Loading...
88-1499 WNI7E - C�TY CLERK PINK - F.�ANCE GITY OF SAINT PAUL Council /y��I G � �Li �CANAR�-�DEPARTMENT File NO. V d � � � BLUE - MAYOR � Council Resolution Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date does hereby RESOLVE , that the Council of the City of Saint Paul does hereby grant the appeal of Gary McGee and does hereby reverse the decision of the Board of Zoning Appeals on the grounds that because the owner of the property no longer seeks a variance is that there are other alternatives for the construction that is proposed, that there has been no showing of a continuing and existing hardship and therefore based upon these new facts , the decision of the Board of Zoning Appeals was in error; and, be it FURTHER RESOLVED, that the appeal of Gary McGee is hereby granted and the variance heretofore granted by the Board of Zoning Appeals is hereby rescinded; and, be it FURTHER RESOLVED, that the City Clerk shall mail a copy of this resolution to Richard Stauble, Gary McGee, the Zoning Rdministrator , the Planning Commission and the Board of Zoning Appeals. 2. COUNCIL MEMBERS Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays Dimond �� In Favor Goswitz Rettman � Against BY Sonnen w�u�n SEP � 5 �g88 Form Appr ed by City At orney Adopted by Council: Date Certified Yas e Council Se ary BY gy, �7" � � � Appr v d by Mayor for Submission to Council Approve Mav r. � — B _ , BY P��S�CD S'�P n � 19 8$ � C��=��� � �°. �12738 . DEPARTMENT - - - - - - — CONTACT NAML� PHONE DATE , � ASSIGN �B�R FOR AOU?ING ORDER: (See reverse, side.) � = Department Director _ Mayor (or Assistant) _ Finance and Manage�snt Services Director _ City Clerk _ Budgat Director _ _ City Attorney _ TOTAL NUMBER OF SIGNA:�'URE PAGES:. (Clip all locations for signature.) i�i G ON D ? (Purpose/Rationale) td�YT'��► 4��►rT��' �;G'�r.'►.0 d p" �i�al� 0� �0+��'�' �/�in`''�l .,�v� � �;ar�►�c ar1" ��� S� �► ��I• l�v�►�a� c.c)� T�► w►iT�,/r��. t����ic.�.7�'�•.. j1/e�r�t�. G�i�o� ax,+ % Z4� /�`�, T � COST/BENEPIT. BUDGETARY. AND PERSONNEL IMPACTS ANTICIPATED: FINANCING SOURCE �ND BUDGET ACTIVITY NUMBER CHARGBD O�t CREDITED: <Iiayor's signature not required if under $10,000.) Total Amount of Transgction: Activity Number: � Funding Source: , Councrl Res�arch Center ATTACHMENTS: (List and number all attachments.) - StN 0�,1988 � AHMINISTRATIVE PROCEDURBS _Yes _No Rules, Regulations, Procedures, or Budget Amendment zequired? `w-• _Yes _No If yes, are they or timetable attached? _ DEPARTMENT REVIEW CITY ATTORNEY REVIEW _Yes _No Council resolution required? Resolution required? _Yes _No _Yes _No InsuranCe raquired? Insurance sufficient? _Yes �No _Yes _No Insurance attached? ��� f 1 �• . .r..:l -Y: ',' 'f f '.�i �:. „' . ,`- .,�.. f� � {/'' '! ° �� /` A y.: � �� � I� � '� �"`+�! � `t ,t� � .'r� . � �� �. � � . ,',�$ ' � F . : . , � , , � , . •_. ,.� # , • , r '� �a . . �.. • .. % � , . -: -� . . �.x '� . \�-a: .. . . �� '. . . .. � .. . .�- ... .,... �� .� , :, -�.n�� . '7. .r � r'� , , � � I . , � �� , '* .. ` k/ .: � . ' _�-.• l} �, A "k . F ' �.. ,�' �_.= f - .. - . . � � �'�, - . .. .. �' " �. . .)i r l � ,�t � _`d � � �� t �'.. �� �� � ... ,�! . . �fr �.\ { ��. f \�, tF 4 a� r. F. � ' \� '' � � ;`. . . � . . �,. .�., l i .�.. ` �.. .. . .t� �' �:� i �1$USt. d��i,, .19�$ , • ` � l � � r�� �' , � �;- . �. �1' . , . . � � � � t �'.'' " : ' ..�... , �, . . �•� , �d:����rw, !cit;� At�o�y ��� % � , , : , �.,� � . , .. , . � . , , � ; . t . . .. <;, r � � �. `� . .. - , � , , , , � . � , , ,. ,: � ;�'1�' ,�'�1'�I �` . „ ' r +, ,. � k >' ; �� , � i '-� ��'L�r p�b1�� ..l�►���g.�b�d��r. t��C1�y Cou�C 11 g�t�E�� �I'r� ��u�;l o:!'"±�r�► �i�' ` � .�' � t,�;� �+���ot��u ��:�:�<����i�rQ erf �4�'t`n� .�PPe�i��.rt��:eM� gf����;±�f a`va��4`a��r��o - y;, �'tt�rd; ��;ai�ib3� :,t� a'��tqar �'or -�+�n�,�Cr�+ction �� ,�t' ��������#e�.;,d��k;��ficg �r� , �. ��te� -�'t�r� f�������at, ��IJ$ �iel d. �, T�e a+c'���� r�a�� ����h �n �.��r ��y�'�� ��; ' , ��� .�� ;�r�e�.`,�L��,, #_���tative#� t�r �t�e� ���f�C,�'t� �; ;��et t�ir� i . ..i�`nr�.,`�at�ds�"#, '",�e� o'�: �� ba��s `tttaE� �l�e; .pr'�pt�� M� ��::����t .ai�t� . � " �d$ a ���i,��, to tl��t��1 a�,g.'st'a�t :�h�� ,h� .����� .��9 �i.�irs�e��� ,,1 ' �t�'Ei��at�` �t#���r. ����e pre� ���e. proper:����'1;���"� ��'��e���� t�t� ' r ° , ' �t?'4`�E�C. % � ; t �t y� . �.� ' d `� � }��* _ �1� \ , l��� M�'7s.�.�'+.��� � �.. �� A � �. '�� � r; �' f ` �,t � p + �` . � �y � ,/� � �. . . ; ��� � ►t t � i�,l bl�ti!"t 6�• M�'SQ� _ , . � �• ����► ���1l1"�. .y� � � 'a y� � , � ;" : ,, � ;_ � � .�. ` . � ;� �' � t. ��;�� ,� �. .�� � ��, � � , ��. . -�5-��. ti � {. �, �� � _ . . , ', �. : , ' : , , _� ; . , . :, , , � � ��.� s � - , _ � ; - �; �` �. -,:�� a't 'y� �°��t ` . � n -, *' a � - � r' Y'id �,,, t � '�x� `� ��. �t , , • . , „ ; � � ; , . . ,' � . „ • ,. ;: .. _ . _ _.. , . ' �• �.i r . "`-'-.