87-193 WNITE - C�TY �LERK
PINK - FINANCE COUnC1I
CANARV - DEPARTMENT G I TY OF SA I NT PA U L File NO. �7_� ��
BLUE - MAVOF
�o ncil Resolution
Presented By
��
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
RESOLVED: 'I'hat Application for renewal of an A-1 Grocery License (I.D. # 15205 )
by Margery Eyinch DBA Natural Health Foods at 1190 Payne Avenue
be and the same is hereby denied for the following reason:
' 1. Failure to maintain minimum sanitary standards.
A) Rodent droppings are on food display shelves and also on
the food storage shelves.
B) Food packages offered for public sale have been chewed open
by rodents, have been contamin.ated by rodent excretia, and are unfit
for human consu�nption.
C) Housekeepmng conditions do not meet the mimimum haaltli standards.
D) The applicant has shown by her privious conduct that she is un.fit
to operate a grocery store and to maintain minimum health standar�.s.
Further ftesolved, That this resolut��n shall be effective from and after February 21 ,
1987, and a copy of this resolution shall be mailed to the applicant by the City Clerk, and
a copy hereof furnished to the City�s Health Division.
COUNCILMEN Requested by Department of:
Yeas DfeW Nays �
�°°"�' [n Favor
RettmaR�
�Scheibel
�Sonnen �__ Against BY
�Tedesco
Wilsoq_
FEB 1 91987 Form Ap o d by City Attorney
Adopted by Council: Date
Certified Pass b cil Se BY
By
Approved by Mavor: D �-�� FED � Approv by Mayor for Submission to Council
By V�.� `v..._.� By
PUBtISHED �_�=� 2 11987
� , 1 f . I •
1' 7
• � I � � • L I • �
�
i �
:•-
I � ��
v �: � ���— .•`�
; � �;� / �
/� � .' �, _ -
i �_t.� _, �, . �
i�;.�: / / �i:v ��e�3 ii i�•ii ✓�i1
�.i���ll�� � r � �,- 1�• , :
/� � �L�/ /�� •• -
T'.
�� � � �' •�' 1• ' 1 �
����� ,
� . /
i � •' 1 1 1"• 1 � �• 1• ► 1 I 1 1 ' •' 1 I I ' / I
�
L✓L...G /�� .i .i//J �. ��= -!=�..a' /_��i �d _'1 � /� /' � L� _i,,
�� / � / �. /�� �
/.+��/.� L.. ' �� . .i�it �i /.' _'./. L_ �� L�:.�--'
S � � � /
��ii/L� �L�!�lL, i✓ � I' i ��� i
/ �� � �,.
� '- "y—� � � �/ � %r-� . .�.���'_.
,ii�. % i L�%�i���/ ��� �l� � _
i t LL.. �%'���/I� /!�...' .iL�, /��/ it _ / , '.I' � �..�
� � � ' ���:�!�� � ' � ;
' % �" / - ' %t �_.�L.:. �L_'_,
� � � !/� �� ,�. ���'// I� /_'� � �/L../ � '�. �
/ _/ <<L.�i /. � --- - - -
i,
/
I/G i/ ./ %/ i, '�/ i/ /lL�� _/ � ".I �i� ��
�! ���`�i�� / / /� l / /� � ���/ �:'-��/ �!/ ,�/C� � L�/S�
�/,«i�T�1 � �� � � �
��� , ,
, , ,
I �..�- _ �. .�, .��_� . �,� � if_ � � . .��
.i ,�� ��� ��L t�, � ! /� � ��•� +l�'�� _
_ /
w,� i �
� �Ji ' � � /�.`1�. � �__ � �,1
_ �' . ./ � � -
_ , �� IL� / / ��/- �� '
�/�, �j � i //f y�//" / //� �ti��/a/ _�
�/ ' � % i '
����I // %� �' �_' � ' i .✓�!� -�-� i � � :
/ ��r- ' ' � /
l/�i//./ � .��r' �.r��:/ . ..�� /� �� � `_' %',�
-
/�! i<. .� _�.✓ .�iRL...�� � _ _�L /� /� � � � � �.�J%�.��,
. .�.���
�/ ,
� � i � �
� ' s'1L .� ./II - —'— L /.c���:.�, �
��/!��ii��. �C L��/l1...�. �. �`��� �-
� � � � %� �Li ' ��lL����� � � � '� � �Ia.�' / t��'.r. , .�
i IJ�`J / i•I .i � aa� I ��IL�II.
