Office of License Inspections and Environmental
Protection, Room 300 Lowry Professional Building, 350 Saint Peter Street, Saint Paul,
Minnesota 55102. The letter should be directed to Ms. Christine Rozek. Payment of the
fine will be considered to be a waiver of the hearing to which you are entitled.
Page 2
Lex Liquor Barrel
August 11, 1999
qa _y�a-
2. Altematively, if you do not dispute the above facts, but wish to have a public hearing
before the Saint Paul City Council, you will need to send me a letter with a statement
admitting the violation and requesting a public hearing. We will need to receive your
letter by Monday, August 23, 1999. The matter will then be scheduled before the City
Council for a public hearing to determine what penalty, if any, to impose. You will have
an opportunity to appear before the Council and make a statement on your own behalf.
3. If you do dispute the above facts, a hearing will be scheduled before an Administrative
Law Judge. At that heazing both you and the City wi11 be able to appeaz and present
witnesses, evidence and cross-examine the other's witnesses. The St. Paul City Council
will ultimately decide the case, If this is your choice, please advise my legal assistant,
Peter Pangborn, and we will take the necessary steps to schedule the administrative
hearing. He can be reached at 266-8710.
If we have not heard from you by Monday, August 23, 1999, we will assume that you do not
contest the facts and tivill schedule this before the City Council for hearing.
Please be advised that the clerk who was identified as having made the sale on this date is also
being chazged an administrative penalty pursuant to Minn. Stat. §461.12, subd. 3. This is a
separate action from this license matter. If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me
at (651) 266-8710.
Sincerely,
� ���.,
�
Virginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attomey
cc: Robert Kessler, Director of LIEP
Christine Rozek, Depury Director of LIEP
Christopher Dart, Community Orgainzer, Lexington-Hamline Communiry Council. 1160
Selby Ave., St. Paul, MN 55104
a q-�►�-
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
) Ss.
COUNTY OF RAMSEY )
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL
JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says
that on August 11, 1999, she served the attached NOTICE OF
VIOLATION on the following named person by placing a true and
correct copy thereof in an envelope addressed as follows:
Owner/Manager
Lex Liquor Barrel
451 Lexington Parkway 13orth
St. Paul, MN. 55104
(which is the last known address of said person) and depositing the
same, with postage prepaid, in the Uni�d�aCes mails at St. Paul,
Minnesota. / \ /1 /�1�.
G \ CLEMENTS
5ubscribed and sworn to before me
this llth day�f Augu�t�999.
/ / /
vv l //o � - R P. PANGBOFiN
Notary PUb7.1 NOTARYPUBUC-MINNESOTA
�` ti1Y Comm. E�ires Jan. 37. 20q
qq �°� ►�
� i�
�
a
a
x
M W
O � �
r � O
U N
� J O
1 M
v
'L
�
C
�
C
O
R
�
�
�
L
d
N
C
N
V
J
N
�
w
N
�
N
U �
J ¢
U
N U
a �
� o
m �
N
C
IU N
IJ U
L
� I��
rn �
w ��
Z
iN �
`U M
J �
O
� m
�
a
z
�
�
N
N
d ?
a W �
Q"�
�
V �
J
W
�
�
m
E �
�O
Z =
m �
� W
J
U
Z
H
Z
w
z w
o ?
a g
�
�U
C
O
U
U
.`
N �
o �
d
m
0
Q
X
W
N
C
N
9
E
�
Z
U
a
�
U
C
N
3
N
c
d
�
m
Z
a
c�
m l Q
0
U
c
R
�
N
C
N
a
�
�
Z
N
� n
o �
-� o
a �
N �
N �
G
� LLJ
m�
0
F �
V
�
v
Z
�
Y
a
Z
O
�
a
�
v
� y
N .._I N V m 01
�
C
U7 � f6 O � NN �s `
a �' � � a � a� °' � a� a '� �
f6 c� •�� w(JwLL �� j O Q�
o '� � p 3 Z a 0 �j �, �.- F , �..
o- .-.0 - 6 ��] O � (60 Nf1 � O
� � a Q � m-OI-3rn ❑�� � o ❑ �
U ac.: �.-_� ��rN ����a� >�
� •i � p1 � X�.�2jo _t a) oCR p_ . U ' r O
I > U�C 6 Wtn > p_��ON �N
Y > � � .�.. � "i � �E$ � >+> J �-�-. � � � (4 11-� �
U aUL� ���3Q�N�N �ON�N �O
C Oe LL M'�`N' � 0� �p�7
d C(0 U(ff �' V JO...WM�p. C a"
U a�_ m'V � CO a�~li �t�� �"� �� c -c
a dod� 0 -o_m�ao'oa�;�mrc Urn
� o m m pcn— m o��co,
V tn� N'y: ~ N OG �-� O��O Q ^
O O��U O �r " � �QO UOOMQ(O
c� m� LLo�c��c -
c� m rn� � c�� a�fp Q�vco�...� c�c�
� �'�� a cm Q- Q��O `m �� c �
O (6"6Q'O QN�U1Cn N j a N C NB-C � O
mu �a�iv`�i`�
��Uarnrn� ��vt��a�
�-Ucom��� o- �,Qao'� m�t>c��°O�• o��y
O] �O)� W m C N N—�MC0t0 C p C dU� C
�� ON< ���C� N N7>.VM� fl ' 100a U� 0 '
O�._�-�- '�T�M
N U�� C C N N � O� p j U O f 6 N` p 7 �� a N � j
� moo00c��oU�o�U�co�nc-t/)>a'?a�tn
qq _q�a
�
�
�
Q
x
M W
O N p
N � N
y U �
07 J O
ip M
a v
0
�
O
Q
d'
L
O
i+
R
�
r
w
C
d
N
c
m
e�
J
N
3�
N
�
N
� '.
