The URL can be used to link to this page

88-1673 WFf�iTE - SITV CLERK . PINK - FINANCE GITY OF' SAINT PAUL Council ��/��. CANARV -OEPARTMENT BLUE -MAVOR File �O. � i r rdindnce Ordinance N 0. 'f �'� Presented By �� I Referred a� Committee: Date i - Out of Committee By Date � An ordinance amending Chapter 60 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code pertaining to zoning for the City of Saint Paul and the zoning maps thereof. WHEREAS, Pursuant to Minnesota Statutes, § 462.357 and § 64.400 of the Legislative Code, John and Helen Regenold duly petitioned to rezone the � northwest corner of Idaho and Arundel (approximately 435 Idaho) from RM�to P-1 for the purpose of constructing a parking lot the petition having been certified by the Planning Division on July 13, 1988 as having been consented to by at least two-thirds of the owners of the area of the property to be rezoned, and further having been consented to by at least 67% of the owners of ! the property situated within 100 feet of the total contiguous property within i one year preceding the date of the petition; and WHEREAS, The Zoning Committee on August 18, 1988 conducted a public hearing for the purpose of considering the rezoning petition, and pursuant to Section i 107.03 of the Administrative Code, submitted its recommendation to the Planning Commission that the petition be granted; and WHEREAS, The Planning Commission considered the rezoning petition at its meeting held on August 26, 1988 and recommended that the City Council approve the petition; and WHEREAS, Notice of a public hearing before the City Council on the said rezoning petition was duly published in the official newspaper of the City ori September 10, 1988 and notices were duly mailed to each owner of affected property and property situated wholly or partly within 350 feet of the property sought to be rezoned; and COVNCIL MEMBERS Yeas Nays Requested by Department of: Dimond ��g In Favor + Goswitz Rettman I s�he;n�t Against By Sonnen Wilson Form Ap oved by City Atto ney Adopted by Council: Date Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY By ( ' Ma or: Date App�'�e y Mayor for Sub ' si � �uncil Approved by y By WH4.�� - OITV CLERK CO1111C11 �J� PINK - FINANCE DLUERr- MAVORTMENT GITY OF SAINT PAiTL File NO. � �F✓ • 0 indnce Ordinance N 0. I � �� Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Commi ee By Date l WHEREAS, A public hearing before the City Council , having been conducted onl September 22, 1988 where all interested persons were heard, and the Councill having considered all the facts and recommendations concerning the petition� now, therefore, THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: Section 1. That the zoning map of the City of Saint Paul , Sheet No. 4, as � incorporated by reference in Section 60.301 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, as amended, is hereby further amended as follows: That property located at approximately 435 Idaho being more particulalrly described as the east 118 feet of Lot 5, Block 3 Edwin N. Ware's Cumberland Addition Plat 1 be and is hereby rezoned from RM-1 to P-l.i Section 2. This ordinance shall take effect and be in force thirty (30) days fro�m and after its passage, approval and publication. I COUNCIL MEMBERS Yeas Nays Requested by Department of: I Dimond P1 anni n d Economi c Dev r�ent � � [n Favor Goswitz Rettman Scheibel � Against BY � I Wilson r Form Ap r ved by City ttorne Adopted by Council: Date ��V — '�� j��g I Certified Pas d by Counc' Secreta BY gY ,Q��t�l� O/r , ^ ��.� �` `' n cil Approv y Mayor: Da , � ' F`�'� APPr b Mayor for Submi o gy B p�� v ov l s 1988 i _ � . ��cEIVEp �� . �� 4 1988 � Q �3783 � PED DEPARTMENT � ��(P�� , GONTACT NA1+IE� � - _ 22R�,3�$ �fNE , � ; � ' 11�teh�±r 4� 19f� DATE . ASSIGN DiUMAER FOR I�t?L1�ING ORDER: (See reverse side.) 1 Department Director 3 Mayor (or Assist t�1� `�, _ F i n a n c e a n d M a nag emen t Sarv icas D irec tor � C i ty C ler k �. ` r Budget Director � � City Attorney _ TOTAL �1[IMBER OF SIGNATURE PAGES: 1 (Clip all locations for signature.) i�I�AT i12LL �E ACHIEVEQ BY TAKIN(3 C�IU�ON THB�ATTACHBD MATERIALSP �Purgose ionale) , Qrdinance impl•ements City Council action of 9/17/88 granting a rezoninq from RP1-1 to , P-1 for the property 1acated at approximately 435 l�est IdaF�o. Rezonin� was ea�ested to enable the an�licant to construct a parkinci lot for an apartment buildin4 located at 42.9 West Idaho. COST,�BENEFIT. BUDGETARI�. AND PERSONNEL IMPACT3.A�iTIC�FAT�D: • , RE�E D °�ror s88 MA Yp�s 0 F��rF FINANGING SOIIRCE AND BUDGET ACTIVITY NtTMBER CHARGED OR CREDITED: (Mayor's signature not required if under $10,000.) Total Amc�unt of Trans�ction: Activity Number: Funding Source: � � Council Research C nfi�:� ATTACHMENTS: (List and number all attachments.) ��"� Q'`� ��8 ADI�IINISTRA�iVE'PROCEDURES � _Yes �No Rules, Regulations, Procedures, or Budget Amendment require ? _Yes _No If yes, are they or timetable attached? �3EPARTMENT REVIEW CITY ATTORNEY REVIEW _Yes _No Council resolution required? Resolution required? Yes _No _Yes _No Insurance required? Insurance sufficient? Yes _No _Yss _No Insur�nce attached? • ; '�r... � a� . n� � � � � ' o+ .1 w � W 0 , � O U ,,� �: W . � . � OO C ( �" F- � � �I Z 1 � O ' � � � 1� U � ►7 � RS H N '� M � m Li d' N O L r-�I . •r- O N �1-� U ar-�.► , ' •r- 3 E s. z •� � x 0 o a N � N � • CY �• j � C M ' � � E � s�.. +� � � M C � H � ►-+ . _ O � N � a Q i �o � J , Q � 5�.. N � ' a � � o� � � ' .� z � � U � � M � � a r >- �- Z 1A � C O ►I--i rF--� 0�0 ar� V d UC� M : -. � � � i 1 `��a `� � , :- r . ; U , �. .� r� , �� c� .�� ,�. r � :�� cc�;�� T � ��,; �v e�} �. f�Lco,:c� �: �,s _ r E8 t� � 39 ��+� ��U , . (_` � ,.�,,; � i � . �� '^ I � � ! � ^� i STATE OF MINNESOTA ) County of Ramsey ) ss. I CITY OF SAIr?T PAUL ) I Albert B: Olson I, . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .City Cle�rk of the City of Saint Paul, Minnesota, do hereby certify that I have compared the attached copy of Council File No.. 88,-1673. . . as adopted by the City Council,, , November. 8:. . . . . . . . . . . . 1988. . , . and approved by the Mayor. . . . . ., , November. 9:. ._ . . . . . . , , i, 1988. . . . with the original thereof on file in my office. i I further certify that said copy is a true and corr'ect copy of said original and the whole thereof. I WITNESS my hand and the seal of the City of Saint Paul, Minnesota this , , , ,?9th. . . . . , day of . , , .JanuaL'y. . . . . _ .A.D. 19.90. I . . . . . .�:''. �.�:��-. .� . . �-�::��:. . . . . . . . . City Clerk. �� 1�� •1, , y ��` ��( ��` , .. ,`C.� `'��e ��,,J ,�f. �� .. .� R Y J� � I •� ( - r�, ° �,ly( � , :� . _,.�-:, :=��, . "{ a 3• -�'� , ' :;�: I : ,pr� •,y��i ili�.1`{�� L F�•� [ti � r a � � [� • s�i qJ'..�O -.r'_ ... �O � I , �� - �q I ��0 �� . �i�� a��t`:.s�` ,.�� L��_ � � :.;w„� 1��311��..,�Z!~�.�- I . 3�6 � �% f� _ _ , WH�:7E - ;ITV CLERK COl1I1C11 PINK � FINANCE GITY OF SAINT PAUL �� .3 CANARV -DERARTMENT aw� �-a�tiroR File N0._T ` ,, • ' � , ! rdin�nce Ordinance N0. ,.