87-681 WHlTE - CITV CIERK � �T �� I r •���»�:� �f�7�+/��.�J... �
PINK - FINANCE GITY OF' SAINT PALTL Council �7''� (f- ('��`
. CANARI( �DEPARTMENT �"'X'�X
B,�.UE -MAVOR File NO. �C�
PBB/City Attny. Ordin�nce
Ordinance N 0. �dt. �k�+
1��5�Presented By
Referred To Committee: Date
,� /
Out of Committee By Date
�� -
An Ordinance amending Chapter 409 of the
Saint Paul Legislative Code pertaining
to Intoxicatin¢ Liquor ; nroviding
presumptive r�enalties for liquor
licensed establisl�ments .
THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN:
Section 1 .
That Chapter 409 of the Saint Paul Legislative Cocle is hereby
amended so as to add the following new provisions thereto:
Sec. 489-��- 409 . 26 . Intoxicating liquor; a.d�ae�se
�.ea�}�.gs; ee�.��e��er�s f x�e�a��e�.s; presumptive penalties .
a) Pur ose. The purpose of this section is to
establi�andard by which the City Council
determines the length of license suspensions; and
revocations , ���es-a�.df e�-�ke-p�ae�.�g-e€-ee�.�.�� e}�.s
t�.ge�.-�ke-bt�s��ess-��ee�.ses; and shall apply to all
on-sale and off-sale licensed premises . These
penalties are presumed to be ap�ro riate or ever
case, owever t e�i Councirl ma deviate t ere rom in
an in ividual case where t e Council inds and
determines that t ere exist substantia and com-
ellin reasons makin it more a ro riate to 0
so. en eviatin rom t ese stan ar s t e Council
sha provide written reasons which speci y w y t e
penalty selected was more appropriate.
COUNCIL MEMBERS
Yeas Nays Requested by Department of:
Dimond Q
�� In Favor
Goswitz
Rettman ✓
Sc6eibel A gai ns t gY
Sonnen
Wilson
Form Appr ved by Cit Attorney
Adopted by Council: Date � �
Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY ��l°��
By
Approved by Mayor: Date Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By BY
I � ' - g�"''L70 �
/��
-2-
b) Presum tive enalties for violations . Adverse
penalties or convictions or violations shall be
presumed as follows :
TYPE OF VIOLATION 1ST VIOLATION 2ND VIOLATION 3RD VIOLATION
1. Commission of Revocation NA NA
a felony related
to the licensed
activity.
2 . Sale of Revocation NA NA
alcoholic
beverages while -
license is under
suspension.
3. Sale of S Consecutive Revocation NA
alcoholic Days Sus-
beverages to pension
under-age person.
4. Sale of 5 Consecutive 15 Consecutive Revocation
alcoholic beverage Days Sus- Days Sus-
to intoxicated pension pension
person.
5 . After hours 3 Consecutive 9 Consecutive Revocation
sale or display Days Sus- Days Sus-
of alcoholic pension pension
beverages .
6 . Refusal to 5 Consecutive 15 Consecutive Revocation
allow City Days Sus- Days Sus-
inspectors or pension pension
police admission
to inspect premises .
7 . Illegal 3 Consecutive 9 Consecutive Revocation
gambling on Days Sus- Days Sus-
premises . pension. pension
8. Permit person 3 Consecutive 9 Consecutive Revocation
to leave premises Days Sus- Days Sus-
with alcoholic pension pension
beverage.
_�� `���-�.
.. . . . . �� - �� �
�.r�
-3-
TYPE OF VIOLATION 1ST VIOLATION 2ND VIOLATION 3RD VIOLATION
9. Fai.lure to 15 Consecutive 45 Consecutive Revocation
make application Days Sus- Days Sus-
for license pension pension
renewal prior to
license expiration
date.
