The URL can be used to link to this page

88-2004 WNITE -'C1TV CLERK COU[1C11 r P�NK -'FINANCE GITY OF SAINT PALTL �d �QO� CANARV - DEPARTMENT BLUE - MAVOR File NO. � Council Resolution j� � Presented By Referred To Committee: Date � �� Out of Committee By Date WHEREAS , Russell and Beverly Oberg made application to the Planning Commission of the City of Saint Paul for change of non-con�orming use and special condition use permit for the pur- pose of establishing and maintaining a foster care home for ten children at their residence at 1636 East Shore Drive, Saint Paul , Minnesota, legally described as Lot 7 , Block 15 , Overbrook Addition to the City of St. Paul , pursuant to the provisions of Sections 62. 102(e) and 60.423( 3) of the Saint Paul Legislative and Zoning Code; and WHEREAS, foll.owing a public hearing conducted by the Zoning Committee, with notice to affected property owners , the Planning Commission by its Resolution No. 88-64, adopted August 26 , 1988 , approved the change of non-conforming use requested, modified the 1 , 320 foot distance requirement between community residential facilities , and approved the issuance of a special condition use permit to allow the establishment of a community residential facility for up to ten young adults at 1636 East Shore Drive, subject to the following four conditions: l . The owners of the property shall live in the structure. 2. At no time shall there be more than ten young adults in the program. 3. No resident of the program shall have a car. 4. When the program terminates , the structure can revert back to being a duplex. and COUNCIL MEMBERS Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays Dimond �ng [n Favor Goswitz Rettman Scheibel A gai n s t BY Sonnen Wilson Form Appro d y C' t ney Adopted by Council: Date Certified Vassed by Council Secretary BY gy � A►pproved by Mavor: Date _ Appr ve by Mayor for Submission to Council By _ BY ; � �=��oo� WHEREAS, the actions of the Planning Commission were based upon the following findings of fact made by said Commission: 1 . The applicants, Russell and Beverly Oberg, have operated a group family foster care home for children ages 16 to 18 at this location since they purchased the property as a duplex in December, 1981 . The property is zoned R-3 , one famil.y residential . Since 1984, Ramsey County has contracted with the applicants to operate an "Independent Living Skills" ( ILS) program in the second unit of the structure. The ILS program is designed to help the residents develop the skills needed to become responsible young adults. Foster children in the ILS program live in the separate quarters located on first and third levels of the building. Residents cook and clean for themselves and do their own shopping and budgeting. They are supervised by the Obergs who live on the second floor of the building. Presently, they have seven residents , three males and four females, and are licensed by the Minnesota Department of Human Resources for up to 10 residents. 2 . According to zoning records , the structure was converted to a duplex prior to adoption of the 1975 Zoning Code. Under the present code, a duplex is first permitted in the RT-1 zoning district. 3. The zoning code (section 60.203c) defines foster care for more than six residents as a community residential facility and it would be first permitted in the RT-1 district subject to special conditions. The applicants are requesting a change of nonconforming use from a duplex to a community residential facility for foster care for up to 10 residents. 4. The Minnesota Department of Human Services records indi- cate that the Obergs were first licensed at this address in April , 1982, as a group family foster care home for six children. The license was increased to nine children in May, 1984, and to 10 children in January, 1985. 5. Foster care for six or fewer children is a permitted use in the R-3 single family district (section 60.412(8) Therefore , the foster care program operated at this address was a conforming R-3 use for over two years . 6. Section 62. 102(e) (5) requires that when a nonconforming use of a structure is discontinued for 365 days , the structure shall thereafter be used in conformance with the regulations in which it is located, unless the Planning Commission, after public hearing, finds that 2 . : : � � �� oo� the structure cannot be reasonably or economically used for a conforming purpose, that the proposed use is equally appropriate or more appropriate to the district than the previous nonconforming use, and that the proposed use is consistent with the health, safety, morals, and general welfare of the community and is consistent with the reasonable use and enjoyment of adjacent property. 7 . According to the applicants and a representative from Ramsey County, the ILS program is more expensive to oper- ate than a typical foster care program and would be econo- mically infeasible to operate with six or fewer residents. The applicants stated that it is necessary to have an average of 7 to 8 residents to cover the additional costs associated with the ILS program. 8 . The proposed nonconforming use, a foster care home for up to 10 young adults, is as appropriate as a duplex, the previous use of the property. Both are first per- mitted in the RT-1 zoning district. Furthermore , it would be possible to have a foster care home for up to six residents in each unit for a total of 12 residents. 9. the ILS program is a unique foster care program for young adults providing a needed alternative to the traditional foster care service. It is the only program of this nature operated in Ramsey County. The ILS program has been more successful at this location than at two other locations, in part, because the property is a duplex, allowing greater physical independence for program partic- ipants . Therefore , to allow the continuation of the program is consistent with the health, safety, morals and general welfare of the community. 10. Since 1984, the ILS foster care program has operated at this location without any negative impact on the sur- rounding neighborhood. 11 . According to the zoning code, a foster care facility for more than 6 residents is a community residential facility and requires a special condition use permit. It is permitted in the RT-1 district subject to five conditions. This nonconforming community residential facility can meet all but one of the special conditions : a minimum distance of 1 , 320 feet is required between zoning lots used for community residential facilities. 3 . : � � � �'�6�� 12. The nearest community residential facility, Balbriggen, is an interim care facility for the mentally retarded operated by Dungarvin, Inc. at 1270 Larpenteur Street. The distance between the two zoning lots is approxi- mately 1 , 000 feet. A modification of the distance condition is required. 13. The Planning Commission may modify any or all special conditions when strict application of such special conditions would unreasonably limit or prevent otherwise lawful use of a piece of property or an existing struc- ture and would result in exceptional undue hardship to the owner of the property or structure , provided that it will not impair the intent and purpose of such special conditions and is consistent with health, morals , and general welfare and is consistent with the reasonable enjoyment of the adjacent property. 14. The intent of the distance requirement condition is to prevent concentrations of community residential facilities in neighborhoods. Since the nearest facility, Balbriggen, has only six residents and is 1 ,000 feet from 1636 East Shore Drive, allowing the foster care program for up to 10 residents at this location will not result in an overconcentration of facility residents in the neighborhood. and WHEREAS , pursuant to the provisions of the Zoning Code, Virgil and Shirley Meyer, 1626 East Shore Drive, Saint Paul , Minnesota 55106 and Arnie Jacobson, 1632 East Shore Drive, Saint Paul , Minnesota 55106 duly filed their appeal from these determi- nations made by the Planning Commission requesting that a public hearing be held before the City Council for the purpose of con- sidering the actions taken by the Planning Commission; and WHEREAS , acting pursuant to Section 64.205 through Section 64.208 and upon notice to appellants , applicant and other affected property owners , public hearings were held by and before the City Council wherein all interested parties were given an oppor- tunity to be heard; and WHEREAS , pursuant to Section 64.206 of the St. Paul Legis- lative and Zoning Code, the City Council ' s review of decisions of the Planning Commission is to determine whether the Commission committed an error in any fact, procedure or finding, and in such cases the Council may reverse or affirm, wholly or partly, 4. : �� 'oa� or modify, the decision or determination appealed from; and WHEREAS, the Council , having heard the statements made, and having considered the appeal , the report of Planning staff, the minutes and findings of the Zoning Committee and of the Planning Commission, does hereby RESOLVED, that the Council of the City of Saint Paul does hereby find and determine that the Planning Coinmission did not commit any error in its Findings and Conclusions , that the Council does hereby concur in the Findings and Conclusions made by the Planning Commission, that the special condition use permit issued by the Planning Commission for the establishment of a foster care home (community residential facility) for up to ten young adults at 1636 East Shore Drive is made expressly subject to the following conditions : 1 . The owners of the property live in the structure. 2. At no time shall there be more than ten young adults in the program. 3. No resident of the program shall have a car. 4. When the program terminates , the structure can revert back to being a duplex. FURTHER RESOLVED, that the appeal of Virgil and Shirley Meyer and Arnie Jacobson is hereby denied; and, be it 5. WSi1TE -�CiT`/ CLERK PFNK� -OFINANCE GITY OF SAINT PAUL Council CANARY - DEPARTMENT � BLUE - MAYOR File NO. Council Resolution Presented By � � Referred To Committee: Date 1�� Out of Committee By Date FURTHER RESOLVED, that the City Clerk shall mail a copy of this Resolution to Russell and Beverly Oberg, Virgil and Shirley Meyer, Arnie Jacobson, the Zoning Administrator, and the Planning Commission. 6. COUNCIL MEMBERS Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays Dimond,/f Lon� In Favor Goswit�' Rettman �- s�ne;�e� _ Against By Sonneo�� Wilson ��C � o � Form Approv d by City Attor ey Adopted by Council: Date Certified Pas e b nc'1 t BY B}� Approved 14 r. ate _ �i� L � � Approv d b Mayor for Submission to Council By �""�"'— BY �$� u r (� � � �� ; j ��''�dOf� � .�1�° 012781 � : . . - - - - - - DEPARTI�,ENT . CONTACT', NAME PHONE ' ' t 7.�' "� DATE ' ' . A�SIGN Nt�MBER FOR �QtJTi�TG ORDER: (S�e reverse side.) ; _ Department Director ' � Iiaqor (ar Assistant) _ Finance and Plan�t.gement Services �irector � City Clerk _ Budgat Director � _ city Acto�ey � TOTAL NtJlIBER O,� SIGNATURE PAGES: ; (Clip all locations for signatwre.) 1 G Y (Purp se/Rationale) e�,�f�►T1�� e� {�r�s d►e cir�o;�w- o� '�-r� �/aw��,u � s � a � •c ti•� . ?.�„ �o,,,,�,� ,�"' fL�`�, ��"'_. ��,,,M,�s. � n,. � � �r - . _ _ . __ . ��,r,,;� ''.��« '� . {ar�� I�-t d �`.+► (7 !�`�=F, , , , ; , �4ST,�BENEFIT. BUDGETARY. AND PERSONNE�. IMPACTS ANTICIPATED. s � , ; Counci( Res�arch Center � � . �INANGZ�TG SOIIRCB AND BUDGET ACTIVITY I�UMBER CHARGED OR CREDITED: � (MaFor's signature not required if un�er $10,000.) DEe' � � 1988 ; Total Amount of Trans�ction: Activity Nwnber: Fundin� Source: ; � REC�iv�n ATTACHMENTS: (List and number all attj�chments.) DEC O� �� CITY CLERK '' S , � AD1�fIN�STRATIVE PROCEDURES _Yes _No Rules, Regulations, �rocedures, or Budget Amendment required? _Yes _No If yes, are they or �imetable attaehed? DEPAR.TME�IT ItEVIEit CITY ATTORNEY R V�IEW _Yes _No Council resolution required? Resolutfon requiredP _Yes _No _Yes _t�o Insurance required? ' Insurance sufficient? _Yes _No Yes No Insurance attached? . . ' � ��'��o� � .��•••�• CITY OF SAINT PAUL �� OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY : :� �,'• _ ^ EDWARD P. STARR, CITY ATTORNEY %ry„,. .... �• 647 City Hall, Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 GEORGE LATIMER 6tz-298-5�2t MAYOR �TM � ��. � �� December 2 , 1988 �"' D�C 5 i988 �� ` � " �,� �...�.�'�` ��C �v '°'� �� ->'�:��'� � b..�34�� E�� ' 19�� Albert B. oison D ��( �►��R� City Clerk �' 386 City Hall Saint Paul , MN 55102 Dear Mr. Olson: You have advised our office that on November 17 , 1988 , a Motion to grant the appeal of Virgil and Shirley Meyer and Arnie Jacobson from a decision of the Planning Commission allowing the foster home for up to ten young adults at 1636 East Shore Drive had failed of adoption by a 3-3 vote. Section 64. 206(b) of the St. Paul Legislative Code requires that the City Council shall render a decision on the appeal without a reasonable delay. Therefore, I have prepared for consideration of the City Council a Resolution affirming the decision of the Planning Commission and finding that the Commission did not commit any error in its decision. You should note that a copy of the Resolution, if adopted, should be mailed to all of the parties , the Zoning Administrator and the Planning Commission. Y u s very truly JER � J. SE L As is ant Ci y Attorney r � JJS�r • � (RETURN TO JEROME SEGAL AFTER ADOPTION) WHITE - CITV GIERK PINK - FINANCE CITY OF SAINT PAUL� Council CANARV - OEPARTMENT File NO• �OD BLUE - MAYOR � Council Resolution . Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date WHEREAS , Russell and Beverly Oberg made application to the Planning Commission of the City of Saint Paul for change of non-conforming use and special condition use permit for the pur- pose of establishing and maintaining a foster care home for ten children at their residence at 1636 East Shore Drive, Saint Paul , Minnesota, legally described as Lot 7 , Block 15 , Overbrook Addition to the City of St. Paul , pursuant to the provisions of Sections 62. 102(e) and 60.423(3) of the Saint Paul Legislative and Zoning Code; and ^ WHEREAS , following a public hearing conducted by the Zoning Committee, with notice to affected property owners, the Planning Commission by its Resolution No. 88-64, adopted August 26 , 1988 , approved the change of non-conforming use requested, modified the 1 , 320 foot distance requirement between community residential facilities, and approved the issuance "of a special conaition use permit to allow the establishment of a community residential facility for up to ten young adults at 1636 East Shore Drive, subject to the following four conditions: 1 . The owners of the property shall live in the structure. 2. At no time shall there be more than ten young adults in the program. 3. No resident of the program shall have a car. 4. When the program terminates , the structure can revert back to being a duplex. and COUNCIL MEMBERS Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays Dimond �� In Favor . Goswitz Rettman B Scheibel A ga i n s t Y Sonnen Wilson Form Appro ed y C' t ney Adopted by Council: Date CertiEied Passed by Council Secretary BY gy. �..__......a �... U.,..,,.. n,.e Appr ve by Mayor for Submission to Council . - � �r�ao�� WHEREAS, the actions of the Planning Commission were based upon the following findings of fact made by said Commission: 1. The applicants, Russell and Beverly Oberg, have operated a group family foster care home for children ages 16 to 18 at this location since they purchased the property as a duplex in December, 1981 . The property is zoned R-3 , one family residential . Since 1984, Ramsey County has contracted with the applicants to operate an "Independent Living Skills" ( ILS) program in the second unit of the structure. The ILS program is designed to help the residents develop the skills needed to become responsible young adults. Foster children in the ILS program live in the separate quarters located on first and third levels of the building. Residents cook and clean for themselves and do their own shopping and budgeting. They are supervised by the Obergs who live on the second floor of the building. Presently, they have seven residents, three males and four females, and are licensed by the Minnesota Department of Human Resources for up to 10 residents. 2. According to zoning records , the structure was converted to a duplex prior to adoption of the 1975 Zoning Code. Under the present code , a duplex is first permitted in the RT-1 zoning district. 3. The zoning code (section 60. 203c) defines foster care for more than six residents as a community residential facility and it would be first permitted in the RT-1 district subject to special conditions. The applicants are requesting a change of nonconforming use from a duplex to a community residential facility for foster care for up to 10 residents. 4. The Minnesota Department of Human Services records indi- cate that the Obergs were first licensed at this address in April , 1982, as a group family foster care home for six children. The license was increased to nine children in May, 1984, and to 10 children in January, 1985. 5. Foster care for six or fewer children is a permitted use in the R-3 single family district (section 60.412(8) Therefore, the foster care program operated at this address was a conforming R-3 use for over two years. 6. Section 62. 102(e) ( 5) requires that when a nonconforming use of a structure is discontinued for 365 days, the structure shall thereafter be used in conformance with the regulations in which it is located, unless the Planning Commission, after public hearing, finds that 2. � � � � ��aoo�. the structure cannot be reasonably or economically used for a conforming purpose, that the proposed use is equally appropriate or more appropriate to the district than the previous nonconforming use, and that the proposed use is consistent with the health, safety, morals , and general welfare of the community and is consistent with the reasonable use and enjoyment of adjacent property. 7. According to the applicants and a representative from Ramsey County, the ILS program is more expensive to oper- ate than a typical foster care program and would be econo- mically infeasible to operate with six or fewer residents. The applicants stated that it is necessary to have an average of 7 to 8 residents to cover the additional costs associated with the ILS program. 8 . The proposed nonconforming � use, a foster care home for up to 10 young adults, is as appropriate as a duplex, the previous use of the property. Both are first per- mitted in the RT-1 zoning district. Furthermore, it would be possible to have a foster care home for up to six residents in each unit for a total of 12 residents. 9. the ILS program is a unique foster care program for young adults providing a needed alternative to the traditional foster care service. It is the only program of this nature operated in Ramsey County. The ILS program has been more successful at this location than at two other locations, in part, because the property is a duplex, allowing greater physical independence for program partic- ipants. Therefore, to allow the continuation of the program is consistent with the health, safety, morals and general welfare of the community. 10. Since 1984, the ILS foster care program has operated at this location without any negative impact on the sur- rounding neighborhood. 11 . According to the zoning code, a foster care facility for more than 6 residents is a community residential facility and requires a special condition use permit. It is permitted in the RT-1 district subject to five conditions. This nonconforming community residential facility can meet all but one of the special conditions: a minimum distance of 1 , 320 feet is required between zoning lots used for community residential facilities. 3 . . � � � - � � �;��'�a°� 12. The nearest community residential facility, Balbriggen, is an interim care facility for the mentally retarded operated by Dungarvin, Inc. at 1270 Larpenteur Street. The distance between the two zoning lots is approxi- mately 1 , 000 feet. A modification of the distance condition is required. 13. The Planning Commission may modify any or all special conditions when strict application of such special conditions would unreasonably limit or prevent otherwise lawful use of a piece of property or an existing struc- ture and would result in exceptional undue hardship to the owner of the property or structure, provided that it will not impair the intent and purpose of such special conditions and � is consistent with health, morals , and general welfare and is consistent with the reasonable enjoyment of the adjacent property. 14. The intent of the distance requirement condition is to prevent concentrations of community residential facilities in neighborhoods. Since the nearest facility, Balbriggen, has only six residents and is 1 ,000 feet from 1636 East Shore Drive, allowing the foster care program for up to 10 residents at this location will not result in an overconcentration of facility residents in the neighborhood. and WHEREAS, pursuant to the provisions of the Zoning Code, Virgil and Shirley Meyer, 1626 East Shore Drive, Saint Paul , Minnesota 55106 and Arnie Jacobson, 1632 East 5hore Drive, Saint Paul , Minnesota 55106 duly filed their appeal from these determi- nations made by the Planning Commission requesting that a public hearing be held before the City Council for the purpose of con- sidering the actions taken by the Planning Commission; and WHEREAS , acting pursuant to Section 64.205 through Section 64.208 and upon notice to appellants , applicant and other affected property owners, public hearings were held by and before the City Council wherein all interested parties were given an oppor- tunity to be heard; and WHEREAS , pursuant to Section 64.206 of the St. Paul Legis- lative and Zoning Code, the City Council ' s review of decisions of the Planning Commission is to determine whether the Commission committed an error in any fact, procedure or finding, and in such cases the Council may reverse or affirm, wholly or partly, 4. . � � � ��roo� or modify, the decision or determination appealed from; and WHEREAS , the Council , having heard the statements made, and having considered the appeal , the report of Planning staff, the minutes and findings of the Zoning Committee and of the Planning Commission, does hereby RESOLVED, that the Council of the City of Saint Paul does hereby find and determine that the Planning Cornmission did not commit any error in its Findings and Conclusions , that the Council does hereby concur in the Findings and Conclusions made by the Planning Commission, that the special condition use permit issued by the Planning Commission for the establishment of a foster care home (community residential facility) for up to ten young adults at 1636 East Shore Drive � is made expressly subject to the following conditions : l . The owners of the property live in the structure. 2. At no time shall there be more than ten young adults in the program. 3. 1Vo resident of the program shall have a car. 4. When the program terminates , the structure can revert back to being a duplex. FURTHER RESOLVED, that the appeal of Virgil and Shirley Meyer and Arnie Jacobson is hereby denied; and, be it 5. WMITE • - CITV CIERK f PiNK - FINANCE COL111Ci1 -^/ CANARV - DEPARTMENT. G I TY OF SA I NT PAUL File NO. v, 00 - BLUE - MAV0�3 � Council Resolution Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date FURTHER RESOLVED, that the City Clerk shall mail a copy of this Resolution to Russell and Beverly Oberg, Virgil and Shirley Meyer, Arnie Jacobson, the Zoning Administrator, and the Planning Commission. 6. COUNCIL MEMBERS Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays Dimond �� In Favor Goswitz Rettman B Scheibel A gai n s t Y Sonnen Wilson Form Approv d by City Attor ey Adopted by Council: Date Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY Bp A►pproved by �Navor: Date Approv d b Mayor for Submission to Council S Y ' - L. ; t-.- .� i .F `E y �'. ' � ;e -,�S Q 3� .' :a }.� � .�� - " '� � ` - �• f ''� �� _ a. � � t � "� i 2 .T L , i , t�"�1�� t �t ;: , + 11" � � 4�,� � {: F i • n*rz � +^ '� ,$ Ar: r° rt � .� � i +� ' ,,,,��".�, r� � � � J t . „ . ,: , Y ." '�� ;. ? �: ; �d' t�,. � � Q�� b � t � a ' R }"t. }$ �' � _ _ �' � 4C 1 � I ; t r � ' t + ��1 1 S �� ' � � � � . .. 4. c'�� -ir �.`� l�� l• � � '� � � �e � C �� t� �� `� , i �, / �L ,��r ,�:. � � �' � � .� ;, � , � � �' '� � ��, �:E� i�� .�. �,�� ,�. �,y i:� � , � - � Y �f � �� F k_ �. � �, �' { r '>' - *,: i �� t, � i . ,� t � r r � , j ;�,.�� i' :` �� t � v: � y_ � ,�I � � f t / � { �'' n 4F 1 �� " �/�F4� �� 'y. � �,� 4 t �-� ' .�s � � '. � t� �.'37� �°a ��1►�'� � �',`� '�'Y�� " ' 'x �� .1�=t��i�f1 �d.;�i�O�qX � � ��,� ��. . �. � ,x, �II�� ►-� �.� �� 1�`��i'�it � ��-:llt� ;�El�' : �r IE�r ;��k�t� a� ��..+� ��y ��i�iY '. ` � � � A'� � �. �=fl�4"�"�s � :� ��"�.�i 3—� �. � ��`��1!!�'�� 1i�"�:�.�; :'�3 �+��I�"� �» icA��`�',�'��Mw� ��` �, � °E � � - � � � y ��'�' "`f,. ? _ { � i � �_r, � { ,, } �t x _ + / , � - f � �` � ft � � �' �,�y� qj�6�� + �+ -a�s V' � - r l F�' �. r� � � � � r ':. '�, .. j} .F J �:� )y�F :. i � � ' t .;�xF� �I � � � � [ � _ �QS�h_ , _ � � � , , �, �„ ��,� � , { � �� F�'�'�,',�i� �� /�� .,��i � Y � `q r 1 r � � � } � fl jf i.�; � _ } 'S' ' "'� � , �� r : � �� 'a .� _ � 4 £ X ' � .J � S� , _ � r� .\ ,�..� 1 � � _ ' k ' /� '~ � � � � - � / {;;i f { � f � 1 . f l l I } � ; � •�` ��S$m 1�.. �., t � � i ��- �. .. �,. � 2 �( l ! F7 i; �� . ! .. F i � � � n` . a I � � � . � �,� -: ' " - � R �� , y.` '� "•� - r - {.'. � . Y s r i� 5; . .� i ±y �� , '� � �-f _. \ � .� ' ' . , . . 1 - + � �� ,z: �t a.i�' ., . . �, �'� � .� �y, .£ 6:_ �Yi . tr� / F � ' �� l . � '' �R Yr� � � ��, 1 - �� . ` .v, �f � �W ,y L �':�',�+�� Y:' �� k. 4 � . 4 : {,��,,�, �: � •�,�� ' � F �V /1 +r�` ( � ��r1 �v: f�'\�� : ` i ,r ( M e. �. � 1-; ' i- � " r�- .X ? .� ' ' , �'• / � ,� 1 • . t r � � � ` �' �d M` ` .. r � � � � j, /« ' ` }` � ; ' .�',"' � ;. ri ' ti . .. � � i . 1� ��" �� 1 ' - � �' •� ' �� +�t a a ._ - -- �-�.,. . _ .�: : , - _.�, f . � , Y , _ _� . �__ � _ . . 4, . ,._ a,.� „ ._ .. . � L��-�� 6 CtTY �` � 4� ,, �� ,; CITY OF SAINT PAUL ° ��,;��,;,, ; DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT °►m °11 �� ha' DIVISION OF PLANNING 25 West Fourth Street,Saint Paul,Minnesota 55102 �86� 612-22&3270 GEORGE LATIMER MAYOR ',�� RECEIVED �-_a..__�-' October 11, 1988 0 CT 111988 Ci��' CLE�K Albert Olson, City Clerk Room 386, City Hall Saint Paul, MN 55102 RE: Zoning File #10386 - Meyer/Jacobson City Council Hearing: October 13, 1988 PURPOSE: To appeal a Planning Commission decision which granted a Change in Nonconforming Use Permit and a Special Condition Use Permit with modification at 1636 East Shore Drive to allow the continued use of the structure as a foster care home for 10 adults. PLANNING COMMISSION DECISION: Approve (15-1) ZONING COMMITTEE DECISION: Approve (7-0) STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Deny SUPPORT: Eight persons testified at the hearing, one letter received; District 5 testified at the hearing and sent a letter in support. OPPOSITION: Five persons testified at the hearing, three letters received and a petition with 145 signatures received. Dear Sir: On August 18, 1988, the Zoning Committee of the Planning Commission held a public hearing on the Oberg's nonconforming use and special condition use application. The applicants testified. At the close of the public hearing, the Committee voted 7 to 0 to approve the request based on public testimony. On August 26, 1988, the Planning Commission upheld the Zoning Committee's recommendation on a vote of 15 to 1. This decision is being appealed two neighbors of the Oberg's, Virgil and Shirley Meyer and Arnie Jacobson. The grounds on which their appeal is based are enumerated in the attached application. They alleged that the Planning Commission made both procedural and substantive errors in granting the permit. f � Albert Olson, City Clerk October 11, 1988 Page Two . The original staff report recommendation on the Oberg application was for denial. After listening to the testimony at the public hearing, however, staff concurs with the Planning Commission decision for the following reasons: the Oberg's foster home is similar is intensity of use to a duplex; the program is uniquely suited to a duplex lay-out; and in the program's four years of operation it has not negatively affected the neighborhood. This appeal is scheduled to be heard by the City Council on October 13, 1988. Please notify me by October 12, 1988, if any member of the City Council wishes to have slides of the site presented at the public hearing. Sincerely, ��-�1 �iL2.�¢�. Lisa Freese Planner II LF:rm Attachments �-� �• � 4 /.." CJ " „�rJ'(J�. 1 APPLICATION FOR APPEAL �NINOZ ZONING OFFICE USE ONLY CITY OF SAINT PAUL Fi le � �� g� RECE�VEp 8861 Z I d3S � �_ Appl�cation Fee S � � �� 12i98g Q�n�� Tentative Hearing Date 10-13'�� ONING Application is hereby made for an Appeal to the Cit Council under the provisions of Chapter 64, Section , aragraph of the oning ode to appeal a decision made by the Board o�ng Appeals X Planning Conmission on August 26 , 1988. _ Zoning Administrator (date of decision) Planning Administrator Other *See Attachment C — A. APPELLANT 733-4938 Name Virgil Meyer ac Shirley Meyer Arnie Jacobson Daytime phone 1626 East Shore Drive I�i3'L"'Eas�S ore rive Address St. Paul, MN 55106 St. Paul, AZN 55106 Zip Code 6. DECISION BEING APPEALED 10343 Zon i ng f i 1 e name Russell and Beverly Oberg Zon i ng Fi 1 e # Property Address/Location 1636 East Shore Drive, St. Paul, MN 55106 Lega1 description Lot ? Block 15, Overbrook Addition C. GROUNDS FOR APPEAL (Use additional sheets if necessary.) (Explain why you feel there has been an error in any requirement, permit, decision or refusal made by an administrative official, or an error in fact, procedure or finding made by the Board of Zoning Appeals or the Planning Commission.) See Attachment A s . If you have any questions, please contact: ; . APP � _ t`s sign u St. Pau 1 Zon i rtg' Off i ce Virgii eyer � 1100 City Ha11 Rnnex S ' tta t B t 25-West Fourth Street ' 5a�nt Paul, Mir�nesota 55102 Da e City sgeM. (298-4154) 9/82 .� � �` a ,, .. .^ � GJ • � {� - �:� APPLICATION FOft APPEAL - C1TY OF SAINT PAUL Attachment A C. GROUPdDS FOR APPEAL 1. The Planning Commission violated the present provisions of the zoning code in that the special use permit was granted to the subject property which is 1,000 feet from another non-conforming use and the requirement is that they be separated by 1,320. 2. The owner of the property is in present violation of the zoning code in that on or about February 20, 1988, a license was issued for ten children at the subject premises in violation of the present zoning. 3. That the special use permit in the referenced zoning file states that "At no time shall there be more than 10 young adults in the program" when the approval granted by the Zoning Committee and the Planning Commission was that none fo the residents could be above the age of 18, which age limit is not set forth in the permit. 4. That the special use permit under law must run with the applicants, but is drawn so that it will follow the property and is not limited to the present owners. 5. That the special use permit reads as follows, "�Vhen the program terminates, the structure can revert back to a duplex", when the internal documents of the City of Saint Paul state that the building is "one of our duplexes in limbo, neither conforming or non-conforming". That for this reason it is improper to permit the property to revert back to a duplex for which use the property has never been zoned or permitted. 6. That the hearing held on the matter was inadequate in that among other things, those persons on the Commissions refused to listen to the persons objecting, were absent for part of the time, refused to consider the violations of the zoning code set forth in this appeal and elsewhere, and appeared to have made up their mind on the subject before the matter was ever heard. 7. That the special condition use permit is in reality a rezoning of the property without proper hearing, study, or due process in that among other things, it runs with the property rather than with the applicants and that the granting of such special condition use permit exceeds the powers of the Planrang Commission and violates rules of the Planning Commission and ordinances of the City of Saint Paul as set forth herein. That attached hereto is a copy of the Dungarvin, Inc. letter of August 18, 1988, indicating it is not discontinuing its operations which are 1,000 feet from the applicants property. Further attached hereto is a copy of the permit issued by the State of 14iinnesota on or about February 20, 1988, indicating the applicatnts v�rere then in violation of the existing laws, ordinances and zonir� for the subject premises and fiad misrepresented the home and property to the State of Minnesota. II/31 i � I . ` • � I' �- -_--- �aa��1ri, IItC. Administrative Office 690 South Cleveland Avenue . SL Paul�MN 55116 Phone:699-6050 August 18, 1988 Dungarvin, Inc. 690 South Cleveland Avenue St. Paul, MN 55116 RE: License and Occupancy Status of Dungarvin III - Balbriggen 1270 E. Larpenteur, St. Paul, Mn 55109 � ' To Whom it May Concern: Dungarvin III - Balbriggen is curreatly a group home for six � mentally retarded adults, owned and operated by Dungarvin, Inc. Two staff persons live with the residents. The bome is certified ; under the Federal Medicaid Program as an ICF/I+IIt, iicensed by the i State Health Department as a Supervised Living Facilty and � licensed by the Department of Human Services under Rule 34. � Within the next 60 days the facility will downsize to five residents with a future plan to decrease to four should a resident choose to move or Ramsey Countq make the request. Concurrent with the downsizing to five, there vould `be a chaage in certification/licensure. The home no longer would carry the � ICF/MR certification; it would continue under a Supervised Living Faciliy license and a Rule 34 license. It would operate under the Medicaid Waiver Program. Should qou need any further information, please contact me at 699-6050. Sincerelq, i � 1�.t� C',�,,t,�,.� , J nice Carver Director ; i' i I i i � a 0o a � r � � � " 0' i q m � � 4 � � ' i � C y � � � H . < E � v � Z Z = � � � � y � � � � f tWA I V � � � o � i < ` J �O O` tlt � ti+ � Y f O � p Z , Z � • � E CC : � ..� O y �e+ O o E t ; p � ° rn �V N � � � ' Q � � W e� > o � �u ~ � o Q C W !� 2 > F N . O = : � � w � � ° o � � � � � ° N � p V � 0 Z � J � Q Z (/� E � � y ,� = . � � _ . � W � H • � Z 2 4 � N � o � W c c ` i ¢ , U . . � °e _ � u � � � i � (� � J J tf1 M = r E- W : °C 2 � t W4 oc � o � .. � V ° O '" _' � z � h • '. Q } o " ~' � � J .., � � W 0 � ui c<c °[ O � Z � O = � LL = � r�.� N � !� �,, � ac iu = � o W � Y O ~ �' '° Z v� ►- '^ O � �` . � � o � `�' > z > F m z � � � .• o < � o � u o � 2 < d -� W � J LL d = = u O N O o u � a '� s ' � t = � y � � h J - � W < i? J� � W � �L C � ~ " � W �� J ~ j p • N � � �'o� ��J� APPLICATION FOR APPEAL -C1TY OF SAINT PAUL Attachment B Applicant's gnature Shirley Me er ��T Date � p ant signat e Arnie Jac on `�/� ,� Date W• �'C. , � � 1�orv,9G,D � - Kcz.j{ J $ ��fc . • r`'""" �Y `of saint ' commission resolution �II�i 1 I�Jt � �l RA-f,4 C�te AuQUSt 26_ �q8s WHEREAS, Russell and Beverly Oberg, file #10343� have applied for a Change of Nonconforming Use and Special Condition Use Fermit under the provisions of Sections 60.412(8) , 60.423(3) and 62.102(e) of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, for the purpose of establishing a foster care home for 10 children on property located at 1636 East Shore Drive, legally described as Lot 7, Block 15, Overbrook Addition; and WHEREAS, the Zoning Committee of the Planning Commission on August 18, 1988� held a public bearing at which all persons present vere givan an opportunity to be heard pursuant to said application in accordance with the requirements of Section 64.300 of the Saint Pau1 Legislative Code; and WHEREAS, Saint Paul Planning Co�ission, based on the evidence presented to its Zoning Committee at the public hearing as substantially reflected in the minutes, made the following findings of fact: 1. The applicants, Russell and Beverly Oberg, have operated a group fa.mily foster care home for children ages 16 to 18 at this location since they purchased the property as a duplex in December, 1981. The property is zoned R-3, one family residentia2. Since 1984. Remsey County has contracted with the applicants to operate an "Independent Living Skills" (IIS) program in the second unit of the structure. The ILS program is designed to help the resident� develop the skills needed to become responsible young adults. Foster children in the ILS program � live in the separate quarters located on first and third levels of the building. Residents cook and clean for themselves and do their own shopping and budgeting. They are supervised by the Obergs Who live an the second floor of the building. Presently. they have seven residents, three males and four females, and are licensed by the Minnesota Department of Human Resources for up to 10 residents. 2. According to zoning records, the structure was converted to a duplex prior to adoption of the 1975 Zoning Code. Under the present code, a duplex is first peraitted in the RT-1 zoning district. 3. The zoning code (section 60.203c) defines foster care for more than six residents as a community residential facility and it would be first permitted in the RT-1 district sub�ect to special conditions. The applicants are requesting a change of nonconforming use from a duplex to a community residential facility for foster care for up to 10 residents. (contirnied) m�, �. �tnR�rr►u �7�-COr1C�d �y L� � 1�'� 15 � . ac�arr�t— city of saint paul planning commission resolution f�e nu�er date File #10343 Page ltao 4. The Minnesota Department of Human Services records indicate that the Obergs were first licensed at this address in April, 1982, as a group family foster care home for six children. The license was increased to nine children in May, 1984, and to 10 children in January, 1985. S. Foster care for six or fewer children is a permitted use in the R-3 single family district (section 60.412(8)) . Therefore, the foster care program operated at this address was a conforming R-3 use for over two years, 6. Section 62.102(e)(5) requires that when a nonconforming use of a structure is discontinued for 365 days, the structure shall thereafter be used in conformance with the regulations in which it is located, unless the Planning Co�ission, after public hearing, finds that the structure cannot be reasonably or economically used for a conforming purpose, that the proposed use is equally appropriate or more appropriate to the district than the prevfous nonconforming use� and that the proposed use is consistent with the health, safety� morals� and general velfare of the community and is consistent with the reasonable use and enjoyaent of adjacent property. 7. According to the applicants and a representative from Ramsey County, the ILS program is more expensive to operate than a typical foster care program and would be economically infeasible to operate with six or fewer residents. The applicants stated that it is necessary to have an average of 7 to 8 residents to . cover the additional costs associated with the IIS program. 8. The proposed nonconforming use, a foster care home for up 10 young adults, is as appropriate as a duplex, the previous use cf the property. Both are first permitted in the RT-1 zoning district. Furthermore� it would be possible to have a foster care home for up to six residents in each unit for a total of 12 residents. (continued) IrtOv�ed by seconded by in €��+or— ��— . .��,: �.�� . � c,ity of saint paul pianr�ng comrnission reso�,tion f�e number date File #10343 Page Three 9. The ILS program is a unique foster care program for young adults providing a needed alternative to the traditional foster care service. It is the only program of this nature operated in Ramsey County. The ILS program has been more successful at this location than at two other locations, in part, because the property is a duplex, allowing greater physical independence for program participants. Therefore, to allow the continuation of the program is consistent with the health, safety, morals and general welfare of the community. 10. Since 1984, the ILS foster care program has operated at this location without any negative impact on the surrounding neighborhood. � 11. According to the zoning code, a foster care facility for more than 6 residents is a community residential facility and requires a special condtion use permit. It is permitted in the RT-1 district subject to five conditioas. This nonconforming community residential facility can meet all but one of the special conditions: a minimum distance of 1,320 feet is required between zoning lots used for community residential facilities. 12. The nearest community residential facility� Balbriggen, is an interim care facility for the mentally retarded operated by Dungarvin, Inc. at 1270 Larpenteur Street. The distance between the two zoning lots is approxiaately 1,000 feet. A modification of the distance condition is required. 