88-1999 WMITE - C�TV CLERK
PINK - FINANCE GITY OF SAINT PALTL Council �JJ V/� /�
CANARV - DEPARTMENT Xa � /��V
BLUE - MAVOR File NO. V �
C ncil esolution
Presented By r�
Refe d To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
WHEREAS, on TJovember 21 , 1988 the Division of Public Health
for the City of Saint Paul ;_ns�ected tne property at 474 Bidwell ,
Saint Paul , P�linnesota, and determined that a nuisance exisied
on said property consisting of a large accumulation of trash
and refuse in the interior of the dwelling structure thereon;
and
WHEREAS , the Division of Public Health on November 22,
1988 sen� a written order �o Sylvia Lee, the owner of the property
per Ramsey County Lax records , directing that she abate the
nuisance by November 28 , 1988 ; and
WHEREAS , on November 25 , 1988 Sylvia Lee appealed said
order of the Division by filing a no�tice with the City Clerk;
and
WI�EREAS , the City Council on December 8 , 1988 conducted
a public hearing on said appeal and upon consideration affirmed
the Division' s cleanup order of November 22, 1988 and determined
that �he nuisance be abated by December 15 , 1988 ; now, therefore ,
be it
RESOLVED, that said order of the Division directing the
abatement of the nuisance at 474 Bidwell is affirmed except
that Sylvia Lee is given until December 15 , 1988 to complete
the necessary cleanup ; and, be it
FURTHER RESOLVED, that in the event the work is not completed
by December 15 , 1988 , the City may proceed to perform or complete
the necessary work with the costs incurred therefrom collected
in the same manner as provided by law.
COUNCIL MEMBERS Requested by Department of:
Yeas Nays
Dimond
�� [n Favor
Goswitz
Rettman � B
Scheibel A gai n s t y
�
Wilson
/�C '� � '� For Approve by Cit rney
Adopted by Council: Date ���- �
Certified Pas Counc.il S et BY• �
By
A►pp ed by iNavor: � � 6 l9w Approved by Mayor for Submission to Co il
By
P�.:�� �;L.�,, :l ° ����
' . , 8�'- t��'-��
�#.0 014187
Communitv Services DEpARTMENTi
Steve Rov CONTACT NA�SE
292-7771 PHONE �
� December 8, 1988 DATE � .
ASSIGN NUMBER FOR ROUTING ORDER: (See �everse side.)
1 Department Director ' Mayor (or Assistant)
3 Finance and l�anagement Services Dir�ctor 4 �itp Clerk
Budget Director , � : C��y Ceuncil
2 City Attorney
TOTAL NUMBER OF SIGNATURE PAGES: CClip all locations fQr signature.)
WHAT WILL BE ACHIESIED B� TAKING ACTION �N THE ATTACHED MATER�ALS? (Purpoaa;lRationale)
�
Resolution reggrding 474 Bidwell and a�firming the Division''s clean-up order of
November 22, 1988 and determining that �the nuisance be abated by December 15, 1988.
If the owner does not clean the proper y by December 15, 1988 the Division of
Public Health is directed to complete �he necessary clean-ug.
Public Hearing Held before City Counci]� on December 8, 1988.;
�
;
COST/BEAIEFIT. BUDGETARY. AND PERSONNEL tMPACTS ANTICIPATED: -
Cost of saidd clean-up i€ completed by ;the City will be col]�ected by assessing
the property tax roles. No personnel �mpacts are anticipated.
i
; �
;
FINANCING SOURCE AND BUDGET ACTIVITY NUfiBER CHARGED OR CREDITED:
,
(Mayor's signature not required if unde� $10,000.)
� Total Amount of Trans�ction: Activity Number: Q3226
Funding Source: j
ATTACHMENTS: (List and number all atta�hments.)
1. Reso�.ut�on
AD1rtINISTRATIVL PROCEDURES
_Yes _No Rules, Regulations, P;ocedures, or Budget Aatendment required?
_Yes _No If yes, are they or timetable attached?