�' � ' � ' 'r �,�� ^ t !� .�i ',� '� 'i . . `a �. ' -r, �f.�� - t�; . ��. 4''4 'l `��� f f ,;� � i�` :��. � �\ t � t:� .1 r . .fi y _ . / � `;'� ' �, , ' '�` � 'ry ._ � ti.'�� I � � _ � �,; _ �: 'F �_r '� � J �_ . �•, .� ,r Y' t t� . � '' •� {, � 'f k r # � 1 , . �� . � �, ; � � �; , � j _ + ,y� �,. ,�; � ,. "i t." Y' . . `j . f J � . - � . - , � e�' _ �7 S . � � �� � � -� ° �� �_tf; -�'`�� ��k � .�' , . ,. . �; . , . t` � � , � �� . � . . �. . � � � � . ` �„ .. . . � - . .d� .+� . . , • , : .. � . . �. ..�; yl � . .. . .� :.�i . . . . ' - � ' • � . , . ' / �-.: . �: . � . "- �,. . . .: .. .- ' ,... � ..�, v.<. . '� .i. .:} _ '„_ '.l_ : . . . . . .....� , ... .. . �j �1 d �:. . � � .,' . � � ./� f , � � - i �� 1 F� � ,�� Y 1,�._ 4 �� ,�:.. � ..1 ��- 1 1 h � t �+ � `� ��1�/�x ,. , . , n. . :i e ,i._ . . . ,. ��.. ., i.. .. _:C. ,. . . . . , .,. . . �, , f .. , i,_ f ..... , . . .ni .�.�C, ,.. .s . . ,.,..�t+�* , —�� � �' �''��Q� •' " . ' ( �t,�, o� , ,�� ' � ��$ +� � CITY OF SAINT PAUL ° ������„�„ ; DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT `�� °11 �� � ha' DIVISION OF PLANNING 25 West Fourth Street,Saint Paul,Minnesota 55102 +ea+ 612-228-3270 GEORGE LATIMER MAYOR .ruiy is, i9ss RECEIVED JUL 211988 Albert Olson, City Clerk Room 386 �ity xall CITY CLERK Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 RE: Zoning File #10335 - Gary McGee City Council Hearin�': Thursdav. July 28, 1988 PURPOSE: To consider an appeal of a decision by the Board of Zoning Appeals to grant a variance of side yard setback for construction of one-car, attached garage and dining room expansion. The variance reduces the setback from 7' to 2.5' . (No Building Permit has been issued and no work has been done on the garage. ) BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS DECISION: Approve (6-1) June 14, 1988 STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approve DISTRICT COUNCIL: Requested a lay over so neighbors could work out an agreement. SUPPORT: 3 Letters OPPOSITION: None at the meeting. Dear Sir: On June 14, 1988, the Board of Zoning Appeals approved a variance to reduce the required side yard setback from 7' to 2.5' at 1905 Field. The next door neighbor, Gary McGee, is appealing that decision. The person who applied for the variance, Richard Stauble, wishes to add a one- car garage to the side of his existing single-family home and later to expand his dining room. The addition would be 14.5' wide: 10.5' for the garage and 4' for the dining room expansion. (See attached plans. ) Mr. Stauble could build a detached garage in the back yard which does not require a variance. However, he would prefer to build an attached garage in order to leave as much of the back yard as green space as possible. Mr. McGee originally told staff that he did not object to a variance for a 2' setback and signed a letter saying that. However, he later told the District 15 Council that he was opposed to it. But he signed another letter for the BZA meeting saying he did not oppose the variance if it was increased to 2.5' . Mr. McGee filed for an appeal after the BZA approved the variance. ,' • � /�I�► {/�.r��9� y�"-'0 0 � File #10335 Page Two The appeal is scheduled to be heard by the City Council on July 28, 1988. I will have a slide presentation set up for the meeting. Sincerely, Tom Beach Zoning Section Attachment TB:ss �Gl�j IM�!%HT�. �, A�p��1 l�ppl���a+� 2. �iZ� Rcsoly��� 3. 1�Z� �'IiNu�Cs �'. ��'� �t v� . �' .5 Va r�4Nc� �c�. ��-� s:� �I�h � �� �iq� 8- 12. l.��'�s 13-� � l.��t�► ���s ����/�� °��I�. CITY OF SAINT PAUL ��~� '�� OFFICE OF 7HE CITY ATTORNEY o �� ''.� iiii�iiiiii �� e;. „�- EDWARD P. STARR, CITY ATTORNEY �`'"��„�,�";;fi��'°�� 647 City Hall, Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 612-298-5121 GEORGE LATIMER MAYOR September 2 , 1988 Albert Olson City Clerk 386 City Hall Re: 1905 Field - Appeal of Gary McGee Dear Mr. Olson: Enclosed is the resolution which the City Council had requested whereby they reverse the decision of the Board of Zoning Appeals in granting a variance for the construction of a garage and dining room at 1905 Field. You will note that the resolution provides that a copy of it shall be mailed by your office to all the parties named in the resolution. Yo r very truly, i ,-' ?