� / � , � _�'.
i .�" � .L/ ' �. �.� /�L.�r/ ' .:�.►�_��r: _ �/!�=- � .�..
� i i i�.. i, .. / � ./�/� _l����lL � /�i//_/' .�i._ � // �� i
i - -
•�� ar�• •�
�a. •-�a-.: � � r �
� - � •��' _ -
� � / ,� / �
�
• • • �+ � : �
i
, ' INSPEC T/ON REPOR T ��-�93
� �Nr,,, ST. PAUL DNISION OF PiJBLIC HEALTH � 11 � ?,
� � 555 Cedal Stleet 292-��1� ��ntn�`3a�` ear
�u p x.�.
.1'y1,�, — Ncc�,,�./ '�tE'� .�c-z t��.r 2 r��C e'`-T�c�e,
� /� P� � Di� pP( pP AF'IER; 1-Routine �
� � � 2-Reinspect
�,i,rv J-0ther
�,Q.� month �aJ eaz �✓�� ����? ❑
°�eZ TI� FOLLOMTING It�ROVEMENTS MU�'T BE Q�I�IET'ED Il�DIATELY OR WTTHIN TI� TIME 3PECIFIED
rro.
� �---- �
�r-c'r � <-t,c- �. Gt� .� �+c' 'zu�: a��� CL Cr=<-t..cc�
/Yll.f f ` ' �L! Y �� ��f i • .�A.l� -t�;`t�� � 4"�►'L[c�
� ' .
-'LL7 (� 'G'hC /..L� �(.����� L kt'2C . � G' "Y ,Ili^� -F `'Ll l�v�'/�.E'.
� a�; �-?w -�--E� aE a� �- �.Ji.t*ts .t �,�
,c `S J�-�.�,�M�' ��C'�u.a ��..<° LcZ C , �.c-� "
n lrt' �.�!I�
��,._ n- ..�� � — L C I.C.�,(. 1 � -1.G�-y41�
n/Vl 1 ^ �/� ` �
� T'/�.0 �l 'Z�h�'I�C7L" :Jt� Q.tM.�9� /^
t �� .�,,/
.�r— /� � /� " '�'J�� ,�,� //� ^ .
��u ;�q� �r .Y `rrLL:��I� li:i .X/u-� ✓ T��l.' r"""`')'� ��CX
C, e .s:' �.CL7� �'C'J Gt��t-�4.i �L�� C, Q� r/, '
FOOD TF�ERATIJR�:
1'��SE QRDF.R3 D�1TED ARE ASAT£D:
� Befora an aLietinQ establiahmnt i• eltered, detailed draxings �Aev ard used equipment to be installed aust be
and equipmant epecifioations shnll be sutmittd and approved by llSF a�preved or equivalant (3ee Sanitarian).
the 9t. Paul Division of Public fiealth.
t�JII.TFI �/�� _Q,/���/��
NOTIC� ItECEIVED BY: 31WITAR7AN: ��µr�h ��"�IG''"�a.��-
Fosm E2/Jnn 198A
�'�-� 93
���"' �� CITY OF SAINT PAUL
' DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND MANAGEMENT SERVICES
. ,
O y .
• �'��'p OG
,,w � DIVISION OF LICENSE AND PERMIT AD!�1iNISTRATION
' '•" � Room 203. City Hal�
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102
George Latimer
Mayor
Januory 30, 1987
Margery Eyinck
Natural Health Foods
1190 Payne Avenue .
Saint Paul, MN 55101
Dear Ms. Eyinck:
As License Inspector for the City of Saint Paul, I am hereby notifying you
that on �?hr>>arv > > �aQ� � public hearing will be held before the Saint
Paul City Council (license matters only) . This hearing will be held in
the Council Chambers, third floor of the City and County Court House at
1Q:00 a.m.
At tt�:ia hearing, the License Inspector will recommend that the Saint Paul
Cit� Council deny your renewal application for an A-1 Grocery License at
119G Payne Avenue. The License Inspector�s office will base its recom-
mendation on the following:
(1) Failure to maintain minimum sanitary standards. (see attached)
You may be represented at this hearing by an attorney or other represen-
tative of your choice. You and/or your attorney/representative will be
allowed to cross-examine witnesses and present evidence through witnesses
and documents at this hearing.
Enclosed is a memorandum of procedures used by the Saint Paul City Council
for hearings on license revocations, suspensions, and denials of new licenses.
