87-1488 WMITE - CITV CLERK I,
PINK - FINANCE � G I TY O F SA I NT PA U L Council
CANARV - DEPARTMENY File NO. �� /���
BLUE - MAYOR
�
' Council Resolution -\
Presented B �����/�`' ;`/'
Y
Referred Tp Committee: Date
Out of Corrymittee By Date I
WHEREAS, the City of Saint Paul through its Division of Public Health is
required b�y Statute to prepare a bienial Corrr�nnunity Health Services Plan to
recieve a �ommunity Health Services Subsidy; and,
WHEREAS, this plan was presented for public review and comment and there were no I
changes re�ommended by the public; and
��
WHEREAS, This plan must be approved by the City Council as the Board of Health;
!
THEREFORE E IT RESOVED, that the City Council sitting as the Board of Health
does accep this plan for submission to the Ramsey County Board for their �
inclusion f this plan in the Ramsey County Community Health Services Plan for
Saint Paul and Suburban Ramsey County to be transmitted to the Minnesota i
Commission r of Health.
�
I
COUNCILMEN Requested by Department of:
Yeas N ys
°feN' � [n Favor
��R��-
Nicosia
Scheibel - __ Against BY '
�� a
Wilson
��j j '� �8 Form Approve by it torne I
Adopted by Council: Date
(� ,
Certifie P :sed by Co ncil , cretary
B `�
sy n
t�pprov y iNavor. a u�� � � �07 Appro by Mayor for Su ss' n to Council
I
By _ 8
' P�.E$�.� ?� � n s t��:�
I I
: �'.'. HOW TO USE THE GRE�N SI�ET
The GREEN SHEET has several PURPOSES: � ' � �
1. to assist in routing documents and in securing required signatures
2. to brief the reviewers of documents on the i.mpacts of approval - �
3. to help ensure that necessary supportin�c materials are prepared, and, if
. - ,;
� required, ettached. .. . ,
Providing complete informa'tion under the li:sted headin.gs enables reviewers to make
decisions on the documents and eliminates follow-up contacts that may delay execution.
The COST/BENEFIT, BUDGETARY AND PERSONNEL IMPACTS T�eading provides space to explain
the cost/benefit aspects of the decision. Costs and benefits related both to City
budget (General Fund and/or Special Funds) and to broac�er financial impacts (cost
to users, homeowners or other groups affected by the action) . T3�e personnel impact
is a description of change or shift of Full-Time Equivalent (FTE) positions. �
If a CONTRACT amount i� less than $10,d00; the Mayor's s�.gna��ire' is nOt required,
if the departm�nt directar signs. A contract musti always be first signed by-the
outside ag�ncy before 'routing�through` City offices. �� �
Below is the preferred ROUTING for the five most frequent types of documents:
. CONTRACTS (assumes authorized budget exists) '
� 1. Outside Agency 4. Mayor
2. Initiating Department 5. Finance Director
3. City Attorney 6. Finance Accounting
� ,
ADMINISTRATIVE ORDER (Budget Revision) AD�IINISTRATIVE�ORDERS ,(all others) .
1. Activ�;ty Manac�er ; 1. ,Initiating DQpaxtment �
2. Department Accountant , ; 2. City Attorney,
3. Department Director 3. Director of Management/Mayor
4. Budget Director 4. City Clerk '
5. City Clerk
6. Chief Accountant, F&MS
COUNCIL RESO�UTION (Amend. Bdgts./Accept. Grants) COUNCIL RESOLUTION (all others)
1. Department Director 1. Initiating Department
2. Budget Director 2. City Attorney
3. City Attorney 3. Director of Manaqement/Mayor
4. Director of Management/Mayor 4. City Clerk
5. Chair, Finance, Mngmt. & Personnel Com. 5. City Council
6. City Clerk
7. City Council
8. Chief Accountant, F&MS
SUPPORTING MATERIALS. In the ATTACHMENTS section, identify all attachments. ' If the
Green Sheet is well done, no let�er of transmittal need be ine�luded (unl�s§ "signing
such a letter is one of the requested actions) .
Note: If an agreement requires evidence of insurance/co-insurance, a Certificate of
Insurance should be one of the attachments at time of routing.
Note: Actions which require City Council Resolutions include:
1. Contractual relationship with another governmental unit.
2.. Collective bargaining contracts. � .
3. Purchase, sale or lease of'land.
4. Issuance of bonds by City.
5. Eminent domain.
6. Assumption of liability by City, or granting by City of indemnific�tion. :
7. Agreements with State or Federgl Goverr�ment under which they are providing
funding. � • .
8. Budget amendments. . ,
�?��/��
TABL� OF CONTENTS PAGE
Secti'on 1 Forms
}
Applilcation Cover Form 166
� � . Ass�nrtancES �d -Agr�eemer�ts .1b7 .
Code Changes 1985-1987 197-198
Sectipn 2
�
Saint Paul Profile 200-217
Sectio�n 3
Environmental Health 220
Family, Health 230
Health� Promotion 238
• Disease Prevention and Control 243
Sect i or� 4
Index 254
II
164
. , � /�/�'�'
� �r �
APPLICATION COVER FORM
INDENTIFICATION AND AUTHORIZATION
::g::::::i::::i:::»>;::;�:;::;:<:?:<::h:i:::::;<:<:;?:;::<.:::i<::::�:::::::::::;::i:::::::?>:«:;:::>::»::>:::<::<?:>:«�:::
�v
AN1E OF A PLICANT ORGANIZATION '�'>`�:1 `>::>::::>:<::::::>;»:?::
�.;:«::;;:.;:.:.;;:;:.::.::.:.:::.::::.::.::;;::;;:.;;:;.;;:::.>�.«.>::.;
I' .;:<:»:>�E3<>i?�E�'�>:�?V�ti���>:1�<'>TH::�::::.:::::::::::::.:
`::<::<:::�S�AC�.::y.:��}H,;���;�.1N#.Y�.;:::::;.:::::>:
1' H alth
P Division of Pub ic e
t aul
Sain
?�<:::>�»`�3A1'�:::'l��;:�Y��`'<:�;::::::�:�<:>::»;�>:::<:<::>':;:>::�;;:;>'<�::::»
.<:;:::.::.::.:::.::.:;:�;;;;:.»:;;;�;:�;;:.;::.:.;:.:;:;;:.;;:.,:.;;:.:;;:;:.>:.;:.;:;.:.;:.;:.;>;;:.;;:.;:.:
:{:;:::`:::::::::::««:;:<::::
.
»:>::»�::<�.>...
..... ....................................:...............:.:.........
..w..�„�:::;�>:::"«:>::::>�>::�><>��:::>:����::>:':;::>�<::::::�:`::::>:::<::<>':>:::>::»::>:»>�><::>:<::
- .4:;:>:::>:.>�.;:.;::.;:.;:;.:;.:.:::;:.::.>:.:.:.;::.::.;:.;:;:.;:.>::::;.:��;.:>.::.:::::::::::::.;>:<:.:::,;».::::.;::;;
SPONSORING UNITS OF GOVERNMENT FLTNDING PERIOD
CiryJCounty Date Approved 1 / 1 / 88 to 12/ 3]/ 89
City of Sa�nt Paul
SUBSIUY REQUEST
Name of Counties 1988 Local Budget 1988 CHS Subsidy Budgct
c�y o s pnt Pa� ��it�,� �r.1�0,R5R (=nmm�r�ril Rn�,?�9
('� nf �ap nt Pai�l i al) 3,035.487 (prot�osedl
�
TOTAL 6,156,345 802,239
1989 SUBSIDIY REQUFST S 802.239
ALL APPRO�RIATE REGIONAL REVIEW AGENCIES (LIST EACH RDC) WERE SENT COPIES OF TH1S
.
APPLICATION:
Director ���Qlm Mitchell Director
Agency 1viPtmnolitan Council Agency
_
Address �nn r�t-,m Srn�arE? Address
�—
�aint Pai�l� Mi_nnesota 55101_ '
Date Sent Oct,obex 30, 1987 Date Sent
Dircctor Director
Abcncy Agency
AdJress Address
Datc Sent Date Sent
Application is made for a subsidy under the provisions of the Local Public Health Ac[ in Ihe amount and for the
purposes state� herein. By signature, the Authorized Official agrees and has the authority to agree to comply �vith the
conditions and reporting requuements, consistent with applicable MDH Rules and Minnesota Statute stated herein.
Authorized Official �
r�gma ignature
Tille p� ti c He?1 th ��rvi c-�G Mar,aqPr Date �cert�}w'' �A-i �987
�
Subsidy Application Materials and Forms 11
166
� � �L%��4
��= 7
ASSURANCES AND AGREEMENTS
BY SIGNATURE, THE AUTHORIZED OFFICIAL AGREED AND ASSURES THAT:
1. Services w+ill be provided :n accordance with State and Federal laws, rules and policies.
2. ' The Board of Health will comply with state and federal requirements for equal opportunity
employment.
. . . . . -3. �� � -Y'��am��-eoa�ply-a�t�-st�te �d �fedes� �roq+�+s�ts��]atiag�ta•data..�riirac� nr .
confidentiality of informadon collected on individuals.
4. The Board will provide the Minnesota Department of Health with information referenced in
the CHS plan where applicable. �
5. . Standards for programs or activities will be used in carrying out affected programs or activities
where those standards exist.
6. The requirements for full community participation, as deGned in Minnesota Rules 4700.1800,
have been met. .
7. The Health Advisory Committee or Health Task Force of any Human Services Board Advisory
Committee in the county where applicabie (Minn. Stat. 402.03), shall meet the composition and
re�orting requirements of the Community Health Services Advisory Committee required by
Minnesota Statute.
8. The Board will comply with all standards relating to fiscal accountability that apply to the
Minnesota Depaztment of Health, specitically,
a. The local match identitied in the budget submission complies with the definition
specified in Minnesota Rules 4700.0100, Subpart 15 and meet the following tests:
' ' 1) Cash contributions are cash oudays, including the outlay of money contributed
by other public agencies and institutions and private organizations and
, individuals. '
2) In-kind/Direct Assistance contributions represent the value of non-cash
contributions provided by (1) the applicant, (21 other public agencies and
institutions, and (3) private organizations and mdividuals. Such goods and
' services directly benefit and are identitiable from the applicant's records.
SpeciFcally, the agency calculates the hours of volunteer services by the same
method used by the agency for its employees, and the Board documents the
basis for determining charges for personal services, supplies and expenses.
b. The Board will submit budget revisions to the Commissioner for prior approval in
accordance with CHS Policy No. 4 (S/1/78). (Attached)
' c. Reports will be filed with the Commissioner of Health in accordance with Mianesota
Rules 4700.1700.
d. The Board will maintain a Financial Management System that provides:
1) Accurate, current, and complete disclosure of the financial results of each
activity.
� 2) Records that identify adequately the source and application of funds for
subsidy supported activities. These records shall contain information pertaining
to subsidy awards and authorizations, obligations, unobligated balances,
liabilities (encombrances), outlays and income.
3) Demonstration that the Board has effective control over the accountability for
all funds, property and other assets.
4) Compazison of actual obligations with budget amounts for each activity.
� Subsidy Application Materials and Forms 13
167
� i.�" ,�' /`���
- C�
.
� Accounting records that are supported by source documentation.
6) Audits that can be made by or at the direction of the Board or the
Department of Health. CHS fmancial records will be retained until audited,
_ with the following qualifications: _
aa) The records will be retained beyond this period if sudit Fmdings have
not been resolved. -
bb) Records for non-expendable property which was acquired with subsidy
funds will be retained for three years after its fmal disposition.
AUTHORIZED OFFICIAL ' •
TITLE Pt�hl i r HPaI th �Pn�i ma ManagPr
DATE Septgnber 10 , 1987
•
14 ' Subsidy Application Materials and Forms •
168
_ _
. C� ��,����,
MDH-�HS AGENCY IMMUNIZATION PROGRAM AGREEMENT
INSTRU�TIONS:
Z'he Saint Paul Division of Public Health CHS Agenry agrees to:
1) Adaiinister Department-supplied vaccine in accordance with MDHpo licy to use federally
supported vaccines for children whose families are unable to pay for them and who aze not �
. . . . . �.,:ca+errd..,�or ..b�r.tbi:�d.�arty.,�a�rers .
;2) Provide the a�propriate "Important Information" forms to all vaccinees (parents or
�guardians) receiving vaccinations m public clinic settings and to private physicians if Ghey elect
�to use the forms in accordance with the conditioas specified in the 'Private Physician
Certi6Cation" form. CHS ageneies may include appropriate identificatioa on the forms. Any
other addition to the forms, or variations from the language must have the prior written
approval of the Director, Centers for Disease Control CDC). Any re4uest for change must
' be submitted to the Minnesota Department of Health �MDH) which will forward the request
to the Centers. The a propriate Important Information forms at the time of this agreement
are dated: Polio - 3/1�3; MMR - 3/1/83; DTP/Td - 2/6/86. If updated forms become
available, the MDH agrees to provide these to the CHS agency at the earliest possible date.
3) Obtain documentation of the recei�t by vaccinees (parents or guardians) of the Important
Informadon form relating to the vaccuie administered.� The documentation shall consist of the
signed lowerpo rtion of the Important Information form or a separate signature card which
contains the following:
'I have read the information contained in the Important Information form(s) about the
' disease(s) and the vaccine(s). I have had a chance to ask quesdons which were
answercd to my satisfaction. I believe I understand the benefits and risks of the
vaccine(s) and request that the vaccine(s) indicated below be given to me or to the
person named below for whom I am authorized to make this request"
• This statement must appear at the top of the signature card or 1og sheet and the form must
include at minimum the following entnes: Name, address, date of birth, age, type of vaccine(s), �
clinic identification, date of vaccination, manufacturer and lo[ number, s�gnature of person to
receive vaccine or person authorized to make the request, date of signature, and date prin[ed
on the appropriate Important Information form.
4) Obtain a signed copy of the "Private Physician Certification" form from all physicians to
- whom the CHS agency furnished vaccine which is to be used in private pract�ce. A new
Certitication must be obtained every two years, corresponding to each CHS Biennial Plan.
5) Establish �rocedures for the retention of the signed portion of the Important Information
form and Prrvate Physician Certification form, and other types of approved documentation for
at least ten years followin� the end of the calendar year in which the forms aze signed and,
upon written request, furn�sh copies of the forms to the MDH or the CDC.
6) Assure that public clinics, schools and other a�encies to which the CHS agency redistributes
vaccane agree to the use and retention of Important Information forms as specified in 2, 3, and
5-
7) Assure that, in the case of a school-based program or other programs where the
iaformation form is to be read and signed in advance of the vaccine by a parent, guazdian or
other suthorized person who will not be present at the immunization clinic when the
vaccination is given, procedures shall be established and made known for answering questions
� by telephone or otherwise.
8) Assure that person(s) are available at each immunization clinic to ensure that prospective
vaccinees (parents or guardians) can read the information provided, and to answer questions
about the vaccine, its expected benefits, its normal risks, its contraindications (special warnin�s
, to vaccinees with low res�stance to infections), alternatives to vaccination, and to provide adv�ce
Subsidy Application Materials and Forms 17
; . 169 �
`�'� �'7_ ,��,�;1�
regarding medical assistance in the event of suspected vaccine reacdons. Clinics serving large
pumbers of persons for whom English is not a first language. must provide Important
Information statements in theu native language. Translations of Important Information forms
iare available from the Minnesota Depaztment of Health.
�9) Assure that the persoa administering the Important Information form(s) routinely asks
iwaccinees (parents or guardians) if they understand the informatioa provided to them and if
Wey have any questions.