� . � R�ME J . S L �Ass�istant City Attorney ���s .c g Encl . . �j, . , . - �����99 APPLICATION FOR APPE�ECEIVED ZONING OFFICE USE ONLY CITY OF SAIN'T PAUL JUN 2� 198g F; te � /0 33� � ZONING �p1 ication Fee S q� Tentative Hearing Oate'���� Application is hereby made for an Appeal to the C��y (,� under the provisions of Chapter 64 Section ,�a�agrap—�L of the oning ode to appeal a decision made by the �C Board o oning Appeals ` Planning Comnission on G / � , 19_. _ Zoning Administrator (dat o decision) _ Planning Administrator Other A. APPELLANT�• / �O _D j� I Name �g,Q,��G��� Daytime phone �D Address �� Fl�Ll� Zip Cade �S// �„ B. OECISION BEING APPEALEDL" Zoning file name S'u�y�,je toning File � �030(0 Property Address/Location ( 9�S �lp�d. Legal description � c 7 �� �, � � �� �'(� C. GROUNOS FOR APPEAL (Use additional sheets if necessary. ) (cxplain why you feel there has been an error in any requirement, permit, decision or refusal made by an administrative official, or an error in fact, procedure or finding made by the Board of Zoning Appeals or the Planning Commission.) i ob No-� wa ►�-r � N,�u� s ��ti � L��T� ��n.��-rur�� �t��s �c.o s� � ��P2c�p�u-rh If you have any questions, please contact: Applicant's ignature St. Paul Zoning Office 1100 City Hall Annex 25 West Fourth Street lo— L�—g$ Saint Paul , Minnesota 55102 Date City agent (298-4154) 9�82 1 . �3. . � . � �/_"�-/��9Q - � CITY OF SAINT PAUL BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS RESOLUTION ZONING FILE NUMBER: 10306 DATE: 7une 14, 1988 . .. . w'HEREAS, Richard Stauble has applied for a variance from the strict application of the provisions of Section 61.101 of the Saint Paul Lcgislative Code pertaining to side yard setback in the R-3 zoning distriet; and WHEREAS, the Saint Paul Board of Zoning Appeals conducted a public hearing on June 14, 1988, pursuant to said appcal in accordance with the requirements of Section 62.204 of the Legislative Code; and WHEREAS, tho Saint Paul Board of Zoning Appeals based upon evidence presented at the public hearing, as substantially reflected in the minutes, made the following findings of fact: 1. The applicant owns a single-family house at this location. The house does not have a garagc. However, therc is a 17' wide driveway from the street to the side of the house and a gravel parking pad along side the house. A tent/camper unit is currently stored on the gravel parking pad. 2. The applicant wishes to add a three-season porch to the back of the house and an attached garage to the sidc of the house. The garage would be 14.5' wide and 29' deep. The front of the garage would be set back 9' from the front of the house. The garage would have a 2.5' setback from the east side property line. 3. The applicant plans to enlarge his dining room at some time in the future by expanding 4' into the garage space, leaving an 10.5' wide garage space. 4. A detached garage could be built in the backyard with a 3' setback. However, the . applicant is claiming that placing the garage and the driveway necessary to get to it in the backyard would result in a hardship in that it is an existing house with an existing yard which he would like to preservo as green space for his family. 5. The proposed variance is in keeping with the spirit and intent of the code. It will not impair an adequate supply of light and air to ad jacent property, nor will it alter the essential character of the surrounding area. The neighboring house is set back 13' from the side property line and its driveway runs between the house and the applicant's property. There are no windows on the side of the neighboring house facing where the garage would be built. 6. The variance, if granted, would not permit any use that is not permitted in the zoning district where the property is located. 7. The request for variance is based primarily on a desire to fully utilize the site rather than economic gain. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, by the Saint Paul Board of Zoning Appeals that ' the provisions of Section 61.101 be hereby waived to allow an attached garage with a 2.5' � side yard setback on property located at 1905 Field and legally describcd as Lot ?, Block 1, Cukier Addition; in accordance with thc application for variance and the site plan on file with the Saint Paul Planning Division. MGO/ED BY: Horak � SECONDED BY: Maddox IN FAVOR: 6 AGAINST: � AiAIL�D: June 15, 1988 SEE REVERSE SIDE FOR: TIME LJMI?/APPEAL/CERTIFICA'TION Z . �. . . ����� TIhiE LtMIT: No order of the Board of Zonia� Appeals permittin� the erection or alterstioa oi a buildio� or oft-street parkin� lacility shall be valid for a period loager than one ysar, unle:s a buildia� permit for such erection or alter�tlon is obtained withln such period and such . erection or alteration is proceeding pursuant to the terms ot such permit. The Board ot Zoning Appeals or the City Councll may Yrant an extensioa not to exceed one year. In grantin� such extension, the Board of Zonin� Appeals may decide to hold a public hearin�. , � APPEAL: Decisions of the Board o! Zonin� Appeals are ffaal subject to appeal to the City Council within 15 days by anyoae affected by the decision. �ERTIFICATION: I, the undersigned Secretary to the Bosrd o! Zoning Appeals for the � City of Saint Paul, Minnesota, do hereby certify that I have compared the