13. The Planning Commission may modify any or all special conditions when strict application of such special conditions would unreasonably limit or prevent otherwise lawful use of a piece of property ar an existing structure and vould result in exceptional undue hardship to the ovner of the property or structure, provided that it will not impair the intent and purpose of such special conditions and is consistent with health, morals, and general welfare and is consistent with the reasonable enjoyment of the adjacent property. (continued) mov�ed by s�econded by inf��- .rtst— � � � c;ity of saint paul pianr�g comrnission re�so�tion f�e nurr�er date File #10343 Page Four 14. The intent of the distance requirement condition is to prevent concentrations of community residential facilities in neighborhoods. Since the nearest facility, ` Balbriggen, has only six residents and is 1,000 feet from 163b East Shore Drive, allowing the foster care program for up to 10 residents at this location will not result in a overconcentration of facility residents in the neighborhood. NOW, THEREFORE� BE IT RESOLVED, that the Saint Paul Planning Co�nission, under the authority of the City's Legislative Code, has determined that proposed foster care home is as appropriate as the previous duplex at 1636 East Shore Drive and hereby approves the Change of Nonconforming Use; r BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that after a public hearing, the Platuiing Commission hereby � finds that the property is within 1�320 feet of another community residential facility, but that modification of the distance condition will not impair the intent and purpose of the special condition and is consistent with the health. aorals and general welfare of the community; . BE IT FINALLY RESOLVED, t�►at the Planning Commission does hereby apgrove the application for a Special Condition Use Permit to allow the establishment of a community residential facility for up to 10 young adults at 1636 East Shore Drive sub�ect to the following conditions: 1. The owners of the property live in the structure. 2. At no time shall the be more that 10 young adults in the program. 3. No resident of the program shall have a car. 4. When the program terminates, the structure can revert back to a duplex. �� s�COnded by _ in fav�or- . aga�nst- �'' �'-��o� . . l�IINUTES OF THE ZONING COI�iITTEE CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS, SAINT PAUL, IiINNESOTA ON AUGUST 18� 1988 �: Mmes. Hirte, Morton, Tracy and Zieman; Messrs. Christenson, I.evy� Neid and Repke of the Zoning Connittee; lir. Segal, Assistant City Attorney; Ms. I.ane of the Building Inspection and Design Division; Ms. Freese, Ms. I�Iurray and Mr. Soderholm of the Planning Division staff. �iBSEI�TT : None. The meeting was chaired by Gladys Morton, Chairman. Russell and Beverly Ober� (#10343): A Change of Nonconforming Use Permit from a duplex to a community residential facility and a Special Condition Use Permit with modification at 1636 East Shore Drive to allow the continued use of the structure as a foster care home for 10 young adults. The applicant was present; there �as opposition present at the hearing. I+Is. Freese sho�ved slides of the sit�. distributed pictures of the home's interior and exterior provided by the applicant, and reMewed the ataff report with a reco�endation for d�enial. She stated that she has been unable to confirn a report that Dungarvin, Inc. , aa interis care facility f�r the mentally retarded at 1270 I.arpsnteur, approafsately 1,0� feet away fxom the applicant's property, is beiag phased out wittiin the next six months. 2oning Committee member� discus�ed staff report findings. � Dale Nathan, 3435 Washington Driva� 8agan, attorney representing the applicants, described the faciiity. 8e aaid tbat sfacs 1984 one of the units in the home has been leased by 8aasey County for the Indepe�ent Living Skills (IIS) program administered by the Obergs and that this �icense is for one to six children. Initially, in 1982. the Obergs �►ere licensed for a total of six children; ia 1984 they were increased for niae children; and in January, 1985 for up to 10 children �rhich includes both the IIS a� foster care children. Mr. Nathan stated that the Oberga have ezpanded heavily in their hoae so that they can better serve thase children. Mr. Christenson requested aore inforaation about the rn�ber of foster children and the progran. Mr. Nathan responded that there are t�ro different prograns� the ILS prograa and traditional foster care, aad that the numbers vary between the programs, but that the rn�bers never eaceed ten. He said that the Obergs are co�itted to haviug six to eigtit childran in the IIS prograa. Ms. 2iartha Gerkey, sugerviaor of the fostar care vmit of Rassey County Hu�an Services� said tbat care such as the Obar�s pravide is a very special asset in the co�nunity and that 1�a aeed for this �tgpe of `facfiity is grol►3.ng. She stated tbat both fsderaY �ad st.ite 6a►e�■sats hav�e i�ez�ased their grants to facilities �hich prepara:childten to su�ecessfully traasition betxeen fost�r care and indepeetulent �.i�ri�j'-��s.' CtrteJ~��e�i�fi+ed �` e�tta33ty of care and the valusble reaource of-xhe t�ergs• IL'S pro�c,m. � , File *10343 Page 1�vo lis. Zieman asked about house rules and about the nuaber of progra�s conducted at the home. Ms. Gehrke responded that the Obergs acco�odate tvo programs, one for foster children and one for the IIS children. The IIS area of the home is upstairs and those children have different rules than the foster children housed on the first floor, and that the children froa the two programs do not associate with each other. She said that the Obergs are licensed for a total of ten children and that those children can be in either program. Kr. Neid asked if ILS has a license. Ms. Gehrke responded that the state of Minnesota licensing process is one by which the antire house is licensed and that there is no separate designation for IIS. Mr. Neid asked hop many IIS facilities are licensed in Saint Paul. Ms. Gehrke said that the Obergs' hoae is the only one. lls. Tracy questioned if foster children at the Obergs are phased into the IIS program. Ms. Gehrke stated that they do not uecessarily go into that program but that they could, depending on the individual case. lir. Repke asked for the rnmber of chi2dren separately housed, upstairs and downstairs. ll�c. Christenson stated that it seems as if the facility is legal ; for siu cbildren. ' Mr. Nathan stated that �vl�sat is before the coanittee is the life or the death of the IIS program. . He said that the Obergs could continua as a foster home Nith no sore tban six children as part of a single fasily hoae or aa a duplex ; �rith aiz ehildren in sach part. ; I�ir. Christenson asked if it Mss necessary to have tora t�an siz children in the progra�s in order to ensure financial viability. �r. Nathan re�sponded yes, that last year Mas the first tiae the operation vas "in the black" and that if the ho�e pas licensad for only six, the Oberg� could tat coatinue the IIS program. llr. I�eid inquired about the length of tiae ILS has bean in the Oberas' hoae. Mr. Nathan said that it began in 1984 and before that tiae tbe ho�e operated as a regular foster hose, licensed for six or fever children. Pat Rife, 1075 Arcade Street, District 5 co�nity orgaaizer, testified that ahe did not "flyer" the neigbborhood but aslred Bevszly Oberg to co�e before their Land Osa aad Zoning Cosittee on Juc�e 3, :1988 in,arder;� diaeuss her �. application. �a. Bife said tbat on Julp 19, ;1958, tbs tail �District 5 ` Platining Couacil aet, tmaai�wusly approved tha aPPlicatio� `�ad tbat .t�►ep did � aot recaive my call� fron t�e neigbborhood at �st tiae._. �S -stat�d-.f�at ; appro�i�ately t�o �res�rs ago t�are ue�e t�no..c�o�►I,�iats, � �s-i� d ; aad found aut t�at theze �as a lot of �isum�ii= >-�.�� ., . ,. stu�din8�� e ,�$; � actioa. and that �he caild aot substantiate �uty of the ca��it�#,s abo�t,tbe � PrOP��Y• . . , - Kr. �att►s� prssented a verbal Iisting-of tbe types of cbi3ds� =saidit� fn the ; Obergs' t�oaie, File N10343 Page Three I.es Johnson, 366 East Larpenteur, said that he is Mrs. Oberg's uncle and that he and his wife reside in the home and care for the children when the applicants are away for a weekend or on vacation. He described abused/misused children that the Oberg's have assisted through this program and said that he considers it a privilege to care for them. Mr. Neid asked if Mr. Johnson resides in a single family home and also the length of time that he has been helping at 1636 East Shore Drive. Mr. Johnson responded yes to the former question and eight or nine years to the latter. Mr: Neid questioned whether or not, during that time period� the applicant's hose has always been a duplex. Mr. Johnson replied affirnatively. Jenny, a resident of the IIS facility at 1636 East Shore Drive, said that she has lived there since the end of February, that the "program is excellent" and that ahe has "coae a 2ong way." that she graduated fron high school on June 9, pill go to I.ake`rood Community College and now �rorks at Rocky Rococo's. Chris Larson, 1601 English� stated that she is graduate of the IIS program� is now at :Lakewood, Morks at Ramsey Nursing Home in the Alzheiaer's care unit. She testified to the aerits of the Oberg's facility. • Bob S1ade,-2090 East Highway 36� North St. Paul, testified that he has lrnoNn the Obergs for' eight years and addressed the merita of the program. xuasell Oberg, 1636 East Shore Drive� said that he is a dispatcher with the llatropolitaa Transit Coapaay and that Beverly, "bia wife, ia the boss" of their foster care bo�e. He testified that their last tax stateaent shoms an aversge of eight residents in their facility. that it is a "coaing and going thing." Mr. Oberg stressed that their property is a private boae, not an institution, auid that it ras his belief that they �rere properly licensed for up to ten childzau. He described an altercation uith the fa�iily abutting their rear yard and told of the $2.000 wooden privacy fence constructed by the Ob�rgs to avoid future probleas. 1�lr. Repke asked about the configuration of beds. l�ir. Oberg replied that there are six v�stairs and four doMnstairs, that they have four a�nciliary beds in the baseaent ("which vas nodified to aeet the fire code•). He described the floor plan of the house as having three floors, first floor (the base�ent), sacond floor {�ahere he and his xife and foster children reside)� and the third floor �rhars t�ere are three bedrooas. Mr. Paid asked Mhich portion of the house is used for the ILS program. lir. Oberg ragponded that it �as the first and ,third floor:. lir.--�pks qu�s��baed lrhsther the ho�e had txa addresses rhen it �ras used as -t�e+o separata ;?tmits. Mr. 0berg said that it has al�ays been one address. , � , File �10343 Page Four Beverly Oberg� 1636 East Shore Drive, traced her personal history from age 16 to the present tiae and said that she has a two-year interdisciplit�ary degree from LakeWOOd and she a:mmually updates her skills by talcing 50 hours of training. She testified that she "runs a very strict program," described the type of children for Whom they care� the rules of the facility, and said that she did �ould like to continue her program. lis. Oberg said that she has the ability to screen applicants to the facility. She stated that their hoae and yard are ,aintained in an excellent condition. Mr. Christenson asked if there is an economic condition which necessitates having aore than six foster children. l�s. Oberg rssponded yes. He inquired about their agreeaeat �ith Saasey County Hunan Services for the IIS program. l�s. Oberg replied that thay tiave a rental agreeaent wit.�i ttaasey Couaty. Mr. Oberg added that it is a one year contract Nith 30 daq notice. l�s. Oberg said that they receive a �nthly check from Ranseq County which is used to cover the needs and skills development of the children. l�r. Christenson aslced Nhether or not the Obergs continue to have tWO separate living units. Ms. Oberg stated that they do. l�r. Repke inquired vhy they need a foster care license. Ms. Oberg replied - that ttie entire house is licensed and that they aaat tbe special condition use attached to the house. Iir. Neid asked how the IIS applicants are screened. 1�Is. Oberg said that there are four acreenings by professionals and that they can accept or reject the applicants too. � Virgil Meyer, 2626 Ba�t Shors Drive. presentad a petition in oppo:ftion to rezoning signed by 145 people representing 100 hoaes. Ms. Iiorton stated ttlat the applicant is applying for aonconforaing use and a special condition vae rather tban rezoning. Mr. Segal stated that the property �ould conti=rue to be zoned as single fasily. Shirleq l�eyer, 1626 Bast Shore Drive, joined her husband and testified that their opposition was due to the size of the lot not beiag conducive to sccoa�odating =ore thaa siz foster children. They aho�red a aap of the area. callsd sttsaticrn to the si.�qgle fasily zaning, and cited staff tsport finding rnaber 9 rega«d#ng the distance betasea.Duagarvin and the applfcsnt's facility. i�ir, Iieyer xelated his opinian about the potential es�alation in re�idents �tie�.catild be pez�itted at th� facility aad also about the Obergs' abilit� �o:.s�rr�.se• !!r. 6�uc3s�anaoa asked for supporting svider►ce regarding s�rvisiaa. ;,l�ir. 1�s�er testifiad �hat lw`�ssked tbe Saint Pau1 Police to �ociseat :iacidsnts af calls raquestad to the Obargs' 'hoae. He distri�utad an infor�ti� .diaclosnre fora froa the Saiat Fsul �'olice Depsrt�aat cavsriag °a pariod af Jamaa=y 1, 1987 to Augu:t.8,- I988. 8e said ttut ttiere nere 42 sepuate in�cid�snts. �' �R' _.�,:.,�� . File �10343 Page Five Mr. Christenson asked if Mr. Meyer had any direct contact with the Obergs or their residents. Mr. Meyer replied that he had no reason to have contact �ith them but that he did notice frequent police calls to the home. Mr. Christenson said that the "bulk" of incidents note runaways or aissing persons, and asked Mr. Meyer that for the period of time of his residence in the neighborhood if he was not personally aware of anq problens that have been caused by that house. llr. Meyer replied� "I have not pezsonally been involved." l�Ir. Christenson asked if anyone told Mr. Neyer that residents of the Oberg progrsm were involved in any problems. Mr. Pteyer responded that it pa� only the incident previously described by Mr. Oberg. l�ir. Christenson whether or not I�Sr. Meyer Would have had reason to imraatigate the matter if he had not received a notice describing the Obergs' request. lir. Meyer atated that he �ight have wanted to start asking soae question� because of a possible change in property values, the integrity of the neighborhood, etc. Mr. Christenson asked if there aas any occurrence over ihe past seven year� which �ould causa the surrounding houses to lose value; also �fiether ar not, in l�ir. Meyer's opinion� that the contiuuing present use of the property or the rental of the upper duplex uait would cause a loss in property valwss to th� surrounding neighborhood. Kr. Meyer responded that in his opinion the conditions under which the house is being operated are being changed and said that in a R-3 zone no more than six foster children Would be permftted. _ lir. Levy stated his appreciation of Mr. Iieqer's concern and observation�. - Nr. Neid asked that if a special condition use pernit is graated to this property for ten young foster care children, ages 16-18, at phat point aay tLe applicant have a larger rnmber than ten. Ms. Freese replied that the applicant could not have aore than ten if the permit is granted for that nimber. Dr. Donald Koza, 1171 East Idaho, said that he has resided in bis ho�e for over 20 years, that his property abuts the rear yard of the �erg�, and tt�at he opposes granting t2►e nonconforaing use perait. He said tbat tu is aasinst having aore than six foster children in the hoae and suggested that perhaps lirs. Oberg could be an instructor for others interested in the II.4 proar�. Mr. Neid asked if it pas Dr. Koza's floaers xhich Nere trao�led. Dr. 16osa said yes, that he coaplained to the Obergs, and that the.situstion �ras resolved. Iir. Christeasoa queationed .if there-had beea sag atbe= p�robin�s �rith tbs ; Oberg's foster childrsn. Dr. Koza repii�d thara :hsv�e bssn:a mmbsr of esergancy vehicle calle' to the house. Mr. t�uciat�rnsa�;.�rs�aed f.f"the tlberg's , : property is well saf,ntaiaed. Dr. Koza respaaded affir�rativalq. . 1 ' . File �10343 Page Six Jerry Bucher, 1642 East Shore Drive� aaid that he has no aniaosity towards the Obargs� but that Mrs. Bucher has a fear of strangers� and that this is his only problem with the Oberg's request. Mr. Neid asked if they share the aaae driveway. Mr. Bucher said yes. Mr. Neid inquired about the number of years they bave resided in their present hone. Mr. Bucher replied 21 years and that the Oberg's ho�e �as a duplex at that time. Mr. Arnold Jacobson, 1632 East Shore Drive, aaid that he has been a real estate broker for 40 years, that he agrees with l�c. Meyer's stateaents. that he is concerned about the potential reduction in property valu�s. and referred to the petition in opposition presented by Mr. Meyer. I�. Zisnan asiced if be was aware that the Obarg's have baan licsnsed fro� the State of Mirn►esota for four qears. Mr. Jacobaon said that ha notices a lot of traffic around the Oberg's house but that because of his �ploy�ant 'durimg `the eveaing hours, obaervation is difficult. Ms. Ziesaa �:ndicatad t-.lsat the petition refers to rezon�ng and asked Mr. Jaeobson if tie a�d t.lu sigaars - realized that. Mr. Jacobson replied yes, but tbat he thought tbe pro�erty - required rezoning. , Mr. Christenson asked if in Mr. Jscobaon•a opinion as s brolcar. :�he �ra'�.ues �of the ad�acent propertiss to the Obergs have changad in valaa sfacs �l�l, �lore than other properties in the neighborhood. 8a questio�ed �hather .�the 4berg property is better, worse or the sane since 1981 md asl�ed if llr:. Jacobaoa Nould disclose, when selling property ia the i�ediate nei�hbor�tood, t�utt ;the Oberg ho�e is used as a foster home. lir. Jscobson r�spoadsd ttwtt tl�I�;�tlt�stgs have aaintained the property and the yard. He added tbat if bs �-.-�nto�rlidge of a uae of md�acent property, it �o�u].d ba his duty to disclo*s tl�et infoiaation to prospective custo�rs. Mr. Neid questioned Whether or not tsr. Jacobsan �ad a� probl�as vith:tt�. foster care children. Mr. Jacobson said t3�at at 11 or 12 fa tbs raenia6� there pas a rapping at his door, he asl�ed the foater child wz� politslf tet to ' disturb thea. I�Ir. Neid askad if tbat incidaat �raa conv�ad to ths E!l�s�s, Mr. Jacob:on said that he did a� added that he has seen as ssny as tlu�se police cars at the Oberg h�. Tom Gallagher, 1628 Duluth, asked to �ehoa the conditianal uae per�it Moald be granted. Ms. l�torton replied that it would ba to ths tybe�cas. Mr. Nathaa thanlcad the Zoaing Co�ittea for tbeir patia� +� . t�t�3t�g. fle related reasans for:of police calls to thi tbara ba�e s�d �� ``��t area, too, is on� tbat is aonducfv�e to traffit bt�a�ss �f�it�s � '�4�{�a I.ake P'l�a�:aa. . ' 1 ' . � , , .r:. - . W ` � � . > :: �; : � .: �,f�� ' '�,�� 1£ti.� .. _.,, . Ms. Zi�e�an aslced that tha .presanca af s�l.iae .at..tt�► ��: � � �� '' � � � . .. �:. �- lirs. Obarg esplafned tfist �er�c��r 3+�-'��-��i►4 , � " P poZice rasiding #n_the.uea aad:�efi�;��.#a ,. ..i�iaYSN j,, � proz�ai�ty to tbe psrt. �.,�� _ �-,� t . . File �t10343 Page Seven Mr. Neid a�ked how �any foster care children, ages 16-18 live in the Oberg residence at the present tine. Mrs. Oberg replied that there are eight, counting the ten-aonth old infant. lir. Repke stated that according to the police report, out of a total of 41 calls to the Oberg hoae, 29 are for runaway or aissing persons� and asiced for more information on that. Mrs. Oberg stated that they ue obligated to call the police for any child that has not returned hone by curfe�r tiae. She added that if one child steals from or fights pith anothar child, they are alao required to report the incident to police. Iir. Neid asked for tha adult to young adult ratio and for the t�usber of adult� supervising the IIS prograa. l�rs. Oberg said that she �d har husband aupervise and nm the prograa and if they are avay, there 'ars alaays txo adults in their home to supervi�e. Mr. Neid inquired abautt the nweber of ' years that the Obergs have had foster cbildren. Mrs. `Oberg repliad that before moving to East Shora .Drive they lived at 1627 Dietar, �a b2ock froa Frost Iake School, and that they have approxisately ll y�sar� of exparienca. Hearing no further testi�ony� Ms. lrtorton closed tbe:public portian of the � seeting. .. . Discussion follo�ed r�garding the conditions fos appravin� a spacial coAdit,ioA use permit pith �wdification becavse of tbe 1320• dis�sot�a 'froe an�ther � com�nunitq residential facility. tha appropriataneas of ths propoa�d � nonconforming use of the property, �rhether or aot its vse as a duplex could be restored upon teraination of the prograa, and licsnsiag. lir. Naid aade a aotion to .recorsnd approval of .the � ot',�pqcwpfNq�;� . _ IIse fron a duplez-ta a foater hose and Indapea�a�t-�t.f'', �Sld�ls'< � young adults; and a 3pecial Condition IIse Psr�it �rith� t to s�cd�„ �e �s � distance requi.r�asnt to coatirn�e aperating tbe c�■�etitf rssl�fen,tisl�facflfty � aub�ec t to the condition� that (1) the oMe�ers of.,t�e Pi''epert9 liv�s in 'tbs < ' structure, (2? at no tfae shall there b� sora tbstt I,0 y+o�mg adults fn the progrsa. (3) no resident of the prograa shall have a cu, and (4) vhen Che prograa terainates, the structure can ravert bact to a +anplax. .�Mr. Christenson seconded the aotion �hich passed an a roll call vote of 7-0. Subaitted by: epp=aved by; �� / �c�¢.s.q_ i�i��%" Lisa Freese G].�s ton, A�aia� ;;:v � �. r:E� -�� ,.�.�� ' �� w� ,� ;t� _, :., _ ..: �,: _ �_: . � � - a� �� ' ZONING COMMITTEE STAFF REPORT FILE #10343 1. APPLICANT: Russell and Beverly Oberg ' DATE OF HEARING: 8/lg/gg 2. CLASSIFICATION: Change of Nonconforming Use and Special Condition Use 3. LOCATION: 1636 East Shore Drive (East side between Idaho and Larpenteur) 4. PLANNING DISTRICT: S 5. LEGAL DESCRIPTION: Lot 7, Block 15, Overbrook Addition 6. PRESENT ZONING: R-3 ZONING CODE REFERENCE: 60.412(8); 60.423(3) ; 62.102(e) 7. STAFF INVESTIGATION AND REpORT: DATE: 8/11/88 BY: Lisa J. Freese A. 0 E: To establish a foster care home for 10 children. 8. PARCEL SIZE: The parcel has 45 feet of frontage along East Shore Drive and a depth of 200 feet for a total lot area of 9�000 square feet. C. FXISTING LAND USE: Presently the structure is used as a foster care home for seven �uvenile residents. D. �L�ROUNDING USE: North, East and South: One family residential West: Lake Phalen E. ZONING HISTORY: In 1965, the City Council approved a variance of the frontage requirement to permit a duplex that had been illegally established by a previous owner. F. �'INDINGS: 1. The applicants, Russell and Beverly Oberg, have operated a group fa.mily foster care home for children ages 16 to 18 at this location since they purchased the property as a duplex in December, 1981. Presently, they have seven residents, three males and four females, and are licensed by the Minnesota Department of Human Resources for up to 10 residents. 2. According to zoning records, the structure was considered a legal nonconfarming duplex in 1981. A duplex is first permitted in the RT-1 zoning district. � 3. The zoning code (section 60.203c) defines foster care for aore than silc � residents as a comaunity residential facility end it would be first permitted in � the RT-1 district subject to special conditions. The applicants are requesting a change of nonconforming use from a duplex to a community residential facility � for foster care for up to 10 residents. 4. The Minnesota Department of Human Services records indicate that the Obergs were first licensed at this address in April, 1982� as a group family foster care home for six children. The license was increased to nine children in May, 1984, and to 10 children in January, 1985. � . Foster care for six or fewer children is a permitted use in the R-3 single family district (section 60.412(8) . Therefore, the foster care program operated at �his address was a conforming R-3 use for over two years. File #10343 Page Two 6. Section 62.102(e)(5) requires that when a nonconforming use of a structure is discontinued for 365 days� the structure shall thereafter be used in conformance with the regulations in which it is located, unless the Planning Commission, after public hearing, finds that the structure cannot be reasonably or economically used for a conforming purpose, that the proposed use is equally appropriate or more appropriate to the district than the previous nonconforming use, and that the proposed use is consistent with the health, safety, morals, and general welfare of the community and is consistent with the reasonable use and enjoyment of adjacent property. 7. The structure was originally built in 1923 as a single family home. It is a large house and according to the applicant, it has eight bedrooms and four bathrooms. The applicant, however, has not demonstrated that it cannot reasonably or economically be used for a conforming foster care program. In fact, the applicants used it as such for over two years. 8. The proposed nonconforaing use, a community residential facility for 10 residents, is not as appropriate as a duplex� the previous legal nonconforming use of the property. Both are first permitted in the RT-1 zoning district� but a community residential facility is permitted only after review by the Planning Commission and if five special conditions are met. 9. This nonconforming community residential facility cannot meet one of the special conditions: a minimum distance of 1,320 feet will be required for zoning lots used for co�unity residential facilities. The nearest community residential facility is an interim care facility for the mentally retarded operated by Dungarvin, Inc. at 1270 Larpenteur Street. The distance between the two zoning lots is approximately 1,000 feet. 10. The intent of the distance requirement condition is to prevent concentrations of community residential facilities in neighborhoods. Therefore, to re-establish nonconforming status to allow a foster care home for 10 residents not meeting the spacing requirement for community residential facilities� is �ore inappropriate than the previous nonconforming use, and is inconsistent with the health, safety, morals and general welfare of the community. G. STAFF RECOPII�ENDATION: Based on staff report findings 1 through 10, staff reco�ends denial of the Change of Nonconforming Use and the Special Condition Use permit to allow a foster care home for 10 persons. APPLICATION FOR NONCONFORMIN6 USE PERMIT CITY OF SAINT PAUL ZONING OFFICE USE ONLY . Zoning File # lD ��,3 RECEiVED Application Fee S ?�s .�UL 11 �9$B Tentative Hearing Date �—($—g`� ZONIN G Number of Lots or Size of Parcel: ______________________________________ A legal nonconforming use of structure/land is one which lawfully existed on October 25, 1975, the effective date of the adoption of the Saint Paul Zoning Code. Application is hereby made for a Nonconforming Use Permit under provisions of Chapter 62, Section 102, Subdivision 5, Paragraph 3 of the Zoning Code. __________________________________________________________________________________________ A. APPLICAN Name S; ��c./ one (Daytime) �7' — 7Z3 � 7` Address �� T �'/�r�,�s' ,�,� Zip �1�� Property interest of Applicant (Owner, contract purchaser, etc.) �G(J,(/f� Name of owner (if different) /V `� =ax�==s=o=azaca=oeaaoa=aao=a=aa==as=:=oaaa==a=xo=sxa=aa==aaasa�xan=ae====as�x=xsr=3==a==a B. PROPERTY DESCRIPTION Address/Location ��v3� ,�,l�S% _S%}��2 Qj2 legal Description: Lot _Z Block � Add. C� u��3,�/� Present Zoning �—� �� Lot Siie � � � 1 ' , � _cxms===a==ac==o===c=======sa=o==o=====a=o===e===o=xs�a=aa--s_s__-____x�=_----_a=�a=mxoa=a __ _ _______ � -___� C. USE INFORMATION Previous Use (Attach supporting documentation) /J�r� ��x Pr;�osed Jse or Change (Attach Site Plan) r��.�� CA�2.� -�r . .___ / , �t. . �_;r.-o�,-, . = .�� . � _ ��_ �..as�� _ _, �iease con�ac±. - _ _-. _ -_- __ � .�0 �;-„ Nal � annex _•�? - - - �- - - - �,- _ __ , M;!inaSQ`3 :�:�itri'L �`�3-=��'+ - - ,��- _a � G� APPLICATION FOR SPECIAL CONDITION USE CITY OF SAINT PAUL ZONING OFFICE USE ONLY File 4��0 3y 3 R E C E I V E D Application Fee $ � Tentative Hearing Date _� -/ u -�� C JUL 111988 Number of Lots or Size of Parcel: ZONING Application is hereby made for a Special Condition Use Permit under the provisions of Chapter (�l� , Section � 23 , Paragraph 3 , of the Zoning Code to operate a � , �;b rr1rn�.��;tT, ��s'.c€c..��fiQ_ f ; {��ft.� -�c>�Y�_, �'z..� �c� lG cG.�lc�e�� A. APPLIC T � �`��e'� 6�1 � - �17 i`t Name S Phone (Daytime) � 7C,/-7Z,:3y Address c .s Zip J S� � �o Property interest of Applicant (Owner, contract purchaser, etc.) �(�� Name of owner (if different) /�/ l� B. PROPERTY DESCRIPTION Address/Location _j�3(o �'��j �,�j��, Q/� Legal Description: Lot �Block_�_�Add.�B�[�Otc� Present Zoning_ �-� Lot Size � _ � /,�f Sr �_ C. SPECIAL CONDITIONS Explain how you will meet each of the Special Conditions. Attach supporting materials (diagrams, site plan, letters of support, etc.) _ �C -;�. - 'f —�_ <Y-. - _ ,- _ _ . : -- :.z - � • - = - - �.- --' a, ;�, - . _ _ .: .._ _ a-- �--:, -��„a - .. . __. - _ -- ._._,___ . _.__. . _ `ain* Pdui _J�i^� �IfiC? : . , , .._. ' .._'_ '... '.P�. i � . � � ,� i 0 � � � � � � -� � � � � �� . � 3 -, � � � � � _ � � � � � � � � �� a � � � � - � � � _ � � `� �° -�` � � . ` � J� ` � ' , � � ` � � , v � � t �� a � � � � � �� : . � � � z � �� ; � � ; � � ; � , � ; � , ;-�, ; _ �' _ � j , 4 __i . ;_ _ F i � � i � � �i � ( � � , f � ' � ` ; � � ; � ' � � ' � ; , � � : � t � , . c)! , � � � � � � � : �; , � ; t/}; � ; � caq � �j: � � cn , N � `'� � J; ; ; � � � �° � � , � � � ' `-'; � � c� ' � `� � �: w ; ; � 1 -� � ��. � j " � � `�, � , � � ; � � ; � � � � � �`; ` �� `� a s - � _� �i � �, � ; � _V � � ' � � F i � � l ' � � ' �� ` � � ; � ! �f� � � i � ' J �, � � �� ; �. , q�. �� ; � � � ; i i � � � i � ' �, , ; � f � � � � � � , � 3� � � � , � ; Q � � � � � `�1 � Q� � E.; ; � � � � _� c� � . � �: �� J , �k ,�'. � f � � °! ; � �� o � c� � � �� a I.l ; � � �,'3 � `� 1+�� ' � v � �� ` � � � �; � W � } � � � � � � 9 � J � 7 �'�'_� �- .� -� � � �' �; � �, �-�, ' � a � �. � �..,,. �; � : � - � � � .� � � � � PROGRAM aT �HF, UBEftG AP�RT>IF.NT revised 7%8� TO 1{ELP aDOLESCE":TS L°:\RN IvDEPENDF\*T LIVING SKILLS . �� `�U(/`�- � FUNCTIO� 1 . To provide a supervisec safe living place that :�eets state, community, and court standards for persons unde- a�e 18. _. To provide an envirornnent in which the residents can learn and/or exercise independent living skills. GOAL Prepa ration of adolescents to become adequately functioning adults who can use their abilities as well as available communitv resources to maintain their independence. " CLIENT POPULATION Young men and women, ages 16 through 18, who cannot live in their parents' h ane and who are not free/or able to yet live independently. Many persons will have been th rough a variety of living arrangements, such as adoptive or foster h anes, treatment settings, the street , prior to placement. HISTORY AND DEVELOPMENT The need for an independent living skills program was defined in 1982. Ramsey County Community Human Services needed a program that would provide an environ- ment for adolescents to achieve independent living skills; in particular, for the adolescent client who needed social services until his 18th b.irthday and who had been through a variety of treatment resources in the ILS (Independent Living Skills) placement. Originally, there were three shelter foster h anes and the Arlington House Shelter who provided independent living skills space. As of September 1 , 1983 only one independent living skills program was needed and this program was provided in the Russell and Beverly Oberg g roup f oster home. The Obergs' have available for this program the first and third floor of their home which has been converted into an apartment with a kitchen, living room, three bathrooms, and f our bedrooms. ADMISSION CRITERIA Persons not appropriate for this program will be ad olescents who are chemically dependent and still using drugs, who have severe emotional probl-ems, who are seve rely mentally retarded and those adolescents not willing to participate in a mutually agreed upon plan for the time they are in the program. The intent of the program is to pravide an enviromnent for the adolescents to Iearn independent living skills. There will be no attempt to force an adolescent into this prog ram, but rather a structure will be created under which hopefully, this learning will take place. REFERRAL PROCESS Social workers and probation office rs should contact the Foster Care Unit regarding availability of space in this program. Social workers should discuss the client needs with Barbara Cann on or Mary Jo Hassel and with Russ and Bev Oberg. The decision to place a client in the ILS Program will be arrived at mutually between the worker for the adolescent and the Obergs' . PAYMENT TO THE OBERGS The. ILS payment process is accomplished through the Shelter Payment Sys[em. Contact Sue Majerus regardine the shelter payment orocess . � RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE PLaCI\G S�CIAL WORKER The Obergs' expect social wor'.�cers using this program :�: tneir c].ient t� ac: primarily as a resource person for the client. It is ex�ected that the �xial eaork approach would be similar to that of :�dult Service, �aith more expectations of the resp onsibility on the client to act as an independent adult. The social workers should be supportive of the Obergs' expectations of the adolescent and encourage the adolescent to compl�� with the rules and structure as established by the Obergs' . The social worker should be available for a meeting with the client and provider one week after the placement. RESPONSIBILITY OF THE FOSTER CaRE STAFF Foster care staff will license the provide r and monitor the proAress of the program. They will provide training and help facilitate meetings between the pravider and social workers when necessary. RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE PROVIDER AND AUTHORI7ED SUPERVISION We expect that the provider will research community resources. With this knowledge they will work on developing a network system for use by the adolescents. They will continue to w ork within the structure of the individual program to expose the client to the skills necessary for independent living. The Obergs' believe an adolescent learns independent living skills by having to live within an environment with clear time structures and rules. Beverly and Russell Oberg will help residents with the f ollaaing: Help with menu planning Setting up education Cooking Purchasing items for independence Checking Accounts - Savings Apartment hunting Budgeting Sewing - Patching Cleaning Washing clothes Job Hunting Child care programs _2_ THF. CRITERIA aND RULES FOR LIVING IN THE OBERG aPART*1ENT j,'��_ �7�j0 t�, FOR LEARNING INDE°ENDENT LIVINC: SKILLS 4 d�5 . BASIC PL�N The basic plan that the Obergs ' will institute for each adolescent in this prog ram is that the pe rson wi'1 be responsible to have a meani�gful activity between 7:00 a.m. in the morning and 3:00 p.m. in the afternoon. Ihis includes the adolescent leaving the apartmer.t during those hours of the day to eithe r attend school, look for employment , work in employment or spend time in a volunteer activity with some organization. The Obergs' do not vary or give exceptions to this rule , unless there is a medical doctor' s slip or medical recovery, job or school reason which requires different hours. The Obergs' believe this criteria creates an attitude on the part of the adolescent that they must have a useful activity du ring that time: The adolescents are expected to work a part-time job even though they are attending school full-time since the ultimate goal of this program is for the person to find employment and be self-sufficient and self-supportive at the time he/she is exited from the Program beyone his/her birthday. The ad olescent is responsible for settin� up all contacts with employers, schools and ca�nunity resources. The information regarding resources will be made available to the adolescent by the Obergs' or by the adolescents' worker, but there will be an expectation that the adolescent will pursue and make contacts on their own. See page 2 of Responsibility of the Provider. The rules that follo�o are rules that have been established by the Obergs' for specific reasons and their intent is that the adolescent must understand �there is an expectation that these rules are adhered to. There will be ve ry little inte rfe rence in the adolescent' s life du ring their time living in the Oberg home, if in f act they are able to cooperate within these minimum rules. The expectations of adolescents learning to live together as a group, c ooperate and share, is one that will be stressed in this living skills experience. I. ATTITUDES TO M.AINTAIN WITH OTHER RESIDENTS IN THE APARTMENT You will be treated with respect and will be expected to treat each other person in residence with respect and with respect to each other' s p roperty. There will be no physical, emotional, or verbal abuse to another person living in the apartment or in the h ousehold. � You will have no wlgar language tawards residents and other persons. There will be no sexual activity between residents or sexual activity between residents and guests. The noise in the apartment should be kept to a minimum and there will be quiet in the apartment after 10:00 p.m. since there are other residents in the property. Each person is responsible to watch his own personal belongings and goods and there is no responsibility on the part of the Obergs' to maintain a vigilance wer each person's property. II. HOUSEKEEPING Rt;LES There will be no cigarette smoking on the property, either in the apa rtment, in the hallways , or on the Oberg property. The apartment vi11 be kept clean and livable with all parties participa[inF in maintaining the apartment standa rds. The eating of ineals will be done in the kitchen dining area only. There ' will be no eating in the becr.�oms or livinQroan area. Shoes should be [aken o:f at the entrance and put on rack in entryway. Grocery sh oppi�; will be Sunday and LJednesdays - you will be assigned a time. The back door should be kept locked at all times . The lights should be turned off when you leave a roan and/or the apartment if there is no one left at h ane. Please do not open the wind a�s with out permission. There will be ao pets living in residence or brought into the property. You will not be able to have your friends mwe in with you or live with you even for a short time. You are responsible to keep the hallway and entryway and stainoay clean. You are responsible to keep your own laundry clean and to have the responsibility to do it once a week. You are not a1loWed to paste, nail, or tape anything on the walls or the property without the peimission of Beverly or Russell Oberg. Working out problems, cleaning apartment and payments to residents will be planned in a group meeting Friday between 5:00 and 7:00 p.m. III. HOURS TO KEEP The curfew hours for living in this residence are: Sunday through Thursday, 11:00 p.m. ; Friday and Saturday, 12:30 a.m. unless arranged by worker. Infant curfew will be done on individual basis for parents. You are expected to be inyour bedro ans by curfew time and lights out unless homework demands extra time - then you can study in the kitchen quietly. No eating - dishes - shawers - noise after 10:00 p.m. on weekdays. Come home in time to finish unless yaur job demands different hours. This is for the c onsideration of others in the apartment. No television or radio after 10:30 p.m. on weekdays. IV. VISITORS, CONTACT WITH NEIGHBORS, AND CONTACT WITH GROUP HOME RESIDENTS You are expected to get authorization from Beverly or Russell Oberg if you want to have a visitor and this should be planned sufficiently�ahead to receive this permission. If there is to be an overnight visit of a friend, you will have to have Beverly or Russell' s permission. If you have company, they must park their car in front of the house and use the back door. AI1 of your company and friends must follow the same house rules that you are expected to f ollow. You will not be allowed to have large parties or groups of friends in at the same time. -2- You will no[ have interaction with the group home residents that live in the d ownstairs of the Oberg h ane. They are younAer adolescents who will � not be allowed to associate with older adolescents who have the , independence that each ui the ILS residents shall have. You are expzcted to treat all of the neighbors and person: living in the vicinity with courtesy. You are not to harass any of the neighbors or bother them witn vour problems. Do not cut through their vards. Be quiet while across the street and in the neighborhood of ILS. Grounds for removal if the neighbors complain. V. CONTACTS WITH BEVERLY AI�D RUSSELL OBERG Each resident must be home on Frida afternoons between 5:00 and 7•00 p m This is the formal time that each resident will meet with Beverly and Russell Oberg to plan for your weekly check receiving and any information that the Obergs' believe is necessary for you to have and a time for you to resolve problems or issues with other group members. This is a mandatory meeting that each resident is expected to be present for unless w ork or school interferes - then that individual sets up a different time to meet with the Obergs' . The shopping for food, personal items, receiving a bus card, and so on will be established by Beverly and Russell Oberg. The role that Russell and Beverly Oberg maintain is that they are resource persons whom you may contact to discuss problems or concerns and persons wh o will be of assistance and help to you when you request such help. The Obergs' expect yau to request permission to come to the lower or upper levels of the house to visit or to discuss matters with them. The Obergs' expect you to check in by teleph one if you are at a place that is not on you r regular schedule. VI. MISCELLANEOUS RULES There will be no drugs, alcohol, paraphernalia allawed on this premises. Anyone f ound under the influence of drugs or alcohol will be sent directly to Detox Center. Smoking of cigarettes must be done off of the property. Please do not litter. Teleph ane calls can be made between 7:00 a.m. and 10:00 p.m. There will be no long distance calls. Do not abuse the telephone or it will be removed. If you have an automobile, you will have to make arrangements to pa rk it somewhere off the property. You must have proof of license, owner of title and insurance. There should be no borrowing of items or money from any of the downstairs residents (or upstairs) . You must leave an address and teleph one number when on overnites. No taxi cabs are allowed to be used in this program. -3- �n � _: � Uv� � � m a Nn � °° � — o� QN ° --� : - - dc � ,; ` ; � � t°� i ( t E Iv I = � _ � � I N 1 < p 2 � W W � �, �.r tN U � •s c OC ! 