87-947 WH17E - C�TV CLERK
PINK - FINANCE G I TY OF SA I NT PA U L Council
CANARY - DEPARTMENT
BLUE - MAVOR File � NO• �� �� - -
�
Council Resolution
Presented By
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By ' Date
RESOLVED, that the Council of the City of Saint Paul does
hereby grant the application for variance from the City' s sound
level restrictions for the Taste of Minnesota live outdoor
music and Fourth of July fireworks to be conducted on the State
Capitol Grounds during the hours of 11 :00 A.M. to 11 :P.M. on
July 2 through July 5, 1987 , and the City Clerk shall transmit
a copy of this resolution to the applicant and to the Environ-
mental Health Section, Community Services Department.
COUNCILMEN Requested by Department of:
Yeas �,�W Nays
�'�"�`r" ��l��i� � [n Favor
NiCGa�;.. �
sc�;���,�: Against BY
5o�+ne�
7edesc��
�' JUN � p 1987 Form Approve by City Attor y
Adopted by Council: Date
Certified Pass d y 1 Secr BY
B. ,�-�-
s 'f
Approv y Mavor: Date �uL —2 �1 Approve b Mayor for Submission to Council
B BY
P��� J U L 1 1 t987
� , ., . �'�_��- ��
City oi Saint Pauf Oftic Use Only
Department of Community Servlces
Division of Public Health Date Rec'd d a Reviewed
Envlronmental Health Sectlon Date Public Notice Referred to
555 Cedar Street, Saint Paul, MN 55101 Sent S�'�� ' F � Council
292"���� Requires Noise Impact Statement �
app0�����o� �op M�aP��a�c�Q
Sound Level Restrictions
City of Saint Paul Noise Ordin3nce
Chapter 293 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code
1 . Organization or Person Seeking Variance Taste of Minnesota
2. AddfQSS st . Paul Down �wn Co �ncil. 600 North Central Life Tower,
_ 445 Minnesota St. , St. Paul, MN 55101
3. Responsible Person Ronnie Brooks
- ' 4. POSItlOt1 _ Director, Saint Paul Downtown Council
5. Telephone �9�-�R9�
6. Briefly Describe the Noise Source and Equipment Involved
, Live_outdoor music, July 2 , 3, 4 , & 5, 1987
Fourth of Julv Fireworks July 4 , 1987
7. Address or Legal Description of Noise Source state capitol Grounds, saint
PauJ-
8. Noise Source Time of Operation > > A_M_ ro � � p.M. . � ,�� 2 - 5 i9s�
9. Briefly Describe the Steps taken to Minimize Noise Level from Source.
There have been no complaints about noise. Taste of Minnesota offers
mainstream family entertainment . Stage sound speakers are directed
to minimize sound spillover from the site.
10. Briefly State Reasons for Seeking Variance Taste of Minnesota is a traditional
IndeAendence weekend festival that because it runs lonqer than one day,
is not exem�ted under the new Saint Paul Noise Ordinance.
11 . Dates during which the Varianc� s R ue di u? 2 - s, i9s�
/
Slgnature of Responslble Person � Date nna�r �i � i qg�
Return Completed Appllcatlon and ;150.00 fee to:
Environmental Health Section, 555 Cedar Street, Saint Paul, MN 55101
Make Checks Payable to the "City of Saint Paul" N-1 5/87
-._ '. ' // �
�c ��-9�7
�.t
� "�"�°�'�� CITY OF SAINT PAUL
?.t� •�"::.
= DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY SERVICES
:� �
�,; ���{��{ :=
' � "- DIVISION OF PUBUC HEALTH
- 555 Cedar Street, Saint Paul, Minnesota 55101
George Latimer (612)292-7741
Mayor
NOr!'ICE OF PUBLIC HF.ARING
May 22, 1987
Purity Bakeries Corp.
10 S. Riverside Plaza
chicago, IL 60606
Dear St. Paul Property Owner:
This is to inform you of an application to request a variance frcYn the
noise source limitations as indicated in the St. Paul Noise Ordinance.