10. Violations of 5 Consecutive 15 Consecutive Revocation
City ordinances Days Sus- Days Sus-
pertaining to pension pension
fire or building
or health codes .
c) Computation of time . For the purpose of determining
the number of occurrences of violations , the council shall
consider a violation as a second occurrence if it oceurred
within 18 calendar months of the first violation; and shall
consider a violation as a third occurrence if it occurred
within 30 calendar months of the second violation.
�.� E�-ga��e--eer���ae�s---��-a.-��eense-�a��e�-l�ias-been
se�iedt��e�-�e�-a�.-s�.�e�se-�.ea���.g;-eet�.�.e��-�e�be�s-sk.a.��-r�e�
d�se�.ss-��.e-��ee�.se-�a��e�-6a��k.-eae�.-e��.e�-e�-�a��k-a�.�-e�
��.e-ga���es-�r��re��ed-��-�ke-�a��e�-t��.�esa-st�.ek-�.�seti.ss�en
eeex�s-e�,-�k.e-gxb��e-�eee�d-�.t��}�g-�ke-pt�b��e-kea�}xgs-e�
�k.e-aia��e�-e�-�.�.��r�g-��.e-eet��.e��'s-���.a�-�.e���e�a�}e�.s-e�
�k.e-x�a��e�-
e} d) Other penalties . Nothing in this section shall
restrict or limit the authority of the council to suspend
up to 60 days , revoke the license, e� impose a civil fine
not to exceed $2 ,000, to im ose conditioris or take an otlier
adverse action in accor ance wit aw, e�-�a}e a�}e�.s-e�
ae�.eerxg �anee-�a}�k-a�.-a�g �eab�e-s�e��.�e,-�t��e-e�-e�d}�.a�.ee
�e�a��r�g-�e-e�eeke��e-be�re�agesb provided that the license
holder has been afforded an o ortunit for a hearing in
the manner provided for in Section . �f this Code.
�� �����
. • ' � � ' � ��� � �.
. " r ' ' • ' ' - � �'
� � � ,
W ITE - CIT'I CLERK
P K - FINANCE CITY OF SAINT PALTL Council
C ARV -OEPARTMENT � 7 / �
E -MAVOR File HO. /'C��/
•
' ' Ordindnce - Ordinance N�. --
t ( ,�
Present d By �` _ �
i, � b Ll�r�� S�—/�` �7 ��� �
Referred To �" �S �T � Committee: Date
�
•,
Out of Committee By `' Date
,,
,.�
An ordinance amendi Chapter 409 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code
pertaining to penalti s for violations to Liquor Laws and providing
procedures for holdin� adverse hear;,,o� �n •»�i�*,�----
WHITE - GTV CLERK COIlI1C11 �i-� �
pINK - FINANCE (jITY OF SAINT PALTL File NO. �� �
CANARV -DEPARTMENT
B4UE - MAVOR /� �
0 rdinance Ordinance 1�0. ����'�"
Presented By
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
-4-
Section 2 .
This ordinance shall take effect and be in force thirty
days from and after its passage, approval and publication.
COUNCIL MEMBERS Requested by Department of:
Yeas Nays �
Dimond In Favor
Long
Gos�vitz Q
t�ca°aa Against By
Scheibel
Sonnen
�"'�' APR 2 8 1988
Form App oved by ity Attorney
Adopted by Council: Date , � �„����
By `
Certified P b Council S t
By
t� ��$ Approved by Mayor for Submission to Counci
Approve y Mayor te �
By
4116LtSHEO M AY 7 1988.
'� . - . � �� � , � : . � � (L'/_-€f'7-Grr�/
- , , . � /
r
,��
Upon `°.the written request of either the Fire Chief or the
Director of,h the Department of Community Services , the Inspector
shall place '^�pn the City Council agenda any case where a licensee
has failed �� correct violations of the fire or building or
health codes �ithin the time permitted by the authority which
ordered the cor�ction to be made .