��0�'� / - /,�r � � � Presented By � : .iI�L��'' ��-�•'" ' , � Referred o Committee: Date (;' Out of Committee By Date An ordinance amending Chapter 60 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code � pertaining to zoning for the City of Saint Paul and the zoning maps tj� thereof. ', � � WHEREAS, Pursuant to Minnesota Statutes, § 462.357 and § 64.400 of the � Legislative Code, John and Helen Regenold duly petitioned to rezone the � � northwest corner of Idaho and Arundel (approximately 435 Idaho) from RM-�?to P-1 for the purpose of constructing a parking lot the petition having been certified by the Planning Division on July 13, 1988 as having been consented to by at least two-thirds of the owners of the area of the property to be rezoned, and further having been consented to by at least 67% of the owners f the property situated within 100 feet of the total contiguous property withirh one year preceding the date of the petition; and WHEREAS, The Zoning Committee on August 18, 1988 conducted a public hearing for the purpose of considering the rezoning petition, and pursuant to Section 107.03 of the Administrative Code, submitted its recommendation to the Planning Commission that the petition be granted; and WHEREAS, The Planning Commission considered the rezoning petition at its meeting held on August 26, 1988 and recommended that the City Council approv� the petition; and WHEREAS, Notice of a public hearing before the City Council on the said rezoning petition was duly published in the official newspaper of the City o September 10, 1988 and notices were duly mailed to each owner of affected property and property situated wholly or partly within 350 feet of the property sought to be rezoned; and. COTJNCIL MEMBERS Yeas Nays Requested by Department of: Dimond �� In Favor Goswitz Rettman scne;be� Against BY Sonnen Wilson Form Ap oved by City Atto ney I, Adopted by Council: Date Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY By Approved by Mayor: Date App� y Mayor for Sub ' si �y cil By _ WHI��.: - CITV CLEfiK PINK - FINANCE COl1flC11 l q� BLU�pr-MAVORTMENT CITY OF SAINT PAUL File �1�. �/� �✓ . 0, dindnce Ordinance N 0. � �!� , ; Presented By � �-�? � - �. (�� Referred To / Committee: Date i Out of Commi tee By Date --T 4rJ WHEREAS, A public hearing before the City Council , having been conducted onl, �D September 22, 1988 where all interested persons were heard, and the Council � having considered all the facts and recommendations concerning the petition� � now, therefore, � � I THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: I Section 1. That the zoning map of the City of Saint Paul , Sheet No. 4, as incorporated by reference in Section 60.301 of the Saint Paul i Legislative Code, as amended, is hereby further amended as follows: That property located at approximately 435 Idaho being more particulajrly described as the east 118 feet of Lot 5, Block 3 Edwin N. Ware's Cumberland Addition Plat 1 be and is hereby rezoned from RM-1 to P-l.l . Section 2. This ordinance shall take effect and be in force thirty (30} days frdm and after its passage, approval and publication, i I I I COUNCIL MEMBERS Yeas Nays Requested by Department oE: I Dimond P1 anni n d Economi c Dev o. ent � � In Favor Goswitz Rettman ✓ Sc6eibel � Against BY ' , .Seauea' Wilson fi!�� _ � !(�+�� Form Ap r ved by City ttorne Adopted by Council: Date Certified Pass;ed by Counc�l Secret%a/t✓`� BY gy _(,�.��1_r 9/r- (. "-U�� Approv y Mayor: Da � ''�V 7 ,,:`�;; Appr b Mayor for Submis on cil gy B p�� N ov i 9 1988 � . z53�8�8 � ._ -�s—.—... � �/�'i •-, ""? � " OCC �� 1.Gtr 2i'�.�etxr _ . ` i � + + -� Q O + + + + + � � � . . �. + + -;- . � + + + + + - - + + + + �,o. ¢ � + .t + �. � 17 • � t ♦ �- + � + ♦ + + ♦ t Q �n+ 36 ' -t t -!- ♦ � + � ♦ ♦ ♦ + �f- , O 18 � � O + + -� � ♦ ♦ + + ♦ �' �/ �- ♦ + ♦ t + + + -� + • � � �- + + + , 4 � O � � + + + + + 3O � + + + + ' � �+ + ]''� + + � 0 ♦ f� + + + - + ♦ + ' � � + + t + + ` 0 0 � I O V � '� O � ..� i' .: - - - + + + + + ' -�! — + ♦ t ♦ 12 < > —� f ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ O ..(�,. '�" < � ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ Y � :t � + ♦ ♦ ♦ t T .� —,o- �Q + •y' + + 12 � ' --- ��' � � � + + + + + O � o O � � < � O 3 -- - - - + + + + o � > � - � + + + + � �p 4-� > < <5 + + + + � + + + + �2 O � � `� � �- + + + + ��j O � Og � �� Q. ♦ + + t 3 � � < ! ` t + i- f- � _ � � � + I ',�' r�'��'�'1 .E ^ I � 7.., � :'4 �i� � ��.k i `� °7 �,J�C�' 4:.�. .. f :.�`• �n..�,� a� f ' 7��i�y �n� xt TV ,-��„� ,�'�r.�•d �' � i .- � .r �. �- !� -. � �.' t i \�- '; fa�� .} s• � ;At �:. � �� ..+ v� �� 5' a 1Ts j� '`u �� ! � �F F �'� •� ��rt 7 '�` I ' fr�� ' � r � � F: �.,x' ' r �� t� ,.fi��'�c e��`'�*1 �`°� n. �i + ' �� 4p �� l g y j � r x ' � J ` . 'f.t . l f+�"�t 7 r'.. r..'� . t�5 '�k �y„l rs �M1 � �t �aF" 1'..�'�� '.Y `�e��,�,�31 y R'• � t�'_ '�a '4 ..�� i f��i_� Z��'��.i a 1'1,t.�r�' � � � '�.�.� � � [ �'. ..: ,, � _ •�� - �r� ,��. �' � r �,- � -F r,�,;� �x�. !; �, ,� : '' .'i ��:.. � s �:Z. �Y ,��:�. � .�} a r k Y�� X. P �i'i,� x � r �.x,:�..�'�� t.�` . ; i a :�r � ti �a � � +�fi � a ,. �' �� -i;a 7�•�� i � �� .i { t��,� a �� i ',� �� ..! � . �wy,� �� t9 ,�.s ' .4� �<�� '�1 '�; 3�f .� �"� �,�� , °*� �yi � � ��'�y��i ,�r �� x, �, ,} �. - �.� ..� 1ti ..i ;r � �� ✓ �� p� �t-�..�. � r�.� .q Y4 fi A�. . � r� .ta i�� f' �� t �. : � � ` t ;� a z: :. � F %- � � � "�, + r � � a � +h,,, "� ;* r��* �u 't' �"� � ,`� °� � �� ' ?� aF � J , I � �. t d' r , } �, i, i�� ,�� ,� y � y �].� i i4 �,��`k �r� y `' ' x�s , � '� � ` i �' �� , ,� � � �r ti�� `�'� ��`��" �'� � '� . �; 1 � �� .; �P ' 3 „� i ''-Y ! 7 � t ri I �:" ,� v; d'. a � 1 .�A � K ' .I C c s� i ' �,_ i1)\rc.: t 4 •,t'� . i �$ .: � a�� t..,�'a .y � �� I � �__ �� 7 �� ,� �� . f! y �,� i f� �. ,�y 1� �"r� Y• � C ,. C�9 � n�� r r �: .� � � . y h #� �". 'dr.s sl� 9 �tl � �� .�+ ..:5 S� t ��d ��.J� � �.: � . � �, � •, ��.� � .,�C' a��.- � f,i �'� �.4 . i� �iefi �i �.� 1-i vr.' ,f�, � � b f i a' ' � �.. l� ! 1 �. r � 't M3 � �. h '� � .;H � >� � : > � :e a ;� " �� '� t:�, ( ;"t 1. rr i .. s .� �' i; �"�s� � n / ,t � .1 t�-..�t' :r A�t �,r�t 4 °n 1 x -' .� 1 �A _j v" '4 F I 7� ��y k�'�� .f � ;a � '� T = �t �'Y . ��4 I �� r ^ � ."Ptq�� h r - t / �7� Y s M^ i '� t ' 1 n � a , . � � �" a � � � ,fi i -�}h � � , F '� f,yw � , r� �y � t � �r� �i r °'��. ,.. ``� �. .e. ` � - �f F y ' 1 � i� � � � , �� ,r 1� e �, �. �a 4��,�� (' - ��: � lti S �� `� ,�� ' i y .-c d _� r� � ��:� �9 ._� ^ r+ ,t � 4�I � ��: � i . � � ;�Y ��V�' �� + t�i.� ` i �. C -� �. � i �' ,� } � ��' wnY �i r ,I A' �� . �`t l t } •t;;j �r �.f � v �; r ,'�t ! � �� t t}�f"�S�LLrt' � 1 I'- lJ I~ � ' VM 1 • faµ� y � �. � F 1 t�� l V �rr-: T,� .: i �- 4� � ' tii� .% (' q •�` � � ) � � ` �i f� ki. ;� � � ' �F � 1'. 1 f �' � � �," f �y� °� , �� ',� �; � �.' � J f� ' / � � �i ' i � t L � a i � A� ��"' � � F . � � .� p� � ��. �¢�� i�� ° P a ( �J� _ � ' 1 �i : §'i }! �/ - < ��. . �i a ° �� " " � a "� '+� •;- a f � ` !"`� .� �t� ' ,r� �� pi � r; i '� ' � .��t ,� -�°�� E ��,� x � r e � ,, ; .: � S � R.} � � +'' �{ . f�� ° �, t� y �i��,, i ,�r i � � � � `l �'' � '- � �y£ / n �•' ��,��,�`�+i! ��a-.�� ` � � �j �" fi � � 4t �, a �� l a �.<'� � ,. s�- � ✓ .Y I� r �� , ' 1 t ,F { ��'�'�� Y. �' d: , 1 ,_r e ,�, � } `; t ,.' r '. �'�� t �rj I �� -/�#!+"s� ss�' j �'V t � a r` 1l � `� �r . � Y �. f� �Yr � ' _�. r _°�� 7n�� "�'�� • `` � �t.�r 1 r t��'� �/ (t, '� !�,r r ' n��p t � �` � 7, :��.� { �✓ �,i y�3 t�,�'� I S '� ��J' �� E � . y� 1� �' � e �� il 'v� �;� v�`� �Y rif JI i `/ . F �� , � � ' + r r � 3�.� �� `q t` `i y l yj� f ��- ,��)'�,, �yy� T�� f _ q_y 'R � l�. �. S� 1�+ } t �' A 1YA�,1�. "'�j�R. !��T ,��1�4�� '+�R�!�'�{ 1ra� ��'�+��w��NM�<. �r p� � '� �� Y'.r � �� _. ��k f t!�r� ' r �.�' ��'� yr�i1��Y ��i� �`� ��.,��i�� 5 � �L y �;'r� y \ �'" + y # xf �v�`iq.�"��1! �,� �'�f:�t - �"�'i��,�,'� �1!�a��.�. � �`� �,�1 �y , kr (,y. 1i d��.: �'` a�,,�y ! � h � � �� '�, � l '. Y 1 uw:t � � 7irF�M R �:y �+ .'�t f . � +C t ��.\ I�� Y r ��1� � � k� � � i'� i � - � i � � . � p� t _ �'� { � .,.. , .