(Chapter 293 of the St. Paul Legislative Code) .
A public hearing before the City Council on this variance request will be
held on:
Date: June 9, 1987
Time: 10:00 A.M.
Location: Third Floor City Hall Council CharT�ers
Written co��ents or objections may be filed with the:
Department of Co�munity Services
Division of Public Health
Environmental Health Section
555 Cedar Street
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55101
within fifteen (15) days of the mailinq date on this notice.
Description of Variance:
Taste of Minnesota, State Capital Grounds
July 2-5, 1987
Live outdoor misic - 11:00 A.M. - 11:00 P.M.
Firewerks - July 4, 1987 (Dusk)
c: Councilperson Scheibel
Councilperson Wilson
District Planning Council)s>
Tho�s-D�le District 7 Planning Council
Midway Civic and Co�rierce Association
Dowrltown Co�munity Development Council
,
. � ���-y`�7
'� � �;�«••�•, CITY OF SAINT PAUL
�! ����;i���1 ':6 � DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY SERVICES
., ��
`�' � DIVISION OF PUBLIC HEALTH
�,
'� S55 Cedar Street,Saint P�ul,Minnesota 55101
George Latimer (672)292•774t
Mayor
June 1, 1987 � _
�
Ronnie Brooks r;
St. Paul Downtown Council � `''
600 North Central Life Tower
445 Minnesota Street ---°
St. Paul, Minnesota 55101 ' � - °
Dear Mr. Brooks:
Your application for variance from the noise source limitations
as indicated in the St. Paul Noise Ordinance (Chapter 293 of
the St. Paul Legislative Code) has been received and is being
processed.
A public hearing before the City Council will be held on
June 9, 1987 at 10:00 a.m. , third floor City Hall Council
Chambers.
After the public hearing the Council may by resolution
grant, deny, modify or revoke the variance request.
If you have any questions, feel free to call me at 292-7705
or Frank Staffenson at 292-7716.
Yours ly,
Peter T. Kishel
Occupational Safety-Health Analyst
k�,, r� . ' � , ,�
���� �. � ��� . ... ;
a i A �. � ; �:ti t 4 �i ` : � �� - ��.�
�. .,. . ��_rt
� r 7 - J � ��'+ � ', i �
'�e s h �� j ' � z � � :: � _ r f- 'd /q� ) �n
; � ., r �a '. ���i..,�y� w',
� 4 �.� tt k , 4 .
4 n '. �'i i i �� -
�l I -� Y 1 �. � �J A ,
( ,�� . . t� 3 .F .
� 1#4� s �, a y'� z_ � � x «� ,
l �:����F��� t � B s' � r �a°� - � t � `�a
k '¢_, � ... - J� . . r �"
� ,� , } c ��l� f � .
�� � �' � �� �
n: " ' �:E F � �' y !' ry
�a ' , �,��t{C �'r'�" .i- Y , - t a �bl a �.r � < � •�'< ' Y�
� t,.x� J�. �, i, ." Yy"^iy��.: � �� r � s � e y� +' �'` 4`' `..
,� 1 7: ' � `�7 w; �r.•,�a �. � .' .. . k e �=r : t+T,
k �; >S .� S^K�; i a. . �. c . E � . k : r .; � v ,, r,y �; � `i � ��
� " ' � �' t
� t � � , d'� a +� �n � ' � �� 7 tr�� 1 � G � . ; y- . ? �.
� ' � '' � p l� �. � ; � . i � S y ..t � j � a r _
5.'. f� r% 'h t �., +f +4 1 . ) 4 y r :^� �' � � '
�, x � '� ,\ �' r �f � : i < � �� � �} � - y � ._ . } .
5 1 �'� 7. 1 C ?kY .� �: d , . _ • : n f�� ) - � .� ,�ei:.