'�4
Subd. 3 . �,dverse Action. The Inspector shall notify
the City Clerk t��, schedule public hearings before the City
Council within 60 ,�ys after the Inspector is notified that
a licensee has eithe� been convicted of a violation of law
or within 60 days aft� receiving the request to do so by the
Fire Chief or Director 3;f' the Department of Community Services .
Notice of the public hea�g shall be provided by the Inspector
in accordance with the ocedures of the Early Notification
Policy, App . A-11 of the Ad inistrati��e Code and section 310 . 05
of this code . The procedu es governing adverse hearings set
forth in section 310 . 05 of is code shall apply to hearings
under this provision . `�..
Subd . 4 . Witnesses ; report . The Inspector shall notify
the appropriate city staff of th� date, time and place of the
hearing at least 15 days prior ther�to . City staff shall provide
to the Inspector a complete file f the facts involving the
conviction or uncorrected code viol tions at least eight days
prior to the hearing date, and sha l appear at the Council
hearing for the purpose of presentin , evidence thereof . The
Inspector shall provide copies of the c nvictions or uncorrected
code violations to all councilmembers a least five days prior
to the scheduled hearing date . '��
�,
Subd . 5 . Penalties for Convictions/Code':,. Violations . Adverse
action for convictions or uncorrected cod&� violations may be
as follows : j�.
,,�
Type of Violations lst Occurrence 2nd Occurrence�'Y, 3rd Occurrence
�:�
l. Sale of intoxi- 14 Consecutive Revocation °� NA
cating beverages Days
while license is
under suspension
or revocation.
2.
. � � � ' � � ,� . � ,� ; � � � �i�� ��r (��/
� �
�����
Type'.,of Violations lst Occurrence 2nd Occurrence 3rd Occurrence
2. Sale`;of into�i- 5 Consecutive 1�+ Consecutive Revocation
cating;,beverages Days Days
to unde�,-age
person.
3. Sale of into�i- 5 Consecutive 14 Consecutive Revocation
cating bevera� Days Days
�
to intoxicated ',
person.
4. After hours sale �"`__;3 Consecutive 7 Consecutive Revocation
or display of in- I�a,ys Days
toxicating or non-
intoxicating ``�
beverages. M1�"
5. Refusal to allow 5 Consecut�;ve 14 Consecutive Revocation
City inspectors Days Days
.,.;.
or police ad-
:.;@,,.
mission to ''�'�k,..
inspect premises.
6. Illegal gambling 5 Consecutive 1'�, Consecutive Revocation
on premises Days Day��,,
licensed for
charitable
gambling.
7. Illegal gambling 3 Consecutive 1�+ Consecut�ve Revocation
on premises not Days Days
licensed for
charitable
gambling.
,.ti
8. Permit person to 3 Consecutive 14 Consecutive �vocation
leave premises Days Days '`
with beverages.
3•
, , _ � . . . , �� ��(� �/
. �
�.�'ype of Violations lst Occurrence 2nd Occurrence 3rd Occurrence
9. F�,ilure to make 3 Consecutive 14 Consecutive Revocation
,
ap�l.ication for Days Days
lice�.se renewal
prior '�,� license
expiratib� date.
Zl
10. Violations°� 3 Consecutive 14 Consecutive Revocation
City ordinance ,� Days Days
pertaining to <�
fire or building �ti,
or health code �,,t
requirements. 6�-,�
�'�.
Subd . 6 . Computat�on of time. For the purpose of deter-
mining the number of o'8,,currences of violations , the Council
shall consider a violatio� as a second occurrence if within
18 calendar months of the fi�c,yst conviction or within 18 calendar
months of the Inspector ' s rep�rt of a first request for hearing
from the Chief or Director; and`-�,,shall consider as a third occur-
rence if within 30 calendar mo�ths of the second conviction
or within 30 calendar months of '���the Inspector ' s report of a
second request for hearing from the C'i�,,ief or Director .
,},
�ky
Subd . 7 . Adverse Action. In ea�;� case the Council shall
consider the evidence and/or circumst�nces as presented at
the public hearing by city officers , `'�,inspectors , licensee,
other witnesses or representatives or `�he general public .
