86-202 WMITE - CITV CLERK
PINK - FINANCE COIlIICIl �/� ` �/�
CANARV - DEPARTMENT GITY OF SAINT PAUL v�
BLUE - MAYOR F11C NO. ��
Valuationsy-tRoom 218 ��unC •` �.e �`u�Z�n
Presented By
�eferred To ���-1�- W� ��--5 Committee: Date 1—��'��
Out of Committee By Date
',7xl:ca�.���SP on Dece;..Aer 5� 198�!� an as5es�rr�eni� in �he amount o�
$860 . 67, ro:� -che a_rnpr_ov�men� oi �L�e �lley i� Bloc,c 3, College
:�lace, Taylo�' s Div_i�ione 1�s�esv�nen-c �'ile iJo. 2525, �-�as leviea
against the iollowing c�scriu�o �ro�e�ty owned by i��. ;arl
S�ce:�ioerg:
Loi: 13, �lock 3o Coll�ge Place, iaylorPs Diva.sion
ana;
s?�.�;�.�A,So an a�peal or -�he a�ove a�se�ar�ten� was filea by
i�x�. Stenb�rg on Dccenibex 21� 193� a��d -�.h�oua� discu�sion a ��o-
.�ao5ea s��Lle�s��n�� �a� a��en reacher� �ursuan� Lo �he a-c��achea
�ti�ula-�:�on of S�-L��ler�len-� and Disrl;ssal�
�'A'��.�FOQ� B� IT R�SOLVED -the Ci�ty Cou,�c�_1 of 'cne Ci�� oi
aa�nt .�a_ul he�eby au-'�.ho�izes -�he C��cy �`�-cto.rney' s Oa�frice �co en��.e�c
in��o a �ti?�ula`ion of �e�-�lemen� ��i��.� M�. .�a�l ��enb��°a -�o se����le
�ne assess�r,en-c a��eal pxea�n-�ly on �ile in Dis���sc-c Cou:��� Fiie
�Vo. 2525 ior �c;�.� ir�l�r.over.:.ien� o� alle� as �_n�ica�ted in such rile;
b� �educing -i.he original assessrnen�� of $860. 67 nlu� acc:�-ued
in-�ebes�. ��o 5450 . 00 ��h�ch is -che amoun�c alrea�y paid ;�y
�ir. S�enberg.
COUNCILMEN Requested by Department of:
Yeas p�� Nays �
�Z�����-� F inan
�� [n Favor �
Scheibel
sonnen � Against B ctor�
�'bdesc�
W i Ison
Adopted by Council: Date FEB � � 1986 Form Appro d by it Attorney�
Certified Pas d by ouncil Se tary By e , �2 2� $S
By c
t�ppr v by Mavor: Date � L `' 1��U Approv Mayor for Sub ' '
�
P ,� ,,.,r� �j�� i - 198 By
l��,L���,� .. ��:
Finance & Ma.�asement Servicesy DEPARTMENT l�`�i�o�� NO 366�
Peter White , •CONTACT
298-5�17 PHONE
January 7, L986 DATE 1 Q,/�� e�
ASSIGN NUMBEf� FOR ROUTING ORDER (Clip All Locations for Signature) :
partment Director � Director of Management/Mayor
Finance �nd Management Services Director � City Clerk
Budget Di'rector
City Attarney
WHAT WILL BE 'ACHIEVED BY TAKING ACTION ON THE ATTACHED MATERIALS? (Purpose/
Rationale) :
Settlement fd�r appeal of assessment for alley improvement at 904 Aldine Street.
�tECEIVED
�p t�� r ' � 'E�w;�
_ RFCElVE� ��,,..