J Q
�
� �
n�
� o
a� U
U C
� .m
�
a� �
d
� ��
� z I
� �
V �
_1 Q
- o
N
�
�
a
z
f--
N �
�Z
-a p W V
Q J O
� �
V �
J
W
�
�
m
m �
�O
W �
Z
m �
� W
J
U
Z
H
Z
W
m oi
z w
`Z
a�
U
C
�
O
U
�
N
o�
a�
m
0
Q
X
{l.�
N
C
N
Q
E
�
z
�
a
N
U
c
�
�
N
G
m�
�{
ml
Z
T
C
a
E
0
U
c
R
7
�
C
�
�
�
Z
C
o r
t r
a °
N �
N �
C
7 �
m �
0
F� �
�
v
Z
�
a
� ..�J
N J N c1 � 01
� � 7 � ` � � �
N � (60 � NN �y. E
� c� �t � a � a m m
~ � O�
a • �
w
m 'c� �0 �U,�u_ F � o a�
o � rn O� Z�.� C) a. L' o_~ ::
c �� �jmo �OLLVE� t6O
0 �vi.� Qo m �°Frn Q c�o �.
� � L�ww ��
U ac� p� �a��.N- c ��� c �c >
O y'�� � �NOQ�-p_ i��"'
y' �.0 N i JJ< a'S �>,> �F� 111�
V -)U—(p N f6W � Q i N
� a, mL 3 c6'a� O�� �MN �O c�0 EN �O
. C 0= ��V- O• � �� p)
� C U(6 ``G O �JJ c7 N LL rn � 6
U N�(0 �U O Cf CJ _1 F"' O �� Q"� N f0 J
f0 � Q U'� `•- C � N � LL m 1 � � E>'CO � c U(O
• y O� C �- Q c6 L a �'o . � .0 rn
� d � � � 'tUQC� ��F.?�cOV)'o Qo���
° y � N' ~J NOa N O'2LL QN O d�O QI�
� ��` c `oE�o�" � -6Q � c �� ocn4m
a�
c�a @ ��L � �� �pa�c°�or
� j'U � V d -p C(6 O_ O_Q N� Q l6 p�� N
o mv °- a�i Qv�ir.a���Q�coO�aE'c�_ico�
-o rnr ca=iN�F��-�N3o°> c°3��°�0
��Uarnrn.� ��vL � � a � rnu:�w °� E� c
�Umm°�n'°'p a `mQo-o� m�tUU�°O� ° o��O
m �O) O) Q� C N�_ C O' �Um C
�O��CVc-�W�C�NG �NV'C7�0'NCna U�Q'
� U67� C CNN� O�� U O NN�O �� d �O 3
r �00000wr-oU....o�UOco�n�tn>a Na.-v7
qq_q
�
`� i0
n
M `W I
�r � N ��
O vll
M � O
d ti'N
lp� I J �
a L�o
0
d
�
C
O
R
�
Y
W
C
d
N
c
m
u
.J
y
ml
��
�I N
N >
J IQ
L i�
T ��
�
C O
N `'
U �
�
_li�
�iJ
m �:
m �
� ��
W �''
Zi
�I�
C � (�p
U � a�-
J j 0
�
m
�
�
a
Z
O
�
�
�X
aWv
¢ '"'� O
� �
V �
J
W
�
�
m
E �
N �
Z �
Q �
� W
J
U
z
N
Z
W
Z W
O Z
d �
U
C
7
0
� c-
�
m
�
�
0
�o
�o
— N
O
M
O
L
�
�
�
�
Z
U
a
U Z
I�6 �
� W
- a
d
� �
Z ?
T �
� W
QQ
o �
= U
N �
N �
_ Q
�
�
�
�
z
N
C �
o r ,
L O
V'
N �
N �,
N �
c
.
� �
m �
�
H �
�
v
�
.
i
.
� �
N J y � �p m
L C
N �' (6 O � N N N y �`
,' m c a .c i � �°' °' �°''° .�
� ��a 'o'`m � F�- o.> 0 0�
o ' m °' p� Z � ,O U ao m•rF �..
