The URL can be used to link to this page

85-421 � WHITE -J.TV CLERK � PINK t�NAN�E I TY OF SA I NT PALTL Council P ,/ CANARV - DEV�ARtMENT File NO. v� `�/ BLUE - MAVOR � ' ou�c�l solution 4 � Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee B Date BE IT SOL D, that the Council of the City of Sain Paul hereby certif'es an approves the action of the City of Sai t Paul Board of Appe ls an Review pertaining to the following lis ed property and s sho n by the excerpted minutes of said Boar of Appeals and R view, dated March 12, 1985 and marked EXHIBIT A, and attached here o and made a part hereof by reference: DATE OF BOARD MINUTES CA E NO. PROPERTY APPELLANT 3-12-85 8- 5-H 1599 St. Anthony Phillip Snyde BOARD ACTION: Gran ed a variance allowing for one stairwel enclosure instead of the required two by City code. Property Descr'ption; Milham Park, Ramsey County, Minnesot except the west 4 .17 feet, lot 27, Block 1 ---- --------------------------�---------- 3-12-85 11- 5-H 628-630 Igenc�ota Raymond I�i. Ap el BOARD ACTION: Grant d a permanent variance on shared bathr om facilities to allow use o two athrooms by five units . Pro ert Descr tion Dana and Humes Subdivision Block 98, Lot 7 ---- ------------------------------------ 3-12-85 13�� 5�H 1012 Marshall Ave. Robert A. Hu t, Sr. COU[VCILMEN Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays Fletcher Drew [n Favor Masanz NiCOSia scnetbei __ Against BY Tedesco Wilson Form Ap oved by City Attorney Adopted by Council: Date ��1.-...-F� C •e� Certified Passed by Council Secr ary BY �� By A�pp e by (Vlavor: Dat � Approved by Mayor for Submission to Co ncil B - By WH17E - CITV CLERK C NARV �'pEPAR MENT COUI�CIl �r /` BLUE - MA;OR ITY OF SAINT PALTL File NO. d-r- �`°Z� ' Council Resolution Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee B Date BOARD ACTION: Grant d variance to allow two apartments on ne floor to share the b th. Granted a vari nce t consider the basement and the first fl or (owner occupied) as o e liv ng unit. Granted a vari nce o ceiling height and light and ventilati n in third floor apartmen , on ondition mechanical ventilation be inst lled in the kitchen an a le al stairway from third floor be install d. Pro ert Descr' tion: Rogers Addition to St. Paul except Avenue, Lot 8, Block l. --------------------------------------- and be it FURTHER SOL D, that upon passage of this resolutio , the City Clerk is h reby uthorized and directed to transmit a c py of this resolution for r cording to the Ramsey County Office of the Register of Deeds. -2- COUIVCILMEIV Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays �FlaioMe� �cHJ�ti� °'ew In Favor Masanz Nicosia Sei+sibeF- __ A gai n s t BY TedesCo YYiFaon, R 2� �9a5 Form App ved by Cit Attorney Adopted by Council: Date Certified s•e Council S ret By � gy. t#p by iVlavor: Date �R Approved by Mayor for Submission to Cou cil By PUBU E� A K � 1985 �� tf�� « ft _ ,-. 8-85-H . :5��_. t... AnthonX Ph i 1 1 i p Snycier �- ` --�-_�� : SUBJECT Req est ariance from code requirement for s airweli enclosures, s app llant would like to use onl y one doo r o n e a c h floor. APPEARANCE Ph i 1 1 i p Snyder -..,�.,,, PROCEEDINGS M . S yder said the request is for a varian e from fire doors . 