foregoing copy with the original record in my off�ce; and fiad the same to be a true and correct copy of said original and of the whole thereof, as based on approved minutea of the Satnt Paul Board of Zoning Appeals meetin� held on June 14, 1988 ind on record in the Safnt Paul Planning DIvision Office, 25 West Fourth Street, Saint Paui, Minnesota. SAINT PAUL BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS ��-�`�y����,����`�--------- ✓ Secretary to the Board � • "�I:�ILTES OF THE '�EETING OF THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS � ��(��9 ' '' ' ', ' t 3 th FLOOR CONFERENCE ROOH, CITY FIALL ANNEX a° � ST. PALTL.. MINNESOTA. JUNE 1�, �988 PRESENT• Mme. Maddox; Messzs. Grais, Kirk, Osborn, Woods, Horak, and Zimniewicz of the Board of Zoning Appeals; Mr. Segal, Assistant City Attorney; Ms. Lane of the Division of Building Inspection and Design; Hr. Beach, Ms. Synstegaard and Mr. Ryan of the Planning Division Staff. ABSENT: None. The meeting was chaired by Sam Grais, Chairman. , �ICHARD STAUBLE [#10306) : Side yard setback for attached garage and three- season porch. The applicant was present. There was no opposition present at the hearing. Mr. Beach showed slides of the site and reviewed the staff report With a recommendation for approval. Highland Area Community Council sent a letter zequesting a one month layovez to permit time for the applicant and the neighbor to work out a plan. Four letters were received in support. Mr. Grais asked the applicant if he had anything to add. Mr. Stauble submitted letters of support from the neighbors to the Board. Mr. Beach stated that since the Highland Area Community Council meeting Mr. Stauble and the neighbor have zeached an agreement of a 2 1/2' setback and staff agrees. Ms. Maddox asked Mr. Beach if finding number 2 would then read 2 1/2' , Mr. Beach replied yes. Hearing no further testimony, Mr. Grais closed the public portion of the meeting. Mr. Horak maae u �iction to . r�ve t�P •-ar'_z:-.��_ - _ -. -��.: based on staff findings 1 through 7. Ms. Maddox scco����,; �._� ;:,u�i,,:,, „-hich passed on a roll call vote of 6 to 1 (Osborn) . Submitted by: Appxoved by: � '1'G"',. Tom Beach � Sam Grais 3 . . ����99 - , BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS STAFF REPORT FILE #10306 1. APPLICANT: Richard Staubel DATE OF HEARING: 6/14/88 2. CLASSIFICATION: Minor Variance 3. LOCATION: 1905 Field (north side between Prior and Sue) 4. LEGAL DESCRIPTION: Lot 7, Block 1, Cukier Addition 5. PLANNING DISTRICT: 15 6. PRESENT ZONING: R-3 ZONING CODE REFERENCE: 61.101 7. STAFF INVESTIGATION AND REPORT: DATE: June 2, 1988 BY: Tom Beach A. PURPOSE: To add an attached garage and three-season porch to an existing single-family house and expand the dining room. B. ACTION REQUESTED: Variance of side yard setback, (2' requested, 7' required) C. SITE AND AREA CONDITIONS: Lot area is 8,410. (58' x 145' ) The lot is level. Field is a dead end street. Surrounding land use is single-family residential to the south, east and west and rail road tracks to the north (rear) . D. FINDINGS: 1. The applicant owns a single-family house at this location. The house does not have a garage. However, there is a 17' wide driveway from the street to the side of the house and a gravel parking pad along side the house. A tent/camper unit is currently stored on the gravel parking pad. 2. The applicant wishes to add a three-season porch to the back of the house and an attached garage to the side of the house. The garage would be 15' wide and 29' deep. The front of the garage would be set back 9' from the front of the house. The garage would have a 2' setback from the east side property line. 3. The applicant plans to enlarge his dining room at some time in the future by expanding 4' into the garage space, leaving an 11' wide garage space. 4, A detached garage could be built in the backyard with a 3' setback. However, the applicant is claiming that placing the garage and the driveway necessary to get to it in the backyard would result in a hardship in that it is an existing house with an existing yard which he would like to preserve as green space for his family. 5. The proposed variance is in keeping with the spirit and intent of the code. It will not impair an adequate supply of light and air to adjacent property, nor will it alter the essential character of the surrounding area. The neighboring house is set back 13' from the side property line and its driveway runs between the house and the applicant's property. There are no windows on the side of the neighboring house facing where the garage would be built. 6. The variance, if granted, would not permit any use that is not permitted in the zoning district where the property is located. 7. The request for variance is based primarily on a desire to fully utilize the site rather than economic gain. E. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Based on findings 1 through 7, staff recommends approval of the variance. � .T� � �. � . .. • , t�., ;t. .... . .. • � � � � ' �o�o �o ^ �����q� � � APP�ICATION FOR 20NIN0 ORDINANCE VARIANCE "' 05648 1 CITY OF iAINT PAUI I A VARIANCE OF ZONING CODE CHAPTEii�,SECTION�Q�PARAGRAPH IS REQUESTED IN CONFORMITY WITH THE RS VESTED IN TME BOAR�OF 20NING AP— PEALS TO PERMIT THE P ON PROPERTV � DESCR18E0 BE��IY. A. Applip�t; NAME: Il / T S/ Q L! / AOORESS /��� �C�_�� °� � DAYTIME TE�EPHONE NO. CO /O�'3�? I 21P CODE S� � 1. Propsrty intthet of appliqnt: low�e►,contract purohsier,�tc.) � � �Whtr -. . . � . . Z._ I�m�of ewMr (if�iil�swtl; ; t � . : . � . . : B. Propetty pesaiption: ADDRESS 'qOS ry�d � � i. l.egsl description: LOT� BLOCK � ADO. K /e f' iz. �t:,�: 5�" � /�S ' � � �' s. �,�. �sr ��� �.��t�,;�9�t. �P-3 � C. Re�wu fo►Reqwet: - � � 1. ProP�d use d�` � f/ � � �7 Gt G�re.� r�ye Q� ; �rrc� - Se.�s� �po r�� �- W�PhYSid d�ristia of th�praptrty ptivent its btitp u�sd for�r►y of ths p�rmirnd yse� m Y�soneT itopognpNY,soil oondtio�s.size a�d shape of bt,�Le.) //� Q//��- /► f�/a c.ea+P,..� p�� �O Kf'� oA 7�fi� �d'� 3. Ststs t!M�p�eific varirtion rpuwt�d.¢vin0�+���PD►uPr�an• � 6(,t//� w;ffli� �2 �eef ef' E4s t /of /��e i,,s f,r,�� ". "�i����t7i:/,i�R'��f �-'.a,.+c� �S�����'���'i ' �. ��ipl�jn Aow 1lo r eiM .�ew�larw�e t��eA of 1M foNowinp:� — a +: __ a. That tM sbiet applie�Kon of tM pro�risions of th�Zoninp Ordiw�p would n�uh i�p�cuiiar or�xeeodomi or�cW�M diifkultiK,a�captio�sl undue lard�hJ'°`- �(JQ /S� 7 J�,S GrVG �e KSt o� �fi P �cI�J►it r�'� / O�, � �f+��/� f'P.�.� /^Q!�L°l� 'f�ifis, Lt�a r�� . cwsH�EAS usE oN�r y b. TMt tM p�ntirq ot a v�rwrwy wiil � G �, ilf` not es • we.nrw.� d.trim�nt eo OS/23/88aoo�zil:G4A� t�ERF: 1 �� •-`. w i a�c�o o d o r s.u�,.�n t��n,o•k- 400! VARIANGE *140.00 m�nt of tl+. ir�nt M+d purpa..oi �.��a��..p�sf.,,�e suRrri �i4o.00 �wee�, 6,,:/.�`� s - �;l/ k c��t� n�r, �i4o.00 ,�- , {=+�r� �.o0 �:�:---��'� _ - NOTE: THIS NILL NOT� tfi MIITMOUT C oLETE SITE�LAN I 1 _ jS"'�r�tt�n° - � j =- �3 ,:,�: -_ _ _ �:�..=. oa,� -�Y /� � . . �. • � V 1 .� � �� � i^l ` Gr �sr �p,,,.n p� Y�v �• • O �h-� :r� �,�+ � 1 � I /� �, ��GhQ • f O�^� L ��"C� A ,J1�:.1 E'J 'o v :� � ` : / ,N�h = ?D �P ` /9oS �;� !� i4ve �'��/�/11� � ` S f. Pa u i , /1�+ N , 5S I l�' , � , .,Lot 7, B•o-k � , �'�k,A. /��� �, �-, p , r ' � � : _^-o� /� •9 j► ' - •1 - �✓a�/ , � ; f � � Q �cor�� ro � � a : '.� :� � °_� ; � J I E!v-'r [ Fenca L �,..� ��PrP Q1� ar,c� c�%�v� �E i�., /� py� �, T;� r�-•"• - rj�'G� � low =� � 0:� - ,! � ' �. = f > � �'o k,..,�y � /Lf, .�.,P S o a , �---_ , � . — -, - —- - - - ------ , . ;�� ��°�' � l�,.=69G- 3?? ' u�i� .Sy"�-::i� =� ' J , ^ -- ------ - �• � rSa�d� N^ . ;. � � �r d ►' i i �'X_ Go. �9e `,��L. �S.i F —'_ " S8� _r --- - �Gi% �Q h 'E' YF4 V PS T r°v' ,^ � � �� 6 n l� � ���-' sP. f-c t \ j � �" �'n �asf s%�� � � ��7; �/he{� I �cncF ; . f /' Q�� ��,s1� a��,"'„+;,� ,rsY'r��i+ OT , IYCN . ��, ��"c �'Jti_ !�. y �P(� L� ! lC�� 7 , OG�. FC i't.' c1 r�A (TG►r 4 9 � � � � � � I � ♦ , J , � . _s, ; 1 -�- - —2 9. �r � ' � ������oa f i� -�� � -- _ _-- - ----— � . . � - - � � � . �.Od ' i . � � � , ` � ����� ,�w^S' I � ,y_ - , G� , ; - - I¢,� StF�-� y V y . _._, C'� S_° � � %�P=� =�+ '� �! �� , /9,?3 F,��� f;i��' .Z��J - - - - -- - -� - s�� , 5� 3,-� ''F— i�� - -' ---- - - ---- �' wa`K ;�• ,= D,-,�� . KAy + • �S'�_ � i�av i ' �-. y�� 3� .. ��z � E- �'-� � i f-- !7�--'r / ���P`'� ! Dr iVP woy� � . �_ � ' ��1 r :.� .. /� '+' = . .�\� ;:-. -�. �. -�- � .�-- ":-� , - � r ,.g 'c. � �r a •:f� . -S- .' . . . � .-�-'' '�'�� ' - . ,t. ,;� - . t e-��.y ��t.i . .' . � ,� . , ,� � . �0.�r'T.�,�+�L�; ''� ¢+ ...' � Ss -�� - t� '"��.+'.-.. . . .t�J V��• ��,� � . . t �., �f� . � ..�..--!" i ".y , . , • _—' .. ' �� � _ -- �� �� � y .�h�.-... ..+ � �� � r� (,f��/�19� . , � �: �, , � � ' _ � . :. " �.'., t=. ' �- - — — - - �. _ `:. .�.. � _ — _ � — ._ _ _ . _ �__ � ��_ �___� - � � l; • s�. • � - - - -- - , � j '..�I �a..,..� �� --� L .� ��. _ _._:_1�'�,�+_ • _ � - � ,_�..a,; _ ' 1 �.- r `..------ _ _ _ ._.... _ .-. _ _ �_. _. .y..;... � t•----.—T -,..:.4.a-_.`- -- ! ' .t- ' �' � •r 'y � , - �t ... 'r�.-' ---- � S•� - _ �.4_..�� ��,._ . .� _ . , � -��'� � . ' ; ��s��ts e�.,. 1 ' � � ` "- �--- i _ . 4—"' �i��•`- -+�T � � �0e,,� . -i- . _. _ i.., __...- •-}----r -rt �n�. �� _ . _._ , � !• _�..��.;.�.� �_� � �/' �. ___._ - _ " .!� . r _�_.._� �:v_� I t ._ ,�� . ' �'�"." _ : - � � .:�j-� - � , : _." ,s.�� -_ � --�,�,�-,,_� '_ =�—� ( I , _ i ,�'. _ . � '. , . � �� 1 r. _� � - - - � _ • - . _ � . . __..�. � \ --�Y - �ro,eose� .% . . � �-"t=; ;i._f:+ • " � . - ; 1 � A�d i�i� � j • _ '-; _t � �.- - � � � ' �� - ;i . _.����� � "' ` 1 / /p� �' . _' - � K�� � �� _ � 1 i� i _ . ` � _ : _ � . .,_�__- -- ��� v� . ; _ �,f��� .j�� ._ _. � _ - - -..