,. ```�' ��,� �o,r�r. ..,. __,n . VI'll\ 8 IJV�
��,��_ .�.�v.t���E
�y+�� OF�ICE Of THE DIRECTOR
COST/BENEFIT, BUDGETARY AND PERSONNEL IMPACTS ANTICIPATED: �P4RT��NT d� �ANCE
R AND MA�rAGEMENT SERy�S
Minor ' ( Installment to property taxes $ 83.38 ('85 pay '86)
Financial ( Balance due 382.35 plus interest
Impact ' (
TOTAL $465.73+
FINANCING SO '�,IRCE AND BUDGET ACTIVITY NUMBER CHARGED OR CREDITED: (Mayor's signa-
ture not re-
Total Amo�nt of Transaction: quired if under
$10,000)
Funding S�urce: Assessments and.PIA 1983
807-62902-0731-62516
Activity Number:
ATTACHMENTS�List and Number All Attachments) :
1. Council 'Resolution for approval.
2. Letter �rom City Attorney"s office recommending settlement.
3. Copy of 'Stipulation of Settlement.
r
�
DEPARTMENT R�VIEW CITY ATTORNEY REVIEW
�Yes No Council Resolution Required? _ Resolution Required? Yes No
Yes �No Insurance Required? Insurance Sufficient? Yes No
Yes x No'�' Insurance Attached:
(SEE REVERSE SIDE FOR INSTRUCTIONS)
Revised 12/84
. . � ������
���T•a. CITY OF SAINT PAUL
;~� '�s�, OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY
�,, �li�ii�n o€ EDWARD P. STARR, CITY ATTORNEY
?� �r
�6Q��•�� 647 City Hall,Saint Paul,Minnesota 55102
612-298-5121
GEORGE LATIMER
MAYOR
December 23 , 1985
To: Members of the City Council
From: John B. McCormick ���/�.�
SZ"
Assistant City Attorney -
Re : Assessment Appeal of Earl Stenberg for improvement of
alley, Assessment File No. 2525, District Court File
No. 470775
On December 6, 1984 the City Council levied an assessment in the
amount of $860 . 67 for the improvement of an alley adjacent to
Mr. Earl Stenberg' s property, Mr. Stenberg filed an apneal of
the assessment on December 21, 1985 which was assigned Jistrict
Court File No. 470775 .
Mr. Stenberg' s property is unusually located in �that it is bounc�ed
on its east and south side by alleys . The improvement which is
the subject of this suit was for the alley located on Mr. Stenberg' s
east side.
In preparation for trial in this r:matter, Valuations Engineer
J. William Donovan viewed the subject property and after recon-
sideration believes that the amount already paid by Mr. Stenberg
would be a fair amount to be assessed aqainst this property in
terms of benefit received as a result of this improvement. The
amount paid by Mr. Stenberg is $450 .00. As attorney for the
Ci�y in this matter I concur with 1vir. Donovan' s analysis and
believe the case should be settled for the $450 . 00 amount that
has already been paid.
JMCcC:rl
Att.Att.
� , . � . � �� -ao�
STATE OF MINNESOTA DISTRICT COURT
COUNTY OF RAMSEY SECOND JUDICIAL DISTRICT .
File No. 470775
-------------------------------
Earl Stenberg, � �
Appellant,
vs. . STIPULATION OF SETTLEMENT
AND DISMISSAL OF APPEAL
City of St. Paul, a Minnesota FROM SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS
Municipal Corporation,
Respondent.
-------------------------------
IT IS HEREBY STIPULATED by and between t;�e parties ,
� hereto, that the proceedings in �District Court File No.
470775 may be and are hereby dismissed with prejudice and
without costs to either party; said proceedings are regarding
property common?y known as 904 Aldine St. , legally described
.
in Ramsey Cour.ty Tax Records as follows (hereinafter referred
to as the subject property) : •
Lot 13 , B�.ock 3 , Colleqe Place, Taylor' s Division
IT IS FURTHER STIPULATED by and between the parties
hereto, that this stipulation of dismissal is based upon
the facts and agreement set forth as follo.ws :
That on December 6 , 1984' .an assessment was levied on
• the subject property by the City of St. Paul in the
amount of $860 . 67 for the improvement of the alley in
Block 3 , College Place Taylor ' s Division by grading and
paving the alley and constructing sewer for storm water
purposes, said assessment to be collected with the
property taxes in 10 equal installments with interest
accruing at 9°� per annum; �
y .