2 J �• � � p �'• � < � �p O` tl! • W i � ][ O � � � � � I = � � O � � E oC (/) �t1 O � E ` � p +� I i/� W r� N c V l'! ; ¢ i > � N Y p o y � Z �' p �D � � � r ip � O � C W -° Z p � d tn � W � � c c aA p� � H `w V � C � ..� � N W m � o, v r « Z � � J ¢ � o � } u _ � O �+ ' G Q N 7 r W a 7 N V 3 i Z z a � �n � $' 1 I � W m a : 4 " � . . c c o = V � ,°, a' °[ e w � J J J tA !� : � F- W e °C 0 W Q aC t� O i « .r �► � U y G =' °c H Z � y ° � Q � o � .' � a J 0 � w o`c °L c Q x � o = � LL = � .'�. v� O °C = ". N ac c v = � •o W � Y O ~ } � Z v� r- �c J � • � � � o o J `i' u. > z � � c, ' � � «. c a " c oc _ � Q � Z Q C � Z a 1 J ,1,, Q J :i T .r r: �C � .� s- ? rn. C C �..> � � a v� S _ Y a 2 • .:� o � t/". .: � 1` N +e � � � � 2 n i I N �/ � :' a Y :/! � U o �C �O :S '.L _ ... .. C � w�. 1 � �"' _ o S �O �' V �' r (l. � �, � � . �-- = : � _ � � i ----4 _�_.. I �S Sl �� ' : � ` � — I . , �,00 il� = ��'j � _ � : : �, � I� G �� . j . -� i-�- � _ � � ; _ , i - . , , �'�5 ; a� �� , ; � — _____ ; _ � � _ � ' 1 � � � .P� . _ . ; � _ . o� o� ; �. � F o : �� . � _ a � �� - � � � _ �� -� _- .__.__ . .�,� � �o� / � � � � ' ��S s � p � � � � � �� ---- "�`' , �,i�� ,-_ � ; �o��` _ �'� �� ', ; __� �� s � � N ; - - ; � 1 �,F � �- -- ,� � P , ; : i �� ; ; � �==- -- -----_ _ �,� , � s . ; . , ;, � � � � �G j-`..,. ; � �� -- � . r'�,�'_ �G,� � . � . � , - � , � ; � � i ! I � � � ,� - - _._.._.._. � � . i _. , t I _ n r O� � � T ��. ` � ' i �� i � ; _ � � 1,�� ; � � 0 , p �� --__----- --- .. ._ .---- �j� -- ..- ,CJ� ; , ��{ ' �R� � � �T�� v �- " _ � �C _ _ __ _ _ ___ ��' � �� : � , -` ` � � ��. - � . . � 1•�� - -- �� - : .:� � �� _ � �� '� � � � . . , �° �� ' � �� 1�° _ : �= -- �..�l� � � � � ; ��' - -��, � J� __ � � " ' .' ; �� f ,� i��' ► . ._ . __� -- - .-- � ��` , ' � : ��- � �� '( C� �,�, ��1 �� o0 1� �� L� � �� '� ' . - - �� . ;y. 2 �.� .. .Y. �::�� -.� v� . � ��..�'`;� � _ � , _ . . . � ��-�- -2��j� t 1 — i t � � , ��. . . , . ' � . ^ - •- . � . . r • � /�� . tQr s . �_ . _ _ _ _. ---- _ _ _ _ __ - - - - - - - ------ - - � _ � _ ._ ___. -- -- -- --- --- -- ------- - - - ---� � _ _. _ _ __ --- -- - - -- --_ - ---- ------ - -- -- --- -- . _._ -- � � ---- _ � --- --- -- - -- - -- _. �- l - - --- --� - ---- - _ _ - ___ _ __ - - -- ---j- ---- • - - _ _ _- -- - ... ... .. 7 . � _ _ - _ _. _ _ _ ._— - - -_ . . --• ---1-- 7,: i— --_. __ ...- -. -._..._- - ----a- - � r '� ._ . . . ..._. . .. _. _ _ _,_._ ._ . _ ._ . . .__' .__' .fL .....;�:_ .�- _' ' .__. ._.._ _. _ .._._. __ ._ \ . :.� 'i . .. _ _._ . _..- _ ___-_ - .__ .__ ._ .. _ _ _. . . . . __._ .__ _'__ _ _ . '-.___ _.___ ___ _^_____-_. , � , ___.. .__ ._"_._ ._ .__.__ _ .__' ___._ .__ . ____.__ � _ _ ' '.__.-_'__-_. ._ _. .___ ' r` . _ ......_._ . . __- ._.. . ��J;T � _ .- � .. � ._..__. _.�_____.-._ ..__. ._.�'____. _ _. . _ _._ .� _._.. _'_'_ __.__._-___"_"1.- _ __'-._.._ . ._ _ .. . r .. . Y. ___._'."_ _ ' _ _.._ _ ..__-_ ._ ._- _ . - '� -_ __. .___. __..-' .. . . _ .._.___._. .. ... � � � .._.' '"__.-' . __ '___ _..__' - .. ._.. ..._'. _ " ._ ..._. . .. _ .. ' _ ' . . ._.._ ___ .. .__ . "_._ _ , _ . .. . __._"_....._._____ _.._.'_-__' .. .. _ _'_" ._' .� _ ' __"' _"_.` _'.___"_._.._ _.__ '_. '. _ _'_'______.' �- ; . , � __.._..�.___"_'___"__-_' _. ""-. ( , . _" , ' -__-� _ ._..___'_'_ '_._.._`__ . . ( ____ __ _._ . ._.___.._ . ._ ._ __...._,___--'_ _ _...'_ "_ ' �._- ` . _ '_. ---_--� '_. .. _..__ .. _ .. . . ._ . ... ._"�.._'__ . ___ __. .. _. _.."__' _. . ._ ._ _" ' �-.-�'_.'_ "'. __.._._"'__'. ._ __ "� , . _. _ ._ __ , ' .__._-'_- -'-__ ._.__"-'___ __ ' _'_"_"__ __'__""___.-_'� ' '_. -_ .._._'__. '___' _-.� '- _ . __' _ __.. .-_ - , ' � �- _�" : . 1-�-- , 1 _ __ __-- — - - — -- -- —— _ — , _' _ , - - -- -- - x -- — ----- _ ------ � - , .— . . .r - -- �- r-,_`_`� `�f�� _� --- - -- . - � -�---� - ----- --____-� , . -� __ , - ----- ----_--� ; _ _ - - - --- --- - - --- . - - -- - - �- -- - - - --�- --3-� -; �-�-- `__ , , -- _ _ _ — ' __ _ - � ' -- —- . - -�--��r ��_��Vt�'�1 -_ -+� � . . - -- _ - ---: ---� -- _ _- . - --- - --- - ---- - _---- -- - ---- - ,_ � , , , . ... . _-___-- '� - - -- ---� - � ,� -- i . •� . . - r . � . - . . . . . i �. I �. ---�------�----- --'.-'_ " , . , . . . , � � . . . . . ,_- '._ --�' . . . - - � '(Y� _. ._._... - . . -- �.�.._ _.._. ._ .... ._._---_.. . _ _ . .. . . - -�--- -_._.__. _. ---- .__ . . __-- --- --. . . . _ __ .. _ f� _ '_ . .. �._� -- - _ _ . . . -- _ _ _ - { 1 - _ -- - _ _ __ ._ _ �-.._,�i - - ------ �- __ _,_. _ ___ _ :. __._ _ _- - --- ---- - , , �� ;� � , � �� • • - � ��' ��-``' r--= �id�Y111., 1riC: Administrative Office � 690 South Cleveland Avenue z � • St. Paul, MN 551 16 Phone:699-6050 August 18, 1988 Dungarvin, Inc. 690 South Cleveland Avenue St. Paul, MN 55116 RE: License and Occupancy Status of Dungarvin III - Balbriggen 1270 E. Larpenteur, St. Paul, Mn 55109 To Whom it May Concern: Dungarvin III - Balbriggen is currently a group home for six mentally retarded adults, owned and operated by Dungarvin, Inc. Ttao staff persons live with the residents. The home is certified under the Federal Medicaid Program as an ICF/MR, licensed by the State Health Department as a Supervised Living Facilty and licensed by the Department of Human Services under Rule 34. Within the next 60 days the facility will downsize to five residents with a future plan to decrease to four should a resident choose to move or Ramsey County make the request. Concurrent with the downsizing to five, there would be a change in certification/licensure. The home no longer would carrq the ICF/MR certif ication; it would contiaue under a Supervised Living Facility license and a Rule 34 license. It would operate under the Medicaid Waiver Program. Should you need any further information, please contact me at 699-6050. Sincerely, %�'� �'-�- Jartice Carver Director � l g �� i � S" /��'� � . , � a . � .t,� ��-�� ' �3y3 , � � �� . s.�/vo�- � 0��►n,� �G. ►.• � �i � d2a� ,i� Go .�-U�'� � � �� v �'/"�o, �� " � �c.� �i _ . � � 60 ,� ' .-� c�� U �yy�, • ,�� '� �� i� �3 �� , �� . �,�/�'� � y��-�a� �� ' � � Ai�qust 16, 1988 To St. Paul City Catmcil Re: BeverlY aberg Beverly Oberg has asked that I write to reaomaent! her to you, and I am pleased to ha�ve the opporbmity to do so. I find Bev to be a oonscientious and dedicated person, who approaches challen�ges with eaqerness and innavative thinkinq. I have � Bev since 1979 and have been a neiqhbor since 1984. As a neiy2ibor, I can attest t�at Bev�s house and property always have a well-kept appearance. In all my walks dawn her street, I have neRrer seen anything abjectionable. Feel free to contact aee if yau have any questions or if I can be of futt,her assistance. Sinoerely, „%" . — �� JC R�abett M. BCt�idt 1138 IVy Ave. E. St. P3ul� I� 55106 872-2894 �lork 778-0820 1'yome ; aJ f��.� �� ,,�,�� , 17 � � � 8'� . . (3 , . � � � � �� . � �� .� v-v-� � . �� . -�."�c,��,--„` ��. � �� n . . GI rI � ��-a�' c,� �c �.�.P.� �«.O �, .�;� .� . � , a.� J ,cvu�� a�,-w�-�.� �� , . �-�'.� a.�- ��. � ��. .�� .�.�.,:t.� .� .��.�- c,c..� f b s b C�� -�C �Jt.c�re r �..� � ,t,t,;,n�,� . ��e ,lA,.i�,_�� X �� .� �,,�-o� ��-- . �� .� . `"'� �� S L�- ��CK'.��Gc�rt.t�_ �x i�`� f � ' . Q� � , �� • ��►— � �w.o J�c'e.�e�v� ' ,c,�.� � o..a� �-ti G'.�a,Ai,l..�,� • /U �l � �;ti„�,�� .c.� � /� �-- G�i�i4�Clt�. � � I ('� � ¢.��,�..� c%� ^ • t /'h�e-C�.ccX 1 ,�"`r�_ ` —.�— G�� • � /k� .�G�Gt, C:�� ✓t�fL � �^-" � '� � , l! .�?� (��,.,-- . c�,..�( r?�,�,� ^ c,� . � � � � � � � , ��,. � � �� . % p� �r s� �. � �, f�U�.�1 �'i'�.� . �5� v 1 t�.��.�% � �� P� � ^� l ' ' A . � ' � - � � � � _ ��\ , ��, ��c�� j� ��u�� S#�Ci�t 1�1V� ��lr�l'��ll� �l.�i�l�i��i� ._, i 075 Arcade Street, Saint Paul, MN 55106 (612) 774-5234 4 xErto .. . .,�.'..�ii _ \.'��u..�.� _ �.='� � _ .. ... . =Ql:_ :� �lil.�lZy � _......�._.. i.'.J1' PRU:•!: rdt P,i�? , ..�•iT1:lU1�ir1 Ql�ci11��`J �AT£ : A�.;gust 2� , 19�38 RE : � Zcning File No . 1G34:, , P1ame : Obei� Gn J�:ne 1 , 19fi8 Eeve�ly ��bery appE.�red ::efere *:� La:7c U�e a::d �',O:i113 C�'OlTifii:.t°_? �.. C1S::U£S �lE1 �Plll].��:?i:i:�ll ��.i� :i:�liC01":�OI-1T;li:_a Ll�r c.:1C1 S�@�:i�ul :.O:;Ciii.iGil US°_ i?I'IT1iC . F. J��O�101: iad5 IildC:: t0 r�'.CGI�jtTiL';1� i0 �ilG itlli L1S�liC',: Fi'. � i'Zc:iliiii_; ....`�l�:Cl� l.la`�l. �i: �S ilpplicati�.: �? �trllJ:TFL:. r.�!' �1:��Z� i1 ��I?C ��c�«3e� a::d pass�c Ltlldi�l:?lOtl�i�. :.�n Juiy -:� , "��88 �tle ful� iistrlc� �iv? �i_zr�r_:ng C :��i�cz� �=-` . T:�e 1'�C��t`1?','�°?l�di.lr;1 Of t71t.' Lan3 USe/�OlilI1Q CO:ilfiitt�'Z �d�StG �:.^_�::i:ia�ous�, ��r ��ippoL�t of �e��ly Gberg' s agplicatle.Z. Pa*_ ,1it ?�/111 c�_ . yis� _�'e�.: _ L'J��CL l�� QLC� 7 L , - August 16 , 1988 LT , Lisa M. Millar St . Paul Police 100 E . ? 1th St . St . Paul , Mn . Dear Sir/Madamn , I am writing to advise you of the excellent service Mr . � Mrs . Oberg of t636 East Shore Drive provide the youth of this community . i would like to share some of my experiances with the Oberg shelter wi th you . I was assigned to the sex-Homicide Division of the Police Dept . for Syrs prior to joining the East Team in July . On many occations 1 had the opportunity to interview youth from the Obero Shelter . They have appeared very well cared for and comfortable in what often is a very frightening time for them. The Obergs have provided the city of St Paul and the County with a very much needed servime . 1 would like to express my concern that the Oberg Shelter be granted whatever zoning considerations they would need to continue the quality care they now provide . The shelter continues to provide the youth of this city and County with a SAFE . place to work out their problems and have a track record of many years of service to prove that the family is dedicated to the care of such children . If I can provide any further information please contact at the East Team H . Q. 291 -1111 Ext . 566 Youfis. Tr 1 ` ,_ -- �.., % . J .. ,� � `�/ J . Li sa M. i l lar � J j' � RAMSEY COUI`ITY JUVEt�11LE COURT �N��E co - 480 St. Peter Street ��'�;.�`' w�,G�,, Sai�t Paul. Minnesota 55102 / . � \ ��_ �.; . '.w�� .. � ': Kenneth M.'iirusx '� � "-�" ~ , Ikferee 9�';,, J�� (612)298-6985 SEY CO TDDRTY(612)298-4508 August 16, 1988 TO WHO�S IT MAY CONCERN: RE: Oberg Independent Living Skills The Oberg family has been providing shelter services and/or an independent living skills program for the past eight years. The program is licensed by Ramsey County Human Services and provides short and longer-term care for children vho, for a variety of reasons� cannot be replaced in their oWn homes. The reasons for placement may be abusiveness by parents, abandonment by parents, parental death or incompatibility with parents. Rids in an independent living skills program are there to learn the skills necessary for living independently in the community, how to obtain and maintain employment� how to budget money to ineet needs, how to use transportation systems� how to maintain their living space and generally how to relate to the adult world. Obergs have provided services to scores of kids over the past years with few difficulties in or out of the home. They are competent, skilled and concerned care providers and provide services vitally necessary to the kids who are placed with them. The numbers of persons both wiliing and able to provide these important services are very limited. Thank you for your thoughtful consideration of the Oberg 's request. Sincerely, / ' _ ��.�.`/��- �--�--'�� Kenneth M. Truax and Williem H. Muske, Jr. Referees Ramsey County Juvenile Court � KT:ab ,/� C ,%�� - Charles A. Flinn, Jr. Judge of Juvenile Court , %., `. ��' �v� u��' p��o � p[��Oor� District Five Planning Council 1075 Arcade Street, Saint Paul, MN 55106 (612) 774-5234 MEMO '�'� . �on�ag ..�m:,ii:�_e .,� S� . ?�.._ :_ s:.r_�:y ,.��m�ss�or, FRO�i: Pat Rife, Com�un�*� Org«r.iz� DATE : August 15 , 1988 RE : Zoning File No. 10343 , Name : Oberg On June 1 , 1988 Beverly Oberq appeared before the Land Use and Zoning Committee �o discuss her application fcr nonconforming use and special conditicn use permit . A motion was maae to recommend to the full District Five Planning Council Lhat this application be approved. The motion was seconded and passed unanimausly. On July 19 , 1588 the full District Five Plann'_ng Council met . The recommendaticn of the Land Use/Zor,ing Committee passed unanimously for support of Eeverly Oberg' s aFglication. P3fi P.liE PR/lh c� : :.�sa Freese 3everly oberg , � r' p ,:t � � �'i�,s��i � �U��USi, ��'�:', 1�^�, �Ti:TE;'�'+T T� S1 . PPL�L ZO�II'�� ."��;1ITTEE-r.; {:roxt��.dtely °:C,^� F. ;' �'U�USt lctl�, 1°c� Tl�: ��cGdi �,��211^I'-u�; ,°. �, E��c'E1":, CF ti�� Ci.. F�U� erir `c�.r,�l ��EE: P . (�'v ;.�':C 1� :r��ol� �i+.00�5C1i�. ��f 1:1�? ,91�C i ;Ii�VC �1Vr. �t �.'�� , c�;G1"C �:1"lVc fG1" �:• yc�l'S . �!1� ? ;�cVE :.�en � �1C°ftSP.;,' real ZStd�E `_ rc��r fCY OVE1" 4'� _yEcl"S. I CC:,,C.UR :?TF: E��.LL �F TI:� F;;CTS PS STFT�� =,Y ;'�•.. VI��:=:� ':�YE�: Ir� addition, it is a t•:E11 !c;�� fact ti�� a c`�anMe ir zoninc froi�: a "-3(sigclQ far.ily� resi�enc� classificatior,) to a nonconforr,;in� use ar�dySpecial Cenc+itior, Use PE nni t, a oul� reduce t;ie ��si rati 1 i ty and val ue of al l of the har�es in the surrour,dinc nei�hhori�ood. I liave in r:y hard a copy of t,}e 13� petitioners, includine E cf �:iiich are prcperty o��ners abutting tb� �terg pro;�erty, tl�at are in strong opFositior. ta the c�rantinc� of this chan�e of Zonin�. ;��y oupstion is? :�!�:o ane ��'�a.t a�cncy ti��as respensible r"or the issuin� of a license tc� Russell ano °everly C::er� at 1c3E E. Si�are f�rive to oper4te a foster nor��e for 1� chilc'rEn w"�t'�out firsi ciiect:ing ti�c legality of tze Zuninc requirer�ents? T�:is license �ras last issued on FeEruary Z�tf�, 19�& to run until P•�arc�� lst, 19�G. F� tne pr�sent ti^°e tE�is hor,�e is in violatior� of its�icerse c�uE to ir��roNer Zorinc. (�r, ti�is t�r.sis, I v:ant to reauest a c�enial of the C;t��erss F.rFlicat�nn to change tne zonine frcr� R-�(one family residential) to a r:onconfcrminc use an� Special $sR�i�i Ccn�ition �sE Fermit for t�&ir �rorprty at 163G E. S`ore i:eive. i haiik ycu - ' / '� �'� ;- .�- ;� , ,L G �� t'Hi� IS THE STA'I6'i�MS BY VIRGIL MEYER AT THE AiIGUST 18, 1988 MEETING OF TI� ZONING COi�9rII TTEE AT THE ST. 1�tR�JL COLINC I L CHAHIDERS I am Virgil Meyer, 1626 E. Shore Dr. My wife Shirley and I have lived at this address for 15 years. T1�E We are opposed to the granting of a nonconforming use and special condition use permit to Mr. and Mrs. Oberg to establish a foster care home for 10 children for the following 5 reasons. 1. 'I':�e Oberg residence at 1636 E. Shore Dr. is situated on a narrow lot measuring 45 ft. of frontage along E. Shore Dr. and a depth of 187 ft. for a total lot area of 8415 sq. ft and shares an eas�nent drive�ay. Their home is in an aesaq- area zoned R-3 one family residential. A spot use €�e� for this special coHdaltion use permit in the �eldd�� middle of a block and surrounded by one family Yianes is not conducive to sound zoning g�a� practices. (REFER TO I�P) 2. The zoning co�mittee staff investigation report dated August 11,1988, page 2 paragraph 9 states and I quote. (READ PAR�+,GRAPH 9). The Oberg residence does not canply with a minimum distance of 1,320 feet required for zoning lots used for ca�munity residential facilities. 3. Prevailing evidence shaws that the issuance of a nonconforming and special use permit �ae� pravides an inroad for the wholesale issuance of such permits. Ttne Oberg residenc� could beco�ne a magnet for the deteriation of the R-3 one family residenc2 of t� neighborhood. 4. Information in file 10343 shows that the Oberg residence is at this time in violation of the present City of St. Paul zoning ordinance because of tY� occupancyd of over 6 children. In file 10343, I would like to read fran a hand written statenent signed by Beverly Oberg (QUOTE). Addit£onally, I would like to read fran the mmnutes of the Land Use/Zoning Ca�mittee meeting, June 1,1988, which is not in file 10343. (Q�JOTE This is in excess of 6 children pernutted imder R-3 zoning regulations without a special use permit which todate has not been granted. 5. The Oberg's capability to adequatedly supervise 10 individual children is questionabl especially when each has special need requiranents. To support this concern I have in my hand a computer generated report frmr the st. Paul Police Department covering the period January 1 , 1987 thru July 31, 1968. :^�is report identifies 41 separate and indivdual �incidents in which St. Paul Police �,rere dispatched to the Oberg residence. (RFAD S�) With the number of foster c�re children increasing to 10, the ntanber of incidents could double to 80 or more St. Paul Folice dispatches. One family residences should not have to be subjected to such undesireable conditirns. In�iew of my stated reasons, and the petition signed by 134 people, I request that the zoning ca�mittee to deny the issuance of a nonconforming and special condition use permit to the residence at 1636 East Shore Dr. �� ' �'�`�7'_" . DONALO W. KOZA, M.D. 1171 E. Idaho Ave. St. Paul , MN 55106 August 24, 1988 RE: Testimony given before St. Paul Zoning Committee on Thursday, August 18, 198A at 8:00 P.M. in the Council Chambers, St. Paul City Hall . The following is my information given at the meeting of the zoning committee as recalled from my notes: IDENTIFICATION-I am Dr. Donald W, Koza. My wife, Lorraine,and I have lived at 1171 E. Idaho Avenue for twenty and one-half years. The back of our yard abuts the yard of the Oberg home. STATEMENT- We are strongly opposed to the plans of the Zoning Conmittee of St. aul to change the status of the Oberg house at 1636 East Shore Drive to include non-conforming Zoning changes as well as special condition pertnit for 10 children. The first problem is that this foster home has been illegally operating over 4 years with more than the 6 children legally permitted for this zoning of R-3 (one family residential ) We also emphasize that the provider lost the status of duplex home by not continuing its use as such fo� 365 days after they purchased the house. Thus the information given by the provider that her house is a duplex (or triplex) with individual sections being paid for by the Ramsey Welfare, is also illegal . WE have only learned at this time of the illegal licensing of this home for the last four years. Only today did we learn of the use of the home as a duplex to take care of two sets of children for the Ramsey Cou�lty Welfare. SOURCE OF THE ILLEGAL IICENSE FOR FOSTER CHILDREN CARE HOME- We are still pursuing the department and individua s that passed on this iliegal stamp of approval on this yearly applicatio� for a license to care for more than 6 foster children in this home located at 1636 East Shore Drive. It appears that the County Welfare Department urged the providers to request this hearing after the errors in information was found. I am looking into the State of Minnesota, Dept of Nelfare position in issuing this license regularly. I believe they receive all of their informatio� from the Ramsey County Welfare Department and that the licensors of this department and the providers were probably in error. Also as I look over the license, as issued, I note that they require a ratio of one adult to every 5 foster children. These providers are Mr. and Mrs. Oberg. However, we know that Mr. Oberg works full time and sometimes overtime at an office. He most camwnly works at night time. As a result he is away from home when the children are most apt to cause the rumpus requiring the frequent police calls already listed for you. Thank you for this courtesy. Yours sincerely, �'��-z<< `� yli /\ } '� lL : DWK:hs Donald W. 'Koza, M.O. i ' B:OBERG.O1 774-7234 (612)771-8705 � � I ! _ :_��; . . ,,�- �'1.�• Y �,.:�> - ° . ', ' - ,�� - ;.� " . - ,r�.� �', .�._�;• ��z � .6��,�� d-t- ,�.�,��,�,�C, �, .�.�ic � � i�, , �9� � � �� -e-a� � �a�-�,��cv , o-r�� .�� .r.w-� �'�� , �r"� . , �c.� /(�,2, I .�v �, �a.r.�.�J G�,.�(, � ,� � .li�-v .6�UC.c'� CL , `� .r�c.�� ' h��.�.'c� /n-e-t- • :�C�,� /7-� � � �� , �c- , � �c�e� . u— ��✓ � � /� 6 � � �1�.�„-� . `�� d-�. a� �,�e,G�u.�2,� �`--w� t�z� - , �� . � � � ,, � � . ��.-i � ^ � �� , �, -�- 7 , .� �� a�, o �.E- �� -� �E2� . ,c�,..� C��..�a- �v � � ' -fr�-� � . � .��t.w �1.�� .�r� .�k.� �� :.�L�G.,� .�.� _ .=, - /f�.o—L . `� G�.,z-,ti. ,�,�:-�•�,,�-. -�'�L��, /o T �� -�_f r ,r. � � G�;r/ � �� ^ -- e � t '^, ' , /{..l�� t � � v /r � . � � "' r ^--t.i... �-��C�t_�- ^ 1�d.��.�-�2�<� Q�eJ Qir✓ — _ �v i.<.�— � , J '"� —!� . 'v J_/LZ��G,�i?i ��'V L-CZ 7'i/ � � /� , , � . _ �.. . -_ '�"?'"z.•_ -. _ ..i"�.t�.:.�{�i14.�L.�Y:--�i� .. � . �%%-.�.,�-�- ` -'�-��-.� n ,:`�-� • � . - - . : ��Y:•F,' �� . � �� J��'Yl�j� �'�(�L�-{i �^�i�L (/�L�t/I� C/v vG��v ,Q/ L��' C/.t�..�'��`L, J �i�/ . r-� �1.-mi � L`'�' !;�-f e.� r',�L'L`��t�c� G� ��..E.� i'j'��. �' . � �-; ., :, %� - -,-��'z .,�-�- �.-�� -�L� �- L- (,v,,�—�-_ �� ' " , `�,�.%'S.�G—Zt�lc�Q—(� v ::1.� ' , � , �(,�.� �:,.-,� a.,�,� � � - � -w--� cc�-�- . G��-�r� a�-�-.�L -�G ��rn� Gl�l�e� � n , �%�,�.r.� r';�t� G'�� . ('�1r�c.��u��i--ee� -,�-� � �/'y��(// �/�/ C��A/w vi . (/'v •- V / � � ^tG, Y�/ '/�✓✓�+�/ A • � � � �-� ��- �yu� �� ' � � C� �(i� %�.,�.� , C� `�/'Lf�Y7u� — �� n �!.�'�"�Lf�✓--L��u� C��ic,� ��t��-✓ ��-d-� �� % 1 . �� ^ �v (t� � n ,� , � . � .i� = ,�/-Lr,�� , 1 i � ,�� .��— �.�. � �'y,,-,�. i ^ � �� ,`� -� / � ' ;� S'--1. � :� i - � �i%��.r' %�;� . � / , � �� . . � � — � � - " � s► � . -- I' • i ♦I - ► / � ,� i � i � . .; �► . � ' � i � -�� - � ' / �� _ �i � � � ` j � � , ,/ � _,/ ��.... ' it } �,�1�. �,� � _� , � r /�,/ '��+' /��^" / ,s-..4-� � t��1�--�- ; !, ��`J�ri � ; �,�,�;�' �,�.�._` � , 1 r � � ; �r�:. r �:�i �� , � ,�t� � � ,, ��, � 1 �� . � i , �� .,` _ „ ► - � �► � � � - � � • � ��i � iy �,� .� � � �..�,. •�� ••� • � ��•� _ ' •,_ � , . � , _ � � � �,r : , i •� ,.�+ . � � � � � I �a��Jl . . .. � i — . 2 , ` � .4.�.i�4 � -l �� . � .��. � ± �.�'°" -- �r�� . : - �� r . . . _ t' ,� �< ry .. �L 1 '� ," _ �> � �. .�, �.� �,!.� _ _ ,�� „� .,; ,�--. . ..�. .. ' `'� �� ,. z - ,�:�,. .: w ��t . � ,4 �� . � � �`; e_ � '$ . � y� .: .. �.� � _ � �. _ ;�.t�:� �, �/, a .r � �t °"� - . .. � <.. � - �', y,y� / /►/, •� ; , � i �:�� - .1e,� � _ a Y . ♦ .:t �0 r. + '- ` ;`�'�i,y+x� . .. Y'�+: `p�� {�+k i4 � � : �. A. �i i� � . .. ��,_�� ` � � � .._ .� I� �. �� .. � � ° ��'°�'�II��I"��i��_....,w � � �-- _ �, � - - Y� � , , - .'�tp.l,i; �j�/:r � �'�{a+.� . .. �i►. ��.,f' �i� i E / /l� i. F�` � sa �• "'.' �- . � � t �•�. � �� t ( �� .lL.�.i!� S� . . ��...,.+,��i ' �. _. '�`�•� � .4" �..,�.. ' .-' �, ., �, :.. �� . .. �� . � d�a' �,: ' �� { � 1` � , � �� ' ' .^E��a �i �� p/r+.y,�. . -�F ��•+�. � / r �/�ip�r � - � �`r. . .�_ _ f� 7 � �, �� ,,.,�:. / a' " _. � - . ,�,. :+°� ��, �, �3�� ..�i. �+� * - - _ . __. �;;a -o- . �-��.�r�1c-� .<-, �,� . ;- �j �. ,: :s�g r�� ' ,�- ��• . ._ _. �, °.�,.' r.. =.•,a ' - - � -:- �„ : :. r ,r�.�� ... .. � •., � f� � r. ' ' . :. � � . . � w . . . . . y� . . _ y"" •_.�F• . . .. ac't . . A tr�°`-�� •.�- .� c: �:' .i�F 3�rs.,-�,��„�-:..-. . � . ._�y.- ......�.., .. Y�' .. _ . . ��r�„- .'` �j��' ` ;a' 'r G ' '' . � � �- ,�; �.- t ° ''?, y k - _. p �', _ �_ � '?� ��j-'-..�' �^I�.= �' �;`� �` " _Y� u ._y � _. . . . ��.. ...'" .. . . . t.� '�i�:: ��s ::�`��'�.'s _ . y.i, "Li7� 'iY<�'`... �, y r, � ' - �sy. �'r��ilF�e.y�. �� ' .3-7,#.��y:r;�.. .�E � -.�..^� . ��_ �.�r�.. . . -a.�» �.5,. . ., _�/� L _:� �°-C- .��'-�.i-,/�•v,/'�/.. Lzi.'\ C ��, ` /' `� ;� , :� %/ /� � ;� - / � � -� � � � ` �� ''�" <� '�yLl "C-.`< ' �'/ � � � /.� � � i"-�'L C__ �`��v 2�3�`"_.�� / ✓� � � f-� ��i2 � � �l c-�� S'� : �� '� � e � �Tv: � ��c-s �l for� ,iur��o /� i� � �,��G %'�� y�.s� �,t,vla, /�:�o� ,�� 7?!/a. .�f' s--v�.��-.� �;o-�� i i 7 / � �►=�-�_lt Q 7�7 � — g"7 �.S'-� � � �� I r �l C- �`--�-E-�, � � � ( - b � �S �d '/� � � /� �v F". �.��40 � �ll-�.8�0 � �,f/,c� ��u-�c�-r,, �� , � �� ,�--76�� /j �,�.��.a-.K,� /�, � s' .�'<' ..�� ,�?�l ; ;'�?C �- 7� �q G��-C�'`'� G�✓'.1�,,..� l � l �� ..�-�-��.4��,��`'`r`� i � 7 1— l�v �.3 4Y� � � � , a�c��,.-.-� r' 1 7 4 l�`�.�`�'.,� � � ?Z � �G 7�..3 ��- ` � ,/�� . /��,�t � 7��' gsy3 c;J � �s� y /J.��.��.�i ; 77� S'y3 j� � ` ^ ISb�-� Qc,�.�� S�- � 7Z4�8�-3 � 1 �� [ ��,t�..�}-� s�-- j ��''l 0 t !s-�t�- � ,�-�. ; -7z fr—c � � � L�� voo D�/�l�>.61 Sy� ! '77<0—,�`��O �6 , ,, ��i �T-h �S 7— � 76 - 3� �8 , �' ...��C, ,� ;� � / ,�,�.�,.�--� � , �' ?�- 7 �� L.��► � ,�� l� 3 � ,� �%� �--. 77� 33 Z� Y�? - . 1�� %��` ,�- ��- �a 33 �tir'e.,..� f � y � ,�u..�� x�. �7F-td'i/ a�e�.�..�.u. Q�e�...o /6 �a' �,k.�...�.� �j�'. 7� �' �/�'�/ '�:�u.�� .�ti% f�� 7 �.�-�.t� S�' 7 7''�—3�� G � �� i � �� 7� --�� i�...� � � 1 �� .� �7`� . , � � � l� .�� , ��-'. ~ 7 y - af� � , --��_-�.; �" .;.� ��ti� /�-� ,��.�'��-r�-. -�� - -�.��Y �- �t,,:.� �C,:�C��.L I�Z� 8 ��..L..,, L 5-�- . 7 z� --� �,r Y �� , ' /,�Z v ��,.Q�� S --��r�~/� � • ?'� � �--�«L�� L� f�� ,c�-�-.� K r-�-- '7 z�— �S 3�j . 1 . , � � � -?/—� � � r� ; ��.�;.,�.-� �� .- +_-cLZ-�� 3 , � ' � ; � •^ , � '-� � � L � � �', .. ..,��; -�x't _� j �'" ,��, � � '��- �l j7/ �'U� (� ��fi�/�'�'� � r''`'�j�'ti.C..c�s. ^ �i � � "�� '- �� '/� � � � S � �� -- �`'' - - - _ .-� .1-.. �...._ � .:-� -: i� - _ �'.� - �,��.� � ..�_ C_ f� , � l' �' -�- -i"Z--<- _ 1/ '^ -�" r �� _ � L �., C � -,� '.�C _� � ,�i`'�' .C' � ` f_;. �' ^ .. / /� y ' / �`--.ZC� � � � '' - _ '"�'C.�� j � �:= ,�: :,_ �-- . _ .�'�►�_-�- _ r � >� ✓ ,. 1 / ' �,,' �- ,� C �' � -S= '' !",�� C� � /� 'Yt � c - � � s�3 ��1 �;�-�, �-� �7 r - �3 s�� %�� .s"�� J��T s� � �� lS-�f 7 f�L v/�C �5T � / �� .��%�- .�dz- 7?� _� �� . . , � �� Q�l�: �� f-� _?�z-Z Ca � o � � �, ��r� u��-� � 77�- 1� %S-ry .�� - ,, �� v � � - �`� /� ` �� Y3zz V�y� J ��r.i � � " �,�,.�� -�. @�oo ��o�� L= � � `��i �s�' � a �i 1a � �' 27�� 7 �� . � � �� / a � � ,�� 1 , � , , J _ . / . , �y� lw.r /�i �./Y�ii . .-�?�-'-,_I� /i-�i�/ �.�Li�LA.C�C � . � 7'.�� i�y:. _ J' �"�r .J � ' r. � _ 1 ' � ' "..� n - �'. � � i ` � L. �''.. r . {,i_ _ !�/! i �:� -�- � `'�'!..�.��._ � =v -"l� ^ ��J 1 'l� � _/ /J �� s �'1`/� �, 7� r` �,�� ''��. i I�.t ��`y'.�` ��-'1-�'•'•'� � 7 �'. _ `.i`=�. `� , �. �,._� _/, _ I � �' _ �,�-" '�,_.��i � r � .-) �� a,� -� �! / ��,�'�" -" ..? .� ��i;�j/ ..�.'- ,r-4 ;i % � n � �--� � � 1 � r � � � � i� .��y'•��L%��"� �, . .}.•_;�_ � ,� . f�' �.G r�C�. � ,. '. ''` � • ` •� ( Q� ' ti�C."A../'��"-� �� /`F / • O�--C.'-- _�� .c..�"�!�-� � � � �. _ ; ' " �L"�:� ''s�'� -"`,/'� �„ �,.:,/'�� , �.G El-�7,.. /%� � � _. " -- - -� � `�_ 4�' r '' `� � . . � � ' � . i ti�[,�.7.� .,,I� ,�� _ _ � .�'- �'7 � _ -� - • i ^ `. ,� -,. � . � ��r. . _ ,, :, �- j �`�_ �� ; ,/ � V . . -�� (..:.� � �� — ;f J �-. �. '_./�^JJ��l� ./L.L?L � /ir _% ( � I i � � � '! ��.� u��s,g�v�a v b.i�c.�' ''�`� �'h � C�.q,� � i� Zo�r�1 �a��s o� 1 � 3(o F. 51.,oeE A� � _ �l/�.G ` ��vC' � Jl��e%t�t,r��`� 7 7/— �y3� / � ��-�,�-�` �a�-�� y s C�,�,�- -�',� �7 y - yy�� ..�� i-�'.�.��,�� 7;�--r��/G ' �' .� ` ' .. �3 �Z.�n�, .,dr: 7 7� - � t � !c % ,�., I,�(� r ,f�,,�t z ; ' S �E .w • 5 �..��,�,�,,,, ��, S� (j,�a�„J�,t S� , '�7 � . �-1 `� i� � � ;�.�J� �Y� l�s � �CCL��.,Z`� .�%'. 7 7 s� - �� s�3 ,;� ,� . � � . � ;�,,�;�n�..c.,� �/'✓'��,�,...�---�- � C� (, / � ,� - � � �/ •- � �5�� i�-��- ✓z:�'� i 673 ' ' �` � � 7� "� �/ � �� ' -�'�r�J(,�-�' ° ^ i � ��3 ��.,��' --�. ' 7��-- ��/ , ,� �- � ; ` �%,�,ut� � � /(��2��--� �� ; 7 �f lG�� .% � � /� _ � ��.� _ � k -�� , ; y� 1�� , ��s ��-�'� �,,,c ' ' :;'� H`� � �z,� i ��L`�s y� � �� . � : ,%l�G�^ �ila�.C2.�,.�- /� ��.�c�,.�.c� ' � ?� _,j.3;�/ , � ' /� 5�D �, 7 7� -�� S�. - . �� 2t^ �G� �-C- � � ' y�3�� . � , :� � ,; � �;j/Z r?,��,�_� � i� x, a! � ,�.� � "�� ;' � � �'i 4�v `j �/ L ! . , li -� �� (i�V A �� ` f c,.,,` � �l,,o.{�,� !�^ c'.,(- ".�"1 t� " Q , .� . . � J; �t;�l��.G.. -;; ,; <,� :,� : - ;;;;�� r, �� 4,• � . ��i� :`i i � � • �.�� ' _ � �.. .. _. j� , _ . --, ,'- .. ' _ r r� --, ,�. __ -� v - .�-- - - - - � , - .� �J '.._,L� •- � ` 'I► �,��U_ , ' . _. . _ f✓ „/ _ ' - - � _ _ . t. _ . i"� ,� - - " � - � . ';c,��. T��c vu�sr 9N�.o ob� u� �a -c'�,� C�.ANg �. � , , . ; ' �,� Zx��»g s�ATvs o �' � c�3co � S�.,o�E _ fJQ . _ _ . , _ _- -- _.-1`1 _M.E _ _ _ _ _ . � s No � � ` " �7 �- �t� °- /�63 ��',t�} �'i� . p __ __---__.._-__ -- - ---- ----- - ' I . 1 � � -- -- --- _ _ ___ �sa l.__--_ ___ - - � ��6--3�$0 � ___ __ _ _-- - _ _ - .�� - _ 1S_ 73- - - 7 7__�-/_/��_ � � __ ��--�.. �S-�s�" ,Q��•�� '77�1- �y�� ,� — �s � s " st -� � 6 - 6x � .--- ----_ _ _ _ - --- _ ____ _ _- ------_ - __ _ ; -� /�Z� �any��R ? 7� --03 6�j ,_ _ _ - - ---- - --- --_-----_—__---- - - - -- --------- ---__ _ _ - ------ �.�,t ��'I ��r,G+r.t � ��- �9 � __ _____. _. _ _ _ , _ � ` - -- _ __-- __ _ ___ __ __ _ _ � � � 16 �5 ��_ _ � �� - �6y� � . _ �..,.� - _ iaso_ �"�_ � �10 _ P�� ' �.1��t� �{- _ _�_��--_gs'a-� �__ � ,.. �� _ �-��- . _ a,�,__ �1, lL� � G�� S T 7 7�'.Za`t 7 - � � l��"�_- . _ . _ _F _ _ __ �7�--��Z. _ _��_ _ � � . � _.��s�.Z _ -- _ �7__6-y�.�a�-- - - --- - -� - --- : . ' --- - ��J_ �G�� _ _ .�- _��--y��' _ ; _ . � ___.. ,l� `�--- -��11��--__ ____7-7�-_�a3 a7 _ __._ __-- _ _ _ . _. ! ___ _ . _ ��3 �___ ._ _ �/ � . _�:�!-�s ; _ �. , : � ��C _- g - _ `��'j�r.'`"" � , �,l.�_ � ; �6z� C�..,�k�.. ��--�8��_ ' g � -�� I lo l� �?� ' �� . ; `��l� 6,�- �r��-��-/ P �, �� ' � � _ �� `11�-��.� �� o� �,�. � is �5 C:�.�,��, ; �? � . �'�3� + ��r/ _ / � ; � . V- , .r � '"?v /� 7�� L}/[��,. 7[ v ` ' � C.. f t r : � � �� -�.��. ��s�s��----Q��.�..+ _-�o --t��.. ��. 1 � . + t� ZoU �ug STATuS o �' __(to3tP � 5�.o�c� O�e . � - A �i-�o � , C a.��,-�,�.c�. -l_�_�2--� ------ -- - � 7� -0 3a_� _ - - ---- - _ _ � � ' s- -- �.�,y `77� `v��s� _ ; �, - -1--y..5-- 1��7� � �� 'g�� ______ ____------ -- � -� ��-��.�a - - _ _ - -_ _ /.�-�1-__ , - - ------ _ , . � . _ - �Sd� --- _ __ --- - � � 5�-�c� � --- - - _ !s�-�--- .�f 7 7� a�f� 8 - - -- , . � ; e �-�� L� __ _ � �' �Sa �-�-c�y,u,�c _ -_ _ � l�. _ �'� _ � �/-..8�,�� " �.,,,,.�_ �,'� /G3! t�: 5 � ??�_ 9 -� t� __ __-- _ I l� 3� __ �-�-- ��-� , . � - , � 1 � � � � 1 � �� - � �� - Willard P. Ericicson 16 i s Dulu� Str�t St. Paul, M�nn�sota s s i o6 C� / . �� /y�� i�. �.� � ' ' ' r.y✓ ` . 7c� � � . .Cir�. i�rt-,�"'�b ' .�.� �l� �� . /m�?f�.� 2�-�� ib. /m3f'�, �� 7�.. '� � � �✓ �w . . , , , ,� �•�.�-.�.. � � ' .�:..�1..�.�'�a-✓ �.c_ �� a.?�-- !6�6 �� .�1�C_ �'.r.�:.�c�� /�1`� ��t.u.�, /�I�v, %i� �.� 5�� .J .�..� Gs�.-3r'...,,..K.� 7''� � e-��.:C- 7�b- ' �i�'c� . � �� . � .a3�" .f.Q w s�C .�-n.., �-c,� 7�lya-�, .�''� ,ZTC.� �st�a—. It.u�t., � .. • . .1,d7✓ .N�- ,G��. ` 6v�G� � �'. a*,�-c¢ Y�it� �i�r.cs.�ly • y , , �� .� .�� - Y � ALp � � NiAR � c.`(�V I DRA SS'AL i 1 7•7 L . .� �t► F-i p s�4 v cj , A v(, ��, 3'�' .`� r. P A�c, M.� _ ss�� c. � �.�,; :.t.. ��,- Z�.L, .� �� - � � �� l��.�.ern�G a.�' !6 3G � / �� .:<J�l�-e� �..;-� �✓' -�'� ° �� t� . ��' `,��.- . �i��. ��-- -�-Lv ,-c"t- ✓� ' � :� `- � °"'`-`�- �� i � , • J ��/� .,,.�.;�. .�� ,�, ..,,,.,�, �- .�� '�� - - �-�- -�� .�.��.�.� �� , .�-� .�, =�,�-�- - � " � � -� �- �:: �.. , , -,. ��Lt:i��` �c-�`-{:—u—G�% �•-L �z� � _ �f� . ,�... r`�t� ��t.�'r"-,r'"': �%u ��'-�..li......-1 � — � � , �:"� .-'✓Yl�:� :�cs-t-.�-i .__ •J:.�t�! � _�- �� - ��=L�c%"— .Z/��-�_ ,.t- i✓�...�i . ,./�'" � . " . _. ��,�_/,�C...^-�-� . '_ _ . _. _' ��c��:.. ' —'"-�'�"!.' --• -. ..�.,,_ .. _ �y w �� __ -`-+�^ -x, , � - ��. �� V� � �� c� -P-�� -�G� �� J"��.y,v�=,� � .�fLC�,.�-� . • U�i �.��'•��.Q� �=:�-��.__1 i�� '� .�, .-�-�� .� �� . f�' . ` �C�> a��. � �� /�/I�. ' 'J ,//'%/7r/� �i��2'I�J j si'Qi i � ��' ,.�%r.._•-f✓,i LZ' � `a� G..� �"�c.-Ljc�-rs�u J ' ,- � �o � �� : ��.�� -� , ✓�` ^ . � ��- : �.. ;-- �=. , __ ,- �. -G�� v,��---' . — - � ,: �, _ . ,. ��--t-''-�-. „_ ,-t.r.�_.rz:_::_. � " _. ��- �o� � , . . .. - . � ,- R -`�.�1't . -- . ; � - � �o� y� ' - ; v�� . G�� %� � � � � �� - � .�� !� � ^ / �� /` W / . 1 � Q� /� .3 � � ' �� ' _ �� ,,�-- � ' - . � , - , �'`� - .� ./n-� � � -� % � � � ` - , � ''`°�" `�'e�s..°�-C � � - � �% � ��'7�� ',% . ) ,� , J � ' rn �;.%�'.�r+-✓ - --�ftf2 L.�. / i: L ' '� r��/� , � . / _�' �� .:� �� :.��=-1.:� , �� _ / a-��f' / fz-,� .� -��G � ,/ . , .. . � N A A +�.r✓ r ` �• .� V � � � j = '° ( t ♦ �d �� +3 w � 2 . : , � •r � ,� � '4' � ; � � • w � �� i sc .�.+.i r i ,rq� r � ` , ' f � � � . �' �' w a � .., e . � . � �� ; 11 : ; � , • t . � , � ..o. � � �r�� N �' � MOw . � t 7: _ ,.. � I ..� M ■ t � •t ,..,... � � _ � 4 . ` s f = . } \ t .` � �r w � i � ..r... M : .. �� °,, • . , � ■,� .� _ w `i /�a ^"'y n �� a�r' M e '° � _ ` � , F � ��.. .. ` 16� „ �',, . � 3 � � . ...�..e. « . � . • e e. i � - 1 g �;� °°°: . � �e i ,,,r� i • � � ' ` � � i / � � � r .d j j ` � � 6 ; j .�� ., 1 � � �. � �A . � ' P e ,e�, � .... g .R � 15 = . � , ` t' �'�r M t � l � � ; � �r • ; .` / � I '� • �P��J 1\ M f.��' I� . � r � � tm ! �R/� �� W CI7IZEN PARTICIPATION PLANNING DISTRICTS 1.SUNRAY—BATTLECREEK—HIGHt�l00D 2.6REATER EAST SIDE 3.NEST SIDE ' UFF 6.NORTH END 8.SH�T•DN`Y R I Y ��'NG F�� a-� UM�II UIEST 9.WEST SEYENTH lO.COMO 11.HAMLINE—MIDWAY 12.ST. ANTHONY 13.l�RRIAM PK.-LEXINGTO�i HAMLINE 14.6ROVELAND—MACAIESTER 15.N I GFILAA!D 15.St1MMI T H I l t � ' 17.DOWNTOW"� �. T. L HR rC�� C �u r~i � t1�}'¢�{�'E N � L U R ' ��t :� ' �' � "� 400p p � ` � � ..� , t _ O � O O _� -_- - p .� .:, :� �� _ _ _ o � � ; ; ' '"_�� 0 • _e : . � �� ., : -, 0 + � - - _ .� -O - - : , ., �� I o � _ ,` .� : ;�,� o _ o - � -c ; ; o -� - � � ,�`' Q -� o 0 ;,� � •= o � - : - o o -: . .�, - _ . _ - a - - " _ o � � ��' � ' - - � ; . a ' � � ' ' - --� - -- �l�c�ev` �� •� � _ �_ � -� � _ _ � (� --� _ � .. � , �- p O _ , O . ,; � � � F..: � � - �� '� � ; 0 V'� - -e - � ` � �, -- - _ : a � a - ' ' _ 6 . �� o�►HO AVE � � G _ _ I OA H 0, � � .`� :.•�, v O o - _D • — � �'� ��- � �- - - -9- - ;;� �� ; O O t5- `� O � • p �� --_ _ '��'-�f' �,� v� " O �-- L=Q � � - - - � _ ._ -- •=' '.� ___.__ O O E..- � -C .� �ti3 �* `� � • � � - �. _ ._ ` cn p �2 �� . r,� �_ _a � _ p _ . ., N � _ . _ p O r� �', .� � �- �_ - � ;,. o Q o . ,� � ••-:3 ��; � O . ; 0�� ' � � - - - _ o , J .� � �. - � I �� Q_ _Q . _ 6 _ - , r, �� ' ' � Q� � O - , � ' �:` ''� '� -0_ ; ; i o- +- A ° _ ; ---° -; , .� �� ,, :� � , o 0 o a- � �°=-;= ---°- ° - - __ .� � � � � � � o - .. � . � HOYT . � . �.., , . A1/E. H 0 YT `I� �• -p - O oipip = _4 Q _ ' _ ��/�\ � � - �� n -- _ --e - -' ` -- W � � -_ 1 Y � n :;,� �t�, �� 0 � � 8 � O � � ., ., t�� Q _ o -� o _a o _ --. ' o ' � r �• � �- � � _ - - . � _ � __� > . a � �� ° o ° ' ' �� ° � °- � � � - -°- - o 0 � � `;,: � o - � - o �__�T :_ —_ .' " '`? -^�� ! � - _' � - � a O � - :` � � -� '�',;; p a_ ♦ _� p , G O "� , .,� , � a--. :.� � O _1C, -C _ ' '_ p O . � • O O O = =-� ,t� O O p ; j �R �. _ __ f�ASKA � - -- - --- — . . AREA M�4P ` PPP�,G �g.� ��e�C,c��(_ LEGENO v�QpS� CC ��' ZONING OISTRICT 80UNOARY P C U� ��'ll� SUBJECT PROPERTY � NG 4 ONE FAM�Y PLANNNG �,yL � TWO FAMILY � p P�E _ .� � �, ,Z ��'� � FA�ttY � T� `�:� ` � � � C � L - S�' PpV� �� ` S�'� �H' � ��► AL Maf�`�Ip�E - . _ . y� .� ` �! .�, i �-�r�� . �f;��. . !�t.��i: r . .. . _ .._ , � � � ' � ��s:�.�� ,� ,'Ji��.; t ' . �' ��>��tt� November 17 , 1988 President James Scheibel and Members St . Paul City Council 7th Floor , City Hall St . Paul , Minnesota 55102 Dear President Scheibel and Members : I understand that you will be taking up an appeal on a special use permit for the residence at 1636 East Shore Drive owned by Russell and Beverly Oberg . The special use permit would allow them to operate a group residential facility for up to ten residents . When I was asked to support the Oberg ' s request , I said I would do so if I could be assured that they operate a well managed fa- cility and have a good track record . I believe having residen- tial facilities in neighborhoods is appropriate if they are not a nuisance or a threat to the safety of their neighbors . Using a case by case approach , I have supported a number of similar facilities in my district . I contacted as many of the Oberg neighbors as I could reach on short notice , and found no evidence that any problems or threats to the safety of people living in the area could be tied to Oberg facility residents . In fact , no area resident suggested that the Obergs did not make an effort to prevent incidents caused by their charges . That the Obergs do not run a good facility is not an issue , and on that basis I drafted a letter of support for their request . But upon further discussions , I was advised that the Oberg fa- cility did not meet one special condition if they operated with more than six residents ; that is , the minimum distance of 1320 feet between community residential facilities . It was that requirement which caused the zoning committee staff to recommend against the Oberg ' s request for non-conforming use of their property . They correctly stated the distance condition ' s purpose of preventing concentrations of community residential facilities in neighborhoods . C Otr)I[�3—Ci:� �• • ,?� , -'� , _ C .�. �� , :cat�on i�ic:_�,n iiEa?*_n a: . :T a __ _ .r�..��s . .. ��.�� ,_ '�.,�_c , �<�i c:ne:;� e ,� � President James Scheibel and Members St . Paul City Council November 17 , 1988 Page 2 The distance restriction can only work if it is considered an absolute . Waiver of that distance requirement for any reason puts the council in a position to defend every subsequent re- quest on subjective criteria , a practice which is legally treacherous and one in which the council has not had a success- ful track record in other regulatory areas . I suggest that waiving the minimum distance requirement in this instance will make it unenforceable for all subsequent cases . I am also aware that the Council has an action pending to fur- ther define the concentration regulation , which includes a flat prohibition of facilities of six or more beds in single family zones . In addition , I need to take issue with a statement in the Plan- ning Commission resolution by the Obergs and supported by the Ramsey County representative , that it is "economically infea- sible to operate the ( ILS ) program with six or fewer residents . " That would be true if there were only one fixed per diem for all such facilities . The fact is , that reimbursement rates are ad- justed based on reasonable costs , and that Ramsey County could increase the per diem to the Obergs if they didn ' t want to lose the program for six or fewer residents . Please understand my argument clearly . I support the Obergs continuing their ILS program at the East Shore Drive location . I do not support waiving the concentration requirement , because it will effectively eliminate it for any and all subsequent re- quests . Sincerely, Gene Waldorf State Senator GW/Jp � ,� -�G�� F.\�: 'i".,,.a} +,i; ,:�� . . ., _ �. .,. .._,.�. .i�.-,r,1t?��; �� ' �� _�� . -,:> �.�..�� :��:� . � .. : ,�;� ----------___.___ .-- �')ii��i�'. 1�)d >>�l��t�t'�(i�i�l � November 17 , 1988 President James Scheibel and Members St . Paul City Council 7th Floor , City Hall St . Paul , Minnesota 55102 Dear President Scheibel and Members : I understand that you will be taking up an appeal on a special use permit for the residence at 1636 East Shore Drive owned by Russell and Beverly Oberg . The special use permit would allow them to operate a group residential facility for up to ten residents . When I was asked to support the Oberg ' s request , I said I would do so if I could be assured that they operate a well managed fa- cility and have a good track record . I believe having residen- tial facilities in neighborhoods is appropriate if they are not a nuisance or a threat to the safety of their neighbors . Using a case by case approach , I have supported a number of similar facilities in my district . I contacted as many of the Oberg neighbors as I could reach on short notice , and found no evidence that any problems or threats to the safety of people living in the area could be tied to Oberg facility residents . In fact , no area resident suggested that the Obergs did not make an effort to prevent incidents caused by their charges . That the Obergs do not run a good facility is not an issue , and on that basis I drafted a letter of support for their request . But upon further discussions , I was advised that the Oberg fa- cility did not meet one special condition if they operated with more than six residents ; that is , the minimum distance of 1320 feet between community residential facilities . It was that requirement which caused the zoning committee staff to recommend against the Oberg ' s request for non-conforming use of their property. They correctly stated the distance condition ' s purpose of preventing concentrations of community residential facilities in neighborhoods . , , . ._. , l�r).iti [I 1�:��: 1',_. -�� • C�.:u. r.:�.. �� ,�_r ?��l;catiun il�v:�ion • F3ca�:tn :.inri I� ��r.in :.ti •ic"s • G��cei� ��- :.a' t!r,�-�'acion: • P�ib:ie- � i _� �i _c! En.�r;p President James Scheibel and Members St . Paul City Council November 17 , 1988 Page 2 The distance restriction can only work if it is considered an absolute . Waiver of that distance requirement for any reason puts the council in a position to defend every subsequent re- quest on subjective criteria , a practice which is legally treacherous and one in which the council has not had a success- ful track record in other regulatory areas . I suggest that waiving the minimum distance requirement in this instance will make it unenforceable for all subsequent cases . I am also aware that the Council has an action pending to fur- ther define the concentration regulation , which includes a flat prohibition of facilities of six or more beds in single family zones . In addition , I need to take issue with a statement in the Plan- ning Commission resolution by the Obergs and supported by the Ramsey County representative , that it is "economically infea- sible to operate the ( ILS ) program with six or fewer residents . " That would be true if there were only one fixed per diem for all such facilities . The fact is , that reimbursement rates are ad- justed based on reasonable costs , and that Ramsey County could increase the per diem to the Obergs if they didn ' t want to lose the program for six or fewer residents . Please understand my argument clearly. I support the Obergs continuing their ILS program at the East Shore Drive location . I do not support waiving the concentration requirement , because it will effectively eliminate it for any and all subsequent re- quests . Sincerely, Gene Waldorf State Senator GW/jp ., �"` ;' �� "� 4� �' �� — �i�v �- R,A ST. PAUL CITY COUNCIL RECEIVED PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE SEp 2919aa ZON�NG - CITY CLERK T0: Property owners within 350' ; Representatives of Planning District 5 FIL E N 0. 