Very truly yours,
� -
Joseph F. Carchedi
License Inspector '
JFC/lp
Enc.
cc: �ouncil Members
Jerry Segal - City Attorney's Office
Frank Staffenson - Envi�onmental Health
M. _ /NSPEG TION REPOR T �'7-/9 3
W�T'i
cr , � �x� ST. PAUL DNI;�I�3� 0� PU3LIC HEALTH
�1J ' �j R.�,�„ 555 Cedar Street 292-7717 ` � � �i7
sni� �aJ� ear
S3TA9 }p¢�T' � �. ��
✓ - � � � �
�l a�rlv e�arture
t �,
� �( DUE aFi OP AF�R. O S 1-Rouclne �
` 0 '�-' 2-Rein�ct � .y
errv � `^ � ,l a�cn�r �--
�` � 7� a�in.u�.f �j
�,C_9"�� arnt^. 3rr eaz �
Order
;jo, TF� FOLLOWITiG II�RCNEMENIS Mib'T BE �MPIETED I2�DIATELY OR WITHIN T'r� TIME SPECIFIED
��.Q� � .-p
� ��� ���
. �
3� �� �.� a�.Q
�� _ _
� �
`�"��e� c�c�c�c� c� �a �= � �c��
.` % � � �,�
�
._ '
o � ' ,� ^
� � �� �`�� �
�1_
` —' ' -� n�/,/.�b--�
aM� -
� , � , �
` c�rY. �e�-�
. . _ � -
1ivv�
� —
.
FO�D TQ�F3uTIdiES: O O �
�sE c�tn�s n�� v ��b �D: � 3
,
�B�foz� an a=SutlnQ artabli�}msnt i• altesod, detailad draxinqs Nerr ard used �qyipment to be installed �:st be
and �quip�s�t �cifioations �hall b� rulmitt�,d and appzev�d b� ❑y� �pre�d os oquivalent (3e• Ssnitariw).
the 9t. Paul M�ision of lth
NOTICE RECEIVED BY: ' r '•''.��1 M n
' ��TT/�u�I�� \� ` /1 w A i SLC
Form E2/Je.n 19b� �� / /, ;��
( C.L�J�
� / . . . . .
i
.
• � r • s • . � • �
-. - -
. '
I ■ ' -
� � � �a ••`�
` / � -
/ . .,
// / .!�� _ _� i �!. � c- -,_/i
��•��c� � � I �A:v ��t�3 i• ii•� ✓\II
r , • •- NI-
�I �"� � '� . � �. -
,
••�+• � ■
i
�
. .- i � r � � r•r i �. . �� r � � i i � � •� � i i • � �
ls . % �� r►l�u a.s � /� � _�,�_�� _ �_� _. f►1i � • .� �
� �
� ���1ia, � "_� i /_ i � � / _I��/1 � /" /_�L
/
�//.� � C ,_ ' /� �� .L_�_�_� /���t � i � �.� � t �� �
/
�/t. % �t i� /�.'�LL�/ i _ f�//� /1 .
��� '� � �/ _ � �/
.... � �� .. � _� %L_ �t� / �. _ � , 'i/L�. .�
� � , ' /
/�� t��t �� . %, �i ����d � / ' _ i
�/ i_. /i�i _ �IL�.� �_' � � _� .�t �i�-' i ,
_/ / / ���.rl � '�iri/� ' / /
//I .�_/ ,iL _ �i ��/ L
� �
��
�/`t� �/ �,I % � /_ � / /�I� / �- L��� �I,J �� ♦ ��
/
� i
. ,I ,.L �. __Y / � _ /. , �!i
, I�
. _ � �
� ,i� .. � „ ,. � � . .�r _ — �
�� L �Q•�. � — � / i.l� ��L ��' L� � � I _
� � La �� �►�./t��� ` i ,��/ �fi �
� !lI/t �. i � �t/ � I L. �.�� �i. i . _ I�
�
��/ . i.���L L i �i � �. i I�� //_ / /�i L���_/� L� _
t� L ��/ i� � , /�� � . L � ��✓ s`�� i1t � �rL. _ � L � .i��`ia7�+
/
i .���'. _:r�� ., . �. �����/
►r�•�'' � �"� �/�1�� �. .�i�''�"/--
�I �J / / i I � /. I/ ir �' /�-�i/ /.