�0) Designate a vaccine reaction coordinator and place the telephone number on each
Important Information form as the number to call regarding vaccme reactions. The reaction
wordmator(s) for thc agency is/are: Muriel Staanson, Peq C�
11) Report to the MDH all illnesses in vaccinees which be�an within 4 weeks of receipt of
vacc�ne and which aze severe enough to require hospitalizat�on or a visit to a physician or
other modical care personnel. Use the CDC Report form "Report of Adverse Event Following
' Immunization."
12) Provide the vaccine, whether administered in public clinics or by private physicians, without
charging the recipient for the cost of the vaccines.
13) Submit a quarterly vaccine usage and inventory report by the lOth of the month following
�he report penod. A report must be fded even if no vaccines were administered or distributed.
Use the MDH form 'Quarterly Report of Vaccines Administered and Distributed'
By signature, the Authorized Official agrees and has the authority to agree to comply with
�6ese conditions and reporting requirements consistent with applicable MDH Rules and the
�HS Act. In addition, by signature below, the Authoriud Official assures full compliance with
�11 items statcd herein.
�'��C �
• u�i t iTor��C�'c� ency.
cal Director Sept�il�r 10. 1987
it e ISate
I
,
18 Subsidy Application Materials and Forms
170 .
� ��_ ,���'
��
STATUTE AND RULE COMPLIANCE INFORMATION
The 'following information is needed to determine compliance with the Statute and Rules established for
ComRnuni:y I':oak� Services:
Age�tcy Name: saint Paul Division of Public xealth
. ,f . . ,,-.,l�t�"CSS' _
.
555 Cedar Street
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55101
Telephone Number:
' 612-292-7712 •
C�m.munity Health Board's Organization and Composition
1. How is your Community Health Board Organized? �
_�_ Single city
Single county
Joint powers Board composed of: (number o� cities
(number o� counties �
2. Is your Board organized under the Human Services Ad? � YES a NO
• 3. Are there any other Boards of Health within your Community Health Boazd's jurisdiction?
� YES � NO If yes, please indicate the number of Boards authorized for
each statutory source of authority.
Joint Powers Agreement (Minn. Laws (198'n, Chapter 309, Section 3, subd. 2,
and Section 10, subd. 2 (a)).
Delegation Agreement (Minn. Laws (198'n, Chapter 309, Section 7, subd. 2)
Eligibility for CHS Subsidy (Minn. Laws (198'�, Chapter 309, Section 10,
subd. 2 (b)) .
Existing CHS pro�ram in a county of 300,000 or more persons (Minn. Laws (198�,
Chapter 309, Secaon 10, subd. 2 (c))
4. Indicate the composition of your Board and the number of inembers who serve on it:
a. City council(s); 7 members
� b. County Board(s); members
c. Administrative Board; members
(describe the Administratrve Board's composition; i.e., "One third county commissioners,
one third general public, one thud providers")
d. Other; members (Describe):
Subsidy Application Materials and Forms 19
180
�
/ �`�
�,�_ �7_ '�
Coritmunity Participation
1. On what date was the written notice of the initiation of the planning process sent to
, interested persons? g� C��, ��on
2. To whom was the notice sent? (Categories are acceptable, i.e., newspapers, physicians,
city council members and etc.) See County Section
3. ' Date of Public Meeting(s)? g� C�ty ��on
4. CHS Advisory Committee:
a. Was the public notified of all advisory committee meetings? � YES � NO
.' b. Are there minutes and records of attendance on fde? � YES � NO
c. On what dates did the advisory committce meet during 1986/87?
, d. Are the advisory committee's bylaws or operating procedures � YES � NO
on fde?
5. , Are the following materials available for monitor review?
a Copies of public notices and miautes? � . YFS � NO
' b. Ctirrent roster for Community Health Services mailing? a YES � NO
.
Date it was last updated �� �„�„- 19R'7
' c. Inventor�+ of existin� health-related services in the a YFS � NO
community? Date it was last updated�eptenber 1987
Special Project Grants
List all'Special Project Grants submitted to MDH and the Date they were submitted.
Special Project Grant: Date Submitted:
� 6/12/87
1�Ft� Z/�i�R7
t�I — c�FrrrrvF; Q/'�i/£i7
E'AMILY PLANLQ , 7�'�1�R7
�'T� �I� _ 10/30/87 �
S[TPPT FMFTITAT. FYY)T� p�p�M F+OR inX�IF�T� TNFAT'FP$
���� 6/ 1/87
� � i Subsidy Application Materials snd Forms .
190 �
�,c ��- ;�i,r�
C
PERSpNNEL
Providd name, address, telephone for the following CHS key personnel: Where one person holds more
than one positioq repeat the. name only, where address is the agency address, write "Agency".
CHS 1Administrator:
Judith Barr 292-7712
Agency
Directnr Community Nursing:
Joa�n R. Forar�an 292-7727
Ager�cy
Directpr Home Health Services: �
Director Disease Prevention and Control:
Dr. Neal Holtan 292-7726
Agency
Directbr Emergency Medical Services:
Director Health Education:
Catlnerine Lyman-0nkka 292-7714
A9��Y
Directqr Environmental Health:
� Frank A. Staffenson 292-7771
Agency
Do the above staff ineet the minimum standards established in Rule 4700.1600 Subpart 3?
� 1'�S � NO If no, please identify and explain.
I Subsid A lication Materials and Forms 21
Y PP
191
Z6T
ZZ
� ��, 8
� � �
� `�
'� � �n ' o �c
�_`; � �= � �o �
\�
�
. � �
� �
tr.
�
�
m
� O O N �'1 O
,,,w � N c+� �--1 N
s
� �
��
� � o � o 0 0 0
ts• �--I M N N �--I lf1
� $ .
s' �
�' �
�
�' � o 0 0 0
.�, � �--1 O N L'1
�i� ri rl
�
h' �
�
�
�
� � -
E ` �y �
� Vl �
� �
` . � d' d' N O M �
.... . . .
, , � . . •
� _ .. . N , , . � . � _ _ _ � , ,; ._:,
''"�
C p
� � i � � �
e ` �
,"' � , J�i Z•2 y o .� � Z' J�i
= A , .� '.!•e _ :� � � i .. � r e � �
� c ± � �ga � � � � � �� � s �� �
� .y H � C.� � '.� � op� '+ � .� w = Z y � ++
E� •E e y S� � � i •�� � .� .Y .Y � e e � �
u. A V �. d L Y �t L r'I
e
< � t� c� r:. O S S�"" 2— 2 s i O � = O � ,
O = N �; e � � � �o a ° _ � = ,: � .� �
�t."�7- �'f��
Title of class:
DIRECTOR OF MEDICAL SERVICES
DES�CRIPTION OF WORK
Gleneral Statement of Duties: Performs managerial work in planning and
, directing the Medical Services of the Division of Public Health� and
performs related prof�ssional duties as required.
S�pervision Received: Works under the general guidance and administrative
direction of the Public Health Services Manager.
S�pervision Exercised: Exercises within the Division's Medical Service
unit medical superviaion directly and through subordinate supervisors
over professional, technical and clerical staff.
TYPICAL DUTIES PERFORMID
The listed examples may not include all duties performed by all positions in
this class.
Organizes, plans, delegates and directa the medical activities of the
Division of Public Health including family planning, iIIanunization,
venereal disease control, tuberculosis control, child health, nutrition,
' geriatric health and other medical programs.
,. Pr,ovides and directs the operation of a communicable disease surveillance
and control program for the City of St. Paul.
Prpvides professional supervision for other physicians working within the
Division.
Acits as a consultant for divisional health education and prevention programs.
Prpvidea technical advice in the operation of the medical laboratory.
Es�tablishes medical priorities and develops new medical service programs
for the .Division of Public Health.
Provides physician support services when needed in one or more of the
medical activities operated by the Division of Public Health.
Prpvides professional liaison between the Division and the Ramsey County
'Medical Society, St. Paul-Ramsey Hospital, and other professional medical
establiehmenta in the community.
As�iste in the development of the annual budget for the Medical Services
'programe.
Paxticipates Qe a member of the Division's Management Team.
Makea reports and recommendations to the Division's manager.
KNOWLEDGES, SKILLS AND ABILITIES
Tharough knowledge of the practice of inedicine.
Conlsiderable knowledge of public health principles, practices and programso
Co�siderable ability to plan, organize and delegate work.
Co�siderable ability to deal tactfully and efficiently with the public and
istaff personnel.
(�ontinued on reverse aide)
' Effective September 13, 1980
DIRECTOR OF MEDICAL SERVICES ,
, 193
��
' ,�� ��' ��f�
DIRECTOR OF MEDICAL SERVICES
, (continued)
Considerable ability to deal effectively with local care institutions and
medical groups.
MINIMUM QU�4�LIFICATIONS
Graduation from a recognized medical school and two (2) years of professional
experience in the field of internal medicine, pediatrics, family practice,
or ob#tetrics and gynecology. A Master's Degree in Public Health may be
subetituted for up to one (1) year of professional experience. Must be
licensed to practice medicine in the State of Minnesota.
t
�
�
�
�
I 194
� CU� �7 ����.
�
CHS i BUDGET FORM
INSTRUCTIONS:
This fbrm is the CHS budget form to be included in the CHS plan.
The fo�rm is divided into the following general fund categories: Local; CHS Subsidy, Vaccine
AllocaCioa; and Special Projed Grants, Other State, Other Federal.
. ,. ,_'i�eesi ,
Report the amount of local dollazs budgeted by program category. "Local" includes local tax levies,
gifts, f es for scrvices and revenues from contracts vv�th or gran[s from local organizations (i.e., schools, '
social �ervice agencies, community action agencies, hospitals, regional groups), or from foundations.
CHS Subsidy
Foi eaeh program, report the budgeted amount of dollars expected from MDH based on the formula in
the Local Public Health Act.
Vacciae AllocafSon
For thq Disease Prevention and Control program, budget the value of the vaccine that the agency
expects to receive from MDH. Also report this amount as an in-kind contribution.
Special Project Grants
Report, for each pr am, the bud�eted amount of dollars expeUed from each of the Minnesota
Department of Heal�s special pro�ect grants.
Other 5tate
Report jdollars expected from any other State agency, other than those identified as special project
. grants.
Other Federal
Report dollars expected from the Federal government under any program not previously specified.
DEFINI�TIONS:
Special �Project Grants: Those grants awarded by the Minnesota Depar[ment of Health for a special
purpose: Grants included in this category are:
• Women, Infan[s and Children Supplemental Food Program
• Family Planning Grants
• Maternal and Child Health Grants
• Refugee Health
• 'Indiaa Health
• Nonsmoking and Health �
• AIDS Prevention
Other State Grants: Revenue received from any other state agency or source other than those
identifie� as special projeet grants.
Federal Grants: Revenue received from the federal government under any program not specified
above.
In-Kind: Non-cash .effort on the part of, or on the behalf of those programs addressed in the CHS
Plan. F�ram�le: Volunteer sernces, supplies, facilities, equipment, and state-supplied vaccibne are to be
included 'as m-kind.
Budgeting and reportin$ in-kind expenditures are oPtiona! except in the case of MDH-supplied vaccine.
Also, ple�se note that d the CHS budget includes m-kind amounts, in-kind expenditures must be
reported.
! .
Subsidy Application Ma[erials and Forms 23
195 .
, 96T
� � tiZ
,�
� , .
i
�
�
��' °o °o rn � a0°o � o�o
w 01 O O� M c'7 � u�
�. . . . . . .
c. �1' O M 00 d' t0 00 �
l0 O N O l� 01 l!�
d1 00 00 01 N r-I 01
� . �
�-i � e-i l0
� � �'
� � �
. ,p 's `
� � �
� N N
O
u
w
N �
i
0
Q M � . .
.
�� �
� s � � � 0
_� �
�
o .
C � 2.�i;xo::>:i � .
:iY'ti>.�}j<;:'
i'r,:�,�
i i;�'{.:}'{:}:
��.�..
.r•..
, ::jty,-...;;.:: .
a,.
:.:k:£i>""'Y:;�'i;!.
"�:7'
Mi�:3:i
i".a..�
0
•::?j::X�S<it
� . ::..W/.•��.ti :�?Y1:S•���ti('i?l�• .v.:Y.i4:•iX�:.�.:
v�v,#.. ytiv�i:' T:::•.{. '>Y�.wSn�{:}'� �'f�'�'•"F....�.�� :•:�•;Z' .
.� :'vFr:::.'�?^+i.,q� 'i;AS9�' .<�.j'�;::•�: . r�r�::i;.r:`L.;.';�;:
�.� :;'Cq}:'�..;•Y,.:.. '•k,'�r �;�n;�; ..": . +>,• .'
:;_:rx'r.'•:,`..: ...{;';iS: .;.i'.,x.,;i: 'r.::o:�u;i.'•:ti':: :v;:z:i'i:�c>.ti,•r�,.�i." O O O r-i 00
'� 4 :•::x.::•>: :::�^�;:::�: •'•;•.�;`:�:::�;�:'•:::::;:'?:v::>.;;:;::::
t� {.., .`:�::?r�•.; <;:,ss5�?'; ,#.•:'r,';:�><.�:;; .... ri��.:`+.:?:;::;?�k;r:i• O O l� �O
r5:,
� ;Y f v.'..<`:;iyF'',f.,',+,r.�,.�,,`.'�•`: ;:�;:,•�,::k;:;: }^�.`;;<.::'3i�� `�'•`'•'"•"`o.,^.•r::::���':� N O O C M
. . .:: .}::':::.,•.':�•" " «�.�..''': ,,
� "'s,.�,�ifY&:<: .r`; .�ic;"`.iii;s .. >��,'.::k '' . f'�)
.c::� •'<��i; •<.%�.3::e:.:.. +�y�.::?: to�=; .•a:'`Y.�,��.;'•Y.::::"�t��. O Lfl d' CO
.4'i?��i:t:}:i�+IJ,:'•:fi':}:::.,t4ii:;:;i: irri+i:::i•',?ir�i�v'i ' v v. v:,.N'y�...y'
•:c?i::ci:::� '.:::5::; :;%•s{:�;r:�:: ; ri••;�,`s:.;.::;:�.}:,i N ln �--1 ri
y 'r:; :' •:;: .:;x•:r::•r:� ::•::;: �• �..:
I ";�Y.'t%:::�i,•yL:•'•;ryf:;. ';�:p.;:o.;ov:.::�.:':fi.,`:�.�x.'':;%A%�f3%:'�i%L� ;,`;::�'
, w•+;•�' ..�.',tl�,x���� •..,>`... ,•r.•::.: /.'%�'% �O
.;^.:;..a.>::::. <-•.:• „';e;:;:;ty:;:;: ;.£;,.;�.
;;:
... �.v O..:. 4::i:v:}'>:�:i:},::;.,y:��''v:.•:. ' ?.
, •.;n.;?:;r.;..:r: .J...... �+•
....::n...i.:.�v..::-.�:n�::..,- : .. ..:........:�..:: .8.:•.;. '
.......... ...... ...:.•s......�::::::.v: ?Y'.�..%
�q O � :ir•.<•: �
M l0 �i� M
l0 r-I .�'j�� CV
~ y ' N rl "::%i:•,•:
:..;x,,,�.
:;x:%�:!::. N
y Ll1 t11 :�:::;c�>:;v. p
V N :>'�.:�� �
:;i;;;::•:.
.r...aa � .
::g.;:,"',.
01 ln 01 N t
01 (� `�
� � � ri � �
� r ��. . � . . _� _ . . . . . .. , . . . . � . .. �. .. . . .
g a
�
� i w
` .S 2 .� $ � . � � .
