88-1600 WHITE — CITV CLERK
PINK — FINANCE G I TY O F SA I NT PA U L Council /�
CANARV — DEPARTMENT /j�/' //�
BI.UE — MAVOR File NO• `� '/TDD —
City Attny/TJW . . „�.--�-- _
Co cil Resolution ��-�.� �,
� � �-a
Presented By
�"� ��
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
b�
RESOLVED, that the�-sale intoxicating liquor , -�_
���, and other licenses held by Charles D. Laverty dba
Hawkeye Liquor Store, Inc. for the premises at 111 Conco d
in Saint Paul are hereby susnended for a period of �_
consecutive days , commencing and ending on the dat s
specified herein: ��� r (4�� ro v
�L„f'o {^j2 r 1
This Resolution and the action taken herein are based
upon the facts contained in tlze attached police reports
which su�port tre allegations contained in the Notice of
Hearing dated August 25 , 198c� , and supplemental letter
notice dated August 30, 19�3 , both of which are also
attached to this Resolution) . Such facts are not contested
by the licenseholder, as evidenced by the attached letter
of ezr. John Pb. Schoe!��.I;er, attorney for the licenseholder.
The action ta?cen is al�o based on the facts , circumstances
and arguments presented by and on behalf of the licenseholder.
COUNCIL MEMBERS � Requested by Department of:
Yeas Nays
Dimond
Long In Favor
��� �
�cr�a�
s�6e;bei _ Against BY
Sonnen
Wilson
Adopted by Council: Date ��� 1 1 � Form Approved by City ttorney
Certified Pa.se unc'1 Se tary BY— � �
gy,
A►pp e by Mavor: Da e WT � � ��U Approved ayor S mis ' n to Council
By .
Tt�Y�;�� i!!: i � . �
4..._e e
. �
•• � MUBNANE, CONLIN, WHITE, BAANDT 8C HOFFMAN ��o '/�OO
' ATTOBNEYS AT LAW
TFIOMAS M.CONLIN• MICHAEL S.BYAN
BOBEBT W. MIIBNANE 1400 CAPITAL CENTEE LAUHA J. McHNI6HT
EOHEBT T.WHITE WABASHA AT SIXTH STBEET SIISAN D.HALL
JOSN E.BEANDT'� AS.P'ONSE J. COCCHIAPELLA
JOHN F.HOFFMAN'� SAINT PAUL,MINNESOTA 53102
MAHY M.BOPE
JOHN D.HIETE TELEPHONE (612) 227-94ll PETEE A.BOLO(3NA
STEVEN J. HIESCH PATBICB M.CONLIN
LAWESNCE B.HIN(}�' SHELLEY A.SIMMEBIN�
AND$EW T. SAE$N TELECOPIEB(612) 223-6199 JAMES F. BALDWIN
— C.TODD HOESELE
E.WILLAED MUBNANE
c,eo�-�9�6, September 13, 1988 ���$�HATO�
CHABLES B.MUENANE MICHAEL P.TIEENEY
(1913-1982) PAUL B.SILC30PE �
MAB% M.VELdIITH
q HEVIN F.6$AY
�����K S��`����`` HIM Z.MASTEO
L.
� � "n-,.«.rt8 JEFFEBY W. DAVIS'�
M.SIISAN BIIHNS
HAND DELIVERED SEP r'!.
1 �(]�(� �"AL50 ADMIITED IN WISCANSIN
J v
Mr. Thomas J. Weyandt �,.���� f; { j. _
Assistant City Attorney '�' ' � a o `�° v,.
Office of the City Attorney
647 City Hall
St. Paul, MN 55102
Re: Hawkeye Liquors, 111 Concord Street
Dear Mr . Weyandt :
As I informed you during our telephone conversation on Tuesday,
September I3 , 1988, our law firm has been retained to represent
Hawkeye Liquors as liguor licensee regarding the August 4, 1988,
incident . Our client is willing to stipulate that unfortunately,
an illegal sale of liquor did take place on August 4, i988, as
noted on page two of your letter urider date August 30, 1988.
Thus , we do not wish to have an administrative hearing concerning
this matter , but instead desire to appear before the City Counsel
concerning this matter . I understand you will contact the ALJ,
John W. Harrigan to cancel tYie Thur�day, September 15 � 1988f
hearing. I will look forward to hearing from you concerning the
date of our appearance before the City Counsel .