11 o her requests by the city have been me , Mr. S�yder stated. Th y have also met ali the qualifications of the �-�... Fire Departme t an everything else from the Buildin Code Department. e sai the building is in top condition. ecause the hallways a e so arrow, putting doors at both ends would make it dark and ha ardou for the tenants, therefore he would like a variance to al ow on y one door. Alice Bijjani , repr senting the city, stated with his pla there would be four dditi nal doors on the first and second flo r and the two stai s wou d be separated from each other. She would have no ob,jection to granting this variance. BOARD ACTION Ron Glassman moved to grant the variance allowing for one stair 11 e closure instead of two as required by city code. Rosann B stro seconded the motion. MOTION CARRIED. THE VOTE Ayes 5 Nays 0 Abstentions 0 , 1 1-8.5-H 28-63 -�Mendota � Raymond H. Appe 1 � SUBJECT Reque t th t the variance granted at the Novembe 10, 1981 meeting f the Board of Appeats which allowed use o two bathrooms to e sh red by five units, be transferred to .a prospective bu er wh would then becorne the new owner, a the � cost to provide addit onal bathrooms would be substantial . APPEARANCE Ray ond H Appe) PROCEEDINGS Mr. App 1 addressed the board and .said the va iance was granted in 1981 f r as long as he owned the building. He is now trying to sell nd has a buyer and would like the va iance transferred to t e ne owner. He said it would cost $12, 0 0 and that would have o be passed on to the tenants who are 1•ow income people. General y, h stated, single people occupy the units and they have had n pro lem renting them as there is a demand for . this type of ren al pr perty. Alice BiS,�ani s id sh always feels this is a good time to make improvements whe a pr perty is being sold, but in this cas she said there is reall not a good place to put a bathroom and everything else s in rder on the property. She would lik the action of the bo rd to be noted on the .abstract. � BOARD ACTION Glenn G usman moved to make the November 10, 1981 � variance a per anent variance. Rosann Bostrom seconded the � motion. MOTION ARRIE . • THE VOTE Ayes 5 Nays 0 Abstentions 0 � . ; . . . . � �.�=yal . � 13-85-H 1012 Marshall Ave. Robert A. H nt, Sr. SUBJECT Re uest ariance from St. Paul Legislative Cod , Section 34. 13, per ainin to escape windows in basernent apartm nt; code requiring bath oom in the first floor unit, and to rovide a bathroom w thin the second floor south unit. Aiso request variance p rtain ng to illegal wiring and height of attic unit, because of inanc al difficulty. APPEARANCE Rober A. Hunt, Sr. PROCEEDINGS Mr. Hunt said ttie building has four units; it was never defi ed in his abstract how many units. He stat d he is prepared to put a new roof on the house and thought tha was all it needed, now h reads a list of 33 items. He bought it for a retirernent situa ion and does not have a lot of money. He said the first loor nd basement are one unit which he and is wife use. The aseme t has not ever been rented out. He d es sleep in the base ent, ut there is no kitchen or cooking ther . Alice Bijj i s id Carolyn Shepard inspected and f und the general main enan e of the building to be good -- it is egal for four units. Th third floor has several violations, ceiling height, the two nits on second floor share one bath, and the first loor and cellar share a bath, but have their own kitchen. BOARD ACTIO Ron Glassman moved that a variance be gr nted to allow two ap rtmen s on the second floor to share the ba h. Bill Tilton secon ed th motion. MOTION CARRIED. THE VOTE Ay s 5 Nays 0 Abstentions 0 FURTHER ACT ON B' ll Tilton moved to consider the baseme t and the first fl or as one unit. Glenn Gausman seconded the motion. MOTION CARRI D. FURTHER PROC EDING The third floor pertaining to the low ceilings and viola ions of the fire exit code was discuss d next. The one stai way d es not meet code and there is not a se ond one. Alice Bij,�an sugg sted, in regard to the matters on the third floor, that the boa d gra t Mr. Hunt additional time to come up with a plan for somethin to c rrect the third floor violations. BOARD ACTIO Bi 1 Tilton moved to grant a variance on the ceiling heig t, a d the light and ventilation, on condit on that he put mec anical ventilation in the kitchen and ake an appropriate legal tairway. Rosann Bostrom seconded the motion. MOTION CARRI D. THE VOTE Ay s 5 Nays 0 Abstentions 0 --------------------------------- i - k � ' � e 1 � I '� �a { y^.f . � � "�r �� S �� v � >> �' 1 ".