DEPARTMENT REVIEW CITY AT�ORNEY REVIEN
_Yes _No Council resolution required7 Resolution required? _Yes No
_Yes _No Insurance required? Insurance sufficient? �Yes _No
_Yes ,_No Insurance attached? '
�
;
;
�
i
� { ( 1 { f : ������4 xf
��e ���' -. f t�..� - . " - ��` � ' ,i; '' .e1
�� � . .. � _ -� l � `r
�� '� � � � , r �d ';
� s � � � � ��,
� '�� 1 t. ;:� �k�'
F \ y , . "'s � J � � . _"�-'p } ,,� M�
1 \� ( � • # � , �� 4 .�
� � i'!. 1� �'. F � � �` t _ � �.
�L; J ��� 1�� g��. / i 1 `"� -' +. .��� � r �l
i n �
.rv �� :.�' . . �.
� . ' �� �. . l. �. . - .
i �. f „ .ta ' �4 ; 'i
� �.�': . � , ��� � � �I
� . � _ �;�,ij.��,�L� �t.� /',� �i `,.. - � �„
` f a _ �'' �`• � " �; # ,; �',4:t .� "�3
�; �. `, t'''t + � ' � x � '` �
r � � , i _p, � � .'�x
,r �' �. . r } � ,;:
�' � • - e ' ' :
� yraiD+ �"���'�r1Y� r�� � � `�� r'a��,� 1 �-. 4 i ^.
�.i3.��1!�'� . �i� - � {.. ` �" r ��"
¢a . ��tl. '�..�.. �� �i� p' � T,�'� A - Ja .�� a�d';
Y � � ..; y.- i : 7 �,
s ���y� ���� � +,�'R fi',�R� .��, • � � t t• � 'i
"5 °,{.JG' - . � �� v } v • .7 $ '. F
� ,.`$1i �.� �f�+�s���� ,hCi�.+L9'8 ��t1�d1."�t�Q �i �MIIk��,'�a �� ±1��.�� Y
`,�c.1�� i� �'-t:i��: ¢�a"t�ei� '. , � �;�i���'�+c�a� +� �!lN�►,�i�;�� a� !�. ' `� , u'
,� ��� .�o; �ri�` :7� '��tb.:.� �uiu�a�;;�r�: �' �'��. �, ��.�� �, ° �,
,, ��" � ���►#��`'-!�.' pr�'' ` �� ��"��d��,��M�, �,� °1,►�j�-�i�t�' �� '
tit� �Ct���'wii���St�a#�� ��tir�. F <
r
; � , . _ ` , � ,
�y �0����: .'v r.
���1 � 1 4' j c \ � �y ''
�• �,�`'�Y� * �.�
9 ti �^ f y ?. �! � y, '.,.,� h l 5+ �( � f 4 rt
�•.Ds �� ..� �� t �3Y 1� 4!t
����.��� - , � �. '
�:. � 'j s i � y � ` �'�
� j��, ,�� ;� :f4: € �
> / . :, ' '�"'i �Y' _ ,�;.n ,�
�' � . �`��i �.� K� � 1 ' � '���h �' .n' ay '; \ .�( .'s� �
+ �' . �'.�1i�11��.�J�MIy���tt ° , ' �"�
6 ' Y, . � � �� � j � �•
E4c � �� �'������ ' � I I Y { � `��
-� * �"` �' �i!sal�'� �+�i�1 - ,, #;�.
,14���i���'�����������M .1 . .� + .�f��` ` r A f :t ��
( _ t .4�1$
{ b' �'rC �h yy Y 1 _ .:" �"y
,, ' '�- .! a � e".� ��x ``�,
, �
.r,. F� ' �' �"� ,� f � � �:t �, � ;
' F� N^," . ` ' q[' .`�C. k _�� i t '1 f��"�'c.�
F.� , t :�� f �:1 �,Sf � ! j{
j � N 0.
� j �_�� � � t �i� R ��i
/ � �� ��, ,S , J � ' � '��
� * ' -3 �� i � 1, ��k �t
� � , ♦ �j+1 w w _� ;-
'r � � � ' s� v �
` ' , ",� � .�i r � r ; \ �,�c��
{ �
,� { '', - , ��..
�-�. � ,� �) t` 1 �1 1 / ��. 2 7'.
� f' r .i �
. � 'S , ( +' ! '�V i''.