Very truly ours ,
� „�V.a..s.�+-
Joh R. S oemaker
JRS/lld
cc : Charles Laverty
�' � . �����
. �„ � �---,, ..- �--', � ��
s��== o, ° CITY OF SAINT PAUL
�`' ' 9 OFFICE OF 7HE CITY ATTORNEY
�O Y'•
� 11 11111111 •?
;+ "" 1°" �� EDWARD P. STARR, CITY ATTORNEY
. ,._
��`'�� �••• 647 City Hall, Saint Paul,Minnesota 55102
``�um.�,.,.��'"`�
612-298-5121
GEORGE LATIMER
MAYOR
August 25, 1988
Mr . Charles D. Laverty, Pres. NOTICE OF HEARING
Hawkeye Liquor _ Store, Inc.
111 Concord Street
Saint Paul, MN. 55107
RE: Hawkeye Liquors, 111 Concord Street
Dear Mr. Laverty:
This is to notify you that a hearing. will be held concerning all
the licenses held at the premises stated above at the following
time, date and place:
Date: September 14, 1988
Time: 9:0f� a.m.
Place: 9th Floor Conference, Commerce Building
4th and Wabasha Streets
St. Paul , Mn . 551P11
The judge will be an Administrative Law Judge from the State of
Minnesota Office of Administrative Hearings:
Name: John W. Harrigan, Esq.
Attorney at Law
19G10 Hennepin Avenue
Minneapolis, Mn. 55403
Telephone: 872-41222 �
The Council of the City of Saint Paul has the authority to
provide for hearings concerning licensed premises, and for
adverse action against such licenses , under Chapter 310 ,
including sections 3141. �5 and 310.fd6 , of the Saint Paul
Legislative Code. In the case of licenses for intoxicating and
non=intoxicating liquor , authority is also conveyed by section
34f�A.415 of the Minnesota Statutes. Adverse action may include
revocation, suspension, fines and other penalties or conditions.
Evidence will be presented to the judge which m ay lead to adverse
action against all the licenses you hold at the above premises as
follows :
((� , . f �
_ i : � � , -- G�jb�sd
On Auqust 4, 1988 , a clerk in the Hawkeye Liquor Store sold
a twelve�-pack of Miller beer to two minors in violation of
section 4PJ9.08 (2) of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, and
section 344l.503, subd. 2, of Minn. Stat. 1986.
You have the right to be represented by an attorney before and
during the hearing if you so choose, or you can represent
yourself. You may also have a person of your choice represent
you, to the extent not prohibited as unauthorized practice of
law.
The hearing will be conducted in accordance with the requirements
of sections 14.57 to 14.62 of the Minnesota Statutes, and such
parts of the procedures under section 314�.�5 of the Saint Paul
Legislative Code as may be applicable.
At hearing , the Administrative Law Judge will have all parties
identify themselves for the record. Then the City will present
its witnesses and evidence, each of whom the licensee or attorney
may cross=exam ine. The 1 icensee may then of fer in rebuttal any .
witnesses or evidence it may wish to present, each of whom the ,
City attorney may cross=examine. The Administrative Law Judge
may in addition hear relevant and m aterial testimony from persons
not presented as witnesses who have a substantial interest in the
outcome of the proceeding; for example, the owners or occupants
of property located in close proximity to the licensed premises
may have substantial interest in the outcom e of the proceeding.
Concluding arguments may be made by the parties. Following the
hearing, the Judge will prepare Findings of Fact, Conclusions of
Law, and a specific recommendation for action to be taken.
You should bring to the hearing all docum ents, records and
witnesses you will or may need to support your position.
Subpoenas may be available to com pel the attendance of witnesses
or the production of documents in conformity with Minnesota
Rules, part 14�f�.7041f6.
If you think that this m atter can be resolved or settled without
a formal hearing, please contact or have your attorney contact
the undersigned. If a stipulation or agreem ent can be reached as
to the facts , that stipulation will be presented to the
Administrative Law Judge for incorporation into his or her
recommendation for Council action.
� ,
� ! '
. � �, w
.� � �-�-/��
If you fail to appear at the hearing, the allegations against you
which have been stated earlier in this notice may be taken as
true and your ability to challenge them forfeited. If non-public
data is received into evidence at the hearing, it may become
public unless objection is made and relief requested under
Minnesota Statutes, section 14.60, subdivision 2.