• . . - ° . �0'.�--;�L�;Z
Tha.t appellant Earl Stenberg has filed an appeai from
the assessment on December 21, 19$y in Ramsey County
District Court and was assigned District Court File
No. 470775.
That since the time of the assessment levy the Appellant
has made one payment in the amount of $450 . 00 which was
credited as a payment of $435.84 against the principal
and $14 . 16 against the interest accrued.
That the City of St. Paul has agreed to reduce the
amount of the original assessment to $435 .84 . As a
result Appellant' s payment of $450. 00 is sufficient to
cover said amount plus the interest that has accrued
� and in effect has paid the assessment in full . Any
remaining amounts owed will be excused from payment and
removed from the property tax roles.
That in return for this reduction the Appellant Earl'
Stenb'erg, Marjorie Stenberg, and Marilyn Cummings agree
to dismiss their appeal of the assessment.
�' � .. . � . . . �n . � - . � . .
D.ated: ,
JOHN B. McCORMICK
� Assistant City Attorney
� 647 City Hall & Courthouse
St. Paul, Minnesota 55102
Attorney for Respondent
APPELLANTS
��t r sl /�..frc1�,
EARL STE'�1BERG `;'
. . ( � _ �,
• l��/!;�s ��..n - _ •._�-/, '
; .:,-( _t_t� ,/'.' .C.-j.�.G�'
MARJORI STENBERG
�
,�;^_�- " �'r.�_) �,?! -.�Ri. � .�� ,
.
M RILYN"CU.MMIN€�S ! 4-
2 .
G�-� -a o.�
. llembers:
___ • �i IT Y U F �AI�T'1` PA U L �nnicaNRe%eman�a�
11111 d ' g(�Ll 9oIItleti
41 ��� lj OFFIOE OF THE CITY COUNOIL � John Draw (Alt)
<
._... ��
Date: February 10, 1986
� � � � C o mmitte e Re o rt
p
To: Saint Paul City Council � �
From: Committee on Public Works
Chris Nicosia, Chair
The Public Works Committee at its meeting of February 5, 1986 took the
following action:
Hearina Date
1 . 2/11/86 VACATION: Petition of Bradley D. Stark and Associates for
the vacation of part of Bradley Street located between
Whitall Street and York Avenue for the purpose of
multiple residential construction.
Recommended approval .
2. 12/31/85 RESOLUTION: authorizing an indemnification agreement
between the City and the Chicago and North Western
Transportation Company for the storage of the Hazel
Avenue Pedestrian Bridge truss on Transportation Company
property ( laid over from 1-22-86) .
Recommended approval .
3. 1 /7/86 RESOLUTION: amending Chapter 113 pertaining to snow
removal - this change will remove exemption of weekends
and holidays from the time the division is required to
allow for removal of snow 8 ice from sidewalks ( laid over
from 1-22-86) .
Recommended approvai .
4. 1/21/86 RES,�LUT i ON: approv i ng 'e��1 ement for ap�pea 1 s�f�.,,��s�smer�t
=:..
�� i ey i mprovernent at 9E##. A�i��Street t�t� Lot ;�;3.�'
�F .--3. Cottag+t Piac�, Ta�le�-'s O�Fvfsian. :."""
Recaanended �a�,ova i .
5. 2/Il/86 FINAL ORDER: To decide on improving Maryland Avenue from
Payne Avenue to Burnquist Street by grading and paving
with bituminous material , constructing concrete curb and
gutter, constructing drainage structures. ornamental
lighting system and signal system, planting trees. and
doing all other work necessary to complete said
improvement.
Sent back to City Council without recommendation.
C1TY HALL SEVENTH FLOOR SAINT PAUL, MINNESUTA 55102 612/298-4475
.�as