- r �° � .�' ` '1� � � t'�{` k ��, + �° � �-' ,. . a ; }b ,� � �r n �� ,� ,r��,} V'* if j' � i�',_��{ 1r� �I�� _,,� .�F� �.�i ��!.�' � � / � � � � .'� ti r"� ��j( '��k�.� �� ":� ��t`A i � p " �. ��. �r � ! � t.� ':�� r�'� f. '"` .y � w � !A_ �a� } � " . Y. �'� k� 1 k t � \ 4 � " �. �`a � „�x o � : �� i�. �.',_ r )�- �. ..� 1� , .,�:�� _ � a � I;�`!�i � � ,:�� a ��, !��9 Ey r � r��4�� a Y� ,_� k h � .i a v .'�t � :r��5 rd,: F .�,5' �zYr�. � � � � ° + � ��`� �.� + � � , ` � r t i' i� i � r z � x i � '; � r T � �, 1 �r - 7 �V ,�.�� x k,!,� � � r � y :1 q 4. � 3 � (.y , y 4 �, y �'; y , �zt�,� r �� 1 / ,� * J rF �. � �. � �.. '� '��r`�� - .,� � `�� - � Y�, - � .�` �n ��ti .y t�y t ._ � � � .d� t'Y { �� ;� ��.,�.J ��rt �. � � ,l� _t r� N �� j,. x'�.? � � E t � 1 �.� � r 1�� 4j'� ?��:. x �' �. 7s�6 �A-� ��' , '� A�� l `f, x '��} ;�° 'Adt .. � �8��2� '�� }�.S x i�.:� iC � af � ,k �f " f��.J�M�},.� 1 � ' . � �'�' � SR'�'�'r � �. y : � � � ; ,�. �N.u�_�k��?5�` ,. h . . � 1� . t ' i� � a� .:y � : s ; . 4 x.: ,� .' r nl� : � .;> I �� i t ��:� s� Y � i� 4 9:� r'j � I � r +'x ; �: � � ,j ) r r E .' t � � � � �� y � ,�� 4 i � � ,� � - � _' � � `' :� � �` � � � ; � , � k � Y� � a I 'e � �3 ��. f t y : t-. : � . � .� _i� . �2 #y t � �.� ,J" �y ��' l � � � �� {'� � �� i z '� �t�e�-� � � F a � � �` r' � (� k � , d � � $� ; ( f y^ X � ��8'� J^� � � u. t ` _ , , t JG Y � f�' � �{ �� '� � �� l l a� b+ �S � ` xF 9 W; : e�t _ ' t �' ��" l 1 i` e �i. ? � I �; � i A�� ( t� i: �`�,� � � r`�i�� . � __� ti � t :'Y�` � i:- �Y � �� .. � b � � ! � �'r.f�' 1 � �t � :� �f ,7 �, r; y � � !�z � � < +� `t k-� {' e+s-. ` t � a ��. {: x ♦ . . � �t 1 �� 6 x;, � �� £' i � �¢�e 4 ; \.� 47 �7� d e �� . d� � ��7 { � �i',�'� �� d��.� ,C � �'i1 �a`�r x �:. � '; • l - 1 p .� � �A , � ,z j��,�x �,( � a �1 r ' '; " .. j, »i J " ' G � a � � i n� u�` ��• ' _ N ' s_� ir'� ., C'r ,� :�- ' ,'. � s.� � ,f ��,�, t�`.� _ '� ).t,t " a --t �� aa � � R �`� ��;ty,� - s�f ^ ��c ; ) � �- J l ;: � �' •v i , . �� '� .� ;,' t '4 •': � ' .:.- 1� � y � � t i �,s � ,.%r / �. F ,. f�:., s . !�... �� y .r �1 �;y f.., r a. { . 1-� M� � .`r"; ..:` t ; � � `,K I � � .Y � t --t�� q , �' �- � — � 1 5 . i r � ✓ ' �i � �� ^ � � � � � j r . �� J � ° ',� -�� y I-,- �'� � � _'� 1- , � r�� . A �.f s y, i i . x"�I � . .' + \ F t - + � '. �� sev . �;4�,�� r t�. ,�� 4.'� '� t i.-. ` �`. � . � ; r � . ?� � . � '� �'� N r � �..�i f � � ,." � ��: � � �� °j+��"5 � �- , �� '�� , ,, t A �. 1 � � . �: �y ' � z� ��.� � . 'F�,� � � ��e� � � � p �� r �� r�r r ��7z� � f,�� n " �/�' .i �� «�.� , ,t�s -�' A ,� s � ' � � Y �� j� �tt R � y ,b� � i ' ' � � � p� � � � . c� ` ,s �i ''�,� '� r ! � 4� '�. ,3,� f � ��e � � � �� _� "� � '�,{ , 9�p^� �' FT , �. �. :4 `i 4 y- v � �1 t {� ], J � � X M ` > �� tp�Y i� :i _ c i� �� P;4�"�� `��E h. l r':rx �i�x � � • � _' ' t . t : ti. a f '.r�� : a i '�,o � "� �"' �a�. � � k �'�`r �o. 4 t�'� � - �r t . � � ✓� [ .r7, : . � ''� t � �i E E :� . r � " X !.��' � .��1 � :.'�� r,; rz, � �,�' �,. �1 I i i�'"�� r � � 1` ��i � �J il„ ; � i� �� ' �� l� � a�� ..� � 6. i � �� ' � ��f� � 4 ` � ,; � ' �� 1 6 �°r t� �� t`t� f , x r i , � (, �y ti ~�� .` ^�" � � r��4 ��; S` i �: x ��' �,_: � '� : t Y ��3,E � o f 4 ( �` T.f ,t a � �� .�:��'; .r'�, x �1`� �� .d�' � .,� F�� 5.4�. tt .K4�s � ./ rJ � ; �:-f �' ,�ti �� k'�;.+ �l� � ,�JF.',t t � ��j .{; � l�,x*�"'��?�� t° h S�ii'` it �'"a��,+�},�S"y,,?�.�, '�'6J,�' �1.,�1 hi h.A+, � a� k� '� '.� t ,x� ^f�,s � �({ Y � r �Y y�� T �''�� y 1 :� > � y � y,�,)T t ..' i �F� a �1 4�,t., r � � �� :h �k � F�. ..N �4 I.� il � +� �'� C v�s�: � �, ( �, } , z Fe i-. 7� { ;SBy.} �€�, 5 �T ;»� e k�: a�♦xtdY;� sa _'. ?� .� � c 1,.. i� �.s � � q {'Y i � � :(.y, 7 -,1 'r �..,� 1 �?s t #�t 'i� � 4 5 y y �.-,, �; '7 t ' ^� d..�. ,i"�r � J '� j�� .',� < �i�"t =�r �i..,� , � e . a i f " ` ` �„5� �;e� a � ' � �'a +q# t'J: 1�''! �>� � � r �f�!tr✓ k `� i c �.` ty7 � % rs '�C" ` 4 i f 1 � � f ►� -. �1' ,�` �.: e `S. ! ��y� �' �i ^t��• �; s= 3 � 7 i � � r f �.M s . "� � y. 4 : t �;,. .. �y� .! �, � �� . �. � '�7, 1 `t 54 s l f s `t �$.y� y .'l ...u r a � � � ; �'� (* � r t �E ,..; � �a ,� � .. � a,a �• �`�6 E > �±� ? ��7 - � i ,� � t ^_� . r . [ . '�..' ° '! �� `��f�� L b �i+ � i ;r y �� !k�.fi 3 f 5 � �r k,_ , t 1' N;� r'4 , �� 1 � ..,� e�♦ ' '� . y �,r��'.;2.: .,q �i 1 tSd �L� �! i�'r�'+,} j.r s�''��; �r� � _ x w^ 4P�{ ��y 15�t�� hi , iV. s � �� -:a r° �.4. � �..:! �a��? ,c.�,s: �'.:,�:•1.. r..�+� . ;i.. ,.;�.��:, ...__ . t .. . . Lf :. . . n z.... .z. ..,� �w L , . .� .. .. ..., , a_u°_._ . ,3i.�� , . ,._ .. ._,rs .',.�. � .. .._a�l.. .,s �.1:...� . � �= - ,,,�� °�..� '��4 Cit= Op Si. CITY OF SAINT PAUL 4 � 'E a-�_��°,,, ; DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ECONOMIC D VELOPMENT � ' �� o' DIVI510 OF PLANNING . � 25 West Fourth Streef,Saint aul,Minnesota 55102 +ss• 612-22&3270 GEORGE LATIMER MAYOR REC�IVED September 12, 1988 �EF 131988 �' r�� Albert Olson, City Clerk xoom 3s6, City Hall CITY CL�RK Saint Paul, MN 55102 RE: Zoning File #10344 - John and Helen Regenold, 435 W. Idaho Ave: City Council Hearing: September 22, 1988 �' PURPOSE: A rezoning from RM-1 (Multiple Family Residential) to P-1 (Parking District) to construct a parking lot with a 20 car garage and 12 surface spaces. PLANNING CONIl�IISSION RECOMMENDATION: Approve (16-0) . i ZONING COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Approve (6-0) . STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approve. SUPPORT: None. OPPOSITION: 1 letter received. I Dear Sir: On August 18, 1988, the Zoning Committee of the Planning Commission held a public hearing on this rezoning. The petitioner testified. At the close of the public hearing, the Committee voted 6 to 0 to approve the rezoning ba�sed on staff findings. ! On August 26, 1988, the Planning Commission upheld the Zoning Committee's recommendation on a unanimous voice vote. This rezoning is scheduled to be heard by the City Council on September 22, 1988. Please notify me by September 21, 1988 if any member of the City douncil wishes to have slides of the site presented at the public hearing. Sincerely, �� .Q.Q. � Lisa J. Freese I City Planner LTF:rm Attachments I ' -��.�r� � �� v. , i � � � � PETITION TO AMEND ZONING CODE ' CITY OF SAINT PAUL ZONING OFFICE USE ONLY � � File # �� 3y� Application Fee $ � �. RECEIVED Tentative Hearing Date JUL 11986 Number of Lots or Size of P�arcel : ZONIN G ___________________________�__=_=_=_==__ TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CI�Y COUNCIL DATE 19�� c/o Zoning Office, 1100 City Hall Annex Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 I � Pursuant to Section 64.210 of the St. Paul Zoning Ordinance and Sectior� 462.357(5) of the Minnesota Statutes, ��ti�v�o�(� �, the owner of all of the land proposed for rezoning, hereby petitions your Honorable Bo�dy to rezone the following described property: � I Street Address: J�W �o C� O D D U�6. �'�' L� � � Legal Description: �E � �IS.oO �CT Df� r S Q�-a�J�� C�cv�r�' 1'vl', w.�,�� s G'��,��.,e�� ,��o.T,e� J��.T � /�.e,��rr�-Y Ce E,�.�T��1e� � from a �� ` Zoniing District to a � � Zoni g District for the purpose of l,.o G^i � (� C^S � W. d� ��, s�. P,� N� N ��p.��rrM��N T ,��.d�� i Subscribed and sworn to By: �• before me this � da of 19� Titl : � . �c.�.. P ag 1 of � otary Public � a nnnnnnn • I p 3�,�/L 2� � �.�, NOEL A. DIEDfilCH ZpN1NG FILE �:'��:,-`—�`��+` MOTA�iY PL"BLlC—AiINNESOTA :• ,�;�, `��'`;;�,�a,`�.: R.