Very truly yours,
PHILIP B. BYRNE
Assistant City Attorney
(612) 298=5121 __ ,
Attny. Reg . No . 13961
cc: Joseph F. Carchedi
License Inspector
Lt. Donald Winger
Vice Unit
Albert B. O1 son
City Clerk
Paige Purcell
Office of Administrative Hearings
o a� .o _
.-�
� � aEi o ►�i _ o .� .E � o d .� �
'� u < .[ 0 8 c0 v] au a.i N G .a .-+ n
o • � • 1J 0! L _ N d W d � .L� O H � 'l7 Q' O�
_ � • w .(�. !A P• rl .r.. M 1-I L � �"� E+ 00 � .0 .-1 V]
i j Y � W O N LJ N .'3+ �C fd d • U' . O . t 4
' s ❑ M � cn o d d � 3 U � oo � �+ c� d � u <
W W � .� D+ •.+ O � O �O 9 �0
Y
u ❑ � j H N d JJ N iJ 'Ll � N aJ � E � l0 '� �--� .G .
F Y �t O x R 7 H C • � ' N .O N .0 d �t .� O .-a a.! a
W o a . �`, U o •a v E d v co 3� •.� ,� �+ 3 .� c� cn o o �
.-i ° � o N x 00 N O N N aJ a� N a.i � u z 'L7 ,O �
O O e a i u e 'C � �+ O � 'O � .� . a.� O .� 'O e7 O �C �
�n c� < > � z � d �o d s� •�+ 1� •�+ m oo ,.� d E � o D, a� .
N p r J F < �O � R1 1J 'S7 H '� •rl „[ 3-I rl .�L O W � 1J S.i 0 �
� N c = W W ; y - •rl .� � y N O 10 L 00 N 'O tA 1+ O 'O � C) �
O Z � f s a , • oo d .n .a N .c •� q .� _^ a� co w A ..-� N d 3
a � f u O H r+ c. 3 •�+ 3 �+ a �0 3
a u a o � �v >, a� •�+ c �+ o a� >, a, - o ,.� k.
Z o0 � Y 6 � ( W W }� tC CI � �'i 'O 3 N A ^ � J..i CJ �1 >l .t�' �C \ C.�
� � u' ; ❑ " ° .� .� co ca o �+ a� .� c .c o �+ v� m a� . 3 .a
, F ' f x � oo D, u .� w .G �+ d 7 .�-� ^ a� E+ a� a �.�+ � o
r a .� H t� O .1] .� O U N .� 'O W a� 'O ¢
� `� aD i < ° a � N � 7 H >, •�+ m d 'Cf � ,a C
� � o � � � � •• � w 'L1 O .�L N- ^ .� O 3 d O cC aJ �+ c0
O a W z p ui W c0 N D+ v •a .�L ? d N A .r. O � N d
o .t o f W a z N w 9 co � v co u > � r-� �..i 3 >, N 9 �: V
W ` � � a W f o 6 �+ •.+ 3 a ,a .� co �, v � �o o �
V ` i : u � „ H o 1+ �+ o A ^ .�i >, .a y 3� � � �O •�I V 3 a
^o � ,-7 u •� s� G a� �+ u 3 E ►+ > ••+ •�+ a� �
J u � � F i ° u7 N �0 � 7 �+ ia - c0 •.� d cn N tn H N '"
O� � �C „ t Q O � .-+ ctl •.+ C 7 O N i-� .G F d �0 • .0 N
p. � W ip X O Oi 4 Ll GI � N � .0 'O � 1J � L O ; N '3 r-1 H I
- w � � W W W � � � 3 -
�. ? � 3 " i z � �+ >, +� o b oo � � a� u d u t� a
a. O r '" � u i .] v' O � 't1 b .-+ � � • d U - � O • N .� W
° z z o a •� w u b ro a� d .� �.�+ 3 �C �n d oo q 3 � �+ E c�
s�-� E., ° a � u W .-a G •,a >, �+ .� N � v' �+ � 'A a! � �n r+
� 2 � O t 3 ` v� � O A �7 u O m F �+ �d N O � •,a •� . N H $ � >
� W < ° � d 'O = N C •-a � 7 u 'O C 'O .0 RS
a � o W p = tn .� •r+ u N O 'b +.� u� N � H O �+
�+ a� 9 cJ $ U •.a d co .� 'G D, N u N �O o O
� � o 0 0 � o d a+ N .0 co S ►+ +-� d E � �
i Q � � W fa O �+ W •-+ 8 y N a� aL ..o • ^ .� � O �
> o u a oo z a� a� �o .� a� E a cn u o a �+ y m � w
; W s u W• � r� a y .� d c� .0 l+ d cn ca �., � � �tl. o-, _
o � a E •o cv ,.a +� �+ w o o � � ra ,� u �n �
3 � N O J � �C d C �O W �+ U Z O aJ �..� 'O 1,+ .--r H 00 cn c'n
2 U = � o W .� t0 O� C!� N @ �l u tn � N G �.�+ d Q
s •r.r c < � �J ch �'i •r+ �l 'O c0 d � H 7 00 .r..