The Council may determine to take adverseP'��.,action based upon
its findings and conclusions in accordance wi'^�h the guidelines
set forth above, which action may take the fort� of suspension,
revocation, imposition of a fine, placing of ��;onditions upon
the licenses or a combination thereof . �`
Subd . 8. Ex-parte Contracts . In the event ��''�.he Council
determines a violation occurred but does not set `°�. penalty
the same day as the public hearing, each Councilmemtier shall
be precluded from any public or private contacts with`',, any of
the affected parties to the case untilsuch time as the �.ouncil
either sets a penalty for the violation or waives their right
to setting a penalty. During the time from the hearing_ to
the time a penalty is set or waived, if a Councilmember has
a question as to the case, that Councilmember shall notify
the City Attorney as to the question . The City Attorney shall
attempt to get an answer or clarification to the question and
shall give a written answer to the affected Councilmember,
all other Councilmembers and all other parties to the case .
�+ .
, l� ' . . �� ��l%
' • /�ii,_.�;,.i����;.�r;+e.. �f.'f r'
. . ./;
. _ .... _. . . . . . .__ _ _.
WHITE — CITY CLERK
PINK — FINANCE GITY OF SA�INT PAiTL Council � _�� �
CANARV — DEPARTMENT
BLUE —MAYOR File NO.
Ordindnce Ordinance N0. menamen 3��,
Presented By
Re�erred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
An Ordinance amending Chapter 40y of the
Saint Paul Legislative Code pertaining to
Intaxicating Liquor; providing presumptive
penaities for liquor licensed establishments.
THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN:
Section 1 .
That Chapter 409 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code is hereby amended so
as to add the following new provisions theretu:
5ec. 409.25. Intoxicati�g liquor; adverse hearings; convictions/
violations; presumptive pena}ties.
a) Purpose. The purpose of this section is to
�stat�iish a standard by which the City Council determines
the length of license suspensions, revocations, fines
and/or the placing of conditions upon the busin�ss licenses,
and shall apply to ali on-sale and, off-sale licensed premises.
b) Presumptive penalties for vioiations. Adverse
penalties for convictians or violations shall be presumed
as follows:
TYPE OF VIOLATION 1ST V10LATION 2Np V�OLATION 3RD VIOLATION
1 . Co�xnission of Revocation NA NA
a felony related
to the licensed
activity.
COUNCIL MEMBERS
Yeas Nays Requested by Department of:
Dimond
�� [n Favor
Goswitz
Rettman
s�ne�ne� Against BY
Sonnen
Wilson
Form Approved by City Attorney ''.
Adopted by Council: Date � �
Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY �
By
Approved by Mayor: Date Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By BY
2. `�a1e t�t Revocation NA NA
Fi�i Cqll(�I i(W 1JE'VI?i"'c�C�E'S
w�i i i e � i cense i s
�anr�er su��ensic�n.
�. 5ale �fi 5 Cans�cutive �tevoc�tion NA
a�cohr.�i �C Days Suspensian
beveraqes to
under--ae�e r�er,sons.
4. Sale af 5 C:onsecutive lh Consecutive Revocatian
a)cah�� ic bPVPraye [1�ys SuspPnsic>n Uays Suspension
to intoxicated
pers�n.
5. After hours 3 C�nsec;utive 9 ConsecutivP Revocation
sale or dispiay t)ays Sus�ension C1ays Suspension
o�F a�caho 1 i<<
beverages.
b. Refusal ta 5 Consecutive 1� Cansecutive Revocation
a 1 1�w C i t.,y Days` 5usp�r�s i�n Days Suspens i on
i nspec�tars or�
����1 ?r.e adm i s�i on
to in�pect premises.