�`„ �N C 'O UC� O (6 LL - O� C (60
O y c co a3c� � c O�-
U ac� a � c��� ���cN� >p
o Y�� �X�.m2 0 �NOQaQ �i�f
y L�` �J`i���N m.C��L� '�(p
�� o ,� a� �o,xf._ T> ��� ��cn w�
c a�� fn���Q�N�N�ONON c°'`o
� Oe lL a Mlt N�y� � m p�3
d CN V m '� �� o �Wch�N c v
U N'_ (6 J
� N � - �p� C� N � E am � C L CO
�E�o O-Qm.ca a m 3 U
� � c � '`CC�atn °�F a�a�fn'o � oco0o
p N��' F"_INQQ�O�LLp_cOpy(O�p,�
0 0� o `oE�rn a��n , �Q�oOOC�Qco
� m-°� � - >om�
� m° 'a"�i cLi o. c m� o_n.¢� �p� m��N
o mv na nN a�a� d 3°'a�`- c��= c o
�a��°� ¢cmmoN�
a m�no'm cm�n�H� 30°�' �(Acrno
��Q�a��� O`'6t � J Ty mLL OO� � EU O
u-Ucom��o a ��ao (pKUU'N > o
O) ��rN� � C¢N N.-�M(O(O C O C�Um C
�� `-ON � .\.• ��MC EN N 3>,VMmO"f00�'UC�O D'
W._[-a-
N UO>oDC=NNOOO�p U O t6N�0 j � yQ ld� j
n moo00c��oU...o�U�co�n.-tn>a!�a v�
qg-q �a-
M
w
O
M
N
�
N
a
�
0
c
d
�
c
0
«
m
E
�
0
w
c
d
N
C
d
t�
...I
�
�
o�i
m
OFFICE OF LICEAISE, [�SPECTIOVS AilD
ENVIRONMENTALPROTECTIOY
Ro6ert Kec:lu. Direc�or
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
A'orm Colem.an, May'or
LOWRYPROFESSIO.'��AL BUlLDI.YG
Suite 300
350 Sc Peter S:reei
Sain1 Paul, Minnuota Si102-I510
TOBACCO C0�IPLLA.1 CE CHECK FOR1I
�9�q�a�
Telephor.e: 672-? 66-9090
Facsimile: 612-266-9G99
61?-?66-91?4
DATE: ��� TLVIE: �� Q� LICENSE I.D. rUNIBER:
NAME OF C0�4PLLANCE CHECKER L..K e
NAME OF ADUI,T SUPERVISOR: �; ra-I LEX LIQUOR BARREL
NAME & ADDRESS OF LICEA'SED VE?�'DOR: 451 LEXINGTON PKWY N
ST PAUL, MN 55104
LicenseType: License»
Cigarettel�obacco 00�3653
TYPEOPESTABLISI�IENT: �ic��^ S�t-
�VAS THE TOBACCO: SELF-SERVE?_ ASSISTED?!r MACHLNE?_
WHERE WAS THE MACHI!VE LOCA3ED? -----'
DOES THE ESTABLISHME N MINORS? ��o
SALE WAS MADE• YES t � NO
WAS AN I.D. REQUESTED? Y'eS
1�'AME OF CLERK: ve �•tew
SEX: M F ��
DRIVER'S LICENSE �I OTHER I.D. TYPE OF I.D. �� J� �J I.D. # �-Loo - 75�r oG`7 -142
AMOUNT SPENT ON PURCFIASE 3•�'s
IF A SALE WAS NOT MADE: REAS�V (CHECK ONE)
I'��
�
1) I.D. WAS CHECKED
2> BUSINE,SS CL�S£D
j'� �N��`� G�P�� -r
lNc� S S�1r2 B�Q�
�- ���-
rn�v ss��-�
�°� 3'�"
� 3) OUT OF BUSIIVESS
�li� BQN EyPs
� 4) UIQSATISFACTORYCONDITIQNS �� / i
7 6 S
� 5) WERE NOT ALLd�VED TO ENTER THE ESTABLISI-LtifENT
License Group Comments Tezt
Licensee: �MS INVESTMENTS !NC
�BA� LEX LIQUOR BARREL
License #: 0013653
08/04/'Ig9g
qg �q I a�
7l28199 Failed tohacco complia�ce check. To CAO for adverse aetion. CAR
09/17/98 Cong2tulations �etter sent. PJW
OS/�0/98 Passed cigarette compliance check. PJW
On 21�7/99 Completed required alcohol awareness training-DL
On 'I/21/99 Failed check; 'unofficial" waming -training due Z24/99-DL
12185
083189 Ph On P.ppn For Trtr QF Off Sale Liquor And Original ConNainer License From L.G., Inc. - Dba LEx Liquor Warehouse (Same Address) Id 16�72
App'D C.F. 89-1548
092292 Ph Suspending Off Sale Liquor 8 Original CoNtainer License Due 7o Sale Of Alcohol To A Minor Heard By City Council, Licenses Suspended For
3 DAys With Two Of The Days Stayed. Suspension To Be Effecfive 101292 - C.F. 92-1451
6/24/93 Renew App'D - Mailed 7/13/93
5/� 3/96 Cig Code Added Fdld �E65222—Lap-Lic
10/9/96 C.F. #96-1268 App'D Imposing Three (3) Day Suspension W/One(1) Day Stayed For 18 Months For The Viola6on Of "Sale Of Alcoholic Beverage
To An Underage Person". Grounds For Departure From The PresumpGve Penalry Is A Previous Similar Violation In � 992. Suspension To Take Place
Commencing 10/30/96.
�0/16/96 C.F. 96-1323 App'D Changing Effec6ve Date Of Suspension To �0/23/967l30l96 Liquor Sale To Minor: Warning
�q -g �a�
Address ( Licensee � CoMect � License, �grtlhpltlec 4
Typc C p�operty �' Licensee r Unofficial T All
Street #: 57
Street Name EXINGTON
Street Typc �—�
Directiarc C_�.,
UnR # r �
CAy eAtl>
���
,'.`"��'!-�7J�.-Now
�
�,t,,.�-_'�
• �;+J'�
— �
�
�_ � ..?�N i� " 3ditlac " '� ° � tjse�.i'e�is
IARD HOANGBILLIARD r H�OAN�G
�L�I
I..tL �y �S
INC ' �p( LIQUOR WAR
i
CJJN_ S70RE'NWVALSI(1'S COu
�� -q� �
��,
�
Atltlre
7ypE � J'� 3Sd Y2�-� 3- „z uwnseeNrvuuvvt�imnviJWC:
�`� '-`�� �'� ` �� ���"' DBA EX LIQUOft BARREL
SYre =
Stre+ License � �jcensee � Lic.Types � Insurance � Bond � Requiremerds �
Stre' !•` propedy � Licensee �' Unofficisl � ProjectFactlrtator. GUNTHER,VNLLIAM(BILL)
Dire�3 Street #: 51 ; Adverse Action Commen[s
und ' �reet Name. EXINGTON ! �
�� � SYreet Type: PkVW Direc[iort �
Und Ind: � Unit #: r
f Cdy iPAUL CammeMs:
� Stffie. �4N — Zip: i5104 `F7n8/99 Failedto6acca compliance check. To CAO
� �,for ativerse ac[ion. � �
� Ward l� ;�09M 1AB Congratulations letter sent. P,IVV -
° Dist Counal: 13 ;�08A Oi98 Passetl cigarette compliance check. P,fW "
€ l
Licensee: �IMSWVESTMENTSMC Cammerrts:
DBA: EX LIQUOR BARREL
Sales Tax Itl� 544207 Bus Phone: 651) 696-4077
N
Off Sale
�i
23 ttems Found
qq .q �a�
TypE .� �.' �t�. � � . x uccnsectu�au�v�aimoviaw�.