i > z X F d d O O +� .� O W "O N N • p c!� O 3+ 0! a�
t < u Z U 'O i-� N 1J �7 V] •rt ,r�.. .O 't7 W W W }+
i o o W � .,� � o � o� � co ,.� •� o• .-� �o a >, e X
y,7 � � W e .-I LJ 1J �7 'O 3-� � GO � N Sd N � d R:� 'b 'O � d O.
0 � 3 � O L+ �n •,a N c� r1 • u U cn y Q N � .� �+ Q
O 4(A a f� O N ct1 .� 00 A x W N cC 7, t0 x x Gl � W �
�: F- aWiw W m � c a y co u� 3 � r-� L+ � d E .0 U u� 3�
� z G z W e � < � vl .� T fs+ N � 'b Y+ U N .-� � 1+ Q
' o� W H W = � - � a u � G � a� � �+ � o �v s� a co a� a� c �
W o M 3 o i � N d d �+ .� 3 •�+ U D, �n w d � H N GL .O •.a
W v, s� c� .c .� a� F+ a� a� m •� a > .c v, o e a� V
� F ; m W � �v E � ,-+ ro .� � .� 3 ^o w d ca a �-+
� � � H •.+ � O L \ H � � � A E 3 � � �G x
-� ap� u „ < H v� C � O • y 3 `.L a
Q u� x o Y ., � x U 1� ro 'O 1� .-+ � .0 .G N �--� � •
W 0 W < u j N � •.+ .a N � N �� d t0 � 7+ �-'� E �d � LYi
z = 3 „ z o � � . �+ � v .�e .� •-+ u v �, H �o ro d •�+ . �
o •O �t7 G •� � G a� U H d U •� d u: •-� �n .0 1+ o
W .-t � � i w i N �+ O �+ .�L d � �1 N �+ H .� W O .0 N � a� Q
� u'1 � y e n ; � }� p .,a N U .n O •'+ .� cd d H a� � a� Ol tn z W
°O� � � W o d U �..1 �A cU U I-� U • .� d S'.. 'O � t!� F-
� � 0 p y IZ- Y Q+ l+ �O �] N f) N � E-� • 'fl .a H iJ N 'A o
„ � t z ; � O v1 � _ .� N tn 'O G O v� • C x p
W a, c� � .c _ ,� x a� ro o >, � � ca u, ,� v� ' N
� � � ' oo a� .0 •.� ,� �o .c • ro v co a �o r+ a .