� �. _. ._ ��G_��, -:+__ �_+'�-�-" _ ,�Ire� � � ; , i ,�t� ---+ =`-«. �{ , -- . . ` �•.�`� � f , ..:� 11Q/l e )► . �-v��jrW r✓al/� � . G"^ G ._ -� ` , `.�.�., s_I`'-� _�-=-i-� hOh !��IQAh� � . , .. -� --i�---t `� � p'' —� I �O��s,eo�.� __ t_ _ �___ " _^ ��� � � ' � '�lY. • __ __"_T' .. � • � . . ... . . ._ t � ' , ' � , ,_ _ i w �. •� r � �' �` � � - • - t :, . , � _..� ` r�t..' � ! � - i . _ ' , � . . . . �� . �. _�- ?�_�_ .r..�-_T Pr s e��t �t:� �. __ . .__ - - -- - - _ ; �_ �_ ' _ �_ _ ----.-,.,--. , � �.---�= _ � :___.__. : . T�1_ _; — — — �' - - — — �' .• - ' -- _ . __ �s. _ •�s � •--- - •--'---; ��_-�—-� L- �. . : ��._ -.-� _ _..-��..7 . � � � � �-. -� � ..� � _ � � ,� .- . 4r.*`-� : -• � 0� W i�^�Ch✓ kI��� q�� .-r t_�1-.�- -= --j-: �� w w��►1� �. -�--�-��-i-:' .:�. e�s�i D.R, w•I1 ._: . �__?�..�"��; ''9 - <_`.�i:� ; - . �- - -��-- .�- {� -, �; �_�. , . .. .. _ . .. .� ��'a".^T'L'h�—t^�- .'' . .� i � �► w � � .► � �) r i � f . —_- , ` - � �'�.�._���'��T-"�}- � � ��._...��,.!-�+� //r� // �/ais� �v� St a�rrif__ ,r ` �do�_. : :�. ,:�-�- I / D O� ' . T r ..��._ . G�//�/�� "~.-_ -"_��; ^--_.�.�_�' i. �, �. , .. . i - . .._ . �-__ . _ . � • _ . . � __ .._ _ __ . .,- - �-r - - -��^ _'y..�,..r-- ' - � -- : � - - . �. . . - . . ' • ---i-. , , • . .. . . ... . + • --L •..��t_y'� � . . . . _-...:.�,*}.�.. '� ��� � �. � � 1,���`�Q� � - j`{ gg S�y s , L�� �� ��� � -� �t �'.� SEaub!�s c,u�1� hu; !� � I � z ��� av�3 rnsl�d o � �-� -� ��,.�, I � -�a-� � a"��, �(�.�.� 1iVa.5 b v�DI�h,��� Prt�c�-.�-e,� . � z /✓ f' C�''���'�Z�_ v � 0 i } � i � F � . .. - ., � � � ���`i4��� , 5/26/�3A To whom it may concern, Ihave looked at 8ichar�i Stauble's site �lan f.or his attached qaraae. I understand his craraQe will stand two feet away from the prooerty line. I do not have any objections about his buildinq this qaraqe. Sincerely, " . �. �, ��..k.�. � � 9 :, � � f 3 a � ' - " ' . ' : • - � - - • • • . - • - '_ �_�.:a." .� - -�,_.._. .�..i , .. ` ��/�/ ` HIGHLAND AREA COMMUNITY COUNCIL 790 CLEVELAND AVE. S. SUITE 2088 ST. PAUL, MN 55116 (612� 690-0866 TO: Board of Zoning Appeals FROM: Highland Area Community Council DATE: June 13, 1988 RE: Variance Application for 1905 Field Avenue The Highland Area Community Council (HACC) met on June 9, 1988 and reviewed the variance application of Richard Staubel 1905 Field Avenue to permit the construction of a garage with a 2' sideyard setback {east side of lot),. The neighbor to the east of the applicant 1903 Field opposed the variance request. Mr. Staubel requested an opportunity to work with his neighbor to develop a plan that would satisfy his concerns. The board recommended that the issues be laid over for a month to permit time for Mr. Staubel and Mr. McGee work on a plan. � ��30�6 cc: �ouncilmember Long Chuck McGuire Richard Staubel Gary McGee � v . 7 t p . �� - �. � � � �,J� ��- i Y9q � CATCO DIMENSION PRODUCTS 530 SELBY AVE. PHONE 612-292-0477 ST. PAUI., MN 55102 �'�3?'3 of Zoning A�peals June 10, 1988 �= Wes� FcL��h S".' . ._. L . ^Q L� � l�:�V . J�1`J c. � . Re : Z�ninq Variance Request for kictiard Staubel , 1905 F:eld Ave . To Who�r� It May Concern: My name is Michael Rone, and I live directly across the street fZOm Richazd Staubel, at 1900 Field Avenue . Richard has discussed the proposed addition vith me, and I see absolutely no problem with his pZans . Obsezving the manner in which Y�.;� property is currently maintained, I am very confident the construction and final appearance of this ad�ition w� il be appropriate for the neiq_hborhood. Richard is an e:lcellent neiqhbor, and has already done more than most of the peopie ;r. �he area, to improve h:s pZOperty and qeneral appearance , of hi� ,.� �'J L. • ' ; .. _3�. :7�_��Ile�_ 3i�j� ���uC��l�n�� piease l,ai� iil� �� �iiE :���:.1����� =a.��ir�. _-. ...._ :�tte��ea= a�-ove . '^:-:.3ni: you . - -•--��e__;, /�������'.�.� j�!�/i�'L,Q,�- *!- —.`. F� i�G*:E -- ° ��Q�� Repn�entingManufactu�rs ofPrecision Wood Components � ..�_.. - 1 . .=Sar.. k . _ . r .. . . .. . .. .y' - - -- f S. �� x �}'L� �:�i''S � . yY. �� . . ' �.z� 'ks� • y it�#-i [(..� r�/� r +-.�4 ��!'� ",� .. - _ - - � . A��t- • '[• R � '�y -Y� ,�v�� f `-• tf ��• y�F'j .�d�.'F+r Y• / � .:�� �T F�.� * �w� ."�'. ' '`���-:t . .. . :�!' r � �� . � ,t•� ��y�. . ty3 �y+t�ae .' :. ;5..`* .. r ,. 'as� �� ; . - -p,`� . . . '{� �"� - �►'t� .#..�i �� :,.�t�+`i:-�:�• ,-�:c �' . : .;��;, ' �r .� :,- � F . -. .r;�yayi � :A� r�.. .;.+�� ?._' . . � .