Lt. � � � � s �E _
_ � � � t _ � �
m E y � � � g � �
� �� � � a. = 2 c3° � 5 F �
� .{� e�i wi i �i �d e� ad et ° . '
I
I ��-=�-�- ;����
ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH CODE CHANGES 1985-7 �
-------�-------------------------------------------------------------------
CODE CHANGES
SECTION
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
SNOW , 113 REMOVES EXEMPTION FOR WEEKENDS AND HOLIDAYS IN
TIME ALLOWED FOR SNOW REMOVAL. SNOW MUST BE
� REMOVED IN 3 DAYS.
JUNK CARS 163 NEW DEFINITION OF ABANDONED VEHICLES INCLUDES:
-VEHICLES WITH PLATES MORE THAN 90 DAYS OVERDUE,
-INOPERABLE VEHICLES ON PRIVATE PROPERTY (WITH
AN EXEMPTION ALLOWING ONE INOPERABLE VEHICLE TO
REMAIN ON OWNER'S PROPERTY FOR 30 DAYS FOR
REPAIR) .
-ANTIQUE CARS BEYOND REPAIR, AND
' -VEHICLES WHICH ARE NOT SECURE
GENERALLY THE DEFINITION MORE CLOSELY RESPONDS
, TO THE PROBLEMS CAUSED BY ABANDONED VEHICLES.
NUISANCE$ 45 COLLECTS AND COORDINATES ALL CITY ABATEMENT ON
PROPERTY RELATED NUISANCES EXCEPT CARS AND SNOW.
' REFINES DEFINITIONS OF NUISANCES TO AID
. ' ENFORCEMENT.
EXPANDS DEFINITION OF NUISANCES TO INCLUDE
VACANT BUILDINGS, HAZARDOUS WASTES, HAZARDOUS
BUILDING PARTS, ETC. .
' EXPANDS ABATEMENT AUTHORITY TO INCLUDE
' DEMOLITION, REMOVAL OF DANGEROUS BUILDING PARTS,
AND BARRICADING OF HAZARDS.
IMPROVES ENFORCEMENT PROCEDURES
HOUSING CODE 34 ALL PREAMBLES CHANGED TO CLARIFY WHICH SECTIONS
' APPLY TO WHICH TYPES OF BUILDINGS.
34.01 EXPANDS AREA OF CONCERN TO INCLUDE ENERGY
34. 02 STANDARDS.
34. 03 CLARIFIES SCOPE TO INCLUDE BED & BREAKFASTS AND
EXCLUDE HOTELS.
' 34. 07 CLARIFIES DEFINITIONS FOR ROOMING TYPE UNITS.
34. 08 REQUIRES THAT THE YARD AREA AROUND A RESIDENTIAL
BUILDING MUST BE KEPT CLEAN EVEN IF THE BUILDING
IS VACANT.
197 ,
'� ��;-- �7_ ,��.��
34. 09 REQUIRES THAT:
-EXTERIOR WOOD BE PAINTED,
-WINDOW HAVE LOCKS, AND
-ALL LIVING UNITS HAVE DEADBOLT LOCKS (EXCEPT
BED & BREAKFAST UNITS. )
34. 11 CLARIFIES REQUIREMENTS FOR ROOMING UNITS.
34. 13
, . 3�.17
34. 18 SHORTENS THE PERIOD FOR APPEAL OF "UNFIT FOR
HUMAN HABITATION" PLACARD ACTION FROM 30 DAYS TO
10 DAYS.
STUDENT �iOUSING 321 EXEMPTS SOME COLLEGE DORMS FROM ROOMING AND
BOARDING HOUSE LICENSING REQUIREMENT. MUST
, STILL HAVE FOOD SERVICE LICENSE AND CERTIFICATE
OF OCCUPANCY. LIMITED TO DORMS WITHIN CAMPUS
BOUNDARIES AS SET FORTH IN SPECIAL CONDITION USE
' PERMIT. DOES NOT INCLUDE FRATERNITIES OR
SORORITIES.
BED & BREAKFAST 378 PROVIDES NEW LICENSE CATEGORY FOR BED &
� BREAKFASTS ESTABLISHMENTS.
' ESTABLISHES STANDARDS FOR BED & BREAKFASTS.
RABIES CONTROL 199 ESTABLISHES GUIDELINES FOR HANDLING UNCLAIMED
' ANIMALS WHICH HAVE BITTEN.
DOG RESTRAINTS 206 REQUIRES THAT DOGS IN UNFENCED YARDS MUST BE
RESTRAINED BY A LEASH OR CHAIN. THE NEW
ELECTRONIC DOGS FENCES ARE INADEQUATE.
198
�� ������
,� �_j_
REVIEW OF SAINT PAUL SPECIFIC NEEDS
A oaa�lete needs assessment for Ramsey County as a whole can be four�d in
Secti�n A. The follvwing section highlights sarne of the special problems
facir� the City of Saint Paul.
DII�IOGRAPF�C SUNIl"�,RY TOTAL POP(TLATION
The Cfty of Saisit Paul is a divexse c�urna.nity. St. Paul acx.ot�nts for 58$ of
the papulation of Ramsey Caunty. The St. Paul pop�lation is 4.8� Black, 2.9�
Hispanic, 0.9� Native American, 0.8� Asian, and 1.8$ "other" based on 1980
census figures.
Non-white Population as $ of Total Population
Native
Black Hispanic American Asian Other
Saint Paul 4.8$ 2.9� 0.9� 0.8$ 1.8�
Suburkk�n Ratnsey 0.7� 0.7$ 0.2� 1.4$ 0.3�
�
', Ramsey Ooiuzty 8.1$ non-white
• ' Saint Paul 11.5$ non�ahite
Suburban Ramsey County 3.5� non-white
(� may differ frcan swn of table due to rounding)
In acklition to the differences in racial oamposition betwePn the City of Saint
Paul a�nd the si.�burbs, there is a major difference in pwerty status. Of eleven
health planning areas in suburban Ramsey Co�nty, none has more than 10� of its
resid�ts belaw 1979 pc7verty level (1980 census data) . Of the seventeen health
planning areas in St. Paul, seven have 12$ or more residents (1980 data) below
1979 paverty levels. January 1986 data also irxlicates that the bulk of those
receiving public assistance are Saint Paul Residents.
PUBLTIC ASSISTANCE UI'ILIZATION F+OR ST. PAUL & � ARF�A - JANUARY 1986
Zbtal Cases
Proara�n Families St. Paul Suburban
AFDC I 7,814 88$ 12$
Genera�h. Assistance 3,198 95� 5$
Medica(1 Assistanoe 9,214 81� 19�
Food Sltamps 11,691 85� 15�
Source: Ramsey Crnmty Ooammuzity Ht,mian Sesices Department
200
/�,�-,��7- � ���'
730 731 732
727 728
: ., �26
729
722 724 723 725
720 �
.
602 6 ,3 604 605
��'"
606 -
' 607
60 0 61 611
14 _
612 613
�-' 1 618
616 "
615
� 20� o� more of residents belvw 1979 povexty level (1980 Census)
�15-20� of residents belaw 1979 paverty level (1980 Census)
�10-15� of residents belvw 1979 pwerty level (1980 Census)
CHAF�I' 2
201
i
. � �,��,�/ ��`�'�
The pe�rce,nt of the aoianty's elderly (65 ar�d aver) residing in the city
of Sai,nt Paul in 1980 was 76�. This has declined slightly based on 1983
estimaltes (Mirmesota Depaztment of Health) to 74�.
SauZt �Paul has 82$ of the minority residents of Ramsey Caunty, 90$ of
the Bllacks, 84$ of the Hispanics, 86� of the Native Americans, ar�d 88�
, . , . . �.c�f thase classified as ��other" (primarily Sautheast Asian RefugePS) .
The suD�urban areas of the county house 53� of the Asian-Paci�ic
Islar�ers.
�ile pur poor, elderly, an�d m.inority residents represent large grnups
with special neec].s, a smaller yr�up with substantial needs has been
identi�fied in th�e hoaneless pc�pulation.
These de�og�raphic differences create needs for more health servioes
within, the city to provide law-cost service.s to these high risk graup.
This is particularly important in light of the studies of insuranoe
caverage of Minnesota residents. Those groups who are most likely to be
uninsured are fv�.u7d in greater nwmbers within the city. While the
Divisibn does not provide primary care, except to Refugees, it does
ac�nini�tex oontracts to five c�mminity clinics to provide primary care
to law-incxane and minority populations.
During the second quarter of 1987, 1,500 Division of Public Health
client� were surveyed to determine levels of insurance oaverage. SuYVey
. firidiriqs are shcx�m graphically on chart 4.
Criart � describes the City's best projections of pc�x�lation changes aver
the next five years. With the projected increase of �z in the work
foroe (Chart 6) and an increase in rnnnbers of children under 10, the
Divisiqn ariticipates day care will be an increasing challenge in the
second'half of this decade. Additionally the increase in the "oldest .
old" n�y strain public health as they require greater support to ren�ain
in the aa�mnmity.
As anticipated in the 1986-87 CHS Plan, AIAS has begLUZ to require
increa5ing r�sources. Z7ie alternate test site continues to see 150
clientS a n�nth. Epidemiology and health education staff each spe.r�d
approximately half of their time on AID6 related activities.
The follaaing sec.�tion highlights sarne health indicators for the city.
II 202
. __ _ .
�;,�"� �_ !u���
,
SPDPH Clients Covered by Third Party Payers
March-April 1986
No
298%
.„.;;:,{:. No
,., �;:::
. ''y�F��.,�.,,�,.
� ,.,�.,.�,"a....���;:� ;.
;r�:•;.,•;::•.5.::.•.��.,�;�'
�.,:. N:<:�::.:..;.,....:� 28°/
.... >:<.�'�.�.•r. o
�r{h�:�f ;�;�;�::
;:;•�::'�#'s�'"4:?:a• 4�.,:.;:
.� .. .. ... . .. , :_ •:7:+:;r'x.•: A?£ . .
:::;t;�:;,t.,.{ +'� r.
:;:::';t.'t.;r�..y;;`•;:,�r:;� `' - . . - _.. .. ._ ..� .
... . x..�.:�y::.�;
c..%;a�;?;��'•;,'•.''.'•w�:t:;;•.;�L+,_:y:
;::;.:,zr>�:•;:,:k�.�`,,.•,; �'
:•,;:.>::^.:;y:;•,x••3Y,�xti;:,,�`.`•'�:' fi
ir\�>'v:�'w:•MrO:;},�;•'.,.i.iC.+�\ }+��y+': �
•':�::i:titi}?:��ti;i%;:�(•:•:{'ry>':.<.Z 'O•.,
.<;,,:;ty�.:.ti:;;,:;'>:n.;iti vif;'a\:,
�\ .,,r�;.;;::,;.,:�.<;���'';.
:»�,:...�>;;::�:.t.,�::.:�f��<>��:� .��..,.:.....:.. Yes
�;ry:>�:;.:::;c:<:..�:� .....
;x::. . .i:.R,:aY. .� �••:\s��yi>:`'•:?,•::•:;;�.;.
,.:y�;..y:�t•w:tX ot�::,? :�....'�• „;;: :�� ,
,•.:..<;... :�:.:::•�". �+ ^,�i , .. '
.... nCiti.: .Ci. , v..2ry �'+f¢�kv:`k}•:k:iii:.
'��:,it�::;>:%�.., :s:.^,�r,.•`q�... ::\ �`•'C,'A'K;.J..
� �. . '� v�;• x t�{�:r'?''''";.
::>.:�>»:.:>;,.�::.;:;�. ..,.,>..v. � 97.02
�;:;:�..•:z:: ::.o;;.;.., ;N;.•;t>:;;;�;::•.;>;::>'�:•'•e::;.>.:;::' %
:.:::'i'. . K:•::{.• ... ..
yi'.::::.?;:{:.;.:�:•t M1�.,y...i.}• ..;;.}ti,r.....::
:;+.::j•s:;;.;;,:y..:•�•>. ���w:�,,+'£',.�x::.::y.•,•':::i':;:'`i:�:'
.•r.:�,�::;:::OR:`.� ' .�:�i.,;:a4...: . ...
;:�:�::::::::r::;:�;;..;.::::::k ,�ti;.;;;:�.f'�:�:•:;;.;:;r?ti;>:;:;;:;::
.�y;n•.;hf Yg;.;i,;,.«,•..#:�•`•:k:•>ii�s:>':::.y:>:•:
Yes :»>:::::>:;:<::�::::>:;<::�:::�<;;<:::�� ...':•>;::::.>;..::.:.::,>.:::::::;.
< �;:. .
O :{'�::'?:'k'`.Y```::"'h::�sY;.:>�:C���:\..`.A'..�,£t,.�..�'.;°:?iV;��;;s:�' .
7//� i:;,�.::);;r f�•',�.•,',F,t�%',.�.,.:.t.•:.;'.,•'..;»S,
`/0 '''�:�i::�y:+:L'{9f4��T}•.,•.?����.\;:•ii•i.:n+ :;:{•i:i::
��::?::�:;;t;k<,;.�.kgy' 'r?$*\•'^,::."•`.;+.;{;i.•^'•'
. >�:;;:��`�2i>�� .
�. :::�5>R.;.H+r73,.�`;::�::;�:�•°•'%"
k::<.•+�k ::x„�
;::i4::.,-;::
' Ail Clients Gertatrics Clinic
N a �.7JG N m �G70
.
�.� � . No
No
t::; � �'.; . 0 21.43/e
-. . ..� .
._ ,; ., o
E:: 53.92/o
;;: ;,. ; . . :.�..:._,..x;.. .
:::::.�::::;:...........
:.::.;:........ :�::...:.
. ....:.....
. .....�.
.:.:.�::;::::::::.�::.. .
: ::.;::::.::.::.::.;>::.::;:.;:.;>: ;
�>
.,. ,�.
...................�::.
.�a::.�.�:..�....
:: . :<:<::>::::::>::;:::::::<;:::»:::::;::;:
�; :� :..:
_ .. I ;� >� �sk.<;����4
; 1> ` � • . �
• 4'�ri
iYt�. •'n"v ;:'f�i'i .
.'.'�O�
�� '�: . � � . .i .:::���ii::;:::v::j"•:i:v:::},:jii:::>�i:ii
•:. y .
.. :. �� ,. J�2�'v 4:1�f•
. :- . . :.; ::�� .. .
:: ' ' •�<i�{�:ti•:i.Y
��' �:�. ..:. .. . : •.,•'•
;�.
.y
;: .......::.....::.:...... � .
• :::•:::::.�.:._:�
`�x'•�•'
..�•.'
�.
I:: ::::::..:::::...:::.�:..:. ... . . .
;:}:
, ............:.::::::.�:::::�>:;>:::<a�:?:»>::�>:x:.;...
Y , , .. . .,.. :::<.;:..»:.:,::::::::::�::::::<:::::::::�::�::�:
. . . :::...::...:..::...
... ....
..............::..:
, .. ..........
-::::::..
............... ::::::::::::::::::::>::<:::.
.:>;:>;:.;::::::......::.:>::.;;�::::::..... ....:_::::::::.::._:::
es � �. .::::.:,:.:::::::::::..::.::.::::::<.:;.::.::.::>,>:<:>:::::>::»::»:�`:;:;:>:::::'�:;;;:���;;
,.f<.:a..:'.�:
; ,. ..::>;:;::::::>;::,:;:;>::.;::.:
. . .,...:,.::..• .,:: :::::.:::.................»:r;:.........: ....... ..
` /'• � ;,:_: :::::.•. :::.::::::�:
>�hz
ry -...:.
,., : ::
•i`.a' '��� :rr ...'..n.f, Y'9�.;:•:. :.:..:...::::.: . .....,, ........::::.
O �� :�;���� t ..'$�,�.:.�..•• .....,.;ao-:>:� . . :�:�:i:J;..
� :::�::::::.:�.