10386 PAGE PURPOSE To a eal a P�annin Commission decision a Pp g pproving a change in nonconforming use to allow a foster home for up to 10 young adults at the Russell and Beverly Oberg residence. LOCATION 1636 East Shore Drive PETITIONER VIPGIL and SHIRLEY MEYER/ ARNIE JACOBSOP� HEARING Thursday, ��ber 13, �9s8 9:00 . A.M. � Cit Council Chambers, 3rd Floor City Hall - Court House Q U E S TIO N S Zoning 298-4154 (�;Sa Freese) Contact the Zoning Section of the Planning and Economic Development Department, Room 1101, City Hall Annex, 25 W. 4th Street, St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Legal Description: On file Notice sent g/29�gg � _ ;� ,� ;� ,; �� % ",:�Jc.J '� `' RECEIVED AUG 2� 1988 To the City Clerk CITY �LERK City of St. Paul We request that we be notified of the decision of the Planning Cotr¢nission regarding the issuance of a nonconforming use and special condition use permit to Mr. & Mrs. Oberg, 1636 E. Shore Dr. , St. Paul, Min. 55106. If this special use permit is granted to the Obergs, we have every intent to pursue the matter to full city council meeting. If this becomes necesarry, please advise procedures required to accomplish this. Thank you for your attention to this request. � Virgil J. Meyer 1626 E. Shore Dr St. Paul, Mn. 55106 �� We are in opposition to the request for the issuance of a nonconforming use and special condition use permit to the Russell Oberg property at 1636 East Shore Drive, St. Paul, Mn. 55106. Enclosed are� attachments for your review in support for the denial of the Oberg request. Very truly yours, �� ^ i��/' .�/`./ VIRGIL J. MEYER 1626 East Shore Drive St. Paul, Mn 55106 INCIASLTRES: Two petitions Police Report Dungarvin Inc. Letter Misrepresentations & unsubstantiated claims by applicant et al at August 18 meeting Statement of Virgil .Meyer at the Zoning Co�nittee meeting of August 18, 1988 Statement of Donald Koza, M.D. , at Zoning Comnittee meeting of August 18, 1988 Statement of �nold Jacobson at Zoning Comnittee meeting of August 18, 1988 August 24th, 1988 ��`� �� Dear Friend & i�eighbor: ;rw ,� � T � ��f On Thursday August 18th, 192£, Ti�e St. Paul Zonin� Cor;��iittee n+ade � reca+N�endation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Perr�it to Russell and Bev!�rlv �bErg of 1636 East Shore �Rive to operate a Foster Care flane for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Caimission of St. Paul k�ill r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Aucust 2Etl�, 1988 or ti�e 13tn fl oor of bhe CBty hal l annex at 25 4J. t'r� St. to scuss e !� er acceptance of re�ection of ti�e Zoning Comnittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, QLEASE SIGi� THE PETITION and deliver to Uie�gi] Meyer at 16,�26 E. Shore DP.ive or ARnol Jacobson at 632 E. Shore Dri ve '�#efore f�0�� ON THLlRSDAY HUGUST 25th, '198�. If you are not able to deliver the petition persanally, please call t4r. t4eyer at 774-2185 or i4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they ►�.ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT L�JE HAVE THESE PETITIONS � U HAND QY NO M THURSDAY OMORROW AS t!E P4UST ERING THEP4 TO CITY HALL BE RE D 9: 0 . . E PJG. k'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty ofi our neighborhood. To the Planning Comnission City Hall & Annex 25 lJ. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the tlndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Corr�nittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the g ranting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. � � , NAM� �% -i' y�/,:.;�.- ,�� ,; , NI�ME._ f:; `��t�`��` -'��' i,-, --- _� �- - ` ,: AODRESS � ' ' /� �� ` ,G ;,�� _ PNONE % �" -� l�" � c.' August 24th, 19EE Dear Friend & yeighbor: '��N � T I G� On Thursday August 18th, 198£, Tlie St. Paul Zoninr Cor.Y.�ittee n�ade a reca+r�endation to. ap�rove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Perr�it to Russell and Bev�arly Qk�erg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Flane for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Carmission of St. Paul will r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida �Au�ust 26�l�, 1988 or ti�E 13th fl oor of bhe C�ty Hal l annex at 25 V�, t'r� St. to scu55 e1� el" acceptance of re,jection of ti�e Zoning Committee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGN THE PETITION and deliver to Vit�gil Meyer at 1G26 E. Shore DP.ive . or Arrnol Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Drive �efore �JOON DN -THI�RSDAY �3UGUST��Sttt;X'8�. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call Mr. ��eyer at 774-2185 or �4r. Jacobson at 776-459£=or 770-3761 and they ��rill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT b�E HAVE TNESE PETITIO�•�S �� UR HANDS BY NOON THURSDA TOMORROW AS �JE t4UST BRING THEP•1 TO CITY HALL BE RE H D 9: P�G. k'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. To the Planning Comnission City Hall & Annex 25 t°�. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon6�rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that proFerty. �.. NAME ---.�C,cr�t�:t �..��,: ��.! �:�. NAME 1 _=� {:,^i '..,! ;i�-�', � ?� A.DDRESS �---• ---�-------_�------------ PHONE �7 Z' �-�'�� Rugust 24th, 198E Dear Friend � Neighbor: ;�HOTIC � On Thursday August 18th, 19�5, The St. Paul Zoninr Cor��ittee n+ade a reca�r�endation to. apNrove ti�� nonconforming use and Special Cen�ition Use Permit to Russell anci Bev��rlv �t�Erg of 1E36 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care flome for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Canmission of St. Paul h�ill r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Au ust 2Etl;, 1988 or ti�E 13th floor of �he C�ty hall annex at 25 �J. t'ri St. to scuss e � er acceptance oF rejection of ti�e Zoning Car�nittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIG�! THE PETITION and deliver to Vi�gil ,Meyer �t 1�26 E. Shore DP.ive or Arrnol Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Drive �efore NdOt� DN THURSDAY .1�UGUST 25th,'��98�. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call �4r. t4eyer at 774-2185 or P�r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they ��ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 4dE NAVE THESE PETITIOtdS �d UR ANDS BY NO P! URSDAY OMORROW AS L•:E t4UST BRING THEF1 TO CITY HALL RE R D 9: P�G. k'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty ofi our neighborhood. To the Planning Comnission City Hall & Annex 25 lJ. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the Undersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the g ranting of a noncon�6rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NAM� ',' � �� "t�-��r-t;l�:-.f� NAME._` � _' �'� `_ ��l�l��'� � '�-��..�s�__ . �, � / .��/ , AODRESS /.��-�, 1� ; .t l,`_ `�.. 1�� PHONE....,..�—L August 24th, 198E ��'��^�J �� Dear Friend & i�eighbor: -�,�T� On Thursday August 18th, 1925, Tl�e St. Paul Zoninc Cax,iittee n+ade a recorr�endation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and Bev�arlv �t�Erg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care F1ome for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Caimission of St. Paul will �eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Aucust 26�I�, 1988 or ti�E 13th floor of �he CBty hall annex zt 25 41. tii St, to SCUSS e � er acceptance oF rejection of tiie Zoning Corcrnittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGN TNE PETITION and deliver to Vi�gil Meyer at 1C�2b E. Shore DP.ive or Arrnol Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Dri ve �efore NOOt� UN THURSDAY BUGUSX �5th,��fi98�. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call Hlr. t4eyer at 714-2185 or i4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they r�aill pick it up. � IT IS URGENT THAT bJE HAVE THESE PETITIOIJS �� UR HANDS BY N �J URSDAY OMORROW AS L•!E t-1llST BRING THEP1 TO CITY HALL BE E D 9: . E P�G. k'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty o�F our neighborhood. To the Planning Carmission City Hall & Rnnex 25 t�J. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the llndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Cor�nittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. r� NAME � ' r�� /i^ � � ,: NAME , . �, ADDRESS ��:'!=:;�.i��:- �%, ----------- PNONE/ � -3 _--.— Rugust 24th, 198E Dear Friend & P�eightor: �10TICE On Thursday August 18th, 1925, Tiie St. Paul Zonin� Cor,x��ittee n�ade a recorr:�endation to. apurove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and Bev��rlv ObErg of 1E36 East Shore �Rive to operate a Foster Care Ffome for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Ca►mission of St. Paul w�ill meet at 9:00 A. M. Frida �Aug u�st 26t1�, 1988 or ti�E 13th fl oor of bhe CBty hal l annex at 25 bJ. tri St. to scu55 ei!�he1" acceptance o� re,jection of ti�e Zoning Committee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGf� TNE PETITION and deliver to Vie�gil Meyer at 16;26 E. Shore DP.ive or Armol Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Drive'�efore NOON ON �FIINtSDAY HUGUS'f �5th, `i98�. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t4r. Meyer at 774-2185 or PRr. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they ►�rill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 4JE HAVE THESE PETITIONS I�� UR HANDS BY N DJ HURSDAY OMORROW AS l•!E t�UST BRING TNEPd TO CITY NALL B RE D : 0 . PJG. w'e thank you for your help to �preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. To the Planning Cormiission City Hall & Annex 25 l�. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the llndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Co�nittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are o�posed to the granting of a noncon��rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NAME ��.,�-�.:_ �� _ �� v--'��,..- NAME._�`�-��-��==----��'_=-�'�'s�.,2�-- --- ADDRESS � `," i - `'' �:,. (. �. 5-k- PHONE�i i _.� i 2_ `f�' � � � ��. Rugust 24th, 198E ��V��vJ� Dear Friend & Neighbor: _ �I,Q T I.rC E� On Thursday August 18th, 19�F= The St. Paul Zoninc Co�.�r;iittee n+ade a reca;r�endation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special CQn�ition Use Permit to Russell and Beverlv Ot�Erg af 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Flome for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Ca�nission of St. Paul w�ill r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Au ust 26tf�, 1988 or ti�E 13tn fl oor of �he CBty hal l annex at 25 Vl. t'ri t. to SCUSS e � el" acceptance of re,jection of ti�e Zoning Carmittee recomnendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGi� THE PETITION and deliver to Vi�gil Meyer at 16`26 E. Shore DP.ive or Arrnold Jacobson at 632 E. Shore Drive b�fore fit00N OlV T#IURSDAY �1)GU5'f �.5�h, �'�988_� If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call Mr. ��eyer at 774-2185 or P�r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they will pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT �dE HAVE THESE PETITIO�JS �J U HAND 6Y NOOP! HURSDA OMORROW AS 4!E h1UST BRING THEP1 TO CITY HRLL 6 RE H D 9: A. . P�G. k'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty o�F our neighborhood. To the Planning Canmission City Hall & Annex 25 l°�. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a nonconG�rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that proFerty. NAME (_��I� ��:SS�1� NAME ADDRESS ��$� '�L�F�!.---------------- PHOME �� -�b� : , au�ust zatn, 198E Dear Friend & yeighbor: �,NOTI 'CE� � On Thursday August 18th, 1925, Ti�e St. Paul Zoninr Ca�r�iittee n�ade a reca:rnendation to. approve ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Perr�it to Russell anci Sev��rlv �k�Erg of 1E36 East Shore �Rive to operate a Foster Care Flome for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Caimission of St. Paul w�ill meet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Aucust 2E��, 1988 or tiiE 13tn floor of bhe C�ty hall annex at 25 �J. t'r� St. to scuss e � er acceptance of re3ection of tiie Zoning Comnittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGi� THE PETITION and deliver to Viergil Meyer at 1C�26 E. Shore DP.ive or Aenol Jacobson at 632 E. Shore Dri ve '�efore NOOt� O�N THURSDAY �tUGUST �5th.'�98�. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t�r. �4eyer at 774-2185 or r4r. Jacobson at 776-459�=or 770-3761 and they �;ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 6JE HAVE THESE PETITIOtJS IN OUR HANDS QY NOOP! THURSDAY TOMORROW AS l•lE t-1UST BRING TNE�1 TO CITY HP,LL B R R D 9: 0 . P!G. k'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty o�F our neighborhood. To the Planning Commission City Nall & Annex 25 l�l. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Cor�nittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon�6rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NAME `��_- `" �Z T, �`' r �-�c'-c�__� NAME � ._____ { ,__._ ADDR�SS �_��► i; �/�G�"� �., r�� , PHQNE�� G' ��- � ...�.:...,,.. August 24th, 1988 Dear Friend & yeighbor: ��,�I�C E On Thursday August 18th, 192£, Tl�e St. Paul Zonin� Ca.��ittee n+ade a 'reca:rnendation to ap�rove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and Bev��rlv �k�Erg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Flome for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Ca►mission of St. Paul w�ill r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida �Au ust�2E#!�, 1988 or tiiE 13th flaor of bhe CQty hall annex at 25 Vl. tr� St. to scuss ei�her acceptance oF re,�ection of ti�e Zoning Committee recor�nendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGN THE PETITION and deliver to Vie!�gil Meyer at 16,26 E. Shore DRive or Arrnold Jacobson at 632 E. Shore Drive bi�fore NOON OW THURS�AY 1�I1GUS� �5th;:'�1988�: .,.�. , If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t4r. �4eyer at 774-2185 or P4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they vaill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT ��JE HAVE THESE PETITIONS IN UR HAND BY NOOPJ HURSD OMORROW AS l•:E t4UST BRING THEP4 TO CITY NP,LL E RE R DA PJG. w'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty o�F our neighborhood. To the Planning Carmission City Hall & Annex 25 lJ. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the llndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Corr�nittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition se Permit to that property. i � NAM� r.//' / �-- NAME._�� _��.,._ l��i./l-c..�,;-- - --- p ADDRESS �� /v f � PHONE �7�— �l �� _-r .�-�- August 24th, 19EE -, �� .- _, — �:a%" Dear Friend & i�eight,or: _.� T `,_� E� On Thursday August 18th, 1925, T{�e St. Paul Zonin� Corr��ittee n�ade � recorrnendation to. a�►�rove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Perr�it to Russell and BPV!�rlv Ot�erg of 1E36 Ee�st Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Flane for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Carmission of St. Paul w�ill r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Aucust 26t1�, 1988 or, tiie 13tn floor of Uhe CQty Nall annex zt 25 �J. t'r� St. to scuss e � er acceptance of re�ection of tiie Zoning Comnittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGN THE PETITION and deliv�r to Vi�gil Meyer at 16,26 E. Shore DP.ive or Arrnol d Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Dri ve �efore Nt)ON �1 �HURSUAY BUGUST,25th,'��'88.�_ If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call l�r. �4eyer at 774-2185 or iAr. Jacobson at 776-459£=or 770-3761 and they ►�aill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 4JE HAVE THESE PETITIONS �� UR HAN S BY N OP� HURSDA OMORROW AS �!E t�UST ERING TNEP•1 TO CITY HALL BE RE R D 9:0 P�G. 1�'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty oF our neighborhood. To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 l-J. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the g ranting of a nonconb�rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that pro�erty. , '7 NAM� '�' �' � C�� , . -- NAME � �% � .___�=-`�-=�`-� 1�-�--`��=`�s�-✓ _--- �) A.ODRESS /v��`i> D �J�:.�' Tf-/ S". PHON�� ''��1� r�- .-- August 24th, 19E8 Dear Friend & PJeighbor: �1� 0TI C � On Thursday August 18th, 1928, The St. Paul Zoninr Ca�;�ittee n+ade a reca;r�endation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Perr�it to Russell and 6ev��rlv �t�Erg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care tlane for teh 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Canmission of St. Paul w�ill r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Aucust 26�f;, 1988 or tiie l�th floor of bhe CBty hall annex at 25 �l. t'ri St. to scuss e � er acceptance oF re jecti on of ti�e Zoni ng Cortmi ttee recommendati on. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIG�t THE PETITION and deliver to Viergil Meyer at 16;26 E. Shore DP.ive or Aenold Jacobson at 632 E. Shore Drive b`�fore :N�t� ON THURS�IY 'BUGUST �5tb,� '�988� If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t4r. �4eyer at 774-2185 or P�Ir. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they ��aill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 4�E HAVE THESE PETITIO�dS �� UR HAN S BY NOOPJ HURSQAY TOMORROW AS lJE t4tfST BRING THEP1 TO CITY NALL E R D 9: PJG. k'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. To the Planning Carmission City Hall & Annex 25 t+l. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the tJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon6�rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to t t property. ��''.. NAM� � - �' � -- NAME � '� L� � � / ,— --_-- . ._ _—_ _ ---------- ,�CvJ � ADDRES �=� °� � .u�.� .�'_ PHON� i Rugust 24th, 19E8 Dear Friend & P�eighbor: '�'�.,0'T � C � .•— On Thursday August 18th, 1928, Tl�e St. Paul Zonin� Ca�;iitt�e n�ade a recor+r�endation to. apNrove ti�� nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell anci Beverly �t�Erg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Elome for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Carmission of St. Paul w�ill r�eet at 9•00 A. M. Frida �ucust 26t1�, 1988 or tf�E 13th floor of bhe C6ty hall annex at 25 VJ. �tr� St. to sCUSS e � er acceptance of re�ection of tiie Zoning Comnittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, QLEASE SIGN THE PETITION and deliver to Vi�gil Meyer at 1f�26 E. Shore DP.ive or ARnol d Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Dri ve�efore��i00f�-�i 'f#iL�SflAY �BUGttS� '�th;�9�6. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call lRr. �4eyer at 774-2185 or P4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they ��rill Fick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT OJE HAVE THESE PETITIO�JS I�� UR HANDS BY N PJ HURSDAY TOMORROW AS L:E hiUST BRING THEP•1 TO CITY HALL BE RE H R D 9:00 . P�G. k'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. �:. To the Planning Carmission City Hall & Annex 25 l°�. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the Undersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opRosed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Cond' ion Use Permit to that property. NAM� - -�-E''�-��--� NAME' aooRESS i_s �f�.�.�-1�,,�s;• � � PHONE�y-- �� august Zatn, �9�� -� :r�'� ',� ��- f� L..* �+", �.: Dear Friend & i�eighbor: -''��'� �'�.�.�.. On Thursday August 18th, 19�5, T{�e St. Paul Zoninr Ca;��ittee n+ade a reca,r�endation to. ap�rove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Perr:�it to Russell and Bev��rlv �berg af 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Flane for ten 1Q Childreen up to 18 years of age. The P1 anning Carmi ssion of St. Paul wi 11 r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Fri da Auc ust 26t1�, 1988 or tiiE 13tn floor of �he CBty Hall annex at 25 4J. tn St. to sCUSS e � e1^ acceptance o� re,jection of tiie Zoning Committee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGiV THE PETITION and deliver to Vie!gil Meyer at 16:26 E. Shore DRive or ARnold Jacobson at 632 E. Shore Drive (34fore P10�1 ON 'xHURSflAY �UGUST 25tfi, �'#988.� If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t4r. �4eyer at 774-2185 or i4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they ��ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT ��JE HAVE THESE PETITIOWS N R HANDS BY NOOM HURSD OMORR W AS L•!E t4UST BRING TNEP•1 TO CITY NALL BE RE HE R DA 9: 0 . JG. w'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 1;1. 4th St. St. Payl , Mn. 55102 We, the llndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a nonconb�rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NAM� __ i�,.G�-r.._... , �f O c-c��L NAME\�_ ^� ,i \ \� ' - �—�-- --�-'�---$" =-----� �--- --�--=-�`_--- " � A.ODR€SS 2- �• -z , �, . .`". c� .k . - _ PHON�`Z � �� August 24th, 1988 • Dear Friend & Neighbor: _��! 'OT��, CE On Thursday August 18th, 1928; The St. Paul Zoninr Ca��iittee n+ade a reca:rnendation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforr�ing use and Special Con�itien Use Permit to Russell ancl Bev�arlv Ot�Erg of 1636 Eest Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Nane for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. ' The Planning Carmission of St. Paul w�ill meet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Aucust 26t1�, 1988 or tfiE 13tn fl oor of bhe C�ty Hal l annex at 25 �!. t'r� St, to sCUSS e � e1^ acceptance oF re,jection of tiie Zoning Car�nittee recomrnendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, QLEASE SIG�I TNE PETITION and deliver to Viergil Meyer at 16�26 E._ Shore DP.ive or ARnold Jacobson at 632 E. Shore Drive b�fore N00t� ON �HURSDAY BUGUST 25th, �`t968.��, If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t4r. �4eyer at 774-2185 or P4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they ��ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT LdE HAVE THESE PETITIONS �� R HAND BY NOOP! THURSDAY TOMORROW AS lJE t4UST ERING THEP�1 TO CITY HALL BE ORE H R D 9: P�G. k'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillt� o� our neighborhood. � -- To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 l;l. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1388 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon6�rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that pro�erty. NAME !t'�� c��.:�'1--� NAME_ �� c�C �'_t� _ 'kJi_?�. _.�__ AODR�SS c'' '� � p( �� ' PH4N� �, �' Rugust 24th, 1988 Dear Friend & Neighbor: -� � T I C� On Thursday August 18th, 192�, T{ie St. Paul Zonin� Con�nittee n+ade a reca;r�endation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and 6ev��rl:,r �t�Erg of 1636 East Shore �Rive to operate a Foster Care tlome for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Carmission of St. Paul k�ill r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Auoust 26#I�, 1988 or tiiE 13th floor of �he CBty hall annex at 25 �J. t'r� St. to scuss e � er acceptance of rejection of tt�e Zoning Corrmmittee recomnendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIG�� THE PETITION and deli er to Vi�gil Meyer .at 1b26 E. Shore DP.ive or Arnold Jacobson at 632 E. Shore Drive�fore �00N ON TNURSDAY �UST 25th, �9Q8. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t�r. �4eyer at 774-2185 or P�r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they ��rill �ick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT LJE HAVE THESE PETITIOWS N UR HANDS BY N 0�! HURSDA OMORROW AS L•!E t-tUST ERING THE�•1 TO CITY NALL BE R D 9: P�G. k'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. To the Planning Carmission City Hall & Annex 25 t;l. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Car�nittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon6brming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that pro�erty. - ,. � � 4, � � .. NAME � `. NAME._��-�1--5�_�_1___..��"� � !� 2_ �' `� =,�+-`= ,- �- � ` -- / ` ADDRESS `"� - i� � ,r.� f� r-- PH4NE�7 �� _�� rt.-�.,--�--�- -�--� --�-�� ugust 24th, 1988 Dear Friend & yeightor: _ N 0 T I C E On Thursday August 18tti, 19�£, T{�e St. Paul Zonin� Cor.��ittee n+ade a reca:rnendation to, ap�►rove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and BPV(`rlv �t�erg of 1E36 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care fiome for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Carmission of St. Paul K�ill r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Au ust 26t��, 1988 or, tiiE 13tn fl oor of �he C6ty hal l annex at 25 �l. tr� St, to SCUSS e � er acceptance o� re�ection of ti�e Zoning Co�rnittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your o�servation and we urge your attendance. If yau cannot attend, eLEASE SIGi� THE PETITION and deliver to Vie�gil Meyer at 1b26 E. Shore DP.ive or Arrnold Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Drive � _ :;• . ' -. � � • --=�--- .. _�. _ . . __ -�.-,.�._._._ _ _ ...r_-------�- If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t1r. t4eyer at 774-2185 or i4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they v;ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT bJE HAVE TFIESE PETITIONS �J OUR HANDS BY NO PJ HURSDAY TOMORROW AS 4:E �1UST ERING THEP�1 TO CITY HALL BE ORE E D JG. w'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty of our neighborhood. � _ .. � - _ To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 l°�. 4th St. St. Pau?, Mn. 55102 We, the llndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are oFposed to the g ranting of a noncon8brming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. �'" � NEVr1E ' �e�-�; ` > 1 , � `,_ ' ,_l'-(.' __ �%kf i�r->; � - ��P4E_----�`--��--!�J i i.-'1��_�_�'--j``--�/�_--_—__ .vr; �,�S - tT � � PHONE '_ � 7 � � �11��c�s�.. � � �'�,�.�,r�.;�_�.C� .._ ,-.�-a.- �-�-� 'S August 24th, 198E C:�'�~ � c`� ``�`�� Dear Friend & P�eighbor: �I �tT � CE On Thursday August 18th, 193E, Tfie St. Paul Zonin; Cor�rnittee ti�ade a reca,r:�endation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Perr�it to Russell and Bev�arlv Oberg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Ffome for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Carmission of St. Paul will r�eet at 9•00 A. M�. Frida�Au ust 26�1�, 1988 or tiiE 13tn fl oor of �he CQty hal l annex at 25 4l. �t'r� St. to disCUSS e � e1r acceptance oF rejection of ti�e Zoning Car�nittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGf� THE PETITION and deliver to Vie�gil Meyer at 1b26 E. Shore DP.ive or Arrnold Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Drive�efore �l80N��FF-��A�- If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t4r. t�leyer at 714-2185 or F�Ir. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they will pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT �JE HAVE THESE PETITIONS IN UR HANDS BY NOOPJ HURSDAY TOMORROW AS L!E t1UST BRING THEP1 TO CITY HRLL BE 0 E ID P�G. k'e thank you for your hFlp to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. To the Planning Corrmission City Hall & Annex 25 W. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1388 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the g ranting of a noncon�6rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. 1 I i NAME �. ..�r.� ll�-", l�—�-t--C� NAME �.�.: � _t� _�/�.0 �// /i. _ _ , ---� - --- ->- - jj� Y-� t-�= ,. /,_ � �� A.ODRESS /��' / ,v/c ��r�`' << �--�� PHONE�G ��° _-� � August 24th, 198E Dear Friend & Neighbor: '�� 0 T `I G � On Thursday August 18th, 1925, Tiie St. Paul Zonin� Cor,��ittee n�ade a reca:rnendation to. apNrove ti�� nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Fussell and BPV�arlv Ot�Erg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Flome for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Carmission of St. Paul will r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frid�Au ust 26�l;, 1988 or thE 13th floor of bhe CBty Hall annex at 25 4J. tr� t. to scuss e � er acceptance of re jecti on of ti�e Zon i ng Commi ttee recor�nendati on. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGN THE PETITION and deliver to Vi�gil Meyer at 16;26 E. Shore DRive or Arnold Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Drive b�fore"��100N �d THURSDAY HIiGUST��3tfi; :�88..s , . - If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call �4r. t4eyer at 774-2185 or P4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they ��ill �ick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 6JE HAVE THESE PETITIONS Pd UR HAN S BY NOOPJ HURSDAY OMORROW AS L•JE h1UST BRING THE�1 TO CITY HP.LL BE E D 9: . . E PJG. w'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty ofi our neighborhood. �- To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 l4. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the llndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon�6rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. . ` . � N�1M��.��.��:.`� - ��. _�J��t t i t;(� _- NAME--��t``--��---��-��_��.1�. c _ � t��-- A.DDRESS l 1 C� -- - /��tit,!- iL.t«_ _ PHONE :l 7� �.J� 7�- _.,� -.r.�.-� -�--- F,ugust 24th, 198E Dear Friend & Neighbor: �'��':,.��,C� -ik 4 .rn On Thursday August 18th, 1935, T{�e St. Paul Zonin� Cor,xaittee n�ade a reca�r:�endation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and Severlv Ot�Erg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care tlome for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Cannission of St. Paul k�ill r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Fri�da�Aucust 26��;, 1988 or ti�E 13th floor of bhe CQty hall annex at 25 VJ. t'r� t, to isCUSS e � er acceptance o� re�ection of ti�e Zoning Carrnittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGN THE PETITION and deliver to i il Meyer at 16�26 E. Shore DP,iye . or ARnol d Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Dri ve ' �e��i`��i��t�.S��`'�'a�i`i,'"��$$. �� 1i -� � .'r.:.a.4:.ai �.. ..� If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t4r. t4eyer at 774-2185 or P4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they ��ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 6�E HAVE THESE PETITIONS P� OU HAND BY NOOPJ HURSDA OMORROW AS 41E t4llST ERING THEM TO CITY NALL BE ORE R D 9: P�G. we thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. To the Planning Canmission City Hall & Annex 25 l•1. 4th St. � St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the Undersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the g ranting of a noncon6drming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. �� ` lZ*z.��-�.. NAM� NAME .,��►,'':_;:� �� 4` ,i`r,lk�..t;� � AODRESS /� /.-� .�..��.�.�- ��'I~�__ PHONE��- z�T� /�� %�y�c•�� r_��"� l� V � Rugust 24th, 19E8 Dear Friend & yeighbor: !�'"!t �? T � ,�.�� On Thursday August 18th, 1925, The St. Paul Zonin� Cor,vnittee n�ade a reca:rnendation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and 6ev�rlv Ot�Erg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Nome for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Carmission of St. Paul K�ill meet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Au ust 26�I�, 1988 or the 13tn floor of �he CQty hall annex at 25 4a, tri St. to scuss e � er acceptance oF rejection of tf�e Zoning Canmittee recor�nendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot ortAenoleLJacobson�atHE632TETIShoredDri ve�eforeV��1�'e��U�T�5th��8. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call �1r. �4eyer at 774-2185 or P�r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they r�ai]1 pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 6JE HAVE THESE PETITIOWS N UR HANDS BY NOOP! THURSDAY OMORROW AS L•!E t4UST ERING TNE�1 TO CITY NALL 6 RE H R D 9: P�G. k'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 t�l. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the l�ndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the g ranting of a noncon8�rming use and Special.` Condition Use Permit to that property. � � 1 � NAM� _ , � _� � N AM E ��•-�.�,�..- G�'. .�,_-�-�-��ri_. IL�_-----=�-- A.DDRESS ��, t,�Z ! �� .� PHON��'�'��7�3 G r... August 24th, 19EE Dear Friend & i�eighbor: '�`-�q p T 7-�C f � On Thursday August 18th, 19�5, The St. Paul Zoninr Cor;�r��ittee n+ade a recorrnendation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Perr�it to Russell and 6everly Ot,Erg of 1E36 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care F1ome for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Pl.anning Carmission of St. Paul will meet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Au ust 26�1�, 1988 or, the 13tn fl oor of bhe CQty hal l annex at 25 VJ. tr� St. to scuss e !� el" acceptance of rejection of ti�e Zoning Committee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIG�� THE PETITION and deliver to Vie�gil Meyer at 16,26 E .Shore DRive or Arrnol d Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Dri ve�it��=�t.�t_.��I��D�fl�"'��t�t,.- . If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t4r. P4eyer at 774-2185 or P�r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they v;ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 4JE NAVE THESE PETITIO��S �� UR HANDS B NOOPJ HURSDA OMORROW AS L•!E t4UST BRING THEM TO CITY HALL BE ORE DA 9: 0 . PJG. k'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty ofi our neighborhood. To the Planning Carmission City Hall & Annex 25 l;l. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. N�,� f � ? iv �SC � ��` ; � � i�: �!�� _��'_��-_ �___,�,-`'`-= �- c/ �� G �`�. -f'� •'�C.� PHONE �� +~ � ADDRESS ,�� Rugust 24th, 19EE ,,.�., �R_, , �;�F{.. t. Dear Friend & Neighbor: '��.�T� :� E On Thursday August 18th, 1935, The St. Paul Zonin, Cor��nittee n�ade a reca,r�endation to, ap�rove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and Bev��rl.v Ot�Erg of 1636 Eest Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Ffane for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Carmission of St. Paul will meet at 9:00 A. M. Frida�Au ust 26t1�, 1988 or ti�E 13tn fl oor of �he CQfy Hal l annex at 25 y1. t'r� St. to sCUSS e � er acceptance of re jecti on of tiie Zon i ng Comni ttee reco�unendati on. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, QLEASE SIG�� THE PETITION and deliver ,to 1f��gil..,,��yer_,,�t��,�26 �r Shore DRive or Arnol d Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Dri ve b�fo�ce �t04G1�1 :�1l�RS:t�AY �1611�T ��#�i: �9.8�• If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t1r. �4eyer at 774-2185 or P�r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they ��ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 4JE NAVE THESE PETITIONS N UR HANDS QY NO M HURSDAY OMORROW AS l:E t4UST BRING THEP�1 TO CITY HALL B D 9: �G. k'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. �:: .� - _ t'4 � To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 lJ. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the llndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Corrnnittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. � , _ �-. NAM€ - ' /� ` -y . �..�� . , NAME%`' ��-��,�.�v� - ,[.- {-- AODR�SS��._.----�------� - --�-- -- -- PHONE 77�6� v��1 _._.�-� � �,�,�,Ci� `��;�-r sr iv,E, To the Planning Carmission City Hall & Annex 25 l�I. 4th St. _ St. Paul , Mn. 55102 . We, the llndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the g ranting of a noncon8�rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. _ ; ; ; /'�-- � C Nl4hl� ' < � � �- � � /r� r�2 i Yi-t t r •r+ �i.�• NAME ADDRESS /��' ``%;- �-�� '"�'t-� L<�-� PH�NE � �� ;�',--`%' 1T �T _ _ �� August 24th, 1988 Dear Friend & Neighbor: �� ., �ui�wa�a�� On Thursday August 18th, 1925, T{ie St. Paul Zonin� Cor,x�iittee n+�de a reca�r�endation to, apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and Bev��rly Ok�Erg of 163b Eest Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Home for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. � The Planning Carmission of St. Paul w�ill r�eet at 9:00 A. M. �Frida�Au ust 26t1�, 1988 or thE 13tfi� floor of bhe CQty hall annex at 25 4J. t'r� t. to disCUSS e � er' acceptance oF re,jection of ti�e Zoning Comnittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGN THE PETITION and deliver to Vi�gil Meyer at 1b26 E. Shore DP.ive or ARnol Jaco son at 63 E. Shore Orive . �.; �,, . ....-:'°-AF�� Yn[.-. , .. . . . •.. SA�..�wYACt �... ... If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call Mr. �4eyer at 714-2185 or P4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they Yrill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 4JE HAVE THESE PETITIONS �� R HANDS BY N PJ HURSDA MORROW AS �!E t-1UST BRING THE��1 TO CITY HALL 6 RE D 9: �G. �r'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty of our neighborhood. � - To the Planning Carmission City Hall & Annex 25 4V. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 551Q2 We, the llndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Co►rnnittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. � �� _ ��O��c NAME �� N�,E._� 53.�_��-----�`sL____ - aooa�ss PHqN�� i'�� a august 2atn, 198E Dear Friend & Neighbor: �� On Thursday August i8th, 1935, The St. Paul Zonin� Ca,x�iittee n+ade a reca�rnendation to. apNrove t1�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Perr�it to Russell and 6ev��rlv �t�Erg c�f 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care flome for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. . The Planning Canmission of St. Paul will r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Fri�da�August 26tti, 1988 or the 13th floor of �he CBty Hall annex at 25 W. t'r� t. to iscuss e � er acceptance of re�ection of tiie Zoning Co��nittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGN TNE PETITION and deliver to Vi il Me er at 16�26 E. Shore DP.ive or Arrnol Jacobson at 632 E. Shore Drive ,� .x z ... .,_.... . — �,. x...r. . .. .. ..a a.....:.4v.+slu-:r...L i� a>.._ Y.:n... If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call F4r. t4eyer at 774-2185 or PAr. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they r�ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 6JE HAVE THESE PETITIONS �� UR HANDS BY N OP! HURSD OMORROW AS L�lE t4UST BRING THEr•1 TO CITY NALL B RE HE R D 9: . . PG. k'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 tJ. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Corr�nittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. :� NAME �/� � �i.'-�.�.,..�-.�-i r.�� -- r NAME aooRESS ��,� c� � .�. �� -� s� PNON� � -- >3 d d � � August 24th, 19EE Dear Friend � Neighbor: -�� On Thursday August 18th, 1935, The St. Paul Zoninr Cor,�nittee n+ade a reca�rnendation to. apNrove ti�a nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Perriit to Russell and Beverl.v �bErg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care F1ome for ten 1Q Childreen up to 18 years of age. � The Planning Cannission of St. Paul will meet at 9:Q0 A. M. Frida Aucust 26t1}, 1988 or thE 13th floor of �he CQty Hall annex at 25 W. th St. to scuss e � e1" acceptance oF re�ection of ti�e Zoning Conrnittee recaronendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, 2LEASE SIG�! THE PETITION and deliver to ViFgil Meyer at lfi,26 E. Shore DRive or Aenol acobson at 63 E. Shore Drive If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call Mr. t�leyer at 714-2185 or P4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they v�ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 4JE HAVE THESE PETITIONS PJ U AN Y N PJ URSDA OMORROW AS WE �4UST BRING THEM TO CITY HALL 6 RE H D �G. 1n'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. To the Planning Carmission City Hall & Annex 25 l�J. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the Undersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon86rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NAME �� ,�<��u�=.� -- I�AME ADDRESS /� .re -------____�--�/—� --- PHONE ��/ ��r,f� � �,.,...,�---- � > August 24th, 198E Dear Friend & Neighbor: ' ��t��^� On Thursday August 18th, 1935, The St. Paul Zoninr Cor;�r��ittee made a recorr:�endation to. ap�rove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and Bev��rl.v �t,Erg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Fiome for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. � The Planning Ca�rnission of St. Paul will r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frid�Aucust 26t1�, 1988 or the 13th floor of bhe CQty hall annex at 25 W. t'r� t. to �scuss e � el" acceptance of re�ection of tiie Zoning Carmittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGN THE PETITION and deliver to Vi�►gil Meyer at 16�26 E. Shore DP.ive or ARnol Jacobson at 632 E. Shore Drive"'�l�4��16f�=��l�B�AY��i��6��68. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, pleas� call t4r. �4eyer at 774-2185 or P4r. Jacobson at 716-459E=or 770-3761 and they r�ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT L�JE HAVE THESE PETITIONS � U H Y N PJ URSDA OMORR W AS l•JE t-1UST BRING THEM TO CITY NALL R D . �G. k'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. �,. To the Planning Carmission City Nall & Annex 25 I�t. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NlIME f�v-ve�-�. ��'�n.��. NAME c-� / ADDRESS �-S � �'� �►�,,�1�� ^ PHON�!� � — 1 �� ' _ ._ Rugust 24th, 19EE ��-�r� � .i"� �E:..��'-- Dear Friend & Neighbor: �.�.'� ��-,^��. On Thursday August 18th, 1935, The St. Paul Zonin� Cor;��ittee n�ade a reconrnendation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and Bev�rly �t�Erg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care N ane for ten 1� Childre�n up to 18 years of age. � The Planning Canmission of St. Paul will meet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Aucust 26t1�, 1988 or thE 13th floor of 6he CQty Hall annex at 25 VJ, t'r� St. to sCUSS e � er acceptance oF re�ection of ti�e Zoning Committee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGN TNE PETITION and deliver to Vie�gil Meyer at 1fx26 E. Shore DRive or Aenol Jacobson at 6 2 E. Shore Drive If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t1r. t4eyer at 774-2185 or P4r. Jacobson at 776-459£=or 770-3761 and they Yaill pick it up. � IT IS URGENT THAT LJE HAVE THESE PETITIONS t� U HAN BY N PJ URSDA MORROW AS WE t4UST BRING THEP1 TO CITY NALL E RDY : P�G. w'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty o�F our neighborhood. To the Planning Carmission City Hall & Annex 25 t�J. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the Undersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon6�rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that prope�ty. %< / •� <<�� )/ ��--� .. ��._�_�...f �f' � NL4M /�� - _, v� Gc, Y __ I�AME ` —� . � AODRESS /i F!' .,._,�,//,�./,,�, l�-�_�� PHONE�� — l.�-- �� ,...��:�.�..:: ,.w....�� > August 24th, 198E r��" �='� �'`�' `� Dear Friend & Neightor: y `�W.^� � �*. ..,$ ��e� ..� . On Thursday August 18th, 1988, The St. Paul Zoninr C�r,��ittee n�ade a recor�nendation to. approve ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and 8ev��rl.v �bErg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Ffome for ten 10 Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Canmission of St. Paul will meet at 9:00 A. M. Frid Au ust 26tli, 1988 or tiie 13th floor of bhe CQty Hall annex at 25 W. tr� t. to sCUSS e � er acceptance oF re3ection of ti�e Zoning Comnittee recon�nendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGN THE PETITION and deliver to Vi�gil Meyer at 16�26 E. Shore DRive or Arrnol Jacobson at 632 E. Shore Drive ��``r � i �1 DAX'�Ik1GlfS'f 35't� ;� �c�_►� � . , .. . .. . ..__�....�ti....�.�:4.��:-_�: . If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call Mr. t4eyer at 774-2185 or P�r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they ►;ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 6JE HAVE THESE PETITIONS � UR ANOS BY NO D! URSD MORROW AS L•!E t�UST BRING THEr1 TO CITY HALL D 9• . �G. k'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty o�F our neighborhood. To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 W. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the Undersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon6�rming use and Special Condi ion Use P it to that property. � NAME �. � NAME_.___.�:_�'�- �1 )�-��fc..�.. --- LI --�- y � AODRESS 1 � � PH�N,E��?' ° -T � T August 24th, 198E Dear Friend & Neighbor: .{'��'�� On Thursday August 18th, 1935, The St. Paul Zonin� Ca,x��ittee n�ade a reconr�endation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and Bev�rly �bErg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Flane for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Cannission of St. Paul w�ill r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frid Au ust 26t1�, 1988 on thE 13th f�oor of �he CQty hall annex at 25 W. tr� t. to sCUSS e � er acceptance o� re�ection of tfie Zoning Comnittee recar�nendation. �-� This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGH TNE PETITION and deliver �.o Vi il Meyer at 16�6 E. Shore DP.ive or Arrnol d Jacobson at 632 E. Shore Dri ve :��'�f,� � � . � �� _ 4. ._..,. . __ _ ._ ._ . ._ � � If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call Nlr. t�eyer at 774-2185 or P4r. Jacobson at 716-459E=or 770-3761 and they vrill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT WE HAVE THESE PETITIONS �� UR HAN S BY N OPJ URSD OMORROW AS WE t4UST BRING THEh1 TO CITY NALL BE D . . �G. w'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty of our neighborhood. �,.,�. -:��. To the Planning Carmission City Hall & Annex 25 l+l. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore De ve, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition e Permit to that property. NE1iM� � - I�AME ADDRESS�3 --,��,�,��;�C.c,Z�f.'�----- --- PH4NE f _ .,_,__r., -�-----_ ! August 24th, 1988 ��- � ��, Dear Friend & Neighbor: �''fl �'�;��. On Thursday August 18th, 1935, The St. Paul Zoninr Ca�x��ittee n�ade a reca+r�endation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and Bev��rl.v �t�Erg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care N ane for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Canmission of St. Paul will meet at 9:00 A. M. Frid Rucust 26�1�, 1988 or the 13th floor of �he CQty Hall annex at 25 MJ. tr� ,t. to scuss e � er acceptance o� re�ection of ti�e Zoning Committee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGt� THE PETITION and deliver to Vie►gil Meyer at 1626 E. Shore DRive or Arrnold Jaco son at 632 E. Shore Drive �ene�it�N �1 �NI�RSt�l1f��IlG�S��r,�� _ , . . :-:w -;�-......,...�. ...._._,. . _ _ ., .� . � _ .�< : If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t4r. t4eyer at 774-2185 or P�r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 710-3761 and they will pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT �dE HAVE THESE PETITIONS �� UR HANDS BY N ON HURSDAY OMORROW AS WE h1UST BRING THEM TO CITY HALL BE R D NG. � �e thsryk y�ou�`or �,,t�l p to preserve the val ue and desi rabi 11 ty o�F our �,�. �.- _.� ;�: neighborhood. ��., . 4 ,ti . .,- , .,.,..,, r � To the Planning Comnission * ' City Hall & Annex 25 l+l. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1388 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NAM 1 � � r\ �� NAME AODRESS��,,,,_�� j�, `�� PHONE;�'� 7 ��3 S ve, r � %. au9ust 24tn, �9sa Dear Friend & Neighbor: �� On Thursday August 18th, 1935, The St. Paul Zoninr Cor,��ittee rr�ade a recorr�endation to. ap�rove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Perr�it to Russell and Bev��rly ObErg of 1636 Eest Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Nane for ten 10 Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Canmission of St. Paul k�ill meet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Au ust 26t1�, 1988 or ti�E 13th floor of bhe CQty hall annex at 25 W, t'r� t. to 1lscuss e � er acceptance oF re�ection of tiie Zoning Committee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGN THE PETITION and deliver to Vi �1 Meyer at 16�26 E. Shore DP.ive or Artnol Jacobson at 32 E. Shore Drive �o `'�"��i� ! :_ �.:,,��--��.�. � �, �� . If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call l4r. Meyer at 774-2185 or P4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they will pick it up. IT IS URGENT.THAT 6JE HAVE THESE PETITIONS �� HAN S BY NO PI HURSDAY OMORROW AS 4!E t4lfST BRING THEP1 TO CITY HALL H R D �G. w'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. �. _ To the Planning Carmission City Hall & Annex 25 lJ. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. � NAME� ��u�ic._ � 21z2�C'_� - I�AME ADDRESS ��.�~ 7,��.�'..�::�1 ��-.-- --- PH4NE �'7(� -�f��" ,�..-_ � August 24th, 198E Dear Friend & Neighbor: �neM4�R'�i�fr� On Thursday August 18th, 1938, The St. Paul Zoninr Cor+�r��ittee n+ade a reca+mendation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and Bev��rl,v �bErg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care F1ane for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Canmission of St. Paul w�ill r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Aucust 26t1�, 1988 or thE 13th floor of �he CQty hall annex at 25 W. t'r� St. to sCUSS e � er acceptance of re�ection of ti�e Zoning Committee recorrimendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGN THE PETITION and del i vea�.9 ��-�:��,X�HU�DA '-�� , �5t�t�� or ARnold Jacobson at 632 E. Shore Drive �`. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t4r. t4eyer at 774-2185 or P4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they Yrill pick it up. � IT IS URGENT THAT WE HAVE THESE PETITIONS P� UR AND BY N PJ URSDA OMORR W AS l•!E tdUST BR NG TNEP4 TO CITY HALL E RE D 9: P G. w'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty o�F our neighborhood. To the Planning Carmission City Hall & Annex 25 !d. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the llndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Co�nittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the g ranting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NAME � �, �� 1�.._�____le .��__-____ _ ADDRESS �O PH�N��„ `�� 3C��— . � August 24th, 198E ,��' �� Dear Friend b Neighbor: �� On Thursday August 18th, 1935, The St. Paul Zoninr Cax�iittee n+ade a recorrnendation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and 6e w�rlv ObErg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Elome for ten 10 Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Ca►mission of St. Paul will meet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Au ust 26�1�, 1988 or tt�E 13th floor of hhe C�ty Hall annex at 25 41. t'r� St. to scuss � � er acceptance oF re�ection of ti�e Zoning Comnittee reco�unendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, QLEASE SIGN THE PETITION and deliver to Vi�gil Meyer at 16�26 E. Shore DRive . or Aenol Jacobson at 632 E. Shore Drive fi�0(��1+t � . If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call Mr. �4eyer at 774-2185 or P�Ir. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they will pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 6�E HAVE THESE PETITIONS �� U HANDS BY NO P� URSD MORROW l�.S L�JE h1UST BRING THEM TO CITY HALL B ORE D 9: . . NG. w'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty o�F our neighborhood. To the Planning Comnission City Hall & Annex 25 t�J. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a nonconb�rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. �� NAME . i t�AME�o?_------ ----- ------ -- ADORESS �J � • � PNONE�� -� d � • • - - Rugust 24th, 19EE ��W� � `''�'`�u� Dear Friend & P�eighbor: ..._-___ � �� On Thursday �+ugust 18th, 192&, The St. Paul Zonin� Ca��nittee n�ade a reca;��endation to. a�Nrove ti�� nonconforming use and Special CQn�ition Use Perr�it to Russell and Beverlv Oberg of 1636 East Shore �Rive to operate a Foster Care Ffome for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. � The Planning Cam►ission of St. Paul will meet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Aucust 2Etl�, 1988 , or thE 13th floor of �he CQty hall annex at 25 W. t'r� t. to SCUSS e � er acceptance of re�ection of tiie Zoning Corrrnittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGN THE PETITION and deliver to Vi�gil Meyer at 16,26 E. Shore DRive or Artnol Jacobson at 632 E. Shore Drive before �d00W ON THURSDAY HUGUST 25th, 1988. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call Mr. Meyer at 774-2185 or P4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 710-3761 and they Yrill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT ��JE NAVE THESE PETITIONS t� UR NANDS BY N PJ URSDA OMORROW AS l!E t-i!!ST BRING TNEM TO CITY NALL D . G. w'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty oF our neighborhood. To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 l+l. 4th St. St. Pau1 , Mn. 55102 We, the Undersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the g ranting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. ' NAM � 14AME �_ �„�_I�_ - .� ADDRESS C� PH�N�� 103 _______ � August �4th, 198E Dear Friend & Neighbor: ��-., , ��:� On Thursday August 18th, 19�5, The St. Paul Zoninr Coc��ittee n�ade a reca:r�endation to. ap�rove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Cen�ition Use Permit to Russell and Bev�arlv �t�Erg of 1636 East Shore �Rive to operate a Foster Care F1ome for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. � The Planning Canmission of St. Paul will r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida�r Auc�ust 26t1i, 1988 or thE 13th floor of �he C6ty Hall annex at 25 VJ. tr� St. to s'CUSS e a er acceptance o� re�ection of ti�e Zoning Carmittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, QLEASE SIGiV THE PETITION and deliver to Vi�gil Meyer at 16�26 E. Shore DRive � or Armol Jacobson at 32 E. Shore Drive If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call �4r. t4eyer at 774-2185 or P4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they Y�i]1 pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT LJE HAVE TNESE PETITIONS �� UR HANDS BY N P� URSD MORROW AS l•!E h1UST BRING THE�•1 TO CITY HALI R D 9: . . �G. w'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. To the Planning Camiission City Hall & Annex 25 lJ. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Comnittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NAhiE�/'�,�" �S'� �, •c�i -- NI�ME . ADDRESS //`�d �<�� d �1`c.� �� PH4NE?� � a��6 � _..._._.- , � ._.... J . . August 24th, 19EE Dear Friend & Neighbor: �� n Thursday August 18th, 1925, T{�e St. Paul Zonin� Cor,�nittee n+ade a reca:mendation to. ap�rove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and BeVC-�rl.v Ot�Erg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Nome for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Carmission of St. Paul will meet at 9•00 A. M. Frida Au ust 26�1�, 1988 or tiiE 13tn floor of bhe CQfy hall annex at 25 6J.�t'r� St. to scuss e � er acceptance oF re,�ection of tt�e Zoning Committee recor�nendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGf� THE PETITION and del i ver 1 M l.fi,26 E. Shore DP,j�� or ARnold Jacobson at 632 E. Shore Drive"�� -�'�`��"� If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call Mr. f4eyer at 714-2185 or PAr. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they will pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 6JE HAVE THESE PETITIONS �� UR HAND B N PI URSD MORROW AS l•lE t-1UST ERING TNE�•1 TO CITY NRLL E RE H R D �G. w'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirability of our neighborhood. � .x. � To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 td. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the IJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning C�ronittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon6brming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NAME` 4'Lha[�,v Cc� NAME.-��=__--°='=-w._-- _��.___ ADDRESS I / 7 C� -��,.a-.�♦�� PHONE �„'� � ' � �p� � � August 24th. 1988 Dear Friend & Neighbor: -�; � a%� On Thursday Aug�st 18th, 192&, The St. Paul Zaninr Ca��raittee n�ade a reca+�nendation to. ap�rove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and Bev�arlv �berg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care tlome for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. . The Planning Cannission of St. Paul k�ill r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Au ust 2Etl�, 1988 or ttiE 13th fl oor of bhe CQty hal l annex at 25 Vt, t'ri t. to sCUSS e � er acceptance oF re�ection of tiie Zoning Carrnittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, QLEASE SIGN THE PETITION and delive,r�to Vi� i_1 Me er at 16,26 E. Shore DRive , or ARnold Jacobson at 63 E. Shore Drive � If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call l4r. t4eyer at 774-2185 or P4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they ��rill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT WE HAVE THESE PETITIOtJS � UR H DS BY N PJ HURSDA OMORROW AS l•JE t�UST ERING TNE�1 TO CITY HRLL RE R D . . G. w'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty oF our neighborhood. _ ,� R To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 l�J. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the tlndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Corr�nittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon86rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NAM� s NAME___ __.��=�t! _ t�__',��--�.__ AQDRESS /I `13 ��— ..1�,�:c�-o PHONE w,�7 `� ' � 7 S� 9` a August 24th, 198E Dear Friend & Neightor: i� � On Thursday August 18th, 192�, The St. Paul Zonin� Cor,x��ittee n+ade a recorrnendation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Perr�it to Russell and Bev��rl.v �k�Erg of 1E36 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Fiane for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Canmission of St. Paul k�ill meet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Au ust 26�1�, 1988 or ti�E 13th fl oor of bhe CQty Hal l annex at 25 VJ, t'r� t. to sCUSS e � e1r acceptance of re,jection of t��e Zoning Corr�nittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIG�! THE PETITION and deliver to Vie!�il Me er at 1 6 E. or Arrnol Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Drive �� If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call Mr. �4eyer at 774-2185 or P�ir. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they will pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 4JE HaVE THESE PETITIONS �� HANDS BY NO P! HURSDA MORROW AS L•!E t4UST BRING THEP�1 TO CITY HALL E ORE D PJG. Vr'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. ;�: .,, To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 t°J. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the Undersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Co�nnittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon6drming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. � NAME � � �Y � , NAME.___��-��-��---�- ---�-'� - �/ � � /� � � ADDR�SS ,� 2�r -.� PHONE�.�;--��` �- -��--` !- � Rugust 24th, 198E ��° - � �o� Dear Friend & Neighbor: �....., ��':; �� 9 On Thursday August 18th, 1925, T{�e St. Paul Zoninr Cor+�r��ittee n+ade a reca.r�endation to. ap�rove ti�� nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Perr�it to Russell anci Bev��rlv Qberg o�f 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care ffane for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. . The Planning Carmission of St. Paul will r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frid�Aucust 26t1�, 1988 on thE 13th floor of bhe CQty hall annex at 25 �J. t'r� t. to I�sCUSS e � er acceptance of re�ection of ti�e Zoning Canmittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGN THE PETITION and deliver to Vi�gil Meyer at 16r26 E. Shore DRive or ARnol Jaco son at 632 E. Shore Drive � �+,,,,,... If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call Mr. t4eyer at 714-2185 or PAr. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they vrill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT ��JE HAVE THESE PETITIO�JS f� UR HANDS BY 0 P� HURSDA OMORROW AS L!E �4UST BRING THEP1 TO CITY HALL E D 9: . . �G. w'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 !J. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore D�ive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. (', Nt�►1�'��o-� a�.�c--,�.�-� -- � �lAME.�`!�.�Q ----°c,n-a�n-a!_� �__ ADDRESS � .�` � . PHONE /-' 3,S n - -- � Rugust 24th, 1988 Dear Friend & Neighbor: ,�:-�,�. :� ��._ On Thursday August 18th, 1935, The St. Paul Zonin� Ca;�+�i ttee n�ade a reca+rnendation to. apNrove tl�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Perriit to Russell and Sev�rl.v ObErg of 1636 East Shore �Rive to operate a Foster Care Flane for ten 1Q Childreen up to 18 years of age. � The P1 anning Carmi ssion of St. Paul wi 11 r�eet at 9•00 A. M. Fri d�Auc ust 26ti1, 1988 or the 13th floor of �he CQty hall annex at 25 W. �t'r� t. to �scuss e � er acceptance of re,�ection of ti�e Zoning Committee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, QLEASE SIGN 7HE PETITION and del i er to Vie�g�1..,Meyer,,,�t , 6�2b E,..,�hQ��e �DP.i ve or ARnol Jacobson at 632 E. Shore Dri ve ` � A�Ot��QN.�THURS�iA�`��'it�S3��tt�,�:;� �,:�:«� .. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call Mr. �4eyer at 774-2185 or P�r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they will pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 6JE HAVE THESE PETITIONS � UR AND BY N PJ URSD Y OMORROW AS t!E htUST BRING TNEP1 TO CITY NALL E D 9: �G. k'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. To the Planning Carmission City Hall & Annex 25 ��1. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the Undersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Co�nittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NEUri ��t�- � � -- � hAME .��. ?�sL-�.w�� _- ADDRESS /� y .. Sf. S'� PHONE �7 � ^/ 8I� ,.�..-� -- a August 24th, 198E Dear Friend & Neighbor: � On Thursday August 18th, 1935, Ti�e St. Paul Zonin� Corx��iittee n+ade a recor��endation to. ap�rove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Perr�it to Russell and Bev��rly �bErg of 1636 Eest Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Flome for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Canmission of St. Paul w�ill �eet at 9:00 A. M. �Frid�a Aucust 26�1i, 1988 or thE 13th floor of bhe CQty hall annex at 25 V�.— tr� St. to dlscuss e �1e1^ acceptance oF re,�ection of tiie Zoning Committee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, QLEASE SIGN THE PETITION and deliver to Viergil Meyer at 16;26 E. Shore DRive or Aenol Jaco son at 632 E. Shore Drive before ..� If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call Mr. 14eyer at 774-2185 or P�r. Jacobson at 776-459£=or 770-3761 and they will pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 4JE HAVE THESE PETITIONS �J U H D Y NOOP! HURSD OMORROW AS L•JE t4UST BRING THEM TO CITY HALL BE RE R D . . �G. w'e thank you for your hFlp to preserve the value and desirabillty ofi our neighborhood. To the Planning Ca►mission City Hall & Annex 25 W. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Pern►it to that property. NAM� ( � NAME'� :,,�,j��-�J:ti.._ _ +_ `\�-� - _ ., ADDRESS�� ' PH4N��S �� a �-�� t;� ��z ��;� S s��; �'� �{. � August 24th, 198E Dear Friend & Neighbor: ; � ,�� On Thursday August 18th, 1935, The St. Paul Zoninr Cor+x�iittee n+ade a reca�r�endation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Perr�it to Russell and Bev��rl.v �t�Erg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care flome for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Ca�nission of St. Paul w�ill r�eet at 9•00 A. M. Frida �Au ust�26�1�, 1988 or thE 13th floor of bhe CQty Hall annex at 25 W. �t'r� ,t. to sCUSS e1�he1" acceptance o� re�ection of tt�e Zoning Comnittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGN THE PETITION and deliver to Vi . il ,�yer at, 16;26 E. Shore DRive or Aenol Jaco son at 163 E. Shore Drive D�� iiS�� th. ,; _ �:k� If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t4r. t4eyer at 774-2185 or P4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they v�ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 6JE HAVE THESE PETITIONS �� AN Y NO M URSD OMORR W AS l•JE h1UST BRING TNEM TO CITY NALL E R D 9: �G. k'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty ofi our neighborhood. .,,, �.. ;� ;.: - To the Planning Carmission City Hall & Annex 25 lJ. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the Undersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NAME ,, -- �_ c :L.� �-_- ��r�+E_ -�-�-=� --- � aooRE s , PH4N�,..�l��Q _ , _ _ August 24th, 19EE Dear Friend & Neighbor: � � � I On Thursday August 18th, 1925, The St. Paul Zoninr CaY�iittee rrade a recorti�endation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Perriit to Russell and BP.V�a1"�,Y ObErg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Fiome for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Canmission of St. Paul will r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida �'+u ust 26�1�, 1988 or the 13th floor of bhe CQty hall annex at 25 W. t'r� t. to sCUSS e � el^ acceptance oF re�ection of ti�e Zoning Committee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGN THE PETITION and deli Vi . il Meyer at 1 � �:. ._ .ive or ARnol Jaco son at 632 E. Shore Driv � �� - _ _. �. If you are not at,le to deliver the petition personally, please call F4r. �4eyer at 714-2185 or P�r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they will pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT WE HAVE THESE PETITIONS � UR HANDS BY NO PJ URSDAY OMORR W AS l•!E t�UST BRING THEP�1 TO CITY NALL BE ORE H D G. w'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty o�' our neighborhood. � w J� : - To the Planning Carmission City Nall & Annex 25 l�J. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon6�rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. . / Nt�IE_��(/�2��c.e �'" (�� f�'L� -- NAME , _ � •r � � ��'�, AODRESS 1.5 7---- �'.l•L¢' ><< �C��...��` PHONE � �, ..�-.-�---_ � August 24th, 198E �.} � f;;- .�.� ��'�. <. �,,:,.�'�.�� Dear Friend & Neighbor: ,� �-, _ �� On Thursday August 18th, 1938, The St. Paul Zoninr Ca,�rnittee n+ade a reca;rnendation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and Bevnrl.v Qberg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Flome for ten 10 Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Cannission of St. Paul w�ill r�eet at 9:00 A. _�M�_. Frida��Au u_st 26t1�, 1988 or ttie 13th floor of bhe C�ty Hall annex at 25 W. t'r� t. to dlscuss ei� e1^ acceptance of re�ection of tiie Zoning Committee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGN TNE PETITION and deliver to Vie�gil Meyer at 16,26 E, Shore DRive, or Aenol Jaco son at 632 E. Shore Drive before �88. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call f1r. t4eyer at 774-2185 or P�r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they rrill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT WE HAVE THESE PETITIONS J R DS BY NO PJ URSDAY MORROW AS 4!E �4UST BRING THEP1 TO CITY NALL B RE R D . . �G. In'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty o�' our neighborhood. To the Planning Commission City Hall & annex 25 lJ. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the llndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the g ranting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. � NAtrIE �`�.�..�.�,.._,.��% �,��r .F :t� I�AME��l�i,.!?.�.___!�---��`=-'=-E�- -- 1 AODRESS ��-5�' c�l��,<<-!ti ��_ , PNON��- ` � _.__,._..__.�..,�, .,— > - August 24th, 198E Dear Friend & Neighbor: _�T� On Thursday August 18th, 1935, The St. Paul Zoninr Corr��ittee n��de a reca,r�endation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and Bev�rlv QbErg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care F1ome for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Canmission of St. Paul w�ill r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Fr�ida�Au ust 26t1}, 1988 or tfie 13th floor of �he CQty Hall annex at 25 VJ. t'r� t. to 1lscuss e � er acceptance of re,�ection of ti�e Zoning Comnittee recorr�nendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGN THE PETITION and deliver to Vie�gil Meyer at 16�6 E. Shore DRive or Arrnol Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Drive ore �1t�J : 014Y�'�i11GU��.'�` : ��..:�,.. . _ .�._�_..��__.._ ..�.. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t1r. �4eyer at 774-2185 or PAr. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they Yrill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT tJE HAVE THESE PETITIONS J UR NANDS BY NO P! HURSDA OMORROW AS l•JE �4UST ERING THEP1 TO CITY HP,LL B ORE H R D 9: G. k'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty oF our neighborhood. - . , �,. � To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 t�J. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the llndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Co�unittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. � , NAM� Gi/G,s � � �a.:2�,._� �!AM E. ..�. _.. - - - - � "...��.�2` �r, (�A K R�� ADDRESS��.��---. �''-. PH(�NE�,�.��-- �/.3/ 7 a August 24th, 1988 Dear Friend & Neighbor: �-� E On Thursday August 18th, 1938, The St. Paul Zonin� Cor.Ynittee n��de a recorr�endation to. ap�rove tl�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and Bev�rlv �berg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Ffane for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. � The Planning Canmission of St. Paul w�ill Meet at 9:00 A. M. Fr�ida�A�� u9 ust 26t�i, 1988 or thE 13th floor of bhe CQty Hall annex at 25 W. tr� St. to liscuss ei� e1^ acceptance o� re�ection of ti�e Zoning Committee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGN THE PETITION and deliver to Vie�gil Meyer at 16r26 E. Shore DRive or Aenol Jacobson at 632 E. Shore Drive before��:�� If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t4r. f4eyer at 774-2185 or PAr. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they will pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 6JE HAVE THESE PETITIONS N UR H S BY NOQP� HURS OMORROW AS l•JE t�UST BRING THEM TO CITY NALL BE E D 9: PJG. w'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty ofi our neighborhood. , To the Planning Carmission City Hall & Annex 25 l�V. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the llndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. Ni4M� I�AME_..�.LIL�I..�_.�.�N_��S� --- ADDRESS �� ` " PHON�7�T �30� � August 24th, 198E , .� � ��' _ ,' Dear Friend & yeighbor: . E On Thursday August 18th, 198&, The St. Paul Zoninr Cor+x+iittee n�ade a reca;rnendation to. ap�rove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and Be w�rly ObErg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Ffome for ten 10 Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Carmission of St. Paul will r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Au ust 26�l�, 1988 or the 13th floor of �he CQty Hall annex at 25 4J. t'r� t. to sCUS e d� er acceptance of re,�ecti on of tiie Zon i ng Commi ttee recomnendati on. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGN THE PETITION and deliver to Vie�gil Meyer at 16�26 E. Shore DRive or Aenold Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Drive before �'`�� ?u!!psnnv .a�r.��cza._ _ �R� If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call F4r. �4eyer at 774-2185 or PAr. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they �•rill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 4JE HAVE THESE PETITIONS � UR HANDS QY NO PJ HURSDA MORROW AS t!E t4llST BRING THEM TO CITY NALL BE E HE R D 9: P�G. w'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. .� To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 lJ. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Cortunittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon6�rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NAME c.'.,`��--- I�AME,___—_---- --- - ------ -- --- � � – �� ADDRESS I Ir, `�L ^� �,'��'`� PHQN�_ � August 24th, 198E Dear Friend & Neighbor: _� �� On Thursday August 18th, 1935, The St. Paul Zonin� Cor;�nittee n�ade a reca�r�endation to. ap�rove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and Bev�arly �t�Erg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Flome for teh 10 Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Carmission of St. Paul will r�eet at 9:00 A. M. F�rid�aY. Au ust 26tti, 1988 on thE 13th floor of bhe CQty hall annex at 25 ��, t'r� St. to discuss e � er accep ance o� re�ection of tiie Zoning Comrnittee reco�nendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, QLEASE SIGN THE PETITION and deliver to Vi�gil Meyer at 1 � 5.;�., Shore DRive or Aenol Jaco son at 163 E. Shore Drive b - U'� � !� A ��,u... �.�... If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call Mr. t4eyer at 774-2185 or P4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they Yrill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT ��JE HAVE THESE PETITIOtdS � U HANDS BY NOOPJ HURSD Y OMORROW AS L•!E h1UST ERING THEP1 TO CITY HALL RE E R D 9: . . P�G. 1�'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. To the Planning Commission City Nall & Annex 25 W. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Corrnnittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon6brming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. � NAM � �-�-� � � I�AME —_E- ` _ _ � �� _ ADDR SS /Lo��r�� y� PHONE� `"7�-'--�O�S � >. August 24th, 1988 Dear Friend & Neighbor: On Thursday August 18th, 1935, Ti�e St. Paul Zonin� Cor�nittee n�ade a reconrnendation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Perr�it to Russell and Bew�rly �t�Erg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Flome for ten 10 Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Carmission of St. Paul will meet at 9:Q0 A. M. Frida Aucust 26�1�, 1988 or thE 13th floor of bhe CQty Hall annex at 25 W. t'r� t. to scuss e � e1^ acceptance of re3ection of ti�e Zoning Committee recor�nendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGN THE PETITION and deliver to Vi�gil Meyer at 16�6 ore DRive or Arrnol Jacobson at 632 E. Shore Drive 88. . . � � _ . -. .. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, NpleaseMca11J �4r. Meyer at 774-2185 or P4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they will pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT WE NAVE THESE PETITIONS �1 R ANDS Y N P� HURSDAY OMORROW AS l•!E t4UST BRING THEP1 TO CITY NALL 6 RE H R D 9: P�G. k'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. To the Planning Carmission City Hall & Annex 25 l+l. 4th St. . St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Co�unittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a nonconb6rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. . � NAME ��,�•�,�.�✓ _�`��,_. R�AME ADDRESS��'�` ..�.. --- --- PHONE 7 � `�_��! � � a P�ugust 24th, 198E Dear Friend & Neighbor: ' ��...#y � ,.�A. ..� On Thursday August 18th, 1938, The St. Paul Zonin� Cor,��ittee n�ade a reconrnendation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and Beverly �berg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Flane for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. � The Planning Cannission of St. Paul w�ill r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Au ust 26�1�, 1988 on the 13th floor of bhe CQty Hall annex at 25 VJ. t'r� St. to �ss e � er acceptance o� re3ection of tiie Zoning Comnittee recaarnendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGN THE PETITION and deliver to �gil Meyer at 16�6 E. Shore or Aenold Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Drive b re' t#Oti'�N��DA�'"� ' �..: '�' � � ... . �.._ :, �.. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call l4r. Meyer at 774-2185 or PAr. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they r�ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 4JE NAVE THESE PETITIONS �� U HANDS BY N PJ URSDAY OMORROW AS l•!E t4UST BRING THEP1 TO CITY NALL BE RE D 9: . . E JG. k'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. To the Planning Carmission City Hall & Annex 25 l�l. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the Undersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the g ranting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. �, � �NAA1� (�AME.__...._.__ - -- ---- --- --- � � � � ADDRESS z� ^S� !� PHONE� ' � P,ugust 24th, 1988 Dear Friend b Neighbor: t�� On Thursday August 18th, 1938, The St. Paul Zonin� Cor,Y��ittee n�ade a reca;r:�endation to. ap�rove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and Bev�,rly �bErg of 1636 Esst Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Nome for ten 10 Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Carmission of St. Paul a�ill meet at 9:00 A. M._�F�_ri_d�_a� �iueust 26t1i, 1988 or ti�E 13th floor of bhe CQty Hall annex at 25 4J. t'ri St. to d�scuss e � er acceptance o� re3ection of ti�e Zoning Carmittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGN THE PETITION and deliver to Vie�gil Me er at 1b26 E. Shore DRive or Aenol Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Drive : . ° . :_ . �,,, _. .�.. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call Mr. �4eyer at 774-2185 or P�r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they will pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT WE HAVE THESE PETITIONS �� R HANOS QY NOOM HURSDAY OMORROW AS L•!E t4UST BRING TNEP�1 TO CITY HALL E H R D PJG. k'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty oF our neighborhood. To the Planning Comnission City Hall & Annex 25 lJ. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Co�nittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon6�rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NAM� R�AM . ADDRESS P� + PH4NE� � August 24th, 198E �� '�`�`' � Dear Friend b Neighbor: .� On Thursday August 18th, 1925, The St. Paul Zoninr Cor,xnittee n�ade a reca�rnendation to. approve ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and Bev�arl_v �k�Erg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Nome for teh 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Canmission of St. Paul a�ill �eet at 9•00 A. M. �Frida��Ru�u�st 26�1i, 1988 or the 13th floor of bhe CQty hall annex at 25 W. �t'r� St. to disCUSS ei�hel" �cceptance o� re�ection of ti�e Zoning Comnittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGN TNE PETITION and deliver to Vi�gil Meyer at 16,26 E. Shore DRive or Arrnold Jacobson at 632 E. Shore Drive b ,... - -- -. � .: � ,, . .. . If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call Mr. t4eyer at 774-2185 or P�Ir. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they will pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT L�dE HAVE THESE PETITIONS �� UR HANDS BY NO PJ HURSD Y MORROW AS L•!E t�UST BRING TH P1 TO CITY HALL E RE R D 9: . � NG. k'e thank you for your hFlp to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. To the Planning Canmission City Hall & Annex 25 l�V. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the Undersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Co�nittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a nonconb6rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NAM� I�AME._ ..^ _ � `—'-i- -- . �a � � �0 ADDR�SS - PHONE � � '�� ! August 24th, 19E8 Dear Friend & Neighbor: _� On Thursday August 18th, 1925, The St. Paul Zoninc Cor,x��iittee n+ade a reca�r:�endation , to. apNrove tl�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and 6everly �t�erg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Nane for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Cannission of St. Paul w�ill meet at 9:00 A. M. Frid Au ust 26t1�, 1988 or tiie 13th floor of bhe CQty Hall annex at 25 Vl. t'ri t. to sCUSS e � el" acceptance oF re�ection of ti�e Zoning Committee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, QLEASE SIGN THE PETITION and deliver to Vi il Me er 16�26 E. Shore DP.ive or Aenold Jacobson at 632 E. Shore Drive : If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call l�r. ��eyer at 774-2185 or P�r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they will pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT LJE HAVE THESE PETITIO�JS t� U HANDS BY NO PJ HURSOAY OMORROW AS L•!E t-9UST ERING THE�1 TO CITY HALL BE RE D P�G. w'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. i b., To the Planning Comnission City Hall & Annex 25 l�V. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning C�nittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NAM /�/ ' G �� NAME ---�-- --- --� S( �l.t� � ADDRESS -�.�,�� PHON� / � � � August 24th, 198E Dear Friend & Neighbor: _� . On Thursday August 18th, 193&, The St. Paul Zoninr Cor,x��ittee n�ade a reca:rnendation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and Bev�arly QbErg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Flane for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Carmission of St. Paul will meet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Aueust 26�h, i988 on the 13th floor of bhe CQty hall annex at 25 W. t'r� St. to sCUSS e � e1r acceptance of re�ection of ti�e Zoning Committee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGN THE PETITION and deliver to Vi il Me er 1626 . Shore DRiv or Arrnol Jaco son at 1632 E. Shore Drive If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call lRr. ��eyer at 774-2185 or P�r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they rrill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT LJE HAVE THESE PETITIONS �� U HAND BY 0 P� URSDAY OMORROW AS L•JE t1UST BRING THE��1 TO CITY HALL E R D P�G. w'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. To the Planning Ca►mission City Hall & Annex 25 lJ. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Cor�nittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the g ranting of a noncon6�rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NAM� ��/--.� ,---- �ar�E. J flh�5__hn_____� 1'r_�L7�__ AODRESS � �7„� ��,,,�� I�'1P �� 'T� �HONE�� " O � rr+�"T� T � August 24th, 1988 Dear Friend & P�eighbor: -� , On Thursday August 18th, 19�5, Tlie St. Paul Zonin� Ca��ittee n�ade � reca�rnendation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Perr�it to Russell and Bev�rlv Qt�Erg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care F1ome for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of .age. The Planning Carmission of St. Paul will �eet at 9:00 A. M. Fr�id�a �Au�us�t 26�1�, 1988 or ti�E 13th floor of bhe CQty Hall annex at 25 4J. t'r� St, to dlsCUSS ei�hel^ acceptance o� re3ection of ti�e Zoning Committee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGN THE PETITION and deliver to Vie�gil Meyer at 16,Zb E. Shore DP' or ARnol Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Drive - If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t4r. t4eyer at 774-2185 or F�r. Jacobson at 716-459E=or 770-3761 and they vrill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 6JE HAVE THESE PETITIOtJS � UR HANDS QY N PJ URSD OMORR W AS 4�E t4UST ERING TNEP•1 TO CITY NALL D . JG. �r'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. �.�� . .._ .. - To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 l�t. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the llndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Corrunittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. N�� 1� � � �l� � S �� q�.n� __ aooaESS 3�'c,�-�.1�=�.�..��5 �'��,S �-�� • PHONE� 2 -� 2 � 1 � Rugust 24th, 1988 Dear Friend & i�eighbor: �'-�1t-`0� I_T� E �., �r��es��--�—•� On Thursday August 18th, 19�5, The St. Paul Zonin; Cor,x��ittee n�ade a reca;r�endation to. apNrove ti�� nonconforming use and Special Cen�ition Use Permit to Russell anu 8ev��rlv Ot�Erg of 16�6 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Efome for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Carmission of St. Paul w�ill r:�eet at 9•00 A. �M. Frida��ust 26t1;, 1988 or tiie 13tn fl oor of bhe CQty hal l annex at 25 �J. �t'r� St. to dlscuss e � er acceptance oF re,jection of tiie Zoning Corrrnittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGiy THE PETITION and del i ver to V��g�,._,Me.yer at 16�6 E. Shore DP.ive or ARnol d Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Dri ve �br��t�L:�M_'tt�URSDAY"�S'�"'�;''#`�6�. � _.,, _.