�� ��" r=-^w �' - DBA EX LIQUOR BARREL
SYre � 7
SYre; �icense Licensee � �ia Types � Insurence I Bond � Requiremet8s �
Stre� UcenseeName: MLSWVESTMENTSWC '^;�r�,��
Dire�� DBA EX UQUOR BARREI
` Sales Tax Id: 544201 �
� Non-ProfM1: [— iNOrker's Comp: 4ROR000 ����!eS_�'�
Un� ;- � CoMred Rec'tl. OfJ0ID000 AA Treining Rec'Q OAOrt1000
�� j AA Fee Colleded ONON000 DiscouM Rec'd: r
�Mail Licefue To: —
r Mat To CoMact
�' License Atl 'uess
-Meil Invoice Ta: —
r Mail To Contact
�` License Atltlress
Backgro�mtl Check Required �
Lieense #
History
54517
OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY
C!¢yton M Rabrnson, Jr., City Anorney
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Norm Cvlemon, Mtryar
Civi! Division
400 Ciry Hall
I S West Kellagg Blvd
Sain! Paul, Minnesata 5510?
q°I -9 i�--
Telephone: 651266-87l0
Facsi�ile: 651298-56! 9
September 8, 1999
NOTICE OF COUNCIL HEARING
OwnerlManager
Lex Liquor Barrel
451 Lexington Parkway North
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55104
RE: Cigazette license held by JMS Investments, Inc. d/bia Lex Liquor Barrel
for the premises located at 451 Lexington Pazkway N. in St. Paul
License ID No. : 13653
Our File Number: G99-0282
Dear Sir/Madam:
Please take notice that a hearing conceming the above-named establishment has been scheduled
for 5:30 p.m., Wednesday, September 22, 1999 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor,
Saint Paul City Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse.
Enclosed aze copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to
the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested hearing in that the facts
contained in the report concerning the unlawful sale of cigazettes have not been disputed. You
will have an opportunity at the Council hearing to present oral and/or written remazks as to the
penalty, if any, to be imposed. The recommendation of the license office will be for a$200.00
fine.
If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710.
Very truly yours,
� Lcc� �U VZLC r.�.c-ti
Virgima`D. Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary
Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP
Christine Rozek, LIEP
Christopher Dart, Community Orgainzer, Lexington-Hamline Community Council, 1160
Selby Ave., St. Paul, MN 55104
oRi��N�� Council File # ���
,
Green Sheet #
RESOLUTION
CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
Presented By
Referred To
T�
. Date
RESOLVED, that the Licensee, 7MS Investments, Inc. 1a Lex Liquor Barrel (License
ID No.13653), located at 451 Lexington Parkway North in Sain aul is hereby ordered to pay a fine
of $200.00 for the violation of the sale of tobacco or tobacco roducts to a minor.
Said fine shall be paid to the Office of License, I pections and Environmental Protection
within thirty (30) days of the adoption of this resolution y the Council and signature by the Mayor.
This resolution and the action ofthe Co�
in the August 11, 1999 Notice of Violation 1�
report, and such azguments as may have been
facts were not contested by the licensee. �
�.3
. ��°�� ��.�
�` �\`�� /
j�fi this matter are based upon the facts contained
to the licensee, the July 28, 1999 Compliance
ented to the Council at the public hearing. The
Requested by Department of:
� ���` .i1v
Adopted by Counc'1
Adoption Cert' ied
By:
Approved y Mayor:
By:
Date Form Approved by City Attorney
by Council Secretary � ' 9 �� p
gY �/VCS� � Q+�(ri4li�
��
Date
Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By:
�
LZEP
1999 Public Hear. ��
RqRWfi
OROER
TOTAL �E OF SIGNATURE PAC,ES
GREEN SHEET
ov�rrrt o.fcrort
q9-9��"
, �,-��;,
No ! 'v "v : U 9
aneawrt
❑ fJ1YATO111EY ❑ OlYMC{�IIK
❑wwwcuuaEaxccane ❑wuicw.mm�ccro
❑ 1110'dtpltAtmtlW1) �
(CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE)
Concerning adverse action against the Cigarette License held by JMS Investment, Inc.,
dba Liquor Barrel, 451 Lexington Parkway North.