`O > o � cv .� > x o a� �v d d u u� -� .n .-+
v
W r � � �+ � � "O = L G �n N > .� pp •� G d @ +� �-+ •� W V
J � z Q � .-i O a) O IO .0 ctl O C 7 � •rl �.' N A � W
� W Z � 'O U 'O 'O tJ �3 .L' cd 'b O •rl �'.. N ? < �
`-' a � ^ s� a� C a.� w 3 .� G v G E �3 • . y m
� � " o o a w a� o �+ a� •� o •�+ � o u �o a� �v a .c .fl .�
u e z n � 04 .� � a� 3 ..� - x c� > a� ro r� �
a n 4 0 � o o u � 3 +� 3 .� G C L .[ � •.a �+ +-i �
�C� W z z +� H Y+ u� 7+ � 1� ^O tn M+ �+ �..� -n w t� - v� 'O
� f m < - CA 3-i � d cA � d •,a a •rl •rl � G .-i � �
J � a W ri � O 'O c0 .G fs+ .-a 'L7 O .� 'O N u N 'O \ sa Q
V J f �"� Ri 1J lO 1.7 �V \ U r-1 �p UI �+ �I (�. �"� �Y. GI �
Q� , N W o � c0 O •� .0 �, C 3 N � • i •a N d N � > p„
� o m 4 �n � � d al �O N .� � c'� u .� 3 'C O P�1 O
a c0 � m " o� o H .� E ro .0 v� a, .-i � •r+ u 3 o u
F h U i d „ � w r-i E E+ ..`l +� .�G A u ctl A d
r < Z O ..a .� 'b {.+ � E 'b 't7 U w .G .� aJ F+
N c . r � r ^O U � d d T1 •� G � c0 N N U H .� ^
O � ► N r ' o „ a.� W •--� •r+ O � 00 al � N � .� 3-i .-i •,� = � H Gp
._ � o � � z < � �+ � .� E u � G .� .n a� .� d a
W o� z � o � .,� W o 3 d cd y �U u 3� 3 u 3 ^ E cti. J
� f.-a r.� W � � �o u .� � a� .� �o .� ..[ a� � �n ^ �o a •
� _ .-� _° > d .-+ � w � d .� � o ao a� � �D � •� �o v�
V � a CL d r-+ O .� �..i � L •� � � � •n c0 .� • �
'a ^ �i � u E .�.' O H C� �+ C.' 9 p r7 tn O � �
F �+ I } m O O � L O .� N .0 . O 3.+ c0 •� 'O • tJ tA MI
- � o U d tn r+ t� t� a.i 7 tJ d . .� l+ c0 Ll 'O �
W� < O d U W W [ „� 'rl : C .0 rl N U J".. � N ^ C) �
'�CO "D J u,p R � W lC 1J � .� •.d � L .`1� � .-� '--i fA �Z f0 ."1�. 'O ,7 �
� W u 0 J I � "X+ ••� r� U O N •--� -'+ S.' 0� O �" 01 J
O > F+ � n n � 00 O U 7� _ .� cC U cn cd � c0 'L7 .� a.� 3�+ •�
u o a� � W f = � ,..� •�+ co ,� p s� u a� 3 0 0� • w
G "•--� n f o H •.� p 7 .-+ �v �.+ .G � 7 w .-+ y tJ y d •� N
f�1' O y [--� z t U n 9 •r+ d •a •� N 00 00 .� C3. E O U N N O G. r+ G .�
t� < U � p•.� � � W a •.� �o o �a 3 a � L o c*� .� � c� •,� ,�
O ° < W� W c � a N 'U m �n O •�+ �+ E .�G u fs+ � GL �n 3 a �
�.� _ � �Z� < � O oo a ►+ �c b a� � o � 3 �. o �
�.-+ M �.�t d Q D+ .�G N .0 C G .� 3-i c0 C 3 c0 N a) +-� (J
�.-+ � � u W �+ >+ •.+ u s� m -�+ a a o d .� 3 4
z ' a ro � u � a� �, >, .� .� a o � •0 3 a� > ,� c
f o0 0 = � a � ,. ►+ oo � d .-+ o v a� � >, a �+ c ,., E r� u� ° N
a � .-I •rl $ U G J'�.. N A J'�.. � •� c0 N �"'.. N 7 Z r-�
a � �c�l < t� E � H Rf u � .� � N N @ �..r .--i •� -
�..i � r w y � �0 3 00 > N .G � .� ? N •� op �
w i i N � W 6 d C n1 � •� q b c0 3 � t� �d c� 3 � � ' �'
a <� o � o z � °4 ,�a, 3 b • a� •�+ d .c ,.� � a on a, z v � : _ . _
E tn .� .l .� 3 E .o � W co ,._ � .