�n�� ` r, v �y� �, � �y � v�'{f�r�� .z 1 ` _�t.! F ' � � � Y'� $ : �' t '�� � � x � '£ � no�� V�`X�' • q ;'""�
.� ; '� � '` �a"� � �l f � '' i �,t � �: � � � K, � � � ; � � c �,,�n +� �
�'F '��'�i��' +P �. F�c.s°� �` A �' �F�� � �`� 7 ' _ 7.2� .`� z, � r' � L .` � .t �
F �- i �:1 z� � ! p{ *..� ,L°{,� �a � . ..}� ,, t �* ,, z'i� '�y � w . v � a -i `� � � ��� ��
X � -G ,.� L(. 9 J`4 t �LY' k J�. !, } � 'i �-1 4 "�.
1�. �" i f"h`�'o:h � �A`4 4{ �" z t!-.1 � a S .� � Y� e�- ��� i � . �
� t�i k, ,'�� ��'�,� y y� � �, �„7 + F a � ! A° x�s.t �r �,` � � 1 '� _ x �
�� a . �1��e 1 �� �c te it.� - �. y - !` 41 �i p el. � �l 6 + � - � ;# � �;:
i' � � ,�,t l�� �,j�r; !' �� °�t � , � f > -
� .{ ; x,h; �a �! �, 4 ; r ,� ,� �. � .' ��., �J�. ,a �' � { �t ,' 7 , � K
�
� i... v l��y�; l�t�.:�'iC"r y��'�.. � ��� x ,� i�+� ._� � y� r� tt�, i �� �,t t �k �f ��" l �, �, � `s �:
�.'C <,Y � 1� 1 . �.� ry 'k
,'�' � �f`�� � i 1� a :� >>�'� t r � �' t ! �'' �� m �'�'
¢ �' � ' # �� �rv ii t.. . i �
F. i ,3 p���� S � � Y.- �'� �. i yt+F�, � �� � �. �� : '� r� � �: b Fe z� '��-f � , � �.
e rt " '� r '� i , � F z - � "� r � ,�.,� t -.� � ,, i', Y,�,
r ✓� w t�� � s � � h�lk a ��" i 1 �. � � r' 1 "i y� { �S k .y s., � ��� izJ ; k ' i i� `� N .k �.`t
� ' h y '" � I � i� ��. . . I � . -p ^M �' 4 ,S, : . �1 ��
�'�� ����fi� � � �t �' `�:;� � ��� 4 � ,T r �'i (.. f! }� 1 f 4 �}f � ;' '4, �' }�� a� ° `�,.✓ F4 b, �rYtW
1 k � �; �E t ° t, ��. � �, �LV ' Y� �l r�r � '1 _- '�� .�� � y°n
} �. ..& .1 dr. a. �"� � f t ti� ,;f � 7'• i r�� � � � . +,. s � � v . �i�s � � � � h '�s a�„�b .. �.�'��,p�
�r � . ,c �:r a � � � �.� i � s r � ' y '��° �� ��a'' rp�. s,� x � �z� 3F , � ���s + q �?`
� ,� ��� �i -, r ; � � .-\� r , �� � .,R `iy,� � 'w I 1 d � �§ i9.a . x� S�: � � t ';�� �4
r `-4�i � ' r rf �`� � :a ° r rl� 'i r a � '' � Ft ,� y
,� ft � � � �� . a �i �+ �, � R ;Y+4
4 � � � f � �? r $��- i ,.' � �� �! ;�, ht i yy :, 1}� • 1 �'�,.�^ ���a"° + � � r �. � - �$,�2r�
1' " �iS� ,K �:, �f�� �M����"''"'`y'��'�� .���M��R����,� . ."�,{ , ',r ,� -� ,. y�f .� d f � !��
> tifr� t K.� .� y yyu t ' � � �� ` � - �4b� � � 3 ���
� t Y{ �� $ . {a ��17FL1�� t '�� ;�d ��xt,,.:: z .�N v + ` a ;;a �� -j f� ��.. � .' yF r i'�!.
