88-1491 WHITE — CITV CLERK
PINK — FINANCE G I TY OF SA I NT PA U L Council /�
CANARV — DEPARTMENT r/_
BLUE — MAYOR File NO• 4 I/��/
Council Resolution �.�---� ,
Presented By ����'�� `�-�'
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
RESOLVED, that the on-sale intoxicating liquor, Sunday on-
sale, and other licenses held by RICOM, Inc. , Henry R. Troje,
Sr. , President, for the premises ;cnown as the Horseshoe Bar,
574 Rice Street, Saint Paul, are hereby suspended for a period
of 5 consecutive days, beginning and ending on the following
dates: September 25, 1988 through September 29, 1988
This Resolution and the action taken herein are based upon
the facts contained in the attached police reports which support
the allegations contained in the preliminary notice dated August 15,
1988, all of which are attached to and made part of this Resolution.
Such facts are not contested by the licenseholder, as evidenced
by the attached letter of Mr. John E. Daubney, attorney for the
licenseholder. The action taken is also based on such facts,
circumstances and arguments as may have been presented by and
on behalf of the licenseholder at the time this Resolution was
considered.
�� W�'�l ��
�t�tuw�
COUNCIL MEMBERS
Yeas Nays Requested by Department of:
Dimond
�� [n Favor
Goswitz
Rettman
Sc6eibel � _ Against BY
*�6e+�.�p
Wilson
SEP 13 �� Form Approved by City Attorney
Adopted by Council: Date • .
Certified Pa.s d by Council Se etar BY ` r �
By
Approved y iVlav . a _ SEP 1 5 �g Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By _ � — , BY
e t �'i. (:� '^!7
F���.e4°�'j�? _..- I�:v U
�. � r r r �p {af �
� 1 A W N ~
•(1 '. n �. � ' > r o �p
_ � � < a ? a o o > y
�7 � a � ' ° � D a ; > { �
� -�i � 'n\a ° � 1�1
1 n' � � � " � 2 � ;
� � � 1 � � �D D Z_ w O (�_ .
+1 � /� � `j m � i '{ ; �
♦ • � n � ' i n P r .
O A 1 ' 1� �' � � � A O ^ ; ; ,n r .:..i � �
V�
`� � ip � a ^ w
/
/� _ ; � � � r
br 0 � 4-�
v n m � a
p � �` ' p rii � n ro > ' �
' a a
� { ; '� 9
N
0 D � � � / A�
• ! � � S � �
a �
D ~ � ��� " i r � � '�^ �
� ' ! a jzt ;! _ O —
'� 3 4 ° � '— {/' '�
, ,. • Z '� w • � = cn
> � � _ � � -�
� y� N O
�
� � � n "_ � D ,,��.
� �' � °Cl -�i � '"
O � � n ` , • _
� a � o
.� S _ > m e ; A .. .
. � � I c ' � � _� ° I � '�-'�
o �
, � O 0 1' � i ���
a
> rn - � w i�1 n , `s
� >
m °i � (� I� � � �', z i r
n �" .. � � � ' � i { � �' _`.
` � � A a � 1
\ N n �D , � o O � r'�'..
�` mC f i
a � r � a
_„� c� o " -' C� `, '- p m!� D n �> �_-9. :+�
T v \z � N E a a R > o _ ��4
D �' �w � - 3Z � o a o \ �w
� 7 � � ' O z a � Z T.�:�.�.
y . � -
� �,' A � � Z Zx �w . �a#�.
1 � o .s
/\� a , ' ^ ••�=,�°
) y� CI �D
� � .` . 10 W r 3 ,
l 7 �� j m p .
O v" ^ � £ " „ •m
O n '� --
) o m ^ �n n ` � �
r I � O 2 m � � l u Z..
O i ���
i0 � j�
a" N w :f[
� � � a f i o :".'���`�
` M n i = � °`.,,�,x�•�
` �l� �.1 ` Z � O t��,t
\ � � � � i '^ > 1 5,�:+'#
� x Z �1 v1
O � I � > O ('� .-+. � �#
< <
� � i � _ \J ..:.�'��L
—i ' l o� o f .,,�,..._ 1 -_�-
2 ' ' � o �yi~~ �'�
m v1 m ,� ' . �,
� o � -� 9 �r. t�..
� N o o •- �
r�i f�, z a '"' C ,;,�_''�""1c�
0 ' t'� = p � ' �
� > w � O
^ { . r \ p � ,1 O ^ � , '�.w; ..�.
) ^ q .
j�,' w � ! � � Z z p � a ����.'.:.` �'.
( '1 � � � 9 a � � �i � � .
N
� �0 ` O X N ° i W � ' "''`k E
N N � , �\ , szi � � � � � �, ��
� �
< � Q � � n 3 � a w n � �`"�� 4
/ 1p n
v • r �( � % I A � n � p p � ''.'�r'� '•
2 � N A 2 A D
- a . � � o a ;fie.�fr�.-.: ��
3 � a � a m �;;.
a . � ) �i �q � ? � m ❑ �q '•.. �.�'. �.
