87-146 WHITE - C�TV CIERK
PINK - FINANCE G I TY OF SA I NT PA U L Council
CANAi7V - D�PARTMENT
BLUE - MAVOR File NO. ��_/��
�. Council Resolution
, ���
Presented By ` �
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
RESOLVED, that upon execution and delivery of a release in
full to the City of Saint Paul, the proper City officers are hereby
authorized and directed to pay out of the Tort Liability Fund
09070-511-223 to Muriel Pavlick the sum of $7, 500 . 00 in full
settlement of her claim for damages sustained August 14, 1985,
when she fell as the result of a pipe protruding through the side-
walk on the northside of East Third Street between Germain and
Hazelwood.
A P P R O V E D:
J e of District Cour � �� �q�
a
/ COUNCILMEN Requested by Department of:
Yea� orew Nays
! '�EO'"°' � In Favor
Rettman
Scheibel �
Sonnen _ Against BY
�'eQeaes.
��114ilian-
Adopted by Council: Date
FEB 10 'gg� Form Approved by City torn y
Certified Pa- C uncil Se BY
By�
App ve y : avor: Dat Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
B - — BY
PUBIoS�;ED '_�"�, `' 1 1987
� (� �1-���
.
��. , .
� �t*=a, CITY OF SAINT PAUL
�•4' ' � OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY
0 y�
�t ����'���'�� �C
�,+o ��� EDWARD P. STARR, CITY ATTORNEY
`0'r �••• � 647 City Hall, Saint Paul,Minnesota 55102
'�..�
612-298-5121
GEORGE LATIMER
MAYOR
M E M O R A N D U M
TO: St. Paul City Council
FROM: Frank E. Villaume, III r�
Assistant City AttorneyT�
DATE: January 28, 1987
RE: Muriel Pavlick v. City of Saint Paul
Our File 585-0673
Plaintiff Muriel Pavlick fell on August 14 , 1985, on the north-
side of East Third Street between Germain and Hazelwood just south
of the Harding High School football field. She claims her fall
was the result of a pipe sticking up through the sidewalk. Our
investigation disclosed that the pipe was part of a stopbox in-
stalled by the Water Utility before Third Street was paved in
1959 to provide water service to vacated properties. The plain-
tiff ' s claim is against the City of Saint Paul and the Water Utility.
The City of Saint Paul received at least two complaints from the
general public about the pipe sticking up through the sidewalk.
On November l, 1983 , a Public Works employee burned off several
of the pipes . It appears that frost action may have pushed the
pipe up through the sidewalk.
The plaintiff suffered a fracture of her right elbow which required
the surgicial removal of the radial head. Her attending physician
finds she has a 25-30 per cent permanent partial disability.
She was employed as a housekeeper, earning approximately $105 per
week and her ability to return to that occupation has been limited.
Her medical expenses are approximately $2 , 750 .
The plaintiff ' s claim has been settled in the total amount of
$15, 000 . The Broad of Water Commissioners of the City of Saint
Paul previously aqreed to contribute on an equal basis and the
City' s contribution is therefore $7 , 500 .
Our office requests approval of this settlement.
FEV:paw
attach.
cc. Mayor ' s Office
Water Utility, Thomas Mogren
Ed Starr
. . - ��- k r- � ��
� � ����,
SAINT PAUL C R COMMISSION
c
SAINT PAUL, �„ INNESOTA 55102
March 30, 1987
Mr. Albert B. Olson
City Clerk
386 City Hall
Saint Paul, MN. 55102
Dear Mr. Olson:
At its March 26, 1987, meeting, the Saint Paul Charter Commission voted
affirmatively to recommend to the Saint Paul City Council passage of the en-
closed ordinance amending City Charter Section 12.04.1 pursuant to the pro-
visions of Minnesota Statutes Section 410.12, Subd. 7.
Please place the ordinance on the City Council agenda.
Very truly yours,
� � r� �ft� � C�,��
��I�f�Jf(�l�'Y�L W
Raymond W. Faricy, Presi nt
Saint Paul Charter Commission
RWF:nla
Attachments
2z
. ; � . _ ��_ � z- ���
. � /��i s��
RESOLUTION
WHEREAS , the Saint Paul City Council by its Resolution of
November 6 , 1986 (C.F. No. 86-1525) requested Charter Commission
review and consideration of a City Charter amendment pertaining
to subpoena power for the Civil Service Commission; and
WHEREAS , the Charter Commission did, at its meetings on
November 26 , 1986 and January 22 , 1987, review and consider the
aforesaid proposed Charter amendment; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, that the Saint Paul Charter Commission hereby
recommends for unanimous Council adoption, pursuant to Minnesota
Statutes Section 410. 12, Subd. 7 , the proposed amendments attached
hereto.