Yr _ �,���_. y� ` ''rr�4 _ a �'��;��R. ., ., �+'�3r �-.� � e �,n h �..� f al S� ' �fy�;
it; ; � � ` �,. .sJ^ ���+<.Y x� 'w, pt�t! '.. � � Ft s � :'1,
, � ,�" g, 3 �"l 1
� , �-1. {, � f-.� y. a', C�� � ) . r '�'1�� �'.�. � �, ;��` .4j a �a � �-� � � t � , a�`
�,� t ���}$ a�y�Y•� ,t�y...��.�'����r;� i::�� � J � I , y � ;PA {� �`.zEa+�t} rr1�� s.� � �,�!'�u�'h ���� 1if " :� x 4 , a
.` '� �u a ^- � }'Y w '�- k t c �F.
E � S� �K� �� '.4, f ,� .���.% �w 4 i �, '.M t r. r� k J,. �b'w f '4'��• i '��RS �{'� � i� t,,ri�� � y� } .s� t�Y -�:",,�3� y Y��: � �
� �� i t I� ,.l ..,r x '� � �' t P x l . i fw:t ..3t �. ' : : � f . ,�r
� �I R ii, t 5.3 ��� -._ � � * o � . !f�r �.�f "�r( tb�� ��- } tt� .; i� 2+y. �1%� !� � �
R � 7. �� � � � � �'i ,5 J '} -t a � r q ��.� p �'�rd i 1� � � � r, � � ��� 'ir ��, �rd
� " T : x � t:� ; � r' ,� c�� �'£�7 {k �. �� '.. ,��'�€�� r �. . "���n
t t�.� , � t r .•' T .r 7 �� @ 1�- 4' � �' "` „ ` ;�
,' � �
F�r.•. rf �. l`' � <�� �.� x�� �, i �� 1 N �'�� � � 4 t-s� r ��' �'� ��`�f�� . A 'Fp�r��(x° i � �y.��s"`x r; a
k ' k1's, St'. _ �,:1 �t.l � � ,l- .:4 Y , 1 �..R t �?y � ,
., B , t�. a .�;� � � �, ��� ' ��� j.�4 e� Z r.� �S..� R � �:r'� !"�-, ,� ,4�,Y r
� .: � ��� �` �����
., �J a, � k , f �f � ��� �+� � �+ H �r � ���'�
7�'.. S �)..T i� � Y' i/ �', '4• '� � 1 'Il� ' � X _ .3
ll�����.! v ) .! �i "� z+ y x t ��F
#t j ' � i, r � ' �r ' � s tf.� 4� '�'�� .!� � �r� � � ,� � '��
�� � � s ����� �� � ? r i��*D�-�:s1i`_ 4 : s � 3 t x � �'f , ✓ x � �,��N�'�
f ` 1 S � �. � b r -�� �e 'a i s t �i C ' t _s �
�: �'.x �.� �, �'� t fi �'' i. � s ' �tr n : �Y . i 5 � t �;� .
¢ g a� � �a ,, � r . , �; < {+ �
1 q F
� - a�"��l� ��.,i������� i d�� t r'�`�,r�. h �' - ,�t� af v `'i � �� � fd ��..���,1 ^ .