�:� 1 �* �'� � ' -� {�`�� k y r t �;, � � ` ' x ' ; ` �� ,.„ �'1 '� ,� v � C •i i� r�r �4 ' � L � � ti .� � ,, } � , a�, �� , .• � - " � �4-� ` +: , _ , F ' •� ,,- . ' '�.� .� �� v + � iiG - � _ � r+ >� ., .i r { � ; � . € �. � � 'h. 3 4�*: ��' - , �`�� r � ~ � � *�~ `.,� � � �±$�� r ;jt s !t t� �y; �a�, rf� ��. ' f , � � 1 �� I � y �i ;� � z • I. �: '. ` _ 1 « , . i ' �y�{. { ky'. I . '.� t'' .. 1 .,� \ .".. .!, �, y k. , :F . ,iI� . � . , � h'Tr s �� {� ��A. ` , • r � . �j��s e'`'. .*-� � ! � . �' . I, w��l�� fy". i � , � :� � �� .j .. ; �' ' ` ' `I ' + ( �'. �< . ; ' � � �� . �. � ' .A�1�' ,'VFJ''.L' , � I 1 / �, f', ' 4 } k °1� "�_ " . . ' . ... ., � . . . . . � ' . ,� y �-. ; � � �. t , � e . � � � � �_� \ . � � . � ' �t .d s �I i �� t �� '�f I - it e�^4 � •',�� \ /' t} ��e: � ' , ' - ��,� . r.� � ��J i +` � � . ( y' � . ` . . 4 � i Y�. . . , . . ' , . . , - r f . �� . . � , . . . . . �� . � '� . ,. i ♦ _ . . � . . ..�, . ! . . . , . .. .. . . . .. . . . . .. . .. . . . . . � . . . . � . T . . . . . . 1` . �,} "� I �f�� ,�5.� �T (• y , � A Y �.� �,' � 'j � ti A, v• �y� ��/. � . � ., � `�; �. H 1 •��W� 1M��f�� fF ' } � y � tt � � �.� � _ .,� � . „ ':�. ' � -A a 4" t i �,.�� m �,r�r�aeati:� ' � a '� ��tif�ed ao�vy ��'�C.F�� ,�5-42�. i�'� $t��i�g i��}�bt�';;, � � ` ° � of��c�t.r 'I1� e�l � � �tp�sov�ng- ac�io�s �� t�e, 3�� io�� a�ei� c��`�� ' .� ; �� tT � � �� 8�,��`:. $i�I �� Cr��'.� _.a.�/a+Rw�� 'a3� ��.'r�il '� � ♦` � , '�+. ' � ' ! ` � � I '•��I � �_ 2 �� '� .}ytilti�� ... � '. t t�<� , � �e rt ,.�,�. . ii.r rr K � . - Y. � k �� — .. � ° � �� . } /��"�� . ' -•F � 1, ' �� y r tt�`' � .. � k � i �j i � ' � �: � �., I �4'�,�� / v ' � -' +., .- , ,k 3 6�S � �R�� :k . `��t 1 �� _ . � 1 � 7� w= sl' I . : .,{ � r a ' - r � � _I � �' j�! �` , f1i��`�� ',�,, �� 4 � � ` `' ` , ` ` } �e ,r" \ • 1 . R ;2�,� I?� 1F�vfl � _ �1, .E �;1 ' '�. 1 � ` �,ryY �j .1 l \ �� '� � Y r , I ` ` � ' . { �F �T : If � /,. - I . �'l ( _" �l � � �� , � � ' - I ./ �� / � -. � � . � , . .. . �f� . . . i . . . + � 1 � .. . . , . . . . . ., .. - i •,� �� " V � 3. � � . � �;� q 3 l� � i'�� . j'.�' Y ��r�� f�� a �r x , ` " �.:`5 t `,$ t�r � 1 I I 1 � � t � ` r ��N� ��r 1 � 3 E i,t � i � , � , �� '��s � ( .r " � / . y ��' j'�� .�. , . ;.., : � . , �: � � �.x �s- � - -.r � � � � r � .: . 4` i � r � � 1, *�,`; �� . \ `i , � �7� �/ � 1A ; `� t � '� i., f i �d`�^.,. ��' , .. `' , � ;. F:� 1 � i 7 � i ./.. 1 S �� Y4� � �� M1 u �;1 .�� ' ��'. r � � � ! .v'. k ae. � � � -;�� '� � � �� I �� ,� � � � i m �x' {i= , • , _ L ,�li:� ' . . . , i . �) . . .. ��- .. _ ... .. . .. '- J. . _. c _.. . . ..,. ..r .. z�'a. o'� , � _ � � ��_ �.�� f„ �� ' � �° �': �-�� STATE OF MINNESOTA ) �'� Cou ty of RamsL�y ) ss. R� CITF r SAI�rT PIATII, ) Albert B. Olson . , . , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .City Clerlc of the City f Sai:nt Paul, Aiinnesota, do hereby cert3_fy tila I have � 85-4 1 � corapazed tl:e attactted copy of Council F3_le �To. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . � as adc ted by t}ie C3_ty Council . . March. 26:. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19.85. . . C � and ap roti�UU by the �Iayor. . . . . March. 28:. . . . . . . . . . . . . 