/ _�.��i./1 LL � t�t� - � -- -� %///_ iL_ " .L �L �/� �i y��
� � �
� , /
/� � � � �� �- � �.. _I / � J� , - -/
�/ l�_ _..� / _ / �.. �� "..r
�f/���//4���� . / , �� ��.t i_i -►i� --�:
..� a� •�. 1
�/�ir_ .r
iy. • �y•.: � � r �
� � � _ -
�
• • - « � : -
/ /
/ I�
� �. /NSPEC T/ON REPOR T �7�93
. � ST. PAUL DNI.SIOF: OF PIT3LZC �ALT:�i �� �l /r
N eti+ � ��
�/v �R� 555 Cedar Street 292-��1� �,—i�'�' ear
ssraet.ist��arr �
, � � `� �����=�� : :
; :�.
� uriv e arture
E
C/' DLE ON OP. AFIER: /�j l-Routine I
I� ! �Ll�l 7'(�� v y 2-Reinspect �
�Iyny i �- J-0ther �
�J,
�7'Z�`T,C.'�.-L� ` �7 ��,� �`��? �
at>nt^ 3a- �ear
�o°S THE FOLlDWIIJG Il�ROVEMENTS MU�T BE G�OMPI�,'rED IN�DIATELY OR WITHIN THE TII� SPECIFt��
a f ? � � -C�-G�''
/
/ r�
— � r_
A�1 , / /
� •
i
C � �{',. ����, �i(p
�� ����L��
/
� 4
1 �
i �
� / �'
� .
✓ �
� "�'% L• L,:,� •7 ` � �� '.7' ��1`'C._ �t���f� -
- ._---- •
� .
-t. ` , � ,
y - :,� � % .�rl�.('/ � tnt .c._.
� , �' i � , ��'z� � , .
� -
,
G. ���C�Z�v��� �, � �' '�- ��� �z
.�-c� o� .� z- � 2� :� ,
.
..�� u�J���t
' " �� ��'.�t�
_..._ , -- -
�d. �
.�L
.
c.'
FOOD TF1��l+T[A2�3:
Ttff:SE ORD�t9 MTED � �- ARE AB�IRED: ��
�B�for� an azistinq artablishment i� altared, detaiLd dzaWitKta �tlev ard use�d oquipment to be iastalled sist be
and �quipaant �cifioations shnll be �ukmiti�d aad appzov�d b� l5F approved oz oquivale�t (3ee Senitnzian).
th� 9t. Paul Division of Public Haalth.
}IFJlI3'H �
NOfICE REC�IVED BY: � SANTTARII.�: � L�L•"7 l-��
Form E2/Jan 19&� � ��� V-'_`
CITY OF SA1�1T� PAUL REFERRAL/RESPONSE FORM
. �'�—/�3
TO: ,.2,..�.�►,,� v ra.�,�� DATE: _ t-z 9 -�
( ) BUILDING ( ) FIRE ( ) LICENSE ( ) POLICE
O CITY ATTORNEY O HEALTH O MAYOR'S I & C O PUBLIC WORRS
( ) CITY COUNCIL ( ) HOUSING � ( ) PARRS & REC. ( � WATER
( ) DOG POUND ( ) AOUSING INFO. � ( ) PED ( ) OTI�R
�
LOCATION OF COMPLAiNT 1��� A��n e A U e OCCUPANCY TYPE
CO�IPLAINANT
NAME ADDRESS PHONE NUMBER
OiWNER/AGENT/
OPERATOR NAME ADDRESS PHONE NLIMBER
C 0 M M E N T S
�
� c�„^r�.r�y �A ,y„c,�2 �r.c,�., � 'Yk�..�u►�-�' ��.6� � .�r� c�' 119U C'����:, :
0
� -� ��-�-f�., �•�.;�..y v„-�r-� .�.��r��� a�! �a�.v �0 4 �-c�.c��.� ��7''
d
� �.� �i�.�.cr'"' � ��►'1�2 �.n�-�, �.•�,,o �:a �c�a.E � �a�� ���r�,� a�
.w. � .P�,( ..lst+�l C�"� �i �ci/ -�v .Q.� Q.t.cs-c►`.� a�`.C(�.� �'� � �o.�� ��'�G
A 1 \ .. ' •
L �."C3Gd� 4� �c1c7'Y�. �tNo ���}'�� i /� G�'7�'��►'y 'NM.oR.-twC�cLy�cn O'N �V�L= /�'i�e.•�..',
1 i'- -- r 0 l/
�«f s:��, � � �,,,. �-�,.�.-� a� ,���..-F -►1i►��( � 119� n�,,� `a� , � f����t
�'
a� � m�� -fs� �'.c.c�,.� u� .Cf(o� a.�4:��'.�, . C.�m w� -�-�.o�,�-� ..�cc�►� co.� L� ►ms�.v�►-�.. � �..�.c:•
�,�.n c� �.��> �y n.+�.p�, -Fre� � .�:�`"a.pp�x..�.t' .� �-� U.;�.�; . ��� •�•
�ROM: '°�"°°�'.` ""� ^..� .�� -�..� .�.� .� ,� �.��.