-.�';:�..;:.,.,.,,�._';i�.... . �r..a.Y:>: ...:......::.: �.>::<:o::.::..:
47 � :::>:»�::::��:>:<.::<;;:;.;:�:;>::::>:>:::>::::>:::::>;;::;<>::::>::;::::::::<<::>::»::<>:;::;;:;.
.0 8/o _ .....:.....
. <.:::>;:.::.;::;::. ............
....... .......
° �. � �<:::::<>:::::<�>:::<:::::<::<::::::::>�<:>::::<::::>:'>::>::>:::::::::::>?::::<?:;:<::<:>:?<::;;;>:
�>:: ::: ::>
Yes
7 8.
57
0
/o
Fami�ly Planning Clintc TB Clinic
N=34r'J Ns2.�8
Source: Client Syrvey � 4
�
203
�� .� y_ '`f�'�►'
. Clinic Summary
No. in Insurance Type
Sampie Yes No Insur Co HVI� Govt Asst
Ciinic
1B 238 78.6 21.4 16.0 21.4 61.0
STD 206 47.6 52.4 60.2 31.6 22.4
Immuni- 274 80.7 19.3 26.7 14.5 58.0
ti0n �
D�ntal 29 27.6 72.4 50.0 25.0 25.0
' Reliability of Da#a
.
Clinic Q1 C� C�3 Total with Insurance
TB 99.9 96.7 91.2 77.3
STD 100 96.7 68.1 44.6
Immuni- 99.9 100 10.1 79.9 -
zation .
Derital 100 100 100 27.6
SOU�tC,'E: DPH CLIF�Pr SLIRVEY 1986
.CHAFZT 4
204
�'�- �.-�-��r�'�'
� �
ao- u .
�E- �
rq• ��
SAIN�T PAUL POPUTATION PYRA.��6 �s - �s .
1980 - 1990 i0 ' �
s�
so- s�
tS- y
IG• M
' 7S,- ?9
70,- 3t
I980 - 1985 ASSUI�TIONS �• �
. �- ri.
Birth Rate 18.84 live births �?- i�
;per 1000 people or !'�
+25,303 births � �
Dea_�te 10.5 cZeaths per . u: �os a a a a o a a a as sos us
1000 pecple or ""� � �ES � -
+-14,006 deaths �
Net M�c�ratian 95$ of 1975-1980
�t of -20,361 or �.
-16,442 _ �,
- ts
, �- ��
ts - �
�o- �
I985 $stimated papulation: 265,085 s - s9
so- s�
IS- q
' �o u
, � �
1985 -, 1990 ASSUI�TIONS is. r
- :•
Birth te 20.50 live births ls - 19
� r 1000 people or 1;- ��
+Q6,677 births • �
Death te 10.7 c�eaths per u: io: u �a a ts o � r. �s n ioz ir.
1 00 people ar � � � ��
- ,819 deaths
Net Mi ation 95$ of assun�ed '
1 75-1980 aanunt of -19,343 _.. �
o� -18,376 . � _ M
�� - n
�o - �.
iS • i9
1990 Fsitineted Populatian: 257,720 s . sµs _
so s�
�d h
�o a
� �
� - u
n r
m . :.
is . i�
�o- �i
d- r
�
sr_ u: u �: 4s 2z o a a r. u �o: iz:
rwca i�so r�c�
Scurce: , U.S. Census, 1980 and PID staff estimates
' Chart 5
�
205
�� � ����
�,��i
. 1�Iinnesota FernaIe and Male L.aIior Force ParticipatiQn Rates
I960-1990 �
ParUcipatJon Rate .
lOG � . _
� , .
------s� .
gp . .
' 80 •
*
70
' �
60 = ' �
SO
�
40
' 30 '
20 '
O 1990 women
■ 1980 womai �
10 • 1970 wcmes� � 1990 mea , �
+ 1960 womw• * 2980 men ' �
0
1619 20-24 • 25-34 35-41 45-54 55-64 65�
-' A9e
swree otns.•r sat.D.iwy..M...w�.w...t,sut•n...1��A p.e�
Qiart 6
II
206
I� ���-'��-1�%�-�'
��
FAN�LY AND OdNIl�JNITY HEALTH
Infant� mortality contiriues to be a problem, especially for Saint Paul's
minority papulation. 'Ihe mortality rate among blacac infants has, for at least
the lalst thirteen years, been declining at a slawer paoe than that among the
ge.nera�l population - it has typically been higher than the overall rate of
infant, mortality. The death rate among all infants born between 1970 ar�d 1983
,.:. . ., ,� ,.._�•i�`:+� �er .i,•0t30�-�ive-�rirt��tal'liit!-t�eTate-�tm�olig-3��ndc���aes 26.1. _ _ .
The fo�llvwiryg table provides Saint Paul resident live b�rth ar�d infarit
death statistics by raoe.
INF'FANT DFATKS BY RACE, 1970-1985
' TdI'AL WHITE SLAQC IldDIAN* Orli�Et*
YEAR , NO. RA'I'E* NO. RA'I'E* N0. RATE* N0. NO.
1970 107 17.9 100 18.3 6 15.8 1 0
1971 ' 109 21.1 95 20.4 10 27.7 2 2
1972 80 18.1 68 17.1 12 34.3 0 0
1973 , 68 17.3 58 16.4 9 28.8 0 1
1974 55 13.6 46 12.8 5 14.5 1 3
1975 62 16.0 48 13.9 11 36.2 2 1
1976 74 19.5 64 19.1 9 28.0 0 1
1977 44 10.9 37 10.4 5 15.1 1 1
1978 55 12.7 47 13.4 7 19.6 1 0
� 1979 42 9.7 29 7.7 10 28.1 2 1
1980 ' 53 11.0 41 10.4 7 19.5 0 5
1981 61 11.9 38 9.5 16 42.1 0 7
1982 54 10.8 38 9.8 10 24.9 1 5
1983 48 9.7 34 8.6 12 32.9 0 2
1984 53 10.5 42 10.6 6 14.3 1 4
1985 38 7.4 29 7.3 6 13.4 0 3
Source: City of Saint Paul Department of Canammity Services. Division
of Public Health
+ Tata1 Infant Deaths per 1000 Live Birth.s
* The rnunbers here are too laa to produoe a meaningful rate statistic
' HIGH RISK B�S
The peYrent of all Saint Paul births characterized as high risk began to climb
between 1980 and 1981 after stayirx� at 20-21 percent for most of the last
decade. ' In 1982, one in four Saint Paul births involved one of the followitzg
high risk oonditions: (1) mother's age less than 18 or wer 39; (2) pre-natal
care beginnirig in third trimester or not at all, (3) birth weight less than
2500 gr�ns, (4) cc¢nplicating illness for the mother, (5) prolonged labor;
and (6) birth injuries or vongenital anvmalies.
i
207
, � ��`" �'7- ���'�
The r�sk factor which changed the most between the mid 1970s ar�d 1981 was the
freqtxency of prenatal care. �ile the pezroentage of births where there was
littl� prenatal care dropped to a lcxa of 4-5 peroe.nt between 1977 at�d 1979, it
climb�d to 7.8 percent in 1981.
Conce�n abaut these rates can be seen in the Advisory Cca�omittees'
ident�fication of priorities for Family Health A�ctivities. Of th�e faur
ca�egories in faini'1y health, three have as �-heir highest priorities seivi� - .
related to high risk child bearing. 'Ihis is consistent with the Stat�wide Goal
#I�1 "'rb prr�vide optimal birth outcames for all M�ruiesota infants." �he
Divisilon provides family planniryg services to lvw in�ene, high risk woanen. Zhe
city, thiro�gh the Division, provides financial support to several ocs�muzity
cliniqs which provide a broad rarige of services, inclwdirig pre-natal care, at
laa aost to lvw incoQr►e wrnttien.
Over the past decade, the pe.rcentage of all births that wpxe low w�eight births
declinied in 12 of the city's 18 health planning areas. Six areas, hawever,
experi�enc�ed an increase: Rice Street: Hayden Heic�ts; Thc�mas Dale; Mt. Airy:
Drayton,'s Bluff; and Hazel Park. The hic�est incide.noe of laa w�ic�t births �ras
in the da�mtc�m where lvw birth weight charac�texized or�e in ten birth.s in
1982-�lvwn fr�an one in five in 1972-75.
I Il�FAAFr NR�RTALITY
�ile there have been annual fluctuations, the infarit mortality rate in Saint
Paul has bee.n declinirig for at least thirty years. Zhe 39 peroent drop bet�reen
' 1970 arhd 1980 was a].most three tim�e.s the rate of decline which characterized
the pr�via�s tw�o decades. In 1984, the infant death rate in the city stood at
10.5 per 1,000 live births. In 1970, the rate was 17.9. �
Il�Il`�JNIZATION STAZ[JS
Over 9'� percent of Saint Paul school children have been inm�ninized against
seven nlajor inm�unizable diseases. State legislation passed in 1980 requires
that a]:1 children be fully iamtunized unless exe�npted.
The Div,isions inmiunization program addresses the statewide goal V, ��Zb reduoe,
to the extent possible, the incidence of preventable and controllable
oo�mminicable disease in the State."
208
��.�-'
� !� � �_ _
HC�LESS
Hoanel�ssness oontinues t,fl be a probl�m. This is particularly ap�arent in dawn
taHm �aint Paul where three of four shelters providing health servioes are
locat.�d. No firm data or actual nw�nbers of hcaneless are available, hawever it
is of ooncern that 22� of those seen in the shelter clinics are under 18 ar�d
that cyver 10� are under age 5. The follawing s�mmiarizes data frcan 280 health
. . __. , _ � c��'`n��_ held in.fa�ur shelters.
FiC�'�S CLII�IICS
1986 1985
Zbtal Clinic visits 2174 771
new Clients 1051 438
return visits 1123 333
' Age (new clients only)
5 years 127
, 5-17 ye.ars 103 82
18-64 ye�.� 781 334
' 65 years 25 15
, Pay sauroe (all visits)
rio source of payment 1068 400
' MA 889 133
. HI�'B� 35 0
, vouchexs 325 DK
Mental Health Services
' (4 mo. of data on1Y)
total visits 348 DK*
; new clients 78 DK*
follaw-up visits 270' DK*
*DK - Data not ]mvHm
, Source: Saint Paul/Ramsey County Hca�neless Services.
209 �
%'
`��- �7 /�`�`��
�
CAUSE OF DEATH
Alm�st one half of all deaths of Saint Paul residents in 1982 w�ere attributable
to camdio-vascular disease, altho�ugh that percentage had cli.ro�q�ed by six
percer�tage points sinc�e 1970. A slcxaly growirig share of all deaths, oa� the
o�ther har�d, wpxe related to malignarit r�eaplasms (cancer)--the seoond leadiryg
cause 'of death in the city. Rsspiratory diseases claimed 19 percent mr�re lives
...in 1982 than they did in 1970 and was the only disease category to see an
increase against the backdrop of an 18 perce.nt decline in the ac�tual ntunber of �
deaths in the city.
The leaading causes of death varied by age group. Children under the age of
five m�st often fell victim to vongenital conditions or those clevelaping
shortly after birth. Accidents were the leadir�g cause of death for those
between 5 and 44 while 15 percent of all deaths in this age group were
attri.bl�table to canoer. Suicides also fiqured more proaminently in this age
group than in ariy other-- claiming 13 percent of the deaths an►ong pezsons
betweeri 5 and 44.
Heart tlisease begins to take its greatest t;oll am�rig the poptalation aver 45
causir�g 40 percent of all deaths in that age group. Cancer, again, was the
seoond� leading cause of death. Zhe perc�ntage of deaths related to c.ancex was
twioe �s high among those between 45 and 64 than it was amor�g those aver 75.
DEATHS OF SAIN'r PAUL RESIDEN'!'S, 1970-1984
� Total
Year Deaths Rate
1970 3,328 10.7
1971 3,306 10.8
1972 3,457 11.5
' 1973 3,260 11.1
1974 3,154 10.9
1975 2,899 10.2
1976 2,904 10.3
1977 2,787 10.0
' 1978 2,935 10.6
1979 2,735 10.0
, 1980 2,871 10.6
1981 2,739 10.2
1982 2,719 10.2
' 1983 2,762 10.3
1984 2,663 9.9
Source: City of Saint Paul Depar�ent of Ccn�rnxnity Servic�s, Division of
Public Health
I�
210 �
%:;L �-7- j����
�
Whilelthe figures below do not identfy �IIV infection related deaths, by 1990
the l�ading cause of YPLL for Males 25-44 will be AID6 or FIIV related causes.
It is'anticipated that this will surpass the ooanbined total for all ather
diseases.
' ZEADING CAUSFS OF DEATH BY AGE GROUP, 1984
Under 5 Years Ntmibe.r $
1. Perinatal Cor�ditions 21 37
2. Congenital Anc�nalies 12 21
3. I11-Defined Condition 7 12
4. Other 17 30
'ICyI'AL 57 100
5 - 24 Yeax's N�unber $
1. A�:cidents 19 43
, 2. Malign�nt Neoplasms 8 18
3. S�icide 6 14
' 4. Other 11 25
TOTAL 44 100
25-44 Years NLm�ber $
' ' 1. Aocidents 21 22
2. Malignant Neoplasms 14 14
3. Heart Disease 14 14
4. Suicide 13 13
5. Other 36 37
TdI'AL 98 100
45-64 Years Ntunber $
1. Heart Disease 157 36
2. Malignant Neoplasms 147 34
3. Accidents 16 4
4. Others 114 26
' TOr!'AL 434 100
65+ Years Ntmiber $
1. Heart Disease 877 41
2. Malignant Neoplasms 412 19
' 3. Cerebrovascular Disease 204 10
4. Other 636 30
'POTAL 2,129 lOQ
Souroes City of Saint Paul, Department of C.omm��nity Services, Division
of Public Health.
' 211
�� �' -- �7- ����"
�F
� �v�oru�r� �Tx
During 1985-1986, tw�o exivirornnetztal health needs assessm�zts were ccenpleted.
The Sa�nt Paul City Council hired a oonsultant to produce the Saint Paul
E�vironmental Study. Zhe Ramsey County CiiS advisory canunittee considered the
findinc�s of that study in preparation of its exrvirormn�ztal health needs
. , t :r.:�--r7FisP�crtwnt,
The relevance of envirornnental health issues to both the City arxl the County
was oorLsidered. Haaever, due to the inmtediate need for CI�S Advisozy Ck�unittee
ii�put into tne cauncil-sponsorea saint Paul �virormnental study, tne issue
review �and rankings are focused on the need for new or c�ontinued action on the
part o� the City, rather than the County.
These programs relate to Statewide Goal II, "To pravide health prot:ection to
car�uminilties by ensuririg sanitary conditions of lioen.sed public establisrnments
t�urough education, suzveillance and regulation.
SOLID WASTE
Among issues ranked by the six subcamnittee m�embers, Solid Waste was
unanima,usly ranked as a high priority, shawing the least variability in rank
position among these 16 issues. Solid waste was a topic of disc.�ussion at
nearly evexy, if not all, of the subcoa�unittee meetings.
The Minizesota Waste Management A,ct direcfis the Camty to assi mee leadeYShip in
� solid waste management, b�t delineates a significant role for the City in waste
management. Ongoitzg discussions indicate th,at there is considerable work to be
done to' coordinate City and County finances and actions to comply with Waste
Management Act mandates r�garding waste reduction� recYc1�J, P�S�J �
disposal.
Restrictions on tire disposal arid the acxeptability of lan�e quantities of yanl
waste, Waste appliances, and tires at the Refuse-Derived-FLiel (RDF) facility
may i�act the effectiveness of the City Housing Sanitation Program (Priority
Area #5a in cleaning up large scale residential rruisances.