a
PLANNING CAMMISSION
CIB COMMITTEE
CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION
IFAPPROVED
AMOUNT OF TRANSACTION
SOURCE
(EJ�WN)
Hac this P�eoMrtn eoer worketl under a contract farthis tleparMerM19
vES NO
Hes fhia Deiawufirm e�er been e dly emvbYee9
YES NO
Doec this P�rm 0� a sldi not normalNP��s�d bY �Y curtent dty empbyee4
YE3 NO
la Min pe(sonlfi'm a ter0eted vmdoR
YES NO
Nain all vea arrevreB m 9eoa2te aheet aM att�h M nfeen sheet
COET/REVENUE BUIXiETm (CIRCI.E ONE)
ACTMTY NUMBER
YES NO
�9-9►�-
UNCONTESTED LtCENSE HEARING
Licensee Name: JMS Investments, Inc. d/b/a Lex Liquor Barrel
Address: 451 Lexington Parkway North
Council Hearing Date: September 22, 1999
Violation: Sale of Cigarettes to a Minor
Minn. Stat. § 609.685
St. Paul Legislative Code § 324.07
Date of Violation:
Place:
Presumptive Penalty:
July 28, 1999
Licensed Premises
$200.00 Fine
Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office
of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection:
$200.00 fine (first offense)
Attachments:
1. Proposed resolution
2. Notice of Violation
3. License information
4. Compliance Report
OFFICr ° T'HE CITY ATTORNEY �� �� ��
Claytan b.. _,obiraax, Jr., Ciry Attorney
CITY OF SA1NT pAUI,
Norm Coleman, Mayor Civil Division
400CiryHall Telephone:651266-8710
ISWestKe!loggBlvd Fauimile:651298-56l9
Saint Paul, bfinnesota 55702 -
August 11, 1999
NOTICE OF VIOLATION
Owner/Manager
Lex Liquor Barrel
451 Lexington Parkway North
Saint Paul, MN 55104
RE: Cigarette license held by JMS Investments, Inc, d/b/a Lex Liquor Barrel for the premises
at 451 Lexington Parkway N. in St. Paul
LicenseID #: 0013653
Dear Sir/Madam:
The Off3ce of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection has recommended adverse
acfion against the cigarette license held by JMS Investments, Inc. d/b/a Lex Liquor Barrel for the
premises at 451 Lexington Parkway North in Saint Paul. The basis for this recommendation is as
follows:
On July 28,1999, an underage person entered the Leg Liquor
Barrel at 451 Lexington Parkway North and asked to purchase
cigarettes. The individual was able to purchase a package of
Marlboro cigarettes without being asked for any proof of age.
This sale was in violation of Minn. Stat. §609.685 and Saint
Paul Legislative Code §324.07.
Since this is a first violation, the licensing o�ce will recommend a$200.00 fine.
At this time you have three options on how to proceed:
If you do not dispute the above facts and do not wish to have a public hearing, you wi11
need to pay the recommended fine for this violation. If this is your choice, you should
make payment directly to the Office of License Inspections and Environmental
Protection, Room 300 Lowry Professional Building, 350 Saint Peter Street, Saint Paul,
Minnesota 55102. The letter should be directed to Ms. Christine Rozek. Payment of the
fine will be considered to be a waiver of the hearing to which you are entitled.
Page 2
Lex Liquor Barrel
August 11, 1999
qa _y�a-
2. Altematively, if you do not dispute the above facts, but wish to have a public hearing
before the Saint Paul City Council, you will need to send me a letter with a statement
admitting the violation and requesting a public hearing. We will need to receive your
letter by Monday, August 23, 1999. The matter will then be scheduled before the City
Council for a public hearing to determine what penalty, if any, to impose. You will have
an opportunity to appear before the Council and make a statement on your own behalf.
3. If you do dispute the above facts, a hearing will be scheduled before an Administrative
Law Judge. At that heazing both you and the City wi11 be able to appeaz and present
witnesses, evidence and cross-examine the other's witnesses. The St. Paul City Council
will ultimately decide the case, If this is your choice, please advise my legal assistant,
Peter Pangborn, and we will take the necessary steps to schedule the administrative
hearing. He can be reached at 266-8710.
If we have not heard from you by Monday, August 23, 1999, we will assume that you do not
contest the facts and tivill schedule this before the City Council for hearing.
Please be advised that the clerk who was identified as having made the sale on this date is also
being chazged an administrative penalty pursuant to Minn. Stat. §461.12, subd. 3. This is a
separate action from this license matter. If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me
at (651) 266-8710.
Sincerely,
� ���.,
�
Virginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attomey
cc: Robert Kessler, Director of LIEP
Christine Rozek, Depury Director of LIEP
Christopher Dart, Community Orgainzer, Lexington-Hamline Communiry Council. 1160
Selby Ave., St. Paul, MN 55104
a q-�►�-
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
) Ss.
COUNTY OF RAMSEY )
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL
JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says
that on August 11, 1999, she served the attached NOTICE OF
VIOLATION on the following named person by placing a true and
correct copy thereof in an envelope addressed as follows:
Owner/Manager
Lex Liquor Barrel
451 Lexington Parkway 13orth
St. Paul, MN. 55104
(which is the last known address of said person) and depositing the
same, with postage prepaid, in the Uni�d�aCes mails at St. Paul,
Minnesota. / \ /1 /�1�.
G \ CLEMENTS
5ubscribed and sworn to before me
this llth day�f Augu�t�999.