REFERRAL REPORT BY (NAME) /����I���y`
PHONE NtJMBER '7'7/ 7
1 �������������������������������������������������������� �N�
RESPONSE (PLF.ASE RESPOND WITHIN 10 DAYS OF ABOVE REPORT DATE): � � °?
� ,
�.,�N1���, .��/��,��/��i —�� .���w,� ,�1.��-� � /D��'"
—��ia—!Lr�� iit�t���l� �eL�LI.!/ �Lxd6�r�-��/, ��s,L i�i � � �
��/4��� se!�1�. /�f�ri ��//4!/ ��_—.�.��,��� ..l�.�O/ ���E�
. . � �
RESPONSE BY (NAME) �� DATE �-�i-��'
� ������������������������������������N���������������������
CALL BACR C�NTS:
SALMON - REEP WHITE �t BLUE ' ��� �ITE TO REFERRING AGENCY
MAY, 1984 WITHIN TEN (10) DAYS. � 2ND REFERRAL
��
�,� ► � � r � �
�
� _�
� . �
_:�� a
F � � � :
� �
� ,. �
�" s�jj 1
t � a :
\V
O
��/�
• Y�
� 4"^,1 � � Ij�
} _^� ,1�
� � � O^ C.,' UI
' C2. �'' ii N
"' �� ^ U .0 �
� `~'�r � •� � E
�"i x
�
. �
N w Ga 'vi
5.�1 N '
. :"�
� 0 J-1 ?". :V ':;
rl CI� u"
.^:'Y i.� rti
...
tiM1 � �
+~G <s
'`',� i�i
`'�. �t: S.i
�+e �
L a�-- t..
. ri ,� :.:.i
� �f �
`'1 �S
O �,Z L. S�
� 1� '� �
� vf
� �� �
O \�
� y�
� ��-+ Le
Y c f: �
� �
W � ;.� „..�
J � :�
U � . .
� a � �
�
V c
W �ro
2 `^ . , �
F- = -,�, �; L I�
LL � r"-.l. . .. . .
O =
u� � � - 1
U a ` _, . i �- ;
V � , �
� �
Q � Q� I��
.�"��'O�
•�
.�
:
��
�+ ����
�i= �7-�93
��"" CITY OF SAINT PAUL
�� �,,,."�
�a��� ';'� DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY SERVICES
wnwu �
b: u1 I�II li. �E
� DIVISION OF PUBLIC HEALTH
�4f�`���� 555 Cedar Street,Saint Paul,Minnesota 55101
George Latimer (612)292•7741
Mayor MEMORANDUM
DATE: February 19, 1987
� TO: City Council Members
Joseph Carchedi, License Inspector
FROM: Saint Paul Division of Public Health
Envirorurental Health Program
SUBJF�r: Inspection of Natural Health Food Store - 1190 Payne Avenue
An inspection was conducted on February 18, 1987 at the Natural Health
Food Store at 1190 Payne Avenue as requested by the City Council. The
inspection was conducted by Diane Olson and William Gunther. The following
items were noted during the inspection:
1. Mouse droppings on bottom shelf of display case on north �11 in
aultiple loeations.
2. Shredded (rodent gnawed> gaper and irouse droppings behind refrigerator
in back room.
3. Improper condensation drain on refrigerated display case.
4. Nio�use droppings on bottom rails of refrigerated display case.
5. Dead mouse on floor under the refrigerated display case.
6. Cobwebs and irouse droppings in on back shelf of display area.
7. Mouse droppings and irouse urine on lower three shelves of center
h�uoden display shelves.
8. Rodent gnawed, puffed millet bags on lawer shelf of display area on
south wall.
9. Mouse droppings by side door (on south wall).
10. Rodent gnawed plastic and fiberglass insulation covering side d�oor
tsouth wall).
11. Rat droppings in utility area in basetrent.
12. Mause droppings behind and on the w�oden cabinet in south room in
basement.
13. Iarge am�unts of mouse droppings in nultiple areas in north room in
basement.
14. Photos and samples taken.
S�:jr