The URL can be used to link to this page

87-838 WHITE - CITV CLERK t PINK � FINANCE GITY OF SAINT� PAUL ��—� � CANA,RV -�DEPARTMENT COUIIC1l x BLUE_ -MOVOR File NO. J • ( � Ordin�nce Ordinance N�. �� Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date An Ordinance amending Chapter 60 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code pertaining to zoning for the City of Saint Paul and the zoning maps thereof. WHEREAS, Pursuant to Minnesota Statutes, § 462.357 and § 64.400 of the Legislative Code, Donald R. Robinson duly petitioned to rezone 735 South Robert Street, located on the northwest corner at Sidney Street, from RT-1 to B-3, later amended to OS-1, for the purpose of establishing a real estate office; the petition having been certified by the Planning Division on March 19, 198_7 as having been consented to by at least two-thirds of the owners of the area of the property to be rezoned, and further having been consented to by at least 67X of the owners of the property situated within 100 feet of the total contiguous property within one year preceding the date of the petition; and WNEREAS, The Zoning Committee on April 16, 1987 conducted a public hearing for the purpose of considering the rezoning petition, and pursuant to Section 107.03 of the Administrative Code, submitted its recommendation to the Planning Commission that the petition for B-3 be denied; and WHEREAS, The Planning Corr�nission considered the rezoning petition at its meeting held on April 24,1987 and recommended that the City Council deny the B-3 petition; and WHEREAS, Notice of a public hearing before the City Council on the said rezoning petition was duly published in the official newspaper of the City on May 2, 1987 and notices were duly mailed to each owner of affected property and property situated wholly or partly within 350 feet of the property sought to be rezoned; and COUNCILMEIV Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays �rew Nicosia lR Favor — Rettman Scheibel A ainst BY Sonnen g Tedesco Wilson Form Approv d y City Attorney Adopted by Council: Date Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY By Approved by Mayor: Date Approv b Mayor for Submis n t Council By By _ � - : : a ` _ � : - . . , g >�� -. � �� NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING ! The St. Paul City Council will conduct a public hearing to consider • the request of John Kerwin for consideration of a Registered Land Survey for property la�ated a the NSP Island Power Plant (Mississippi ' River at' foot of Randolph Avenue). The hearing will b�, - - - .M. in the Council Chambers, 3rd F1oor, .City Hall and at-said time and place, the Council will hear all persons and all objections and recommendations to the proposed amendment_ � . � .. . . . . . . . . . . - ' . . . '. F ,..:'.. Dated May 8� 1987 � " � Albert B. Olson - City Clerk . � (May 12� 1987) - q � , . , � - - . , :. a -- . - � ' -- �t ST. PAUL CITY COUNCIL PU6l.iC HEARING NOTICE ZONING - Property owners within 350 feet; FIL E N 0. SBb #202 Representatives of district 9 PAGE P U R P 0 S E To consider the approveal of a Registered Land Survey for property located at the NSP Island Power Plant. LOCATION Mississippi Rivex at foot of Randolph Ave. PETITIONER ,7ohn Kerwin HEARIN6 �, - io:oo a.M. • Cit Coun m e , d Floor City Hall - Court House Q U E S T10 N S Zoning 298-4154 CAllan Czaia) Contact the Zoning Section of the Planning and Economic Development Department, Room 1101, City Hall Annex, 25 W. 4th Street, St. Paul, Minnesoia 55102 Legal Descr�pti.on: On file Notice •ent �7—�ra y ST. PAUL CITY COUNCIL PU6LIC HEARING NOTICE ZONING - Property owners within 350 feet; FlLE N0. SBD .�t202 Representatives of district 9 PAGE PU R P 0 S E To consider the approveal of a Registered Land Survey for property located at the NSP Island Power P1ant. �ocAT�oN Mississippi River at foot of Randolph Ave. PETITIONER John Kerwin HEARING �r,uTgaay, May 21 19�� io:oo a.M. . Cit Council Cham�iers, 3rd Floor City Hall - Court House QUESTIONS Zoning 298-4154 �Allan Czaia) Contact the Zoning SectiDn of the Planning and Economic Development Department, Room 1101, City Hall Annex, 25 W. 4th Street, St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Legal Descrintion: (hi file r -_ � _- ,;. . . � r.,,. frT Notice aent ' � ° � � NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING The St. Paul City Council will conduct a public hearing to consider the �-� request of John Kerwin for consideration of a Registered Land 5urvey for :' . `property located at the NSP'Island Power.Plant(Mississippi River at.foot of � Randolph Avenue).The heaxing will be Thursday.M� 21. 1987 at 10:00 A.M :n , the Council Chambers, 3rd.Fioor, City Hall and a sai une a� p ace, . e ' - .- Council will hear all persons and all objections and necomme.ndations to the -'-:-: proposed amendment. • Dated May 8, l98?. . ALBERT B.OLSON,City Clerk . (May 12. 1987) � . St. Paul Legal i.,edger-3 � . ,�L C� Iso � PLAT STAFF REPORT � � �� FILE #202 1 . APPLICANT : John Kerwin DATE OF HEARING : 5-21-87 2 . LOCATION : Mississippi River at foot of Randolph Ave . 3 . LEGAL DESCRIPTION : See R. L. S . 4 . PRESENT ZONING : I - 2 , RC- 1 , RC- 2 ZONING CODE REFERENCE : 67 . 00 5 . STAFF INVESTIGATION AND REPORT : DATE : 5- 12 -87 BY: Al1an Czaia e�__�_m__=�___�aam=��=_a��s��a�sc��_s9�a�s=�=�sa_=s�__a��as��_a�a-_= -------------------------------s----=----------------------------=-�a� A. PURPOSE : To consider the approval of a Registered Land Survey for property located at the old NSP Island Power Plant . This property is unplatted and the R . L. S . is needed for recording purposes . B . SITE & AREA CONDITIONS : This property is now located in the Floodway, Flood Fringe , Urban Diversified River Corridor Overlay Zoning District . The proposed Floodway 40 Acre Study zoning study recommends that most of the property be in the Flood Fringe District . It is surrounded by the Mississippi River and Shepard Road. There is an existing building on this site that used to be an old power plant . There are scattered trees and underbrush on site . This is a landlock parcel . C . REOUIRED FINDINGS : 1 . All the applicable provisions of the Legislative Code are complied with . 2 . The proposed subdivision will not be detrimental to the present and potential surrounding land uses . The surrounding land uses are heavy industrial . 3 . The area surrounding the subdivision can be planned and developed in coordination and compatibility with the proposed subdivision. The surrounding area is NSP land and is undeveloped. 4 . The subdivision is in conformance with the Comprehensive Plan. The River Corridor Plan proposes open space for the site with adaptive commercial reuse of the existing building . 5 . The subdivision preserves and incorporates the site ' s important existing natural features , whenever possible . No development has been proposed at this time . , 6 . All land intended for building sites can be used safely without endangering the residents by peril from floods , erosion, continuously high water table , severe soil conditions or other menace . This site is in the Mississippi River Corridor Floodway . Any proposed development must meet all River Corridor Overlay Zoning requirements . 7 . The subdivision can be economically served with public facilities and services . This site has no water services at this time . D . ADDITIONAL FINBItiGS ; The Ramsey County Recorder , Charles Repe , told the appli.cant to implement this R. L. S . for recording purposes . E . STA�F RECOMi�1EhDATION : Base�d on findings � a.nd D , Staff recommends approval of this i.t . 1. . S . for recording purposes only . � , . . \ � �� CITIZEN PARTICIPA I0 ; DIS RI S •.ry••ly .� ' ` ' O ` \ �Y # t � ' 4r i =� ; 1� �� .�,�..� „ , .�. 2 � � s ' � 6 = � ' S � : . �. � 12 • - , , � .,� F a ........� „R + � � t I 4 = � I p� 1 ^y, ` � � e.� s' � w , w a • � � ...soe�. �:� - 11 = 4 ; M ; � 4 € � � ,. F :, �� , - ,,. S : � + +' i � f 'S- � .. s � € _ �,� 4 � � � � .\ s� � � �• � \ , M '_� - 1 � u�rrH tiiM �'! f l � Y�l�' � - ��"J � � y'c • �q � '� �• . yH•. � � � s� �� 1 Y1, w� � \\ � � � i S f ; S � � 8 e s $ '� - s �... .R i �6$ ,� y�.� v - �i�4 . 3 - `\,`�, .� � ,,.�+u.. ., � : ` � �b�+d ucw� 5� � � ao.('. ++ ' S G � a, � ��' '� � � 7 j ' o �_ . = r �F 4 2 '� f � ? X. Y � g a - i' i x � p �I � y b f . � 7 } w.., F N: '��` �� .e �� V'' . � � 15. � � � �A, �� \ � .,� ,� .,�.�.,.. .� S 1 i :. � ,>�..,� , r . \',, .. ; �r- ; � j�/ �\;, ,\ F r 1 :1 y`� � � 1 r` 1 ' � �` , _ _`__�/ n y� ��,1 , �� . o � .�, .�.u, � ,�., '� CITIZEN PARTICIPATION PLANNING DISTRICTS 1.SUNRAY—BATTLECREEK—HIGHlJ00D 2.GREATER EAST SIDE 3.WEST SIDE 4.DAYTON'S BLUFF 5.PAYNE—PHALEN 6.NORTH END 7.THOMAS—DALE . — NI SIT EST 10. 11 .HAMLINE—MIDWAY 12.ST. ANTHONY 13.MERRIAM PK.—LEXINGTON HAMLINE 14.GROVELANO—MACALESTER 15.HIGHLAND 16.SUMMIT HILL 17.004JNTOWN APPLICATION FOR SUBDIYISION REVIEW CITY OF SAINT PAUI SUBDIYISION REYIEW # z-D z saz:aaaassaasaza=:rasssa==asaaaasa=aaaazssaa=casaaaas=ssa��=�zs�cassasssussasas�:ssssss PROJECT NAME Island Station Power Plant DESCRIPTION OF PROJECT Split building on 10 acres to allow sale to City PROPERTY ADDRESS/LOCATION Mississippi River at foot of Randolph Avenue LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF PROPERTY See Attached APPLICANT John Kerwin COMPANY N�co9,let Restoration, Inc, ADDRESS 500 East 36th Street, Minneapolis, MN �ZIP� 55408-1544PHONE 822-8170 !� �rq.r.� r IL:��::i.'v�N,7 TYPE OF DIVISION: (Check one) F'l.�te��;;i�'� C!'!. - r- - C;"',' ('= � . r , LOT SPLIT PLAT: Preliminary Final � � Combined RLS (4 or Fewer Tracts) R (F' or More Tracts) APPLI ANT'S S AT RE "/« -MAR 5 19`,5 DATE 2�28�86 C IGN U 2 2 � r � � FEE PAID $ � �C� CITY AGENT ,�t��; � � � sassssssas==aasca==a=maacascaca===ac=a=c=sacas=a=ao=ccs=m=aa=acc=ca=n==sas=zssasmasss::ssa OFFICE USE ONLY --, .