` l ! � ..3 \" { 1 � $�L
I• . � .� .. �', '.y. ���{ :�
y I . .��" ` N �� ! `f'� l /i� � ���
. � S� / � N s t ����
,. .. .. ,. � <
� � . . .. -S F � ..
� .
�
... , � . '. �: � ;., .. �. t
1, n!T,d`
i""
�
.� :,. .. ..,. . . . . 4 ;. . .. . ,.
,
.
e� .,.' �� • �.',. . ..S ... . . �:'-�.• . y .,.: ^.."�„`. '. . i �.:.� ,
. ` +. - �Cf`"j� �'J
� . .
' " SUAAMAR'Y ABATEMENT APPEAL APPLICATION
� t �
'` Requestir�g a t�eeMn� before City Council to appesi a summary abatement order
MiJST BE FlLED W THE CITY CLERK'8 OF�lCE. ROOY 386, CITY HI►�I,, 9EFppE THE ARPLA�. DEADUNE
APPLICANT
Nam�_ �y�V'/A /.� � //—o?.�"��
,__,_„__,.__, Date
Address ,�TT7` � •�� 7 ���YO� Hom� Phone
��'c�J�l(J tiJ, /�/,� Daytle�ls phon� —
�p Cod� �5�/O�-
ORDER BEING APPEALED - ATTACH COPY
From whish oific� _ �il'hJL�O� . L��4�.T(-� • Dat� mati�d_��o�o���"
Reyardin� propecty at ��� �/d Gc�E� A U �_ Deadlin• L�"o2�' ��
Issu�d to � Y�1�/i4 �•�E
+-�
Vlmat �s app�l�t•s k+t.n� M tn. property �Grl�tJ v�„
� .�
REASO!'N FOR APPEAL
`�EG�dt�s� �r�l -E,4so�cJs i9-8�E '� C',�C�.tc,cl' P
-r �
��o P�,�.r� '3 � ��ao��xJ� �- - - - .
�
�
�
�: ��::.::.:::.
�,��r�.�.,rw[#:.�.. ♦� ..'� • •u .C,4:tv'. .\•:?':
`':?::::;�.'.�i�.w• �+.. �`�;. ., \S� ti�;.�..;�r�.
k:;x .� ... . �{. '�;t;?i
���� �k•, ` }\ \\`� 4� ,\ '�� `���..t��
�fio�.. 'x �;�. �•. �'� .�4�����.�. �:C �'��:ah.\1,;,;sC,.;.''.
,'�1 '�:. •`�. :`. 4, ` 'i t: 4;:
:`::\::i`i\'+,�'v':�.1�\:. \•,�;•.1 . K'`'2. •ti •`., ...,.` • .`�., . .
�,.•;,s •�:'::.,v \ .�� �`, \.� \ � \�.a.,{4,,,...\o::•� \'<',::::i>?i
�.� • . � �t� +x... �:.*� k
''' �\��.'�.. \ t. • • \}h� h • `�'�,',��.,.. �vt `t4 .�\., �' }. �V'f'T.S�\ �' 'Qi��;'i:ii.
u�,i.�,}yt �. ��a����:
.�7.FJ,.,.,•.F'�lS.�,'..�� ••��.. \ qYt. .. '4\\•.,_. . � �4\ �• 4�ytii*y\}tii„}}.,
L . , i�., . � 14��;;::::Si.,
`ii�':.ii'�'.1,:�tij.;\.�n:•.:P :N:C\:' ' 4 i:Ei:•.\..'Q�'?. •'..h\.\?n'�\A��' \,' n.`F:•.:� ��. vi�.''�X�' . . .:::..
•��.�+.�••�• v\�'v\\ti•\Li:.ii:
:;'•:y., '�.��' vv\., ';2�\��tiC�•'4• 4 • '\ \t\ •`2i '\ • '\ ' 4 ti\ . .
;:;:Ri::•`•';... y; �v:i�a,.+.. ...��.,,•.'�. `.L;.... �' `�'r`'u.'.,`��,r\: .'�}n�..+. , ':'C�` . k �. \-: �:k::.`.'