� - � � � � " ' � �� u� �o>> �� ���►�-�. ���-/�'9 ; . j� � �y � _.i ��:?I-i Lj�_i i t ��a r, _. �•r n p E,r-�±.y ��?1'"v i C:�?5 �ame� �. an�� Judy �;. C�1 .a.sen �. ��a F i�1 �1 ��j .e �i?.. � -,�_�1 . i�IN �::�1 1 c Jun� i��, i'�b8 C.h�iirp?rson an�� f•lernb�=rs t�n`�r-d °1 �°nln�� HpPPal he: h=ittached Garage V�riance-�?' �ity of St. Paul The Fiichard Stauble Family i� West 4th St. 19�=�5 Field Ave St. Faul St. Faul , MN JJ 1 i�� Dear Board Members, During the past few months, I have met with Mr. Richard � Sta.uble relating to his plans to attach a single car garage to the east end of his ho►_�se whi 1e at the same timE e>:panding primary living �re� to the bac�:: or north end af his home. The original p 1 ans f or� th i s no��s� SnoWEd a si ng 1.e car attar_hed garage but i n the Spring ot 19E6 w��en it was completed, we determined to sell t.he property wi tho�.it a garage, ptr, Staubl e p�irchased the house ti-;a.t Sprinq with �n intentzon of attaching � =,ingle car garage �s sonr� �s he r_{.�ui d f i nanc i al 1 y do sr�. I t-�a�.�e re�vi.ewed t�E pl an= and f i. nd them ta bP ar-chi tectu�.l 1 y =suppor-t i ��e �n� wi 1 l. �?r���•:i de !:at no si gn i t i car�t er:onomi c ber�ef i t to thc 5taublF +«rnilyi a =_��itabl.e and convenient sin�iE ear structure. l_i ��i r�c� acros=_• th� stre�.t �r-orn t��e St a��i�l e r•�si 1�nce �nd aw�,re of the typFs c�f homes ��n F�.e�� r�ve iwe F-,a.ve bui 1 t thr-ee ��ame= on tt-�i s Jri ve; . 1. b�Ol.! i rj =aa S�_ti_h c!f"t ;�L�.��.r�;a�� � �Y'cl�"F? �?i'�1 par-t of thG i`�OUSE� :� � a s ._•.n i n t� r �. _rr�_irT�trA .as w�l. i as r��ce_=.ary ba.sed ��n o!�r- NlinnFSC�t� weather . 1 aa�i�ii iJ �_ryt-t ct1;`i i `�' S�:p�iC�°L. �� 1 �R1 SLtY"E �Tiy f1r31��"itiOt'S i1ciV� �.i S�� :. n:�i c.�,t�r7. i�1r. �taubl e' s ae=i;�e fvr� a varian�_e tc� eor�sir�!ct thi s �tta�_hed gar-�g� ancl hr��e tha± yo�� w�uld �e .��ilF to provide him the support hz needs to accomplist� tf-,is construction. TF.anF: �:ou for �:r��_ir k:in�� at_an±lon regardinq ,ny l�tt�t- . i cerel y, . L Jame= L. C1asEn .�TLG,: �c : �Z ; � � . -.. . .- . � � ����y9� � � ZO�l�;�� ���� a� �� -� - ��.. . ` , . ti � . ...... .. .. r � � ' Z 1Z� ; � 10 � . � g � � � . .. _ � . .....e .. t � I..,.. .. S ` , • / � ' , '�' N w r � • � � ` � . , • ��1 . �� � � � � w� � � � rr�w N `� � �• � rr � • � �� f M � r� 1 �..�w•• f � � � � i • • � � -.. .� i e � � �.�� M � N . � • � � � ��► M . r0 �' Yr� K � / � �� �• �0 , � 3� � � _ i �r nr ra ��� t �`• � L � a s t • L � �. '4 ,n.�.o. M 9 �j �= S � ; ` ��a°. 1 � _ N � � t � � , ' �/ : � � it � � � � � � 1 � Ai � �w � r0` ww � � O i• � � � � � ' 15 ' �M � � , ` s .o+a w f � � . j ` •.. ' '� �" '�\, �� L \ w _/" � „ �� � • s � ��. ,� CITIZEN PARTICIPATION PLANNING DISTRICTS 1.SUNRAY-6ATTLECREEK-HIGHWOOD 2.GREATER EAST SIDE 3.WEST SIDE 4.OAYTON'S BLUfF S.PAYNE-PHALEN 6.NORTH END . 7.THOMAS-DALE B.SUMMIT-UNIVERSITY 9.WEST SEVENTH 10.COMO 11.HAMLINE-MIOWAY i2.ST. ANTHONY i3.MERRIAM PK.-LEXIN�TON HAMLINE 14.6 RO VE 1 i1N 0-MAC AL E ST E R 15.H1GHLAND 16.SUMMIT HILL v�� ��.�TO4m �3 ii , ���� � �. � � I • ~� ' `'����� ' � • ������� � � i �•'� , �� l � ' • � � � � � � � • � • � • • • � • � • • � � � - � • � � - -', � � �'• • • • • � • • � � • • • • • • • .� _ -`�-` -� " , � .�'2 _ .> �_z i� ���:»td#c��^�t+'•Ma--.-c ti���t4'y�f.f�'n'i��.,t�/v;, ,��y �i '=i _ ' __ � 3� � _..�-r�,��.�.F'P?F..,f y� �y� `.�.��s.�� .'. `� �� w �':1lllr� �.:�.°� a C�r tn+x:t`[..�^-7 Hi, ,, :.. ��,:i'�..1 _: .�a �� 4 � . . �- . .i "� � ,�n�✓ �aw� r�s h� - ^..,�_ � -.� y� �'.� s - t" '..: -� ��: tK+;�N�^ivrurrfx bAFS*v..e�.u�cr.rK'ssrm.. r is�•t.'a:ri:��.�r r'� �S��� � _ '---� �. A.,,,r.fl �t-�s.'�I�+..rt .'?ro tr1�i;,..: '��= � ',�'�t'����`..5�.'S ��ti✓:.r1,:L'+i,C•i��..:J.'fL'�Wi'." .,. r r-.- ;�r.t 1��►7� .,1 �r....+'Zt •J.n^ �r r/'�.�- �^�'c�S"i� -OI .1�r - .A14CV1.'*Wi.G'IW3NIQR�'-Gg+ilUJl.t N � h�. 'G l�. vi-- .. ,nw. .. .-.rrek.�rn.YwvcYR6a0.u�' . •.� ..-.-r�x i �Z +" '� � r,j� ����l i, �fJ� I' .';r i y ..,� 9'.}�""�q-Y� t�^}.:':`:ti�._'�"r ,i�';3,`r <<.�;. ,��f� °� d.�..�/�d�r ./ r�Y ✓�{ �r .�',� � � ,_ �,. .�� � a: u� y !t.'...��.J..i •� r --t .. ,J�t Yi' ���E.�.e-'•'.. ,�v: �ri^.r. ;�-�'ycr�wL:y:� �:�.. ✓/�,yy'�`�,'-!�":iilit$f<.:1'�3:��nYsJ �.ar.a��ii�+.n� , � �.� � / • � w • • • � • • • • • • ��� • • � � - � . • • • • � ` • � • � � � Y � n S � � � � � � � � • � � � � � �� . - , . e o. .o . . . . . . . . . . . . . . - � � . . ' ; , - , � • ' , e � �� • • � • • • • • • • • • • • � G� � � � � • � � � � • � � • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • � • • • • • • • � • � � � � • • • • A� O � • • � � • • • • � • • � • • • • � � � • � • � • • • • • • • • • • � • • • � • • • • • • � � � � � � • ' � � Li � � � � : • � . � � � i,// � � � ' � I � � � � � • • v _ • • . , � � � . ' . � � � � • . /� , � � • • � - � � - . � 1 1 � •s � • � . • V� V � r/I • / �� �, ��G�� ��i�/�� G, , ,��� n� � �ti�'s ' � � ll� G,�i f{�l� %►�N�� �.� k1e s� �f-{� �f �f� ��-�, /�l�/ .�/D� � �P � = z�, �.,�, t=/� /'�/,.,,�d� /0 3O� � � � � G� ,S-�d/� I��✓� �e/G( /;� Sf, ��./� �l/�� ���� 1 �� � � 1�A GZ/�-�L( -�" L� 29 J� 'G-��l � id��2 w�// � � ,�/✓ �-v-t, a /� '� �� ai��c c�� � � �� e a� � �. � �� �,��� .