87-983 WH17E - GTV CLERK -
PINK - FINANCE G I TY O F SA I NT PA U L Council q
CANARV - DEPARTMENT 9�(/���2)
BLUE - MAVOR File NO. ` r y �+
Co ncil solution -
. - � �� �
r �`
Presented By
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
WHEREAS, the Commissioner of the Departmsnt ot Transportation has
prepared a Stipulation Agreement among the City of Saint Paul �'Cit�'�, Remsey
County �'County') and the Commissioner of the Minnesota Department of
Trensportation t'Commissioner�), regarding the replacement af existing Bridge
No. 90402 and appraaches for o pro ject on Remsey County State Aid Highwey
tC.S.A.H.� 46 tRa�mond Ave.} from Raymond Piace to proposed Energy Park Dhve,
and
WHEREAS, representatives of the City, the County and the Commissioner
have met and agreed thet if the Cit� complies with certein condltions with
respect to the project that a variance may be grantsd and Bridge No. 90402 ond
its approaches mey be reploced with a new structur�e with a deck wid#h of 44
f eet betwsen curbs ond 8 f est si dewal ks on both si des, and
WHEREAS, the Cit� agrees to ind�mnify, save and hold harmless the
County of Remse�, the State of Minnesota, its Commissioner of Transportation
and ali their agents and employees of and trom any and all claims, demands,
actions or causes ot action of whatsoever nature or charocte�istic arising out
ot or by reason ot the replacement of Bridge No. 90402 in an� oiher manner than
with a structure 52 teet wide (measured curb to curb? in accordance with
Minnesote Rule Sec. 8820.9912, or nrising as a result of the Commissione�s
decision to gront this varience for the pro ject, new 8ridge No. 62546 and its
epproeches on C.S.A.H. 46, Now then be i t
RESOLYED, that seid Stipulation Agreement of said County State Aid
Highwoy {C.S.A.H.) 46 withln the corparate limits be and hereby is approved.
COUNCILMEIV Requested by Department of:
Yeas p� Nays
Masen2 � In Favor Puhl i r Works AW/mp ����7
W+cos�a J�,�J� ���,' �
Scheibel � � ��"�c���txJ �� �
Sonnen - -- Against BY —
���E`�� Donald E. Nygaard, Direct r
WFtsor, JuL _ 7 '�8'l Form Approve b City Attorney
Adopted by Council: Date
Certified Ya s d � ouncil Sec tary BY
fl
By, a�
t�pproved by Mavor: D te � — � a� `�� JUL j t� lAppro by ayor for Submissi n o ounci�
By _ —��,•�`c�..�
Q�.�s� �uL �. a �9s7
?i�l� 1�'I�fb��rll�ltfG � Y ?�� ti�'��"�IL''t�"+.! Jf F ii� -t.�!'4:;!t='�{l'2i'i:�_ "�1�� .��"+'13t:'��"�'fi`.
'l��Illa! ,l ;.31f�c":� ���fi'� '�?'�s� 1•" f F��3 � ,_ r;ft,i(t�l� j'"19:17y•�'��'i 1�!�t�1L,° r;jil,r_: � 1'��^I�l�cetin
�i� f�4�ryt-���t�a+.� ^'Ct���1!T'�'� •3�sr ;� �'��,:�t:?fi�l!"��.�3 �+i�i �?ffE i� z't�;`JiJ�� ,j l,f�ii�,:j�,
9�t��'� G�ff'1:�:�9 T�. :'3i`.�9:it�t���" ���i� �'1i�±��C:-,� .1 �yt'!��(G�f�,�n•�,s� �.; �;�3�t8#'��?:��fl��T
�J�sr•11�iH [1:`� �tn}:' !.ltn�+�:� �l4�mfi'� tl�? t;,•;}c<'!q � 'I�Ci+ ;-w,�i,,BQ't►���E, ht�E: �r;i�.i_r�. �±yrt
:i'.l�L' .��E►�'� �1!��!ilf� V!�_.lt�ll�y i7 !�7��� i�€�t�ii�(�F:.��, j;'f[ Ci � `{�LE �ll��'.��R3�3�"�� t. ��, i'�.�i +'. .���
'1i:Li
"69n .f?.- ;:��!`f1U.! ��!s �nr :+;s��ri� 91�? ,�±�r� on r i,� _�,�t i3G�t�!?�'�+'1t�°� 'k�°�.�;��,
:llr��: .�i•��lr}��'�it��^t '�{!_j#`/C:"� .'�lr�, _f.i�l ftft�.,7 ` ���`� ��� !� I�t1f ft�]t:�'1ir,'.�i EJ{1�.' ���t.:�j !{{�J't!i
3
f-
:sil� _.���s iL' r"�l 9(1l�:-i;� !'•�7�3 �1�+;:�3;�; 9� t i; ' 71�`:� �',� L� �. f� � (i1�t�� 9��1 �:; ��►�,., y�
c' _s r:� g_ : +� i i 4 �,�.