7. Iliegai "3 Consec�ativ� 9 Consecuf.ive �evocation
c��mt�i i nc� an Days Suspens i o� Days SuspPns i on
r.�rern i ses.
tc. t�ermit r�erson i Consecutive '`., 9 Consecutive Rev�cation
Co �eavP premises �ays Susp�nsion Llays 5uspension
with alcoholic
bevera�e.
9. Failure to 1�� Cansecutive 45 Con�ecutive Revocation
make applicatiar� Days Suspension Days Suspensian
fo►� 1 i�.ense
rP_I'1P.W�1 prior to
license expiratiar�
d�t.e. '"
..,.
10. Vio�a�ions of 5 Consecutive 15 Cansec�.�tive ` Revocation
City ordinan�es [lays Suspension U�ys `�uspension
per�ta i n i ng to f i re
��r bu r i c�i ng ar
lne�a 1 t.h codes.
;�
�� ���i���
___
WHITE - CITV CLERK
PINK - FINANCE GITY OF SAINT PALTL Council �
CANARV - DEPARTMENT
BLUE -MAVOR File NO.
Ordindnce Ordinance NO.
Presented By
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
`
�
c\ Computation of time. For the purpose of determining the
number f occurrences of violations, the council shall consider
a violat'on as a second occurrence if it occurred within 18 calendar
months of he first violation; and shall consider a violation as a
third occur�nce if it occurred within 30 calendar months of the
second v i o 1 at`i,on.
,
4,�
d) Ex-parte c'�ntacts. If a license matter has been scheduled
for an adverse hea?�.ing, council members shall not discuss the
license matter with �ach other or with any of the parties involved
in the matter unless s�ch discussion occurs on the public record
during the public hearir4gs of the matter or during the council 's
final deliberations of thA, matter.
,.
e) Other penalties. Noth`i,ng in this section shall restrict
or limit the authority of the c`�iuncii to suspend up to 60 days,
revoke the license, or impose a L�ivil fine not to exceed $2,000
for violations or noncompliance wi'�h an applicabie statute, rule
or ordinance relating to alcoholic ti�verages, provided that the
license holder has t�een afforded a he�ing in the manner provided
for in Section 310.05 of this Code.
Section 2.
This ordinance shall take effect and be in force thirty days from and
after its passage, approval and publication.
s.
�
3
COUNCIL MEMBERS
Yeas Nays Requested by Department of:
Dimond
�ng [n Favor
Goswitz
Rettman
Scheibel A gai ns t BY
Sonnen
Wilson
Form Ap ved by Cit Attorney
Adopted by Council: Date _
Ceatified Passed by Council Secretary BY � `"
By
Approved.by Mayor: Date Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By BY ,
.iwH�re �t�c�rv CLERK � Council t�r /_� '
�1�p�NK - FINANCE � C I-TY O r SA I NT ��A U L File N0. / �o
�INAQY -DEPARTMENr �
oYUE -M�VOR « �� I
I • 13 Ordin�nce �Ordinance NO. ��� `
` " .y_- .., _...
Presented Qy,,ti. !i�%-,��,--,�-c..` <� ?7 � - _
.l .
� Referred Tq Committee: Date
,,�
Out of Commi�e By Date
:,�
An�`�rdina�ce amending Chapter 409 of the Saint Paul
l.egi lative Code providi�g p�ocedures for processi�g
of i� stigative reports, holding adverse heari�gs
on liqu� law violations. and establishing presumptive
penaities� or violations of liquor laws.
The Council of the Cit of Saint Paul does Ordain:
. Section l -
That Chapter 409 of the int Paul Legislative Code is hereby
amended to read as follows.