�, . PLNG DIST �_ LAND USE �, �-� 20NING � � HISTORY TAX MAP 1�r , � � —T_, PLANS DISTRIBUTED RETURN BY REVIEWED BY COhWIENTS (continue on back) sssssszsssasss=ma=asascs==assmss=c=mc==asaaaa=a=aa=�a=s=c=sac=sss=aa��asssss=zassasassssss FOR STAFF USE ONLY Legal Notice Published City Council Hearing Date Approved/Denied 7/1/85 APPLICATION FOR SUBDIVISION REVIEW CITY OF SAINT PAUL SUBDIYISION REYIEW # Z-C� Z sss�:=sssaz:sszzzzzrss�z�aaass�c=saa�aaar:s=acaar=aaarn=maszaasaaaassa:sssssssssszssssssss PROJECT NAME Island Station Power Plant DESCRIPTION OF PROJECT Split building on 10 acres to allow sale to City PROPERTY ADDRESS/LOCATION Mississippi River at foot of Randolph Avenue LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF PROPERTY See Attached APPLICANT John Kerwir COMPANY N�co��et Restoration, Inc, ADDRESS 500 East 36th Street, Minneapolis, MN �ZjP� 554os-15��PHONE 822-8170 F'�'��'�P"�'� TYPE OF DIVISION: (Check one) F�.Qr�i�,��,��',,,�``,�_.. C"" (';':;- ,-,,. LOT SPLIT PLAT: Preliminary Final Combined RLS (4 or Fewer Tracts) R (F' or More Tracts) APPLICANT'S SIGNATURE �� -MA R 5 19�� 2�28�86 2 2 DATE !, - /i' � � FEE PAID $ f� �O CITY AGENT 'I �f't-��; . � � � ssss:�zx�assas�caca=c=:nc=�=a=aan=a=�=s==a=====aa==�=aa�cxaasaas�ca==crosnsass�saassss=ss=s OFFICE USE ONLY --, .. PLNG DIST � LAND USE ' ��' ZONING -1 t� HISTORY TAX MAP �� PLANS DISTRIBUTED RETURN BY REYIEWEO BY t��4 T�P_ I�TI L ! T � COMMENTS a� i � �Z r� � . .- IS S� � � � � _ 1 (continue on back) sssssssssazaaas�saaaseax=x=amasoc==�=cs=a=ca�acaac===csa=c=maxxaacrosc=sssssassa�s�ssssssss FOR STAFF USE ONLY Legal Notice Published City Council Hearing Date Approved/Denied 7/1/85 s - � ' , , ' �t _. ZONING OFFICE USE ONLY . � I Plat Review �� _ L �_ PJanning District / Project Name � J �-�� _ Land Use Map ' �l ^ Zoning ! �:- � History � ,�-. � ; �_. } REVIEW Preliminary Final Comments Sent Rec'd Sent Rec'd Building Department �,�j �y Fire Department ;_ � w Sewer Engineer bJater Dept. ��/��'l Traffic Maintenance IJ�,pti„�ed — Tl�.�s Pul'a�-+� ha s Public Works i � tic s�t-E�b �de1«aled )1'►-�,�a g .e , , . uit�•r •' r � :,�� .. Planning/Zoning N c z;(� � �a,.. dQJ C�0��'�1�T��,t�c 1 l Planning District / � � _ -----._. �. Return by �� l�/ /%�l� to Division of Planning, 1100 City Hall Annex. ; –=� � - —�., ZONING OFFICE USE ONLY > � C/ Plat Review �/ �. � �— Planning District Project Name � ` �� . _ Land Use Map - Zoning I `�. History i REVIEW Preliminary Final Comments Sent Rec'd Sent Rec'd Building Department '� �-' ' _��'�/ ( n � I ��^� Q C� i �r /t-�' l/� 'L O Fire Department � Sewer Engineer Water Dept. �'/�r! Traffic Maintenance Public Works � - Planning/Zoning Planning District ;� /� ; Return by '� �%�/ �'�(. to Division of Planning, 1100 City Hall Annex. . . . :o:: CITY OF SAINT PAUL INTERDEPARTMENTAL MEMORANDUM March 27, 1986 TO: Linda Duckhut 1100 City Hall FROM: Edward B. Heinen . � Assistant Fire Chief RE: Plat Review #202 Island Station Power Plant Mississippi River at foot of Randolph Avenue We, the Department of Fire and Safety Services have reviewed your plans and have no objections at this time. Inspected by : J . Fee District Chief lmr 1 � - • I � _ . — /�� •� �� ► � � . � i � ; � " � � , J ` - - t No. 5�,5�,9� (A_r.r. 21, 1970) District Coutt No. �919 red the 29th day of ��y � 133 Register of Titles � i �c�t�lralio�t � r+orthern States Power Company, a corporation City of Minneapolis and State of Minnesota ..4=,»�,,,::�,: - ,�Mn: _�,.,,�>: . ,,,,,.r ..�,.�_.. .,...,� .r.:_.�,r- ._�. �,��._:,�:,.�.-,�,s-.,.-�-..�-..,��-.�-,�--.��. � of Ramsey and State of Minnesota, to wit: n� and bein� in Section 12, Township 2F� Pdorth of Range 23 West, of the ndary lines, to-wit: Startin� at a poir.t of beginning on the North and South ` h line is South 0° 06' East from the P�orthkest corner of the Northeest q�iarter � said Section 12, as said point and lines are fixed by the United States ` ti�est, 303.0 feet; thence South 13° 24' West, 167.2 feet; thence South �?° : thence I�:orth 66° 0' East, 237.1 feet; thence South 6° 51' East 91.0 feet: 42' East 567.0 feet; thence I�;orth 44° 50` East. 165:73 feet; thence Ilorth C° eet; thence South 49° 30' West 500 feet; thence South 77° 22' West 8?��.F? f�et ,...r..�:.. _;..,:w -..z..... T�•tT ..�"'` . .. ,.,._._ .,.,. � ._•_... .,�,.,..:, �.:,.., � :' � ` � . . .. a -�.,...._.... ..:,..._,-.`� °;.;1�y_1�x _. t��...asaz�c:;:.:�+eac,.�s_.. ... , • � ' '...�,�: .«,;.:zeabesa�Ef,,.,.�.a.�.'�'�^,.,'"'�.,..,,^3-',r,Pr"..�^� .. lyin� and bein� in Section �12, Towtiship 28 North of Ran�e 23 ti'est, and ti:ithin - � � . �st quarter'bf�the ldortheast qua�t'er of said Section 12, accordine to the t�nited ;�ce South 91ong the E�st line of said Northwest quarter of the Northeest qu�rter rtition P1aL and of, Mctdillan's Addition, accordin� to the respective plats thereof ister of�.Deed�s of Ramsey County, Minnesota, and the true bearing of which line is ning) and elon� the extension of said line 1931� feet; thence South 62° 23' West �; thence South 77° 22' West 33•5� feet�to the intersection of said last described �n Plat, extended Southerly; thence North elong the said Westerly line of Lot 15, �aring of vhich line is North 0° 06' West and slon� the said line 2191.2 feet to aeapolis and Omahs Railrrey; thence North �4° O1' East elong the line of said right �tion 12; thence East alon� the North line of said Section 12 to the �lace of �scribed Z�aet:� Cozr�encing et e point of beginning on the Westerly line of Lot rth from the grenite monumPnt loceted at �the intersection oP said line and the f' l��f','1111�nr hpin� �}1n .,,.j.,�. �'ti1n1'� !"?i�l k'�!;t^1'],y 1i11n n1' l,r�+ l�. �'A�?.it �..., r �., , , i ,i y , � � .� � i � � /' � �—_ — � !� .l�..� ' �� 1 ' � `� � Ccrt;Scatc No. 239135 Documc Trarsfer fro.m No. 188778 Originally re_qis� A. D. 19 23 Folium 104 pQ9� Stntc• oi 111i��it��tst, ss COUII�j O� �illll�Q�. J,is i� fn ��r�r i that • �!� Counly of Hennepin of the is now the owner of an estate, to wit3 ..�n �ee>.��mFle �..�-..� .�H.::.:,->.<..ti , '.c..,. =a;•��,. . ...,rr--.,,d warsa, ro. .._;e ,.. ., .<.. _�-and in the folloi.c�ing descri6ed land situated in the Coun All that certain tract er parcel of land 15- r. i Fourth Principal b".eridian, and within the followin� be �� 1 center line of said �ection 12 (the t�tae bearing of whi � �;'' of said Sectior.) 2522.8 feet South of the Idorth line o �;� �l Gcverrua�nt survej� of said section; thence South 58° 0 �}r � 41' �+est, 31�+.2 *_'eet; thence South 32° 0' East 13? fee' �J thence I•Jorth 67°. 55' East 1100.p feet; thence North 51{; 6' West 289.79 feet; thence South 62° 23' West 144.28 ; � o lace of be�innin�. .� ,�y�,:,+�,<,:�=.ff«y��+�:.v�.�arc�.x�.=��,�!.:r:?7::T,a�.�4,:.,�wc,cm ..�� ... 9� . _ .mx h.:_ And also gll that certain tract or � parcel of land:. the followin� boutidaiy lines, to-wit: Startin� at the Northeast corner of the North� States Government Survey of said Section; th� (which is also the Easterly line of Lot 16, Pa on file and of record in the office of the Rel South 0° 06' East from the said point of begi� 144.2$ feet; thence South 49° 30' West 500 fe� � line wit:� the Westerly line of Lot 15, Pertiti: Fartition P]at, extended Souther]y (the true 1 the ri�ht of vay of the Chicago, St. Paul, Mit of way 193.6 feet to the North line oi said Se beginning, e�i�cepting therefrom the following ;t 15, Pei'tition Plat, 1�+76 feet, more or less Nc North line of the Levee Road (the sc�id poir.t � a � f � � � O � v I � � � � � •�, > � �, 3 � � � N c1� 0 N G � N N .� Q1 �' � 'U � [ � � a.� w v U O � y,� � .� C � � O 'D .� U � O M � W o � � � [ N � � a1 • ° •.a '� � U ,� o �� ..� cv .� x � v .� � +� rn � � co U w r+ 'L7 O �-+ +.� � �.-{ O s �+ � u� v� � � � � p ts •.-a �., m � u-i Ul +� ••�n � 11 � �-7 � > Ca�iv Na�iro03c�na� v •- +� v � 3 � w � .-i .,� .� +, cn E •� .� � u +� v v m - � o � v , C � � +� .� i.� rU � Q1 N w b .o O � ;� 0 � +, y +� G � ro U 3� y v y w . W � v] v � � z � E Cn •-i r� a! O � tA .� w O O U � j..� � ;� n. tr cn z w v � cv N � m � � y,J � CT•�-d � � N r`1 r-1 N ,� U '-'� ,� r{ Q (A � r.. U •r� 'L� Ql 00 •� .. . � Q1 C l} .f-. Q. •� CT•ri � �6 v •rl G +� •� ,� � �--+ � c'� o Lr � � +.t W �n � -� � � a..i N O � � +� a� O .� O `� cx rt3 .,,� � � � 1-1 � UI N 'b •r-1 .-� U1 (n tfl ",t 1-� J-� N - � � � � ro a +� e �r, � �.., rt � ,� , „ �, � a b u� w o � b � � ww � a� •- +� Q� rn C .c o � � +� +� u +� y ° �-� U ,-i w r0 +� •• 4� -- � U� u� - - �..� C G1 41 � r., � � � � N C C � o .--� O Q1 � w � y Q �.w tr � �� c +� o ��+ 'ti 3 0 �n z ,.0 w • ° � a � O ?. C O 3 •�+ u� �� O •� cv o � ao � Ll � „ �.� tr.. � � � .�.� a �1 - r� � QJ oo � � cn c >. o w u �n � � .. �,, �,. `° , �, a� v � � a� +.� s� a� � � � .c c � • M �' �:, o Z .c � c .c v - cn �.� w o +� � v v �r x � � � � �a � - � � �o or, � � � v � .-, �n �, � �, C ;n � o � �n ,-� O O +� w � ,� v � C � L �3 v � w �1 �J � -� � �n s �� E C ^. +.i � ^-� O C Ci o � t1I a1 .0 •� "n 1� N � rQ �.cn +� •r1 cn rts > +� N a, +.� r cn 3 � y w � .-� � .� s.. � U U v • v +� � E p � i � w � � O C C y �n3 - V � •'� C Ul � � � O N (n CI� v �i W �D N � ;, +� -+ � N S-a O O � � .� '-+ ' N 1-1 7 � v3 �ocncn s� +- v +� +� o r^ � �' G: � � U '� Q� � � U • J-> N i � i7 C ,'0 �.1 M .-r'. 'C� (0 l) � � w.. .. .. p � o (� J C C -� � N � �.-i � •� E Ql � +� O rC, cv � I �� QS �-+ �: O �L' r0 t� � .0 � (�J � W �D .� � � �ri Q� .� � � U �-1 ti� �I QJ ^ �� r', ?�1 ZT � C �3' 41 Q) W W - �.�.. � �e-1 .-1 W .�y , O � CT J� •.� UJ � •` . +� O � O �; oo l..r ro c � •-� +� o � cv .� cn �n � !� � �: o U � x ••� O cA TJ U 41 • �0 � Q � � yu, '� U 3 Z .0 RJ �� N �' � f�. v' � CJ ;,� N W O U 4J r0 cn W �+ M � � N }; '.a ;-1 S: O � Q1 �r+ L 'J1 4J ^� N - �: ,, i-� � :y 1� -a � � t� �-1 rJ ��, � 'U .^..' � W r�, ;_, .� .c o � 3 s� �,-.r r� . . .�n ..; � ..0 c +.+ w C O � �� a-+ +� � s� Q7 +� j, . . L. .i S-a � W Z C!: o Jl �� ^` C ,� � x � � �Q O N O O N M � R3 �o � a. • 3 � � "� � Z ,: ti � 'n ` 3 i7 +� � � �'' � s., l.i � tT.0 r+ �J � N �- � � 1 W :I; � c0 C G ...� .-a :J � ,--r - �, ^ � ^� n � U N � �.-+ --� -� �n O O ►. 3i w . � � � ,� � C S.� w .� C di � � C C� flJ � � �...� C �v O :� � 3 N .D Z .� w o �' n � �. 'iS �•y �% �-a Qi i� �D �:J +� O !S � a .� .� -^'� �' � �-i O Qi - {�J �T '� � I . .,.`�� .,`.� a.= u! 3 4i Qi Z .0 N .