a o � < d d a� a s� o v d o a� � s� r� .� U
� � � = ' ` x .c .� �o v, o o a .� s� .� � a� .a � ��,
a► a, H��-j� +-� H cn u 6 3 �-+ �C u p'��` +� 3 x +� r-� I—
y . ,
-�, �
.. } _<>-°��}`o`��,,, ' �.� �� � :' � � CITY OF S INT PAU�
3�•` ;,-;. ,
;o �;, OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY
'� i�uu nnr �;
�`;,; '!'!1!!1"' ^:� EDWARD P. STARR. CITY ATTORNEY
'`;
�o, .... ,. 647 Ciry Hall, Sain1 Paul.Minnesota 55102
�4111tIR':.�n`�``�
612-298-5121
GEORGE LATIMER
MAYOR
August 30, 1988
Mr. John Brandt
Murnane Law Firm NOTICE OF RESCHEDULED HEARING
140P1 One Capital Centre Plaza
St . Paul , Mn. 55161
RE: Hawkeye Liquors, 111 Concord Street
Dear Mr. Brandt:
This is to notify you that a hearing will be held concerning all
the licenses held at the premises stated above at the following
tim e, date and place:
Date: September 15, 1988
Time: 9:0� a.m.
Place: 9th Floor Conference, Commerce Building
4th and Wabasha Streets �
St . Paul , Mn. 551�1
The judge will be an Administrative Law Judge from the State of
Minnesota Office of Administrative Hearings:
Name: John W. Harrigan, Esq.
Attorney at Law
1900 Hennepin Avenue
Minneapolis , Mn. 554�3
Telephone: 872�=4l222
The Council of the City of Saint Paul has the authority to
provide for hearings concerning licensed premises , and for
adverse action against such licenses , under Chapter 31�J ,
including sections 310.g5 and 310.06 , of the Saint P�aul
Leqislative Code. In the case of licenses for intoxicating and
non=intoxicating liquor , authority is also conveyed by section
340A.415 of the Minnesota Statutes. Adverse action may include
revocation, suspension, fines and other penalties or conditions�.
Evidence � will be presented to the judge which may lead to adverse
action against all the licenses you hold at the above premises as
follows :
. � �`� �� �? �� _"/��
. ;, ,. ���`
On August 4, 1988 , a clerk in the Hawkeye Liquor Store sold
a twelve-pack of Miller beer to two minors in violation of
section 4g9.�8 (2) of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, and
section 34�1.503, subd. 2, of Minn. Stat. 1986.
You have the right to be represented by an attorney before and
during the hearing if you so choose, or you can represent
yourself. You may also have a person of your choice represent
you, to the extent not prohibited as unauthorized practice of
law.
The hearing will be conducted in accordance with the requirements
of sections 14.57 to 14.62 of the Minnesota Statutes, and such
parts of the procedures under section 310.fd5 of the Saint Paul
Legislative Code as may be applicable.
At hearing , the Administrative Law Judge will have all parties
identify themselves for the record. Then the City will present
its witnesses and evidence, each of whom the licensee or attorney
may cross=examine. The licensee may then offer in rebuttal any
witnesses or evidence it may wish to present , each of whom the
City attorney may cross-examine. The Administrative Law Judge
m ay in addition hear relevant and material testimony from persons
not presented as witnesses who have a substantial interest in the
outcom e of the proceeding; for example, the owners or occupants
of property located in close proximity to the licensed premises
m ay have substantial interest in the outcome of the proceeding.
Concluding arguments may be made by the parties. Following the
hearing, the Judge will prepare Findings of Fact, Conclusions of
Law, and a specific recommendation for action to be taken.
You should bring to the hearing all docum ents, records and
witnesses you will or may need to support your position.
Subpoenas m ay be available to com pel the attendance of witnesses
or the production of documents in conformity with Minnesota
Rules, part 14410.700J0.
If you think that this m atter can be resolved or settled without
a formal hearing, please contact or have your attorney contact
the undersigned. If a stipulation or agreement can be reached as
to the facts , that stipulation will be presented to the
Administrative Law Judge for incorporation into his or her
recommendation for Council action.
� - f� �! �� �' ��—/6ae
.. , , .
If you fail to appear at the hearing, the allegations against you
which have been stated earlier in this notice may be taken as
true and your ability to challenge them forfeited. If non-public
data is received into evidence at the hearing, it may become
public unless objection is made and relief requested under
Minnesota Statutes, section 14.60, subdivision 2.
Very truly yours,
THOMAS J. WEYANDT
Assistant City Attorney
(612) 298-5121
Attny. Reg . No . 116336 ;
cc: Joseph F. Carchedi
License Inspector
Lt. Donald Winger
Vice Unit
Albert B. Olson
City Clerk
Paige Purcell
Office of Administrative Hearings