!u
409.25. Procedures for ocessi�g of investigative reports,
holding adverse hearings. and e tablishing presump�ive penaities
for intoxicating liquor violatio
a) Purpose. The pur se of this section is to
estabiish standardized procedures by hich the City Cou�cil and
the License Division (hereinafter "Oi •'sion" process police and
other investigative �eports, hoid adver e hearings, and determine
� the length of license suspensions, revoc ion, fines and/or the
placing of conditions upon the business li .ense. This section
shail appiy to all on-saie and off-sale lic nsed busi�esses.
b) Pr-ocessi�g of Police Report and Other Investi-
gat i ve Oata. ,- .r
( 1) A summary of all police reports or citation
issued by a cit De artment or Oivision within the o eratin
de artments which can be the basis for adverse acti n regarding
a licensee shall be p�ovided to the Division within en (10) days
after its issuance, exce t that this time ma be exte ded when
issuance of such information could ' rdize a� activ c�iminal
investi ation. �_
';.
COUNC(LMFN "
Yeas Nays Requested by Department of:°`,t
Orew 1
Nicosia j[1 FaVOf !�
Rettman
,
Scheibei B�.
Son�en Against
Tedesco
Wilson
Form Approved by City Atto�ney
Adopted by Council: Datc
Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY
,�
Ap��rc�v�t�� b}' �tayor. [).:ilc _____.____. npproved b}' Alayor for Submission to Council
--- -___----- -- �
I
Ii Ii: -- _----
li,: — -- -- -_---- -- -___ _ -- _..- --------------- - ------ --
i'
��
• � -
t�� ThP [tivision shall maintain an•accurate record of `
d� � p�l �re �ePorts and other� investigative data received, includinq
such dat.a from law enforcement a encies other than the Nolice
�epartment� reqar�ing any licensee, and a summary of suCh �ecords
shall be provided to the City Council on a monthly basis.
(c? Adverse Hearings to be Conduc�ed By Hea�ing
Examiner. %
tl ) For purposes of this section, e types of violations
include, but are not limited to, any convic �on of a felony, and
convictions or alleged violations pertaini to: sale of intoxi-
cating beverages while license is unde� s spension or �-evocation;
sale of intoxicating liquor o� non-intox'cating malt liquor to
underage person; sale of intoxicating b verage �to an intoxicated
person; after hours sale or display of intoxicating liquor or non-
��toxicating malt liquor beverages; r fusal to atiow City inspec-
tors or police admission to inspect remises; iitegal gambling on
premises; permit person to leave pr mises with alcoholic bever-
ages; failure to make application or license renewal prior to
license expiration date, any viol tions of the fire, building, or
health codes and an other viol tions of federal state, or
iocal iaw.
(2) ln the case of conviction �f any violation �
cfescribed in paragraph ( l ) o this subdivision and with the
consent of the City Council the Division shall schedule an
adverse hearing in accorda e with section 3i0.U5 before a Hearing
'�;�; Examiner duly appointed by the City �Council to be held within 60
days of the conviction.
(3) Upon writ n request by a City Depart_ment, or Oivi_
si�ns within the_o era n de artme�ts and with the consent of
t_he City Council , the ivision shall , within 60 days of tiie
request, schedule an dverse hearing in accordance with section
3l0.05 before a Heari g Examiner duly appointed by the City
Council i� any case here a licensee has failed to correct viola-
tions of the fire o building or health codes within the time per-
mitted by the auth rity which ordered the correction to be made.
A Uepartment or a Oe rtment Uivision may request an earlier -
�ate ror an adver e hearing if the request demonstrates that an
imminent threat o pubiic safety or the general welfare exists if
the earlier hea ing is not held.