� � ti •-t` --� � � :� n 3 C � � c � o � 1..� c ,., • �.% C � ,._, � � 3 ''7 7 s.., y a � � �1 1: =` !� ... � �,, ; ,� '-+ J C w !.� G � �ca O O .� � co y .-� W �, � .� .. �t "r-+ 'tS ^.� 1-% U �+ S; i!l UJ Z � t+-� N 3 U� '� ,�,,; : �. c .- � c �.w -, � - ^ 3 � T. � u � y � �, .� - t � L �. -�; L :� _ � _ . . _ .� W _ m _ _ _ . � - _ _ _ li. - � ' w � W . W _ � � � cn v v � .� ,-, ;, y � a� >, � U �J GJ � � U � �.% � v � .-� �. � � a � n �' w o ,+� _ c� ' � m v .-• �v o • o � � � +� � c � � � � � o .� rt w rtf �n • ' - , � -� N � G U1 � (• ._ -. . _ � N I� 41 'u I _ C � �l.� � � _ rl � C � E 7 0� � t� • �"� x � � v � V _ . � ?� �+ I `t7 O ; � -� � � 41 C � ^' � � C .� > N '-' U � � � �.: � rn �� - o� ,_.] . � �'.-�+ w O N C/� � - +� TJ ••i • � � � •� � p � v 3 � �0 v •,.� � � '� � UJ +� UI ;n •� O O O � ' w •.a > O U G +� , p � •� n, o � j � b � � � �n � �. cz .� ro v � a� � m .� � o - �-+ m c1� U E � � Z � �� . . � °, �E � I v ..� r, Q � a� � • o C' � w > rn ( � i . . � G a1 � O L+ � .n w �n .� � y, W � �. �«-� � O o > � v y � ` � O rn u� '0 U �-' � � T .--� '� C � C] Q � � � '� � w 'O C � w O tn � � u - o -� � o � a v � c i:.: .r., u � � � ` cn I J s� �, � >, 'b +' � 3 I� � '� � � � E� C� rC U� cn 'C -� y. C E y � ` . .� i ! � +� '+-� �,y � � � x N � � .-� � +� y _ _ J O I+� � ( O w CT ` S.+ - -'" tn 7 rs, � O 4! !d Q1 � �J J-� ,--� � � �'' � � i C ;n � 1 �a �, +� �, � .�, +, c ! x � m .r .-� � �� C �� -+ - �. � � =+ � .� � C' A � + � O � ti v-+ 1 , , � �.-1 � C� � � � � t� "7 O � � ,� � ( �: ;n �� I �� ;A � ?, � s.a > �.: �+ � � O C �, � GL �: � rtf �-� ^� w � s. � � ` � '-' � "-' rJ C :. �. .-+ !y T3 � 1ti �..� �.+ .� L � � � � �i i G� �,-! W �S-� rJ` b �+ � �6 ta ( � -�--� ti 7 r6 :J �;..; r,li � I w :-� ,1� f '9 �L � � O ,� ++ � O +a 1.1 E � .--� � � ._ � G � .. .^J � � � � !� i Y' nS � QJ { � Y �J .Z � . �t I ~ � � � � C � � . � •� � � 1 ` � �. .i, � `'� ,�.�., I +� +� Q) �Q1 :� O f � :u ��-' J) �% � � � ` ;!? ..� '*J � � r� C. � T. � �� i. U7 � { C � r}. � i= X �6 I �� T � -� (� � s.. :� � � � v ;a � C. : O � � 4''� i .�. :, U � . c. J.� � Q 1'. --+ � � , r': � � . I i •�Yfl1 C0. 011�MIi! •OYT. •.�.C011M!■ O� •.a. �i� or �ec. �a-��•�• �_ I I . 35�.j � � `'�'� s�\ ' .. � � y�� ` i —_�. �v b / �`p !/�� / �\ �, %- F� „�j�� oii SIT E '° I n;: I, �� RANDOLP AVE. �/ P 4 - � �Pa ;�:�-�--- T QP�i r � � �' !1_"\Pp,� l- ,1E' ' �SS � �s '�IA,� S� ' .� � s� � I `.±. `� -- +--- � -- � �Q PO. : :.j SEC. 12-28-23 I "�� VICINITY MAP i � , Q P�p� .�� E �- - - / � NOT TO SCALE �� -' ��% ,� ' �� _`- . � .,�. _� o,�'o pe � /^�� i/� t � � , �C �( ' 63�.e �oM� � -" � �,�� :0 11� �� sa�.zb � -- -- - ------- -- - .o , :'��i/� '\1'�� '' � N8469�5�•� �� - �� a\r� &�✓ / -- — -- -�.� - � i• � 60 ii�" 1y 1. j J\ I .r, � �� . .\ a �� 1 / Q�. \ �j, , \ � � 4� � � .:� �I i ° • � , �, , �% ;� �� 6 • ,,�' o' +.�y. ' c� �' �� t i�'.' • i. `� `7 �`�:°ti o,e +s'-'i�= ' u+ i , � � � 9,b• i4�.T � �r e��trtMr • � �/.� i � / ♦ � � � �� i i � ��-�q or.• } :. I p ` B ��! / 1�1 �/� \ i w i I y \ 1 --- C Il • - ! / . ♦� \ � \ 2 � ' �1�' //// i � � e � /� � 1 t� ,� ./-�' �O / �OB i �1� � � , --' p � � / \ o�� .o�� @ • � / i�� , o+ '.,\ �p6 . � � a:•- _ . ' �i i / � �+'i • � q +. d :�� ,' .��' �� ,i.� � •/�� °i' ♦►\ ? d � ��po� � + \ 3 �� e� 1�' / ` � • .+� / \ ` �i ,.j!"Op o 7.s pa E � _ � � �� i �; / i�?�'. �N�� o • \1 \Il Z',.1 P.o � i ` ,:� ',i '{''/�..4 //,. °, �' "s •/ �� i i\ � � T \ �?O/ �• / � `� i j �. / ��``�?e j� � p . � ' e `�� / `� ; � , . , ,�e.�, -- '; M�gS . , t �� . �,��, ��. ; � : � � - ,.-;,,,. i ; o .- M! � • j • � • ♦ O / . �- '�M�'` •/ � � �, � � f % PROPOSED • REGISTERED LAND SURVEY � DESCRIBED AS: . . �ll lnol . rto�� tr�� ..i . .. _ . . .- . .. . n :d .. . -. _ i3 at. of l�e fo�rlh Pri��..�.�<� �ue,�i .., .., .� . . ... .. . ., -.. . � , t�-.� ..r . � . Geqi ing tn< �+a+t�lan.: �,u . rter i.- . . • _ • . • . 1.`! ' 0'06��Ea t � T. tn< �mre�..st .. oi ��r,•.� .._ . .. ,.. .c ... ... _ an... � . Norlh l��e of� c�C ct. 1.. .. .�, !c • • . . .� . . ••• pf. . aa�d ct�o�: t�,.�.<'. .. 58'C2' ,._ `JC7, . .... _. _.,,i.. . ��a• . a� .. .., . e7'Ol��wes�. 7 U.2 . � �..�r,72' .. ., .. e. . . ei. _ r �o��. 6`SI' Eas� ot . 't . •�- SS . � .�^ .a Se.'.. � ei' ttie�ce Nortr a�'S0' .t .. 3 -t��t , �. . . ,t..�fl9.' . �, e '7' st�I�a.3B feet: the�c< So��t� �9aJL' we�t i�0 eet.•t�rnce ..... . .. ..st 6i�.B ... � ... . _ s ^"�. � __. r �'- � j� :TI ;E�� ` �� . � , : '-��%�% �� / ,_��,�/ ; / ,, �; �- f� � /e ' � ,�� . �'JGt / � ,'�? /' �/�� . OM�/ . � -/� . o •�/ / �' ►1�a�► ' / . ��/p 1' �� • ``�j / �, •/j/✓/// �O �g��j �' ,'�t I � 16 ► � T t� �p' / / � _ � ' / � , '!. � p o . �� +.��'O� ��/ // � � �. /�;� , �� / �-�� '��'� � -�j�j_��. /;/.« � ��: �%�� .� ,' �� . ' � '� �6 / '�� i_ % / � ;�,�'�� '�� , �1M / i% � � /�y oe�°��o�y,'�DE��.%"0/� //� / � /�' ///� /r 5 1Y?��"H G i� , e ; �,� � s 1 8��3�� w _,j�jy C �o � j�/ �� ' /e � j�, , � �, �/ � �'' ; � �' %�j / �.QwE��'��//tiE �'///_, ' / � _ � - . �/ 0b ► �/ +` -� .�c` OO�"//b' / / // � .•�� ' j� j; � ; � " l SCALE� 1"_ 100' o �.; / � i � ° 2 i � /�� y°� ,o / i �' �/% / � /i 'Op: • 4�� / �%/ ` / °6 OWNER �oo•� � % i°/ � r� / > %'" 'S� t, � i �� N�PiHE�H 5Tp7ES 70MER CONC�NY • •'O��/ ! /� � -. 41� NICOILEI MA�L �p !� - . NI!+NEAVOII$, M�+ SS�01 4•'� �y� p��. j %.� , � ��IJiAC/. � +� �/� /�' `1 � .AVE F�SMEP ,�T /� �% . JJO-5981 • 5�� 1 G♦' ��' � � J V --'�,. : 1 Q�� TOTAL AREA 1�=_"o��Ma tN�*°� � �M . � ; 1�.7 4CRC5 0 s _ '.A�.E Z _.,: _ ': +I'.�.. I'1'. w 1.96 '�.-so.+ 4�00�� -:e-t:l I 51. Fc::.. �+.+ 75106 . � B.M. TOP OF N.E.CORNER OF STEEL , � . aRAiE PLIITFORM ON E'LV WALL � � e-�. thot lh�s p+u� or reoort \ OF M�IN BLDG. NEAR N'LY WALL �^c t• "' � ^<< u��VCrsien PP � _P _ �� .,o�a�P � CONTOUR INTERV�L = � FEET i/ //'��/ --7��c-�...-c.�� ' — .�uRr6 E. _o^le. �i^Fl/:.L.S. No. 1�887 . v ... .�e 2�R� ..o. ;f JANUARY �o se - � I �. �- � . .1 r�. 1;.� ' .,- -::�� 2nd � �1��-�� . � k 3rd j f�'-�' � Adopted � -d�.� -,� `� � Yeas Nays � DREW n� �-7_ ��/ (; o.� S � � NICOSIA j 7y�,� RETTMAN SCHEIBEL SONNEN WILSON � MR. PRESIDENT TEDESCO \' . ��, :. . �/ ... :�,- WHITE - CITV CLERK - � PINK - FINANCE G I TY O F SA I NT PA U L Council //yy CANARV -•DEPARTMENT File NO. �� BLUE f MaVOR • O/ indnce Ordinance 1�0._L �(D Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date WHEREAS, A public hearing before the City Council , having been conducted on May 14, 1987 where all interested persons were heard and where the petitioner stated his desi�e to amend the petition, to OS-1, and the Council having considered all the facts and recommendations concerning the petition; and WHEREAS; , the City Council requested that a new site plan be submitted by the petitioner to the Planning Division and to the West Side Citizens Organization which indicates a new rear parking lot configuration with four off-street spaces; now therefore, THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: Section 1. That the zoning map of the City of Saint Paul , Sheet No. 37, as incorporated by reference in Section 60.301 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, as amended, is hereby further amended as follows: That property located at 735 South Robert, being more particularly described as Lots 9, 10 and the south 10' of Lot 8, Paul Martin's Rearrangement of Block 144 be and is hereby rezoned from RT-1 to OS-1. Section 2. This ordinance shall take effect and be in force thirty (30) days from and after its passage, approval and publication. COUNCILMEN Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays Drew PLANNING ND ECONOMIC EVELOPMENT Nicosia ln Favor — Rettman _ I +�F�siisi� Q.�� . ��e� Against �Y T�a�o wi�son JUN 2 5 �$7 Form Approved City Attor y Adopted by Council: Date Certified Pass d il Secr a BY By Approv Mayor: Da JU 2 9 Approve ayor for Submiss' n t oescil B By P��}�p J U L 3 198� . . ,('i�-�y�-�'3$� o + .�j� : ' l�E PARTMENT N. O s��I 5 otirv�} � �,i, CONTACT l Z��, X 3345 PHONE 6 � DATf �� . �r I�SSIGN NUM3,ER fOR ROUfING. ORDER (Clip All Locations for Signature) : � Department Dire�tor � Director of Management/Mayor Finance and Management Services Director - ,� City Clerk Budget Director „3Q, ' Cou,�c�"l,� G[/��cn_r � City At.torney WHAT WIII BE ACHIEVED BY TAKING ACTION ON THE ATTACNED MATERIALS? (Purpose/ Rationale) : I r1l�t'►Ri€ F/N�F�RE�oNiNCy ,¢G�7pN FOR pRppERfi! L� � ��S �o. �old�tT.cS'r',� FRtrM RT-/ f-o OS-1 � �o �S�A��St9 A- R�k- �8�r'�a�Flc�. Ce�'�1 Cvu�vu� .4�p2ov�D RE�on��rtry S/!K/8� RECEIVED � C�OSTJBENEFIT, BUDGETARY AND PERSONNEL IMPACTS ANTICIPATED: MAY 2$ 1987 N� MA�YOR'S OFFICE � � �� - �- . �INANCING SOURCE AND BUDGET ACTIVITY NUpBER CHARGED OR GREDITED: (Mayor's signa- ture not re- Total Amount of 'Transaction: �� quired if under , - ��o,000) Fund:iqg Source,: Activity Number: . RECEIVitD ATTACHMENTS (List and Number Al l Attachments) : �A1(.271987 T'�"'�"""�`" ��'�'�`��`�� CITY ATTORNEY ,2P, o,�.�.� . - qEPARTMENT REVIEW � � CITY ATTORNEY REVIEW Yes No Council Resolution Required? ' Resolution Required? Yes Na Yes No Insurance Required? � Insurance Sufficient? Yes No Yes No Insurance Attached: � - � .,._ (SEE•RE�IER�� SIDE FOR IMSTRlKTIONS) � Revised 12/84 , � , . . �`��' �'°'� ' ��`�t7� �p�. CITY OF SAINT P�UL ; ��„�� ; DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT � �� ha DIVISION OF PLANNING . 25 West Fourth Street,Saint Paul,Minnesota 55102 �86� 612-292-1577 GEORGE LATIMER MAYOR May 22, 1987 Albert B. Olson, City Clerk Room 386 City Hall Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 Dear Sir: Attached per your letter of request, is the proper ordinance for the implementation of the City Council action approving the petition of Doanld Robinson to rezone property located at 735 South Robert Street from RT-1 to OS-1 to establish a real estate office. Please contact me if our office can be of further assistance regarding this matter. Sincerely, � C�1n Vt.:�...�L.,%��,�—'_"`�_` Donna Datsko City Planner II Zoning Section DD:ws : Is t l�j=�/� �� 2nd _ � `/�'� 7 . . 3zd _ �r�- Q?_�-�'7 Adopted �7-�-�7 Yeas Nays � DREW � �"/-��3 9 ! NICOSIA : � �7�,� S CIiEIBEL SONNEN WILSON � MR. PRESIDENT TEDESCO i � : � � ,� �, � < - r ' .