��f Sci'COUtdTY � PAY CQi'�9Rfl.EX?IRES MRR. 27,1991 Y°✓V�NVWV' • �.. � /„ �� /� `I3 • � � CONSENT OF ADJOINING PROPERTY OWNERS TO REZONING I , . � I We, the undersigned, owners of property within 100 feet of the total co�tiguous descriptions of real estate owned, purchased, or sold by Petitioner within o�e year preceding the date of this petition, acknowledge that we have been furnished with the following: I 1 . A copy of the Petition of ��G AHO �E EN o name of petitioner 2. A copy of Sections � o• �� through � o• � ,3 , inclusive of the St. Paul Zoning Code; and ' I acknowledge that we are aware of all of the uses permitted under a �— �I Oistrict zoning classification and we are aware that any of these uses can b� established upon City Council approval of the rezoning; and we hereby consent to the reza�iny of the Froperty described in th2 I Petition of �I�,4CIG '�� E��N �GEN�� to a � �- I District. name of petitioner j P/lY. LOT BLOCK ADDIT�ON RECORD OWNER SIGNATURE DATE �� /. ��.n:..�S! � ��,��-or. ��EC--� / n p ,!1 S-N��'T F vJ� Cz.�..��-� /� . I /O �/ �O� / 5 � f,.�-�%„ `k!. CC�aa'.a �ar, QC�ti..d�.�.. �' 6 s�er. T E nt t s, e x s '� �--t^��- C-' 4 �''YMn.G; I �'/��c'S1' . � �S/s�r. ��.�Eee--4 /�cts".a.. W� o F Fo IC. yARr�e F.. -y��' , �f.t.a!o ��.,�i � i ��) Lora9rty 3L, _oF /� i` ! jQ,,� (j�'� Z �y( cFRuG�FAoM�,',.L�n� 0�' ...lw,fry,.,-e� �" . _�qc V� ^ /J� v � fo� �X-5 �9f7. ef Ml, ofuv.�-� . 2l�a,e... �� ' . `�p) -79:r. ��DazE-s9ff,o ��,.6,�,�,''J� /�� . / v Wl93fr.oF /7S�/oFF�° - T� �� GVGti� (J /� f�� ..o ��,..a- . z.�.�..�-'� �('��r#. �? e�, q..��. �r/ )� �,f� sosr:?� aET�/Ra� �NO �1..,...Q �„ ` /I�J/��._)�"__� % �D ��.. ' A�ot<cTS , �W`�'G� �� .. &/ 2.�,.�.= �.�-..Q. a.,,E �'``" �s) /->r.s� B�-K- 3 �....�...-r-(..� ��-°-�. �• I .. � �i �� -so F�. F Ed�..�:..`�f zllswb Oa.�..�L' S. vv[,'-s�niz�...A. �f /)/) (�c� <°T" s' !s�/t �/ G..�L��-�.E. �G � �1(;s�/�/ / U`l � ��J l v� U 5-� ,,�.�t 3 P�A�L �6-,..-:4i(. Zc;a..E-4 f c E O w a E R: 38� of_Le�rs d s at ��..,..�:�4,.,� �m,,...v yE q�•-�+o Er A� �%EfY"`"„' � � I b '� �y ��'A c�r ary �.cK B �� I� '1 �� pe�,as rca aeQ ; �....ti�. �� 6 �,� N� of�o sa-AHO kl.l. �.:.�j zJr...i �.+-.c-a�fl� 3 9� �F L•�'a9 B�K 8 �-'',"..G"�"`E- /�.Qo-�.=..�--�E"-Q �r. A►- :�o� t m r s o �K 8 ��..-�- �r.�-�- -�°u"�` 4f �..�..�..� ��, � � 6Ti 3 -8-� i/a) �•T 30 — �r'.o Cl•a��t�- �°`..�. . Er A1- �J ' I f? � T� �G , e C! '�3� .0 o7' a 9 — �.�efw .��.t`6 � ��..�`-a-�. L�o I / p Z�` 5� L �d ��'�) .�e r 3 Y — ".�°'/`° �¢c�ia�, ��ca-�JP�. � ��-�-� Petitions shall not be considered as offi4ially filed until the lapse of 7 wo�king days after a petition is received in the Zoning Office. Any signator of any petit�on may withdraw his name therefrom by written request within that time. I e! � of 3 ��NING FILE 1o3__yy-- � �._.._ _. � I . .. , �. � , I . -� � CONSENT OF AOJOINING PROPERTY OWNERS TO REZONING We, the undersigned, owners of property within 100 feet of the total contiguous descriptions of real estate owned, purchased, or sold by Petitioner within one year preceding the dat� of this petition, acknowledge that we have been furnished wlith the following: 1 . A copy of the Petition of G �ND ��-G� ��E a�D name of petitioner 2. A copy of Sections � O• �J�a through � o, , a 3 , inclusive of the St. Paul Zoning Code; and acknowledge that we are aware of all of the uses permitted under a __�� District zoning classification and we are aware that any of these uses can be�— established upon City Council approval of the rezoning; and we hereby consent to the �2zo�iny of the Froperty de�cribed in th2 I Petition of A� �Nn /�I. �CE�Slalp to a — District. name of petitioner I , LOT BLOCK ADDITION RECORD OWNER SIGNATURE DATE �a ,Z e.r �9, ____ ,�/,�1.�Q�e.,. -��, � .'� ,""' Y 6/ �°r a G — .�`O (./cP�s., ��-b�• �C-�eLLf�w E� A� k/7� .t o r a s _ „(/a,/*., �/�+-�' p� �.1+�"' t r A t• ��rg� %��Nu ia ---- ��w��'"„ /K�� /� ��°' ,EY•E L3 T �d�.�-:-_�(' 2t!'n*�-% �...Es-��cY'-an.E. L'o .ks�t � , �S) .c eT i ,�.c K � �-�..�.°�..�•� " � _ �,//G/�� ,a �5 Fr. F w.y; �.�.,.-k� �;�.�.� ,.�. T'"� �bL) ,[or a ;/3�r,( 6 cs...»f....Ca--� ��I.fl�� li/7<s'ir. �� os �a....%-�7.t�..�..'o c�.� oc.,(�•»,.c�M. ` (}Q ��r� ,�o T a �3.�K b �«.c�.-�.--•� �.,�X�i . !7 O 1I f Y N.9S F. e t ��,,,.:.,��..s,a �'!��+.�� .s.bu�. Cf �Gg� .t.oY- a Ls�tK � ��'�~� . I ' � �I- �' E /oo FT. •i L�sF:-�I. Zr�a�,� �r,..-� Q�.�',�a! ET Al. � 6 -'��(J / ,�a� L oT / Ii�.,r s ��-�C' ., N .� ,. �.a.� ��..� 6 —a �—�� hRT o/�.tey- /5�y u F Fo4 ��/N ZJ.0+ Q,.R,..G r`W � �q. '�� /� L Bec W vJ.a ef Apa G7FT. �_. . /� i�.. /' /•y Fp.wt NW CeC Te S E C ryt ��,.� ��,,,�f�. .LGG�� .X� �,� OFSO Lot AM� A�L GF �T � �� «� su8r� [sw� ri[ Poa s.1y � Qsl4-�-� 7:�(�is«.� �r. mv w 79 f. ANU E S�Fr. �� Cl V �' ,�j ( l�/��' �/!) ri oJ�/LO-r'. or s�q e� .c � BLK . f X W S9 Xo FT, �..&...» � 2/�aw,�. Qo�+�- � .�+-�..-..�c� Et AL. / ' ;/a) .teT s a�K a �^.."�s«�"`°Q � �1' (C �� 5 'S� w. Q 9 �� Fr. o� ��...... 9c! zJ.w.� (L.2,.C/ .�..E.� Er A t � � ��3) ,[o r s es,c K a �;-._e..-�°.-.� d� ,�1,� / c�_ Petitions shall not be considered as officially filed until the lapse of 7 working days after a petition is received in the Zoning Office. Any signator of any petition may withdraw his name therefrom by written request within that time. � _ ._.._.e.�ge 2 of � � �'��'�' � �� I � , �� . �� l� � � I . , CONSENT OF ADJOINING PROPERTY OWNERS TO REZONING , We, the undersigned, owners of property within 100 feet of the total contiguous descriptions of reai estate owned, purchased, or sold by Petitioner within one year preceding the date of this petition, acknowledge that we have been furnished with the following: � 1 . A copy of the Petition of C N° �,��N �G�No.�� name of petitio er 2. A copy of Sections � �• �a a through � o• 7a.3 , inclus�ive of the St. Paul Zoning Code; and acknowledge that we are aware of all of the uses permitted under a � l I District zoning classification and we are aware that any of these uses can be� established upon City Council approval of the rezoning; and we hereby consent to the re2o�ing of the Froperty described in the Petition o A� �'�� E,�EN � ��E�Slo�.O to a — � District. name of petitioner LOT BLOCK ADDITION RECORD OWNER SIGNATURE DATE �� ,�.�.�..�, o. /- Q �/9) .[or � 8fK � (�;�'�"� 2c�E�u-. Er A� � CD �O . ��...,.�r a�.....� ��,�. 1�f. �.�u:r. ��q� �ar ac 6�K 8 a.«� �.rs i-a ��?�� '�"Q r'sv C! . �j �'1�� i.NS �— 8.�2.,'C�e.,, � �• �Q � Q ,t o T 3 69� 1 eT S' — ��iP��•-- % q �P C 'o` f� .s�c � " // � k ��o� t.r 7 — ..G��,r�:.�:.� �°.�`� �, " � �. I (v ///k � .��, A �""F� (L 3) �l o T S — � QoE.E'c�"cc..: � '°f � /�/ �/ /G 4 l i� i, i� I� /�I�,.f...- /G(• �_i'Sy-'„�C ..¢.f�c.c � ,. (� (�/�LS f � ' ' , " (�...Q. � J..s" �(. ` (y `63)� LaT � _ _ .J.�o� ��`°'.. v �� (�' �/ /�fS l� �G�� T / cf n �° ��= ��iQG�°- R�.... 9e/ %�.u.� �t+"'� (l ��/ O � I ��5�.. 9i/ Zc��....'. � �'o� .Cof 3 ,6R,Y � �.,�,,.�o,.,f �"`�' ,lj `��-.� . / � �..a � ��... � '/&9) .[o r 9 `-- .�4e G�d�2.-�.%-.' �,T ` / ..C�� !J 'J ,�,� � �'�."�..��..... �a �, �v � ,��T� 1G��wa�i<r�. � � _ Petitions shall not be considered as offi;,ially filed until the lapse of 1 working days after a petition is received in the Zoning Office. Any signator of any petition may withdraw his name therefrom by written request within that time. '0,��/ Pa e.� of 3 ZON�NG FI�.E -.