/ / /
vv l //o � - R P. PANGBOFiN
Notary PUb7.1 NOTARYPUBUC-MINNESOTA
�` ti1Y Comm. E�ires Jan. 37. 20q
qq �°� ►�
� i�
�
a
a
x
M W
O � �
r � O
U N
� J O
1 M
v
'L
�
C
�
C
O
R
�
�
�
L
d
N
C
N
V
J
N
�
w
N
�
N
U �
J ¢
U
N U
a �
� o
m �
N
C
IU N
IJ U
L
� I��
rn �
w ��
Z
iN �
`U M
J �
O
� m
�
a
z
�
�
N
N
d ?
a W �
Q"�
�
V �
J
W
�
�
m
E �
�O
Z =
m �
� W
J
U
Z
H
Z
w
z w
o ?
a g
�
�U
C
O
U
U
.`
N �
o �
d
m
0
Q
X
W
N
C
N
9
E
�
Z
U
a
�
U
C
N
3
N
c
d
�
m
Z
a
c�
m l Q
0
U
c
R
�
N
C
N
a
�
�
Z
N
� n
o �
-� o
a �
N �
N �
G
� LLJ
m�
0
F �
V
�
v
Z
�
Y
a
Z
O
�
a
�
v
� y
N .._I N V m 01
�
C
U7 � f6 O � NN �s `
a �' � � a � a� °' � a� a '� �
f6 c� •�� w(JwLL �� j O Q�
o '� � p 3 Z a 0 �j �, �.- F , �..
o- .-.0 - 6 ��] O � (60 Nf1 � O
� � a Q � m-OI-3rn ❑�� � o ❑ �
U ac.: �.-_� ��rN ����a� >�
� •i � p1 � X�.�2jo _t a) oCR p_ . U ' r O
I > U�C 6 Wtn > p_��ON �N
Y > � � .�.. � "i � �E$ � >+> J �-�-. � � � (4 11-� �
U aUL� ���3Q�N�N �ON�N �O
C Oe LL M'�`N' � 0� �p�7
d C(0 U(ff �' V JO...WM�p. C a"
U a�_ m'V � CO a�~li �t�� �"� �� c -c
a dod� 0 -o_m�ao'oa�;�mrc Urn
� o m m pcn— m o��co,
V tn� N'y: ~ N OG �-� O��O Q ^
O O��U O �r " � �QO UOOMQ(O
c� m� LLo�c��c -
c� m rn� � c�� a�fp Q�vco�...� c�c�
� �'�� a cm Q- Q��O `m �� c �
O (6"6Q'O QN�U1Cn N j a N C NB-C � O
mu �a�iv`�i`�
��Uarnrn� ��vt��a�
�-Ucom��� o- �,Qao'� m�t>c��°O�• o��y
O] �O)� W m C N N—�MC0t0 C p C dU� C
�� ON< ���C� N N7>.VM� fl ' 100a U� 0 '
O�._�-�- '�T�M
N U�� C C N N � O� p j U O f 6 N` p 7 �� a N � j
� moo00c��oU�o�U�co�nc-t/)>a'?a�tn
qq _q�a
�
�
�
Q
x
M W
O N p
N � N
y U �
07 J O
ip M
a v
0
�
O
Q
d'
L
O
i+
R
�
r
w
C
d
N
c
m
e�
J
N
3�
N
�
N
� '.
J Q
�
� �
n�
� o
a� U
U C
� .m
�
a� �
d
� ��
� z I
� �
V �
_1 Q
- o
N
�
�
a
z
f--
N �
�Z
-a p W V
Q J O
� �
V �
J
W
�
�
m
m �
�O
W �
Z
m �
� W
J
U
Z
H
Z
W
m oi
z w
`Z
a�
U
C
�
O
U
�
N
o�
a�
m
0
Q
X
{l.�
N
C
N
Q
E
�
z
�
a
N
U
c
�
�
N
G
m�
�{
ml
Z
T
C
a
E
0
U
c
R
7
�
C
�
�
�
Z
C
o r
t r
a °
N �
N �
C
7 �
m �
0
F� �
�
v
Z
�
a
� ..�J
N J N c1 � 01
� � 7 � ` � � �
N � (60 � NN �y. E
� c� �t � a � a m m
~ � O�
a • �
w
m 'c� �0 �U,�u_ F � o a�
o � rn O� Z�.� C) a. L' o_~ ::
c �� �jmo �OLLVE� t6O
0 �vi.� Qo m �°Frn Q c�o �.
� � L�ww ��
U ac� p� �a��.N- c ��� c �c >
O y'�� � �NOQ�-p_ i��"'
y' �.0 N i JJ< a'S �>,> �F� 111�
V -)U—(p N f6W � Q i N
� a, mL 3 c6'a� O�� �MN �O c�0 EN �O
. C 0= ��V- O• � �� p)
� C U(6 ``G O �JJ c7 N LL rn � 6
U N�(0 �U O Cf CJ _1 F"' O �� Q"� N f0 J
f0 � Q U'� `•- C � N � LL m 1 � � E>'CO � c U(O
• y O� C �- Q c6 L a �'o . � .0 rn
� d � � � 'tUQC� ��F.?�cOV)'o Qo���
° y � N' ~J NOa N O'2LL QN O d�O QI�
� ��` c `oE�o�" � -6Q � c �� ocn4m
a�
c�a @ ��L � �� �pa�c°�or
� j'U � V d -p C(6 O_ O_Q N� Q l6 p�� N
o mv °- a�i Qv�ir.a���Q�coO�aE'c�_ico�
-o rnr ca=iN�F��-�N3o°> c°3��°�0
��Uarnrn.� ��vL � � a � rnu:�w °� E� c
�Umm°�n'°'p a `mQo-o� m�tUU�°O� ° o��O
m �O) O) Q� C N�_ C O' �Um C
�O��CVc-�W�C�NG �NV'C7�0'NCna U�Q'
� U67� C CNN� O�� U O NN�O �� d �O 3
r �00000wr-oU....o�UOco�n�tn>a Na.-v7
qq_q
�
`� i0
n
M `W I
�r � N ��
O vll
M � O
d ti'N
lp� I J �
a L�o
0
d
�
C
O
R
�
Y
W
C
d
N
c
m
u
.J
y
ml
��
�I N
N >
J IQ
L i�
T ��
�
C O
N `'
U �
�
_li�
�iJ
m �:
m �
� ��
W �''
Zi
�I�
C � (�p
U � a�-
J j 0
�
m
�
�
a
Z
O
�
�
�X
aWv
¢ '"'� O
� �
V �
J
W
�
�
m
E �
N �
Z �
Q �
� W
J
U
z
N
Z
W
Z W
O Z
d �
U
C
7
0
� c-
�
m
�
�
0
�o
�o
— N
O
M
O
L
�
�
�
�
Z
U
a
U Z
I�6 �
� W
- a
d
� �
Z ?