- r 4 � � `` �` �� .�_ ,� � . � `��` ! �.1 1S �r� J ' �j,M1 .��' �� .�. .. � , d�, Y j u�:� ri� .F,:. 1, . � � �� ,� _ i i , } f ',U �; '�e�� :� 3�,� , ` ' , �, y { ;i ' r.` � � ,A 1�, ' r'f '�' � . ' �� i ' ��,? � . (� `� �� ,_� i�. � " .: � .� � l . � � � i k� �� '� � $f� � � { y f �� f .��L� � � r�j ; - � � ' ` -.`t"'�r � � . ��. �.� i � ;, r., s ^� f� .� f- , i 1 F : 1, 1 . - i `. � � t'� i t x � f � y �t � �' � t r ' _ �'�` .� a' .} '� t �+� -.� .� �., �-. . �� : , :. _: ' � { � . C ° , < "_ � t M + ��. 1�� ` ` , � t �r � ; t y f�1 �^ i 3K� / � �: r � �� F � a ) � � } � h 'rt'f � , , . _'�� t t,��ar w. r. \ M t �' � � •�: r A� �1�� '�, 1 [ I' . :.�' � ^ ,�, , - ; ` ' l '�` ti� � ' x�_: if•s � �� f � 1 ' �� " ,j' . { .. F a�_ 1�� t � '�. i � _ , �.' . . ` � !' .:. . . [ !` t � 3 t � . I '. � <! -�a. �r,i �� .�� ,�'��r� �,' ��l'# s�„' t � ;; , ::�i�,;1�;f��cx _t'�:t�':t�t1'i�r�ae' T� ,, ' �r� i •I)A�lC .��5 „� �� . a r^�, -a� , ` i, t> ±; � � ':� � . . . �-� 1 r- r �'�� ''� "�; .� `�� y��@�c �r1i� h�� t`��' � �L�#�,�+!�t'�jr�� C� v�� t�'+��„�► ��rt � { ,. 1 .�+�+'� �a� !R1Vwf�ww�+.e.+rti�,;;di� � �""�, {r�i' � ': , f � - � r z , � (� P,*,.s ��r��-i47! ��,� l�� 'n�"'*'Gri�1�� ."��F't�.:' �!!K� S s$ . 4„ �j ' � ' i \ j�!WdN� �';�'��i��.Yi.M�!�T—� �`.�':��"'.�/�'�� i,�,'�"t��r� �1�'p�: � :�� .�� !�iR� �� M*�j. Y .�f � J � 3�: . . . � . 4 . { 1 ' '�'� ,�r YT—i �� 1 { a y y1 t � � � , ,.. � ' � .�t � r . 2� F . 1�' �'� � I . �� 3 r. � � ;�?k x,i t (. '�{ �� i• / �f.L�II11��4�;�1! �}YM�a � ' { ' }. � � A y.��,W+ii!` �'� { ,. - � C' 7}f f'� �h� F• "� y ' ' i� J � 4 t. 1 4 f ,� �. � � : 1 .. , , � ,- , �.�, • ; r ' { �" ��., a s 1W�: _ r' { r.: - �i ';t. � . o v:i `�.�' 1 �i y-� } f I, 1 t 1 :i� .� n'�. �S � "�'.i'; '� p� / ,� c -�, "; � � '�, '1. . ��/, t f ^ ` F / / ,�.� t r ` C ! 4 � x ��1 v . , �:.! � 7 � �.. � 4,�� ,V ` ��.1 .1 �:.� a 1 - e � ' , �. { ;. . �-i �a�� 1 �� '�` � d`^ 1�. r " �e 7�'� } � ' � � f:� ! � � � `+ � � �-- ''t�� h , , t. f. 1 _ � ��,' J 7 t' �!r� � .. � ,. -� : ; . �i 'a. _ _ , ,S r �P_. � ;T 'i �'Y I �' ,g a ` � . � lA�� :. y� �`_, � f N A I � ' , .�� . p k`' ,,:t �F. l`i ' . � ��. ' i ' � a.;, F (� � t- � / 5 ' �� 1 a /�� .'� .�€z ' .�.: � 9 .[ { � t � � W�`'C /• _ ! . J `� „^f(r '? � � r a ,� ` a i,, , h�� l �i�. `� t.' . ;f �. � '�i '• 1 � � S � , Y� i' / } � J �i F � �.�;,,` �, , ��' � I x � Fr �� ? �� '�� -� Y � _ f �� i � i ,��`, i a ��. � � V ., j i r� , � ' � . � `� .. y �� y � �l . ; , r �yi ,� . . - �� '!� � q�,i y , % � p I�. � ,� L ' �7 S �� F � .:,1 �X , � � � � y f� 1 i � 't� ,�,�`� � a ,�. i '�� .. : * y -.y .. ��i t a �1c��F�: . ��, . ,.,� . , . : , � ....� ' , ,. , .. . '. ,.. � � .. , ,_ �_ ..., .�.. .... ' ; s+, �� t�� _ ,.. .;.., ...�. . . �,.:�� 1,!. s. ... .r . - , .. � ,..�.w�. �... r . _, ....�:�..a . . _ . . ,. . .. . .,._ , . . � , w. vn, e.... , A ., l.t.r" ..xPc. .la , _ r� y� .:t ' ' ; ` �. �. _. ,y,,"V "'S - �' 1 �.>t � � �. �,�.� � { ' � � t +'�� '.1 t � -? ��. 54f;y �_t Y :'f''i ��'�`, �� 1 �,: . r 't � s � tr' �.,,5 ? ".. 4T�*`'1'�;:- T�`� � E'._ Y ..-i x �� /�� '; t � f � ��R �: s c � ��'� � i f_� S { � �i,� yfu. � � '� �, . T *f .. , / .:. . . � t -& _ lr t ? �i3' .�� J e.., q: fi z. �, �)� ��' S�-i t ' '�r .. y' #k . i: ��. ) ¢.� t t :{`4 �?q t ��'e�: ,y1+w� • , J' y$ f �+ -4, �a r rt L � ��' � .y� }� ?�' ' � x± �� s ' t-�r»'�§�t° �` ` � .c ` . �Sa. .y� E �`�•�',�ye�. '^ � �"s�'r'� � s ,S t �. �t�. .._ . � v + '� � `�d a .�� x: � y - z y�� .* �� e s-� r - ;a .s �i s�� [ t ��m �`-� � 'A�c`*'..P. �,� �f '':.� + � � ' g� � � .s y '§�+ ` �i > .A r'� � i yv: � z� +s �,' � � �t �. ` �1� /� �:� rt r�i �:� 4�. �., r. � _ x ' . 3S 7 t+ ~ . .Y , � �' � �r" i y4� � f ��'i '�rk �� ' ��Y �'a 7x�� , � f' �� 3� �; 5�� -.� , � ,� y �' : :, .�,c�� , , � ,' , � r . i F` ��` � � � J � i r�"A �`� f i � b��i ,�_. ,� . S ' } 5 1� �A �� F, . � �F �° � s- �g ' i,� `e �' �;�+� ,� � �t �.G . ,� �' � � d d ?�' �;t d �' � r: � '� s?? . i ' �z' � � r- ` i t� `,, h f F h : f �T��• �. 3 � �+ ;�� y �'� ,.r } � f �z t}v, ��, � Y J t ,, t I1�' ^d ��, _ 1`/ � Y .�I �S >�I'f � r 1, t k : 3 ,"'�" � t` ^, g ��, � �� - ,.rt , �r,.� � � � � .� ' 4; .'3 �� . :j� . . '* �� .� f' . �. , � . .. . . . *' _ :. r'F � ^l . � f.'. �� S �J�� ~ ai ' �'+. k � 1 �x I�� f _ R�- •4 ,I. ,E-� �f h .:.�. .��_.', . t � +:-�, ...,- i '�'�� ::: �� ::n . ;� -.:��: � � . . , .. � ,� . ' �'��' _ ... t y � _ .` ? , :.�i .., � � - 4 �'. i � �' ,,' } `.' } s�`say � � - '$'1 ��t A� fl� j, ' � d P•rj J i , � � h Y.�. „ � j 5 @� 9 �-js� .�. � r �i � �. ': .:t�� ^�� 1 h � xy �� 1 � � �� t �1 � , ` ��}.,h ° � �.g?''' : � ..,� { �� S i ty ,: ��t t s ' R'� � �q.'�x�t��'yt �.n s 1�{ z� r � r 'r � .Y y 4 �} :t�,� �� Y -� �i {� ! , �F � . � �� '� � �� y� 'r'�3�''�� 4 41�t5�' i�.� �'.. .,� , t� r M S i :l°h�� i a 5�Sr -.:? . 4' � .�� . � �\ �- 1 j S 1 ^ Y! '�v: � < ,rFG , ' � ,� ,�� .�,� {..'� � .` s� �# �:i h�� Y � rk1 �J, i � � �'' .1 j, \ _ 5. �� -,r �� ; f ��, r �� 3 3 +'�u��Y � `"r�"`I r ; T� y�t q '" , ' ,.f� � , � R T � ; _^� � ,f � M1 �, 1`Y�.;' � ,�� ; �S ! ,� 2 . _. 6 � 1 : -' � _ .^,. ' �`.� y+�,I Aj � { ! � li � 1 '�` � ` t t ,! i �y iaY 3 :. * ! � �_ f � a � �! ! � � � ��2 � S'..� � �� '� .� � � t,� i�- ��3' t . d .4�€ s� �. i n" � ' �'�. ; �'' .�� '� r'�� 4 , a - �' - -.r '�, _+ -.� � �, . y, ' a � � ;�. �i'° � � g K- ��. �i f' 4 .�� l 1 - .� 4 c iS i l f j � ' .t _y�' f � # �} � "�r ' � � , �'. � t � d„�iy�. 'i `n�."�� ,K '` � `t` --'� a �� 5�'� � �` ��r�� "� �� . � .%t 7�' � � } �.r..� � '`,� '� »� � "a'�� '/: . t,.' �, ,h t= � s1 - � �. . � , 1 ` �`k,v ,e . - �� . _� ' . _ `. � ut i� �- r�: r: . Y 1. ;i :�. _ ' ' .. . .. ' . ,. ... ,.., �. . ._ ..� . . , . , .; -'_; '� . _ '�, , . fi L � . ' : . . ::, . .i � ... .. �. . �-�, ✓ } . �} 41 .�,,�,, - [+ •� 4 , r � �� . � . . " i �n�3' T - ,,_/ t `ti � u: �� a , �" - / � . ' - i: i`�" 'i � / i � � F / ' - `�. �„ ,t�' "k :•ze � r � = s ` ;s �,j y` � � ' .€ � �., i `� 3� ` X�_ `t _�' � A� '� ,% � � � a( � � 1 t p�� 1 �� f 2 -� d - �„�a, �1 f ,,f � f �!+ . '/ � ' �a `,i _ 3. � �,. - Y,�� , �, _ � � ,: . � ; �� ; � ,� _, , � i , .. . �. . , '�, � �'� �t hf' _ t r T� �� - � � t� - n � -� � { ,�� ' '�-� �.r� ` M .�.N.>., ti_ „._ . .<.\ ,:1c.' .. � , , . � ., .,r. �"? _. ., . ., � .a., r"c �.�.ti.t ..wc:...,. ...Ra.s ,.. .,..... . ., ... .. . . , . . _ . . .. _ . . � � � Z �---__ Q w � � . � � � " � H � �{ � H � � x A "' fl} � � a � `� m ro a� � I � `� -� ,�,.?� 't�$C t T! oA �i 4 � CITY OF SAINT PAUL ° ��„ ro DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT �m °11 �� Aa DIVISION OF PLANNING 25 West Fourth Street,Saint Paul,Minnesota 55102 +ea• 612-292-1577 GEORGE LATIMER � - MAYOR - May 8, 1987 _._.. � __ -� � � t-:: rn Albert Olson, City Clerk °- ° Room 386, City Hall __ ;' Saint Paul, MN 55102 RE: Zoning File #10091 - Donald Robinson City Council Hearing: May 14, 1987 PURPOSE: A rezoning from RT-1 (one and two family residential) to OS-1 (office-service) to accommodate real estate and contractor's offices. Original request to rezone to B-3 (general business) was amended by letter, dated April 21, 1987. PLANNING COMMISSION RECONIl�'IENDATION: Deny B-3 ZONING COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Deny B-3 STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approve OS-1 SUPPORT: Original petition submitted with twelve signatures, District 3 sent letter in support of OS-1. OPPOSITION: Three people spoke, one letter submitted. Dear Sir: On April 16, 1987, the Zoning Committee of the Planning Commission held a public hearing on this rezoning. The petitioner testified. At the close of the public hearing, the Committee voted 6 to 2 to recommend denial of a B-3 rezoning. On April 24, 1987, the Planning Commission upheld the Zoning Committee's recommendation on a unanimous voice vote. This rezoning is scheduled to be heard by the City Council on May 14, 1987. Please notify me by May 12, 1987 if any member of the City Council wishes to have slides of the site presented at the public hearing. Sincerely, �/ 0'VIV�G`� A�� Donna Datsko Planner II DD:rm Attachments �� PETITION TO AMEND ZONING CODE CITY OF SAINT PAUL ZONING OFFICE USE ONLY File # � D q� � -�� Application Fee $ � e.,�e � �� ,�-1 Tentative Hearing Date I �►�lZ Number of Lots or Size of Parcel: � � � ------ -- TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL DATE �ebruary !D �-� 19�.Z— c/o Zoning Office, 1100 City Hall Annex Saint Paul , Minnesota 55102 Pursuant to Section 64.210 of the St. Paul Zoning Ordinance and Section 462.357(5) of the Minnesota Statutes, Donald R. Robinson , the owner of all of the land proposed for rezoning, hereby petitions your Honorable Body to rezone the following described property: Street Address: 735 South 1�obc�rt St st- pa,�i.� T�'�i nn _ Legal Description: South 1Q �eet o� Lot 8, and all o� Lot 9 and 1.Q, Paul Martin' s Re-arrangement o� Block 1.44 West St. 'Paul. from a Resid�ntial �T= � Zoning District to a Cor.�mercial ,�'¢� �"� Zoning District for the purpose of Conduct o� a Real. Estate O�fice therei.n� and Contractox� s sho�s. . Subscribed and sworn to By: before me this /O '-'� day � Donald R. Roba;nson of , February 19�2 Title: owner ,�„�••�,�.�,n��,.�.:w�., Page 1 of ' h!'t�i,1�.� N ar P u bl i c t�` ��'��`w"y 4080 ` F'�-� t��tttrp.�tt.�--n:�:�-��:� `` 2/85 A, , �y� ltA�'1'1�'COu'�Y't ;: /�z..s0 NeT//��f _ r A�1'00�','�,fi�' *.�''� 1A�"�1�,t�S" > �i�✓]�'ON /g/�A�JNf} /,/f �v'i;n,-�v�!rvwvw�^vv:�r�w►��V.,:, �}�,��3> '�►,� � ` � � a� ��f� W �.�� iLE �— � �S'6 N, Gv9 9� 9 �� c. , /`�.v.� ��5�o Z - " -r �- '�� + i� � ' . CONSENT OF ADJOINING PROPERTY OWNERS TO REZONING We, the undersigned, owners of property within 100 feet of the total contiguous descriptions of real estate owned, purchased, or sold by Petitioner within one year preceding the date of this petition, acknowledge that we have been furnished with the following: 1 . A copy of the Petition of Donald R. Robinson name of petitioner 2. A copy of Sections 60. 5�0 through 60. 