88-1997 WMITE - CITV CLERK �
PINK - FINANCE GITY OF SAINT PAUL Council L��3 .� �94 �7
CANARV - DEPARTMENT
9LUE - MAVOR File NO. Q
City Attny/PBF3 Council Resolution
. �� �lo
Presented By ✓����
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
RESOLVE?�, that the on-sale intoxicating liquor license and
all other licenses held by E .S .W. , Inc. dba Easy Street West ,
Daniel Eichinger, Pres . , for the premises located at 616 Como
Avenue in Saint Paul are hereby suspended for a period of ar�-�
^°�~°°�'-v�� day� , bPuinning on the following date : �/a-�v�}2Y
l �
This P�esolution and the action taken herein are based on the
facts contained in the attached police reports . Such facts are
not conte�ted by the licenseholder, as is evidenced by the
attached letter of I�Zr. Michael Whalen, attorney for the license-
holder. The action taken is also based on the facts , circumstances ,
and argur_ments presented by and on behalf of the licenseholder.
COUNCIL MEMBERS
Yeas Nays Requested by Department of:
Dimondf�
�o�' In Favor
Goswitz
Rettroan
��;�� _ Against BY
sonneai'
Wilson ��Q
p�C � 5 It7V�� Form Ap oved by ity ttorney
Adopted by Council: Date '
Certified Yasse ncil ,ecr y gy �f /ll� �
By
Approved by a r. Date '� R7W Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
gy By
P{��� D c C `' �: i988
. ;,� , �''�'V ��1C_'`�.
,
' � � � � ..,.._�._.,,..-�.�.._...,.�..R
i
I�,;�' �-. ,
������� �-:r,
�..�,,
r�GV ti� �ss�
'�'��'� , .
:. ,� �- ;-r
t1`� �1 � y�'-,L� _ ..
, •� 4,
�
�U�/�i:C..i:./•.:L .. c� �.���i:j
��� _....j ;�: ;. '.i. ! .
. L t . ,.,�.• . ..�t.l w � � -
'._..�.._ li.. :,.;._. L1.i..1 :aLt.Olil�3�I
. _�! +..1.. ,1 . �
�:1 i
.... . :��1�.� ..:� ��i�t`,:
�S �7iL11� _;♦ i j'.�.. . .
r�.7 cl.i.:.i`�.�.:i i 1: i i t:j' t�:.i:�,:i�'t..:�;
:?�z �;:�;�, 'Ci:c. �,/u/a �:ac;y StreQt L�ar,
�..j*i '�',v:�:0 [:VL.I�s:
;• .,, -•: i , �, ,�_
.�.� i � ` .G• ..5. `.s3.
:�;z.:tl' . i,l! .
�� ,�� �.:.v.r, *_':i.; .:i�:�; L•��� :r::�:::►�:� _:a�� „�:.r--�::: . .t�.
:.''�1`.3i�:3:i� �U UCl� �i:�C:li: LOiIV�:i':��C1O:.'cY� .i��<2:^.�t:' .)L: i.i.iV.l:i�'.�.� 'ti1cl�
.,
:�ar �lia:s:. r,a:: :���:�ori::ciu a.ic:' .iirL.:c�c.i �:s �c, :.�a.ai: r:.�
•�11f}��11:lOIl:3 �:�ilt �i: a�:1ij' ?1� �J�liS �li�;; ::.ir :i�i.2.�1 tl� u:e�lt.j
:24'�:«i,:3 tll::i]Oi1L" :i �:i;BCai.�]:JJ.E: •yd•,l,�il;ls LiL�::;i,C. •
�`:IZ�2ie: i'JU ::U� lrGl:L a5::1:it3:2Cc: :.tt' ' • '1. �s .�;7 L,�1
.t.. ::i i:l t:. .',.. ;y
;
�+t��`.iQl. �'
, 'lviat23 Vc: � Li�2J. I�
_ ��
- J
/
�
���Cil:lE31 t:• �i.11.�.�,.'71
3
I:I�k7/c:a,;z
: cc:: '�avi:3 �:c3ii:�ger
' !�'�� � �i /� -�1.c-V �'Ll/ - �
�SJ cn' � � 1C �, /`r e �r� �-r�L/
h�► / . /�.��� ��u�,�� �o �o , �'
� n� t
, �\
i
-----_-____--_------__�-__ -�- - ...K........:.�.,..�,.
� g�� ��'�? �
_ ' r
� ' ' � �. �„ „
� y� ' � . . , °;o• ` s • a � N `o � '�
_ - o • . . .,�u � .�.. f et 0+ Oi C �.:i.<J � Z o � r o ,n
c . . • -�. �r o, s rr e-r v+ -n ' D ` N o o$ cn i
T y � ' • � 7 VI (� p � � �� � ) � �
� �-+- 3 3 �- c � a � --i, � m
.-. ° - � . � � c °' � � --� � � a � y ..�_.r � r' o =
y w ' — _ � . . � o �G r+- E a. c� �- � fl. m �' ^�z � o ��
G'�� - � — - � ' ? � �.. rp �. �. -S �. < ; (/1 Z ^S ♦ � 0
j� —i� : "s c�r cD 3 O � � � a� � tq � r, „ _.