(�) � the case of a�y alieged violat+on described in
para�raph { 1 �of this subdivision where �o conviction was obtained
pr no charges werE filed by the appropriate law enforcement agency
within a reasonable time after the alleged incident, the Ui_vision
shall present tt�e aileged violation to tf�e City Attorney"s office
for e w�°i r.ten deter m i naL i o�� of whethEr suf=f i c i ent ev i dence Nx i sts
,-�� u��������� W i rr� an adver se hear i ng. I f tl��e C i ty At.torney deter- i
!n I(1P5 l-I i%�t tiU�1 1 C 1?f1T_ E V 1 dN(iC? d0C:5 eX 1 St L %�(1d_W 1 th Yht' Ct�fISF'fl?�
of *_t�e �:i*v CounC i I_, the D+v i_s i on sha 1 1 sch?du i e an r�dver st�
� 1��2 7��1 f1C� I fl ci< f'��7'rt fflf_� _W 1 th Sf�C1_1 nfl � ��-�1�� bPf-O�f� a HC'd�1!1�_]
_-----, --�- --� - rt�� Cit Council within 'vU c��y� o+ t.li•=
'c;<dni i n��r ci�.�I � .,�.��o i nte=i Gy Y
„
:
. w
� City At:torney's determination. The City Attorney's written deter-
minat.ion of whethEr evidence exists to proceed with adverse
t�earing st�all be maintained in the Oivision's records regarding
the licensee in question.
d) Public Nearing and Adverse Actio� by City Council .
( ) fihe Oivision shall notify the City Clerk to schedule
a public h ring before the Council 's Cortmittee designated to hear
� license mat rs �herei�after "Committee”) withi� 10 days afte� the
Oivision rec ives the Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law from
the Hearing E miner. Notice of the public hearing shall be
p�ovided by the Division in accordance with the Council 's Early
Notification Pol 'cy. App. A-1 ! of the Administrative Code and
section 310.05. he procedures gove�ning adverse hearings set
forth in section 3�O.U5 of' this code shall apply to hearings under
this provision. Th� Division shall rovide the licensee and all
members of the Citv uncil with a copY of the heari�q examiner's
findinas and recommend tions,
i
(2? The Committ e shali conduct a ublic hearin at
which time it shall co�sid the evidence contained i� the record,
the tiearinq Examiner's findi' s conclusions and �ecommendations,
and shall not consider an fa ual testimon not reviousi sub-
mitted to and considered by the hearin examiner. Public testimon
received at the co�nittee's hear shall be limited to whether the
hearinq examiner made an error in the a lication of law or erro-
neous inter retation of the facts a d also testimon related to
r the recommended adverse action or en ties. U n conclusion of
the ubiic hearin the committee shall fter considerin the
record, the heari� examiner's,-findin s d recommendations, and
such additional testimon received at the earin submit its
findinc7s, conclusio�s and reccxnmendations to the full Cit Council_
e} Witnesses; reports. The Div� ion shall notify
the approp�iate city staff of the date, time and lace of the
hearings before the Hearing Examiner and before t Committee at
least 10 days prior thereto. City staff shall prov e to the
Division a complete file of the facts involving the nviction, or
ai !eged violations at least eight days prior to the he ring dates
and shal ) appear at the hearings for the purpose of pre enting
evidence thereof.
f) Citv Council 's decision. Upon receipt o the
conxnittee's report, the Council shall place the matte� upon �its
regular_meeting agenda at which time the Council shall consi�Jer
tt�e record ot the erocPedinqs, the findinqs, conclusions andi'e,
recommendation of the hearing examiner and cor►�nittees. Writt�n
notice_of this meeti�� _shall be qiven to the licensee. �he
Council sha11= based on the record and proceedinqs, determine
wr�at, i f any_,__ahverse act i on sr�a 1_1 be taken. The Counc i i 's
����c i s i on sl�a I I b� by reso I ut i on, and a copy of the reso 1 ut i on
tir�.i 1 I b� f_�r'UV i hF�C1 to th� i i CenSPe �nd t ha U i v i 5 i on_ ---- —
• H
y) Presumptive penalties for violations. �
Adverse penalties for convictions or violations shall be presumed
as tollows:
7YPE OF V10LATION !ST VIOLAI�lON 2N0 V[O�A710N 3R0 VIOLATION
1 . Commissio� of a kevocation NA NA ,,
felony related /
to the licensed f`
activity.
2. Sale of intoxi- 15 Consecutive Revocation NA
catiny beveTages Oays
while license is
under suspension
or revocation.