V
}.��• ?�) -;�>:; �� �4:;��� �� ('.f�l�' 9'!>�j�t��f� �+��g,y 3 ti�•'1"� t?�JB't�9� 4d �,��f{. rwit'�9C�1��R ;_t'r
b�'�r .?9���- ±�t0�f n�� :_�l�R;�;,yr,r;� t��,i b br�� ?�!~tt.: �19y�19±.� t99t
!4!�� •=t:yl��i� �f01'� �1�� ��#`JG .t�1�ni'�9�i�� +�� ;�`��Fr�: �ii� 4�1; �-?i�i��Nf��
310{=[i�'1+'�:;:�:18-,i fiC; '3Lis:_�f�;t.(fl"+.�11Q.: ^r. .�j;��Si't�!�r,, t�:r �;�ii' ':�;' t�'9c11!�'� '�t ���i![t,-._�
������'�w`�Z� ..�t'CIiSI�- <<�� ;it1Ci IS;':� fYrt�'�� i�(1�� I+� � =a�,i0f?a�Y� �`itE• :!ti9��G -ii��1? i3G �.".r_,
.''1 l;it•_�_,C,� '�r.TCrry•�t'`I�i�.�'~1 '�f� :��IL:}Csl�} �1!��;'`�ii�:j�tt'�w�' �r; �^1rr!_!r_ T(1 ;'=>>�,2�'� �!l :?;�f��'"'{�
f�'�.lt "!3!�f�r�:i� -t .�!�- �_ty`. ,�r r,:�4ia ��w y�t.�i-?;� i`."� ts'l�t�aa;��c(���,-� y►'�f T�) +,°t►�?ti't �!ei ��� �;��t
�'!'[ �?:i���C�'t!]�JB i+i ;''1Lt.� �# ti11Jn ;'t�ll;?ny(p� g�,"� '��,3 _ _ .����t—.. f_ -; �rt=;.,;
� �'�;�1t:?2t+11^1il a,'�t ��? t���Q'4 ci �=-� �ftt_f'�� -�s, `. 1p�� �_+`;: �' .;- �� _� t . �?�'�r=:M
.�t : ' ��_ ��;r ► Q •:.ry. s . r;-: -1.. y`! r,,- F i t; :# r7fs ;� � r
(I"'��� s.�?�•i? i'� q�l�' �47 . . `-� !� �1'�i �1i l . :`-.�+ ?��. .�J i=' �.. .. ' . _.`�1
i� �d R��i t ,�,,��n ,=,A .k '..: ;;�~ _ _�i:tc�e?�.�Qc
� �rt :�'�tl."� ���1.°�14t f ��i.�_ . JIS� ��`.� }���. tjf�f.��/1����� ��, �tj�'. T�If� �JJ,�L�.��Jl.j.�
.L`.?:..,,-;,�a� �� �����`:;c �i=l� '�� ,JE,�?�; yi��-�l;��':c�1 �,Ei `:=f- ct '^it�: Y ''� �.� �.�� ��`" .:.,.��'!
p,.i�W�rks = Bridge - DE PARTMENT �����3 NO� 12 6 7
Arrhur Werthauser � CONTACT •
298-6320 PHONE
June 16, 1987 DATE �Q/�� e e
ASSIGN NUMBER FOR ROUTING ORUER (Clip All Locations for Signature) :
or 3 Mayor
�4 Finance and Management Services Director � City Clerk
Budget Director 6 c�ty Council
� City Attorney
WHAT WILL BE ACHIEVED BY TAKING ACTION ON THE ATTACHED MATERIALS? (Purpose/
Rationale) :
The approval of the Resolution and attached -Stipulation Agreement will allow the City to proceed
with the contract letting and construction of a new Raymond Avenue Bridge over Burlington
Northern and Minnesota Transfer tracks. The Public Works Department, Planning District 4�12
and Neighborhood support the pro�ect as per the Stipulation Agreement. The Resolution
authorizes the proper City officials to execute the Stipulation Agreement.
