86-1572 �MHITE — C�TV CIERK
6PtNK — FINANCE C011I1C11 �
CANARV —DEPARTMENT G TY OF SAINT PAUL �'lle NO. `��/�� •
Bl�E • nr^,vOR
:� � �
�
Ordin�nce Ordinance N0.
Presented y
Referred To C- t'1� C Committee: Date �''� � �
Out of Committee By Date
An rdina ce amending Chapter 409 of 'the
Sai t Pau Legislative Code pertaining to
Int xicat 'ng Liquor.
THE COUNCIL OF HE CI Y OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN:
Section 1 .
That secti n 409.08(11 ) of the Saint Paul Legislative Co e be
and is hereby a ended to read as follows :
(11 ) Ther shal be provided in all zoning districts ,
other than B-4 o B-5 districts , off-street parking
spaces for all o -sale premises as provided herein:
(a) ransf r or new issuance to a structure
newly const ucted for that purpose, off-street
parki g at he rate of one space for each 45
squar feet of patron area.
(b) ransf r or new issuance to an existing
struc ure n t previously licensed for on-sale
purpo es , o f-street parking at the rate of one
space for e c�z 45 square feet of licensed patron
area inus he number of off-stree par .ing
space whic would be required for the previous
use o the ame area under the existing zoning
code rovis ' ons . Existing parking ���� which
revi usly erved the p�e��et�s t�se same area
shall not b counted to meet the requirements;
unles any re in excess of what would have been
requi ed fo the previous use. ar3d-}r3-r3e-e�aeri�
s�ia�� �a��} �-be-�e�t���ed-}�-e�eess-e�-w�ia�-wet���
�ia�e- eeri-� qr���e�-��-��ie-s��t�e�t��e-we�e-�ew��
COUNCILMEN Requested by Department of:
Yeas Nays
Drew
Nicosia ln Favor
Rettman
Scheibel A gai n s t BY
Sonnen
Tedesco
Wilson
Form Appro by City Attorney
Adopted by Council: Date
Certified Passed by Council Secreta y BY
By
Approved by Mayor: Date Approved by ayor for ubmission to Cou il
By By
. _ � � . . : . ��,��°z
� . , � ,y����.
�e�s� t�e�e�. --P�e�}ded,--�ievae�e�,--�i�at No ad-
itio al of -street parking shall be required
k�-�l� -ee�►p �e�-����e�e�ee-be�wee�-��ie-e�d-a�d
�iew-t� es-�s �ess-�l�a�-�9-pe�ee�� ,--e� if the
humbe of a ditional spaces required is five
or fe er sp ces.
(c) xpans ' on of licensed area, off-street
parki g at he same rate e�-e�e-spa�e-€e�-eaet�
4�-s� a�e-� e�-e�-e��a�de�-�a��e�-a�ea,--a�d-��
a�d}� ' e�,- a transfer or new issuance to an
exist 'ng st ucture not previously licensed for
on-sa e pur oses , plus 25 percent of any parking
short all f r the existing ����d��g licensed
area. "Par ing shortfall" shall mean the
diffe ence etween ��ie-�tza�be�-e€-�a�l�}�g-spaees
�i}e�i vaet��d l�a�e-bee�-�eqt���ed-}�-�l�e-bt�}�d��g
et�s� g-�l�e �}ee�sed-es�a��}s�ia�e��-kad-bee�
e6a�� ee�s� t�e�e�-a�d-�l�e-�t�x�be�-e�-�a����g
paee -ae�t� ���-p�e�}ded-e�-�l�e-da�e-e�-eex�-
�e�� �-e�- l�e-e��a�s}e�-e�-��e-��ee�sed-a�ea
ne s ace f r each 45 square feet of patron
loor area or the existing licensed area minus
he n mber f parking spaces actually provided
�or t at ar a.
(d) ' Patro area" shall mean to include all
areas used y the public , and excludes all areas
used xclus 'vely by employees for work, storage
or of ice s ace.
(e) odifi ation of Parking Requirements .