19.85. . . � �„ with t a original thereoz on file in my office. -___ � � � I further certify tli•at said copy is a true and c rrect copy cf sa:i orig�nal_ aad ttie cahole thereaf. t•1� r!'t'ESS n� hard an�'� the seaJ. or the C.i*y of Sair. �aul, Minnes ra tl�is . , . . . lOth . . . . d�y of . . . April. . . . . . . . .A.D. 19. 85. C�� , City Clerk. • • � • • . . . � Y �,�, ; 't ,^.:." ;« -�� i 4 ��.`-{ r � . " � � S E,s ,' • ,y �' .,�� . �F?A. � 763� U a. � �F — � / -'17E. - CITY CLEF2K . ' ±.��A�� _-��A7TMENT• ITY �pF S�� INT �,ALTL Council p ,/ ,...,F k:- M A�:� File N 0. 4.�` �`�� , � 01�11�CZ� SO ZZl tZO�'l L �resented By Referred To Committee: Date Out ot Committee By Date BE IT SOL D, that the Council of the City of Sai t Paul hereby certifi s an approves the action of the City of Sai t Paul Board of Appe ls an Review pertaining to the following listed property and a sho by the excerpted minutes of said Boa of Appeals and Re iew, ated March 12, 1985 and marked EXHIBIT A, and attached heret and ade a part hereof by reference: DATE OF BOARD MINUTES CAS NO. PROPERTY APPELLANT 3-12-85 8-8 -H 1599 St. Anthony Phillip Snyde � BOARD ACTION: Grant d a variance allowing for one stairwel enclosure � instead of the requi ed two by City code. � Propert Descr ption Milham Park, Ramsey County, Minnesot � �; except the west 4 .17 feet, lot 27, �. Block 1 - 3-12-85 11- 5-H 628-630 I�Zendota Rayraond ��. Ap el BOARD ACTION: Grant d a permanent variance on shared bathr om facilities to allow use o two athrooms by five units . Pro ert Descr' tion: Dana and Humes Subdivision Block 98, Lot 7 3-12-8� 13 �s5--H 1012 Marshall Ave. Robert A. H t, Sr. COUNCIL�1EtV 4'eas Nays Requested by Department of: Flstcher o�8w In Favor Masanz - Nicosia scnetbe� Against BY Tedesco Wilson Form Ap oved by City Attorney T�dopted by Council: Date � C � � � Cer,ified Yasset3 by Councii Secret ry By �—�•---�� /� B� ��ppi ved by IVlavor: Dat ` Approved by Mayor for Submission to Co ncil g�� , �'�-i, � gy l� � •-�ITE. — �� =�-EHK . =:vp�vCE ` __ ✓:,':�,'�7cGnRTMEN� - ITY O�' SAINT ��AUL F1eci1N0. �-s_ �� -,.,.- - MaVOR ,. , C r " Council �Zesolutio� � �resented By Referred To Committee: Date" Out of Committee B Date BOARD ACTION: Grant d variance to allow two apartments on ne floor � to share the b th. � Granted a vari nce t consider the basement and the first t oor (owner � occupied) as o e liv'ng unit. � 1.� � �}' Granted a vari nce o ceiling height and li.ght and .ventilat'on in third �; floor apartmen , on ondition mechanical ven•tilation b� ins alled in the kitchen an a le al stairway from third floor be. ,instal ed. Propert Descr' tion: Rogers Addition to St. Paul except Avenue, Lot 8, � Block 1. and be it � FURTHER RESOL ED, that upon passage of this resoluti n, the City Clerk is ereby authorized and directed to transmit a opy of this resolutio for ecording to the Ramsey County Office o the Register of Deeds_._ _ -2- COUNCILMEN Requested by Department of: 4'eas Nays 'FiaieMe� �',rJ�,'�Jy� I�rew [❑ FSVOf Masanz Nicosia sz�e�e+- _ Against BY . reassco Mtitson- 1 iHR 2� �9�� Form App ved by Cit Attorney Adopted b}� Council: Dat Certified s•e Council S et BY � B� � :�ppwyec,' by �tavor: Date — 7'�xj{ `' ;Q � Approved by Mayor Eor Submission to ouncil �. � � ; ^ , B �'� j . �, _ � �j( 0 �`J-�5 Y � Gi �� ' � ' � . . � �'`��. � . � �=��i �� . � � + � w ,_ � �'� .00 � T .� o � .-�t O (n �l� ' � .. r�f ° � G a " l'� �" � � C� r.., ca. =o � c� '' �. w � _; � + � 'Vw N � W, (J `' rT' � �., G ^� y tD R �' �. � U • r y � � � `+� L pp� � � r, p ih �' o � � ';� � � � •� .`' � N ` � ._.�_a�. � _ � r� � �.�.� ��R �T -., f1 -� � K z �- O K c �, � n � � � � � � � '�"r � A. � � � ,�., � N � a O � � 0 � D . ��, � C� � �Y. �' � �� ° � � , � • _� � �� i` . I;� r�_- � � � �,.. '� �3 � `< � � �" ,L, (7 fl. r` �. � � 3i � L� . tn � ., .� -� C � � --�-