� ' y,f ,. ✓' � y r v f t y�, F �� r i> �'(s ��iisk 'k�! 'f � . e 6 F t,, i r � P �
� r�( �•t : r ; { � �;� �.�t,Ri 4 � fi ..� S 4�. .,� � ��' � �� ` f �� ��� �P��-�, !�'�"
r...` „K {:��� i . } fi ' � � i� k ai� b P � :,ez 'TV pY �.� � y .� ��' .�' � �r j i '� ,41.�
i � � �i s �f � �ti �z ?n �t ;, F t �,. � � � vx ���t f�N y ta�' � 1^' � .� } �= � " �� �t�
,� � � i Tt F- 1 t ' t� f i f i a r T'xp �' t�� fi .. '
.< `L� t i � + c c - 5 'rx J r 't S - � 1 ir t
� - } �!F 1 t .:� � �� � ,r �f � k f�.`} � �.t r 2 i y f�r<C� �4 ...r� � �r� x � � i .� � � .�°? �q �`*'L �q�,i
tb,: 4E �, ; t t �S - ti tx �r �e e p � < G � b
�r r �''� r�� ��� ..�, tc� �,! � ��� :��. , . J.ti,�k�. ':'•� � �` � � �� ri3..;"`� ���� �� ���� i f.��X � 5.;� � i�w,��� �� �
1 h ,� l�" �; � P� � � �� �• .'i �;
y. -��t. �� �� x i g,1 �. , 1 � �- .,�. �,rn,i �?r'� 1 r � P'� s ti � '�
� r ` �^. t� r � � r . � :� .+, {f :. s .� � M1 y v N '�!� � t 4� : ♦ f�:.� '� � 2 � '� � � �'}�
# � .. 7 � 6, R �f 1 b.. �I : t {� a? 4 , +',, r r � a . I �r1° ` k! -i 7.✓t�j�
f rrc�� �,.. . � �� � � � ' ' �y r J a f��1' ���-., �' �-�5$+ti � /"� ,�� a r.'.� �'� ,; 1 ��. e �� ,
k.s� �A Sf ��, '( x ,�'g� � , ,r,� �' ; � n r 5 .� �' � 4 s s � `, s '�t , w t r r' ..
Y� ��.�� d � �`,a� � : i ��:`� �!� { ��� �� �'��" r �� �,�r °� � T� '� �� . 3��� �� �� ' �ti � � ;���1 ��`�' �r
Jt' /' l � .., T.� . N i* 4 . 4 � � zr ., t 0.
r � � ,�� .J �, � �-t � ^ � � r��� , i r � t�?h� F,�� '�. � � .r t�:
�� � �'F- tt�;. �1�t �. r� "1 r �� " d � �-4 j t I ,•M i �l:, ` t x , .„ �.k�l yi y- �i g{ �y 1+"'�� � �.'tr�",
�', t �r� j u 2'k�tr 't [ �� i t y� 3 +t ' ,7 a �• , i`� ; '�` �;.1 + .i i� �� ��t€
y i.YZ � '�" !` . a E�;a� � yr o't , 1'� +e'- .. a 6 a ;. ; t X a ,+
a}. „:1.'r eb' t �- t a, 4 r ; � E '- J A! �i x 4 � ,�,j � 1,f . - 4" . �,r r �"
�q � �` v� ;' y`r k.. r y. #: j �_ � ;} ��� _, �. ` ._ k;� r � ��ir f ; 4��h � } i� �k ' �j >3 � ��A
� T � �� . ,�,� ' . ;!� � �i; 7 ,.� t_.. f:� :;4 1 -., t � �•±'" iw ��` ^ .s ��S� �r;�' '��p '����� i r ^�' ��
! t;` a „��1� R ea;, r. � Ka <� r �� �`f y.,,w i� �` -'- ���R{ ., � � t 4 � � q� �,,:
;t . �y.�c ��. ..�.� 1' 3:' f (n ,y . . � . ,�� ` t,+ � , } 1�. -� �({�SS,�
y� '�'�t tt�FF�R 7y t 1�.�.*�� # ` �.� .� . '�;�'R�id�t k r �CR. �,,� ._ ,� i � «' "�;` 47. �i:-`1 y{� ��;:�'i'�a,3�'
.�'� � a r � �` : �t..� i �,�'a-� � t ��'* r : aQt r -t{ c r��. rl� J �.�. 4 -��*r- r l., ���i�kl:,
r �r. 1���, �r� h� � �rh �"Y� '� p�=� ;;� � i �I ` 1 �,A:: � � � � f �G_.� �v �.�, � ` � d
� � r � ' �� � � � k r y,f��y� � �� . .}� 1� � ,�` i � � i j � ` � � �,�r?�� 1�!t s ...�t r� �� ,�t :� �}��
y r" + f��
��+.F rP � �� Jt � )��J;� ♦� ' � � �# �� y 4 ���r��,aY� � �� �; � �a� �� � �A � ,� � t $
" � 'ti °d'' � � � � F �" �� 4 ' .� � � n •�5 � �. � 1� A
}s i r� 9 � ;1 ` I 1 , tl ' ..a ��'� � i.� y � � ,F 4 ` , ? w, � : 3 s ��'��
�er � �x'' � sh ,� r i � � �r�,� ; ' ' `� � ' �' � ` ��y� a�. �� ai � ��
r.x� ��i r <�.� r ��a � i.c r:� ���'� s i � 1� �� A e 1� � � x x .j, ,�
� v �,c� y" e � 1 �°�
! -
�� s��� �,�� � ., 1� - � � •� t-b t � � � t 3 f � t �`r 3 � �x, � ',� ! �r ¢�1 .�' �+�,t �..�� .