3. 5ale of intoxi- 5 Consecutive 1� Consecutive Revocation
cating beverages Uays
to under-age person.
4. 5ale of intoxi- S Consecutive �. 15 Consecutive Revocation
cating beverage Oays �� Uays
to intoxicated
perso�s.
S. After hours sale 3 Consecu ive 9 Consecutive kevocation `.
or display of Oays Oays
intoxicating
°' or nor�-i ntox i-
cating bevera�es.
6. Refusal to allow 5 Cons utive 15 Consecutive Revocation
City inspectors Uays Days
or police admis-
sion to inspect
premises.
7, lllegal gambling 3 onsecutive 9 Consecutive Revocation
on premises ays Days
licensed for
charitabie
garnb 1 i ng.
8. lllegal gambl �'ng 3 Consecutive 9 Consecutive Revocation
or+ premises not Uays Days
licensed For
ct�aritabie garnbling.
9. Permit per'son to 3 Consecutive 9 Consecutive Revocation
IPave premises Uays ���Y�
wirh beverages
n
� ' .
1 '
10. F"ailur-e to make 3 Consecutive 9 Consecutive Revocation
appiication for Uays Gays
ticense re�ewal
pri�r to license
expiration date.
I1 . Violations of 5 Consecutive 9 Consecutive Revocation
City ordinances Oays Days
pertai�ing to
fire or building
or health code
reUUirements.' -
h) Computation of time. For the purpose of deter-
minin4 the'�,number of occurrences of violations, the Council shall
consider a v�olation as a second occurrence if within 18 calendar
months ot the.,fi�st violation or within 18 calendar months of the
Division's re � rt of a first request for hearing from a de-
partment or div'sion within an oPeratinq department and shall
consider as a th rd occurrence if within 30 calendar months of the
second violation within 30 calenda� months of the Division's
�eport of a second equest for hearing from a Oepartment or Oivi-
sion within an o era ing department.
� i ) Ex-pa te Contacts. lf a license matter has been
scheduled for a� adversE earing, Councilmembers shali not discuss
the license matter with ea other or with any of the parties
involved in the matter unle such discussion occurs on the public
record during thz Committee's ublic hearing of the matter or
during t�e Council 's fin�l deli erations of the matter.
j) Other Penalties. Nothing in this section shall
restrict or limit the authority of e City Council to suspend up
to 60 days. revoke the license, or i ose a civil fine not to
exceed $"L,OUO for violations or non-co liance with an applicable
statute, rule or ordinance relat.ing to coholic beverages, pro-
vided that the license holde� has been a orded a hearing in the
manner provided for in Section 310.05 of t Legislative Code.
Section 2
This ordinance is deemed part of the Saint aui Legislative
Code dnd shell be incorporated therei� and given n appropriate
section nurnber at. the time of the �ext replication of said legis-
�ative code, or supplement tlieret.�.
�
,
�\
� \�
.-
WHITE — CITV CLGNK * r t l,0URC11 .
PINK — F/n+wNCE G 1 Il Y O 1 S� I NT l�A U L �
CANARV —OEPARTMENT F11C NO. �
BIUE —M�YOR �
• � y
Ordindnce Ordinance N�. � �
Presented E3y
Referred To Committee: Date `
Out of Committee E3y Date
Sect�i`�n 3
,`
This ordinance shall take effec� and be in force thirty days
from and after its passage, approva) �nd pubiication.
�,.
�
�
..- .,�
�
6
COUIVCII.IVIEIV Requested by Department of:
Yeas N a}�s
o`e"' In Favor
Nicosia
Rettma�
Scheibel A ga i�s t BY
So�nen
Tedesco
Wilson
Form Approved by City Attor�ey
Adopted by CounciL• ��:�t�
Certified Passed by Council Secretary
QY —
�
�
[3y ------ --
Approved by hlayor for Submission to Council
Approved by �1ayor. Datc - _--- -- —
Eiyf3y --—-- --- ---- ------------- _ –