-�--�- `4. � .n. I � • ' ST�rTE`'OF MINNESOTA) I : SS i COUNTY OF RAMSEY ) , , bein first duly sworn, deposes and states that Ihe is the 9 person who circulated the within petition and consent, consisting of page�; that affiant is informed and believes that the parties described are the owners res ectively of the lots placed immediately before each name, that affiant is informed and elieves __ that each of the parties described above is the owner of property which is wit in 100 feet from any property owned or purchased by petitioner or sold by petitio�er within one (1 ) year preceding the date of this petition which is contiguous toithe property described in the petition; that except for __ none of the parties described above has purchased or is purchasin property frpm petitioner contiguous to the above described property within one �(1) year of t�he date of the petition; that this consent was signed by each of said owners in the presence of this affiant, and that the signatures are the true and correct signatures of e�ach and all of the parties so described. i �-1. i " (.� �'Yl�. �� Address r."�.1nM/!tiM M MMP/\M.".A�MA A/t�tP.AM�� ,/ /� :. tL� :�, a;'' � H I"'i t < r1 � �j7'C. � /i'rl�x— � I S �� / r:'" !��`:',r?t,t ,: _ .SuT;1 ; � �<.t � r i Y � � �� - 3a.� `� ` �� f Y�'i:,'v �"� �� :,11��i.2?, t°`�' S � n�.�:��f��<�'ti��'�`"''''�'"°�'v"'° Telephone Number Subscribed and sworn to before � me th i s �� day of��____, 19�' I �-1�u��,�-s�- � Nota y Publ;c i � i i � . i � I Ap�roved as to form - Feb. 85 Page � of �_ Planning Department ZONING FIl.E �03�� i I - _ . ,.,, .. . . . . - ;- _. . _ ' _ . � . . .. - _ . . ___ .. � . . . 1sC �D — _d'.l" .2nd 1 �—�.�� 3rd 1 1— / — g c� Adopted 1�� c�� Yeas . Nays I DIMOND ��P7--� GOSWITZ ��p/�-- : I LONG . RE7'TMAN . SONNEN " I _ : WILSON MR. PRESIDFNT� SCHEIBEL I _ : . 1 , : : . I _ . .. . I .: . ' _ � , � I , ' . : . ': , I : I I ` _ _ ... . . _ - + - _ . . � � . • .. I , . I , . • city of saint paul � pianning commission resolution file number $8-66 C�te Au�ust z6, �98s . � WHEREAS, Jack and Helen Regenold, file #10344, have petitioned to rezone t e northwest corner'of West Idaho Avenue and Arundel (approximately 435 West daho Avenue) from RM-1 to P-1 for the purpose. of constructing a parking lot wit a 20 car garage and 12 surface spaces to be used by an existing apartment building o the east (429 West Idaho Avenue) ; and WHEREAS, the Zoning Committee of the Planning Commission on August 18, 198 , held a public hearing at which all persons present were given an opportunity to b heard pursuant to said application in accordance with the requirements of Sectio 64.400 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code; and WHEREAS, Saint Paul Planning Commission, based on the evidence presented t its Zoning Committee at the public hearing as substantially reflected in the m nutes, made the following findings of fact: � 1. The applicant proposes to construct a parking area to serve the existi g 30 unit building to the east (429 West Idaho Avenue) . A total of 32 spaces wo ld be provided: 20 in a large garage which would have doors on both the nor h and south side and 12 surface spaces along the north edge of the site. 2. The apartment building was constructed in 1968 and currently provides 33 parking spaces: 12 garage spaces and 21 surface spaces_ Under the present zo ing code parking requirements, a 30 unit building would be required to provide 5 off- street parking spaces. Since the building was constructed prior to th adoption of the current parking standards, the parking shortfall of 12 spaces is considered legal nonconforming. 3. The applicant states that the apartment market has changed since the b ilding was constructed and today most apartment dwellers are requesting garages. In fact, there are six tenants on the waiting list for the 12 existing ga ages. I (continued) , moved by MORTON s�;conded by REPKE I in favor - �nanimni,g against - ._ - . . . . _ . ., _ .. , G / 2 . _ . �D - �(o ��./�, _ � - _ . � " , , _ . . , . I File �10344 Page Two 4. The apartment is located in an RM-2 zoning district. The parcel in question is zoned RM-1, a more restrictive district. Section 62.104(3) requires th t off- street parking facilities for nonresidential uses (a) be on the same zo�iing lot, (b) in a P-1 vehicular parking district, or (c) within the same or less restrictive zoning district as the principal use. So, to allow parking for the apartment on this parcel, it must be rezoned RM-2 or P-1. The applicant is petitioning for the P-1 district. 5. The P-1 parking district is intended to permit the establishment of off street parking facilities to be used solely for off-street parking of private assenger vehicles as a use incidental to a principal use. The applicant's petit on is for incidental parking. 6. .Establishing a P-1 zoning district requires a review of eight conditions as .set forth in Section 60.723; these conditions and the applicant's ability t� meet them are as follows: ' a. The parking facility sha1l be accessory to and for use in connection with one or more businesses. The parking facility is intended solely for the use of the existing apartaent building at 429 West Idaho Street. b. The parking facility sha11 not be used during hours when the princi a1 use is not in operation. During such periods the parking facility sha11 be inaccessible for public use. The parking facility is accessory to a residential use and therefore, access � to the lot is necessary on a 24-hour basis. c. The parking facility sha11 be used solely for parking of private pas'Isenger vehicles and sha11 not be used as an off-street Zoading area. The applicant has stated parking is the sole intended use. (continued) I � I _ t _ . � . .. , . . - . . .� � . � . � . - - � ' - � . ...�a. . i . . . - .�.. ' . . . .. . . . . . ... . ' . - -...�...,' • File #10344 Page Three d. No commercial repair work or service of any kind, or sale or displa thereof, sha11 be conducted in such parking facility. The applicant states that the tenants are not allowed to store inop rable vehicles or repair vehicles on the parking lot. e. No signs of any kind, other than signs designating entrances, exits and conditions of use, sha11 be maintained on such pa.rking facflity. No signage is planned for the site. f. No building other than that for the shelter of attendants sha11 be rected upon the premises unless specifically approved by the planning admi istrator during site plan review. The applicant plans to construct a 40' by 110' 20-car garage struct re.The Planning staff is reviewing the site plan and the proposed garage a pears to meet setback provisions and building code requirements. g. Applications for P-1 District rezoning sha11 include a site plan wh"ch conforms to a11 standards set for[h in section 62.Z04. The site plan submitted meets all standards of 62.104, with the exc ption of the south driveway. The zoning code requires tha� all driveways be set back 30' from the curbline, but this driveway is only 19' north of the c rbline of Idaho Street. On August 9, 1988, the Board of Zoning Appeals gr nted a variance to allow this driveway. h. P-1 Vehicular Parlcing Districts sha11 be developed and maintained i ' accordance with the requirements of section 62.104. All standards of the code can be met by this proposal. (continued) � . ._ . . . . ._ _ - I - _ - _., I File #10344 Page Four I, 7. The City's Comprehensive Plan Land Use section states that " . . , the City through . . , zoning . . . will encourage businesses to reduce traffic and parking problems. " The addition of the lot will reduce the on-street parking presently occurring on Arundel and Cumberland Streets adjacent to the apartment building. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, by the Saint Paul Planning Commission that the petition of Jack and Helen Regenold to rezone property at the northwest corner of West Idaho Avenue and Arundel (appraximately 435 West Idaho Avenue) more particularly described as the East 118 feet of Lot 5, Block 3, Edwin N. Warje's Cumberland Addition Plat 1, from a RM-1 zoning classification to a P-1 zoni�g classification is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan for the City; and BE IT FIJRTHER RESOLVED� that the Saint Paul Planning Commission does hereby recommend to the Council of the City of Saint Paul that property located at the northwest corner of West Idaho Avenue and Arundel (approximately 435 West I aho Avenue) be rezoned from RM-1 to P-1 in accordance with the petition for rez ning on file with the Saint Paul Planning Division. , �� I �I , � � � , . . _ - ... . r :«. . I . _ . � MINUTES OF THE ZONING COMMITTEE I CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS, SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA ON AUGUST 18, 1988 PRESENT: Mmes. Hirte, Morton, Tracy and Zieman; Messrs. Christenson, L�e , Neid and Repke of the Zoning Committee; Mr, Segal, Assistant C ty Attorney; Ms. Lane of the Building Inspection and Design Divis on; Ms. Freese, Ms. Murray and Mr. Soderholm of the Planning Divis on staf�:� ABSENT: None. The meeting was chaired by Gladys Morton, Chairman. Jack and Helen Re�enold (#10344) : A Rezoning for property located at approximately 435 West Idaho (northwest corner at Arundel) to construct a parking lot with a 20 car garage and 12 surface spaces. The applicant was present; there was no opposition present at the hearing. Ms. Freese offered to answer questions from the Zoning Committee regardin the staff report recommending approval of the rezoning. There were no inquiries. Mr. Christenson made a motion to recommend approval of the rezoning based on staff report findings 1 through 7. Ms. Ziaman seconded the motion which j passed on a unanimous voice vote. Submitted by: Approved by: G7J�-�.a �"'�-r�,�-e- , Lisa Freese Gladys Morton, Chairman ' i � r�� . � � f 7,� ZONING COMMITTEE STAFF REPORT FILE #10344 1. APFLICANT: Helen and John Regenold DATE OF HEARING: 8/18/88 2. CLASSIFICATION: Rezoning from RM-1 (Multiple Family residential) to P-1 (parking) . 3. LOCATION: Approximately 435 West Idaho (northwest corner at Arundel) 4. PLANNING DISTRICT: 6 ! 5. LEGAL DESCRIPTION: East 118 feet of Lot 5, Block 3, Edwin N. Ware's Cum erland Addition Plat 1. 6. PRESENT ZONING: RM-1 ZONING CODE REFERENCE: 60.720, 6 .104(3) 7. STAFF INVESTIGATION AND REPORT: DATE: 8/9/8$ BY: Lisa J. Freese A. PURPOSE: To construct a parking lot with a 20 car garage and 12 surface spaces to be used by an existing apartment building to the east (429 West Idaho Avenue) . B. SUFFICIENCY: The petition was declared sufficient by the Planning Division on July 13, 1988; 37 parcels eligible, 25 parcels required, 30 parcels signed. C. PARCEL SIZE: A lot split application has been filed by the applicant. tChe proposed parcel has 118' of frontage on West Idaho and 120' on Arundel f r a total lot area of 14,160 square feet. D. EXISTING LAND USE: Vacant E. SURROUNDING LAND USE: - North: Vacant, RM-1 i East: Multiple family residential, RM-2 I South: Mixed residential, RM-2 � West: Vacant - 1 lot, one- and two-family residential beyond, RM-1 F. FINDINGS: , 1. The applicant proposes to construct a parking area to serve the existing 30 unit building to the east (429 West Idaho Avenue) . A total of 32 spaces would be provided: 20 in a large garage which would have doors on both the north and south side and 12 surface spaces along the north edge of the site. 2. The apartment building was constructed in 1968 and currently provides 33 parking' spaces: 12 garage spaces and 21 surface spaces. Under the present zoni g code parking requirements, a 30 unit building would be required to provide 45 off- street parking spaces. Since the building was constructed prior to the doption of the current parking standards, the parking shortfall of 12 spaces is considered legal nonconforming. . 3. The applicant states that the apartment market has changed since the bui ding was constructed and today most apartment dwellers are requesting garages In fact, there are six tenants on the waiting list for the 12 existing gara es. 4. The apartment is located in an RM-2 zoning district. The parcel in question is zoned RM-1, a more restrictive district. Section 62.104(3) requires that off- street parking facilities for nonresidential uses (a) be on the same zoning lot, (b) in a P-1 vehicular parking district, or (c) within the same or less restrictive zoning district as the principal use. So, to allow parking �for the apar�t��ent on this parcel, it must be rezoned RM-2 or P-1. The applicant is pe�itioning for the P-1 district. � I . I File #10344 Page T�ao I 5. The P-1 parking district is intended to permit the establishment of off-Istreet parking facilities to be used solely for off-street parking of private p ssenger vehicles as a use incidental to a �r�ncipal use. The applicant's petiti�n is for incidental parking. 6. Establishing. a P-1 zoning district r�quires a review of eight conditions as set forth in Section 60.723; these conditions and the applicant's ability to meet them are as follows: a. The parking facility sha11 be accessorp to snd for use in connectiori with one or more businesses. The parking facility is intended solely for the use of the existing apartment building at 429 �:est Idaho St.e�t. b. The parking facility sha11 not be used during hours when the principal use is not in operation. Durir.g s�ch periods the parking facility shallibe inaccessible for public use. The parking facility is accessory to a residential use and thereforei, access to the lot is necessary on a 24-hour basis. c. The parking facility shaZ1 be c3.se:i sole�p for parking of private pas�enger vehicles and sha11 not be used as an of�-street Zoading area. The applicant has stated parkir_g is the sole intended use. I d. No commercial repair work or service of aay kind, or sale or display thereof, sha11 be conducted in such parking facility. The applicant states that the terants are not allowed to store inoperable vehicles or repair vehicles on the parking iot. e. No signs of any kind, otker than signs designating entrances, exits �and conditions of use, shaZ1 be maintained on such parking facility. I No signage is planned for the site. f. No building other than that for tze she?ter of attendants 'sha11 be erecCed upon the premises unless specifically approved by the planning administrator during site plan revie-a. The applicant plans to construct a 40' by 110' 20-car garage struct re.The , Planning staff is reviewing the s:te plan and the proposed garage appears to meet setback provisions and build:ng code requirements. g. Applications for P-1 Disrrict rez�ning sh�Z1 include a site plan which conforms to a11 standards set for=h in section 62.104. The site plan submitted �eets all stand�res of 62.104, with the exception of the south driveway. The zoning cade recuires that all driveways be set back 30' from the curbline, but this d_ivewa�- is only 19' north of the curbline of Idaho Street. On Aug�,:st 9, 1°'sE, the E,�ard of Zoning Appeals granted a variance to allow this drive�:ay. , h. P-1 Vehicular Parking Districts s�all be ceveloped and maintained in accordance with the requ�re�ents �r sec�ic� 62.104. I Al1 standards of the code can be net by tris proposal. 7. The City's Comprehensive Pls.