O � a • .'�' . . O (� � V � J_ � � � � � - > G'1 Z� � 1'~T7 Z � �
. � � -h 7r C+ -. c+� tn � vf pi a � o n R r
� tD e�►� w S . • -r a O .n ^ n o " � ; o O
3 ' �'1` � "S ct fD fD '�► ct 'S 'S • n > z ' n N� �
� � � � . M S O �D "'s Q J� J. 'f� i � A Y A N �/1
m '�. . . — (D G! � 'S N 2 'T � 7 �. 2 ; n . O 'S7
� • . � N C (D O 7C 7 ; � 0 � n .i
c+- O' -+1 � "A �f Q� �• tG O ^ � � D
J.
v �.. . � � O (� X f'f � 07 (� �1 ' O ti a o m M �� ��
. . ' Q� �. D �+. � � � O �_ � ^ O.�" �~ S
• O �G 3 (D = :.
' Ci SL Vf �. , • A { a • fT1 • n G'.
'S ft � + � � � N �' � ff n' � 'e.
r" Q � �_ �
_2' N v� -�Dn � � c�'i � m `D > = iZ o" o
G� rr �c rD � rr !
�. �p w � tD c�r cr -1 �• C � o , , O �
� d � 'S ? N � f � w w � a
(p J. J. Z Y 1 Y . N
� � Q. S H � � � � �� � N � � � �
� • N C� fD Cl1 "'G fT1 (C 7C" � a a O �
O . , [�D cat -S � O c'O'� 3 (D iv � m n D
� Oi G. � .� r p �C
� � � -,' c - m m � a. u � ; r
� � � fD '� �• ' o
� [0 S GT ta c+ a W � � �. > •
_ fD � fD - N � O � � p �' ; � '
_ � � � O � Gi G. 0. X c+ r a o C7 y .
� � � C a < � � ]e-
� C � W = � � O O a n � "
� j . "S O � � � Q� cC —� � 01 w p y n �.
� � ct tt �. >
n .,�i -_. � (D ct ? f�D iU lD � � � a Z � r .
Q- -�• X S lD � � --+ c'h O � � � ^ �'�
a __ � C) �• c} O .� �• � C� n o <
X � �'F e-h n tt -+ _ � a " a
O
N �1 J. �
� � 07 Q1 ..�• 4 n N
-i o c�f� 'Q 3. C 7r � fD O !D d c-f x 1 � N o p� c0� i
� c+ et O S = z ^ �c � n Gn i i
rn N i O O cD -+• N c* � v� O (D � ^ � R �> �o
� D � p . � CT -N+. � d N O CG � 'S N I 2 ^ Z O q (D o 7 (. .
I 5, +� S c-r c+ tn O C f f c z '" E � z R1 :.
w
� J. � S � � n f=p � � r n i n w RI I'
r � O iv fp � x Q x n � �
I m a 'O � c�t -{
(/� S � � O G+ N (D f�D � u ^ � ? r :
r.. �-r �- cc o+ o �, rn cr a � � N r o ; . �•
- � o co � c m w � ro a < " � t
Q ~ o° �- �- o�, co � -vo, � m n' � � � � -
m
f u n
� -- 3 � a e�-r � �G ct .P �. Oi c�1- > o u�i a i z i � �
� A� -S fD et O e-h �G � e-* o i n "' 'r�n � F
a • O
� � e�r O 0. rD � v�i c�. C 3 � a f "n° ,
S T � fD 'S 7r • ^ i i -I �
x' A cD • -s (n o ci fD c� `�C m � '" o � i.
- n O 'Q !D d N � � N i X 2 � � }
O -i "Q ct f0 � c� n � ° n �
� � S tD �C n. or �, � � °r � o m
� �_ . < (D � -+• (n o r �
_ � (D fD �'Y � 7r � �G - ct a o f
rr7 � m _ �S � a -+• tp lp .� ..S .� n o R1 •
� � � - G� 'S ct � N d AJ � C � n � � D
Q n _ CT �"h ? Q (Q Ct 64 ti1 C't u 2 a � .
'- ..d. (C fD O O �" -� O CD = le � -�
o � �+ ro • -s o E >_ : ° �+; m
a`< - - - . 7 � $. 'S r+ � o ct m a a o �� .
G --I a ` - , . Z � � � ''. O 64 (D � O z = � �p 'i .
� e-t- e-F' -f�
� W �1 ' � �• Q S �1 � W ; M � M \'� Q
(7 ^� .�.�_ '_ r�' '� �G C'f � S !D Q � "s r N C q �� � .