' ) The council may modify the off-street
arkin requirements contained in this
ectio upon application made for that
urpos and upon findings made by the
ounci that granting of such modifi-
ation would not have a substantial
etrim ntal impact on the surrounding
eighb rhood. Modification, if granted,
hall e by resolution adopted by at
east ive affirmative votes.
I
2 .
... . ., - . . ' , j° �''_�� ,�
` � � ' � ���j�,
I, ii ) The council shall consider the appli-
'� cation at a public hearing following
' ailed otice thereof to property owners
ithin 350 feet of the proposed licensed
remises. The council may require , by
esolution, the payment of an admini-
strati e processing fee for parking
odification applications . Applications
d fees shall be made to the license
i spect r.
}}}�-� e-eet�rze��-�►a�-�e�-r�ed���-�ke
eqt�}�e -e��-s��ee�-pa�l���g-�eQt���er�e��s
-x�e�e-�Y�a�-���-e�-��ie-ax�et���-�eq�}�ed
-�13}s-see��e�.-
��� iii ) In �ranting any modification, the
uncil may attach reasonable conditions
, egardi g the location, design, character
d ot r features of the licensed struc-
re a d parking area deemed necessary
or th protection of the adjacent neighbor-
�� ood.
aa� i ) Of -street modifications shall remain
ith licensed premises so long as the
c arac eristics of the licensed establish-
ent r ain unaltered. In the event parking
roble s arise , the council may consider
aking adverse action pursuant to the
roced res set forth in Chapter 310 of
is c e. Such adverse action may
i clud requiring the licensee to do
e or ore of the following:
) Pr ide more off-street parking;
) Re ce the usable floor space ;
� c) Re ce patron capacity (seating or
! bar area) .
3.
WHITE - C1TV CLERK
PINK - FINANCE COU�ICII 6 �j 2
CANARV - DEPARTMENT CITY OF SAINT PAUL {y -/�/I'7
��y�..-.���oR File N0.
. � , . /-
O� in�nce Ordinance N 0. �7`f�5�
Presented By
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committ e By Date
Section 2.
This ordina ce sh 11 take effect and be in force thirty ays
from and a ter i s pas age, approval and publication.
4.
COUNCILMEN
Yeas Nays Requested by Department of:
Drew � _
Nicosia �0J [n Favor
Rettman �1
s�n.�bai Against BY
sonnen
TedeSC!!
Wilson
Adopted by Council: Date
FEB It Form Approve City Atto y
Certified Pa Counc 1 re BY
By
Approve Mayor: Da Approved by yor for Sub ission to Cou cil
BY BY
P ISHEO �;: ';�: � 1987
. � � . � -15��
'� � � ' . - . i75�.��
An rdina ce ending chapter 409 of the Saint Paul
Legislative Code pert ining to Intoxicating Liquor.
THE COIINCIL �OF E CI Y OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN:
' Section �
That sectibn 409. Q8(1 ) of the Saint Paul Legislative Code b and
is hereby amend to ead as follows:
(11) Ther shal be provided in all zoning districts, ther
than -4 o B-5 istricts, off-street parking spaces fo all
on-sa e pr ises as provided herein:
(a) ransf r or new issuance to a structure ewly
const ucted for that purpose, off-street parking a the
� rate of o e sgace for each 45 square feet of p tron
area.
b) Trans er or new issuance to an existing stru ture
ot revio sly licensed for on-sale purpases, off-
stree par ing at the rate of one space for eac 45
squar feet of licensed patron area minus the aumb r of
� off-s reet parking spaces which would be required for
he revio s use of the same area under the exi ting
onin code provisions. Existing parking �seri�a�srg hich �'�
rev' usl served the prediana n'e same area shal not
e c unted to meet the requirements,-unless an a in
exces of what would have been re uired or e
revi us us . end in no eden� sha�� parking be req �red
" n e eeas e€ Frhat �►en�d he�re been reqn�red if �he .