� � L �; � x ; i . a:;�.�, iy�.
� � � � � N PI < � f ,,�y�:fy.
� � • � � � �•;t'_.
I � � � o ; o D 1 �
y p � ' ; s c°
° � r � r �I if � r = a
o • �"
n
n\ , ��F )� �'• �� " � n � n a � o 1
�� . . 1 C� �; J� x a�", g o ,°, /"' r �
x I '� ° ; x i �.7 r
c D � ; � D � � � �
� > -� � : F� � « o =
� � ' o
b , � �; � ^ ' M C �
� n � .
� �` .. " ' ' ' \
I •
v � -1 �
� � _
,
c � -
� � �
�
,
.
,
rn
7 � ° _
, � �
, . � n,
� � � �
T � �
\
_ � � �
O
Z
-i
1 Z
C
m
z
� � a
� _
z
a
. �
N • • m
� I x
� m
�
� m
� �
�� v _ ,
N
� L
�
�� ,
,
CJ
� D
l
N
� . . � `I � •
..:.�_ ...s... .,..._ :.. ._.r...:..: �,.:.•. . _..:�.z.W.,..._: ... , ..,:.:.k.,..v,.,..... :� _... . .. � . . .. ..... .....s.� .. .._.,. .,.... ... . ... ._ . _... . . . .. _...
' t ' ' ��_ /`1�/
. .
.>>,°��=�"o;�, � • ' CITY OF SAINT PAUL
34, �z..
3. ,:, OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY
'� ����� :I..�
`;.; ,'-'=!1!'1"' . - EDWARD P. STARR. CITY ATTORNEY
"�n,y �p•��,,.��°' 647 Ciry Hall, Saint Paul.Minnesota 55102
612-?98-512�
GEORGE LATIMER
MAYOR
August 15, 1988
Mr. Henry R. Troje, Sr.
RICOM, Inc. dba Horse Shoe Bar
574 Rice Street
St. Paul , Mn. 551P13
RE: Horse Shoe Bar , 574 Rice Street
Dear Mr. Troje:
The Vice Unit has given me reports containing inform ation which
could lead to action by the Saint Paul City Council against your
intoxicating liquor and other licenses. The allegations in
summary form are that you have sold liquor to minors on August 5,
1988 .
If you do not dispute the allegations or facts, and agree that a
violation accurred , but want to have an opportunity to speak to
the Council to argue for the lightest possible penalty under all
the circumstances , please call me at 298-5121 to work out the
procedures .
On the other hand, if you contest the allegations or dispute the
facts, I will take the necessary steps to schedule a hearing
before an independent hearing examiner and provide you with a
proper notice of hearing so you will know when and where to
appear , and what the basis for the hearing will be. If I do not
hear from you within seven (7) days from the date of this letter,
I will assume you want to have the hearing .
Very truly yours,
PHILIP B. BYRNE
Assistant City Attorney
cc : Joseph F. Carchedi
License Inspector
Lt. Donald Winger
Vice Unit
a ��/�
.
. - ` y • . ��/Y"%�
, � LAW OFFICES
JOHN E. DAUBNEY
ATTORNEYS AND COUNSELORS AT LAW
700 AMHOIST TOWER
FOURTH AND ST. PETER STREETS
JOHN E.DAUBNEY ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55102 16121224-43a5
JANET C,FESLER"
•AL50 ADMITTED IN WISCONSIN
�Y�'�4 r a L'FI=r.�
August 29, 1988 a �f.�.:��-$ -
AU G � l 1988
Mr. Phi l ip B. Byrne r..�: Y � � � '` r `� '
Assistant City Attorney -� � -
Office of the City Attorney
647 City Hall
St. Paul, MN 55102
RE: Horseshoe Bar, 574 Rice Street
Our File No: 9351
Dear Mr. Byrne:
This is in response to your letter of August 15, 1988 , addressed
to Henry R. Troje, Sr. , at the Horseshoe Bar in connection with
an allegation of sale of liquor to minors on August 5, 1988 .
It is the custom and practice at the Horseshore Bar to have a per-
son at the door checking I .D. ' s when customers enter and to prevent
patrons from leaving the establishment carrying alcoholic beverages.
This policy was in force and effect on August 5, 1988 , but this was
an extremely busy evening and, unfortunately, the patrons in
question did enter and did purchase an alcoholic beverage (beer) .
Under these circumstances, a Hearing before an Administrative Law
Judge is not requested although the license holder would wish to
appear for the Counsel at the time sanctions are being considered
to explain the extenuating circumstances.
Very truly yours,
�
ohn . Daubney
ttor ey for Ricom, Inc.
d a orseshore Bar
JED:kd
CC: Craig Troje