R7 . -. , . � a O �vl y
O c-r [0 G� � �n � C� � 0 0 > u Z A O
- c" o� -�. � sv v� o m Z � > c" C
_ < � � Q- . •
' lD � 'S O � �.i. -� � f� • n 3 �^ a n n a m
- C. O fi O .�. �' a n n i p p o
� c'1' � C � (D a � z �n a o
C� (D (p n . w � .
s ' — ? G. a Ar a c+ f� e+ 7r 3 n '" j ° o
' . ' � (� � l"1' (� � �• � a ; '� p � 1 � N E
3 ' - - _ � Z �• � (D � � a PI � � f �� n
Cr - • - - •
I _ . _ � CZ� �� � CI �. _ ¢I � Ie 2 ti n l0 N � 2 E.
�.. 9 (1 Z �wI u �
< Gr -1 Ci � � � n n o 3 a a e z O t0
J• � S 'S trt' LV 2 O a � L 0 � v
o ._ ' - - --- lD � (D ct !L O fD � r f a ^ Z � �y
� � � ( � E O �G d_ � > 1 � n a N
(+ �� �(1 �' a n i t i N
� ���:� 4'�d (r- vi�� OO�� et � O� SY � Q' � � � a
� �3 S C'I � ct 7 tn � � �. x w � a o 0
a fD (D t'1' �
(D (D 'i � a u ; n w
C. fD lD � "S O t't �
x ,._ .,.-- . -.,, 1 _ o > x
� •f:1ij _.�.�.i.i �� �i:l�,.lif � � < C) ; o ❑ a n
11 s � 1�,!�?-�� a fD C� a . n
� � s �:�1ii..JJG [p � n� � Z
b W Z . �p z N � �
C
V � '� ^ � �
�, > � '4
b a
° � o .x
m Z o x � �
E ''u' � y � � o—°'
� - -
� _ ,o � �a o � Q = `e
o u �� p •� d t-
E .o g' o ,� d -p '^ V �
-g °' � ° �> ii V �i m � � • �
� o ` �� � � i i O° o N
a
om °� �� � �Q � v � m a
°' ❑ a_ 1
� ~ �V �
��o a i
a � m
� I� • s � � o � E d �o d
` \, —� � O J ° ° ` d �
� o � .a .� � � or N E V
LL� o � � � � V .�` -v
� o
�0 Z � o o E a a E � � . V
(� �° • � Q Q '� o Q �>_
\f\ y c o � •� U n. a V V p �ar
� J � •� I 1 i 1 I y �
j.A\ ' . • 0 P'� �
U-0 J � � �
o� J J � J U o i
�) , ` '? -� Q U a a V V � � �� I
Z �,��` in n.
Lj \` Z
N V . � m . °
> C
� �� -�v � s
W �� 3 � � N
V Y" 0 y a �u
, � y �
� � � ; �E a� ,C
oP o Q � �
,� ` . v , a „ Q � a
O d ° � o e n, o
` Z m ''i= � >. �
�� E d v � P.
�w :r c .°
O� � � > j �
W ^ D (.� C d Q 7
C � a �
�' � ^ � in
� `y
W � �
a O
Q �p U
d• 6 d
� � � �
d � 1
'D �
Q � �
� a ,
e �
� W ^
� , //
, /_/
y O � •O .n d �!/
O C m - ;� . /
E � � �r` � �' ` �E"
„ a
� g 3
o • rn � �, •J m
� `n � Z `^ o `o ��
� O '- v V � � V
a �
H � S •d W m � � I
{,L d�� � � Z
O ._ � o m
c °�
o �- c
� '- a�i O s :J
�- -o
U � � , d ...
W O ^: � 0>
��N ` � ~ '
° a a W v d
� � a u � � F- E �
� N d � �V Z �
� \
I �. � � )I
�
� � a� � �Q °' v
,d
� � o � o d d � � ,.
� �
u .. ° _ �=0 0 = �( w
.r °' � .o- I E"
C p c 0 •p- ` � A
� � � � o = °' +° z
m m m a' �3 .. � 00 0 � p
� � � � Z o 0 o g'� ° I U
Z �� a � a � • • W
• , `o • � m `Z � Z Q �
y � a z
��,:. � . � , ...
. . � .
��- / ��'7
.��*••• CITY OF SAINT PAUL
:~� ':� OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY
�'•�^� EDWARD P. STARR CITY ATTORNEY
.... '
647 City Hall, Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102
GEORGE LATIMER 612-29&512t
MAYOR
December 1, 1988
�ECEIUF�
Mr. Michael M. Whalen DFc Q ; 1988
Attorney at Law
464 Century Plaza ��T1( CLEKK
1111 3rd Avenue South
Minneapolis , MN. 55404
RE: East Street West Bar, 616 .Como Avenue
Dear Mr. ti�Th.alen:
I am enclosing a copy of the resolution on ESW which will be
on the Council agenda on December 15 , 1988 . The Council meetings
start at 9 : 00 a.m. , but you might want to check with the City
Clerk' s office early that week to see where this item wi11 be
on the agenda and when it might come up .
Very truly yours ,
PHILIP B. T3YRNE
Assistant City Attorney
Enc.
cc : Albert �. Olson
City Clerk �