�rne ttre ere nex�y eons�rt�e�ed- Pravided; hair ver;
hatN addi ional off-street parking shall be req ired
' � �h eemp ted dt€�erenee be�ireen �he o�d aad new t�.sea
ia �e a tha �8 perean�,- er if the number of addit'onal _
, , space requ red is five or fewer spaces . -
�• ' i,(c) xpans on of licensed area, off-street parki g at.
he ame r te e� one sp�ee for eneh. 45 aqt�nre �ee of
xpan ed p tron area; and in nddstion,-as transfe or
ew s.suan e to an existin structure not rev' usl
licen ed fo on-sale ur oses lus 25 percent of any
parki g sh rtfall for the existing bai�ding lia nsed
area. "Pa king shortfall" shall mean the diffe ence
, etwe n �he nt��nber af perksng spaeea xkrch �aoe��d have
een reqtti ed sf �he bt�i�d�ag ho�esisg �he �ie naed
'�ab sshme � kad been neFr�y eans�rtseted and the n ber
�e� p rk�ng apeces ae�ne��y grovtded on �he dn� ef
eomp� tton of the expen�ien o� bhe �icensed n eone
. s ace for ach 45 s uare feet of atron floor ar for
the e istin icensed area minus the number of ki
's ace actu 11 rovided for that area.
(d) ' Patro area" shall mean to include all areas used
'by th publ c, and exclu�es all areas used exclusively
1
� � ' . � � �,- /572
� � �7�.��
by emp oyees for work, storage or office space.
Qe) M dific tion of Parking Requirements.
) T e co ncil may modify the off-street pa in�
r quire ents . contained in this section upon
a plic ion made for that purpose and upon
f ' ndin made by the council that granting of such
m ciifi tion would not have a substa tial
' d trim tal impact on the surro ding
, n ighb hood. Modification, if granted, sha 1 be
b resolution adopted by at least five aff irm tive
v tes .
ii ) T e c ncil sha11 consider the application t a
p blic earing following mailed notice thereo to
p oper owners within 350 feet of the pro osed
1' cens premises. The council may require, by
r solu ion, the payment of an administr tive ,
oces ing fee for parking modific tion
a plic ions. Applications and fees shall be made
t the license inspector.
ii) � e eo et� meey ne� �nedify the req�sred eff-a ree�
rk�n reqniremen�a by mere than �546 of �he
onnt reqnired bp thi' see�ien-
_ _,� .�.::a,i ' )In ranting any modification, the council may
a tach reasonable conditions regarding the
1 cati n, design, character and other featur s of .
! t e 1 'censed structure and parking area d emed
cess ry for the protection of the adj cent
ighb rhood.
v� iv) Of -street modifications shall remain with
licens d premises so long as the characteris i.ces �
th licensed estatilishment remain unalt red.
..----�- I the vent parking problems arise, the co ncil _
y co sider taking -adverse action pursuant t the
roced res set forth in Chapter 31Q of this ode.
ch dverse action may incl.ude requiring the
. licens e to do one or more of the following:
. . '� ) Pr vide more off-street parking;
� - ' ) Re uce the usable floor space; •
) Re uce patron capacity(seating or bar are ) .
Section 2
This ordin nce hall ake effect and be in force thirty days from
and after ts p ssage, approval and publication.
�.
. • 2
' :, � � G1`'�1' ':,� �J -/��� �
_ .. , � ly���
CI Y OP` SAINT PAUL
i�ii�ii�n '
O ICE OF TH� CITY COIINCIL
KIKI SONNEN '
Councilmember
MOLLY O'ROURKE
I.egidative Aid� '
MEMORANDUM
DATE: Nove ber 12 1986
T0: Joe arched •, License Inspector
FROM: Kiki Sonnen Councilmember �J'�
�
RE: Park ng Req irements for Bars
Recentl , I as ed Jerry Segal to amend Chapter 410 of the
Legislative ode wh ch deals with parking requirements for the
3.2 or non-i toxica ing malt liquor establishments so that it
would be con istent with the recent amendment to Chapter 409.08
(11) of the egisla ive Code which deals with off-street parking
requirements for li ensed onsale liquor establishments.
In disc ssions ith Wendy Lane, Jerry found that the code
did not adeq ately eflect the interpretation used by the Zoning
Sectio to d termin parking requirements. In fact, the existing
code allowed for th ee or four separate interpretations.