� � �h 'S � � �� 'r ' e .�i,�^.- 1 s '�.i 1 �" � �,�{� ��'' .! ..�y '� ` �t��x �����
s v� � ./ � � � ���
°g��f �`'� R � . T� �." �' M,`� ' � � .�1'f a' �:f � '� r - * � � 0 9� �! � �._ ��
r . ^ � ".w` z . y� c k + v�: + ` a+a
.-3 pe a � R � �� a 1.�:. i° r ;. � � Y Es�' �. 1 p.3, ; �� .�R t ., � � ,�.CA+� : • A .3 �� t w �r�.
�.'�r t�,�. �, �. `,P . '/ ,,4. SR� y„ Sr` t �•_ . �/ ^(a� v .:� �� �s Y '�-t�''q : '� .� 2� ''�",�x
b 'i 4 4 �{�.+ :�'� M�� �r a 9�'.,� � �b.;i b� / f M . , . 1.j j ��
� � �q ,�'*" � � ' _a N a; ��' ;� � r t e'� ' - y �
`` �.� �� r � '�' �. � y T� � � :t t ✓ :* r � f r, �+ r?�.�y. r r�" a k� .�k� r�-� �� ,7.� �'�
1 fi ��' r I � � � 'yv ,� '4���y I�� -',� .. +' �� . � �: p .J�.. '" �y'�i
`� '�+ ' �ti a ' � r o �:' �c y�, ` � _, ir � �=r as r (r,� �a4' + - `�
p �' t�{ �z�E��r�� v v �. � i-� ��� '' "� �+,gi � " � t ` A G. t I i� �d ra� s; ;, i �
�'�' 7 i y � . 4 t - �r ���' s a.�,�' � pt � n �_ o . � � � o ,� 'K ��
ti ;t -� �;�, a� P - � ` � Y t ���5 '.r a< b,t a. � t.� � �.�,: �- 6 7� 4 i'��,��.}�;
r .`i � , � i� � r .�� 'Y �' �� ; tr v., � { )� ;� c � �� t"�^�� - �y ��1 �. ' i x.�` .�r°'.�r ei�
�y Ak I �`� y�_ � v 7 � - }` � . � �" i` � rxy i� �A x1 �If`�'�� F- ��
� ` �k '� '*'� �f t� 1 'I � �7 � a � 1'` �_ + �� > �`;� C.'G � � ".�3 d� t r m� :
j � �' � �� ! �' #�1 ��. '¢ �'+d w .:��4 ti :
�y �ti ,�� � 1.4 �'#_f K,�rza.,� C+�n� � h y�a ,>� �e � � t � t / i �'` �9° ,:,��" t i i � ��,�i ,��I d .x �' �r �+:k.�
t�2'�e.���?�^s2r i��-��:,.`I.�w� '3�a -�:n2.3i��_ ..:�}-��.;�as����i��-Jx_s�..a�,'-��._...�� �, �,�:.��.:3'�.,�!:�� .. �. _ at�f.�z�r.�.r:`4.i�.'�`.�t�'c ��..:u..,:.[s.��6.$AF:?5..���.;:.ai€ ,b.Y'��;4 a>l..._t_..,..,, � a.,��':" '�A-n��.....