� QUALITY
There a�e approximately 200 private water wells in the City of Saint Paul which
do not �eceive ariy regular monitoring.
There a�e approximately 25 landfills in Saint Paul, of whirh only seven have
wells monitored by the Minnesota Follution Control Agency and the Minnesota
Depaztment of Health. These landfills have potential for contaminating
grour�lwatex'•
The Minrie.sota Departiment of Health (N�i) recently found small amounts of
volatile� organic ahemicals in two of five non-canumuzity public water supply
wells (s�eervirig more th�n 25 people) . 'IY�e an�wzts detected were not
oonsidered by N�i to pose an imn�ecliate health concern. Nonetheless they
indicate�d a potential for pollution, which is especially critical given the
difficultty of monitoririg and clean up of grow�dwater.
Graundwater Quality has been designated in the City Council sponsored Saint
paul Envirormnental Study as the rnmibex two priority. The Study rec�x�ds
regular monitoring of private wells arid landfill sites.
' 212 �
�� � r- :<<<��
FnUD SANITATION
Food s�nitation is a maridated activity of the Saint Paul Division of Public
Health (DPH) , which has been performing this activity for wer 100 years.
Only a' fraction (1� - 10�) of food borne illness are reported. Food borne
illnes�es can result in death, hospitalization, or, more co�tunonly, severe
. ..intestinal distress of one or two day duration which may preclude the normal
activi�ies of daily Yiving such as work and school.
Food s�nitation was not considered by the Saint Paul F�virornnental Study. It
is an issue that is rarely considered, except when it mak,es front page r�ws
during a large autbreak. It is i�ortant to maintain an adequate level of
sexvice in this maridated activity as DPH turns its attention to more subtle and
possi.bxy more marginal hazards in the envirormtient.
, AIl2 QUALITY
Air Zbxics is the rnm�ber one priority of the Saint Paul IIYVirornnental Study,
due largely to ooncerns about the inadequacy of state re.sources to address this
issue. The City Council Study reca�ed lol�bying by the City to increase
funding for state air toxics control efforts.
Locally, there have been a significant rnm�ber of citizen oca�laints r+egardirig
odor and potential health effects frcAn the Ford MAtor C�npany Assembly Plant.
The PCA; has requested Ford to initiate an odor abatement study ar�d an update of
' a previausly cc�mpleted non-criteria pollutant emissions stwdy.
The City Council is in the proce.ss of directing the Division of Public Health
to assi�t in studying the health effects associated with the emissions. 'Ihis
irYVOlve�nent will most likely irYVOlve an analysis by the DPH epidemiologist of
va�laii�ants'diaries of e.xposures and effects.
HOUSIl�TG SANI'rATION (Gtlapter 34 Legislative Code)
This mandated activity enforces the Housirig Code, which establishes minumun
star�ds which are essential to make dwellings safe, sanitaxy and fit for
hwnan h�bitation. �
, PRIORITY ARFrP, NU1�Eft 6 - II�II�1CY RESPONSE
The tragedy in Bhapal, India has made officials and the ooamnunity aware of the
possi.bility of seri�as chemical accidents and the need for local ocemmini.ties
to have in place an effective program to deal with chemicals that can cause
death or seriaus injury if an accidental release occurs.
The recet�tly enacted U.S. nnergency Planning and C.ceimm�nity RightJlb-Knc�w Act
of 1986, within the U.S. Superfund Amex�nts of 1985, requires each State to
establish a State Canm�ission, emergency planning districts and local emer�gency
planning ocatrtn.ittees to develop an�cl facilitate the it�lementation of emen�ency
response'plans with participation of facilities who produce, use, or store
extremely hazardous substances.
Applicat�.on is beirx� made for City participation on the State Carmnission, with
City par�icipation in local emPa�gency planning caRanissions to follaw. 'Ihe
Saint Pa�l Departrnent of Fire and Safety Services, the lead emerger�y r�sponse
agency, �as and maintains ar�d updates an emergencY Plan. The Saint Paul
�i�
/� �- /�'�`�
T'�
xAZ�DOUS �
Hazan�ous wastes may contaminate drinkirig water suppplies, release toxic vapors
to the air and create explosive d�anp sites. Significant advances can be made
in preivention of grow�d�rater and air pollution utilizir�g available technology
for icll�ntifying and abating haza�lous wastes.
_ " " ,."The abat.�in�nt 'of �11 qu�a't�titi�"s b'f hazardous waste has been a�pr�itln fvr _ �
the City Hausi.ng Code Inspec�tion staff. Zhe rruisance oniinance is expectsd to
expedite the effective and proanpt handliizg of small quantities of hazanlous
waste.
In add,ition, the Saint Paul Deparbment of Fire ar�d Safety Services is malting
available well trained and equipped hazardous materials teahnicians to respond
to rec�ests froan the Housirig Code Inspection staff for the safe sampliryg of
un�a�m waste materials.
ANIl�i� OONTROL
Rabies is deadly. Animal attacks can be disfiguring. Barking and free roamir�g
dogs c�►n be a public nuisance.
The Division of Public Health operates a longstanding, effective animal
c�ontro� program. The oontinuing high n�unb�x of animal ooamplaints, inclwding a
substantial rn�nbex of urban wildlife �laints regarding animals such as
skunks and ra0000ns, reflects the priority of animal oontrol in the czemm�nity.
.
T F.AI� UOI�I'I'P��iA'I'IODT
Concerns about lead contamination reflects simultaneously the scientific
uncertainty of health effects frc�m ccmm�riplace and moderate to lvw-level
exposure to lead and the grcxaing evidence and amount of research activity
ir�clicating effects frcan lcxa and moderate-level exposures.
Lead, a useful but toxic metal, is an integral part of the econoar�y. As a
result, the erivi.rormeent is pervasively contaminated with lead.
In response to the public's concern over possible chronic effects of
erYViror�mental exposure to lead, State legislation was passed requiriryg the
Minneso�a Pollution Control Agency (N�C'A) to sample soils for lead and to
report �oil-lead concentrations in excess of 1,000 p�¢n to the Minnesota
Departm�,nt of Health (N�i) . As a part of this study, N�1Ei is required to
sa�le tthe blood-lead levels of children livirig in the areas with soil leads in
excess of 1000 p�nn and to examine sites for all sources of lead where elevated
blood-lead levels are found.
To protect the health and welfare of susceptible populations, the N�C'A is
further �chan�ed with the task of developing a soil lead staridard and of
adoptirx� rules to establish priorities for response action.
DPH has 'routinely ooriducted screenings for high blood-lead levels in its
Suppleme�tal Food for Wo�[�en, Infants ar�d Children (WIC) Program and abated
identifi�ble saurces of residential lead for children with high blood leads.
DPH oontracted with N�CA and N�i to perform soil ar�d blood lead screenirig.
DPH will also participate with N�C'A and NIDEi in applying for federal monies for
removal bf lead contaminated soils.
214
C� � `�
�,r-�7- �t�'.�'
HO[JSEHOLD HA7,ARDOUS S�II�.STE
Hazarc�aus wastes are not restricted to industrial or �rcial settir�gs.
Minnesota's households generate wastes such as solvents, pesticides, oils,
paint�, thinners, corrosives ar�d other material which are as hazardaus as
highl�t regulated it�dustrial waste. At this tiune there are no means for
Minne�ota citizens to prop�xly and safely dispose of most household hazardaus
wastes. `As' a resul� they are'sent to._s�nita��1�'ills, po��d dvHm`t�e sewe.r , .".
or onto the gra�uxl, or stored for long periods under generally unsafe
conditions.
The N�1C'A is conductirig a study of ways to best manage household haza�laus
waste. N�C'A has designated household haza�rlous waste as one of five priority
issues for 1987. They are approaching the legislature to establish a
perntian�ent program inc.orporating the follawing three elements.
l. Co�lection proj ects for at least scat�e types of waste;
2. A �ystem for answering citizen telphone inquiries about hau�sehold hazaniaus
waste, �avoidance, storage, hoane treatinent and disposal;
3. Pul�lic information education efforts aimed at waste prevention, pro�pex
product� use ar�d storage, and responsible disposal.
NOISE POLIIJTION
' Noise pollution is more than a rruisance. The link between noise and specific
disabilities or diseases has not yet bee.n clearly d�monstrated. Nonetheless,
existiryg evidence indicates the danger is real for increased risk of hearing
loss, sleep disruption, distress, educational disruption, work inefficiency arid
aacider�ts.
A City bn3inance is movirig through the legislative process to expand City
Health �nd Police Department authority to control noise pollution.
IAWN P�'.STICIDES
A study! rega�lirig the most c�om�mionly used weedlciller, 2,4,D, conducted by the
Natiorial Cancer Institute arid a private laboratory rhosen by a group of
ch�mica�l manufacturers, shvws that Kansas farmers exposed to 2,4,D while usi.ng
the chemical to fight weeds among crops were six times more likely to develap
non Hod�kin's lymphc�na, a ttunor of the lymph system, than farmers who had not
been ex�OSed to the chemical.
The EPA is reviewing the new findings. Before turnirig to other alternatives,
most of'the ch�mical arxl lawn care industries are waitirig for the EPA revic�a.
The popullarity of 2,4,D stems from the fact that it is less to}cic than soane
other w�edkillers, less expealsive and extxemely effective.
CnemLawrr, the leading lawn care servioe, suspe,nded all use of 2,4,D. ChemLawn
chose t.� make the susper�sion announc�xnent in Saint Paul in reoognition of the
strong rtegul.ation of lawn pesticides adopted by the City Council.
215
, �� �. -r_ /�-��:�
SIJRFACE 4�,TER QUAL►ITY
Untreated sewage fromn both ssewwer werflows and animal wastes threaten himian
health because they carry potentially harmful bacteria and vinises.
The City Water Utility and Ramsey County Public Works monitor surface�aater
_quality�. While there is sarne evidence of degradation of surface�water ytza].ity,
_ the ex�stincl Pr'oc�'ams for surface�aater quality protection are maintainirig the _
werall quality of surface-water in a good condition which does nat pose a
problem for health.
HAZARDOUS N�,'I�RIALS
The reaeiztly enacted U.S. En�ezgency Plannirig and Cartmn�nity Right�!'o-Knaw Act
of 198�, within the U.S. S�.iperfund Amenckrrents of 1985, requires awners/
operato�rs of facilities to pravide information on the manufacture, use, and
storage of chemicals present at their facilities. This information is required
to be pravided to the State Ccmm�ission, local ccmunittees, and local fire
dep�nts ar�d must be made available to the general pa�blic.
Haza�lous materials in transit pc�se a greater prablem for regulation. A reoent
report by the U.S. Office of Teclznology Assessnent irxlicates that, at present,
no one ]mvws for cextain the total quantities and ty�es of haza�lous matQxials
that ar� being transported. The report further states that confusion exists
wer how safe the transportation process is or ought to be. The report
recarmnP.�nds better public ccarnminication and training of emergency-response
' personnel.
A hazardous materials ordinance is one of a select rnnnber of ordinances beirig
oonsidezced currently by the City Council.
I.1�7iJRY OONI'ROL
Injuries are the leadirig cause of death and disability in cniiaren ar� your�
adults. They destroy the health, lives and livelihoods of millions of people,
yet they receive scant attention c�pared with diseases and other hazards.
Injuries have traditionally been rega�rled primarily as an unavoidable accident
or a beh�avioral problem rather than a health problem.
Three general strategies are available to prevent injuries:
Persuade persons at risk of injury to alter their behavior for increased self-
protection -- for example, to use seat belts or install smoke detectors.
R�equire individual behavior change by achninistrative rule or law, such as the
City vehicle seat belt rule arid the housing code onlinance pravision for smok,e
detector5.
Provide autoanatic protectian by product ar�d erivirorrmental design such as
built-in sprinkler systems that autarnatically extinguish fires.
i
216
� `'�� ,%- ����
oc���x�c�r-�ro-xi�ow
Conce�ns about Lawn Pesticides reflect a recognition of inadequate regulation
ar�d cqntrol.
In addition to the e�ency response and hazardous materials, reportirig
measur,es mentioned previously, the recexitly enacted U.S. F�ne.rgency Plannir�g and
Gartmwnity Right-To-Knvw Act of 1986, requires facilities to notify the state
. . _ -����reapanse-�o��si�cros-�mcl sioca�-�er�cY°��e�e•-�.a�t� ,:
regarding the accidental release of extremely hazardous ch�micals.
Beginnling in 1988, routine emissions irrventories will be required of facilities
that a¢�uzually manufacture, process, or use more than a threshold amaunt of
certai.ri toxic chEmicals. EPA is required to ocanpile this information ar�d make
it ava�ilable to the public through a�uterized data bases.
.
' 217
��� ��_ � ����
' ,�
SECTION 3
, PROGRAM DESCRIPTIONS, GOAIS, OBJECTIVES
.
218
��� d �--�- � ���
�r
ENVIROMIENTAL HEALTH
.
! 219
' ����1- ����'
ENVIROI�IENTAL HEALTH - Activities intended to achieve an environment
conductive to human health, comfort, safety, and well being: these
activities include the coordination or provision of education, regulation,
and consultation related to food protection, hazardous substances and
prOduct safety, water supply sanitation, waste disposal , environmental
pollution control , occupational health and safety, public health nuisance
control, institutional sanitation, recreational s.anitation, and housing
code enforcement for health and safety purposes.
� RELATED RAMSEY COUNTY PROGRAMS
-Hazardous waste
-Solid waste
-Community environmental sanitation
' RE�ATED DPH PROGRAMS
-Food regulation
-Environmental sanitation
-Housing code enforcement
-Animal control
PROGRAMS THIS SECTION
ACTZVITY: Food Regulation
GOA�: The community will be protected f rom foodborne illness.
TAR6ET AREA: Saint Paul
ACTIVITY: Environmental Sanitation
• GOAL' : Persons residing in community institutions will be at a
mi nimcm ri sk of i 1 lness and i nj ury from t hese environments.
The public will have access to non-community water supplies
free from harmful contaminants.
' Residents of Saint Paul will have the necessary knowledge,
skills, motivation, and opportunity to protect and improve
' the environmental health of the City of Saint Paul .
TARGET AREA: Saint Paul
ACTI'VITY: Housing Code Enforement
GOAL: Housing in Saint Paul will not deteriorate below the minimum
standards established in the Housing Code.
TARG�T AREA: Saint Paul
ACTINITY: Animal Control
GOAL: Residents of Saint Paul will be at minumum risk of animal
related attack, disease and nuisance.
TARG�T AREA: Saint Paul
I 220
I
,� ��- i���'
FOOD REGULATION
The Food Regulation Program addresses environmental priority three, food
sanitatio�. The program performs facility plan review and on-site inspection on
all new or remodeled food establishments before they are allowed to open. Once
opened, ongoing inspections are conducted to insure compliance with all food and
health ordinances. Complaints and suspected foodborne illnesses are immediately
investigated and corrective action is taken if necessary.
Educational materials are developed for use by the sanitari•ans in instruction of
food handlers and managers on the safe handling of food.
Food regulation also addresses injury control and hazardous materials priorities
by inspection for correct practices of injury control and handling and storage
of hazardous materials in food establishments.