So the nclose amendments to both 3.2 and full liquor
license esta lishme ts will conform with the Zoning Section�s
current meth ds of etermining parking compliance. In addition,
the amendmen s allo s the City Council to modify the parking
requir�ements if the e is not alot of negative impact on the
surrou ding eighbo ood.
Y, ur co ents the proposed amendments are most welcome
since they a e part f the licensing statutes.
If you ave an questions, please call me at 298-5378. I am
introd cing hese a ndments now so that your comments and
anyoth r's c n be b ught forth in committee discussion.
KS/mb
, � . c��
Enc.
�,n,�,�;{ �,�
cc: W' ndy L e, Hou ing & Building Code Enforcement ?�,'�' _;
J rry S gal, Ci y Attorney's Office ,'
C ty Co cilme ers • • ,�
='�' t, �
��Y> _�=? �
. ..rj �<
� -..
�'� C.,+�,�
CTTY HALL SEVE TH FLO R SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA 55102 �'� 612/298-5378
s�4e
_ -
• � ' �G/-'-'�(o-/57Z
. . /7�3�
CIT OF SAII�T PAUL
� :..o.:.
OF CE OF THE CITY CQIINCZL
•f19\����4��T . .
.�� ��l��ijQaY�� •
=='g�" �dte .
.
January 26, 1987
C MM TEE REPORT
�
TO = �aint PQUi City Cour�cil
F R O M � C O i'11 !r t@� 0 h C i ty Deve 1 opment and Transportat i on
CNAIR i 11 iam L . Wi ison
� ;; , � , 11 Ap eal MidwaY Coalition, District 11 , N �-
`�� �r )�'" co formi g use for 1415 Thomas tMoved out of
;,`� co itte without recammendatian}
,,
2 Or inanc amending Chapter 410 of the Legislati e ' �
Co e per aining to Non-Intoxicating Malt �iquor
. - -�, -- - (C mm i tt e -recommends approva l ) .4.
3 -. . . A � � . #t'�f-�t'�" .�449 of t l�'i� :L.�'�1��;. �
G . ;.� �,,,� � -�t� I�c��c��r� ;L i q�a�r f"�rk�i�+g
r e u i�:�;m ts f€�r ba�*s} ••f` - tee" .r�z�+�ends
a , .crv�t 1�
4. An lysis and recommendations on panhandling
(T is it m was referred to committee on 7/29/86 '
fo disc ssion - no action was needed by commit ee)
I
CTTY HALL SE ENTH FLpOR SAINT PAUL. MIN ESOTA 55102
__ *�'�i,��
�= ��- �s7z.
^ �' e 7�13 C.�
-��������^��vo -� � � ��� CITY OF 5 I NT PAU L
_._.,.�,.. .,�,�
=�'� �'%'- OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK
'; �;
�` ��� '' ALBERT B. OLS N, CITY CLERK
S q� wQ c
" ,,, �.�'' 386 City Hall,Saint Pa I,Minnesota 55102
`'o �..•
Umnw ..a
612-298-4231
CEORGE LATIMER �
MAYOR
February 5, 1 87
ATTE TION DISTRICT COUNCILS
P BLIC HEARING NOTICE
At the r gula City Council meeting on Tuesday, February 24
1987 at 10:00 A.M. in the City Council Chambers, a publi
hearing �'will be h ld to consider final adoption of tw
ordinances a nding Chapter 409 and Chapter 410 of th
Legislat�ive Code pertaining to intoxicating an
non-into icat ' ng m lt liquor establishments and parkin
requirem nts (86-1 72 and 86-1573) . Copies of th
ordinanc s w re pr viously sent to District Councils b
Councilm�ember Sonne .
�
ABO:th
;
- { . 'C;`� I
lst ., _
j- �i ��'� 2nc1`_ _ '' :-� - =� ��
3rd - � '�
- "'� � �/ Adopced t,� ; c, ,�
�
Yea �_��,��,-
Nays �
DREtJ
,I ��_ �� �����
' NICOSIA �
: !7 y�=�^
RETTMAN
�CHEIBEL
SONNEN
�dILSON
MR. P ESIDENT T�DESCO
i
I