T �
� W
QQ
o �
= U
N �
N �
_ Q
�
�
�
�
z
N
C �
o r ,
L O
V'
N �
N �,
N �
c
.
� �
m �
�
H �
�
v
�
.
i
.
� �
N J y � �p m
L C
N �' (6 O � N N N y �`
,' m c a .c i � �°' °' �°''° .�
� ��a 'o'`m � F�- o.> 0 0�
o ' m °' p� Z � ,O U ao m•rF �..
�`„ �N C 'O UC� O (6 LL - O� C (60
O y c co a3c� � c O�-
U ac� a � c��� ���cN� >p
o Y�� �X�.m2 0 �NOQaQ �i�f
y L�` �J`i���N m.C��L� '�(p
�� o ,� a� �o,xf._ T> ��� ��cn w�
c a�� fn���Q�N�N�ONON c°'`o
� Oe lL a Mlt N�y� � m p�3
d CN V m '� �� o �Wch�N c v
U N'_ (6 J
� N � - �p� C� N � E am � C L CO
�E�o O-Qm.ca a m 3 U
� � c � '`CC�atn °�F a�a�fn'o � oco0o
p N��' F"_INQQ�O�LLp_cOpy(O�p,�
0 0� o `oE�rn a��n , �Q�oOOC�Qco
� m-°� � - >om�
� m° 'a"�i cLi o. c m� o_n.¢� �p� m��N
o mv na nN a�a� d 3°'a�`- c��= c o
�a��°� ¢cmmoN�
a m�no'm cm�n�H� 30°�' �(Acrno
��Q�a��� O`'6t � J Ty mLL OO� � EU O
u-Ucom��o a ��ao (pKUU'N > o
O) ��rN� � C¢N N.-�M(O(O C O C�Um C
�� `-ON � .\.• ��MC EN N 3>,VMmO"f00�'UC�O D'
W._[-a-
N UO>oDC=NNOOO�p U O t6N�0 j � yQ ld� j
n moo00c��oU...o�U�co�n.-tn>a!�a v�
qg-q �a-
M
w
O
M
N
�
N
a
�
0
c
d
�
c
0
«
m
E
�
0
w
c
d
N
C
d
t�
...I
�
�
o�i
m
OFFICE OF LICEAISE, [�SPECTIOVS AilD
ENVIRONMENTALPROTECTIOY
Ro6ert Kec:lu. Direc�or
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
A'orm Colem.an, May'or
LOWRYPROFESSIO.'��AL BUlLDI.YG
Suite 300
350 Sc Peter S:reei
Sain1 Paul, Minnuota Si102-I510
TOBACCO C0�IPLLA.1 CE CHECK FOR1I
�9�q�a�
Telephor.e: 672-? 66-9090
Facsimile: 612-266-9G99
61?-?66-91?4
DATE: ��� TLVIE: �� Q� LICENSE I.D. rUNIBER:
NAME OF C0�4PLLANCE CHECKER L..K e
NAME OF ADUI,T SUPERVISOR: �; ra-I LEX LIQUOR BARREL
NAME & ADDRESS OF LICEA'SED VE?�'DOR: 451 LEXINGTON PKWY N
ST PAUL, MN 55104
LicenseType: License»
Cigarettel�obacco 00�3653
TYPEOPESTABLISI�IENT: �ic��^ S�t-
�VAS THE TOBACCO: SELF-SERVE?_ ASSISTED?!r MACHLNE?_
WHERE WAS THE MACHI!VE LOCA3ED? -----'
DOES THE ESTABLISHME N MINORS? ��o
SALE WAS MADE• YES t � NO
WAS AN I.D. REQUESTED? Y'eS
1�'AME OF CLERK: ve �•tew
SEX: M F ��
DRIVER'S LICENSE �I OTHER I.D. TYPE OF I.D. �� J� �J I.D. # �-Loo - 75�r oG`7 -142
AMOUNT SPENT ON PURCFIASE 3•�'s
IF A SALE WAS NOT MADE: REAS�V (CHECK ONE)
I'��
�
1) I.D. WAS CHECKED
2> BUSINE,SS CL�S£D
j'� �N��`� G�P�� -r
lNc� S S�1r2 B�Q�
�- ���-
rn�v ss��-�
�°� 3'�"
� 3) OUT OF BUSIIVESS
�li� BQN EyPs
� 4) UIQSATISFACTORYCONDITIQNS �� / i
7 6 S
� 5) WERE NOT ALLd�VED TO ENTER THE ESTABLISI-LtifENT
License Group Comments Tezt
Licensee: �MS INVESTMENTS !NC
�BA� LEX LIQUOR BARREL
License #: 0013653
08/04/'Ig9g
qg �q I a�
7l28199 Failed tohacco complia�ce check. To CAO for adverse aetion. CAR
09/17/98 Cong2tulations �etter sent. PJW
OS/�0/98 Passed cigarette compliance check. PJW
On 21�7/99 Completed required alcohol awareness training-DL
On 'I/21/99 Failed check; 'unofficial" waming -training due Z24/99-DL
12185
083189 Ph On P.ppn For Trtr QF Off Sale Liquor And Original ConNainer License From L.G., Inc. - Dba LEx Liquor Warehouse (Same Address) Id 16�72
App'D C.F. 89-1548
092292 Ph Suspending Off Sale Liquor 8 Original CoNtainer License Due 7o Sale Of Alcohol To A Minor Heard By City Council, Licenses Suspended For
3 DAys With Two Of The Days Stayed. Suspension To Be Effecfive 101292 - C.F. 92-1451
6/24/93 Renew App'D - Mailed 7/13/93
5/� 3/96 Cig Code Added Fdld �E65222—Lap-Lic
10/9/96 C.F. #96-1268 App'D Imposing Three (3) Day Suspension W/One(1) Day Stayed For 18 Months For The Viola6on Of "Sale Of Alcoholic Beverage
To An Underage Person". Grounds For Departure From The PresumpGve Penalry Is A Previous Similar Violation In � 992. Suspension To Take Place
Commencing 10/30/96.