-� Land Lisa section states that " . . . the Cit�y through . . . zoning . . . will encourage busiresses to reduce traffic and parking problems. " The addition of the lot ti-ill reduce the on-street parking p esently occurring on Arundel and Cua:�erland S�reets a�jacent to the apartment b�ilding. G. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Based on staf� findings 1 through 7, staff recom�hends approval of the rezoning fro� R*i-1 tc P-1 a:. 435 West Idaho. . I . I _ : . ,.�...... -,: . - .. � � c� F�'�"�`°`'°§` .'� � �'�'",_ y _ ;. :� .,- r x w �� ` * ��/� K.�v},,_ ,, _4 w T. .. y� I = 3 -�-�+ • ..i Y , ' . � � � �, I �� ° � ' -. .r� �,. +; � � '' ;°- � -{,'�:��'k.;` ' . <., I . �.� ,� i i �, �' �.�.. .a .o � x , r�.' _ �.�,.�.,., I. � = ° ,,� ysS'.��'q ,� .N � 3 �nm ^ ,� .. ,`� r�,'t l� . . �.y R c c i ' � - a'y aan .. - . 1..v`t. -�ys�, �' . -��-- ' � - . . -- ' � . . F'.♦ . . - •-_ .�s'q `.1V.-.:.- . I . ..� . �... .' ..�.... . ,� . . .. .. --r 1��d�1S h�Yl�1� 1 -:I�;�e=:�,Nn� y��dzs ��o_��'.._ .__.._ . - . ` � • !; �-- �;��--� I ,.�--,,r,_,— . —f-----o-,+£ ---�— o.,_.-r�: _ _ -�c�c" .;-e/ �-^� . , �_ — ------ ', ----_��,. v �-� �j-- � t � 1=< - , .:ry� �� . r; �i '< � . 1{ � - ^ n � � _ � � w V 2 ". . — 3Ni�;Alldd`'Y,�— I-� ,�/ 1y . `', - � i __ — zl � • � � e~ � . - '__ . � � �'i� �I �_ xl �,N�y 3 � j I �J i..N�w � �� '��' �� 1 ¢ � i k ��- [ .� F \�.- ,. � .\�� I � , � _ ' � �� G� '~ �" `\�1�` •\ . ``\ <;�I� �,f > . r . • i F �' i %p� 3 \ \G � c = � � .s��y ��0 � m � �� u �j•J �sr.f � __ . oL�`v _,i x . ' . . . pp: ., _ '-�.Fb •w' '� ___'_ __. ._ '' M,O , �,' . :��.sr w .. /'� _ . -..- ' .- �.v ., n i �1..� I � 3` tr�; Ct---_ . \'1�� 'i - v � I 2 " ��.; ID ` {� ~ I �� ' \M�� 'C'I � , ' 3 ~ w _ : t I \\� �� : �c \ � �l-� . o h - . . [' � m 30 �. �i ,• m - . _ t `� . o� �y r r ae 1� � � �n � W ; x (� � � �4� : ZO , � � �c,y� �� Qq � � V . � ¢�Z „ � � j `\\a \F,� �� r . � ;�, i � • o �� ,;\ �`^ � io: ; _ � ` 3 4� ��C Y ��' \a �tiu 1 2� ' _� I� , � � I . I Z �_ \. R. e�: '. �� `a � e ~ a, :. • ,� � r l�e�v 3 p�4FG� =��.i Z � �� . ' � , ;J j c�c o � � �; � �'�5: ` �� 2 I � �^ y o v. +. � frJ{ 1' Q ��.-J. e: � K �� . ti ':�t . +' 1 .� . �v ' � 3� . .-�'��-� '� ` j� Y 1 � i u� •� Z . �Z; = 1� c�i � � ' �. b `0. � � I � I o � I v �O . .` < �r- � ~�� f " O� � O ; y� '•7. rr s+� . 4, o� � �� . l O' � ,` I 1 '� o� v�i 1� � . i ;O1 l7 p �. � �� i � �� Z ,4� 9 .L° I ' ^C � �. � p i � O�-- . � , ' � � z o. , ' =o z:' � � I i `+� 1 ?�r i t �O 10?O � v .� G, :d O:s�yeJ �-. .;� r� � � � O � � � � ,''�.; : 1 �I� � ,�� .,o-ot/ W ' ' _ �iN�y Ai��1oy� = I. � ` ��\ /` 3 F Q ;� `•-� � �; W '� y I� ., � � ` ` � � � � � _ � \ � i I Q ° ,�`"_,8�—f � i �' � ` � - 1 C / oi f;8-� \ k°e` 4 � � �I Q ; 'J _ �_ ' � *' ,� ` * o a� Z ` �I ; q � - v c � � �I N , � �' � � � 4 i � -+ t r . I/ .. t , � ' � ' y \` �N �� . � � � �V � 'U � �� F ` t ! � i C .. '_ y :, . . O -�V , W � ? F � a V � �� tl � . .o ° � �'�n .�. ~N �. F � i �� . �� •• S��Q r � oaD '�a � 0 � � a� ! � � 4 � ��-�- I = � �- � fl e �; 3 � _ � o �f ac- � �o. ,,, .�. � e �: . � � 3 �=... � - � � � . - � 3 � � + M ' r ' ' I �,� + � ��' �� o rt i �� i a �o f � I • t t W4 . � ~ Z� � ZO v � ; i �f . I I � " . . • � -- . .. _ . - _ - ` - . . i � . .. I � . . ,• - _ . - . . _ - . _ , j . : - -_ � " �� /� � �`�" - " _ I ' , � _ � . . I _ " . I • I August 16, 1988 ATTN: Lisa Freese � Zoning Committee . 25 West Fourth Street I St. Paul, MN 55102 . RE: Public Hearing on Thursday, August 18, 1988 FILE �0344 FILE NANfE Regenold I Dear Zoning Committee: � I I firid this hearing my opportunity to voice my concern regarding on street parking along Cumberland Avenue, which parallels Arundel St�eet and is perpendicular to West Idaho. I It has been my concern for some time that emergency vehicles do not have adequate access to my home for the following reasons: I 1. Cumberland Avenue permits parking on both sides of the street, therefore narrowing it so only one vehicle can I pass through at one time. 2. Arundel Street is not completed through to Larpenteur Avenuel. 3. Cohansey Street is only wide enough to accomodate one vehiclle at a time. 4. Makubin Street along Elmhurst Cemetery is not paved. I I feel the zoning committee should address whether the building of ga�rages could alleviate parking congestion along Cumberland Avenue, therefore improving access to my home for emergency vehicles. I propose that one side of Cumberland Avenue, preferably the west si�}e, be designated as 'NO PARKING' . The west side of Cumberland runs inf�"ont of the apartment building for which these garages are being builte I It is my hope that aithough I cannot attend this hearing, my concernlwill be heard, and my proposal taken into consideration. I , I hope to hear from you regarding the feasibility of my proposal. I I Sincerely, , - . . Karen Frilseth � 1573 Arundel Street �� G,�� St. Paul, MN 55117 � cc: Traffic Engineering Department i Division of Public Works 25 West Fourth Street - 8th Floor � St. Paul, MN 55102 i I . - I . , , - : � : _ / - � - p . . - d ` ,�(� � . : . _ � �� , , . ,. _ . --. -• �- ., . ... .. � ,► . � • 1 N A A .�... ! �� r f � � � � r � _�� ..� � � �O � • �sa � , � s � : ` D( = 7/1` � ~ �� + � � � � `r • w � L �'! 1 • ��K N� T � S ! �1� Y � � ♦ `� . � � ' � , ' 'e'' �' ! �„� r w� .N.� �� s �� : ` � � S < < � � i I ' � i „°' '~�. � .r�.. M •� ...r�.. r ... . s � 7; i � j . _ . M = 1 � s �{ 4 s 7 O w�• { � � i i • � � � i „r � „r � 6 ` � _..... .. � .... ..'' '� . . , � .,. .� _ . r Z /'. �� '!. � 1 ....+ « s �' 0 ' � � � i g i ! • � •. ' L i � t r�.r .a � � �r f a` • �- i i e �• � 3 • : • s • p � �. _ 14 ...�.o. ., 9 �,. � s,, s � � . 1 ��a 1 s � f � r � i � • a j � �t � � ; t � � f i � � � � �� "s = ..o .... � � � .. �. t �.i , , � a � � � M r15 • • , ` '°"- " i � _ '� � 1 � .. . � .m. � . � .� . ��` � s �• '� l ' � , M � I � �� . . � _ _.�. .� � CI7IZEN PAR7ICIPA7ION PLANNING DISTRICTS I.SUNRAY-BATTLECREEK-HIGHlJ00D 2.6REATf R EAST S I DE 3.WEST SIDE • � � 4.DAYTON'S BLUFF . ' - 5.PA1fNE-PHA EN � 7. -DALE 8.SUMMIT-UNIVERSITY 9.��fEST SEVEN7H � 10.CDt�+iO . 11.HAMLINE-MIDWAY 12.S7. AriTttONY 13.MERRIAt4 PK.-IEXINGTON HAMLINE 14.GROYELAND-MACALES7ER 15.HIGHLAND 16.SUMMIT HIII �^A��A'� ( ' 17.DO►+'NTOM� V 1 V 1 V �� { - , i��-%�� , � _ �l.ar � �Cek� � � . �. + + ,� _ + + + + + � � h' � � + + + � �; + + + + + � + + + + ��.. ¢ ► + + + + '� • ` + + + + ..�} + + + + + p ... 36 - + + -� + ^ + � + + + + � �✓ ` -� � � + + o o � ° + + + + ♦ � + + � + . + + + + + . � � �- + ♦ + + o � o � o + + + + + 3O 0 + + + + � �.+ + + + Q + � + + + + + + + + + p O O � v v .� � T ��- + + - - - -a + + + + + � + + + + t2 < > _� � + + + + � ..�. -�- < > � + + + ♦ � > .: + + + ♦ � � -,o- �2 h R + •y' + + s --- � + + + + + O a 0 O _ �_ � � � _O + + + + �' > � - � + + + + v 10 ) � ' � + + + + 12 � O O � `" � � � + + ♦ + ' + + + + '� � g � �, O + + + + � I > < ► + + + + � � y -0 _ ; y4 - + + + + � . 1 -� � � + { � . + + + ♦ + T + + . ' ♦ �. � , + + + t � + + ♦ + + + + + ' - - � + + + + + + + + + + + + + + -F- - � �--� � � - -0- + + + + + + + + + + + + + � � � �-.e- + + + + + + + + + + + ♦ + + �{ � _ � � ♦ ♦ ♦ -� � ^ �' ♦ ♦ + + V ~ O '� � . + + + + + ♦ + + + + + + q � � O +O - + + + + + +� --� �-—-- s + + + + -' � + + + + + �- O , O . � + + + + + + � � —� �- - - - + + + + + + + + + ♦ + + •: � ' ' -- � ---, - � + + + + + + ,+ + + + + + j O ; � O � ' � o + + + + + + + + + + + � + �+ L -- � - ' - � � � � + t � + + + 4 + + + + + � � -o- - t t -a �, c�-� , : � + + , + + + + + + �+ + + + � - - ' � � a. �. 