544 , inclusive of the St. Paul Zoning Code; and � B-3 acknowledge that we are aware of all of the uses permitted under 3 Commercial District zoning classification and we are aware that any of these uses can be established upon City Council approval of the rezoning; and we hereby consent to the rezoning of the property described in the � B-3 Petttion of Donald R. Robinson to a Commercial District. name of petitioner LOT BLOCK ADDITION RECORD OWNER SIGNA URE DATE 15 ' of 8 Paul Donald R. 9 and Paul Florence � , 7 � 3 and �''� 5 and N. Paul David M. 20 ' of n Julie R. So. 5 ' of Paul Gary G. � 6 ,7 ,N. � � 7 Paul H. E. � / � 17 an Paul Robert A. `' 1 5 an 1 �-�L`r Paul Audrey f Lot 14 4 M r ins "''� Taxpayer: ,/� - --� _ Annette Hoaaar h��IZ _ --_ __— s� �.--� Lots 11 , Paul James T. (��_ v 12 and 13 144 Martins Karas 7~ �'��_`�7 Kimberly A. ' Q �� ` . ��, Karas l� N�. 25 of 8 1 00-1 7 West John n _z�,g � Lots 9 10 151 St. Paul Nasseff .C. E.1/3 , 1 &2 100-17 West Donald K. Lot 3 1 1 t. Paul b �-��-�� C.D.Purchaser �- Danie S Klin ner a � � Petitions shall not be considered as officially filed until the lap of 7 working days after a petition is received in the Zoning Office. Any signator of any petition r��y withdraw his name therefrom by written request within that time. �`� P age 2 of 3 ��V�� . �. _._. _ ��.E �/ ��,! _�r �'+� ! CONSENT OF ADJOINING PROPERTY OWNERS TO REZONING � We, the undersigned, owners of property within 100 feet of the total contiguous descriptions of real estate owned, purchased, or sold by Petationer within one year preceding the date of this petition, acknowledge that we have been furnished with the following: 1 . A Copy Of the Petition of Donald R. Robinson name of petitioner 2. A copy of Sections 60 . 540 through 60. 544 , inclusive of the ' St. Paul Zoning Code; and B-3 acknowledge that we are aware of all of the uses permitted under d Commercial District zoning classification and we are aware that any of these uses can be established upon City Council approval of the rezoning; and we hereby consent to the rezoning of the property described in the � B-3 Petition of Donald R. Robinson to a Commercial DiStriCt. name of petitioner LOT BLOCK ADDITION RECORD OWNER SIGNATURE DATE E.2W. 2/3 100-171 West Thomas G. 3/�;/ of 1 , 2 3 151 St. Paul - > � est St.Pau Lester A. � .� Lot 8 9 Im . S n. 1 M Marion J. • Mor est St.Pau Eliseo ( � f� �-f Lot 9 9 Im .S n. 1 Cast ' �� est St.Pau Eliseo � Lot 10 9 Im . S n. 1 - � Paula 0. � `/O D est St. Pa 1 Elvira � � � Lot 1 � Petitions shall not be considered as officially filed until the lapse of 7 working days after a petition is received in the Zoning Office. Any signator of any petition may withdraw his name therefrom by written request within that time. P age 2 of w .3 � ._ ..,.._ .. .... Z��G �� __�,.__.,_ -, � 2/ ---...�.� ,_ ��..�--_. - � �.1:: :�_.:�.�. ._ _—_______�._��...��...---�wr.w.OT1'�+S•.�`I?.i'ST....�.�.'L2'�.�.'X.��.p•r4:..�...'.. _.Lr . _�R�v�..��i.�1.y.T�f�R��r�'t'��<rWfi!_'�t� ..�...'Y�14��7.�s:'�f�f+LAKAVn/'Y�r±, . .. a.`. ...." . . .��..'Tl'IT• _ . .. . a+sJVAStr i•w/+;p�� i + . s � STATE OF MINNESOTA) : SS COUNTY OF RAMSEY ) Donald R. Robinson and Gerald G. Klinqner , being first duly sworn, deposes and states that he is the person who circulated the within petition and consent, consisting of 2 pages; that affiant is informed and believes that the parties described are the owners respectively of the lots placed i�nediately before each name, that affiant is informed and believes that each of the parties described above is the owner of property which is within 100 feet from any property owned or purchased by petitioner or sold by petitioner within one (1) year preceding the date of this petition which is contiguous to the property described in the petition; that except for none of the parties described above has purchased or is purchasin property from petitioner contiguous to the above described property within one �1) year of the date of the petition; that this consent was signed by each of said owners in the presence of � this affiant, and that the signatures are the true and correct signatures of each and all of the parties so described. � �� ` .f p es�.r�`,�"l��r;n�i� 735 So. Robert St. St. Paul, rZinn. • 222-1777 Telephone Number Subscribed and sworn to before me, this 12thday of pqarch , 1987 Notary P i .. Approved as to form - Feb. 85 Page _,� of 3 Planning Department ��Ot�G FILE �� • �� P' WES�' O SIDE CI7�'IZENS ORG�ANIZATION �?09 Weat Pcge, St. Potrl, MN SS20T 292-8020 March 31 , 1987 To: Mr. Gerald Klinger, Klinger Realty Councilmember Jim Scheibel • . . From: West Side Citizens Organization, Paul Mandell , CO Re: Rezoning A�plication for 735 S . Robert This is to noti�y all interested parties that the WSCO Building and Land Use Committee has recently acted to recommend approval for the rezoning request pending for 735 S. Robert from RT-1 to B-3. The committee was acting on referral of the matter from the full WSCO Board at their March 9 meeting. At the committee meeting on March 11 , staff presented the packet of information in their hands and then had Mr. Klinger present his plans in detail , including architect ' s drawings . The committee was well satisfied with the thoroughness of Mr . Klingers responses , recognizing that while late, was all in order beyond any doubts . Tt was because of the late notice that the full Board had referred it to committee rather than set a precedent allowing for a change in a strongly participative process .by rul- ing on an item that had not gone through committee review. The committee did review his plans for improving the corner and the traffic flow, along with his intentions for the future . They came to recognize Mr. Klinger' s professionalism and his good intentions to help the community, and acknowledging the trends along Robert Street as a major thoroughfare, then passed unanimously their recommendation to the WSCO Board for approval of the rezoning request . This action will permit Mr. Klinger to set up his Real Estate office along with a �eneral Contracting office w�hout storage on site. The WSCO Board will be meeting on Apri,l 13 to review the recommendation , and I will be advisiing interested parties again at that time of the Board action. � , � ! , i � t . � � , �' � ; . � _ . i i � . ' .. � ' I � � I ; � i F Yr � � � _ ; i .. f `, � d. � + ! i , _ � � .., , ' P � '' •�1' � ,� • :�• � �1�� . - � �� SID� � ' CITIZENS � ORGANIZATION 209 West Pa�e, St. Paul, MN SS10? 292-8020 April 15 , 1987 To: Members of the St . Paul Planning Commission___ From: WSCO Board, Planning District 3 Re ; Rezoning of 735 S. Robert At the April IIoard meeting of the West Side Citizens Organization, the WSCO Board approv.ed .the rezoning.�ofl 735 South Roliert� hut rather than rezoning from its present RM-�1 to the reque,sted B�3, the Board approved a rezoning to OS-1 , allowing for whatever non-conforming use permits might be deemed necessary for Mr. Klinger to conduct business � as he had planned. The B.oard ,took this action based on their desire to maintain some control over the �evel o£ commercial development along Rohert Street , where there is still a mix of residential and business zoning. The Board did, however, want to help Mr. Klinger, who has shown good faith and has developed some plans that are viewed as improvir�g the area. Should you have any questions , please feel free to contact us . cc: Councilmember Jim Scheibel ' I � ' ! I _ r �� . � _ � r � '�. ; � � �� 1 4 _ �� r: �. • � ;; : , :.� t � , � ti , . , � _ • ; i� j � � C . ` � � G+ �'� �:.-r � ITIZEN PAR ICIPA I DI I ...,,•�' ., ,, �aT� M � � Y � � t r 1 i I � � A+ 7 j N�l.r7. �[ 1 . 1G�P � � 1 a' .�w� r . 12 �� € �.,:� _ �� 2 , ,, ,, ; � s ; � 5 � �,: . �. .,, ' � a � � r :,o.. .. �..�...rc .� F f w.�w M � J' y f ' � 4` s y n .,d.. �. � o 3 .a..� � uu u � w w a� � t � i � M ,�'�.. ' 11 ` { � rcn i v e ..o � Y w�... .� ! �• ` f t. i i � � ........,. � •, _ � ?+ � y � � w n i � F ' 4 , � . E i f � ~''•• • • O ,-M � 3 ` � o � ��~ ....,..,., ., .... .� �. , • . . � .,� ,� �--- � ' � `p ".� ,. _ .. ,M„ `+i, � , • sw,. M / Jc'► a� `'4 / I � � ` wp s � � � �+ � ^ j n c..n .� �L�t '� ��'° o /� i a e F � � �� ♦ �� 's + o�o � .,.,,�.. N 9 �;. � �,.� yf� uau v � i �w�' � ' ,.�on.. N ✓ i � F � 1 i i i • � F � � j 1� = p f � � : 11 E � ` � � � .i`� � � s � � �`' � � r..� 1.w. � rc. � . :..e A .«�.rr.e �' � � A c �oc � ... � ,M ' t A �C9 St �7 � � , = w.�a., ut S � � : rti �x�✓r �� , \�` �a ; � ` ' � \ � t ��p �� / / 1 °.a � M � l_��' �� \ 0 IOGD Ut[ WO ry(1 �W � CITIZEN PARTICIPATION PLANNING DISTRICTS 1.SUNRAY-BATTLECREEK-HIGHhI00D ST SIDE 3.WEST SI ��'� . S BLUFF 5.PAYNE-PHALEN 6.NORTH END 7.THOMAS-DALE • 8.SUMMIT-UNIVERSITY 9.WEST SEVENTH ' lO.COMO . 11 .HAMLINE-MIDWAY 12.ST. ANTHQNY 13.MERRIAM PK.-LEXINGTON HAMLINE 14.GROVCLAND-MACALESTER 15.HIGHLAND 16.SUMMIT HILL 17.DObJNTOWN � � , ! I ; ; i ; ; i � • � f M , "� � � � � d' { F i � i � , . . � . � . .. l � � 1 � � ! .. [`.'.' 7 .� . . April 20, 1987 Honorable George Latimer �� Rm.