221
C� � %-l y��
FOOD REGULATION
On oin Pro ram Objectives On oin Pro ram Indicator
o protect the health o t. Paul * ost per ood related
residents arld visitors by ensuring inspection 68.91
the safety of food and beverages sold/
consumed in St. Paul food and beverage Illness outbreak investigation 40
establishments. Complaint investigation 260
Investigate and report 100% of all real .
or suspected foodborne illness out- Food-beverage establishments
breaks. investigations 900
Investigate '100% of all complaints re- Itinerant Food License reviews 300
garding real� or suspected food ordinance
violations. Food-beverage establishment
Investigate 100� of all applications inspections 1,800
for food and beverage establishment Food-beverage establishment
licenses. ' inspection/frequency/year 2.00
Inspect 100%, of all food-beverage
establishments at least twice a year *Total Food related inspection 5,000
or more frequently if warranted. (includes above mandated food-
Abate 90% of all food code violations beverage inspections plus bakery,
Reduce by 10% the number of serious grocery, butcher store inspection
(grade 4 & 5) violations that could as well as all reinspections,
contribute to foodborne illness, plan reviews & on-site short term
Reduce by 10% the number of food estab- consults)
lishments with serious violations or
rating scores less than 90 at the most Violations found 10,000
recent inspection. Violations abated 9,000
� ' % Violations abated 90%
,1988-89 # of serious violations 641
# of estab.with serious
To microfilm 50% of records in 1988. violations or scores of 90 170
Revise the food inspection management
information system, to include a
category sys�em for food establishments
based on violation frequency & severity.
Implement a aharge for restaurant re-
views which would cover the cost of
this consultaitive service by 1989.
�
222
�� ��- � `���
ENVIRONMENTAL SANITATION
This prpgram addresses the #2 priority of ground water quality through its
routine �� inspection and monitoring of non-community public water supplies.
Samples drawn from these supplies undergo bacteriologic and nitrate testing.
lead contamination is addressed through soil lead sampling conducted in
conjunc�ion with State studies. This program also conducts envirormental
assessments of homes of chi ldren with elevated bl ood 1 ead 1 evels.
Educatianal activities include presentations to City policy makers, management
and the 'public on hazards and/or current control strategy developments
associated with the priority areas of air quality, emergency response, lead
contamination, hazardous materials, household hazardous wate, and community
right-to-know.
Surface 'water quality is addressed through routine swimming pool inspections,
routine bacteriologic and chemical testing of pool water and educational
' seminars for pool operators.
Injury control is addressed through routine inspections of schools for health
and safety hazards.
�
i
223
� �7-- ,��-�
�
' Environmental Sanitation
Ongoing Program Objectives Ongoing Program Indicator
To protect he health of t. Paul Cost/Contact
residents arid visitors by ensuring (Total Activity Cost/*Insp.) 177.67
the safety of public swimming pools,
noncommunit,y public water supplies, Oisease outbreak
institutions, school buildings, and investigation 1
rooming houses in St. Paul through *Noncorr�nunity public water
food inspection, enforcement and supply inspections 68
educational efforts.
Investigate and report 100% of all Swirraning Pools
real or suspected waterborne disease Complaints investigated 15
outbreaks. license application investig. 115
Investigate 100% of all complaints *Inspections 230
regarding real or suspected swimming Violations found 500
pool ordinance violations. % Violations abated 90%
Investigate 100% of all applications Institutional Food
for swimning pool licenses. Complaints investigated 15
Inspect 100� of the 34 noncommunity License Application investig. 225
public water supplies in St. Paul . *Inspections 450
Inspect 100� of all swirrrning pools at Violations found 2,100
least twice 'a year or more frequently � Violations abated 90%
if warranted. School Buildings
� Inspect 100� of all institutional food Complaints investigated 2
establishments at least twice a year License application investig 85
or more frequently if warranted. *Inspections 85
Inspect 100� of all school buildings Violations found 150
at least once a year to screen for X violations abated 90%
health and safety hazards.
Abate 90% of all water, pool , instit-
utional food, school building,
rooming house violations and hazards.
*Total Inspections 833
1988-89 Objectives
To implement annually, in a unified
approach, City Council, Mayoral and
CHS Advisory Committee recommendations
for environr�ental education and
protection. ',
224
��-- �-�- i'���'
' HOUSING CODE ENFORCEMENT
This program directly relates to environmental priority five, housing sanitation.
This program inspects residential dwellings, and all properties on a complaint
basis, to determine compliance with the Housing Codes. The program is
authorized to order remedial action for code violations, which may include
injury control, to enforce penalty provisions, to condemn buildings as unfit for
human habitation, and take direct corrective action (sumnary abatement) in
removing public health nuisances, which may involve solid waste, hazardous
waste, and hazardous materials, all of which represent areas of environmental
priority as defined by CHS Advisory Committee.
This program also monitors compliance with the lawn pesticide posting
requirements of the Saint Paul Lawn Pesticide Ordinance.
lead Con�amination is addressed through home survey and lead abatement visits to
homes of children identified as having lead poisoning.
Educatior�al activities include development of educational materials and regular
presenta�ions to City policy makers, management, corr�nunity organizations and the
public on hazards and/or current control strategy developments associated with
the priority areas of housing sanitation, solid waste, hazardous waste and lawn
' pesticid�s.
225
'� , �7- ���'
�
HOUSING INSPECTION
1988-89
Ongoing Pragram Objectives Ongoing Program Indicator Promised
Investigate 100% of all complaints *Cost/Housing Complaint
regarding i�nterior and exterior Inspection 23.97
violations pf the St. Paul Housing
Code and issue order to correct the # of inspections/complaint 2.36
violation ih a timely manner.
Housing Code Complaints 8,200
Investigate 100% of all complaints *complaint inspections 19,500
regarding r�ntal property suspected Violations 8,800
of not complying with State energy Violations corrected 7,920
conservation standards. % Uiolations corrected 90
90% of Housing Code violations Structures condemned 90
detected will be corrected.
' Violation tags issued 215
50% of energy conservation violations
detected will be corrected. Court appearances 25
City Council appearances 156
Survey and �orrect lead hazards with- Lead Hazard Surveys 40
in 14 days, ,in homes of children
detected wi�h high blood lead levels. Energy Conservation �°
Complaints 140
To maintain the average number of Energy conservation inspections 200
' inspections to less than 2.5 per Energy conservation violations 600
complaint fi''led. Energy conservation violations
, corrected 400
X Violations corrected 67
*Total Housing costs/by Housing complaint
inspections
�I
�
226
I
' � ���
C��=- ��-
ANIMAL/PEST CONTROL
This program directly relates to environmental priority eight, animal control .
The program enforces ordinance concerns such as rabies .vaccination, leashing,
disease transmission and noise. The program impounds dogs running at large.
Dangerous dog cases (attack and/or bites) are investigated, a hearing is
conducted and a decision is made regarding appropriate disposition of dogs
determined to be dangerous.
The program also investigates complaints of nuisnace animals, traps these
animals where appropriate and may examine them for rabies. Community wide sewer
baiting, broken residential sewer line testing, trapping and extermination
activities are also conducted.
Educational programs on animal control and pet owner responsibilities are
regularly conducted for the public.
227
� �U�- �7- ����,
ANIMAL/PEST CONTROL
� 1988-89
Ongoing Pro,gram Objectives Ongoing Program indicator Promised
To respond �promptly to all citizen *Cost per major work units 18.61
animal complaints and facilitate
reduction in pests/rodents and stray Animal Bites 530
animals with the City. *Animal complaints pests/pets 7,000
Barking dog complaints 700
To provide 24 hour emergency animal *Dog/cat quarantine calls 700
control services. *Cats impounded 900
To investigate 100% of all reported *Dogs impounded 2,000
bites by pest nuisance animals *Summonses issued 700
(raccoons,slkunks, bats, squirrels, rats, Dangerous dog hearings 40
muskrats,and woodchucks). Dogs disposed of 1,300
To investigate 100% of all public pro- Dogs redeemed 800
perty roden� complaints. Education pamphlets 5,500
To maintain ,the number of dog bites at Animal care talks & tours 15
the current level of 475 or less. Emergencies after hours 30
To loan anir�al traps to private *Warning tags 1,600
citizens for stray cats and nuisance Dog licenses issued-pound 1,430
animals. Animals examined for rabies 16
To abate 90� of pest and nuisance
animal complaints. *8ite Investigations 10
To maintain an ongoing vehicle replace- Rabies examinations 10
ment cycle of one vehicle per year. *Nuisance animals trapped 300
. *Broken sewer line check 50
1988-89 Objectives *Catch basins baited/rebaited 3,000
*Traps set 400
To provide w�ekend coverage of 10 hours/ Traps loaned 350
days on Saturdays and Sundays in 1988
if one additional FTE is funded. Receipts collected by DPH 30,000
' Receipts % of
To conduct a rodent census in six Budget 11.2
selected area of the City using rodent
activity in Catch basins as an indi-
cator of area infestation.
To increase the number of dogs licensed
at the pound by 10%.
� Comments
h�r separation project has increased the
demand on our rodent control activity.
' 228
FAMILY HEALTH - Activities intended to promote optimal health outcomes �rd� 7-���
related to human reproduction and child growth and development; t hese
activities include the coordination or provision of education, counseling,
screening, clinical services, school health services, nutrition services,
f amily planning services as defined in section 145.925, and other inter-
ventions directed at improving family health.
�I RELATED RAMSEY COUNTY PROGRAMS:
', -Child health screening and assessment
', -Child abuse prevention
' -High risk parenting
-Child health
-Parent health
-Comprehensive prenatal/postpartum/inf ant care
-Southeast Asian services
REIATED DPH PROGRAMS:
-Dental health
-Family planning
-WIC
-Chi ldhood 1 ead poisoni ng prevention program
RELATED JOINT PROGRAMS:
-Nutrition
-Homeless
-Day Care
' PROGRAMS THIS SECTION
,
ACTIVITY: Dental Health
, GOAiL: To ensure, promote, and protect the oral health of the
people in the City of Saint Paul .
TARGET AREA: Saint Paul
ACTIVITY: Family Planning
GOAL: To provide comprehensive family planning services to
residents of Saint Paul and Ramsey County.
TARGET AREA: Ramsey County
ACTIVITY: Supplement Food Program for Women, Infants and Children
, (MIC)
GOAjL: To provi de suppl emental foods and nutrit ion educat ion to
' eligible pregnant and breastfeeding women, ir�f ants, and
' children to ameliorate and/or prevent nutrition related
health problems.
TARGET AREA: Ramsey County
ACTIVITY: Childhood Lead Poisoning Prevention
GOAI: To eliminate all sources of lead-based paint which may
contribute to undue lead absorption by small children
residing in Saint Paul . To reduce childhood lead poisoning
so that it is no longer a public health concern.
TARGET AREA: Saint Paul
��n
� �i,�� �-i��
DENTAL HEALTH
The Dental Health Program provides services which fit under both the Family
Health an�d Health Promotion categories. Both areas are included in this
section.
The DPH Dental Program provides comprehensive and therapeutic services to low
income ch;ildren 2 1/2 - 21 years of age who live in the City of Saint Paul.
Eligibili�y is determined by income and size of family. Services are provided
on a sliding fee scale according to financial ability to pay. Statistics show
that one third pay 10% to 75% of the total charges. The remainder are on
Medical A�sistance and are seen at the clinic because of the limited number of
private pi�actice dentists that will take Medical Assistance.
Dental se'rvices for the majority of the elderly and handicapped are provided by
dentists in private practice. Others obtain services at community clinics on a
sliding f�e basis according to eligibility.
The DPH D�ntal Program provides dental education to children and their parents
who receive services at the clinic. Education is provided to target groups such
as refuge�s and group homes residents as staff and time permit. Movies, slides
and printed material are used to convey the dental message and identify
resources 'available for dental care.
Dental as�essment, referral and education is provided on a limited basis to
children in day care centers and their parents. Dental staff reductions in 1987
prohibit rtlore than a limited approach. No other agency provides similar
. services.
These services reflect the priorities of the RCCHS Advisory Committee for dental
health acc'essability.
II
�
�'
I 231
; C�--�7- i���
I� DENTAL HEALTH
' 1988 1989
On oin Pro ram Objectives Ongoing Pro�ram Indicators Estimated Promised
o provide education, assessment, re- *Cost relative value unit —6 8 —�7p
ferral & follow+up annually for 95%
of preschoolers in attendance.
To screen, assess and refer 92% of Preschool children assessed 500 500
refugees attending the Refugee and referred 50 50
Screening C1iniC.
To provide information to community Refugees assessed 470 423
groups regarding the most effective Refugees referred 100% 100%
methods of preventing oral disease.
To provide preventive and thera- # preschool ed. programs 12 12
peutic services 'at least annually
to children and certain adults who
would not otherwise receive care.
To maintain dental liaison with # in attendance 650 700
public and private health and
welfare agencies''.
Monitor the level of fluoride in Preventive encounters 1,150 1,170
the St. Paul water supply. Therapeutic encounters 1,_280 1,280
Total Visits 2,203 2,250
1988-89 Project Dbjective (by Priority) Completed patients 625 625
o provide a wor plan including mod- Relative Value Units 968 9,000
ification of program work schedules in Prophylaxis 953 970
prder to accomodate for staff re- Fluoride treatments 700 750
ductions and yet maintain both edu- X-Rays 1,575 1,590
cation and treatment aspects of Surfaces of sealants 620 650
program. Tooth surfaces filled 3,409 3,408
' Root canal treatments 20 20
, Extractions 100 100
To develop a modified plan for # of homeless referred to dental 28 32
maintaining community agency contacts # keeping appointments 26 30
regarding availability of dental Total Visits 30 35
clinic resources ,at OPH Community agency contacts 60 65
232
C��7 c���'
FAMILY PLANNING
The activities of the Family Planning Program reflect the highest priority of
the RCCHSAC for family planning service accessability for those without other
resource�.
The goaliof the Family Planning Program is to promotP and to improve the
general public health of the community, especially that of women and infants,
by assisting individuals in determining family size, spacing children,
achieving desired pregnancy, and avoiding unwanted pregnancy. Within the
Division of Public Health, the Family Planning Program contributes
significantly to the Maternal Child Health component. It is one of the
largest providers of inedical and education services, second only to the WIC
Program. The Program provides reproductive health care with particular
emphasis on voluntary contraception. Other services include pregnancy
testing, counseling and referral, natural family planning (NFP), education,
and infertility counseling. Services available to males include
contraceptive supplies, NFP, vasectomy, education, and infertility
counseling.
Program data demonstrates that 86.5� of clients are at or below 150� of
federal poverty levels; 8% are Title XIX recipients. Thirty percent of
clients a�re under 20 years of age.
I
233
/�i (�.�
,r- �7- �
FAMILY PLANNING PROJECT
' 1988 1989
On oin Pro ra Objective On oin Pro ram Indicators Estimated Promised
o provide acc ssible, confidential *Cost me ical encounter 6�0 �—
family planning services to 6,900
users each calendar year.
To provide a mi'nimum of one documented Medical/education users 6,900 6,900
reproductive h�alth education/counseling Medical users 3,500 3,500
session for 100% of staff and initial Medical Visits 8,000 8,000
and annual patients during each calendar Encounters 19,500 I9,500
year. Pregnancy tests 1,300 1,300
To provide 15 offsite community ed- Users at or below 150% poverty 85� 85�
ucation/outreach programs each Users 19 years or under 30X 30%
calendar year.
To maximize pragram effectiveness by Program generated revenue 85,000 90,000
adhering to the Department of Health & Users 19 years or under 30� 30%
Human Services' reporting requirements, Cost attributable to
utilizing consu�ner input & generating administration 14% 14%
program income throughout 1988 & 1989.
Community Education programs 40 40
participants 3,000 3,000
Project Objecti,ves (by priority) Comments
The above objec�tives are consistent h�amily Planning Project is primarily funded by
with the prograpn, Title X Grant Title X, PHS. An additional grant is submitted bi-
Application, as submitted to the annually to the MN Dept of Health. The
• Department of Hlealth & Human Services. State funds are used solely for provision of female
Objectives are �vritten for the project voluntary sterilization. The program has realized
period. reduced Title X funds for the past 3 years. Despite
In addition to voluntary contraceptive the reduced funds, the caseload continue to grow
services & related medical procedures, significantly. There is concern regarding ability
other program services include follow- to maintain quality in the face of shrinking
up, pregnancy testing and counseling, dollars, decreased staff, and increased program
referral , infertility counseling, demand. Emphasis placed on alternate funding
sterilizations, community education, sources.
morning after care, Natural Family
Planning(NFP). Medical services are
offered at three sites; Division of
Public Health & the Health Education
& Screening Cen�ters in White Bear Lake
& Moun�sview. Special clinics are
available for tieens & refugees.