. _. _R-.-- - -__ ___ . ----- _ _- ---�- ----�-----=-- --------- _�� �z��
«MIT$ �.�ITY CLERK � . —__—_—_--"-- '
o�e.K � F�w.AwCE .• . .�
CANARr �OEPAR.MENT GITy pF SAINT PAUL Council- � r7�y�,
���E _M.YOp File NO.
O��iI`���'i e Ordinance N 0.
Presented By • �
Refer:ed To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
An ordinance amending the Saint Paul -
City Charter, Section 12.04.1, pertaining -
to the hearing of grievances by the Civil
Service Commission. �
• TF�E COUNCIL C= THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: �
Section 1.
Pursuant to Minnesota Statutes, Section 410. 12, Subdivision
7 , and upon recommendation of the Chart�r Commission of the City
of Saint Paul, Section 12.04.1 of the Charter of the City of
Sai�t Paul is amended to read as follows:
"Section 12.04.1 . Hearing of grievances. The
civil service rules shall include provisions estab-
� lishing a formal procedure for the review of employee
grievancss not covered under labor agreements. After
exhausting the formal grievance procedure, the com-
. _ pl.aining employee may petition the civil service
commission for a hearing and the commission shall, --- �
within a reasonable time, conduct a hear�ing at which
all parties to the grievance or their representatives
may be heard. The commission shall have the power to
issue subpoenas and to administer oaths and to compel
the atte�dance and testimony of witnesses and the
producti�n of books and papers relevant to the
grievanc�. The commission may make complaint to the
district court of disobedience of its subpoena or orders
under this section. Following the hearing, the
commission shall promptly rule on the grievance
petition. Its decision shall have such binding
effect as the civil service rules prescribe."
COUNCILNFN
Yeas Nays Requested 6y Department of:
Drew
N��s�� In Favor
Rattman
' ScheibN �
�„�.,, Against gY
T�a�o
w�im� .
�do?ted by Council• Date Form Approved by City Attomey
bY ry g ��C.� 1�• !/YGF,/�.�LZ�G� ��'B'"�j�c
Certified Passed CaunciI Secreta y __
5y . .
.y�pcoved by Mayor: Date Appr ed by Mayoc for Su si n to Couricil
� .�.
�Y --- SY
: • e � _ � . ' • .
_ _.__...--- — - - -- -•._ _-----�--- --- --- - ---_
�H�TE — Cirr C�EraK � - . --- -- �---,_` . _._�.._.
�1NK � FINANCE •
��MARr �OEPARTMENT CITy pF SAINT PALTL Council �
i�uE _w��roR F11e NQ.
•
Ord��l�znce Ordinance N�.
�resented By
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date �
Section 2. -
This ordinance shall take effect and be in force ninety (90)
days after its passage, approval and publication. �
�
COUNCILMFN
Yeas Nays Requested by Department of:
Drew
N�ros�� In Favor
Rettman
Scheibd
so,,,,o� Against BY
Tedeseo
Wilwn
i
4dopted by Council• Date � Focm Approved by City Attorney _
:ertified Passed by Council Secretary By ��- /'ci'- �Z��L�6��L�.,� �O "S ^�(R
By .
. . .
\pproved by Mayor: Date Appr d by Mayor for Submis o to ou
[Z.. —�JI . ��7 — /� � w �
• , . , f�,,r_--�,� '-I'��
" . ' , i ��tif<,�
' �,� i r t�t •��,e `...►�. ..-.F- � v:,-rky.. .,.-;.,.. . r..�,�., a.ry.. a'-..
+dk.i A . � � ��+ ... a e
0��3��e�� �t�.:
���4�;� �'Y�,.II ��3�II�r���r- �� '�C:} 'aC���
,- , _ . , �`.�t ;�I�
a public ti�rl;u. ` ����'
City Ha21�d`., �; 1�
File 87-�.24'.�i i� ��- � i
�
��� ��� ���b� � �Q$c
��� = t�G o�ee:is ets 14��#�st•��::,`��I'C���'' �'�"` L�-�Ii
.o�iriance amen Fa�.`t � O:.