#347, City Hall ��r �D 18 W. 4th Street � St. Paul, Minn. #55105 Dear Sir; ��e sold our home at 735 South Robert Street, St. Paul, Minnesota, last Septemb�r 30th, 1986 to a youny man named Donald Robinson. Lesc than tcao �aeeks after the sale, we received word from former neighbors that the house �aas taken over by a man named Klinger who turned our old house into a Real Estate office. Our home of twenty-two years is located on the corner of South Robert Street and Sydney. Now, in 11pri1, c.e ur� gettin� ca]1s from back there--pre�Pnt olc.c�r neighbors still living in this neighborhoo�3, that he, Mr. Klinger, has applied for and is attempting to change the Zoning of this blocic to incor�r- ate a cabinet making business in the basement; a construction Company from this residence; and about nine�rl;iny placs, to the rear and si.de of this residential home. We understand from received letters and pt��ne calls, that the neighk�or- hood/neighbor� on Su�ath Rok��rt Street object very much to him doinc� some- thing lilce this. Now, I don't lcnow if this letter will do much to help their cause, btzt they callecl us--lon� distancP--out here in Denver, Colorado (where �ve moved from South Ro�ert :�treet) after living there for some twenty-two years. I realize the are busines�es both up and down South Robert Street, but not in this particular blocic--700 blo�:k--and have been for years. But these r,00d pe<�ple, who have lived in this particular block for many, many years, are trying to l:eep this residential neighborhood from being turned into more business places. When tli�y took the time to call us out here, they are plead- ing a desperate czu;�. These people have lived there for many, many years and would li]ce t� lcec�p it just a residential place to live. I certainly hope this letter will hel�� their respective cause. We feel like we owe the:;F c�ood people, present c;oud St, Paul citi2.en'�, some help in tYieir desires. ' Follo�riru., �:re a l.ist c�f questions I'd lilce to have answered, tYi�t havP come into r,i,� r�� cl: 1. Why is Mr. Klinger pushing for a change of a R-1 Resident:i��] DistricL to a B-3 Commercial District when apparently his full. name i� iiot on ar,y rc�cii�tration/property paperwork? 7_. ��hy was Mr. Y.linger permitted to operate a Real F.state .busin- ess from our old residrri�e at 735 Soizth Robert StrePt with�iit ��r��r zoning; pro�>er permits since October O1, 1986? It is not cic�ar to mc� if Mr. Klinc�e�r��rofe��ional--semi-agent--has a true meaning. � 3. li� �-c�Cc�rc�i►c�c� t,o tlic vacant lot prop��ty, lc��..�tc�d ir� t:li�� 7l)0 blc�ek ��1- �.ivin��:;�on, iL i�i��s I�een rum��'c�d Lhat Mr. l<l �iricJc�r, �iLt��m�.,1,��c1 Lc� E�urc�l�a:sc� a v�Gar�t; lc�t uCCc�1'c:cl Cc�c `�l�i,QUQ.UO foC u Lotal oL $G,OOU. OU to Ll�c pre,�ent �wcler, u►�I;�iutrr� r��:�nie of ��nr��lia�c�r. Page O1 of 02 Pages �. i ; � . ; _ I . : , � , , I f �.i. ' . . . .:j (� � �� ' � � ��i .... . � . . . � V .,� � i � � � i � � ', Page #O1 Continued' q, From information -received about my past next door neighbor's house and property--725 South Robert Street--it was just purchased by a Mr. Iflinger--supposedly Mr. Klinger Sr.s son--with the older Mr. Klinger's name not mentioned on the papenrork. Who knows what his future plans are for this property? 5. 7 realize some of the above conditions are just rwnors, as I am not presently living in St. Paul anymore, but, as mentioned in the al�ove letter the entire neighborhood is totally upset with the manner of business siag- yested. Thank you for the time consumed in reading the above information, and please, feel free to respond, as I am quite concerned with this entire situation. �, . , �-` � �� r�'' , Ac�� s . . T:mil T. Kleidon ✓ . Concerned former owners 735 South Robert Stree� St. Paul, P4innesota #55107 Presently r�siding zt: CC: 5618 South Youngfield 4�ay ' Littleton, Colorada ��80127 James Scheibel Ward #02 Rm.#716--City Hall 15 4d, Kellogg �t. Paul, Minn. #55102 � Donna Datsko Planning and Economic Development Rm.#1100, City Hall 25 W, 9th Street City Hall Annex St. Paul, Minn.#55102 P�ge #02 of 02 Pages � � ; .� . . . , . � , � �� ; � � _ � ; � � :; r .. E � : � � , � , .� : � a ` �� ? � � � �- �'.��' ZONING COMMITTEE STAFF REPORT FILE # 10091 1. APPLICANT: Donald R. Robinson DATE OF HEARING: April 16, 1987 2. CLASSIFICATION: Rezoning to B-3 3. LOCATION: 735 South Robert Street (northwest corner at Sidney) 4. PLANNING DISTRICT: 3 5. LEGAL DESCRIPTION: Ex. N. 15' of Lot 8 and all of Lots 9 and 10, Paul Marin's � Rearrangement �� 6. PRESENT ZONING: RT-1 ZONING CODE REFERENCE: 60.540 7. STAFF INVESTIGATION AND REPORT: DATE: 4/2/87 BY: Donna Datsko — ��sa A. PURPOSE: To permit the establishment of a real estate office and contractor's shop. B. SUFFICIENCY: The petition was declared sufficient by the Planning Division on March 19, 1987; 14 parcels eligible, 10 parcels required, 12 parcels signed. C. PARCEL SIZE: The parcel has 60' on So. Robert and 140' on Sidney for a total lot area of 8,400 square feet. D. EXISTING LAND USE: The property is now used as a real estate office with a dwelling unit on the second floor;a small, detached one-car garage faces the alley. E. SURROUNDING LAND USE AND ZONING DISTRICT: North: One and two family residential, RT-1 i� East: Residential and commercial, RT-1 and B-1 South: Commercial, B-3 West: One and two family residential, RT-1 E. ZONING HISTORY: Prior to 1975 this parcel was zoned commercial. F. FINDINGS: 1. The applicant proposes converting the residential dwelling into a commercial establishment for a real estate office and contractor's (remodeling) shops. 2. The applicant has stated that the building would contain no dwelling unit, would �eneXally operate between the hours of R;00 a.m, a�d a;OQ p.m. , would have three to four emplayees and have about 1000' aquara �aet of �loor area, Tl►e amall gure�ga ii� tha reur of the proper�y would be re��noved aiid eurLuce Nurking for nine vehicles would be provided. 3. Permitted uses in the B-3 zoning district include all OS-1 through B-2 uses, mortuaries, manufacturing of small precision goods, car washes, auto repair, new and used car sales and fast food restaurants. Contractor's shops are first permitted in the B-2 zone. 4. The applicant's property is one lot, 8,400 square feet in area, with only 1000' square feet of usable floor area in the structure. It does not seem likely that an actual shop area as well as office area can be accommodated in a building of this size. A more likely scenario would be that offices for both real estate and contractor's work would be situated in the building. This type of activity could be accommodated in the OS-1 zoning district. File #10091 Page T�ao 5. The parcel is a corner lot on a minor arterial and in an area where four streets converge. Within one block from the parcel are found four other business districts--OS-1, B-1, B-2 and B-3. To the immediate north of the parcel and on the same block are exclusive one and two family residential uses however. To introduce an intensive commercial zone such as B-3 to an exclusive residential block is inappropriate. A rezoning to OS-1 would accommodate the proposed uses and would provide a reasonable transition from the B-3 use located to the south and the residential uses to the north of this parcel. 6. The City's land use component of the Comprehensive Plan states as policy 4.2-1 that "the City will support a diverse commercial activity base by working with business and community groups to. . .continue efforts to encourage small business." Policy 4.2-5 states that the City will "review its present . . .zoning to ensure that each zoning classification reflects uses appropriate to the intended application of the district." 7. The District 3 plan recommends a mix of residential and commercial uses along Robert Street " in order to reinforce neighborhood-based commercial development." G. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Based on staff findings 1 through 7, staff recommends rezoning 735 South Robert from RT-1 to OS-1 to permit the establishment of real estate and contractor's offices. _�� i , ;;, , , , , � � ;a . ' ' � � , , , ; `/ , ;', �I I1I I I: �' ,' !� � �. �, : • � �r''�, . � .1, � � � . ' i . ' { : � . �� .�,,.� � ' � ! .I ,,� , i ,, . , ,. � i �1,�..�,�� 1 ,',,.�. „ � � �'.�1� �I � i.. ' 1 ' ,1��..'�I •� J � � •� � '' ��r 1 1 �� ' � •./ ,' rl �1 � .�M ' i �,I',.'�I� . � � � � � � ��"l�� .. � �/ � ' . , . '.G: . .� � ,�. '��. �7 :� 1( . � f �. � . � . � 'I�I.i., �'21 ' , � , �e�,� O �1 . r;i �')} , �''�Yt + ; , ' ' �� y1, � : . � i '1.�� . k; l� 1 ' � *. . ' � ��r t y, '. .:��..1 � � , '" '• , ' �� ,� �� ' �� , ;y,."tiY' .1! . ��...� � +' "�� .,ti' o . � . , : .r. .r'f 1{�'�� , � �y .�,�' ` l?►:�.� f � �. , � �, i, � . �r ; i� � � ', � �� . . � . . i ,'f I � '1;� , ''� , r ' � ��. , . ; � 1 t 5 � F,�.. + '�' - 2 . � h, , � . .x' � . . ' � y.^ . , :,I t � . ,p. . . . . . �•�� ' L ,i�' • �� . . . - J � � ' . � , � ti� A.:' ' � - . . �: i /:1 f . � �. , � ' �' � �.+ • Y ' . � , ' .. . , '; . . � .. . , '. ;�' � � 4 '�, j ; j , '4 , „� :>> , <.� . � � � , � . • • ;,. o� � � ' ', ' . . ' , . ' ' :i ` '� 'i. . , � i F `, . ,, , ` . . I �I�� , ti, C`;�►'`''� • � . � '. -u+.: � '. .tJt�� ..�,.,•„5�, f � l � .' . .t N..� I. .' ��rs . . „ ,� �Q .' � .I� � �r� ��.i.... � ' ' . . � I. . . ,;i; � • . .,, . . � _�,,�i + . : � }� ; , � • � �� ,w � �:� � ,��r , r 'i � � � ' � . .:y ' ;1 `� � �_ - a�.-- - _ � i _` .� � � � r � � � ( ;� � ;� ' , � .,; ; ;� ;;, .� � ` �J �_ . , �.r � ;;� - --- -- -- - ; ! i, � ' _',; , , �:.� ,; o , .' �� - � � i . �� ..` K � I . � i ' ' . �� { � � � � �� . � . , � d o� : � . I ,j�,.w � ; 4 ,n � 1 J;' ,1 `' . ` t'`, � .ti � • ' I I � # �'R 1 .k � �' [1' � " `��; � ,�j� � -�: ��j � t I ;'� H;- •.j� , �i � �;.. ��'"' I �,� � , ' 11 '' � . ,��'� � � ,�' " �`''' 1 a'" f, t f y y�� ': '�� , '.1 . �� '�I[ •,�,: ' .��. . f� � , '� t 'i . ?'•, t .t i . � {. � • �' L .f '� � I, , f . ',. . . �;• ' � ,'4, ��. ,. .. . .� ' ti��'' �,r . .. . *, .. � U -- �'' ; , o o � o � _ o � ooa� � o � o -_ - _ = o . E. BAK R ° � -°--- 0 v ae ---- � g i v — — ; � � — ----- --O ' ..� � � � 7 , - - - --� � '�j � �V ORTO o °C ; � , � � E• � � � , � � � a ° � -- . o ' Q' �; � . � u �, � � o �, : � aeo Z . o � O > -p . : C7 " QB J O �� -- E. Pa�E OS�1 ; - ;�, :. � �-� - �� _--� .;:��. �, � � � � �:.� ..�►��;��:i� �= o , .: , , � :. : -�-. � � � � � :� �� `: __ _ � , , . �: .� �.-. �• i i w ',,;�' t.:, `� ,�' ='' �`1��, • p --� - (� 4J O O r: . �. ��"� � f'' � �, �.> �` � C:� �'' �.:+ �..�'•'•' �.,, 1�,. �� {, n �- �' ` G _ � c �' ,�• ! �, t� � ��J . �� 1 ,., ;.: -- , _/� t.r r,w, �� .n � ��. � tw.n. � --- � �b0�.�. � . E. SID EY - � � � , � � a e � T _�_ o 0 0 �o , - _ .._ _ � � . _ ___ _ _ _ _ _ ,� -�--- --o= o ' ° . � � =a � o •�- � � ST. _ �_ E. P�BLIC �U IC ` c� O OO � �� v Q,_ �� I v �"� � � � , � , i i � � � 0 � � I � � ' � � O � I ' � I � � � � � �� v' � O - � • �� 0 � � E• 6ELVIDERE. ! q b c� � � � a Q o __ d 'ooc� - ° ; � oo '� ; � ► � i i � , , i � � ° 4 4 � � ;_ , � I � I - , • - C � �- -�� - � � i � _ _ i � i p � �� o o� � o b � e � , d b � ' , o � � AREA MAP APPLICANT D�t,qa�� Ro � LEGEND -� S[zcL -- — ZONiNG DISTRiCT gOUrvDARY PURPOSE Re?