,, •ti t ..ti, k`C �..y. . ,.\ .`+.:.�:. \.t.. :�. ,.�,�..:�;k:'���':::;<:
:k; 'r\ k � ,e� ''k �' 'y ,t:a:•:�`%R:.:
:::4. • ti. 1 \.. \�'•'.:�ii�n .
Vv. :: £ �� + [� �. . \..
;;::�:.. .�� �'.+......:
;��. `.�.��'. >
.s�
�4�.
+? \
�
��.�
�\
...... .
��::.�. `
..... .
:::::: • . ••.
......... . . ~
........
....... � yy{
:^::•>::? . .
v
`•��;:#*:#�� •:�:.•'.:
����<�i :.>;�.. �
. .; ,.. .. �.,
........ +�, .. .
:�.:_.:::.: ,..,.. .
...................1vv�•m:%vv:•... ::O:.:•.::i:.v`>::.•.:v.;M1..;.;i........::.t�:j: ....26vti.�.• ...:....................•. ... .........\�. .. \\\+:�vv::
.....:....�..��..... . . . � M1. .1...... , ;.v...\n..,-�..v.,..v n..;n.. ......�.......'.�.v�A.. M.... ..�.. ...\�\•.�i�vv �' '�. „�:.n�!
qT\Sii•:\:4 i.\`•?i\::•'2. \;: v.).�y� n �'+'+��\. :}}��k.:nv�.\':P�•i�\C:i;
>Sti^ii�\:::vS:.�::L:i\i ': (,} �y ., n.�\'ti ::�\:4C♦ .,:L\1•:i•`.r•\\�i?4�:
\..,.v., . }'•1. . �1S� <>� ' �k. *i�..:.\��.:i�'.•:::.•�.
�.i ti��� ' � .\�..
�:::.::.�:::
:ii?:C•:ii:v: . • . j� �F
......:.... • •j, ��
�\.} �,.�., . � �'.�' ... : :�R;. "1T Gl:' 4 ��v�:v
......... . .. . .:
.:...::::.v..v..,....� .::•. :i ' .' .
-::...........:.�t,\.k\�..:'�•. � �••.�' ., . . • .'•..,4.:��:. '�. ,,� •.�� �♦ �.:�`.``.. '•:ti`.'.?:� � �.:.•;�+:
;�:�<:;\�'`,,.. ;`16w'�p''�v::�id,":;;';�::'..•, .}: + ��,••\��r,.. .�.::\ti'•w ..� \•:���•� ;:'�."�• \;`'+; 'a, �.+. • .4\•.>\. ,k�n.\;',::k.
..::::.�::::.: 1 . ��: .
. + .
..:::....:::..: . . �:� . , ., .
..�.
tC"vt.v�'�ii:i�.n..v.. \\'� �. v 'i . v .. �. \�. � ...\�. 4 ' v •:+� . � ��'��'•.\ . `.. '•yk.;n•\ �\+k.+ .'v\:v.�.•�+}•Lyi:
�y;.�.
� � . �\ . ' .. . .. �_
� +__y y
y � �
;r.
, �
' � .
��
INSTRUCTIONS TO ClTY CLERK'S OFFICE
1. Do not accept application after appeai deadiine or without copy of orders
�.�.... '�"�� �..r.. The�appeai deadline is 7 days after
SUMYARY ABATEIAENT ORDER �
T� the date mailed, or the same as
�
T. --
M---�^—�� the deadiine given in the order
. yww�lr�M�W ri�Y�MY�����'
wh�ehever comes first.
■rrr�w�wwr w �i3ww�a�w
� .rMt t�..Unw..w.lr� �M�/rq r...r..e f� . �
r wrAY�M fn����I• . MM) .
� �ML4/I!TO C01M1.t MN KN
"`°""""°°'"""°°" `'""` 2. Within 2 weeks, set hearing date
� N yw irr►N����N�N4.M wNY�MU r M�MA� �
��°�"""""" '"""' '�'�" ""'"''""'"' and place on agenda
reY rr wr w.r.r rrw.nw�w w aru�..r b+�..x�+�wr�.w
e.qr.rr.r.w.wrwrrw irr.ir..rrw..�..arrw�+�waw.ti.