�� �/� �y 5��/ ��,� G�nr �° / ui � i%�e�/_ .j'h�-ze.�j S+�! � c2t r � �c /� q � . E /� � / `� ( �, i i/� ��.; �-L� ��-� ��� a ��� �� � � ,� �c� ���� /� �'�f �ti��� s7�-�����-,e s , �� � �a.��� ��� �� /r'r� �. � s�yes�� y yGt �s I U �!'�`y,, �� � w��� ,-,�n f ,o v�s s �I%� � c� , 7- _ / / / - _ � �e c �s , �, a s � o�o rr�f �,�.� sG� 7L �1-�v'� 7�-1`e �t�'w, �-,� -� c�-�7��-,�� ��-e 7�? � � 7� y �� �js � c Ps�. � // i � %�LZ�� m'�` � �.c �- ��o-z� � � ��� r y �� �o� c e s s — �c�'u Q v-e a 7�r�.P �o K� �c se�- Ya�-.� � , /� / / / a v�,o��/ �z � /H 1��e flu S��� e y f oc(SO , / ✓/ 11aC�iv-�l . . -�'�9 q � "• • � � . . � , N�P r 1 P►-•��'�� I - - - - - - - - - - - - - - , � � � f- l3'a I i li h@ � i I � t ; I � 1 T 3 - Sea s� : � � � ( �/��" /-oYch i � � � C��p,�SP�� � - - - - - - - - - - - � --__ _ - � , � � � � i i ' I � i � /�/E i��t bo-Ys � � � __ � . � . __. � , �r•vt W . ` . � va Ner J ' �9'� �. I � I ( � �/R�� � � � � �lh/h9 �1�9C � !D' I�r�a �P,��oS��� , �, I . . . . . . . - - — - - -� _ i q• �+;t � i _ , � g � N.f�: � � ; � /Ve;9 L s._ . ( /}�cS� �s - � /3 �'.-�... . � �.�Pe•-�y �', � � - � � - - - - - - - - , - - - -� ✓� ' ---�: s' � � E�h�ee N► �c� ���e�+ sf"r�c��� � i �lo�r P/a h �? S � H Q�-e = I f��f� � 1 � � / � /� �� f'"O r 1'w r �Q r ' " o t l�v J` `� ° '6,7 �:�, L.n. ' r n � p l /� n � ' /� i G/i O � ^,�" o r•� L ,�+of a :7�Gt u b�L° � v� . = o ScQ/� . / ���I, ?D �eef /9 S �;P /d Ave �`�''/�9� Sf. Pau � , /�+ N , SSl !� ; ••Lot 7 , B�'o�� ! � �'K1<;P, Aa/� �'�:,. iFo�` r0�� /P �i � - •� - j✓a e ; . 9 y Q C C o�-d , .,9 �i ��,p �. �4 �-:�o�r- .,�.2� EIoc±7�L F�N�e L%r.P T�PyP �'`, G�hQ Si�L�Cc �P /y �p �'►";$°� T•%P�.... ; y�o 7b Jow �oa.�, •. Po/e � �—'� l° 9 Cow..l�y � /�% i7n PS O�G� . i s�,�; s�,od _ _.--1� oi � o ;� - - � 1��=6�0- 3�?l wk= 5yy 03�� -- — o fl � ; � � Saw _�� Ne �a,� 'vor S , Ga �- e�e r+ Box Go• v9 e P / • fs � + 5-8�_,�..�_� �IGt/� i CL h �e rP4 u P S T PG -�, + ! �o,. o�+I y � �'^. ' i ; o„! spf tiar i � Oh CQSt S�QE G��e�" ���� �/y e.�a I 1Can c e _ /+ ' a��P Pos�'S aarcl,�,c*:-•� ,r;�c=e,:� or � Pro/GosQO► �•+o%SP/ ; ,'. �Q w i i%�°U 7 ToOT, i p � � , � /OyG,: q n e� �TO r e�9 Q ; . � � � ! � I � ' i \ \7� 1 � t ��,`\ ! , , �� � r �—� � � � + i � 3 _ _ .. _ I � , , i3. ^QS t �Vo .,� n o>% � - S'rP°'� �f:u s p PRE�Fti T ��. /`�:� 3 ,-;,.-!,� �c„V'° ,�o w�= Scc■r�c �6�Y3� � , � g' s6' i�' ----- --. i.ar�c D�"�< : DI'1Yp . Wwy t ._ 5�.�.�1 , yyay � r • ,t y�� 3� ,>ejbnc:. � � 9'��: i � , � � o . �- 17' j � ; ���se«f � � ! � :jDr ive woy� � • r j . ; I , ----�-"' •• V�s .. ; � e� h�61w� ctJd��'•ic�,Gh� �o+� F�� � D /�Y • � _ - w�� ?• �' s���c� a ravcc� � � �, �� 0 � 1 � � t �L A /r FCr Yw♦ �„�r ' � pt YQY� �P ` • . bp ..�� ��n� � Ilr /� iG�4 � � or+� Lil�+drl J�Qu �li,� � �� $ca�e : / �N��, _ .?D �Pf /��S ��� /d Ave �,lc"��/�/�,� Sf. Pau / � /L� N , SS1I(' „Lof 7, �/oc.k �� Cwk;Py A�� .:'.,,,. �'r"o� �r Owc� /P �+ � � ' �✓a r, - � �� � y a ccor-aP� ..9 � ��p rPr :�.��a ,J a E/v�•`r'c Ft"�`' [ '^' ��PrP p� a�e� S;�aCi�F ih �um;°i T/t P�.�r.P proP � �Ow 9 r ou,�, i' Po/P � �� Co w.,��r � /�% rin P S��G� . s1��� i s�hoo� .. __.+ n o �;r----� X�=6�0- 32�/ +�/k: ,Syy-Os�J �� i � ----i o � � � � sawo�� - Ne �g,'�vor s ; Go r den i �eo'�I P / • fs • Go, o y r ` . , 'JrB� 1.__._�_ yQi�/Qh !� rP4 uPS �"P� r __._� j -�'i,. a n ly .� -ro;,� se��a�, + � ��T �Qrit S�4F ti��a�,. . IJ 1 � ,'/11 e�a I Jtarf c e jf / � /� f � �7✓C Q..� �OOt;..s QdQ,7'ld-r.� inS � �e* �:a CT � PrflP�SPd F���OSp�', ; �Q Le �+'t°� 7 yo0�, i . , f� � Poyc:, a n af Ga• n� Q � � , ; � \ ' ` � . `�� �';. ' J � � --�\ � - - - ; \ � -—�9'--�a � , � . � � � i � r � � � � -- - • a „, : � • . '`as { --- . , , , iv� ::, � bo� � � - Sf��-� No4 s� � . c^ PiC��FN T } "_ /9� 7 F;C!a( Av� flCi/�r f ' '`i z6'•s;' 5' 3�' F— i�� --- -- ::>?'.a�k p�;i� ! �__ Dr%yf -�-�-_ � �y w�/ � a . . S �.�P.i : y!�L.� : . F y�,.� 3�' �Pj�ac:: � 1 9,�: ' e J �- I 7�—� ' . f / rnSAn'� � ,. , � : :Dt iv+' wa�+ , ; . � �".. �e�ed ara.�c ak� f�� L r f� � f • Or` 5 � _ f� �1 w �i � sc��c. � �• � . . . . � �i�—�y�� , . �� ST. PAUL CITY COUNCII. PUB� IC HEARING NOTICE RE�E��ED ZONING `15�ga$ sv C1,� ��ERK FiLE NO 10335 T0: Property owners within 350' ; • Representatives of Planning District 15 PA G E P U R P O S E Mr. McGee is appealing a decision by the Board of Zoning Appeals which would permit the owner of the neighboring house to the west to build a garage 2' from their common property line. LOCATION 1905 Field PETITIONER G�RY MCGEE H E A R I N G Thursday, July 28, �98s 9:0o A.M. . Cit Council Chambers, 3rd Floor City Hall - Court House Q U E S T10 N S Zoning 298-4154 (Tom Beach) Contact the Zoning Section of the Planning and Economic Development Department, Room 1101, City Hall Annex, 25 W. 4th Street, St. Paul, MinnesoLa 55102 Legal Description: On file Notice sent 7/6/88 ,.'