�.nQ �rdY1^ CLCll� SUBJECT PROPERTY p�_ 1 .� �_.� O ONE FA�AILY ��.�r�rvirv� ,�' �� GiSI'RICT FILE N0. I DDqI TWO FAMILY � DATE ��' O MULTIP�E FAMILY • � n COMMERCIAL SCALE : ��= 200� NORTH � r� INDUSTRIAL �tAP N0. SAINT PAUL PLANNING 80AR� V VACANT 7 �' ;. � .... .�, . -� ��. . ._ _.� � � �' �- �"�� ST. PAUL CITY COUNCII. PUBI.IC HEARING NOTICE 1 ZONING To : Property owners within 350' ; ' Representatives of Planning District 3 FIL E N 0. PAGE ioo91 PURPOSE To rezone from RT-1 (one and two family residential ) to S-1 office-service district) to accomodate real estate and contractor' s offices. LOCATION 735 South Robert Street (northwest corner at Sidney) PETITIONER DONALD ROBINSON H E A R I N G Thursday, May 14, 1987 10•00 A.M. � Citv Council Chambers, 3rd Floor City.Hall - Court House Q U E S T 10 N S Zoning 29s-4154 (Donna Datsko) Contact the Zoning Section of the Planning and Economic Development Department, Room 1101, City Hall Annex, 25 W. 4th Street, St. Paul, MinnesoLa 55102 Legal description : South 10' of Lot 8, and all of lots 9 and 10, Paul Martin' s Rearrangement of Block 144. Notice sent 5-1-87 • . - .- j . `-. : : . ' �� • ,, . ' - : , . . � - i ' . i • . _�.�. ,; : _ _ ; . • . <V �� , _ , - , . . . .� ..�.. . . �... . . . ._ J .. , . . - .. ._. . . ... :i . � :. . . , � _ ' � ..:�' . . �:, .. . :^ . --� . . ,. - . ..._� '_ ,' . . . � � � . � . � � . .. � . . . . .. .. . . . . •.. . � . . . �. . :. ��. ,': ._ . . _ . . . . � _ .. �. . � • � . � _ - .. , . ., , � - y��_ NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING ' _ I` �tt� . . ; . . _ - __��. _ : . . ;,� _ ;_�'�"`�.� A petition having been filed requesting that the Zoriing Ordinance - ..: ,s of the City of St. Paul, be amended so as'to rezone from RT-1•to -,:�,;= - OS-1, property described as So_ 10 feet of Lot 8r all of Lots 9 and - -- . : �,_. 10, Paul Martins Rearrangement of: Block 144. �� The property is located - _� ° ` at 735 So. Robert�Street (northwest corner at_Sidney). The Council - .��_ .�� . . , of the City of St: Paul.has fixed the�:' - � ~��"�10:00 - A.M. in the Council Chambers in the_ City�HalT. of said City and ,at ' ` ` . �.;' said time and place,. the Council will_hear:'_all persons and al,l objectials � . - and recommendations telative to the proposed amendment.� � � '. � r.� , ` ; � , ,,. ,.:, : : _ . ,� - Dated April 28� 1987 ' - � - -'-� � - __,_ A7,bert B. Olson _ . _ F �.- . . ; . , , -,5,- City Clerk � � -- , � - �� . _ . . : - .-::.., (May 2. �198'�) .. . . . . : - - ' _ i: . . . � . . � . •• _ . . . . � � - . - _r. . . .r . . _ . . . . . .. . : ,.- . . ;- ,.. . . . . .' . - :. .. �_ _ . . . . �. , . _. _. __. . � . . �' . , ..:... . , . --� . . . . . -. . � . .... . � - ��. , . ,. : . . . , -- ,�;-. . . . .. . . . �. . . . . . .. .. . . �.. . .� - , .�� _ � . '�. �� ,. . � ' � � . .. � . .. . � � . . : .. . -� . . . ��'� . . . -• . . . �� . . . � . .. � .. .. . � . - � � . , .... � .. . . .. _ � .: . , . - . . � - - ' , . .. , . . . . . .. . -, _. ._ - . . . . , . \. . . - . . . ��- .� . _ __ . ._ . � � . � .. . � � , _ '� � -� . . . ... , . . . . � _ _ ��:. J ., - .�... � _!: . . �.� �� .. . � :,. .� �� -.. , .. . .. '. � ..-. �.. � ,. ' ,�>?` . . . ; . .� .�. . ��.. . � � .• :::_-. . .� �. �. '• ' . .. _ � . ' :. - - � ' .- . .. . , . . . - � . � . _ ... �)-'•� . . . , . . _ . . . _ _ � , � _ ._. . . , , _ , �:.. .. . F,.. �.. . . . ' : �.,.. ; ..'"`j "� �� . � � . . . . . . ' . � _ '�(."}�,� .. � .-. ... . .�_. ,,. �. .. :' .<� .;: . � .�� .. � � . . . , .. �_ .� . �4.. � v.. r . . ' . . �..� ' . '. � - . .�. . �,.. . .. : . -.; . ; .. , � . ; .: , " . - . .. ', ,' ' . . . . � _. . . .. . ... �.. �' , ,. . xn•;.. . � . � � . . � � . . � ��. � � . . � . - . � . a .. .. . _ . . - . ._ .'. .- . . . , . � ��4�-ra .��.� . . .. . ., . ' .. . .. . ' . . . . . .. __ ��' . . ' - - . _ . .. . � . . .. ' . ,.�o.c,,.� -_. � �� . . . . . ' . . ; . . . _ . , � , . � �'y�.-. . � . . ...� . .. . . . , -. . ' '._-. y, . . - : . .. � . . .. . . . .. . - �.,_�_ .:, . .. . � � . . . � � . � . . ; . .• _ . - . . . . . . ;�,,� i ' . ' . ' . ..- _ ' . . :. . � , � ., . � .� - . �. �- : . ,.� -. '� � - ' - � � .� � � z��:s� . . . .. ' . . . - � � ' . . .. . . . ��, , � . . . . . . . . . . .' - . ' . � . . . . . _ _ '. � .. . . .. . . � . .. ' .. � .°7''„- /' � " � � . . . . . � . . , ' � .' . �. . . . . - .�:'`�: . � . � � , . . � . � . .n� . � . . . , � - . . ! - . . - . . . � . . � . . .. . . ' .. � . � - . ... � . . . _ ._ . �. . . . . ' � . . . . ' -. . � � . � � . � � '. �:�. ' . . .. ' . . .. . _ . . . .,_�: '..' . . , . . ." ..., ... . � . . � .. . . � . . . . � . ' ' . . ' . . . . , . . . , . � ' " . ' t_.;.. , - . . . . . �,�. . . . . . .' _.' . . . . . �. . . .....� . . . � ��,� . . . ' ' . _ . . . . .. ';7.. . � .. ' � . . . . � � . . . .:. . .. � . - ' . ' � .. . .. .. � � ' . . ' . . .�.. . . �.. .:. . ..... .:, . ' � . . . -, .: . . � . .� . ,. i - .:-: . �: ... !�.$ .. ,.. . ,-. _ ��; .. T . . . .� - . . . '�_:� , . �. � � ' . . . � � - ' , .d'�" � � �- .. � , •a - . . _ .. ., . .. , - _ . _ . , .. . . - . .. . .�', . _:�. ,_��. '. . . ._'.... :.�,�.. ..� . ... .�::. �. - . _ . , _ .. . .. .. • . .. . . .' ��..� . . i� � ,�- . . .-... .� ._ . .. _ .. ,�. . . ... - _ , ; . .. . ; . �;, . , ,.' . .�. : .:-: _ . .. , . � � � ✓ � � ST. PAUL CITY COUNCIL � PU6�IC N� EARING NOTICE ZONING - To: Property owners within 350� ; fiL E N 0. Representatives of Planning District 3 PAGE loo9i PURPOSE To rezone from RT-1 (one and two family residential ) to ��office-service district) to accomodate real estate and contractor's offices. LOCATION 735 South Robert Street (northwest corner at Sidney) PETITIONER DONALD ROBINSON HEARIN6 �urgd8y, May 14, �9s� �o:oo A.M. . Cit Council Chambers, 3rd Floor City Hall - Court House Q U E S T10 N S Zoning Z9s-4154 (Donna Datsko) Contact the Zoning Sectinn of the Planning and Economic Development Department, Room 1101, City Hall Annex, 25 W. 4th Street, St. Paul, MinnesoLa 55102 Legal description: South 10' of Lot 8, and all of lots 9 and 10, Paul Martin' s Rearrangement of Block 144. Notice aent 5-1-87 . _ . '.- rn��p �,-'�.y�ce'AC`'s�:�.,,r ��rd��t �- _ . N��(i�P��"��' � <,. � : � A tatiop ..��.uesting t�it t� <.. � 4 r'.' c.�'"{��P ��;:�:; •o�� ts '�eaone'FACf��'F I �� ,� Sa 1 .. � ` ��;"�`��°�rtl�E�'�Id�, -�,. •:�-� 'f'� .. . . � . . ... $ , t�f t� ' �� 3�Q � :' 'C.t�fa�'�'t�`i,�te ot ll�ai - '� �!"�`f ��ldex�i��re��1"�� ' �i �'�t��a��e�ds srs�ii��+d$��, �I�wM�!�� P�1� ' ,Xt r Y � ; * . {(�J :t'�>� ';��n ri�� ,�:,: t �A;D''�., a.'��!'A+a6�1 i'� �i 7'o' ,q.:` '.,M'.j`, +�,�4�I'i�-i..K.�� 3.:s�9'.r y� . , �P�Q`. � . . . '' OL$ON,Cit;�rc�lerk ' pp� ., r<1ii� ,<^ °�� , . �c" "2,°'��!�.#�RR�'� �-.� >� �Z{-.a.�'i,;� . `� ,;'�`- r , *".r, t.....,. . .. . . . ... . .. . .... . . . . . ,,��; �.sa�C-p.c;... . � �� Honorable George Latimer May 1, 1987 Mayor C ity of St. Paul Respected Members of the City Council My husband and I wish to voice our ob�ection to the rezoning of tot 8,9,10 of block 144 from RT-1 to OS-1. We have not been contacted by said petitioner or by Mr. Klinger, who is now occupying said address, concerninq the issue. The building at 735 S. Robert St. is extremely small and we cannot see how it will accomadate said businesses within environmental codes. Also, the porposed 9 car parking lot leaves us concerned as we have two small children. Their safety will be further compromised by traffic on three sides of our lot located at the opposite end of s�id block 144. We feel strongly too, that 'Mr. Klinger has misrepresented the issues involved , and has blantly done his imQrovements without regard to �roper city procedure or to neighborhood attitudes. We feel that the rezoning tQ anythiRg other than RT-1 will lower the market value of our home, raise property valuethus raising our taxes. �� are against this. This is-a_multi-generation neighborhood with pride in their hanes and hertiage. Our children are the fifth generation to live in our home. We would like it to remain that way. For these reasons we are opposed to rezoning now or at anytime in the future. Thank-You Nancy and Alan G. Bertram 711 S. Robert St. St. aul , �4innesota ,� � Q��,�� April 19, 198? The Honorable George Latimer Hayor City Hall 8 Court House St. Paul, ISinnesota 55101 Dear ?[ayor Lntimer: Sub,ject: Zoning File Aumber 10091 Legal Description: Lots 9, 10, and South 10 Feet Of Lot 8 Paul Martin's Rearrangement Of Block 144 West St. Paul Ve, the Undersigned, were asked for our approval of a zoning change for the above-referenced property. Vhen we were asked, we were told it involved a realty companq anly. Because of the�added construction and cabinet�aaking companies� plus nine parking places, we feel Mr. Klinger misrepresented his intentions. Ve would like our names stricken from that petition and wish to maintain the present RT-1 zoning. Respectfully, �(`nSt�h...ryw�S �i.�� b �'• �r�.,��.� �l. �.•� ;r►}✓/ � ? � � � � � �f�.2� � , '��ta..�. 73� �.i✓iN�sr�ti �.v�. ��. �r%m.. �,,�c,�- �2 L; vi n s,�-�r„ .�J c/e . �a� � ' �. . ��u.�P�" � i�`�f .e�-� .� 6K;�t�-S,; • �� . %��—�� ; -� � -� �,� �� ,�./'� <�'. v v. C�.e. ?�a �o• S��-�G�� CC: All St. Paul City Councilmembers May 7, 1987 The Honorable George Latimer Mayor City Hall & Court House S# . Paul , Minnesata 55101 Dear Mayor Latimer : Subject : 2oning File #10091 Legal Description : Lots 9 , 10 , and �outh 10 Feet of Lot 6 , Faul Martir�'s Rearrangement of BlacK 144 West St . Paul In regards to rezaning the abo�e RT-1 to OS-1 We the undersigned property owne�s , want to reaffirm our petition of April 19, 1987 far no zaning chan�e .0ur request is to remain RT-1 ( twa family residential > Sincerely, Barbara J. KratzKe 720 LiUingstan St . Paul , Minnes ta 55107 � GG : A11 St . Pa ty Gauncilmembers �.c.(- ✓��-�� "7��1 x> �o�'�ic%` ��.�� :..�-� � �-�c��►^a.�` '�.?i .��.�o/-�T" 7 si Sh c�c baq' ✓�T. ` —� � / SJ S , ��e� �is�� v�� 7�i ,So �� G�t7� ..cQ�• �� /3.e�,�'.r... ?ii 1'0. �P�r ri. ✓' C� /' ,��'iii"'''� ( ��"`Z<'-.,/ i J� �-� ��G� y >-J�, ,JG /��C`�� S�� .