', *Cost per encounter based on BCRR report.
' Comments
' h�e program will explore the feasibility of obtaining
City and/or Community Health Services funds.
234
�.' . _1- �`�f9�
� �
SUP!PLEMENTAL FOOD PROGRAM FOR WOMEN INFANTS AND CHILDREN - WIC
The WIC Program serves eligible persons throughout the county. The program
reflects, the high priority the RCCHSAC places on addressing inadequate
nutrition in mothers and infants.
On oin ro ram Objectives & 1987 On oin Pro ram Indicators
o provide nutrition education and food Cost per W c ient contact 6.52 6.52
vouchers to 7,500 WIC participants
monthly. , Number of WIC client contacts 95,200 95,200
per year
To screen, assess intervene with and/ Monthly WIC participation 7,500 7,500
or counsels 16,300 pregnant women
infants and children to achieve the Clients screened, assessed, 16,950 16,950
following ou�comes after 6 months of intervened, counseled
nutrition in�ervention:
- 70% of anemic clients will have normal Nutrition outcome after 6 mo.
hct, levels of intervention:
- 30� of unde�rweight clients will -anemia to normal levels 70% 70�
achieve ag� >5th percentile -underweight to quality assurance
- 15% of short stature clients will standards 30% 30�
achieve age, >5th percentile -short stature to >5%ile
- 25� of overweight clients will length of stature/age 15% 15%
achieve qua'lity assurance standard -overweight to the quality
- less than 5% of infants born to women assurance standards 25� 25%
enrolled in WIC at least 3 months -WIC infants breastfed 6 weeks
will be low birth weight, or longer 25� 25%
.
-Low birth weights <5% WIC infants 5% 5%
Food Cost 2,745,348 2,841,435
City Grant 538,816 538,816
TOTAL 3,284,164 3,3$0,251
I City Costs of Program 17.4� 17.4%
1 88-89
To increase tNe percentage of pregnant
WIC participants to 13.5% annually.
To investiage alternative service de-
livery methods & negotiate with the
State WIC offi'ce for permission to
implement alte'rnate methods (if any
are found to b�e better than current
methods).
' 235
i
/
�,�- �7- ���'�
�
' CHILOHOOD IEAD SCREENING
The ChildYhood Lead Screening Program does follow-up on all abnormal blood
tests preformed on WIC clients. An environmental component of the program
inspects �he home environment for possible source of the lead. A PHN
interview$ the parents and educates the family on how to avoid lead
contamination.
CHILDHOOD LEAD POISONING PREVENTION
' 1988 1989
�On oi�n Program Objectives Ongoing Program Indicators Estimated Promised
o c tinue emythrocyte protoporphyrin *Cost per test 9.99 0 90
(EP) testing, evaluation monitoring and
treatment to reduce problems of lead *Children Tested (EP) 6,000 6,000
toxicity in children in St. Paul
Elevated EP tests 500 800
To better infprm the public of effects of
lead toxicity' in children in St. Paul . *Blood Lead Tests 450 640
To identify lpad sources other than New cases identified BL>25 ug/dl 50 50
paint.
1988-9 Project Objectives (by Priority) Children retested EP 45-74 1,700 1,700
To test 4,880� children 9mos-5yrs of age Children referred for medical
. with EP test. evaluation (ABC or PMD) EP>75 550 550
To do blood l�ad (BL) tests on 90% of Children with identified lead
children with elevated EP 45-74 & toxicity followed at DPH for
monitor at 3 mos. EBL >25ug/dl 50 50
To refer children with EP >75 and/or Children with reduced ZEP and/or
HCT <30 for medical evaluation to rule BL in 6 mos by chart audit 70% 70%
out lead toxi�city (ABC Clinic at SPDPH) Referred for environmental
To identify 5b children with undue lead surveys 100% 100�
absorption (Blood Lead >25ug/dl ). Community & Staff Education
To monitor 90� of children with Programs 8 8
elevated blood lead (EBL) levels every Persons attending 210 210
3 months.
70% of childrien with identified EBL WIC performs EP on 100% of children in their program
will have documented reduction in BL annually.
in 6 months. �
To refer 100% of dwelling units of
newly identified lead cases for
environmental' evalaution.
To provide at least 8 community edu-
cation & staf,f inservice programs.
236 '
/
�� ;�-7-/�{;{'�'
HEALTH PROMOTION
.
�
�
� ��,
C�:�--`�7- ���'
HEALTH PROMOTION - Activities intended to reduce the prevelance of risk
cpnditions or behaviors of individuals or communities for the purposes of
p►�eventing chroni c di sease and effecting other defi nabl e advances in heal th
status; these activities include the coordination or provision of community
organization, regulation, targeted screening and education, as well as
informational and other scientifically supported interventions to foster
health by affecting related conditions and behaviors.
, RELATEO RAMSEY COUNTY PROGRAMS:
' -Adult health mini-clinics and occupational health
-Mental health
-Community health education and consultation
-Community planning and system development
RELATED DPH PROGRAMS:
', -Health services for the elderly: Mini-Clinics, Walking program
-Community health education
-Employee health
-Firefighter Fitness
-Dental health
RELATED JOINT PROGRAMS:
' -Community Nutrition
' -Homeless
PROGRAMS THIS SECTION
ACTIVITY: Health Services for the Elderly
G014!: To maintain and/or improve the level of wellness among the
elderly population in order to enable them to continue to
.
live independently as long as possible.
TARGET AREA: Saint Paul
ACI�IVITY: Corr�nunity Health Education
GOAL : To provide health education to the residents of Saint Paul
that informs people about health, i l lness, di sabi 1 ity, and
ways in which they can improve and protect their own health,
i ncl udi ng more eff i ci ent use of the del i very system.
TA�GET AREA: Saint Paul
AC7IVITY: Employee Health
GOAI: City of Saint Paul employees will be physically fit to
' perform their jobs.
TARGET AREA: Employees of the City of Saint Paul
ACTIVITY: FIRE FIGHTERS fITNESS
GOP�L: Fire fighters will be fit to perform their jobs and will
reduce their risk f actors for cardiovascular disease.
TARGET AREA: City of Saint Paul Fire Fighters
I 238
�� � I` j ��k.
I HEALTH SERVICES FOR THE ELDERLY
The Health Services for the Elderly offers Health Promotion for Seniors through
Free mini-�linics offered in Community Centers and high rises where anyone can
consult wi$h health professionals, have their blood pressure evaluated, pulse
and weight monitored and receive health education on a variety of topics.
Assessment�, referrals and follow-ups are done as needed, sometimes during a
home visit. This staff also gives flu shots each fall and administers a walking
Program for Seniors.
This program reflects the Advisory Committees priorities of developing personal
responsibil,ity for one's health and of promoting wellness in the Elderly.
1988 1989
Ongoing Progr,am Objectives Ongoing Program Indicators Estimated Promised
Operate 231 mini-clinic sessions in *Cost per visit 7.72 7.72
11 locations in St. Paul with 4,850
visits by 575' clients. Mini clinic sessions 135 132
To do health iassessments of 100% new Mini clinic visits 4,850 4,850
clients and periodic follow-up assess- Clients served 575 575
ments annuall�. Health Assessments (new) 154 150
' Follow-up health assessments 1,930 1,930
To continue hypertension screening, *Visits for HTN monitoring 4,826 4,826
monitoring, clounseling follow-up & Counseled for HTN 1,930 1,930
, education. Referrals made 80 80
*Home visits by PHN 70 70
' Screened & counseled in
health education areas 575 575
1988-89 Objec�ives (by priority) Participating in walking
To screen and monitor 1,930 persons program 55 55
for hypertens�on & refer 80 for Exhibiting increased endurance 75% 75%
treatment. '
To continue tMe Walking Program,
involving 55 people.
��o
� /� ,(''� /���
�.:�
COMMUNITY HEATLH EDUCATION
The Health 'Education program provides technical assistance to health division
staff as w�ll as education and technical assistance to the community at large.
This program reflects the Advisory Committee's priorities of developing personal
responsibility for one's own health as well as the priority to reduce
comnunicable diseases through education of at risk populations.
1988-89
On9�o—in Pro ram Objectives Ongoing Program Indicator Promised
�prov�de hea th education support for Health education programs
Division of P!ublic Health (DPH) Programs for the community 400
including:
assigned priority programs Participants in Health
requests from other programs Education programs 12,000
general public health promotion
Total number persons served 19,575
To provide 404 health education programs
for 12,000 cohmunity residents in areas
that support DPH programs and public
health.
To provide technical assistance/expertise
for: '
' community agencies/residents & staff
school teachers/administrators
community agency planners
student interns
information �nd referral requests
other City Departments
1988-89 Objectives
To establish � cost per contact system
for health education by end of first
quarter 1988, , and maintain the system
throughout th� years.
Provide healtN education services to
a minimum of 19,575 persons through the
community, cl �nical and administrative
sectors.
To identify a 'policy and charges for
non-St. Paul health education services
provided by DPH health educators.
' Comments
he ivision of Public Health reorganized its Health
Education section in 1987 to emphasize the role of
educational efforts in the promotion of public healtF
initiatives.
240 ,
I
�� ����
���-j-
PREVENTIVE HEALTH SERVICES
The Firefighters Wellness Program is a Health Promotion program done under
contract 'with the Saint Paul Fire Department offering health screening,
monitoring, evaluation, referral and education to maintain physical fitness
among firefighters.
This pro�ram of Employee Health and Firefighters Fitness are primarily
designed to meet the RCCHSAC priority of developing personal responsibility
for one's health.
EMPLOYEE HEALTH/FIREFIGHTER FITNESS
' 1988-89
On oin Pro ram Objectives Ongoing Program Indicators Promised
To provide sp cialized primary care Hours of service provided
health physician services to identified by support staff in this
residents/empl�oyees in St. Paul . activity
City Staff 4,000
1988-89 Objectives Urban Corp Students 4,000
Physician 450
To provide publlic health learning
experiences through Urban Corps for
undergraduate/graduate students which
contribute to public health services
in St. Paul through 1988-89.
� To provide Div�sion sponsored training Number of individual employees
to 200 employees in 1988 & in 1989 attending Division sponsored training 200
To provide mantoux tests, hearing tests Employees tested 560
and firefighter fitness exams to 560 DPH employee mantoux tests 70
employees in 1988 & in 1989 Chest X-ray 4
Chemoprophylaxis for positive mantoux 0
To provide appropriate health record Audiometric (hearing) tests 60
documentation pf health status and Firefighters exams 430
improvement on a timely basis.
Comments
ThiTactivity will coordinate non-programmed
needs, consolidate student and contractual services
and serve as the fund for increased health services
, based on changing volumes of services.
241
�'� ��� �_ ����
DISEASE PREVENTION AND CONTROL
242
DISEASE PREVENTION AND CONTROL - Activities intended to prevent or ����?-/�/�
control communicable diseases; these activities include the coordination or
provision of disease surveillance, investigation, reporting, and related
cou�nseling, education, screening, immunization, case management and related
services.
RELATED RAMSEY COUNTY PROGRAMS:
� -Communicable disease control
RELATED OPH PROGRAMS:
-AIDS screening/Sexually transmitted disease control
, -Epidemiology and communicable disease control -
-Immunizations
, -Tuberculosis control
-Refugee health care
-Occupational health and safety
' -Supervised rooming and boarding inspection program
-Public health laboratory
REl ATED JOINT PROGRAMS:
' -Homeless
-Day Care
PROGRAMS THIS SECTION
ACTIVITY: AIDS Screening and Prevention/Sexually Transn�itted Disease
' Control
GOAL': To reduce the incidence of all sexually transmitted
diseases.
, TARGET AREA: Saint Paul
ACTIV'VITY: Epidemiology and Cormnunicable Disease Control
GOAL: To reduce mor bi di ty and mort al i ty from communi cabl e di sease
in Saint Paul .
TARGET AREA: Saint Paul
ACTI�IITY: Immunizations
GOAL c To el i mi nate al l cases of vacci ne preventabl e di sease in
Saint Paul and achieve and maintain a level of disease
resistance.
TARGET AREA: Saint Paul
ACTIWITY: Tubrculosis Control
GOAi_s To interrupt transmi ssion of tubercul osi s infection, prevent
, tuberculosis infection from progressing to disease, and
protect the non-infected person from becoming infected.
TARG�T AREA: Saint Paul
243
DISEASE PREVENTION AND CONTROL - PROGRAMS THIS SECTION - Continued
�'�7-/U,�.
ACTIVITY: Refugee Health Care
GOAL: To achieve a level of health in the newly arrived refugee
which prevents the transmission of communicable diseases and
facilitates the refugee's resettlement.
TAR!GET AREA: Saint Paul
ACT'IVITY: Occupational Health and Safety
GOA�: City of Sai nt Paul gnpl oyees wi 11 have a worki ng envi ronment
free from recognized hazards.
TAR�ET AREA: Saint Paul
ACT,IVITY: Supervised Rooming and Boarding Inspection Program
GOAL: Persons residing in community institutions will have minimum
risk of illness and injury from these environments.
TARGET AREA: Saint Paul
ACTTVITY: Isolated Adults Program
GOAI.: To intervene in crisis situations for isolated and/or
• ' vulnerable adults to prevent illness, injury or death.
TARC�ET AREA: Saint Paul
244
C�.,f�_ ,���
AIDS/SEXUALLY TRANSMITTED DISEASE CONTROL
DPH has a�ternate test sites which serve clients from Ramsey County and surrounding areas.
Counseling is provided both pre and post testing. A physician is available for
consultation, further testing, treatment referral , additional counseling.
The STD W�lk-in Clinic provides diagnosis and treament of STD' s and contact follow-up of
syphilis, 'gonorrhea and chlaymdia. Test of cure is done as indicated. Physician services
are ava i l abl e if needed.
AIDS SCRE�NING AND PREVENTION
_ �
1988 1989
On oin Pno ram Ob 'ectives Ongoing Program Indicators Estimated Promised
o provide, HIV screening & counseling Cost per visit 20.40 20.40
& referral service as an alternate
test site through 8,800 clinic visits Total clinic visits 8,800 8,800
in 1988 anid 1989. Initial screening visits 3,750 3,750
Follow-up visits 4,200 4,200
Referral s made for pos i t ive
test results 100� 100%
To increasie awareness of the AIDS epi- Physici an vi sits 300 300
demic & prpventive measures through
100 Commun7ty Education Programs in Community Education
both 1988 �nd 1989. presentations 100 100
Community Education
' participants 10,000 10,000
Community based test sites 2 2
• 1988-89 Prpjectives (by priority) Comments
� To review annually City's AIDS policy This program is funded in part via a contract with
f or City gnployees. the Minnesota Department of Health.
To monitor prevalence of AIDS & AIDS
related conditions in the community.
To refer or provide medical services to
100% of persons who test positive for
the AIDS virus.
To provide training and support to
develop oth�er Community test sites in
Ramsey County.