COST/BENEFIT, BUDGETARY AND PERSONNEL IMPACTS ANTICIPATED:
There are no cost/benefit,budgetary or personnel impact as a result of said Resolution.
� R�'�,Yi'JtD
�
����) �ll�! ? � 1987
�"; , .. � '��k"��t�E � .�.
Y;i'' y_'
FINANCING SOURCE AND BUDGET ACTIVITY NUMBER CHARGED OR CREDITED: (Mayor's signa-
ture not re-
Total Amount of Transaction: None quired if under
$10,000)
Funding Source:
Activity Number:
ATTACHMENTS (List and Number All Attachments) :
1. Stipulation Agreement to be executed after resolution is passed. R EC EIV ED
JUN 17 19$7
Cl�Y A�TTO�N�Y
DEPARTMENT REVIEW CITY ATTORNEY REVIEW
�Yes No Council Resolution Required? Resolution Required? X Yes No
Yes �No Insurance Required? Insurance Sufficient? Yes No
Yes x No Insurance Attached:
(SEE REUERSE SIDE FOR INSTRUCTIONS)
Revised 12/84
. �
.. .. � . , ���-�'�
STATE OF MINNESOTA
DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
In the Matter of the Resolution
of the City of Saint Paul requesting
a variance from Department of
Transportation Technical Services STIPULATION
Division State Aid Operation AGREEMENT
Minnesota Rules Chapter 8820.9912
for Ramsey County State Aid
eighway 46 (Raymond Avenue)
between Raymond Place and proposed
Energy Park Drive; which street
does not meet minimum design
street widths.
This Stipulation Agreement is made by and among the City
of Saint Paul ("City" ) , Ramsey County ("County" ) and the
Commissioner of the Minnesota Department of Transportation
( "Commissioner" ) .
WAEREAS, the City applied for and was denied a variance
from Minnesota Rule � 8820.9912, minimum design street width
standard, for a project on Ramsey County State Aid Highway
(C.S.A.H. ) 46 from Raymond Place to proposed Energy Park Drive. The
proposed project is Bridge No. 62546 and its approaches over the
Burlington Northern Railroad Company tracks; and
WHEREAS, the City has requested a contested case hearing
to appeal the Commissioner 's refusal to grant the variance; and
WHEREAS, representatives of the City, the County and the
Commissioner have met and agreed that if the City complies with
certain conditions with respect to the project that a variance may
be granted and Bridge No. 90402 and its approaches may be replaced
���'
_ . " . ��-�'�-�
with a new structure with a deck width of 44 feet between curbs and
8 feet sidewalks on both sides.
NOW, THEREFORE, IT IS AGREED BY AND AMONG THE PARTIES AS
FOLLOWS:
1. Bridge No. 90402 and its approaches will be replaced
with a new structure and approaches (Bridge No. 62546) , and that the
deck width shall be 44 feet measured curb to curb and that 8-foot
sidewalks across the bridge on each side will be included in the
structure and approaches.
2. The City agrees to indemnif y, save and hold harmless
the County of Ramsey, the State of Minnesota, its Commissioner of
Transportation and all their agents and employees of and from any
and all claims, demands, actions or causes of action of whatsoever
nature or characteristic arising out of or by reason of the
replacement of Bridge No. 90402 in any other manner than with a
structure 52 feet wide (measured curb to curb) in accordance with
Minnesota Rule � 8820.9912, or arising as a result of the
Commissioner 's decision to grant this variance for the project,
Bridge No. 62546 and its approaches on C.S.A.H. 46.
3. The Commissioner hereby grants the variance of
44-foot curb to curb street width for Bridge No. 61546 and its
approaches on C.S.A.H. 46 as requested by the City of St. Paul and
as conditionally concurred in by the County in its
resolution 87-154, dated March 9, 1987.
-2-
(/�
_ , � � . ��,����
4. The parties hereby agree to the dismissal of the
contested case appeal of the variance denial upon egecution of this
Stipulation Agreement.
MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF CITY OF SAINT' PAUL
1'RANSPORTATION
r
LEONARD R. LEVINE Mayor
Commissioner of Transportation
Dated:
Director, Department of Finance
and Management Services
Director, Department of Public
Works
APPROVED:
By.
Assistant City Attorney
COUN'I'Y OF RAMSEY
Chairperson, County Board
Dated•
Chief Clerk, County BoarG
Dated:
APPROVED:
By:
Assistant County Attorney
- 3 -