� �',�u� �G ' l -� `�'�'� � -,�., � .` � �fti7�'c/' � /,� �,�-�� °��- �� t 24,�.,, �, � � �2�� 7� � ��ti� �� r�� 7�� ` � C�, � ,-�� —��' 7� � � e i�' � �j� � / U�! J .�N./l.r��JAi L � ✓iri ,r/�f_� '7ti / A Ci�. .' A A . � �.7��/ � �Y� ��' ,� � ` �- �, � �-��%�� -� �v',��\ `/ c3►�-^ /��`, f�� __ � �� 7.3 �� >1 SSiu�'I ��., � ��. C�' ' ,� %� � �� S .��-��,� G -'-�� -� � �� S�� , � ' /��a � � � � �� , � ^ �, � ;� t- . ,�� , �,�� .�� , �, . April 19, 1989 The Honorable George Latimer Mayor City Hall � Court House St. Paul, Minnesota 55101 Dear Mayor Latimer: Sub,�ect: Zoning File Number 10091 Legal Description: Lots 9 10, and South 10 Feet Of Lot 8 Paul Martin's Rearrangement Of Block 144 West St. Paul This property has a sixtq-foot lot with a small one-family dwelling and garage on it. The previous owners, Mr. and �Irs. Emil Kleidon, are appalled at what is happening to their property because they thought they sold their home to a bachelor for his residence; Re: Donald R. Robinson Application for Rezoning. (Mr. Klinger represented Mr. Robinson at the closing, even thaugh Coldwell Banker was the listing realtor). The Zaning Committee �Ieeting on April 6, 1987, was full of false statenents by Mr. Gerald Klinger. It was stated Mr. Klinger bought the above-referenced property without knowing the zoning status. Mr, Klinger, a realtar for more than two decades, stated that he did not find out it was zoned residemtal until he went to get a permit for his oversized realty company sign. I personally called the Building Department once the sign was up and was told no application had been made. �[r, Klinger responded to a question at the meeting as to whether he owned other property in the area. He said one son owns property one block south at Curtice and South Robert Streets. A second son owns the duplex located at ?25 South Robert Street (right next door to the Sub,�ect Property). Also, one of the two sons owns property at 84 East Sidney Street Cacross the street from the Sub�ect Property>, Plus, Mr. Klinger purchasing the Sub,�ect Property. Xr. Klinger did not contact everyone within 350 feet of the Sub�ect Property as stated in t�e Zoning Committee's Public Hearing Notice, mailed April 3, 1987. People not contacted: xayor George Latimer -2- April 19, 198? �r. and �rs. Alan Bertram, 711 South Robert Street Mrs. Clara L. Schnber, 750 South Robert Street Mrs. Grace Bienhaff, 752 South Robert Street Mrs. Frances Kisch, 756 South Robert Street Mr. and 14rs. Ll.,o�d Waite, 76 East Sidne Street, />?�y a�d rlJ�lS ✓ �Se�� t��J � �� .�a. fi�, �i � .��= . The people that were contacted were asked for permission of a REALTY COXPA�TY QNLY; far different than the added request for a construction company, a cabfnetmaking shop in the basement, and nine parkfng places in the back. I do not feel �[r. Klin$er has been up front or honest with the property owners in the immediate area. I, like my neighbors, hope you will maintain the present zoning af RT-1. Sincerely, Barbara J. Kratzke 72�: I.ivingston St. Paul, �tinnesota 5 07 �a�� ,��.�./ � CC: All St. Paul Ci y Councilmem ers /' i � �'' ✓r✓ S J%v i? .t/�:�v.�' �Sd�'"v� � :� l S�: �a��i S %, 5 i. �/�c/� /i��. ��i�,G _ `'��;r,�c �'j. 1,��i.,\_.�..e:�"1� �c%��'/ �i�� . `�'��r��_-'�:��_ �J.�� .�.�-� ��7� . ��'``' � .��;�.t ,��1G. �// _�o �c�v.�� ' ��.P /o''� �'S—/o % ��'�s C�;: - ,l� �r� '�' - ,�', j ' �,e� 7�� -� � 6t'�G�.�" .1�` e°a,,,,�, ,y�,,,, . ss�� ' .� � — �-�.� ��' �'�.�� S s!° � �� os � ��-� , ,.� � �� '( .�. �� ,�.�� ,�-f�� .�� . , �',�� G�'�� t. � �.�� -s--�� - � J//�`�%/`� ' +�a-t�r ! �� ^"^'. /`(= ��G .�J _.�; �� /? ,�� ,�; � % �� / �.. � 7 .. ., � �— r � ` �'� `" �, i� - ��•,t.a,r=k..� '75'G.� .�-c� r'��.-✓-�'x�� .�'�' � � ``� I J �"� � . ��^-I �, i \S �-_ / I `/ .��\ ' �.L,. V J `u-rl�,� ,�,.,,�� ;__,__-�.�-�- � i`'� `�l �' � I L1� ;;��1 C�� v� � ��,�% , � ��. � �.->��--� �� c � �; � , 7�� JC�� -�" Kayor George Latimer -2- April 19, 1987 �f�'S �'KOM✓1'f � �'1/'t ✓� Z 7 �O / .l♦ JCO �sar�� l�'i V'S �1�'V'`�Z�l+�'C F��2 ✓'CZ '�f(i O 5 u �Z.�� G u.r� N!r �o `'.�p �• ?'� v�� 3 7loU So � o l�o �t NlIZS /VlRrin � I�o�av� 73Z S %A C� 5?r-a .. t. - �[r. and �[rs. Alan Bertram, 711 South Robert Street Mrs. Clara L. Schnber, 750 South Robert Street Mrs. Grace Bienhoff, 752 South Robert Street Mrs. Frances Kisch, 756 South Robert Street Mr. and Mrs. Llo�yd 4laite,,76 East Sidne�r Stree� � .� L /'?� �� i�I.ls T�se�� /Kit��S 7 �s .�e. �s�,x � .�� . The people that were contacted were asked for permission of a REALTY COMPAHY ONLY; far different than the added request for a constructian company, a cabinetmaking shop in the basement� and nine parking places in the back. I da not feel �[r. Klinger has been up front or honest with the property owners in the immediate area. I, like my neighbors, hope you will maintain the present zoning of RT-1. Sincerely, Barbara J. iCratzke 720 Livingston at. Paul, �[innesota 55107 CC: All St. Paul City Councilmembers �� ,��- � �' /�e ��- 7•a a°-��-�,,, ,•C� `1��. � �,� �� ,�-, cz.�,�o�u., f I t� �y�t.a�. �. �.a�.u.�e — 73L �� S-�' �-"f�awE. 1�1d.� �s t o� `�I' P�r %(c o .�-Cr. ,D'�Q�G�Zc�7` ��'7Z(/J. _ �,t�,�, � �. ��`� �• r�a�', �'rr1. �Sie 7 �� l��.e-rk,a�+ 7�/ S o �%�,,c . �°. ,� G� . /c� � �. S , � �____________________________� ' KLINGNER`S Ff�E MO'VE�C�IARANTEE � IKlingner Realty will see to it that you receive c contract from Hirte Trcnsfer � ' to move you... kit and caboodle... as soon aa Klingner Realty or Jerry aelis your � I home. Your moving contract is paid for by Klingner Raclty. The controct i: limited � ' to a 25 mile radius from your home and houaehold goods totoling 5,000 Iba. or Isaa. � IShould your move be farther than 25 miles or if your hou:shold goods sxceed � I 5,000 Ibs., you'll only hcve to pay the difference. � � Stop in and taNc to Jerry about oomplete details on this free move oifer! � . I 735 South Robert Street � 1 (Corner of Robert and Sidney) � � 222 - 1777 � �------------------�•---��.��--.� . , . , KLINGNER REALTY '1(L I N�N E �, Jerry Klingner, Broker �REA�TIf 735 South Robert St. \�`� ' ,� , St. Paul, Mn. 55107 � Q•Z�` 1 �7��, � . ..\ ,,\ \ , , � � Call on us anytime . We'll be happy to answer your questions about home values, market conditions, financing,etc. We'll also be glad to explain the detoils on Klingner Realty's FREE moving offer. If you're not quite ready to sell, pass this information along to o friend , or keep it for future reference. YOUR NEXT NIOVE CAN BE � - . , co�pl,�nt: or � i KLIN6I�R REALTY� � . ��' �- 1 � '' r ��r • -r� i 1 I RA $FEd l I plarEasTAt� $�S RAGE, INC. �� . . � . ; � . . ��._ , _ HERE`S AN EXCLUSNE OFFER JUST FOR YOU! CALL 222 - 1777 CALL HERE'S HOW THE OFFER WORKS Every home that Klingner Realty lists is eligible. When your home is sold through Klingner... you'll receive your certificate for your FREE Hirte Transfer move. There are no other requirements ... no tricks or strines attached. It's Klingner Realty's woy of showing that they care about the poople they serve. KLINGNER REALTY C�1N WORK FQR Y4U With a sales record thot ahows that J�rry Klingner's sold over 95% of the homes he's listed, you know that your home is going to get the attention it deserves. You know that your home will be moving off the market... and you know tha� you'II be moving... oomplanerrts of KNngneri The only thing Jerry Klingner needs now to complete the sale of your home... is the listing. � CALL JERRY AT 222-1777 KLINGNER R�AITY BRINGS YQU... EXPERIENCE -25 years * CON[�RN- for community and you * PERSONALIZED HELP - person to person advice * GUARANTEED SALE - A cash offer for your home if you prefer • p�OFESS10t�AL MARKEIING - a free persona) inspection and eycluation oi your property Jerry Klingner SU�S.SFUL RESULTS! Jerry Klingner was born here in St Paul.He'; a graduate of Humboldt High School and involved in West Side Civic affairs. In the past 25 yeor:, Jerrya been tuccosafully selling Reol Estote in the Twin Cities area... over�30,000,000 to datel But it's only the baginning. A brand naw office means a new commitment to servo friends vnd tu:tgmera like yqu. " '" . L ^` ... . �► , �;�;• MOw��A�'S : _ � � �' � '�L�Exii�1i11�LE�.i�il�� o oos .; ., ,_ . „' .. _ .. . S >" �.r.'"s+�{`,�„ ,'.� -=��.S< �..� -�.:s:3''sr:- � ._ � � G� .��. 714 80. Robert St., St. Paul, MK 55107 obert St., St. Paui, MN 55107�� — nJ , _ i .. �• �r , ` , � • � ♦ �" I �.- 1 : � y.� � ' 1 a � , � J . : �rr ,.. _ • .... _� ir -- ?�'��.� �a � •�`. ...�' °�'*,�' � �'} ��. . ��_��,w ,. � � . .:,� ;� . 1 ` - },' ,.. , - ` .,,, _.,�. '�.rn. . ,.;s�,.. . , ' . _ . , ... «r.�i.�+�rt',, �.,� 735 So. Robert St., St. Paul, MN 55107 ._._745 So. Robert St., St. Paul� MN 55107 ___ Wl�AT DO TH �$� FQUE� _ _ _ . BUSI �VESSES HAVE . . _ _ . �N connnnoN?:.:� . ._ . __. . _ : ___ __ . To.find the answers, . _ _ simp/y unscramb/e _ � the phrases listed below! s - - --- _ _ _ .___----___ __�. a . _ STAND BEHIND THErIR SERVICE I Y� � ..�_-- �`' _ .. ��CL.IPPER CGUPON �� 1) datsn nbedih itreh $��;�� ENTRY BLANK � --_.___.__ � — — "�� BELIEVE IN FIRST RATE SERVICE ,�� , ; 2, 1 2) ivlebee n� tfsri aert v��seir. � 3, ; _ �� F��3VING SOUTH $T PAUL FO& �IAi�Y HAPpY YEARS ' I am interested in: � 1 ❑Buyin�a new house o S�ling my home 1 3) gsrienv uohSt tS lau P orf � ❑ Buying a car � C Send entry blank to one d the addra�.5es listed abov+e ` nyam pyaph syrea. � ; ^�e�� ; Contest Ends April 30, 1987 � � `�.•�.r�.�•��.•��....�i► 5 � � c �`�-��' May 12, 1987 Dear Mr Klingner, I am writing in regards to your property located at 735 So. Robert St. In my opinion I feel that you have greatly improved the corner both in appearance and image as far as being able to offer a quality service for the neighboring community. I am personally in full favor of a Real Estate business joining the many other neighboring businesses here on Ro2aert Street. I wish • you the best of luck in ok�taining the OS-1 zoning, I feel your � business would be an asset to the area. Very Truly, . 4 �� -�'.�f/�L� � --. Lester an Marion Mor�an Owners, Morgan's Mexican & Lebanese Foods