1 1 1 � . . . . . . . � O � O � � O AREA MAP APPLICANT �► � �-�Q� � r10� LEGEND - ZONING DISTRICT BOUNDARY SUBJECT PROP�RTY PURPOSE l�� .one � '�� ' �,� �� O ONE FAMILY �PLANNING « 1 DISTRICT � h ��jJ Q TWO FAMILY " � FILE N0. � � � �� ! f,�-�- Q MULTIPLE FAMILY � �)�TE • • � COMMERCIAL � � � � INOUSTRIAL A�P NOE �CALE : 1��= 200� NORTH , � SQINT PAUL P�ANNING DIVISION V VACANT � � �r:) �- II �t0 / �, : I . - . ' . � � . NOTICE OF PIIBLIC HEARING I , . I A petition having been filed requesting that the Zoning Ordinance _ � of the City of St. Paul, be amended so as to rezone from RM-1 to � PM-1 ��` property located at 435 W. Idaho (northwest corner at Arundel). � The �auncil of the City of St: �au1" has fixed th� 22nd day of September 1 " 1988 at 9:00 A.M. in the Council Chambers in �he City Hall of �aid j City, and at `said time and place, the Council will hear all persons and all objections and recommendations relative to the proposed amendment�. _ I Dated September 2� 1988 � Albe�t B. Olson ` j City Clerk : I , - _ - (September 10� 1988) II : _ _ _ _ , . _ I +^ I. : _ � - . . I . I � �, : _ . _ _ I I� � � _ _ o _ _ _ . - _ . _ , . ; . . . , _ . . � . . : �. . _ o . I -:.. I :_ . . . � . . . _ _ . . I _ , . : , I _ . ` . . : :' I < . _ _ . . _ . ` . ` _ . _ _ , , _ I ., . i S T. P I AUL C T Y COUNCIL I'� PU6LIC HEARING NOTICE �'� ZONING , - T0: Property owners within 350 feet; FIL E N 0. 1034� Representatives of Planning District 6 PAGE PURPOSE A rezoning from RP+I-1 (Multiple Family Residential ) to �P-1 (Parking District) to construct garages. LOCATION '� Approximately 435 W. Idaho (northwest corner at Arund�l ) PETITIONER �ACK AND HELEN REGEI�OLD H E A R I N G Thursday, September 22, 1988 9:00 A.M.i • Cit Council Chambers, 3rd Floor City �al�. - Court Hous� Q U E S TIO N S Zoning 29s-4154 (Lisa Freese) Contact the Zoning Sectinn of the Planning and Economic ! Development Department, Room 1101, City Hall Annex, 25 W. 4th Street, St. Paul, MinnesoLa 55102 Legal Description: On file . Notice sent 9/06/88 i - i � ��I �� ST. PAUL CITY COUNCIL '�, PUBI.IC H�EARING NOTICE ��, Z O N I N G RECEINED SEP 1 �41988 CITY GLERK T0: Property owners within 350 feet; FIL E N 0. 10�,44 Representatives of Planning District 6 � PAGE PURPOSE A rezoning from RM-1 (Multiple Family Residential ) tp P-1 (Parking District) to construct garages. � �.�CATION Approximately 435 W. Idaho (northwest corner at Arun�el ) PETITIONER JACK AND HELEN REGEHOLD H E A R I N 6 Thursday, September 22, 1988 9:00 A.M. . Citv Council Chambers, 3rd Floor Crty �lall - Court Hou�se QUESTIONS Zoning 29s-4154 (�;sa Freese) Contact the Zoning Section of the Planning and Economi� Development Department, Room 1101, City Hall Aanex, 25 W. 4th Street, St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 i Legal Description: On file �� 90688 i Hotice �ent / / . 1 � ,�� i.... ,,�� ,. .. . . . .. .. f .n �.X5''.�i�"3Si�` � � � . ., t r't:id '.)?�� r `v��."3di-' .Ji.°-tla�:i��` . . �.. . . � � 5#.'..".,+� .'3'Y:-:.JY F `ry�,s i %�� i � y! - A��. = F`{riC`i�v�..� . . - ' � ♦��.�:_g,�. . : . 1'�iY �(i� '>+:3'��d �1 i..,,.�k .. � 'i �;"i�` i �"i *Vi"i$.'�+ �a ... ;r.� �. i. ��L�C�!'�IAVI ... _ �'�j _ ; ��, r" !�`a`; Ot.�.PaLi1,be 83rilti - ' r' 1 1 > ._ �'< � . . . . ,� W.Idaho(north�aest co ner a �i�a�e�:'� . .. �, .� . '� :$ '; f�oed the a�8:00' ` ° City H o# said Y. ata a � ��,f.�' � �� ;��_ Persons and all objections and riei�ie� . � a�r�ettdment, '� t; �� t°,�� p r=f � ' . .-. — -JG:i i ��d 5e��ember 2.]98$::� ". k � _ , i ' ,�$RT B. OI,i50N,City Clerk ` - ^ -. . : ��ePtemb�es 1R,•389� � r ��,:;.:.x ; � • - :_ ,.• . . ,_ ,,: . � � .. . .. ��_�� ZONING COMMITTEE STAFF REPORT FII.E #�10344 1. APPLICANT: Helen and John Regenold DATE OF HEARING: 8/18,�88 2. CLASSIFICATION: Rezoning from RM-1 (Multiple Family residential) to P-ll (parking) j 3. LOCATION: Approximately 435 West Idaho (northwest corner at Arundel) i 4. PLANNING DISTRICT: 6 5. LEGAL DESCRIPTION: East 118 feet of Lot 5� Block 3, Edwin N. Ware's Cumb�rland Addition Plat 1. 6. PRESENT ZONING: RM-1 ZONING CODE REFERENCE: 60.720, 62!104(3) 7. STAFF INVESTIGATION AND REPORT: DATE: 8/9/88 BY: Lisa J. �'reese A. P 0 To construct a parking lot with a 20 car garage and 12 surface �paces to be used by an existing apartment building to the east (429 West Idaho l Avenue) . I B. SUFFICIENCY: The petition was declared sufficient by the Planning Divisi n on July 13, 1988; 37 parcels eligible, 25 parcels. required, 30 parcels signe�. C. PARCEL SIZE: A lot split application has been filed by the applicant, Tt�e proposed parcel has 118' of frontage on West Idaho and 120' on Arundel for a total lot area of 14,160 square feet. I D. ERISTING LAND USE: Vacant E. SURROUNDING IAND USE: North: Vacant, RM-1 I East: Multiple family residential, RM-2 South: lrtixed residential, RM-2 - - - -- - i I I ' . � � ��l0 73 File #10344 Page T`wo 5. The P-1 parking district is intended to permit the establishment of off-st�lreet parking facilities to be used solely for off-street parking of private passenger vehicles as a use incidental to a principal use. The applicant's petitio� is for incidental parking. 6. Establishing a P-1 zoning district requires a review of eight conditions as set forth in Section 60.723; these conditions and the applicant's ability to m�eet them are as follows: a. The parking facility sha11 be accessory to and for use in connection w�th one or more businesses. The parking facility is intended solely for the use of the existing apartment building at 429 West Idaho Street. I b. The parking facilitp sha11 not be used during hours when the principalluse is not in operation. During such periods the parking facility sha1Z b� inaccessible for public use. The parking facility is accessory to a residential use and therefore, �ccess to the lot is necessary on a 24-hour basis. c. The parking facility sha11 be used solely for parking of private passenger vehicles and sha11 not be used as an off-street Ioading ares. I �� The applicant has stated parking is the sole intended use. � d. No commercial repair work or service of any kind, or sale or displap thereof, sha11 be conducted in such parking facility. I The applicant states that the tenants are not allowed to store inopera�le vehicles or repair vehicles on the parking lot. e. No signs of any kind, other than signs designating entrences, exits and� conditions of use, shall be maintained on such parking facilitp. I No signage is planned for the site. f. No building other than that for the shelter of attendants sha1Z be ereclted - • •�• ��— -----'-�1 7... r�l,e.. �7n»nino tl�IDln]Cl_'�.7^BtOr I M ��/�� ' ein.'�t�t�c` ! + + ♦ i• ' ♦ + ♦ ♦ ♦ � � � /� + t + t . ' � `! + + ♦ + ♦ � + + ♦ ♦ ��r �7 + � + t + ♦ � ; . �. �. ♦ + � }; + ♦ + + ♦ Q ��r ' t + -4- ♦ � _.� + + + + .} ♦ + + ,�. t8 �.� � � Q ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ O V + ♦ -�F ♦ � ♦ + ♦ ♦ . ..� ♦ + + + � � O V ' � � � �� + + + + + 3O p � + + + + �+ � ♦ + � : + � + + � �, + + + + + o o O � vv � T -�- � , : + - -- �a � _ ♦ ♦ ♦ 4 ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ' + + + + 12 < > _� ; ; ♦ + + + + O .�. -�- < > � ; : , + + + + .- . + + + + � e„ < � � —�O' ' R + •y' + + 12 s --- , + + + + + � a O p _ �_ � � _ _O ' < + + + + � > � _ � r � + + + + �o > < 6 � ; + + + + 12 O > �. } ; � + ♦ + + . ; � + + + + '� � O � ` O ; �- ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ � � i ti t + + t < 7 � + + + ♦ 1 -0- - - Q _ . � + ♦ + . � + + ♦ ----� � ♦ Y + ♦ . ♦ < ' ♦ ♦ '} � ♦ • ♦ ♦ � �' ♦ '� ♦ '� - - ' + + + + + + + + + + + + + + -F - --- � � Ir -a- - � i � _ __• Ta_