, 245
I � _.���
� �� �
SEXUALLY TRANSMITTED DISEASE CONTROL
1988 1989
On oin Pro ram Objectives Ongoing Program Indicators Estimated Promisec
To provi e 6,0 0 v� sits to persons *Cost per patient vi sit 2— 4.�� ��
seeking 5exually Transmitted Disease
Clinic service. *Total clinic visits 6,000 6,000
To treat 500 cases with positive diag-
nosis of gonnorhea Total gonnorhea treated 500 500
To treat ,20 cases with positive di ag-
nosis of syphilis Total syphilis treated 20 20
To treat 2,500 cases with positive
diagnosed� of other STD' s. Total Chlamydia treated 500 500
To provide STD education to 10 com-
munity groups. Other STD 2,300 23,00
To treat 500 cases of diagnosed
chlamydia during 1987. Community Education
' presentations 109 10
1988-1989 Project Objectives (by Patient contributions 20,000 20,000
priority �
To maintain patient contributions at Community Education Data may include AIDS Infor-
a level of at least $22,000 year, mation with STD: patient contribut ions were for bot
• To seek remuneration for chlamydia HIV and other STD.
testing.
�
; 246
I
�� �� / ���.
IMMUNIZATION PROGRAM
Immunization has daily walk-in clinics. The program provides routine child and adult
immunizati''ons, DPT, OPV, Td, MMR, with informed consent, as well as immunizations and
informatian for foreign travel . (Cholera, typhoid, yellow fever, Immune serus globulin,
Salk polio. Prescriptions for malaria, validation of Certificate for International Travel) .
A referral system exists with SPRMC for meningitis vaccine. Validation is done of Health
Certificat,es required in specific instances by foreign countries. Special vaccines are
offered su'�ch as Hepatitis B Vaccine; Rabies vaccine; Hemophilis Influenza B vaccine and,
Influenza !vaccine yearly for at risk groups.
Follow-up is done of preschool children to complete immunization series.
IMMUNIZATIQN
1988 1989
Ongoing Prpgram Objectives Ongoing Program Indicators Estimated Promised
To provide�' immunizations against vac- *Cost per immunization 4.44 4.44
cine preventable diseases to St. Paul
residents. ' Clinic visits 4,400 4,400
To provide immunization & health in-
formation $or foreign travel. *Immun. given D PH 7,000 7,000
1988-1989 Project Objectives (by Doses vaccine dispensed to
• priority) other providers 4,000 4,000
To provi e ,approximately 1,000 immuni-
zations to St. Paul residents at the Traveler visits 1,000 1,000
Publ ic Heal��th Center.
To dispense approximately 4,000 doses Immunizations given to
of vaccine to neighborhood clinics. travelers 2,000 2,000
To provide immunizations & health
counseling to 1,000 travelers to Influenza Immunizations 2,500 2,500
foreign countries.
To provide irr�nunization against in- Imm. levels of St. Paul
fluenza for 2,500 senior citizens & preschool enterers 98� 98�
high risk individuals.
' Average imm, levels of
, K-12 students-St. Paul 99� 99%
*Cost per Immunization �cpenditures + t otal
' immuni2ations.
247
,�
/�t�'.
�� �-
' TUBERCULOSIS
Maintaining informed, trained staff to receive reports, doctor-diagnose disease registry; do
contact fol'low-up. The physician treats disease; a�ninisters ch�no-prophylaxis, provides
education, information and consultation services.
This progra�n works closely with the Refugee Screening Program.
TUBERCULOSI6 CONTROL
1988 1989
Ongoing Program Objectives Ongoing Proqram Indicators Estimated Promised
To maintain TB case finding & follow- *Cost per patient 56�5 5g,�5
up.
To obtain r�ports of all cases of TB cases newly dx in
tuberculosis occurring in St. Paul St. Paul 20 20
within 1 wee�k after they are detected. Cases on regi ster at end
To have 95% �of active TB cases with of year 20 20
positive bac�teriology convert to neg- Cases with positive bacter-
ative within 6 months. iology converted to negative 95% 95%
To have 90% of cases complete pres- Cases completing Chemo. 90% gp%
cribed cours�e of treatment & follow-up. Contacts identified 100 100
To conduct contact follow-up on al l Cl inic sessions PHP-U(��I 350 350
new cases wi�hin 2 weeks. *Patient vi sits (PHP-U(��I) 4,000 4,000
To have 75% pf new significant mantoux Refugee visits 40% 40%
. reactors under age 35 complete 1 year County patient visits 150 150
prophylactic ' chemotherapy. Screened (mts tests) 1,650 1,600
To provide specific clinic services to Chest x-rays PHC-U(�I 1,000 1,000
county resid�nts under contract to T6. Significant mtx reactions 200 200
Patient starting chemo 150 150
1988-1989 Ob�ectives (by priority) Refugees 70% 70%
Selected persons requesting HIV testing Completing prophylaxis 7p% 7p%
are also being screened f or T6. PPD dispensed (doses) 1,800 1,800
To use interpreters to increase Consultation with MD 600 550
chemoprophylaxis compliance in Refugee 60% 50�
refugee patiehts. *Home visits by PHN 150 150
*Program costs = activity 03216 costs + patients &
home vi sits.
248
%���y���'
�
REFUGEE HEALTH CARE
The clinic �does screening for TB, parasites, physical inspection with treatment of diseases
and test of cure as indicated. Immunizations are given as indicated and follow-up is done
as needed f�r 1 year with referrals as needed for speciality care, including WIC, dental and
various cli�ics at SPRMC.
The Refugee clinic provides screening for entire family and follow-up for 1 year. Ongoing
well baby csre for 1 year for refugees. Referrals to MIC made to pregnant refugee women.
Referrals ar,e made from Refugee Clinic to Ramsey County Nursing Services for every new
family scre�ned f or follow-up, education, assistance and further referrals as needed.
The Refugee 'Program has a primary function of communicable disease control. This population
often arriv�s with numerous communicable disease problerr�s and the program reflects the high
priority the RCCHSAC gives to this function.
REFUGEE HEALTH CARE
1988 1989
Ongoing Prog�ram Objectives Ongoing Program Indicators Estimated Promised
To locate 96� of refugees in St. Paul *Cost per patient vi sit �2 54.90
within 2 weeks of arrival .
To provide screening for 75% of new New refugees 950 950
refugees loc�ted in St. Paul within % of refugees located 96% 96%
1 month. New refugees who left area 50 50
. To assure that screening is received *Refugees screened at DPH 350 300
from other providers for remaining 25% Screened elsewhere in St. Paul 100 100
within 1 mon�h. Primary care users 900 1,200
To submit encounter forms for 100% of *Primary care visits 1,300 1,800
refugees screened in St. Paul to State Refugees referred for
Surveillance'System 1 month after special problems 150 150
screening. Encounter forms submitted
To offer dir�ct primary care services to State Surveillance system 100% 100%
for 100% of newly arrived refugees for Children referred to ABC Clinic 200 200
1 year after arrival . Chi ldren screened at DPH 75% 75%
To evaluate Children with abnormal Referred to other providers 20 20
blood chemis�ry referred from WIC & *Visits to ABC Clinic 400 700
Lead Programs for lead poisoning.
1988-1989 Praject Objectives (by
riorit
To o tain int'erpreter services for
refugee popul�ation to be used also by
other program�s - eg. Lead & TB.
To seek 1 ong ,term fundi ng sourc es for
the provi sion of refugee health
services. '
249
��� �,� i�'�"
�
OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH
' 1988 1989
On oin Pro ram Objectives On oin Pro ram Indicators Estimated Promised
o con uct training courses for vari- W.C. cost per city emp oyee 556.92 556.92
ous groups 'of city employes in re-
sponse to the requirement of the No. of city employees 3,250 3,250
"Employee Right To Know Laws" lst occurrence lost time injury .
To investig�ate city owned worksites frequency ratea 4.6 4.6
for compliance with OSHA standards, lst occurrence lost time injury
Clean Indoor Air Act requirements & severity rateb 39.0 39.0
Hazardous W�ste Generator require- Cost of Workers Comp� 1,810,000 1,900,000
ments. ' Field visits/work site
To monitor worksites & employee ex- inspections 180 180
posed to high noise levels. Noise studies made 60 60
To conduct �annual audiograms for all Complaints investigated con-
employees in job titles determined to cerning toxic-noxious agents 50 50
have high nbise exposure. Reported injuries 780 780
To reduce t�e incidence of injuries Lost time injuries inves-
among city employees. tigated 80 80
To provide assistance to all Depart- Employees fitted for eye
ments in establishing safety com- protection 310 310
mittees, conducting worksite in- Employees training in "Right
spections & accident analysis. To Know Law" 450 450
' Employees given audiometric
1988-1989 P�roject Objectives (by testing 200 200
priority
• To decrease the prevalence of non- Comments
compliance with State/Federal OSHA Fr� equency Rate = # of disabling injuries/200,000
standards by 2�. manhours of exposure
To conduct industrial hygiene studies bSeverity Rate = # of days lost per 200,000/man-
for noise problems, CO levels, ven- hours of exposure
tilation prpblems & miscellaneous en- �Does not include special fund and WCRA premiums
vironmental complaints.
To collect, 'tabulate, analyze & in-
vestigate reported accident & injury
reports.
To establish hearing conservation pro-
grams for those employees exposed to
noise levelg exceeding OSHA standards.
To establish base-line audiograms for
selected grdups of employees (200 em-
ployees to ae tested).
To develop & institute a system for em-
ployees to request an investigation of
worksite problem.
250
i
C`�=� ���-'�'�.
PREVENTIVE HEALTH SERVICES
1988 1989
On oin Prb ram Ob'ectives On oin Pro ram Indicators Estimated Promised
upervise ! oomin Boar in upervise ooming oar ing
o inspect 00 of licensed supervised Licensed SBR homes 35 35
Rooming & Boarding Homes (SRB) twice Residents 360 360
a year. Inspections 70 70
To abate 9�% of orders issued within Orders abated (%) in 3 months 95% 95%
3 months. ' Seminars offered 2 2
To provide consultation for all SRB Persons attending 36 40
home operators. Consultations with SRB home
operators 45 45
Day Care Centers Day Care Centers
o assure hat 00% of day care cen- Licensed day care centers 108 108
ters are l�censed. Children enrolled 5200 5,200
To inspect �100% of day care centers Inspections 210 210
twice a year (3-4 times for those Orders abated {%) in 6 months
day care centers with infants in Educational seminars offered 3 3
diapers). Day care providers attending 45 45
To have 95� of orders abated within Consultation with day care
6 months. providers 130 130
To provide consultation for 100% of
day care pr,oviders regarding special Corronents
problems. ls�o see Joint City/County Programs
• 1988-1989 Ph^oject Ob 'ectives (by
priorit
uperv�sed Roomin & Boardin
o provide ;two educational seminars for
Supervised Rooming & Boarding Home op-
erators and staff.
To computertize Rooming & Boarding Home
inspection process.
Da Care Centers
To provide hree educational seminars
for day care providers.
To computerize day care center licen-
ing & inspe�tion process.
To work witb joint City/County public
health day �are committee, metro day
care nurse Consultants & Human Services
Council on child care.
� 251 '
ii ,/(�/%.
' ' '_'"i /� L��
�l-- �- i--
ISOLATED ADULT HEALTH PROGRAM
The Isol'ated Adult Program offers Emergency Care and Crisis Intervention to
persons living in isolation, condemned housing and/or refusing needed medical care.
It is a model program coordinating services of a Public Health Nurse, Adult
Protect ion, Pol i ce, Fire, Housi ng Code, Animal Control and Sai nt Paul Ramsey
Social S�rvices.
PREVENTIVE HEALTH SERVICES
1988 1989
Ongoing Program Objectives Ongoing Program Indicators Estimated Promised
Isolated `Adults Isolated Adults
�o respor�d t�00� of requests for Timely responses to requests 100% 100�
health assessment of isolated adults Persons served 100 100
within 24 hours, if necessary. Persons receiving assistance(%) 100% 100%
To assess, the health status of 100 (hospitals, nursing homes,
persons i�n potential crisis situ- Adult Protection, In-home
ations. Program, Catholic Charities
' MD, Housing Code)
1988-89 �roject Objectives (by Isolated Adults Team Meetings 12 12
riority) Isolated Adults
o etermine after 30 days that 100% Comments
of isolat�ed adults were contacted/ Requests for health assessment of isolated adults
received assistance form the referral came from H&HBCE, Adult Protection, Police, Para-
service. ' medics, & individuals - i .e., landlords, neighbors,
• To faci 1 i tate Isol ated Adul ts Cri si s rel at ives. A cri si s intervention team of profes-
Interventpon Team meetings. sionals evaluate responses to crisis situation and
facilitate timely care acceptable to the client and
or compliance with guidelines of Minnesota Commit-
ment Act.
252
i
i
�--�--�- j�',���
Program/�Goal Area Method Page
ENVIRONM�NTAL HEALTH
Food Reg�lation Investigation 222
Inspection 222
' Abatement 222
Environm�ntal Sanitation Investigation 224
Inspection 224
Abatement 224
Housing Code Enforcement Investigation 226
' Survey and Correction 226
Animal/Pest Control Investigation 228
' Equipment Loan 228
Abatement 228
Rodent Census 228
FAMILY H�ALTH
✓ Dental Heal th ;�-�--� Assessment 232
Referral 232
Monitoring 232
Family P�anning Education 234
Medical Service 234
, Counseling 234
. WIC ' Screening 235
Assessment 235
Intervention 235
Counseling 235
� Childhood Lead Screening /� '�~ � Testing 236
Education 236
, Monitoring 236
Follow-up 236
' Referral 236
HEALTH PRpMOTION
� Health Services for the Elderly Assessment 239
Screening 239
Education 239
' Follow-up
�Community, Health Education Education Programs 240
Technical Assistance 240
Employee Niealth/Firefighters Fitness Testing 241
Training 241
' Clinical Services 241
254
; _ �����'.�
� C,�- � I
Program/G'oal Area Method Page
DISEASE P�tEYENTION AND CONTROL
�- AI DS Scre�eni ng '�y�-�-� �) Screen i ng 245
° Counseling 245
' Referral 245
, Community Education 245
Training 245
STD Control �-� \ Screening 246
' ` Treatment 246
, Community Education 246
� Irranunizat�on Program -✓f��`�- �- ' Dispense Vaccine 247
Immunize 247
_ Tuberculo5is �'�-°Y° ' ' Case Finding & Follow-up 248
Treatment 248
Refugee z- � Screening 249
Referral 249
Occupatiorhal Safety and Health �=� Investigation 250
, Screening 250
Technical Assistance 250
Training and Education 250
Preventiv� Health Services: Supervised �,��° Insepction 251
Rooming/Boarding and Day Care Abatement 251
-- --- Consultation 251
Education and Training 251
� Isolated Adults Assessment 252
Follow-up 252
�
255
_________�______________________ AGENDA ITEMS - ------------------------
ID�: [295 ] DATE REC: [09/29/87] AGENDA DATE: [00/00/00] ITEM �: [ ]
SUBJECT: [�OMMUNITY HEALTH SERVICES PLAN - BIENNIAL REPORT TO STATE ]
STAFF ASSIGNED: [ �� __S �� �0 7 SIG:[ ] OUT-[ ) TO CLERK [00/00/00�
ORIGINATORt[COMMUNITY SERVICES ] CONTACT:[JUDY BARR (292-7712) ]
ACTION:[ ]
C 7
C.F.� [ ] ORD.� [ ] FILE COMPLETE="X" [ ]
� s � +� � � � � a � � ■ �
FILE INFO: ',[RESOLUTION/REPORT FOR 1988-89 ]
[ 7
[ ]
_____________________________________________________�R� '_____-_______
4eT 5 1981
JAA4 S S�IH�AN
1eEL
� �. C��/�� , �' ` ^� °�'
�J L�� ������ �f� .
`G��t��� .
� A r� '�
�-ca��"�L— `'L2�/�i�-��Z.-�._��
� �� � � �
�
� ��
�--�, . � U �"
� �
. ��
� r��
f