�-��---�K���~'�~'� Mark hearing date on front of
va.�re�reww�rr.nwwi�aro.�na�.`�waaurw.�./r+.w an�a
m.rra�ru,.wrrr s�a+w ww rr.M�w�r��r wr rw t��M�R
�n.ay..�+wir�wr�:�a..�.w�r wre.wa..�.wn�+.+.�wr+�.� �p�l '(�tl�ll
.�w�we..r..n. .r.ww.wau+ww
3. Determine the City Council district and ci#izen participation district ,
in which the nuisance is located (census tract is marked on order)
Mark nuisance location and districts on the front of the application
in the shaded area
4. Send notice of hearing, with copies of application and order attached, to:
1. The applicant
2. Any other party to whorn the summary abatement order is addressed
3. Office which issued the order
4. District council office for the district where the nuisance is located
5. Counciiperson's office for the district where the nuisance is located
5. After hearing send copy of the resolution to the same parties that
received the notice of the hearing
4-23-87
c� i w. y
� EPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY SERVICES
�` " DIVISION OF PUBLIC HEALTH '� 1 �Q
._�ate of Ir�poc.�on: - ����/Ii�ONMENTAL HEALTH SECTION Da�Mailed: � w
� 555 CEDAR STREET
, Date Issued:. ST. PAUI.. MINNESO'f�A 55101 By: CT:_ .
2�2-7771
SUMMARY ABATEMENT 4RDER
To Address �� �
To Address
To . Address �
As owner or person responsible for: 7L /l
� '
you are hereby notified to eliminate the foilowing nuisance:
�
If you do not correct the nulsance by or fl� an appeal, the Clty wlil
correct the nulsance and charge all costs agalr�st the property as a speclal assessment to
be coilected in tha sam• way as propsrty taxecs. (appsel Informatlon below)
FAILURE TO COMPLY MAY ALSO
NECESSITATE COURT ACTION Issued by:
If you have questions regarding this or,der, the requirements or the deadline,
you may contact the inspector by calling 292-7771 between 8 and 9 a.m.
You may appeal this order and obtain a hearing before the City Council by �ling a written request with
the city cierk before the appeal deadline which is the deadline above or seven calendar days after the
date mailed� whicMever comes first. No appeals may be �led after that date.
You may obtain an appiication from the City Clerlc's Office, Room 386, City Hall� St. Paul, MN 55102.
The�#elephone number is 298-4231.You must submit a copy of this order with your appllcetlon.
;:::
r
If the Ci�y corrects the nuisance� the charges will include the cost of correction� inspection� travel time,
equipment� etc... The hourly rate wiil be around $120.00.
4-23-87
• . . �� � 1 � ��
LAW OFFICES OF
BENJAMIN M. KAIL
DE6REE OF NONO� BLD6.
SAINT PAUL. MINNESOTA 35f01
TELEPMONE 612-291-80/4
December 6 , 1988
Albert B. Olson , City Clerk
City of Saint Paul
386 City Hall
Saint Paul , M2nnesota 55102
�
Councilmember James Scheibel �C����Q
716 City Hal.l ��'C
Saint Paul , Minnesota 55102 �� �988
��rr
Mr. Frank Staffenson CLF/�jC
Health Division
555 Cedar Street
Saint Paul , Minnesota 55101
Gentlemen :
Re : MS . SYLVIA LEE
Property : 454 Bidwell Avenue
Saint Paul , Mn .
Ms. Sylvia Lee , 273 Dayton Avenue , Saint Paul , Minnesota,
55102 , has retained this office to represent her in the
above matter wi�h respect to cleaning up the refuse at
474 Bidwell Avenue. Attached is a copy of the letter
of the City Clerk of December 1 , 1988.
Ms. Lee is over 70 years of age and supports herse7.f. As
the hearing is set before the City Council on Thursday ,
December 8, 1988 , I will not be abl.e to investi�ate or
prepare this matter for hearing, and I sincerely request
that the hearing be continued for sixty days to see that
this home is sufficiently cleaned to comply with the law.
Very truly yours ,
lc�� ' ���E,°'"
, /"�/
Benjam�n M. Kail
BMK/bms