=p�rta�ning to the - �H"
The Co�uictl of the Gity,s�►i�l�o�s x.
rct�eK�t.i�+s�.i�:' •C�c�����`3F�'`i` +'Tt
_ r p�-�-�ssggp3'1•Ip1R7$� y����.��T,�"�,.��1' s.v 1�1�-
' �. : . , �j������ �'�'���
recom e
12.04.1 oi e�of the Cit Saiat' . �'te ;
��� .I
�rievanee�s. .ThE civi2 11�
a forn�I Procedure;,-i�t�i.�pt�of
;��� � AtE����hansting
;��co ` �#np}sFee"�'.p�Y��ion the
���. 8�n tor s h�earin������ "._.�:�r;
��;.�.�td�et`,� at Whtcla all. ,qr ,
.+:�h � y � �'lie eoaui` � .�ives to :
aa�1:ta c��t�a .. I�nee and.
- � o wi� e proe�urti�at af�books � ]��to
�Bri ce commission m�r mals� � " " of
di�� �t+.c�rt
,
�tpoena or,arderg'4ffi, �F��� .
heai�. thez��[ffifssion shall prolnptly rule, I�S
decisioa shall have s�ch'b�!!�g°t�flect a$tlu ` ,,
�w�sctwv,M;:•, aza A � :i.3
� - S�C'I�AN 2 -,
%���� l�ot►aN�tii�.._ pe e :�}d b��m�o�a+a '�t���a',
�i ,� �a�ra���+la�na�:�«�a,..i
p� ._�A� °:
'w2' . ��`cP3� .� ,. ��. p!� 3 ,. ^�vS9 �c s6 �i
��i:tT�f . .�1 1�A;.�"��i.i4j�.
+`'�! `�'�Q�f a y::eetrc Yli]IF.A�'jtTyl+i7'P. �
ir2eb ols2�ert �rsf+ac�'�i 'c -ti t ;; "� .g�^' $S �'Kc
...�. , _�_. .. ._ ..�. Q'l�itiar;y 2$,-Mar�h�;SiA873 �d a��.,- .��,_
. t T (.E/�._ ����_. I��n
�,L �
. , r 1 y��'
w�via�iYi Vi���l$�� i' " 3 :5:. � �r ;i'-. ...
'�* r'lt . "
' �i��lL##DEE�t1r �r���1��'� =-
� ��� � ' � �t�e��.'�'�, �
G'IttY I�ali asd�rE ou�e to cvnside�'�1����o�ae ordi�ssYiotbei�C�a�il� `
, I�ile S7-I24, a�►d�C3�apter 1s.04.1 at�bt Charter'e��ie�=ot S�tiei:#�iit�., =
P�rtrin�ns ta#�l�rl�oi,�rFeva�bY-�e'C�v�ll-$�e3vice�o�fa�ssfos� ,,
i -;The,te3ct`o�`tt��°is'as�`toltow�s :
' A�s or�fiia�nce air�df� tl� 3afmt��t�l��i�y�Ch�rf�..��etf�1T:t�1`�. , '
� Pertaini�t�tt�e hessi�g cf 6rieva�ee�.1�Y t;�t�'i;�v�ii Servk�,.�at�dssio�:
i T!��o�i10!t�e Cf�j�ot 3a3nt'Pattl iioea C)ndain:
�� ,� ,�-''�r '�`' �s� _ i �..t, _
G: �Ta
-�M`:. �, `�- �:
� _ _ - - -- - - , - - - — --
�--S�
�=�1pe���►n4oe'�.f� ° __ ' ` ' !1� ,: � w
` �1��`Ps'��'�'��,���►��
�. �,s+�missioalctr.a:�u°in6-a�1 the�� �p-�,, ;
`�a'�.eondirct a at�;`�I p�,=i����,
���'.�ap��ve�riaay�e�b�The�fd��ha�►e tttr�o�er�.
a �'s��as a�.ta�r�niaist�er#ouths ui�t�k�au�p�2-'�-�►t#e�da��n�,1
' � �_�#�esse�.awd������odu¢t���f•ba0lc��aed;pa�pers relevaint.�o
.��e- laf�it`t'cr"�t►�distrtct ccut��!
�' :a�i,`i�e�s��prcieaa or��rder�4 �t2€ls s�io�:�Fo3�.t�.�-��
��s�ril< -
-�te on-�re� �.
� ���vt such.biqdii��i.��as the Mvil service rulea p��
i= .. _ . _ ;�;-> •
. _ _ . _. . �-,,
" ,i_ '� ; ��: � �QN 2 . .
{ A � �_ ���:M�w�oC a[i���7 ��l��'���� .
t "- p i v¢ -���;�1'�i��h . �x , . ._.
,... �_ " �PTY�� $�•M,�f. �,�Y��� �, - t '.,V: f t.. . .
- �Nz� �3 . - . . _. ._. .