�<_ .._,__ _ If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call Mr. �4eyer at 774-2185 or i4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they ��ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT bJE HAVE THESE PETITIONS IN UR HANDS QY NOOP� HURSQ Y TOMORROW AS L•!E t-1llST BRING THEP•1 TO CITY NP.LL B RE R D Y 9: �G. k'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 t°!. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NAME il,�- ,d�`:�� .r -.��.�� _ � , ` � - � �, NAME ��-�, �.-�` _, �' . --------- --� -- -=�`"L`----1 -- J ,. '�,"'_ . ;-- •' __ '� �%- A.DDRESS ��-',- ,' " �' � ,•-�__,:, -�f - PHONE /�� - �� Rugust 24th, 19�E Dear Friend & i�eighbor: �,ti��T� On Thursday August l�tf�, 19�5, The St. Paul Zonin� Coc�;�ittee n+ade e reca�rnendation to apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Cen�ition Use Perr�it to Russell anci 6ev��rl.v Obcrg of 1E36 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Ffome for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Canmission of St. Paul H�ill r�eet at 9:00 A. M. F�rida��Ru�u�st 26t1�, 1988 or, tiiE 13ti� floor of bhe CBty hall annex at 25 4!. tri St. to disCUSS el�her acceptance of re,jection of ti�e Zoning Co�nittee recomnendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIG�� THE PETITION and deliver to Vi_ il Meyer at 16�6 E. Shore DP.ive or ARnold Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Drive �ore 'A��l+14'�HURSDAY'�i1Gl�5T'"'�'5�i;'�86. �- . r. . . If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t1r. �4eyer at 774-2185 or P4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they �;ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT �JE HAVE THESE PETITIONS I�� R HANDS QY NOOPJ HURSDAY OMORROW AS WE h1UST ERING THEP•1 TO CITY HALL 6 R E 0 P�G. w'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillt� o� our neighborhood. ,,._.....:-::,�r,.,,,,,,,,�,,...�.. To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 lJ. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the llndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon6brming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. � � ,�' ,,; , : ._ r NAME - _ . -� , � -- NAME - ;� , , � � _ --; ` T ---__ -_= ' '—�----_--__ PHONE � % �' `� � �% �� .-�. Rl�R�SS:;,� � � - ��_,/i',�. �� f �.��__.__ AuSust 24th, 198E �`'�} `�J�� Dear Friend & i�eighbor: `�-$-�` �.."� f _; � On Thursday August 18th, 192£, The St. Paul Zoninc Caa,iittee n+ade a reca:r�endation to. apNrove ti�� nonconforming use and Special Con�itien Use Permit to Russell and 6ev��rl.v �k�Erg of lE3b East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care F�ame for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning CaRnission of St. Paul ��ill r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Aucust 26t1�, 1988 or tfiE 13tn floor of bhe C4fy hall annex �t 25 VJ, tn St. to scuss e � e1^ acceptance oF re�ection of ti�e Zoning Coirrnittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGi� THE PETITION and deliver to Vi�gil _Meyer at 1b26 E. Shore DRive or Arnol d Jacobson at 632 E. Shore Dri ve�eft�rp'��1 THURSDAY �'F��S�;�=�.�. - _ � If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t1r. �4eyer at 774-2185 or PAr. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they ��ill pick it up�. IT IS URGENT THAT �dE HAYE TNESE PETITIOtJS �� UR HANOS 6Y NO P! THURSQA OMORROW AS t!E �-ilfST ERING THE�1 TO CITY HP.LL B RE H R D Y 9: . E PJG. k'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty of our neighborhood. ;� To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 l�J. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the Undersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Corr�nittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, �an are opposed to the granting of a noncon6�rming use and Special Con /xion U3e e it to that property. �; <_ NAM€ �i=�'!�i j� ` :� � . �, - NAME ADDRESS_�/ � �--Y---/_I-` �.r" �v i �� —�-- PH4NE.`��-�� s�� "_ ,) , . _, . . ,� ;•1 c � �ugust 24th, 198E Dear Friend � yeightor: �,�...Q-- -..�� -�+..r.� , On Thursday August 18th, 19�5, T{�e St. Paul Zonin� Ca�rnittee n�adE a recorr�endation to apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special CQn�ition Use Permit to Russell anu 6ev!�rl,Y Ot�erg �f 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care flonle for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Carmission of St. Paul w�ill r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Fr�id�a F�ucust 26tl;, 1988 or, tiiE 13tn floor of �he CQty Hall annex �t 25 �J�t'ri St. to lisCUSS e � er acceptance of rejection of tiie Zoning Co�rnittee recor�nendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGi� THE PETITION and del i ver to Vi_ i 1 Meyer_at.�1 f2,26 E,.. Shore DP.i ve � _.. ,.. or Arnol d Jacobson at 632 E. Shore Dri ve�efiore � "�N Tt4URSDAY �I�T '25�;� If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call f1r. ��eyer at 774-2185 or P�ir. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they �-�ill �ick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT LJE HAVE THESE PETITIO�JS I�� R HANDS 6Y NOOM HURSDA OMORROW AS l!E h1UST 6RING THEP4 TO CITY HALL E RE DAY 9: 0 . �G. k'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty o�F our , neighborhood. To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 t°�. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1388 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a nonconG6rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that pro�erty. NAM� ��Z O�C NAME /��!-��{?___ _ l'�.��-�� -- �-_ ,--- �/,� ' / �t�/c ADDRESS ��S��,�� %�' PHONE�T�7" / � Rugust 24th, 1988 Dear Friend & P�eighbor: `'�l .0 T I C.� On Thursday August 18th, 198&, T{�e St. Paul Zoninr Cau�iittee n�ade a reca:r�endation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to P,ussell and Bev�,rlv �k�Erg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care F1ome for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Carmission of St. Paul w�ill meet at 9:00 A. M. F�rid�a �Au us_t 26tf�, 1988 or tt�E l�th floor of bhe CQty hall annex at 25 Vl�t'r� St. to discuss e1�he1^ acceptance of rejection of tiie Zoning Comnittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGiV THE PETITION and deliver to Vi�gil Meyer at 1b26 E. Shore DP.ive or ARnol Jacobson at 1 32 E. Shore Drive b�ore NOON ON THURSDAY �IUGUST �25th, ��B. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t�r. �4eyer at 774-2185 or P�r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they ►��ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT ��JE HAVE THESE PETITIOtJS J UR HANDS BY NO DJ HUR DA OMORROW AS 4!E t1UST BRING THE�•1 TO CITY HALL 6 E H D 9: P�G. k'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. �: To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 1��. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the tJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon6�rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. � �: l — NAM� _'/ '. ; . -- NAME A.ODRESS _.____�f�- _f`�I _`� l�_��.___ PHON��.- �f , Rugust 24th, 1988 Dear Friend � i�eighbor: . N 0 T I C E On Thurs�ay August 18th, 19�£; ThE St. Paul Zonin; Car�;�ittee n�ade � reca;anendation to. ap�rove ti�c nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and 6ew_�rlv �bErg of lE3b East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care f�ane for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Carmission of St. Paul K�ill r�eet at 9•00 P,. M. Frida Au ust 26��, 1988 or tiiE 13th fl oor of �he CBty hal l annex at 25 VJ. �t'ri St. to scuss e � el" acceptance of re�ection of t'r�e Zoning Corrrnittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGid THE PETITION and deliver to Vit�gil Meyer at 16,26 E. Shore DP.ive or Arrnold Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Drive I�forei:N00t`� UN "3Nl�tSDA�F�� '��''�i9� �r`..r�t►'!�..�., ,�..� ,i.��.F 7 ��e If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t1r. Meyer at 774-2185 or i�r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they ��ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 6�JE HAVE THESE PETITIOWS I�� UR HANDS 6 NOOPJ HURSDAY TOMORROW AS l:E t�11lST ERING TNEP•1 TO CITY HALL B RE H R D 9:0 G. w'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the val ue and desi rabi 11t�� o�F our neighborhood. ,�_ To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 t�J. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree vrith the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a nonconb�rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NA(rl� �� ,'�, =� ,��'� '�Ir..; ;Y��_-- � �. .� :,. NAME.___-�___—-------------- ------- - ADDRESS �c`- - , , ,�, �,� �'-' PHON�� 1 _. ,...- �r... - ;,._.. i �, - �- �,� . � . �Jt. ' '`_/// `_ ,,- % - f� _ P,ugust 24th, 1988 Dear Friend & P�eightor: !�i�0 T I C E On ihursday Rugust 18tt�, 192£, Tfie St. Paul Zonin; Cor,��iittee n�ade a reca+r�endation to. ap�rove ti�2 nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to P.ussell anci 6ev��rlv �t�Erg of 1E36 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Ffome for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Canmission of St. Paul will r�eet at 9:00 P,. M. Frid�Aucust 26�I�, 1988 or tiiE 13tn floor of bhe CQty hall annex at 25 �J. tr� St. to scuss e � eP acceptance oF re3ection of ti�e Zoning Car�nittee recor�nendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIG�� THE PETITION and deliver to ViFgil Meyer at 1f�26 E. Shore DP.ive or Arnold Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Drive'�efore f�00t� tiN TFt�fRSTiAY�°�UGilS�-�t;�8. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t1r. tqeyer at 774-2185 or P4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they v;ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT �JE HAVE THESE PETITIONS �J UR HANDS 6Y N M URSDAY OMORROW AS L•JE h1UST BRING THEP�1 TO CITY NALL 6E 0 H D 9: PJG. k'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. To the Planning Carmission City Hall & Annex 25 l•!. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon6brming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. . NAME `-��;�C c � � t��"i�'�"';��" -- NAME � ' � � ��', , ,;�� _.� 7 ._ ''-1-=--�------- -------.�_____--------- ADDRESS PHONE� August 24th, 198E d �� 'vv � Dear Friend & i�eighbor: '��,,N 0 T �I C E��, On Thursday August 18th, 19��, The St. Paul Zonin� Cor��iittee n+ade a reca;N�endation to apNrove ti�e nonconformi ng use and Speci al Con�i ti on Use Perr�i t to itussel l anc{ Bev��rl.v �t�Erg of 1E36 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Ffome for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Canmission of St. Paul will meet at 9:00 A. M. Frida �Au�ust 26t�;, 1988 or ti�E 13tn fl oor of �he C�fy hal l annex �.t 25 V). t'r� St. to sCUSS ei.� el" acceptance of rejection of tiie Zoning Carmittee recor�nendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGi� THE PETITION and del i ver to Vie►yi 1 Meyer at 16�26 E., M hore DP.i ve �. or Arrnold Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Drive �¢'fbre'fiiDON��"�MM �l�RSD�PY'"�iJS� �t�i3:°�. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call Mr. �4eyer at 774-2185 or P4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they �-�ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT LJE HAVE THESE PETITIONS �� UR HANDS BY N PJ HURSDAY OMORROW AS L1E h1UST BRING THEP•1 TO CITY HALL BE E HE R D 9: !G. k'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty ofi our neighborhood. To the Planning Comnission City Hall & Annex 25 t•�. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the Undersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1�88 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the g ranting of a noncon6brming use and I Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NAME '\ � �" ._ 1` � 1 ,. _ -, �- T' -- N AME._---�-�t------r--=��= �- -`J------- . �. � _, , � _,. 1 .. , ^ r ` PHONE `� i � � � F- VI AODRESS , a� , . _ � �,, � Rugust 24th, 198E Dear Friend & P�eightor: .�iOTICE On Thursday August 18th, 19�£, The St. Paul Zonin; Cor,xnittee n�ade a reca:r�endation to apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Cen�ition Use Permit to Russell and 6evcarlv �k�Erg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care flane for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Pl anni ng Carmi ssion of St. Paul K�i 11 ►�eet at 9•00 A. M. Fri d�Aue ust 26�f�, 1988 or tiie 13tn floor of bhe CBty Hall annex at 25 V1. �tri St. to �scuss e � er acceptance o� rejection of ti�e Zoning Corrrnittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIG�� THE PETITION and deliver to Viergil Meyer at 16�26 E. Shore DPive or Arnol d Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Dri ve �iefore��1�Ot4.�V �DA'� �UST 25tFi;�1:98$._ If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t�r. t4eyer at 774-2185 or P1r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they ��aill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT LJE HAVE THESE PETITIO�JS �� OUR HANDS 6Y NO PJ THURSDAY TOMORROW AS L•:E t4UST ERING THEP�1 TO CITY HALL BE RE E R D 9: PJG. k'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty oF our neighborhood. To the Planning Carmission City Hall & Annex 25 l°�. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon��rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that pro�erty. Nl4ME �'�= �- --r'� %�: ..�..%,/��- __ � . NpNt�� j , ,•l: , i�.. -�j� —.,---��,� �--�->' � 7 PHONE .� �� - � %� r �J aooR�ss . � :_ �� a.ugust 24th, 198E De�r Friend & P�eightor: �;,�1 a 'T I � E On ihursday August 18tr�, 193�, Tl�e St. Paul Zonin� Cor+-��ittee n+adE a reca+r�endation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Cen�iti�n l7se Perr�it to Russell and SPV%�rlv �bcrg of 1E36 Eest Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Nome for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Carmission of St. Paul will meet at 9:00 A. M. Frida �Au u�st 26t1�, 1988 or tiie 13th fl oor of bhe CBty hal l annex at 25 41, tr� St. to sCUSS ei�hel^ acceptance o� re,jection of ti�e Zoning Co�rnittee recorrunendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, QLEASE SIG�� THE PETITION and deliver to Vie�gil Meyer at 16r26 E. Shore DP,ive or ARnold Jacobson at 632 E. Shore Drive before��"TNURSDAT �tIST'`23tfi;�. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t4r. t�eyer at 714-2185 or P�r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they v�ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT �JE HAVE THESE PETITIOWS �� OUR HANDS QY NOOPJ URSDAY TOMORROW AS L•!E t4UST BRING THEP�1 TO CITY NALL BEF E H D Y : P�G. w'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. To the Planning Carmission City Ha11 & Annex 25 tJ. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncondbrming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. . %"� ,�. NAM��..�� -- � �-..-1-/l ;-� � r±aM�� J��-�-� � �.-� ��.:- � �, _��i ADDRESS I ��,_._ � '�'y,�; �-� ,.�� PHONE � � � ��.%� —�----- _ �--= August 24th, 198E Dear Friend & P�eighbor: t�l 'OTICE . -.�+. . � On Thursday August 18th, 198�, The St. Paul Zonin� Ca�nittee n�ade a reca,r:�endation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Perr�it to Russell and Bev�arlY �k�Erg of 1E36 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care flane for teh 1C Childreen up to 1� years of age. The Planning Carmission of St. Paul will r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frid Aucust 26t��, 1988 or tiiE 13tn floor of �he C�ty Hall annex at 25 �l.�t'ri St. to sCUSS e d� er acceptance of re3ection of tiie Zoning Corr�nnittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot • attend, 2LEASE SIG;� TNE PETITION and deliver to Vitrgil Meyer at 16�26 E. Shore DP,ive or Arrnold Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Drive �efore NOON ON `[Ht�SDAY �11GUS�' �5�fi;'198� If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call Mr. t�leyer at 774-2185 or P4r. Jacobson at 776-459£=or 770-3761 and they r��ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 4JE HAVE TNESE PETITIOfdS �� UR HAND 6Y NO P� URSDAY OMORROW AS l•:E t-1llST BRING TNEP�1 TO CITY HALL 6 RE R D 9: �JG. k'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 l°J. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the llndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Corr�nittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that proFerty. NAME ,./� - NAME A.DDRESS��`�,� -- ---------------- PNON��..I ' "� / O �—"- p.ugust 24th, 198� ��J� Dear Friend & i�eighbor: _'�N 0 T 'I Z E On Thursday August 18th, 19�F,, TIiE St. Paul Zanin� Cor��;iittee n+ade a recor+r�endation to. ap�,rove ti�e nonconforming use and Special C�n�ition Use Permit to Russell anG EP.V!-'1"�Y Ot�Erg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Elome for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Ca�nission of St. Paul a�ill r�eet at 9•00 A.. M, Frida Au ust 2Etl;, 1988 or tiie 13tr� fl oor of bhe C6ty Hal l annex at 25 VJ�t'r� St. to scuss e d� er acceptance of re�ection of ti�e Zoning Car�mittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, QLEASE SIGiV THE PETITION and deliver to Vi�gil Me�y,e��r at 1b26 E. Shore DP.ive or Arnol d Jaco son at 632 E. Shore Dri ve l�efore 'NOOti`�lV�liCJRSDA'Y'`�1G11�� ;�. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call Mr. Meyer at 774-2185 or P4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they r;ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT WE HAVE THESE PETITIONS I�J UR HANDS 6Y NO PJ HURSDAY TOMORROW AS 4!E t4UST BRING THEP4 TO CITY HALL B RE H D �G. k'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. To the Planning Carmission City Hall & Annex 25 lJ. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Corr�nittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon6�rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to �hat property. � - ' � �i NAM� �l�Z{�'1�� ,�� . — i i� �.!��`,'-�r� :�. G � - -- NAME `/,l �.' r--�/.�� ``,�, � A _J -_--- c) AQDR�SS % '' <'= ;�� ,< /�'� . PHONE '/ � - � l i -� / ,_�..� August 24th, 1988 Dear Friend 8 �eighbor: NOTICE On Thursday August 18th, 1925, The St. Paul Zoninr Co��xnittee n+ade a reca+Nnendation to. apNrove ti�� nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and 6everlv �t�Erg of 1636 East Shore �Rive to operate a Foster Care Nome for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Carmission of St. Paul k�ill meet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Aucust 26t��, 1988 or ti�e 13th fl oor of bhe CQty hal l annex zt 25 ��. tTi t. to SCUSS e � e1r acceptance o� rejection of tt�e Zoning Comnittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIG�! THE PETITION and deliver to Vie�gil Meyer at 16,26 E. Shore DRive or ARnol Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Dri ve°before ��OON �1`T'�S�AY '�t35'f�'�S'th;"�988� If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call F4r. �4eyer at 774-2185 or iAr. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they will pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT L�E HAVE THESE PETITIO��S � U HANDS BY N P� URSDAY OMORROW AS WE h1UST ERING THE�1 TO CITY HALL BE H R D JG. k'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. To the Planning Carmission City Nall & Annex 25 l�. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the Undersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Corr�nittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the g ranting of a noncon6brming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. � NAMg` C�l. `',� � :�; / � � ��J`�)� ��'�,�� C -- NAME.___-�`-----------__��___---------- A.ODR€SS � J�i U��I�1%�� C �� j� `� ' PHONE '/ �, • �� t � Rugust 24th, 19E8 Dear Friend & iJeighbor: _�+�! 0 T I G E On Thursday August 18th, 192£, T{�e St. Paul Zonin� Cor�;�ittee n+ade a reca+rnendation to. apNrove ti�� nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Pe rn�it to Russell and Bev��rlv �k�Erg of 163b East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care flane for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Carmission of St. Paul w�ill r�eet at 9•00 A. M. Fr�ida�Au ust 26t��, 1988 or tiiE 13tn fl oor of bhe C�ty hal l annex at 25 ��. �t'r� St. to disCUSS e � er acceptance oF re,jection of tiie Zoning Co�rmittee recar�nendation. This FAeeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGi� THE PETITION and deliver to Vi�gil Meyer at 1b26 E. Shore DP.ive or ARnold Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Drive before �P100N ON "�iURSDAY g1�UST �f�5tb. ��. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t1r. �4eyer at 774-2185 or r4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they ►;i]1 Fick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT LJE HAVE THESE PETITIONS �� UR H DS 6Y N PJ HURSDAY OMORROW AS L•!E t4UST BRING THEM TO CITY HALL BE H D �G. k'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. _�: To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 1��. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the llndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Comrnittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that pro�erty. NAME `�'�'? ' 1, ' �,��?-,1� l�`'� ; ��_r MAME � � ! ,�-� ' �� , �_ � ,� � � �-- - .-. - ----- �" .--- �------ � ��. � J �; �_ , �-�_----- _ -- -_ . ��j � ; , AODRESS � -' — i � ',' }'`�� ^ _�, , PHONE '_ % � , -, , ' , , f r .-, . A.ugust 24th, 198E Dear Friend � _i�eighbor: _ �,1 4 T I G E —r On 7hursday August 18th, 1985, Tl�e St. Paul Zaninr Cor,�;ittee n+ade a recor+Mnendation to. a�►Nrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and Bev��rlv Ot�Erg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Ffane for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Ca�mission of St. Paul will r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida �Au�u�st 26�1;, 1988 or thE 13tn floor of bhe CBty hall annex at 25 �f, tr� St. to scuss eidcher acceptance of re�ection of ti�e Zoning Carmittee recomnendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIG�! THE PETITION and deliver to Vie*gil Meyer at ]6r2b E. Shore �P.iYe or ARnold Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Drive fiefore �lOON-ON THURSDAY :�UGUST 25th,..a988� If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please ca11 �4r. t4eyer at 774-2185 or P�ir. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they will pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT bJE HAVE THESE PETITIOWS � UR NAND BY N P! HURSDAY OMORROW AS L•!E �-9lfST BRING THEP1 TO CITY HALL BE ORE H D Y : PJG. t�'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. To the Planning Carmission City Nall & Annex 25 !°J. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the tJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon6brming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NEUt1E �`: .� , � ?��;: ___f. �, �- [�!AME._ ----� ;i =_�-� C_��z1, L � -- PHONE �7� / r�(.�-,.3 ADDR�SS f-, ,�— _ - P�ugust 24th, 198E �,� —�Ju�' Dear Friend & i�eighbor: '�lOTICE - � On Thursday August 18th, 1935, T{�e St. Paul Zonin� Ca�,iittee n�ade a recor,r�endation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell anci Beverly �t�Erg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care F1ane for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Cannission of St. Paul w�ill r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida F�ucust 26ti;, 1988 or ti�E 13tn floor of �he CBty hall annex at 25 V�. tri St. to scuss e � er acceptance of rejection of ti�e Zoning Corrmittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGN THE PETITION and deliver to Vi�gil Meyer at 1626 E. Shore DP.ive or Arnold Jacobson at 632 E. Shore Drive t�fore At00W OW THURSDAY BUGUST 25th, ;�98�. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t�r. �4eyer at 774-2185 or P�ir. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they r�i11 pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT ��E HAVE THESE PETITIONS � UR HANDS 6Y NO PJ HURSD Y MORROW AS L•SE f1UST ERING THEP�1 TO CITY HALL RE D PJG. k'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighbQrhood. To the Planning Comniss�on City Hall & Annex 25 l°J. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the Undersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Corr�nittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon6�rming use and Special Candition Use Permit to that property. NAME ' ��/ . �,,� NAME .__----�----------------------- --- � �� `J A.DDRESS / ��" `� '; ��.�� ;;:f_t .a%. PH4N�f/ Y . , _..,�� Rugust 24th, 1988 Dear Friend & Yeighbor: � �l .0 T i C � On Thursday August 18th, 19��, The St. Paul Zonin� Cor��iittee n+ade a reca:r�endation to. ap�rove ti�� nonconforriing use and Speci al Con�i ti on Use Perr�i t to Russel l and Bev��rlv Ok�Erg of 1E36 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Home for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Caimission of St. Paul will r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Au ust 26t��, 1988 or thE 13tn floor of bhe C4ty hall annex at 25 VJ, t'r� St. to scuss e � er acceptance oF re�ection of ti�e Zoning Car�nittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, QLEASE SIGN THE PETITION and deliver to Vi�gil Meyer at 16�26 E. Shore DRive or Arnol d Jacobson at 632 E. Shore Dri ve #�efore NOON ON TNURSBAY fIUG�ST 25th,� �9�B. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t1r. t4eyer at 774-2185 or iAr. Jacobson at 77G-459E=or 770-3761 and they r��ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT b�E HAVE TNESE PETITIOtdS N U AN S QY NOOM HURSDAY OMORROW AS L!E t4UST BRING TNEP•1 TO CITY HALL BE ORE H R D 9:0 JG. Ir'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty o�F our neighborhood. To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 l�. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the llndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon8�rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that pro�erty. NAM� �� J� `/y' _��E-�.,E� - NAME �� ,- z�-!.�.`�// --.X �t�/1.��("� .^�._.�--------- ---t------ -_ - AODRESS /�:.::_��:��'��--��.- -�f PHON�� r.,-.-- � i=; ' ':�_>�/ C: �� < .-- � t� ��;-� � Rugust 24th, 19E8 Dear Friend & iJeighbor: :��-...y...�.0 T�I ,� � On Thursday August 18tP�, 19�£,, Ti�e St. Paul Zonin; Ca��ittee n�ade a recorr�endation to. a�►Nrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Perr�it to Russell and Beverlv �t,erg of 1E36 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Nome for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Canmission of St. Paul will r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Aueust 26�l�, 1988 or ti�E 13tn floor of bhe C�ty hall annex at 25 4J. ti� St. to scuss e � er acceptance oF rejection of ti�e Zoning Co�rnittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, QLEASE SIGi� THE PETITION and deliver to Vi�gil Meyer at 16,26 ,E. Shore DRive or Arrnold Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Drive �iefore��J�ON ON'THURSDAY �UGUST �`5th;°#98�. � If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call ��r. t4eyer at 774-2185 or i�ir. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they raill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT �JE HAVE THESE PETITIONS �� UR HANDS 6Y NOOPI THURSDAY MORR W AS L:E t4UST ERING THE�•1 TO CITY HALL BE RE R D : 0 . PJG. k'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty ofi our neighborhood. To the Planning Cor�nission City Hall & Annex 25 l�J. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 4Se, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Corrnnittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are o�posed to the g ranting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Us /Perm,i`t to that property. �� ,� N AM� " � C.��-r'�-' �J� _� � '�i -- �--= ------- ADDRESS/�� %�`;i ��.�� '°'l!i � f�--- PH4NE � ��'�� Rugust 24th, 198E Dear Friend & i�eighbor: �.�,� � � E On Thursday August 18th, 192�, The St. Paul Zoninc Ca�r��ittee n��de a reca.rnendation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and Bev�arlv Ot�Erg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Ffome for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Canmission of St. Paul will r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Aucust 26�f�, 1988 or ti�E 13tn floor of �he CQty Hall annex at 25 �l. t�� St. to sCUSS e � er acceptance oF re3ection of ti�e Zoning Corrrnnittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGf� THE PETITION and deliver to Viergil Meyer at 1f�26 E. Shore DP.ive or ARnol Jacobson at 632 E. Shore Drive '�efore ��00t� ON THURSt#�Y .�l�US3 �Stt�,��98�k, If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call Mr. t4eyer at 774-2185 or �qr. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they will pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT L�JE HAVE THESE PETITIOtdS �� UR HANDS BY NO P� HURSDA OMORROW AS L!E t4UST ERING THEP•1 TO CITY HALL BE E H R D Y 9: P�G. k'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty o�F our neighborhood. To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 l°J. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the g ranting of a noncon6�rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. ' NAM� _ , ' , �, , . � . , NAME ''r . , �_ _�_ t � ( ' A.DDR�SS ^_..-----------__.__—� -- .��:�- PHONE ' , ` � , � - � August 24th, 19E8 Dear Friend & i�eighbor: '�,�.�M.I.:�` E On Thursday August 18th, 1985, Tl�e St. Paul Zonin� Cor,��ittee n�ade a reca;r�endation to. apNrove ti�� nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and 6everlv �t�Erg of 1E36 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care flome for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Canmission of St. Paul H�ill meet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Au ust 2E�1�, 1988 or ti�E 13th floor of bhe C�ty hall annex at 25 tiJ. tn St. to SCUSS e � e1^ acceptance oF rejection of ti�e Zoning Corr�nittee recor�nendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, QLEASE SIGf� THE PETITION and deliver to Vie�gil Meyer at 16�26 E. Shore DP.ive or Arrnold Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Drive l�fare��189N-�t�H4lR�iflA�f°�S��#3. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call tRr. t4eyer at 774-2185 or i�ir. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they ►�;ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 6�JE HAVE THESE PETITIOP�S � UR HANDS BY NOOP! THURSDAY OMORROW AS L•!E hiUST ERING THEP4 TO CITY HALL BE 0 R D Y 9: 0 . . EE JG. k'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. To the Planning Carmission City Hall & Annex 25 1��. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the llndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the g ranting of a noncon6brming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. , l- / N��,'� ��' . � ��'/f!''�t7,1,�/'�. NAME._��=;�;y, R-.��-ti=��-�---------- �-� � f�' n ` � `� ADDRESS PHONE�� ,,-� , _ :-�- , ti �� i ; � ,, .�, ,� �1 .. ; . ��. . J�•�1 �iv V�/V. � f � ��JU7� �, August 24th, 19EE Dear Friend � i�eighbor: NOTIGE On Thursday August 18th, 198£,; Tl�e St. Paul Zonin� Cor��iittee n��de a reca.r�endation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforning use and Special Cen�ition Use Perr�it to Russell anci Bev��rlv Qk�Erg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care tlome for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Caimission of St. Paul w�ill meet at 9:00 P.. M. Fr_i_d_a_��Ru�us,t 2Etl:, 1988 or tiiE 13th floor of �he C�ty Hall annex at 25 V1. t'ri St. to dliscuss ei.� er acceptance of rejection of ti�e Zoning Com�nittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGi� THE PETITION and deliver to ViFgil Meyer at 16,26 E. Shore DP.ive or Arnold Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Drive fs�^�`•��lt��RS�'' _ � � ��, w._. ��:�:,��- �_ -= - If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t4r. �4eyer at 774-2185 or PAr. Jacobson at 77G-459E=or 770-3761 and they v�ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 4JE HAVE THESE PETITIOt�S �d UR HANDS QY NO P! HURSQAY OMORROW AS LlE� t4llST BRING THEP•1 TO CITY HALL RE HE D 9: . . E �G. w'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty o�F our neighborhood. �;- - To the Planning Commission City Nall & Annex 25 ld. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disa�ree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 r�garding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon�brming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NAME�G��rr.�� , .�O�L.�C1-Y�' -- f R NAME � � �� . __--_____ _ .,� - ADDRESS —i S � �e.. •�—�-� PH4r�E ? ?� 3 � I 7 ��, � s�s—/ c � ��1-�L � Mr. & Mrs. E.J. Schulte � 1444 East Shore Drive Saint Paul , MN 55106 August 24th, 1988 Dear Friend & i�eightor: N 0 T I C E On Thursday August 18tf�, 192£, TI�E St. Paul Zonin� Cor,�,iittee n�ade a reca:r�endation to apurove ti�e nonconforr�ing use and Special Cen�ition Use Permit to Russell anci 6ev��rlv Ot�Erg �f 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Ffane for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Canmission of St. Paul K�ill r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida F�ucust 26t��, 1988 or tiiE 13tn floor of Uhe C6ty Hall annex at 25 Vl. t�i St. to sCUSS e � er acceptance of re jecti on of ti�e Zon i ng Corr�mi ttee recommendati on. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIG�� THE PETITION and deliver to Yi � il Meyer at 16�26 E. Shore DP.ive �" �;��!��3��6��'r`».`��. or ARnold Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Drive ° �for+e. , �: ..Y , . .�a.:_�.�.... .-. .____, If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call l4r. �qeyer at 774-2185 or i�r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they v�ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 4JE HAVE THESE PETITIOtJS �� R HANDS 6Y NOOP! URSDA OMORROW AS l•!E t4lSST ERING THEP•1 TO CITY HP,LL BE ORE HE R D 9: PJG. k'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. _;:. _ To the Planning Carmission City Hall & Annex 25 IJ. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon�drming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NAME - ,;. ,l ,�� . , � i% ,, ,:, ;,��: �J _�� NAME.--------.__.-�----�------�--.�—.____—__.--- AODRESS � � � �`' ' PH4NE ;i i'i - �-:�; _' �: ,. , .,,.,,,.-_—_ August 24th, 198E Dear Friend & Neighbor: _ 11:�� TI CEs On Thursday August 18th, 19��, Tlie St. Paul Zoninr Cor.�;�ittee n+adE a recorr�endation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and BP.V!'rlv �berg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care tfome for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Caimission of St. Paul will r�eet at 9•00 A. M. Frida �Au�u�st 26t�;, 1988 or tiiE 13th floor of bhe CQty hall annex at 25 VJ. �tri St. to scuss ei�her acceptance oF rejection of ti�e Zoning Comnittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, QLEASE SIGN THE PETITION and deliver to Vit�gil Meyer at 16�26 E. Shore DP.ive or Arrnold Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Drive �efore Pa00N ON TtiURSDAY BUGUST �5th, �988:> ;�_ : . . If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call lQr. �4eyer at 774-2185 or t�r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they ��ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT LJE HAVE THESE PETITIONS �� UR ANOS BY NO PJ HURSDA OMORROW AS L•!E t-itfST ERING THEP1 TO CITY HALL E RDY 9: P�G. w'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. To the Planning Cormiission City Hall R Annex 25 l;l. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the llndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon6�rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NAM� .-U'� /� � i. l NAME ..�c%��:., �''_� 1� - �h - AODRESS �,� a,� , � �HON r Rugust 24th, 198E Dear Friend � f�eighbor: �;,'N 0 T I G E� On Thursday August 18th, 1935, The St. Paul Zoninr Cor,�nittee n�ade � recore�endation to. apNrave ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and Bev��rlv Ot�erg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Nome for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Carmission of St. Paul K�ill r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Au ust 2E��;, 1988 or tnE l�tn floor of �he C�fy hall annex at 25 41. 4t'ri St. to sCUSS e � e1^ acceptance oF re,�ection of ti�e Zoning Carmittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, 2LEASE SIGf� TNE PETITION and del i ver to Vie�gi 1 Meyer at 16;26 E, Shor��;i�Y� or ARnold Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Drive�efore NOON 'ON 7HlfR5DAY �(tS�l' �btfi;�98 If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t1r. �4eyer at 774-2185 or i�tr. Jacobson at 776-459£=or 770-3761 and they ��aill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 6JE NAVE THESE PETITIOtdS �� UR HANDS BY NOOPJ HURSDAY TOMORROW AS L•!E t4UST BRING THEh1 TO CITY HP,LL BE ORE H R DAY : PJG. k'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty o�F our neighborhood. �:- To the Planning Comnission City Hall & Annex 25 !J. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the llndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon��rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that proFerty. NAM� � �' �-�'�u`'��J_.,,L/ NAME � �' %, � '- _ , '',- ---� ��-- � ; A.ODR€ � , ,.-,`* �� PHON�1 � �1� - �� R.ugust 24th, 1988 Dear Friend & i�eighbor: �:�I � T i C �:, �,e,�.._ . On Thursday August 18th, 1925, The St. Paul Zonin� Ca��r�iittee n+ade � reca:r�endation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforni ng use and Speci al Cen�i tion Use Perr�i t to Russel l anci Bev��rlv �bcrg af 1E36 Eest Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Nome for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Caimission of St. Paul w�ill r�eet at 9:00 A. M. F�rida�Au ust 26t1�, 1988 or, thE 13tn floor of bhe CQty Hall annex zt 25 6�J, tr� St. to dlsCUSS e � er acceptance of rejection of ti�e Zoning Corranittee recor�nendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIG�1 THE PETITION and del i ver to Vigg i 1 Mex��r_.�x_,1.�6 E Shore DP.i ve or Aenold Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Drive t��ore:♦N001�1�� NURSDRY'��1�tIS�f��Sth,�.�,• If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t4r. �4eyer at 774-2185 or i�r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they vrill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 4JE HAVE THESE PETITIOt�S �J UR HANDS 6Y NO PJ HURSDAY OMORROW AS L-:E t4UST BRING THE�1 fi0 CITY HA,LL E ORE HE ID 9: . EE P�G. k'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty oF our neighborhood. � `_ To the Planning CarKnission City Hall & Annex 25 1-�. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the IJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1388 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the g ranting of a noncon��rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NAM€ �-�. 1-C � �.�__ � w I�!AME .__------- - ;:.-� ---- '7 '7 �u - vJ--f`J c�� AODR�SS 1`� ,� c-- -�- �� / �, PHONE _�,____ R.ugust 24th, 198E Dear Friend � i�eightor: _ NOTICE On Thursday August 18th, 19��, ThE St. Paul Zonin� Car��ittee n�ade � recorr�endation to apNrove ti�e nonconfo rniing use and Special C�n�ition Use Perr�it to Russell and 6�w�rlv Ok�Erg of lE3F East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Nome for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Canmission of St. Paul k�ill r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Au ust 26tf�, 1988 or ti�E 13tn floor of bhe C6ty hall annex at 25 �!. 4t�� St. to sCUSS e � er acceptance o� re�ection of tiie Zoning Co�rnittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your o�servation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIG�4 THE PETITION and deliver to ViFgil Meyer at 16,26 E. Shore DP.ive or ARnold Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Drive�� "4~ ��. � _ . ; . : _ :_: --�::_ ... .�:- �. -: �._- .ti�._ If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call Mr. �4eyer at 774-2185 or i�r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they will pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 6�E HAVE THESE PETITIOtJS f1 UR HANDS 6Y NOOPJ HURSD Y OMORROW AS l-:E i-1UST BRING TNEP�1 TO CITY HALL RE R D P�G. k'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillt� o� our neighborhood. �:• - To the Planning Canmission City Hall & Annex 25 l°�. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the llndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Corrnnittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon��rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that pro�erty. NAME NAME ADDRESS l�-`f--� '_�� ------- PN4NE I � � � � � �Z' _.�.—� �. F:ugust 24th, 198E Dear Friend & P�eighbor: _ N 0 T I G E On Thursday August 18th, 19��; The St. Paul Zonin; Cor,�.�ittee n�ade a reca;r�endation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Cen�ition Use Perr�it to Russell and 6evcarlv �t�Erg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care F1ome for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of aqe. The Planning Canmission of St. Paul K�ill r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Au ust 26�1�, 1988 or tiiE 13tn floor of bhe C4ty hall annex at 25 Y!. tn St. to scuss e d� er acceptance oF re,jection of tiie Zoning Corr�nittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGiJ THE PETITION and deliver to Vi�gil Meyer at 1626 E. Shore DRive or Arnold Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Drive wl�For�e�lA��i�`'��.��;�� _ �..� .. _ _ .,,,.r.... .,�,�. ,.,:._ . ....__...,,,;.�_ � ��.�:,._,�.,....: M�„. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call �4r. �4eyer at 774-2185 or r4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they ►ai11 pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT bdE HAVE TNESE PETITIOtJS �� UR HAN S QY NO PJ HURSDAY MORROW AS l!E t-1UST BRING THEP4 TO CITY HP,LL BE RE H RID Y 9: JG. k'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. To the Planning Commission City Nall & Annex 25 t�. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the llndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Dcive, and are oFposed to the granting of a noncon8�rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. . , . , ��,�. , •, �t� � " '" NAME y ��'L � , .�.;,,�,.�,,.