�0/16/96 C.F. 96-1323 App'D Changing Effec6ve Date Of Suspension To �0/23/967l30l96 Liquor Sale To Minor: Warning
�q -g �a�
Address ( Licensee � CoMect � License, �grtlhpltlec 4
Typc C p�operty �' Licensee r Unofficial T All
Street #: 57
Street Name EXINGTON
Street Typc �—�
Directiarc C_�.,
UnR # r �
CAy eAtl>
���
,'.`"��'!-�7J�.-Now
�
�,t,,.�-_'�
• �;+J'�
— �
�
�_ � ..?�N i� " 3ditlac " '� ° � tjse�.i'e�is
IARD HOANGBILLIARD r H�OAN�G
�L�I
I..tL �y �S
INC ' �p( LIQUOR WAR
i
CJJN_ S70RE'NWVALSI(1'S COu
�� -q� �
��,
�
Atltlre
7ypE � J'� 3Sd Y2�-� 3- „z uwnseeNrvuuvvt�imnviJWC:
�`� '-`�� �'� ` �� ���"' DBA EX LIQUOft BARREL
SYre =
Stre+ License � �jcensee � Lic.Types � Insurance � Bond � Requiremerds �
Stre' !•` propedy � Licensee �' Unofficisl � ProjectFactlrtator. GUNTHER,VNLLIAM(BILL)
Dire�3 Street #: 51 ; Adverse Action Commen[s
und ' �reet Name. EXINGTON ! �
�� � SYreet Type: PkVW Direc[iort �
Und Ind: � Unit #: r
f Cdy iPAUL CammeMs:
� Stffie. �4N — Zip: i5104 `F7n8/99 Failedto6acca compliance check. To CAO
� �,for ativerse ac[ion. � �
� Ward l� ;�09M 1AB Congratulations letter sent. P,IVV -
° Dist Counal: 13 ;�08A Oi98 Passetl cigarette compliance check. P,fW "
€ l
Licensee: �IMSWVESTMENTSMC Cammerrts:
DBA: EX LIQUOR BARREL
Sales Tax Itl� 544207 Bus Phone: 651) 696-4077
N
Off Sale
�i
23 ttems Found
qq .q �a�
TypE .� �.' �t�. � � . x uccnsectu�au�v�aimoviaw�.
�� ��" r=-^w �' - DBA EX LIQUOR BARREL
SYre � 7
SYre; �icense Licensee � �ia Types � Insurence I Bond � Requiremet8s �
Stre� UcenseeName: MLSWVESTMENTSWC '^;�r�,��
Dire�� DBA EX UQUOR BARREI
` Sales Tax Id: 544201 �
� Non-ProfM1: [— iNOrker's Comp: 4ROR000 ����!eS_�'�
Un� ;- � CoMred Rec'tl. OfJ0ID000 AA Treining Rec'Q OAOrt1000
�� j AA Fee Colleded ONON000 DiscouM Rec'd: r
�Mail Licefue To: —
r Mat To CoMact
�' License Atl 'uess
-Meil Invoice Ta: —
r Mail To Contact
�` License Atltlress
Backgro�mtl Check Required �
Lieense #
History
54517
OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY
C!¢yton M Rabrnson, Jr., City Anorney
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Norm Cvlemon, Mtryar
Civi! Division
400 Ciry Hall
I S West Kellagg Blvd
Sain! Paul, Minnesata 5510?
q°I -9 i�--
Telephone: 651266-87l0
Facsi�ile: 651298-56! 9
September 8, 1999
NOTICE OF COUNCIL HEARING
OwnerlManager
Lex Liquor Barrel
451 Lexington Parkway North
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55104
RE: Cigazette license held by JMS Investments, Inc. d/bia Lex Liquor Barrel
for the premises located at 451 Lexington Pazkway N. in St. Paul
License ID No. : 13653
Our File Number: G99-0282
Dear Sir/Madam:
Please take notice that a hearing conceming the above-named establishment has been scheduled
for 5:30 p.m., Wednesday, September 22, 1999 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor,
Saint Paul City Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse.
Enclosed aze copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to
the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested hearing in that the facts
contained in the report concerning the unlawful sale of cigazettes have not been disputed. You
will have an opportunity at the Council hearing to present oral and/or written remazks as to the
penalty, if any, to be imposed. The recommendation of the license office will be for a$200.00
fine.
If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710.
Very truly yours,
� Lcc� �U VZLC r.�.c-ti
Virgima`D. Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary
Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP
Christine Rozek, LIEP
Christopher Dart, Community Orgainzer, Lexington-Hamline Community Council, 1160
Selby Ave., St. Paul, MN 55104