- . � -- NAME i/ ______.---------, .__._ ---- ---------- % �' c �� AODRESS�"� �''� ` ' T ' PHONE �� ' / �, �..� �� _��_' '`-"�-� ' � ' �--�--�-- , , � F�ugust 24th, 19EE ��Y"'.-�,�J � Dear Friend & P�eighbor: _ N 0 T I C E On Thursday August 18tf�, 192£�, TIiE St. Paul Zoninr Corr;�ittee n+ade a recor+r�endation to. ap�rove ti�� nonconforriing use and Special Cen�itien Use Permit to Russell an� 6FVerlv Ot�erg of lE3b East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Ffome for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Canmission of St. Paul w�ill r�eet at 9:00 P.. M. Frida F►ucust 26ti�, 1988 or tiiE 13t� floor of �he C6fy Hall annex at 25 6J. t�� St. to scuss e � er acceptance of rejection of ti�e Zoning Committee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIG�� THE PETITION and deliver to Virgil Me,y er at 16�26 E. Shore DP.ive or Arrnold Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Drive �for�e°F��F'1'HP��Y� , �.' •� � If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t�r. �4eyer at 774-2185 or P�r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they will �ick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 6JE HAVE THESE PETITIOWS �J U HANDS 6Y NOOPJ THURSDA OMORROW AS b!E t4UST BRING THEP1 TO CITY HALL BE R R D 9: �G. k'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. To the Planning Carmission City Hall & Annex 25 t°�. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon6brming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that proFerty. / NAME Gi�. � ��`✓5�'U / ( „ -- „ �� NAME.��./��`� ' � �__ _ --__ , � -- ��.�,�.�.__ �s- J ADDRESS / !�'4' ��, ,��:�;-� ,�'/, PN�NE.�-� ` i�/ �' :. � �' F�ugust 24th, 198E Dear Friend & i�eighbor: NOTICE On Thursday A�ugust l�th, 19��, Tiie St. Paul Zonin� Cor;r�;�ittee n+ade a reca:Nnendation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforriing use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and Bevc�rlv Ot�erg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care flome for teh 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Canmission of St. Paul K�ill r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frid Aucust 26�1�, 1988 or t1�E 13ti� fl oor of bhe CBty Hal l annex �t 25 VJ, t�� St. to SCUSS e � e1^ acceptance of re,jection of ti�e Zoning Car�mittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, QLEASE SIGi� THE PETITION and deliver to Vi�gil Meyer at 16,26 E. Shore DP.ive or Arrnold Jacobson at 632 E. Shore Driv fore � �!i`"�U�i�' �l'�'� �.-:`�',�B� �_. .�-.. _ . _ . ---_,.. ___..__._.__._._.._.�., If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t4r. �4eyer at 774-2185 or i4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they will pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 4JE HAVE THESE PETITIOWS �� UR HANDS 6Y NO PJ HURSDAY TOMORROW AS L!E t1lfST BRING THEP•1 TO CITY NRLL BEF RE HE R DA 9: 0 . PJG. k'e thank you for your hEip to preserve the value and desirabillty o�F our neighborhood. �:- __. : � - To the Planning Carmission City Hall & Annex 25 1��. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the l]ndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are o�posed to the granting of a noncon6brming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. N�,m� �%�-�� l"�1 �`��-,_ , ' w,� O .. � �.��J NAME�_�w`-=._r� . ` � -7 7 � / 7 3 ADDR�SS � � �' /r�i � :-�-� 'j ,F'"��c,�-- PHONE � -, Rugust 24th, 1988 Dear Friend & yeighbor: �'NOTTC � � . - On Thursday August 18th, 1925, The St. Paul Zoninr Cor.x�;iittee n+�de a recorrnendation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell anci 6ev�arl.v Qk�erg of 1636 East Shore �Rive to operate a Foster Care Flome for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Carmission of St. Paul a�ill meet at 9:00 A. M. Frida �Au us_t 26��, 1988 or tt�E 13tn floor of bhe CBty hall annex at 25 �J. t'r� St. to sCUSS el�her acceptance of re�ection of tiie Zoning Carmittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIG�J TNE PETITION and deliver to Vie�gil Meyer at 16,26 E. Shore DRive or ARnold Jacobson at 632 E. Shore Drive l�fore N00t'� ON ?HURSDAY tUGUST �5th,�'�'�BS. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t4r. �4eyer at 774-2185 or PAr. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they ��ill Fick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT �JE HAVE THESE PETITIO�JS �� UR H DS BY NO PJ HURSQA OMORROW AS l•!E h1UST BRING THEP�1 TO CITY HALL BE E H DA 9: E P�G. k'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. � � _ To the Planning Carmission City Hall & Annex 25 l°�. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the llndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncondbrming use and Special ,�ondition Use Pe it to that property. �� , ; NAhIE �-� �- ' C� ' N AM E.__� —.�`"�'1_`�' -- '�-�'" ' �.��--_- l' �� PHONE � � � -G � 3I ao�R�ss ,� � -�-�.-�e�, � � August 24th� 198E Dear Friend & Neigh�or: � On Thursday August 18th, 19�8, T{ie St. Paul Zoninr Cax�iittee n+ade a reca;��endation to. a�►Nrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Perr�it to Russell and Bev�arl.v �berg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care tfome for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Carmission of St. Paul k�ill �eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Aucust 26t1�, 1988 or tfiE 13th fl oor of bhe C�ty Hal l annex at 25 VJ. tr� St, to scuss e � er acceptance oF re�ection of ti�e Zoning Conmittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGi� THE PETITION and del i ver to Vi i l. Me er.a�t�,,,1,�b,E,, Shore DRi ve or Aenol Jacobson at 632 E. Shore Drive t� � . .+ �'. ��KY '''�"� 88. " � _oti-.>�:,.,..;, If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call FRr. t4eyer at 774-2185 or P�r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they will pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 6�E HAVE TNESE PETITIOtJS �1 U HANDS BY NOOP! URSD OMORR W AS 4JE�4UST ERING THEM TO CITY NALL E R D P�G. k'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty ofi our neighborhood. To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 l�l. 4th St. St. Pau1 , .Mn. 55102 We, the Undersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Comrnittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a nonconbbrming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. Nl4ME �.��'ti�,� ��1. :�t'�?iYt[�vt��'�9-i�- -- NAME.___�'_�'•f _.�?_`:��^=��...._._�.-- AODR�SS /(r�S" 3,,L.��.��,�i.-� __�� PHONE,�� / � � b r � August 24th, 1988 Dear Friend & Neighbor: �#�,� ,� ��:s: On Thursday August 18th, 19�5, The St. Paul Zoninr Cor,��iittee n�ade a recorr:�endation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell anc( 6ev��rlv �t�Erg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Flome for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. . The Planning Carmission of St. Paul will meet at 9:00 A. M. Fr�ida��Au�ust 26#i�, 1988 or ttie 13th floor of �he C�ty Hall annex at 25 W, tri St. to dlsCUSS ei� e1r acceptance of re,jection of ti�e Zoning Committee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, QLEASE SIG�! THE PETITION and deliver to Vi�gil Meyer at 16►26 E. Shore DP.ive or Arrnol Jacobson at 632 E. Shore Drive fio�0�t�1 �N1�Dd�F��-�9�8. ��t..�i�r.s""si...�,.•c.�.:.ne� ,�'x._`:�.,.;s•, <-,:�rvet�m�r �+irr.r.��.. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call Mr. �4eyer at 774-2185 or P4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they will pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 4�JE HAVE THESE PETITIOWS N OUR HAND BY NO M HURSDA MORR W AS l!E t4UST BRING THE�•1 TO CITY HALL E E H D :0 P�G. w'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty of our neighborhood. �.,;,.„�., .,. � To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 l�J. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the IJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon86rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. � NE11rl� ",� ," `)��, NAME AODRESS�.�Z.1.,r1.:11 ,l_;�• ��r�, ��— PHONE � ��— `i � � 3 � .,�....._'_— > August 24th, 198E ��a�� Dear Friend & Neighbor: �� On Thursday August 18th, 193&, The St. Paul Zoninr CocYnittee n�ade a reca+r�endation to. apNrove ti�� nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and �ev��rlv �t�Erg of 1636 Eest Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Home for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. - The Planning Canmission of St. Paul k�ill r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Aueust 26ti�, 1988 or tfiE 13th floor of �he CQty Hall annex at 25 W. tr� St. to scuss e � er aceeptance o� re,�ection of tt�e Zoning Committee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGN THE PETITION and deliver to ViFgil Meyer at 16�6 E. Shore DRive or ARnol Jacobson at 632 E. Shore Drive f4r�e7��+IN��t�Y�=�t�ST'��88. �i,•. .. � �rlil!q i�n!ii i�i� ��,�i µ — i+_ - If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t1r. �4eyer at 774-2185 or PAr. Jacobson at 776-459£=or 770-3761 and they v�ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 4��E HAVE THESE PETITIONS � UR HAND BY N PJ URSD OMORR W AS L•!E t-1UST BRING THEM TO CITY HALL B RE D 9: 0 . . P�G. w'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty oF our neighborhood. To the Planning Comnission City Hall & Annex 25 l+i. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the Undersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Conanittee decision of August 18th, 1388 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are o�posed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. � � v �� , � �'��, NAM�� i �' � , ,�e��a�. ��`} NJ�ME AODRESS //� �'`� y �( ,�� ---��-t-�_�--- PH4NE� / �' S �r� r � a August 24th, 1988 Dear Friend & Neighbor: !�`�':��*`�Y1'S� -�-r�*„'�-- On Thursday August 18th, 192£, The St. Paul Zonin� Cor,�r��ittee n+ade a reca,r�endation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Perr�it to Russell and Bev�arlv �k�Erg vf 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Flane for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Carmission of St. Paul will r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Au ust 26t��. 1988 or ti�e 13tn fl oor of �he CQty hal l annex at 25 4!. t'ri t. to scuss e � er acceptance of re,�ection of ti�e Zoning Comrnittee recor�nendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGN THE PETITION and deliver to Viergil Meyer at 16�26 E. Shore DP.ive or ARnol Jaco son at 632 E. Shore Drive ��. tNt�t�t�'�U�'C; ' '�`��. 88. � __ _ s .. . .._. - . .. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t1r. �4eyer at 774-2185 or PAr. Jacobson at 716-459£=or 770-3761 and they will pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 6�E HAVE THESE PETITIOWS N U HAND BY NO PJ HURSD Y MORROW l�S l-!E t4UST BRING THEP1 TO CITY HALL E D . �G. k'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. .�,�. To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 l�i. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NAM Y�� .,� �! NAME � _��zC��'��-��! -- ,.,��r_ _ _�_.___ ADDRE S �,�Z -3 �d";�`�'��'��-,,��_ PH4NE � � � � �L/l / > a�gust 2atn, �9s� Dear Friend & Neighbor: �� >, _r ,, .....cr:+5,k,i..: .. On Thursday August 18tf�, 193F, The St. Paul Zonin� Coc�r�iittee n�ade a reca:r�endation to. apNrove ti�� nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Perr�it to Russell and 6everlv Ot�E rg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Fiane for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. � The Planning Canmission of St. Paul ��ill r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Au ust 2Eti�, 1988 or tiiE 13th floor of bhe CQfy hall annex at 25 W. t'ri St. to sCUSS e � el" accepta cn e of re3ection of tiie Zoning Corrrnittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGi� THE PETITION and del i ver to Vi_ i 1, M�yer, at 16�6 E. Shore DP.i ve or Aenol Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Dri ve '�1�;�tlU�SD�I�'�l�"`�$'�h,-`��8• p y�;}l111��11��I��I I I I��1 .. � k-__sx$� ..�.�*i�.„.. . If you are not able tq deliver the petition personally, please call Mr. f4eyer at 774-2185 or P4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they vrill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 4�JE HAVE THESE PETITIOtJS J DS BY N Pl HURSDA OMORROW AS L-!E �4UST BRING TNEP�1 TO CITY NALL BE D JG. w'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirability o� our neighborhood. To the Planning Carmission City Hall & Annex 25 W. 4th St. St. Pau1 ,�Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Co�nittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NAM� � NAME_�f�,�t�°��YLLc— .� �'�—''!-- --- AODRESS � � < < n ^ � � PH4NE � •— .S� a August 24th. 19E8 Dear Friend & Neighbor: 1�"��.� On Thursday August 18tt�, 1935, T{ie St. Paul Zonin� Cor;r�iittee n+ade a reca;r�endation to. apNrove ti�� nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and Bev!�rly �berg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care flane for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Carmission of St. Paul k�ill r�eet at 9:00 A. M.��F�r. id�. �Au�u�st 26�1�, 1988 or, ti�e 13th floor of bhe CQfy Hall annex at 25 4J. t'r� t. to disCUSS el�her acceptance oF re3ection of ti�e Zoning Committee recomnendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, 2LEASE SIGN THE PETITION and deliver,to,Vie�il, Meyer. at 16�26 E. Shore DP.ive or Aenol Jacobson at 632 E. Shore Drive �fo� �il`�Id �- ' p�Y,; _ � �� :u 8. �,� If you are not able tq deliver the petition personally, please call F1r. �4eyer at 774-2185 or P4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they ��ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 4JE HAVE THESE PETITIONS � U HANOS BY NO P! HURSDA OMORROW AS L•lE t-1llST BRING THE�4 TO CITY HALL RE D . . P�G. w'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. �---_---;�::. .-, ., ,,-3- To the Planning Carmission City Hall & Annex 25 la. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the �ndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Canmittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. � .. NAME ,�-c_ -_ , NAME. �" -��,�/_=�--�.�-�c�:�-----��^.__ r/ ADDRE S��.:L�� PHONE��,��lG� � 6 1 � . Rugust 24th, 198E Dear Friend & Neighbor: �� r�� _ '�'+.wa, . On Thursday August 18tt�, 192£, The �t. Paul Zoninr Cor,�rnittee n+ade a recor.r�endation to. ap�rove ti�e nonconforming use and.Special Con�ition Use Perr�it to Russell and Bev��rlv �bErg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Flome for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Caimission of St. Paul a�ill r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Au ust 26t1�, 1988 or the 13th floor of bhe CBty Hall annex at 25 �J. t'ri t. to sCUSS e !� er acceptance of re�ection of tiie Zoning Committee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGN THE PETITION and deliver to Vi�gil Meyer at 16;26 E. Shore DP.ive or Aenol Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Dri ve ` fQ�;�! `' `�ltfRSDAY�US��, : �a�,�. . ,. . . - _ _ .uu.»._. ..::��. -_.�. _�x,.: If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t�r. �4eyer at 774-2185 or P�r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they raill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 4JE HAVE THESE PETITIONS � UR HANDS a NO P! UR D OMORROW AS�lE�4UST BRING THE��1 TO CITY NALL RE D aG. V�'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirability o� our neighborhood. � : To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 t�J. 4th St. • St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NlYfIC ��l'C'C��1 �{ (4� F, �-(, i�t r _ NAME ADDRESS ,�.� S �� ,.r��11� �� it � --��__ PHONE��b� C� 7 y �� . a August 24th, 1988 Dear Friend & i�eighbor: '�� ..�,�-iry�—�.� On Thursday August 18th, 19�8, T{ie St. Paul Zoninr Cor,�nittee n�ade a reca�r�endation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special CQn�ition Use Permit to Russell and 6ewarlv Ot:�Erg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Fiome for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Ca�rnission of St. Paul will �eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida �Au ust 26_�1�, 1988 or tf�e 13th floor of �he CQty hall annex at 25 y1�4t'r� ,t. to scuss ei�her acceptance o� re3ection of ti�e Zoning Car�nittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, QLEASE SIG�� THE PETITION and del i ve r to Viergi 1.Me _e�r,,��.��Zb.,E;,,.�hare ,D ive or ARnol Jacobson at 63 E. Shore Drive b �� "� `�dEfOt��_ ri T- � 988• If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call 11r. t4eyer at 774-2185 or PAr. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they �rill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT bJE NAVE THESE PETITIONS � U AND B N M URSD OMORROW AS l•!E h1UST BRING TNEP1 TO CITY HALL B R R D 9: .G. k'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. '?� r i - i� To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 l;l. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the Undersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning C�ranittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NAME ��-� r,_ �� <<��-�� Nl�ME ao�R�ss iG y�;--��-- --- PHON 7�� S' � , � August 24th, 19E8 Dear Friend & P�eighbor: �NC � ,��:_�—': �" On Thursday August 18th, 1935, T{ie St. Paul Zonin� Con�+iittee n+ade a reca+rnendation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special CQn�ition Use Perr�it to Russell and BPV��'rly Qberg of 163b East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care flane for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Cannission of St. Paul a�ill �eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Au�ust 26tf�, 1988 or tf�E 13th floor of bhe CBty hall annex at 25 Vl�lt'r� ,t. to scuss e � er acceptance of re3ection of ti�e Zoning Crnr�nittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, QLEASE SIGi� THE PETITION and del i ver to Vi.e!�1r�_ er, �,,�6,26 E. Shore DRive or Arrnol Jaco son at 632 E. Shore Drive �-�� If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call �4r. �4eyer at 774-2185 or PAr. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they vrill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 4JE HAVE THESE PETITIONS � UR HANDS BY NO P� HURSQ OMORROW AS t•lE �4llST BRING THE�1 TO CITY HALL B !G. k'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty of our neighborhood. . , 7r:.-..�.,,. .._ .. .. . . - . To the Planning Comnission City Hall & Annex 25 l�i. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Comrnittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the g ranting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. l - ��-�v�'2- ��.Z,��-��;�.� NAME ,: - - �� __1�z��.��:�----_____ . AODRESS PHONE 7�� --�� .�.–� a August 24th, 1988 Dear Friend & Neighbor: AY Pt;�_:.�� On Thursday August 18th, 19�&, The St. Paul Zoninr Ca;�r��ittee ra�ade a reca+r�endation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Perr�it to Russell and Bev��rly �t�Erg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Flome for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Cannission of St. Paul w�ill �eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Au ust 2E�1�, 1988 or thE 13th floor of �he CQty hall annex at 25 I�J. t'ri t. to SCUSS � er' acceptance oF re�ection of tiie Zoning Committee recarmendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIG�� TNE PETITION and deliver to Vie�gil ,Me er_„at 16�26 E. Shore DP.ive or Arrnol Jacobson at 632 E. Shore Drive ae�`�� . �I�RSDA�::: '�'� _ � �: . __ ..� .,��;� ., If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t4r. �4eyer at 774-2185 or PRr. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they will pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT �JE HAVE THESE PETITIOtJS � HANDS 6 N �J HURSD Y OMORROW AS 4JE t4UST ERING TNE�1 TO CITY NALL E 0 9: P�G. k'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. To the Planning Carmission City Hall & Annex 25 l�I. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are o�posed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NAM� '' � .c� - d-c,,,.�../`` NAME o�'t,..4._ �� -�-�1-� --�------ _ �= ---------- A.DDRES ��'fL .L'�.. PHONE 7 76 ��_ , - -� � . Rugust 24th, 19EE Dear Friend & Neighbor: ,��w��#::� �°�I�� On Thursday August 18th, 19�5, The St. Paul Zoninr Cor,�r�iittee n+ade a reca+r�endation to. ap�rove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and Bev��rl.v �bErg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Nome for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Carmission of St. Paul will meet at 9:00 A. M, Frida �Au _ust 2Eti�, 1988 or tiiE 13th f]oor of �he CQfy hall annex at 25 �l, tr� t. to scuss e1� er acceptance oF re�ection of tiie Zoning Comnittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGt� THE PETITION and delive to Vi�i� � b,E. Shore DRive . or Aenol d Jaco son at 1632 E. Shore Dri ve b � ��i': _ : ._:_ `:�lt'�t�S��i:` ' ' If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t4r. t4eyer at 774-2185 or P�r. Jacobson at 776-4598=or 770-3761 and they will pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT b�E HAVE THESE PETITIONS � U NAND QY N PI HURSD MORROW � AS lJE t1UST 6RING THE�1 TO CITY NALL D 9• . �G. k'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty oF our neighborhood. .,. ,, �.:� ' To the Planning Commission City Hall � Annex 25 1�1. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Corr�nittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NAME " �,� ,�� .�a� �� r I�AME„f°��.,.�.�� ,�f�-�� .�.�__ ADDRESS /C� '' � �.�—�� ..� + PHON�7 � �.3 �/ � August 24th, 19E8 ��'' �U U �' Dear Friend & Neightor: ��.�'.�:..!€-- . .� On Thursday August 18th, 193�, ThE St. Paul Zoninc Corx�iittee n+ade a reca�r:�endation to. a�►�rove ti�� nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and Beverl.v �t�Erg of 1636 East Shore �Rive to operate a Foster Care Ffane for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Cannission of St. Paul will r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida �F�u u_st 26t��, 1988 or ti�E 13th fl oor of �he CQty hal l annex at 25 W.�t'r��t, to scuss e1� e1r acceptance o� re�ection of ti�e Zoning Committee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, QLEASE SIGN TNE PETITION and del i ver to Vi i 14_Me ��,. t .ab26 E_. Shore DP.i ve or Armol Jacobson at 32 E. Shore Dri ve �f�fi"�'1 ��t��Y:�T��S_��.F,��8. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call 11r. �4eyer at 774-2185 or P4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they raill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT VJE HAVE THESE PETITIONS � U H D 6Y N M URSDAY MORROW AS LJE htUST BRING TNEP4 TO CITY HALL RE R D �G. w'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. _ .' r To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 W. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the llndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. _ ;�,_ , NAME " •�z ' �'✓ _ � � .. NAME. ��1��L,t � ` lc � t�z.��-,��_ �._.�--------�--— �f � AODR�SS �� GC�+�7Z. 1 w� �� PHANE �T — � T '�r r' � August 24th, 1988 Dear Friend � Neighbor: � `�;,� �� =� On Thursday August 18th, 19�5, The St. Pau1 ,Zoninr CocYni ttee n�ade � reconrnendation to. a�Nrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Perr�it to Russell and Bev�arlv �k�Erg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Ffane for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. , � The Planning Canmission of St. Paul ��ill r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Au ust 2Etl�, 1988 or thE 13th floor of �he CQty hall annex at 25 W. t'r� St. to sCUSS e � er acceptance o� re�ection of ti�e Zoning Committee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIG�! THE PETITION and deliver to Vi 71 ,: �r..a�. 6k26�,�hor� �iue, or ARnol Jacobson at 63 E. Shore Drive . � � . :. ; t�5tki -.: �� ?�+� �;. .,: If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call F4r. t�eyer at 714-2185 or P4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they raill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 6JE HAVE THESE PETITIONS �� H DS B NOOPJ URSD OMORR W AS 4JE h1UST BRING THE��1 TO CITY HALL H R D 9: . . P�G. t�'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty of our neighborhood. � To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 l+i. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the Undersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Co�ranittee decision of August 18th, 1388 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. � Nl�It'I ��1Z1- c r :, ' � �"L.�a:.h.r��L'_i�; �'� � __._._ _ �`� 2�� ADDRESS /C; /� �'TL-/9!1/J/C S% PHANE ��. �,�.--- °'....."---- l August 24th, 1988 Dear Friend & Neighbor: �','4��`°:;�"'t� � On Thursday August 18th, 193&, The St. Paul Zonin� Caxnittee n+ade a reca.rnendation to. ap�rove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Perr�it to Russell and 6everl.v Ot�erg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Fiome for teh 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Carmission of St. Paul w�ill r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Fr�ida Au ust 26t1�, 1988 or the 13th floor of �he C6ty hall annex at 25 VJ. t'ri St. to iscuss e � er arcceptance of re�ection of t}�e Zoning Committee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGN THE PETITION and deliver to Vi�gil Me er_at,�1�26 E.. Shore DRiye or ARnold Jaco son at 1632 E. Shore Drive �r.��' ' .-- If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call Mr. �4eyer at 774-2185 or P4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they Y�ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT t�JE HAVE THESE PETITIONS � U H DS BY NO P! URSD MORROW AS WE t4UST BRING THE�•1 TO CITY HALL RE H D 9: . . �G. f�'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty oF our neighborhood. To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 l+l. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Corranittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Pe it to that property. NAM� '�.`�-r. �� `' � ;�% MAME ADDRESS�( .,. -, �--; � `-�a��, ��--------- PH4NE `7 `� � i S�� ,.- _.r.______ �-t--__-.--- � August 24th, 1988 Dear Friend & f�eighbor: �,.�ll,.z-�,D"fi '�'��E .�.�•�. On Thursday August 18th� 19uS, The St. Paul Zonin� Ca�Y�iittee n+�de a recor.rnendation to. approve ti�� nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and Beverl.v �bErg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care F1ane for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Canmission of St. Paul w�ill meet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Au ust 2Eti;, 1988 or thE 13th floor of bhe CQty hall annex at 25 W, t'ri t. to scuss e � el^ accep ance of re�ection of tiie Zoning Committee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, QLEASE SIGN THE PETITION and deliver to,1� a�;�yer.:,�at ,�fi,2b E. Shore DRive -°�l�t�DAY =�U� �:�tb. :�.�` or ARnold Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Drive 'fore � � �-�. � . . , If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t4r. f4eyer at 774-2185 or P�r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they r�ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 6JE HAVE THESE PETITIONS � UR HANDS BY N P� URSDA OMORROW AS �!E t41lST BRING THEP�1 TO CITY NALL BE 0 IDA JG. k'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty ofi our neighborhood. �r�,,. . .. � _ _y. r. To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 I�J. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. . � � 1 N14ME RAME._�?P�!�.t�i_�Cti�_.� ��f^��__.�__ AODRESS f S � ��L--� Tt c._ � 7`' PN�NE� ��6'�Q � August 24th. 1988 Dear Friend & Neighbor: _ N 0 T I C E On Thursday August 18th, 19�E, The St. Paul Zonin� Cor+��iittee �nade a recor�nendation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and Bev�rly ObErg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Flane for tei� 10 Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Cam►ission of St. Paul will r�eet at 9•00 A. M. Frida Aueust 26��, 1988 or thE 13th floor of �he CQty Hall annex at 25 W. �t'ri St. to scuss e � er acceptance oF re�ection of ti�e Zoning Comnittee recommendation. This trleeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, 2LEASE SIGN THE PETITION and deliver to Vie�gil Meyer at 16`26 E. Shore DRive or ARnold Jaco son at 632 E. Shore Drive before fd00t� ON THURSDAY �iUGUST 25th, 1988. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call 11r. t4eyer at 774-2185 or P�r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they will pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT ��JE HAVE THESE PETITIONS P� R HAND BY N PJ HURSD OMORROW AS l!E t4UST BRING THEM TO CITY NALL RE D Y : . . P�G. w'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. To the Planning Comnission City Hall & Annex 25 l�J. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the tlndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Co�unittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. � , ' ' A .. NAME � � ; ; - � L I�I�NlE.��'� C.��v_ t�r1_.� --- --- ADDRESS � )��/ `� v - �' PHONE 7� ��Sl � August 24th, 198E �� _ �,v v li.L Dear Friend & Neighbor: !I��'�:a��— On Thursday August 18th, 19�5, The St. Paul Zoninr Co�x+�ittee n�ade a reca.r�endation to. apNrove tl�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and Bev��rlv Ot�Erg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care F1ane for teh 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Carmission of St. Paul w�ill meet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Au ust 26�1�, 1988 or thE 13th floor of bhe CQty Nall annex at 25 W. tri t. to scuss e � er acceptance of re�ection of ti�e Zoning Committee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, QLEASE SIGiV THE PETITION and deliver to Vi il Me er at 16,26 E. ; � Riv or ARnol Jaco son at 32 E. Shore Drive �ar�' i ��t�lY ��`e �. t'� : E�. �=x ._. .. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call Mr. t4eyer at 774-2185 or P�Ir. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they Yrill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT �JE HAVE THESE PETITIONS � ANDS BY NO PJ HURSD Y MORROW AS l•JE h1UST BRING THEP�1 TO CITY HALL 6 D . . �G. w'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty ofi our neighborhood. To the Planning Carmission � City Hall & Annex 25 l�J. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon�6rming use and Special C �dition Use Permit to that property. � � NAM� �l.t_iJ �� E � ��5 ADDRESS �� ' --�--- .- � -----��__ PNONE � � r r _ .�.�----- � August 24th, 1988 Dear Friend & Neighbor: � iil�w On Thursday August 18th, 1935, The St. Paul Zonin� Ca+�nittee n�ade a recorr�endation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and Be w�rlv �berg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Nome for teh 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Canmission of St. Paul will r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Aucust 26t1�, 1988 or ti�e 13th floor of �he CQty hall annex at 25 W, t'r� t. to sCUSS e � el^ acceptance o� re�ection of ti�e Zoning Comnittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, QLEASE SIGN THE PETITION and deliver to Vie�gil Me er at 16,26 E. Shore DP.iv _. or Arrnold Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Drive before If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call tRr. t4eyer at 774-2185 or PAr. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they will pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 6JE HAVE THESE PETITIONS fJ UR AND BY N �! HURSD MORR W AS L•!E t�UST BRING TNEP1 TO CITY HALL E E D �G. k'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty o�F our neighborhood. j. ., To the Planning Carmission City Hall & Annex 25 lJ. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Cort�nittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon�6rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NAM� �_ �'�--- � -- NAME ADDRESS I (o �-3_ _C-�-�-.. �-�——�-- PHONE��— -7 "] 1 Z � ..... �— � August 24th, 198E Dear Friend & Neighbor: -� _ �. On 'fhursday August 18th, 1925, The St. Paul Zonin� Cor,�nittee n+ade a reca:Nnendation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Perr�it to Russell and Beverly �bErg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Flane for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Carmission of St. Paul will meet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Au ust 26t1�, 1988 or tfiE 13th floor of bhe CQty Nall annex at 25 4J. tr� St. to scuss e � er acceptance oF re�ection of ti�e Zoning Committee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, QLEASE SIGN TNE PETITION and deliver to VieFgil Shore DRive or ARnol Jacobson at 63 E. Shore Drive before ,LL y� �;�,. . . � . - If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call �4r. Meyer at 774-2185 or PAr. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they will pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT WE HAVE THESE PETITIONS �� U HAN S BY N PJ HURSD Y MORROW AS !JE t4UST ERING THEM TO CITY HALL E RE R DA . . P�G. w'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty of our neighborhood. _ , ;," „ ,. - �-,... �.,.__ To the Planning Carmission City Hall & Annex 25 t�J. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. � - Nl4ME v N�� 6y� ADDRESS ^T..'.� �!� „�r�'�� ±k'?— - --- PNONE�,�;,--:�� August 24th, 1988 Dear Friend & Neighbor: - � On Thursday August 18th, 19�5, Tlie St. Paul Zoninr Ca�nittee n�ade a recormendation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell and Beverly �berg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Elome for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. � The Planning Carmission of St. Paul will �eet at 9:00 A. M. Frid�Au ust 26t1�, 1988 on the 13th floor of 6he CQty Hall annex at 25 W. t'ri St. to di�scuss e � er acceptance of re,�ection of tf�e Zoning Corrmittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you Cannot attend, QLEASE SIGN THE PETITION and deliver to Vie�gil Meyer at 16:26 E. Shore DRive or ARnol Jacobson at 632 E. Shore Drive before P �:. �;' bA �� U��` If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call �4r. �4eyer at 714-2185 or P4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they wi]1 pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT WE HAVE THESE PETITIONS �� UR HANDS BY N PJ HURSDA OMORROW AS L•JE t4UST BRING TNEP•1 TO CITY HALL BE 0 R DA 9: JG. k'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. 'R' _ .�.w' " -{ � '� . . . . .:;�.. — ^i',;�r;�..'•,',� �..a..r�»..... To the Planning Carmission City Hall & Annex 25 t�J. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Cornrnittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NAM� ��V� NAME _��._._____� _ � , c� ADDRESS C�,a�vv„��C'_ _ PNON� t �� I .... > Rugust 24th, 198E Dear Friend & i�eighbor: '�;r„�1 O T I C f': ; On Thursday August 18th, 198£, Tlie St. Paul Zonin� Ca��iittee n+ade a reca+r�endation to, apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�itien Use Perr:�it to i?ussell and Bev��rly �t�Erg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Ffane for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Caimission of St. Paul will neet at 9:00 A. M. Frida �Au u_st 26tl�, 1988 or tiiE l�tn floor of �he CQty hall annex at 25 Vl:�tr� St. to scuss e1� er acceptance o� re�ecti on of ti�e Zon i ng Carrni ttee recommendati on. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGi� THE PETITION and deliver to Vie'gil Meyer at 1626 E. Shore DRive or Arnol Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Drive�fore NOON t�l THIiRSDAY BllGUST ��5th, ��=�988�� If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t4r. Meyer at 774-2185 or i4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they �;i]1 pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT L�E NAVE THESE PETITIOtJS t� OUR HANDS BY NO P HURSDA MORROW AS lJE 4UST BRING THEP•1 TO CITY HALL B RE R D Y 9: P�G. 1�'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty ofi our neighborhood. To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 1��. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the llndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Corr�nittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon6brming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that pro�erty. ,/ ' '�,, , ;�. ` � NAM� , /' / .` �r , ,�' �, r. � �-- - NAME �, .%,,. _ , ADDR�SS _ . " PHONE �, ° � � ' � .�.�--r A.ugust 24th, 19E8 Dear Friend & PJeighbor: �I'0 ? I C E T On Thursday August l�ths 19��; Tl�e St. Paul Zonin� Cor,�:iittse n�ade a recor,r�endation to. apNrove ti�� nonconforming use and Special Cen�ition Use Perr�it to Russell and Bev��rlv �t�erg of 1E36 Eest Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care F1ome for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of aqe. The Planning Canmission of St. Paul K�ill r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Au ust 26tt�, 1988 or tnE 13tn fl oor of �he CBty-#ial l annex zt 25 Vl. t'ri St. to scuss e � er acceptance of re,jection of ti�e Zoning Carmittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGi� THE PETITION and deliver to Virgil Meyer at 1626 E. �hore �p,P.i e or ARnold Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Drive I�fore t+i�ON flr! TMURSDAY BUGUST��5th,�19�. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call Mr. t�eyer at 774-2185 or P4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they will pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT �JE HAVE THESE PETITIONS I�� UR HANDS BY N M HURSDAY TOMORROW AS La.E t-1lfST BRING THEP�1 TO CITY HALL BE E H R D 9: P�G. k'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. �: To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 t°�. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the IJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon��rming use and Special �ondition Use Permit to that pro�erty. � � NAME ._ ` _" NAME._��-------------------------------- A.DDR€SS PHONE � P,ugust 24th, 19�8 Dear Friend & i�eighbor: �;. `'il 0 �: .I C E 4 On Thursday August 18th, 19�5, TI�E St. Paul Zonin; Cor��,iittee n+ade a reca+r�endation to, apNrove ti�� nonconforming use and Special Cen�ition Use Perr;�it to Russell and Bev��rl.v �bErg �f 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Flome for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Carmission of St. Paul will meet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Au ust 26t��, 1988 or tiiE 13tn floor of bhe CQty hall annex at 25 YJ. tri St. to sCUSS e � er acceptance of re,jecti on of ti�e Zoni ng Corrrni ttee recommendati on. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIG�� THE PETITION and deliver to Virgil Mey er at 1b26 E. Shore DP.ive or Armold Jacobson at 632 E. Shore Drive l�efore�IOONI "t�1 THURSDAY eUGU5T"�tt�; �988. � If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t4r. t4eyer at 774-2185 or P1r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they v�ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT L�E NAVE THESE PETITIO�JS i� UR NANDS QY NOOPJ HURSDAY TOMORROW AS 4!E �1UST ERING THEP�1 TO CITY iiALL B RE H D 9: 0 . P�G. k'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. x... �' - To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 l�. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the Undersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon�6rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. Nt1M�1/�;.•lf-�t r'� ..,�� _.� �._� ��.;,� ,i' __ NAME ._ -__ -- -----.__----- ;-- r!�� , �� A.DDRESS .,�,�;T ,t�r�,�,� --; PHONE ._ � ' � � .--� Rugust 24th, 19EE Dear Friend & i�eighbor: _�"'�T_.,�.� On Thursday Rugust 18th, 198£, T{�e St. Paul Zanin� Ca�nittee n�adF � reca�r�endation to. apNrove ti�� nonconforming use and Special Ccn�ition Use Perriit to Russell and Bev��rlv �t�Erg of 1E36 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Flome for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. The P1 anning Caimi ssion of St. Paul k�i 11 neet at 9:00 A. M. Fri da Auc ust 26t1;, 1988 or tiiE 13tn fl oor of bhe C6ty hal l annex at 25 VJ.— tr� St. to scuss e � er acceptance oF rejection of tiie Zoning Committee recorr�nendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, QLEASE SIGf� THE PETITION and deliver to Vie�gil Meyer..at ]b26 �. �hore �BRive • or ARnol Jacobson at 632 E. Shore Drive �efore tJ00N �11N THllRSDAY -,AUGUST �2�►th�s ;��l88.L If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call l�r. t4eyer at 774-2185 or i�ir. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they r��ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT �JE HAVE THESE PETITIONS IJ U HANDS BY N OPJ HURSDAY OMORROW AS l:E t1UST ERING THEP4 TO CITY HALL 6 D PJG. k'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our . neighborhood. �� To the Planning Camiission City Hall & Annex 25 l�. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon6brming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. , NAM€ ,�?%��.�! � �, < <<�f -- �- _ � NAME ,� `. ;_�, ,,,' �' °' . ; �� :=�.�� .__---------�----�-=------....____.---------- ADDR€SS � ` .< �: i��-�. ��..E-: _ PHONE_�R____%�'/- f��" �� x� Rugust 24th, 1988 Dear Friend & i�eighbor: "'�„� ::D` T T C � � On Thursday August 18th, 19��, The St. Paul Zonin� Cor,r�,iittee n+�de a reca.��endation to. apNrove ti�� nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Perr�it to Russell and fiev!�rly Ok�e.rg of 1E36 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care fiane for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Carmission of St. Paul will roeet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Aucust 26��, 1988 or tiiE 13tn fl oor of �he CBty hal l annex at 25 �l. tr� St. to scuss e � e1^ acceptance of rejection of tiie Zoning Cor�nittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGi� THE PETITION and deliver to Virgil Meyer �t 16,26 .E. Shore DP.ive or Arnol Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Dri ve [l�fore NO�� :OW THURSDAY RU6UST;�#h, '39�8. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call l4r. t4eyer at 774-2185 or P�ir. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they ��ri11 pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT VJE HAVE THESE PETITIOWS � UR HANDS BY NO PJ URSDAY OMORROW AS 4!E t1UST ERING THE�•1 TO CITY HALL B RE HE R D PJG. 4r'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty ofi our neighborhood. �- To the Planning Comnission , City Hall & Annex 25 l°�. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the IJndersigned, disagree vrith the St. Paul Zoning Corranittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a�noncon6brming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that pro�erty. -, � _ � NAM€ �,�-:, , � _�� "'.-• ��/ �`_ ,/ " L NAME------ --__------- , ----�-- -T-------- � /'..- - - , � A.DDRCSS _ , �.._ ; �' ;;!i` . i- '- PHONE,.�,�—_- F:ugust 24th, 198E Dear Friend & i�eightor: �;'1�1 �0 T I C E : � On Thursday August 18th, 1925, Ti�e St. Paul Zoninr Ca�r�iittee r��ade � reca+rnendation to. ap�,rove ti�e nonconforn►ing use and Special Cen�ition lJse Perr�it to Russell anu Bev%�rlv Ok�Erg of 1E36 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Ffome for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. The P 1 anni ng Canmi ss i on of St. Paul wi 11 r;�eet at 9:00 A. M. Fri da Auc ust 26t��, 1988 or ti�E 13tn floor of �he CQty Hall annex at 25 �f, t'r� St. to sCUSS� e � e1^ acceptance o� re3ection of tiie Zoning Comrnittee recor�nendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGi� TNE PETITION and deliver to ViFgil Meyer at 16�26 E. Shore DP.iy� or Arnol d Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Dri ve M�:fore �OQOW ffN THURSbA,Y ;lIUGUST.25th, :`1988', If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call l4r. ��eyer at 774-2185 or ��r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they ►��ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT �JE HAVE THESE PETITIOtdS P� R HANDS QY NO P� HURSDAY OMORROW AS l!E t-1UST BRING THE�1 TO CITY HALL BEFORE D �G. k'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty o�F our neighborhood. -� To the Planning Commission City Nall & Annex 25 1��. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the tlndersigned, disagree vrith the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a nonconGbrming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NAME �•�• �i r�� f.�-�L_ G!-��-� �='z-L-��-z r NAME��i�_J-__.�/2�� '��.:�-�-�ir?__Z_..._�_ � i � PHONE 7" / - �' �� ADDRESS i S7 � ��C� ��t�� -r�: _-�.�� .-�-�� _1_._ A.ugust 24th, 1988 Dear Friend & yeighbor: `�:1�_� G E, On Thursday August 18th, 19��, The St. Paul Zonin� Cora;�ittee n+ade a recor+rnendation to a�►Nrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special CQn�ition Use Permit to Russell anci 6ev��r1�� t�erg of 1636 Eest Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Ffane for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Caimission of St. Paul w�ill meet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Au ust 26t��, 1988 or tiie 13tn fl oor of bhe C6ty Hal l annex at 25 V1. tr� St. to scuss e � er' acceptance of re�ection of ti�e Zoning Co�rnittee recomnendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIG�� THE PETITION and deliver to Vitrgil Meyer at 1b26 E. Shore DRive or ARnol Jacobson at 632 E. Shore Drive t�fore NOt�� I '�'t{t�RSDAY `6UGll�T:`�th, -i988. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t�r. t4eyer at 774-2185 or ?�ir. Jacobson at 776-459£=or 770-3761 and they ►;ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 6JE HAVE THESE PETITIOtJS �� R HANDS 6Y NOOP! HURSDAY MORROW AS L!E t1UST BRING THEPd TO CITY HALL BE RE R D 9: P�G. k'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. To the Planning Canmission City Hall & Annex 25 !°�. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the llndersigned, disagree v�ith the St. Paul Zoning Corr�nittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncan6brming use and Special Cond ion Use Permit to th t pro�erty. NAME � NAME ADDR�SS ��I J �O �'f'(��L ��' s-- PH�NE � 7 � G�� ,�..�,.,_—_ August 24th, 19EE Dear Friend & i�eighbor: .�.�;�.�.,�. On Thursday August 18tt�, 198F, Tl�e St. Paul Zonin� Ca�;iittee n+ade a reca+r�endation to. apNrove ti�2 nonconforming use and Special Cen�ition Use Permit to Russell and 6�verlv Ot�erg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care tlome for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Carmission of S�. Paul v��ill meet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Au ust 26t��, 1988 or tiiE 13tn floor of bhe CBty Hall annex at 25 �l.�t'r� St. to sCUSS dt er acceptance o� rejection of tiie Zoning Corr�nittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIG�� THE PETITION and deliver to_V_iFgil Meyer a.�,,,,�,6,26_ hore DP.ive or ARnold Jacob�on at 1632 E. Shore Drive ,. �� ;: ' ��.: .,88. �.;. ___ .. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call �4r. �4eyer at 774-2185 or �4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they ��ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 6JE HAVE THESE PETITIOtdS �� UR HANDS 6 NOOPJ HURSQA OMORROW AS L•!E f4UST BRING TNEP•1 TO CITY HALL E ORE HE R D Y 9:0 P�G. k'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty of our neighborhood. �.. ,_:.�.. To the Planning Carmission City Hall & Annex 25 1��. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the tJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Cornrnittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon6�'rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that proFerty. NAME � "�� `':, �,`� ,. a` � __. �.�r./'.._ . .__ �!AME ADDRESS ' � --------: ---�1--- --------- PHONE �!c'� =�� 1 �: �:_...�- -- F�.ugust 24th, 19E8 Dear Friend � i�eighbor: �'�:� ��_� - T On Thursday August 18tr�, 19�5, The St. Paul Zonin� Cor,��iittee n�adE a reca;r�endation to apNrove ti�e nonconforrii ng use and Speci al Ccnci ti on Use Perr,ii t to Russel l and B�V�'rl:,r �t�erg of 1636 East Shore �Rive to operate a Foster Care t;ome for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Caimission of St. Paul K�ill r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Aucust 26t1�, 1988 or, tiiE 13tn fl oor of bhe C6ty Hal l annex at 25 Vl. tr� St. to sCUSS e � el^ acceptance of rejection of ti�e Zoning Car�mittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIG;� THE PETITION and deliver to Vie�gil Meyer at 16�26 E. Shore DP.ive or A�nold Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Drive If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call Mr. �4eyer at 774-2185 or i�fr. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they ��ai11 pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT �dE HAVE TNESE PETITIOWS td UR HANDS �Y NO P! HURSDAY OMORROW AS L:E h1UST BRING TNEP1 TO CITY HALL ORE H R D Y 9: P�G. k'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty oF our neighborhood. , � To the Planning Correnission City Hall & Annex 25 t�J. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the llndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Corr�nittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon6�rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NAME�//f�� -�v;".i � `'�.�-t,-- __ `.. NAME AODRESS /-�" ,'-�' --- G�C�-,,.�. t---------- PNON�>/- /� �/ Z V \�� v � Rugust 24th, 19E8 Dear Friend � i�eightor: ,' � � �� E On Thursday August 18th, 19�£, The St. Paul Zoninr Cor,r��ittee n�ade a reca,N�endation to. a�Nrove ti�e nonconforriing use and Special Cen�ition Use Perr�it to Russell anu 6PV��rlv Qk�crg of 163b East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care F1ome for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Ca�rnission of St. Paul w�ill r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida �u ust 26t1�, 1988 or tiiE 13tn fl oor of �he CQty Hal l annex at 25 41. tri St, to scuss e dt e1^ acceptance of re,�ecti on of ti�e Zon i ng Car�ni ttee recomrnendati on. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIG�� THE PETITION and deliver to Virgil Meyer at 1626 E. Shore DP.ive or Arnol d Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Dri ve�:��fi��!�1�1�'�fUR�tY�a�@fr��'� �+ a3��T+le±_, . . ' e r,� ^�`... ..._r--._.._...::ir:�.:.�...:�..��...a.-.. _' _. .. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t1r. ��eyer at 774-2185 or ►�lr. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they �;ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 4dE HAVE THESE PETITIOtJS �� 0 R HANDS 6Y NOOP! THURSDA OMORROW AS L:E t-1lfST BRING THE�•1 TO CITY HALL B RE DA 9: JG. k'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillt� ofi our neighborhood. To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 t°�. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the Undersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NAM�/�� .-�%�./`��:��..�.�' l -- . � � NAME , •� � A.ODRESS /�%�j'� !%�G-2 .,�<��---------- PH4NE_��`)/�� '�7�/ ��., �s. August 24th, 1988 Dear Friend & Neighbor: _ 4 -� �i :� E ;,..�, On Thursday August 18tt�, 19�£�, Tlie St. Paul Zonin; Cor,�;�ittee n+ade � reca+r�endation to. apNrove ti�� nonconforming use and Special Ccn�ition Use Permit to Russell and 6�v!,rlv �bcrg of lE3b East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Home for ten 1� Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Carmission of St. Paul K�ill r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frid�Aucust 26t��, 1988 or the 13tn floor of bhe CQty hall annex at 25 4J. tn St, to scuss e � er acceptance o� rejection of ti�e Zoning Carmittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you can�ot attend, eLEASE SIG►� THE PETITION and deliver .�o ,�i�gi� .Meyer at 16.26 E. Shore DP.ive or Arnold Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Drive b�r��±iQOIi �1+i TNURS[�Y ��5�it:''�. �,._.,��..�.,,_.�x. If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t1r. �4eyer at 714-2185 or iRr. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they ►�rill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT bJE HAVE THESE PETITIONS �� UR HANDS 6Y NOOP� HURSDAY T MORROW AS t!E t�1UST BRING THEP•1 TO CITY NALL BEFORE D Y 9: P�G. k'e thank you for your hFlp to preserve the value and desirabillty ofi our neighborhood. _.___.r..i--..�..v��MWw.^_�E�.Sw.r•.t�nrv....:�i -. ....._..... .. .-...... To the Planning Coim�ission City Hall & Annex 25 l°�. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree v�ith the St. Paul Zoning Corr�nittee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncond�rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NaM�., "f� : � l, �: �' , -_ NAME .__._� .______ _ _-- ---------------- - � ;, ,� _ (, ! , , ^* ADDRESS ! � � � � � / % � �� ' r,� Y ��% _ PH4NE�=�.. _ � _ . a... P:ugust 24th, 1988 Dear Friend & i�eighbor: '�'�t A �'.�I .0 E On Thursday August 18tf�, 192£; The St. Paul Zonin� Corr;�ittee r��de a reca+r�endation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Perr�it to Russell anu Bev!arl�,� �t�crg c�f 163b East Shore �Rive to operate a Foster Care tlane for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Canmission of St. Paul K�ill r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Aucust 26�1�, 1988 or ti�E 13tn fl oor of �he C6ty Hal l annex at 25 �J. tr� St. to sCUSS e � elr acceptance of re,jection of ti�e Zoning Car�nittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIG►� TNE PETITION and deliver to Vi�gil Meyer at 16�26 E. Shore DRive or Arnold Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Drive fore NOOt1 't�TfiURSDA�Y �IiGUST'�°�88� � . : _ If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t4r. �4eyer at 774-2185 or iAr. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they tirill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT �JE HAVE THESE PETITIOWS �� UR HAN S 6Y NO PJ HURSDAY OMORROW AS lSE �4lfST BRING THEP•1 TO CITY HALL BE ORE HE D 9: P�G. k'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty o�F our neighborhood. � _ To the Planning Commission City Hall & finnex 25 t°�. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon��rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that proFerty. '�. : , j . . N�it1€ � C'r�l 1'�� .� ��t_-ac._ .r,..z.1.t,�. P!AME.__ ,�-- --- -- -- , / � SC '�`�. �� T��_r �� !rl �\ A.ODRESS T,' '_�) L � �t��I� � i � C �� PNONE / / ! �. �t� U' ;•*� �� Rugust 24th, 19EE Dear Friend & i�eighbor: �� '�.T Y�'t E On Thursday August 18tr�, 192F�, The St. Paul Zonin� Cor�aittee n�ade a reca+r�endation to. apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Ccn�itien Use Permit to Russell anu Bev��rl.v �k�erg of 1E36 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Ffome for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Caamission of St. Paul w�ill �eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida��F�u�u�st 26�I;, 1988 or tiiE 13tn floor of bhe C�ty Hall annex at 25 �J, tr� St. to sCUSS ei!�her acceptance oF re�ection of tiie Zoning Corr�nnittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGi� THE PETITION and del i ver to V�.�gj.�.�Mexer at 16;26 E. Shore DP.i ve or ARnol Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Dri ve , ��ore�NOOt�.-.�t.'�i�JRSDAY �ii6lt�fi'�ti, �'�. = . �..: .u.r.i.� If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call tRr. t4eyer at 774-2185 or P4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 710-3761 and they vaill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT LJE HAVE THESE PETITIOtaS I�� UR HAND QY N PJ HURSDAY OMORROW AS l•:E t4UST BRING THE�1 TO CITY HP,LL BE R D 9:0 �G. k'e thank you for your help to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. � - To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 1��. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the llndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the g ranting of a noncon�brming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NAME ,,�- �`.-« ., .-v�°_.-� �.{� -� • � `� � '.�i � �- ,., , . : NAME /�-z-� `�`-_� �, � ,.; �� •___._._- �-- < °=----1 -- ._.� �� . _7-'- r/ � � � � `�.__ AODRESS � �"''• ',. ,-, ! .�'- �.�';, .�y'+ PH4NE_`� � Rugust 24th, 19EE Dear Friend � i�eightor: ��„�iflT� On Thursday August 18th, 19�£�, The St. Paul Zonin� Cor�rnittee n+ade a reca+r�endation to. ap�rove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Cen�ition Use Perr�it to Russell and Bev%�rl:,r Ot�erg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care flome for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Canmission of St. Paul v►�ill r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida Rucust 26t��, 1988 or ti�E 13tn floor of �he CBty hall annex at 25 61. t'r� St. to sCUSS e � er acceptance oF re3ecti on of ti�e Zon i ng Con�r►i ttee recorr�nendati on. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIG�! THE PETITION and deliver to Vit_�i� l Meyer at_ 1C�6 E. Shore DRive or ARnol d Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Dri ve+��fore '1�1�1 'iHURSDAY `�US'F'�rV�'�_ If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call l�r. �4eyer at 774-2185 or P4r. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they r�rill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 4JE HAVE THESE PETITIONS �J UR HANDS 6Y NOOP! THURSDAY OMORROW AS t:E h1UST ERING THEP•1 TO CITY HALL E RE E D 9: 0 . �G. 4r'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabil�ty oF our neighborhood. __� ........,.�.M.._i..»... ,.......:."'i-�a�:f.':..yp �'F;_' � To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 t°J. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the llndersigned, disagree vrith the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon�6rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. ._____ , ,� f , NE1h9E - � ,_ __ , _ --- - , � -- :� ., � _ N1�ME_�� % � � . A.ODRESS-� `- c._[,.�-_`1.I�i��---�`�/'__��._.__ PHONE % % � .� /-, c? « -� -- Rugust 24th, 198E Dear Friend & yeightor: ��'._� ��. On Thursday August 18th, 19�£, The St. Paul Zonin� Ca��ittee n+ade a recorr�endation to. apNrove ti�� nonconforming� use and Special Con�ition Use Perr�it to Russell and 6evcarlv �k�Erg of 1E36 East Shore �Rive to operate a Foster Care ffome for ten 1C Childreen up to 18 years of age. The Planning Carmission of St. Paul w�ill r�eet at 9:00 A. M. Frida �Au�ust 26tl�, 1988 or tfiiE 13tn floor of bhe C�ty hall annex at 25 Vl.— t'r� St. to sCUSS ei�her acceptance of re�ection of ti�e Zoning Comnittee recorrunendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, 2LEASE SIG�� THE PETITION and deliver to Vitrgil, Me er at 1b26 E. Shore DRive or Arnol d Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Dri ve.�refot� Nt�1 �f+1�rHt�RSDAY �Gt3S'��.�5.#fi;.--�,1�„� If you are not atle to deliver the petition personally, please call t�r. t4eyer at 774-2185 or ?�r. Jacobson at 776-459£=or 770-3761 and they r�rill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT bJE HAVE THESE PETITIO�JS t� UR HANDS 6Y NO M HURSDA OMORROW AS L!E h1UST BRING THEP•1 TO CITY HALL BE RE E RID Y : 0 . PJG. w'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our neighborhood. t s ._. _..::._...--. ___._ . _ ,.... To the Planning Commission City Hall & Annex 25 l�J. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, an are opposed to the granting of a noncon6brming use and Special Con i�ion Use er�it to that property. NAME �� "r_.�c . , -- � , P!AME AODRESS:'/ �, �-Y---�-( T r�r�i��i �� 1 � PHONE `,� �_� � � '� S� ,� �-_- �..�.-..� �"� ! �� ' � . . � ,..< < � Rugust 24th, 19EE Dear Friend & i�eighbor: _ .�I 0 I I_ C E On Thursday A.ugust 18tt�, 19�5: Tlie St. Paul Zonin, Ca�r�iittee n�ade a reca:r�endation to apNrove ti�e nonconforming use and Special Con�ition Use Permit to Russell anu Bev!�rlv �bErg of 1636 East Shore DRive to operate a Foster Care Hon�e for ten 1� Childrean up to 18 years of age. The Planning Canmission of St. Paul w�ill �eet at 9•00 P.. M. Frida Auoust 26 I;, 1988 or tiiE 13tn fl oor of bhe CQty Hal l annex �t 25 V1. �ti� St. to sCUSS e � er acceptance oF re�ection of tiie Zoning Carrnittee recommendation. This Meeting is open for your observation and we urge your attendance. If you cannot attend, eLEASE SIGi� THE PETITION and del i ver to Vi_ i 1 Me _er�at�1 F�,26 ,.E. Shore DRi ve Y or Arrnol d Jacobson at 1632 E. Shore Dri ve'�efore "f1 ��I�TNURSDAY �A�T'ST��''"�, If you are not able to deliver the petition personally, please call t1r. �4eyer at 714-2185 or �Rr. Jacobson at 776-459E=or 770-3761 and they �;ill pick it up. IT IS URGENT THAT 4�E HAVE THESE PETITIONS � UR HANO QY NOOP� HURSD Y OMORROW AS L!E �4UST ERING THEP•1 TO CITY NALL BE RE H R D 9:00 . P�G. Vr'e thank you for your hElp to preserve the value and desirabillty o� our , neighborhood. To the Planning Comnission City Hall & Annex 25 l°J. 4th St. St. Paul , Mn. 55102 We, the lJndersigned, disagree with the St. Paul Zoning Committee decision of August 18th, 1988 regarding the Application of Russell and Beverly Oberg of 1636 East Shore Deive, and are opposed to the granting of a noncon66rming use and Special Condition Use Permit to that property. NAME �f�-Z (�- � -- P!AME /��4%_-��"�_�___ __�'`/��_-�,� ___ - `� �� AODRESS� , � <? � i- PHONE �� . � � / • , �-�'�-'Lf�(6- / � � l�/P� '�ii P� GcicD�P-/`"i .-��c� 0 6J e,G� � �h� r�-�.-z_i� pY" �� J�o F. ��7c�r� �ri Y� /v��C ��o��-s s ��o�v� �� .l.%` ,Ai;�{��,�p� /�,�i � ��7� ��t,"'�- 1� rL( �/ / / `/� �'/I �--�G� ��r.c�< ;'' ,��.-�..._ 7�_ - j� =�� ,� . _„�.-/�4..tc� L%`-,'�i . ?7-� --��'. �< ��,� \�- . /��d-�,�. /�-l 0 (_ - S y a�1 F � Z . 7 7 � � �{ a � Z ��,:�r:.�% �;;'%_�� i� il� ��" � �� '`'Z • � 7 %_ ?S'3� ',,.-t >Ct�'��;. r� ` �� `-� C��' ��'�c,v, i�\- � �l � - I 11 C9 � t � tc; = �;1,�,� -.�,.�.c I `t 1 � � . % . �� ! ` �` =.,- ..� ,� ��,y �- ' . � r�i — 9/jI/ • - � . �g`� ��. ,� , .� , r�'r - Y,�� s� , � , .� r f) J �� `�� !,/A,�c� : �i/ •� � �� r � / /'y <<� ({%7 ��..'�l�T'�.�/'Jr • J�, v!^" i , _i "�).�I�' �i -=��. / '� `" � ``>� � ._..�.:�.ti.w,r-,� �S �-- � ,(/ > 1 . �77 - " j � / � � .-LC..�(.L c � � �,c c-t�r—r-� ��- `� �'J L C.�'' �- �_�i - •,;t—P-,--�->-- 1�SC� � . �-.��+�' � � ' ��' - � � � �►�!�:y, fi'� �?�G �� - �►�-�-: '��11 - �DS _:'� - � �� ,} , )��F' �,,1- _ `, ��.�., 7 71 - G.�io� ��.�"�.-��t.-�: �-,� -?�e�,�,- ; I�� d . r `771`� 7' e,�-' �:� ,��; ' - i��,� �. ,c�.,s��,��f� � - �3 3 - �s-� .�� _ - `1-t � ��-' �=�-�°� t r 7( � � �.d� �'f-� . ��71 - �T o� ^ .� _ , �' �! ��2 �� s�d�r ��-� v� �7 b `.�-� �z _ . �e - , �� , � . ,6�-�-- �� .�-� 7� � •- � �� c ; _ ,.�/�� /��a � ;� �� 7� ,�- y - t� � C��zGr- . --��i s�- �- -��-.-�-� �'r�r� . �-:�. , ,�- � � � -- _ ,�� _ /�- � � , ; ��,GZ: �y� � � . � �� ' ��., ,s-7 � � �" ��6 - a �°3 �� 'f= �� .�-�-� _ 1;j.��{�.1�,. �a',�� _:: .�?�,� �;�. 77�- •�"� ��' _�� { i _�( ( �,�` � �,�. �� 7,�r_%�JC.�4� �'�'�7.. .'� ' ' �, t' t,''t-t� ' •7 / � z - , �} �. , � � , �;�-� 1 �c� �{ � S_.�u�,�._ 1�� , � ' �— � ,;�,,.v.. -.- _ � �� _ :, , I y �' �r � ' � ._ �� ---` ± � 4• / �,�•r: ►.� er;! �r. ...:->L-iJrs � � /' �.- . �"�'✓:� �1 G. ��1��._•L:.•-c;�-� G � / � 'i J L.. ��t/�' ;� r � � /. � : � (� /,/ ' �� ' ��. � 7JL= - "`�`T 7 - ',��r;_ �.1. - 4 , C �'.!%� ., , , �. � i .� � . , ` �S i �'�� ,��.� �,; � � i�,i:'14. < %/ �I� c� ;�l�x� . `�� ' 7y %� ' � �� 9'7 f� �� r��{ %7L� -5/�-��:.� .�,�c�� :; � ��C��.,�►-- _ y l; .� �lt�,,. -,c--1�=f-.�r•�-. //`/7 � �y�f.� �� 7-7G -q�GZ. .. � , � - ,�t� '7 7 r.� -- CJ y v`~S ±},�,�;,,� �.��i�t;.- .�->- I�' � � ,5�7`t: � �, � / /�i , L-� _ � . ► � i � `�' � i < < 'l• !'� c _��ir'1��// '-�: ,._,,�� t -i�-t \ l �-C� , `(- ` '7 :( . � . , � � � � ' ��, � --, � ` ' "l C, {'%L t C" •/ � .__.�� . .� t��7 L' �� Z �1�. _ ) ��'--/lJ ; E- - �7" c�`'/ �'^ `�- � �� [� l � � a � � �, �-" -'- � � -�,�°` �—�. - � ��, - . �,� ,G�- r��r� / � � y �-- ` � C -� /- y�.� �.��u,�. `�� /Gs� �,�u�-l-� � • 7��/a j� a- 'l -. . � Gc - /' ��' �t_-��1. � [� �� l _ - $7 G,,�— . -�-a t . `- � � - � / / � � �.�,_-�_.1��- `��---' ✓�� r �� L_ ��L`��, I �� ( - 3 � ��S �•�'� , ' i� a. �� ` �� a 4 ?�� o�Z$�O //c%'�ti� ``"'��2,�.`-7,,�-,',-- �G i � �c.z```�� /�. �`�G '��G �� , �; . ; �-��;�, i� t.�:-��- r� � s� ,c;�.��s� ,� � ;�� .- -��. �q � � ��--�-� --�� ..�,,..�,,,..: I � � �� `"��a�;,�,:�-�--, -�;��-- � � � r- �W �3 � � ^ 7 4-,..�,�._ .�, �-��._� � � r `� �z.��.� .�.�� ; 7 I�-- r c:� 7.3 � �:�= �'f, a /��'� L � �- i��,�t_ j �7�- �s�3 � /s� Y /�-��..E;u.z�1 i 77� 8'f 3�/ ' ISrd-� Qc,�l l:� S�- � �zg ��3 � ' 1 �� ( I��,l�.� s'�-- j '77�''� Q l �.� l S�'�- � ��_ ; -7z £�r—c � � � L'�y /�op Dv<<i�.l� Sy� ! 77<o—�y� ! � 76 - . , - , ; . -•• /60 o v� �TSi �S � , 3� 78 % ,�.�_�;.�(� /U z- / �,c_�.�c_�--� � , �7 7�- 7 .�� ; . � _. � ��..��`. ��,�r-�� l� 3 � � �� - 77� 33 c�c"7"�, Y�� . �,.�ez - �l�� ,,c��.�c� ,,�- 71�- �� 3 �ti�rtc f k S/ 6� �u�cc.�k S f. 77F-- /d�// �'a�� 2��e�: /E `�� -�-��- �'. 77 �' �- /d'�/ 'r.�C�u.�%� � �.cti% �� 7 ,�.,w-�•�.t� S�' 7 7 '�--�� %�� - �� 1� � � -�, 7 7� --� � �y � � � �� R � � � f � -� �� l� . � � .�7" ✓ /.G�.6 �: �• : 77 y - aid' S �,,i<<.-�; :L.� �t1_ /_�- � ��,1';�.ff-�f�• ; �� /- �.��Y ,�Q,tir. �!,.LC�Q�•� /J`7r 8 �� f-� . ? z�( --�.�,r Y �,-� /,l"L� ��.�� S --�7�'-7�J h � e.ti- c�t,c t.� �� ,�-`:�'k�� 7 Z�- �s 3�j � . a�,Q,Q.�.�, /�n / y a�-�.�� /—� �3 9 v�,� /� � S� •C.f��,�'�.�- � 7 �—��3 9 • a �,,�n�� a��' �r..-�'-t.�� - Jf7l �/g- 5�0� �� - 3�.� / � � 7 -,,,. . _�� I To ^� �2.��'.-tz'�� 7-�l - -�� 7 � � . - � , � /. �� /• � t � \ f C� . . t. � , � t L ,� ) � l,.� -�' �--�r� �l c , C'' � t' � � �f(.._(' .�' ^ _ . /�' �__ �� , .. �-� _�� -� �.,��{.;�� -� /�� _ . �.�.z� -�-�� =- .� � . �_ ' SS l �� dh � /�' t�'- .�`Z � � �- � P , Z � y -� -- - - -- f `l 3 l{) �_}- � �v ? 1 3 S'�'� %�'� -� ��s-'�! ? ��T� s1� d�j� � 7 ��-� �/^�c .sT ,, � / � J' �� f l�%.�-�-��- .�d�" 77� -� �! `� � . � �� ,�L �� ,{-C� .77z-2 lo � � l� �, ��-i� u�F� �7�- ��a , � °� , �� y �� cs y .�:�� /� � � � _ � ��z� J �� ti�.. �� Q� � ` � -� > � - �3 �� . @ oo ��:03 1= � � �j11 - � s� �� a � � � �l 1�� 7 ��`" / � � n ,c�-�� l�" / a � � � A� � 1 . , ' �� I ��t U N D�S�s�v Gt� c�b.1£.�'t' '�-p �h E� . G�q,� � l � Zo nl r� A-�uS O� 1 (D 3� �. S1..oeE AQ• _ � /,. � j L�- ��%//� � �;.-C�; -�/ri �L, �li � �� L' 7 7/- 7`�3� ��C.'�.,1.-c�a' ��c �-f�.�� /G� y :: ��.�Et: �,�t`-� -�-� �7y - `7y�� -� �-.:F�? , ��-..,�� s:�l��-.---�c� 7��--��//� � � . !�',�.�.�� ' ,�;�-��: f� I 1r S^:3 ��q,z�� 7 'I� - � I � !c �� ..?�.i � � cS•�-�.cy,.�'Y�.�,.., �� S•-5 0,.,-U.0.'�nl�;,,Z, S�'C . "7� � - `t"� "1 � � � �..%� �� . -� �%�l�.,�z',�� 1/. 7 7 S' ' �-'� �� 4'i � . , �- _ ✓^;,�-�„�.t-,�' �%�-�,. � i � � ! c�-=..�.�-� �' � 1 �7 � .- �- �5"� �`'�� '� i�� 73 �'-�--��'� 7 7`� `�} �� ; , � _ �� ..��,�xt�� .�-� " � c/.� `ft��,��.�-� - � �f- � / � (�: ' ' ��'� � � 7y -��l'�'� 1� 'v�,f t`!, �rr'�� C��-XZ /�='��1- ��7''ll�= ''� % �'.C-%.., «:z�c,:..l� %� yf �L��,��`.�.c -�-f i 7"/ - s.�l.�S �, � '�/ �7 � ^� { � " �' "� �f� �-J 'C�^✓ l.��l w' j'�' "� / c ./�,r'i.� / . C ✓ �� i '� Ci,�.:J�- 7-��►�C�t�-•. /,� f��'ic2�c� .� �� ,j 5 . �/ � � I� �o � ' 77� -�'b sa.. -�� :..�c 1 ��,t., I(�� 7 G';;.f�—>-..-Z—�� y/�3�/ � � , ;,r� ��C`� ,j'��t�;:h- �C�J.,� �"� G��-�� ?i `� � J �/ / - �. �- ► t�z-�-� , -�-� �� SP�� , ' ;J / � 1 � ` .✓ �- / � �� , �- �•��=- �� /� r��. �� -- � /(l�'.� f ��! � f , 1 �:%. _� - — + �,�. _ r"�,�: 1,.,�,r� .� �-� �. _ C c� <_ n �,-ti I l L. ��; r . ./ �� , ' �c,�. / � y�- (,�,��C, ��— � � 4� � ��J� ��<.,�., ' .� � .� -�; ��-��:,�; � 1� � cY:� J�� ,� •-�.. � `. � '� ' � �' u4l� y� �y�';',r-�- �c l`.i:i- j� �: :�-:��i�c_: �77=�- ��-7--� . . �. �' `�'< < ' f _��- ��.7 � ,� �` � `��' ''�' � `'�� ` �{1�.Y+�..,, r�_ ._> �� - / �i�i. i1�+�� ;/ [t �:. �'� �� (� ,�rn'�� li. . � �� tv �' / . l� �J�, 'T'h�,c v u o�.e,s�9 N�.o o►�'� c�.� `�T'o -tl�,�, C�.Aw g E, �� Zx�N,Ng S`1�i4"Tv s o � � t�3� �. S�.o�.E (J R • N�1M � F} � s PNo�J � - /.s � _ 1�., �' � � � _ ,l '��3 �� -,,c.q 1'/C_ �� ;��'� �ti� , . �wu-�-� l5� I Gc�---�� "7�,�-3�$O � ��z- ��- ;v'�� 1.5�i 3 ��-�� 7 7 �i -//-=� _. �9Z1-^- `��,�vc'�''L �� 5 -�j�.1�r�-- �— �F�� ` . � �� . � , � �5 r � �4��. Srt �7 7 E� — � �.,e.: 3 - ,a -� /� z� C�i�r,�n��R ? 7�' - 0 3��j , Ci�. �� a� G�:�r�u.�ir �` `7��- 03�I �� 1 �6 �5 � �� .�f � �� y� t� - � �.,.� iasG �� o P�.`k�� ,, � � , �� o.� a l��y � �� = �s"�� ^ �- .-_ � �� ...:�.�., S T � ��a�- 7 �-�_ ._ � � l6�� 77�-��Z_ �� sa.Z � �7��5�-�c�- ' �;��.�F�G��J ��y� ��,��',�- 7��- '�� ' � - �� yy ��,�i�a�� _ �3�� . � � ��.� _ � � � _ . � � � �� o�a.� �d (�,�.,� /6 z z C1�,�.. ��y� -9g/� �,1�-� I � �� 7�c� - 3�� `��,(.�, ,6,� �l�!-/,��'� � _ � c�� '�1�C��.� . � � . .��2. c�- ►5�s 5 C�r�,,;,1� �1? � . ��fi,�� . � , �s �=/ r° � 77� � �93� � . . . '` ' 1 . . I � ' ; �,J�. -�.� v�o�.RSr9ti� ob, �.�.+ -T'o -c�.�. Ct,A��. � i� ZoN �ug srtA�'vs o � t�3cP � St,o�� Q� • � - �D s �►-�o � � '-t �7 � �� 0..w—�"�►�'c�l.,/?( - L'"�. , J� �' / [,�-'�.''�-,�,f-' � >� "�� .�o� �- ,." ,.. �, '�`/ � `� C..=r'��I'7!i `�s/,✓ / / v G� ��/ S"/. � -� 1j _// l y y� ' �� . �P � �fI�C. l��J �'�/E- /� �1� � �� "' �',� /��/ �� `r'� ��7�_��l�z�� l� � - " - �� , .,��.� is� � ��.�� y `1 �, � n' `' �L �x.� �' ��r�.d„Jl'� � �-�'�� =G'�u.-�-�,d� 7 7(s v��l � � � � � �-- � � �� t ��I��.�.v � � �c� C � .�,�-' / �.a s��,��L > >/�..3..� cG ��Q1�ct� �a-�s � Jv�' �.. ( � ' �� / .� �.;. I� ??l- `71� �_� ,,.,,,.,_ �� E..i� t, t � � 9 �.s�- fC. -�.D�� c� �j � ��- �-�-f— �� , 1 , � � l ` . .. � A.�irOUESTER COMPLETE(Items 1-5/ CITY OF SAINT PAUL � t DnTE OF REOUEST - � INFORMATION DISCLOSURE REQUEST & COPY COST CALCULATION FORM � ' 9 - 8 � Minnesota Government bata Practices Act 2 REOUESTER NAME ILast.F�rst.M� pEQUESTER NOTE: A Request Frequency---Prlvate Data on individuals.After you have been �r�� '�� shown the data and iMOrmed o(its meamn the data need nol be J ADDRES �if neeuedl 9� dlsclosed to you six months thereafter untess a dispute or action is } �. pending or addit�onal data on you has been collected. PMONE(�r nesded� B.You may be required to pay Ihe actual costs ol making,certifyiny a�d/or complling the copies of intormation requested. �. -� 38 � DESCRIPTION OF THE INfOFMATION REOUESTEO - �u3� ��f D � /.1.�_ . �� 5 REQUESTER SIGNATURE X B. DEPARTMENT/DIVISION COMPLETE 6.DEPARTMENTiOIVISION NAME 7 HEOUEST IiANDLEO BY .�" 8 REOUEST TVPE 9 REOU STEO OY ❑In-person ❑Ma�l �Phone ❑Sub� ol tr,e Eata !�J Nol tne subj.ot the date 10 TNE INFOiiMAT10N REOUESTED IS CLASSIFIED: 11.REDUEST �PUBUC ❑NON-PUBIIC - �Approved ❑DenieO ❑Approved in pan(explsm in 13) ❑PRIVATE ❑PFOTEC7ED NON-PUBLIC 12. AUTHORIZED SIGNATURE ❑CONFIDENTIAL x 13 REMARKS/COMMENTS(ll��puesrsd data Is Gassilisd so as to deny accsss ro fAe reQuester crte auM n1y or�eason. o enter any oMer remarks/commenfa approWiate�. C.�EPARTMENT/DIVISION COMPLETE WHEN FEES ARE ASSESSED _ (Comp/ete Pho�otopy line only!or fLAT RATEJ ESTIMATED COST ACTUAI (On/y Necessary fo�Mepaid) COST 1.Labor: X ........................ (NO.OF HRSJ (MOURLV RATE) X ........................ (NO.OF HRS.� (HOURIY RATE) 2.Photxopy: X ........................ (PHOTOCOPY RATE)• (NO.OF PAGES) 3.Mailing: 4.PubliCation Printi�g Cost: C-�-�u� �� ..................... lC' 5.Other costs,descriDe:(To include computer time,programming fime,ferminal access,video tepes, mitrolilming systsms and any ofher costs not listed above.) e. b. c. d. TOTALCHARGES � � AMOUNT TO BE PREPAID s 'See Admin.Manual for current rate. (50%ol EST. TO TAL i1$50 0►over) RECEI�T� AMOUNT DUE (Upon completion ol copying) $ ,(./�� PREPARER NAME DEPT./DIV DATE u.l,¢..� /.�i�.� �i�,c.� - rrQ w� 4 /g�d nisao��o-es� .. ! SPPD INCIDENT REPORTING SYSTEM HISTORY OF 0163E EASTSHORE DR FROM @1/01/87 —TO— 08/08/88 CRIME INCD CN DATE RUNAWAY 3000 @70�6603 01/17/87 SUSP ACTIVITY 0037 07�15693 02/@9/87 RUNAWAY 3000 @7023055 Q2/28/87 x OTHER A88AULT �B60 07024926 03/04/67 RUNAWAY 3000 @70�7499 03/11/87 RUNAWAY 300@ 070�9255 03/14/87 RUNAWAY 3000 �7Q44153 04/18/87 RUNAWAY 3@00 �7051924 05/05/87 MISSING PERSONS @040 07@57369 @5/16/87 MISSING PERSONS 0040 07057370 05/16/87 n OTHER A8SAULT 0860 07@594�7 05/20/87 RUNAWAY 3000 07068581 06/�8/87 RUNAWAY 3000 Q7�68B57 06/06/87 RUNAWAY 3000 07a87283 07/13/87 INVESTIGATE 0�70 07@90135 @7/18/87 INVESTIGATE 0071 07�90145 @7/18/87 TNEFT 0663 07@92887 07/23/67 � OTHER ASSAUL7 0870 07�93558 07/24/87 RUNAWAY 3000 071�9656 08/^c4/87 ALARMS 0036 0711�486 08/28/87 -�l�A[30 ASSAUI..T 0400 07116407 09/04/87 DOC — �e:ov�u� �� 2420 07119`''c63 09/10/a7 INVESTI[3ATE �'`'``�"` 0070 07123@62 09/17/87 RUNAWAY 3000 07144314 ill03/87 RUNAWAY 300ta 07148990 li/13/87 RUNAWAY 3000 0715�664 12/08/87 RUNAWAY 31d00 @7164631 12/�0/87 RUNAWAY 3000 08�09�82 Q�1/?2/88 MISSINQ PER90NS 0040 08029449 03/10/8$ RUNAWAY 3000 06033353 03/2�/8B RUNAWAY 3000 08045939 Q�4/17/89 RUNAWAY 3000 08@53988 05/03/88 RUNAWAY 30�0 - 08Q�59242 05/14/68 RUNAWAY 3000 08Q�60971 05/17/88 RUNAWAY 300@ 08063806 05/c�/88 RUNAWAY 3000 08�D78891 06/19/86 RUNAWAY 3000 0A083273 06/28/88 RUNAWAY 3000 08090247 07/09/88 RUNAWAY 3000 08�90248 07/09/88 � THEFT 0673 0A092790 07/14/69 RUNAWAY 3000 08097133 @7/22/98 �*+E END OF TRANSMISSION *+�* 41 INCIDENT (S> r.....,�j,.-, .. '' A� � 9 � � r--�-- ��rYlll �C. � Administrative Office � t 690 South Cleveland Avenue � , St Paul,MN 55116 5 Phone:699-6050 I 9 ; August 18, 1988 E : � Dungarvin, Inc. 690 South Cleveland Avenue � St. Paul, ZQI 55116 RE: License and Occupancy Status of Dungarvin III - Balbriggen 1270 E. Larpenteur, St. Paul, Mn 55109 I To Whom it May Concern: Dungarvin III - Balbriggen is currently a group home for six mentally retarded adults, owned and operated by Dungarvin, Inc. �tao staff persons live with the residents. The home is certified under the Federal Medicaid Program as an ICF/MR, licensed by the State Health Department as a Supervised Living Facilty and licensed by the Department of Human Services under Rule 34. Within the next 60 days the facility will downsize to five residents with a future plan to decrease to four should a resident choose to move or Ramsey County make the request . Concurrent with the downsizin.g to five, there would be a change in certification/licensure. The home no longer would carry the ICF/MR certification; it would continue under a Supervised Living Faciliy license and a Rule 34 license. It would operate under the Medicaid Waiver Program. Should you need any further information, please contact me at 699-6050. Sincerely, L[�.ti l.��l.t.Cti� J nice Carver Director � . . t � MISREPRESENTATIONS & UNSCJ$�TA�PIATED CLAIMS RE: ISSUANCE OF A NONCONFORMING USE AND SPECIAL CONDITION USE PERMIT TO THE PROPERTY AT 1636 E. SHORE DRIVE 1. The above stated residence is not a 3 story house. 2. The above stated residence does not have 21 rooms. 3. No proof was shown at the August 18, 1988 meeting of the zoning co�nittee of financial hardship when operated at conforming use. 4. Since Mr. Oberg works as a dispatcher for T.C. Transit, there is nonconfortnance to the adult to child ratio of 1 to 5 as specified in the Minnesota Department of Human Services Family Care License for a licensed capacity of 10. 5. 'Pestimony of Mrs. Oberg that there were neighbors in favor of the approval of stated permit who were afraid to appear at the August 18, 1988 heariag is refutable. 6. The Obergs' response to the computerized police call report did not address the facts of the report and did not satisfy their burden of proof. 8. A possible phase-out of Dungarvin home at 1270 Larpenteur Avenue was mispepresented and undocumented. 8. Citizens of the neighborhood were not notified of the heariagg before the District 5 meeting in regard to th� property at 1636 E. Shore Dr. 9. No evidence was offered as pertaining to compliance to fire codes at this property. 10. Noncompliance to existing zoning codes was evident and disregarded. 11. Statements cancerning an inability to set up additional Independent Living Skills facaliity at 1636 E. Shore Dr. could not operate without a nonconforming special usee permit were not substantiated with any proof or evidence. 12. The zoning coiRnittee failed or explore or discuss the fact that special permission of this kind can be given to a property owner only vs. the property. 13. There was a failure to state or discuss the staff report recomnendation to deny issuance of a change of nonconforming use and special condition use permit (refer to Zoning Co�nittee Staff Report). 14. There was failure to demonstrate that the property cannot reasonably or economically used for conforming foster care. 15. Failure to show that proposed use is consistent with health, safety, moral and gener� welfare of the communi�. 16. There was a failure to show that the proposed nonconforming use and special conditio use is consistent with the reasonable use and enjoyment of adjacent property. ; . ' 17. There was failure to show that modification of the distance requirement will prevent concentration of comRnunity residential facilities in the neighborYiood. 18. There was failure to show that establishing nonconforming status to allow a foster care home for 10 residents not meeting spacing requirements for camnunity residentaal facilities is more appropriate then a former nonconfo=ming duple�. 19. There was failure to shaw that the facility has operated �ithin zoning guidelin�� and therefore cannot be ex�cted to do so in the future. 20. The Zoning Comnittee has not complied with their own ordinance regarding the minimum distance of 1,320 feet required between group family hanes. I /'�� _>"i -J"' ♦ /� ' j t� „� �„wi..r .fi.;..�` . V t. �°' • . t"�ii� IS THE STATBMENTS BY VIRGIL MEYER AT THE ALIGUST 18, 1988 MEETING OF Tf� ZONING CONA4ITTEE AT THE ST. �4UL COUNCIL CHANIDERS I am Virgil Meyer, 1626 E. Shore Dr. My wife Shirley and I have lived at this address for 15 years. . Tf-IE We are opposed to the granting of a nonconforming use and special condition use permit to Mr. and Mrs. Oberg to establish a foster care hane for 10 children for the following 5 reasons. 1. The Oberg residence at 1636 E. Shore Dr. is situated on a narrow lot measuring 45 ft. of frontage along E. Shore Dr. and a depth of 187 ft. for a total lot area of 8415 s�q. ft. and shares an easement driv�eway. Their home is in an �eeaq- area zoned R-3 one family residential. A spot use €ele� for this special coeudaltion use permit in the �}��e middle of a block and surrounded by one family ho�nes is not conducive to sound zoning g�ae practices. (REFER TO MAP) 2. The zoning comnittee staff investigation report dated August 11,1988, page 2 paragraph 9 states and I quote. (READ PARAGRAPH 9). 'Plie Oberg residence does not comply with a minimum distance of 1,320 feet required for zoning lots used for community residential facilities. 3. Prevailing evidence shows that the issuance of a nonconforming and special use permit g�aev provides an inroad for the wholesale issuance of such permits. The Oberg residenc�� could become a magnet for the deteriation of the R-3 one family residence of th neighborhood. 4. Information in file 10343 shows that the Oberg residence is at this time in violation of the present City of St. Paul zoning ordinance because of the occupancy� of over 6 children. In file 10343, I would like to read from a hand written statement signed by Beverly Oberg (QUOTE). Addit�onally, I would like to read from the mmnutes of the Land Use/Zoning Co�nittee meeting, June 1,1988, which is not in file 10343. (QUOTE) This is in excess of 6 children permitte� under R-3 zoning regulations without a special use permit which todate has not been granted. 5. The Oberg's capability to adequatedly supervise 10 individual children is questionable especially when each has special need requirements. To support this concern I have in my hand a camputer generated report from the St. Paul Police Department covering the period January 1, 1987 thru July 31, 1988. This report identifies 41 separate and indivdual , � incidents in which St. Paul Police were dispatched to the Oberg residence. (READ SOME) With the number of foster c�re children increasing to 10, the niunber of incidents could double to 80 or more St. Paul Police dispatches. One family residences should not hav�e to be subjected to such undesireable conditions. In�iew of my stated reasons, and the petition signed by 134 people, I request that the zoning comnittee to deny the issuance of a nonconforming and special condition use pennit to the residence at 1636 East Shore Dr. ! DONALD W. KOZA, M.D. 1171 E. Idaho Ave. St. Paul , MN 55106 � August 24, 1988 RE: Testimony given before St. Paul Zoning Committee on Thursday, August 18, 1988 at 8:00 P.M. in the Council Chambers, St. Paul City Hall . The following is my information given at the meeting of the zoning committee as recalled from my notes: IDENTIFICATION-I am Dr. Donald W, Koza. My wife, Lorraine,and I have lived at 1171 E. Idaho Avenue for twenty and one-half years. The back of our yard abuts the yard of the Oberg home. STATEMENT- We are strongly opposed to the plans of the Zoning Committee of St. Paul to change the status of the Oberg house at 1636 East Shore Drive to include non-conforming zoning changes as well as special condition permit for 10 children. The first problem is that this foster home has been illegally operating over 4 years with more than the 6 children legally permitted for this zoning of R-3 (one family residential ) We also emphasize that the provider lost the status of duplex home by not continuing its use as such for 365 days after they purchased the house. Thus the information given by the provider : that her house is a duplex (or triplex) with individual sections being paid for by the Ramsey Welfare, is also illegal . WE have only learned at this time of the illegal licensing of this home for the last four years. Only today did ` we learn of the use of the home as a duplex to take care of two sets of � children for the Ramsey County Welfare. i SOURCE OF THE ILLEGAL LICENSE FOR FOSTER CHILDREN CARE HOME- We are still s pursuing the department and individuals that passed on this illegal stamp of � approval on this yearly application for a license to care for more than 6 foster children in this home located at 1636 East Shore Drive. It appears that the County Welfare Department urged the providers to request this hearing after the errors in information was found. I am looking into the State of Minnesota, Dept of Welfare position in issuing this license regularly. I believe they receive all of their information from the Ramsey County Welfare Department and that the licensors of this department and the providers were probably in error. Also as I look over the license, as issued, I note that they require a ratio of one adult to every 5 foster � children. These providers are Mr. and Mrs. Oberg. However, we know that Mr. Oberg works full time and sometimes overtime at an office. He most commonly works at night time. As a result he is away from home when the children are most apt to cause the rumpus requiring the frequent police calls already listed = for you. Thank you for this courtesy. Yours sincerely, ��'; � L.'a=sc.� `�i: - . .,� �� DWK:hs Donald W. Koza, M.D. _ B:OBERG.O1 774-7234 (612)771-8705 � � � � r; � '..� r�`� � ,v r � �Llcil.;5� ��ti1, ��u STATEt;EtiT TG ST. PF.UL ZO,JI��G COi1�1ITTEE-A;�{�roxirr,ately �:00 F. :�. �,u�ust 1Fti�, 1�8E T0: t'�,Ga�,� Ciia.i r��.ar�� : r:er�;:ers cf ti�e �t. Paul ?onin� Cai.,n�i ttee: R . My r?.��c is �r��ol� ,'aco!.so�;, "fy ti�,i�'� ai��' I >>�ve livec a.t 1632 � . Shcre f:rive for �E> years, and I hGvE !;�en a licensed real estatE �-�rcker far ovEr 40 yEurs. I CL;IC.UR I��ITfi E�.LL nF TFiE FkCTS /'S STFTEiJ �,Y ('F. VIRCIL i"�EYEi�: In auc'itien, it is a ��E11 !<no�ii fact tf�<<t a cti�nge in zoning fron; a R-3(siggle fa�t�,i 1y resi c!ence cl assi fi cnti or�) to a norconforr:ing use ar��d SFeci al Cendi ti on GsE Pe n�i t, H:o�l c: re�uc� the ��s i rati 1 i ty and val ue of al l of the hares i n the surr�ur:dine nei�hk�cr�iood. I have in r-�y hard a copy of t��e 13E petitioners, includif�e E of ;�<i�i c� �re prcpertv o�-��ners ahutting t�� ber� prorerty, that are in strony e��ositior, ta the rrantin� of t!�is char�ne of Zcning. i'y ouestior is? :•!no acid ��'i�.i: agency v:�as responsit:le for tl�e issuine: of a license to Russell and °everly C�:er� at 1G3E E. Si�ore f)rive to operate a foster har:�e for 1C c�iilc'..ren w�t'�out firsi cl��eckinr• tf�c le�ality of the 7_oning requirc,�er�ts? Tt:is licer�sE t-!as lust issued on FeL�ruary ZGti�, 1?e� tc� run until P�arcn lst, 198�. F.� tne pr�s�nt ti,�>E t`�is �;oc�e is in vielatior� of itslicer,sc c+ue to ir�,�roNer Zo,�ing. �t; t��is t��sis, I �;ant to request a denial of the Ct��ergs AY�lica.t��n to change ~ ti�e zoninr fror� R-�(one far�ily r�si�ential) to a r:onconf�r��inc use and Special 8��i�� Ccndi ti on i.,'se Fern�i t far tlhYi r pro�erty at 163G E. Shore �ei ve. i;iuitk you -. � _ .� .�dl ,.- � f , l �